qc!r1.$344.4!3!h.23 … · agudos, cuidados não urgentes e cuidados intensivos porque a...
TRANSCRIPT
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
BD""
QC! R1.$344.4! 3! H.23-.4! 23! 1&$#.$*)#.! )&! +.H&2&! 23! 23$#47./! !0.)+1#G,+.4!!!!
$.)$3N+,!3!#)+311.<&6O34!
?).#(&,"@".9>(+)?)0$-'%,'&$",+):$)!"#$%&'($&4)<"8=$%38:':$):$)>=+%')
,"-)(.&/%!(+)?)0$-'%,'&$",+):$)!"#$%&'($&4)<"8=$%38:':$):$)>=+%')
;-"&4%-+(#")?)0$-'%,'&$",+):$)!"#$%&'($&):')<"8=$%38:':$):$)>=+%')&)
!
I'" $)L$0($&05'" K/$" &)4$N0*(" *'" $K/&6*'" ,$" /)&,*,$'" ,$" 2/&,*,5'" [5'6&4*%*0$'" 41("
K/$"60$;$)&0-"(&)&(&E*0"$"2500&N&0" '&4/*7M$'"2%\)&2*'" &)'4P;$&'W"S("25)'$K/1)2&*",&''5"
,$L05)4*(@'$",&P0&*"$"'&'4$(*4&2*($)4$"25("*"5F0&N*450&$,*,$",$"45(*0",$2&'M$'")5"
25)4$Z45",*"*785"QO[5(6'5)"m"V5r,&)N-"!AAHR"$"*N&0"$("25)L50(&,*,$W"S%$'"41("K/$"
45(*0",$2&'M$'")/("$'6*75"K/$")85"`"0$'$0;*,5"$"K/$"$'4P"25)L&)*,5"*"/(*"4$&*",$"
0$%*7M$'"K/$"*25)4$2$("$)40$"5",5$)4$-"*"L*(\%&*"$"5'"0$'4*)4$'"($(F05'",*"$K/&6*"
,$"'*Y,$"Qg$))$0"$4"*%-"!ACC_"O*))$0-"!AAD-".56$'-"!AADRW":("$'6*75"5),$"*25)4$2$("
(Y%4&6%*'" &)4$00/67M$'" K/$" 605;1(" ,$" 6052$,&($)45'" ,$" 40*F*%[5" $" $Z&N1)2&*'""""""
25)'4*)4$'" ,$" *4$)785" *" 2*,*" ,5$)4$" Qq$,F$0N"m" .*0''5)-" !AAB_" c544$0" $4" *%-" !AAH_"
o5%L"$4"*%-"!AADRW"T85",$2&'M$'"6052$''/*&'"$"(/%4&,&($)'&5)*&'"K/$"41("K/$"25)'&,$@
0*0"$("'&(/%4i)$5-"5"K/$",$;$"'$0"L$&45-"25(5",$;$"'$0"L$&45"$"K/*),5",$;$"'$0"L$&45-"
)5" 0$'6$&45" ,*" '&)N/%*0&,*,$" ,5" ,5$)4$" $" ,5" '$/" 25)4$Z45" 2&02/),*)4$" Q3&%%$'6&$-"
!AA=RW"S'4*",&)i(&2*" 4*(F`("$'4P" &)4$0%&N*,*"25("5'",*,5'"2%\)&25'"K/$" 0$2500$)4$@
($)4$"$($0N$(-"F$("25(5"b"*2$''&F&%&,*,$-"(/%4&6%&2&,*,$"$"*(F&N/&,*,$",5'",*,5'"
2%\)&25'"QU/))5%*"$4"*%-"!AA!_"9*0)$;*%&"mO[5(*'-"C==G"T&((5)'-"!ACAR-"*5"4$(65",$"
,$2&'85" $" b'" ,$2&'M$'" 25)L%&4/5'*'" QO[5(6'5)-" !AABRW" T85" *(F&$)4$'" 2%\)&25'" 5),$"
*25)4$2$(" 25)4&)N1)2&*'-" *%N/(*'" ,$%*'" *%$*4a0&*'-" K/$" $Z&N$(" K/$" 5'" $)L$0($&05'"
&),$6$),$)4$($)4$" ,5'" )\;$&'" ,$" 605L&2&1)2&*" '$]*(" 5F0&N*,5'" *" 45(*0" ,$2&'M$'""
25(6%$Z*'",$"L50(*"0P6&,*"$"60$2&'*-"6*0*"54&(&E*0"5'"0$'/%4*,5'"$'6$0*,5'"Q9/00x"m"
g544&-"!AADRW""
I" 25)[$2&($)45" $" 5" 0*2&52\)&5" K/$" 5'" $)L$0($&05'" /'*(")*" 45(*,*" ,$" ,$2&'85" '85"
$%$($)45'-"$)40$"5/405'-"K/$",$L&)$("(/&45",*"60P4&2*"605L&''&5)*%"Q95,x-"!AADRW"c50"
&''5-"25)'2&$)4$'",*"0$*%&,*,$"$)/)2&*,*"*40*;`'",*"&);$'4&N*785"K/$"4$(";&),5"*"'$0"
,$'$);5%;&,*-"L5&")5''*"&)4$)785"*)*%&'*0"20&4&2*($)4$"5'"(5,$%5'",$",$2&'85"K/$"41("
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
B>""
$Z60$''85")*" %&4$0*4/0*",$"$)L$0(*N$("$"K/$" 41("'&,5",$'$);5%;&,5'"$(",&L$0$)4$'"
P0$*'",5"25)[$2&($)45"Q95)250*)@c$00x"$4"*%-"C===R-")5"'$)4&,5",$"0$25)[$2$0"5"'$/"
65,$0"$Z6%&2*4&;5"6*0*"*" 45(*,*",$",$2&'85",5'"$)L$0($&05'W"X%N/)'",$%$'" '85"*60$@
'$)4*,5'")/(*"$'40/4/0*")50(*4&;*-"5/405'")/(*",$'20&4&;*"$"$("L/)785",&''5-"65,$("
,&;&,&0@'$" $(" ,/*'" 2*4$N50&*'" 4$a0&2*'-" '&'4$(P4&25@65'&4&;&'4*" $" &)4/&4&;5@[/(*)&'4*"
QO[5(6'5)-"C===_"X&4J$)-"+*0'[*%%-"S%%&544"m"+2y&)%$x-"!AA>RW""
X'" *F50,*N$)'" '&'4$(P4&25@65'&4&;&'4*'" '/N$0$(" K/$" *" 45(*,*" ,$" ,$2&'85" *25)4$2$"
)/("6052$''5"'$K/$)2&*%"60$;&*($)4$",$L&)&,5"$"$Z6%&2&4*,5W"X''$)4*(")5"60$''/65'@
45" K/$" $Z&'4$" *%N/(*" *4&;&,*,$" ,$" *)P%&'$" 5/" ,$" 0$'5%/785" ,$" 605F%$(*'" $(" 2/0'5-"
6*0*"5"$)L$0($&05"45(*0"/(*",$2&'85W"d*'"*F50,*N$)'"&)4/&4&;5@[/(*)&'4*'"*",$2&'85"
`"$)4$),&,*")5"'$&5",$"/("6052$''5"25(5"/("45,5"$")5"25)4$Z45",$"/(*"*F50,*N$("
)*4/0*%&'4*"Qg$))$0-"C=?B_"O[5(6'5)-"C===RW"S%*'"65,$("'$0",&L$0$)2&*,*'-",$',$"%5N5-"
*"6*04&0",5'"'$/'"2$)405'",$"&)4$0$''$W"S)K/*)45"*"60&($&0*"'$"&)4$0$''*"6$%5")Y($05"
,$",*,5'"$"6$%5'"6052$''5'",$"*)P%&'$"25N)&4&;*"6*0*"/(*"($%[50",$2&'85W"X"'$N/),*"
,P"60&(*E&*"*5'"25)4$Z45'"0$%*2&5)*&'"$",$"25(/)&2*785"25("5'",5$)4$'"$"'$0;$@'$",*"
6$0L50(*)2$"2%\)&2*"6*0*"$%$N$0"*'"($%[50$'"*7M$'W""
"
"
R1.$344.4!3!H.23-.4!23!1&$#.$*)#.!)&!+.H&2&!23!23$#47.!!
l/*'$" 4/,5" 5" K/$" /(" $)L$0($&05" L*E" $);5%;$" ,$2&'M$'W" 95)2$64/*%&E*0" '5F0$" *'"""""""
,$2&'M$'" `" K/*'$" 5" ($'(5" K/$" 25)2$64/*%&E*0" '5F0$" *'" *4&;&,*,$'" ,$" K/*%K/$0"""""
$)L$0($&05-"'$"4&;$0(5'"25(5"0$L$01)2&*"/(*"K/*%K/$0"/)&,*,$",$"2/&,*,5'"[5'6&4*@
%*0$'CW" d$'4*'" /)&,*,$'" $'4&(*@'$" K/$" 5'" $)L$0($&05'" 45(*(" 2$02*" ,$" ,/E$)4*'" $"
K/*0$)4*" ,$2&'M$'" 650" 2*,*" ,/*'" [50*'" Qg/2J)*%%-" !AAARW" X6$'*0" ,$" 5" )Y($05" ,$""
,$2&'M$'" 0$N&'4*,5"65,$0" 4$0" &(6*245")*",&)i(&2*",*"/)&,*,$",$" 2/&,*,5'" &(6504*"
L*E$0" '*%&$)4*0" K/$" 5'"(5,$%5'" )85" 0$40*4*(" *" K/*)4&,*,$" ,$" ,$2&'M$'-"(*'" '&(" *"
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""C"A designação de cuidados hospitalares decorre não só da natureza do ambiente de cuidados mas também
da necessária imediatez dos cuidados e de uma dependência de meios técnicos. Ela envolve cuidados
agudos, cuidados não urgentes e cuidados intensivos porque a concepção e desenvolvimento de cuidados
imediatos (por exemplo, gestão e monitorização hemodinâmica) e cuidados desenvolvidos a partir de uma
avaliação do doente acontecem em qualquer uma destas áreas e com os mesmos níveis de perícia clínica
(Benner et al, 2011).""
"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
B?""
L50(*"25(5"`"/'*,*"*"%&F$0,*,$",$",$2&,&0"Qq*)'5)-"!AAHRW"qP"567M$'"6*0*"$'25%[$0"
$" *'" $'25%[*'" *25)4$2$(" ,$" /(*" L50(*" )85@*%$*4a0&*W" X'" $'25%[*'" *25)4$2$(" $("
L/)785",$"'&4/*7M$'"25)20$4*'"$",$"*250,5"25("5'"5F]$4&;5'"'$%$2&5)*,5'"5/"0$'/%4*@
,5'"$'6$0*,5'W"+5,$%*0"5"6$)'*($)45",5'",$2&'50$'"6*0*"*%2*)7*0"/("0$'/%4*,5"`-"
5F]$4&;*($)4$-"*"L/)785",5'"(5,$%5'",$",$2&'85W""
I'"(5,$%5'",$",$2&'85"0$25)[$2&,5'"25(5")50(*4&;5'"$'485"L52*,5'")5"6052$''5",$"
,$2&'85"K/$"65,$"*25)4$2$0"$(",5&'"4$(65'W":("60&($&05"K/*),5"*",$2&'85"`"45(*,*"
$")/("5/405"4$(65"K/*),5"$%*"`"56$0*2&5)*%&E*,*"Qq*)'5)-"!AAHRW"S'4*'",$2&'M$'"'85"
,$")*4/0$E*"4$a0&2*-"*4`"b"'/*"$Z$2/785-"K/$"%[$"65,$"25)L$0&0";*%&,*,$"2%\)&2*"5/")85W""
I'"(5,$%5'",$")*4/0$E*",$'20&4&;*"0$L%$4$("*'",$2&'M$'-"K/$"52500$(")*",&($)'85",$"
/("25)4&)//(",$"6$)'*($)45"$"*785-",/0*)4$"5"6052$''5",$"2/&,*,5'-",$"4*%" L50(*"
K/$" '$" 450)*"($'(5" ,&L\2&%" 25(60$$),$0" 5),$" 25($7*" /(" $" *2*F*" *" 5/40*" Q.56$'-"
!AADRW"c5,$(5'"L*%*0",$",$2&'M$'"60P4&2*'-")85"'a"650"565'&785"b'"*)4$0&50$'"K/$")85"
41("$Z$2/785" &($,&*4*" K/$" *'" ;*%&,$" 5/" 0$L/4$-"(*'" 650K/$" $'4*'" ,$2&'M$'" 41("/("
4056&'(5"6*0*"*"*785W""
X'",$2&'M$'"60P4&2*'"0$($4$("6*0*"/("6$0\5,5",$",$2&'85"'$N/&,5",*"*785",$2&'&;*"$"
K/$"65,$("'$0"$)K/*,0*,*'")*"4&65%5N&*",$"0*2&52\)&5",$'20&4*"650"30$$)r55,"QC==?RW"
S'4*" &);$'4&N*,50*"'*%&$)4*"K/$"5"0*2&52\)&5"K/$"4$0(&)*")/(*"25)2%/'85"$"K/$"65,$"
'$0" $Z60$''5" 650" /(*" ,$2&'85" `" 2[*(*,5" ,$" 0*2&52\)&5" 4$a0&25-" $" 5" 0*2&52\)&5" K/$"""
4$0(&)*")85")*",$2&'85"(*'")*"*785"K/$"*" 450)*"56$0*4&;*"`"2[*(*,5",$" 0*2&52\)&5"
60P4&25W"S"$'2%*0$2$"K/$"*'"&);$'4&N*,50*'"K/$"41("L52*,5"*"'/*"*4$)785")5"0*2&52\)&5"
K/$" 4$0(&)*" )/(" ,&*N)a'4&25" Q5/" /(*" 25)2%/'85-" e/(*" ;$0,*,$fR" 41(" $Z6%50*,5" 5"
0*2&52\)&5"4$a0&25",5'"$)L$0($&05'W"I"0*2&52\)&5"4$a0&25"*;*)7*"*40*;`'",$"(*)&6/%*785"
&),/4&;*"$"[&654`4&25@,$,/4&;*",$"60565'&7M$'"*",&L$0$)4$'")\;$&'",$"&)2%/'85"$"N$)$0*@
%&,*,$W"I"0*2&52\)&5"4$a0&25"25($7*"&),/4&;*($)4$"*"6*04&0",$"/(*"60565'&785"56$0*@
2&5)*%",$"/(*"��&'45"`"/(*��"$"��&'45"`",$'20&45"25(5��")*4/0$E*"$"6052$,&($)45'",$"
)\;$&'" 20$'2$)4$'" ,$" &)2%/'85" $(" ;$0,*,$'" 25(6%$Z*'" 5/" 25)2%/'M$'" Q�,&*N)a'4&25'�R"
*2$02*" ,5" (/),5" $Z6$0&$)2&*,5W" S'4*-" 650" '/*" ;$E-" 2*6*2&4*" 6*0*" *" (*)&6/%*785""""""
[&654`4&25@,$,/4&;*",$"5/40*'"60565'&7M$'" 4*&'" 25(5" ��'$"$'4*" %$'85"$'4P" &)L$4*,*��"
$)485"$%*"$'4*0P";$0($%[*-"K/$)4$-"$,$(*2&*,*"�$42W�W"V&'45"'85"$Z$(6%5"5'"(5,$%5'"
,$"0*2&52\)&5",&*N)a'4&25",$'$);5%;&,5'"6$%5'" &);$'4&N*,50$'" Q350,5)-C==B_"9*0)$;*%&"
$4"*%-"C=?B_""V5$)N$'"m"+550[5/'$-"!AAGRW"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
B=""
j$45($(5'")5",&'2/0'5"5'"(5,$%5'")50(*4&;5'"650K/$"41("50N*)&E*,5"*"(*&50"6*04$"
,*" 6$'K/&'*" '5F0$" 45(*,*",$",$2&'85W"X" $'40/4/0*" ,$'4$'"(5,$%5'" `" ,$'$);5%;&,*" *"
6*04&0",$"/("25)]/)45",$"*''$07M$'"'5F0$"5"[5($("$"*'"'/*'"2*6*2&,*,$'-"K/$"*"2%*''&@
L&2*("25(5"/(*"*F50,*N$("65'&4&;&'4*W"I"K/$"'&N)&L&2*"0$25)[$2$0"K/$"5"6$)'*($)45"
$"5"25(6504*($)45"[/(*)5"'85" %aN&25'"$"25)'&'4$)4$'-"25("2*6*2&,*,$'"0*2&5)*&'"$"
*F'5%/4*'W"X''&("'$),5-"65,$("650"/("%*,5",5(&)*0"45,5"/("25)]/)45",$"65''\;$&'"
*%4$0)*4&;*'-"25)'$K/1)2&*'"$"605F*F&%&,*,$'",$"525001)2&*-"650"5/405-"65,$("(*Z&(&@
E*0" $" *4&)N&0" ,*" ($%[50" L50(*" 65''\;$%" 5'" 5F]$4&;5'-" '/F564&(&E*),5" 5'" 0$'/%4*,5'"
Q9*0)$;*%&"$4"*%-"C=?BRW"S'4$'"(5,$%5'")50(*4&;5'"4$),$("*"/'*0"*"*)P%&'$",$",$2&'M$'"
5/"*'"*F50,*N$)'",$"6052$''*($)45",$"&)L50(*785-"5),$-"'5F"*"($'(*"%aN&2*-"45,5"5"
0*2&52\)&5"`"$)4$),&,5"25(5"/("6052$''*($)45"&)4$0)5"$"25(6/4*2&5)*%",$"&)L50(*@
7M$'" '$K/$)2&*&'"$" '&(Fa%&2*'-"K/$"56$0*(",$" L50(*" 0$2/0'&;*" 8"-D,?6052$''*($)45?
+D,-D,W" T85" 0$2$F&,5'"5'" 8"-D,3" $" 25,&L&2*,5'"650"6052$''5'"6$02$4&;5'"$("'\(F5%5'W"
S'4$'"'\(F5%5'"'85"&),$Z*,5'"$"N/*0,*,5'")*"($(a0&*"Q9*0)$;*%&"m"O[5(*'-"C==GRW"
S'4$'"(5,$%5'"0$'/%4*(",$"$'4/,5'"K/$"41("/("25)405%$",$";*0&P;$&'W"j*E85"6$%*"K/*%"
65,$(")85"'$"$)K/*,0*0",$)405",$"/("6*0*,&N(*"2%\)&25-"K/$"'$"6*/4*"650";*0&P;$&'"
K/$" )85" '85" N5;$0)P;$&'" QX0Nx0&'"m" T2[�)-C=>BR" $" 650" /(*" $'40/4/0*" 65%\4&2*-" `4&2*-"
%$N*%" $" '52&*%" QV5r&$" m" S%'4$&)-" C===RW" I" 0$25)[$2&($)45" ,*'" 6*04&2/%*0&,*,$'" ,5""
(/),5"2%\)&25"4$(-")5'"Y%4&(5'"*)5'-"6$0(&4&,5"K/$"'$"5F'$0;$"/(*";&0*N$("6*0*"*'""
*F50,*N$)'" ,$'20&4&;*'" $" &)4$060$4*4&;*'" 6*0*" $Z6%50*0" 5" 6052$''5" ,*'" 45(*,*'" ,$"""
,$2&'M$'W"I'"$'4/,5'",$'$);5%;&,5'"'5F"*'"*F50,*N$)'"&)4$060$4*4&;*'"'85"N$0*%($)4$"
2&02/)'20&45'"*"/(*"/)&,*,$"$'6$2\L&2*"$-"4$50&2*($)4$-")85"'85"6*''\;$&'",$"N$)$0*%&@
E*785"Qg/2y)*%%-"!AAGRW""
X%N/)'"&);$'4&N*,50$'"Q95)2500*)@c$00x"$4"*%-"C===R",$L$),$("K/$"5'"(5,$%5'")50(*@
4&;5'"$"*)*%\4&25'"65,$("'$0"/'*,5'"$("'&4/*7M$'"$'6$2\L&2*'")*'"P0$*'"2%\)&2*'W"I/405'"
25(5"g$))$0"$4"*%"Q!ACCR")85"6*04&%[*(",$'4*"&,$&*"$"0$L$0$("K/$"5"0*2&52\)&5"2%\)&25"`"
/("6052$''5"$("40*)'&785-"K/$"*25)4$2$")/(*"60P4&2*" &),$4$0(&)*,*"$-"650" &''5-" 'a"
65,$" '$0" 6$)'*,5" b" %/E" ,$" (5,$%5'" ,$'20&4&;5'W" d*" ;$0,*,$" 4*)45" *" 40*)'&4&;&,*,$-"
K/*)45"5"25)L05)45"25("'&4/*7M$'-"2/]*'"65''&F&%&,*,$'",$"0$'/%4*,5'"'85",$'25)[$2&@
,*'"0$60$'$)4*("/(*"'&4/*785"605F%$(P4&2*"6*0*"5'"(5,$%5'",$",$2&'85"*)*%\4&25'"$"
)50(*4&;5'" Qq*)'5)-" !AAHRW" I'" (5,$%5'" )50(*4&;5'" '85" 4$50&*'" K/$" $'4*F$%$2$(""
)50(*'"6*0*"45(*0"/(*",$2&'85"$"5'"(5,$%5'",$'20&4&;5'"'85"4$50&*'"K/$",$'20$;$("
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
HA""
5'" 6052$''5'" K/$" 6$0(&4$(" K/$" 5'" 2%\)&25'" 45($(" ,$2&'M$'" QO[5(*'" $4" *%W-C==C_"""
q*)'5)-"!AAH_"g*05)-"!AA?RW""
O5(*0" /(*" ,$2&'85" 2$04*-" *" 6*04&0" ,*" &)L50(*785" ,&'65)\;$%" )5"(5($)45-" )/)2*" `""
LP2&%W"X",$2&'85"65,$"4$0"0$'/%4*,5'"&),$'$]P;$&'"'$")5'"50&$)4*0(5'"485"'a"650"L*450$'"
605F*F&%\'4&25'W" O5($(5'" 25(5" 0$L$01)2&*" /(" $Z$(6%5W" I'" ,5$)4$'" 25(" '&)45(*'"
2%P''&25'",$"/("6a'@56$0*4a0&5",$"/(*"2&0/0N&*"*F,5(&)*%"65,$(-"52*'&5)*%($)4$-"4$0"
/(*",50")5"6$&45W"T/65)[*(5'"K/$"/("$)L$0($&05",$"/(*"/)&,*,$",$"2/&,*,5'"2&0Y0@
N&25'!*,(&)&'40*"/("($,&2*($)45"60$'20&45-"$("L/)785",5"*20a)&(5"QTITR-"6*0*"*%&;&*0"
*",50"*F,5(&)*%"$"0$N/%*0&E*0"5'"(5;&($)45'"6$0&'4P%4&25'W"qP"/(*"'`0&$",$"0$'/%4*,5'"
65''\;$&'-"$("L/)785",5"$'4*,5",5",5$)4$"e0$*%f"$",5"(5,5"25(5"5"($,&2*($)45"`"
*,(&)&'40*,5n"QCR"*",50",5",5$)4$"65,$"0$;$%*0@'$",$"50&N$(")85"*F,5(&)*%"5/"Q!R")85"
&),&2*4&;*",$"*/'1)2&*",$"(5;&($)45'"6$0&'4P%4&25'"5/"QGR"5"($,&2*($)45"65,$"25(@
605($4$0"5'"'&)*&'";&4*&'",5",5$)4$"5/-")*"($%[50",*'"[&6a4$'$'-"QBR"*"&)4$0;$)785"4$("
5"$L$&45",$'$]*,5W""
T$"K/&'$0(5'"/4&%&E*0"/(*"P0;50$",$",$2&'85-"$'40/4/0*"2/]*"(*40&E"`"/'*,*"6*0*",$2&,&0"
$(" '&4/*7M$'" ,$" 0&'25-" $%*" 65,$" *65)4*0" 6*0*" *'" 605F*F&%&,*,$'" $00*,*'-" %&N*,*'" *"""
65)45'",$"$'25%[*-"5/"*"P0;50$"65,$"4$0"/(*"$'40/4/0*"&(6$0L$&4*W"I"(5,$%5"[&654`4&@
25@,$,/4&;5" 65,$" '/N$0&0" K/$" 5'" '&)*&'" ;&4*&'" ,5" ,5$)4$" Q4*&'" 25(5" 60$''85" *04$0&*%-"
%52*%&E*785" ,*" ,50-" $42WR" )85" $'485" *" N$0*0" [&6a4$'$'" 2500$4*'W" k'45" %$;*" *" ,$,/7M$'""
L*%*2&5'*'" )5'" '&)*&'" ;&4*&'" $'6$0*,5'-" $Z*2$0F*),5" *''&("5" 605F%$(*" 25("[&6a4$'$'"
&)*,$K/*,*'" 5/" &)2500$4*($)4$" 65),$0*,*'W" :(" ]/\E5" 2%\)&25" &)4/&4&;5" 65,$" 605650"
K/$" 5'" '&)*&'" '$" %&N/$(" *" 2*4$N50&*'" ,$" ,&*N)a'4&25-" K/$" )85" '85" *'" *,$K/*,*'" 650"
65),$0*7M$'" $00a)$*'-" $" *" &)4/&785" 65,$" 605650" K/$" *'" ,$2&'M$'" 0$'/%4*0*(" ,$""""""
($(a0&*'"$00a)$*'",$"2*'5'"*)4$0&50$'W""
:(*",$2&'85"*6*0$)4$($)4$"(P"5/"F5*"65,$" 4$0" ;P0&*'" $Z6%&2*7M$'-" 45,*'",$'20&4*'"
$(" 4$0(5'" 6052$''/*&'" ,&L$0$)4$'-" ,$6$),$),5" ,5" (5,$%5" ,$" 45(*,*" ,$" ,$2&'85""
/'*,5W"T$(60$"K/$"*20$,&4*(5'"K/$"5"(/),5",*'"605F*F&%&,*,$'")5'"65,$"5L$0$2$0"
'$N/0*)7*" 6*0*" 45(*0" ,$2&'M$'" /'*(5'"(5,$%5'" ,$" ,$2&'85" K/$" 0$($4$(" 6*0*" /("
2P%2/%5" $" /(*" (*)&6/%*785" ,$" 605F*F&%&,*,$'" 25(6%$Z*'-" b'" K/*&'" '85" *40&F/\,5'""""
;*%50$'"6*0*"'$"25)'$N/&0$("54&(&E*0"*'",$2&'M$'"$"25("&''5"(*Z&(&E*0"5'"F$)$L\2&5'"
6*0*"5'",5$)4$'W"S'4$'"(5,$%5'"0$60$'$)4*("/(*"*F50,*N$(")50(*4&;*"K/$",$'20$;$"
(*4$(*4&2*($)4$"25(5"`"K/$"5'",*,5'"2%\)&25'",$;$("'$0"65),$0*,5'"6*0*"L*E$0"/("
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
HC""
,&*N)a'4&25" 5/" $'25%[$0" /(*" *785" K/$" 4$)[*" (*&50" 605F*F&%&,*,$" 6*0*" *%2*)7*0" 5"""
0$'/%4*,5"(*&'";*%50&E*,5"QO*))$0-"C=?D*RW""
X" 0$60$'$)4*785" 605F*F&%\'4&2*" ,*" ,$2&'85" 2%\)&2*" (*&'" 25(/(($)4$" /4&%&E*,*" `""""""
&,$)4&L&2*,*" 25(5" /(*" P0;50$" ,$" ,$2&'85W" <" /(" (5,$%5" K/$" 65,$" '$0" /'*,5" )/(""""
(5,5"L50(*%"Q(*4$(P4&25R"$"5/"&)L50(*%-"K/$"$'40/4/0*"*"605N0$''85",*'"$'25%[*'"$"*'"
'/*'"25)'$K/1)2&*'"Q9*0)$;*%&"m"O[5(*'-"C==G_"d*0*x*)-"!AAGRW"X%N/(*'",*'"0*(&L&2*@
7M$'" ,*" P0;50$" 0$60$'$)4*(" 2*(&)[5'" *%4$0)*4&;5'" Q65)45'" ,$" ,$2&'85R" $" 5/40*'""""""
0*(&L&2*7M$'" '85" 605;P;$&'" *25)4$2&($)45'W" T85" $'4&(*,*'" 605F*F&%&,*,$'" 6*0*" 5'"
*25)4$2&($)45'" $" '85" *40&F/\,5'" ;*%50$'" *5'" 0$'/%4*,5'" L&)*&'-" K/$" 0$60$'$)4*(" *"""
60$L$01)2&*",5",5$)4$W" S'4*" *F50,*N$(" 4$)4*"(&'4/0*0"F$)$L\2&5'" '/F]$4&;5'" Q/4&%&,*@
,$'R"25("605F*F&%&,*,$'"5F]$4&;*'"Qg/2J&N[*("m"X,*('-"!AAARW""
:(*"P0;50$",$",$2&'85"&)L50(*%"/'*"/(*"*F50,*N$(")85"(*4$(P4&2*-"*"6*04&0",$"/(*"
N0$%[*" K/$" 0$60$'$)4*" 567M$'-" 0$'/%4*,5'" $" 605F*F&%&,*,$'W" IF$,$2$" *" /(" 6052$,&@
($)45"K/$"`",&0&N&,5"650"/(*"'`0&$",$"K/$'4M$'-"6*0*"50&$)4*0"*"6$''5*"K/$"4$("K/$"
,$2&,&0"Q2%\)&25"5/",5$)4$R")*"45(*,*",$",$2&'85W"X'"567M$'"'85",$L&)&,*'"$("L/)785"
,*'" 654$)2&*&'" *7M$'" *" 25)'&,$0*0W"I'" 0$'/%4*,5'" '85" 25)'$K/1)2&*" ,$" 2*,*" 56785" $"
,5'";*%50$'"*40&F/\,5'"6*0*"5'"0$'/%4*,5'W"X'"605F*F&%&,*,$'"25),&2&5)*&'"'85"*K/$%*'"
K/$"L50$(",$L&)&,*'"6*0*"52500$0"25(5"0$'/%4*,5W"X"N0$%[*"$"5"25)]/)45",$"6$0N/)4*'"
6$0(&4$(" K/$" 5" ,$2&'50" 65''*" 25)'&,$0*0" /(*" ;*0&$,*,$" ,$" 2$)P0&5'" 65''\;$&'" 25("
F*'$")*'"567M$'"25)'&,$0*,*'"Qd*0*x*)"$4"*%-"!AAGRW"
I/405'"*/450$'-")*"($'(*"%&)[*-"0$2500$0*("*5"4$50$(*",$"g*x$'"5/",$"605F*F&%&,*@
,$'-" 5/" *5"(5,$%5" ,$" .$)'" 6*0*" *)*%&'*0" *'" ,$2&'M$'" 2%\)&2*'" ,5'" $)L$0($&05'W" S'4$'"
(5,$%5'" ,&L$0$(" $)40$" '&-" 6$%*" L50(*" 25(5" &)4$060$4*(" 5'" ,*,5'" K/$" &)4$N0*("""""""
Qg/2J&)N[*("m"X,*('-"!AAARW"I"4$50$(*",$"g*x$'-",$'$);5%;&,5")5"'`2/%5"�hkkk-"650"
O[5(*'" g*x$'-" 20&5/" *'" F*'$'" (*4$(P4&2*'" ,*'" &)L$01)2&*'" 605F*F&%\'4&2*'W" d*" P0$*""
2%\)&2*"`"/(*!*F50,*N$("$'4*4\'4&2*"K/$",$'20$;$"*"L50(*"6$%*"K/*%"5'"]/\E5'",&*N)a'@
4&25'"65,$("'$0"0$;&'45'"*"6*04&0",$")5;*"&)L50(*785W"I"4$50$(*",$'20$;$"5"6052$''5"
,$" 0$;&'85" ,*" 605F*F&%&,*,$" ,$" /(*" [&6a4$'$" $" `" '/'4$)4*,5" $(" 401'" 60&)2\6&5'W" I""
60&($&05" 0$L$0$@'$"b"605F*F&%&,*,$"K/$"*"[&6a4$'$" 4$("*60&50&'4&2*($)4$_"5" '$N/),5"
0$L$0$@'$"b"605F*F&%&,*,$"K/$"/(",*,5"4$("6*0*"/("2$045",&*N)a'4&25_"/("4$02$&05",&E"
0$'6$&45" b" 605F*F&%&,*,$" ,$" /(" ,*,5" '$(" 0$L$01)2&*" *" /(*" [&6a4$'$" ,&*N)a'4&2*""""
QO*x%50-"!AAARW"I"4$50$(*",$"g*x$'"(5'40*"25(5"'$"65,$"*]/'4*0"*")5;*" &)L50(*785"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
H!""
6$%*'"%$&'",*"605F*F&%&,*,$W"c50"$Z$(6%5-"/(*"$)L$0($&0*"K/$"2[$N*"b"$)L$0(*0&*"4$("
/(*"$'4&(*4&;*-"650"*%45-",$"4$0"/(",5$)4$"25("$)L*04$",5"(&52P0,&5W"S'4*"$'4&(*4&;*-"
5/"605F*F&%&,*,$"')-%8+%8-"`"F*'$*,*")*'"$Z6$0&1)2&*'",5'",&*'"*)4$0&50$'"$"*"L0$K/1)@
2&*"25("K/$"52500$("$)L*04$'",5"(&52P0,&5-")$'4*'"$)L$0(*0&*'W"I/"*"605F*F&%&,*,$"
6*0*"/(",$4$0(&)*,5",5$)4$"`"*%4$0*,*"*''&("K/$"`" 0$;$%*,*" &)L50(*785"0$%$;*)4$-"
25(5" 650" $Z$(6%5" *" %52*%&E*785" ,*" ,50W" X" )5;*" 605F*F&%&,*,$-" ') -+3,$%8+%8-" `" *""""""""
605F*F&%&,*,$"')-%8+%8"*,*64*,*"25)'5*)4$"*"%52*%&E*785",*",50W"c50"5/40*'"6*%*;0*'-"5'"
]/\E5'"'5F0$"*"*;*%&*785",5'",5$)4$'";85"'$),5"*]/'4*,5'"25("5"*2/(/%*0",$",*,5'W"
d*"P0$*",$"$)L$0(*N$("5"(5,$%5"4$("'&,5"65/25",&;/%N*,5-"(*'"*&),*"*''&("q*)52["
m" c*2[/0-" Q!AABR" 0$25)[$2$(@%[$" /4&%&,*,$" $" '/N$0$(" K/$" $%$" '$]*" 25)'&,$0*,5" )*"
L50(*785" $'4*4\'4&2*" ,5'" $)L$0($&05'W" y5'J$%*" Q!ACAR" /'5/" 5"(5,$%5" ,$" g*x$'" 6*0*"
&,$)4&L&2*0"*"6$0'&'41)2&*",$"L*450$'",$"0&'25-")5"i(F&45",5'"2/&,*,5'",$"'*Y,$"60&(P@
0&5'"$"q*0F&'5)"Q!AADR"6*0*"*L$0&0"*"0$%*785"$)40$"$;&,1)2&*"$"]/%N*($)45W""
I"(5,$%5",$".$)'"`"/(*"$'40/4/0*"4$a0&2*",$"/(*"*F50,*N$("(*4$(P4&2*"K/$"0$60$@
'$)4*"/("0$2/0'5"6*0*"*;*%&*0"5"(5,5"25(5"5'"2%\)&25'"/'*("$"65),$0*("*"&)L50(*@
785-" K/$" %[$'" `" *60$'$)4*,*" 6*0*" L*E$0" /(" ,&*N)a'4&25" 5/" /(" 40*4*($)45" $" K/85""""
25)'&'4$)4$'"$"0&N505'5'"'85"5'"]/\E5'"0$*%&E*,5'"$("'&4/*7M$'"'&(&%*0$'W"#5&",$'$);5%@
;&,5"650"g0/)'r&2J")*",`2*,*",$"K/*0$)4*"$"(*&'"4*0,$"L5&"/'*,5"650"q*((5),"$4"*%"
QC=DBR"K/$",$'$);5%;$0*("*'"&,$&*'",$"g0/)'r&2J")5",5(\)&5",5'"]/\E5'"[/(*)5'W"d*"
P0$*",$"$)L$0(*N$("$'4$"(5,$%5" L5&"/'*,5"6*0*" &);$'4&N*0"*" 0$%*785"$)40$"5'" ]/\E5'"
2%\)&25'" $" *'" ,$2&'M$'" $" 5" /'5" K/$" 5'" $)L$0($&05'" L*E$(" ,*" &)L50(*785" 2%\)&2*-" )*'"""
60P4&2*'"$,/2*4&;*'"Q9*0)$;*%&"$4"*%-"C=?B_"O[5(6'5)"m"V5r,&)N-"!AA!RW""
d5'"*)5'"'$4$)4*"*"6'&25%5N&*",$2&,&/"/'*0"5"(5,$%5",$"6052$''*($)45",$"&)L50(*785-"
6*0*"&);$'4&N*0"5"0*2&52\)&5"2%\)&25")*"0$'5%/785",$"605F%$(*'-")*"$'L$0*",5"&),&;&,/*%"$"
)*"P0$*",*"'*Y,$"6YF%&2*W"X"4$50&*",5"6052$''*($)45",$"&)L50(*785"L5&",$L&)&,*"25(5"
/(*"4$50&*"*F0*)N$)4$")*" 0$'5%/785",$"605F%$(*'"[/(*)5'"$"N$05/"N0*),$"$)4/'&*'@
(5W" S;5%/&/" *"6*04&0" ,5" 40*F*%[5",$" T&(5)-"60`(&5"d5F$%",*"$25)5(&*-" K/$"$("C=B="
&)&2&5/"5"$'4/,5",5"6052$''5",$"0$'5%/785",$"605F%$(*'")*'"50N*)&E*7M$'-"$"$("C=HD"
,$L$),$/"*"&,$&*",$"K/$"5"(5,5"(*&'"*,$K/*,5"6*0*"$'4/,*0"*"0$'5%/785",$"605F%$(*'"
25(6%$Z5'"$0*"'&(/%*0"$''*"'&4/*785"25("605N0*(*'"&)L50(P4&25'"Q3*0,)$0-"!AA!RW""
#5&" 6$0*)4$" *" )$2$''&,*,$",$"/(*"$'40/4/0*" 25)2$64/*%" $" )50(*4&;*" 0$25)[$2&,*" )5'"
*)5'" '$4$)4*-" K/$" *" $)L$0(*N$(" *,5645/" *" 4$50&*" ,5" 6052$''*($)45" ,$" &)L50(*785"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
HG""
6*0*"20&*0"/("(5,$%5",$"0$'5%/785",$"605F%$(*'W"S'4*"4$50&*"65'4/%*"K/$"*"2*6*2&,*,$"
[/(*)*" 4$(" %&(&4$'"6*0*"6052$''*0" *" &)L50(*785-"$" *" 0$'5%/785"$L$4&;*",$"605F%$(*'"
,$2500$",*"[*F&%&,*,$"&),&;&,/*%"6*0*"'$"*,*64*0"*"$'4*'"%&(&4*7M$'W"X"4$50&*"4$("25(5"
*''/)7M$'" FP'&2*'n" QCR" 5'" [/(*)5'" 65''/$(" ($(a0&*" *" %5)N5" 60*E5" $" &)L&)&4*" 6*0*""
N/*0,*0" 25)[$2&($)45" 4$a0&25" $" 60P4&25_" Q!R" 41(" 2*6*2&,*,$" %&(&4*,*" ,$" ($(a0&*" *"""
2/045"60*E5_"QGR" %&,*("25("4*0$L*'"25(6%$Z*'"/'*),5"*F50,*N$)'"'$%$4&;*'"$"6052$''*@
($)45",$",*,5'"$("'`0&$W"d$r$%%"m"T&(5)"QC=>!R"$)L*4&E*0*("*"/4&%&,*,$",*"4$50&*"6*0*"
25(60$$),$0")85"'a"5"0*2&52\)&5")*'",$2&'M$'-")5'" ]/\E5'"$")*"'5%/785",5'"605F%$(*'-"
(*'" 4*(F`("5'" 6052$''5'" 25N)&4&;5'" $" ,$" 25)[$2&($)45-" K/$" $'485" 60$''/65'45'" )5"
0*2&52\)&5" K/$" %$;*" *5'" 0$'/%4*,5'W" X" 4$50&*" ,$'20$;$" *" 0$'5%/785",$" 605F%$(*'" 25(5"
/(*"&)4$0*785"$)40$"5"'&'4$(*",$"6052$''*($)45",$" &)L50(*785"Q$)K/*)45"'5%/2&5)*@
,50",$"605F%$(*'R"$"/(*"*785W"I"25)]/)45",5"6052$''5",$"0$'5%/785",$"605F%$(*'"65,$"
'$0"*)*%&'*,5"25(5",5&'"'/F6052$''5'"Q25(60$$)'85"$"6052/0*R"K/$"52500$("'&(/%4*)$@
*($)4$W"X"0$'5%/785",5"605F%$(*C"52500$"K/*),5"*"6$''5*"K/$"6052$''*"*"&)L50(*785"*"
40*,/E")/("605F%$(*-"$"$)485-"6052/0*"/("2*(&)[5"6*0*"$)25)40*0"/(*"'*\,*"QO*x%50-"
!AAARW" S'4$" 6052$''5" 60$''/6M$" K/$" 5" '&'4$(*" ,$" 6052$''*($)45" ,$" &)L50(*785" $"""""
,$2&'85" " "[/(*)*"65,$"'$0"'$6*0*,5"$(",5&'"25(65)$)4$'n"($(a0&*"*"2/045"$" %5)N5"
60*E5W" +$(a0&*" *" 2/045" 60*E5" K/$" *25%[$" *" &)L50(*785" ,$" $'4\(/%5'" )$2$''P0&*" *5"""
�,$'F%5K/$*($)45�" ,5" 25)[$2&($)45" L*24/*%" Q'$(i)4&2*R" $" $Z6$0&($)4*%" Q$6&'a,&25R-"
N/*0,*,5'")*"($(a0&*",$"%5)N5"60*E5"Q9*0)$;*%&"$4"*%-"C=?BRW""
d*"%&)[*"4$a0&2*",$"6052$''*($)45",$"&)L50(*785"*"&)4$0L*2$"$)40$"$'4$'",5&'"*0K/&;5'"
,$" &)L50(*785" 25N)&4&;*" L5&"(5,$%*,*"$("$'40*4`N&*'" L*'$*,*'-" 2/]*"$'6$2&L&2&,*,$"$"
)Y($05",$"L*'$'",&L$0$"$)40$"5'"&);$'4&N*,50$'-")*"4$)4*4&;*",$"'&(6%&L&2*0"5"6052$''5W"
X" 25(65)$)4$" 25(60$$)'85" L5&" ,$L&)&,*" $" )50(*%&E*,*" 25(5" /(*" 60&($&0*" L*'$-"""
)5($*,*"25(5"25%[$&4*",$",*,5'-"*"25(65)$)4$",*"6052/0*"6*''5/"*"'$0",$L&)&,*"650"
/("25)]/)45",$"L*'$'"QO[5(6'5)"m"V5r,&)N-"C===_"S%'4$&)"m"g50,*N$-"C===RW"!"#$%&'$
!"#$%#%$&'()*+,&,#!',&')$+!,#&-.)'$&/+),&0'()"',)!"#$%"&'("#$&'$')*'+%,-'%$#".+'$
!"#$%#&'$%( )$"*'+,-$#%.( "*%!"( -"/01/( ,%0( 2/"( 3+*$#"( 4$5%-1-$#%@!"!#$%&'() *+,%-.)!!!
!"#$%#&'%( #%)( #$*"'"+,")( -$./,")")( #$%0+/),$1%)( 23"( )"( .&#$%!( 1&4&1%'( "( 23"( ,5!(
!"#$%&'(#!)*$+#*+,"-*.*+.%+.%!)$/"0+"
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""C"A resolução de problema é aqui entendida como uma estruturação do problema e não como a fase final
da sua resolução."
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
HB""
X4`"*5'"*)5'"5&4$)4*"5"(5,$%5"[&654`4&25@,$,/4&;5-"25("50&N$(")*"($,&2&)*-"L5&"4&,5"
25(5"5"(5,$%5"(*&'" &)L%/$)4$")*" 45(*,*",$",$2&'85" 4$a0&2*",*'"$)L$0($&0*'" QU5)$'"
C=??-"9*0)$;*%&"m"O[5(*'"C==GRW"I"(5,$%5"0$25)[$2$",5&'"4&65'",$"0*2&52\)&5n"&),/785-"
)*"0$25%[*",$",*,5'"K/$"%$;*"b"605,/785",$"[&6a4$'$'-"$",$,/785-"$("K/$"*'"[&6a4$@
'$'" '85" /'*,*'" 6*0*" 60$;$0" *" 60$'$)7*" 5/" */'1)2&*" ,$" ,*,5'" K/$" 5'" 2%\)&25'" ,$65&'"
6052/0*(-",$"(*)$&0*"*"25)L&0(*0"5/")85-"*'"[&6a4$'$'W""
c*0*" 350,5)" QC=?BR" *'" $)L$0($&0*'" 25($7*(" 5" 6052$''5" ,$" $);5%;&($)45" 25(" /(*"
0$25%[*" ,$" ,*,5'W" d*" L*'$" &)&2&*%" $'4$'" '85" *2$&4$'" 4*%" 25(5" 5" ,5$)4$" 5'" *60$'$)4*W"""""
X%N/)'",$%$'"'85",*,5'"(/&45"6$04&)$)4$'-"5/405'")$("4*)45"5/"*4`"($'(5"&00$%$;*)4$'-"
6$02$785"K/$"`"4&,*",$"L50(*"0P6&,*"$")/("60&($&05"25)4*245W"!"#$%&'!"#"$%&%'()*+)'&,%
!"#$%&'()"()*(+&+)*(),-$+)*(.)*(/0$1#$0)*(1$."-)*(+#($.-#0&23)(4)1()(+)#.-#(*3)(*"5!"
!"#$%#&'()*+*(#&%*,#-#!#+(*-./0*&(1")2%#&#&(3"*.$2&%"!*&4(5&%*&(1")2%#&#&(#&%67(+#-*!"!"
!"#"$%&'(%'$%#"#'$%)*&'+,-#'$%*%"%-!.')("/0'%!"%(*(1)-"%#*%&2)3'%4)!"#$!!"#$%&'("#$
!"#$%#&!"'(#)"#&#*+&,+-'+&'+.#(#$".$"#&"&"#$*+&/-($+&!",".!".$"#&!+&'+.$"0$+1&.+&2-%3&
!"#$%$!"#"&!#'(')'%*+,(-,#.,/),0'$!"1#2#)!(3,/45()'%6#.%/%#%*47("#$%$!"#,+#.%/-')7*%/#,#
!" #$%&'()*" +#" *',-!(" .-#!(/" %*0123'-!@!"# $%&'(!# )"*"!+# (,"-(!# ./$/! !"#$ %&'!#()*$!!!!
!"#$%&'&()*"*+%&,%-*,"./&"0"@!"#$%$"&%"#!%'$"()"'$**+,+-+(!()*")"&%")*.$/0$"()"/!"
!"#$%&'%()*+*,-&!%&./%'011%&!*-()21+*'%3&!"#$%&'(")&"*+,-.&/&/"0'+1)1/"2"3&'14%&#.&"
!"#$%&'()!)*+%)*,%!-().$%$#&'(/)0")'&'(")-!1(.2$'(")"3()$*#!-4-!#&'(")'+-!"#$%!%&!'$%
!"# "$%&'&()*# +# ,"# -".+/*0&1"()*# !+'.+'2# $%+0# '+3"4# -*,5&04"!*'2# 0+3+&."!*'# *%# ,)*#!!!!
!"#$%&'()*+,)%)+)+-&,.$/0/+&#&!&)12+3,.0+)+!)$/4"%&5)67"8+)+9)0/+9&#)18+:/+);)1&)67"8+0(4/%/+
!"#$ %$ #&'#()#*(%$ +%&,#(#$ %-$ +(.-$ #$ %-$ /%&0(1$ ,#$ /1,1$ 120#(&10*314! !"#"$ %&%'()*+,$!!!!
!"#$%&"%'()*+("%#,-."/()(0)$%(1)2,/32"-("0(14567,(!)%("2$!85#$)%9"
X" '$K/1)2&*" FP'&2*" ,$'4$" (5,$%5" L5&" /'*,*" 25(5" '/6504$" ,$" /(" 5/405" $'K/$(*""""""
,$'$);5%;&,5"9*0)$;*%&"QC=?BRW"S'4*"*/450*",$'20$;$"%&)$*0($)4$"/("6052$''5",$"'$4$"
L*'$'" ,$" ,&*N)a'4&25-" 650K/$" '/F,&;&,$" *'" L*'$'" ]P" ,$'20&4*'n" QCR" 25%[$&4*" ,$" ,*,5'"""
60`;&*" *5" $)25)405" 25(" 5" ,5$)4$" Q!R" *;*%&*785" ,5'" 60&($&05'" ,*,5'" QGR" 25%[$&4*" ,$""
,*,5'" )*" &)4$0*785" 25(" 5" ,5$)4$" $" 25(" 5/40*'" L5)4$'" ,$" ,*,5'" QBR" *60$'$)4*" *'"""""
60&($&0*'"[&6a4$'$'",$",&*N)a'4&25"QHR";*%&,*"5/"0$]$&4*"*'"[&6a4$'$'"25(")5;5'",*,5'"
QDR"4$'4*"*"[&6a4$'$",$",&*N)a'4&25"(*&'"*]/'4*,*"b"'&4/*785",5",5$)4$"Q>R",&*N)a'4&25W"
T$"&'45")85"*25)4$2$0"5"605F%$(*",$;$"'$0"0$&)&2&*,5"*4`"K/$"*";$0&L&2*785",*"[&6a4$'$"
'$]*"*%2*)7*,*"Q9*0)$;*%&"$4"*%-C=?B_"O[5(6'5)"m"V5r,&)N-"C===RW"c50`("*"'$K/1)2&*"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
HH""
%&)$*0",5"(5,$%5"[&654`4&25@,$,/4&;5")$("'$(60$"`"5F'$0;*,*")*"60P4&2*"Q95)2500*)"
c$00x"$4"*%-"C===R-"650K/$"5'"$)L$0($&05'"L0$K/$)4$($)4$-"'5F0$6M$("L*'$'"$"(/,*("
*"'/*"50,$("QO[5(6'5)-"C===RW"I'"$'4/,5'",$"Qg$))$0-C=?B_"V5$)N$'"m"+550[5/'$-"
!AAG-".56$'-"!AAD-"T&((5)'"!ACAR-" 0$;$%*("K/$"5"6052$''5"`" &)4$0*4&;5-" 0$2/0'&;5"$"
$'4P"&(F/\,5")*"60a60&*"*785-"$")/(*"0$%*785"485"60aZ&(*"K/$"'$"450)*",&L\2&%"6$02$F$0"
5),$"25($7*"/(*"L*'$"$"*2*F*"*"5/40*W""
"X"'&4/*785"2%\)&2*",5'",5$)4$'"65,$"4$0"(/,*)7*'"0P6&,*'-"650"&)'4*F&%&,*,$"[$(5,&@
)i(&2*"K/$"$Z&N$("/(*" 45(*,*",$",$2&'85" &)4$%&N$)4$"650"6*04$",*'" $)L$0($&0*'" $"
$(" 2/045" $'6*75" ,$" 4$(65" Q30$$)r55,-" C==?_" g/2y)*%%-" !AAARW" X" K/*)4&,*,$" ,$"""""
&)L50(*785" ,&'65)\;$%" '5F0$" 2*,*" ,5$)4$-" $(" *(F&$)4$" 0$*%-" `" N$0*%($)4$" %&(&4*,*"
*(F\N/*" $" 0$,/),*)4$-" 5" K/$" L*E" 25(" K/$" 5'" $)L$0($&05'" 4$)[*(" ,&L&2/%,*,$'" $("
65),$0*0"'5F0$"45,*'"*'"*%4$0)*4&;*'"65''\;$&'W"X%`(",&''5-")$("45,*'"*'"*%4$0)*4&;*'"
'85"6*''\;$&'",$"'$0$("K/*)4&L&2*,*'")/(*"L50(*"K/$"'$]*"6*''\;$%",$"'$0"25(60$$)@
,&,*W"c*0*"g$))$0"$4"*%W"Q!ACCR-"*",$2&'85"2%\)&2*"$);5%;$"/(*"*F50,*N$("605N0$''&;*"
(*&'",5"K/$"/("6052$''5" L50(*%",$"*)P%&'$W"X'"($(a0&*'"/'*,*'" 25(5"'/6504$",5'"
(5,$%5'"*)*%\4&25'"'85"Y4$&'"6*0*"5'"2%\)&25'-"(*'"$%*'")85"'85"'/L&2&$)4$'"6*0*"N/&*0"*"
60P4&2*W"S"/(*"F5*"60P4&2*"2%\)&2*"0$K/$0"(*&'",5"K/$",$2&'M$'W"
:(*" *F50,*N$(" 605N0$''&;*" 6$0(&4$" K/$" *'" N0*),$'" $" ,&L\2$&'" ,$2&'M$'" 65''*(" '$0"
L0*4/0*,*'" $(" '$K/1)2&*'" ,$" 6$K/$)*'" $'25%[*'-" 2*,*" /(*",*'" K/*&'" 65,$" '$0" L$&4*"
25("F*'$")/(*"K/*)4&,*,$"0$%*4&;*($)4$"%&(&4*,*",$"&)L50(*785W"I"K/$"'&N)&L&2*"K/$"
5"6052$''5",$"6%*)$*($)45"K/*),5"`"&)4$005(6&,5-"25(5"`"L0$K/$)4$"*25)4$2$0")*'"
'&4/*7M$'" 2%\)&2*'-" 65,$" '$0" '/'6$)'5" $" K/*),5" *'" 25),&7M$'" 5" 6$0(&4$(-" 65,$" '$0"
0$2/6$0*,5"$",$'$);5%;&,5" Q30$$)r55,-"C==?RW"X'",$2&'M$'")85"65,$("'$0" 45(*,*'"
,$"/(*"L50(*"%&)$*0-")85"'a"6$%*"25),&785"2%\)&2*",5",5$)4$-"6$%*'"2*0*24$0\'4&2*'",5'"
25)4$Z45'"2%\)&25'-"(*'" 4*(F`("6$%*'"2*0*24$0\'4&2*'",5",$2&'50"K/$")85"`" &)'$)'\;$%"
)$("*5"6052$''5")$("*5"0$'/%4*,5",*",$2&'85"Qg05r)-"!ACARW""
I'" (5,$%5'" )50(*4&;5'" $" *F'40*45'-" 2$)40*,5'" )5'" 0$'/%4*,5'-" 41(" (*)4&,5" *" '/*"""
;&N1)2&*"4$a0&2*W"g$))$0"$4"*%"QC==DR-"0$L$0$("K/$"$Z&'4$("K/*405",&($)'M$'"$'40/4/@
0*)4$'-" K/$" *65&*(" /(*" ,$6$),1)2&*" 25)4\)/*" ,$''$'"(5,$%5'" 25(5" F*'$" ,$" /(*"
,$2&'85"`4&2*"$"2%\)&2*n"Q&R"*")$2$''&,*,$",$",$'$);5%;$0"0$N0*'"]/'4*'"$"$K/&4*4&;*'-"K/$"
65''*(" '$0" *6%&2*,*'" &(6*02&*%($)4$" *" 45,*'" *'" 6$''5*'" $" '&4/*7M$'" 2%\)&2*'_" Q&&R" 5"""
,$'$]5" ,$" ,$'$);5%;$0" '&'4$(*'" 0*2&5)*&'-" F*'$*,5'" )/(" '&'4$(*" ,$" ,*,5'" 2/]*"""""""
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
HD""
0$%*785" 2/'45^F$)$L\2&5" 605(5;*"/(*" ]/'4&7*" ,&'40&F/4&;*" $" 0$,/E*" 5" N*'45" $Z2$''&;5"
$(" 40*4*($)45'" &)$L&2*E$'_" Q&&&R" /(*" 25(60$$)'85" $6&'4$(5%aN&2*" ,*" 0*2&5)*%&,*,$-"
5),$"*'"$'25%[*'"'85"L$&4*'"650"565'&785"$)40$",$2&'M$'"2$04*'"$"$00*,*'-"F*'$*,*'")5"
,$'$);5%;&($)45" ,$" 20&4`0&5'" K/$" *]/\E*(" '5F0$" *" *,$K/*785^&)*,$K/*785" ,$" ,/*'"
65'&7M$'" ,&L$0$)2&*,*'" $" $Z6%\2&4*'-" (*'" $'40$&4*'-" $)40$" *" $Z6%*)*785" 2&$)4\L&2*" $" 5""
0&N50",5'"'$/'"0$'/%4*,5'_"Q&;R"5"(5;&($)45"$(",&0$785"*"/("$)4$),&($)45",*"'*Y,$"
25(5" '$0;&75'-" ,$" 4*%" L50(*" K/$" 5'" 40*4*($)45'" '85" 25($02&*%($)4$" *;*%&*,5'" $"""""
6*N5'-"$)K/*)45"5"2/&,*,5-"*"*4$)785"$"*"0$2/6$0*785"'a"(*0N&)*%($)4$"'85"25)'&,$@
0*,5'-")5'"'&'4$(*'",$"25)4*F&%&,*,$"$")5",&'2/0'5"65%\4&25"$"6YF%&25"'5F0$"2/&,*,5'",$"
'*Y,$W"I'"(`45,5'",$"6$'K/&'*-"*''52&*,5'"b")50(*4&;&,*,$",5'"(5,$%5'"*F0$(@'$"b"
65''&F&%&,*,$",$"2*4$N50&E*0-"$Z6%&2*0"$"60$,&E$0"0$'65'4*'"[/(*)*'W""
d*'"Y%4&(*'",`2*,*'"$'4$'"(`45,5'" 41("'&,5"*"F*'$",5"25)[$2&($)45"2&$)4\L&25"K/$"
4$("N$0*,5" 4$50&*" $" 41("*%&($)4*,5" *" &(*N&)*785" ,5'" *2*,`(&25'" ,$" $)L$0(*N$(-"
650K/$"5'"(5,$%5'-"*''&("N$0*,5'-")85"41("'/'4$)4*785"$(6\0&2*")*"P0$*"2%\)&2*-"6$%*"
'/*" 0$25)[$2&,*" 25(6%$Z&,*,$" Qg$))$0" $4" *%-" C==D_" O*))$0-" !AAHRW" I" 6052$''5" ,$""""
2/&,*,5'"`"50&$)4*,5"650"/(*"$'40/4/0*"2*6*E",$"2*64*0"*"&),&;&,/*%&,*,$"25)20$4*",*"
$Z6$0&1)2&*" ,$" '*Y,$" $" $'40/4/0*,5" *" 6*04&0" ,*" 25(6%$Z&,*,$" ,*" '&4/*785" 2%\)&2*W" X""
0&K/$E*" )*" 25(60$$)'85" ,*" $Z6$0&1)2&*" [/(*)*" ,$" '*Y,$" $" )*" 0$'65'4*" *" $%*" )85"""
6*''*"650"/("6052$''5"*)*%\4&25"$"*F'40*45"(*'"'&("6$%5"25)[$2&($)45"6*04&2/%*0",5"
,5$)4$"Q5'"'$/'"60a60&5'"6*,0M$'",$"0$'65'4*-"*"'/*"[&'4a0&*-"*"'/*"L50(*",$";&;$0"25("
*",5$)7*R"$"*&),*"6$%5"25)[$2&($)45"2%\)&25"K/$"'$"N*)[*"6$%*"$Z6$0&1)2&*",$"2/&,*0"
(/&4*'"6$''5*'"25("'&4/*7M$'"'&(&%*0$'"Qg$))$0"$4"*%-"C==D_"O*))$0-"!AAHRW"X"25(60$@
$)'85",$'4$"6052$''5"*65&*@'$")/("5/405"(5,5",$"25N)&785-"&W$W"*"&)4/&785"QV5r,&)N"
$4" *%-" !AA=R-")/(*" 0*2&5)*%&,*,$",$%&F$0*4&;*C-" )/(*",&'65'&785"6*0*"5"K/$"`"F5("$"
2$045-")*"'*F$,50&*"60P4&2*"*,K/&0&,*"25("*"$Z6$0&1)2&*-")5"$);5%;&($)45"25("*"'&4/*@
785"$"5"25)[$2&($)45",5",5$)4$"$("6*04&2/%*0-"25("5"K/*%"4$("K/$"$'4*0"$("'&)45)&*"
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""1"Na racionalidade deliberativa, a regra formal delibera até ao ponto em que os prováveis benefícios para
melhorar o planeamento valem o tempo e o esforço de reflexão utilizado. O processo de decisão não é um
fim em si mesmo. O bem como racionalidade [goodness as rationality] não atribui qualquer valor especi-
al ao processo de decisão (Rouanet, in: Benner et al, 2011)."
"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
H>""
6*0*" 0$25)[$2$0" 5" '$/" 6*,085" [*F&4/*%" ,$" 0$'65'4*'-" *40*;`'" ,*'" )*00*4&;*'" ,*" '/*""
$Z6$0&1)2&*",*",5$)7*"Qg$))$0"$4"*%-C==DRW""
X")5785",5"K/$"`"F5("$"2$045"6*0*"$'4*'"*/450*'")85"`"/("4$(*",$"`4&2*"&),&;&,/*%-"`"
*)4$'"/(*"25)'40/785"'52&*%($)4$"$(F/4&,*")*",&'2&6%&)*-"25(5"'$"L5''$"/(*")50(*"$"
/(" 25'4/($" ,$" /(*" K/*%K/$0" /)&,*,$-" )*" K/*%" 5'" $)L$0($&05'" $Z$02$(" *'" '/*'""""""
60P4&2*'W"+*'" &'45")85"`"/("60&)2\6&5"FP'&25-" )5" '$)4&,5",$" 0$N0*"5/"60$2$&45"K/$"5"
$)L$0($&05" 25)'&N*" 450)*0" $Z6%\2&45" $" K/$" *25)4$2$(" ,$" L50(*" N$)$0*%&E*,*" )*'""""""
'&4/*7M$'W"XK/&%5"K/$"`"F5("450)*@'$";&'\;$%")*'"*7M$'",5'"$)L$0($&05'"$("'&4/*7M$'"
6*04&2/%*0$'W"c50"$Z$(6%5"*"&)4$)785",$"[/(*)&E*0"$"6$0'5)*%&E*0"5'"2/&,*,5'-"*"`4&2*"
6*0*" $'2%*0$2$0" 5'" ,5$)4$'" $" L*(&%&*0$'-" *''&(" 25(5" *" &(6504i)2&*" ,$" 25)L504*0" $("
L*2$"*"/("$Z40$(5"'5L0&($)45"5/"/(*"(504$"&(&)$)4$_"4/,5"*K/&%5"K/$";*&"'$0")54*,5"
)/(*"'&4/*785"2%\)&2*"$"2/]*'"0$'65'4*'"'85"$'6$2\L&2*'",5'"$)L$0($&05'W"
g$))$0"QC=?BR"$"g$))$0"$4"*%"QC==D_"!ACCR-"6&5)$&0*'")*"(/,*)7*",$"25(6504*($)45"
25(5"&);$'4&N*,50*'"*''/(&0*(")5;5'"25)4$Z45'"$"5F]$45'",$"&);$'4&N*785W"95)40&F/\@
0*(-" ,$" L50(*" '/'4$)4*,*-" 6*0*" 5" 0$25)[$2&($)45" ,*" ,&($)'85" 60P4&2*" ,5" 25)[$2&@
($)45" $(" $)L$0(*N$(" $" 6*0*" 5" 0$25)[$2&($)45" ,*" L50(*" 25(5" 5'" $)L$0($&05'""""
/4&%&E*("5"25)[$2&($)45-"6*0*"50&$)4*0"*"'/*"45(*,*",$",$2&'85-"$)K/*)45"0$*%&E*("5"
6052$''5",$"2/&,*,5'W"d5"'$/"Y%4&(5"40*F*%[5"*'"*/450*'-")/(*"*F50,*N$("&),/4&;*"$"
,$'20&4&;*"40*)'6504*(@)5'"6*0*"/(*")5;*"25(60$$)'85",*"$''1)2&*",*"$)L$0(*N$("$"
,5!6$)'*($)45"52/%45",5'"]/\E5'"2%\)&25'"$"45(*,*",$",$2&'M$'W"V$")5;5-"'$("0$,/E&0"
5'"2/&,*,5'"*"60&)2\6&5'")$("6052/0*0" 450)*0" LP2&%" *" '/*"*60$),&E*N$(-")5($*0*("$"
,$L&)&0*("5'"25)2$&45'"*"6*04&0",$"/("4$(65"0$*%-"(5($)45"*"(5($)45-")5"25)4$Z45-"
$"25("45,*'"*'"25(6%&2*7M$'"K/$"65,$("'$0"$)25)40*,*'"$("'&4/*7M$'"0$*&'W""
X'"&);$'4&N*,50*'"*2&(*"2&4*,*'"0$2/6$0*0*("*"$Z60$''85",$"T&(5)"@"*"0$'5%/785",5'"
605F%$(*'" 0$'/%4*" ,*" [*F&%&,*,$" &),&;&,/*%" 6*0*" '$" *,*64*0" b'" %&(&4*7M$'-" $" )5""""
($'(5"'$)4&,5"'*%&$)4*("K/$"*"0$'5%/785",5'"605F%$(*'")85"*,;`(",*"/4&%&E*785",$"
4`2)&2*'" $'6$2\L&2*'" (*'" ,*" '*F$,50&*" K/$" 2*0*24$0&E*" 5'" 60P4&25'W" c50" &''5" $%*'"""""
25)2$)40*0*(@'$")*'"[*F&%&,*,$'"5/"$'40*4`N&*'"K/$"5'"$)L$0($&05'"/'*("6*0*"L*E$0"
]/\E5'"2%\)&25'"'&'4$(P4&25'W""
X"25(60$$)'85"2%\)&2*"`"2$)40*%"$("45,5"5"6052$''5"K/$"25($7*"25("*"6$02$6785"$"
&)2%/&"*"&,$)4&L&2*785",5"605F%$(*"25("/("]/\E5"2%\)&25"*2$02*",*'"40*)'&7M$'"$'6$2\L&@
2*'" ,$" 2*,*" /(" ,5'" ,5$)4$'-" *5" %5)N5" ,5" 4$(65W" S'4*" 25(60$$)'85" 4$(" K/*405""""""
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
H?""
/)&,*,$'",$"'&N)&L&2*785"K/$"&)2%/$(n"QCR"L*E$0",&'4&)7M$'"K/*%&4*4&;*'"Q!R-"$);5%;$0@'$"
)/("40*F*%[5",$",$4$4&;$"QGR-"0$25)[$2$0"*"0$%$;i)2&*",*"(/,*)7*-"$"QBR"5",$'$);5%@
;&($)45",$"25)[$2&($)45"2%\)&25"$("656/%*7M$'"$'6$2\L&2*'",$",5$)4$'W""
X'" ,&'4&)7M$'" 2%\)&2*'" 'a" 65,$(" '$0" L$&4*'" *6$)*'" )/(*" '&4/*785" 25)4$Z4/*%&E*,*" $""
)/(*"[&'4a0&*" 2%\)&2*" 6*04&2/%*0W"I" 25)4$Z45" $" *" '$K/1)2&*" ,$" $;$)45'" '85" $''$)2&*&'"
6*0*"L*E$0",&'4&)7M$'"K/*%&4*4&;*'"$-"6504*)45-"5"2%\)&25",$;$"$'4*0"*4$)45"b'"40*)'&7M$'"
)*'"'&4/*7M$'"$"*5'"]/\E5'"2%\)&25'"'5F0$"$%*'W"+/&4*'",*'",&'4&)7M$'"K/*%&4*4&;*'"65,$("
'$0" L$&4*'" *6$)*'" 6$%*" 5F'$0;*785" $" 6$%5" /'5" ,5" 25)[$2&($)45" '$)'a0&5@(5450"
Qj*'[544$"m"9*0)$;*%$-"!AABRW"c5,$("'$0"0$25)[$2&,*'",&L$0$)7*'"*40*;`'",5"45K/$-",*"
6*%6*785" *F,5(&)*%-" ,5" '5(" ,*'" '/27M$'" 5/" ,5" 0$'6&0*0-" ,*" 250" ,*" 6$%$" $" ,*" '/*""""""
45)&2&,*,$",*'"2*0*24$0\'4&2*'",$"/(*" L$0&,*-" 250-" '&)*&'" &)L%*(*4a0&5'-"5/"*" '/*" L507*"
*)\(&2*-" $)40$" 5/405'" '&)*&'" ,*" %&)N/*N$(" ,5" 25065W" :(*" '$N/),*" 60560&$,*,$" `"""""
0$;$%*,*"6$%*" 2*6*2&,*,$",$" '$"$);5%;$0")/(" 40*F*%[5",$",$4$4&;$-"650K/$"*'" '&4/*@
7M$'" 2%\)&2*'" )85" 41(" L&(" $" '85" &),$4$0(&)*,*'W" I" K/$" &(6%&2*" 4$0" /(" 6$)'*($)45"
*,$K/*,5" *5"&+:D3) +-$%'":8" ,$" $)L$0($&05" $" 0$'5%;$0" 605F%$(*'" 2%\)&25'" 25(5" '$"
L5''$(" 6/EE%$'W" I" 6$)'*($)45" ,$"&+:D3) +-$%'":8" *25(6*)[*" 5" ,5$)4$-" 5" (5,5"""
25(5"*"'/*",5$)7*"'$",$'$);5%;$-"5"'&N)&L&2*,5",*'"'/*'" 0$'65'4*'-")/(*"'$K/1)2&*"
4$(650*%"$"6*04&2/%*0W"d$'4$"0*2&52\)&5@$(@40*)'&785"'85" &,$)4&L&2*,5'"5'"N*)[5'"$"*'"
6$0,*'" $" L$&45'" 5'" ,$;&,5'" *]/'4*($)45'" )*" *F50,*N$(" *5" 605F%$(*W" d$'4$"&+:D3)
+-$%'":8"`" &(6504*)4$"0$L%$4&0"'5F0$"*'",$2&'M$'"K/$"L50*("45(*,*'"$";*%&,*,*'"$"5'"
0$'/%4*,5'"K/$"4&;$0*("5/")85"4&;$0*(")5",5$)4$W"V0$xL/'"m"V0$xL/'"QC==DR"2[*(*(@
%[$"0$N0*'",$"5/05"*,K/&0&,*'")5'"$)'&)5'"2%\)&25'"$")*"$Z6$0&1)2&*"605L&''&5)*%W":(*"
4$02$&0*" 60560&$,*,$" ,5" 25)2$&45" `" *" 2*6*2&,*,$" ,$" 0$25)[$2$0" (/,*)7*'" 2%\)&2*'""
0$%$;*)4$'" )5'" ,5$)4$'-" 25)'&,$0*),5" K/$" 5'" '&N)&L&2*,5'" ,5'" '&)*&'" $" '&)45(*'" '85"
*%4$0*,5'-" 6$%*" '$K/1)2&*" ,*" [&'4a0&*" ,5" ,5$)4$W" j$25)[$2$0" $" 25(60$$),$0" $'4*'""
(/,*)7*'"65,$",&0$2&5)*0"$"*%4$0*0"*"0$%$;i)2&*",5'"L*245'"5F'$0;*,5'",$"/(*"'&4/*@
785"6*04&2/%*0W"S"650"L&("`"4*(F`("&(6504*)4$"6*0*"5"6052$''5",$"25(60$$)'85"2%\)&2*"
,$'$);5%;$0" 25)[$2&($)45" 2%\)&25" 25(" 656/%*7M$'" $'6$2\L&2*'" ,$" ,5$)4$'W" T85" *'"""
%5)N*'" $" ,/0*,5/0*'" $Z6$0&1)2&*'" 25(" /(*" 656/%*785" $'6$2\L&2*" ,$" ,5$)4$'-" 25(""
%$'M$'" 5/" ,5$)7*'" '&)N/%*0$'-" K/$" 6$0(&4$("K/$" 5" 2%\)&25" L*7*" 25(6*0*7M$'-" ,&'4&)@
7M$'"$"*2$)4/$"*'",&L$0$)7*'",$)405",$"/(*"($'(*"656/%*785W"X'"25(6*0*7M$'"$)40$"
,5$)4$'-" 25(" '&4/*7M$'" (/&45" $'6$2\L&2*'-" 20&*(" /(*" F*'$" ,$" 25(6*0*785" 6*0*" 5'""
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
H=""
2%\)&25'-"*''&("25(5-"/("25)]/)45" 4P2&45",$"$Z6$24*4&;*'-"K/$"`"20&*,5"6$%5" 40*F*%[5"
,$",$4$4&;$-"$'6$2\L&25"6*0*"*"656/%*785"$"$'6$2\L&25"6*0*"5",5$)4$-"'$"$%$")85"*60$@
'$)4*0" *'" /'/*&'" $" 60$;&'\;$&'" 40*)'&7M$'" )*" 0$2/6$0*785W" c50" $Z$(6%5-" $)L$0($&05'"
25("$Z6$0&1)2&*"$("2/&,*0",5$)4$'"25(",&*F$4$'"65,$(",$4$0(&)*0"'$"*"25),&785",5"
,5$)4$" `" $'4P;$%-" *5" 25)40P0&5" ,$" $)L$0($&05'" 25(" $Z6$0&1)2&*" $(" 2/&,*0" ,5$)4$'""
2&0Y0N&25'W"I'"25)[$2&($)45'"60$$Z&'4$)4$'"$"5'")5;5'"K/$"50&$)4*("5"L525",$"*4$)785"
,5" $)L$0($&05" *%4$0*(@'$" K/*),5" 52500$(" (/,*)7*'" *5" K/$" $0*" 60$;&'\;$%" )*""""""""
25),&785"2%\)&2*",5",5$)4$W""
95("5"4$(65-"5"2%\)&25",$'$);5%;$"/("605L/),5"5'BK(%+D":"$"25(60$$)'85"K/$"%[$"
6$0(&4$" 4$0" 25(6$41)2&*'" ,$" *;*%&*785" ,&*N)a'4&2*'" $" ,$" &)4$0;$)785" 25(" 6$0\2&*W""
d$'4$")\;$%",$"605L&2&1)2&*"5'"$)L$0($&05'"'85"2*6*E$'"&)4/&4&;*($)4$",$"'*F$0"5"K/$"
L*E$0" $" 0*6&,*($)4$" 0$25)[$2$0$("5'" *'6$45'" 20\4&25'",*" '&4/*785W"I'"$'L5075'"6*0*"
*,K/&0&0" 25(6$41)2&*" ,$"6$0\2&*" F$)$L&2&*(",$"/(*"(5)&450&E*785" 25)4\)/*-" 6%*)$*@
($)45"$"*;*%&*785"0$405'6$4&;*W"+*'"4*(F`(",*"2*6*2&,*,$"&),&;&,/*%",$"/'*0"*"&)4/&@
785"5/"25)[$2&($)45'"*,K/&0&,5'"*40*;`'",*'" &)4$0*7M$'"25("5'",5$)4$'W"I'"2%\)&25'"
25(" 6$0\2&*" ]/)4*(" b" '/*" '$)'&F&%&,*,$" 6$02$64&;*" *" '*F$,50&*" ,*" 60P4&2*" 2%\)&2*-" *'"
25(6$41)2&*'",$"0*2&52\)&5"2%\)&25-"K/$"$Z&N$("6$)'*0"'5F0$"*"'&4/*785"6*04&2/%*0",5'"
,&L$0$)4$'",5$)4$'" *5" %5)N5",5" 4$(65-"5" 25)[$2&($)45" 4P2&45"$" *'"[*F&%&,*,$'"6*0*"
L*E$0",&'4&)7M$'"K/*%&4*4&;*'")*'"'&4/*7M$'"6*04&2/%*0$'",5'",5$)4$'W""
I'"6052$''5'"K/$";$$("'$),5",$'20&45'"25(5"(5,$%5'"'85"0$60$'$)4*7M$'"'&(Fa%&2*'"
,5'"L$)a($)5'"K/$"5F]$4&;*("0$60$'$)4*0"/(*",$4$0(&)*,*"6$0'6$4&;*"'$]*("$%$'",$"
)*4/0$E*" 4$a0&2*" Q)85",&0$4*($)4$"5F'$0;P;$&'R-"5/"$(6\0&25'" Q0`6%&2*'",$"/(*" 0$*%&@
,*,$"5F'$0;P;$%RW"S%$'"$'6$%[*(",&L$0$)4$'";&'M$'"K/$"41("*25(6*)[*,5"5",$'$);5%@
;&($)45",*"$)L$0(*N$(W":(*";&'85"0$2$F&,*"5/"25)[$2&($)45"0$2$F&,5"*L&0(*"K/$"*"
;$0,*,$" 2500$'65),$"b"5F'$0;*785-" b" 0$,/785-" b" ;$0&L&2*785-" *5" 25)405%$" $" b" 2&1)2&*"
%&;0$",$"6*02&*%&,*,$W"VP"1)L*'$"b'"La0(/%*'"(*4$(P4&2*'"6*0*"$Z6%&2*0"5'"L$)a($)5'"$"
60$L$0$",&2545(&*'"'&(6%$'"$"2%*''&L&2*785",$"25)2$&45'W"c$%5"25)40P0&5"*";&'85"6$02$F&@
,*"L52*@'$")*'",$'20&7M$'"K/$",$0&;*(",*'"$Z6$0&1)2&*'";&;$)2&*,*'",$"L50(*"25%$4&;*-"
*";$0,*,$"`-"650")*4/0$E*-"[&'4a0&2*-"25)4$Z4/*%"$"2*00$N*,*",$";*%50W"d85"$Z&'4$"/(*"
'a";$0,*,$W"I"25)[$2&($)45"`"25)'&,$0*,5";$0,*,$&05"K/*),5"0$'&'4$"*5'"4$'4$'"60P4&@
25'",$"/4&%&,*,$"$"0*E85"Q+$%$&'"!AAH-".56$'-"!AAD_"+2Sr$)"m"o&%%'-"!AA=RW"c$)'*(5'"
K/$" *(F*'" 65,$(" '$0" Y4$&'-" $(" L/)785" ,*" 25)2$64/*%&E*785" ,*" $)L$0(*N$(" K/$" `"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
DA""
/'*,*W":(*"P0$*"K/$" %&,*" 25("5" 25065"$"*" '/*";&;1)2&*-" 2/]*" 0$%*785"`",$" &)4$0*785"
(Y4/*-"6$)'*(5'"K/$"65,$"'$0"Y4&%"5"6%/0*%&'(5"4$a0&25"$"($45,5%aN&25W"d5"$)4*)45"
$("*%N/)'"*'6$45'"*"$)L$0(*N$("6*0$2$"$'4*0"*&),*"&),$2&'*W"
<"650"L507*",*"&),$2&'85"4$a0&2*"$"($45,5%aN&2*"K/$"'$"4$("5F'$0;*,5"/(*"25)405@
;`0'&*-"0$'6$&4P;$%-"$)40$"5",$'$);5%;&($)45",5'"(5,$%5'"K/$";&'*("5F4$0"0$'/%4*,5'"
5/" 5'" (5,$%5'" K/$" ,$'20$;$(" 5" /'5" K/$" L*E$(" ,5" 25)[$2&($)45" 6*0*" 45(*0" *'"""
,$2&'M$'"K/$"65,$("5F4$0"0$'/%4*,5'W"I",$F*4$"$'4P"0$%*2&5)*,5"25("*"/4&%&,*,$",$"
/("(5,$%5"(*4$(P4&25")*'",$2&'M$'",&*N)a'4&2*'"5/")*"/4&%&,*,$",5'"(5,$%5'"&)4/&@
4&;5'"QO[5(6'5)-"C===_".$$"$4"*%-"!AADRW"l/*%K/$0"/(*",*'"*F50,*N$)'"4$("654$)2&@
*%&,*,$'"6*0*"5'"5F]$4&;5'"*"K/$"$'485",$'4&)*,5'"(*'")$)[/(*",$%*'"$'4P"&'$)4*",$"
L0*N&%&,*,$'-"K/$-")/(*"6$0'6$4&;*"20\4&2*-",$;$(5'"L*E$0"'*%&$)4*0W""
X" *F50,*N$(" &)4/&4&;5@[/(*)&'4*" )85" $'4P" &'$)4*" ,$" L0*N&%&,*,$'-" 650K/$" $'4P"""""""
,$6$),$)4$" 4*)45",5" 25)[$2&($)45"*2*,`(&25"K/*)45",5" 25)[$2&($)45"6$''5*%" $"
605L&''&5)*%-"6$%*'"[*F&%&,*,$'"&),&;&,/*&'")$2$''P0&*'"b"25(60$$)'85"2%\)&2*W"X"2*6*@
2&,*,$",$" &)4/&0-" 4$0"*2/&,*,$"6$02$64&;*-"'$0"2*6*E",$"6$)'*0"$"*N&0"$("'&)205)&*"$"
)/(" 0*2&52\)&5"$(" 40*)'&785-" $)40$"5/40*'" 2*0*24$0\'4&2*'"K/$",&L$0$)2&*("5'")\;$&'"
,$"605L&2&1)2&*-"65,$("20&*0",&L&2/%,*,$'"6*0*"5'"$)L$0($&05'" 0$2`(@L50(*,*'-")5'"
25)4$Z45'"2%\)&25'"$("K/$"$)L$0($&05'"25("6$0\2&*")85"L*E$("6*04$",*"$K/&6*",5",&*"
5/",*"/)&,*,$",$"2/&,*,5'W"
d5'"(5,$%5'" &)4/&4&;5'C"*" 2$)40*%&,*,$" )*" 25(6$41)2&*" 2%\)&2*" 65,$" 450)*0@'$" /(*"
%&(&4*785" 650" '$0" K/*'$" &(65''\;$%" 25(/)&2*0" *" *%N/`(" *%N5" K/$" `" &)4*)N\;$%" $""""""
&(65''\;$%",$"$Z60&(&0"6$%5"605L&''&5)*%"QO[5(6'5)-"C===RW""
T$" *"605L&''85" '$" *65&*" $(" L50(*'"[5%\'4&2*'" $" �&)4/&4&;*'�" L50(*'",$" 25)[$2&($)45"
)5'"K/*&'" 5'" 2%\)&25'" '/'4$)4*("*"F*'$",*" '/*"60P4&2*-" $)485" '$(",Y;&,*-" 0$25)[$@
2$),5" *" 25(6%$Z&,*,$" ,5" 40*F*%[5-" )$2$''&4*(" ,$" /(" (*&50" 25)[$2&($)45" ,5'""""
,5$)4$'-" ,$" 4$(65" 6*0*" 5" L*E$0" $" '$(" 65''&F&%&,*,$" ,$" 5" L*E$0" )/(*" 605N0$''85"""
%&)$*0"QO[5(6'5(-"C===RW"
X"*F50,*N$("&)4/&4&;5@[/(*)&'4*"65,$"'$0"20&4&2*,*"650"2*/'*",5"'$/"*Z&5(*"K/$",&E"
K/$"2*,*",$'*L&5"2%\)&25"`"Y)&25W"d*'"*F50,*N$)'"'&'4$(P4&25@65'&4&;&'4*'"*"45(*,*",$"
,$2&'85"65,$"'$0"20&4&2*,*"650"0*E85"565'4*"p"5"&)2%/&0-"/("60$''/65'45"&(6%\2&45-"K/$"5"
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""C"De acordo com Benner et al (1996), a intuição é a compreensão imediata do conhecimento, sem evidên-
cias de pensamento sensível. "
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
DC""
]/\E5"2%\)&25"`"5" 0$'/%4*,5",$"/("6052$''5"N$)`0&25"$"/)&4P0&5"/4&%&E*,5"650" 45,5'"5'"
2%\)&25'"$("45,*'"*'"52*'&M$'"Qg$))$0-"C=?BRW""
j*'[544$"m" #0*)25" 9*0)$;*%$" Q!AAGR" 25)'&,$0*("K/$" 5'"(5,$%5'" 605F*F&%\'4&25'" '85"
/("0$'/%4*,5",$"/(*"(5,$%*785"&)L50(P4&2*",5"6052$''5"25N)&4&;5-"K/$"'$"450)5/")5'"
Y%4&(5'" *)5'" /(" ;$\2/%5" ,$" &)K/&0&785" ,*" 45(*,*" ,$" ,$2&'85" [/(*)*W" I'" (5,$%5'""
(*4$(P4&25'"60$'/($("K/$"5"6$)'*($)45"[/(*)5"L/)2&5)*")*"($'(*"L50(*"K/$"5'"
'&'4$(*'"&)L50(P4&25'-"25(5"'$"L5''$"/("'&'4$(*",$"F*'$'",$",*,5'"5/"/("'&'4$(*",$"
&)4$060$4*785",$"6*,0M$'W"d5'",5(\)&5'"605F*F&%\'4&25'"(*&'"/4&%&E*,5'"650"2%\)&25'-"*'"
,$2&'M$'" '85" F*'$*,*'" )*" 60$;&'85" ,*" 605F*F&%&,*,$" ,5'" 0$'/%4*,5'" ,$" ,$4$0(&)*,5"
,5$)4$W"I'" 0$'/%4*,5'"'85",$L&)&,5'-"b"60&50&"6$%5"*%2*)2$",*",$2&'85-"$"65,$("$'4*0"
0$%*2&5)*,5'" 25(" *'" ,5$)7*'" ,5" ,5$)4$-" )\;$&'" ,$" ,50-" 25),&785" L\'&2*" $" $'4*,5" ,$""
$'6\0&45W" I" 65)45" &(6504*)4$" `" K/$" 5" $'4*,5" $Z*45" ,5" ,5$)4$" `" ,$'25)[$2&,5" $" 5'""
2%\)&25'" 4$)4*(" ]/%N*0" '$" *" 605F*F&%&,*,$" ,$" 2*,*" 0$'/%4*,5" $'4P" ,$" *250,5" 25(" 5""""
;$0,*,$&05"$'4*,5",5"6*2&$)4$W"
d5" &)\2&5" ,*" ,`2*,*" ,$" '$4$)4*-" $" 6$0*)4$" /(" 25)4$Z45" ,$" ,$'%/(F0*($)45" 25(" *""
&)4$%&N1)2&*"*04&L&2&*%-"q/F$04"V0$xL/'"4*(F`("L$E"/(*"20\4&2*"&)'&,&5'*"*5'"(5,$%5'",$"
0*&E" (*4$(P4&2*W" X0N/&/" K/$" e*5" 25)40P0&5" ,5'" 25(6/4*,50$'" 5'" '$0$'" [/(*)5'""""""
65''/$("/(*"25)'2&1)2&*"6$0&L`0&2*-" 45%$0*("*"*(F&N/&,*,$-"5" '$/"25065"50N*)&E*"$"
/)&L&2*" *" $Z6$0&1)2&*" ,5'" 5F]$45'" $" *'" &(60$''M$'" '/F]$4&;*'" '85" 6*''\;$&'" ,$" 2*/'*0"
(*%@$'4*0-"2*)'*75-"5/"6$0,*",$"$'4\(/%5"$"N$0*("&)4$)7M$'"$")$2$''&,*,$'"2%*0*'-"K/$"
50N*)&E*("*"'&4/*785"$("K/$"'$"$)25)40*(f"Q3*0,)$0-"!AA!-"6W"!!>RW"
I"/'5",5"4$50$(*",$"g*x$'-"6*0*"*%`(",$")50(*4&;5"4$("/("'$)4&,5"60$'20&4&;5W"S"650"
&''5" 4$("5"654$)2&*%"6*0*"($%[50*0"*'" 45(*,*'",$",$2&'M$'-"*5" &);`'",$",$'20$;$0"*"
0$*%&,*,$",*"60P4&2*"2%\)&2*")5"6052$''5",$",$2&'85"QO[5(6'5)-"C===RW"I"(5,$%5"*)*%\@
4&25",$"P0;50$",$",$2&'85"&)L50(*%" &)2$)4&;*"*"6*04&2&6*785",5'",5$)4$'")*"*40&F/&785"
,$" ;*%50$'" 6*0*" 5'" 65''\;$&'" 0$'/%4*,5'W" d5" 4$50$(*" ,$" g*x$'" 5'" ]/\E5'" ;85" '$),5"""
*]/'4*,5'"25("5"*2/(/%*0",$",*,5'W"S'4$'"(5,$%5'-"2$04*($)4$-")85"0$60$'$)4*("*'"
40*)'&7M$'"$"(/,*)7*'"0$%$;*)4$'")*'"'&4/*7M$'"2%\)&2*'"0$*&'"Qg$))$0"$4"*%-"C==DRW"
X'" ,&L$0$)4$'" L0*N&%&,*,$'" 65,$(" '$0" /("6052$''5-" K/$" $(" '&"($'(5-" 65,$" )85" '$0"
(/&45"0$%$;*)4$W".*/0&"m"T*%*)4$0�"QC==HR",$'25F0&0*("605;*'-"*40*;`'",$"/(*"*F50,*@
N$("*)*%\4&2*"$"/(*"*)P%&'$"L*450&*%-"K/$"4*)45"5"(5,$%5" &)4/&4&;5",$"g$))$0"25(5"*"
*F50,*N$(" [&654`4&25@,$,/4&;*" ,5" 6052$''*($)45" ,$" &)L50(*785" 41(" /(" N0*/" ,$"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
D!""
/4&%&,*,$" *)*%\4&2*" )*" $Z6%&2*785")*" 45(*,*",$" ,$2&'85" $("$)L$0(*N$(" QO[5(6'5)-"
C===RW"T&N)&L&2*"&'45"K/$"*(F5'"5'"(5,$%5'"65,$("4$0"*%N5"*"5L$0$2$0-"(*'"K/$"2*,*"
/(",$%$'-"650"'&"'a-")85"5"4$(v"X"'$0"*''&("*F0$"$'6*75"6*0*"/("(5,$%5"*%4$0)*4&;5"
K/$"*''52&$"5'",5&'"(5,5'",$"25N)&785W"
X" 4$50&*" ,5" B+",8"DD&" 25N)&4&;5" ,$" q*((5)," K/$" '/0N&/" )*" '$K/1)2&*" ,$" /(*"""""
,&'2/''85"$)40$"y$))$4["q*((5),"$"q$0F$04"$"T4/*04"V0$xL/'-"'5F0$"*'",/*'"*F50@
,*N$)'" ,$" 25N)&785" &)4/&4&;*" $" *)*%\4&2*" *60$'$)4*" /(*" *%4$0)*4&;*-" ,$'$)[*,*" *"""
6*04&0" ,*" 2%\)&2*"(`,&2*W" X" 4$50&*" `" *65&*,*" 650" /(*" $'40/4/0*" 5),$" 5'" 605F%$(*'"
2%\)&25'-"4*)45"*K/$%$'"K/$"'$"*60$'$)4*("($%[50"$'40/4/0*,5'-"K/*)45"*K/$%$'"K/$"
'$"*60$'$)4*("(*%"$'40/4/0*,5'-"'85"25%52*,5'")/(*"%&)[*"25)4\)/*"K/$"%&N*"5"65%5"
,*"*)P%&'$"*5"65%5",*" &)4/&785W"V$"*250,5"25("$'4*"4$50&*")&)N/`("6$)'*",$"L50(*"
$Z2%/'&;*($)4$"&)4/&4&;*"5/"*)*%\4&2*W"X"4$50&*"'/N$0$"K/$"5'"&),&;\,/5'"56$0*(")/("
B+",8"DD&",$",&L$0$)4$'"(5,5'"25N)&4&;5'-"25(",&L$0$)4$'")\;$&'"$"/(*"(&'4/0*",$"
*)P%&'$"$"&)4/&785"QK/*'&@0*2&5)*%&,*,$R"K/$"0$2*&")5'"65)45'"&)4$0(`,&5'-"$("L/)785"
,$"/("25)]/)45",$"25),&2&5)*)4$'W""
q*((5),",$L&)&/"5"6$)'*($)45"&)4/&4&;5-"5"6$)'*($)45"*)*%\4&25"$"/("6$)'*($)45"
,$")\;$%"&)4$0(`,&5"*"K/$"2[*(5/",$"K/*'$@0*2&5)*%&,*,$W"I"(5,5"&)4/&4&;5")85"`"'a"
/("65%5"565'45"*5"*)*%\4&25"(*'"e$Z60$''*"/("6$)'*($)45"0P6&,5"K/$"6052$''*",*@
,5'",$"/(*"L50(*"&)25)'2&$)4$-"K/$"25(F&)*"25("*"&)L50(*785",&'65)\;$%"]P"$Z&'4$)@
4$_"4$("65/2*"25)'&'41)2&*"$"`"(5,$0*,*($)4$"60$2&'5f"Qq*((-"C=??"6W?CRW"I"(5,5"
*)*%\4&25" `" %$)45-" 25)'2&$)4$" $" 25)'&'4$)4$W" I" 6$)'*($)45" *)*%\4&25" `" )50(*%($)4$"
60$2&'5-" (*'" 65,$" %$;*0-" 52*'&5)*%($)4$-" *" N0*),$'" &)2500$7M$'W" I" (5,5" 25N)&4&;5"
2[*(*,5" ,$" K/*'$@0*2&5)*%&,*,$" `" 5" 4&65" ,$" 6$)'*($)45" K/$" '$" '&4/*" )5"($&5" ,5'"
$Z40$(5'",$"&)4/&785"5/"*)P%&'$"$"25("/("(&'45",$"*(F5'_"6$0(&4$"/(*"�4052*�"$)40$"
5'",5&'"(5,5'",$"6$)'*($)45")*"($'(*",$2&'85"Qq*((-"C=??RW""
V$"*250,5"25("*"4$50&*",5"25)4&)//("25N)&4&;5-"*'"60&)2&6*&'"25),&2&5)*)4$'"6*0*"/("
605L&''&5)*%"/4&%&E*0"/(*"*F50,*N$("&)4/&4&;*"5/"*)*%\4&2*"'85"60&(*0&*($)4$",$4$0(&@
)*,*'"650"401'",&($)'M$'"Qq*((-"C=??Rn"QCR"*"25(6%$Z&,*,$",*"$'40/4/0*",*"'&4/*785"
2%\)&2*"K/$"$);5%;$"5")Y($05",$",*,5'"2%\)&25'-"*"0$,/),i)2&*",5'",*,5'"$"*")*4/0$E*"
,5"60&)2\6&5"50N*)&E*,50_"Q!R"*"*(F&N/&,*,$",5"605F%$(*"K/$"$'4P"0$%*2&5)*,*"25("*"
$Z&'41)2&*" ,$" /(" 60&)2\6&5" 50N*)&E*,50-" *" L*(&%&*0&,*,$" 25(" 5" 605F%$(*-" $" 25(" 5""""
654$)2&*%" ,$" 60$2&'85_" QGR" *" )*4/0$E*" ,*" *60$'$)4*785" ,5" 605F%$(*" K/$" $'4P"""""""""""""
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
DG""
,$6$),$)4$" ,*" 2*6*2&,*,$" ,5" 2%\)&25" 5" ,$25(650-" ,*" L50(*" 25(5" *" &)L50(*785" `"
*60$'$)4*,*"$",5" 4$(65",&'65)\;$%" 6*0*" *]/&E*0" '5F0$"$%$" Qq*((-"C=??_" O[5(6'5)-"
C===RW" S'4*" 4$50&*" '/N$0$" K/$" *" &)4/&785" `" 5"(5,5"(*&'" $L&2&$)4$" ,$" 0*2&52&)*0" )*'"""
'&4/*7M$'"5),$"5"2%\)&25"$)L0$)4*"/(*"N0*),$"K/*)4&,*,$",$" &)L50(*785"6$02$4&;*"$"
&)4$00$%*2&5)*,*-" (*'" 5),$" *" 0$N0*" `" *" %&F$0,*,$-" $);5%;&($)45" $" 0$'65)'*F&%&,*,$"
6*0*"'$N/&0"$"5"4$(65"`"%&(&4*,5W":("(5,5"*)*%\4&25",$"0*2&52\)&5"`"(*&'"*60560&*,5"
)*'" '&4/*7M$'" 5),$" 5" 2%\)&25" 4$(" (*&'" &)L50(*785" 5F]$4&;*($)4$" $'40/4/0*,*-" K/$""
65,$"'$0"2*4$N50&E*,*"L*2&%($)4$",$)405",5"4$(65",&'65)\;$%"QV5r,&)N"$4"*%-"!AA?RW"
I'" 2%\)&25'" (5;$(@'$" F&,&0$22&5)*%($)4$" *5" %5)N5" ,$'4$" 25)4&)//(-" ,$6$),$),5""
,$'4*'"401'",&($)'M$'W"l/*%K/$0"/(",5'"(5,5'"25N)&4&;5'"/'*,5'-"*&),*"K/$"&)4$0(`@
,&5'-" '$0P"5"*,$K/*,5"'$(60$"K/$" '$"5F'$0;*0"K/$"[P"/(*"25&)2&,1)2&*"$)40$"$'4*'"
,&($)'M$'",*"$'40/4/0*",5"605F%$(*"$"5"(5,5"25N)&4&;5"6*0*"*]/&E*0"'5F0$"$%$W"c5,$"
,&E$0@'$-" K/*),5" *''&(" *25)4$2$-" K/$" 5" 654$)2&*%" ,$" 60$2&'85" */($)4*W" q*((5),"
4*(F`(" 0$25)[$2$" K/$" 5" 605F%$(*" 65,$" '$0" 0$$'40/4/0*,5" $"(/,*0" 6*0*" /(")5;5"
(5,5",$"25N)&785"Qq*(("C=??RW""
O*(F`(")$'4$"(5,$%5-"*65&*,5"6$%*"4$50&*",5"6052$''*($)45",$"&)L50(*785-"'$"65,$"
5F'$0;*0"K/$"5"(5,5",$"25N)&785"/'*,5",$6$),$",*"2*6*2&,*,$"&),&;&,/*%"$",*K/&%5"
K/$"5"605L&''&5)*%"'*F$W"95)4/,5-"$)K/*)45"$%$($)45",$"/(*"$K/&6*-"*"'/*"2*6*2&,*@
,$" &),&;&,/*%"65,$"'$0"*65&*,*-" 0$L507*,*"5/"0$]$&4*,*"'$")85"4&;$0"'/6504$"*)*%\4&25W"
q*((5)," *,(&4$" K/$" )/(*" $K/&6*"(/%4&,&'2&6%&)*0" 5'"($(F05'" 65''*(" *6$%*0" *5"
6$)'*($)45" *)*%\4&25" ,$" 5/405'-" 6*0*" 0$,/E&0" *" &)2$04$E*W" I/405'" ($(F05'-" 2/]5'""""
,$'$(6$)[5'" '$]*(" 0$25)[$2&,5'" 25(5" 25(6$4$)4$'-" 60aZ&(5'" $" K/$" 52/6$(-"""""
[*F&4/*%($)4$-"65'&7M$'"[&$0*0K/&2*($)4$"'/6$0&50$'-"*&),*"K/$")85"L50(*%&E*,*'W"V*"
($'(*"L50(*-"5'"($(F05'",*"$K/&6*"65,$("0$]$&4*0"'5%/7M$'"&)4/&4&;*'",$"25%$N*'"$("
65'&7M$'" �&)L$0&50$'�"5),$"*"0*E85"*)*%\4&2*")85"65,$"'$0",$(5)'40*,*"Qq*((-"C=??_"
O[5(6'5)-C===_"V5r,&)N"$4"*%-"!AA=RW"S'4*"'5%/785")5"$)4$),$0",$"O[5(6'5)"QC===R-"
*605Z&(*"*'",/*'" *F50,*N$)'-" $)K/*)45"$Z40$(5'",$"/("25)4&)//(W)c5,$("'$0"/%@
40*6*''*,*'"*'"L0*N&%&,*,$'",$"2*,*"/(*",$%*'"$"'$0"/'*,5"25(5"'&'4$(*",$"'/6504$",$"
,$2&'85" 2*6*E" ,$" 2556$0*0" 25(" *" 6%/0*%&,*,$" $" 5" 4$(65" ,$" 2/&,*,5'-" )5" $Z$02\2&5"""
2%\)&25",5'",&*'",$"[5]$W""
S'4*"&,$&*"65,$"'$0"0$25)[$2&,*"25(5"6$04&)$)4$"'$"0$25)[$2$0(5'"*"6$'K/&'*"K/$"L5&"
,$'$);5%;&,*" 6$%*'" &);$'4&N*,50*'" 95)2500*)@c$00x" $4" *%-" QC===RW" S%*'" 4&;$0*(" 25(5"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
DB""
5F]$4&;5" &,$)4&L&2*0" *'" %&)[*'" ,$" 0*2&52\)&5 C "/'*,*'" 6$%5'" $)L$0($&05'" 6*0*" 45(*0""""""
,$2&'M$'W"S"5'"0$'/%4*,5'"0$;$%*0*("K/$"4*)45"5'"6$0&4*'"K/*)45"5'"60&)2&6&*)4$'"/4&%&@
E*0*("(Y%4&6%*'" %&)[*'" ,$" 0*2&52\)&5" ,/0*)4$" 5" 6052$''5" ,$" ,$2&'85W"+*'" [5/;$" /("
)Y($05" ,$" %&)[*'" ,$" 0*2&52\)&5" /4&%&E*,*'" K/$" L50*(" 60$,5(&)*)4$'W" S)40$" *'" K/$""""
L50*("60$,5(&)*)4$'"*6$)*'"/(*",$%*'"25&)2&,&/"25("*"K/$"$'4$;$"%&N*,*"b"25)2%/'85"
5/",$2&'85W"S"*(F5'"5'"N0/65'"/'*0*("/(*";*0&$,*,$",$"%&)[*'",$"0*2&52\)&5"6*04&2/%*@
0$'"25(5"60$,5(&)*)4$'W""
X'" */450*'" 25)'&,$0*(" K/$" 5" $'4/,5" *%*0N*" 5" 25)[$2&($)45" ,$'$);5%;&,5-" 650"""
25(6*0*0"5"25(6504*($)45",$2&'a0&5",$"$)L$0($&05'"6$0&45'"$"60&)2&6&*)4$'"$"4$'4*0"
*";*%&,*,$",5"/'5",*'"%&)[*'",$"0*2&52\)&5"25("2*'5'"[&654`4&25'W"V$'25F$04*'-"K/$")5"
'$/" $)4$),&($)45" 65,$(" '$0;&0" ,$" F*'$" *" /(" 605]$45" ,$" /(" '&'4$(*" F*'$*,5" )5"
25)[$2&($)45-"[/(*)5"$^5/"25(6/4*,50&E*,5W":("'&'4$(*"K/$"'/6504$"*'",$2&'M$'-"
*40*;`'",$"*%$04*'"5/"*;&'5'"*5'"$)L$0($&05'-"b"($,&,*"K/$"$%$'"45(*("*'",$2&'M$'"
2%\)&2*'W"V$'25F$04*'-"K/$")5")5''5"$)4$),&($)45"2*0$2$(",$"/(*"(*&50"'/'4$)4*@
785"2&$)4\L&2*"650K/$"5"25)[$2&($)45"6*0*"'$0"0$25)[$2&,5"25(5";$0,*,$&05"60$2&'*"
,$" 0$'&'4&0" *5'" 4$'4$'" 60P4&25'" ,$" /4&%&,*,$" Q+$%$&'-" !AAH-" .56$'-" !AAD-"+2Sr$)" m"
o&%%'-"!AA=RW"
d/("40*F*%[5",$"'\)4$'$"65,$(5'"5F'$0;*0"K/$"&),$6$),$)4$($)4$",*"*F50,*N$("
/'*,*"[P"'$(60$"/(*"*;*%&*785",*"25),&785"2%\)&2*",$"/(",5$)4$W"T$]*"$%*")5($*,*"
25(5"/(*",$2&'85"5/"/(",&*N)a'4&25"5/")85")5($*,*-"650K/$"`"25)4\)/*"$"$Z60$'@
'*"25(5"]/\E5'!"2%\)&25'W"X"*;*%&*785",*"25),&785"2%\)&2*",5",5$)4$"5/",5"605F%$(*"`"
&),$6$),$)4$",*")*4/0$E*",5'"(5,$%5'"/'*,5'-"K/$" L&2*(")5" %&;0$"*0F\40&5",$"2*,*"
$)L$0($&05-",5'"4$(65'"2%\)&25'"5/",*"25(6%$Z&,*,$",*"'&4/*785"2%\)&2*W"I"6052$''5"
,$"*;*%&*785-"K/$"`"6*04&%[*,5"65,$"'$0"2[*(*,5"/("e6052$''5",$"*;*%&*785",&*N)a'@
4&2*f-" 25(5" .56$'" Q!AADR" 5" )5($5/W" V&'4&)785" 0$'6$&4*,*" 650K/$" `" /(" $%$($)45"
2$)40*%"$("K/*%K/$0"(5,$%5"$"K/$"65,$",$4$0(&)*0",$2&'M$'"$"*7M$'"25)'$K/$)4$'"
6*0*" *" K/*%&,*,$" $" F$(@$'4*0" ,5'" ,5$)4$'_" '$]*(" $%*'" 25)'40/\,*'" )/(" 0*2&52\)&5"
,$,/4&;5-"'$"*2*'5"'$"40*4*",$"/("(5,$%5"605F*F&%\'4&25-"5/")/("0*2&52\)&5"&),/4&;5"
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""C"Linha de raciocínio definida como um conjunto de argumentos nos quais o conhecimento está inserido
em processos de tomadas de decisão, que levam a uma conclusão. O poder de uma linha de raciocínio é o
de combinar conhecimento e processos cognitivos numa só representação e como alguém utiliza o conhe-
cimento durante o processo de raciocínio, numa situação particular (Corcoran-Perry, et al 1999). !"Juízo clínico corresponde à expressão anglo saxónica “clinical judgment”.
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
DH""
$",$,/4&;5-")/("(5,$%5"[&654`4&25@,$,/4&;5-"5/"*&),*")/("0*2&52\)&5"&),/4&;5-")/("
(5,$%5"25(60$$)'&;5W""
l/*%K/$0"/(",$'4$'"0*2&52\)&5'"&)L$0$)2&*&'"'85"6052$''5'"'&'4$(P4&25'",$"6$)'*($)45"
K/$" 605,/E$(" 25)2%/'M$'" 5/" 0$'/%4*,5'" *" 6*04&0" ,$" 6$02$67M$'-" 6$)'*($)45'" 5/""""
*L&0(*7M$'" (*'" K/$" 65,$(" &)2500$0" $(" $);&$'*($)45'" 5/" 6052$''5'" L*%*2&5'5'W" I"
0*2&52\)&5",$,/4&;5")85"`"L%$Z\;$%-"'$"*/($)4*0"5")Y($05",$"60$(&''*'-",$L&)&,*'"6$%5"
,$2&'50-"*"6*04&0",*"K/*%",$,/E"*2*F*0P"650")85"4$0"4$(65")$("2*6*2&,*,$",$"($(a@
0&*" 6*0*" 2[$N*0" *" /(*" 25)2%/'85W" X" &),/785" `" /(*" L50(*" ,$" 0*2&52\)&5" K/$" /'*" 5"""""
25)[$2&($)45"'5F0$"2*'5'"$'6$2\L&25'"25)[$2&,5'-"6*0*",$'$)[*0"/(*"&)L$01)2&*"'5F0$"
2*'5'",$'25)[$2&,5'-"$-")85"`"65''\;$%"25)[$2$0"45,*'"*'"525001)2&*'",$"/("K/*%K/$0"
L$)a($)5W"l/*%K/$0"/(",$%$'")85"`"&(/)$"b'"%&(&4*7M$'",5"'&'4$(*"25N)&4&;5")$("b"
6$0($*F&%&,*,$",*"&)4$0*785"[/(*)*W"d5"0*2&52\)&5"&),/4&;5-"*"L*%P2&*",*"25)L&0(*785"
`"/(*"60$'$)7*"25)'4*)4$C!d5"0*2&52\)&5",$,/4&;5-"*"25)2$)40*785"'5F0$"*";$0,*,$"5/"
L*%'&,*,$" ,*'" ,$2%*0*7M$'" &),&;&,/*&'" ,5'" '&%5N&'(5'-" &N)50*(" 25(" 0$N/%*0&,*,$" *""""
%&N*785"%aN&2*"$)40$"*'",$2%*0*7M$'W""
O*(F`("65,$(5'"5F'$0;*0"K/$"[P"/)&L50(&,*,$")5"$)K/*,0*($)45"4$a0&25-"(/&45"
$(F50*"*6$)*'"5"(5,$%5",$"0*2&52\)&5",&*N)a'4&25"$"[&654`4&25@,$,/4&;5"5"0$L&0*",$"
/(*"L50(*"$Z60$''*W"d5",5(\)&5",5'"6052$''5'"25N)&4&;5'"5/",*"'/*"0*2&5)*%&E*785-"
*6$'*0",*"0*2&5)*%&,*,$"[/(*)*"'$0"%&(&4*,*-"$("6*04$"6$%*'"%&(&4*7M$'",*"($(a0&*"
,$"40*F*%[5-")/(*"5/40*"6*04$"650"K/$'4M$'"(54&;*2&5)*&'-"5"6052$''5",$"*;*%&*785"
,&*N)a'4&2*"65,$"'$0"L*2&%&4*,5"6$%5'"(`45,5'"*)*%\4&25'"$^5/"&)4/&4&;5'-"25(5"'/N$0$"
*"4$50&*",5"25)4&)//()25N)&4&;5",$"q*((5),"Qq*((-"C=??RW"d5"$)4*)45"25)4&)/*("
*" %$;*)4*0@'$" *%N/(*'" K/$'4M$'n" K/*),5" *25)4$2$(" ,$2&'M$'-" $(" 6*0*%$%5-" 25(5"
350,5)"QC=?BR"0$L$0$)2&*-"25(5"`"K/$"$''$"6052$''5"52500$v"<"*"4$50&*",5"6052$''*@
($)45",$"&)L50(*785"K/$"65,$",*0"'/6504$"*"$'4*'",$2&'M$'v"S"K/*),5"5'"$)L$0($&@
05'"41("K/$"&)4$0;&0",$"L50(*"&($,&*4*"650K/$"*'"25),&7M$'"2%\)&2*'",5'",5$)4$'"'$"
*%4$0*("$"$Z&N$"/(*"0$50N*)&E*785"25)'4*)4$"Qc544$0"$4"*%-"!AAD_"c5)4$"$4"*%"!AA>Rv""
S" $(" '&4/*7M$'" ,$" 25)L05)45-" '&(/%4i)$5-" 25(" ;P0&5'" ,5$)4$'" Qc544$0-" !AADRv" T$0P"
K/$" *" $'40/4/0*" ,*" 4$50&*" ,5" 6052$''*($)45" ,$" &)L50(*785" 4$(" 2*6*2&,*,$" ,$"""""
0$'65'4*"*"$'4*'"K/$'4M$'v"
d5"K/$"'$"0$L$0$"b'",$2&'M$'")85"'$"5F'$0;*"25$01)2&*"$)40$"*'"*F50,*N$)'W"I"0$25@
)[$2&($)45-"*"&,$)4&L&2*785-"*")5($*785"$"*"K/*)4&L&2*785",5")Y($05",$",$2&'M$'"'a"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
DD""
65,$"5F'$0;*,*"b"%/E",*"*F50,*N$("'&'4$(P4&25@65'&4&;*W"d*"*F50,*N$("25(60$$)'&@
;*-" ,$'$);5%;&,*" )/(" 25)4$Z45" )*4/0*%&'4*-" *'" ,$2&'M$'" *25)4$2$(" )5" i(F&45" ,5"""""
25)4$Z45" ,*" *785" $" '85" 6$02$F&,*'" 6$%*'" $'25%[*'" ,*" *785-" *''/(&),5@'$" 5" 4$0(5""""
,$2&'85"25(5"/(*"$'25%[*",$"/("2/0'5",$"*7M$'W"S'4*0$(5'")a'"*"L*%*0",*",&L$0$)2&*@
785"$)40$",$2&'M$'"4$a0&2*'"$",$2&'M$'"60P4&2*'v"
c*0*"*%`(",*'"25$01)2&*'"$" &)25$01)2&*'-"/(*"5/40*"K/$'485"'$"%$;*)45/")5",$2500$0"
,*"$'20&4*-"*"6056a'&45",*"0$%$;i)2&*",*"45(*,*",$",$2&'85v"I)0$'/%4*,5",5)6052$''5"
,&*N)a'4&25-"'$),5"5/")85")5($*,5"25(5"/(*",$2&'85"2*0$2$"'$(60$",$"'$0";*%&,*,5W"
<" *" *785" K/$" 0$25)[$2$" 5" (`0&45" 5/" ,$'(`0&45" ,*" *;*%&*785" 5/" ,$2&'85" $)K/*)45""""
0$'/%4*,5",5"6052$''5",$"*;*%&*785",&*N)a'4&2*W"X",$2&'85"0$'/%4*",$"/(*"*)P%&'$"4$a0&@
2*"$"2%\)&2*-"K/$"/(*";$E"*''/(&,*-"`"'/F($4&,*"b"605;*"($,&*)4$"*7M$'"$"*;*%&*7M$'"
,*" *785-" 25(5"650" $Z$(6%5n" 5F'$0;*@'$" *" ,$2&'85",$" *,(&)&'40*0" /("($,&2*($)45-"
60$'20&45"'5F"5"*20a)&(5"TIT"$"`"$Z$2/4*,*"*"*785",$"5"*,(&)&'40*0"'$),5"$'4*-"K/$"
;*%&,*"5/"0$L50(/%*"*",$2&'85_")*"'$K/1)2&*",*"*;*%&*785",&*N)a'4&2*",$"/(*",5$)4$"
*2*(*,*"$"25("5Z&N$)54$0*6&*-"*"$)L$0($&0*",$2&,&/"K/$"*",5$)4$",$;&*"'$0"(5F&%&E*@
,*_"*"*785"L5&"$Z$2/4*,*"$"*6a'"*"(/,*)7*",$",$2YF&45"*"'*4/0*785",$"5Z&N`)&5"K/$"
$0*",$"=A�"F*&Z5/"6*0*";*%50$'",$"?A�_"L5&"*"*785"0$*%&E*,*-"K/$"%$;5/"*"K/$"*",$2&'85"
4&;$''$" K/$" '$0" 0$L50(/%*,*W" X'" ,$2&'M$'" 65,$(" 4$0" 65,$0" 60$'20&4&;5"(*'" )85" 41("
/4&%&,*,$"2%\)&2*"'$("K/$"*"*785"'$]*"$Z$2/4*,*W"<"5"0$'/%4*,5",*"*785")*K/&%5"K/$"$%*"
`"$")5"(5,5"25(5"`"0$*%&E*,*-"K/$"*;*%&*"*"605F*F&%&,*,$"(*&50"5/"($)50",5"'/2$''5"
4$0*61/4&25",*",$2&'85W"S)485"650K/1"*"1)L*'$",5'"(5,$%5'")*",$2&'85"$")85")*"*785v""
"
0.)$-,47.!
X"4$50&E*785"'5F0$"*"45(*,*",$",$2&'85"`"0$'/%4*)4$",5'"2$)P0&5'"[&'4a0&25'"$"&,$5%aN&@
25'"K/$"*"$)L$0(*N$("*40*;$''5/W":("6$02/0'5",&)i(&25"25("$;5%/785"$"(/,*)7*'"
K/$" 0$L%$4&0*(" )5;*'" $Z6$0&1)2&*'" $" 0$,$L&)&785" ,*" 60a60&*" ,&'2&6%&)*W" 95($75/" 650"
25)2$64/*%&E*0" *)*%&4&2*($)4$" *" 6$''5*" 25(5" /(" '$0" F&56'&25''52&*%" $" *" '*Y,$" $" *""
,5$)7*"25(5"6052$''5'"K/$"65,$("25*F&4*0"6*0*-"*)5'"(*&'" 4*0,$-"25)2$64/*%&E*0"*"
6$''5*"25(5"/("'$0";&;$)4$"$"Y)&25"K/$" 4$("$Z6$0&1)2&*'",$" '*Y,$W"X'"*F50,*N$)'"
*K/&"$Z60$''*'" L&%&*(@'$"$("60$''/65'45'" &,$5%aN&25'",&L$0$)2&*,5'"$"K/$",$',$" %5N5"
'$"$;&,$)2&*("6$%*" &(6504i)2&*^)85" &(6504i)2&*"*40&F/\,*"*5"25)4$Z45"5),$"*25)4$@
2$("*'"45(*,*'",$",$2&'85W"I"(5,$%5",5"B+",8"DD&-"2/0&5'*($)4$-"0$25)[$2$"K/$"5"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
D>""
0$2/0'5"*5"(5,5"25N)&4&;5"*)*%\4&25"5/"&)4/&4&;5"$'4P",$6$),$)4$",$"/("25)]/)45",$"
;*0&P;$&'"$Z4$0)*'W""
I'"(5,$%5'")50(*4&;5'"0$60$'$)4*("*"$Z60$''85",*"0*2&5)*%&,*,$"K/$"56$0*2&5)*%&@
E*"/("(5,$%5",$"60$,&785",5"25(6504*($)45"[/(*)5"QT[*L&0"m".$g5$/L-"!AA!RW"S("
565'&785" *" 4&65%5N&*" ,5'" 6052$''5'" ,$" *60$),&E*N$(" *60$'$)4*,*" 650" g$))$0" $""""
,$'$);5%;&,*"650"q/F$04"V0$xL/'-")85"*)/%*"*" &(6504i)2&*",*" %aN&2*"5/",*'" 0$N0*'-"
(*'" ,&E@)5'" K/$" K/*%K/$0" ,$'$(6$)[5" [/(*)5" 'a" 65,$" *%2*)7*0" *" 6$0\2&*" '$" L50"
&)4/&4&;5-" '&)20a)&25-" [5%\'4&25-" &'45" `-" 25(60$$),&,5W" V0$xL/'" '/N$0$" 5" 4$0(5"""""""""""""
*@0*2&5)*%"25(5"L50(*",$"'/6$0*0"*"'$6*0*F&%&,*,$"&)405,/E&,*"6$%*"0*E85n"*"60P4&2*"
2&$)4\L&2*" )85" $'4P" '$6*0*,*",*"60P4&2*" [/(*)*W"X" 4$50&*" ,5" 25)4&)//(" 0$60$'$)4*"
/(*" $'40*4`N&*" [\F0&,*" K/$" '&)4$4&E*" *'" ,/*'" *F50,*N$)'" ,$" i(F&45" 25N)&4&;5W"""""
95)'4*(5'" K/$" 5'" *''/)45'" ,*" &00$,/4&F&%&,*,$" [/(*)*" $" *" &(60$;&'&F&%&,*,$" ,5'"
L*245'"25)20$45'"K/$"*25)4$2$(")*"0$*%&,*,$"2%\)&2*-"$'6*75"3D8)($"$%83"6$%*",&)i(&@
2*" 56$0*4&;*" ,*'" &,$&*'" K/$" &(6M$-" $" K/$" 41("K/$" *25)4$2$0" '&'4$(*4&2*($)4$" )5"
'$&5",$"/(*"4$&*",$"0$%*7M$'"25)4&)/*("*",$&Z*0"/(";*E&5"$Z6%&2*4&;5")5'"6052$''5'"
,$"45(*,*",$",$2&'85")*"P0$*"2%\)&2*",$"$)L$0(*N$(W""
"
!
Z3:31K)$#&4!@#G-#.<19:#$&4!
X&4J$)-" .W" +W-" +*0'[*%%-" TW" cW" S%%&544-" jW" m" +2y&)%$x-" TW" Q!AA?RW" 90&4&2*%" 2*0$" )/0'$'�""""""
,$2&'&5)"(*J&)Nn" '$,*4&5)" *''$''($)4" *),"(*)*N$($)4" &)" &)4$)'&;$" 2*0$W" j+D%"'7) +#)
*78"8B'7)iD%38"(-"C?-"GDpBHW"
X0Nx0&'-"9W"m"T2[�)-"VW"XW"QC=>BRW"2A$+%X)8")-%'B,8B$/) 8"B%$'38"()-%+#$338+"'7)$##$B,8=$?
"$33W"T*)"#0*)2&'25n"U5''$x"@"g*''""c/F%&'[$0'W"
g*05)-"UW"Q!AA?RW"2A8"K8"()'":):$B8:8"(W"9*(F0&,N$n"9*(F0&,N$":)&;$0'&4x"c0$''W"=>?@A@
HCC@BDB?>@B"$@g55JW"
g$))$0-" cW" QC=?BRW" #05(" d5;&2$" 45" SZ6$04n" SZ2$%%$)2$" *)," c5r$0" &)" 9%&)&2*%" d/0'&)N"
c0*24&2$W"X,,&'5)@o$'%$x"+$)%5"c*0JW"
g$))$0-"cW-"yx0&*J&,&'-"cW"qW"m"T4*))*0,-"VW"Q!ACCRW"*78"8B'7)@83:+&)'":)8",$%=$",8+"3)8")
'BD,$) '":) B%8,8B'7) B'%$) ') ,A8"K8"(?8"?'B,8+") '--%+'BAW" d$r" }50Jn" T60&)N$0" c/F%&'[&)N"
95(6*)xW"S@F55J"kTgdn"=>?@A@?!DC@AH>B@HW"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
D?""
g$))$0-"cW-"O*))$0"9W"m"9[$%'$*"9W"QC==DRW"!^-$%,83$)8")"D%38"()-%'B,8B$R)*'%8"(4)B78"8B'7)
[D:(&$",)'":)$,A8B3W"H|"S,W"d$r@}50Jn"T60&)N$0"c/F%&'[&)N"95(6*)xW"
g05r)-" .W" Q!ACARW" T,',$) +#) ,A$) '%,) 8") B78"8B'7) 3D-$%=838+"W" S,W" U5[)" 9/%F0$4[" *)," .50&""""""""
.W"g05r)"W"j$2/6$0*,5"$("C!",$"V$E$(F05",$"!ACG"[446n^^"rrrW4*x%50*),L0*)2&'W25("
g/2J&)N[*(-"9W"VW""m"X,*(*'"XW"Q!AAARW"9%*''&Lx&)N"2%&)&2*%",$2&'&5)"(*J&)Nn"*"/)&Lx&)N"
*6605*2[W"j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"(-"G!"QBR-"=?C@=?=W"
g/2J)*%%-"OW"Q!AAARW"90&4&2*%"2*0$")/0'$'�",$2&'&5)@(*J&)N"*24&;&4&$'"&)"4[$")*4/0*%"2%&)&2*%"
'$44&)NW""j+D%"'7)+#)*78"8B'7)iD%38"(-"=-"!H@GDW"
g/2J)*%%-" OW" " Q!AAGRW" O[$" 2%&)&2*%" %*),'2*6$" 5L" 20&4&2*%" 2*0$n" )/0'$'�" ,$2&'&5)@(*J&)NW"
j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"(-"BG"QGR-"GCA@GC=W"
9*0)$;*%&-"VW".W-"+&42[$%%-"cWqW-"o55,'-"dW"#W"m"O*))$0-"9W"XW"QC=?BRW"08'("+3,8B)M$'3+"?
8"()8")iD%38"(-"c[&%*,$%6[&*n".&66&)2544W"
9*0)$;*%&-" VW" m" O[5(*'-" +W" VW" QC==GR" 08'("+3,8B) %$'3+"8"() '":) ,%$',&$",) :$B838+")
&'K8"()8")"D%38"(W"c[&%*,$%6[&*n"U"g".&66&)2544"95(6*)xW"
95,x-"oW" yW" Q!AADRW" YA87+3+-A8B'7) '":) ,A$+%$,8B'7) -$%3-$B,8=$3) #+%) ':='"B$:) "D%38"()
-%'B,8B$W"B|"S,W"g/0%&)N45)n"o&%%&*("yW"95,x"U5)$'"*),"g*04%$44"c/F%&'[$0'W"
95)250*)@c$00x-" TW-"d*0*x*)-"XW"m"952[0*)$-" TW" QC===RW"9505)*0x" 2*0$")/0'$'" �2%&)&2*%"
,$2&'&5)"(*J&)NW"iD%38"()'":)W$',A)TB8$"B$3-"C-"B=@DCW"
9/00$x-" UW" m" g544&k" +W" Q!AADR-" O[$" &)L%/$)2$" 5L" 6*4&$)4" 25(6%$Z&4x" *)," )/0'$'�""
$Z6$0&$)2$"5)"[*$(5,x)*(&2",$2&'&5)@(*J&)N" L5%%5r&)N" 2*0,&*2" '/0N$0xW" Q",$"38=$)U)
*%8,8B'7)*'%$)iD%38"(-"!!"QBR-"C=B@!AHW"
V5$)N$'-"+W"m"+550[5/'$-"+W"#W" Q!AAGRW"X66%&2*4&5)"5L")/0'&)N"6052$''"*),")/0'&)N"
,&*N)5'&'" *)" &)4$0*24&;$" 4$Z4" L50" ,&*N)5'4&2" 0$*'5)&)N-" B|" S,"c[&%*,$%6[&*n" #W" XW"V*;&'"
95(6*)xW"
V5r&$-"UW"m"S%'4$&)-"XW"QC===RW"Y%+#$338+"'7)jD:(&$",/)')%$':$%)8")B78"8B'7):$B838+")&'K?
8"(-"D|"$,W"9*(F0&,N$n"9*(F0&,N$":)&;$0'&4x"c0$''W"
V5r,&)N-" VW-" T6&%'F/0x-" yW-" O[5(6'5)-" 9W-" g05r)%5r-" jW" m" c*44$),$)-" UW" Q!AA=RW" O[$"
,$2&'&5)"(*J&)N"5L"[$*04"L*&%/0$"'6$2&*%&'4")/0'$'"&)"2%&)&2*%"60*24&2$W"j+D%"'7)+#)B78"8B'7)
"D%38"(-"C?-"CGCG@CG!BW"
V0$xL/'-"qW"m"V0$xL/'" TW" QC=?DRW"+&),"5;$0"+*2[&)$n" O[$"c5r$0"5L"q/(*)" k)4/&4&5)"
*),"SZ6$04&'$"&)"4[$"S0*"5L"4[$"95(6/4$0W"d$r"}50Jn"O[$"#0$$"c0$''W"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
D=""
S%'4$&)-"XWTW"m"g50,*N$-"3W"QC===RW"c'x2[5%5Nx"5L"2%&)&2*%"0$*'5)&)NW"k)"c05L$''&5)*%"U/,N@
($)4n"*"0$*,$0"&)"2%&)&2*%",$2&'&5)"(*J&)N-"D|"$,W"9*(F0&,N$n"9*(F0&,N$":)&;$0'&4x"c0$''W"
3*0,)$0-"qW"Q!AA!RW"L)"+=')B8O"B8'):')&$",$W".&'F5*n"S,&785"j$%aN&5",�uN/*W"""
3&%%$'6&$-" +W" m" c*4$0'5)-" gW" Q!AA=RW" q$%6&)N" )5;&2$" )/0'$'" (*J$" $LL$24&;$" 2%&)&2*%""
,$2&'&5)'n" 4[$" '&4/*4$," 2%&)&2*%" ,$2&'&5)@(*J&)N" L0*($r50JW" d/0'&)N" S,/2*4&5)""
c$0'6$24&;$'-"GA"QGR-"CDBpC>AW"
30$$)r55,-"UW"QC==?RW"S'4*F%&'[&)N"*)"&)4$0)*4&5)*%")$4r50J"5)")/0'$'�"2%&)&2*%"0$*'5)@
&)NW"U5/0)*%"5L"X,;*)2$,"d/0'&)N-"!>-"?BG@?B>W"
350,5)"+W"QC==BRW""iD%38"():8'("+383/)-%+B$33)'":)'--78B',8+"W"G"S,W"T4W".5/&'n"+5'FxW"
q*((-"jW+W"QC=??RW"9%&)&2*%"k)4/&4&5)"*),"9%&)&2*%"X)*%x'&'n"SZ6$04&'$"*),"4[$"95N)&4&;$"
95)4&)//(W"k)"UW"V5r$x-"m"XW"S%'4$&)"QS,'R-"Y%+#$338+"'7)jD:(&$",/)L)M$':$%)8")*78"8B'7)
0$B838+")9'K8"(W"9*(F0&,N$n"9*(F0&,N$":)&;$0'&4x"c0$''W"
q*((5),-"yWjW"QC=DBRW"X)"*6605*2["45"4[$"'4/,x"5L"2%&)&2*%"&)L$0$)2$"&)")/0'&)Nn"6*04W"
kkW"iD%38"()M$3$'%BA-"CG"QBR-"GCH@GC=W"
q*)'5)-"TWIW"Q!AAHRW"0$B838+")2A$+%X/)L)S%8$#) Q",%+:DB,8+"W"T452J[5%(n"V$6*04($)4"5L"
6[&%5'56[x"*),"4[$"[&'450x"5L"05x*%"&)'4&4/4$"5L"4$2[)5%5Nx"QyOqRW"
q*0F&'5)-" UW" " Q!AADRW" 9%&)&2*%" ]/,N($)4" &)" 4[$" &)4$060$4*4&5)" 5L" $;&,$)2$n" *" g*x$'&*)"
*6605*2[W"j+D%"'7)+#)*78"8B'7)iD%38"(-"CH-"CB?=pCB=W"
q*)52[-" }W" m" c*2[/0-" O" Q!AABRW" d/0'$'" *'" &)L50(*4&5)" 605;&,$0'n" L*2&%&4*4&)N" /),$0@
'4*),&)N"*),"25((/)&2*4&5)"5L"'4*4&'4&2*%" &)L50(*4&5)W"iD%3$)$:DB',8+") ,+:'X-"!BQGR-"
!GD@BG"
q$,F$0N-"gW"m".*0''5)":W"Q!AABRW"S);&05)($)4*%"$%$($)4'"*LL$24&)N"4[$",$2&'&5)"(*J@
&)N"6052$''"&)")/0'&)N"60*24&2$W"j+D%"'7)*78"8B'7)iD%38"()9'%-CG"QGR"GCD@G!BW"
U/))5%*-" OW-" S0&J''5)-" SW-" T*%*)4$0*-" TW" m" .*/0&-" TW" Q!AA!RW" d/0'$" ,$2&'&5)" (*J&)N" &)""
25%%$24&)N"L50"4[$"*''$''($)4"5L"6*4&$)4'�")/0'&)N"605F%$('W"j+D%"'7)*78"8B'7)iD%38"("CC"
Q!R-"C?D@C=DW"
y5'J$%*-"OWqW-" "jxx)*$)W"IWcW"m"T5&)&-"SW" UW" Q!ACARW"j&'J"L*2450'" L50"6$0'&'4$)4"L0$K/$)4"
/'$" 5L" 4[$" 60&(*0x" [$*%4[" 2*0$" '$0;&2$'" *(5)N" L0$K/$)4" *44$),$0'n" X" g*x$'&*)""
*6605*2[W"TB'":8"'=8'")j+D%"'7)+#)Y%8&'%X)W$'7,A)*'%$4)!?-"HHpDCW"
.*/0&-" TW"m" T*%*)4$0�" TW" QC==HRW"V$2&'&5)"(*J&)N"(5,$%'" 5L" #&))&'[")/0'$'" *),"6/F%&2"
[$*%4[")/0'$'Wj+D%"'7)+#)':='"B$:)"D%38"(4"!C-"H!A@H!>W"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
>A""
.$$"UW-"9[*)-"XW9W"m"c%[&%&6'-"VWj"Q!AADRW"V&*N)5'4&2"60*24&'$"&)")/0'&)Nn"X"20&4&2*%"0$;&$r"
5L"4[$"%&4$0*4/0$W"iD%38"()'":)W$'7,A)TB8$"B$3-"?-"H>@DHW"
.56$'-" +WUW" Q!AADRW" X" 0$%*785" $)L$0($&05@,5$)4$" 25(5" &)4$0;$)785" 4$0*61/4&2*W""
95&(F0*n"#50(*'*/W""
+2Sr$)-"+W"m"o&%%'-"SW"Q!AA=R"S'3$3),$G%8B'3)-'%')')$"#$%&'($&W"O0*,/785"X)*"+*0&*"
O[50$%%W"!|"S,W-"c5045"X%$N0$n"X0($,"
+$%$&'-" XWkW" Q!AAHRW" 2A$+%$,8B'7) iD%38"(/) 0$=$7+-&$",) '":) -%+(%$33W" Gz" S,W-""
c[&%*,$%6[&*n".&66&)2544W"
d*0*x*)-"TW+W-"950250*)@c$00x-"TW-"V0$r-"VW-"q5x(*)-"yW"m".$r&'-"+W"Q!AAGRW"V$2&'&5)"
*)*%x'&'" *'" *" 455%" 45" '/66504" *)" *)*%x4&2*%" 6*44$0)@5L@0$*'5)&)NW) iD%38"() '":) W$'7,A)
TB8$"B$3R)H-"!!=p!BGW"
d$r$%%-" XW" m" T&(5)-" qW" XW" QC=>!RW"WD&'") -%+57$&) 3+7=8"(W" S)N%$"o55," 9%&LL'-" d$r"""
U$0'$xn"c0$)4&2$"q*%%W"
c544$0-"cW"$4"*%W"Q!AAHRW""":),$0'4*),&)N"4[$"25N)&4&;$"r50J"5L")/0'&)N"&)"4[$"*2/4$"2*0$"
$);&05)($)4W"j+D%"'7)iD%38"()L:&8"83,%',8+"-"GH"Q>@?R-"G!>@GGHW"
j*'[544$-" UW" m" 9*0$);*%$" #W" Q!AABRW" +$,&2*%" *)," )/0'&)N" 2%&)&2*%" ,$2&'&5)" (*J&)Nn""
*"25(6*0*4&;$"$6&'4$(5%5N&2*%"*)*%x'&'W"iD%38"()YA87+3+-AX4"H-"CDA@C>BW"
T[*L&0-"SW"m".$g5$/L-"jW"Q!AA!RW"j*4&5)*%&4xW"L""D'7)%$=8$@3)-3XB+7+(X-"HG-"B=C@HC>W""
T&((5)'-"gW"Q!ACARW"9%&)&2*%"0$*'5)&)Nn"25)2$64"*)*%x'&'W"j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"("
DDQHR-"CCHCpCCH?W"
O*))$0-"9WXW"QC=?D*RW"j$'$*02["5)"2%&)&2*%"]/,N($)4W"j$;&$r"5L"0$'$*02["&)")/0'&)N"$,@
/2*4&5)W"d$r"}50Jn"d*4&5)*%".$*N/$"L50"d/0'&)NW"
O*))$0-"9WXW"Q!AADRW"O[&)J&)N"%&J$"*")/0'$n"*"0$'$*02[@F*'$,"(5,$%"5L"2%&)&2*%"]/,N($)4"
&)")/0'&)NW"j+D%"'7)iD%38"()!:DB',8+"-"BH"QDR-"!AB@!CCW""
O*x%50-"9W"Q!AAARW"9%&)&2*%"605F%$(@'5%;&)N"&)")/0'&)Nn"k)'&N[4'"L05("4[$"%&4$0*4/0$W""
j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"(-"GC-"?B!@?B=W"
O[5(6'5)-"9W" QC===RW"X"25)2$64/*%" 40$*,(&%%n" 4[$")$$,"L50" �(&,,%$"N05/),�" &)"2%&)&2*%"
,$2&'&5)"(*J&)N"4[$50x"&)")/0'&)NW"j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"("GA-"C!!!pC!!=W"
O[5(6'5)-"9"m"V5r,&)N"+"Q!AA!RW"*78"8B'7)0$B838+")9'K8"()'":)jD:($&$",)8")iD%38"(W"
.5),5)n"9[/02[&%%".&;&)N'45)$W"
O[5(6'5)-"9W-"V5r,&)N-"VW" QC===RW"*78"8B'7):$B838+")&'K8"()'":) [D:(&$",) 8")"D%38"(W"
S,&4$,"Fx"9*0%"O[5(6'5)"m"V*r)"V5r,&)Nn"+5'Fx"*),"T*/),$0'W"
!"#$%&'($&)*+",$&-+%."$'/)0$1)2$&'34)0$1)0$5',$3)
>C""
O[5(6'5)-" 9WX_" #5'4$0-" XW-" 95%$-" kW" m" V5r,&)N" VWoW" Q!AAHRW" :'&)N" '52&*%" ]/,N$($)4"
4[50x" 45" (5,$%" )/0'$'�/'$" 5L" 2%&)&2*%" &)L50(*4&5)" &)" 20&4&2*%" 2*0$" $,/2*4&5)W""
iD%38"()!:DB',8+")2+:'X-"!H-"D?@>>W"
o5%L-".W"$4"*%" Q!AADRW"V$'20&F&)N")/0'$'�"r50Jn"25(F&)&)N"K/*)4&4*4&;$"*),"K/*%&4*4&;$"
*)*%x'&'W"2A$)j+D%"'7)+#)WD&'")6'B,+%3)'":)!%(+"+&8B3)T+B8$,X-"B?"QCR-"H@CB"
c544$0-"cW"$4"*%W"Q!AAHRW""":),$0'4*),&)N"4[$"25N)&4&;$"r50J"5L")/0'&)N"&)"4[$"*2/4$"2*0$"
$);&05)($)4W"j+D%"'7)iD%38"()L:&8"83,%',8+"-"GH"Q>@?R-"G!>@GGHW"
j*'[544$-" UW" m" 9*0$);*%$" #W" Q!AABRW" +$,&2*%" *)," )/0'&)N" 2%&)&2*%" ,$2&'&5)" (*J&)Nn" *"
25(6*0*4&;$"$6&'4$(5%5N&2*%"*)*%x'&'W"iD%38"()YA87+3+-AX4"H-"CDA@C>BW"
T[*L&0-"SW"m".$g5$/L-"jW"Q!AA!RW"j*4&5)*%&4xW"L""D'7)%$=8$@3)-3XB+7+(X-"HG-"B=C@HC>W""
T&((5)'-"gW"Q!ACARW"9%&)&2*%"0$*'5)&)Nn"25)2$64"*)*%x'&'W"j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"("
DDQHR-"CCHCpCCH?W)
O*))$0-" 9WXW" QC=?D*RW" j$'$*02[" 5)" 2%&)&2*%" ]/,N($)4W" j$;&$r" 5L" 0$'$*02[" &)" )/0'&)N""
$,/2*4&5)W"d$r"}50Jn"d*4&5)*%".$*N/$"L50"d/0'&)NW"
O*))$0-"9WXW"Q!AADRW"O[&)J&)N"%&J$"*")/0'$n"*"0$'$*02[@F*'$,"(5,$%"5L"2%&)&2*%"]/,N($)4"
&)")/0'&)NW"j+D%"'7)iD%38"()!:DB',8+"-"BH"QDR-"!AB@!CCW""
O*x%50-" 9W" Q!AAARW" 9%&)&2*%" 605F%$(@'5%;&)N" &)" )/0'&)Nn" k)'&N[4'" L05(" 4[$" %&4$0*4/0$W""
j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"(-"GC-"?B!@?B=W"
O[5(6'5)-"9W" QC===RW"X"25)2$64/*%" 40$*,(&%%n" 4[$")$$,"L50" �(&,,%$"N05/),�" &)"2%&)&2*%"
,$2&'&5)"(*J&)N"4[$50x"&)")/0'&)NW"j+D%"'7)+#)L:='"B$:)iD%38"("GA-"C!!!pC!!=W"
O[5(6'5)-"9"m"V5r,&)N"+"Q!AA!RW"*78"8B'7)0$B838+")9'K8"()'":)jD:($&$",)8")iD%38"(W"
.5),5)n"9[/02[&%%".&;&)N'45)$W"
O[5(6'5)-"9W-"V5r,&)N-"VW" QC===RW"*78"8B'7):$B838+")&'K8"()'":) [D:(&$",) 8")"D%38"(W"
S,&4$,"Fx"9*0%"O[5(6'5)"m"V*r)"V5r,&)Nn"+5'Fx"*),"T*/),$0'W"
O[5(6'5)-" 9WX_" #5'4$0-" XW-" 95%$-" kW" m" V5r,&)N" VWoW" Q!AAHRW" :'&)N" '52&*%" ]/,N$($)4"
4[50x" 45"(5,$%" )/0'$'�/'$" 5L" 2%&)&2*%" &)L50(*4&5)" &)" 20&4&2*%" 2*0$" $,/2*4&5)W"iD%38"()
!:DB',8+")2+:'X-"!H-"D?@>>W"
o5%L-".W"$4"*%" Q!AADRW"V$'20&F&)N")/0'$'�"r50Jn"25(F&)&)N"K/*)4&4*4&;$"*),"K/*%&4*4&;$"
*)*%x'&'W"2A$)j+D%"'7)+#)WD&'")6'B,+%3)'":)!%(+"+&8B3)T+B8$,X-"B?"QCR-"H@CBW"
!
""