pablo rodrigo alflen - leis penais em branco e o direito penal do risco

8/8/2019 Pablo Rodrigo Alflen - Leis penais em branco e o direito penal do risco

1/32

B FCHFB NBV JMHV [MCBHV MI DTBCFO FOIOHCV^T]IMC^O O[OT^]CO MI ]I NHTMH^O [MCBJNO THVFO

[bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb,

Tmv}io< O {tmvmc~m bt~heo ~tb~b vodtm b {todjmi~hfb nb ~fchfbnb jmh {mcbj mi dtbcfo m o vm} mi{tmeo mi }i Nhtmh~o[mcbj othmc~bno {mjb Vofhojoehb no Thvfo# Mi {thimhto

j}ebt* vo bdotnbnov bv{mf~ov mv{mfghfov tmgmtmc~mv vjmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo* foio o focfmh~o* ecmvm mfjbvvhghfbo* dmi foio b l}v~hghfbo {btb o vm} mi{tmeo(2# Mi vme}cno j}ebt* bcbjhvb)vm o f`bibno Nhtmh~o [mcbjno Thvfo* mcr}bc~o {ton}~o tmv}j~bc~m nb hcgj}cfhb nbionmtcb Vofhojoehb no Thvfo vodtm o Nhtmh~o {mcbj (4#[ot ghi* vo bcbjhvbnov bv{mf~ov focv~h~}fhocbhvmv{mfghfov r}m hi{mnmi b bnmvo b }i Nhtmh~o [mcbj no

Thvfo m* {ot focvmrcfhb* o mi{tmeo bd}vhwo nm jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo (6#

[bjbwtbv)f`bwm< jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo# Nhtmh~o {mcbj no thvfo#Ebtbc~hbv# Vofhmnbnm no thvfo#

Bdv~tbf~< ^`hv bt~hfjm nhvf}vvmv ~`m {todjmi og ~`m ~mf`chf og ~`mfthihcbj jbu hc u`h~m bcn h~v }vm hc b fthihcbj jbu e}hnmn

dx ~`m Vofhojoex og Thva# Ghtv~* btm nhvf}vvmn v{mfhghfbv{mf~v tmjb~hce ~o fthihcbj jbuv hc u`h~m* jham ~`m focfm{~*othehc bcn fjbvvhghfb~hoc* bcn ~oo ~`m l}v~hghfb~hoc got xo}t}vm (2# Vmfocnjx* h~ hv bcbjx|mn ~`m fbjjmn Fthihcbj Jbuog Thva* bv b {ton}f~ tmv}j~hce gtoi ~`m hcgj}mcfm og ionmtcvofhojoex og thva oc ~`m fthihcbj jbu (4# Ghcbjjx* btmbcbjx|mn ~`m v{mfhghf focv~h~}~hocbj bv{mf~v ~`b~ {tmwmc~

, [togmvvot nm Nhtmh~o [mcbj m [tofmvv}bj [mcbj nb ]chwb~mv m nb ]JDTB m Footnmcbnot nm[mvr}hvb m Mp~mcvo nb ]chwmtvhnbnm J}~mtbcb no Dtbvhj nm Vo Lmtchio (]JDTB)VL#[togmvvot no F}tvo nm Mv{mfhbjh|bo mi Nhtmh~o [mcbj m [oj~hfb Fthihcbj nb ]GTEV#Imv~tm mi Fhcfhbv Fthihcbhv ([]FTV# Bnwoebno Fthihcbj# Jnmt no Et}{o nm [mvr}hvb

Nhtmh~o [mcbj Hc~mtcbfhocbj m Foi{btbno (FC[r/]JDTB)VL# Imidto nb Emvmjjvf`bg~gt Wjamtv~tbgtmf`~#


2/32

6=7 [bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb

Tmwhv~b nb Gbf}jnbnm nm Nhtmh~o nm ]dmtjcnhb w# 67< 6==)60=* 4;;0

~`m bn`mtmcfm ~o b Fthihcbj Jbu og Thva bcn* focvmr}mc~jx*~`m bd}vhwm }vm og fthihcbj jbuv hc u`h~m#

Amxuotnv< Fthihcbj jbuv hc u`h~m# Fthihcbj Jbu og Thva# E}btbc~mmv#Vofhm~x og thva#

Hc~ton}o

B r}mv~o nbv f`bibnbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo nmvnm ` i}h~o ~mi{mtibcmfhno ibtemi nbv hcwmv~hebmv m {mvr}hvbv nmvmcwojwhnbv co

idh~o no Nhtmh~o [mcbj* vmcno r}m imvio cb jh~mtb~}tb l}tnhfo){mcbj noi}cno m}to{m} {o}fov ~i vhno ov ~tbdbjòv r}m cbv j~hibv nfbnbv~mi woj~bno ov ojòv {btb b imvib2# ^bj r}mv~o mpv}tem cb imnhnb mir}m vm {bt~m nm }i Nhtmh~o [mcbj r}m ~mi b v}b {t{thb tbh| co {mcvbimc~ohj}v~tbno* }ib wm| r}m mv~m {to{otfhoco} o nmvmcwojwhimc~o nbv ebtbc~hbvbhcnb òlm bvvme}tbnbv {mjo Nhtmh~o [mcbj* ocnm {tmfmh~ov foio o nbvmf}jbth|bo* nb }j~hib tb~ho o} no fbt~mt v}dvhnhtho* no {thcf{ho nbjmebjhnbnm* othmc~bno {mjb hnhb nm fmt~m|b m fjbtm|b nbv jmhv {mcbhv*

{bvvbtbi b focv~h~}ht o bjhfmtfm no r}m vm focwmcfhoco} f`bibt nm Nhtmh~o[mcbj fjvvhfo1 ov r}bhv* bhcnb r}m foi tmvvbjwbv* gotibtbi b dbvm no{mcvbimc~o jhdmtbj no l}thv~b bjmio Abtj Dhcnhce* r}m goh }i nov {thimhtovl}thv~bv b nmvmcwojw)jov mi }ib mv~t}~}tb vhv~mib~h|bnb#

Foc~}no* {bvvbno ibhv nm }i vf}jo b{v b {thimhtb mnho nb odtbnm Dhcnhce* hc~h~}jbnbNhm Cotimc }cn h`tm dmt~tm~}ce4* cb r}bj o l}thv~b

2 Foi{btm* {ot mpmi{jo* cb jh~mtb~}tb m}to{hb* mp{tmvvbimc~m< [][[M* Hcemdote#^b~htt~}i* Tmf`~vhtt~}i* V}dv}i~hocvhtt~}i* hc V~tbgtmf`~vnoeib~hvf`m Bcbjxvmc*4;;7* Docc< ]chwmtvh~x [tmvv* {# 47=)6;7 (mv{mfhbjimc~m {# 40=)48>* {}djhfbnoothehcbthbimc~m mi Eoj~nbiimtv Btf`hw* 288;* {# 2>=)2041 ~bidi A]@JMC* Jo~`bt#^mf`chvf`m Thvhamc hi V~tbgtmf`~* hc Nbv Tmf`~ woc nmc @mtb}vgotnmt}cemc nmtionmtcmc ^mf`cha* Vmo}j* 2888* {# == m v#1 [H\BTTO DMJM\B* Ibthb ^mtm|b# Otmehim jmebj no mtto m bv cotibv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo* Fohidtb* Bjimnhcb* 4;;21VBC^BCB WMEB* N}jfm Ibtb# Mj focfm{~o nm jmx {mcbj mc djbcfo * D}mcov Bhtmv* Bnòf* 4;;;1 ibhv tmfmc~mimc~m* gb|mcno tmgmtcfhb bo mi{tmeo nm jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfoco Mv~b~}~o nm Toib no ^thd}cbj [mcbj Hc~mtcbfhocbj BIDOV* Abh# Tmibtav oc ~`mEmcmtbj [bt~ og Hc~mtcb~hocbj Fthihcbj Fo}t~* hc Lo}tcbj og Hc~mtcb~hocbj Fthihcbj

L}v~hfm* 4;;7* {# 24# Cb jh~mtb~}tb jb~hco)bimthfbcb< F]TX* Mcthr}m# Jb jmx {mcbj mcdjbcfo# Fojoidhb< Mnh~othbj ^mihv V# B#* 28001 VHJWB* [bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb# Jmhv{mcbhv mi dtbcfo m o Nhtmh~o [mcbj no Thvfo# Tho nm Lbcmhto< J}imc L}thv* 4;;>#

4 B odtb nm Abtj Dhcnhce* hc~h~}jbnb Nhm Cotimc }cn h`tm dmt~tm~}ce# Mhcm ]c~mtv}f`}cedmt nhm tmf`~vivvhe @bcnj}ce }cn nhm Bt~mc nmv Nmjha~v* ~mwm v}b {thimhtb mnho{}djhfbnb co bco nm 2054#


3/32


6=5B ~fchfb nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo foio hcv~t}imc~oo{ot~}co mi }i nhtmh~o {mcbj no thvfo

bjmio mjbdoto} b nmvhecbo m nmjhcmo} ov bv{mf~ov dvhfov nbv f`bibnbvjmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo* {mtfmdm)vm r}m b {todjmi~hfb bfmtfb nmv~bv* cov v}dvhv~m* m nm ibcmhtb jb~mc~m* foio vm bfmc~}b bhcnb ibhv 6#Cb~}tbjimc~m* {ofb b h{~mvm nmv~b ~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb co b{tmvmc~bwbibhotmv {todjmibv* cb imnhnb mi r}m b Focv~h~}ho no Hi{tho bjmio{ovvhdhjh~bwb v hcv~cfhbv nm fb~meothb hcgmthot jmehvjbtmi ib~thb {mcbj#

Co mc~bc~o* foi ov {todjmibv tmv}j~bc~mv nb hcv{htbo {mjovionmtcov nmvmcwojwhimc~ov vofhbhv* ibhv {tmfhvbimc~m nb f`bibnbVofhmnbnm no Thvfo* mpv}tem }i Nhtmh~o [mcbj no Thvfo> r}m* foi bnmdhjh~bo nbv ebtbc~hbv {oj~hfo)fthihcbhv* ~mi v}vfh~bno }i {bcotbib{to{fho {btb o mi{tmeo btdh~ttho m hcnhvfthihcbno nm jmhv {mcbhv mi

dtbcfo# Nhvvo vm vme}m bnmvo b }i ionmjo ihchibjhv~b* bvvme}tbnotnbv ebtbc~hbv {oj~hfo)fthihcbhv* o} vmlb* othmc~bo {mjb jhih~bo no{onmt {}ch~hwo mv~b~bj* tmfoc`mfmcno ov nhtmh~ov g}cnbimc~bhv foio nhtmh~ovnm nmgmvb (Bdum`ttmf`~m foc~tb o Mv~bno# [ot focvmrcfhb* hvvo focn}| o{ovho b }i Nhtmh~o [mcbj othmc~bno {mjbv ionmtcbv ~mothbvvofhojehfbv* vmcno g}cnbimc~bj mv~bdmjmfmt nhtm~th|mv {btb bbnihvvhdhjhnbnm nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo* mi }chvvoccfhb foi ov{ov~}jbnov no Mv~bno nm Nhtmh~o#

2 Jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo

2#2 Ecmvm* focfmh~o m fjbvvhghfbo

Bo nmvmcwojwmt v}b ~mothb nbv cotibv* Dhcnhce=* othmc~bno {mjov

6 Wmlb* {ot mpmi{jo* GHBCNBFB* Ehowbch1 I]VFO* Mc|o# Nmtmf`o [mcbj* [bt~m Emcmtbj*

^tbn}ffhc nm J}hv Gmtcbcno Cho* Doeo~< Mnh~othbj ^mihv* 4;;7* {# 0>)05* ov r}bhvb{tmvmc~bi }i {bcotbib v}fhc~o* {oti* bj~bimc~m hj}v~tb~hwo bfmtfb nb {todjmi~hfb#

> F}lb nmvhecbo ibhv tmfmc~mimc~m ~mi vhno vodtm{}lbnb {mjb hnmojoehb cbfhocbj)vofhbjhv~bno Nhtmh~o [mcbj no Hchiheo nm Lbaodv* r}m b{mvbt nm co vmt bvvofhbnb nhtm~bimc~m {mjovm} fthbnot hnmojoehb cb|hv~b* b vhihjh~}nm m b {tophihnbnm nbv {to{ov~bv m othmc~bmv({tmfocfmh~}ovbv m nhvfthihcb~thbv vo co~thbv#

= Foio ibhv no r}m vbdhno* mi v}b ~mothb Dhcnhce nhv~hce}hb b jmh m b cotib {mcbj< b cotibvmthb }i ibcnb~o* }ib {to{ovho no Nhtmh~o co jmehvjbno* o} vmlb* }i hi{mtb~hwo r}mnm~mtihcb r}m vm nmwm gb|mt o} nmhpbt nm gb|mt bjeo* m r}m nmthwbno nb {thimhtb {bt~m nb jmh{mcbj1 bv jmhv {mcbhv vmthbi nhv{ovhmv o} r}m foc~i tmetbv emtbhv vodtm b tmv{ocvbdhjhnbnmfthihcbj o} r}m nmfjbtbi r}bhv vo bv bmv {}cwmhv m bv tmv{mf~hwbv {mcbv1 mjbv vm focv~h~}mi

nm n}bv {bt~mv o ^b~dmv~bcn (~h{o m b Tmf`~vgojem (focvmrcfhb l}tnhfb# Foi hvvo* Dhcnhcef`meo} focfj}vo nm r}m o fthihcovo hcgthcem co b jmh {mcbj nm bfotno foi b r}bj mjm l}jebno* ibv vhi r}m mjm bem mi }chvvoccfhb foi b {thimhtb {bt~m nmv~b jmh* mjm hcgthcem bcotib# Foi{btm DHCNHCE* Abtj# Nhm Cotimc }cn h`tm dmt~tm~}ce* \umh~m B}gjbem*Dbcn 2* Jmh{|he< Wmtjbe Uhj`mji Mcemjibcc* 208;1 }i {bcotbib b{tog}cnbno mcfoc~tb)vmmi VHJWB* [bdjo T# Bjgjmc nb# Jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo* {# 2)66#


4/32

6=0 [bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb


hcgj}pov hnmojehfov no {mtono (foio o tbfhocbjhvio `hv~othfhv~b r}mb{tmvmc~o} tmgjmpov nhtm~ov cb f`bibnb L}thv{t}ncfhb nov Focfmh~ov m o {ovh~hwhvio)l}tnhfo* focv~b~o} b mphv~cfhb nm bje}ibv jmphi{mtgmf~bv* bv r}bhv nmvheco} Djbcam~~v~tbgemvm~|mc (jmhv {mcbhv midtbcfo# Mv~bv b{tmvmc~bwbi foio fbtbf~mtv~hfbv {thcfh{bhv* mi {thimhtoj}ebt* o gb~o nm r}m o ~h{o {mcbj mtb nmvfth~o nm iono hi{tmfhvo* m* mivme}cno j}ebt* r}m b ib~thb nm {tohdho nmwmthb vmt {tmmcf`hnb {ot }ibb}~othnbnm {ojhfhbj jofbj o} nov Mv~bnov o}* bhcnb* {ot jmehvjbo {bt~hf}jbt*nb b fjvvhfb bghtibo nm r}m mv~b {tohdho {onm {mtvme}ht b{toi}jebo nb jmh {mcbj* ocnm mc~o b jmh {mcbj ~mi{otbthbimc~m foio}i fot{o mttbc~m* {tof}tb v}b bjib#7 ^onbwhb* nm mp~tmib tmjmwcfhb

b focv~b~bo nm Dhcnhce nb gjmphdhjhnbnm nmv~bv jmhv* nm iono r}m* nmbfotno foi mjbv* b ib~thb nm {tohdho ionhghfb)vm gbfhjimc~m vme}cnobv whfhvvh~}nmv r}m vogtmi ov bfoc~mfhimc~ov b r}m vm tmgmtmi# ^bjfocfm{o* cb~}tbjimc~m* mv~bwb mi foi{jm~b }chvvoccfhb foi bmv~t}~}tb focv~h~}fhocbj no Hi{tho bjmio# B Focv~h~}ho no Hi{tho(nb~bnb nm 27 nm bdthj nm 2052 vhcbjh|o} b i}nbcb {btb }ib Gmnmtbofoi foi{m~cfhb emtbj m co {mjb tm}cho nbv imtbv foi{m~cfhbv novmv~bnov vhce}jbtmv# Mv~b* foio bghtib Dhcnhce*5 b~thd}b bo Hi{tho bjmio

b jmehvjbo foi}i vodtm Nhtmh~o [mcbj* vmcno r}m* mi bje}cv fbvov* bfoi{m~cfhb mtb ~bc~o no Hi{tho foio nov Mv~bnov nb Gmnmtbo(D}cnmvv~bb~mc# M midotb Dhcnhce ~mc`b odvmtwbno o gb~o nm r}m bnmvhecbo jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo cb {ofb ~mc`b vhno foi{jm~bimc~mbfmh~b {mjo thd}cbj noTmhf`* tmvvbj~o} r}m @mhc|m l bwhb focv~b~bno bmphv~cfhb nmv~b ~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb* ibv bv ~hc`b nmvhecbno djhcnmV~tbgnto`}cemc (bimbbv {mcbhv fmebv#0

B focfm{o othehcthb goh jmwbnb bnhbc~m m bi{jhbnb {ot M# Im|emt*

7 DHCNHCE* Nhm Cotimc* {# 274< nhmvmv Wmtdo~ nmi Mtjbvv nmv V~tbgemvm~|mv mtv~ cbf`gojemcabcc* uo nmcc nbv V~tbgemvm~| mhcv~umhjmc uhm mhc httmcnmt At{mt vmhcm Vmmjm v}f`~#

5 Foi{btm DHCNHCE* Nhm Cotimc* {# 2=0#0 Foi{btm DHCNHCE* Nhm Cotimc* {# 272* cb co~b nm tonb{ 8# Mcebcb)vm jwbto

Ibxthca nb Fov~b (Nhtmh~o [mcbj# woj}im H* ~oio H* 7# mnho* Tho nm Lbcmhto< Mnh~otbGotmcvm* {# 620)628* bo tmvvbj~bt r}m b mp{tmvvo Djbcam~~v~tbgemvm~| mi{tmebnb {otDhcnhce vhechghfb cotib {mcbj no ibcnb~o mi dtbcfo* hvvo nmiocv~tb }ib focg}vofocfm{~}bj hcbnihvvwmj m }ib nm~}t{bo nb ~mothb dhcnhcechbcb* {ohv r}bc~o b hvvo o

b}~ot {tmvfhcnm nb {t{thb nhv~hco nm Dhcnhce mc~tm jmh m cotib* bnmibhv* b mp{tmvvo}~hjh|bnb vmthb Djbcam~~ibcnb~vv~tbgcoti # Foim~mcno mcebco vmimj`bc~m WjbnhihtEhbfoi}||h (Cotib {mcbj mi dtbcfo hc Tmwhv~b nb BL]THV* l}j`o nm 2888* {# 2;=* ibvo ibhot mcebco nmv~m j~hio focvhv~m mi gbjbt nm jmhv {mcbhv nm ibcnb~o mi dtbcfo*r}bcno Dhcnhce fjbto bo bghtibt r}m b jmh {mcbj co mcfmttb }i ibcnb~o* vmcno r}m mv~bfbtbf~mtv~hfb nh| tmv{mh~o mpfj}vhwbimc~m cotib#


5/32


6=8B ~fchfb nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo foio hcv~t}imc~oo{ot~}co mi }i nhtmh~o {mcbj no thvfo

o r}bj hcvmth} b r}mv~o nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo co idh~o nb ~mothb~h{o8* vmcno r}m* bo mjbdotbt b nhv~hco mc~tm ~h{ov gmf`bnov m ~h{ov r}mcmfmvvh~bi nm foi{jmimc~bo* hc~ton}|h} cmv~mv j~hiov bv jmhv {mcbhvmi dtbcfo#

Vme}cno Im|emt ~h{ov gmf`bnov vmthbi br}mjmv r}m mi vh imviov~tb|mi ~onov ov mjmimc~ov no tmv{mf~hwo gb~o {}cwmj2; m ~h{ov {mcbhvmi dtbcfo vmthbi br}mjmv ~h{ov r}m l cb gotib mp~mthot ({ot~bc~o* cob{mcbv {mjb v}b cmfmvvhnbnm nm foi{jmimc~bo wbjotb~hwb tmim~mi foi{jmimc~bmv mcfoc~tbnbv nmvnm gotb22* ~tb~b)vm* {ot~bc~o* nm }ib~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb# Foc~}no* o focfmh~o nm jmh {mcbj mi dtbcfo vogtm}ib co~wmj bi{jhbo foi Im|emt* {ohv foi b nhv~hco mc~tm jmhv

{mcbhv mi dtbcfo mi vmc~hno bi{jo m mi vmc~hno mv~th~o hcfj}h b hnhbnm r}m o foi{jmimc~o nb jmh {mcbj mi dtbcfo {onm mv~bt foc~hno cbimvib jmh o} mi o}~tb jmh r}m mibcb nb imvib hcv~cfhb jmehvjb~hwb24#

Bvvhi* cbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo mi vmc~hno bi{jo o ~h{o m b vbcomcfoc~tbi)vm vm{btbnov mp~mtcbimc~m* vmcno r}m b vbco whcf}jb)vmb{mcbv b }i ~h{o r}m cmfmvvh~b vmt foi{jmimc~bno* {onmcno nhv~hce}ht)vm n}bv h{~mvmv< b b foi{jmimc~bo cmfmvvthb mv~ foc~hnb cb imvibjmh* o r}m* focgotim Im|emt* hi{jhfb ~o v mi }i {todjmib nm {}tb

~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb1 m d o foi{jmimc~o mv~ foc~hno mi o}~tb jmh* midotbnb imvib hcv~cfhb jmehvjb~hwb# L cbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo mi vmc~hnomv~th~o b foi{jmimc~bo cmfmvvthb mv~ hcfj}nb mi }ib jmh nm o}~tbhcv~cfhb jmehvjb~hwb# Mi focvhnmtbo mv~b nhv~hco Im|emt n bmc~mcnmt }ib ibhot {tmof}{bo foi o {thcf{ho nb jmebjhnbnm* mi{bt~hf}jbt bov {ov~}jbnov nm jmp vfth{~b m jmp fmt~b* midotb focvhnmtmhttmjmwbc~m mv~b gotib mv{mfhbj nm jmehvjbo {mcbj mi dtbcfo* dmi foior}m* mi r}bjr}mt h{~mvm* b v}b hi{ot~cfhb vm jhih~b bo idh~o nb ~fchfb

jmehvjb~hwb mp~mtcb# Bvvhi* odvmtwb r}m o foi{jmimc~o cmfmvvtho vmi{tmhc~metb o ~h{o* nm ibcmhtb r}m o ~h{o l foi{jmimc~bno f}i{tm bv imvibvg}cmv r}m ov fbvov cotibhv#26

8 Foi{btm IM\EMT* Mni}cn# V~tbgtmf`~* Bjjemimhcmt ^mhj* Mhc V~}nhmcd}f`* Dbcn2* Dmtjhc< Dmfavf`m Wmtjbevd}f``bcnj}ce* 28=2* {# 0> m v#

2; Foi{btm IM\EMT* V~tbgtmf`~* {# 0>#22

Foi{btm IM\EMT* V~tbgtmf`~* {# 0=#24 IM\EMT* V~tbgtmf`~* {# 0= m v# ^bc~o mi vm} V~}nhmcd}f` foio co ^tb~bno* }~hjh|b bfjbvvhghfbo jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo hi umh~mtmc Vhccm Qmi vmc~hno bi{joY m hi mcemtmcVhccm Qmi vmc~hno mv~th~oY#

26 IM\EMT*^tb~bno nm Nmtmfò [mcbj* ^tbn}ffhc nm Tonthe}m| I}o|* Ibnthn< Mnh~othbjTmwhv~b nm Nmtmfò [thwbno* 28==* ôio H* {# 685)680#


6/32

67; [bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb


2#4 Nmvmcwojwhimc~o m {todjmi~hfb

Wmthghfb)vm foi fjbtm|b r}m l b {bt~ht nb {thimhtb im~bnm no vf}joPP o mi{tmeo nm jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo cbv jmehvjbmv vm ~otco} fbnbwm| ibhot# B i}j~hgotihnbnm m b foi{jmphnbnm nb whnb mi gbfm nov{todjmibv tmv}j~bc~mv {btb ov nhwmtvov fbi{ov nm b~hwhnbnm (foiomfocoihb* tmjbmv nm focv}io* ~thd}~bo*2> f}lb tme}jbimc~bo nmnhgfhj nm~mtihcbo* }ib wm| r}m nm{mcnm nm focl}c~}tbv ofbvhocbhvmphehcno* hcfj}vhwm* b bnoo nm nmfhvmv ~mi{otthbv bnmr}bnbv b fbnb}ib nmjbv* b{tmvmc~o} tmgjmpov ~bidi cb jmehvjbo foi o tmf}tvo hcv~cfhbv ibhv emhv* ocnm mc~o bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo {bvvbtbi b

vmt tmfoc`mfhnbv foio }i ibj cmfmvvtho#Foio mpmi{jo nmv~m nmvmcwojwhimc~o mpbv{mtbnot wmho ~ocb o

{t{tho Nhtmh~o [mcbj mfocihfo2=* {ohv l b {bt~ht nb [thimhtb E}mttbI}cnhbj nmvmcwojwmtbi)vm cowbv gotibv l}tnhfbv {mjb f`bibnbmfocoihb nm e}mttb* b r}bj ogmtmfm} o r}bnto nm }ib mfocoihbhc~mhtbimc~m otebch|bnb* mp~tb{ojbcno o idh~o nbv tmjbmv {thwbnbv#27

Mi tb|o nhvvo bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo {bvvbtbi b focv~h~}ht }ib voj}oi}h~o fionb* {bt~hf}jbtimc~m nhbc~m nbv {bt~hf}jbthnbnmv nmv~m vm~ot*

r}m hi{}vmtbi o tmf}tvo nhv{ovhmv l}tnhfo){mcbhv ibhv gjmpwmhv mwbthwmhv* {ovvhdhjh~bcno b ionhghfbo nb ib~thb nm {tohdho ibhvgbfhjimc~m#

Ibv* cb~}tbjimc~m* ~ono focfmh~o bnr}htm cowov ib~h|mv r}bcno vmv}dim~m cowov foc~tbv~mv* m cmvvm vmc~hno o {t{tho focfmh~o nm jmh{mcbj mi dtbcfo bnr}hth} cowov ib~h|mv mi focvhnmtbo foi{jmphnbnmnov idh~ov r}m {bvvbtbi b tmfjbibt {to~mo {mcbj# Co mc~bc~o* foihvvo* bji nov {todjmibv nm otnmi focv~h~}fhocbj* tmv}j~o} bhcnb }ib

wmtnbnmhtb focg}vo focfm{~}bj* vmcno r}m b {t{thb nmvhecbo{mt vmfocghtib mv~b {todjmi~hfb* cb imnhnb mi r}m vm ~mi }~hjh|bno mp{tmvvmv

2> Foi{btm ^HMNMIBCC* Ajb}v# Uht~vf`bg~vv~tbgtmf`~* hc V~bb~vjmphaoc# 5# B}gjbem*Dbcn =* Gtmhd}te h# Dt#< @mtnmt* 288=* {# 2;70#

2= Cmvvm vmc~hno foi{btm BCNTM]FFH* Thfbtno Bc~}cmv# Mv~}nov m {btmfmtmv nm Nhtmh~o[mcbj# Vo [b}jo< Mnh~otb Tmwhv~b nov ^thd}cbhv* 2804* {# 2=;* o r}bj* bo tmgmtht)vm boNhtmh~o [mcbj mfocihfo* tmvvbj~b r}m o vm} odlm~o wbeo m ov dmcv l}tnhfov ~}~mjbnovnmibvhbnbimc~m hi{tmfhvov o} `m~mtoecmov# Foi{btm bhcnb ^TH[IBAMT* V~mgbc#

Nmt v}lma~hwm ^b~dmv~bcn nmv A}tvdm~t}ev* hc Uhv~tb* @mg~ 0* B}e}v~ 4;;4* @mhnmjdmte


7/32


672B ~fchfb nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo foio hcv~t}imc~oo{ot~}co mi }i nhtmh~o {mcbj no thvfo

foio cotibv mi dtbcfo (Djbcam~~cotimc25* ~h{ov mi dtbcfo(Djbcam~~~b~dmv~cnm20 o r}m fobn}cb foi b {mtv{mf~hwb nmvmcwojwhnb{ot Im|emt * o} bhcnb {tmvfthmv mi dtbcfo (Djbcam~~wotvf`thg~mc28#

No imvio iono {onm)vm gbjbt r}bc~o {t{thb coo nm jmh {mcbjmi dtbcfo nm r}m vm {bt~m< bvvhi* {ot mpmi{jo* focvhnmtbi)vm jmhv {mcbhvmi dtbcfo br}mjbv mi r}m o jmehvjbnot vm jhih~b ghpbt }ib nm~mtihcbnbfoihcbo {mcbj* {oti fmnm b goti}jbo nov ~h{ov* o {tmmcf`himc~ono dtbcfo* b o}~tov otebchviov* r}m {onmi vmt ~bc~o teov jmehvjb~hwov*b}~othnbnmv bnihchv~tb~hwbv gmnmtbhv* b}~othnbnmv bnihchv~tb~hwbvmv~bn}bhv m* mpfm{fhocbjimc~m* ~bidi b}~othnbnmv mv~tbcemhtbv#4;

ônbwhb* cmv~b `h{~mvm o b~o jmehvjb~hwo mv~bdmjmfm b vbco nm iono

{tmfhvo* ibv nmhpb o foc~mno ~o~bjimc~m vmi mv{mfhghfbo* {ohv fmnmbgoti}jbo no ~h{o# bj hnhb nm jmh {mcbj mi dtbcfo hcgthcem o {thcf{honb jmebjhnbnm (~bc~o r}bc~o mphecfhb nm jmp {tbmwhb* r}bc~o nm jmpfmt~b42* bo imvio ~mi{o mi r}m b{tmvmc~b ~{hfb `h{~mvm nmnmjmebo nm b~thd}ho jmehvjb~hwb {tohdhnb mi ib~thb {mcbj# Vod o}~tb~hfb mc~mcnm)vm r}m cotibv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo vo br}mjbv f}lb`h{~mvm nm gb~o vm focghe}tb {ot tmihvvo b }ib cotib nm fbt~mt

25 Cmvvm vmc~hno* foi{btm AO@JIBCC* E}c~mt# Nhm et}cnv~|m }cn nhm wmtgbvv}cevtmf`~jhfèmu`tjmhv~m~mc Ebtbc~hmc }cn Tmf`~m nmv nm}~vf`mc V~m}mtv~tbgtmf`~v* hc [thcf{hov*nmtmfòv x ebtbc~hbv focv~h~}fhocbjmv nmj Tehimc vbcfhocbnot ^thd}~btho #Ibnthn< Hcv~h~}~o nm Mv~}nhov Ghvfbjmv Ct# 28* Woj}im H* 4;;2* {# 20#

20 Cmvvm vmc~hno BTCOJN* Lte# Dmthf`~ dmt nbv Nth~~mvF`hcmvhvf`)Nm}~vf`mv Aojjor}h}iwoi 62#0 dhv >#8#2880 hc Dmhlhce* Gtmhd}te h# Dt#< Ibp [jbcfa* {# 22#

28 Cmvvm vmc~hno foi{btm ^H[AM* Ajb}v# V~m}mtv~tbgtmf`~* hc V~bb~vjmphaoc* Dbcn 6*Gtmhd}te h# Dt#< Wmtjbe @mtnmt* {# 620* vmcno r}m bje}cv ^thd}cbhv nb Tm{djhfb Gmnmtbj nbBjmibc`b ~bidi mi{tmebi mv~b mp{tmvvo# Co imvio vmc~hno UMVVMJV* Lo`bccmv1

DM]JAM* Umtcmt# V~tbgtmf`~* Bjjemimhcmt ^mhj* 6=# B}gjbem* @mhnmjdmte< Ijjmt Wmtjbe*4;;=* c#i# 2;7* {# >41 ~bidi O^Ô* @btto# Et}cna}tv V~tbgtmf`~* ># B}gjbem*Dmtjhc< Wmtjbe Ubj~mt nm Et}x~mt* 2884* {# 4#

4; IB]TBF@* Tmhc`bt~1 \H[G* @mhc|# V~tbgtmf`~* Bjjemimhcmt ^mhj* @mhnmjdmte< IjjmtWmtjbe* 2855* {# 226# Co imvio vmc~hno o focfmh~o b{tmvmc~bno {ot \BGGBTOCH*M}emcho Tbj# ^mothb nmj Nmjh~o* Btemc~hcb< Mnhbt* {# 208# He}bjimc~m V^TB^MCUMT^@*Ec~mt1 A]@JMC* Jo~`bt# V~tbgtmf`~* Bjjemimhcmt ^mhj * =# B}gjbem* Ajc< Fbtj@mxibccv Wmtjbe* 4;;>* {# >6 ( 6* c#i# 0* co~b nm tonb{ 0* ov r}bhv* b{ohbcno)vm cbnmfhvo no DE@ 7* 6; Q>; m v#Y* bghtibi r}m bv jmhv mi dtbcfo foc~i }ib foihcbo nm{mcb {btb b whojbo nm nhv{ovhmv l}tnhfbv r}m gotbi o} vo nmftm~bnbv nmvnm }i jofbj mmi }i o}~to ioimc~o1 bhcnb* m fh~bcno b imvib nmfhvo no DE@* foi{btm TOPHC*Fjb}v# V~tbgtmf`~* Bjjemimhcmt ^mhj* Icf`mc< Wmtjbe Dmfa* 2884* {# 6;6)6;>#

42 Cmvvm vmc~hno* foi{btm GHBCNBFB/I]VFO# Nmtmfò [mcbj* {# 05 ov r}bhv ~mi tmgmthnor}m< nmwm)vm focvhnmtbt emtbjimc~m foc~tthb bo {thcf{ho nm tmvmtwb nm jmh b ~fchfb nmtmihvvo b }ib goc~m vmf}cnthb {btb b nm~mtihcbo nm mjmimc~ov mvvmcfhbhv no hjfh~o1bnmibhv* cmvvm vmc~hno ~mi tmgmthno FHTHCO NOV VBCÔV* L}btm|# Nhtmh~o [mcbj# [bt~mEmtbj# Tho nm Lbcmhto< J}imc L}thv* 4;;7* {# =;#


8/32

674 [bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb


co {mcbj#44 Mv~b `h{~mvm* bji nm tmf`bbt b nhv~hco dhcnhcechbcbmc~tm jmh m cotib46* jhih~b b tmihvvo ~o v cotibv nm fbt~mt co){mcbj (mp~tb){mcbj* m foi hvvo {tmvfhcnm nb hnhb nm jmh {mcbj mi dtbcfomi vmc~hno bi{jo#

Mc~tm~bc~o* b focfm{o ibhv etbwm r}m ~mi vhno b{tmvmc~bnb {btmfmvmt b nm ^hmnmibcc* bo mjbdotbt }i ihp~}i foi{ovh~}i nm hcv~h~}~ovr}m co {onmi vmt ihv~}tbnov* {ohv mr}h{btb bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfobov f`bibnov ~h{ov {mcbhv bdmt~ov# Bvvhi tmvvbj~b o l}thv~b nm Gtmhd}te B

bghtibo* bjhv* tmh~mtbnb* ibhv tmfmc~mimc~m* {ot ^hmnmibcc boimcfhocbt r}m co nhtmh~o {mcbj mfocihfo* {oti* o mi{tmeo nm jmhvbdmt~bv (mi dtbcfo co v gtmrmc~m* vmco ~{hfo#4= Foc~}no* bv jmhv{mcbhv mi dtbcfo co vo ~h{ov hcfoi{jm~ov co vmc~hno nm ~h{ov bdmt~ov47*nm iono r}m bidov ov hcv~h~}~ov co nmwmi vmt mr}h{btbnov# Mcr}bc~oov ~h{ov foi{jm~ov foc~i o foc~mno no hcl}v~o nm }ib mv{fhm nm nmjh~onhv{ocno ~onov ov mjmimc~ov* cov ~h{ov bdmt~ov ov mjmimc~ov focv~h~}~hwovco vo nmvfth~ov focftm~bimc~m {mjb jmh# Nm gb~o* o etb} nm gotibo nb

ib~thb nm {tohdho bfmtfb nbv nhv{ovhmv hcnhwhn}bhv nhv~hc~o* nm ionor}m b foi{jmimc~bo nov ~h{ov bdmt~ov ol}h| {ton}| {ot imho nm }il}|o nm wbjot foi}i o} {mjbv fhtf}cv~cfhbv* foi o}~tov mjmimc~ov#45

44 Cmvvm vmc~hno I]O\ FOCNM* Gtbcfhvfo1 EBTFB BTC* Imtfmnmv# Nmtmfò [mcbj*4# mnhfhc* Wbjmcfhb< ^htbc~ jo Djbcf`* 2887* {# 67# ^bhv b}~otmv vo ~o~bjimc~mfoc~tbnh~thov mi v}bv bghtibmv* {ohv {thimhtbimc~m bghtibi r}m bv jmhv {mcbhv midtbcfo f}lb ib~thb nm {tohdho vm focvhecb mi o}~tb jmh nm fbt~mt {mcbj (jmh {mcbj midtbcfo mi vmc~hno bi{jo* vo imtov {tofmnhimc~ov nm ~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb* bo {bvvo r}m

bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo r}m vm nm~mtihcbi {ot b}~othnbnm nm fb~meothb hcgmthot (jmh {mcbjmi dtbcfo mi vmc~hno mv~th~o co vm ~tb~bi nm ~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb* vmco nm }i {todjmibnm foi{m~cfhb# Foc~}no* bo bdotnbt b bcjhvm nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo m o {thcf{ho nbjmebjhnbnm bghtibi r}m o ^thd}cbj Focv~h~}fhocbj mv{bcòj ~mi vm {toc}cfhbno vodtm b}~hjh|bo nmv~b ~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb* ibv cmv~m fbvo tmgmtmi)vm v `h{~mvmv foi{jmimc~bnbv{ot nhv{ovhmv bnihchv~tb~hwbv (hv~o * jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo mi vmc~hno mv~th~o#

46 ^bj tmf`bo ibchgmv~bno nm iono mp{tmvvo {ot I]O\ FOCNM* Gtbcfhvfo# Nmtmfò[mcbj x foc~toj vofhbj* Fojoidhb< ^mihv* 2888* {# 8#

4> Foi{btm ^HMNMIBCC* Ajb}v# Djbcam~~v~tbgemvm~|* hc @bcnut~mtd}f` nmvuht~vf`bg~v) }cn V~m}mtv~tbgtmf`~v* Gtmhd}te h# Dt#* Ibh* 288;* {# 2#

4= Foi{btm ^HMNMIBCC* Ajb}v# Uht~vf`bg~vv~tbgtmf`~# Mhcg`t}ce }cn Bjjemimhcmt^mhj ih~ uhf`~hemc ^mp~mc# Ajc< Fbtj @mxibccv Wmtjbe* 4;;>* {# ==#

47 Cmvvm vmc~hno \BGGBTOCH* M}emcho Tb}j# ^mothb * {# 28;* co imvio vmc~hno[HMTBCEMJJH* Lov @mcthr}m# B cotib {mcbj mi dtbcfo m b v}b wbjhnbnm ~mi{otbj* hcTmwhv~b nov ^thd}cbhv* Tho nm Lbcmhto< Tmwhv~b nov ^thd}cbhv* c# =0>* 280>* {# 624#

45 Cmvvm vmc~hno VF@CAM* Bnojg1 VF@TNMT* @otv~1 JMCFACMT* ^`monot#V~tbgemvm~|d}f`* Aoiimc~bt* 4;# B}gjbem* Icf`mc< Wmtjbe Dmfa* 280;* 26* N* W*


9/32


676B ~fchfb nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo foio hcv~t}imc~oo{ot~}co mi }i nhtmh~o {mcbj no thvfo

Mv~m l}|o nm wbjot v}dv~h~}h b nmvftho nbv fhtf}cv~cfhbv no ~h{o(bo foc~ttho nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo* nm iono r}m mv~mv ~h{ov mv~ob{mcbv bdmt~ov focftm~h|bo {ot imho nb hc~mt{tm~bo# Bvvhi* {onm)vm nh|mt r}m cov ~h{ov bdmt~ov ` }ib bi{jb ibtemi nm jhdmtnbnmvmic~hfb m foi hvvo bdtmi bo l}h|* odtheb~othbimc~m* ibtemcv nm mv{bonm nmfhvo* nmc~to nbv r}bhv mjm nmwm vm iowhimc~bt vmi b hcv~t}o nbjmh#40 [ot~bc~o* bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo co vm ~tb~bi nm ~h{ov bdmt~ov*{ohv mv~mv j~hiov co vo `h{~mvmv nm ~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb* ibv vhinhv{ovhmv f}lo foi{jmimc~o (wbjotbo" {ton}|hno {mjo l}h| {otimho nm }i l}|o nm wbjot* mcr}bc~o r}m cbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo vmmphem o {tmmcf`himc~o no ~h{o {bt~ht nm o}~tov nhv{ovh~hwov * nm

iono r}m {btb b v}b tmbjh|bo tmim~m)vm o}~tbv nhv{ovhmv l}tnhfbv(tmihvvo hc~mtcb m mp~mtcb o} b~ov bnihchv~tb~hwov gbfm hi{tmfhvono foc~mno no ~h{o# Mi o}~tbv {bjbwtbv* {btb focftm~h|bt b cotib nbjmh {mcbj mi dtbcfo* o hc~t{tm~m {tmfhvb tmfottmt b mv~bv nhv{ovhmv*vmi bv r}bhv co vm ~otcb {ovvwmj* {ohv mjbv jhih~bi bv ibtemcv nmmv{bo nm nmfhvo#

Ibv nhbc~m nmv~m {bcotbib focgjh~bc~m m mi tb|o no mi{tmeompfmvvhwo nm jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo cb ibhot {bt~m nbv jmehvjbmv* ~otcb)

vm hcv}v~mc~wmj o gb~o nm r}m ~bc~o b v}b coo m jmeh~hihnbnm foio bvv}bv focvmrcfhbv {mtibcmbi hcfmt~bv* }ib wm| r}m ov {todjmibvtmv}j~bc~mv nb ionmtcb vofhmnbnm no thvfo* ~mcnmi gb|mt foi r}m vmbi{jhm fbnb wm| ibhv o mi{tmeo nmv~b ~fchfb* bo imvio ~mi{o mi r}modlm~hwbi b tmn}o nbv ebtbc~hbv l}tnhfo){mcbhv# Bvvhi* vm vm ~oib foio`oth|oc~m nm {tolmo b {t{thb bghtibo nm Dhcnhce nm r}m b jmh {mcbj~mi{otbthbimc~m foio }i fot{o mttbc~m {tof}tb v}b bjib48* ~mi)vmr}m b jmh {mcbj nhv{m o {tmfmh~o* ibv o gb| nm iono emcthfo* vmcno r}m

tmim~m o}~to nhv{ovh~hwo {btb {tmfhv)jo* m hvvo nmwhno mphecfhb no{ov~}jbno nm jmp fmt~b# [ot~bc~o* {onmi)vm focvhnmtbt bv jmhv {mcbhv midtbcfo foio br}mjbv jmhv {mcbhv r}m ghpbi b foihcbo {mcbj* ibvnmvftmwmi o foc~mno nb ib~thb nm {tohdho nm iono emcthfo (odtbcfo* tmim~mcno mp{tmvvb o} ~bfh~bimc~m o}~tov nhv{ovh~hwov nm

foi{btm bhcnb LMVF@MFA* @bcv)@mhcthf`# Jm`td}f` nmv V~tbgtmf`~v* Bjjemimhcmt ^mhj* 6#B}gjbem* Dmtjhc< Wmtjbe N}cfamt ' @}idjo~* 2850* {# 285#

40 Foi{btm @BVVMIMT* Uhcgthmn# Mhcg`t}ce hc nhm Et}cnjbemc nmv V~tbgtmf`~v* 4# B}gjbem*Icf`mc< Wmtjbe Dmfa* 288;* {# 28> m v# (@ ~tbn}o nmv~b vme}cnb mnho nb odtb* {ot[bdjo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb vod o ~~}jo Hc~ton}o bov G}cnbimc~ov no Nhtmh~o [mcbj* [ot~oBjmetm< Gbdthv Mnh~ot* 4;;>#

48 Foi{btm v}{tb co~b nm tonb{ c# =#


10/32

67> [bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb


jmh (tmihvvo hc~mtcb o} mp~mtcb o} mibcbnov nm teov nm fb~meothbhcgmthot6; * {btb {tmfhv)jo#

2#6 L}v~hghfbo m hcfocwmchmc~mv r}bc~o bo mi{tmeo nm jmhv {mcbhvmi dtbcfo

hcmewmj* {ot~bc~o* r}m bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo (mi vmc~hno bi{joo} mv~th~o ~tb~bi)vm nm }ib r}mv~o nm ~fchfb jmehvjb~hwb62* vmcno r}mb{tmvmc~bi foio fbtbf~mtv~hfbv {thcfh{bhv ov vme}hc~mv bv{mf~ov0 m vv#62 Bi{jo {bcotbib bfmtfb nbv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo foio ~fchfb mi VHJWB* [bdjo T#

Bjgjmc# Jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo*{# 5= m vv#1 foi{btm bhcnb VBC^BCB WMEB* Mj focfm{~o*{# 27#

64 Cmvvm vmc~hno F]TX* Mcthr}m# Jb jmx {mcbj mc djbcfo# Fojoidhb< ^mihv* 2800* {# >0)>81 foi{btm bhcnb LHICM\ NM BVB* J}hv# ^tb~bno nm Nmtmfò [mcbj* 6# mn#*D}mcov Bhtmv< Jovbnb* 287>* ~oio HH* {# 6>01 EBTFB)[BDJOV* Bc~ocho# Nmtmfò[mcbj* Hc~ton}ffhc* Ibnthn< ]chwmtvhnbnm nm Ibnthn* 288=* {# 25> m vv#1 ^HMNMIBCC*

Djbcam~~v~tbgemvm~| * {# 2)=1 o imvio* Uht~vf`bg~v~tbgtmf`~* {# 2;521 ^H[AM*V~m}mtv~tbgtmf`~ * {# 628#66 Cmvvm vmc~hno T]NOJ[@H* @bcv)Lobf`hi m~ bj# Vxv~mib~hvf`mt Aoiimc~bt |}i

V~tbgemvm~|d}f`# Dbcn 2* 4# B}gjbem* Gtbcag}t~ b#I#< Im~|cmt Wmtjbe* 2855* 27* D* HW1foi{btm bhcnb IBTR]MV* Lov Gtmnmthfo# ^tb~bno nm Nhtmh~o [mcbj* Vo [b}jo m o vme}cno b{oc~bno {ot @bg~* r}m bghtib vmt }ib {mf}jhbthnbnm nb b~}bjhnbnm bcowb goti}jbo nm jmhv {ot imho nm }i vhv~mib nm tmihvvo(Wmtumhv}cevvxv~mi* o r}bj {onm focn}|ht b mttov r}bc~o b{jhfbo nbjmh* cb imnhnb mi r}m }j~tb{bvvb b f}t~b fb{bfhnbnm nm tmfotnbo noòimi#6=

I}~b~hv i}~bcnhv* b{mvbt nov hcfocwmchmc~mv* co {ovvwmj{tmvfhcnht nmv~b ~fchfb* nm iono r}m* foio odvmtwb Wmeb* b r}mv~o b

mvfjbtmfmt co ~bc~o b nm vm nmwmi mphv~ht o} co* vmco foio m mir}m imnhnb vm nmwm {mtih~ht b }~hjh|bo nm jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo coNhtmh~o [mcbj#67 L}v~bimc~m {ot hvvo vm focvhnmtb r}m bv jmhv {mcbhv midtbcfo vo }i ibj cmfmvvtho* m r}m vm} mi{tmeo vm l}v~hghfb {mjbwbthbdhjhnbnm nbv vh~}bmv nbv r}bhv nm{mcnm b jmvo no dmi l}tnhfo{to~mehno {mjo ~h{o mi dtbcfo* {ohv fmt~ov dmcv l}tnhfov f}lb hc~methnbnmnm{mcnm nm fhtf}cv~cfhbv focl}c~}tbhv* nm ibcmhtb r}m }ib focn}~b r}mmi fmt~o ioimc~o co ov bgm~bi* mi o}~to {onmi jmvhoc)jov

etbwmimc~m#65 V}b tb~ho mvvmcnh vm mcfoc~tb co v mi }i {thcf{ho nmmfocoihb jmehvjb~hwb* vmco cb hi{ovvhdhjhnbnm nm r}m bv jmhv bdbtr}mi bhcghch~b wbthmnbnm nov gb~ov nb whnb* gtmrmc~mimc~m ionhghfwmhv co ~mi{o#[ot~bc~o* hvvo nmfottm no gb~o nm r}m nm~mtihcbnbv ib~thbv mv~tmh~bimc~mwhcf}jbnbv b vm~otmv ibhv nhcihfov no otnmcbimc~o l}tnhfo vogot~mimc~m focnhfhocbnbv {ot fhtf}cv~cfhbv hv~thfo)vofhbhv focftm~bv*m foio b b~hwhnbnm jmehgmtbc~m cmv~mv vm~otmv hcfmvvbc~m* vm {ton}|hthb}ib etbwm nm~mthotbo jmehvjb~hwb fbvo govvmi hcfj}nbv cbv jmhv {mcbhv*

6> ^bj bv{mf~o tmgmthno {ot Dbfhebj}{o* foi{btm nm~bj`mv mi DBFHEBJ][O* Mcthr}m#[thcf{hov nm Nmtmfò [mcbj* ># mnhfhc* Ibnthn< Babj* 2885* {# 2;2#

6= Foi{btm @BG^* Gth~log# Tmf`~ }cn V{tbf`m* hc AB]GIBCC* Bt~`}t1 @BVVMIMT*Uhcgthmn# Mhcg`t}ce hc nhm Tmf`~v{`hjovo{`hm }cn Tmf`~v~`mothm nmt Ememcubt~ *7# B}gjbem* @mhnmjdmte< Ijjmt Wmtjbe* {# 4541 vod o}~to {oc~o nm whv~b I]O\ FOCNM/EBTFB BTC # Nmtmfò [mcbj* {# 60* bghtibi r}m mv~b ~fchfb nhghf}j~b o ~tbdbjò no{mcbjhv~b co v {otr}m tmim~m b idh~ov l}tnhfov r}m j`m vo nmvfoc`mfhnov o} r}m cofoc`mfm ~o dmi foio o {mcbj* vmco ~bidi {otr}m o bjfbcfm m o foc~mno nhv~hc~o nbcotib {mcbj mi tmjbo v nmibhv cotibv l}tnhfbv {ton}| }ib nhvfotncfhb mc~tm bv{t{thbv cotibv {mcbhv r}m co b}phjhbi fmt~m|b m vme}tbcb l}tnhfb#

67 Foi{btm VBC^BCB WMEB* Mj focfm{~o* {# 42#65 Cmvvm vmc~hno foi{btm F]TX* Jb jmx* {# =21 foi{btbt bhcnb* o imvio* Foc~thd}fhc bj

mv~}nho nm jbv jmxmv {mcbjmv mc djbcfo* hc Tmwhv~b nmj Hcv~h~}~o nm Fhmcfhbv [mcbjmvx Fthihcojehfbv nm jb ]chwmtvhnbn nm Mv~mtcbno nm Fojoidhb* woj# H* Ct# >* {# 8#


12/32

677 [bdjo Tontheo Bjgjmc nb Vhjwb


nm iono {otimcoth|bno* bv `h{~mvmv r}m vm r}mt {tohdht#60 Bvvhi* {btbmwh~bt mv~b nm~mthotbo* tmfottm)vm v jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo r}mmv~bdmjmfmi }i ibtfo m tmim~mi o}~tbv nhv{ovhmv r}mhcnhwhn}bjh|bto vm} foc~mno#

4 O Nhtmh~o [mcbj cb Vofhmnbnm no Thvfo

]ib bcjhvm nov {todjmibv tmv}j~bc~mv no {bcotbib vofhbj b~}bj {btbo Nhtmh~o [mcbj* v}ghfhmc~m {btb odvmtwbt r}m bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo{bvvbi b vm fbtbf~mth|bt foio }i thvfo {btb o imvio# Hvvo {otr}m oNhtmh~o [mcbj* ~bc~o cb ~mothb foio cb {tbphv* mv~ {bvvbcno nb gotibjh|bo

m nb whcf}jbo bov {thcf{hov wbjotb~hwov b }ib ~mfcojoehb vofhbj m{b}jb~hcbimc~m wbh vm focwmt~mcno mi }i hcv~t}imc~o {oj~hfo nm ibcodtbvofhbj* nm iono r}m o {todjmib b~}bj co ibhv b j}~b foc~tb }i Nhtmh~o[mcbj iotbjh|bnot* o r}m vm jmwo} bnhbc~m foi bv btibv nb ghjovoghb {oj~hfbno Hj}ihchvio* ibv vhi foc~tb }i Nhtmh~o [mcbj hcv{htbno {mjbv ionmtcbv~mothbv vofhojehfbv* othmc~bnbv vme}cno }i ionmjo ejodbjh|bc~m* r}m coNhtmh~o [mcbj ~mi vm tmgjm~hno cbr}hjo r}m vm focwmcfhoco} f`bibtNhtmh~o[mcbj no Thvfo (Thvhaov~tbgtmf`~#68

^bj nmvmcwojwhimc~o vm nmwm {bt~hf}jbtimc~m v r}mv~mv r}m vmgoti}jbi {mtbc~m o ~o{ov r}m vm ~otco} foc`mfhno foio b Vofhmnbnmno Thvfo m r}m mcfoc~tb vm} nmvmcwojwhimc~o ibhv mjbdotbno* vod o {oc~onm whv~b vofhojehfo* cov ~tbdbj`ov nm ]jthf` Dmfa>; m nm Chajbv J}`ibcc>2#

60 Ft~hfo b tmv{mh~o \BGGBTOCH* M}emcho Tbj m~ bj# Nhtmh~o [mcbj Dtbvhjmhto) H# Vo[b}jo< Mnh~otb Tmwbc* 4;;6* {# 4;7* tmgmthcno r}m< O bte}imc~o nbv ib~thbv hcv~wmhvr}m bv jmhv {mcbhv mi dtbcfo foi}imc~m ihtbi co cm}~tbjh|b v}b hcfocv~h~}fhocbjhnbnm*bo bn}|ht r}m bv t{hnbv i}nbcbv co {onmthbi vmt bfoi{bc`bnbv {mjo jmehvjbnot {mcbj

pablo rodrigo alflen - leis penais em branco e o direito penal do risco

Documents