o que é a crítica - um ensaio sobre a virtude de foucault

21

Upload: avelinoneto

Post on 25-Dec-2015

36 views

Category:

Documents


25 download

DESCRIPTION

Ensaio de Judith Butler sobre a noção de "crítica" em Michel Foucault.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

���������

���������� ����������������

��������������������������

���������� !"�#�

$%"&��'()��!�*�+�&,)�-!++.&//�0& &1�&2�3

4

4

54678494:;8<8=8<47>?4=<@AB=?CD4EBF4?GH:4678I4874:7F?<B?4JBK8<I4?4>?B:<B?4J84LMF4

=:>N<88LJ848>47>47F:4>?BF4:74>8L:F4:<JBLO<B:P4Q4678FAR:I4A:J?SB?I4A:<L?TF84>?BF4

=:LA7<U?J?4F84A8LA?>:F4JBFABLH7B<47>?4=<@AB=?4J8FA?4:74J?678G?4N:FBVR:4J?4=<@AB=?4=:>:4N<OAB=?4

>?BF4H8L8<?GBK?J?I47>?46784F84N7J8FF84J8F=<8S8<4F8>4<8;8<WL=B?4?4F87F4:UX8A:F48FN8=@;B=:FP4Y4

N:FF@S8G4;:<>7G?<TF84F8>8GZ?LA84678FAR:I4?=8<=?4J:4=?<OA8<4H8<?G4J?4=<@AB=?I4F8>4?N:LA?<4N?<?4

7>?48FFWL=B?4J?4=<@AB=?C4EI4F84?=?F:4?G=?LVOFF8>:F47>467?J<:4H8<?GI4:;8<8=8LJ:4?GH:46784F84

?N<:[B>?FF84J847>?4;BG:F:;B?4J?4=<@AB=?I4N8<J8<@?>:FI48LAR:I4?4N<MN<B?4JBFABLVR:48LA<84;BG:F:;B?4

84=<@AB=?I46784;?K4N?<A84J?4N<MN<B?4J8;BLBVR:4J84=<@AB=?C4\<@AB=?494F8>N<84=<@AB=?4]_?GH7>?4N<OAB=?4

BLFABA7=B:L?GBK?J?I47>4JBF=7<F:I47>?4abcdI47>?4BLFABA7BVR:P4e8LJ:4?FFB>I48G?4N8<J84F874

=?<OA8<4UOFB=:4L:4>:>8LA:48>4678I4?UFA<?@J?4J84F7?4:N8<?VR:4=:LFABA7ABS?I494N:FA?48>4BF:G?J:4

=:>:4N<OAB=?4N7<?>8LA84H8L8<?GBKOS8GP4f?F4JBFA:4LR:4F84F8H7846784L8LZ7>?4H8L8<?GBK?VR:4F8X?4

N:FF@S8GI4:74?BLJ?I46784L:F4?A:G?>:F48>4N?<AB=7G?<BF>:FP4Q:4=:LA<O<B:I4:4A8<<8L:48>46784?67B4

NBF?>:FI494J847>?4H8L8<?GBJ?J84<8FA<BA?46784U8B<?4:4;BG:FM;B=:I4>?F46784J8S8I4F84F874BLA8LA:494:4

J84N8<>?L8=8<4=<@AB=:I4H7?<J?<4JBFAgL=B?4J8FF84>8F>:48>N<88LJB>8LA:P4

548LF?B:46784?67B4:;8<8V:494F:U<84h:7=?7GAI4A:J?SB?4N8<>BA?T>84BLB=B?<4=:>4?4F7H8FAR:4

J?67BG:46784BLA8<N<8A:4=:>:4F8LJ:47>4N?<?G8G:4BLA8<8FF?LA848LA<84:46784i?j>:LJ4kBGGB?>F484

lZ8:J:<4QJ:<L:I4=?J?467?G4?4F874>:J:I4A8LA?<?>4?U:=?LZ?<4F:U4:4L:>84J84mnoacanabdp484:46784

3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333q4rstuvwxvyzwuw{|}~v��v}xxt�v��v��|yt|�u�xv�wzu|}P44

�4QH<?J8V:4H8LABG>8LA84?4?7A:<BK?VR:4J?4?7A:<?4N?<?4A<?J7KB<48FA84?<ABH:4��P4l�P44

D4���������������������������������������������������������������m�������� �������p��������������������

\?>U<BJH8I48>4>?B:4J84�¡¡¡I4N7UGB=?J?4N:FA8<B:<>8LA848>4¢�£iQfI4¤?SBJ4�8JP�P4¥¦_§©acanª©«_¬ª]a­®b_a­_

¯­ca­­cª©_§¦a©b¦°P4±:LJ<8F²4³?FBG4³G?=µ8GGI4�¡¡�P4e:748[A<8>?>8LA84H<?A?4?4kBGGB?>4\:LL:Gj484?4k8LJj4

³<:µL4N:<4=:LA?4J84F87F4=:>8LAO<B:F4¶A8BF4F:U<84:F4N<B>8B<:F48FU:V:F4J8FA84A8[A:P444

Page 2: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#!$%&%'(% !&" )*+''(,'+&*'$ &%'+) &-"+.%/"#01&2'+') 3&4!'&*#+%'&,#&*+5*+/#&

" (%+/6!/78 &,'&� !"#!$%&#&!)#&9/$ 3 9/#&* $.%/"#&*+ :+'33/3%#&'&3'!&" )*+ )/33 &" )&'$#&

% +(#+;3';8 &'</,'(%'3&( &,'"!+3 &,'33#&" )*#+#78 1&&

=#>) (,&?/$$/#)3&/(4!/'%#<#;3'&" )& &9#% &,'&4!'&#&( 78 &,'&"+.%/"#&9 +#&

/(,'</,#)'(%'&+'3%+/(:/,#&@&( 78 &,'&-ABCDEAF&,'9'/% 30&'&*+ *!(G#&4!'&'(" (%+H33') 3&!)&

< "#6!$H+/ &*#+#& 3&%/* 3&,'&+'3* 3%#3&4!'&9 +)#) 3I&')&'3*'"/#$&@3& 6+#3&"!$%!+#/3&-4!'&(8 &

3!*J')& &GH6/% &K%#)* !" & &,/+'/% & !&,'<'+L&,'&M!$:#+0N1&O& &4!'&'$'&*+'%'(,/#&'+#&!)#&

'3*P"/'&,'&+'3* 3%#&)#/3&'3*'".9/"#I&4!'&(8 &3'&:'('+#$/Q#33'&)!/% &+#*/,#)'(%'R&- &4!'&

3')*+'&*+'"/3#&3'+&" )*+''(,/, I0&'$'&'3"+'<'!I&-P&#&'3*'"/9/"/,#,'&,#&+'3* 3%#I&4!'&(8 &P&!)&

STUVCWXYAZXTYAXBF[E\]A0^1&_+'/ &4!'&'3%#&$%/)#&$/(G#&,'&+#"/ ".(/ &%#)6P)&"#+#"%'+/Q#&#&

%+#M'%5+/#&, &*'(3#)'(% &,'&� !"#!$%&" )&+'$#78 &#&'33'&%5*/" I&!)#&<'Q&4!'I&3':!(, &'$'I&#&

-"+.%/"#0&P&M!3%#)'(%'&#&*+H%/"#&4!'&(8 &#*'(#3&3!3*'(,'& &M!.Q &)#3&4!'&%#)6P)& 9'+'"'&!)#&

( <#&*+H%/"#&,'&<#$ +'3I&6#3'#,#&('3%#&*+5*+/#&3!3*'(38 1&

a#+#&?/$$/#)3I&* +%#(% I&#&*+H%/"#&,#&"+.%/"#&(8 &3'&+',!Q&@&" ("$!38 &,'&M!.Q 3&K'&@&3!#&

'b*+'338 L1&c/:(/9/"#%/<#)'(%'I&d, +( &#*+'3'(%#&!)#&%'3'&3/)/$#+&4!#(, &'3"+'<'&3 6+'& &

-*'+/: &e111f&,'&M!$:#+& 3&9'(g)'( 3&/(%'$'"%!#/3&,'&)#('/+#&+',!% +#I& 63"!+#&'&#,)/(/3%+#%/<#&

'&#33/)/$H;$ 3&@3&" (3%'$#7J'3&,'&* ,'+&, )/(#(%'3I&4!'&# &/(%'$'"% &"#6'+/#&,'(!("/#F0h1&d&

%#+'9#I&* /3I&,'&'b* +&'33#3&-" (3%'$#7J'3&,'&* ,'+0&P&3#6 %#,#&*'$#&i(3/#&* +&-M!$:#+0I&

3!* 3%#)'(%'& &#% &"+.%/" &* +&'b"'$j("/#1&a#+#&d, +( I&#&*+5*+/#& *'+#78 &,'&M!$:#+&3'+<'&

*#+#&3'*#+#+&#&"+.%/"#&, &)!(, &3 "/#$&"/+"!(,#(%'I&*#33 &4!'&#(!$#& 3&+'3!$%#, 3&,'&3!#&

*'+#78 I&" (3%/%!/(, &!)&-AkAZEAYlDECXmAXBF[n\Z0o1&d, +( &#9/+)#&4!'&-AXBFpBF\AXBF\YAV\AX

,#&"+.%/"#&q&#&*+'%'(38 &#&!)&" (G'"/)'(% &)#/3&*+ 9!(, &, & 6M'% I&#&3'*#+#78 &,#&/,'/#&,'&

3'!& 6M'% I&)',/#(%'&#&/(,'*'(,j("/#&, &M!.Q &"+.%/" &q&#)'#7#&3!"!)6/+&@&#*#+j("/#&%#(:.<'$&

, & 6M'% I&4!#(, &#&"+.%/"#&"!$%!+#$&+'" ++'&#&!)&" (M!(% &,'&/,'/#3&')&'b* 3/78 &'I&* +&#33/)&

,/Q'+I&9'%/"G/Q#&]AElrCF\AZX\ZCsAmAZ0&KtuvwL1&a#+#&4!'&#&"+.%/"#& *'+'&" ) &*#+%'&,'&!)#&*+Hb/3I&

,'&#" +, &" )&d, +( I&P&*+'"/3 &4!'&'$#&#*+''(,#& 3&) , 3&*'$ 3&4!#/3&#3&"#%': +/#3&38 I&

'$#3&*+5*+/#3I&/(3%/%!.,#3I& &) , &" ) & &"#)* &, &" (G'"/)'(% &P& +,'(#, I&'&" ) & &4!'&

'$'&*+'3"+'<'&+'% +(#I&* +&#33/)&,/Q'+I&" ) &3!#& "$!38 &" (3%/%!%/<#1&a#+#&#)6 3& 3&

*'(3#, +'3I& 3&M!.Q 3& *'+#)&" ) &)#('/+#3&,'&3!63!)/+&!)&*#+%/"!$#+&#&!)#&"#%': +/#&MH&

" (3%/%!.,#1&d&"+.%/"#I&# &" (%+H+/ I&</3#&#&,'3<'(,#+&#&" (3%/%!/78 & "$!3/<#&, &"#)* &,#3&

*+5*+/#3&"#%': +/#31&x&4!'&3'&% +(#&'3*'"/#$)'(%'&/)* +%#(%'&*#+#&� !"#!$%I&('3%#&4!'3%8 I&P&

�������������������������������������������������N&?yzzyd{c1&=#>) (,1&|v}~��u�1&� <#&y +4!'R&xb9 +,&�(/<'+3/%>&a+'33I&��ohI&**1&o;h1&

&?yzzyd{c1&|v}~��u�1&��ohI&*1&oh1&

h&������WX��lCmCFX��X-�TsETFAsX�F\E\]\ZYXADmX�C]\lE�0�X�D�X�����X�F\ZYZ�X�AZZA]�TZlEEZ�X���X�FlZZWX����WXB�X���&

o&�������X-�TsETFAsX�F\E\]\ZYXADmX�C]\lE�0�X���NI&*1&��1&

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Page 3: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

�� �!"#$� %!"#&#$"&'(�)!#*!#(+'�"*!*�#�,#-&)#�.�+�&,#*!#/�+-!#�)#0�"!(,#!(/)#*&#1234&#5#&#

$� %!)� �&#-"3�+-&#-& %�+�2+#�%��#�+$&#*�#�%.&"6&7###

8)#9:;<,#=&2-!2(�#$"&.�"+2#!#$!(�%�"!#+ �+�2(!*!#>?#@2�#/#!#-"3�+-!A>,#��B�&#@2�#

$"�$!"&2#&#-!)+ C&#$!"!#&#%�2#� %!+&#)!+%#-& C�-+*&#>?#@2�#/#&#8%-(!"�-+)� �&A>#D9:<EF<7#

G3,#�(�#$�"02 �!# H&#%&)� ��#&#@2�#/#!#-"3�+-!#-&)&#�!)'/)#$"&-2"!#-&)$"�� *�"#&#�+$&#*�#

@2�%�H&#@2�#!#-"3�+-!#+ %�+�2+,#&.�"�-� *&#!(02)!%#)! �+"!%#�!��! ��%#*�#-+"-2 %-"�I�"#%2!#

!�+I+*!*�7#J!(I�4,#&#@2�#"�%��#*�#)!+%#+)$&"�! ��#*�%%!#$!(�%�"!,#�#*&#� %!+&#)!+%#

*�%� I&(I+*&#@2�#%�#(C�#%�02+2,#/#!#.&")!#-&)&#&#!%%2 �&#/#-&(&-!*&#$�(!#@2�%�H&7#K&+%#!#

$"L$"+!#$�"02 �!#M&#@2�#/#-"3�+-!AN#/#2)!#+ %�O -+!#*&#�)$"�� *+)� �&#-"3�+-&#�)#@2�%�H&7#G#

$�"02 �!,#$&"�! �&,# H&#%&)� ��#$&%+-+& !#&#$"&'(�)!#5#&#@2�#/#�%%!#-"3�+-!#@2�,#

%2$&%�!)� ��,#.!4�)&%#&2#@2�,#*�#.!�&,#!()�1!)&%#.!4�"A#5#-&)&#�!)'/)#"�!(+4!#2)#

*���")+ !*&#)&*&#*�#@2�%�+& !)� �&#@2�#$"&I!"P%�PQ#-� �"!(#R#$"L$"+!#!�+I+*!*�#*!#-"3�+-!7#

S&)#�.�+�&,#�2#%20�"+"+!#@2�#&#@2�#=&2-!2(�#'2%-!#.!4�"#-&)#�%%!#@2�%�H&#/#!(0&#

+ ��+"!)� ��#*+I�"%&#*!@2+(&#-&)#@2�,#�!(I�4,# &%#!-&%�2)!)&%#!#�%$�"!"#*�#2)!#-"3�+-!7#

T!'�")!%#�&" &2#!#&$�"!6H&#-"3�+-!#'!%�! ��#$"&'(�)Q�+-!,#@2! *&#%20�"+2#@2�#2)#$!%%&#$!"!#

!(/)#*!#��&"+!#-"3�+-!#�"!#$"�-+%&#%�,#!&#.!4�"#1234&%#!I!(+!*&"�%#!-�"-!#*�#-& *+6U�%#�#)��!%#

%&-+!+%,#'2%-Q%%�)&%#"�-&""�"#!# &")!%7#V!#I+%H&#*�(�,#!#$�"%$�-�+I!#-"3�+-!#/#-!$!4#*�#-&(&-!"#

.2 *!)� �&%#�)#@2�%�H&,#*�#*�% !�2"!(+4!"#C+�"!"@2+!%#%&-+!+%#�#$&(3�+-!%#�,#+ -(2%+I�,#*�#

�%�!'�(�-�"#$�"%$�-�+I!%#!#$!"�+"#*!%#@2!+%#2)!#-�"�!#*+%�O -+!#-&)#&#)2 *&# !�2"!(+4!*&#$&*�#

%�"#�&)!*!7#V&#� �! �&,# � C2)!#*�%%!%#!�+I+*!*�%#$&*�# &%#*+4�"#�)#@2�#*+"�6H&#

*�I�"3!)&%# &%#*+"+0+",#�!)$&2-&# &%#0!"! �+"#@2�#!%#!�+I+*!*�%# !%#@2!+%#�%�!)&%#� I&(I+*&%#

�%�H&#-2)$"+ *&#-�"�&%#�+$&%#*�#)��!%# &")!�+I!)� ��#12%�+.+-!*!%7#

W&0&,# !#I+%H&#*�(�,#$!"!#.&" �-�"#2)#.2 *!)� �&#!#%+#$"L$"+!,#!#��&"+!#-"3�+-!#�+ C!#

*�#*!"#(20!"#!#2)!#��&"+!# &")!�+I!#)!+%#.&"��,#�!(#@2!(#!#*!#!6H&#-&)2 +-!�+I!,#!#.+)#*�#

$�")+�+"#!#$&%�2(!6H&#*�#1234&%# &")!�+I&%#.&"��%#�#!#-& %&(+*!6H&#*�#2)!#$&(3�+-!#@2�,#!(/)#

*�#$&%%2+"#2)!#!%$+"!6H&# &")!�+I!#�#2)!#)��!#-(!"!,# &%#$&%%+'+(+�!%%�#!I!(+!"#!%#$"Q�+-!%#

!�2!+%#-&)#'!%�# !#%2!#-!$!-+*!*�#*�#!(-! 6!"#�!+%#)��!%7:#G&#.!4�"#�%%�#�+$&#*�#-� %2"!#R#

-"3�+-!,#T!'�")!%#)&%�"&2P%�#-2"+&%!)� ��#!-"3�+-&#%&'"�#&#$"L$"+&#%� �+*&#*�#

&")!�+I+*!*�#@2�#�)$"�0!7#K&"@2! �&#!#@2XYZ[\]M\]_X]XaXb\Y]cdeXfgN]hfXYY_hiX]_b]

�������������������������������������������������<#jklmnlopq]rstuXvw]MxudZ]sY]mfsZs_XgN]yz{]okp|y}~�|q]��va�fX]dz]�km�|kp�q]osYd]�XY�w]�������������

��������7#V��#�&"��#��)+&��B�D�F,#9::;7#J"! %-"+�&#$&"#�& +@2�#8)�"�,#"�I+%!*&#$&"#�24! �#��(&")�,#��#!(7,#

�"!*24+*&#$!"!#&#+ 0(�%#$&"#W�%!#T&-C"&�C7#8%��#� %!+&#&"+0+ !()� ��#.&+#2)!#$!(�%�"!#$"&.�"+*!# !#�&-+�*!*�#

="! -�%!#*�#=+(&%&.+!,#�)#�;#*�#)!+&#*�#9:;<,#%2'%�@2� ��)� ��#$2'(+-!*!# &#�2((��+ #*�#(!#�&-+/�/#."! 6!+%�#*�#

(!#$C+(&%&$C+�#<E��#D9::�F# ¡P¢ £#�97##

:#K!"!#2)#"�(!�&#+ ��"�%%! ��#!-�"-!#*!#�"! %+6H&#*!#��&"+!#-"3�+-!#R#��&"+!#*&#!0+"#-&)2 +-!�+I&,#I+*�#

�8VTG�¤�,#���(!7#¥����¦��§���©§�ª«¬�­��®�ª�°�±��¬²��������³��«¬ª���«�����¥�����ª�������²#V&I!#¤&"@2��#S&(2)'+!#

µ +I�"%+��#K"�%%,#9:<¢,#$$7#9P9 7#

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Page 4: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

�� !"#$%&#'(#!&#)*+,*%#&#$%&#!&#-*�.&-&/#-%'0#012*#3#4*!!56&7#&#-%'*#-0,4*#8&#09%012*#3#

:;<=>=?@A;<BCDE?F;?GE?HICJ;C;JJGJCKFLKF=GJCMHF>GNO;JC;C:;<=>=?GNO;JC?P>CJQGJCRHEJ;SQPER=GJC

EHF>G?=AGJICJ;F@ICKHF?GE?HICE;R;JJ@F=HCKFHRQFGFCK;<HJCAG<HF;JCSQ;CJQJ?;E?G>CHCKG<RHCEHCSQG<C

GCGNTHCJ;C:;J;EFH<GBCDJ?GCKFHRQFGCJ;F@CQ>GC:=>;EJTHC=>KHF?GE?;C:;CSQG<SQ;FC=EA;J?=UGNTHC

RFV?=RGCGR;FRGC:;CSQ;J?O;JCEHF>G?=AGJBC

WQ=?HC;>XHFGCHJCYGX;F>GJ=GEHJC?;EYG>CQ>GCF;JKHJ?GCKGFGC;JJ;CKFHX<;>GIC>;QC

KFHKLJ=?HCYHZ;CETHC[C;ER;EGFC;JJ;JC:;XG?;JIC>Q=?HC>;EHJCF;JKHE:;F\<Y;JBCW;QCKFHKLJ=?HC[C

>GFRGFCGC:=J?]ER=GC;E?F;CQ>GCEHNTHC:;CRFV?=RGCSQ;C[CRGFGR?;F=G:GCRH>HCEHF>G?=AG>;E?;C

;>KHXF;R=:GC;>CG<UQ>CJ;E?=:HC;CHQ?FGC\CSQ;C;JK;FHCHM;F;R;FCGSQ=C\CSQ;C[CETHCGK;EGJC>G=JC

RH>K<;_GC:HCSQ;CJ;QJCRFV?=RHJICU;FG<>;E?;ICJQKO;>C>GJCSQ;C?;>IC;QCGFUQ>;E?GF=GICMHF?;JC

RH>KFH>=JJHJCEHF>G?=AHJCSQ;CJ;CF;A;<G>C;>CMHF>GJCSQ;CJ;F=G>C:=MVR;=JICJ;ETHC=>KHJJVA;=JIC

:;C<;FC:;E?FHC:HJCG?QG=JCKGF]>;?FHJC:;CEHF>G?=A=:G:;BCH>C;M;=?HICE;J?;C;EJG=HIC;JK;FHC

>HJ?FGFCETHCJH>;E?;CSQ;CaHQRGQ<?CF;G<=GCQ>GC=>KHF?GE?;CRHE?F=XQ=NTHCKGFGCGC?;HF=GC

EHF>G?=AGICRH>HC?G>X[>CSQ;CGCJQGC;J?[?=RGC;CJQGCEHNTHC:;CJQZ;=?HC;J?THC=E?;=FG>;E?;C

F;<GR=HEG:GJC?GE?HCRH>CGCJQGC[?=RGICSQGE?HCRH>CGCJQGCKH<V?=RGBCDESQGE?HCG<UQEJCHC

:;JSQG<=M=RGFG>CRH>HC;J?;?GCHQCG=E:GICRH>HCE==<=J?GIC;JK;FHCJQU;F=FCSQ;CGC=ERQFJTHCSQ;C;<;CMGC

EHC?LK=RHC:GCRF=GNTHC:HC�;Q"CbcdefgC;ICKHFCRHEJ;UQ=E?;ICEGCKFLKF=GChijdcjckC[CR;E?FG<CKGFGCGCKH<V?=RGC

:;C:;JGJJQZ;=?G>;E?HCSQ;CKFHKO;BClGFG:H_G<>;E?;ICGCR+m012*#8*#�&%"#&#*C:;JGJJQZ;=?G>;E?HC

HRHFF;>CRHERH>=?GE?;>;E?;CSQGE:HCJ;CGFF=JRGCQ>C>H:HC:;C;_=J?PER=GCSQ;CETHC[CRHFFHXHFG:HC

KHFCGSQ=<HCSQ;C;<;C:;EH>=EGC:;CF;U=>;C:;CA;F:G:;BC

aHQRGQ<?C=E=R=GCGCJQGCMG<GCGM=F>GE:HCSQ;CY@CA@F=HJCJ;E?=:HJCKGFGCHC?;F>HC�RFV?=RG"IC

GR;EGE:HC?GE?HCKGFGCHC�;<;AG:HC;>KF;;E:=>;E?HCnGE?=GEH"CSQ;CJ;CRYG>GCRFV?=RGICSQGE?HCKGFGC

�GJCG?=A=:G:;JCKH<P>=RGJC>;EHF;JCSQ;CJTHCRYG>G:GJC:;CRFV?=RG"opBCq;E:HCGJJ=>IC;<;CEHJCGA=JGC

:;J:;CHC=EVR=HCSQ;CGCRFV?=RGCETHCJ;F@CQ>GCRH=JGCrE=RGC;CSQ;CETHCJ;F;>HJCRGKG;JC:;C:;M=E=\<GC

J;>CF;RHFF;FCGHJCA@F=HJCHXZ;?HJCK;<HJCSQG=JC;<GCKFLKF=GCJ;C:;M=E;BC�lHFCRHE?GC:;CJQGCMQENTHI"C

;<;C;JRF;A;IC�GCRFV?=RGCKGF;R;C;J?GFCRHE:;EG:GCsC:=JK;FJTHICsC:;K;E:PER=GC;CsCKQFGC

.&9&+*�*,m0"tC�D<GCGK;EGJC;_=J?;C;>CF;<GNTHCGCG<UHCHQ?FHCSQ;CETHC;<GCKFLKF=Gt"C

aHQRGQ<?CXQJRGICGJJ=>IC:;M=E=FCGCRFV?=RGICKHF[>C:;JRHXF;CSQ;CGK;EGJCQ>GCJ[F=;C:;C

GKFH_=>GNO;JCJ;F@CKHJJVA;<BCuCRFV?=RGCJ;F@C:;K;E:;E?;C:;CJ;QJCHXZ;?HJIC>GJC;J?;JICKHFCJ;QC

?QFEHIC:;M=E=FTHCHCKFLKF=HCJ=UE=M=RG:HC:GCRFV?=RGBCu:;>G=JICGC?GF;MGCKF=>HF:=G<C:GCRFV?=RGCETHC

J;F@CGAG<=GFCJ;CHJCJ;QJCHXZ;?HJC\CRHE:=NO;JCJHR=G=JICKF@?=RGJICMHF>GJC:;CRHEY;R=>;E?HICKH:;FC;C

:=JRQFJHC\CJTHCXHEJCHQCFQ=EJICG<?G>;E?;CAG<HF=G:HJCHQC>;EHJKF;G:HJIC>GJCJ=>CKvFC;>CF;<;AHC

GCKFLKF=GC;J?FQ?QFGC:;CGAG<=GNTHBCwQ;CF;<GNTHC;E?F;CRHEY;R=>;E?HC;CKH:;FCMGCSQ;CGJCEHJJGJC

R;F?;GJC;K=J?;>H<LU=RGJCGRGX;>CJ;FA=E:HC:;CJQKHF?;CGCQ>C>H:HC:;C;J?FQ?QFGFCHC>QE:HCSQ;C

HX<=?;FGCKHJJ=X=<=:G:;JC:;CHF:;EGNTHCG<?;FEG?=AGJxClH:;>HJCK;EJGFIC[CR<GFHICSQ;CQ>GCR;F?;GC

�������������������������������������������������opCayz u{|BC}~�����������������BCCo���ICKBC��C

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Note
Devo incluir isso na tese, sobretudo no terceiro cenário.
Page 5: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#�$%&'(!)*+,+-�)�""./!*+ */*+01�+"�+*2!/$�3+)%$+)%-4!)56%3+01�+%+$1-7%+,+�+7�4�+"�/+

%/7�-*7%+7�+7*7*+$*-�!/*8+

9%-#17%3+*#,+01�+ %-#%+�""*+)�/#�:*+-6%+,+*/01!#�#*7*+ �&*"+2%/$*"+7�+)%-;�)!$�-#%3+

/�)!"*$�-#�+*+2!$+7�+%<&!#�/*/+*+ %""!<!&!7*7�+7�+1$+ �-"*/+7!2�/�-#�=+>/*3+ %7�/?"�?!*+

"*<!*$�-#�+ �/(1-#*/3+%+01�+;.+7�+<%$+�$+1$+ �-"*/+7!2�/�-#�+"�+-6%+"*<�$%"+7�+*-#�$6%+

"�+�""�+ �-"*/+ /%71:!/.+1$+$1-7%+$�&;%/=+@�$%"3+*2!-*&3+1$+�"01�$*+$%/*&+ */*+7�)!7!/+

)%$+)�/#�:*+01�+-%4*"+ %""!<!&!7*7�"+%1+$%7%"+7�+ �-"*/+7!2�/�-#�"+)/!*/6%+1$+$1-7%+)1A*"+

$�&;%/!*"+ %7�$%"+A1&(*/+ %/+ *7/B�"+)�/#%"+�+A.+�"#*<�&�)!7%"=+C!"+1$*+/, &!)*+)%$1$+

)%-#/*+D%1)*1&#+�+)%-#/*+%"+01�+)%$+�&�+"�+!$ %/#*$8+C+*)*"%+7�4�/E*$%"+ /�"1$!/+01�+%+

/�&*#!4%+"!&F-)!%+)%$+01�+"�+#�$+/�)�<!7%+�""�+;.<!#%+7�+* %-#*/+2*&;*"+�$+D%1)*1&#+,+1$+

!-7E)!%+7�+01�+"1*+#�%/!*+-6%+#�$+-�-;1$*+/�" %"#*+/�)%-2%/#*-#�+*+-%"+7*/=+9/�!%+01�+

%7�$%"+ /�"1$!/+01�+*"+/�" %"#*"+01�+�"#6%+*+"�+* /�"�-#*/+-6%+#�$3+-%+/�)%-2%/#%3+%+"�1+

/!-)! *&+%<A�#!4%8+G"#%3+,+)&*/%3+-6%+"!(-!2!)*+01�+01*&01�/+)%!"*+01�+-6%+"�+ /�"#*+*+-%"+

/�)%-2%/#*/+-6%+)%-"#!#1*3+ %/+7�2!-!56%3+1$*+/�" %"#*8+9%$+�2�!#%3+*+H-!)*+/, &!)*+ %""E4�&3+

*/�)�?$�3+,+/�#%/-*/+ */*+1$+"!(-!2!)*7%+$*!"+21-7*$�-#*&+7%+#�/$%+I)/E#!)*JK+*+2!$+7�+

*4�/!(1*/+%+01�+;.+7�+�//*7%+)%$+*+01�"#6%3+#*&+01*&+�&*+,+2%/$1&*7*+�3+)%$+�2�!#%3+*+2!$+7�+

2%/$1&*/+*+01�"#6%+7�+1$+$%7%+%/!(!-./!%3+7�+"%/#�+01�+1$*+*<%/7*(�$+$*!"+ /%71#!4*+ */*+

%+&1(*/+01�+*+,#!)*+%)1 *+7�-#/%+7*+ %&E#!)*+ %""*+"�/+!7�-#!2!)*7*8+L%7�/?"�?!*+!-7*(*/+"�3+7�+

2*#%3+%+01�+);*$%+7�+I /%71#!4%J+"�/.+*2�/!7%+ %/+ *7/B�"+�+$�7!7*"+01�+�"#%1+7!" %"#*+*+

/�4�&*/3+%1+)1A*+* /��-"6%+$�+,+)%$ &�#*+-%+$%$�-#%+�$+01�+%"+*2!/$%8+M*"+*01!+�1+ �7!/?

&;�"?!*+1$+ %1)%+7�+ *)!F-)!*3+1$*+4�:+01�+*+)/E#!)*+,+*+ /.#!)*+01�+/�01�/+1$*+7�#�/$!-*7*+

7%"�+7�+ *)!F-)!*3+7%+$�"$%+$%7%+)%$%+*+&�!#1/*3+7�+*)%/7%+)%$+N!�#:");�3+�O!(!1+01�+-%"+

%/#.""�$%"+1$+ %1)%+$*!"+)%$%+4*)*"+7%+01�+)%$%+;1$*-%"+�+* /�-7F""�$%"+*+*/#�+7*+

/1$!-*56%+4*(*/%"*8+

P+)%-#/!<1!56%+7�+D%1)*1&#+ */*+%+01�+* */�-#*+"�/+1$+!$ *""�+7�-#/%+7*+#�%/!*+

)/E#!)*+�+ '"?)/E#!)*+7�+-%""%+#�$ %3+,+A1"#*$�-#�+-%"+ �7!/+01�+/� �-"�$%"+*+)/E#!)*+)%$%+*+

/.#!)*+-*+01*&+ %$%"+�$+01�"#6%+%"+&!$!#�"+7�+-%""%"+$%7%"+7�+)%-;�)!$�-#%+$*!"+)�/#%"3+

*01!&%+*+01�+Q!&&!*$"+"�+/�2�/!*+)%$%+%"+-%""%"+I;.<!#%"+7�+�" E/!#%+-6%?)/E#!)%"J+�+01�+

P7%/-%+)&*""!2!)*4*+7�+!7�%&%(!*+R+"�(1-7%+�&�3+%+ISTUVWXTUYZ[U\Z[]TZ_a]bZ[c[WdeT_T+01�+

-6%+"�+ �/$!#�+/�71:!/+*%"+f#�/$%"+% �/*)!%-*!"g+�+01�3+*%+!-4,"3+&1#*+1-!)*$�-#�+ */*+01�+*"+

)%!"*"+"�+*/#!)1&�$+7�+$%7%+*+"�+7�")%&*/+W[_]UaeWaTX[ZX]UWUYTJhh8+N6%+-%"+7!/!(!$%"+ */*+

%+&!$!#�+ %/01�+01�/�$%"+1$*+�O �/!F-)!*+�$%)!%-*-#�3+%1+ %/01�+%"+&!$!#�"+"6%+ �/!(%"%"+�+

"�-"1*!"3+%1+*!-7*3+ %/01�+4!4�/+-%+&!$!#�+-%"+&�4*+*+1$*+ /%O!$!7*7�+�O)!#*-#�+7%+$*&8+

G-7*(*$%"+ �&%"+&!$!#�"+7%"+$%7%"+7�+)%-;�)!$�-#%+ %/01�+-%"+7� */*$%"+)%$+1$*+)/!"�+

7�-#/%+7%+)*$ %+� !"#�$%&'(!)%+�$+01�+4!4�$%"8+P"+)*#�(%/!*"+"�(1-7%+*"+01*!"+-%""*+4!7*+

�������������������������������������������������hh+ijklmkn[Ioe_YepW_[op]Y]b]VX[WU[qZb]TYrJn[stuvK[Sn[wtn+

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Page 6: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$%&% '()*#(#+%,' (-.)/%-/#%!)'0#%"*! )'1*!"#% -%( /2*" �%"*0)"' �%()%"*"*0)$"3"4"$"(#()5%

6%&%#%,#'0"'%()%)*07 +%#%,#'0"'%( %)�3#'8#/)*0 %( %0)!"( %()%* ��#%')()%),"�0)/ $93"!#+%:-)%#%

,';0"!#%(#%!'20"!#%)/)'3)+%<-*0#/)*0)%! /%#%! *�!"1*!"#%()%:-)%*)*=-/%("�!-'� %#:-"%&%

#():-#( %)%()%:-)%-/%"/,#��)%> "%,' (-."( %, '%* �� �%("�!-'� �%( /"*#*0)�5%? /%)>)"0 +% %

,'9,'" %()4#0)+%* %:-#$%-/#%@"�7 %> '0)/)*0)%* '/#0"@#%3-)'')"#%! *0'#%#%0) '"#%!'20"!#+%, ()%

@"'%#%,' (-."'%<-�0#/)*0)%#%> '/#%()%"/,#��)%("�!-'�"@ %#%,#'0"'%( %:-#$%#%*)!)��"(#()%)%#%

-'31*!"#%(#%!'20"!#%�)%! $ !#/5%%

A#'#%B -!#-$0+%#%!'20"!#%&%C-/%/)" %,#'#%-/%>-0-' % -%,#'#%-/#%@)'(#()%:-)%#"*(#%

*7 %�)%! *=)!)% -%:-)%#"*(#%*7 %)D"�0)+%)$#%@#"%()%)*! *0' %#%-/%( /2*" %:-)%*7 %()�)<#%

, $"!"#'%)%# %:-#$%&%"*!#,#.%()%')3-$#'E5%F%!'20"!#+%, '0#*0 +%! *>"3-'#';%-/#%,)'�,)!0"@#%� 4')%

/ ( �%()%! *=)!"/)*0 %)�0#4)$)!"( �%)% '()*#( ')�+%:-)%*7 %�)%#��"/"$#%"/)("#0#/)*0)%G%

>-*87 % '()*#( '#5%H"3*">"!#0"@#/)*0)+%,#'#%B -!#-$0+%�)/)$=#*0)%)D, �"87 %( %$"/"0)%( %

!#/, %),"�0)/ $93"! %)�0;%$"3#(#%G%,';0"!#%(#%@"'0-()%I%! / %�)%#%@"'0-()%> ��)%! *0';'"#%G%

')3-$#87 %)%G% '()/+%! / %�)%#%,'9,'"#%@"'0-()%! *�"�0"��)%)/%()�#>"#'%#% '()/%)�0#4)$)!"(#5%

6$)%*7 %&%! /)("( %! /%#%')$#87 %:-)%, �0-$#%#:-"5%CJ;%#$3 %*#%!'20"!#+E%)$)%)�!')@)+%C:-)%&%

�"/"$#'%G%@"'0-()5E%6%)*07 %)$)%(".%#$3 %:-)%, ()%�)'%! *�"()'#( %#"*(#%/#"�%�-','))*()*0)K%

C)��#%#0"0-()%!'20"!#%L&M%#%@"'0-()%)/%3)'#$ENO5%%

J;%#$3-/#�%/#*)"'#�%4;�"!#�%()%! /,'))*()'/ �% %)�> '8 %()%B -!#-$0%, '%

#,')�)*0#'%#%!'20"!#%! / %@"'0-()5%F%@"'0-()%&%3)'#$/)*0)%! /,'))*("(#% -%4)/%! / %

#0'"4-0 % -%,';0"!#%()%-/%�-<)"0 +% -%4)/%! / %:-#$"(#()%:-)%! *("!" *#%)%!#'#!0)'".#%

()0)'/"*#( %0", %()%#87 % -%,';0"!#5%6$#%,)'0)*!)%#%-/#%&0"!#%:-)%�)%!-/,')%*7 %/)'#/)*0)%

,)$#% 4)("1*!"#% 4<)0"@#%G�%$)"�%)%G�%')3'#�%> '/-$#(#�5%6%#%@"'0-()%*7 %&%#,)*#�%-/%PQRQS()%

! *�)*0"'% -%()%�)%! *> '/#'%! /%* '/#�%,'))�0#4)$)!"(#�5%6$#%&+%/#"�%'#("!#$/)*0)+%-/#%

')$#87 %!'20"!#%! /%)��#�%* '/#�%:-)%�)%()$"*)"#+%�)3-*( %B -!#-$0+%! / %-/#%)�0"$".#87 %

)�,)!2>"!#%(#%/ '#$"(#()5%

B -!#-$0%* �% >)')!)%-/#%"*("!#87 %( %:-)%)*0)*()%, '%@"'0-()%*#STUVWQRXYZQSG%[\]VW\_S

R_S]aX_b\R_RSTTcSQSX]QSRQ]SdW_eW]5Nf%g)��#% 4'#+%)$)%()"D#%!$#' %:-)%@"�#%#%-$0'#,#��#'%#%

! *!),87 %()%>"$ � >"#%&0"!#%:-)%)/"0)%-/%! *<-*0 %()%,')�!'"8h)�5%i %/)�/ %/ ( %! / %#%

!'20"!#%! *@)'3)%G%>"$ � >"#%�)/%, '%"�� %! "*!"("'%! /%)$#+%#��"/%B -!#-$0+%)/%�-#%TUVWQRXYZQ+%

4-�!#%>#.)'%()%�)-%,'9,'" %,)*�#/)*0 %-/%)D)/,$ %()%"*@)�0"3#87 %/ '#$%*7 j,')�!'"0"@#5%

k-0' ��"/+%)$)+%#("#*0)+%"*(#3#';%#!)'!#%(#�%> '/#�%()%)D,)'"1*!"#%/ '#$%:-)%*7 %�)%()>"*)/%

'"3"(#/)*0)%, '%-/#%$)"%<-'2("!#+%-/#%')3'#% -%! /#*( %("#*0)%( �%:-#"�%�)%�-,h)%:-)% %C)-E%

�-4/)0)j�)%/)!l*"!#% -%-*"> '/)/)*0)5%k%,'9,'" %0)D0 %:-)%)�!')@)+%)$)%* �%! *0#+%&%-/%

�������������������������������������������������NO%Bkm?Fmno5%pqrstuvwuxyvtvz{|}~5%%N���+%,5%O�5%

Nf%Bkm?Fmno+%�"!=)$5%��S�]SQ�S�b_]XWcS��S[\]VQW�SQ�S�aX_b\V�+%@ $-/)%0� 5%g @#%� ':-)K%A#*0=) *%A')��+%

N���5%

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Note
O eu "posto anteriormente", pressuposo.
Page 7: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� �!"#$%&�%'(#%")*'+,(%-./�%� "#$)(%$%./�%0%"(1123�#%&�%1�)%!/&(&$4%�!%1�/%")5")+$%

"�61(!�6'$4%(')(301%&�%/!(%")*'+,(%&�%,$67�,+!�6'$%./�%#7�%89:;<=>?@:A=>BCDE%F%� "�)+G6,+(%

!$)(#%'�!%./�%3�)%,$!%(%')(61H$)!(IJ$%&�%1+%+61'+K(&(%"$)%/!(%H$)!(%&�%,$67�,+!�6'$%./�%0%

�1')(6K�+)(%L./�#(%,$!%(%./(#%$%1/M�+'$%1�%(,$1'/!$/E%N%�11(%H$)!(%&�%� "�)+G6,+(%!$)(#%1�)*%

&+H�)�6'�%&(%1/O!+11J$%(%/!%,$!(6&$E%P$!%�H�+'$4%6(%!�&+&(%�!%./�%+6'�))$K(%(%� "�)+G6,+(%

!$)(#%(./+%$/%(#7/)�14%Q$/,(/#'%,$!")��6&�%(%1+%")5")+$%,$!$%(#K/0!%./�%)�(#+R(%/!(%

+63�1'+K(IJ$%&(1%� "�)+G6,+(1%!$)(+1%./�%6J$%0%")+!*)+(%$/%H/6&(!�6'(#!�6'�%"(/'(&(%"$)%

/!(%")$+O+IJ$%$/%+6'�)&+IJ$E%

S$%")+!�+)$%3$#/!�%&TUVWXYZ[\X]V]VY_a]bX]_4%Q$/,(/#'%")$,/)$/%!$1')()%./�%(1%

+6'�)&+Ic�1%O*1+,(1%1/"$1'(1%"�#(%"1+,(6*#+1�%�%"�#$%�1'/&$%�1')/'/)(#+1'(%&(1%")$+O+Ic�1%

,/#'/)(+1%6J$%"$&�!%1�)%(11/!+&(1%,$!$%,$61'(6'�1%7+1'5)+,(1ECd%F&�!(+14%,$61+&�)(&(%

7+1'$)+$K)(H+,(!�6'�4%(%� "�)+G6,+(%!$)(#%6J$%"$&�%1�)%,$!")��6&+&(%("�6(1%!�&+(6'�%$%

)�,/)1$%(%/!%,$6M/6'$%&�%+6'�)&+Ic�1%&$!+6(6'�1%")�1�6'�%�!%&�'�)!+6(&$%!$!�6'$%

7+1'5)+,$E%N!O$)(%7(M(%,5&+K$1%(%1�%�1'/&()4%�11�1%,5&+K$1%&�3�!%1�!")�%1�)%�1'/&(&$1%�!%

1/(%)�#(IJ$%,$!%$1%!$&$1%&�%1/OM�'+3(IJ$%,$))�1"$6&�6'�1E%Q$/,(/#'%(&/R%(%'�1�%&�%./�%(%

M/)+1&+,+R(IJ$%&(%#�+%(#,(6I(%,�)'(%7�K�!$6+(%6$%10,/#$%efff%�%(H+)!(%./�4%1�%3$#'()!$1%L%

,/#'/)(%,#*11+,(%K)�,$g)$!(6(4%�6,$6')()�!$1%")*'+,(1%$/%-()'�1%&�%� +1'G6,+(B9hi:9

�1'(O�#�,�!%$%,/+&(&$%&�%1+CjE%%

F$%+6')$&/R+)%(%6$IJ$%&�%-()'�1%&�%� +1'G6,+(B4%Q$/,(/#'%'(!O0!%)�+6')$&/R%�%)�11(#'(%

-(1%(Ic�1%+6'�6,+$6(+1%�%3$#/6'*)+(14B%�1"�,+H+,(!�6'�%-(./�#(1%(Ic�1%6(1%./(+1%$1%7$!�61%6J$%

("�6(1%�1'(O�#�,�!%"()(%1+%/!(%)�K)(%&�%,$6&/'(%!(1%'(!O0!%O/1,(!%')(61H$)!()%(%1+%

")5")+$1%�!%1�/%1�)%1+6K/#()4%H(R�6&$%&�%1/(%3+&(%/!(%$O)(%&�%()'�EB%k(#%3+&(%6J$%1�%,$6H$)!(%

1+!"#�1!�6'�%,$!%$1%")�,�+'$1%$/%6$)!(1%!$)(+14%&�%1$)'�%(%�6,(+ ()%$%1�/%-�/B9:l%/!%

!$#&�%./�%0%H+ (&$%"�#$%")�,�+'$4%H�+'$%(#K$%")�H$)!(&$%�!%/!(%#+67(%&�%!$6'(K�!E%m/+'$%

"�#$%,$6')*)+$4%$%-�/B%./�%1�%!$&�#(%6$1%'�)!$1%&(%6$)!(4%"(11(%(%7(O+'*g#(%�%(%+6,$)"$)*g#(n%

'$&(3+(%]Vop\q]VorpVsVo_YY_VY_oZXpV_Z_\Xp\V]pVt\XouvtXpVt_bpVwa]bVpV-_aBVY_Vxp\q]E%y%./�%�1'*%�!%M$K$4%

"()(%Q$/,(/#'4%6J$%1J$%$1%,$!"$)'(!�6'$14%(1%+&�+(14%(1%1$,+�&(&�1%6�!%(1%-+&�$#$K+(1B4%!(1%

-(1%")$O#�!('+R(Ic�1%"�#(1%./(+1%$%1�)%1�%&�+ (4%6�,�11()+(!�6'�4%"�61()%z%�%(1%")*'+,(1%(%"()'+)%

&(1%./(+1%�11(1%")$O#�!('+R(Ic�1%1�%H$)!(!BC{E%%

N1'(%|#'+!(%'�1�%6J$%0%H*,+#%&�%,$!")��6&�)E%S$%�6'(6'$4%�#(%1/K�)�%./�%,�)'$1%'+"$1%&�%

")*'+,(1%./�%1J$%")$M�'(&(1%"()(%#+&()%,$!%,�)'$1%'+"$1%&�%")$O#�!(1%")$&/R�!4%($%#$6K$%&$%

'�!"$4%/!%&$!26+$%$6'$#5K+,$%)2K+&$%,$!$%1/(%,$61�./G6,+(4%$%./�4%"$)%1/(%3�R4%#+!+'(%

�������������������������������������������������CD%Qy}PF}~kE%�W_V�Y_VpxV�b_]Ya\_�V�W_V�XYZp\�VpxV�_a]bXZ��%C��d4%"E%�E%

Cd%Qy}PF}~kE%m+,7�#E%k7�%�+1'$)�%$H%�� /(#+'�4%3$#/!�%$6�E%S$3(%f$)./��%�(6&$!%�$/1�4%C�{�E%

Cj%Qy}PF}~kE%�W_V�Y_VpxV�b_]Ya\_�V�W_V�XYZp\�VpxV�_a]bXZ��%C��d4%"E%C�E%

C{%Qy}PF}~kE%�W_V�Y_VpxV�b_]Ya\_�V�W_V�XYZp\�VpxV�_a]bXZ��%C��d4%"E%CCE%

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Note
Explorar as relações do corpo (enquanto princípio epistemológico) com esta afirmação.
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Note
O que Foucault explorou em Subjectivité et Vérité, texto ao qual Butler, provavelmente, não teve acesso por ocasião da escrita de seu ensaio.
Avelino
Texte surligné
Page 8: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

�� �!"��#$"%&$�'�!(�!)*$!+!,� -.$/0!1! �&$�'$!"�&!2$3$24�"%5!5!$ $!#�2%6��'$!��'�/78%"�!

(�&%�5�'$!9!$/$!,27,2%�!"�� '%'*-(�!,�2!*&5! +2%$!($!,2:'%"5 !9!)*$!�� !'�2�52$&� !"5,56$ !

($!"�&,2$$�($2!5 !$ ,+"%$ !($!2$/5;<$ !"�&!� !,2$"$%'� !&�25% !)*$! $!3�2&525&!$!)*$!5%�(5!

$ '=�!,�2! $!3�2&520!>�*"5*/'!$?5&%�5!&%�*"%� 5&$�'$@!,�2!$?$&,/�@!(%.$2 5 !,2:'%"5 !($!

5* '$2%(5($!$!5 !5 �"%5!"�&!5!,2�(*;=�!($!*&!($'$2&%�5(�!'%,�!($! *A$%'�!&5 "*/%��0!B !

,2:'%"5 !($!5* '$2%(5($!�=�! $!2$ *&$&!5!*&5!,2�%C%;=�!D�%"5!$!%�3/$?-.$/@!&5 !'25C5/#5&!��!

$�'%(�!($!&�($/52!*&!($'$2&%�5(�!'%,�!($!E$*F0!G*@!(%'�!($!&5�$%25!&5% !,2$"% 5@!�!E$*F@!

5�!%�"�2,�252!5 !2$825 !($!"��(*'5!)*$!2$,2$ $�'5&!5!.%2'*($!(5!5* '$2%(5($@!"2%5!,525! %!

,27,2%�!*&!($'$2&%�5(�!'%,�!($! *A$%'�0!H 5!5*'�,2�(*;=�!+!E5!$/5C�25;=�!$!$ '%/%65;=�!($!

*&5!5'%.%(5($!$&! $*!$?$2"-"%�!($!,�($2!$!5!,2:'%"5!($! *5!/%C$2(5($0F!H '5!�=�!$25!*&5!

,2:'%"5!)*$! %&,/$ &$�'$! $!�,*�#5!5�!,256$2@!&5 !*&5!($'$2&%�5(5!,2:'%"5!(�!,27,2%�!

,256$2@!*&5!,2:'%"5!($!,256$2! %'*5(5!��!"��'$?'�!(5!$?,$2%4�"%5!&�25/0!

I�2'5�'�@!�5! $;=�!'24 !($ '5!&$ &5!JKLMNOPQRN@!>�*"5*/'!($%?5!"/52�!)*$!�3$2$"$2!*&5!

#% '72%5!,��'*5/!(� !"7(%8� !&�25% !�=�!C5 '5@!,�% ! $&$/#5�'$!#% '72%5!�=�!,�($!�� !(%6$2!

"�&�!$ $ !"7(%8� !$25&!.%.%(� !$@!&5% !$ ,$"%3%"5&$�'$@!)*$!3�2&5 !($! *CA$'%.5;=�!'5% !

"7(%8� !$?%8%5&!$!%� '%85.5&0!S$ $!&�&$�'�@!�!5*'�2!,52$"$!,2�"$($2!"�&�!3$��&$�7/�8�0!

T$A5!"�&�!3�2@!$?% '$!$&!>�*"5*/'@!5/+&!($!*&!2$"*2 �!5!*&!&+'�(�!$?,$2%&$�'5/!5'25.+ !(�!

)*5/!5 !"5'$8�2%5 !&�25% ! $!5,2$$�($&@!*&5!8*%�5(5!"2-'%"5@!,�2)*5�'�!5!2$/5;=�! *CA$'%.5!

"�&!$ 5 !��2&5 !�=�! $2:!,2$.% -.$/!�$&!&$"U�%"50!B!2$/5;=�! $2:!E"2-'%"5F!�5!&$(%(5!$&!

)*$!�=�! $!"��3�2&52:!"�&!�$�#*&5!"5'$8�2%5!(5(50!H/5!"�� '%'*%2:@!5�'$ @!*&5!2$/5;=�!

,2�C/$&5'%65(�25!"�&!�!,27,2%�!"5&,�!($!"5'$8�2%65;=�@!2$&$'$�(�V $@!��!&-�%&�!

%&,/%"%'5&$�'$@!,525!� !/%&%'$ !(�!#�2%6��'$!$,% '$&�/78%"�!($�'2�!(� !)*5% !$ 5 !,2:'%"5 ! $!

3�2&5&0!G!,2%�"%,5/!�=�!+!2$&$'$2!5!,2:'%"5!5!*&!"��'$?'�!$,% '$&�/78%"�!,2+V(5(�0!1@!5�'$ @!

3%2&52!5!"2-'%"5!"�&�!5!,2:'%"5!)*$!$?,<$!� !/%&%'$ !(�!,27,2%�!#�2%6��'$!$,% '$&�/78%"�@!

356$�(�!)*$!� !"��'�2�� !($ $!#�2%6��'$!5,52$;5&@!,�2!5 %&!(%6$2@!,$/5!,2%&$%25!.$6!��! $*!

/%&%'$0!B($&5% @!5!,2:'%"5!"2-'%"5!$&!)*$ '=�!%&,/%"52:!$&!*&5!'25� 3�2&5;=�!(�!E$*FWX�5! *5!

2$/5;=�!"�&!5!2$825!($!"��(*'50!Y$!)*$!&5�$%25@!,�% @!5!'25� 3�2&5;=�!(�!E$*F!"��(*6!Z!

$?,� %;=�!($ $!/%&%'$[!\�&�!,�($&� !"�&,2$$�($2!5!'25� 3�2&5;=�!(�!E$*F!"�&�!E,2:'%"5!

($!/%C$2(5($F!$!"�&�!$ 5!,2:'%"5! $!$�"5%?5!��!/+?%"�!3�*"5*/'%5��!(5!.%2'*($[!

Y$'$�#5&�V�� !,2%&$%2�!�5!��;=�!($!'25� 3�2&5;=�!($! %!)*$!$ ':!$&!A�8�!5)*%@!,525!

$�'=�!"�� %($252&� !"�&�!$/5! $!2$/5"%��5!"�&!�!,2�C/$&5!(5!E"2-'%"5F!)*$!+!�!"$2�$!($!

�� 5!(% "* =�0!T$&!(D.%(5@!"��(*6%2V $!"��3�2&$!*&!"7(%8�!($!"��(*'5!�=�!+!5!&$ &5!

"�% 5!)*$! $!"�� '%'*%2!"�&�! *A$%'�!+'%"�!�5!2$/5;=�!"�&!*&!"7(%8�!($!"��(*'5!]&5% !

(%3$2$�'$!5%�(5! $2:!"�� '%'*%2V $!"�&�!5)*$/$!)*$!($ 53%5!5!�2($�5;=�!2-8%(5!(�!,27,2%�!

"7(%8�0!B !2$825 !($!"5 '%(5($!3�2�$"$&!5!>�*"5*/'!*&!C�&!$?$&,/�0!_:!*&5!(%3$2$�;5@!,�2!

$?$&,/�@!$&!2$,2%&%2!($ $A� !)*$!.%�/5&!*&!,2$"$%'�!5�!)*5/! $!$ ':!&�25/&$�'$!�C2%85(�!$!

($ $�.�/.$2!*&5!,2:'%"5!($!($ $A�!)*$@!,�2!5 %&!(%6$2@! $!8*%5!,�2!($'$2&%�5(�!,2�A$'�!�*!

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Note
Por quê?
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Note
Perguntas que eu tb posso me fazer para chegar às "regularidades" no cenário II, e daí haurir as implicações para o cenário III.
Page 9: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"# $%�&' ($)$*+,"-+$.+$/0 -$1"$!"/0"!$/0"$ /0&"12 *+1$ $0* $!"3! $+0$-"&$.+1$'+*4!+*"�"$

$.5+$ 3&!*+1$,"$,"�"!*&. ,+1$*+,+16$&*4+.,+$0* $4!+&7&25+$'+.�! $ $!" -&8 25+$,"$'"!�+1$

,"1"9+1($:+$".� .�+6$+$*+,"-+$/0"$;+0' 0-�$701' $'+*4!"".,"!$"6$,"$# �+6$&.'+!4+! !$"$

"<"*4-&#&' !6$ #&!* $ $4!"1'!&25+$*+! -$'+*+$#+*".� ,+! $,"$0* $"14%'&"$,"$ 25+($=$/0"1�5+$

,"$;+0' 0-�6$ /0&6$4 !"'"$1"!$/0"$+$1 '!&#>'&+$"$ $4!+&7&25+$.5+$&*4?"*6$."'"11 !& *".�"6$0* $

*+, -&, ,"$%�&' $4 11&@ $+0$&. �&@ ($=*7+1$#+!* *6$ +$&.@%1$,&1�+6$0* $*+, -&, ,"$%�&' $,"$

'+.,0� $"$0*$*+,+$,"$"1�&-&8 !$� .�+$ $ 25+$/0 .�+$+$4! 8"!($$

A!"&+$/0"$+$'+.�! 1�"$/0"$;+0' 0-�$,"-&."& $".�!"$0* $%�&' $7 1" , $.+$'+* .,+$"$

+0�! $/0"$'+.@&, $+$B"0C$ $1"$'!& !$"1'- !"'"$,"$* ."&! $&*4+!� .�"$ $,&1�&.25+$".�!"$

+7",&D.'& $"$@&!�0,"$/0"$ 4!"1".� $"*$1"0$".1 &+$B)$/0"$%$ $'!>�&' EC($:"11"$�"<�+6$;+0' 0-�$

'+.�! 1� $ $* ."&! $'+*+$&.�"!4!"� $ $@&!�0,"$'+*$ $+7",&D.'& 6$*+1�! .,+$'+*+$ $

4+11&7&-&, ,"$,"11 $#+!* $,"$@&!�0,"$1"$"1� 7"-"'"$ $4 !�&!$, $,&#"!".2 $'+*$ $+7",&D.'& $

&!!"#-"�&, $F$ 0�+!&, ,"($

=$!"1&1�D.'& $F$ 0�+!&, ,"$'+.1�&�0&6$%$'- !+6$ $4!&.'&4 -$' ! '�"!>1�&' $,+$

G1'- !"'&*".�+$4 ! $;+0' 0-�($=$-"&�0! $,+$G1'- !"'&*".�+$/0"$+$ 0�+!$.+1$ 4!"1".� $.5+$

4". 1$"1� 7"-"'"$0* $'+.�&.0&, ,"$'+*$1"01$+79"�&@+1$'+*+6$� *7%*6$@D$. $H&1�I!& $,+$

G1'- !"'&*".�+$0* $4!+7-"*J�&' $1&*&- !$F$10 $4!I4!& ($:".H0*$4".1 ,+!$B&-0*&.&1� C$

'"&� !& $ $,"1'!&25+$,"$;+0' 0-�K$�+, @& $"11 $!"1&1�D.'& $.5+$&.@ -&, $10 $' ! '�"!&8 25+6$4+&1$

+$/0"$+$ 0�+!$701' 6$'+*$10 $' ! '�"!&8 25+$,+$L-0*&.&1*+6$%$!"13 � !$ /0&-+$/0"$4"!* ."'"$

B&*4".1 ,+C$,".�!+$,"$1"01$4!I4!&+1$�"!*+1$M$, >$/0"$1"0$!"- �+$1"$'+.#&30!"$'+*+$H&1�I!& $

'!>�&' ($N"$ '+!,+$'+*$"-"6$ $'!>�&' $'+*"2 $ $4 !�&!$,+$*+*".�+$"*$/0"$4+*+1$"*$/0"1�5+$ $

."'"11&, ,"$,"$0* $+7",&D.'& $ 71+-0� $"$107*"�"*+1$�+, 1$ 1$+7!&3 2?"1$3+@"!. *".� &1$

/0"$.+1$15+$&*4+1� 1$ $0*$"< *"$! '&+. -$"$!"#-"<&@+($=4"1 !$,"$.5+$1&*4 �&8 !$'+*$ $3! .,"$

4+1� $&-0*&.&1� $. $! 85+6$;+0' 0-�$4"!30.� !J6$.5+$+71� .�"6$/0 -$+$'!&�%!&+$/0"$,"-&*&� $ 1$

! 8?"1$"$901�&#&' �&@ 1$/0"$1"$'+ ,0. *$'+*$ $+7",&D.'& ($G-"$&.�"!"11 !M1"MJ6$4 !�&'0- !*".�"6$

4+!$&.@"1�&3 !$'+*+$"11"$' *4+$,"-&*&� ,+$#+!* $+$109"&�+$"$'+*+$"1�"6$4+!$1"0$�0!.+6$ ' 7 $

4+!$#+!* !$"$!"#+!* !$"11 1$! 8?"1($G11 $' 4 '&, ,"$,"$ ,08&!$! 8?"1$"1� !J$&.�&* *".�"$

!"- '&+. , $'+*$ $104! *".'&+. , $!"- 25+$, $�! .1#+!* 25+$,"$1&($=,+� !$0* $4+1�0! $

'!>�&' $,& .�"$,"$0* $ 0�+!&, ,"$/0"$1"$4!"�".,"$ 71+-0� $"<&3"$0* $4!J�&' $'!>�&' $/0"$�"*$

4+!$7 1"$ $�! .1#+!* 25+$,+$B"0C($

O 1$'+*+$"#"�0 *+1$"11 $4 11 3"*E$A+*+6$, $'+*4!"".15+$, 1$! 8?"1$/0"$�"*+1$4 ! $

'+.1".�&!$"*$0* $&*4+1&25+6$4 11 *+1$ $#+!* !$"11 1$! 8?"1$4+!$.I1$4!I4!&+1$"$ $.+1$

�! .1#+!* !$. $*",&, $"*$/0"$ 1$#+!* *+1$P !!&1' .,+6$4+!$#&*6$+$4!I4!&+$' *4+$, $! 85+QE$

G1�"1$4!+7-"* 1$15+$,&1�&.�+1$+0$+$4!&*"&!+$&.@ !& @"-*".�"$.+1$-"@ $ +$1"30.,+E$=$ 0�+.+*& $

/0"$'+./0&1� *+1$/0 .,+$#+!* *+1$! 8?"1$/0"$1"!@"*$,"$7 1"$4 ! $ $.+11 $ '"&� 25+$+0$

!"9"&25+$,"$0* $-"&$4!","�"!*&. , $1"$'+.#0.,"$'+*$ $�! .1#+!* 25+$,"$1&$/0"$+'+!!"$/0 .,+$

0* $!"3! $%$&.'+!4+! , $. $4!I4!& $ 25+$,+$109"&�+E$A+*+$@"!"*+1$ ,& .�"6$� .�+$ $

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Page 10: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$% &!'(%)*+)#,-)"!) +.!'(%)/%&)%#)0 +/+,�%#)1�,/%#-)23!"�%)!)0 4�,/!)*!)/ 5�,/!-)#(%)

6789:;<=>;>9?@7=A>9?;<?B>=C<DE?<9C:F:G>HI<9?<?=<0+�,'J+#K)L#�%)#3M+ +)23+)"(%)N4)/%&%)!/+,�! )%3)

=<O<:C>=?PA>?=<Q=>?9<A?PA?B<PD?RP<?9<?<9C:F:G<?<A?=<9S79C>?T?;<A>8;>?UC:6>?RP<?9<?FV<?:ASI<W)

X%)23+)/%&0+�+)Y)%Z+*,["/,!-)\%3/!3.�)!).%/!.,]!)"%)*+#+%)23+) +#0%"*+)Y)23+#�(%)

B/%&%)"(%)#+ )M%_+ "!*%DabK)c#�+)*+#+%-)+)%)&! !_,.N!&+"�%)23+)%)#+M3+-)/%"#,#�+)"!)

0 ,"/,0!.)$% '!)&%� ,])*!)/ 5�,/!K)X(%)$,/!)/.! %-)/%"�3*%-)*+)23+)&%*%)%)*+#+%)*+)"(%)#+ )

M%_+ "!*%)#+).,M!)Y)_, �3*+K)d)!3�% )*+,e!)/.! %-)0% 1&-)23+)"(%)+#�4)!)0%#�3.! )!)0%##,Z,.,*!*+)

*+)3&!)!"! 23,!)�%�!.)+)23+)%)0%"�%)+&)23+#�(%)"(%)1)/%&%)�% "! f"%#)�%�!.&+"�+)

,"M%_+ "4_+,#K)g !�!f#+-)!"�+#-)*+)3&!)23+#�(%)+#0+/5$,/!)23+)+&+ M+)+&) +.!'(%)!)3&!)$% &!)

*+)M%_+ "%)+#0+/5$,/!h)i/%&%)"(%)#+ )M%_+ "!*%)jkklm-)0% )�!.)0+##%!-)+&)"%&+)*+##+#)

0 ,"/50,%#-)+&)_,#�!)*+)�!,#)%Z+�,_%#)+)0% )&+,%)*+)�!,#)0 %/+*,&+"�%#-)"(%)*+##+)&%*%-)"(%)

S7=?678C>?;:997E?8<A?S7=?<F<9D?nlopmqK))

c##+)23+#�,%"!&+"�%) +_+.!f9<?PA?A>=67?<99<86:>F?;>?B>C:CP;<?6=rC:6>D?<?;<?9P>?s:=CP;<?

0! �,/3.! )tlopmqK)u! !)\%3/!3.�-)%)0 v0 ,%)23+#�,%"!&+"�%),"!3M3 !)3&!)!�,�3*+)0%.5�,/!)+)&% !.h)

B>?>=C<?;<?8w7?9<=?Q7s<=8>;7E?7P?A<FV7=E?>?>=C<?;<?8w7?9<=?Q7s<=8>;7?;<99<?A7;7?<?TRP<F<?

S=<H7DaxK)y)_, �3*+)23+)\%3/!3.�)!23,)"%#)!0 +#+"�!-)#+!)+.!)23!.)$% -)�+ 4)23+)_+ )/%&)!)%Z+'(%)

/%"� !)!),&0%#,'(%)*%)0%*+ -)/%"� !)%#)#+3#)/3#�%#-)/%"� !)%)&%*%)/%&%)+.+)1)!*&,",#� !*%)0% )

!23+.+#)23+)%)!*&,",#� !&K)u%*+ f#+f,!)0+"#! )23+)\%3/!3.�)+#�! ,!)!0+"!#)!)*+#/ +_+ )!)

=<9:9Cz86:>E?<?;<?@>C7?S>=<6<?RP<?>RP:?>?Bs:=CP;<D?C7A7P?7?FPQ>=?;<9C<?C<=A7E?7P?>:8;>E?23+)+.!)#+)

�% "%3)%)&+,%)0+.%)23!.)!) +#,#�["/,!)#+) +*+#/ +_+{)�+ +&%#)*+),"_+#�,M! )%)0% 23[),##%)

>678C<6<W?|;<A>:9E?<99>?s:=CP;<?U?C>A}UA?;<96=:C>?67A7?PA>?B>=C<D~?>?>=C<?;<?8w7?9<=?

Q7s<=8>;7?BC>8C7?>99:ADW?�P>F?UE?S7:9E?>?=<F>Hw7?<8C=<?<9CUC:6>?<?UC:6>)23+)+#�4)+&)%M%)!23,))

\%3/!3.�).%/!.,]!)!)% ,M+&)*!)/ 5�,/!)"!) +.!'(%)*+) +#,#�["/,!)Y)!3�% ,*!*+)

<6F<9:�9C:6>W?�7A?=<F>Hw7?T?;7PC=:8>?;>?:Q=<O>E?B8w7?RP<=<=?9<=?Q7s<=8>;7?<=>?PA>?6<=C>?

&!"+, !)*+)"+M! -) +/3#! -).,&,�! )t*,M!&)/%&%)23,#+ +&q)%)&!M,#�1 ,%)+/.+#,4#�,/%-)+ !)!)

_%.�!)Y)c#/ ,�3 !-)+ !)!)23+#�(%)�KKK�)*%)23+)$%,)+$+�,_!&+"�+)+#/ ,�%)"!)c#/ ,�3 !-)+ !)!)

RP<9Cw7?;<?RP>F?U?>?97=C<?;<?s<=;>;<?RP<?;:G?>?�96=:CP=>D��K))c)+#�!)%Z+'(%)+ !)/.! !&+"�+)

0 %&%_,*!)!)0! �, )*+)3&)$3"*!&+"�%)*+)_+ *!*+)+)3#�,'!)!.�+ "!�,_%)%3-)"%)&5",&%-)

:86:S:<8C<W?�9C7?F<s>?�7P6>PFC?>?@7=APF>=?PA>?9<QP8;>?;<@:8:Hw7?;<?B6=rC:6>D~?B�w7?RP<=<=?

#+ )M%_+ "!*%)�KKK�)"(%)23+ + )!/+,�! )+#�!#).+,#)0% 23+)+.!#)#(%),"3#�!#)%3)0% 23+)�KKK�)

<9678;<A?PA>?:F<Q:C:A:;>;<?@P8;>A<8C>FWD?tlopmqK)

y)/ 5�,/!)1)!23,.%)23+)+#/!"/! !)+##!),.+M,�,&,*!*+K)X%)+"�!"�%-)"(%)1)0% 23+) +/% +)!)

3&!)% *+&)0%.5�,/!)%3)&% !.)&!,#)0 ,&4 ,!)23+)!)/ 5�,/!)1)/!0!])*,#�%K)\%3/!3.�)!$, &!)23+)%)

�������������������������������������������������ab)\d��y��gK)�������������������K))axx�-)0K)�bK)

ax)\d��y��gK)�������������������K))axx�-)0K)�xK)

��)\d��y��gK)�������������������K))axx�-)0K)��K)

Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Avelino
Texte surligné
Page 11: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$!%& '$(&!%)#*+, ,%&!-%!%.!/# 0!%#%,%!+#1(20&(,%�! %#3#%#*$(�43,1,5%#%64#%)!%*(.0(7(&,1!%

1,%& '$(&,5890#**#%&!0$#:$!;%<%)�!*(&(!0, %1( #($!*%40(/# *,(*%#%( #/!.=/#(*%,!*%64,(*%64,364# %

>?@ABC?89DAEF9AGA9?9HIA9J?B9K9ILF9L?CFBHIMF89IL9LF>MDNBFO?89IL9AOIPFO?B9?I9QRSTUVWRXYZYR[9K9

$# =%1#%*#%*4+-#$# 5%\Y]TX9_9BaNMPF9OF9PBbNMPF89P?CNIO?89F9OADAMN?9O?9HIA9?D9NAcBMP?D9

MGILMCMDNFD9DIDNACNF@FL89Cd?9OADP?eBA9ADDAD9OMBAMN?D9ICM@ABDFMDf9AGF9?D9?DMPM?CFg9h?BiL89Cd?9

?D9?DMPM?CF9&!-!%1( #($!*%�!*($(/!*j%k%)�!*(&(!0, 5%<%4-%,$!%64#%3(-($,%!%�!1# %1,%3#(;9FN?9

HIA9P?CNBFBMF9A9BM@FGMlF9P?L9?D9LAPFCMDL?D9O?9?OAB9C?9L?LACN?9AL9HIA9ADNAD9DA9BAC?@FLg9

mMD9?9?DMPM?CFB9OF9BcBMF9GMLMNFnd?89HIA9FOHIMBA9F9J?BLF9OA9IL9HIADNM?CFLACN?9A9HIA9

,**#/# ,;%,!%*# %� !040&(,1!;%!%)1( #($!5%1#%64#*$(!0, j%o!%*<&43!%pqr%#-%1(,0$#;%,%64#*$s!%

)&!-!%0s!9*# %.!/# 0,1!t5%*#%,� #*#0$,%#*�#&(7(&,-#0$#%&!-!%)u4,(*%!*%3(-($#*%1!%1( #($!%

1#%.!/# 0, t5%\Y]TXvj%)wxd?9HIABAB9DAB9>?@ABCFO?y89i9PGFB?89Cd?9i9FPAMNFB9P?L?9@ABOFOA89zggg{9?9

HIA9ILF9FIN?BMOFOA9OMl9DAB9@ABOFOAMB?89?I9F?9LAC?D9Cd?9i9FPAMNFB9MDD?9DA9Cd?9DA9P?CDMOABF89?B9

DM9LADL?89e?FD9BFl|AD9FBF9FPAMNa}3,%,**(-5%\Y]TXg9~a89i9PGFB?89ILF9O?DA9BFl?a@AG9OA9

FLeM>IMOFOA9CADNF9DMNIFnd?g9�9HIA89FJMCFG89HIFGMJMPFB}DA}a9OA9JICOFLACN?9@aGMO?9OF9FPAMNFnd?9

OA9ILF9FIN?BMOFOA�9_PFD?9F9@FGMOFOA9OABM@F9O?9P?CDACNMLACN?9AL9FPAMNFB9F9FIN?BMOFOA�9�A9J?B9

FDDML89MDN?9HIAB9OMlAB89ACNd?89HIA9?9P?CDACD?9@FGMOF9FD9BFl|AD89DAEFL9AGFD9HIFMD9J?BAL�9�I9Cd?9

DABMF9FCNAD9?9PFD?9OA9HIA9i9FACFD9P?L9eFDA9AL9ILF9@FGMOFOA9Bi@MF9HIA9?JABAPAL?D9C?DD?9

P?CDACNMLACN?�9�9F9@FGMOFOA9OADDFD9BFl|AD9Bi@MFD9HIA9N?BCFL9?9P?CDACNMLACN?9@aGMO?�9�A9F9

BMLAMBF9FGNABCFNM@F9J?B9P?BBANF89ACNd?9?9P?CDACNMLACN?9i9?9PBMNiBM?9F9FBNMB9O?9HIFG9EIG>FL?D9F9

@FGMOFOAg9_9?DMnd?9J?IPFIGNMFCF9FBAPABMF89FDDML89BAOIlMB}DA9F9ILF9ADiPMA9OA9@?GICNFBMDL?g9

�FD89NFG@Al89?964#%�!4&,43$%!7# #�,%�! %-#(!%1,%)& '$(&,5%<%4-%,$!;%4-,%� =$(&,%1#%3(+# 1,1#%

HIA9Cd?9DA9OAM�F9BAOIlMB9JFPMGLACNA9F?9@?GICNFBMDL?89?BHIFCN?9F9BaNMPF9HIA9?DMPM?CF9?D9

GMLMNAD9OF9FIN?BMOFOA9FeD?GINF9OAACOA89JICOFLACNFGLACNA89O?9�?BMl?CNA9O?D9AJAMN?D9O?9

P?C�APMLACN?9OACNB?9O?9HIFG9AGF9?ABFg9_9BaNMPF9OF9PBbNMPF9Cd?9E?BBF9OA9ILF9GMeABOFOA9MCFNF9�9

FGLFg9mGF89FCNAD89J?BLF}DA9C?9ALeFNA9OA9ILF9NB?PF9ADAPbJMPF9ACNBA9IL9P?CEICN?9OA9BA>BFD9?I9

BAPAMN?D9�HIA9Ea9ADNd?9OFO?D9A9ILF9ADNMGMlFnd?9OA9FN?D9�HIA9A�FCOA9A9BAJ?BLIGF9ADDA9

P?CEICN?9Bi@M?9OA9BA>BFD9A9BAPAMN?Dvj%�**,%#*$(3(�,�s!%1!%)#45;%#-% #3,�s!%�*% #. ,*;%,&,+,9

�! %&!0*$($4( %4-,%)� =$(&,5j9

�?IPFIGN89AL9ILF9@AMF9L?OADNFLACNA9�FCNMFCF89AC�AB>F9?9FN?9O?9P?CDACNMLACN?9P?L?9

L?@MLACN?9BAJGA�M@?9HIA9FNBMeIM9?I9OADNMNIM9F9FIN?BMOFOA9OA9@FGMOFOAg9�?OF@MF89ADDF9

BAJGA�M@MOFOA9Cd?9?P?BBA9AL9FG>IL9G?PFG9MCNABC?9O?9DIEAMN?g9�A>ICO?9�?IPFIGN89NBFNF}DA9OA9IL9

FN?9HIA9ML GMPF9FG>IL9BMDP?89?MD9F9HIADNd?9Cd?9DABa9FACFD9?eEANFB9F9ADNF9?I9FHIAGF9A�M>�CPMF9

>?@ABCFLACNFG89LFD9NFLeiL9A�FLMCFB9F9?BOAL9CF9HIFG9DALAG�FCNA9OALFCOF9N?BCF}DA9GA>b@AG9A9

?DDb@AGg9m9DA9FHIMG?9F9HIA9DA9?eEANF9Dd?9FD9?BOACFn|AD9AMDNAL?Gc>MPFD9BAD?CDa@AMD9AG?9

#*$,+#3#&(-#0$!%1,*% #. ,*%1#%/,3(1,1#%.!/# 0,-#0$,3;%1(�# %)0s!5%,%#**,%! 1#-%(-�3(&, =;%

?BNFCN?89FeFCO?CFB9?D9JICOFLACN?D9ADNFeAGAPMO?D9OA9DIF9@FGMOFOA9A9ML ?B}G�AD9IL9GMLMNA9K9?9

HIA9i9OMJABACNA9A9LIMN?9LFMD9FBBMDPFO?9O?9HIA9PGFDDMJMPFB9ILF9OFOF9?BOAL9OA9MC@aGMOFg9�?L9

Page 12: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$%&�'�()"*#+,$�'-"., #$%/�'*#0,.�)"., #"#0,( !'1%'#1."#'�2")3,#0'-!%0"#0,.#� !" #

,'$�(")4� #�#0,.#, #+'�0�%!, #5!%0, #61�#$�2" # �# �71�.8#9#+',:2�."#$� � #&1($".�(!, *#

;<=>?@<AB<CD>E=F@GHFB>E=>IHC=JKDHG@LMN>(3,#5#61�#�2� # 3,#+"'0%"% #,1#0,(!'"$%!O'%, *#,1#61�#

�2� #$3,#&,')"#"#+, %)4� #.,'"% #P%+O0'%!" 8#9#+',:2�."#5#Q1 !".�(!�#61�#�2� #R% ".#,:2%!�'"'#

�# ":,!"'#,# 1'7%.�(!,#$�#61"261�'#'�2")3,#0'-!%0"*#% !,#5*#�2� #R% ".#"#�S+"($%'#,# �1#+,$�'#$�#

.,$,#"#,'$�("'#,#0".+,#$, #Q1-/, #.,'"% #�#+,2-!%0, #�.# 1"#0,.+2�!1$�8#T2� #&":'%0".#,#

0".+,#$"#+'O+'%"#0�'!�/"#�#,#� 7,!".8#U,.,#5#+, -R�2#+V'#�.#61� !3,#"#+'�!�( 3,#�S"1 !%R"#

61�#� " #'�7'" #$�#,'$�(")3,#!W.# ,:'�#"#0�'!�/"*# �.# �#�('�$"'#("#%(0�'!�/"*# �.#P":%!"'#

"61�2�#0".+,#$�#%($�!�'.%(")3,#61�#(, # 1 0%!"#" #"01 ")4� #$�#%.,'"2%$"$�*#."2$"$�#�#

� !�!%0% .,X#Y#"!%!1$�#0'-!%0"#(3,#5#.,'"2*# �#+,'#.,'"2#�(!�($�'., #"61�2" #'�7'" #01Q, #

2%.%!� #"#'�2")3,#0'-!%0"#:1 0"#%(!�'',7"'8#Z" #$�#61�#,1!',#.,$,*#�(!3,*#"#0'-!%0"#+,$�'%"#

'�"2%/"'#"# 1"#!"'�&"# �.#$�(1(0%"'#, #61�#("!1'"2%/".#�#!,'(".#P�7�.V(%0, #, #!�'., #

.,'"% #61�#�2"#+4�#�.#61� !3,X#

Y#$% !%()3,#&,10"12!%"("#�(!'�#7,R�'(,#�#7,R�'(".�(!"2%/")3,#R% "#"#., !'"'#61�#,#

"+"'"!,#0,.+'��($%$,#+�2,#+'%.�%',#%.% 01%[ �#(" #+'\!%0" #$, #61�#� !3,#"# �'#7,R�'("$, *#

�(!'"(P"($,[ �#(,# �1#+'O+'%,#.,$,#$�# �'#�#$�#0,(P�0�'8#]�'#7,R�'("$,#%.+2%0"*#"25.#$�#!�'#

1.#.,$�2,#%.+, !,# ,:#"# 1"#�S% !W(0%"*#'�0�:�'#$�#"(!�.3,#, #!�'., #$�(!',#$, #61"% # 1"#

�S% !W(0%"# �'\#,1#(3,#+, -R�28#9# 1Q�%!,#$� +,(!"'\#"#+"'!%'#$�# 1"#'�2")3,#0,.#1.#'�7%.�#$�#

R�'$"$�#� !":�2�0%$,*#+,'5.#�2�#!".:5.#+,$�'\#"$,!"'#1."#+�' +�0!%R"#+�'"(!�#� �#'�7%.�#

61�# 1 +�($�*#'�!', +�0!%R".�(!�*# �1#&1($".�(!,#,(!,2O7%0,8#

I=>B>J@_=FBG=FDBCHaBbc@>d>efg>� �#.,R%.�(!,#+�2,#61"2#, #%($%R-$1, # 3,#

" 1Q�%!"$, #h#'�"2%$"$�#$�#1."#+'\!%0"# ,0%"2#.�$%"(!�#.�0"(% ., #$�#+,$�'#61�#'�02".".#$�#

1."#R�'$"$�*#+,% #61�# �Q"i#T1#$%'%"#�(!3,#61�#jklmnopljkqkrksrtpsuvorkwuxrkyzjxkrk{z|upork{uk}~krk

}pmupork�xuk{z|uok{uk}rvvukxuk}mrpo�k}ukpvoummr�jmkjktum}j}uk{r�muk{uz{ku�upor{k}ukwr}umkukrkwr}umk{r�muk{uz{k

}p{lzm{r{k}uktum}j}uM��8##

�=�B=>B;<H>A@G@>L=>B�HGB>;<=>@>L<�=HD@>I �#$\#@>EH=HD@M>[#1.#.,$,#$�#"2,0")3,#�#

B<D@HaBbc@>E@>I=<M>�BB>A@FLHJ@>;<=>�B=A=>&1($"'*#$�#"(!�.3,*#"#'�&2�S%R%$"$�#$"#

'�%R%($%0")3,8#�'"!"'[ �[%"*#�(!c@N>E=><G>G@_HG=FD@>=FJ=FEBE@>B�=FBL>�=C@>I=<M>;<=>HFL<CB>

,# 1Q�%!,#0,(!'"#1."#"1!,'%$"$�#"(!"7V(%0"X#T#61�#%.+,'!"# ":�'#61�#� "#"2,0")3,#�#

E=LHJFBbc@>E@>I=<M>A@F�HJ<B><GB>IBD=M�>I�>AKDHABNM>EHa>?@<AB<CDN>IL=�>B>BD=>E=>%( �'R%$3,#

R,21(!\'%"*#$�#1."#%($,0%2%$"$�#'�&2�S%R"#�x�pv}rlpxpoqkmq�xql�pu�M>�p}us�8#]�*#(,# �(!%$,#&,10"12!%"(,*#

!'"!"[L=>E=><GB>IBD=MN>=FDc@>B>AKDHAB>Fc@>L=�><G>BD@>�FHA@N>DBG�@<A@>�=D=FA=�>

�S021 %R".�(!�#"#1.#$,.-(%,# 1:Q�!%R,*#+,'61"(!,# �'\#"#'�2")3,#� !%2%/"$"#0,.#1."#,'$�.#

� +�0-&%0"#��S!�'("�#61�#"#0"'"0!�'%/"'\8#9#� !%2,# �'\#0'-!%0,#("#.�$%$"#�.#61�#(3,#&,'#

+'�R%".�(!�#$�!�'.%("$,*#("#.�$%$"#�.#61�#%(0,'+,'"'\#1."#0,(!%(7W(0%"#",#2,(7,#$,#

���������������������������������������������������#�9�UY���8#�������������� ¡¢£¤8#�¥¥¦*#+8#§�*#7'%&,#(, ,#+8#§¥#("#�$%)3,#,'%7%("28#

Page 13: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

�� !"#$%&�$'�() )�*+,$"$*(-*.-�$'*$-*!*-)'*'�$"+'�.*'"+*$'"$!"'�+$%&�$"$+"'�)*/$0$

1234546789:;<1237;=>:?37<1@;AB:<C64BDE;A:42E;CF;2CG143:;HC1;?9:;I;AB:?37F1?31;J:K?:2JL>15;2:M;

:;A7BNF13B:;<1;>1B<7<1;1237M151J4<:O;P1;F:<:;74?<7;F742;B7<4J75E;Q:CJ7C53;<1J57B7R;=0$-+S�)-*$

��+)*$�TT�.-)*( �.��$!"+$U&.VW"$"$'�T*TT&X�)�* �.�"$'"$T&X�)�"$."$X"Y"$Z[\]\_$'"$%&�$T�$

!"'�+)*$-a* *+#$� $& *$!*(*b+*#$*$!"(S�)-*$'*$b�+'*'�@;cde\fg/$$

0$!"(S�)-*$'*$b�+'*'�$!�+��.-�$hT$+�(*Vi�T$'�$!"'�+$%&�$*TT).*(* $'�$*.�� W"$"$%&�$T�$

%&*()U)-*+,$"&$.W"$-" "$b�+'*'�#$"$%&�$)+,$"+'�.*+$"$ &.'"$-".U"+ �$ "'"T$+�Y&(*+�T$�$

+�Y&(,b�)T$�$"$%&�$T�+,$"&$.W"$*-�)�,b�($'�.�+"$'�$'���+ ).*'"$-* !"$'�$-".a�-) �.�"/$

j"'� "T$-" !+��.'�+$*$) !"+�k.-)*$'�T��$!".�"#$& *$b�l$%&�$).'*Y&� "Tm$"$%&�$T�$

%&*()U)-*$-" "$!�TT"*n$o$%&�$T�$%&*()U)-*$-" "$Yp.�+"$-"�+�.��n$o$%&�$T�$%&*()U)-*$-" "$

-)'*'W"n$0$%&� $!�+��.-�$"$ &.'"$%&�$q$(�Y)�) *'"$-" "$+�*(n$r&sX��)b* �.��#$

!�+Y&.�� "Tm$%&� $!"TT"$T�+$� $& $ &.'"$�*($%&�$"T$T�.�)'"T$�$() )��T$'�$%&*(%&�+$T&X�)�"$

�$TW"$�T�*s�(�-)'"T$'�$*.�� W"n$t&*)T$TW"$*T$."+ *T$%&�$ �$-"*Y� $%&*.'"$!*TT"$*$

%&�T�)".*+$"T$() )��T$'"$%&�$!"TT"$T�+n$u$"$%&�$"-"++�$%&*.'"$!*TT"$*$T�+$*%&)("$!*+*$"$%&*($

?9:;vD;5CK7B;<1?3B:;<1;CF;<7<:;B1K4F1;<1;>1B<7<1w;x9:;21B47;GC237F1?31;423:;=:;

<12722CG1437F1?3:;<:;2CG143:;?:;G:K:;J:F;yOOOz;7;A:5L34J7;<7;>1B<7<1@;c3B7<C89:;?:227gn$

o$%&�$�T�,$� $X"Y"#$*%&)#$q$*$+�(*VW"$�.�+�$"T$() )��T$'*$".�"("Y)*$�$'*$�!)T�� "("Y)*#$

"$�("$�.�+�$"T$() )��T$'"$%&�$!"TT"$T�+$�$"T$() )��T$'"$%&�$"&T"$T*s�+/${�+)b*.'"$T�&$T�.�)'"$

'�$-+S�)-*$'�$|*.�#$}"&-*&(�$U"+ &(*$& *$%&�T�W"$%&�$.W"$q$T�.W"$*$!+~!B47;JBL34J7R;=�:J�;

27M1;73I;HC1;A:?3:;5v1;I;51KL34F:;J:?v1J1Bw;yOOOz;�;7;?:227;54M1B<7<1;HC1;123D;1F;G:K:;7HC4O@;�;

()s�+'*'�$q$*(Y"#$!")T#$%&�$"-"++�$."T$() )��T$'"$-".a�-) �.�"$�$q$.�TT�$ " �.�"$%&�$T�$',$"$

'�T*TT&X�)�* �.�"$'"$T&X�)�"$'�.�+"$'�$& $'*'"$+�Y) �$'�$b�+'*'�#$ " �.�"$� $%&�$.*T-�$

CF7;<131BF4?7<7;ABD34J7;HC1234:?7<:B7;HC1;21;7AB121?37;2:M;7;21KC4?31;�:BF7R;=�;HC1;1?39:;

T"&$�&$�$�&$%&�$!�+��.V"$*$�T�*$a& *.)'*'�#$�*(b�l$h$ *+Y� #$.�TT�$ " �.�"#$.�TT�$).T�*.��$

'�$a& *.)'*'�$%&�$�T�,$T&X�)�*'"$*"$!"'�+$'*$b�+'*'�$� $Y�+*($�$'*T$b�+'*'�T$� $

!*+�)-&(*+n@��/$�"&�+*T$!*(*b+*T#$�TT*$%&�T�W"$!"'�+)*$T�+$*TT) $U"+ &(*'*m$"$%&�#$'�$*-"+'"$

-" $*$"+'� $".�"(~Y)-*$-".�� !"+k.�*#$!"TT"$T�+n$r�$*$!"T)VW"$'�TT*$%&�T�W"$!i�$� $X"Y"$

."TT*$()s�+'*'�#$�.�W"$q$!"TTSb�($%&�$*$ *.)U�T�*VW"$'*$()s�+'*'�$��.a*$%&�$b�+$-" $*%&)("$

%&�$}"&-*&(�$'�." ).*$'�$b)+�&'�#$-" $& $-�+�"$+)T-"$%&�$q$!"T�"$� $ *+-a*$!�("$

!�.T* �.�"$�#$-" $�U�)�"#$!�(*$().Y&*Y� #$("-*($� $%&�$*$"+'�.*VW"$'"$T�+$-".�� !"+k.�*$q$

(�b*'*$*"$T�&$() )��/$

�" "#$!"+q #$-" !+��.'�+$�T�*$"+'� $".�"(~Y)-*$-".�� !"+k.�*$%&�$�&$ �T *$

7J7M:;A:B;A:23C57Bw;�:;4<1?34�4J7B;7;=B7J4:?7546789:@;J:F:;:;1�143:;K:>1B?7F1?375467?31;<7;

".�"("Y)*#$}"&-*&(�$�T-"(a�$-*+*-��+)l*+$�T�*$"+'� $".�"(~Y)-*$a)T�"+)-* �.��$-".')-)".*'*$

���������������������������������������������������$}o��0���/$�����]�������������/$$����#$!/$��/$

Page 14: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

�� !"# "#$�%&# '!� ( #))(*%# + ,�(&%# *&-,%*# �# .)*(/# �� 0&#$12!&,3 42%/%#$�(5)� # !"#

,&#�%67( *&-,%*# �� �)'!�&�# 89)51#$,%#$#: 0(!*#!/, #2%&"#;

." ,(�( *#)(: �# �)'!�&�# <�=�/%#$# + .)*(/# �� 0&#$12!&,: <(!>� ,(�# !"#

*&-,%*# �( 8()%,%>%)"(: �( (?@�,%>%)"(: �# &#*%($#/%A#67(: �# BCDEFG � �#

,�*$%*%)#67(: ,(�# !"# *&-,%*# �#) &�/#6H�) �$,&� ( 8&(@�,( 2!$�#"�$,#/ �#

*%I$*%# � �# ,J*$%*#: '!� ,�" 8(& (?@�,%>( 2#A�& #8#&�*�& () �/() �$,&� !"#

8&�)!$67( %$=I$!# �# *%I$*%# �� !" /#�(: � #) 2(&"#) �� �("%$#67( 8&98&%#) +

2(&"# �# )(*%��#�� *($,�"8(&K$�#: �� (!,&(LM3

N� #*(&�( *(" �/�: # &#*%($#/%A#67( #�'!%&� $(># 2(&"# '!#$�( )� 8H� + )�&>%6( �(

?%(8(��&3 . ( '!� *($,%$!# )�$�( �%2-*%/ 8#&# # "#%(&%# �() #,(&�) )(*%#%) � *&-,%*(): ��$,&(

��),# )%,!#67(: J �%OPQRSTRUVURQWVXYZUQS[RQU\RVPTZSVWT]VXYZUQUZ_QRUabcCde3 f '!� 8#&�*� )�&

"�&#"�$,� !"# (&��" �8%),I"%*#: !" "(�( �� (&��$#& ( "!$�(: $7( ��%g# &�>�/#&

2#*%/"�$,� #) *($),&%6H�) $�*�))h&%#) 8#&# '!� )!# (&��$#67( (*(&&#i ,#"8(!*( )� �%)8H� #

#�"%,%& '!� # %$,�$)%2%*#67( � ,(,#/%A#67( �# &#*%($#/%A#67( � )�!) �2�%,() =�&# !"#

TS[QSOTjTPVXYZU_ZUZ_QRkUlZmPVmW[UQRnmS[VoU\( '!� 2#A '!� # &#*%($#/%A#67( *($�!A# #( 2!&(&

�( 8(��&pLq3 .>%��$,�"�$,�: # *#8#*%�#�� '!� # &#*%($#/%A#67( 8())!% �� ��>#))#& #)

"%$r*%#) _VUsT_VtUPVRVP[QRT]VUSYZUOZuQS[QUZOU_TsQROZOUuZ_ZOU_VURv[TPVUPTQS[wjTPVtU\"#)

,#"?J" #) &�/#6H�) )(*%#%): #) (&=#$%A#6H�) �),#,#%): #) 8&h,%*#) �*($x"%*#) � ,#/>�A #,J (

PZu ZR[VuQS[ZU_ZOUTS_Tsw_mZOLykUzURVPTZSVWT]VXYZUZ{[|uUOQmU\jmRZRUQUOQmOUWTuT[QOUSV

"��%�# �" '!� *#8,!&# � ��8#!8�&# ( )!@�%,( '!� #))!@�%,#3 f 8(��& ��/%"%,# ( '!� J /-*%,( #(

Om}QT[ZU\OQR~UVRVUVW|uU_QOOQOUWTuT[QOtUSYZUOQU\|tUZmUVTS_VtU�V{T[V5)� !" �("-$%( ��

($,(/(=%# 8&�*h&%#3 �( �$,#$,(: ( 8(��& >%)# # &�8&%"%& ( )!@�%,( #,&#>J) �� !"# 2(&6#

PZQRPT[TsVUQU|UVURQOTO[�SPTVUVUQOOVUPZQRXYZU�mQUPZSjTnmRVUVUQO[TWT]VXYZU_ZU\QmUQRVS[QUZOUWTuT[QOU

�),#?�/�*%�() �( '!� )� 8(�� )�&3

�uVU_VOU[VRQjVOURTuZR_TVTOU_VUPRw[TPVU|U_TOPQRSTRUVURQWVXYZU\QS[RQU"�*#$%)"() ��

*(�&67( � �/�"�$,() �� *($<�*%"�$,(L�3 �#%) !"# >�A: ��8#&#"(5$() *(" () /%"%,�) �( '!�

J *(=$()*->�/3 .),�) /%"%,�) �g�&*�" !"# 2(&6# '!� $7( )� 2!$�#"�$,# �" $�*�))%�#��

#/=!"# � 8(��" ,7( )("�$,� )�& *($,�),#�() (! %$,�&&(=#�() !"# >�A '!� $() �%)8($<#"()

# @(=#& 8#&# ( #/,( #'!�/# )�=!&#$6# � *($2(&,( 8&�)�$,�) ��$,&( �# ($,(/(=%# �%)8($->�/;

�������������������������������������������������LM 0f��4���3 �������������������3 ����: 83 M�3

Lq 0f��4���3 �������������������3 ����: 83 qL3

Ly 0f��4���3 �������������������3 ����: 83 qM3

L� 0f��4���3 �������������������3 ����: 83 y�3

Page 15: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#"$%&#'$()*+,",$-&.&$'/'.'01&$#'$2"3',$2'4$#'$+.$/"#&4$05&$'216$

-&0(&,.'$"$+.$-&07+01&$#'$,'*,"2$'$#'$-&"89'2$-","-1',:21)-"24$%&,$

';'.%/&4$#'$1"/$1)%&$#'$#)2-+,2&$-)'01:()-&$0+."$<%&-"$#"#"4$'$2'4$#'$&+1,&$

/"#&4$05&$#&1"22'$#'$'(')1&2$#'$-&',85&$&+$2).%/'2.'01'$#'$)0-)1"85&$

%,=%,)&2$"&$>+'$<$?"/)#"#&$-&.&$-)'01:()-&$&+$2).%/'2.'01'$,"-)&0"/$&+$

-&.+.'01'$"#.)1)#&4$'1-@AB$

$

C"0#&$-&01)0+)#"#'$D$2+"$",*+.'01"85&4$E&+-"+/1$#'21"-"$>+'4$'.$F/1)."$)021G0-)"4$

-&0H'-).'01&$'$%&#',$05&$2'$2'%",".B$I.3&2$1,"3"/H".$7+01&2$%","$'21"3'/'-',$+.$-&07+01&$

#'$-,)1<,)&2$2+1)2$'$';%/:-)1&2$%","$"$JKLLMNOPQRPSTKNLKUOPNKNVWJXKYNZ 5&$2'$1,"1"4$'015&4$#'$

#'2-,'?',$&$>+'$<$&$2"3',$'$&$>+'$<$&$%&#',$'$-&.&$+.$,'%,).),)"$&$&+1,&$&+$-&.&$&$&+1,&$

"3+2",)"$#">+'/'4$."2$1,"1"[2'4$"01'24$#'$#'2-,'?',$+.$0';&$#'$2"3',[%&#',$>+'$%',.)1"$

'01'0#',$&$>+'$-&021)1+)$"$"-')1"3)/)#"#'$#'$+.$2)21'."\@]B$

'0#&$"22).4$&$-,:1)-&$%&22+)$+."$1",'("$#+%/"_$.&21,",$-&.&$"$",1)-+/"85&$'01,'$

-&0H'-).'01&$'$%&#',$-&021)1+)$+.$.&#&$#'$&,#'0"85&$.")2$&+$.'0&2$2)21'.61)-&$#&$

VWJXKNaKVNLWMLNbOcbOdMLNZ-&0#)89'2$#'$"-')1"3)/)#"#'$#'$+.$2)21'."\NPNMReVNXdLLKNZ2'*+),$

"2$$/)0H"2$#'$,+%1+,"$>+'$.",-".$2+"$'.',*f0-)"\@gB$h$0'-'226,)&4$%&)24$05&$"%'0"2$)2&/",$'$

)#'01)()-",$&2$0';&2$%",1)-+/",'2$'01,'$%&#',$'$-&0H'-).'01&$>+'$-,)".$+.$-".%&$#'$&37'1&2$

)01'/)*:?')24$-&.&$1".3<.$,"21,'",$&$%&01&$'.$>+'$'21'$-".%&$3'),"$&$-&/"%2&4$&2$.&.'01&2$

#'$2+"2$#'2-&01)0+)#"#'24$&2$/&-")2$'.$>+'$"$)01'/)*)3)/)#"#'$>+'$1"01&$2+21'01"4$".'"8"$

-"#+-",B$ &+1,&2$1',.&24$&$>+'$2'$%,&-+,"$<$1"01&$"2$-&0#)89'2$-&021)1+1)?"2$#'$#'1',.)0"#&$

-".%&$#'$&37'1&2$>+"01&$&2$/).)1'2$#'21"$-&021)1+)85&4$.&.'01&2$'.$>+'$2+"$-&01)0*f0-)"$'$

.+1"3)/)#"#'$1&,0".[2'$%"1'01'2B$ "2$%"/"?,"2$XPNiKWaMWRjNZQMRMJXKNXPNVKXKNPLkWPVljdaKNKN

>+'$1'.&2$<$+."$.&3)/)#"#'$%',%<1+"4$+."$(,"*)/)#"#'$'22'0-)"/$&+$"01'24$+.$'.","0H"#&$

'01,'$">+)/&$>+'$,'%/)-"$&$.'2.&$%,&-'22&$'$&$>+'$&$1,"02(&,."\mnB$$

o&.$'(')1&4$&+1,"$."0'),"$#'$#'2-,'?',$'21"$#)0G.)-"$%,'2'01'$0"$-,:1)-"4$<$#)p',$>+'$"$

,"-)&0"/)p"85&$'0-&01,"$2'+$/).)1'$0&$#'2"22+7')1".'01&B$'$<$?',#"#'$>+'$&$#'2"22+7')1".'01&$

#&$2+7')1&$'.',*'$0&$.&.'01&$'.$>+'$"$qrstuqvq4$-&021)1+:#"$.'#)"01'$&$%,&-'22&$#'$

,"-)&0"/)p"85&4$';%9'$&$2'+$/).)1'4$'015&$<$)*+"/.'01'$?',#"#'$>+'$&$#'2"22+7')1".'01&$

"22)0"/"$7+21".'01'$"$(,"*)/)#"#'$'$"$.+1"3)/)#"#'$#"2$qrstuqvqt$#&$%&#',B$

I$-,:1)-"$-&.'8"$-&.$"$%,'2+085&$#'$*&?',0".'01"/)p"85&$'$#":$%,&22'*+'$-&.$2'+$

."/&*,&$'.$1&1"/)p",$&$2+7')1&$>+'$?)2"$"$-&0H'-',$'$"22+7')1",B$o&01+#&4$&2$.')&2$%'/&2$

�������������������������������������������������@A$EwxoIxyzB${|}~���������������B$�ggA4$%B$�@B$

@]$EwxoIxyzB${|}~���������������B$�ggA4$%%B$�@[mB$

@g$EwxoIxyzB${|}~���������������B$�ggA4$%B$�mB$

mn$EwxoIxyzB${|}~���������������B$�ggA4$%B$�]B$

Page 16: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$#%$!&'"( )!$%#'!$&%)!*+,$#+,$-%#(&"',#.$-%#(,/(%&'!/'%0%/'%.$(,0,$1"('2(",#3$4,&$� %$%$

5678957:5;<=>?7:5@=A67B=C<DC=?:E7F?9CA9G<7AG9>57A796A7HI@J<=CA7K=:<L@=C?M1"),#N1"(!$-%$1!O%&$

# !$P&NP&"!$Q"#'N&"!.$-%$1!R&"(!&$(,0,$P,&$1"(*+,$!$Q"#'N&"!$� %$#%&"!$!'&!S%##!-!$P%)!$� %#'+,$

-!#$&%)!*T%#$%/'&%$!#$%#'& ' &!#$-%$&!(",/!)"-!-%$� %$!&'"( )!0$,$-"#( &#,$S%&-!-%"&,$%$,#$

65CA;=:6?:7>57A::9U5=<A65;<?78957A75G5:7:V?7G=WA>?:XYZ3$[\"#'%.$P,"#.$%0$/,##!$P&NP&"!$

0%',-,),]"!.$ 0!$-"0%/#+,$� %$$!$-!$1"(*+,.$� %$'&!*!$)"/Q!#$1"('2("!#$%/'&%$!$&!(",/!)"O!*+,$

%$,$-%#!## _%"'!0%/',.$%/'&%$,$/%\,$(,/Q%("0%/',MP,-%&$%$# !$1&!]")"-!-%$%$,$#% $)"0"'%3$

, (! )'$/+,$/,#$-"O$� %$'"P,$-%$1"(*+,$#%&"!$%#'!.$P,&0$P!&%(%$()!&,$� %$%)%$%#'a$P%/#!/-,$

%0$b"%'O#(Q%.$%0$P!&'"( )!&$/!$# !$/,*+,$-%$]%/%!),]"!.$� %$'!0R0$#%$'"/Q!$(,0,$ 0!$

%#P("%$-%$1"(*+,3$

c,(d#$-%S%0$#%$)%0R&!&$� %.$0 "',$%0R,&!$%#'"0!##%$!$]%/%!),]"!$-!$0,&!)$(,0,$

'%/'!'"S!$-%$),(!)"O!&$!$,&"]%0$-,#$S!),&%#.$,$� %$b"%'O#(Q%.$/!$S%&-!-%.$R #(!S!$-%#(,R&"&.$%&!$

(,0,$!$P&NP&"!$/,*+,$-%$,&"]%0$#%$"/#'"' 2!3$[$,#$0%",#$P%),#$� !"#$R #(!S!$%\P)"(!&$!$,&"]%0$

%&!0.$%)%#$P&NP&",#.$1"('2(",#3$b"%'O#(Q%$/!&&!$ 0!$1aR )!$-,#$/,R&%#.$, '&!$#,R&%$ 0!$&%S,)'!$

%#(&!S!$/!$0,&!)"-!-%.$%$0!"#$ 0!$!"/-!$#,R&%$!#$&%)!*T%#$%/'&%$(&%-,&%#$%$-%S%-,&%#3$

b%/Q 0!$-%#'!#$1aR )!#$P,-%$#%&$),(!)"O!-!$/,$%#P!*,$, $/,$'%0P,$%$',-!$'%/'!'"S!$-%$

%/(,/'&!&$ 0$(,0P)%0%/',$Q"#'N&"(,$P!&!$!#$]%/%!),]"!#$/"%'O#(Q%!/!#$%#'a$1!-!-!$!,$

1&!(!##,3$e%$1!',.$/,$) ]!&$-%$ 0$&%)!',$� %$),(!)"O%$!$,&"]%0$-,#$S!),&%#$f$, $!"/-!.$!$,&"]%0$

-!$,&"]%0$f.$b"%'O#(Q%$/,#$,1%&%(%$%#'N&"!#$1"('2("!#$-%$(,0,$,#$S!),&%#$1,&!0$#%$,&"]"/!/-,$

!,$),/],$-,$'%0P,3$g0$/,R&%$-"O$� %$!)],$$,$(!#,$%$"##,$!(!R!$#%/-,$,$(!#,h$,$!',$

-"#( &#"S,$"/! ] &!$,$S!),&$%$',&/!M#%$ 0!$%#P("%$-%$%S%/',$!'NP"(,$%$!'%0P,&!)$� %$-a$

,&"]%0$!$S!),&%#3$i,0$%1%"',.$!#$P&NP&"!#$/!&&!'"S!#$1"('2("!#$/"%'O#(Q%!/!#$%\%0P)"1"(!0$,#$

!',#$-%$"/! ] &!*+,$� %$%)%$!'&"R "$!,#$� %$(&"!0$S!),&%#3$b"%'O#(Q%.$P,&'!/',.$/+,$!P%/!#$

-%#(&%S%$ 0$P&,(%##,j$# !$-%#(&"*+,$!(!R!$P,&$#%$',&/!&$ 0$%\%0P),$-%$P&,- *+,$-%$S!),&.$

&%!)"O!/-,$,$0%#0,$P&,(%##,$� %$/!&&!3$$$$

e%$� %$0,-,$%##%$ #,$P!&'"( )!&$-!$1"(*+,$#%$&%)!(",/!$(,0$!$/,*+,$1, (! )'"!/!$-%$

(&2'"(!k$l%0R&%0,M/,#$-%$� %$ , (! )'$'%/'!$(,0P&%%/-%&$!$P,##"R")"-!-%$-%$

-%#!## _%"'!0%/',$-%/'&,$-,#$� !-&,#$-!$&!(",/!)"O!*+,$#%0$!1"&0!&$� %$Qa$ 0!$1,/'%$-%$

&%#"#'d/("!$� %$%#'a$!),_!-!$/,$# _%"',$, $%0$!)] 0$, '&,$(!0P,$1 /-!(",/!)3$e%$,/-%.$%/'+,.$

S%0$!$&%#"#'d/("!k$4,-%&2!0,#$-"O%&$� %$%)!$$!$"&& P*+,$-%$ 0!$)"R%&-!-%$Q 0!/!$!P&"#",/!-!$

P%),#$P,-%&%#$-!$&!(",/!)"O!*+,k$m%$Qa.$(,0,$, (! )'$-%$1!',$1!)!.$ 0!$S,/'!-%$-%$nopq#%&$

],S%&/!-,.$-%$� %$0,-,$Q!S%0,#$-%$(,0P&%%/-%&$,$%#'!' ',$-%##!$S,/'!-%k$

[0$&%#P,#'!$!$ 0!$� %#'+,$� %$S!"$/%##!$)"/Q!.$,$! ',&$!1"&0!h$

$

�������������������������������������������������YZ$rgisglt3$uvwxyz{|z}~{y{�����3$Z���.$P3$��3$

Page 17: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$%&#'($)&*#+&,#(-(./&*#0!(#1#2&$/13(#3(#$%&#)(4#5&2(4$13&#3(#6(./&#

$($7!,##)(61#185&#0!(#)(#'&))1#+&$).3(414#+&,&#!,1#1)'.419%&#&4.5.$:4.1;#

<($)&#0!(*#3(#-1/&*#1#2&$/13(#3(#$%&#)(4#5&2(4$13&#=#)(,'4(#1#2&$/13(#3(#$%&#

)(4#5&2(4$13&#1)).,*#3())1#-&4,1*#'&4#()/1)#'())&1)*#'&4#())(#'4(9&>?;##�

<4&))(5!.$3&#+&,#)!1#(@'81$19%&*#A&!+1!8/#$&)#18(4/1#+&$/41#1#1B)&8!/.C19%&#3())1#

2&$/13(#0!(#1#-.8&)&-.1#)(,'4(#)(#2.!#/($/131#1#4(18.C14;# 8(#2.)1#1#(2./14#&#0!(#+71,1#3(#

D'14&@.),&#-.8&)E-.+&#(#/(E4.+&#3(#185!,1#+&.)1#0!(#)(4.1#())1#2&$/13(#3(#$%&#)(4#

4(81/.21,($/(#5&2(4$13&FGHIJKLM;#A&!+1!8/#3(.@1#+814&#0!(#()/!314#())1#2&$/13(#&#+&$3!C#1&#

'4&B8(,1#31#&4.5(,*#(#=#'&4#'&!+&#0!(#(8(#$%&#3().)/(#3())(#/(44($&*#,1)#!,1#+(4/1#4(8!/N$+.1#

$.(/C)+7(1$1#=#&#0!(#'4(218(+(;#O.C#(8(P#�

!#$%&#,(#4(-(4.1#1#185&#0!(#)(4.1#!,#1$140!.),&#-!$31,($/18*#0!(#)(4.1#

+&,&#1#8.B(4313(#&4.5.$:4.1#1B)&8!/1,($/(#.$3E+.8#(#1&#-!$3&#3(#/&31#

5&2(4$1,($/18.C19%&;# !#$%&#3.))(#.)/&*#,1)#.))&#$%&#0!(4#3.C(4#0!(#(!#&#

(@+8!1#1B)&8!/1,($/(;#Q4(.&#0!(*#+&,#(-(./&*#,.$71#(@'&).9%&#':41#10!.P#

'&40!(#6:#/.$71#3!413&#/(,'&#3(,1.)R#,1)#/1,B=,#'&40!(#,(#'(45!$/&;;;#)(#

)(#0!(4#-1C(4#1#(@'8&419%&#3())1#3.,($)%&#31#+4S/.+1#0!(#,(#'14(+(#/%&#

.,'&4/1$/(#1&#,(),&#/(,'&#'&40!(#(81#-1C#'14/(#31#-.8&)&-.1#(#$%&#-1C#'14/(#

3(81*#$%&#)(4.1#3(2&82.3&#+&,&#B1)(#31#1/./!3(#+4S/.+1#1#185&#0!(#)(4.1#&!#1#

'4:/.+1#7.)/E4.+1#31#4(2&8/1*#31#$%&T1+(./19%&#3(#!,#5&2(4$&#4(18*#3(#!,#813&*#

&!*#3(#&!/4&*#U#(@'(4.V$+.1#.$3.2.3!18#3(#4(+!)1#31#5&2(4$1,($/18.313(W>>##�

)/1#2&$/13(#0!(#.$2&+1,&)#0!1$3&#4()XYZX[\YG]G\_abc[bZcdXecfg\GhGDijLjk

l[cGdXmancnG\aXXboaXcFGGYX[XdcaGD]GpaoZXqcGrXYZsaXqcGncGa_\dZcFGHaXt\Gb\YY\uvGwg\xGq\[G

(-(./&*#+&,&#(81)*#,1)#1'14($/(,($/(#$%&#1#,(),1#+&.)1;#y!1$3&#,($+.&$1#!,1#

DdXmancnG\aXXboaXcFxGz\lqcldZGcGnXeGc\G[Y[\GZ[p\G[G{lGcGnYnXevGD|lGbg\GnXYYG

XYZ\xFGdGb\ZcGd\\GcpsYG{lcYGctXa[oT81*#3('&.)#3(#$&)#(2.3($+.14#+&,&#()/(2(#'4E@.,&#

3(#1-.4,:T81*#3('&.)#3(#(@(4+(4#!,1#&!)13.1#()+1$+14131#0!(#'&3(4S1,&)#8(4#+&,&#!,1#

'4&2&+19%&;#y!(#3.)+!4)&#=#()/(#0!(#&#)(3!C#10!.*#3&,.$1$3&T&#+&,#&)#)(!)#/(4,&)W# #

+&,&#=#0!(#(8(#4(+&44(#1&)#'4E'4.&)#/(4,&)#0!(#4(+!)1W#y!(#14/(#=#())1#(,#0!(#1#3.)/N$+.1#

+4S/.+1#0!1)(#)&-4(#!,#+&81')&#$1#$&))1#-4($/(W# #)(4.1#())1#,(),1#3.)/N$+.1#1#0!(#$&)#

+&,!$.+1#1#'4:/.+1#31#.$2()/.519%&*#3&#0!()/.&$1,($/&W#y!(#8.,./()#3&#+&$7(+.,($/&#

A&!+1!8/#&!)1#(@'1$3.4#0!1$3&#)(#$&)#+&8&+1#'4&B8(,1)#(,#18/1#2&CW#}#+($1#.$1!5!418#31#

qa~ZXqcGX[pdXqcGD�k���KkncGXbYa_Xng\G_\dlbZoaXcFGxGq\[GtXZ\xGDcGdXmancnG\aXXboaXcFGYZoG

�������������������������������������������������>?#A��Q}���;#��������������������#����*#';#�?;#

>>#A��Q}���;#��������������������#����*#'';#�?T>;#

Page 18: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$�%&'%(#%�)#*�#+,-%�#./#!%�#0,*1/$!-�(#*�#+,-%�#./#!%�#�-$/# !/#)!)2/*./#�#

,*$,3,4"�#/# !/#*,)#0,*.!5#2�-�#./*$-,#.�#)!)2/*)6,#.�#./)0-/*7�8##

9,!0�!3$#.:#!%#1/"$,#./#;<=>?@A>@B<CD?E>ED@F?<G<HI?<>JK@LMNFHOF@PMD@N?FHMH;<>?@DL=>L@

2�3�Q-�)#$/*R�#3R/#.�.,#/*,-%/#2-�5/-#/#%/.,8#S3/#�)#."5(#%�)#$6,#),%/*$/#�)#/*0/*�(#

3"Q-�*.,T)/#./#!%#0,%2-,%")),#,*$,3U4"0,#/#3"&/-�*.,#�)#2�3�Q-�)(#/3�)#2-U2-"�)(#2�-�#

./$/-%"*�.,#!),8#S3/#)/#-/+/-/(#� !"(#�#!%�#3"&/-.�./#,-"4"*:-"�V#W!�#"*$/*76,#'#-/0,--/-#�#/3�V#

X0�),#/3/#/*0,*$-,!#,#2,7,#.�#3"&/-.�./#,-"4"*:-"�#/#*/3/#)/#/%&/&/.,!V#Y!#�0�),#/3/#�#

2,)$!3�(#�#%/*0",*�(#�#�+"-%�#./#%,.,#)"4*"+"0�$"Q,#)/%(#./#+�$,(#."5ZT3�V#S)$�-"�#/3/#�#

"*Q,0�*.,#2�-�#./)Q/*0"3R:T3�#./#)!�)#�)),0"�7[/)#2�))�.�)(#./#),-$/#�#*,)#�2-/)/*$�-#/#

-/*,Q�-#)/!#2,./-V#X#/*0/*�76,#.,#$/-%,#*6,#'#)!�#�))/-76,(#2,-'%#2,./%,)#�+"-%�-# !/#�#

�))/-76,#'#/*0/*�.�(#�2-/)/*$�.�#�-$\)$"0�#/#�-."3,)�%/*$/(#)!&%/$".�#�#!%�#)!)2/*)6,#

,*$,3U4"0�(#1!)$�%/*$/#2�-�# !/(#/*$6,(#2,))�#)/-#+�3�.�8#S#'#/)$/#�$,#.")0!-)"Q,#]# !/#2,-#

>BGM@=DNF@B<_?>@>@?>LD@AB<CD?E>ED@F?<G<HI?<>J@E>@NFBa=<;>@DN<L=b<;>@PMD@>@DHGBFC>@]# !/#

-/�3"5�#!%#./)�))!1/"$�%/*$,#/)2/0\+"0,#.,#)!1/"$,#./*$-,#.�#2,3\$"0�#.�#Q/-.�./8#c,")# !�*.,#

+�3�%,)#./))�#%�*/"-�(#),%,)#�--/&�$�.,)#/#3"&/-�.,)#2/3�)#2�3�Q-�)# !/#./#!%#1/"$,#,!#./#

,!$-,#2-,+/-"%,)8#W/%#.dQ".�(#�#2,3\$"0�#1�%�")#'#!%�# !/)$6,#)"%23/)%/*$/#.")0!-)"Q�(#/#*6,#

'#%/!#./)/1,#-/))!)0"$�-#X-")$U$/3/)#2,-#%/",#./#9,!0�!3$#e%!"$,#/%&,-�(#0,*+/)),(#

)/%/3R�*$/#/)$-�$'4"�#%/#"*$-"4!/(#/#)/#� !"#�#/)&,7,(#'#2�-�#,+/-/0ZT3�#0,%,#2,))"&"3".�./#)/%#

0,%#/3�#%/#0,%2-,%/$/-f8#g/)$/#4/)$,#Q/-&�3# !/#)/#."-/0",*�#2�-�#,#+"%#./#)!�#2�3/)$-�(#

!%�#0/-$�#3"&/-.�./#)/#/h/%23"+"0�(#*6,#2,-#%/",#.�#-/+/-Z*0"�#�,#$/-%,#)/%# !�3 !/-#i*0,-�#

!/#,#+!*.�%/*$/(#%�)#)"%#2,-#!%�#2/-+,-%�*0/#�-."3,)�# !/#3"&/-�#,#0,*0/"$,#./#)!�)#

-/)$-"7[/)#.")0!-)"Q�)#R�&"$!�")(#.,#/*4,.,# !/#*,)#3/Q�#�#0-/-# !/#�2/*�)#2-,+/-"%,)#�34,#)/#

)�&/%,)#./#�*$/%6,# !�3#)!�#i*0,-�#R:#./#)/-8##

S!#."-"�# !/#,#4/)$,#+,!0�!3$"�*,#'#/h$-�,-."*�-"�%/*$/#Q�3/*$/(#*�#%/.".�#/%# !/#

)�&/# !/#*6,#2,./#+!*.�%/*$�-#)!�#2-/$/*)6,#j#3"&/-.�./#,-"4"*�38#S))�#0�-Z*0"�#./#

0,*R/0"%/*$,#'#,# !/#2/-%"$/#,#!),#2�-$"0!3�-#.,#$/-%,#./*$-,#./#)/!#.")0!-),8#g6,#

,&)$�*$/(#9,!0�!3$#-/"Q"*."0�#�#3"&/-.�./#,-"4"*�3(#/#)!�#%/*76,#/#"*)")$Z*0"�#*/3�#

-/2-/)/*$�%#!%�#�3/4,-"�#2�-�#� !/3/#-")0,# !/#)/#.:#*,#3"%"$/#.,#0�%2,#/2")$/%,3U4"0,8#

k)$,#0,*+"4!-�(#$�3Q/5(#!%�#2-:$"0�#./#Q"-$!./#e/#*6,(#0,%,#)/!)#0-\$"0,)#�3/4�%(#!%#)"*�3#

./#./)/)2/-,#%,-�3f#1!)$�%/*$/#*�#%/.".�#/%# !/#�#2-:$"0�#./))/#$"2,#./#+�3�#2,)$!3�#2�-�#

)"#!%#Q�3,-# !/#*6,#)�&/#0,%,#+!*.�%/*$�-#,!#�))/4!-�-(#%�)# !/#'#2,)$!3�.,#*6,#

,&)$�*$/(#/Q"./*0"�*.,(#2,-$�*$,(# !/#R:#!%�#"*$/3"4"&"3".�./#2�-�#�3'%#.�#"*$/3"4"&"3".�./#

1:#/)$"2!3�.�#2/3�#.!23�#2,./-T0,*R/0"%/*$,8#k)$,#�0�&�#)/*.,#!%�#Q"-$!./#e2/3,#%/*,)#

*!%#)/*$".,#-/.!5".,f#1!)$�%/*$/#2,- !/#,+/-/0/#�#2/-)2/0$"Q�#2/3�# !�3#,#)!1/"$,#4�*R�#

!%�#.")$i*0"�#0-\$"0�#+�0/#j#�!$,-".�./#/)$�&/3/0".�8#c,-'%(#$-�$�T)/#$�%&'%#./#!%#�$,#./#

0,-�4/%(#./#!%#�4"-#)/%#4�-�*$"�)(# !/#�--")0�#,#)!1/"$,#0,*$-�#,)#3"%"$/)#.�#,-./*�76,8#

Page 19: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

�� !"# $%&"'(�)&�*+"# " * " #+%, ## "-&$&"-$(. $%$"# ! */&0+ #"-&*&,$&#1"��&*"("

2 #&##�3 %+&! 0+("4� " * "0(#"$ &*%5&")(!" #+&" *()�67(1"

8&$&"'(�)&�*+9":&0/&$"�!&"2%#+;0)%&")$<+%)&"- $&0+ "&"&�+($%2&2 " #+&= * )%2&"07("

#%:0%.%)&"&- 0&#"$ )(0/ ) $"(#"!(2(#")(!("(#" . %+(#")( $)%+%,(#"2(")(0/ )%! 0+("

!&0%. #+&!># "0&".($!&67("2("-$?-$%("#�3 %+(@"A%:0%.%)&9"+&!=B!9"-C$" !"$%#)("0(##&"-$?-$%&"

.($!&67(" 04�&0+("#�3 %+(#@"A 02("&##%!9" !"DEFGHIJKLEIELEMLNIOPQRSTUVTWXQYZ[Z\YZ]Q_TZQZaXVQ

.($!&"2 "-(2 $"4� "# "&-*%)&"b",%2&"%! 2%&+&" "4�(+%2%&0&")&+ :($%5&"("%02%,<2�(9"2%#+%0:� >("

-($"#�&"-$?-$%&"%02%,%2�&*%2&2 9"&0 c&>("b"#�&"-$?-$%&"%2 0+%2&2 9"%!-(02("*/ "�!&"* %"2 "

, $2&2 "4� " * "2 , "$ )(0/ ) $" "4� "(#"(�+$(#"2 , !"$ )(0/ ) $de"\ZWZfdg@"h"4�&02("

# ! */&0+ "* %",&)%*&"(�")(*&-#&9"&"-$?-$%&"-(##%=%*%2&2 "2 "$ )(0/ )%! 0+(" #!($ ) @"i##%!9"

_TV\YSQjZ]kT\XVlSaQUSlSQjSYZlSaQ[VWV]QYZQWmnZ]YVYZQS]mkm\]mVfPQZQVQV[m]lVlSaQUSlSQ_TZQ

%02&:&02(9"+&!=B!"-(!(#" !"4� #+7("("#�3 %+("4� "#�-(#+&! 0+ " #+o" 0$&%5&2("0 #+&".$&# 9"

*%= $&02(>(9"-&$&2(c&*! 0+ 9"-&$&"�!&"&, 0+�$&"4� "-(##&9"2 ".&+(9")(0. $%$"0(,(#")(0+ p2(#"

"-(##%=%*%2&2 #"-&$&" #+&" c-$ ##7("2 #:&#+&2&@""

h!")(0)*�#7(9":(#+&$%&"#%!-* #! 0+ "2 "$ +($0&$"b"qrKOLNGstLEYuDEGvLENLvEwOxyIOIv@"z #+&"

(=$&9"'(�)&�*+"&.%$!&"4� "&"-$o+%)&"4� " #+�2&"{"VaQV]XZaQYZQZ|maX}\UmVf{"# ")&$&)+ $%5&"-($"

�!&"$ *&67("2 ")�%2&2("2 "#%@"h#+&".($!�*&67("0(#"&-$(c%!&"2&4� *&" #+$&0/&".($!&"2 "

,%$+�2 "4� "("&0+%.�02&)%(0%#!(".(�)&�*+%&0(")/ :&"&"$ -$ # 0+&$@"~(!" . %+(9")(!(".&* %"

&0+ $%($! 0+ 9"'(�)&�*+"+&!=B!"2%5"4� "+&%#"&$+ #"2 " c%#+�0)%&"-$(2�5 !"#�3 %+(#"4� "

=�#)&!"+$&0#.($!&$"&"#%"-$?-$%(#" !"# �"# $"#%0:�*&$9".&5 02SQYZQaTVQ�mYVQTlVQSn]VQYZQV]XZf"

�Lw�E�JK@�@"8(2 $<&!(#"- 0#&$"4� " ##&"&.%$!&67(")($$(=($&"&"&)�#&67("2 "4� "'(�)&�*+"

#+ +%5(�"&" c%#+�0)%&")(!-* +&! 0+ 9"b#" c- 0#&#"2&"B+%)&@"h!")(0+$&#+ 9"("4� " �"#�: $%$%&"B"

4� "'(�)&�*+"+7("#(! 0+ "0(#"!(#+$(�"4� "3&!&%#"-(2 $ !(#"+ $"�!&"B+%)&9"+&!-(�)("�!&"

-(*<+%)&9"# !"$ )($$ $"&" ## "# 0+%2("#%0:�*&$"2 "wLJIvJv@"�"#�3 %+("4� "B".($!&2("- *(#"

-$%0)<-%(#"2%#-(#+(#"- *("2%#)�$#("2&", $2&2 "&%02&"07("B"("#�3 %+("4� "*�+&"-&$&"# ")$%&$@"i("

0:&3&$># "\VaQV]XZaQYVQZ|maX}\UmVfPQZaaZQaT�ZmXSQ�QXV\XSQU]mVYS]Q_TV\XSQU]mVXT]VPQZQVQWm\�VQ_TZQ

2%,%2 "(#"!(! 0+(#" !"4� "# ".($!&9"2(#"!(! 0+(#" !"4� "B".($!&2("B9"# 07("%!-(##<, *9"

) $+&! 0+ "2%.<)%*"2 "# $"+$&6&2&@"i#")(%#&#"07("# "-&##&!")(!("# "("#�3 %+("�!&"/($&".(## "

.($!&2(" "0(�+$&"/($&" * ",%$&## "-&$&"("*&2(" "#�=%+&! 0+ ")(! 6&## "&"# ".($!&$@"8 *("

)(0+$o$%(9"&".($!&67("2("#�3 %+("2o># ")(!"&"%0#+%+�%67("2&"-$?-$%&"$ .* c%,%2&2 "4� 9"

%02%#+%0+&! 0+ 9"+(!&"-&$&"#%"&"+&$ .&"2 ".($!&67(@"h#+&"*%0/&"B"%02%#+%0+&"3�#+&! 0+ "0("*()&*"

!"4� "&#"0($!&#"#()%&%#")(0, $: !")(!" c%:�0)%&#"B+%)&#" " !"4� "&!=&#"# "-$(2�5 !"0("

)(0+ cXSQYZQTlQZTfQ_TZQaZQU]mVQlVaQ_TZQ\T\UVQaZQm\VTkT]VQUSljWZXVlZ\XZ�"�������������������������������������������������de"'��~i���@"��ZQ�Tn�ZUXQV\YQ�S�Z]f�Q����9"-@"���@"

dg"RSTUVTWXPQ�mU�ZW�Q��ZQ�Tn�ZUXQV\YQ�S�Z]f�Q�\�Q����R��PQ�TnZ]XQ��QV\YQ�� �¡¢£PQ�VTWQ¤ZYa¥�Q¦J�§IE

©LG�xGKªE«I¬LrNEFKOG�KGOxJv­ExrNE®IO­IrIGKJ�v�"~/%)&:("�0%, $#%+°"(."~/%)&:("8$ ##9"����9"--@"�±�>���@"�

Page 20: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� !"#$%&!%"!%$!'!$($%&!%)#*!($#%+!)%!, -./(0#%1%(*0!*234%!%1%&!-(+!$#234%*!"0!%0!,045%

6789:8;<=<:>?@>=A7B=97ACDBB:=E8D=BDFG=HICJ9I;=97>KFDDAHDF=DBB:=DB<I;IL:MN7=H7=OD8P=A7B=

QR#&$4"%!"0#+!-!/(&4"%&#"%*42S!"%&!%(*0!*234%!%&!%&!-(+!$#234T%U#$#%QR!%!*0!*&#)4"%#%$!V("34%

&4"%0!$)4"%QR!%4%"!R%R"4% #$0(/R-#$%*4"%$!QR!$5%W4R/#R-0%(*0$4&RX%&4("%/4*/!(04"5%#%"#+!$5%

O>7H7B=HD=:BB8YDI<:>DA<7=D=B8?YD<IZ:MN7P[=\B<DB=97A9DI<7B=AN7=FD;:<:>=BI>K;DB>DA<D=:=

)#*!($#%/4)4%4%"R]!(04%%'4$)#&4_%!-!"%0#)+)%!, -(/(0#)%/4)4%4%"R]!(04%04$*#"!%/# #X%&!%

"!%'4$)#$T%a4$*#$"!%R)%"R]!(04%0(/4%*34%%R)#%"() -!"%QR!"034%&!%#R04/4*b!/()!*04%4R%

#R04/4*"/(c*/(#T%a$#*"'4$)#$BD=D>=8>=B8YDI<7=@<I97=HDA7<:=O8>=KF79DBB7=D>=E8D=7=

(AHIZJH87=HD;I>I<:=E8:;=K:F<D=BDFG=7?YD<7=HD=B8:=KFG<I9:=>7F:;P[=d=OD8P=HD;I>I<:=:=BI=KFeKFI7=D=

!"/4-b!%4%)#0!$(#-%#%"!$%R0(-(X#&4%K:F:=:=B8:=9FI:MN7[=f7H:ZI:g=:=HD;I>I<:MN7=E8D=7=OD8P=FD:;IL:=

&h"!% 4$%*4$)#"%QR!5%(*V#$(#V!-)!*0!5%]h%!"034%&#&#"T%U4$0#*045%"!%/4*"(&!$#$)4"%QR!%!""#%

9FI:MN7=DB<@<I9:=H7=OD8P=BD=HDBH7?F:=HDA<F7=HD%R)#%&!0!$)(*#&#% $h0(/#%0(/#5%V!$!)4"%QR!%

!"0!%0$#+#-b4%0(/4% 4&!%"4)!*0!%4/4$$!$%&!*0$4%&!%R)%/4*0!,04% 4-.0(/4%)#(4$i%#"% 4-.0(/#"%

&#"%*4$)#"T%W4R/#R-0%&!(,#%/-#$4%QR!%*34%bh%*!*j8>:=C7F>:MN7=H7=OD8P=C7F:=HD=8>=>7H7=HD=

B8?YD<IZ:MN7g=7=E8D=I>K;I9:=HILDF=E8D=AN7=jG=C7F>:MN7=H7=OD8P=C7F:=H:B=A7F>:B=E8D=

#$QR(0!0#)%#"%/4*&(2S!"%&!%'4$)#234%&4%"R]!(04T%

k:BB:>7B=B8:ZD>DA<D=HD=8>:=A7MN7=HIB98FBIZ:=H7=B8YDI<7=K:F:=8>:=A7MN7=H7=OD8P=

)#("% "(/4-4l(/#)!*0!%$!0R)+#*0!%!%% 4"".V!-%QR!5% #$#%W4R/#R-05%#%"!lR*&#%/4*0!*b#%)#("%

-(+!$&#&!%&4%QR!%:=KFI>DIF:[=d=OD8P=BD=C7F>:g=>:B=BD=C7F>:=HDA<F7=HD=8>=97AY8A<7=HD=

$h0(/#"%'4$)#&4$#"%QR!%"!%/#$#/0!$(X#)%/4)4%)4&4"%&!%"R+]!0(V#234T%mR!%!""!"%)4&4"%&!%

"R+]!0(V#234%&!-()(0!)5%&!%#*0!)345%4%#-/#*/!%&!%"R#"%'4$)#"% 4"".V!("%*34%"(l*('(/#%QR!%4%

OD8P=AN7=BDY:=9:K:L%&!%"!%'4$)#$5%0#) 4R/4%QR!%"!]#%/4) -!0#)!*0!%'4$)#&4T%U!-4%/4*0$h$(45%

7=OD8P=@=97>KD;IH7=:=BD=C7F>:F=B7?=>7;HDB=E8D=YG=C7F:>=97AB<F8JH7B=D=E8D=DB<34%)#("%4R%

>DA7B=D>=7KDF:MN7[=d8g=K7HDFJ:>7B=HILDFg=7=OD8P=@=97>KD;IH7=:=BD=C7F>:F=HDA<F7=HD=KFG<I9:B=

QR!%!"034%$!-#0(V#)!*0!%!"0#+!-!/(&#"T%U4$)5%"!%!""#%'4$)#234%&!%"(%%'!(0#%!)%&!"4+!&(c*/(#%

:7B=KFIA9JKI7B=KD;7B=E8:IB=7=OD8P=BD=C7F>:g=DA<N7=:=ZIF<8HD="!$h%#% $h0(/#% !-#%QR#-%4%"R]!(04%"!%

'4$)#% !-4%BD8=HDB:BB8YDI<:>DA<7[=nI<7=HD=78<F7=>7H7g=7=OD8P=E8D=:BBI>=KF79DHD=#$$("/#"!%#%

&!'4$)#$"!%!*QR#*04%"R]!(045% #""#*&4%#%4/R #$%#QR!-#% 4"(234%4*04-4l(/#)!*0!%(*"!lR$#%

QR!%/4-4/#%#%QR!"034%&!%R)%)4&4%4$(l(*h$(4i%QR!)%"!$h%R)%"R]!(04%#QR(5%!%4%QR!%"!%QR#-('(/#$h%

&!%V(&#o%p("%R)%)4)!*04%&!%&!-(+!$#234%0(/#%QR!%!,(l!%#%$R 0R$#%&!%*4""4"%bh+(04"%&!%

]R-l#)!*045%!)%'#V4$%&!%R)#% $h0(/#%)#("%#$$("/#&#5%QR!%'#2#%#%#$0!% $!V#-!/!$%"4+$!%#%/4#234T%%

%�����

Page 21: O Que é a Crítica - Um Ensaio Sobre a Virtude de Foucault

������������������ ������ �� ������ ������������������������� �����������

� ! "#$%&'()*&*+&,-".!&%'(/)�

01234256789:;:<6=>6?@ABCA<DB6@<ECEFEGH6DI;6J:FE9CKL>6MNOPQQQQQQRPSTUVWVRPXYZZY[\]Z__ZOP

XMPabZZcPdefgRP

hijklhMhcPmnoYRPpTUqUrstuvwxTWuvyz{v|qx}UyOPlPm_]~nP��P_\P��]N~Y_��NZP��P�b�_�[YoP\�bnRP

j��YPM�b�]OP��o]���YP�N��bZ�_nPabZZcPdef�cP��RPd�d�RP

����l��cPX�[\oRP��tv�UVqxT�vx�v�t�sy�Uq�cP��o]�P�NRPj��YPM�b�]OP�YN~��Pk�]ZcP

de�fRP

QQQQQQ>6?7896JA��9FC6DI;6�:�9<L>6�I�613� ¡¢J56k]�b_P�RPYN~P�lhMj�£cPaY]oP¤~Z¥RP

¦U§�t�vxs§ys�qOPhn�N~Pm_b][_]bYo�Z�PYN~Pkb� N]_�[ZRP�\�[Y©�OP�N��bZ�_nP��P�\�[Y©�P

abZZcPdefªcP��RPª«f�ªªfRP

QQQQQQRP��tv|Vtvx�vS�tyVsTt¬v\Pk�Z_�bnP��Pm­]Yo�_ncP��o]�P_®�RPj��YPM�b�]OPaYN_\�NP

abZZcPdefRP

QQQQQQ>6?=8DC6EG6@<ECE°A9±L6�I�6²� �Mj³i�cPmno�bPYN~Pk��k�� kcP��ZYP¤~Z¥RP��tv

Sx�UqU§Vvx�v�Tsq�RPj��YPM�b�]OPm���_­_¤¥cPdee�RPbYNZ[b�_�P��bPX�N��]Pi�bncPb��ZY~�P��bP

m]µYNNP¶o�b�cPtqvy�RcP_bY~]µ�~�P�YbYP�P�N©o·ZP��bP�nZYPk�[\b�_\RPP

£M��MlXmcP�Yn��N~RPt�¹xT{VRPj®Pº�b»OP�­��b~P�N��bZ�_nPabZZcPde��RP

����

�����������