3$x)83sreo&)aia3, 3*^crsr'63^3&) ^o5)o^od^&- · ag*aa a^g^r^-* j^ -^ :5o5^ejj - 7...
TRANSCRIPT
)0- 2 IX 7 R^aOaR), !995,
4Td3 - !6)-
^S- !&0-
\3$x)83sreo&)aia3, 3*^crsr'63^3&) ^o5)o^od^&-!995-
^) 0)0- credbg
o35- ^c*gfyc&)§
3 o ^ ^ &.
X).
h
^!T^J
e$s*6 3353
fbdbcTd&O, 7 *SiLg,oad), !995-
(K)$ &)yg^o !2-oo ?So&) &) &&r3g3j<j68)
"€^ J§- ^o^^grgDKrd&o^brrS sr3bgso5*3 &)o§)&)o^8^^
^ 3 *$Xio )3Soi!b&) fb3o8
(yo?^^ ^ 6 ^ &)6c&o 3€o?bS$o s^oOgj 3o&^ o^^boS
Sri P. Janardhan Reddy (Khairtabad):- Sir, a point of order.
Sri Gade Venkata Redd%:- Sir, I am also on a point of order.
(Interruptions from Congress-1 benches?
Sri P. Janardhan Reddy:- Sir, I am on a point of order or a point of clarification.
\ ^ Mr* Speaker:- No point of order please. I have to take up firspt the Vote of Confidence. So, please take your seats.
\ ' (Interruptions) \ I am not allowing anything. First, let the Motion be
moved by the Chief Minister.
*Ex^ asterisk before the name indicates confirmation by the Member.
E3]
J. 184-t
?y(3SD&r7S nr(&)^o^S &>o§)
&)0^§^ X)$ &^X)0 R%^0&;&) ?b6o3
fri P. Janardhan Reddy:- Sir, please allow me. I am on a point of order.
Mr. Speaker:- Please guote the Rule. I request all the other Members to take their respective seats. I am allowing Sri P. Janardhan Reddy.
§3 5- aa*03&5&,;:-- 9%gS*<n, 3?& 302 §30& 3&) 'aS*0J)0g; 8^
e6<.§* Boa)§ 3 X b ^ ^ - <A5-S' cr&rcr^rrdo ^3 ^ o ^ ^ o ^rS^ o))S
3 o ^ ^ B^§^5Ro e^)h:^o5' o6)gFa3nrdiD&)rpgo grty ^ 3€b^3$o
^g."H&&o^ e^ a2as§*a%o e(b^^o5- €r?S g a^5-&- g%5&) eS
tr&r(r^rr& eo&s:^(b- ^o53^^:?y(RD&3rr&3 &TG* ^ 3 3-3-o)§ &*
63633 eo&o^<b- ^^3r 'S&'^ s^gS^o 8 bod) S&eS* J^do g g
f3e)R3S%o 6 ^ go^ocS § ^ eo^d^oo)
Mr. Speaker:- I request all Members to take their respective seats. First, let the Motion be moved. I will allow discussion later.
(9o3krd3ao)
%3 5- aKrdo53&s:- S)<&x) eaRcroS^ g^RMoB? <JR6 35&) &{b
* a ^ 8 ^ * g X b ^ ^ , o)35 '3 ^ ' ^ & & h38^Xo^^ §5(3S3gd^§-
Mr. Speaker:- First, let the Chief Minister move^the Notion* I request all Members to keep silence. ^
Sri Gade Venkata Reddy (Parchur):- Sir, I want po give you some more information on the same point* My request is, you have to hear it before the ruling is given. I will abide by the Chairs' decision. But please hear me before you give your ruling.
Mr. Speaker:- I had already given an opportunity to your leader Sri P. Janardhan Reddy. He said something. I will answer it first. So, I request you to please take your seat.
Sri "Gade Venkata Reddy: - Sir, I want to speak on the same point. First, you have to give a ruling on this. What I mean
ag*aa a^g^R^-* J ^ - ^ :5o5^ejj - 7 ^osa&y.^ass-
&)oR§^ Jj$ S^^o ^^g^o^b^ R38oa-
to say is, ^OJ^O 3*<63 X)$3§oS '<&P0^ &^;^ ^' 3*<38§ XS5_.^oa,
Mr. Speaker:- I request all Members to Keep silence. I am appealing to the House. I request all Members *uo maintain silence.
Sri Gade Venkata Reddy:- Sir, are you going to clarify .n point? I want to read some portion of this Rule.
Mr. Speaker:- Your leader hal already raised one point here. I will answer chat first. So,, i request you to pleas? take your seat.
#) n*3 3oga3&<-:- e$gs*.i, 63ba> Rrg3 &gi3*3 ^^y^o ^sr^3-
I want to give you some more information on the same point.
Let me read some portion from....
Mr. Speaker:- That is not necessary here. Let me answer
your leader first. The Leader of the Congress-1 Legislature
Party raised a question asking as to which whip is valid.
That is not the question here. Here the question is Vote of
Confidence. That may be takenup first. ^ ^ 5 <2Sd3 &3\,&3 6935
5$5o^ <§o - I am not concerned with those matters at this
^resent juncture. pre:
(&o&o*d3oo)
&6) g 5*^5*5- §^6rr R^osr&M c y ^ &Cb drgo^ 5t^o5-
Mr. Speaker:- I am very categorically saying that here it is not a question of whip. As to which whip will be taken into consideration will be decided after the voting. This is my ruling. Now, please take your seats.
#3 §- eMRAdbgyae (u*a&)oa3):- <9$ss*„, &oj)o45 s^ 36,36 *
Mr. Speaker:- I had already given my ruling. So, I request you to take your seats.
Mr* Speaker:- You go through the Rule. It says that after Vote of Confidence, the complaints have to be given by the respective Members to the Speaker. The Speaker then get it examined after giving proper notice to the Members. That is the rule position. So, please take your seat.
Sri N.T. Rama Rao (Hindupur):- Sir, I have been thrown out of office. I should explain to the people, through this Assembly the reasons for that. Please give me a chance. That is my privilege.
Mr. Speaker:- After the Motion is moved, you will be given a chance.
(Interruptions from some Telugu Desam Party Members)
I am putting one straight question to you. How cjan I allow a Member to speak before the Motion is moved? You please show me a Rule with regard to that. I will allow everybody to speak after the Motion is moved by the Chief Minister. Till that time I cannot allow. Please resume your seats.
(eo$So*33oo)
t2*:oj €3 &- aoiS^ahgarRS:- &r& 302 SS^Ro shapo^ e^ e6<-5 oooo§
(93aa*<33oo)
(39ogu*<33ao)
jrd&D&rre nrd3og$so5^S &)o§)
& ) 0 ^ ^ X)$ 33*5X0 oi^3o&)&) h:8o&-
Mr. Speaker:- Here Rule-302 is not pertinent. There is no
such deviation from the Rules. You please take your seat.
Sri G. Butchaiah Chowdary:- Sir, we want to raise a point
of order.
(eoskrdbo)
g&)&) hg sr8o 5 sj€orr e^XBoSX &p*;3*o&) Aoao^oS
Mr. Speaker:- You have to quote'the Rule first. Under
what rule are you going to raise it? Please tell me.
(Interruptions from some Telugu Desam Party Members)
Without moving a Motion how can I allow any Member tc
speak on the subject? Please let me know that. So, let the
Chief Minister move the Motion first. Then I will allow every
body to speak on that.
(fT63 g^R&gbgac €3 S* RxtR^g^o^^c&D^' ^3 < o- R6,30oh)aa,
(Interruptions)
ri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- Sir, they are casting as-
pertions on the Chair
Mr. Speaker:- Any aspertions against the Chair will not
90 on 'record.
(eo&u*(3bo)
First, let the Motion be moved by the Chief Minister. After that I will definitely allow Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak. But without a Motion being moved, how can I allow a Member to
\
8 - 7^^0QOJ^ !995- ' 33T3R ^)§^5^S : '^ )&- goS^ana)
&^o<g§^ Xt% 3^sXo 3)g3o&)&) ?^8o&- .
speaK on that? Please understand this point and co-operate
with the Chair. Now, I would request the Chief Minister to
move the Motion.
(At this stage Sri T.S.L. Naicker, Sri K. Appala Naidu, Sri D. Veerabhadra Rao, Sri G. Yerrunaidu, Sri G. Butchaiah Chowdary, Sri A. Brahmanaiah, Sri D. Rajasekhar, Sri M. Sesha-giri Rao, Sri G. Muddukrishnama Naidu, Sri N. Prasanna Kumar Reddy, Sri P. Brahmaiah, Sri B. Rajasekhar Reddy, Sri B.V. Mohan Reddy, Sri M. Narasimhulu, Sri, M. Damodar Reddy, Sri D. Ramesh Babu, Sri D. Pranay Bhaskar, Sri M. Pedda Rathaiah, Sri P. Mahender Reddy, Sri P. Indra Reddy, SriCh. Ramachandra Rao, Sri P. Chandrasekhar, Sri Ch. Venkata Krishna ^Reddy, Sri G. Lingappa, Sri Ch. Appaiahdora, Sri G. Ramamohan Rao, Sri Y. Kista Reddy, Sri N. Moola Reddy and Sri G. Babu Rao, approached the Speaker's Podium demanding permission to Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak first).
Mr* Speaker:- You have to understand me. Without moving a motion, how can I allow any Member to speak on that? Let the Chief Minister first move the Motion. After that I will definitely allow Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak on that. Please take your seats.
Hon'ble Chief Minister (Sri N. Chandrababu Naidu):-
(Amidst interruptions)
Sir, with your permission, I beg to move:
"That this House expresses its confidence in the Council of Ministers headed by Sri N. Chandrababu Naidu".
Mr* Speaker:- Motion moved.
The Chief Minister has already moved the Motion. Np%7, I am permitting Mr. N.T. Rama Rao to speak. I, therefore, request you all to take your respective seats. /
(Interruptions) * S
I had already told you that the Motion has been movetp. by the Chief Minister. Now, I will allow everybody to spealq on the Motion. You are all intellectual people. You please\try to understand me. I request you all to take your respective seats.
(At this stage, some Members who were at* the Speaker's Podium started shouting slogans "N.T. Rama Rao - Zindabad")
Please hear me. This is Vote of Confidence. The Chief Minister wants to take Vote of Confidence and he moved the Motion. If anybody wants to speak on the Motion, they can speak
^bod§^ 3$ 33*a;3o j)g^o^&) ?^8o3-
Sri G. Butchaiah Chowdary:- Sir, the Rule says....
Mr. Speaker:- I know the rules. I do not understand how can you ask me like this? Without moving a motion how can a Member speak on that. I had already taken a decision. You all please take your seats. I am not allowing anybody except Sri N.T. Rama Rao.
(Interruptions)
The Motion has already been moved without moving a Motion how can you speak on the subject? Please quote me a Rule which is in support of it.
Sri G. Butchaiah Chowdary:- Sir. you please 3,llow Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak on this subject.
Mr. Speaker:- I had already given him the permission. I had already told the Members that the Motion has been moved. If anybody wants to speak they can also speak.
(Interruptions)
You are not allowing Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak. I know the rules and I had already taken a decision. I am requesting the Members to allow Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak first. But he has to confine himself to the subject only. I am allowing him to speak within the purview of Parliamentary Practices.
(Interruptions)
Now, Motion has been moved and it is before the House. I ve to go according to the procedure* Now, I am requesting
B . N.T. Rama Rao to speak.
(Interruptions)
The Motion is before the House.
(The Hon'ble Members standing'at the podium shouted "No, No")
Sri Rama Rao Garu can speak on the Motion.
(Interruptions)
The Motion is before the House. I am going according to the procedure. Please go to your seats and argue but not from here. You cannot dictate me, you cannot say "you must allow".
(Interruptions)
to *7*Rt,sOa3j, *995- ^ 3^s^=^§^6^.^"^J^- Ro&)grsD.-
5bod§3j X% g^s^o j)g o&)&) h:6o3.
I am appealing to each and every Member to go to their seats and speak, if anything is there. The Motion has been moved and it is before the House. I am requesting Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak on the Motion.
(Interruptions)
If you want to speak anything I will not obstruct. I have already requested Sri Rama Rao to speak on the Motion.
(Interruptions)
The Motion has been moved by the Hon'ble Chief Minister. I am not only calling but requesting him to speak on the Motion.
Sri K. Vidyadhara Rao:- It is against the priciples of democracy. If they are interested in the discussion, they can participate and discuss on the Motion of Confidence. If they have respect in Parliamentary Democracy they must participate in the Motion of Confidendce.
Mr. Speaker:- Already the Motion has been moved by the Chief Minister and it is placed before the House. After moving it....
(Interruptions)
I am permitting him to speak. Without the subject how can I permit him to speak? Please hear me. I know the rules. I am permitting him to speak on the Motion.
(Interruptions)
Yes, that is why we are respecting him. We have allotted him a seat in the fr6nt row since he is the former Chief Minister. I am requesting him to speak on the subject. What more you want?
(Interruptions)
I said that the Motion has already been moved. If you want to prevent the proceedings of the House, I have nothing to say I am requesting the former Chief Minister, Sri Rama Rao Garu to speak on the Motion. Whatever he wants to speak, he can speak.
(Interruptions)
The Motion is before the House. If anybody wants to speak on the Motion let him speak. I have no objection.
(Interruptions)
^ o d § ^ ^ S^r^ao 3)g<goi5oa hoSoS-
Now, that is nob the subject. I cannot help. I am requesting you all to take your seats. I am very clear. I cannot allow anything except the discussion on the Motion. It is my decision. I have taken up the business as per the agenda. Please take your seats. I am doing justice. I am allowing Sri N.T. Rama Rao and other Hon'ble Members to speak on the Floor of the House. I am going according to rules and procedures. The Motion is before the House. If anybody wants *co speak on the Motion, I will allow him but don't prevent the proceedings of the House.
(Interruptions)
Why you are so adament? (Addressing the Members standing at the podium)* Once again I am repeating that I will take up the Motion of Confidence first. If anybody wants to speak let him speak on the Motion.
(At this juncture the Hon'ble Members standing at the podium shouted "No, No")
Let me hear first.
€3 &3*5. <5s*g;3*?13u*5) (3345a3„):- e$&s*<n, 33^53 srg* &&Kj$ao
9co3§o8* & & 3r%5 axr5 ccoa^rr 3s^&*
€3 J5-^- trarcra):- e>os$&) &)ooS 3a? 33?$oo&n^^-
** €3 &3*5- 3cra;3*;l3c* - a^ag^orr, a^ya a^ag^on* - 5o<Sr
3gcybS3o& R35J6, 33&r-ao' R5* R d ^ o ^ S ^ R 3o&3 Rgr s*6gg)Rr
^ 3- 3o3gg36o*3> (5^$6):- o$g^, a^ s^g^areS* 3 r ^
a^y5 e&oa^? Scr? 33*35 garS s^sr^o^ a$i a^^o^aoorr &oc*8 gcr:
6c&)3S) M5^ Roea^ 5T&3 gy^o&- ar^dc^a§ ^as^^o ^ ^ 6 ^ <s;&
§"o^<y^&)- &aj. 3^a^ S3g) &3oe* g§^ 2o§A &aj. 5r&^, a33bg-s3<3.
R6g$*o3a sr&)* e ao: %u"^ao axr5 3^u^? Sty? aroSad^aa^c^SS^ay^o
^asoa- 'aoR8A ar^^^3§ ^a^^o a^o&-
J. 184-2
^diDdbrrS arcR3ggso5*3 ^o§),
&)od^ <(i S^s^o gSo&a o6o3 *
.<2-3o: Mr. Speakei:- Piea&e hear me firsr. If you want to give ^j. ) suggestions ou can give. There is no binding on you. I am
very cle^r, I am not pushing any weight on you. You are at
liberty to give suggestions.
33 3 aaa^sx ^cr§- 3^-0^33^ sr^^dsao^ ^ 6 5 ^ 3 ^ 0 : <§3a&'osr'§*
cr*a§ gr$s^^o5rS- ^dosr^ r eg^cRreo 3^cr^§ ecSy^o &o^ooS-
€^ S* e?yd^55^:- e$g^, (^y&)^5?r i^r^ 90s* &)^5 y3d:-
^$^<3&r€c 3Sb S 3trS§ oy8§ 93Ss*$o 5r^6-
srdo a3§33.toS* y&^^^do g oatb &)o&))e: o^gy&r ^ ^ 8 ^ o & ^ ^ ^
osr?S 3Sr6To^^' S srB - ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ? u*Srtr^rr&) <Mg,§ ^^S§
xro^SS^o S5S*^KrjS^, 35^ &3o §6c3i)§d5y&' sr-do 9o^&)^boo&: & ^ ^
&)0§)n* &sr^&) yt&So 5 6§ e^y^o 3&30&* §Sd35r o r ^ r§ 3d5jo f.
Mr. Speaker:- You need not quote me rules.
Sri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- Speaker Sir^ the/Hon'ble Chief Minister has moved the Motion of Confidence. Sri N*T. Rama Rao Garu can always speak on the Motion. There is no problem. If he wants to speak as a resigned Chief Minister, he can give a separate notice to us. There are no two things about it. There is no question of denying opportunity to speak. You are kind enough in allowing Sri Rama Rao Garu to speak first on the Motion. This is my humble submission to the Chair*
Sri N.T. Rama Rao.- It is my prerogative. I must get an opportunity.
(Interruptions)
- c&o&)rr8 <3*cR)ga5o^*3 &)o^^ " -' * - " -
&*o<2§^ nj$ 3^rs^o ^So&)&) 8o3*
Mr. Speaker:- Mike is there. I request you (addressing the Hon'ble Members standing at the podj.u*n) to take your seats. I have asked the Chief Minister to mcs/e t o Motion smd he has moved it. The Motion is oefore the Hcue If you wanL to speak on the Motion, you can speak.
(Interruptions)
I cannot give. I am very clear about the rules*, I have got ample powers. Mr. Chandrasekhar you are a Lawyer* Without taking up the Motion and without any subject, how canaMe^b^r speak? I will permit him. I am requesting ana to speak.,..
(Interruptions)
I know it. This is the Motion ofCcrfidence. Mte^ taking up the Motion of Confidence, I will permit him. I h&ve nc objection at all. He can speak as much time as he wants. I am very clear about the rules, procedures and traditions. The Motion has been moved by the Chief Minister and it i* before the House. If Sri N.T. Rama Rao wants to speak on tne Motion he can speak otherwise he can speak after the Motion is completed. I am requesting you all to take your seats. Let the Motion be taken up first.
(Interruptions)
Yes, I am cooperating with him. I am' allowing him to speak. Hear me first. As per the procedure, I have to start from this side but still I am preferring Sri N.T. Rama Rao to speak first on the Motion.
(Interruptions)
I will go according to the rules. I am appealing to you all 'xxx go to your seats, xxx will not go to the records. Sorry\ by mistake it was uttered. I am allowing Sri N.T. Rama
on the issue or he can speak whatever he* wants, s been moved. I am giving mike to Sri N.T. Rama m allowing him to speak on the Motion.
5 stage the Hon'ble Members standing at the podium shouted "No, No")
^33*5- Scrg^^6^r^:-a$g^, ^rg&)j^^o§)^-g-o-3ru-^n-6^ ara^s-oR gxb^r^b* a*&) a ^ 5 3nre3 a & u <Ao§* dtr^og* as-ARx)-s°,§ ar*Rgjeoaar go* enS3sgfi<9(3o sr?bog%53*
Rao to-tspeak But, Motion h Rao Garii* I
(e>o&U"c&)0)
?yc&o&)rr6 srcR)g$so5*3 &>o§)
gbo^§^ X)$ S^^Go 33g($o&Kb ?b6oR
3^^&)oo^6? 2, 3 a*&)f, &)o^)cSdo6^rr c5)Kr y * eo55§ ^3^ 33<R3*<ar
€oJ(o- crcrA 40 ^3uo^€orr ccoer ^o^u^c&)o ^Si^^^A^ 3^di)o oj&
gogo g & ^ S ^ O §o ?5o ^xr5 ScSodo, c r ^ s g ^(3&)^&)rr sydo
a&^g*g%o 3db^&)^* g^o^ J^-g-^6* n-8S 3a,ao3 gSnO^soocr sr63
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- My friends, I am still the Leader of T.D.L.P. So this resolution I must say is not accepted by our party. So I must be given an opportunity to explain about what are the things that are resulting out of this. Then I will tell....
(Interruptions)
Mr. Speaker.- The Motion is before the House. If you want to speak on the Motion you can speak, otherwise, I will follow rhe next procedure.
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- 1 am telling proudly....
Sri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- Speaker Sir, he is trying to threaten the Members.
Mr. Speaker:- That is not the point here. ^
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- As a Party President, I am telliny^l..
Mr. Speaker:- That is* not the point here. The MotAon is before the House, you can speak on the Motion. t
Sri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- Speaker Sir, you 'are kind enough to put the Motion before the House which was, moved by the Hon'ble Chief Minister. You are also kind enough to provide an opportunity to Sri N.T. Rama Rao. ^
3 5b- j SoS eo3o 335*aa &r&;6o R)3c5*a;i- ^aocs-S* &^&DSSoS <soig*3§
gajLorr a*6*g u-3&*§ 3*Sar3§ gai^ic- s*3 g&&> gy^oR s^R ggoa-g
Sri Ch. Appayya Dora (Tekkali):- No, No. That is not correct....
* ' - ^ < _ " .--. tlnterruptins)
&5"a&3j)§3*R;6 : " ^ <^^' tSo5)grgD 7*&6Jg,oado, !995- !5
KTd<03&Drr6 rrdi)^5o5^3 &)o§) &)odS^^^$ S^^o ^3^3o&)^)h:8oS-
Mr. Speaker:- I am requesting all the Members to take rheir seats. I am to once again announce to the House that the Motion has already been moved by the Chief Minister and it is before the House. If anybody wants to speak on the Motion, he can speak, otherwise, I will proceed as per the procedure and the rules. If anyone wants to speak on an issue other than the Motion, he could speak afterwards.
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- I object it. As President of the T.D.P. I would not allow this to go on.
Mr. Speaker:- Here, it is a Vote of Confidence Motion moved by the Chief Minister. How can the issue of the President of the Party be decided on the Floor of the House?
(Interruptions)
This is the Legislature. I cannot allow any other subject other than the Motion. I am requesting all of you to take your seats. I have got every right to use my discretion. You can't question me.
(Interruptions)
I don't permit anyone to speak except on the Motion. I am very clear on that. If you want to stall the House, it is not good. I am requesting you once again to resume your seats.
(Interruptions)
After voting on Confidence Motion, I will permit discus-gs on on the resignation of the former Chief Minister.
\ (Interruptions)
i am well within my powers. I am going according to the rules \and procedure.
Sr3, N.T. Rama Rao:- I am still the President of the T.D.P. Nobody has the right to put the resolution. You can also not participate in the voting.
Mr. Speaker:- Casting of my vote will arise only in case of tie. I request*-a31 of you to co-operate with the Chair.
(Interruptions)
I am going acordin^ to the rules. Here, the Motion is already moved on which you have to vote. I request you to leave the Podium and resume seats.
(Interruptions)
-16 7 o a R ) , t-995 " ^ a R ^]§5^^ : "#3 <5 ' go jSTSR
Hr(&o&3rr8 u r d i o ^ o ^ cbo§3 & o d § ^ &3S S^s^o )ggo&)&) rb3o3 -
Please leave the Podium. I will take opinion of all the Members about vote of Confidence Motion.
(Interruptions)
I don*t permit anyone to discuss any other thing except on Motion. I am categorically saying that the Motion is before the House. I request Sri Janardhan Reddy to speak on the Motion.
#3 S- sKrap^aag:- e^gs*^, 3r^5 305* abJ*a) s*3$&' 3exR3(Sgo
;3*gt,S* gRad) g-e-J5'S- g%&^ &a*A3b- °)g&) e ^ X S-3^§*5- &i&)?
(At this juncture, the Hon'ble Members standing near the Podium raised slogans 'T.D.L.P. Leader - N.T.R.)
(3oa3XS<n5,3)
i2*5o!
^ ^ &)^6 g<aS6:- &o*s^h6cr^n*6y, &db 3Sr^do5-
§) aig"5- 3u*s^Mc*g):- ^6§5*^, &r€o ?6 6 S o r r goo§3n*^,
&o^§^o§)rrg o*^3*&r 3&A^o^g 6rdo & r ^ 3 €HS5*^3boo8- &&>&)
&r&r^ enSy^&)^^3 e ^ & - &r$D 335*60 33*35 2ay55i*g&Roa)'
&r^c*8- cUSdo &RO&; o^^cyo^S S^gdon*6 65^3^ & e y 3 3 a M -
3og^o5 ^gd^oug J ^ &5
%) 5- 300*306,, (333<,):- .^cdj 5ybo^ ^yrt, <3a<b ^ ^ Ssr^g....
(^os)6^§^)
S^RXj^&sHaa. "^) J^ iio gra: 7*^^os3tb, (995- !7
&o<3Sa,. i:^X)o sj;gtSogo&) 6 oS-
3r^§ &y5 3^3 Ro5)grs):^ddD^ 3cr ^g6r?do 5c&r§-
(goaRXj^)
o)^*g'e5- Xjy rdi)&)&) s*&) y^, 6^ o$g^^o sr3^3 e^db-
-g& SS3^do.^g--
\
(906)33.1^)
urdiD&yrrS ;rcaog§$,so&*<3 ^Jo§?
&;oR§^ m$ S^s^o ggo&nb 8o3-
sa^) $bg^o68A s°6 or3 ^ ^ ^ ^ &r6^^3^^^&o8rro)^ &- car
cr r7'8§ Sa-yS 3 ^ ^ ^ -
(goagX.,^)
(3 5(3 0 ah^6 & ^ ^goo 'Rrgi dr^ 3^§^
e37S 3-&^ 3)053' Sj^Sj^r^)
€^ g- 8D (R)g y%8:- (§^0$&)08 ^€0rb3$O ^$3§o3^ & y ^ )
(Qoaga^)
Mr. Speaker:- Already motion has been moved. I am request
ing all of you to take your seats. a gs39*oprT'33', 3r&To%0&-
€) aa-5- 0^g^6(Tol):- ^ $ § ^ , ge X0§n3a ^8^&)€)S^, ^S^g
^ ^ M ^ , SbXig §"o^d&) 8^6^00 8*&)g3&)oaaiSa3 e § X b ^ ^
(^o^6Sj^)
&db3 i ooa& gy^oS-
(^o&)6R^)
Rdioga &r^o3, 3*gosorr 6db35 3 ^ 8 3^o5-
(goaga^)
(Slogans from Hon'ble Members standing at podium. We want - justice. We want - justice.)
Mr. Speaker:-* I am requesting you to keep silence. I hear every-one of you. ^
nrr&Dgbrr8 ?a*3i)ggaoa*3 &)o§?
Mr. Speaker:- Please cake your seats.
(Interruptions)
Whatever they speak will not go on record. I have permitted Sri Rajeswara Rao no speak. Sri Rajeswara Rac may speak.
% 55*5* crggsoo^:- 3^3j 3?a J3osrS* ^ ^ y 6 ^ ^ o g H - ^ -
e3r^^j Sj)^6o do*yoaoaa,aaaoao4SS- ^ o ^ R ^ c ec?^^ ^^^orr
Sagr^* eocog ^g^d ^3^o^^! ^03)&Xoo§) #) ^^-g- !r Srcr$)rrdo
(3-3-o)§.&. ^r<±o^€o, o&33>& ooo^^ ^3^d)&)^ ^^^^ 6(r ^ jL qr3o§
3^FT^d3- srg d-3-^§-&- e)$s^&^ gyoaaar dj- ^rdj 5^^j p^^o^
rcjoo&r egadorr ggo& h38^o3 ao^g5^^, &oo&^ JS-g- cr&>^^fr6
^ojDO&r^ ^6^&3^ 3^3^§ S<R)0(3- ^ ^3^Er$, ^g^gcr^^3jL M j ^ ^
Mr. Speaker:- My stand is very clear. I will take up Motion first. Then only I will allow others to speak.
%3 <s6' crara3o<3,. (&o?t&:5.,):- 3* 3$ a)^ocr^3 a&o;ib g b
^oo] ^ A ^ M 3&)ocr3 aaHoRM ^-g-^5 S ^ ^ & 5 ?i33^ &5* sr y
J. 184-3
Mr. Speaker:- I will takeup the agenda. I am proceeding
as per the agenda.
y^Sr S^X3 ^sc&), ^ ^ & ^ 3 ^gbgc&) §c&) d5oG*3§ srcb ^ ^ o ^
53,S6o rj^jg^o- s*6§ e5Ss- o s}sr e3 33^ & tr cr ^dj&xr^- o°3
Mr. Speaker:- I will permit him after the Motion is over.
A$3g€0 '&&) sro^ s5^' '3&AS*aon-&)<!D ^os*§' eSet&tXty^&ry^do)
Mr. Speaker:- I request the Hon'ble Members at the
^ podium to sit in their chairs.
€3 <35a- S*aog3&s (&!J§crsr§):- ^5 °6 - sjocy^&.^&), y ^
&r 99^)c&!"go g3°s* 3^3Sgo&- &S Si%§g Sj6^§€^ & 3*aa;3%&) ^&r3^
^ a ^ ^ & < 333 &oo&: gxb§^s*8, 333 ^doy^ ^§^B°6 e3 o-3§ e3^
o-s§c&) g.o s-ASap- SJ^fT-c&)&)o&)ao53&o3^$5'6gg^3jLdy^ro5o3
X^g5n°do eBoty &r* &JoRa A)&r.,d)- cr33 BG-g^rr 3^3 Sjo&osrdo- n*3
^^s*don* y^Xi$ s6rr§- &r e)^3d5y-4K, r- s°o?)% ^*g^ Rs*.)& ^ .
n-c&!&)d3 &5?%,6 ^r3$o a 6 ^ ^ ^ ^ H5 &;jo5r. e^ o-3§ <3*S. e)$^)6^o
B^Ro s5^So3- eoDsr &rc &db 3^c&)0 33 &$ s*d§g)&)o 33*&/ & & o
n*3§ oi3Ce,€)3o &otr§- y&A SJ%gM ^060*^0^ ?*3jL $S 3x)0&g3 ^^ojo-
eS 3$3con- &r^ &R9g&)0§3 rTdS3(&oeD ^^-^5- c*&r(r )rT-&) 8.g &)Ag?&3
3agg-& 3Xc 3r&r-o s* S- H6 ^ o & R8 3Xcg s^cy3§^)so^) oao§o3
e gsSXJd 33<j&rso A^^j^b Sj^^^ceo srococy 3& 3d&)go, e!SSs* o S3
X ^ & 3HSM arc S* !b Qg^ ^djs°6 & R ^ g gXb&^srd^j- ecm^
&cb o*3 <3*3p*;$ga;& og. S^3-&)- e o & ) ^ &)&) 33.<3bo g^o^srS- ^
3Sjc&)0 &r-&-^^^^*^ sr6 e&5*3(j&)o B^RoiSr^og §^&)OG° 3^5-
RSjy X)$* s*dg^)&o X)^)^on* s3rr§, s°6 s$ * c&r-cD 3< ^ cr3§ e^y^o
<!son-8- &&) 3 ^ ^ ^ s*6s )&)0 ^s-6o S eaj s}g 5§ 5S3^X)^&) 3
&J0&) 3 3&;g e^g & & 3^cXbc g&)§^So^o6fr gb&nT^-
^ ^ ^ 3<<y^ &3*A&>)
€^ 3o^^^^^^-- ^$g^ - -
(30^3^5,3)
Mr. Speaker:- I am allowing Sri B. Venka<.eswara Rao to
speak.
(Interruptions)
After hearing I will say something. But, *iot Know...^
ft)saorT 6y3^o3ot5o§^^ 6y5^ ^ r ccj Xir ^o^)jrc&ro^ &oao$o8
3*H X)-^ 3d^ocoo3^&u^o^ c r 3 § ^ ^ ^ oS ^8n^ 136 ^o^o^ e^
^6^6 3^$^sb^- s R^orr fT6o5 §bgeD J ^ 3 ^ 333§^ cr^S 3!)&)
3 ^ ^ ^ # b§ 3 dy§o^) 3 ^ 3*33 rrgSoaaoSR gr^g^ ^$bg€)o63^^
&^5^^ * *
Mr. S&eaker:- I request the Hon'ble Members at the podium
to keep silence.
(Interruptions)
I will give you. Let him finish.
^ iS- 3og^^6^^):- 353 3&o 3^5^^^og fT6^ goo&db grey
^g ^ SS ^ o^ ^&)^o S*;3o &D a?&5r5 5r(b Q^&<D a^S S^crM
€^ J5 t§ CP^cr^:- e$§y^- *- I am still the Telugu Desam
legisla-ELJte Party Leader. I am having that mandate. You have
not ca'3ed *?e. Why have you avoided me?
^ 3- aog3g&6c*a:- &&) ^ ^ ^ ^ o ^ 5-d&g555ro ^S^6o, &(&)&
^ao$^ 2j ydo J ocr yd^^i^ro) 3 ^ ^ ^ ^ ^&) H^nr e^go^do &o§ 33* 3 g ^ &&) Sd^^o #Xc&)ty^ 5T&3 J^^S R^dir^^ ^ ^
^) o3<§- - cr&ro^^:- 29^ 3R ^ J ^ § ;6&3 o)o&)&) 5o5S &)?
I am still the Telugu Oesam Legislature Party Leader. You have
not called me on 29th.
(Interruptionos)
Mr. Speaker:- I will" tel3 your. I will let you know.
§3 ^5-3- o-aru*;&:- iS-J a- &Sorr§ SoSSS r ^ ^ aea3&< &)d) &S3 oS eiy& 35^ &o3sr&3 IS^ o&)gj 5§^^ S rxb oS-
o #) §- gog cxb 3**&6.- g-o) A A^SrS^^g cr&rcr^rrS^ <Jo&g3
€3 &- Kr7%33trg) (sp^o).- e$g^, sSr o srgsg^eo &&)& S*sr5- &RO& & ^o^3rSabo;&o& adba&3 3^ ye^g^&^R AdbSh^sreo^ & & 3^&^ SA5 H&3^o^ 5^5^ ^5 SSo^ro^^ ^^6^. 3<ja)o&
--3-J-&-S <^o&)^ 5o$^6^- 59 00 & g)&)3 &)3?
&g*RX)X))§3*a;6 : "€) o - ^05)6T2D 7*Rae,oa&), !995- 23
S b o ^ ^ Xj$ S^s^o ^^^o&^&) R:8oa-
Mr. Speaker:- That is their opinion. Why do you repeat
it? I am taking the opinion of the Leaders. You cannot say
others' opinion. I will not give you opportunity. I will
permit him after the motion. Please. Please.
€) S- e§*§ Raagtrao:- X5
(e>o&u°c&iO)
Mr. Speaker:- I am permitting the Legislative Affairs
Minister Sri P. Ashoka Gajapathi Raju.
g) &- 303*356,-:-, S*, gf
^ J5-4S- crarcra:- e$gs*,n &&) Tj)5 ^ 3 o o ^ ^ ^ 6 0 3Xp
Mr* Speaker:- It is immaterial here.
(Interruptions)
I am requesting you to keep silence at Podium.
V-
^ ^ §2S)^co3S^ RoRgffga)
I am allowing the Legislative Affairs Minister. I am telling
you. I am telling you once again. We have informed on that
day the then Home Minister. Then he was on camp. That was the
evidence.
(Interruptions)
24 Tl^ORd), 1995 33*3$ 3§^^J6 - "^ ^^' ^o6^6Ts^
S ? o ^ ^ Xj$ 3^s^o )g<So&)a 8 o 3
Please. I cannot answer all the questions. Please take your
chair. I have answered all the questions already. Please.
e& ^ ^ ^ ^ o j o S ^ 3nrcy€o ?6$S §^)3)^ rSoRdffgo )
!-!3 The Hon'ble Members, who are at the Podium, raised
&)- slogans "NTR - Zmdabad" "We want - Justice". Some of
them have broken the mike of the Hon'ble Speaker and thrown
away the same. Some of other Hon'ble Members have broken
the table-glass of the Hon'ble Speaker. When the Hon'ble
Members have gone to the Hon'ble Speaker's Chair and surroun
ded him, the Speaker immediately retired into his chambers).
(&$ 35R artyg^o fSo- 2-30 3-e&) &33o$33s.35)
(fr33 RgbgoD €3 <S*3iot c&)5- nrc&3g8, 3 5- e^5)?yd&30&^ ^3 8 33
$R)u*&, €3 §- o)3j^^.-d&od3, 3 § ^ ^ d b g y^6, 3 <A- gr^g,s3(^og,
^3 d5o^- S)^^&)^r6 53a, €3 S- g33^35og, €3 3- (rsg^daa,.,
€3 g-3- Ar^^aa^, %3 oSo* ^3Ao^h)€c, ^3 dioo- s*ara538,.,
^3 5- 33b^ grsD, €3 &. S3^(±ogr^5, €3 o* "aa3$ ,(3$og, & - &)^o&6
M ^ , ^3 &- 3on*35a<;, €3 &3r§ cr^aoa)o^^), €3 a* ^ o a ^ 5 ,
€3 aa^§- 3ogag^3-o3a,;, €3 §- So^^, €3 a- c*^ar^5o*3), €3 3 ^ §^aa^, €3 <35* ^?syaa^, €3 §- grayed a ^ o
^&^ ygo Fr 3o)
^ Mr. Speaker:- As you have observed what had just now
occurred was a bad incident: So, I would like some of the
Floor Leaders to react on it.
(Interruptions)
^) S- 3oa-)3a<.:- &&) '^ g5^' e r &3- <3<5-g-e5-ir83 e?y &)* crS§ &rSjs3 3^6- 8(±o;$&) Sj&3 3 e r d)-
(S Sc&)0 2S^ ho ;6§b§a3 e^go^do g^c^g? gr&r g rrdo)
Mr. Speaker:- Please resume your seats. I am taking up
the subject.
J.r. Speaker:- Please go to your seats. I appeal to all
of you to go to your seats* Please take your seats. Let the
business of the House be taken up.
€) 5- & ) j ^ ^ a ^ ^ ( ^ ^ (&&\,&)):- Rrgo eggoggo 3&- '^ 1§6 c&D, M &*5' ea"^- ^^-S-e8- rr65 3&o^S ea*jt&>- g SSrSss 3^o5-
(^o&)d$j^)
Mr^. Speaker:- I have never said that. I have never said
those weirds* I have never said that please.
(6s*6,.' &R3&>3 a*S(R30 3&o fT- §ee egflRo &6^o5)
$) &- s?yg^&^:- 3$ fT3sr3,i ^d3o&^ sr gg ^^oCSS &R &o&- S g5rr5§ ^o& g§^o&oS arSi S^orr oS- o^^^oo^ s6M XSo aXa $ 5 §^5^ &^o^5^ S g6rr5§ 33^06 coooS. S g5rr6 uosb
(* 0, *^0, g>0&3* ^€0)
2t> ?1ua.,oa&), '993 33*53 a3&3-a;$". " ^ - - ^0630-00
'3 §- sS )6:.g e,&'-?rcj&o&):- "$o* &r-&) 5-65-
€3 §- sna,yR3g y&3.- g5rrS &)&)3 s;5os*-
(goagoj.,^)
sg^oS- ty^cr^rr-ob ^j^gsbo^^rr- a-gnrRr 3^*&) sr8§ e-^y^o s)sr-goS
g8FS<&!„ S -ob- s;og&)^jo& &yc 36c&)X) 3^6.3 ^Kr^- < 1 ^ ^ ^
sSfS r s-g ^^6rr3 & a 3^§.rr Jsr§ 3c&g3o ag^6o-
^ Jo- %^6o-^) (Eraa^).- J<5-^e6-n-33 XS^.&)^ ' ^ ig6 '
are &33*oS*§ 2nTf,g- s3^^ cr^§ sr&So, Scrcr^j. § c & ) ^ gr^o&ooS-
%) Jo- ?%MtrS):- 3gT^5§ 3ooo2 Q5r^§-
^di)o ^ ^ o S - ^ ^ ^ $ b § ^ ^o a6R?3- ^r&) 6^ss g^^oti^^ edo?^
gr&o- & 3 & & . 6^s3 363 gr$Xi&sbo3? &r&^ a^o&rr &o&oo3-
€3 a- sK cHog yb3:- ^^s^g^g d^s3 s*3oaa eMg^ooa-
^^SrS^^^Qo^6^§rrg<D^5r§. g^g5rr8&6ge3^)33^&)- &&r5o^g
2 b o d ^ XgS 3^^^o Xi^Sot^&) 8o3"
^o5^ ^^&r ^5r^^- Xny ^o^^crd&ye^, ^g5rr6 fTSsr^ ^o^^os-
&0&30&- ^ o o ^ Xgr ^o^crd&ra&r, & rT6ar^§ ^0^0 3 ^ 5*&&&$3see
3g33j$ ^d&€c ^&)ocr §§o$o^o^5- e5)^S a*3§ <yoocr§ orr &o^o&-
e j,3a, ^5Sr^ss 3 ^ S eo&y S ddt o ^6^ f - adjgoo e^^rvgb)
(3oe6^^)
This is my opinion* Please wait. I am appealing to all
of you once again. 53*6-3 $5ob &B"U"^. cSg^O 3d3^S^, ^^0&cQy6§rr
3 ^ o ^ FT en s cRoorr &§^o 3^^^&)-
(^o&)6^^)
..- _ Mr. Speaker:- I request all the Members who are at the
podium to leave the podium and to resume their seats. I also
request the Members to keep silence.
€3 &-^3og^gs6u*3&:- e$gs*.,, g5n*8 f^ga*^* ^$ oocr^iyS^
y^r^oA^ s3r$gg ^^&) &o&- ^nr6^^3a^^^^ nr^dcr^rrgo 3^33*
S^g5rr3% 6^S3 %^ R$S* H ^gbg^§ gg s? o^dj- 38 tre*asr6gdao<ja
SeQdijo- &db3A &6j ^6rr§- sr8 e^^dSyco SiyS- cr^S* &>;63*a33o&
%&r- y^ ^^&D eB^^ o*3§ ??&3 g:oo&r ^goRXi^rr $sb 3sro*3<3L &S^o
g&R ^6j5r6 36^ 86rr&- ^g5rr*3 rTSor^, §5 ocr^Br^ s*a-cr8- ^3
)85o&) S oSeA ^S^6o ao&- eB^R cr^§ fTgR Xi$Dg€o ^onvr gg^
Scrcr^ §§(3b3<3irgg-
J. 184-4
28 7H^oad3, 1995- S^aR ^)S^r&^ : " 3 o)^- ^o&)gra:
^ o ^ S ^ 3^^^o 3g<goa>a hr^oS^
€^ - ac^dbg ^68.- ^jg6rrdo cr^ro-^rr83 $9^ o^^ Sycy*
s 5y§ gcr?
^) ^dr5- 3crs23*h3u*a).- $ 6 ^ , ^ ^ S - u #cr^^r^ anoar. g^b^jo^^r gg cr&rcr )rr85 ^ooo&) &r&r^^^^ ^ ^o^o & SS o&3 &o&- 5"3 ^^d3 sr r 3syd^co)?&&o^oS8, eo&do o3oLS6/S?6 X)Oqb&) s8^o3- ^^gjL^oo^ RRcooKr, JsSdo S) Jo rr & rj., 3g3 cconr e? eo^o g Soo ^S &^g^ Xoao$o &^& s-&)- R&) §^^ ^sog* ^o&^& &o5 ^ ^ 5 ^3d5 a)aeo 3b^ 3 b &r^nr^dj- 6S3 3*a<33oo oSR ^^ ?6$bg^ ^6^,o5r§^ jg5n-8lg dg es g & ^ ^ ^ 3 r & S § dg ss e3 eo&oFr^do-g^g5r"8g dg ss 33&3§ ^nr&) &o&- ^ r ^ ^ S ^ crSSrcr rrdo Rl^a S 6 ^5)&o3- nj^ogo^ gr$ &o5- ^ gr €c ft8^o3o&-g) S Sdorr &8 o3o&:'gb
2-4o4 6 H eo$o 2co55 Fr s?r b S!05i* ^sr^g^go & & S2b go &o3-3o- ] g&tg 3 60 eoddo gycr* ^ ^&)go 3oR, ^g5rr8 & 5 S^gi^o ^j^ggo^o^ oa;3go &o5- ^^rd3 ^g6rr6 3eoogc ag^ Bo gDOD g& SA8 3d3odoS^, g<ag6rr63 dg ss 35 Sj8^§ gg^oSoS- gS 550 3 cr^oS^ gcKrd) &g ggg 8?&orr 3 ^ $^3^Kr^- ^ ^ s^dogo E gSSroogc ^$b§ oo^dr ^^D&) er$ &^^S§ gcrdo ^g^,o 3db^o, g^RrXa ^S^^ dosr^ ?&^ s-d^g^&ro: SXSg sr^o&oo&S §^djd:Fr^- ^?ydD ^ 3§on* s38 3 0-4.50^ )$3^o^^S, H t5^o s*3 A^^dJoorr 3do* ^3^orr ^g6rrdo g?a dg€o gXe^^^A ^ ^ S g ^ s r ^ - y^^
^ b o ^ ^ R$S 33*3X0 ggo'Rra Rr.SoS*-'
Sri Asaduddin Owaisi (Charminar):- Mr. Speaker, Sir, as M.L.As. we have taken otah to uphold the Constitution of India. When we had taken the oath to uphold the Constitution of India, it also includes respecting the Chair of theHon'ble Speaker. We have also to look what kind of message we are sending to the people of Andhra Pradesh. We have not only to respect, we have to uphold the dignity and honour of the Chair. I request my learned friends, who are more educated and who are more experienced and who had seen the different dimensions of life, to apologize to the Hon'ble Speaker. Whatever differences they have with the other party, or the other group, that should not include the Speaker. The Speaker is an impartial person here. I request them to reconsider their stand and go back to their seats. Whatever argument we have, let us put forward in a democratic way. The people of Andhra Pradesh are watching us. We have become the laughing stock. People have elected us to put forward their problems and to see that they are solved. For the last 15 days, there is no machinery. The poor people, the down trodden are suffering because of this political imbroglio. I request them to reconsider their stand, apologize to the Chair and uphold the Constitution of India.
3* 5- a&t3^^&u*& (3656-5):- <9$§s\, g*5*so & ^ s M R
RoqbaR Er<3* 3sr3g33o,j6 S dfoo- R6 5, 6 RoSS^^o^o^ooS &rXb ,<3*jL&)-
en§s*3 i*5<s, X3§Xs%€o a&oa)3* &rar Rrar eR3S*aao, 33bdS 30s*
Rgojour s*3§g)cSr(ao aSrrox) s*3 fT33 ^g6rr6 ^ 3s ggorr crcrXh n*B
33 XoqbaX a6RR SSjcRio J^&r sgR&RRA 33<33oo & eo&6# 3<E&-
RRoooKr u*s§3$oorr S'*a*fyd3S*sr8, adba X^aeS* BSb^srg s*3 3e 8$orr
^g5n*6 *aj6 eXi^^&)§orr ^ 3$orr Sc&M3o ^tSgdioo- S3§ 3?&>og-
3 u r 3 o ^ ^ o ^Rr^ & 3*<2<Rx> R^^b 33^ e 3$orr 333 sr3o &&)
eSrSjsa SS^3 ^3osr^ R$r 5-3§g)Sbo 3^o&- & ^jo^e ^5oc ^o5 cr3
aj)H 3o Sdb^oR- *6j(So€o cr&rcr^rr3§ 3)SSx) ^o53&o" ^ycr a&^&o*
s*3<33& 3r^3 & R ar&^%g&^* e8 & 3P§8*3 33<3ho- gR^boc
g3o^r 3o&)o o?6? ^r55s3 63 &3o5r^ y3gg)&>o 3 ^ . ^ ^ -
€3 3-<S cr3rcr^):- e$§^, a6^3 3 di)o gr^dorr & 3 ^ S §
^5 u-3o3o5 ycb- ^3^ ^ 3 6 3 ^ & ^ 3^3c&o333^o&, R Si53^&)^
cr^3r ^3^3o3 33^oS ^3 5)^^3§ e3y^o e&rr33- r o?*h&o X8rr
36)- nr ^Xoo^&o ^ ^ Sj&}o o&) 5c&33 nrg3 ^2Sy$o ^3$3^3 ean*&>.
e3 3l&_. KTgcCbo tSxbo artb- &&> aeoXo - ^Ro K$oS* &M3>§obo33rr
&^^d3 ^ao3o^ Roqb&)3 <^^&r s6hlg^- Jo^&) ^o^3&r 33^o53^&
obo^S^ 3^^o ^ ; M o ^ ^ ^6o3?
&&) gy y 3o5^g^8 e^SotSoS- 3r sr8^ eSrr^r, 0)06: 3 ^ ^ ^ 0 6
$90^ &r^3 g^o g§ao& '<3*J d^o' e^ 1L^ sr^do a8fSo<3 eKrj.&)
I am sorry for it. You must care for all. 'Who cares for you'
eS 3&>A oRj. &r&) a&Ra&tR y6o eXio^&^ 3^d)- &)&5 y&^^goy&^*
srd) g)^o^&^ 3^do ^6^08 s-3 3$3^^ aS Xjo y5&&)^S3^o^ry^-
3& bJ gorr 6cb3§ &)^33^^^ 4 s ojooRCf, ^ ^ o ^ - a g ^ K)$&)
Roao§o33 srco30&o &o5 363 g&)g R6rr ^oSry^o 3&^ o^ ^^o^o^5
SSS S y&r I am the Ex-Chief Minister. Ir is my right to say
under what circumstances I was forced to go. ^ ^S&p&S*^ 3 ^
o5oS) SS8 oS 33a ^ cr cr 3^^^eA^ gr$g$ &o<5- ycb eo^ &&) e6^
80&0&- J0&:R3 3$OfY 3, A no&tRfT 8gorr^O&* &^ ^*0J)0^ RRroS
g-H-X)- &^0h3
Mr. Speaker:- One minute. You said that I have used 'Who
cares for you'. I never used those words.
(eo&o*33oo)
€3 §- gpR cRos 5*38:- &3o e?y (b-
Mr. Speaker:- If you think that I have used those words,
I am withdrawing them. — -" r
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- One behalf of all my brothers, I am
apologizing to you.
Mr. Speaker:- If you think that I have used those words,
I am withdrawing them. I have no objection.
(Repeated Interruptions)
I am "not allowing any "discussion. I am allowing only on the incident that took place on the floor of the House. Beyond that, 1 cannot allow. 1 will consider th<* issued next.
€^ J^-$- croSru-^:- Qo^goS 3&j. S^XbgD cr36c,og grrboSB-
Mr. Speaker:- Only on the incident that took place at the podium.
€3 c35* - 3*&ru*^):- urg) sg3*o, S^^ ^3^o3- ecconr 3so&iy^&-
I have apologized to you. eo^goEf < &J 3 oSro&rd3? oT&3 ar# 5&)
2-50 tsboTjL ' ^ ^ S*&} enTJ.dc- S3 $9 e)3 § - Q05" 3&) &08? 33L&
Ao^6rr ^Sry^o 3S^ )o^ ^06 $o&)^ e8?S& s*&;-
Mr. Speaker:- That is not the issue. No, I can't. I can't go beyond that. You have expressed your apology. That is O.K. I request you to resume your seat. I am taking up one issue. I cannot go beyond that. You should understand me. I cannot, go^ beyond the issue.
Sri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- Mr. Speaker, Sir
(Repeated interruptins from the Members standing at the podium)
Mr. Speaker:- I am not controlled by any one on the issue that had taken place at the podium. I said I never used the word and he expressed his apology. I request you to take your seats and then I will take up the agenda. I cannot expand* the issue. I have given the opportunity. He cannot go on 3ayjE3?g everything. I am requesting everybody once again to sonfin^ to the subject that had taken place at the podium.
Sri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- Mr. Speaker, Sir, as a parliamentarian of over a decrde's time....
Mr. Speaker:- (To the Members who are standing near the podium) Bleasla take your seats.
#) <35-R- trarca):- 3 ^ 33^5 5305* 1 am still the leader
of the T.D.L.P^ I have the right and nobody else has the right-
o)33o(§ &T,&;$0 2j)3^&Te)Cr^? Nobody has the right. &<3b3a 90&3b
gycr e6*3oaoS-
€3 33*5- crg$s(Sy3):- a*o-Do45 e& ts3n5 &5*
32 ?Hia<,oa&, '995- 33*33 R^sWSR : " ^ ^ - ^o^er^
S3A.5 Sjg6:- H&3 <3*oo30 e^ ed.5^ M^oS-
J^-S- o sSrcr&rr&) s 5 cS3oo & R &^&r^5 ^SSr^sa ^o-do- ^ &de & &
Jh3os*3aog*, gr$6^^ ^gc&^8o3 <3b(& 3Sr^s3 aaaao&xasb 5T5T ^ o ^
$on* &^3- srSA (€) § ^ - trS^rcr^rySA) o o ^ d o ^ ^ 3*&<R3o 5h^d
Mr. Speaker:- I am also requesting them to take their seats. (To the Members standing at the podium) I request you to resume your seats*
(The Members persisted to interrupt the proceedings standing at the podium)
I am requesting you to resume your seats.
? Sri G* Butchaiah Chowdary:- Allow us to speak.
Mr. Speaker:- I will hear you. Please take your t i-ss
(Continued interruptions from the Members standing at the podium)
Please take your seats, otherwise I will take dyicsiplinary action on all those Members. ^
Sri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- As a parliamentarian of over a decade's standing, in my legislative career, I have never seen a day like today. There has been a direct attack on the Speaker. This is the first attack in the parliamentary democracy....
(Repeated interrupting)
Mr. Speaker:- Please, please.
Sri P. Ashok Gajapathi Raju:- All the floor leaders have expressed their views. Even the former Chief Minister Mr. Rama ' Rao also stood up and unqualifiedly apologized to the Hon. Speaker* But, the problem here is with the Members who have
&s*g& &}§&&;$ : "^3 ^^- tSoS^gra: T-Ll^oagb, (995 * - 33
2 b o g ^ ^ 33raRo )g^ot3c&) ?^5o3^
heaped abused and who have descended to nhe level of resorting to this dastardly act. They unfortunately have had no remorse. This is the unfortunate situation, rather a predicament, that this August House has been placed in. The democratic practices are for all to practice and not for a few. I hunbly submit to the Chair that it is the duty of all of aa, including you, to protect the honour of the Chair. We are with you in protecting the honour of the Chair. Whatever action von deem fit, we will whole heartedly without reservation support. This is the assurance"!: want to makel
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- I am still the leader of the T.D.I .P.
e3 e;$%o a6Ro3)
50 gooiB s*33S<so<3, Xospg o)og etoaxs* 3&),a. g-<3-aS5-2- 6<%6rr b8^ccr§-
(Interruptions)
Mr. Speaker:- Please, let the Hon. Members....
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- They must give requisition notice.
Mr. Speaker:- I am not taking up that issue.
Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- It is illegal.
Mr. Speaker:- I will now take up the vote of confidence.
(Loud shouting of 'No, No' from the Members ^ standing at the podium)
If yots- want to speak, you can speak.
Sri P. !&shok Gajapathi Raju:- You kindly name* them. I will move the^esolution.
(Interruptions unabated)
Mr. Speaker:- If you want to speak on the motion, I have no objection.
(Interruptions)
Even now, if you want to speak on t%ie motion, I have no objection.
(Repeated interruptions)
34 7 HA.,oa3b, i995- S^&^ X^gsMR : "^ c)^- &o&?gra:
&o^6&^ 3s*s;3o )ggo&&) 808*?
If you want to speak on the motion, I have no objection. I will allow you.
(Slogans of 'We want - Justice' from the Memaers standing at the podium)
Please* Please. I am taking up the Vote of Confidence. The Motion is before the House.*..
(Repeated interruptions from the Members near the podium)
Please* don^t interrupt the proceedings. I am requesting you to go to your seats. I am requesting you to go back to your seats.
(Members continued to interrupt the proceedings near the podium)
I am warning you. Please leave the podium. Please leave the podium. Please leave the podium, otherwise I will take action.
(Members persisted to interrupt the Proceedings near the podium)
Now* I request the Minister for Legislative Affairs to move the motion.
Sri P. Ashok Ga^apathi Raju:- Sir, with your kind permission* I beg to move:
"That the following Members be suspended from the service of the House for the day: ^
Sri T. Satyalinga Naicker Sri K. Appaia Naidu Sri Dadi Veerabhadra Rao Sri.G. Yerrunaidu -Sri G. Butchaiah Chowdary Sri A. Brahmanaiah Sri Devineni Rajasekhar Sri M. Seshagiri Rao Sri G. Muddukrishnama Naidu Sri N. Prasanna Kumar Reddy Sri P. Brahmaiah Sri B. Rajasekhar Reddy Sri B.V. Mohan Reddy Sri M. Narasimhulu Sri M. Damodar Reddy Sri D. Ramesh Babu Sri D. Pranay Bhaskar Sri M. Pedarathaiah Sri P. Mahender Reddy Sri P. Indra Reddy
3g*a&R3§s3f*&& : "%) J§- tSo& gTSD 7*&ae)0a&), i995- 35
Sri Ch. Ramachandra Rao Sri P. Chandrasekhar Sri Venkatakrishna Reddy Sri Gade Lingappa Sri G. Rama Mohan Rao Sri Y. Kista Reddy Sri N. Moola Reddy Sri Gadde Babu Rao."
Mr. Speaker:- Motion moved. Now, the question is:
"That the following Members be suspended from the service of the House for the day:
Sri T. Satyalinga Naicker Sri K. Appala Naidu Sri Dadi Veerabhadra Rao Sri G. Yerrunaidu Sri G. Butchaiah Chowdary Sri A. Brahmanaiah Sri Devineni Rajasekhar Sri M. Seshagiri Rao Sri G. Muddukrishnama Naidu Sri N. Prasanna Kumar Reddy Sri P. Brahmaiah Sri B. Rajasekhar Reddy Sri B.V. Mohan Reddy Sri M. Narasimhulu Sri M. Damodar Reddy ^
\^ Sri D. Ramesh Babu \ Sri D. Pranay Bhaskar \Sjpi Pedarathaiah Sri P. Mahender Reddy Sri p. Indra Reddy Sri dh. Ramachandra Rao Sri P JL Chandrasekhar Sri VeiMtatakrishna Reddy Sri GacMp Lingappa Sri G. Rama Mohan Rao Sri Y. Rista Reddy Sri N. Moola Reddy Sri Gadde Babu Rao."
(Pause)
The motion was adopted and the Members were suspended from the service of the House for the day.
^.od§^^3^^o^5^otio^h36o3^ ;
I request the Members who are suspended just now to leave the House.
(The Members persisted to stand at the podium raising slogans 'We want - Justice*. Thereupon, the Marshals entered the House and lead the suspended Members*
from out of the House.) 3-00 Sri N.T. Rama Rao:- Sir, I am still the T.D.P. Leader
and T.D.L.P. leader. They have not applied to me. They have not given the requisition notice.
(At this juncture, the Hon'ble Members from T.D.P. who were suspended from the House raised slogans persistently)
Mr. Speaker:- I am requesting the Members who are at the Podium and who are under suspension for today to leave the House. You- are requested to leave the House. You are requested to leave the House.
(The suspended Hon'ble Members were still raising slogans at the Podium)
I request you to leave the House. I instruct the Marshals to take the Members out of the House.
(At this stage the Hon'ble Members of T.D.P. under suspension were escorted out of the House by the Marshals)
(Slogan of 'Chandrababu Naidu Zindabad' from the Treasury Benches)
Plea&e. Have patience for sometime. Now, the -Motion of . Confidence is taken up for voting. As has been discussed wit%T the Floor Leaders there would be no discussion on the- Motion of Confidence. I will straight away t^ke the vote of confluence. Now, the question is:
"That this House expresses its confidence in tflie Council of Ministers headed by Siri N* Chandrababu Na^du." f
- '*.;''-'"''"''',.,!-- /":.."/'.'.:"'/,':'''-^(Pause); '"-,'-, /.-;*'. -' ..-,\ r -' ' - . ' * , - . ^ ' *' v . . *
(Sri Ch* Vidyasagar Rao pressed for division and the House divided t h u s ) : -
_ AYES ...227 -"'-''/ ''i .'...'"''/
t . 3ri &. Chandrababu, Naidn
2. Qri t* Y^err^haidn
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
Sri C. Krishna Tad a?
Sri R. Chandrasekhar Reddy
Sri T. Bhadrayya
Sri V.7.S.S. Chowdary
Sri B .0 . (Covindappa
Sri A. Govind Naik
Sri Gone Hanumantha Rao
Sri K. Hanumantha Rao
bri C. Mutyam Reddy -
Sri T.D. Nagaraja Reday
Cri E. Nageswara Rao
Sri P. Rambhupal Reday
Sri E. Ramachandra Raju
Sri E. Ramachandra Rao
zzi Dr.P. Subbaiah
Sri P. Subba Rao
19. -Tpri E. Ssbbarayodu.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
SrS^K. Subba Reddy
Sri T. Ashok Gajapathi Rajn
Sri T. Devender 3ond
Sri A. Madhgva Reddy
Sri E. Vidyadhar Rao
Sri Ch. Ayyanna Patrudu
Sri S. Satyanarayana
Sri T. Seetaram
Sri K. Srihari
38 * 7 Ha<,oa&, 1*995- -'*-' 5^S^ ^ § ^ ^ J /'^ -4^' ^ S T M
29. Sri G'. Nagesh ^
. 30* Sri D. Achnta Raoiayya
31* Sri Do Anjaneyalu
32^ Sri N. Anjaneyaln
33. Sri S.V.Ch* Appala Naidu
34* Sri R.S.D.P. Appala Narasimha Raja
35. Sri 3+ AppaLa Suryananyana
36. Sri J. Babji Rao
37. Sri A. Babu Rao
38* Sri B. Bhaskara Rama Rao
39. Sri A.J.?* Bnchi Maheswara Rao
40* Sri P. Chalapathi Rao
41 . Sri V. Chander Rao
42. Sri S. Chandra Mohan Reddy
43. Sri A* Chandrasekhar
44* Sri J* Chandrasekhar Rao
45* Sri 3. Daya%ar Rao . ^
46* Sri Kothakota Dayakar Reddy
47* Sri Suddala DevaiaJh
48. Sri 7* Doraiswamy Rajn
49* Sri Dakku Labudn Bariki
50. SriB* Durga Prasad Rao
51* Sri G* Dwarakanadha Reddy
52. Sri Bmaurajan
53* Smt. A* Annapurna Devi
54* Smt* P* Arona
55* Smt. E^ Pra^i^ba Bharatn-
56. S&nt. al. Seenara aKBBAa
57. Smt^ Y. Sita Devi
58. ant. A. Veakata Lakshmi De^
59* Sri B. Hari Babu
60. Sri K. H%risbyar Reddy
61 . Sri B. Huli uji'Jappa
62. Sri B. Janardha^
63* Dr^ N. Jaaardhao Re^cy
64* Sri T. Jaya^.aLaiA
65. Sii N. ^^ar^ju.
66. Jri jfe Jayar^a
67. Sri P. Kanaka Sundae a Hao
63. Sri M. Easi Reddy
69 . Sri P . Eeshav
70. Sri S.A. Shaleel Basha
71* Sri Y. Krishnamurthy
7 2 ^ Sri H.V. Krishna Rao
73. Si^R. Krishna Sagar
74* Sri NT? Eristappa
75. Sri E. Sakshmaiah Naidu
76. Sri T. Nageswara Rao
77^ Sri V. Nageswara Rac
78. STl B. Nagt Redcy.
79^ SrL P+V. Narasimha Ra3u
80. Sri B. Narsdmulu
81. Sri Narayana Rao Pat el.
82. Sri P. Naray anas-waxy aidu
83. Sri D. Nareadra Kumar
84. Sri K. Nooka Raju
85. Sri B+ Pandari
86. Sri E.Peddi Red y
87. Sri Y.T. Prabhakara Red(^
88. Sri K.Prakash Reddy
89. Sri R* Prakash Red<%r
90. Sri Ch. Ranachandra Reddy
91. Sri K.Rama Krishna Red<3y
92. Sri Nara Ramamoortby Naidu
93. Sri G.Ramamurthy Yadav
94. Sri L. Ramana
95. Sri P+ Rama Subba Reddy
96. Sri P. Rgna Rao
97. Sii J. Ratnesh Babu
98. Sri T. Ram ash Red<& _^^
99. Sri N. Ramakishan Rao
100. Sri Ch. Ram Red3/
101. Sri P. Ramulu
3D2. Sri M. Ranga Rao
103. Sri M+ Ranga Reddy
3D4. Sri P. Ravindra
105. Sri R. Ravindranath
106. Sri Redctr Satyanarayana
107^ Sri K. Sadastva Reddy
108. Sri G. Sgnbasiva Rao
109^ Sri SatishPawar
HO. Sri S.V^Subba Red^
111. Sri 4.Sudershaa+
112. Sri Jonna Suryanarayana
113. Sri P. Suiyanarayaaa
114. Sri N^ Svmydas
115. Sri G. Sygma Smdara Sivaji
116. Sri ChilkurL Vaman Reddy
117. Sri D, Vasudwa Rao
118. Sri V, Veerabhadra Rao
119. Sri B. Veera Red<&
130. Sri G. Veera S&va Reddy
121. Sri Chappidi Vtngaiah
122. Sri J. Venkata 4*ppa Rao
123. Sri N. Vaakatalah
" fS^ Sri P. Venkata Krishna Rao
125. M G. Venkata Naidu
126. S r i % Venkata Rama Krishna
127. Sri D.\veRkata Ramana
128. Sri K. Veckat Rao
129. Sri P. V. Ratnaish
130. Sri Mohd. Farook
131* Sri P. Purushotham Rao
132. Sri Asaduddin Owaisi
133. Sri B. Venkateswara Rao
^rd&D&)n-5 Kr<j$oga3og'*3 goo§5
134. Sri P. Nageswara Rao
135. Sri C. Baganna
136. Sri Basheeruddia Babu Khan
137^ Sra P. Ramaiah
138^ Sri J. Venkaiah
139. Sr . Ch. Rajeswara Rao
140. Sri Ch. Vittal Reddy
141. Sri K. C&andrasekhar Rao
142. Sri A. Chandulal
143. Sri V. Chennaiah
144. Sri K. Chitti Naidu
145. Sri J. Venkat Reddy
146* Sri T* Trimurthulu
147. Sri M, Abdul Gafoor
148. Smt. P. Bharathi
149. Pr^ K, Svbba Raju
150. Sri Vaaka Satyanarayana
151^ Sri Maeala Branna
152. Sri R. Gandbi
153. Sri M* Gopala Krishna
154+ Sri 9. Sepals Krishna Reddy
155. Sri N* Qopala Rao
156. Sri G. Gpvar^haa
157: Sri M. Malle^ham
158. Sri D.Kn Bh^rath Simha Reddy
159. Sri Kunya Bojji
2oo^^ A$ S^aXo ^ ^ o ^ ^ rb8o&"
160. Sri T. Chenchaiah
161. Sri K. Rama Krishna
162. Sri V. Abbaya
163. Sri M. Anjaneyulu
164. Sri Kunja Biksham
165. Sri B. Lakshmana Rao
166. Sri S. Madhusudhana Chary
167. Sri K. Madhusudhan Rao
168. Sri K. Meenakshi Naidu
169. Sri A, Mohan
170. Sri K. Mohan Rao
171. Sri B.Ch. Garataiah
172. Sri Gottipati Hanumantha Rao
173. Sri N. Narasimha Reddy
174. Sri N. Raghava Reddy
175. Sri D. China Mallaiah
175. Sri M.B. Chowhan
177. Sri Demudu Goddeti
178. Sri G. Mallesh
179. Sri K. Rynna Reddy
180. Sri N. Raghuram
181. Sri A. Rahman
182. Sri M. Rajaiah
183. Sri B. Rajamallu
184. Sri N. Raja Reddy
185. Sri A. Rajendra Prasad
44 7*XiaoOa&* !995- S ^ ^ Sj)§c3r6i$ : "€3 J5* tSo STSD
186. Sri R+P. Bhanjdeo
187. Sri K. Vijaya Rami Reddy
188. Sri V. Yellamanda Rao
189. S^i D. Rajagopal
190. Sri Ch. Raji Reddy
191. Sri Mohd. Rajab Ali
192. Sri V. Narayana Rao
193. Sri G.M.N.V. Prasad
194. Sri B. Pullaiah
195. Sri B. Satyanarayana Murthy-
196. Dr. Metla Satyanarayana Rao
3 97. Sri G. Sayanna
198. Sri P. Simhacbalam
199. Sri P. Singanna Dora
200. Dr. K. Siva Prasada Rao
201. Dr. D+ Sivaram
202. Sri R. Sobhanadri Chowdary
203. Sri N. Sreeramulu
204. Sri G.V. Srinadha Reddy
205. Sri Y. Srinivasa Rao
206. Sri P. Srinivasa Reddy
207. Sri T. Srinivas Yadav
208. Sri Y. Srinivasulu Reddy
209. &ri N* Ramamohan Rao
210. Sri K. Ramulu
211. Sri J. Ranga Reddy
212. Sri S. Venkata Veeraiah
S b o ^ ^ ^$ &ygXjo giSoSaa h3 6o&'-
, 213. Sri P. Saraiah
214. Sri G. Yadagiri Reddy
215. Sri A. Venkata Satyanarayana
216. Sri M. Venkata Subbaiah
217. Sri A. Venkata Suryanarayana Raju
^ 218. Sri M. Venkateswara Rao ! ' 219. Sri S. Venkateswara Rao i
220. Dr. S. Venugopala Chary ^ 221. Dr. G. Vijaya Rama Rao
222. Sri M. Vijaypal Reddy
223. Sri K. Viswanatham
224. Sri S. Viswanatham
225. Sri V.V.B.K. Yachandra Velugoti
226. Sri Yella Reddy
227. Sri S^M. Ziauddin
NOES . NIL NEUTRALS .... 31
01) Sri Mohd. Amanullah Khan
02) Sri Ch. Vidyasagar Rao
03) Sri R. Damodar Reddy
04) Sri Mumtaz Ahmed Khan
05) Sri B. Bal Reddy
06) Sri P. Ramaswamy
07) Syri K.R. Suresh Reddy
08) Sri N* Varadarajulu Reddy
09) Sri P. Janardhan Reddy
V6
Sri K. Bapi Ra^u
Sri Gade Venkata Reddy
Sri Kanna Lakshmi Narayana
Sri M. Kodanda Reddy
Sri K. Rambhupal Reddy
Sri D.S. Redya Naik
Sri J.C. Diwakar Reddy
Sri C.K. Jayachandra Reddy
Sri D. Nagender
Sri M. Narayana Reddy
Sri E. Pratap Reddy
Sri P. Rajasekharam
Smt. V. Ratna Kumari
Dr. D.L. Ravindra Reddy
Sri S. Sambaiah
Sri M* Sashidhar Reddy
Sri M* Sikhamam
Sri B. Subha Rao ^
Sri N. Venkata $ama Raju
Sri Gudibandi Venkata Reddy r
Sri Y+S. Vivekananda Reddy
Sri K. Yanadi Reddy
The Motion was adopted-*
Sri Ch. Vidyasagar Rao:- Sir, the stand of Sri Harikrishna is not known.
Mr. Speaker:- He has not voted at all. Sri Harikrishna is a Minister only. He is not a Member of this House and therefore, he has no voting right.
The House is adjourned to meet again at 10.00 a.m. on 12.9.1995.
(The House then adjourned at 3.15 p.m. to meet again at 10.00 a.m. on Tuesday, the 12th September, 1995)
