stanley cavell - aprender uma p

8/17/2019 Stanley Cavell - Aprender Uma p

1/8

1

UFSM/Departamento de FilosofiaFilosofia da LinguagemProf. Ronai Pires da RochaOutubro de 2012Leituras de Filosofia da Linguagem

Stanley Cavell. As reivindicações da razãoDigressão sobre a visão wittgensteiniana da linguagem

"#$%&'%$ ()* #*+*,$*•

-.*&+%/ 0*,%++

-(#1&2* 3(% #%$4(&.%)156 78(*&'1 ()* 9$:*&;* *#$%&'% 1 &1)% '% *+41 ?4*.1@> ?%5.$%+*@> ?*ABA1$*@C 1A,:*)%&.% %+* &D1 *#$%&'% *#%&*5 3(%!"#! 51)

7*5 '(*5 91:5*5IM #M XYC L :551 )% +%,1(*#$%9:*$ % * 3(%$%$ :&,%5.:4*$ *.O 3(% #1&.1 1 .%)* '% 5*A%$ 1 3(% *+410 > O ()* 3(%5.D1'% 5*A%$ 91)1$4*&*&%" *+41G % * *'):.:$ 3(*&.1 O +:):.*'* 1( %5#%9:*+ * ,%$'*'% 3(%5% %=#$%55* &1 +%)*6 7J1'%)15 )('*$ 1 &1)% '*5 91:5*5> )*5 * &*.($%Q* '%+*5 % *N1$)* 91)1 1#%$*) %) &1551 %&.%&':)%&.1 &(&9* )('*)I 5+!*#("! > [11\ ]]>J*$. ]]]> -%9M ]MCM

T1 )1)%&.1 ':$%: *#%&*5 :5516 .*+ $%5#15.* &1 )U=:)1> *#%&*5 #*$* *3(%+%5 3(% FU '1):&*) ()* +K&4(*M T1 9*51 '%()* 9$:*&;* %) #$19%551 '% '1)K&:1 '% 5(* +K&4(*> #1'% 5%$ 3(% &%&2()* '*5 '(*591:5*5 5%F* 3(% N$%3(%&.%)%&.% #*$%9%) 21&%5.:'*'%> % *55:)N$%3(%&.%)%&.% *5 92*)*)15 '% 21&%5.*5M

• 0*,%++> -.*&+%/M54! 71*(& %8 9!*"%- M T%W ^1$\6 P=N1$' _&:,%$5:./ J$%55> Y`a`M P .$%921 *3(: .$*'(Q:'1 O ()* 5%;D1 '*7R:4$%55D1 51A$% * ,:5D1 W:..4%&5.%:&:*&* '* +:&4(*4%)I> &* 5%4(&'* #*$.% '1 +:,$1M L5.* .$*'(;D1> *:&'* %) $%,:5D1> N1:N%:.* #*$* (51 %) ):&2*5 *(+*5 '% V:+151N:* '* b:&4(*4%)M J*$* %55* .$*'(;D1 )% ,*+: %=.%&5:,*)%&.% '1 .$*A*+21 '%R:%41 c:A%5 T:91+U5> 3(% .$*'(Q:( 1 +:,$1 #*$* 1 %5#*&21+ 51A 1 .K.(+1 '%9!(2(-'($*$(%-!" '! 1* +*:;- M d*)AO) )% 5191$$:'1 .$*A*+21 '% -*&'$* b*(4:%$> * .$*'(.1$* '% 0*,%++ #*$* 1 N$*&9e5> 51A 1 .K.(+1


2/8


3/8

3

-:.(%)1E&15 *41$* &1 ':*> 5%)*&*5 '%#1:5> 3(% %+* 51$$:( ':*&.% '% ()* %5.1+*'% #%+%5> * *9*$:9:1( % ':55% 74*.:&21IM S:&2* #$:)%:$* $%*;D1 N1: '% 5($#$%5* %> 5(#1&21'%9%#;D16 %+* &D1 5*A:* $%*+)%&.% 1 3(% 5:4&:N:9* 74*.:&21IM S*5 ):&2* 5%4(&'* $%*;DN1: )*:5 5*.:5N*.B$:*6 %+* 3(%$ ':Q%$ 91) 74*.:&21I 1 3(% %( 3(%$1 ':Q%$ 91) 7#%+%5IM P(%$*> *1 91&.$U$:1> 1 3(% %( 3(%$1 ':Q%$ 91) 7N1N1I 1(> .*+,%Q> 7*4$*'U,%+ *1 .*.1IH P(

.*+,%Q &D1 3(%$:* ':Q%$ '% )1'1 *+4() 1 3(% * ):&2* 5:&.*=% $%4:5.$* 91)1 7:551 O ()mIM "N:&*+> 3(*&'1 %+* ,e 4*.15 $%*:5 &D1 *#%&*5 #$1N%$% 5(* ,%$5D1 *+1Nn&:9* 74*.:&21I 5%&D1 3(%> &1$)*+)%&.% 4$:.* * #*+*,$* )*:5 '% ()* ,%Q> 5%&.*E5% &1 92D1#%$.1 '%+%> %5.%&'% 15 A$*;15 #*$* 1 4*.1 *A$:&'1 % N%92*&'1 15 '%'15 1( 71+2* 3(% 4*.:&21 )*:5 ':,%$.:'1I> 1( 7*5 91:5*5 N1N*5 5D1 .D1 *4$*'U,%:5oI1(> 7)% '1( 91&.* '% 91)1 N:9*5 91&.%&.% 3(*&'1 %( ':41 ?4*.:&21@I> 1( 7%( 415.1 3(% )%N*;*) 9*$:&21IM J1'%)15 '%9:':$ 51A$% :551H p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e 91&.* 3(% &D1 %5.*)15 #$%#*$*'15#*$* 9*):&2*$ F(&.15 #1$ 9%$.15 +(4*$%5M

S*5 )%5)1 3(% %( &D1 .%&2* +2% ':.1> % %+* &D1 .%&2* *#$%&':'1> &%) 1 3(%5:4&:N:9* * #*+*,$* 74*.:&21I &%) 1 3(% () 4*.:&21 O> 5% %+* 5%4(% '*&'1 5*+.15 % %( 5:41

1+2*&'1 #*$* %+* % 51$$:&'1> *#$%&'%$U *5 '(*5 91:5*5M P 3(% %( 3(%$:* ':Q%$ O6 %) 5%()(&'1 *:&'* &D1 %=:5.%) 4*.15 q *3(:+1 3(% 92*)*)15 '% 74*.15I EM L+* &D1 *'3(:$:(*:&'* *5 N1$)*5 '% ,:'* 3(% :&9+(%) 4*.15M L %+%5 &D1 %=:5.%) '% )1'1 #*$%9:'1 * 91)1*5 9:'*'%5 % 15 #$%N%:.15 &D1 %=:5.:$D1 %) 5%( )(&'1 *.O A*5.*&.% .%)#1 '%#1:5 '% 3(%%=:5.*) 4*.15 % *ABA1$*5G 1( '1 )1'1 91)1 R%(5> 1 *)1$> * $%5#1&5*A:+:'*'% 1( *A%+%Q* &D1 %=:5.%) %) &1551 )(&'1G &D1 '1):&*)15> 1( %53(%9%)15> 1( ':5.1$9%)15>1( *#$%&'%)15 #1$ )%:1 '% )1'%+15 N$*4)%&.*'15> *5 N1$)*5 '% ,:'* 3(% #('%$*)N*Q%$ 91) 3(% %=#$%55h%5 91)1 7R%(5 %=:5.%I 1( 7R%(5 %5.U )1$.1I> 1( 7.% 3(%$1I> 1(7&D1 #1551 *4:$ '% 1(.$* N1$)*I> 1( 7* A%+%Q* &D1 O )*:5 3(% 1 91)%;1 '1 .%$$1$I9*$$%4*55%) .1'1 1 #%51 3(% #1'%$:*) .$*&5):.:$> 3(% %=#$%55*55%) .('1 1 3(%#1'%$:*) .:$*$ '% &B5M TD1 91&2%9%)15 1 5:4&:N:9*'1 '%5.*5 #*+*,$*5M R%5,:*)15 1 1+2*$% '*)15 5*+.15 *1 $%'1$M

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

P 3(% %( $%9%:1 O 3(% %5.*)15 %=9%55:,*)%&.% 5%4($15 *9%$9* '*5 :)#+:9*;h%5'1 *#$%&'%$ % '1 #*$.:+2*$ * +:&4(*4%)M P 3(% 2U '%!++*'% %) #%&5*$ 1 *#$%&':Q*'1 '*

+:&4(*4%) 91)1 91&5:5.:&'1 %) 3(% &15 %&5:&%) 1( &15 ':4*) 15 &1)%5 '*5 91:5*5HJ1$3(% O 3(% r:..4%&5.%:& 92*)* *4('*)%&.% * *.%&;D1 #*$* 1 N*.1 '% "415.:&21 .%$':.1 1( :)#+:9*'1 3(% O *55:)> % #1$3(% N*+1( '% ()* 791&9%#;D1I #*$.:9(+*$ '%


4/8


5/8

5

d*+,%Q #155*)15 ':Q%$ 1 5%4(:&.%6 -% ':Q%5 7TD1> %+* &D1 %5.U 91+19*&'1 $B.(+15&*5 91:5*5> #*4*&'1 91) ':&2%:$1


6/8

6

L) #$:)%:$1 +(4*$> &D1 O 9%$.1 3(% .1'1 )(&'1 51(A%55% 3(% "415.:&21 &D1%5.*,*$*C*1&!-#! 7*#$%&'%&'1 1 &1)% '*5 91:5*5I 3(*&'1 ':55% 3(% *1 *#$%&'%$ *+:&4(*4%) *#$%&'%( 1 &1)% '*5 91:5*5> % &D1 O 9%$.1 3(% .1'15 &B5 75*AK*)15 15%&.:'1I %) 3(% "415.:&21 3(%$:* ':Q%$ 1 3(% ':55%M 5%) 5*A%$ $%*+)%&.% 3(*:5 5D1 %55%5 #1'%$%5> 3(

%5#%$*)15 '%+%5> &%) %)./*1 5%&.:'1 5D1 :&%=#+:9U,%:5MCR* )%5)* N1$)*> &%) r:..4%&5.%:& &%) %( ':55%)15 3(% %$*!++*'% '(:!+ 3(% *9$:*&;* 7*#$%&':* 15 &1)%5 '*5 91:5*5I> 1( 3(% 7#*4*,* 15 :&4$%5515I> 1( 3(% 791+*,*$B.(+15 %) 5%(5 #1.%5IM _)* '*5 91:5*5 3(% %59(.*)15 r:..4%&5.%:& ':Q%$ 51A$%7*#$%&'%$ &1)%5I O6 7MMM "415.:&21 '%59$%,% 1 *#$%&':Q*'1 '* +:&4(*4%) 2()*&* 91)15% * 9$:*&;* 92%4*55% * () #*K5 %5.$*&21 % &D1 %&.%&'%55% * +K&4(* '%55% #*K5G :591)1 5% FU .:,%55% ()* +K&4(*> 51)%&.% 3(% &D1 %55*I &1 )%5)1 %5#K$:.1#1'%$K*)15 ':Q%$6 '%59$%,%$ * 9$:*&;* 91)1 791+*&'1 $B.(+15 %) 5%(5 #1.%5I 1(7#*4*&'1 15 :&4$%5515I O '%59$%,%$ * 9$:*&;* 91)1 5% N155% () *'(+.1 '% .1'15 15)1'15> 91)1 5% %+* '1):&*55% *5 *.:,:'*'%5 '15 *'(+.15CM ]5.1 O> ':Q%)15 '* 9$:*&;* 3(%7%+* %5.U 91+*&'1 $B.(+15 &15 #1.%5I> 1( 7%+* #*41( 15 :&4$%5515I> 3(*&'1 '%,%$K*)15':Q%$ .*)AO) 7%+* O ()* )*)D%I 1( 7%+% N1: 1 d:1 0$%51 '($*&.% () ':*IM T:&4(O)3(%$:* ':Q%$ 3(% O %$$*'1 % &D1N155% 9*#*Q '% ':59%$&:$ 3(% *:&'* O ()* 9$:*&;* 3(% A$:&9*> % 51A$%.('1 3(% %5.U9$%59%&'1M T1 9*51 '% 791+*$ $B.(+15I> 7A$:&9*$ '% #$1N%551$I> 7N*Q%$ 91):'*I> 7%&91&,:.%5I> %.9M> .*+,%Q :551 5%F* NU9:+ '% ,%$M L) 1(.$15 9*515 .*+,%Q &D1M

l*)15 #%&5*$ *41$* %) ()* 9$:*&;* )*:5 ,%+2*> 3(% 5%F* :4&1$*&.% '%> )*5)*'($* #*$* ()* *ABA1$* FU 3(%> 91)1 O 1A,:1> %+* .%) () &1)% #*$%9:'1 91) *'* N$(.*M S*5 :551 #$1,*,%+)%&.% &D1 .$*$U &%&2()* ':N:9(+'*'%> % () ':* * #%551* 3(%N1: %5.* 9$:*&;* +%)A$*$U> #1$ *+4()* $*QD1> 3(% *9$%':.*,* &%55*5 91:5*5 % 3(% N*Q:*%55*5 *5519:*;h%5> 3(*&'1 %$* 9$:*&;*M (""% 5%$U 1A(59*'1M 8(*&'1 ':Q%5 7.% +%,*$%: * #*55%*$ *)*&2D> #$1)%.1I * 9$:*&;* 91)%;* **#$%&'%$ 1 3(% O * '($*;D1 .%)#1$*+> % 1 3(% O$%-8(*+ > % *3(:+1 3(% N:Q%$%5 )15.$*$U 1,*+1$ 3(% * 91&N:*&;* .%)M 8(*&'1 ':Q%5 791+19* .(* A+(5*I> * 9$:*&;* *#$%&'% 1 3(% 5D1*5 1$'%&5 % 1 3(% O **/#%+('*'! > % 5% '*$ 1$'%&5 O *+41 3(% #$1'(Q *&5:%'*'% %) .:>%&.D1 *5 *(.1$:'*'%5 5D1 *&5:15*5> * *(.1$:'*'% )%5)* O :&5%4($*M

T*.($*+)%&.% * #%551*> *1 9$%59%$> *#$%&'%$U 1(.$*5 91:5*5 51A$% %55%591&9%:.15 % .*)AO) 51A$% %55%5 71AF%.15IM d1'*5 %55*5 91:5*5 :$D1 9$%59%&'14$*'(*+)%&.% 5%4(&'1 ,U 9$%59%&'1 1 )(&'1 '* 9$:*&;*M S*5 .('1 1 3(% %+* 1( %+% 5*A%51A$% *5 )%5)*5 O 1 3(% *#$%&'%(> % .('1 1 3(% *#$%&'%$*) N1$)*$U #*$.% '1 3(% 5D1ML 91)1 5%$U 1 ':* %) 3(% * #%551* 75% 'e 91&.*I '1 3(% 7%+% *9$%':.*,*I 3(% %$* 1 *)1$>* 91&N:*&;*> * *(.1$:'*'%H L 91)1 '%:=* '% *9$%':.*$H P 3(% *#$%&'%)15 &D1 O *#%&*5 1

3(% %5.('*)15G % 1 3(% 5% &15 %&5:&1( &D1 O *#%&*5 1 3(% 5% #$%.%&':* 3(%*#$%&'e55%)15M P 3(% .%)15 %) &155*5 )%)B$:*5 &D1 O *#%&*5 *3(:+1 3(%)%)1$:Q*)15M


7/8

7

P 3(% O :)#1$.*&.% &1 N$*9*551 %) ':59%$&:$ 71 %5#K$:.1I &1 3(*+ ':Q%)15 7*9$:*&;*> *1 *#$%&'%$ * +K&4(*> *#$%&'% 15 &1)%5 '*5 91:5*5I O 3(% :)*4:&*)15 3(%%=#+:9*)15 * &*.($%Q* '* +:&4(*4%) 3(*&'1 *#%&*5 %,:.*)15 1 ':59%$&:)%&.1 '% 5(*&*.($%Q*G % &D1 *9%$.*)15 %) ':59%$&:$ 91)1 % 5:) 1 3(% O () &1)%G &D1 *#%&*5 3(*+ O *N1$)* '% %=#$%55D1 #*$* %=#$:):$ () '%5%F1> 5%&D1 3(% %) 3(% 91&5:5.% %=#$%55*$ ()'%5%F1G &D1 *#%&*5 3(*+ O * #*+*,$* #*$* 7#*:I> )*5 1 3(% O () #*:G &D1 *#%&*5 3(*+ O *#*+*,$* #*$* 7*)1$I> )*5 .*)AO) 1 3(% O 1 *)1$M "1 *#$%&'%$ * +:&4(*4%) &D1 5%*#$%&'% 51)%&.% * #$1&(&9:*$ 51&5 % 5(*5 1$'%&5 4$*)*.:9*:5> 5%&D1 3(% *5 ?N1$)*5 '%,:'*@ 3(% N*Q%) '*3(%+%5 51&5 *5 #*+*,$*5 3(% %+%5 5D1> N1$)*5 '% ,:'* 3(% N*Q%) 3(%%5.%5 51&5 N*;*) 1 3(% N*Q%)> #1$ %=%)#+1> &1)%*$> 92*)*$> *#1&.*$> %=#$%55*$ ()'%5%F1 1( () *N%.1> :&':9*$ ()* 1#;D1 1( ()* *,%$5D1> %.9M q L r:..4%&5.%:& %&.%&'% *5$%+*;h%5 %&.$%!"#*" N1$)*5 .*)AO) 91)1 ?4$*)*.:9*:5@M

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

()* A1N%.*'*CM 7L&5:&*$I 5:4&:N:9*$:* *3(: *+41 91)1 7)15.$*$ * %+%5 1 3(% ':Q%)15 % 13(% N*Q%)15I % 7*9%:.*$ 1 3(% %+%5 ':Q%) % N*Q%) 91)1 1 3(% &B5 ':Q%)15 % N*Q%)15I>%.9MG % :5.1 5%$U )*:5 '1 3(% &B5 5*A%)15 1( #1'%)15 ':Q%$M

L) 3(% 5%&.:'1 5D1 91:5*5*)+!-'('*" * 9*#*9:'*'% '* 9$:*&;* #*$* &15 75%4(:$I>5%( :&.%$%55% #%+1 3(% N*Q%)15> % 5%( 91&2%9:)%&.1 '% 3(*&'1 5:) % 3(*&'1 &D1*9%:.*)15 * :'%&.:'*'% '% 5(*5 #*+*,$*5 % *;h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e&9:*5 *&.%$:1$%5M -% *5 #%551*5 &D1 N1559*#*Q%5 '% N*Q%$ %55*5 91:5*5 %+*5 &D1 9$%59%$:*) %) &1551 )(&'1G )*5 %,:.*$ %55*91&5%3(e&9:* O * $*QD1 #%+* 3(*+ N*Q%) :551H

01)%;*)15 * &15 5%&.:$ *.%$$1$:Q*'15> 1( '%,%$K*)15> #1$3(% .*+,%Q *+:&4(*4%) '% )1'1 3(% 1 3(%-;" 792*)*)15I '%5*#$1,*;D1 N155% #*$* %+* ()!-$%+*H*&!-#%H p #1$ *9:'%&.% 3(% %55*5 91:5*5 &D1 191$$*) &1$)*+)%&.%H d*+,%Q


8/8

stanley cavell - aprender uma p

Documents