sentença que livrou lula de processo

40
7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 1/40 RLHGP JWHDODËPDL XPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL _GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI  Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06 OIK__G : >?22 ‟ KÎÏL HG DERPL@DHKHG KHEDMD_XPKXDSK RPLOG__L : >62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 KWXLP : EDMD_XÄPDL RÚ@IDOL CGHGPKI PÄW_ : IWDZ DMËODL IWIK HK _DISK g KEDP CPKMOD_OL IKMHL _GMXGMÎK D%PGIKXßPDL L EDMD_XÄPDL RÚ@IDOL CGHGPKI kjwåzk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk olmxpk IWDZ DMËODL IWIK HK _DISK g KEDP CPKMOD_OL IKMHL) pgsrgoxdkegmxg) gv%Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok g gv%Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki) xgmhl rlp l`jgxl ls sgnwdmxgs ckxls) kssde mkppkhls mk dmdodki: ’K rpgsgmxg kîïl xge rlp l`jgxl k derlsdîïl hg skmî÷gs odds%khedmdsxpkxdks kl  rpdegdpl pg{wgpdhl &gv%Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok$ g k olmhgmkîïl hg ke`ls ls pg{wgpdhls kls pgsskpodegmxl hls rpgjwåzls okwskhls kl gpëpdl) ge pkzïl hk rpëxdok hg kxl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) olmsdsxgmxg ml gmdl dppgnwikp hg olppgsrlmhêmodks kls  sgnwpkhls hl DM__) kxpkäs hks {wkds dmclpekke sl`pg k rlssd`didhkhg hg l`xgmîïl hg gerpäsxdels olmsdnmkhls ole xkvks hg jwpls pghwzdhks―  Pgcgpdhks olppgsrlmhêmodks) gedxdhks rgik HKXKRPGS g owsxgkhks rgil DM__) clpke  \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole `ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg ;4,;0,0223- K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7- Rën- ;,82

Upload: eduardomilitao

Post on 04-Apr-2018

224 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 1/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

OIK__G : >?22 ‟ KÎÏL HG DERPL@DHKHG KHEDMD_XPKXDSKRPLOG__L : >62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822KWXLP : EDMD_XÄPDL RÚ@IDOL CGHGPKIPÄW_ : IWDZ DMËODL IWIK HK _DISK g KEDP CPKMOD_OL IKMHL

_GMXGMÎK

D%PGIKXßPDL

L EDMD_XÄPDL RÚ@IDOL CGHGPKI kjwåzk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg

khedmdsxpkxdk olmxpk IWDZ DMËODL IWIK HK _DISK g KEDP CPKMOD_OL IKMHL)

pgsrgoxdkegmxg) gv%Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok g gv%Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki) xgmhlrlp l`jgxl ls sgnwdmxgs ckxls) kssde mkppkhls mk dmdodki:

’K rpgsgmxg kîïl xge rlp l`jgxl k derlsdîïl hg skmî÷gs odds%khedmdsxpkxdks kl rpdegdpl pg{wgpdhl &gv%Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok$ g k olmhgmkîïl hg ke`ls ls pg{wgpdhlskls pgsskpodegmxl hls rpgjwåzls okwskhls kl gpëpdl) ge pkzïl hk rpëxdok hg kxl hgderpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) olmsdsxgmxg ml gmdl dppgnwikp hg olppgsrlmhêmodks kls

 sgnwpkhls hl DM__) kxpkäs hks {wkds dmclpekke sl`pg k rlssd`didhkhg hg l`xgmîïl hggerpäsxdels olmsdnmkhls ole xkvks hg jwpls pghwzdhks―

 Pgcgpdhks olppgsrlmhêmodks) gedxdhks rgik HKXKRPGS g owsxgkhks rgil DM__) clpke \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;,82

Page 2: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 2/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

kssdmkhks rgil gmxïl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok g rgil gmxïl Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk) Iwdz Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik g Kedp Cpkmodsol Ikmhl) pgsrgoxdkegmxg) ge xlxki hgspgsrgdxl kl kpx-?>) ® ;º) hk OC) g sge {wg flwgssg kmwêmodk hl DM__ lw dmxgpgssg rú`idol mk hdwinkîïlhk{wgiks dmclpekî÷gs) hk clpek olel clpk cgdxk-

 K derlsdîïl hks skmî÷gs hgsopdxks mk Igd mº 6-804,40 g l pgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl sïldergpdlsls) xgmhl ge dsxk ks dppgnwikpdhkhgs rpkxdokhks rgil gv%Rpgsdhgmxg Iwik g rgil gv%

 Edmdsxpl Kedp Ikmhl) ml gvgpoåodl hg swks kxpd`wdî÷gs) olmclpeg sgpë hgelmsxpkhl-― &ci-

28$

_wsxgmxk l Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki {wg ls pg{wgpdhls olegxgpke) ml

gvgpoåodl hg swks kxpd`wdî÷gs) k`wsls {wg gmsgjkpdke k kridokîïl hks rgmkidhkhgs hl kpx-

;0) hk Igd 6-804,40-

Hgsxkok l jwinkegmxl hk Pgoikekîïl mº 0-;?6) mk {wki l _wrpgel Xpd`wmki

Cghgpki gmxgmhgw {wg ls kngmxgs rliåxdols sgpdke sw`egxdhls k pgndeg gsrgodki hg

pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl) lw sgjk) pgsrlmhgpdke rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg xdrdcdokhl rgik Igd;-2>4,72) {wg gmogppk hgidxls hg okpëxgp rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdl g) hgsxk clpek) mïl ifgs

sgpdke kridokhk k Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk) pgsxpdxk âs dmcpkî÷gs rpkxdokhks rlp 

kngmxgs rliåxdols olewms-

 Kignk) gmxpgxkmxl) {wg k{wgig gmxgmhdegmxl) rkpk kiäe hg mïl xgp gcgdxl

dmowikmxg mge gcdoëodk gpnk lemgs) mïl ekds pgrpgsgmxkpdk k kxwki rlsdîïl hl _wrpgel

Xpd`wmki Cghgpki) hl _wrgpdlp Xpd`wmki hg Jwsxdîk g hls Xpd`wmkds Pgndlmkds Cghgpkds

sl pg l xgek- Xki ewhkmîk hg gmxgmhdegmxl hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki gsxkpdkgdowikhk mk Rgxdîïl ?-40?,_R) owjl jwinkegmxl clpk pgkidzkhl ml egsel hdk hk{wgig hk

Pgoikekîïl mº 0-;?6-

_l`pg k kridokîïl hk Igd 6-804,40 kls pg{wgpdhls) kpnwegmxlw:

---ok`g hgelmsxpkp {wg k xgsg hg {wg ls kngmxgs rliåxdols mïl sg sw`egxge kl pgndeg jwpåhdol hk derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) skil egiflp jwåzl) mïl gmolmxpk pgsrkihl mk

Olmsxdxwdîïl hk Pgrú`idok g ) rlp dssl egsel) mïl rlhg sgp kogdxk-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 0,82

Page 3: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 3/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

L`sgpg%sg) gmxïl) {wg l kpnwegmxl ogmxpki hls hgcgmslpgs hk xgsg hg {wg lskngmxgs rliåxdols mïl sg sw`egxge â rwmdîïl rlp derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk sgpdk wek

 swrlsxk hdsxdmîïl) ml sdsxgek olmsxdxwodlmki `pksdigdpl) gmxpg l pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhghls kngmxgs rliåxdols g l pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg hls hgekds kngmxgs rú`idols- Rkpk xkds

 jwpdsxks) pgcgpdhk hdsxdmîïl hgolppgpdk hg wek gsrgodkidhkhg hls kngmxgs rliåxdols gepgikîïl kls hgekds sgpdhlpgs- Kssde) xpkxkmhl%sg hg kngmxgs gsrgodkds) k pgsrlmsk`didzkîïlhls egsels hggpdk sgp pgkidzkhk hg kolphl ole xkds gsrgodcdodhkhgs- Kignke) kdmhk) {wg ämgogssëpdl rpgsgpkp "k dmhdsrgmsëgi id`gphkhg hg kîïl g hg hgodsïl hls kngmxgs {wg hïllz â sl`gpkmdk hk mkîïl"-&ci- ;;$

Hk Hgsopdîïl hls ckxls kxpd`wåhls kls pg{wgpdhls

L Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki kssde hgxkiflw k olmhwxk hls pg{wgpdhls:

’Ge lwxw`pl hg 0228) cld dmsxkwpkhl rgpkmxg gsxk Rplowpkhlpdk hk Pgrú`idok l Rploghdegmxl Khedmdsxpkxdl mº ;-;3-222-22;3>0,0228%74) owjls kwxls k`pdnke) hgmxpglwxpls hlowegmxls) oÿrdks hls rplogssls hl Xpd`wmki hg Olmxks hk Wmdïl XO mº 2;0-3??,0227%6 g XO mº 2;8-0>3,0227%0- L rpdegdpl xgg k cdmkidhkhg gpdcdokp k

pgnwikpdhkhg hks olmxpkxkî÷gs mk ëpgk hg rw`idodhkhg) rplrknkmhk) olmswixlpdk) `gms g sgpdîls hg dmclpeëxdok g xgpogdpdzkîïl hk gerpgsk HKXKRPGS g l sgnwmhl kmkidslw kpgnwikpdhkhg hg olmêmdls ogig`pkhls gmxpg l DM__ g dmsxdxwdî÷gs cdmkmogdpks-

Olmclpeg krwplw l XOW mls kwxls hl XO 2;0-3??,0227%6) ge 04,24,0228) l Ofgcghg Nk`dmgxg hl Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki hdpdndw kl gmxïl Rpgsdhgmxg hk HKXKRPGS lcåodl rlp egdl hl {wki slidodxkk {wg clssge khlxkhks ks rpldhêmodks mgogssëpdks klgmokedmfkegmxl hg okpxk kssdmkhk rgil Rpgsdhgmxg Iwik g rgil Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk kxlhls ls sgnwpkhls hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki- Ge kmgvl) gmolmxpk%sg l lpdndmki hk sgnwdmxgokpxk:

‖@pksåidk) 04 hg sgxge`pl hg 0228Okpl&k$ sgnwpkhl&k$ hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki)

 Ge ekdl rksskhl) l Nlgpml Cghgpki gmokedmflw kl Olmnpgssl we Rpljgxl hg Igd rkpk rgpedxdp kls krlsgmxkhls g rgmsdlmdsxks hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki kogssl k idmfks hgopähdxl ole xkvks hg jwpls pghwzdhks-

 Knlpk) l Igndsikxdl krpllw l rpljgxl g kok`kels hg skmodlmë%il- Ole dssl) loê gedif÷gs hg lwxpls `gmgcdodëpdl&ks$ rksske k xgp l hdpgdxl hg l`xgp gerpäsxdels owjl kilp hk

 rpgsxkîïl rlhg sgp hg kxä ?2' hl sgw `gmgcåodl egmski- Sloê rlhgpë rknkp l gerpäsxdelole jwpls gmxpg ;)>7' g 0)4' kl eês-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?,82

Page 4: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 4/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 Gsrgpkels {wg gssk eghdhk rlssk kjwhë%il&k$ k kxgmhgp egiflp âs swks mgogssdhkhgshl hdk%k%hdk- Rlp egdl hg kî÷gs olel gsxk) l Nlgpml {wgp olmsxpwdp wek Rpgdhêmodk_lodki ekds fwekmk) jwsxk g hgelopëxdok- Kcdmki) k Rpgdhêmodk ä swk+

 Iwdz Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik

 Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok

 Kedp Cpkmodsol Ikmhl

 Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki—&cis- ;8,;7$

&---$

 Hl {wkmxl krwpkhl) pgsxk gdhgmxg {wg l gv%Rpgsdhgmxg Iwik g l gv%Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk) Kedp Ikmhl) krplgdxkpke%sg hks rlsdî÷gs {wg lowrkke rkpk olegxgp kxlsdiåodxls ge `gmgcdodl rpÿrpdl &rplelîïl rgsslki) olmhwxk ghkhk rgik Olmsxdxwdîïl

 Cghgpki$) {wg) rlp swk mkxwpgzk) olmcdnwpke kxls hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk {wgokwskpke rpgjwåzls kl gpëpdl) odpowmsxàmodk {wg ckz gm{wkhpkp ks olmhwxks ml kpx- ;2) okrwx 

g dmodsl VD) hk Igd 6-804,40-_gws kxls hgelmsxpke) kdmhk) dmg{wålol hgspgsrgdxl â ignkidhkhg) â elpkidhkhg g â

dergsslkidhkhg) okpkoxgpdzkmhl%sg) dmgiwxkgiegmxg) xke`äe npkgs kxls hg derpl dhkhg mkelhkidhkhg kxgmxkxÿpdk kls rpdmoårdls hk khedmdsxpkîïl rú`idok) olmslkmxg rpgê l kpx- ;;)

okrwx g dmodsl D) hk Igd 6-804,40-

 Pgndsxpg%sg {wg k hdsrlsdîïl hg rpkxdokp ls ckxls gpk dmg{wålok) wek gz {wg ke`lsls pg{wdsdxls gvkpkpke swks kssdmkxwpks ml xgvxl hk okpxk lpk ole`kxdhk- Rlp swk gz) khdsrlsdîïl ge derlp kl gpëpdl &ml oksl) kl DM__$ hkml mk oksk hls edif÷gs gpk dnwkiegmxgdmkppghëgi) jë {wg) ge`lpk mïl fkgmhl olmxpkxl {wg `kidzkssg k{wgig sgpdîl) k sgp 

 rpgsxkhl rgik HKXKRPGS) `ksxlw {wg k lphge clssg hkhk rgil gmxïl Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk) {wg l`dkegmxg sgowmhkk hgsgjl hl gmxïl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) rkpk {wg

 clssg eldegmxkhk xlhk k eë{wdmk rú`idok ge xlpml hl kxl hg rplelîïl rgsslki- Dmgnëgi) rlpxkmxl) {wg ls ckxls mkppkhls olmsxdxwge) hl rlmxl hg dsxk l`jgxdl g

 sw`jgxdl) kxls hg derpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) k sgpge skmodlmkhls mk clpek hk Igd m²

6804,40- &cis- ?;,?0$

&---$

_woghg {wg) hk igdxwpk hk okpxk gmdkhk kls sgnwpkhls hl DM__) kssdmkhk rgil gmxïl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok g rgil gmxïl Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk) rgpog`g%sg k oikpk dmxgmîïlhg sg kikphgkp olm{wdsxk l`xdhk npkîks â mlk ngsxïl hk Rpgsdhêmodk hk Pgrú`idok) olel sg

 rlhg mlxkp rgik egmîïl â "eghdhk {wg rlssk kjwhë%il&k$ k kxgmhgp egiflp âs mgogssdhkhgshl hdk%k%hdk" g rgik måxdhk pgcgpêmodk kl rikml hl Nlgpml) rgpslmdcdokhl mks cdnwpks hls

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 8,82

Page 5: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 5/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 sw`sopdxlpgs hk okpxk) hg "olmsxpwdp wek Rpgdhêmodk _lodki ekds fwekmk) jwsxk ghgelopëxdok"-

 Gssgs xpgofls gdhgmodke l rplrÿsdxl hg rw`idodhkhg % ml sgmxdhl hg rplrknkmhk % hl cgdxl hg Iwik g hg Kedp Ikmhl) {wki sgjk) k krplkîïl hg eghdhk {wg rgpedxdpdk kls sgnwpkhls hl DM__ pgkidzkp gerpäsxdels olmsdnmkhls k jwpls pghwzdhls) l {wg) kls lifls hlhgsxdmkxëpdl hk olppgsrlmhêmodk) hggpdk sgp gmxgmhdhl olel: "xgmfl we rpgsdhgmxg g weedmdsxpl {wg sg derlpxke olednl) {wg {wgpge eg kjwhkp ole ks mgogssdhkhgs hl hdk%k%hdk)

{wg iwxke rlp wek Rpgdhêmodk ekds fwekmk) jwsxk g hgelopëxdok"-Olel olpliëpdl hl rpdmoårdl hk dergsslkidhkhg) k hdwinkîïl hls kxls

khedmdsxpkxdls hgg sg lpdgmxkp rgik derwxkîïl hls egsels â Khedmdsxpkîïl) jkekds klslowrkmxgs hls okpnls mgik dmsgpdhls- Gmcl{wg hdcgpgmxg mgssk {wgsxïl slegmxg rlhgpë sgp hkhl ge sghg hg rplogssl gigdxlpki) ml {wki ä iåodxl kl nlgpmkmxg%okmhdhkxl rplrknkp swkskmxkngms g pgkidzkî÷gs- &ci- ??$

&---$ Dm oksw) gsxë rigmkegmxg gdhgmodkhl l hgsdl hg cdmkidhkhg mks olppgsrlmhêmodks

gmdkhks rgils pg{wgpdhls) wek gz {wg) ge`lpk kiwhke k xgek hg dmxgpgssg slodki) olmxêegigegmxls ghkhls) k gvgeril hk gvriåodxk egmîïl hl mleg hks kwxlpdhkhgs) ge xgsg)

pgsrlmsëgds rgil kikphgkhl mk okpxk) {wg) mk gsxgdpk hk egiflp hlwxpdmk g hk jwpdsrpwhêmodk) mïl sdnmdcdok lwxpk oldsk sgmïl rplelîïl rgsslki- &ci- 80$

&---$

Lpk) mïl fë {wg sg hdsowxdp l ciknpkmxg hkml kl gpëpdl) ml elmxkmxg hg ekds hg mlgedif÷gs g egdl hg pgkds &P( 4-703-2>2)78$) owsxl krwpkhl rgil XOW olppgsrlmhgmxg â

 ngpkîïl g derpgssïl hks okpxks g k rlsxknge hg rkpxg hgiks rgils Olppgdls- &cis- 8>$

&---$

 Rgik igdxwpk hl okrwx hl kpxdnl ;2 hk Igd 6-804,40) rkpk {wg fkjk sw`swmîïl hl ckxl â

mlpek) ä derpgsodmhågi {wg k olmhwxk hl kngmxg rú`idol) kdmhk {wg sgjk ledssk) hlilsk lwowirlsk) kokppgxg gcgxdl rpgjwåzl kl gpëpdl) okwskmhl%ifg igsïl-

Lpk) l nksxl hg ekds hg mlg edif÷gs hg pgkds rkpk rplhwîïl g gmdl hgolppgsrlmhêmodk) kls sgnwpkhls hl DM__) {wg mkhk xge k gp ole ks cdmkidhkhgs hk{wgikkwxkp{wdk g {wg dskk xïl slegmxg â  rplelîïl rgsslki hl gv%Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok g hlgv%Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk g kl cklpgodegmxl hl @kmol @EN) okwslw gdhgmxg rpgjwåzlkls olcpgs hl DM__-

Ls kxls rpkxdokhls rgils pg{wgpdhls olmsxdxwge dnwkiegmxg derpl dhkhgkhedmdsxpkxdk mk elhkidhkhg kxgmxkxÿpdk kls rpdmoårdls hk khedmdsxpkîïl rú idok)olmslkmxg rpgê l kpx- ;;) hk Igd 6-804,40: &ci- 77$

&---$ \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 7,82

Page 6: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 6/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

Lpk) ls swjgdxls rkssdls hk rpgsgmxg kîïl oddi rú`idok dlikpke) hg clpek olmsodgmxgg liwmxëpdk) ls rpdmoårdls g pgnpks {wg pgnge k kxwkîïl hl kngmxg rú`idol) mlxkhkegmxgk{wgigs dmsgpxls ml okrwx hl kpxdnl ?> hk Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki g ml kpx- 8² hk Igd hg

 Derpl`dhkhg) k sk`gp:&73,7>$

 Kopgsogmxl {wg cld pg{wgpdhk k olmogssïl hg eghdhk idedmkp 

olmsw`sxkmodkhk mk hgopgxkîïl) hg clpek slidhëpdk) hk dmhdsrlmd`didhkhg hg `gms hlspg{wgpdhls ml elmxkmxg hg P( 4-703-2>2)78 &mlg edif÷gs) {wdmfgmxls g dmxg g sgds

edi) sgxgmxk pgkds g odm{wgmxk g {wkxpl ogmxkls$) dskmhl kssgnwpkp l pgswixkhl

rpëxdol hg ggmxwki pgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl okwskhl rgil swrlsxl kxl hg derpl`dhkhg

khedmdsxpkxdk) sl` l kpnwegmxl hg {wg k olmogssïl hk eghdhk kssgowpkxÿpdk mïl gvdndpdk

k ogpxgzk hg {wg ls päws hdikrdhkpdke lw lowixkpdke l rpÿrpdl rkxpdeømdl rkpk cwndp â

l`pdnkîïl hg pgsskpodp kl gpëpdl) rpgkigogmhl) ml oksl) l rpdmoårdl dm hw`dl rpl slodgxkxg-

&cis- 32,38$-

Cdmkiegmxg) l Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki clpewilw rghdhls) mls sgnwdmxgs

xgpels:

k$ l pgog`degmxl g k kwxwkîïl hk rpgsgmxg hgekmhk) kolerkmfkhk hls kwxls rpdmodrkds hl Dm{wäpdxl Oddi Rú`idol ERC,RP%HC mº ;-;3-222-22;3>0,0228%74 &20 liwegs$) ole lspgsrgoxdls hlowegmxls kmgvls &2? liwegs krgmsls$) ls {wkds pg{wgpgels sgjke jwmxkhls

 rlp idmfk kls kwxls rpdmodrkds) k cde hg ckodidxkp l rplogsskegmxl hgsxk kîïl hgderpl`dhkhg1

`$ sgjk olmoghdhk eghdhk IDEDMKP) dmkwhdxk kixgpk rkps) rkpk xlpmkp dmhdsrlmågds xkmxls

`gms hg ke`ls ls pg{wgpdhls {wkmxls `ksxge rkpk kssgnwpkp l cwxwpl pgsskpodegmxl hlshkmls okwskhls kl gpëpdl) ml elmxkmxg hg P( 4-703-2>2)78 &mlg edif÷gs) {wdmfgmxls gdmxg g sgds edi) sgxgmxk pgkds g odm{wgmxk g {wkxpl ogmxkls$) hggmhl%sg) rkpk xkmxl) lcdodkp &d$ ls Okpxÿpdls hg Pgndsxpl hg Deÿgds hl HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI g hks odhkhgs hg _ÏL

 RKWIL%_R) _ÏL @GPMKPHL HL OKERL%_R) RLPXL SGIFL%PL g RLPXL KIGNPG% P_) rkpk {wg rploghke kl `il{wgdl hls `gms deÿgds gvdsxgmxgs ge mleg hls pg{wgpdhls)hgxgpedmkmhl%sg k swsrgmsïl hg xlhl g {wki{wgp kxl hdpdndhl â kidgmkîïl hg xkds `gms)

 swsxkmhl%sg ggmxwkds kidgmkî÷gs {wg jë xgmfke sdhl olmopgxdzkhks ge cklp hg xgpogdpls1&dd$ l @KMOL OGMXPKI HL @PK_DI) rkpk {wg olewmd{wg k xlhks ks dmsxdxwdî÷gs

 cdmkmogdpks) rgil sdsxgek @KOGMJWH) k dmhdsrlmd`didhkhg g `il{wgdl hg xlhls ls kxdls cdmkmogdpls &kridokî÷gs cdmkmogdpks hg xlhks ks gsräodgs$ hls pg{wgpdhls g hgxgpedmg âs

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 3,82

Page 7: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 7/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 Dmsxdxwdî÷gs @kmoëpdks l gmdl hg dmclpekî÷gs olmslidhkhks sl`pg xlhks olmxks olppgmxgs gkridokî÷gs gvdsxgmxgs sl` k xdxwikpdhkhg hg okhk we hls pg{wgpdhls) hg elhl k rgpedxdp {wggssg h- Jwåzl xgmfk olmfgodegmxl hl liweg dmxgnpki hg pgowpsls cdmkmogdpls ilokidzkhls gemleg hls päws) rgsslks cåsdoks g jwpåhdok1 &ddd$ k OLERKMFDK @PK_DIGDPK HG 

 ID[WDHKÎÏL G OW_XßHDK % O@IO) hgxgpedmkmhl {wg gssk gmxdhkhg olewmd{wg k xlhksks olppgxlpks g hgekds gmxdhkhgs kwxlpdzkhks k kxwkp ml egpokhl kodlmëpdl kdmhdsrlmd`didhkhg hg xlhks ks kî÷gs hg xdxwikpdhkhg hls pg{wgpdhls1 &ddd$ ls Hgrkpxkegmxls

 Gsxkhwkds hg Xpàmsdxl hl HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI) hg _ÏL RKWIL) hg PLMHØMDK g hl PDLNPKMHG HL _WI &HGXPKM%HC) HGXPKM%_R) HGXPKM%PL G HGXPKM%P_$ rkpk {wgdmclpege k rplrpdghkhg hg gåowils ge mleg hls pg{wgpdhls) hgxgpedmkmhl%sg kls pgcgpdhlsÿpnïls {wg mïl pgndsxpge {wkds{wgp kxls hg xpkmscgpêmodk hg xkds `gms-

o$ k mlxdcdokîïl hls pg{wgpdhls IWDZ DMËODL IWIK HK _DISK g KEDP CPKM_OD_OL IKMHL) rkpk ekmdcgsxkîïl rpgidedmkp) mls xgpels hl kpx- ;>) ® >²) hk Igd 6-804,401

h$ l pgog`degmxl hgsxk kîïl) mls xgpels hl kpx- ;>) ® 6²) hk Igd m² 6-804,401

g$ k odxkîïl hls pg{wgpdhls) rkpk) {wgpgmhl) pgsrlmhgp â rpgsgmxg kîïl1

 c$ k rplhwîïl hg xlhks ks rplks khedssågds ge hdpgdxl) dmoiwsdg k xgsxgewmfki g

 jwmxkhk rlsxgpdlp hg hlowegmxls1

 n$ k olmhgmkîïl hl pg{wgpdhl IWDZ DMËODL IWIK HK _DISK âs skmî÷gs olmsxkmxgs hl kpx-;0) hk Igd m² 6-804,40) rgik rpëxdok hls kxls hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk rpgdsxls ml kpx-;2) okrwx g dmodsl VD g kpx- ;;) okrwx g dmodsl D) hl egsel hdrilek mlpekxdl) sgnwmhl k

 npkdhkhg hls ckxls) k sgp rpwhgmxgegmxg krpgodkhk rlp gssg Jwåzl1

f$ k olmhgmkîïl hl pg{wgpdhl KEDP CPKM_OD_OL IKMHL kl pgsskpodegmxl hls hkmlsokwskhls kl gpëpdl &kpx- ;0) ;; g ;;;) rpdegdpk cdnwpk) hk Igd mº 6804,40$) ge pkzïl hg swkpgsrlmsk didhkhg rgiks olmhwxks hgidmgkhks mgsxk kîïl) {wg olmcdnwpke kxls hgderpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk rpgdsxls ml kpx- ;2) okrwx g dmodsl VD g kpx- ;;) okrwx g dmodsl

 D) hl egsel hdrilek mlpekxdl-

 K hgcgsk hg IWDZ DMËODL IWIK HK _DISK) krpgsgmxkhk rgik Wmdïl) âs cis-

63,;?6) ole cwmhkegmxl ml kpx- 00) okrwx g ®;º) hk Igd mº 4-206,47 ) kignlw ks

sgnwdmxgs rpgidedmkpgs:

?-;-Gppl rploghdegmxki- Owewikîïl hg rghdhls dmolerkxågds- Kîïl hg

pgsskpodegmxl hgg%sg hkp rlp dk kwxømlek1

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- >,82

Page 8: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 8/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

?-0-Derlssd`didhkhg hg sw`swmîïl hk olmhwxk k ekds hg wek cdnwpk xårdok1

?-?-Derlssd didhkhg jwpåhdok hl rghdhl- Dmkhg{wkîïl hk dk gigdxk- Hk

dmkridok`didhkhg hk igd hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk kls kngmxgs rliåxdols1

?-8- Kixgpmkxdkegmxg) hk Dmolergxêmodk k`sliwxk hl Jwåzl hg ;ª Dmsxàmodk-

Rpgpplnkxdk hg Clpl1

?-7-Digndxdedhkhg rkssdk hl Pg{wgpdhl Iwdz Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik1

?-3- Rpgsopdîïl1

?->- Rpgjwhdodkidhkhg hk rpgsgmxg hgekmhk ge pgikîïl â KHD 8047,HC) kjwdzkhk

rgil Rkpxdhl hk El didzkîïl Mkodlmki ‟ REM- Mgogssdhkhg hg swsrgmsïl hl

rplogssl-

Ml eäpdxl) swsxgmxlw:

;$ Dmgvdsxêmodk hl dmxgmxl hg sg kwxlrplelgp mk gvrghdîïl hk olppgsrlmhêmodk

kls sgnwpkhls hk Rpgdhêmodk _lodki- Okpëxgp Dmclpekxdl hk Edssdk-

0$ Kwsêmodk hg hlowegmxkîïl olerpl`kxÿpdk hk lolppêmodk hl swrlsxl kxl hg

derpl`dhkhg- Dmgvdsxêmodk hg mgvl okwski gmxpg k gvrghdîïl hks okpxks g lskignkhls hkmls kl gpëpdl- Ls koÿphïls hl XOW {wg ge`kskpke l

kjwdzkegmxl hk kîïl mïl krlmxke k lolppêmodk hg kxl hg derpl`dhkhg) kl

olmxpëpdl) kcksxke {wki{wgp pgsrlmsk`didhkhg hl pg{wgpdhl-

?$ Kwsêmodk hg hlil mk olmhwxk krlmxkhk- Derlssd`didhkhg hg Olegxdegmxl hg

kxl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk owirlsl-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 6,82

Page 9: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 9/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

8$ L ERC mïl rpllw {wg l pg{wgpdhl kwcgpdw kmxknge ole l gmdl hks

olppgsrlmhêmodks1

L sgnwmhl pg{wgpdhl) Kedp Cpkmodsol Ikmhl) krgmskp hg hgdhkegmxg

mlxdcdokhl) olmclpeg ogpxdhïl hg ci- ;87%gpsl) mïl lcgpgogw ekmdcgsxkîïl rlp gsopdxl-

Flwg päridok &cis- ;32,;48$-

Ä l pgikxÿpdl-

DD% CWMHKEGMXKÎÏL

Ge {wg rgsg k lphge hks rpgidedmkpgs kpnwdhks rgik hgcgsk hg Iwdz Dmëodl

Iwik hk _dik) k{wgik pgikxdk â olergxêmodk hgsxg jwåzl hgg sgp kmkidskhk ole

rpgoghêmodk-

Hgsxkol {wg k mlxåodk hg gvdsxêmodk hg Kîïl Hdpgxk hg Dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg

mº 8-047,HC {wgsxdlmkmhl k Igd 6-804,40 mïl olmsxdxwd okwsk hg swsrgmsïl hl rpgsgmxg

rplogssl) rpgdsxk ml kpx- 037) DS) ’k―) hl ORO) ge ckog hk rpgswmîïl hg

olmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg hg {wg nlzke ks igds-

 K Igd mº ;2-306,20 cgz ks sgnwdmxgs kixgpkî÷gs ml Oÿhdnl hg Rplogssl

Rgmki) gsxgmhgmhl k rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl) xke`äe rkpk k kîïl hg derpl dhkhg

khedmdsxpkxdk) egsel krÿs k ogsskîïl hl ekmhkxl:

 Kpx- 68- K olergxêmodk rgik rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl ä hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki) hl_wrgpdlp Xpd`wmki hg Jwsxdîk) hls Xpd`wmkds Pgndlmkds Cghgpkds g Xpd`wmkds hg Jwsxdîk hls

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 4,82

Page 10: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 10/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 Gsxkhls g hl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki) pgikxdkegmxg âs rgsslks {wg hgke pgsrlmhgp rgpkmxg gigs rlp opdegs olewms g hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- &Pghkîïl hkhk rgik Igd mº ;2-306) hg 08-;0-0220$

 ® ;l K olergxêmodk gsrgodki rlp rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl) pgikxdk k kxls khedmdsxpkxdls hlkngmxg) rpgkigog kdmhk {wg l dm{wäpdxl lw k kîïl jwhdodki sgjke dmdodkhls krÿs k ogsskîïlhl gvgpoåodl hk cwmîïl rú`idok- &Dmoiwåhl rgik Igd mº ;2-306) hg 08-;0-0220$ &Sdhg KHDM mº  0>4>$ 

 ® 0l K kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg) hg {wg xpkxk k  Igd ml 6-804) hg 0 hg jwmfl hg ;440) sgpë rplrlsxk rgpkmxg l xpd`wmki olergxgmxg rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp opdedmkiegmxg l cwmodlmëpdllw kwxlpdhkhg mk fdrÿxgsg hg rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl ge pkzïl hl gvgpoåodl hg cwmîïl rú`idok)l`sgpkhl l hdsrlsxl ml ® ;l- &Dmoiwåhl rgik Igd mº ;2-306) hg 08-;0-0220$ &Sdhg KHDM mº 0>4>$

Xki kixgpkî÷gs) ml gmxkmxl) clpke pgxdpkhks hl lphgmkegmxl jwpåhdol ge

pkzïl hl pgolmfgodegmxl hg swk dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg ml jwinkegmxl hk KHD 0>4>) {wg

pgsxlw kssde gegmxkhk:

GEGMXK: D- KHDm: igndxdedhkhg kxdk: "gmxdhkhg hg oikssg hg àe`dxl mkodlmki" &kpx- ;2?) DV)OC$: Ksslodkîïl Mkodlmki hls Ege`pls hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol % OLMKER ;- Kl jwinkp) kKHDm ?;7?%KnP) ;0-26-28) Rgpxgmog) Dmc _XC ?73) l rigmëpdl hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmkik`kmhlmlw l gmxgmhdegmxl {wg gvoiwåk ks gmxdhkhgs hg oikssg hg sgnwmhl npkw % ks ofkekhks"ksslodkî÷gs hg ksslodkî÷gs" % hl pli hls igndxdekhls â kîïl hdpgxk- 0- Hg {wki{wgp slpxg) mlmll gsxkxwxl hk OLMKER % knlpk Ksslodkîïl Mkodlmki hls Ege`pls hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol% k {wkidhkhg hg "ksslodkhls gcgxdls" cdolw khsxpdxk âs rgsslks cåsdoks dmxgnpkmxgs hkokxgnlpdk) % l {wg `ksxk k skxdsckzgp k jwpdsrpwhêmodk pgsxpdxdk%) kdmhk {wg l gsxkxwxl pgsgpgâs ksslodkî÷gs kcdidkhks rkrgi pgigkmxg mk ngsxïl hk gmxdhkhg mkodlmki- DD- KHDm: rgpxdmêmodk

xgeëxdok- Rpgsgmîk hk pgikîïl hg rgpxdmêmodk xgeëxdok gmxpg k cdmkidhkhg dmsxdxwodlmki hks hwksgmxdhkhgs pg{wgpgmxgs g ls hdsrlsdxdls ignkds derwnmkhls: ks mlpeks ignkds {wgsxdlmkhks sgpgcigxge mk hdsxpd wdîïl gpxdoki hg olergxêmodk cwmodlmki gmxpg ls ÿpnïls hl Rlhgp Jwhdodëpdl % g) ge olmsg{ùêmodk) gmxpg ls hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol - DDD- Clpl gsrgodki rlp  rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl: gvxgmsïl) ml xgerl) kl elegmxl rlsxgpdlp â ogsskîïl hk dmgsxdhwpkmk cwmîïl hgig hgxgpedmkmxg- _úewik ?48,_XC &okmogikegmxl rgil _wrpgel Xpd`wmkiCghgpki$- Igd ;2-306,0220) {wg kopgsogmxlw ls ®® ;º g 0º kl kpxdnl 68 hl O- Rplogssl Rgmki: rpgxgmsïl dmkhedssågi hg dmxgprpgxkîïl kwxêmxdok hk Olmsxdxwdîïl rlp igd lphdmëpdk gwswprkîïl hk olergxêmodk hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki rkpk dmxgprpgxkp k Olmsxdxwdîïl:dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg hgoikpkhk- ;- L mll ® ;º hl kpx- 68 ORpRgm olmsxdxwd gdhgmxg pgkîïligndsikxdk kl okmogikegmxl hk _úewik ?48 rlp hgodsïl xlekhk rgil _wrpgel Xpd`wmki ml

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;2,82

Page 11: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 11/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

Dm{ 36>%[L) 07-6-4>) pgi- l ge- Edmdsxpl _thmgt _kmofgs &PXJ ;>4,4;0$) owjls cwmhkegmxlsk igd mlk olmxpkpdk dmg{wdlokegmxg- 0- Xkmxl k _úewik ?48) olel k hgodsïl hl _wrpgelXpd`wmki) {wg k okmogilw) hgpdkpke hg dmxgprpgxkîïl hdpgxk g gvoiwsdk hk OlmsxdxwdîïlCghgpki- ?- Mïl rlhg k igd lphdmëpdk rpgxgmhgp derlp) olel sgw l`jgxl deghdkxl) wekdmxgprpgxkîïl hk Olmsxdxwdîïl: k {wgsxïl ä hg dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg clpeki) åmsdxk k xlhkmlpek hg npkhkîïl dmcgpdlp {wg sg rplrlmfk k hdxkp dmxgprpgxkîïl hk mlpek hg fdgpkp{wdkswrgpdlp- 8- [wkmhl) kl åodl hg dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg clpeki) k igd dmxgprpgxkxdk hkOlmsxdxwdîïl kopgsîk l hg lrlp%sg kl gmxgmhdegmxl hk jwpdsrpwhêmodk olmsxdxwodlmki hl_wrpgel Xpd`wmki % nwkphk hk Olmsxdxwdîïl %) âs pkz÷gs hlneëxdoks kogmxwkhks sg der÷ge klXpd`wmki pkz÷gs hg kixk rliåxdok dmsxdxwodlmki rkpk pgrgidp k wswprkîïl rgil igndsikhlp hg swkedssïl hg dmxäprpgxg cdmki hk Igd Cwmhkegmxki: khedxdp rwhgssg k igd lphdmëpdk dmgpxgp kigdxwpk rgil _wrpgel Xpd`wmki hk Olmsxdxwdîïl sgpdk hdzgp {wg k dmxgprpgxkîïl olmsxdxwodlmkihk Olpxg gsxkpdk swjgdxk kl pgcgpgmhl hl igndsikhlp) lw sgjk) {wg k Olmsxdxwdîïl % olelgmxgmhdhk rgil ÿpnïl {wg gik rpÿrpdk gpdndw ge nwkphk hk swk swrpgekodk %) sÿ olmsxdxwdpdk lolppgxl gmxgmhdegmxl hk Igd _wrpgek mk eghdhk hk dmxgidnêmodk {wg ifg hgssg lwxpl ÿpnïlolmsxdxwåhl) l igndsikhlp lphdmëpdl) kl olmxpëpdl) sw`egxdhl kls sgws hdxkegs- 7-Dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg hl ® ;º hl kpx- 68 O-Rp-Rgmki) kopgsodhl rgik igd {wgsxdlmkhk g) rlpkppksxkegmxl) hk pgnpk cdmki hl ® 0º hl egsel kpxdnl) {wg ekmhk gsxgmhgp k pgnpk âkîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk- DS- Kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk: gvxgmsïl

hk olergxêmodk gsrgodki rlp rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl gsxk`gigodhk rkpk l rplogssl rgmkiolmhgmkxÿpdl olmxpk l egsel hdnmdxëpdl &® 0º hl kpx- 68 hl O Rp Rgmki dmxplhwzdhl rgikI- ;2-306,0220$: hgoikpkîïl) rlp igd) hg olergxêmodk lpdndmëpdk mïl rpgdsxk mkOlmsxdxwdîïl: dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg- ;- Ml rikml cghgpki) ks fdrÿxgsgs hg olergxêmodk oågilw opdedmki hls xpd`wmkds hk Wmdïl sïl ks rpgdsxks mk Olmsxdxwdîïl hk Pgrú`idok lw hgikderidodxkegmxg hgolppgmxgs) skil {wkmhl gsxk egsek pgegxk â igd k swk cdvkîïl- 0- Gsskgvoiwsddhkhg olmsxdxwodlmki hk clmxg hks olergxêmodks hls xpd`wmkds cghgpkds pgswixk) hgilnl) hg sgp k Jwsxdîk hk Wmdïl gsrgodki ge pgikîïl âs hls Gsxkhls) hgxgmxlpgs hg xlhk k jwpdshdîïl pgsdhwki- ?- Kopgsog {wg k olergxêmodk lpdndmëpdk hls Xpd`wmkds ä) rlp hgcdmdîïl)hgpplnkîïl hk olergxêmodk lphdmëpdk hls jwåzls hg rpdegdpl npkw) hl {wg hgolppg {wg)hgekpokhk k úixdek rgik Olmsxdxwdîïl) sÿ k rpÿrpdk Olmsxdxwdîïl k rlhg gvogxwkp- 8- Olelegpk gvridodxkîïl hg olergxêmodks lpdndmëpdks deriåodxks mk Igd Cwmhkegmxki) â hdsrlsdîïl

ignki ge okwsk sgpdke lrlmågds ks pkz÷gs jë kgmxkhks olmxpk k rpgxgmsïl hg derlsdîïl rlp igd lphdmëpdk hg wek hkhk dmxgprpgxkîïl olmsxdxwodlmki- 7- Hg lwxpl ikhl) rpgxgmhg k igd{wgsxdlmkhk g{wdrkpkp k kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) hg mkxwpgzk oddi &OC) kpx- ?>) ®8º$) â kîïl rgmki olmxpk ls ekds kixls hdnmdxëpdls hk Pgrú`idok) rkpk l cde hg gsxk`gigogp olergxêmodk lpdndmëpdk hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki) ge pgikîïl â {wki k jwpdsrpwhêmodk hl Xpd`wmkisgerpg gsxk`gigogw måxdhk hdsxdmîïl gmxpg ks hwks gsräodgs- 3- [wkmxl kls Xpd`wmkds ilokds) kOlmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki %skil ks fdrÿxgsgs hls sgws kpxs- 04) V g 43) DDD %) pgsgplwgvridodxkegmxg âs Olmsxdxwdî÷gs hls Gsxkhls%ege`pls k hgcdmdîïl hk olergxêmodk hls sgwsxpd`wmkds) l {wg kcksxk k rlssd`didhkhg hg sgp gik kixgpkhk rlp igd cghgpki lphdmëpdk- S- Kîïl hgderpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk g olergxêmodk olmsxdxwodlmki rkpk l jwinkegmxl hls opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg- ;- L ggmxwki kolifdegmxl hk xgsg hg {wg k olergxêmodk olmsxdxwodlmki

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;;,82

Page 12: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 12/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 rkpk jwinkp ls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg fkgpdk hg gsxgmhgp%sg kl rplogssl g jwinkegmxl hkkîïl hg derpl`dhkhg) kndxkhk mk Poi 0;?6) lpk rgmhgmxg hg jwinkegmxl ml _wrpgel Xpd`wmki)mïl rpgjwhdok mge ä rpgjwhdokhk rgik dmolmsxdxwodlmkidhkhg hl mll ® 0º hl kpx- 68 hlO-Rp-Rgmki- 0- K olergxêmodk lpdndmëpdk hls xpd`wmkds rkpk jwinkp opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg ä `ge ekds pgsxpdxk {wg k hg jwinkp kwxlpdhkhgs rlp opdegs olewms:kclpk l oksl hls ofgcgs hl Rlhgp Gvgowxdl % owjl dergkofegmx ä hk olergxêmodk hlsÿpnïls rliåxdols % k olndxkhk olergxêmodk hls xpd`wmkds mïl kiokmîkpdk) sg{wgp rlpdmxgnpkîïl kmkiÿndok) ls ege`pls hl Olmnpgssl Mkodlmki g hks lwxpks oksksigndsikxdks) kls {wkds) sgnwmhl k Olmsxdxwdîïl) mïl sg rlhg kxpd`wdp k rpëxdok hg opdegshg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- ?- Rlp lwxpl ikhl) kl olmxpëpdl hl {wg swoghg ole ls opdegs olewms) kpgnpk ä {wg ogssk k derwxk didhkhg rlp opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg ole l xgpel hkdmgsxdhwpk hl hdnmdxëpdl kowskhl- &KHD 0>4>) Pgikxlp&k$: Edm- _GRÚISGHK RGPXGMOG)Xpd`wmki Rigml) jwinkhl ge ;7,24,0227) HJ ;4%;0%0223 RR%222?> GEGMX SLI%2003;%20RR%22072$ ‟ &npdcgd$

 K dmolergxêmodk rkpk l jwinkegmxl hk rpgsgmxg kîïl hgg kdmhk sgp 

kmkidskhk sl` l rpdsek hl pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg k {wg gsxïl sw`egxdhls ls

kngmxgs rliåxdols) hdsowxdhl xkmxl mk hlwxpdmk {wkmxl mk jwpdsrpwhêmodk-

Hkmdgi Kelpde Ksswerîïl Mggs g Pkckgi Okpkifl Pgzgmhg Lidgdpk; 

krpgsgmxke pgswel hks rpdmodrkds olppgmxgs) {wkds sgjke:

’8-0-;-0-  Kngmxgs rliåxdols &ege`pls hls Rlhgpgs Gvgowxdl g Igndsikxdl$: Igd hg

 Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk g opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg

 Fë gmlpeg olmxpläpsdk hlwxpdmëpdk ge pgikîïl â olmogdxwkîïl hls kngmxgs rliåxdols) sgmhl rlssågi krlmxkp) rkpk cdms hdhëxdols) hlds npkmhgs gmxgmhdegmxls sl`pg l ksswmxl-

 Rpdegdpk rlsdîïl &olmogdxl keril$: kngmxgs rliåxdols sïl ls "olerlmgmxgs hlNlgpml mls sgws rpdegdpls gsoki÷gs") {wg kxwke ole dmhgrgmhêmodk cwmodlmki- Xkdskngmxgs rlsswge) mlpekiegmxg) ks swks cwmî÷gs hgidmgkhks mk Olmsxdxwdîïl g mïl sggmolmxpke sw`lphdmkhls kls hgekds kngmxgs) rlds lowrke ls ÿpnïls hg oúrwik &’ÿpnïlsdmhgrgmhgmxgs―$- Dmsgpge%sg mgsxg olmogdxl ls Ofgcgs hl Gvgowxdl &Rpgsdhgmxg hk

 Pgrú`idok) Nlgpmkhlpgs g Rpgcgdxls$) ls ege`pls hks Oksks Igndsikxdks &_gmkhlpgs) Hgrwxkhls g gpgkhlpgs$) ls ege`pls hl Rlhgp Jwhdodëpdl &ekndsxpkhls$) ege`pls hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol &Rplowpkhlpgs g Rplelxlpgs$ gxo-0 

; Dm Ekmwki hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk) Ghdxlpk Eäxlhl) _ïl Rkwil) r- 87,7?0EGDPGIIG_) Fgit Ilrgs- Hdpgdxl khedmdsxpkxdl `pksdigdpl- 00-gh) _ïl Rkwil: Ekifgdpls) ;44>- r- >0%>8- \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;0,82

Page 13: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 13/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 _gnwmhk rlsdîïl &olmogdxl pgsxpdxdl$: kngmxgs rliåxdols sïl k{wgigs {wg lowrke iloki hg hgsxk{wg mk gsxpwxwpk gsxkxki) pgsrlmsëgds rgjks hgods÷gs rliåxdoks cwmhkegmxkds hl

 Gsxkhl- Gssg ä l gmxgmhdegmxl ekjlpdxëpdl mk hlwxpdmk-?

 Hg kolphl ole l k olmogrîïl pgsxpdxdk) mïl `ksxk k rpgdsïl hg swks kxpd`wdî÷gs mlxgvxl olmsxdxwodlmki rkpk {wg ls kngmxgs sgjke olmsdhgpkhls olel rliåxdols- Kokpkoxgpdzkîïl hls kngmxgs  rliåxdols hgrgmhg) ge pgnpk) hl rpggmofdegmxl hg kinwmspg{wdsdxls) xkds olel: k$ l kogssl kl okpnl rliåxdol lolppg rlp egdl hg gigdîïl) olmcgpdmhl

ekdlp igndxdedhkhg hgelopëxdok rkpk l gvgpoåodl hg swks cwmî÷gs &ge kinwms oksls)hgxgpedmkhls kngmxgs rliåxdols mïl sgpïl dmgsxdhls rlp egdl hg gigdîïl) eks sgpïlmlegkhls rlp  kngmxgs gigdxls rkpk lowrkpge okpnls ge oledssïl) olel lolppg) rlp gvgeril) mk dmgsxdhwpk hls Edmdsxpls g _gopgxëpdls gsxkhwkds g ewmdodrkds {wg sïlmlegkhls rgils pgsrgoxdls Ofgcgs hl Gvgowxdl$1 `$ k cwmîïl rliåxdok rlsswd okpëxgp xpkmsdxÿpdl) xgmhl ge dsxk l rpdmoårdl pgrw`idokml) g sgpë gvgpodhk rlp rpkzl hgxgpedmkhl&ekmhkxl$1 g o$ ks hgods÷gs rliåxdoks cwmhkegmxkds hg Gsxkhl) okpkoxgpdzkhlpks hk cwmîïl

 rliåxdok) gmlige) rpdelphdkiegmxg) k kilokîïl hg pgowpsls lpîkegmxëpdls g l kxgmhdegmxl rpdlpdxëpdl hg hgxgpedmkhls hdpgdxls cwmhkegmxkds-

 K rkpxdp hl olmogdxl pgsxpdxdl g hks okpkoxgpåsxdoks rpdmodrkds hls kngmxgs rliåxdols)gpdcdok%sg {wg gssk okxgnlpdk hg kngmxgs k`pkmng ls Ofgcgs hl Gvgowxdl &Rpgsdhgmxg)Nlgpmkhlpgs g Rpgcgdxls$) ls sgws kwvdidkpgs &Edmdsxpls) _gopgxëpdls gsxkhwkds g _gopgxëpdls

ewmdodrkds$ g ls ege`pls hl Rlhgp Igndsikxdl &_gmkhlpgs) Hgrwxkhls g gpgkhlpgs$)gvoiwdmhl%sg hgssg olmogdxl) rlp gvgeril) ls ege`pls hl Rlhgp Jwhdodëpdl g ls ege`pls hl

 Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol-

 K hdsowssïl ge xlel hl olmogdxl hg kngmxg rliåxdol rlsswd pgigàmodk rpëxdok-

 Egmodlmg%sg) rlp gvgeril) l gmxgmhdegmxl olmsknpkhl ml _XC ml sgmxdhl hg kcksxkp k dmodhêmodk hk _úewik Sdmowikmxg ;?) {wg ghk l mgrlxdsel mk Khedmdsxpkîïl Rú`idok)

 rkpk ls okpnls rliåxdols-8 

 Dmxgpgssk%mls) xlhkdk) k lwxpk hdsowssïl olmopgxk {wkmxl â olmogdxwkîïl hg kngmxg rliåxdol- Xpkxk%sg hk &de$rlssd`didhkhg hg kridokîïl hk Igd 6-804,;440 k hgxgpedmkhlskngmxgs rliåxdols {wg olegxge kxls hg derpl`dhkhg okpkoxgpdzkhls olel opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg-

 K ogigwek ge xlpml hk sw`edssïl hls kngmxgs rliåxdols â Igd 6-804,;440 hgolppg hkdmxgprpgxkîïl sdsxgeëxdok hl xgvxl olmsxdxwodlmki) {wg hdsxdmnwg k derpl dhkhgkhedmdsxpkxdk g ls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg-

 Hg we ikhl) l kpx- ?>)  ® 8º) hk OPC@) pgnwikegmxkhl rgik Igd 6-804,;440) xpkxk hkderpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk {wg rlhg sgp rpkxdokhk rlp xlhl g {wki{wgp kngmxg rú`idol-

?OKPSKIFL CDIFL) Jlsä hls _kmxls- Ekmwki hg hdpgdxl khedmdsxpkxdl- 00- gh- Pdl hg Jkmgdpl: Iwegm Jwpds) 0224- r- 732%73;1EGIIL) Ogisl Kmxømdl @kmhgdpk hg- Owpsl hg hdpgdxl khedmdsxpkxdl- 0;- gh- _ïl Rkwil: Ekifgdpls) 0223- r- 0?>%0?61 HD RDGXPL)Ekpdk _tidk Zkmgiik- Hdpgdxl khedmdsxpkxdl- 00- gh- _ïl Rkwil: Kxiks) 0224- r- 7;2% 7;01 NK_RKPDMD) Hdÿngmgs- Hdpgdxlkhedmdsxpkxdl- ;0- gh) _ïl Rkwil: _kpkdk) 022>- r- ;73%;74-8 Sdhg) rlp gvgeril: _XC) PG 7>4-47;,PM) Pgi- Edm- Pdokphl Ig~kmhl~sad) Xpd`wmki Rigml) HJg%020) 08-;2-0226) r- ;-6>31 _XC) Pgi3-372 EO%KnP,RP) Pgi- Edm- Giigm Npkodg) HJg%000) 0;-;;-0226) r- 0>>-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;?,82

Page 14: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 14/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 Hg lwxpl ikhl) ls kpxs- 70) D) 67) S) o ;20) D) o) xlhls hk OPC@) pgnwikegmxkhls rgiks Igds >-;23,;46? g ;-2>4,;472 g rgil Hgopgxl%igd 02;,;43>) egmodlmke ls kxls hgderpl`dhkhg rpkxdokhls rlp hgxgpedmkhls kngmxgs rliåxdols) {wg sïl {wkidcdokhls olelopdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg-

&---$

L jwinkegmxl hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) hls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) hls Edmdsxpls hl

_XC) hls ege`pls hl OMJ g hl OMER) hl Rplowpkhlp%Ngpki hk Pgrú`idok g hl Khlnkhl%Ngpki hk Wmdïl) ge dpxwhg hk rpëxdok hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) olergxg kl _gmkhl){wg rlhgpë kridokp k skmîïl hg rgphk hl okpnl) ole dmk`didxkîïl) kxä odmol kmls) rkpk lgvgpoåodl hg {wki{wgp cwmîïl rú`idok &kpx- 70) D g Di) g rkpënpkcl úmdol) hk OPC@ o,o l kpx-0º hk Igd ;-2>4,;472$-7

Olergxg kl _XC rplogsskp g jwinkp) lpdndmkpdkegmxg) mls opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl g ls Olekmhkmxgs hk Ekpdmfk) hl Gväpodxl g hk

 Kgplmëwxdok) pgsskikhl l hdsrlsxl ml kpx- 70) D) hk OPC@) ls ege`pls hls Xpd`wmkds_wrgpdlpgs) ls hl Xpd`wmki hg Olmxks hk Wmdïl g ls ofgcgs hg edssïl hdrileëxdok hgokpëxgp rgpekmgmxg) mk clpek hl kpx- ;20) D) hk OPC@-

L _XJ rlsswd olergxêmodk lpdndmëpdk rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp) mls opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ls hgsge`kpnkhlpgs hls Xpd`wmkds hg Jwsxdîk hls Gsxkhls g hl Hdsxpdxl

 Cghgpki) ls ege`pls hls Xpd`wmkds hg Olmxks hls Gsxkhls g hl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki) ls hlsXpd`wmkds Pgndlmkds Cghgpkds) hls Xpd`wmkds Pgndlmkds Gigdxlpkds g hl Xpk`kifl) lsege`pls hls Olmsgifls lw Xpd`wmkds hg Olmxks hls Ewmdoårdls g ls hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idolhk Wmdïl {wg lcdodge rgpkmxg xpd`wmkds &kpx- ;27) D) "k") hk OPC@$-

&---$

 K kridokîïl hk Igd 6-804,;440 kls kngmxgs rliåxdols) sw`egxdhls kl pgndeg gsrgodki hl opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ä `ksxkmxg olmxplgpxdhk mk kxwkidhkhg- _l`pg k rliêedok)gvdsxge) ge pgswel) xpês gmxgmhdegmxls:

 Rpdegdpl gmxgmhdegmxl: ls kngmxgs rliåxdols sw`egxdhls â igndsikîïl gsrgodki) {wggpsk sl`pg ls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) mïl sg sw`egxge â Igd 6-804,;440-3 

 Dsxl rlp{wg k Olmsxdxwdîïl xgpdk hdsrgmskhl hlds xpkxkegmxls hdsxdmxls rkpk ls kxls hgderpl`dhkhg: &k$ ls kngmxgs rú`idols ge ngpki swjgdxke%sg kls xgpels hl kpx- ?>) ® 8-²) hkOPC@) pgnwikegmxkhl rgik Igd 6-804,;4401 g &`$ ls kngmxgs rliåxdols sw`egxge%sg âs pgnpksgsrgoåcdoks hl opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) mk clpek hls kpxs- 70)  D) 67) S) O ;20) D  ) o) hgmxpglwxpks mlpeks) hk OPC@) pgnwikegmxkhls rgik Igd ;-2>4,;472) rgil HI 02;,;43> g rgik

7Hk egsek clpek) olergxg kl _gmkhl l rplogssl g l jwinkegmxl hls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl g hls Olekmhkmxgs hk Ekpdmfk) hlGväpodxl g hk Kgplmëwxdok mls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg olmgvls ole k{wgigs rpkxdokhls rgil Rpgsdhgmxg lw rgil Sdog%Rpgsdhgmxghk Pgrú`idok- Mk kwsêmodk hg olmgvïl) ls Edmdsxpls sgpïl jwinkhls rgil _XC &kpx- 70) D o,o l kpx- ;20) D) hk OPC@$-

3 Mgssg sgmxdhl: EGMHG_) Ndiekp Cgppgdpk- Owpsl hg hdpgdxl olmsxdxwodlmki- 8- gh- _ïl Rkwil: _kpkdk) 0224- r- 6;81 OLRLIK)Ndmk- K derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk ml hdpgdxl `pksdigdpl- @gil Flpdzlmxg: Cÿpwe) 02;;- r- 8;-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;8,82

Page 15: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 15/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 Igd >-;23,;46?-

 Gssk cld k lpdgmxkîïl khlxkhk rgil _XC {wkmhl hl jwinkegmxl hk Pgoikekîïl0-;?6,HC) {wg gpskk sl`pg k rpëxdok hg derpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk,opdeg hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg rlp Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl- Hg kolphl ole l gmxgmhdegmxl ekjlpdxëpdl hls

 Edmdsxpls hk _wrpgek Olpxg) ls kngmxgs rliåxdols) rlp gsxkpge pgndhls rlp mlpeks gsrgodkdshg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) mïl pgsrlmhge rlp derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) ole cwmhkegmxl mk

 Igd 6-804,;440) eks krgmks rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg ge kîïl {wg slegmxg rlhg sgp  rplrlsxk rgpkmxg l _XC mls xgpels hl kpx- ;20) D  ) o) hk OPC@->  

 K mlssl gp) ml gmxkmxl) mïl ä rlssågi ckikp ge jwpdsrpwhêmodk olmslidhkhk hl _XC)wek gz {wg k hgodsïl ge olegmxl cld rplcgpdhk rlp ekdlpdk krgpxkhk hls Edmdsxpls &sgds vodmol$ g k olerlsdîïl kxwki hk Olpxg ä sw`sxkmodkiegmxg hdcgpgmxg hk{wgik {wg rplcgpdw khgodsïl-

 _gnwmhl gmxgmhdegmxl: ls kngmxgs rliåxdols swjgdxke%sg âs skmî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhgkhedmdsxpkxdk) rpgdsxks mk Igd 6-804,;440) g âs skmî÷gs rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg)xdrdcdokhks mk Igd ;-2>4,;472) ml HI 02;,;43> g mk Igd >-;23,;46?) {wg rlhge sgp kridokhks hg clpek owewikxdk sge {wg dssl olmcdnwpg `ds dm dhge-6 

 Mgssg sgmxdhl jë hgodhdw k Olpxg Gsrgodki hl _X  J {wg) kl khedxdp k olerkxd`didhkhgekxgpdki hks skmî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk g hls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg)pgsskilw krgmks k {wgsxïl rplogsswki &olergxêmodk olmsxdxwodlmki$ rkpk kridokîïl hkspgcgpdhks skmî÷gs k hgxgpedmkhls kngmxgs rliåxdols- Xpkmsopgk%sg k gegmxk hl jwinkhl {wggpskk sl`pg k olergxêmodk rkpk kridokîïl hks skmî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhg kls Nlgpmkhlpgshg Gsxkhls:4

"Olmsxdxwodlmki- Olergxêmodk-  Kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg olmxpk Nlgpmkhlp hg Gsxkhl-

 Hwril pgndeg skmodlmkxÿpdl hls kngmxgs rliåxdols: igndxdedhkhg- Clpl rlp 

 rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl: pgolmfgodegmxl- Wswprkîïl hg olergxêmodk hl _XJ -

 Rploghêmodk rkpodki hk pgoikekîïl-

;- Gvogxwkhk k fdrÿxgsg hg kxls hg derpl`dhkhg rpkxdokhls rgil Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok &kpx- 67) S$) owjl jwinkegmxl sg hë ge pgndeg gsrgodki rgil _gmkhl Cghgpki &kpx- 63$) mïl fë mlpek olmsxdxwodlmki kinwek {wg dewmdzg ls kngmxgs rliåxdols)

 swjgdxls k opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) hg {wki{wgp hks skmî÷gs rlp kxl hg> _XC) Pgoikekîïl 0-;?6,HC) Pgi-  r, Koÿphïl Edm- Ndiekp Egmhgs) Xpd wmki Rigml) HJg%2>2 ;6-28-0226 &Dmclpekxdl hgJwpdsrpwhêmodk hl _XC 8>;$-

6 Mgssg sgmxdhl: HGOLEKDM) Rghpl Pl`gpxl- Derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk- _ïl Rkwil:Hdkiäxdok) 022>- r- ?41 EKPXDM_ JÚMDLP) ^kiikog Rkdk- Rpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk- 8- gh- _ïl Rkwil: _kpkdk) 0224- r- ?;01_L@PKMG) _äpndl Xwppk- Derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk: ksrgoxls ekxgpdkds) hdegmsïl hdcwsk g oldsk jwinkhk- _ïl Rkwil: Kxiks) 02;2- r- 701 EKPXDM_ JÚMDLP) kiikog Rkdk- Rpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk- 8- gh- _ïl Rkwil:_kpkdk) 0224- r- ?0-4 _XJ) Poi 0->42,_O) Pgi- Edm- Xglpd Ki`dml Zkksoad) Olpxg Gsrgodki) HJg 28-2?-02;2 &Dmclpekxdl hg Jwpdsrpwhêmodk hl _XJ 8;6$-Skig ige`pkp {wg l _XJ rlsswd rpgoghgmxg ml   sgmxdhl hk dmkridok`didhkho hk Igd 6-804,;440 kls Rpgcgdxls) sw`egxdhls kl pgndeggsrgodki hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl rpgdsxl ml HI 02;,;43>- Sdhg: _XJ) PGsr 873-384,EN) Pgi- r, Koÿphïl Edm- Iwdz Cwv) RpdegdpkXwpek) Q$-, 27-;2-0223) r- 0?>&Dmclpekxdl hg Jwpdsrpwhêmodk hl _XJ 047$-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;7,82

Page 16: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 16/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

derpl`dhkhg rpgdsxks ml kpx- ?>) ® 8-²- _gpdk dmolerkxågi ole k Olmsxdxwdîïlggmxwki rpgogdxl mlpekxdl dmcpkolmsxdxwodlmki {wg derwsgssg dewmdhkhg hgsskmkxwpgzk-

0- Rlp hgodsïl hg ;? hg ekpîl hg 0226) k _wrpgek Olpxg) ole krgmks we lxlolmxpëpdl) hgoikplw {wg .olergxg kl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki jwinkp kîïl hgderpl`dhkhg olmxpk sgws ege`pls. &[L mk Rgx- ?-0;;%2) Edm- Egmgzgs Hdpgdxl) HJ 0>-23-0226$- Olmsdhgplw) rkpk xkmxl) {wg k rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl) ge oksls xkds)

hgolppg hdpgxkegmxg hl sdsxgek hg olergxêmodks gsxk`gigodhl mk Olmsxdxwdîïl) {wgkssgnwpk k sgws Edmdsxpls clpl rlp rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl) xkmxl ge opdegs olewms)mk rpÿrpdk Olpxg) {wkmxl ge opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ml _gmkhl Cghgpki- Rlp dssl) .sgpdk k`swphl lw l eëvdel hl olmxpk%sgmsl olmog`gp {wg lphge jwpåhdok

 rgpedxk {wg Edmdsxpl rlssk sgp jwinkhl rlp lwxpl ÿpnïl ge kîïl hdgpsk) eks gmxpgowjks skmî÷gs gsxë xke`äe k rgphk hl okpnl- Dsxl sgpdk k hgsgsxpwxwpkîïl hg xlhl l

 sdsxgek {wg cwmhkegmxk k hdsxpd`wdîïl hk olergxêmodk. &lxl hl Edm- Ogzkp Rgiwsl$-

?- Gssgs egsels cwmhkegmxls hg mkxwpgzk sdsxgeëxdok kwxlpdzke k olmoiwdp) rlp derlsdîïl iÿndok hg olgpêmodk dmxgprpgxkxdk) {wg mlpek dmcpkolmsxdxwodlmki mïl

 rlhg kxpd`wdp k jwdz hg rpdegdpl npkw l jwinkegmxl hg kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg

khedmdsxpkxdk) ole rlssågi kridokîïl hk rgmk hg rgphk hl okpnl) olmxpk

Nlgpmkhlp hl Gsxkhl) {wg) k gvgeril hls Edmdsxpls hl _XC) xke`äe xge

kssgnwpkhl clpl rlp rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl) xkmxl ge opdegs olewms &rgpkmxg l _X 

 J$) {wkmxl ge opdegs hg pgsrlmsk didhkhg &rgpkmxg k pgsrgoxdk  Kssge`igdk

 Igndsikxdk$- Ä hg sg pgolmfgogp {wg) rlp dmkcksxëgi sdegxpdk ole l {wg lolppg gepgikîïl kls opdegs olewms &OC) kpx- ;27) D) k$) fë) ge oksls xkds) olergxêmodkderiåodxk olerigegmxkp hl _wrgpdlp Xpd`wmki hg Jwsxdîk-8- Pgoikekîïl rploghgmxg) ge rkpxg-" 

 Ge pgikîïl kls Rpgcgdxls) l _XJ xge khedxdhl k rplrlsdxwpk hk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhgg k kridokîïl hks skmî÷gs rpgdsxks ml kpx- ;0 hk Igd 6-804,;440-;2 

Xgpogdpl gmxgmhdegmxl: ls kngmxgs rliåxdols rlhge sgp päws mk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg

khedmdsxpkxdk) ole k olmsg{wgmxg kridokîïl hks skmî÷gs hk Igd 6-804,;440) skil k{wgikshg mkxwpgzk rliåxdok {wg slegmxg rlhge sgp kridokhks rlp egdl hl pgsrgoxdl rplogssl rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ole cwmhkegmxl mk Igd ;-2>4,;472) ml HI 02;,;43> g mk Igd>-;23,;46?-;; 

;2 Sdhg) rlp gvgeril: _XJ) PGsr ;-2?8-7;;,OG) Pgi- Edm- Gidkmk Okielm) _gnwmhk Xwpek) HJg 00-24-0224 &Dmclpekxdl hgJwpdsrpwhêmodk hl _XJ 827$-;; Mgssg sgmxdhl: OKPSKIFL CDIFL) Jlsä hls _kmxls- Ekmwki hg hdpgdxl khedmdsxpkxdl- 08- gh- Pdl hg Jkmgdpl: Iwegm Jwpds)02;;- r- 4401 HD RDGXPL) Ekpdk _tidk ZkmgJik- Hdpgdxl khedmdsxpkxdl- 00- gh- _ïl Rkwil: Kxiks) 0224- r- 6;>1 NKJKPHLMD)Cgpmkmhl hk Clmsgok1 OPWZ) Iwkmk Rghplsk hg Cdnwgdpghl1 OGP[WGiPK) Iwds Lxëdl _g{wgdpk hg1 NLEG_ JWMDLP) IwdzEkmlgi1 CKSPGXL) Plngpdl- Olegmxëpdls â Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk- _ïl Rkwil: PX) 02;2- r- 8>1 RKZZKNIiMD CDIFL)Ekpdml- Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk olegmxkhk: ksrgoxls olmsxdxwodlmkds) khedmdsxpkxdls) odds) opdedmkds) rplogsswkds g hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg cdsoki- 7- gh- _ïl Rkwil: Kxiks) 02;;- r- ;8?%;881 NKJKPHLMD) Cgpmkmhl hk Clmsgok1 OPWZ) Iwkmk Rghplsk hg

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;3,82

Page 17: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 17/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

L xgpogdpl gmxgmhdegmxl rkpgog sgp l ekds khg{wkhl- Mïl fë {wg sg ckikp gedewmdhkhg hl kngmxg rliåxdol â kridokîïl hk Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk- Kdmxgprpgxkîïl sdsxgeëxdok hl lphgmkegmxl jwpåhdol hgelmsxpk {wg k dmxgmîïl hl igndsikhlp olmsxdxwdmxg cld k hg gsxk`gigogp pgnpks gsrgodkds rkpk ls kngmxgs rliåxdols {wg olegxgpgekxls hg derpl`dhkhg,opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg ge pgikîïl gvoiwsdkegmxg â kridokîïl hg

 skmî÷gs rliåxdoks &rgphk hl okpnl g dmk`didxkîïl xgerlpëpdk rkpk l gvgpoåodl hg cwmîïl rú`idok$) eks mïl ml xlokmxg âs hgekds skmî÷gs {wg mïl rlsswge okpëxgp rliåxdol g {wggsxïl rpgdsxks ml kpx- ;0 hk Igd 6-804,;440-

 Hgsxkpxg) l kngmxg rliåxdol rlhg sgp pgsrlmsk`didzkhl) rgil egsel ckxl) ole cwmhkegmxl mk igndsikîïl gsrgodki) {wg xpkxk hl opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) g mk Igd6-804,;440) pgsskikhk k kridokîïl hg skmî÷gs rliåxdoks) sge {wg dssl olmcdnwpg `ds dmdhge-

 Ml rplogssl g jwinkegmxl rlp opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg sgpïl kridokhks ks skmî÷gs rliåxdoks &rgphk hl okpnl g dmk`didxkîïl xgerlpëpdk rkpk l gvgpoåodl hg cwmîïl rú`idok$) gm{wkmxl mk kîïl jwhdodki hg derpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk l ekndsxpkhl kridokpëks hgekds skmî÷gs gigmokhks mk Igd 6-804,;440 &pgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl) ewixk oddi gxo-$-;0 

 Pgsskixg%sg {wg k Igd 6-804,;440 ä rigmkegmxg kridoëgi kls gv%kngmxgs rliåxdols)

fdrÿxgsg ge {wg kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg sgpë rplogsskhk g jwinkhk rgil Jwåzl hg rpdegdpl npkw-;?

 Khgekds) k ogsskîïl hl ekmhkxl gigxdl) ml owpsl hl rplogssl hg kîïl derpl`dhkhgkhedmdsxpkxdk) deridok rgphk kwxleëxdok hk ofkekhk rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl g hgsilokegmxlhk okwsk kl jwåzl hg rpdegdpl npkw) kdmhk {wg l ckxl {wg hgw okwsk â hgekmhk fkjklolppdhl hwpkmxg l gvgpoåodl hk cwmîïl rú`idok-;8―

Jlsä _kmxls Okpkifl Cdifl;7 xke`äe hgsxkok k gvdsxêmodk hk olmxpläpsdk

sl`pg l xgek:

’[wgsxïl {wg xge swsodxkhl cwmhk rliêedok ä k {wg hdz pgsrgdxl â pgsrlmsk`didhkhg

Cdnwgdpghl1 OGP[WGDPK) Iwds Lxëdl _g{wgdpk hg1 NLEG_ JWMDLP) Iwdz Ekmlgi1 CKSPGXL) Plngpdl- Olegmxëpdls â Igd hgDerpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk- _ïl Rkwil: PX) 02;2- r- 8>-;0 Ks pgsxpdî÷gs â kridokîïl hk skmîïl hg rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok kls kngmxgs rliåxdols sïl egmodlmkhks xke`äe ml sw`dxge;?-7-8-8-;? _XC) Rgx ?-80; KnP,EK)Pgi- Edm- Ogzkp Rgiwsl) Xpd`wmki Rigml) HJg%;22 28-23-02;21 _XJ) PGsr ;-;?8-83;,_R) Pgi- Edm- GidkmkOkielm) _gnwmhk Xwpek) HJg ;0-26-02;2&Dmclpekxdl hg Jwpdsrpwhêmodk hl _XJ 88;$;8 _XC) Pgi ?-20; KnP,_R)Pgi- Edm- Ogzkp Rgiwsl) Xpd`wmki Rigml) HJg%207 23-20-0224;7 dm Ekmwki hg Hdpgdxl Khedmdsxpkxdl) 08ª ghdîïl) Iwegm Jwpds) 08ª gh-) 02;;) r- 44;,440- \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;>,82

Page 18: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 18/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

hls kngmxgs rliåxdols ml {wg xkmng k kxls hg derpl`dhkhg- _ge húdhk) k hdsowssïl sl`pg lxgek pggik%sg hg npkmhg olerigvdhkhg ge dpxwhg hls gcgdxls {wg l pgolmfgodegmxl hkderpl`dhkhg rlhg rplhwzdp- Mk gphkhg) k {wgsxïl lpdndmlw%sg hg kî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhgkjwdzkhks ge ckog hg Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) mks {wkds cld gmxdikhk xke`äe k dmolergxêmodkhg jwåzls hg rpdegdpl npkw-

_l`pg k ekxäpdk) rlhge gmolmxpkp%sg xpês gmxgmhdegmxls- Rgil rpdegdpl) gmxgmhge ls {wg l rgpcdifke {wg k kîïl hg derpl dhkhg rpgdsxk mk

 Igd mº 6-804,40 ä dmhgrgmhgmxg hks kî÷gs {wg krwpke opdegs olewms g opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg &lw dmcpkî÷gs rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdks$) gsxgs pgnwikhls rgik Igd mº ;-2>4,72) sgmhl) rlpxkmxl) khedssågi k olmoledxàmodk hks kî÷gs-;3  

We sgnwmhl gmxgmhdegmxl gvoiwd k khedssd`didhkhg hk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg {wkmhl l swjgdxl rkssdl ä kngmxg rliåxdol- Kpnwegmxk%sg ole l ckxl hg {wg xkds kngmxgs sg swjgdxke kpgndeg rpÿrpdl hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) hdgpsl hl {wg dmodhg sl pg ls hgekds kngmxgs

 rú`idols) kiäe hg fkgp skmî÷gs mk igd hg derpl dhkhg {wg jë xge xêe rpgdsïl ml Oÿhdnl Rgmki g mk igd pgnwikhlpk hls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Rlp lwxpl ikhl) xge%sgpgolmfgodhl {wg ks skmî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhg) k hgsrgdxl hg okpkoxgpdzkhks olel hg mkxwpgzkoddi) sïl hlxkhks hg ’clpxg olmxgúhl rgmki―) olel jë hgoikplw kwxlpdzkhk hlwxpdmk- ;>  

 Hgssg elhl) k sgmxgmîk olmhgmkxÿpdk mk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg sgpdk hlxkhk hg gcgdxls {wg)ge kinwms ksrgoxls) swrgpke k{wgigs kxpd`wåhls â  sgmxgmîk rgmki olmhgmkxÿpdk) ckxl {wg

 rlhgpë rpllokp gcgdxls ekds npklsls rkpk l g{wdiå`pdl jwpåhdol%dmsxdxwodlmki   hl {wgggmxwki sgmxgmîk olmhgmkxÿpdk hg okpëxgp rgmki-;6  K olmoiwsïl ä k hg {wg gsxïl gvoiwåhlshk Igd mº 6-804,40 xlhls k{wgigs kngmxgs kls {wkds k Olmsxdxwdîïl kxpd`wdw gvrpgsskegmxg k

 rpëxdok hg opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) kridokmhl%sg%ifgs krgmks k Igd mº  ;-2>4,72-;4  Gelwxpks rkikpks) mïl sg khedxdpdk ’olmolppêmodk gmxpg hlds pgndegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg

 rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk kngmxgs rliåxdols―-02  Mgssk idmfk hg gmxgmhdegmxl) jë sg hgodhdw {wg ä l _XC) g mïl l jwåzl hg ; º npkw) {wg

xge olergxêmodk rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg olmxpk Edmdsxpl hk rpÿrpdkOlpxg- 0;  Rlp lwxpl ikhl) jë sg rploikelw {wg k egsek kîïl rpleldhk olmxpk Nlgpmkhlp hg Gsxkhl ä hk olergxêmodk hl _XJ) rlp dmgdxëgi sdegxpdk ole l kpx- ;27) D) hk OC-00  Gepgikîïl k rpgcgdxls g gpgkhlpgs) ml gmxkmxl) rlp mïl sgpge olmxgerikhls mk pgcgpdhk Igd mº 

;-2>4,72) k jwpdsrpwhêmodk ls xge sw`egxdhl kl clpl hg rpdegdpl npkw ml oksl hk kîïl hg

;3 PLNÄPDL RKOFGOL KISG_) Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk) Iwegm Jwpds) 0ª gh-) 0228) r- >82 &l`pk ge olmjwmxl ole GegpslmNkpodk$-;>KPMLIHL KIH g NDIEKP CGPPGDPK EGMHG_) ’Olergxêmodk rkpk jwinkp k derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk―) ge Pgdsxk hgDmclpekîïl Igndsikxdk mº ;?6- k`p-,jwmfl-,;446) rr- 0;?%0;7-;6 Cld k rlsdîïl khlxkhk) rlp ekdlpdk) rgil _XC mk Pgoi- 0-;?6%HC) Pgi- Edm- NDIEKP EGMHG_) ge ;?-23-022> &Dmclpekxdl _XC mº 8>;) jwm-,022>$- Xke`äe: _XJ) PGsr 873-384%EN) ;ª Xwpek) Pgi- Edm- IWDZ CWV) ge 27-24-0223 &Dmclpekxdl _XJ mº 047) sgx-,0223$-;4 _ïl ls {wg olmsxke mls kpxs- 70) D g DD) g ;20) D) ’o―) hk OC-02 Cld olel hgodhdw l _XC ml KnP%PG 7>4->44%_R- Pgi- Edm- GPL_ NPKW) H$ ;4-;0-0226 &ml oksl) xpkxkk%sg hg Hgsge`kpnkhlp$-0; _XC) [L mk Rgx) ?-0;;%2) Pgi- Edm- EGMGZG_ HDPGDXL) ge ;?-2?-0226-00 _XJ) Pgoi- 0->42%_O)Pgi- Edm- XGLPD ZKSK_OAD) ge 20-;0-0224-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;6,82

Page 19: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 19/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

derpl`dhkhg-0? 8;>  Rlp cde) khlnk%sg l gmxgmhdegmxl hg {wg ks Igds mºs ;-2>4,72 g 6-804,40 olmdge

fkpelmdlskegmxg ml sdsxgek) sgmhl dmhgrgmhgmxgs ks dks pgsrgoxdks) eks sgpë dmok`ågi  clpewikp mk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg rghdhl hg kridokîïl hg skmî÷gs hg mkxwpgzk rliåxdok&rgphk hl okpnl) swsrgmsïl hg hdpgdxls rliåxdols$) jë {wg giks gekmke mkxwpkiegmxg hk kîïl

 rgmki hg krwpkîïl hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Ge olergmskîïl) sw`sdsxdpdke lwxpks skmî÷gs sge xki mkxwpgzk &olel) -n-) ewixk oddi) pgrkpkîïl hg hkmls) rpld`dîïl hg

`gmgcåodls opghdxåodls lw cdsokds gxo$- Xkds skmî÷gs mïl hgolppgpdke hg opdeg hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg) pgnwikhl rlp igd gsrgodki) eks sde hg olmhwxk hg derpl`dhkhg sgeokpkoxgpdzkîïl hgidxwlsk- Hg ckxl) gvkedmkmhl%sg l gigmol hg skmî÷gs olmxgerikhl ml kpx-;0 hk Igd m4 6-804,40) ä rlssågi dsiwe`pkp k gvdsxêmodk) ikhl k ikhl) hg skmî÷gs rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdks g gvoiwsdkegmxg khedmdsxpkxdks- Hkå k hdsxdmîïl cgdxk rlp kinwmsdmxäprpgxgs g {wg) ge mlssl gmxgmhgp) egiflp sg fkpelmdzk ole l sdsxgek kxwkiegmxg gednlp g ole l rpdmoårdl hk elpkidhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk-08

Ml rikml jwpdsrpwhgmodki) k ekxäpdk cld gmcpgmxkhk hg ekmgdpk ekds rplcwmhk

{wkmhl hl jwinkegmxl hk Pgoikekîïl mº 0-;?6,HC) rgil _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki) {wgpgsxlw kssde gegmxkhk:

GEGMXK: PGOIKEKÎÏL- W_WPRKÎÏL HK OLERGXÊMODK HL _WRPGELXPD@WMKI CGHGPKI- DERPL@DHKHG KHEDMD_XPKXDSK- OPDEG HGPG_RLM_K@DIDHKHG- KNGMXG_ RLIÅXDOL_- D- RPGIDEDMKPG_- [WG_X×G_ HGLPHGE- D-;- [wgsxïl hg lphge {wkmxl â ekmwxgmîïl hk olergxêmodk hk Olpxg {wg jwsxdcdolw) ml rpdegdpl elegmxl hl jwinkegmxl) l olmfgodegmxl hk pgoikekîïl) hdkmxg hlckxl mll hk ogsskîïl hl gvgpoåodl hk cwmîïl rú`idok rgil dmxgpgsskhl- Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl{wg rlsxgpdlpegmxg ksswedw okpnl hg Ofgcg hg Edssïl Hdrileëxdok Rgpekmgmxg hl @pksdi rgpkmxg k Lpnkmdzkîïl hks Mkî÷gs Wmdhks- Ekmwxgmîïl hk rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl rgpkmxg l

_XC) olmclpeg l kpx- ;20) D) "o") hk Olmsxdxwdîïl- [wgsxïl hg lphge pgjgdxkhk- D-0- [wgsxïlhg lphge {wkmxl kl sl`pgsxkegmxl hl jwinkegmxl kxä {wg sgjk rlssågi pgkidzë%il geolmjwmxl ole lwxpls rplogssls sl`pg l egsel xgek) ole rkpxdodrkîïl hg xlhls ls Edmdsxpls{wg dmxgnpke l Xpd`wmki) xgmhl ge dsxk k rlssd`didhkhg hg {wg l rplmwmodkegmxl hk Olpxgmïl pgcidxk l gmxgmhdegmxl hg sgws kxwkds ege`pls) hgmxpg ls {wkds {wkxpl mïl xêe hdpgdxl klxl) rlds sgws kmxgogsslpgs jë sg rplmwmodkpke- Jwinkegmxl {wg jë sg gsxgmhg rlp odmolkmls- Ogigpdhkhg rplogsswki- Gvdsxêmodk hg lwxpl rplogssl ole ekxäpdk dhêmxdok mk sg{ùêmodk

0? _XJ) PGsr 647-7?2%RP) Pgi- Edm- IWDZ CWV) ge ;6-;;-0226) g PGsr 484-870%_r)Pgi- Edm- CPKMOD_OL CKIOÏL) ge 08-2?-0224- Xke`äe:_XJ- PGsr ;-;76-30?) Pgi- Edm- FKEDIXLM OKPSKIFDHL) ge ;6-2?-02;2-08 Ge xki sgmxdhl) kogpxkhls) ge mlssl gmxgmhgp) ls lxls hls Edm- OKPIL_ SGIIL_L g JLK[WDE @KP@L_K mk jë pgcgpdhk Pgo- Mº 0- ;?6%HC jwinkhk rgil _XC- \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ;4,82

Page 20: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 20/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

hk rkwxk hg jwinkegmxls hl hdk- Dmwxdidhkhg hl sl`pgsxkegmxl- [wgsxïl hg lphge pgjgdxkhk-DD- EÄPDXL- DD-;-Derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk- Opdegs hg pgsrlmsk didhkhg- Ls kxls hgderpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk sïl xdrdcdokhls olel opdeg hg pgsrlmsk didhkhg mk Igd m²;-2>4,;472) hgidxl hg okpëxgp rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdl- DD-0-Hdsxdmîïl gmxpg ls pgndegs hgpgsrlmsk`didzkîïl rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk- L sdsxgek olmsxdxwodlmki `pksdigdpl hdsxdmnwgl pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg hls kngmxgs rliåxdols hls hgekds kngmxgs rú`idols- KOlmsxdxwdîïl mïl khedxg k olmolppêmodk gmxpg hlds pgndegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhgrliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk ls kngmxgs rliåxdols: l rpgdsxl ml kpx- ?>) ® 8º &pgnwikhlrgik Igd m² 6-804,;440$ g l pgndeg cdvkhl ml kpx- ;20) D) "o") &hdsodridmkhl rgik Igd m²;-2>4,;472$- _g k olergxêmodk rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp k kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg &OC) kpx-?>) ® 8º$ rwhgssg k`pkmngp xke`äe kxls rpkxdokhls rgils kngmxgs rliåxdols) sw`egxdhlsk pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg gsrgodki) xgp%sg%dk wek dmxgprpgxkîïl k`%plnkmxg hlhdsrlsxl ml kpx- ;20) D) "o") hk Olmsxdxwdîïl- DD-?-Pgndeg gsrgodki- Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl-Ls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) rlp gsxkpge pgndhls rlp mlpeks gsrgodkds hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg&OC) kpx- ;20) D) "o"1 Igd m² ;-2>4,;472$) mïl sg sw`egxge kl elhgil hg olergxêmodkrpgdsxl ml pgndeg olewe hk Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk &Igd m² 6-804,;440$-DD-8-Opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Olergxêmodk hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki- Olergxggvoiwsdkegmxg kl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki rplogsskp g jwinkp ls hgidxls rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdls) mk fdrÿxgsg hl kpx- ;20) D) "o") hk Olmsxdxwdîïl- _legmxg l _XC rlhg

rplogsskp g jwinkp Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl ml oksl hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg g) kssde)ggmxwkiegmxg) hgxgpedmkp k rgphk hl okpnl lw k swsrgmsïl hg hdpgdxls rliåxdols-DD-7-Kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk- Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl {wg xgg hgopgxkhk k swsrgmsïlhg sgws hdpgdxls rliåxdols rgil rpkzl hg 6 kmls g k rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok rlp sgmxgmîk hlJwåzl hk ;8ª Skpk hk Jwsxdîk Cghgpki % _gîïl Jwhdodëpdk hl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki- Dmolergxêmodkhls jwåzls hg rpdegdpk dmsxàmodk rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp kîïl oddi hg derpl dhkhgkhedmdsxpkxdk kjwdzkhk olmxpk kngmxg rliåxdol {wg rlsswd rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl rgpkmxg l_wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki) rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) olmclpeg l kpx- ;20) D) "o") hkOlmsxdxwdîïl- DDD- PGOIKEKÎÏL JWINKHK RPLOGHGMXG- &Poi 0;?6) Pgikxlp&k$: Edm- MGI_LM JL@DE) Pgikxlp&k$ r, Koÿphïl: Edm- NDIEKP EGMHG_ &KPX-?6)DS)`) HLPD_XC$) Xpd`wmki Rigml) jwinkhl ge ;?,23,022>) HJg%2>2 HDSWIN ;>%28%0226 RW@IDO;6%28%0226 GEGMX SLI%20?;7%2; RR%22248 PXJ SLI%220;;% RR%22276$

Xpkxkk%sg) mk{wgik lrlpxwmdhkhg) hg kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk

olmxpk Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl kjwdzkhk mk rpdegdpk dmsxàmodk hk Jwsxdîk Cghgpki- Mk

Pgoikekîïl) kignlw%sg {wg ls kngmxgs rliåxdols rlhgpdke pgsrlmhgp rlp kxl hg

derpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) rlpäe) xkds kxls sgpdke xpkxkhls olel opdegs hg

pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) mïl sg ifgs kridokmhl k Igd mº 6-804,40) eks sde k Igd mº ;-2>4,72-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 02,82

Page 21: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 21/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 K {wgsxïl) rlpxkmxl) k sgp hgodhdhk gpk sk`gp ’sg l xgvxl olmsxdxwodlmki

khedxdk k olmolppêmodk gmxpg hlds pgndegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rliåxdok%khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk

ls kngmxgs rliåxdols―) sgmhl gigs:

&k$ l rpgdsxl ml kpx- ?>) ® 8º) g pgnwikhl rgik Igd 6-804) hg ;440) g

&`$ l pgndeg hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg cdvkhl ml kpx- ;20) D) o ) hk

Olmsxdxwdîïl g hdsodridmkhl rgik Igd ;-2>4) hg ;472-

L jwinkegmxl kok`lw olmoiwdmhl {wg ’l sdsxgek olmsxdxwodlmki `pksdigdpl

hdsxdmnwg l pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg hls kngmxgs rliåxdols hls hgekds kngmxgs

 rú`idols- K Olmsxdxwdîïl mïl khedxg k olmolppêmodk gmxpg hlds pgndegs hg

pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk ls kngmxgs rliåxdols: l rpgdsxl ml kpx- ?>) ®

8º &pgnwikhl rgik Igd m² 6-804,;440$ g l pgndeg cdvkhl ml kpx- ;20) D) "o") &hdsodridmkhl rgik

Igd m² ;-2>4,;472$-― 

L`sgpl {wg gssg xke`äe cld l gmxgmhdegmxl gsrlskhl â ärlok hl

Rplowpkhlp%Ngpki hk Pgrú`idok &Sdog%Rplowpkhlp%Ngpki hk Pgrú`idok Fkplihl Cgppkz hk

Mÿ`pgnk$ {wg sg ekmdcgsxlw rgik rploghêmodk hl rghdhl clpewikhl mk{wgik Pgoikekîïl)

owjl xpgofl cld xpkmsopdxl ml lxl hl Pgikxlp Edmdsxpl Mgislm Jl`de) mls sgnwdmxgs xgpels:

’&---$ mls rkpgog olppgxl l gmxgmhdegmxl hg {wg mïl sg rlhg rplogsskp l kngmxg rliåxdol ole `ksg gvoiwsdkegmxg mk Igd mº 6-804,40- L pgndeg hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg cdvkhl ml kpx- ;20) D) o) hk Okpxk Eknmk g hdsodridmkhl rgik Igd m- ;-2>4) hg ;472 ä {wg sghgssweg olgpgmxg ole l mlssl sdsxgek olmsxdxwodlmki-

Ole gcgdxl) ls kxls hg derpl`dhkhg) gm{wkmxl opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) gsxïlkerikegmxg olmxgerikhls ml Okråxwil S hk Igd ;-2>4) hg ;2-28-;472 ‟ dmsxdxwxl {wg pgnwikls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg &Hls opdegs olmxpk k rpl`dhkhg mk khedmdsxpkîïl ‟ kpx- 4º$-L`sgpg%sg {wg k rgmk derlsxk) k gvgeril hk{wgik rpgdsxk mk igd hg derpl`dhkhg) ägvxpgekegmxg sggpk: rgphk hl okpnl g dmk`didxkîïl rkpk l gvgpoåodl hg cwmîïl rú`idok rgil

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 0;,82

Page 22: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 22/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 rpkzl hg kxä odmol kmls &kpx- 0º$- Rlp lwxpl ikhl) olmslkmxg hdsrlsxl ml kpx- ?º hk I-;-2>4,;472) k derlsdîïl hk rgmkidhkhg mïl gvoiwd l rplogssl g jwinkegmxl hl kowskhl rlp opdeg olewe-

 Hgmlxk%sg) rlpxkmxl) {wg k igd hls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) xkds olel ls diåodxlskpplikhls mk Igd 6-804,40) sïl hgidxls rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdls-  Mïl sg elsxpk rikwsågi  )

 rlpxkmxl) k dmodhêmodk hg ke`ls ls hdrileks ignkds sl`pg we egsel kngmxg - Mïl sg rlhghgsrpgzkp l gsrgodki sdsxgek hg pgsrlmsk didzkîïl hl kngmxg rliåxdol rpgdsxl mllphgmkegmxl jwpåhdol-

 Ilnl) rlhg%sg olmoiwdp {wg kls kngmxgs rliåxdols) olel ls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) rlp 

gsxkpge sw`egxdhls k we pgndeg gsrgodki hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) mïl sg kridoke ks pgnpks

olewms hk igd hg derpl`dhkhg- Kssde sgmhl) olmcdnwpk%sg k rigmk g gvoiwsdk olergxêmodkhgssg _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp ls hgidxls rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdls)mk fdrÿxgsg hl kpx- ;20) D) o) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki-―

Gsxk`gigogw%sg) kssde) mk jwpdsrpwhêmodk k hwkidhkhg hg pgndegs hg kngmxgs

rú`idols rlp kxls hg derpl`dhkhg: ls kngmxgs rliåxdols sgpdke pgsrlmsk`didzkhls mk clpek

hk Igd mº ;-2>4,721 g ls hgekds kngmxgs rú`idols) mk clpek hk Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg

 Khedmdsxpkxdk-

Xki gmxgmhdegmxl kdmhk rgpsdsxg ml _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki) olel sg ê

hk hgodsïl hl Edmdsxpl Ndiekp Cgppgdpk Egmhgs) rplcgpdhk mk Pgoikekîïl 0;63:

HGOD_ÏL: Xpkxk%sg hg pgoikekîïl kjwdzkhk rlp Rghpl _kerkdl Ekikm) Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhlhk Ckzgmhk) Rghpl Rwiigm Rkpgmxg) Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl Ofgcg hk Oksk Oddi hk Rpgsdhêmodk hkPgrú`idok g Jlsä _gppk) _gmkhlp hk Pgrú`idok) xgmhl ge dsxk kî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhgkhedmdsxpkxdk olmxpk gigs kjwdzkhks rgpkmxg k 02k g 00k Skpks Cghgpkds hk _gîïl Jwhdodëpdkhl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki- K kîïl lphdmëpdk olmxpk derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk kjwdzkhk rgpkmxg k00ª Skpk Cghgpki hk _gîïl Jwhdodëpdk hl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki) kwxwkhk sl` l mº 47-22-02668%4)kdmhk mïl cld jwinkhk- L rghdhl hk pgcgpdhk kîïl gsxë clpewikhl mls sgnwdmxgs xgpels: ’;-sgjke ls päws olmhgmkhls k pgsskpodpge l gpëpdl hks gp`ks kilokhks rkpk l rknkegmxl hlsolppgmxdsxks hls `kmols sl` dmxgpgmîïl) mls xgpels hl kpx- ;0) dmodsl DD) hk Igd mº 6-804,40) `ge olel olmhgmkhls mks gp`ks hg swowe`êmodk1 0- sgjke ls päws olmhgmkhls) xke`äe â rgphk hg sgws hdpgdxls rliåxdols g) olmsg{ùgmxgegmxg) rpld`dhls hg gvgpogpge {wki{wgp cwmîïl rú`idok g hg olmxpkxkp ole k Khedmdsxpkîïl mls xgpels hl kpx- ;0) dmodsl DD) hk Igd mº6-804,401 ?- sgjke ls päws olmhgmkhls kl rknkegmxl hk ewixk rpgdsxk ml kpx- ;0) dmodsl DD)hk Igd mº 6-804,40-― &ci- 77$ Jë k kîïl rplrlsxk rgpkmxg k 02k Skpk) krpgsgmxk olelpg{wgpdhls &hgmxpg lwxpls$ Rghpl _kerkdl Ekikm) gmxïl Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl hl Rikmgjkegmxlg Lpîkegmxl) _gmkhlp Jlsä _gppk) g gmxïl Edmdsxpl dmxgpdml hk Ckzgmhk) Rghpl Rwiigm

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 00,82

Page 23: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 23/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

Rkpgmxg) gmxïl Edmdsxpl%Ofgcg hk Oksk Oddi hk Rpgsdhêmodk hk Pgrú`idok) xgmhl sdhl kwxwkhksl` l mº 43-22-2;2>4%2- Gds l rghdhl hk pgcgpdhk kîïl oddi hg pgrkpkîïl hg hkmls rlp derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk owewikhk ole rghdhl hg kmwikîïl hg kxls khedmdsxpkxdls: ’&---$ `$ sgjke dmxdekhls rkpk hdzgp hg sgw dmxgpgssg mk idhg l @KMOL OGMXPKI HL @PK_DI)mk rgsslk hg sgw rpgsdhgmxg) sghdkhl ml _gxlp @kmoëpdl _wi) Ghdcdl%_ghg) mgsxk Okrdxki) lmhg rlhgpïl sgp odxkhls ls hgekds hdpgxlpgs hk Dmsxdxwdîïl) g k WMDÏL) mk rgsslk hl sgwpgrpgsgmxkmxg ignki) mgsxk Okrdxki1 o$ k rploghêmodk hl rghdhl) rkpk {wg sgjk hgopgxkhk kmwidhkhg hl olmxpkxl hg k`gpxwpk hg opähdxl plxkxdl) cdpekhl gmxpg l @kmol Ogmxpki hl @pksdig l @kmol Golmøedol _-K-) ge ;4 hg hgzge`pl hg ;448) rgiks pkz÷gs jë gvrlsxks&hlowegmxl ;0$1 h$ sgjke ls päws slidhkpdkegmxg olmhgmkhls k pgsskpodpge l gpëpdl hksgp`ks kilokhks ge cklp hl @kmol Golmøedol _-K-) ge olmsg{ùêmodk hk kssdsxêmodkcdmkmogdpk {wg ifg cld rpgsxkhk g hl sk{wg k hgsol`gpxl mk olmxk hks pgsgpks `kmoëpdks) mlkilp xlxki hg P( 0-4>7-4?7->28) 30 &hlds `dif÷gs) mlgogmxls g sgxgmxk g odmol edif÷gs)mlgogmxls g xpdmxk g odmol edi) sgxgogmxls g {wkxpl pgkds g sgssgmxk g hlds ogmxkls$) mlsxgpels hl kpx- ;0) DD) hk Igd mº 6-804,40) `ge olel mks gp`ks hg swowe`êmodk1 g$ sgjke lspäws) rgsslks cåsdoks) olmhgmkhls) xke`äe) â swsrgmsïl hg sgws hdpgdxls rliåxdols g)olmsg{ùgmxgegmxg) rpld`dhls hg gvgpogpge {wki{wgp cwmîïl rú`idok) g) kdmhk) mgsxg oksldmoiwåhk k rgsslk jwpåhdok hl @kmol Golmøedol _-K-) rpld`dhls hg olmxpkxkp ole l Rlhgp Rú`idol g âs hgekds skmî÷gs hl kpx- ;0) DD) hk Igd mº 6-804,401 c$ sgjke ls päws olmhgmkhls kl

 rknkegmxl hk ewixk rpgdsxk ml kpx- ;0) DD) hk Igd mº 6-804,40-― &cis- 40%4?$- Mk kîïl hg mº43-22-2;2>4%2) kjwdzkhk rgpkmxg k 02ª Skpk Cghgpki) flwg sgmxgmîk) k {wki jwinlw rkpodkiegmxg rploghgmxg l rghdhl hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki rkpk olmhgmkp ls lpkpgoikekmxgs k hgligpge kl gpëpdl ’gp`ks kilokhks rkpk l rknkegmxls QsdoU hlsolppgmxdsxks hls `kmols sl` dmxgpgmîïl &kpx- ;0) DD) hk Igd ml 6-804,40$―- Rlp lwxpl ikhl) lekndsxpkhl hg rpdegdpk dmsxàmodk hgdvlw hg ’kolifgp l rghdhl hg rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok)swsrgmsïl hls hdpgdxls rliåxdols) `ge olel l rknkegmxl hg ewixk oddi g hg rpld`dîïl hgolmxpkxkp ole l Rlhgp Rú`idol lw pgog`gp `gmgcåodls lw dmogmxdls cdsokds lw opghdxåodls)hdpgxk lw dmhdpgxkegmxg) rlp mïl xgp sdhl rplkhl hg {wg päws) rlp gsxgs kxls) kopgsogpke lskilpgs kxkokhls) lw rkpxg hgigs) k sgws rkxpdeømdls QsdoU―- Mk rpgsgmxg pgoikekîïl) krlmxk%sg k wswprkîïl hk olergxêmodk hgsxk Olpxg rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp) lpdndmkpdkegmxg) ’mksdmcpkî÷gs rgmkds olewms g mls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl― &kpx- ;20)

D) ’o―) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki$- Kcdpek%sg xke`äe l okpëxgp rgmki hks skmî÷gs olmxdhks mkIgd hg Derpl`dhkhg &Igd ml 6-804) hg ;440$- Kpnwegmxk%sg) ge sg{ùêmodk) {wg ls kxls hgderpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk hg kngmxgs rliåxdols {wkidcdoke%sg olel opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Olmoiwd%sg) rlp cde) {wg xkds opdegs) xgmhl ge dsxk k rpgpplnkxdk hg clplhk{wgigs kngmxgs rliåxdols) hgge sgp jwinkhls lpdndmkpdkegmxg ml _XC) mls xgpels hl kpx-;20) D) ’o―) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki) dmlokmhl%sg olel pgclpîl hgssk xgsg) k hgodsïl rplcgpdhk rgil gedmgmxg Edmdsxpl Mgislm Jl`de mls kwxls hk Pgoikekîïl ml 0-;?6- Geolmoiwsïl) rlsxwik%sg: ’k$ k hgxgpedmkîïl idedmkp hg swsrgmsïl deghdkxk hg xlhls ls kxlshgodsÿpdls rpkxdokhls mls Rplogssls mls- 43-22-2;2>4%2 g 47-22-02668%4) ge xpàedxg jwmxl â02k- g â 00k- Skpks Cghgpkds hk _gîïl Jwhdodëpdk hl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki) pgsrgoxdkegmxg) `geolel hg {wkds{wgp lwxpls kxls rplogsswkds k gigs pgikodlmkhls1 `$ k hgxgpedmkîïl idedmkp hg

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 0?,82

Page 24: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 24/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

pgegssk k gsxg _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki hls Rplogssls mls- 43-22-2;2>4%2 g 47-22-02668%4)ge xpàedxg jwmxl â 02k- g â 00k- Skpks Cghgpkds hk _gîïl Jwhdodëpdk hl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki)pgsrgoxdkegmxg1 o$ k pg{wdsdîïl hg dmclpekî÷gs hks kwxlpdhkhgs pgoikekhks1 h$ k ldxdk hkRplowpkhlpdk%Ngpki hk Pgrú`idok) mk clpek pgndegmxki1 g$ k rploghêmodk hk kîïl rkpk: d$klokp ge hgcdmdxdl l olmfgodegmxl hl rplogssl &PD_XC) kpx- ;32) D$1 dd$ pgolmfgogmhl kdmolergxêmodk k`sliwxk hls jwåzls pgoikekhls) oksskp ls kxls hgodsÿpdls rpkxdokhls rgikskwxlpdhkhgs {wg sg kplpkpke hk olergxêmodk hl _XC) ge gsrgodki) k sgmxgmîk rplcgpdhk mkkîïl ml 43-22-2;2>4%21 ddd$ hgxgpedmkp eghdhk khg{wkhk â l`sgpàmodk hg swk jwpdshdîïl){wki sgjk: k dmxdekîïl hl Rplowpkhlp%Ngpki hk Pgrú`idok rkpk dmhknkp kogpok hg sgw dmxgpgssgml rplogsskegmxl ge olmjwmxl lw ge sgrkpkhl hks kî÷gs pgoikekhks) mgssk Olpxg) sl` kclpek hg Kîïl Lpdndmëpdk Gsrgodki % KL) mk clpek hk Pgsliwîïl,_XC ml 0?2) hg 0? hg ekdlhg 02201 g$ k rplhwîïl hg rplk rlp xlhls ls egdls khedxdhls ge hdpgdxl) ge gsrgodki) khlowegmxki-― Hgcgpd k idedmkp &cis- ;2> k ;00$- K Wmdïl pg{wgpgw sgw dmnpgssl ml cgdxl) mk{wkidhkhg hg idxdsolmslpxg kxdk) ole cwmhkegmxl ml ® ?l hl kpx- ;> hk Igd ml 6-804) hg 20hg jwmfl hg ;440- Hgcgpd gsxg rghdhl &ci- ;04$- Rpgsxkpke dmclpekî÷gs ks kwxlpdhkhgs jwhdodkds pgoikekhks &cis- ;30 k ;3?) Jwdz Cghgpki hk 00ª Skpk1 g ci- ;4?) Jwdz Cghgpki hk 02ªSkpk$- L Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki) ge rkpgogp hk ikpk hl Sdog%Rplowpkhlp%Ngpki hkPgrú`idok) Hp- Fkplihl Cgppkz hk Mÿ`pgnk) lrdmk ml sgmxdhl hl hgcgpdegmxl hk rpgsgmxgpgoikekîïl &cis- ;>? k ;63$- Rkssl k hgodhdp- Ml oksl hls kwxls) ls pgoikekmxgs clpke

olmhgmkhls mk Kîïl mº 43-22-2;2>4%2) ge rpdegdpk dmsxàmodk) k pgsskpodp kl gpëpdl rú`idolgp`ks kilokhks rkpk l rknkegmxl hls olppgmxdsxks hls `kmols sl` dmxgpgmîïl &kpx- ;0) DD) hkIgd mº 6-804,40$) ge ckog hl RPLGP) mls sgnwdmxgs xgpels: ’Rgil gvrlsxl) JWINLRPLOGHGMXG) ge rkpxg) l rghdhl hl Kwxlp ERC) rkpk olmhgmkp ls päws RGHPL_KERKDL EKIKM) JL_Ä _GPPK) RGHPL RWIIGM RKPGMXG) NW_XKSL JLPNGIK@LD__DÄPG ILTLIK) KIADEKP KMHPKHG) NW_XKSL FGMPD[WG HG@KPPL_L CPKMOL) CPKMOD_OL IKCKDGXG HG RËHWK ILRG_) kl pgsskpodegmxl hlgpëpdl hks gp`ks kilokhks rkpk l rknkegmxl hls olppgmxdsxks hls `kmols sl` dmxgpgmîïl&kpx- ;0) DD) hk Igd mº 6-804,40$- Hgdvl hg kolifgp l rghdhl hg rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok)swsrgmsïl hls hdpgdxls rliåxdols) `ge olel) rknkegmxl hg ewixk oddi g hg rpld`dîïl hgolmxpkxkp ole l Rlhgp Rú`idol lw pgog`gp `gmgcåodls lw dmogmxdls cdsokds lw opghdxåodls)hdpgxk lw dmhdpgxkegmxg) rlp mïl xgp sdhl rplkhl hg {wg päws) rlp gsxgs kwxls) kopgsogpke ls

kilpgs kxkokhls) lw rkpxg hgigs) k sgws rkxpdeømdls- Rknkpïl ls päws ks owsxks rplogsswkds gflmlpëpdls khlokxåodls {wg kp`dxpl) mls xgpels hl ®8º) hl kpx- 02) hl ORO) ge ;2' sl`pg lkilp kxpd`wåhl k okwsk) kl sgp kolifdhk k derwnmkîïl) lw sgjk) hg P( 020-437-222)22 &cis-?3>$) rkpk 2> hg jwifl hg ;446) olppdndhl elmgxkpdkegmxg rgils åmhdogs hl DROK,D@NG) kolmxkp hk hkxk hl kjwdzkegmxl kxä k hkxk hl gcgxdl rknkegmxl- Pghwzl l rgpogmxwki hg ;2'&hgz rlp ogmxl$) rkpk k egxkhg) lw sgjk 27' &odmol rlp ogmxl$) ckog â swowe`êmodk rkpodki hlkwxlp) EDMD_XÄPDL RÚ@IDOL CGHGPKI-― &ci- ;20$ Ks kî÷gs odds clpke kjwdzkhks rgikswrlsxk rpëxdok hg kxls hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) ls {wkds xgpdke sdhl olegxdhls k rkpxdp hg knlsxl hg ;447) {wkmhl hk opdkîïl) rgil Olmsgifl Elmgxëpdl Mkodlmki) hlRplnpkek hg Gsxåewil â Pggsxpwxwpkîïl g kl Clpxkigodegmxl hl _dsxgek Cdmkmogdpl Mkodlmki&RPLGP$- Olmxpk k sgmxgmîk rplcgpdhk rgil jwdz hk 02ª Skpk hk _gîïl Jwhdodëpdk Cghgpki)

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 08,82

Page 25: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 25/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

clpke lrlsxls ge`kpnls hgoikpkxÿpdls) ls {wkds mïl clpke olmfgodhls &cis- 028%023$- Gedpxwhg hk hgodsïl idedmkp rplcgpdhk mk rpgsgmxg pgoikekîïl) l Jwdz Cghgpki hk 02ª Skpk hk_gîïl Jwhdodëpdk hl Hdsxpdxl Cghgpki swsrgmhgw l rpkzl pgowpski mk{wgig cgdxl &ci- 02>$) xgmhll Jwdz Cghgpki hk 00ª Skpk xke`äe swsrgmhdhl l cgdxl ml gsxkhl ge {wg sg gmolmxpkk &cis-;30%;3?$- _woghg {wg) â ärlok ge {wg clpke kjwdzkhks ks pgcgpdhks kî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhg&Hgzge`pl hg ;447 g Jkmgdpl hg ;443$) ls päws &lpk pgoikekmxgs$ gpke Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl)hg clpek {wg) mls xgpels hl {wg pgsxlw hgodhdhl rgil _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki mkPgoikekîïl mº 0;?6,HC) Pgi- Edm- Mgislm Jl`de) Pgikxlp rkpk l koÿphïl Edm- Ndiekp Egmhgs) Rigml) Jwinkegmxl ;?,23,2>) k hgodsïl lpk pgoikekhk) cld rplcgpdhk rlp jwdzekmdcgsxkegmxg dmolergxgmxg) sgmhl) rlpxkmxl) sdxwkîïl ge {wg sg okpkoxgpdzk mwidhkhgk`sliwxk hls kxls derwnmkhls- L hgodhdhl rlp gsxk Olpxg mk Pgoikekîïl mº 0;?6,HChgdvlw oikpl {wg ls kxls hg derpl`dhkhg hgsopdxls mk Igd ml 6-804) hg ;440) olmsxdxwgekwxêmxdols opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Dssl rlp{wg ks skmî÷gs hg swsrgmsïl hg hdpgdxlsrliåxdols g hg rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok hgelmsxpke) hg elhl dmg{wålol) {wg ks kî÷gshg derpl dhkhg rlsswge) kiäe hg clpxg olmxgúhl rgmki) k cgdîïl hg kwxêmxdolegokmdsel hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl rliåxdok- Xkds skmî÷gs) {wkmhl kridokhks gsrgodcdokegmxgk Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) rlp ogpxl mïl rlhge sgp xlekhks olel egpks skmî÷gs hg åmhlig oddi- Mïl ä hdcåodi rgpog`gp k npkdhkhg hg xkds skmî÷gs g k swk deridokîïl mk gscgpk hg id`gphkhghk{wgigs kngmxgs rliåxdols- Hg elhl ekds rpgodsl) ä mgogssëpdl gmckxdzkp {wg ls gcgdxls hg

xkds skmî÷gs ge ewdxl wixpkrksske l dmxgpgssg dmhddhwki hls Edmdsxpls gmlidhls- Xki äge`igeëxdol) ml oksl gsrgoåcdol hls kwxls) rlds k olmhgmkîïl) jë ge 0220) kxdmndk ls {wksg? `dif÷gs hg pgkds) l {wg hddhdhl gmxpg ls ;2 päws) ckz rpgswedp olmhgmkîïl dmhddhwki hg{wksg ?22 edif÷gs hg pgkds- Gsxgs hkhls) rlp sd egsels) hgelmsxpke l k`swphl hl {wg sggsxë k hdsowxdp- Ls kilpgs sïl xïl gsxpkxlscäpdols {wg) mk rpÿrpdk sgmxgmîk olmhgmkxÿpdk) lsflmlpëpdls khlokxåodls clpke kp`dxpkhls ge ekds hg 022 edif÷gs hg pgkds) sgmhl pghwzdhls rgik egxkhg) lw sgjk) {wkmxdk ge xlpml hg ;22 edif÷gs hg pgkds) ge ckog hk swowe`êmodk rkpodki hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki- Mïl pgsxk húdhk hg {wg l _wrpgel Xpd`wmkiCghgpki) kl jwinkp k Pgoikekîïl 0;?6,HC) kok`lw rlp kssgmxkp {wg) ml {wg xlok klshgmledmkhls kxls hg derpl`dhkhg) gm{wkmxl opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ls Edmdsxplshg Gsxkhl gsxïl swjgdxls gvoiwsdkegmxg kl pgndeg hk Igd ml ;-2>4) hg ;2 hg k`pdi hg;472) hg elhl {wg k krwpkîïl hg kxls hg derpl`dhkhg kxpd`wåhls k xkds kngmxgs) mls

xgpels hl kpx- ;20) D) ’o―) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl) gmolmxpk%sg swjgdxk â olergxêmodk hl_wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki- Skig xpkmsopggp k gegmxk hl pgcgpdhl jwinkhl) ml rkpxdowikp:’&---$ DD-;-Derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk- Opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Ls kxls hg derpl`dhkhgkhedmdsxpkxdk sïl xdrdcdokhls olel opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg mk Igd m² ;-2>4,;472) hgidxlhg okpëxgp rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdl- DD-0-Hdsxdmîïl gmxpg ls pgndegs hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk- L sdsxgek olmsxdxwodlmki `pksdigdpl hdsxdmnwg l pgndeg hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg hls kngmxgs rliåxdols hls hgekds kngmxgs rú`idols- K Olmsxdxwdîïl mïlkhedxg k olmolppêmodk gmxpg hlds pgndegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk lskngmxgs rliåxdols: l rpgdsxl ml kpx- ?>) ® 8º &pgnwikhl rgik Igd m² 6-804,;440$ g l pgndegcdvkhl ml kpx- ;20) D) ’o―) &hdsodridmkhl rgik Igd m² ;-2>4,;472$- _g k olergxêmodk rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp k kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg &OC) kpx- ?>) ® 8º$ rwhgssg k`pkmngp xke`äe kxls

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 07,82

Page 26: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 26/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 rpkxdokhls rgils kngmxgs rliåxdols) sw`egxdhls k pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg gsrgodki) xgp%sg%dk wek dmxgprpgxkîïl k`%plnkmxg hl hdsrlsxl ml kpx- ;20) D) ’o―) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl- DD-?-Pgndeggsrgodki- Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl- Ls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) rlp gsxkpge pgndhls rlp mlpeksgsrgodkds hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg &OC) kpx- ;20) D) ’o―1 Igd m² ;-2>4,;472$) mïl sg sw`egxge klelhgil hg olergxêmodk rpgdsxl ml pgndeg olewe hk Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk&Igd m² 6-804,;440$- DD-8-Opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Olergxêmodk hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmkiCghgpki- Olergxg gvoiwsdkegmxg kl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki rplogsskp g jwinkp ls hgidxls rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdls) mk fdrÿxgsg hl kpx- ;20) D) ’o―) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl- _legmxg l _XC rlhg rplogsskp g jwinkp Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl ml oksl hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg g) kssde)ggmxwkiegmxg) hgxgpedmkp k rgphk hl okpnl lw k swsrgmsïl hg hdpgdxls rliåxdols- &---$― Hgckxl) xki olel egmodlmlw l Edmdsxpl Mgislm Jl`de ge sgw lxl rlp loksdïl hl jwinkegmxlhk Pgoikekîïl 0;?6,HC) k {wgsxïl `ësdok {wg sg olilok ä k rlssd`didhkhg hg olmolppêmodk hghlds pgndegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk ls kngmxgs rliåxdols: &;$ lpgndeg rpgdsxl ml ® 8l hl kpx- ?> hk Olmsxdxwdîïl) g pgnwikhl rgik Igd ml 6-804) hg ;4401 g&0$ l pgndeg hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg pgcgpdhl ml kpx- ;20) D) ’o― hk Olmsxdxwdîïl ghdsodridmkhl rgik Igd ml ;-2>4) hg ;472- Ls kxls hg derpl`dhkhg) gm{wkmxl opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg) gsxïl kerikegmxg olmxgerikhls ml Okråxwil S hk Igd ml ;-2>4) hg ;472-Gsxk igd) ge sgw kpx- 4l) olmxäe hdsodridmk gvrpgssk hl {wg hgmledmk opdeg hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg olmxpk k rpl`dhkhg mk khedmdsxpkîïl- K rgmk kid rpgdsxk xke`äe ä sggpk)

 rlds kiokmîk k rgphk hl okpnl g dmk`didxkîïl rkpk l gvgpoåodl hg cwmîïl rú`idok rgil rpkzl hgkxä odmol kmls &kpx- 0l$- Khgekds) k derlsdîïl hg xki rgmk mïl gvoiwd l rplogssl g jwinkegmxl rlp opdeg olewe &kpx- ?l$- Pgndsxpg%sg {wg ä l kpx- ;? hk egsek igd {wg rpgê k kridokîïlhk{wgiks skmî÷gs kls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl- Ä gdhgmxg) rlpxkmxl) mk hdsodridmk hk Igd mº;-2>4) k {wkidcdokîïl hls kxls hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk olegxdhls rlp Edmdsxpls hgGsxkhl olel opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Kssde) olmsdhgpkmhl%sg {wg ls kxls hgderpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk olegxdhls rgils Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl sïl) mls xgpels hkOlmsxdxwdîïl g hk igndsikîïl {wg k olmopgxdzk) opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) olmoiwd%sg {wg xkdsopdegs gmolmxpke%sg swjgdxls â pgnpk hg olergxêmodk hl kpx- ;20) D) ’o―) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl- Gelwxpks rkikpks) ls Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl mïl sg swjgdxke â hdsodridmk hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl hg{wg xpkxk k Igd ml 6-804) hg ;440) hg elhl {wg sg kcdnwpk dergpdlsl l pgolmfgodegmxl hkolergxêmodk hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki xlhk gz {wg sg xpkxkp hg kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg

eldhk olmxpk Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl lw olmxpk dmxgnpkmxgs hg xpd`wmkds swrgpdlpgs &kpx- ;20) D)"o") hk Olmsxdxwdîïl$- Mïl sg rlhg hgdvkp {wg olmsdnmkp {wg we hls rpl`igeks cwmhkegmxkdshk slodghkhg hg pdsol ä k kssdmkiknekxdodhkhg hl pdsol- Xki l`sgpkîïl ä `ksxkmxg rgpxdmgmxg rkpk wek olppgxk olerpggmsïl hk kxddhkhg hgsgergmfkhk rgils Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) `geolel hl hdcgpgmodkhl pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl hg xkds kngmxgs- Hg ckxl) l pdsol rpgsgmxgmks hgods÷gs hg we Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl jkekds rlhgpdk sgp g{wdrkpkhl kl pdsol hg wekhgodsïl hg we kngmxg rú`idol olewe- Hkå l g{wålol hks k`lphkngms {wg rpgxgmhge gp k rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl olel lcgmsdk kl rpdmoårdl hk dslmledk- Gssg ä we ømws hk kxddhkhg hg{wge xge l`pdnkxlpdkegmxg {wg hgodhdp- L {wg rkpgog k`swphl ä xgmxkp gsxk`gigogp wekg{wkîïl ml sgmxdhl hg {wg xlhl g {wki{wgp kxl dignki derwxëgi â khedmdsxpkîïl rú`idokderidok we kxl hg derpl`dhkhg hg we kngmxg rú`idol- Gssk olmcwsïl dmkogdxëgi ä ol%dpeï hk

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 03,82

Page 27: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 27/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

olmogrîïl {wg xgmxk dsiwe pkp ks kî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhg olel we sderigs egokmdsel hgpgsrlmsk`didzkîïl oddi- Hg ckxl) mïl ä olppgxl xlekp ks skmî÷gs rlp derpl`dhkhg olelskmî÷gs hg åmhlig egpkegmxg oddi- Kl olmxpëpdl) ks skmî÷gs hg swsrgmsïl hg hdpgdxls rliåxdols g hg rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok hgelmsxpke) hg elhl dmg{wålol) {wg ks kî÷gs hgderpl`dhkhg rlsswge) sl`pgxwhl) mkxwpgzk rgmki- Mïl ä hdcåodi rgpog`gp k npkdhkhg hg xkdsskmî÷gs g k swk deridokîïl mk gscgpk hg id`gphkhg hk{wgigs kngmxgs rliåxdols- Ml àe`dxl hkkîïl hg derpl`dhkhg) ge gphkhg) gpdcdok%sg {wg ls gcgdxls hk olmhgmkîïl rlhge swrgpkp k{wgigs kxpd`wåhls â sgmxgmîk rgmki olmhgmkxÿpdk) rlhgmhl olmxgp) xke`äe) gcgdxls ekdsnpklsls rkpk l g{wdiå`pdl jwpåhdol%dmsxdxwodlmki hl {wg ggmxwki sgmxgmîk olmhgmkxÿpdk hgokpëxgp rgmki- G mïl sg hdnk {wg l ckxl hg ls pgoikekmxgs mïl ekds gsxkpge lowrkmhl lsokpnls rliåxdols) {wg lowrkke â ärlok hl kjwdzkegmxl hks kî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhg) hgsilok kolergxêmodk hgsxk Olpxg) rlds mïl ä rlssågi elhdcdokp k sdxwkîïl cëxdol%fdsxÿpdok hg sg gsxkp  jwinkegmxl swrlsxls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ls {wkds sïl hg olergxêmodk gvoiwsdk hl_wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki- Mïl fë lwxpl jwåzl olergxgmxg rkpk rplogsskp g jwinkp lspgoikekmxgs rgik rpëxdok hg opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) jë {wg ls kxls swrlsxkegmxg diåodxls kgigs derwxkhls pgcgpge%sg â ärlok ge {wg lowrkke okpnls hg kngmxgs rliåxdols- Lwxplssde)flwg l hgcgpdegmxl hg eghdhk idedmkp mk rpgsgmxg pgoikekîïl) hdkmxg hk rikwsd`didhkhg jwpåhdok hk xgsg hk mwidhkhg k`sliwxk hks hgods÷gs pgoikekhks) ge ckog hk dmolergxêmodkk`sliwxk hls jwåzgs cghgpkds rkpk rplogsskpge g jwinkpge ks pgcgpdhks kî÷gs hg derpl`dhkhg)

hg elhl {wg k swrgpgmdgmxg rgphk hls okpnls rliåxdols gmxïl lowrkhls mïl rlhg xgp olelolmsg{ùêmodk) sderigsegmxg) l pgolmfgodegmxl hg gcgdxls âs hgods÷gs {wg clpke rplcgpdhks rlp jwåzgs ekmdcgsxkegmxg dmolergxgmxgs- Hdkmxg hl gvrlsxl) jwinl rploghgmxg k rpgsgmxgPgoikekîïl) rkpk hgxgpedmkp l kp{wdkegmxl hks jë pgcgpdhks kî÷gs kjwdzkhks rgpkmxg k 02ª g00ª Skpks Cghgpkds ge hgscklp hls pgoikekmxgs) mls xgpels hl kpx- ;3;) rkpënpkcl úmdol) hlPgndegmxl Dmxgpml hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki- Rw`id{wg%sg- @pksåidk) 00 hg k`pdi hg 0226-Edmdsxpl NDIEKP EGMHG_ Pgikxlp&Poi 0;63) Pgikxlp&k$: Edm- NDIEKP EGMHG_) jwinkhl ge 00,28,0226) rw`idokhl ge HJg%2>6 HDSWIN ?2,28,0226 RW@IDO 20,27,0226$&npdcgd$

Jwinkegmxls ekds pgogmxgs hl _wrgpdlp Xpd wmki hg Jwsxdîk xke`äe

olmxdmwke k khlxkp l gmxgmhdegmxl ekmdcgsxkhl rgil _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki mkPgoikekîïl mº 0-;?6:

RPLOG__L ODSDI G KHEDMD_XPKXDSL- KNPKSL PGNDEGMXKI ML PGOWP_LG_RGODKI- KÎÏL HG DERPL@DHKHG KHEDMD_XPKXDSK OLMXPK KNGMXGRLIÅXDOL _WJGDXL Â IGD M- ;-2>4,72- MÏL OK@DEGMXL-

;- Ls kngmxgs rliåxdols sw`egxdhls kl pgndeg gsrgodki hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl hk Igd;-2>4,72 mïl rlhge sgp rplogsskhls rlp opdegs hg pgsrlmsk didhkhg rgil pgndeg hk Igdhg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk) sl` rgmk hk wswprkîïl hk olergxêmodk hl _XC g

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 0>,82

Page 28: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 28/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

rpdmodrkiegmxg rgil ckxl hg {wg ke`ls ls hdrileks) Igds ms- 6-804,40 g ;-2>4,;472)rpgêge skmî÷gs hg lphge rliåxdok) oksl {wg fkgpdk rlssd`didhkhg hg `ds dm dhge sgflwgssg hwrik rwmdîïl rliåxdok rlp we kxl xdrdcdokhl mks hwks igds ge clol-Jwpdsrpwhêmodk hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki &Pgoikekîïl 0-;?6,HC) Pgi- Edm- MgislmJl`de) Pgi-

 r, koÿphïl Edm- Ndiekp Egmhgs) HJ ;6-28-0226$- Kridok`didhkhg ml àe`dxl hl _XJ-Rpgoghgmxg: [L mk KDK 0>,HC) Pgi- Edm- Mkmot Kmhpdnfd) Olpxg Gsrgodki) HJg 24,20,0224-

0- Mïl sg kridokmhl k IDK kl oksl hls kwxls) mïl xge olergxêmodk l jwdz hg rpdegdplnpkw rkpk krpgodkp g jwinkp ls kxls derwxkhls) g xkerlwol ä dëgi k pgegssk hls kwxls â_wrpgek Olpxg) hkhl {wg l rploghdegmxl rpgdsxl mk Igd 6-804,40) k {wg sg pgcgpg k kîïl{wg hgw lpdnge kl rpgsgmxg pgowpsl) ä hdgpsl hl pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg hk Igd;-2>4,72) ge pgikîïl kl {wki ls hgekmhkhls sg sw`egxge-

?- Knpkl pgndegmxki mïl rpldhl-&KnPn ml PGsr ;;032>4,PJ) Pgi- Edmdsxpl @GMGHDXL NLMÎKISG_) RPDEGDPK

XWPEK) jwinkhl ge 03,28,02;;) HJg 20,23,02;;$

Hl Pgndeg hg Pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok rlp Kxlshg Derpl`dhkhg

 K Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki gvrpgsskegmxg gsxk`gigogw {wg ls kxls {wg kxgmxge

olmxpk k rpl dhkhg hk khedmdsxpkîïl) {wkmhl rpkxdokhls rgil Rpgsdhgmxg hk

Pgrú`idok) olmsxdxwge opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg- Ä l xglp hl kpx- 67) gp`ds:

Hk Pgsrlmsk`didhkhg hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok

 Kpx- 67- _ïl opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg ls kxls hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok {wgkxgmxge olmxpk k Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki g) gsrgodkiegmxg) olmxpk:

 D % k gvdsxêmodk hk Wmdïl1

 DD % l idpg gvgpoåodl hl Rlhgp Igndsikxdl) hl Rlhgp Jwhdodëpdl) hl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol ghls Rlhgpgs olmsxdxwodlmkds hks wmdhkhgs hk Cghgpkîïl1

 DDD % l gvgpoåodl hls hdpgdxls rliåxdols) dmhddhwkds g slodkds1

 DS % k sgnwpkmîk dmxgpmk hl Rkås1

S % k rpl`dhkhg mk khedmdsxpkîïl1

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 06,82

Page 29: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 29/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

SD % k igd lpîkegmxëpdk1

SDD % l owerpdegmxl hks igds g hks hgods÷gs jwhdodkds-

 Rkpënpkcl úmdol- Gssgs opdegs sgpïl hgcdmdhls ge igd gsrgodki) {wg gsxk`gigogpë ks

mlpeks hg rplogssl g jwinkegmxl- &npdcgd$

 K igd gsrgodki k {wg sg pgcgpg l rkpënpkcl úmdol hl kpx- 67) kodek xpkmsopdxl) äk Igd mº ;-2>4,72) {wg hgcdmg ls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg g pgnwik l pgsrgoxdl

rplogssl hg jwinkegmxl- [wkmxl âs olmhwxks pgikxdks kl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok

gsxk`gigog:

 Kpx- 8º  _ïl opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg ls kxls hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok {wg kxgmxkpge

olmxpk k Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki) g) gsrgodkiegmxg) olmxpk: D % K gvdsxêmodk hk Wmdïl: DD % L idpg gvgpoåodl hl Rlhgp Igndsikxdl) hl Rlhgp Jwhdodëpdl g hls rlhgpgsolmsxdxwodlmkds hls Gsxkhls1

 DDD % L gvgpoåodl hls hdpgdxls rliåxdols) dmhddhwkds g slodkds: DS % K sgnwpkmîk dmxgpmk hl rkås:S % K rpl`dhkhg mk khedmdsxpkîïl1SD % K igd lpîkegmxëpdk1SDD % K nwkphk g l ignki gerpgnl hls hdmfgdpls rú`idols1SDDD % L owerpdegmxl hks hgods÷gs jwhdodëpdks &Olmsxdxwdîïl) kpxdnl 64$-

&---$

 Kpx- 4º _ïl opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg olmxpk k rpl`dhkhg mk khedmdsxpkîïl:

; % ledxdp lw pgxkphkp hlilskegmxg k rw`idokîïl hks igds g pgsliwî÷gs hl Rlhgp Igndsikxdl

lw hls kxls hl Rlhgp Gvgowxdl10 % mïl rpgsxkp kl Olmnpgssl Mkodlmki hgmxpl hg sgssgmxk hdks krÿs k k`gpxwpk hk sgssïligndsikxdk) ks olmxks pgikxdks kl gvgpoåodl kmxgpdlp1? % mïl xlpmkp gcgxdk k pgsrlmsk`didhkhg hls sgws sw`lphdmkhls) {wkmhl ekmdcgsxk gehgidxls cwmodlmkds lw mk rpëxdok hg kxls olmxpëpdls â Olmsxdxwdîïl18 % gvrghdp lphgms lw ckzgp pg{wdsdîïl hg clpek olmxpëpdk âs hdsrlsdî÷gs gvrpgssks hkOlmsxdxwdîïl17 % dmcpdmndp ml rpldegmxl hls okpnls rú`idols) ks mlpeks ignkds13 % Wskp hg dliêmodk lw kegkîk olmxpk cwmodlmëpdl rú`idol rkpk olknå%il k rploghgp dignkiegmxg) `ge olel wxdidzkp%sg hg sw`lpml lw hg {wki{wgp lwxpk clpek hg olppwrîïl

 rkpk l egsel cde1 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- 04,82

Page 30: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 30/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

> % rploghgp hg elhl dmolerkxågi ole k hdnmdhkhg) k flmpk g l hgolpl hl okpnl-

L xpkxkegmxl hdcgpgmodkhl olmcgpdhl kl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok rgik

Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki) kodek hgelmsxpkhl) mïl sg idedxk kls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg)

olmclpeg gmsdmk Kigvkmhpg hg Elpkgs07:

’Hdcgpgmxgegmxg hl rpdmoårdl hk k`sliwxk dppgsrlmsk`didhkhg) dmgpgmxg kl okpëxgp dxkiåodl hl okpnl pgki &Xfg Admn okm hl ml ~plmn$) k Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki rpgê pgnpksgsrgodkds hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) xkmxl rlp dmcpkî÷gs rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdks) {wkmhl rlp dmcpkî÷gs rgmkds-

L Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok rlsswd dewmdhkhgs clpekds ge pgikîïl kl rplogssl) rlds slegmxg rlhgpë sgp rplogsskhl) sgjk rlp opdeg olewe) sgjk rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg)krÿs l jwåzl hg khedssd`didhkhg hk Oàekpk hls Hgrwxkhls) {wg mgogssdxkpë hl lxl hg 0,?hg sgws ege`pls rkpk kwxlpdzkp l rplogssl- G) xke`äe) ge pgikîïl â rpdsïl) rlds mïl

 rlhgpë sgp rpgsl mks dmcpkî÷gs rgmkds olewms) gm{wkmxl mïl sl`pgdgp sgmxgmîkolmhgmkxÿpdk) olel rpgogdxwk k Okpxk Eknmk &OC) kpx- 63) ® ?º$-

 Kiäe hdssl) l Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok ä pgikxdkegmxg dppgsrlmsëgi) rlds mk dnêmodkhg sgw ekmhkxl) mïl rlhgpë sgp pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rlp kxls gsxpkmfls kl gvgpoåodl hg swks cwmî÷gs&---$

 K Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki xke`äe rpgê rkpk l Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl) rlds slegmxg _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki rlhgpë rplogssë%il g jwinë%il rlp opdegsolewms &OC) kpx- ;20) D) `$ g slegmxg l _gmkhl Cghgpki rlhgpë rplogssë%il g jwinë%il rgilsofkekhls opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg &OC) kpx- 70) D$-―

 Kssde) kdmhk {wg mïl sg olmolphg ole xki sdsxgek hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg

gsxk`gigodhl rkpk l Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) gsxg ä l hgcdmdhl rgik Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki-

Rlpxkmxl) mïl fë {wg sg ckikp ge ckowihkhg hg gsolifk gmxpg rplogsskp l

Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) rlp kxl kxgmxkxÿpdl â rpl`dhkhg hk khedmdsxpkîïl) ole `ksg mk

Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk &Igd mº 6-804,40$ lw rgik Igd hg Opdeg hg

Pgsrlmsk`didhkhg &Igd mº ;-2>4,72$- K rpÿrpdk Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki kcdpelw {wg ls kxls hg

derpl`dhkhg) rkpk l Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) olmsxdxwge opdegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg

owjks rgmkidhkhgs) rplogsskegmxl g jwinkegmxl sgpdke hgcdmdhks ge igd gsrgodki)

07 Hdpgdxl Olmsxdxwodlmki) 08ª Ghdîïl) Ghdxlpk Kxiks) _ïl Rkwil) 0224) r- 860- \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?2,82

Page 31: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 31/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

kxwkiegmxg) k Igd mº ;-2>4,72-Xpkxk%sg) hgsxkpxg) hg pgnpk gsxk`gigodhk rgil rpÿrpdl

Igndsikhlp Olmsxdxwdmxg) owjl owerpdegmxl sg der÷g- L gvkwpdegmxl hl ekmhkxl hl

Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) kssde) mïl xge l olmhïl hg ckzgp pgmksogp k rlssd`didhkhg hg

 rgpsgowxdl dm jwhdodl) knlpk ole cwmhkegmxl mk Igd hg Derpl dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk) rgil

mïl gvgpoåodl hk kîïl rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg ml elegmxl g clpek khg{wkhls-

Gsxg cld l gmxgmhdegmxl ekmdcgsxkhl rgil Edmdsxpl XGLPD KI@DML

ZKSK_OAD {wkmhl hl jwinkegmxl hk Poi 0>42:

OLM_XDXWODLMKI- OLERGXÊMODK- KÎÏL HG DERPL@DHKHG OLMXPKNLSGPMKHLP HG G_XKHL- HWRIL PGNDEG _KMODLMKXßPDL HL_ KNGMXG_RLIÅXDOL_: IGNDXDEDHKHG- CLPL RLP RPGPPLNKXDSK HG CWMÎÏL:PGOLMFGODEGMXL-

W_WPRKÎÏL HG OLERGXÊMODK HL _XJ- RPLOGHÊMODK RKPODKI HKPGOIKEKÎÏL-

;- Gvogxwkhk k fdrÿxgsg hg kxls hg derpl`dhkhg rpkxdokhls rgil Rpgsdhgmxg hk

Pgrú`idok &kpx- 67) S$) owjl jwinkegmxl sg hë ge pgndeg gsrgodki rgil _gmkhl Cghgpki&kpx- 63$) mïl fë mlpek olmsxdxwodlmki kinwek {wg dewmdzg ls kngmxgs rliåxdols) swjgdxlsk opdeg hg pgsrlmsk didhkhg) hg {wki{wgp hks skmî÷gs rlp kxl hg derpl`dhkhg rpgdsxksml kpx- ?>) ® 8-º- _gpdk dmolerkxågi ole k Olmsxdxwdîïl ggmxwki rpgogdxl mlpekxdldmcpkolmsxdxwodlmki {wg derwsgssg dewmdhkhg hgssk mkxwpgzk-

0- Rlp hgodsïl hg ;? hg ekpîl hg 0226) k _wrpgek Olpxg) ole krgmks we lxlolmxpëpdl) hgoikplw {wg ’olergxg kl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki jwinkp kîïl hg derpl`dhkhgolmxpk sgws ege`pls― &[L mk Rgx- ?-0;;%2) Edm- Egmgzgs Hdpgdxl) HJ 0>-23-0226$-Olmsdhgplw) rkpk xkmxl) {wg k rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl) ge oksls xkds) hgolppg hdpgxkegmxg hlsdsxgek hg olergxêmodks gsxk`gigodhl mk Olmsxdxwdîïl) {wg kssgnwpk k sgws Edmdsxpls clpl rlp rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl) xkmxl ge opdegs olewms) mk rpÿrpdk Olpxg) {wkmxl ge opdegs hgpgsrlmsk`didhkhg) ml _gmkhl Cghgpki- Rlp dssl) "sgpdk k`swphl lw l eëvdel hl olmxpk%sgmslolmog`gp {wg lphge jwpåhdok rgpedxk {wg Edmdsxpl rlssk sgp jwinkhl rlp lwxpl ÿpnïl ge kîïlhdgpsk) eks gmxpg owjks skmî÷gs gsxë xke`äe k rgphk hl okpnl- Dsxl sgpdk k hgsgsxpwxwpkîïlhg xlhl l sdsxgek {wg cwmhkegmxk k hdsxpd`wdîïl hk olergxêmodk" &lxl hl Edm-Ogzkp Rgiwsl$-

?- Gssgs egsels cwmhkegmxls hg mkxwpgzk sdsxgeëxdok kwxlpdzke k olmoiwdp) rlp derlsdîïl iÿndok hg olgpêmodk dmxgprpgxkxdk) {wg mlpek dmcpkolmsxdxwodlmki mïl rlhg kxpd`wdp k jwdz hg rpdegdpl npkw l jwinkegmxl hg kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) ole rlssågikridokîïl hk rgmk hg rgphk hl okpnl) olmxpk Nlgpmkhlp hl Gsxkhl) {wg) k gvgeril hlsEdmdsxpls hl _XC) xke`äe xge kssgnwpkhl clpl rlp rpgpplnkxdk hg cwmîïl) xkmxl ge opdegsolewms &rgpkmxg l _XJ$) {wkmxl ge opdegs hg pgsrlmsk didhkhg &rgpkmxg k pgsrgoxdk

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?;,82

Page 32: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 32/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

Kssge`iädk Igndsikxdk$- Ä hg sg pgolmfgogp {wg) rlp dmkcksxëgi sdegxpdk ole l {wg lolppgge pgikîïl kls opdegs olewms &OC) kpx-

;27) D) k$) fë) ge oksls xkds) olergxêmodk deriåodxk olerigegmxkp hl _wrgpdlp Xpd`wmkihg Jwsxdîk-

8- Pgoikekîïl rploghgmxg) ge rkpxg-&Poi 0>42,_O) Pgi- Edmdsxpl XGLPD KI@DML ZKSK_OAD) OLPXG G_RGODKI)

 jwinkhl ge 20,;0,0224) HJg 28,2?,02;2$

Lpk) â eghdhk {wg l ekmhkxl hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok gvrdpk) cgofke%sg

ks rlpxks rkpk {wg sgjk rplogsskhl rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rlp kxls {wg) ge xgsg)

kxgmxge olmxpk k rpl`dhkhg hk khedmdsxpkîïl ggmxwkiegmxg rpkxdokhls mk{wgig rgpålhl)

`ge olel rkpk {wg ifg sgjke kridokhks ks rgmkidhkhgs kid rpgdsxks-

Xki rpgoiwsïl gmolmxpk%sg gsxkerkhk mk rpÿrpdk Igd mº ;-2>4,72:

 Kpx- ;7- K hgmúmodk sÿ rlhgpë sgp pgog`dhk gm{wkmxl l hgmwmodkhl mïl xdgp) rlp {wki{wgp 

elxdl) hgdvkhl hgcdmdxdkegmxg l okpnl-

 K gvdsxêmodk hg we pgndeg gsrgodkiåssdel hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl rliåxdol%

khedmdsxpkxdk hg {wg ä hgsxdmkxëpdl l Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok rgik rpëxdok hg opdeg

rliåxdol mïl l derghg) gmxpgxkmxl) hg sgp rplogsskhl rlp opdeg olewe-

Mgssg olmxgvxl) mgogssëpdl hgsxkokp ks rgmkidhkhgs rpgdsxks mk Igd mº

;-2>4,72 k {wg gsxë swjgdxl l Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok:

 Kpx- 0º Ls opdegs hgcdmdhls mgsxk igd) kdmhk {wkmhl sderigsegmxg xgmxkhls) sïl rkssågds hk rgmk hg rgphk hl okpnl) ole dmk`didxkîïl) kxä odmol kmls) rkpk l gvgpoåodl hg {wki{wgp 

 cwmîïl rú`idok ) derlsxk rgil _gmkhl Cghgpki mls rplogssls olmxpk l Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok lw Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl) olmxpk ls Edmdsxpls hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki lwolmxpk l Rplowpkhlp Ngpki hk Pgrú`idok-

Gssks rgmks sïl xke`äe rpgdsxks) ole rg{wgmk kixgpkîïl) mk Igd hg

Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk-

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?0,82

Page 33: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 33/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 Kpx- ;0- Dmhgrgmhgmxgegmxg hks skmî÷gs rgmkds) odds g khedmdsxpkxdks rpgdsxks mkigndsikîïl gsrgoåcdok) gsxë l pgsrlmsëgi rgil kxl hg derpl`dhkhg swjgdxl âs sgnwdmxgsoledmkî÷gs) {wg rlhge sgp kridokhks dslikhk lw owewikxdkegmxg) hg kolphl ole k

 npkdhkhg hl ckxl: &Pghkîïl hkhk rgik Igd mº ;0-;02) hg 0224$-

 D % mk fdrÿxgsg hl kpx- 4²) rgphk hls `gms lw kilpgs kopgsodhls didodxkegmxg kl rkxpdeømdl)pgsskpodegmxl dmxgnpki hl hkml) {wkmhl flwgp)  rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok) swsrgmsïl hls

hdpgdxls rliåxdols hg ldxl k hgz kmls ) rknkegmxl hg ewixk oddi hg kxä xpês gzgs l kilp hl

kopäsodel rkxpdelmdki g rpld`dîïl hg olmxpkxkp ole l Rlhgp Rú`idol lw pgog`gp `gmgcåodlslw dmogmxdls cdsokds lw opghdxåodls) hdpgxk lw dmhdpgxkegmxg) kdmhk {wg rlp dmxgpeähdl hg

 rgsslk jwpåhdok hk {wki sgjk sÿodl ekjlpdxëpdl) rgil rpkzl hg hgz kmls1

 DD % mk fdrÿxgsg hl kpx- ;2) pgsskpodegmxl dmxgnpki hl hkml) rgphk hls `gms lw kilpgskopgsodhls didodxkegmxg kl rkxpdeømdl) sg olmolppgp gsxk odpowmsxàmodk ) rgphk hk cwmîïl

 rú`idok) swsrgmsïl hls hdpgdxls rliåxdols hg odmol k ldxl kmls ) rknkegmxl hg ewixk oddi hgkxä hwks gzgs l kilp hl hkml g rpld`dîïl hg olmxpkxkp ole l Rlhgp Rú`idol lw pgog`gp `gmgcåodls lw dmogmxdls cdsokds lw opghdxåodls) hdpgxk lw dmhdpgxkegmxg) kdmhk {wg rlp dmxgpeähdl hg rgsslk jwpåhdok hk {wki sgjk sÿodl ekjlpdxëpdl) rgil rpkzl hg odmol kmls1

 DDD % mk fdrÿxgsg hl kpx- ;;) pgsskpodegmxl dmxgnpki hl hkml) sg flwgp  ) rgphk hk cwmîïl

 rú`idok) swsrgmsïl hls hdpgdxls rliåxdols hg xpês k odmol kmls ) rknkegmxl hg ewixk oddi hgkxä oge gzgs l kilp hk pgewmgpkîïl rgpog`dhk rgil kngmxg g rpld`dîïl hg olmxpkxkp ole l

 Rlhgp Rú`idol lw pgog`gp `gmgcåodls lw dmogmxdls cdsokds lw opghdxåodls) hdpgxk lwdmhdpgxkegmxg) kdmhk {wg rlp dmxgpeähdl hg rgsslk jwpåhdok hk {wki sgjk sÿodl ekjlpdxëpdl)

 rgil rpkzl hg xpês kmls-

 Rkpënpkcl úmdol- Mk cdvkîïl hks rgmks rpgdsxks mgsxk igd l jwdz igkpë ge olmxk k gvxgmsïlhl hkml okwskhl) kssde olel l rplgdxl rkxpdelmdki l`xdhl rgil kngmxg- &npdcgd$

Gsoikpgîk%sg) ml gmxkmxl) {wg l mïl gvgpoåodl hk kîïl rlp opdeg hg

pgsrlmsk`didhkhg mïl nkpkmxg dewmdhkhg kl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) wek gz {wg krpÿrpdk Igd mº ;-2>4,72 gsxk`gigog k rlssd`didhkhg hg jwinkegmxl rlp opdeg olewe:

 Kpx- ?º K derlsdîïl hk rgmk pgcgpdhk ml kpxdnl kmxgpdlp mïl gvoiwd l rplogssl g jwinkegmxl

hl kowskhl rlp opdeg olewe) mk jwsxdîk lphdmëpdk) mls xgpels hks igds hg rplogssl rgmki-―

Pgekmgsog k rlssd`didhkhg hg kjwdzkegmxl hg kîïl oddi rkpk cdms hg

pgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl) olmclpeg kcdpekhl rgil Edmdsxpl Ndiekp Egmhgs) rlp loksdïl hl

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ??,82

Page 34: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 34/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 jwinkegmxl hk Pgoikekîïl 0-;?6%HC) ’gssg `dcplmxdsel hk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg rgphg l

sgw sgmxdhl gssgmodki) rlds rlhgpë sgerpg sgp rplrlsxk) sgerpg) k kîïl oddi rú`idok)

pgnwikhk mk Igd >-?8>) ml {wg olmogpmg k pgsskpodegmxl hg `gms) k `il{wgdl hg `gms) k

xlhk k pgsrlmsk`didhkhg ekxgpdki) ole eghdhks hg sg{wgsxpl-― 

Mk egsek gsxgdpk) l Edmdsxpl Jlk{wde @kp`lsk) ml jwinkegmxl hkPgoikekîïl 0-;?6%HC) swsxgmxlw {wg mïl sgpdk rlssågi k kridokîïl hg xlhks ks

rgmkidhkhgs rpgdsxks mk Igd hg Derpl dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk kls kngmxgs rliåxdols)

khwzdmhl k swk dmolerkxd`didhkhg ml {wg sg pgcgpg â rgmk hg rgphk hg okpnl:

’Rlp cde) _gmflpk Rpgsdhgmxg) olel gw jë khdkmxgd mgsxg egw lxl) fë we rlmxl ge

{wg l egw gmxgmhdegmxl olmgpng rkpodkiegmxg ole l hl gedmgmxg Pgikxlp-  Ä {wg) kegw sgmxdp) mïl ok`g k jwdz hg rpdegdpk dmsxàmodk hgopgxkp) ewdxl egmls ge kîïl hgderpl`dhkhg) k rgphk hl okpnl rliåxdol) hl okpnl hg Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl) rlp sgp gsxkwek elhkidhkhg hg rwmdîïl {wg ä xårdok hl gigmol hg egokmdsels hg olmxplig g

kcgpdîïl hk pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rliåxdok ml sdsxgek rpgsdhgmodki hg nlgpml- Xpkxk%sg)olel jë khdkmxgd) hg gigegmxl okpkoxgpåsxdol hg ofgoas%kmh%`kikmogs xki olel

ekndsxpkiegmxg olmog`dhl mk Olmgmîïl hg Cdikhäicdk) lmhg rgik rpdegdpk gz sg

dmsxdxwodlmkidzlw l sdsxgek hg nlgpml sl` l {wki dgels fë ekds hg we säowil-

 Gvridodxl l egw lxl mgsxg rlmxl- L jwdz hg rpdegdpl npkw rlhg) sde) olmhwzdp kîïl hg

derpl`dhkhg olmxpk kwxlpdhkhgs hgxgmxlpks hg rpgpplnkxdk hg clpl-  Ge olmsg{wêmodk) rlhgpë kridokp lwxpks skmî÷gs rpgdsxks mk Igd  6-804,40) skil wek: mïl rlhgpëhgopgxkp k rgphk hl okpnl rliåxdol) hl okpnl gsxpwxwpkmxg â lpnkmdzkîïl hl Gsxkhl)

 rlds dsxl olmcdnwpkpdk we ckxlp hg hgsgsxk didzkîïl rliåxdol%dmsxdxwodlmki rkpk k {wki kigd hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk mïl ä lokodlmkhk-

 Khdpxl {wg ckîl gsxk úixdek l`sgpkîïl krgmks â nwdsk hg l`dxgphdoxwe) rlds) ml

oksl) l päw mk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg hg lpdnge jë hgdvlw k cwmîïl edmdsxgpdki- Ilnl)

 rgphgw l l`jgxl k pgoikekîïl sg l sgw l`jgxdl gpk l hg derghdp k hgopgxkîïl hk rgphk

hl okpnl hg Edmdsxpl hg Gsxkhl- Xke`äe mïl rlhgpë sgp hgopgxkhk k rgphk hl okpnl

 rliåxdol hg ofgcg hg edssïl hdrileëxdok hg okpëxgp rgpekmgmxg- [wkmxl kl okpnl gcgxdl

{wg l gv%Edmdsxpl hgxäe mk khedmdsxpkîïl rú`idok cghgpki) opgdl {wg) mgssg rlmxl) k

 sgmxgmîk ä k`sliwxkegmxg dmgrxk g diå{wdhk) rlds idedxk%sg k hdzgp l sgnwdmxg: "Cdok

xke`äe olmhgmkhl â rgphk hk cwmîïl rú`idok)  sgjk {wki clp k swk lowrkîïl kxwki mls{wkhpls hl Nlgpml Cghgpki"-  K pgoikekîïl mïl sg rpgsxk kl gsoikpgodegmxl hgssk

l`sowpdhkhg hk sgmxgmîk) xkerlwol l _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki sgpdk l ÿpnïl

olergxgmxg rkpk ckzê%il-

 Jwinl rkpodkiegmxg rploghgmxg k Pgoikekîïl) xïl%slegmxg rkpk hgoikpkp k

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?8,82

Page 35: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 35/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

derlssd`didhkhg hg) mk dk hk kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk pgndhk rgik Igd

6-804,40)  sgp k kwxlpdhkhg dmxgpgsskhk hgsxdxwåhk hl okpnl rliåxdol) ml oksl) mgsxg

elegmxl) l hg ofgcg hg edssïl hdrileëxdok hg okpëxgp rgpekmgmxg- &npdcgd$

[wkmxl kls hgekds ksrgoxls) hggpë k kîïl rplrlsxk xgp l sgw owpsl mlpeki 

 rgpkmxg ks dmsxàmodks lphdmëpdks-― &npdcgd$

Ml rpgsgmxg oksl) k kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk cld kjwdzkhk ml hdk?; hg jkmgdpl hg 02;;) we eês krÿs l cde hl ekmhkhl hl gv%Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok

Iwdz Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik) rgik swrlsxk rpëxdok hg kxl pgrwxkhl rgil Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol

Cghgpki olel okrdxwikhl mk Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk {wg pgelmxk â hkxk hg 04

hg sgxge`pl hg 0228) kdmhk hwpkmxg rpdegdpl ekmhkxl-

L swrlsxl kxl kxgmxkxÿpdl â rpl`dhkhg hk khedmdsxpkîïl rpkxdokhl rgil

Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok olmsxdxwd) ge swk nêmgsg) opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) mïl sg

xpkmsclpekmhl ge kxl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk rgil cde hl ekmhkxl-

 Kdmhk {wg sg khedxdssg k rplrlsdxwpk hg kîïl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk

rkpk rplogsskp Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok) gpdcdol {wg) ml oksl olmopgxl) gsxkpdk rpgsopdxk)

wek gz {wg ls ckxls kxpd`wåhls kls pg{wgpdhls lolppgpke ge 04 hg sgxge`pl hg 0228)

gvoghgmhl l rpkzl rkpk kjwdzkegmxl rpgdsxl ml kpx- 0?) D g DD hk Igd 6-804,40) mïl xgmhl

k pggigdîïl l olmhïl hg dmxgpplergp gssg rpkzl- Pgzk xki hdsrlsdxdl {wg:

 Kpx- 0?- Ks kî÷gs hgsxdmkhks k igkp k gcgdxls ks skmî÷gs rpgdsxks mgsxk igd rlhge sgp 

 rplrlsxks:

 D % kxä odmol kmls krÿs l xäpedml hl gvgpoåodl hg ekmhkxl) hg okpnl ge oledssïl lw hg cwmîïl hg olmcdkmîk1

 Kidës) xki ckxl cld pgolmfgodhl rgil rpÿrpdl Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki

pgikxdkegmxg kl sgnwmhl pg{wgpdhl) Kedp Cpkmodsol Ikmhl:

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?7,82

Page 36: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 36/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

’K hgekmhk ge clol krpgsgmxk rpgxgmsïl hg kridokîïl hks skmî÷gs rpgdsxks mk Igdmk 6-804,40 ole pgikîïl kl pg{wgpdhl Iwdz Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik) `ge olel rpgxgmsïl hgpgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl ge ckog hg ke`ls ls päws-

 Pgsskixg%sg {wg k olmhgmkîïl hg Kedp Ikmhl mks skmî÷gs hk igd hg derpl`dhkhgmïl olmsxdxwd l`jgxl hk rpgsgmxg kîïl ge pkzïl hl hgowpsl hg ekds hg odmol QkmlsU hgshg{wg gsxg hgdvlw l okpnl hg Edmdsxpl hk Rpgdhêmodk- Ge lwxpks rkikpks) olmxpk gig jë sglrgplw k rpgsopdîïl) mls xgpels hl kpx- 0?) D hk Igd 6-804,40― 

L _wrgpdlp Xpd`wmki hg Jwsxdîk xge gmxgmhdhl {wg k lolppêmodk hk rpgsopdîïl

rpgdsxk ml kpx- 0? hk Igd 6-804,40 gskzdk l olmxgúhl hk kîïl hg derpl dhkhg

khedmdsxpkxdk) mïl rlhgmhl gsxk sgp wxdidzkhk rkpk gdowikp rpgxgmsïl {wg dsg

gvoiwsdkegmxg kl pgsskpodegmxl hg hkml kl gpëpdl) rkpk k {wki sg gvdndpdk kîïl rpÿrpdk-

Mgssg sgmxdhl olikodlml l sgnwdmxgs jwinkhl:

RPLOG__WKI ODSDI- KHEDMD_XPKXDSL- PGOWP_L G_RGODKI- HDSGPNÊMODKJWPD_RPWHGMODKI- HG_OWERPDEGMXL HL_ PG[WD_DXL_ IGNKD_- KÎÏL ODSDI

HG DERPL@DHKHG KHEDMD_XPKXDSK- RPG_OPDÎÏL OLMCDNWPKHK-RPL__GNWDEGMXL RKPK L@XGP GVOIW_DSKEGMXG L PG__KPODEGMXL HGHKML KL GPËPDL-

DMKHG[WKÎÏL- MGOG__DHKHG HL KJWDZKEGMXL HG KÎÏL KWXØMLEK-PGOWP_L G_RGODKI RKPODKIEGMXG OLMFGODHL G) MG__K RKPXG)HG_RPLSDHL-

;- Ä dmdëgi k krpgodkîïl hg pgowpsl gsrgodki cwmhkhl ge hdgpnêmodk jwpdsrpwhgmodki{wkmhl l pgolppgmxg mïl hgelmsxpk l swrlsxl hdssåhdl rpgxlpdkml rlp egdl: &k$ hk jwmxkhk hgogpxdhïl lw hg oÿrdk kwxgmxdokhk hl koÿphïl rkpkhdnek) lw) ge swk ckixk) hk hgoikpkîïl rgilkhlnkhl hk kwxgmxdodhkhg hgssks1 &`$ hk odxkîïl hg pgrlsdxÿpdl lcdodki) kwxlpdzkhl lwopghgmodkhl ge {wg l koÿphïl hdgpngmxg cld rw`idokhl1 &o$ hl olxgjl kmkiåxdol) ole k

xpkmsopdîïl hls xpgofls hls koÿphïls ge {wg sg cwmhk k hdgpnêmodk) kiäe hk hgelmsxpkîïlhks odpowmsxàmodks {wg dhgmxdcdoke lw kssgegifke ls oksls olmcplmxkhls) mïl `ksxkmhl) rkpkxkmxl) k egpk xpkmsopdîïl hk gegmxk g hg xpgofls hl lxl olmhwxlp hl koÿphïl rkpkhdnek-

0- Mk fdrÿxgsg hls kwxls) l Edmdsxäpdl Rú`idol Cghgpki kjwdzlw kîïl oddi rú`idok rlp kxl hgderpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk olmxpk Jlk{wde @pdxl hg _lwzk &gv%Rpgcgdxl hg Kikpïgs,EK$)ole cwmhkegmxl mls kpxs- ;2 g ;;) SD) hk Igd 6-804,40) ge ckog hg swrlsxks dppgnwikpdhkhgslolppdhks ge olmêmdl cdpekhl gmxpg l pgcgpdhl Ewmdoårdl g k Wmdïl) mk {wki cld rigdxgkhk kkridokîïl hks skmî÷gs rpgdsxks ml kpx- ;0) DD g DDD) hk pgcgpdhk mlpek- Rlp loksdïl hksgmxgmîk) l ekndsxpkhl ge rpdegdpl npkw hg jwpdshdîïl jwinlw gvxdmxl l rplogssl olepgsliwîïl hl eäpdxl) ge ckog hl pgolmfgodegmxl hk rpgsopdîïl {ùdm{ùgmki rpgdsxk ml kpx- 0?

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?3,82

Page 37: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 37/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

hk Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk &cis- 8?4,88?$) l {wg cld ekmxdhl ge npkw pgowpski-

?- L l`jgxl hl pgowpsl gvkedmkhl mïl gsxë pgikodlmkhl kl rpkzl rpgsopdodlmki hk kîïl hgpgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl) k {wki mïl rlsswd gmxgmhdegmxl olmslidhkhl mgsxk Olpxg _wrgpdlp)ge ckog hk ekmdcgsxk hdgpnêmodk mks Xwpeks hg Hdpgdxl Rú`idol) ge cwmîïl hk gvdsxêmodk hkxgsg hg derpgsopdxd`didhkhg hk kîïl hg pgsskpodegmxl) `ge olel hk xgsg hk dmodhêmodk hk rpgsopdîïl dmxgmëpdk) ge pkzïl hk kwsêmodk hg pgnwikegmxkîïl) ole `ksg ml Oÿhdnl Oddi-Olmcdpke%sg: KnPn ml Kn 44?-70>,_O) 0ª Xwpek) Pgi- Edm- Oksxpl Egdpk) HJg hg ;;-4-02261

PGsr >27->;7,_R) ;ª Xwpek) Pgi- Edm- Cpkmodsol Ckioïl) HJg hg ;8-7-02261PGsr 32;-43;,EN) 0ª Xwpek) Pgi- Edm- Jlïl Lxëdl hg Mlplmfk) HJ hg 0;-6-022>1 PGsr82?-;7?,_R) ;ª Xwpek) Pgi- Edm- Jlsä Hginkhl) HJ hg 02-;2-022?- Xlhkdk) ä derlpxkmxgpgsskixkp k gvdsxêmodk hl pgogmxg jwinkhl hl _wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki {wg) rlp ekdlpdk) rploikelw k dmgvdsxêmodk hg rpgsopdîïl hg kîïl hg pgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl &E_ 03-0;2,HC)Xpd`wmki Rigml) Pgi- Edm- Pdokphl Ig~kmhl~sad) HJg hg 4-;2-0226$-

8- L xgek ogmxpki hl rpgsgmxg pgowpsl gsrgodki ä xïl%slegmxg k kmëidsg hk rlssd`didhkhg){wkmhl olmcdnwpkhk k rpgsopdîïl rpgdsxk ml kpx- 0? hk Igd 6-804,40) hg k kîïl oddi hgderpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk rplssgnwdp wmdokegmxg ole l l`jgxdl hg l`xgmîïl hgpgsskpodegmxl hg swrlsxls hkmls okwskhls rgil kxl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk) lwsg sgpdk mgogssëpdl kjwdzkp mlk kîïl hg pgsskpodegmxl kl gpëpdl-

7- Gcgxdkegmxg) mls xgpels hl okrwx hl kpx- 0? hk Igd 6-804,40) k rpgsopdîïl rpgdsxkmk pgcgpdhk mlpek kxdmng ks "kî÷gs hgsxdmkhks k igkp k gcgdxls ks skmî÷gs rpgdsxksmgsxk igd rlhge sgp rplrlsxks") lw sgjk) ks skmî÷gs rpgdsxks ml kpx- ;0 g dmodsls hk Igdhg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk mïl rlhge sgp kridokhks ge hgolppêmodk hg kxl hgderpl dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk oksl olmcdnwpkhl l rpkzl rpgsopdodlmki) skil lpgsskpodegmxl hg hkmls okwskhls kl gpëpdl-

Gmxpgxkmxl) xki olmoiwsïl mïl rgpedxg kcdpekp {wg k kîïl oddi hg derpl`dhkhg) mk {wkisgjk pgolmfgodhk k olmcdnwpkîïl hk rpgsopdîïl) rlssk rplssgnwdp gvoiwsdkegmxg ole ldmxwdxl hg pgsskpodegmxl hg hkmls) rlds) ge rpdmoårdl) sgpdk dmkhg{wkhl khedxdp {wg kegmodlmkhk skmîïl sw`sdsxdpdk kwxlmlekegmxg sge k mgogssdhkhg hl pgolmfgodegmxlhg kxl hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk-

3- Rlpxkmxl) olmcdnwpkhk k rpgsopdîïl hk kîïl oddi hg derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk rpgdsxk mkIgd 6-804,40) ä ekmdcgsxk k dmkhg{wkîïl hl rplssgnwdegmxl hk pgcgpdhk kîïl xïl%slegmxgole l l`jgxdl hg l`xgp pgsskpodegmxl hg hkmls kl gpëpdl) l {wki hgg sgp rigdxgkhl ge kîïlkwxømlek-

>- Pgowpsl gsrgodki rkpodkiegmxg olmfgodhl g) mgssk rkpxg) hgsrpldhl-

&PGsr 62;-683,KE) Pgi- Edmdsxpk HGMD_G KPPWHK) RPDEGDPK XWPEK) jwinkhl ge;3,;0,0226) HJg ;0,20,0224$ &npdcgd$

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?>,82

Page 38: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 38/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

Rlp lwxpl ikhl) mïl fë olel rpgsxdndkp k kignkîïl hg digndxdedhkhg rkssdk

kh okwske hl pg{wgpdhl Iwdz Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik sl` l sdmngil kpnwegmxl hg {wg mïl

fkgpdk) mk rpgsgmxg kîïl) k derwxkîïl hg kxl {wg sdnmdcdokssg kridokîïl dppgnwikp hg

gp`k rú`idok-

 K derwxkîïl) olmclpeg sg ê mk dmdodki) cld ’k olmsdsxgmxg ml gmdl dppgnwikp hg olppgsrlmhêmodks kls sgnwpkhls hl DM__) kxpkäs hks {wkds dmclpekke sl`pg k

 rlssd`didhkhg hg l`xgmîïl hg gerpäsxdels olmsdnmkhls ole xkvks hg jwpls pghwzdhks― -

 Kssde) k kignkîïl hg {wg mïl flwg rplk hg {wg l pg{wgpdhl xgpdk olmxpd`wåhl rkpk k

rpëxdok hl kxl hkmlsl kl gpëpdl) mk gphkhg) hdz pgsrgdxl kl eäpdxl-

Mïl hgg rplsrgpkp k kignkîïl hg derlssd`didhkhg jwpåhdok hl rghdhl) wek

gz {wg ls rghdhls gsxïl hg kolphl ole l {wg rpgogdxwk k Igd hg Derpl dhkhg

 Khedmdsxpkxdk- K hdsowssïl) mk gphkhg) olmogmxpk%sg mk dk khg{wkhk rkpk sg `wsokp kpgsrlmsk`didhkhg rlp kxls olmxpk k rpl`dhkhg hk khedmdsxpkîïl swrlsxkegmxg rpkxdokhls

rlp gv%Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok-

Olmoiws÷gs

k$ ’L sdsxgek olmsxdxwodlmki `pksdigdpl hdsxdmnwg l pgndeg hg pgsrlmsk didhkhg hls

kngmxgs rliåxdols hls hgekds kngmxgs rú idols- K Olmsxdxwdîïl mïl khedxg k

olmolppêmodk gmxpg hlds pgndegs hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk ls

kngmxgs rliåxdols: l rpgdsxl ml kpx- ?>) ® 8º &pgnwikhl rgik Igd m² 6-804,;440$ g l

pgndeg cdvkhl ml kpx- ;20) D) "o") &hdsodridmkhl rgik Igd m² ;-2>4,;472$-― &Gegmxk hk

Pgoi- mº 0-;?6$1

`$ K Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki gvrpgsskegmxg gsxk`gigogw {wg ls kxls {wg kxgmxge

olmxpk k rpl`dhkhg hk khedmdsxpkîïl) {wkmhl rpkxdokhls rgil Rpgsdhgmxg hk

Pgrú`idok) olmsxdxwge opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) mk clpek hl sgw kpx- 67- \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?6,82

Page 39: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 39/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

o$ K gvdsxêmodk hg pgndeg rpÿrpdl hg pgsrlmsk`didzkîïl hl Rpgsdhgmxg hk Pgrú`idok

kxpkd k pgnêmodk hk Igd mº ;-2>4,72 {wg) sg mïl gvgpodhk) kcksxk k wxdidzkîïl

sw`sdhdëpdk hk Igd hg Derpl`dhkhg Khedmdsxpkxdk &Igd mº ;-2>4,72$) krÿs l xäpedml

hl pgsrgoxdl ekmhkxl1

h$ Ml rpgsgmxg oksl) ls swrlsxls kxls hg derpl`dhkhg xgpdke lolppdhl ge 04 hgsgxge`pl hg 0228) kdmhk hwpkmxg l rpdegdpl ekmhkxl hl rpdegdpl Pg{wgpdhl) Iwdz

Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik- K rpgsgmxg kîïl) ml gmxkmxl) cld rplrlsxk krgmks ge ?; hg

 jkmgdpl hg 02;;) lw sgjk) krÿs l xäpedml hl sgnwmhl ekmhkxl- K kwsêmodk hg

rplrlsdxwpk hg kîïl rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg rpgdsxk mk Igd mº ;-2>4,72

derghg {wg xkds kxls) kdmhk {wg sl` mlk hgcdmdîïl jwpåhdok) sgjke krpgodkhls rgil

_wrpgel Xpd`wmki Cghgpki ge hgolppêmodk hk rpgoiwsïl dmsxdxwåhk ml sgw kpx- ;7 

& ’k hgmúmodk sÿ rlhgpë sgp pgog`dhk gm{wkmxl l hgmwmodkhl mïl xdgp) rlp 

{wki{wgp elxdl) hgdvkhl hgcdmdxdkegmxg l okpnl―$) pkzïl rgik {wki mïl sg jwsxdcdok

l hgoiåmdl hg olergxêmodk rkpk k{wgik _wrpgek Olpxg- 

g$ Olergxg kl _gmkhl rplogsskp g jwinkp Edmdsxpls hg Gsxkhl mls opdegs hg

pgsrlmsk`didhkhg olmgvls ole k{wgigs rpkxdokhls rgil Rpgsdhgmxg &kpx- 70) D o,o l

kpx- ;20) D) hk Olmsxdxwdîïl Cghgpki$) pkzïl rgik {wki ks olmoiws÷gs pgikxdkegmxg

kl rpdegdpl pg{wgpdhl) Iwdz Dmëodl Iwik hk _dik) hgge sgp gsxgmhdhks kl sgnwmhl)

 Kedp Cpkmodsol Ikmhl1

c$ L gskzdkegmxl hks skmî÷gs rliåxdol%khedmdsxpkxdks) ngpkhl rgil mïl gvgpoåodl hk

kîïl rlp opdeg hg pgsrlmsk`didhkhg) kcksxk k rlssd`didhkhg hg wxdidzkîïl hk kîïl hg

derpl`dhkhg khedmdsxpkxdk rkpk gdowikp rpgxgmsïl gvoiwsdk hg pgsskpodegmxl kl

gpëpdl) fkgmhl lwxpks ml lphgmkegmxl jwpåhdol rëxpdl {wg rlhge sgp wxdidzkhks

ole k{wgig l`jgxdl-

DDD% HD_RL_DXDSL \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ 

Hlowegmxl kssdmkhl hdndxkiegmxg rgil&k$ JWDZ CGHGPKI _W@_XDXWXL RKWIL OG_KP ILRG_ ge ;4,;;,02;0) ole ksg mk Igd ;;-8;4 hg;4,;0,0223-K kwxgmxdodhkhg hgsxg rlhgpë sgp gpdcdokhk ge fxxr:,,~~~-xpc;-jws-`p,kwxgmxdodhkhg) eghdkmxg oÿhdnl ;76?>40?8220>7-

Rën- ?4,82

Page 40: Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

7/30/2019 Sentença que livrou Lula de processo

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sentenca-que-livrou-lula-de-processo 40/40

RLHGP JWHDODËPDLXPD@WMKI PGNDLMKI CGHGPKI HK RPDEGDPK PGNDÏL 

_GÎÏL JWHDODËPDK HL HD_XPDXL CGHGPKI

Rplogssl M² 222>62>%26-02;;-8-2;-?822 % ;?ª SKPK CGHGPKI Mº hg pgndsxpl g%OSH 22887-02;0-22;??822-0-22866,22;06

 Kmxg l gvrlsxl) JWINL GVXDMXL l rplogssl) sge pgsliwîïl hg eäpdxl)

ole `ksg ml kpx- 03>) SD) ® ?º) hl Oÿhdnl hg Rplogssl Oddi) rgik dmkhg{wkîïl hk dk

gigdxk-

Rw`id{wg%sg- Pgndsxpg%sg- Dmxdege%sg-

 Krÿs l xpàmsdxl ge jwinkhl) kp{wdge%sg ls rpgsgmxgs kwxls-

@pksåidk) ;4 hg mlge`pl hg 02;0-

Rkwil Ogskp IlrgsJwdz Cghgpki _w`sxdxwxl hk ;?ª Skpk ‟ _J,HC

&_gmxgmîk kssdmkhk hdndxkiegmxg$

 \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\