saad-filho_neoliberalism in crisis_marxism 21 korea2010

7/29/2019 Saad-Filho_Neoliberalism in Crisis_Marxism 21 Korea2010

1/24

!"#$% &'(#)*+% &',-+$% ("&(% ("+% )-''+.(% ,*/0&*% )'#$#$% #$% &% )'#$#$% !"% .+/*#0+'&*%)&1#(&*#$23% &*("/-,"% ("#$% #$% ./( 4 5+( 4 &% )'#$#$% /6% .+/*#0+'&*#$27% !"+% &'(#)*+%

+8&2#.+$%6#9+%&$1+)($%/6%6#.&.)#&*#$&(#/.%#.%/':+'%(/%*/)&(+%.+/*#0+'&*#$2%&.:%("+%

)'#$#$%"#$(/'#)&**57%!"+$+%#.)*-:+%("+%6#.&.)#&*#$&(#/.%/6% )&1#(&*%&))-2-*&(#/.3%("+%

,*/0&*%+)/./253%("+%$(&(+3%#:+/*/,53%&.:%("+%'+1'/:-)(#/.%/6%("+%;/'


2/24

!"#$%&'(#)*+%&',-+$%("&(%.+%&'+%,/#0,%("'/-,"%&%)'#$#$%#0%0+/*#1+'&*%)&2#(&*3

#$45%&*("/-,"%("#$%#$%0/(%3%6+(%3%&%)'#$#$%/7%0+/*#1+'&*#$48%!"+'+7/'+5%#(%#$%0+)3

+$$&'6%(/%$(&'(%7'/4%."&(%#$%0+/*#1+'&*#$45%&09%."6%#(%#$%#0%('/-1*+8

:+/*#1+'&*#$4%#$%/7(+0%)/0)+2(-&*#$+9%2'#4&'#*6%&$%&0%#9+/*/,65%/'%&$%&%$+(%

/7%+)/0/4#)%&09%$/)#&*%2/*#)#+$8%;%9#$&,'++%.#("%("+$+%#0(+'2'+(&(#/0$8%;0%46%


3/24

!"#$%&$'#(%)**+, )"-, !"#$%")#!(")**+,.)&, /%)-0)**+, )"-, &+$1)#!')**+, #%)"&2

3$%%$-,#(,)",!"'%$)&!"/*+,/*(4)**+,!"#$/%)#$-,3!")"'!)*,&$'#(%5,!",.6!'6,78,!"2

!#0#!("&,$9$%'!&$,),-!&:%(:(%#!(")#$,!"3*0$"'$;,#,$"'(1:)&&$&,#6$,%$:%(-0'#!(",(3,!"-0%!)*,'):!#)*5,#6$,%$2

:%(-0'#!(", (3, #6$, )#$5, )"-, #6$, %$:%(-0'#!(", (3, #6$, .(%C!"/, '*)&&;,

O("&$P0$"#*+5,!#,:*)+&,),!"#$%&%'%&(),?#6)#,!&5,')0&)**+,-$#$%1!")"#@,%(*$,!",#6$,

'):!#)*,%$*)#!(",!",#6$,'0%%$"#,?"$(*!4$%)*@,:6)&$,(3,'):!#)*!&1;

>#,!&,4$')0&$,(3,#6$!%,%)#$/!',:(&!#!(",)#,#6$,'(%$,(3,)''010*)#!("5,)"-,&(2

'!)*, %$:%(-0'#!(",1(%$,/$"$%)**+5, #6)#, #6$, 3!")"'!)*, !"!#0#!("&, 2, !"'*0-!"/,

#6$,4)"C&5,!"&0%)"'$,'(1:)"!$&5,10#0)*,30"-&5,6$-/$,30"-&5,('C,4%(C$%&5,

)"-,1)"+,(#6$%,3!")"'!)*,3!%1&5,)&,.$**,)&,#6$,3!")"'!)*,)%1,(3,!"-0%!)*,'):2

!#)*5,$&:$'!)**+,*)%/$,)0#(1(4!*$,1)"03)'#0%$%&5,&0:$%1)%C$#&5,)"-,(#6$%,'("2

/*(1$%)#$&,2,6)=$,)::%(:%!)#$-,)",!"'%$)&!"/*+,*)%/$,&6)%$,(3,&0%:*0&,=)*0$;,


4/24

!"#$%&'()*%+$,-$./%$0-,.%1$2.'.%3$4./%$)#"5,.3$"5$5,-'-6,'*$6"()'-,%3$78()9

%1$5#"($:%*";$


5/24

!"!#$"%& '(')*+& $!#,*"'$!-%(& ./%!*,"0%*& )1& #2"!-*'& $!& %$3/$4$)(& $!& )2*&

,/!5/6&)1&)2*/,,*!),$'$'7&

87&9/,$!-&)2*&011+&$!&)2*&*",%(&:;;;'


6/24

!"#$%'%()$!*!+,%-#.$/#*.0!12#32!(%--%-#&),*%#(!432%--,$+#2%.*#&.+%-#5-%%#

0%*!&67#8'#.#"12')%2#2%4!9%:# ')%#",$.$(,.*,-.',!$#!"# ')%#+*!0.*#%(!$!4;#).-#

-133!2'%/# ')%# 2%(!43!-,',!$# !"#


7/24

!"#$%&'()*'$+%(!',(&-'.()'#/!0"-&1'-+%'2%*'*%$#*%*'-+(-'34'#)-%"%&-'"(-%&'

5%"%'6"#7+-81'()*'9%!-'-+%/'-00':05;'$(::%*' 6%/%"7#)7'/("9%-&81'

5+#$+' 7"%5' AB' 34CD;E' -"#::#0)' A%-5%%)' -+%' %)*' 0=' -+%' FGGH&' ()*' I?:B'

JHHKLM0:=1'JHHGN;

)()$%>*"#@%)')%0:#A%"(:'"%&-"?$-?"#)7'0='$(!#-(:'+(*'A%%)'&?$$%&&=?:1'()*'-+(-'

-+%'%$0)0/#%&'5+#$+'+(*'70)%'=?"-+%"'(:0)7'-+%')%0:#A%"(:'"0(*'L%&!%$#(::B'

-+%'34'()*'-+%'3PN'*#*'$0)&-%)-:B'6A%--%"8'-+()'-+%#"'/0"%'"%:?$-()-'=0:>

:05%"&'L=0"'%Q(/!:%1'2"()$%1'R%"/()B1'S-(:B'()*'I(!()N;'

07#%&'+%:!%*'-0':%7#-#/#&%')%0:#A%"(:#&/'!0:#-#$(::B1'()*'*#&7?#&%'-+%'=($-'-+(-'

-+%'A00/'5(&1'#)'=($-1'*?%'-0'?)&?&-(#)(A:%'*%A->:%*'7"05-+'&?!!0"-%*'AB'&%>

"#0?&:B'/#&(:#7)%*'%Q$+()7%'"(-%&;'S)'-+#&'&%)&%1'-+%'$?""%)-'$"#&'"%@%(:&'-+%':#/#-(-#0)&'0='=#)()$#(:#&(-#0)'(&'-+%'*"#@%"'0='-+%'#)-%")(-#0)(:'($$?/?:(-#0)'

0='$(!#-(:;'

!"#$%'()*)+(*,(-*.(/)#/0#.%.*.&

$(?&%' #-' #&' !"%*#$(-%*' 0)' )#=#$()-' :%7(:' ()*' "%7?:(-0"B' $+()7%&' ()*' "%>


8/24

!"#$%&'()%'$%*$%&+,'+-'.#&&%,('-+$'/,'%0(%,.%.'*%$#+.1'2)#$.3'%4+,+5#4/6673'

()%'&(/(%'&"**+$(&'()%'4+,&+6#./(#+,'+-'()%',%8'#,&(#("(#+,/6'&($"4("$%'#,46".9

#,:'#,."&($#/6'/,.'-#,/,4#/6'4/*#(/63'/,.'()%'-#,/,4#/6#&/(#+,'+-'()%'%4+,+573'

()$+":)'/';/$#%(7'+-'#,4%,(#;%&1'2)%&%'#,46".%'()%'#,4$%/,:'$%6#/,4%'+-'()%'

&(/(%'#(&%6-'"*+,'-#,/,4#/6'5/$


9/24

!"#$%'()#!"#*('+(,-!..#(''#./%&-&.#!"#.!,0('#-&/-!1+,$0!23#$%($#0.3#)01&4

./-&(1#,!55!10"0,($0!23#$%""+.0!2#!"#,!55!10$6#"&$0.%0.53#(21#$%&24

&-('0.($0!2#!"#$%/-!"0$#5!$0*#.!,0('#&8,%(27&.9:,;(''63#?@A%0.#%(.#

B&&2#C+.$0"0&1#01&!'!70,(''6#B6#D+.$-0(2#(21#5!2&$(-0.$#10.,!+-.&.#(B!+$#$%

&""0,0&2,6#!"# $%(-E&$3#)0$%# $% "02(2,0('#5(-E&$.#B&027#/-&.&2$&1#(.#$%

/(-(1075($0,# ,(.&@# :!- B-!(1'63# 2&!'0B&-('0.5# 0.# 05/!.&13# (21# 0$.# 024

&F+0$(B'!+$,!5&.#(-C+.$0"0&13#$%-!+7%#$%,!2.!'01($0!2#(213#&*&2$+(''63#

$%($+-('0.($0!2#!"#(#%&7&5!20,#10.,!+-.-()027#+/!2#$)!#.&/(-($B+$#

,'!.&'6#-&'($&1#/-02,0/'&.@#G0-.$3#H,!5/&$0$0*&2&..I3#02#$%.%!-$4$&-50.$#.&2.

(..!,0($&1#)0$%#$%7&10($$&-&.$.#!"#$%"02(2,0('#5(-E&$.9J+53#?@#

J&,!213#H1&5!,-(,6I3#02#$%.%(''!)#.&2.!"#,!5/&$0$0!2#B&$)&&2#.%(1&.#!"#

2&!'0B&-('0.5#02#$%/!'0$0,('#5(-E&$@#A(E&2#$!7&$%&-3#&,!2!50,#,!5/&$0$0*&4

2&..#(21#/!'0$0,('#1&5!,-(,6#+21&-/02#$%&!'0B&-('#*0.0!2#!"#$%H7!!1#.!4

,0&$6I(21#02"!-5#$%!-5.#!"#.!,0('#B&%(*0!+-#,!5/($0B')0$%#$%0.#.6.$&5#

!"#(,,+5+'($0!2@#A%&6#02,'+1$%*('01($0!2#!"#$%)0$%1-()('#!"#.$($.+/4

/!-$# "!-# $% /!!-3# %07%&-# 02&F+('0$63# (21# $% ,%!0,&3# C+.$0"0,($0!23# 054/'&5&2$($0!2#(21#-&7+'($0!2#!"# $%&,!2!50,#(21#.!,0('#/!'0,0&.# '&(1027# $!#

$%&.!+$,!5&.9G02(21#:0'!2(E0.3#


10/24

!"#$%"&"'%()*!"#$%&'!%()**+,%-*,.*%,&/%"0-1*."2/2&"/%*/21*3/%/2&-*,.*$/(#-2'0*

"20'/3"%"'(4*3-&/50-*'6-(*6-%$*',*"#$,0-*1"0&"$%"2-*,2*7,+8-+04*"29-0',+0*/21*

$,%"&(:#/8-+04*/21*+-7/+1*.,+#0*,.*3-6/9",5+*&,#$/'"3%-*7"'6*'6-*0'/3"%"0/:

'",2*,.*2-,%"3-+/%"0#;*-2-+/%"0/'",2*,.*'6-*%/7*,.*9/%5-*/&+,00*#,0'*/+-/0*,.*

0,&"/%* "2'-+/&'",24* /21* 0,&"/%* &,20-2'* ',* '6-* 2-,%"3-+/%* $+,>+/##-4* /+-*

3,521-1* 3(* $,%"'"&/%* &,20'+/"2'0* /21* &,2.%"&'0* 76"&6* #50'* 3-* &,2'"25/%%(*

&,2.+,2'-1*,9-+*'"#-;*=6"+14*'6-*&5++-2'*&+"0"0*6/0*#/1-*"'*&%-/+*'6/'*"2.%/'",2*

"0* 2,'* '6-* #,0'* 0">2"."&/2'* '6+-/'* ',*#/&+,-&,2,#"&* 0'/3"%"'(4* '6/'* "2'-+-0'*

+/'-0* /+-* %"#"'-1* /0* /* $,%"&(* ',,%4* /21* '6/'* ."2/2&"/%* "20'/3"%"'(* &/2* 3-*

1-0'+5&'"9-;*=6-*5$06,'*"0*'6/'*'6-*#/+8-'*"#$-+/'"9-*6/0*%,0'*/*%,'*,.*"'0*%-:

>"'"#/&(* /0* '6-* "1-,%,>"&/%* .,521/'",2* .,+* -&,2,#"&* $,%"&(4* /21* '6-* 2-,:%"3-+/%*$%/'.,+#*"0*6/9"2>*1".."&5%'"-0*',*+-&,9-+*'6-*"2"'"/'"9-;

!"# $% '()*)+(*,(-*.(/)# /0# .% 1&23/45+.(/)# /0# .%/37()8#

9,*--

=6-*7,+8"2>*&%/00*6/0*/%7/(0*3--2*"2'->+/'-1*"2',*."2/2&"/%*&"+&5"'04 D)*.,+*

-E/#$%-*/0*$-''(*&,##,1"'(*$+,15&-+0*+-F5"+"2>*."2/2&"/%*0-+9"&-04*/0*7,+8:

-+0*76,0-*$/(&6-&80*/+-*1-$,0"'-1*7"'6*3/280*/21*76,0-*$-20",20*/+-* "2:

9-0'-1* "2* '6-* 0',&8*#/+8-'4* /0* &,205#-+0* 1-$-21"2>* ,2* &+-1"'* /21* &+-1"'*

D)* ?,+* /* 1-'/"%-1* +-9"-74* 0--* G/2"'&6* /21* H"21"2* !@AAB)* /21* G/2"'&6* /21* I,2"2>0*

!@AAJ);


11/24

!"#$%&'"($'"%')*#+,",-$'.*)-*/(-#%0'1.-%-'#-2"+3*(%.34%'5-!")-'3(!#-"%6

3(,27'4#*)3(-(+'8($-#'(-*235-#"23%)0'9('+.3%'%7%+-)'*:'"!!8)82"+3*(&'+.-'#-6

2"+3*(%.34'5-+/--('!"43+"2'"($'2"5*8#&'"($'+.-'#-2"+3*(%'5-+/--('!*)4-+3(,'

3($8%+#3"2'!"43+"2%&'.";-'5-!*)-'-)5-$$-$'/3+.3('"':3("(!3"23%-$':#")-/*#


12/24

!"#$#%&"'"#$()*+&$)('),*#-.,'/!0)1'

2,!'/!3!4#5%!$)('#-)4&$!/'+0#3!',+3!"#$)*&0-)!/')#'),!'*&(!'&$'()*-")-*+4'

-$!%54#6%!$)'+$/'&$7#*%+4'!%54#6%!$)'-$/!*'$!#4&0!*+4&(%8'+('9!44'+(')#'

,&.,!*'5!*(#$+4'/!0)'+$/'7+()!*'4+0#-*')-*$#3!*'&$'%#()'"#-$)*&!(1'2,!6'"+$'

0!' (-%%+*&(!/' +(' ),!' !"#$#%"$&"'$(")#* )!* (+,* -,.-)/0%(")#* )!* (+,* 1)-2"#3*

%&$'':7&$+$"!'0!&$.'+';!6'%!",+$&(%'#7'(#"&+4'&$)!.*+)$'&$'+'4#9'9+.!'*!

saad-filho_neoliberalism in crisis_marxism 21 korea2010

Documents