valoração de danos ambientais irreversíveis_steigleder

7
24 MPMG Jurídico Especial O ao ambiente pressupõe a compreensão sobre as formas de reparação do dano, a opção prioritária da ordem constitucional brasileira, juristas com fórmulas matemáticas e com as abstrações para compreensão da Disposição do Consumidor em 1 representado pela formulação 2 VALORAÇÃO DE DANOS AMBIENTAIS IRREVERSÍVEIS

Upload: renato-pereira-claus

Post on 13-Nov-2015

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Danos ambientais irreversíveis.

TRANSCRIPT

  • 24 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

    !"#"$%&'%$()*+,"&,"&)%,")-.$'%/)0"$11'2'1342'0

    O "#$%$&'$! '#()(*+,!"(#'$!-(!"#$./%%(!-$!01$!(!$2$'/3/-(-$!&(!#$"(#(45,!-,!-(&,!ao ambiente pressupe a compreenso sobre as formas de reparao do dano, -$!.,-,! (! "$#./'/#! (! $%6,*+(! -(01$*(!

    01$!.$*+,#!('$&-(!7%!21&48$%!-(!#$%",&%()/*/-(-$!6/3/*!$!.$*+,#! (%%$91#$! (!"#,'$45,! /&'$9#(*!-,%! )$&%! (.)/$&'(/%!.('$#/(/%!$!/.('$#/(/%:

    ;(!('1(*/-(-$-(! "$*,! (#':! ??@! -(! A,&%'/'1/45,! B$-$#(*! -$!CDEEP!"#$6/%,!$%6*(#$6$#!01$!(!3(*,#(45,!$6,&O./6(!-$!#$61#%,%!&('1#(/%!&5,!F!1.!'$.(!/&$K"*,#(-,:!Q6,&,./%'(%!3N.!%$!-$-/6(&-,! (,! $%'1-,! -$! .$',-,*,9/(%! -$! 3(*,#(45,! -$!#$61#%,%!&('1#(/%!6,.,!2$##(.$&'(%!-$!9$%'5,!(.)/$&'(*!para compreenso da Disposio do Consumidor em R(9(#! SLTRU!",#!1.!)$.!,1! %$#3/4,! (.)/$&'(*! 01$! *+$!"#,",#6/,&(#J!)$.G$%'(#:1

    A,&2,#.$!(!Q6,&,./(!-,!T.)/$&'$!SATVRWX!YZ;[W\-(!",#!1.!6,&e1&',!.$&,#!-$!3(*,#$%!01$!()(#6(.!(%!-/2$#$&'$%!",%%/)/*/-(-$%!-$!1%,!$6,&O./6,!01$!",-$.!%$#!2$/',%!-,!.$/,!(.)/$&'$:!T%%/.C! !Q%6*(#$6$!X$#O(!-(!V,''(!01$!f(!'(#$2(!-$!3(*,#(#!$6,&,./6(.$&'$!1.! #$61#%,! (.)/$&'(*! 6,&%/%'$! $.!-$'$#./&(#! 01(&',!.$*+,#! ,1!"/,#!$%'(#J! ,! )$.G$%'(#! -(%! "$%%,(%! -$3/-,! (!.1-(&4(%! &(! 01(&'/-(-$!-$!)$&%!$!%$#3/4,%!(.)/$&'(/%

  • MPMG Jurdico Especial !25

    ,!3(*,#!$6,&O./6,!','(*!S`QaU!6,&%'/'1/G%$!$.!3(*,#!-$!1%,!$!3(*,#!-$!&5,!1%,6/,! (-3/&-,! -$! '$#("/(%! 9$&F'/6(%! 6,.! )(%$! $.!"#,"#/$-(-$%!-$!9$&$%!(/&-(!&5,!-$%6,)$#',%!-$!"*(&'(%!'#,"/6(/%:

    Valor de no uso ou valor de existncia! S`QUk! 3(*,#! 01$!$%'J! -/%%,6/(-,! -,! 1%,! S$.),#(! #$"#$%$&'$! 6,&%1.,!(.)/$&'(*U!$!-$#/3(!-$!1.(!",%/45,!.,#(*Q%'(! 2,#.1*(45,! 2,/! /&6*1>-(! "$*(! T%%,6/(45,! m#(%/*$/#(!-$! ;,#.(%! aF6&/6(%! STm;aU-1,%!01(&',!(!3(#/(48$%!-$!01(*/-(-$!,1!01(&'/-(-$!(.)/$&'(*a(.)F.!,! [&%'/'1',! m#(%/*$/#,! -,!V$/,!T.)/$&'$! $! -,%!\$61#%,%!;('1#(/%!\$&,3J3$/%!S[mTVTU!3$.!%$!-$-/6(&-,!(,!$%'1-,!-(!3(*,#(45,!$6,&O./6(!-,%!/."(6',%!(.)/$&'(/%!-$6,##$&'$%!-$! /&%'(*(48$%!-$!6,.1&/6(45,W!01$!F!#$(*.$&'$!&,3(!F!(!"#$,61"(45,!-$!'#(&%",#!$%%(%!.$',-,*,9/(%!"(#(!(!%$(#(!-,!L/#$/',-/6,%! "#,'$9/-,%! "$*,! ,#-$&(.$&',! e1#>-/6,!(.)/$&'(*!$!(%!21&48$%!-(!#$%",&%()/*/-(-$!6/3/*!,)e$'/3(:!T'F! #$6$&'$.$&'$_! !VF',-,%!-/#$',%k!(-./'$.!(!(*'$#(45,!-,!)$.G$%'(#!"$*(!3(#/(45,!-(!-/%",&/)/*/-(-$!-$!1.!#$61#%,!(.)/$&'(*!$3$*!$.k!vwww:'#2_:e1%:)#x:!T6$%%,!$.k!Ch!-$M:!?]C]:

  • 26 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

    6/$&'/H6/-(-$!"(#(!(%!.$',-,*,9/(%!-$!3(*,#(45,!-,!-(&,!.('$#/(*!/##$3$#%>3$*6/(!(!HK(45,!-,!3(*,#!-(!/&-$&/M(45,3$*! -$! (2$#/45,! ",#! "$#>6/(:! R(#(! $%'/.(#! ,! 3(*,#! -(! /&-$&/M(45,-(!(,!2(',!&(!%$(#(!(-./&/%'#('/3(3$/%!'(/%! 01$! #$%1*'$.! ,1! ",%%(.! #$%1*'(#! $.! -(&,%! 7! %(=-$! +1.(&(&%$6,H6,R,#! %1(!3$M3$/%:!X(*/$&'$G%$!01$!(!#$"(#(45,!/&'$9#(*!F!1.!/-$(*!e1#>-/6,3$*!&(! #$(*/-(-$! 2J'/6(:C]! X,)! ,! ",&',! -$! 3/%'(! -(! Q6,*,9/(3$/%Portanto, quando da ocorrncia de um desmatamento, ",#! $K$."*,}:::~!&5,!'$.!3(*,#!-$!.$#6(-,E! !T&$K,C]! !T!#$%"$/','/.(g!SXT;XQ`Q\[;W

  • MPMG Jurdico Especial !27

    6,.,! (.$(4(-(! -$! $K'/&45,}:::~!"#,61#(.!01(*/H6(#!$!+/$#(#01/M(#!1.!-$'$#./&(-,!$6,%%/%'$.(! $.! 21&45,! -,%! .(/%! -/3$#%,%! "(#p.$'#,%!",%%>3$/%!}:::~:!Q%%$!2(',#!",-$!%$#!-$%$&3,*3/-,!$.!21&45,!-$!>&-/6$%!(6(-N./6,%,-,!&$6$%%J#/,!7!#$%'(1#(45,H6(%:C@

    T!.$',-,*,9/(!`Q\L!S`(*,#!Q%'/.(-,!-$!\$2$#N&6/(!"(#(!(! L$9#(-(45,! (.)/$&'(*UC_! TzVQ[LTCh! !AT\LWXW01$&%Ct! ! W! .F',-,! 6,&%/-$#(! ,%! ('#/)1',%! 01$! $K$#6$.! /&l1N&6/(! &(!2,#.(45,!-,!3(*,#

  • 28 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

    X$.!$&'#(#!&,!.F#/',!-(!6/$&'/H6/-(-$!-,%!3(*,#$%!(",&'(-,%!para cada um dos atributos analisados, entendemos que caberia, ao menos, um estudo mais apurado sobre (! ",%%/)/*/-(-$! -$! 1'/*/M(45,! -,%! ('#/)1',%! /&-/6(-,%!&$%'$! L$6#$',! "(#(! 3(*,#(45,! -$! /."(6',%! &$9('/3,%! 7!)/,-/3$#%/-(-$!&(!$%2$#(!-(!#$%",&%()/*/M(45,!6/3/*!Sex postU:

    ;$%'$!6(%,-(%!S61%',%!-$! %1)%'/'1/45,UW%!"$#/',%! e1-/6/(/%-1,%! /&-1%'#/(/%! "$#/9,%,%! &,!\/,! X,#,6()(q[!b![Xm!d!ATR!d![cA[Xm!b![."(6',!%,)#$!(!m/,-/3$#%/-(-$j

    ATR!b!A,."#,.$'/.$&',!-$!#$(!R#/,#/'J#/(j!$

    [cA!b![&l1N&6/(!$.!c&/-(-$%!-$!A,&%$#3(45,:

    CD! !VTqz[T;W6/(! 2$-$#(*:! L/%",&>3$*! $.k! v+''"kuu_66#:"9#:."2:9,3:)#u-,61.$&',%G$G"1)*/6(6,$%u61#%,%u61#%,G-$G3(*,#(6(,G-,G-(&,G(.)/$&'(*u`(*,#(6(,-$L(&,%T.)/$&'(/%R,*/6/(B$-$#(*:"-2x:!T6$%%,!$.k!?^!.(#:!?]CC:

    ?]! !aYXR-$&%/-(-$!(#)I#$(!-$!h]]!J#3,#$%!",#!+$6'(#$?C! !LQ!TzVQ[LT>6/&'#)*()5(#()!)/!"#$%&'()*$)+!,!&$-.()"/!!7'5&!%&!8

    Obra irregular

    ?!0(#'-.()*$)(:/$

  • MPMG Jurdico Especial !29

    T"I%@!" A1,;'&$-'%/,3" =1'0$-$%)1'3" B" 2)0,1)*+,C" )";,%/1$.>$*+,"&,"5$%$3/D1$,"AE.0$;,

    1(*01$#! 01$! %$e(! (! .$',-,*,9/(! $*$/'(! "$*,%! "$#/',%!e1-/6/(/%!,1!-,!V/&/%'F#/,!R=)*/6,L$%%(! 2,#.(P! 6,&3$&/$&'$! 01$! (! "$#>6/(! %$e(! #$(*/M(-(! ",#!'F6&/6,%! +()/*/'(-,%-1,%-,%:

    R,#! H.??! !T! (1',#(!\,.(&(!A:!T#(1e,! S?]]^

  • 30 !MPMG Jurdico Especial

    F!"G,%;0>3+,

    T!,"45,!",#!1.(!,1!,1'#(!.$',-,*,9/(!"(#(!01(&'/H6(45,!-(!/&-$&/M(45,!(!%$#!"(9(!"$*,!-(&,!(.)/$&'(*!/##$3$#%>3$*!F! 1.! '$.(! 01$! "$#.(&$6$! $.! ()$#',3$*!-$!/&2,#.(48$%!-/%",&>3$/%3$/%!-,!$6,%%/%'$.(&$;$)0"'"3';>1$/L1$)!"[."(6',*/(mQ\a|W14&$;)" &,"5$%$3/D1$," AE.0$;," &,"Estado de Minas Geraism\TX[z:! L$6#$',! &s! h:@C_3" 2)0,1'3"econmicos associados:!R,#',!T*$9#$k!X$#9/,!T&',&/,!B()#/%LQ\T;[[;Xa[acaW! m\TX[zQ[\W!LW!VQ[W!TVm[Q;aQ! Q!LWX! \QAc\XWX!;Tac\T[X! \Q;W``Q[X! n! [mTVT:! 5,&'0," &'" 2)0,1)*+,"';,%zQ[aQVTzQ\XT;XQ`Q\[;WXaQ[qzQLQ\