uma reflexÃo crÍtica sobre as ediÇÕes do manual de diagnÓstico e estatÍstica das...

Upload: fabricio-santos-silva

Post on 05-Jul-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    1/108

    UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DO RIO DE JANEIROCENTRO DE CIÊNCIAS DA SAÚDE

    INSTITUTO DE ESTUDOS DE SAÚDE COLETIVADEPARTAMENTO DE MEDICINA PREVENTIVA

    UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DEDIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES MENTAIS – DSM

    THAATY DA SILVA BURLE

    O!"#$%&'(!

    PROF) DR) ANDR* MARTINS

    R"( '# J&$#"!(

    +,,-

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    2/108

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    3/108

    UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DO RIO DE JANEIROCENTRO DE CIÊNCIAS DA SAÚDE

    INSTITUTOS DE ESTUDOS DE SAÚDE COLETIVADEPARTAMENTO DE MEDICINA PREVENTIVA

    UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E

    ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES MENTAIS – DSM

    THAATY DA SILVA BURLE

    O!"#$%&'(! 

    PROF) DR) ANDR* MARTINS

    D"++#!%&,-( '# .#+%!&'( &/!#+#$%&'& &(I$+%"%0%( '# E+%0'(+ #. S&1'# C(2#%"3&4

    '& U$"3#!+"'&'# F#'#!&2 '( R"( '#J&$#"!(4 5(.( !#60"+"%( /&!5"&2 /&!& &(7%#$,-( '( %8%02( '# .#+%!& #. S&1'#C(2#%"3&)

    R"( '# J&$#"!(

    9::;

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    4/108

    THAATY DA SILVA BURLE

    UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO EESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES MENTAIS – DSM

    D"++#!%&,-( '# .#+%!&'( #. S&1'# C(2#%"3& '#+#$3(23"'& $( I$+%"%0%( '# E+%0'(+ '# S&1'#C(2#%"3& '& U$"3#!+"'&'# F#'#!&2 '( R"( '# J&$#"!(4

    A/!(3&'( #. R"( '# J&$#"!(4 >> '# .&"( '# 9::;)

    B&$.& #/&0"$&'(!&

     111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 P!(2) D!) A$'!3 M&!%"$4 V"5&! '# C&!6&57( 8UFRJ9 O!"#$%&'(!:

     1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 P!(2) D!) A!%7;! A!!;'& L#&5 8UFRJ:

     11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 P!(2

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    5/108

    A(+ .#0+ 60#!"'(+ &3?+ M&$(#2 # T@#!#& /(! %#!#. #"%( .&"+ 5(2(!"'& # #2" & ."$@&3"'&)

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    6/108

    AGRADECIMENTOS

    A!&'#,( &(+ .#0+ /&"+ /#2( &.(!4 50"'&'(4 5&!"$@(4 &/("(4 5(./!##$+-( ##$%0+"&+.( '# #+%&! &( .#0 2&'( '0!&$%# %('& & $(++& 5&."$@&'&)

    A ."$@& "!.- /#2& &0'& "$5($'"5"($&24 & /&!5#!"& /#!#"%&4 & +"$%($"& "$#/2"5

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    7/108

    E0 &.&"+ "!"& /&!& & (0#"!& /(! 0.& (/"$"-(."$@&4 &"$&24 $-( %#$@( 5#!%#& &20.&)P(!.4 #0 "!"& /#2( '"!#"%( '# %#! # .0'&! '#(/"$"-(4 60&$%&+ 3##+ #0 60"+#++#)F!"#'!".7 N"#%=4.7#

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    8/108

    RESUMO

    O '"&$?+%"5( '(+ %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ 0. '(+ /!"$5"/&"+ &+/#5%(+ '& /+"5(/&%(2("&)D"3#!+&+ (!&. &+ (!.&+ 5!"&'&+ &( 2($( '(+ &$(+ /&!& '"&$(+%"5&! & '(#$,& .#$%&2) E.>;9 (" 5!"&'( /#2( C(."%= '# N(.#$52&%0!& # E+%&%8+%"5&4 '&  American Psychiatric

     Association4 ( M&$0&2 '# D"&$?+%"5( # E+%&%8+%"5& '&+ P#!%0!7&,#+ M#$%&"+ K DSM) D#+'#+0& 5!"&,-( ( M&$0&2 < %#3# 60&%!( #'",#+ # '0&+ !#3"+#+) A%0&2.#$%# & 60"$%& #'",-( #+%<#. &+# '# #2&7(!&,-() O7+#!3&.(+ 60# & 5!"&,-( '( M&$0&2 !#2#%# ( .(.#$%( @"+%?!"5( '&.#'"5"$&4 # ( +#0 5($%#1'( "$%#!#!# '"!#%&.#$%# $& (!.&,-( # /(! 5($+#0"$%# $& 5($'0%&'( /+"60"&%!&) N-( +# %!&%&4 /(!%&$%(4 &.&"+ 0.& +"./2#+ '#+5!",-( '# 0.& +0/(+%& $&%0!#&

    (!$"5& (0 7"(2?"5& '& '(#$,& .#$%&24 (0 0. '"&$?+%"5( $#0%!() E+%# %!&7&2@( %#3# 5(.((7#%"3(+ '#+5!#3#! 5(.( +0!"0 ( DSM4 60&"+ &+ .0'&$,&+ 60# (5(!!#!&. #$%!# &+ +0&+#'",#+4 +"%0&$'(K&+ $& @"+%?!"& '& /+"60"&%!"& 5(.( 0. !#2#( '#+%& &$&2"+&! 60&"+ (+

     /!(5#++(+ 60# #+%-( #. 50!+(4 60&"+ &+ (!,&+ &%0&$%#+ #. 5&'& $(3& #'",-( '( M&$0&2 '#+'#( +#0 2&$,&.#$%( # 60&"+ &(!& '#%#!."$&!-( &+ .0'&$,&+ 60# (5(!!#!-( $& /&++&#. /&!& (DSMKV # /!(.(3#! 0.& !#2#-( +(7!# ( '"&$?+%"5( /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    9/108

    ABSTRACT

    T@# '"&$(+%"5 ( .#$%&2 '"+(!'#!+ "+ ($# ( %@# .&"$ &+/#5%+ ( /+5@(/&%@(2()M&$ &+ @&3# 7##$ (0$' %( '"&$(+# %@# .#$%&2 '"+#&+# %@!(0@(0% %@# #&!+) I$ >;9 %@#

     N(.#$52&%0!# &$' S%&%"+%"5+ C(.."%%##4 !(. %@#  American Psychiatric Association4 5!#&%#'%@# .&$0&2 ( D"&$(+%"5+ &$' S%&%"+%"5+ ( M#$%&2 D"+(!'#!+ K DSM) S"$5# "%+ 5!#&%"($ "% @&+@&' (0! #'"%"($+ &$' %( !#3"+"($+) N(4 %@# "%@ #'"%"($ "+ 7#"$ /!#/&!#') # (7+#!3#' %@&%%@# 5!#&%"($ ( %@# M&$0&2 !#2#5%+ & @"+%(!"5&2 .(.#$% ( %@# .#'"5"$#4 &$' "%+ 5($%#$%"$%#!#!#+ '"!#5%2 "%@ %@# (!.&%"($ &$'4 5($+#60#$%24 "%@ %@# &%%"%0'# ( %@# /+5@"&%!"+%) I%"+ $(%4 %@#!#(!#4 & +"./2# '#+5!"/%"($ ( & +(K5&22#' (!&$"5 (! 7"(2("5&2 $&%0!# ( %@# .#$%&2

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

     7"(2("5&2 /+5@"&%!) A+ & 5($520+"($4 # 0$'#!+%&$' %@&% " # &'(/% & @#&2%@ 5($5#/%"($ &++(.#%@"$ 3"3#$%"&24 @"5@ 5&$$(% 7# !#'05#' %( '"&$(+%"5+ $(! 5&$ "% 7# .#&+0!#' +05@ &+%@# ($# /!(/(+#' 7 M&!%"$+4 9::Q4 $#5#++&!"2 %@# "'#& ( %@# '"&$(+%"5 "%+#2 5(.#+ %(&$(%@#! '".#$+"($4 & .(!# "$+%!0.#$%&2 0$5%"($4 @#2/"$ %(&!'+ 5(./!#@#$+"($ ( %@# !#&25(./2#"% ( .#$%&2 @#&2%@)

    # (!'+ DSM4 '"&$(+%"54 .#$%&2 @#&2%@4 /+5@(&$&2+#+4 7"(2("5&2 /+5@"&%!)

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    10/108

    SUM>RIO 

    I$%!(';?@( )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))

    C&%;5( C($%#/%;&5"=&?@( 7"4%!".& # & .!"&?@( '( DSM )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))+-

    C&%;5( + A4 0;'&$?&4 (.(!!"'&4 $(4 %#/%(4 '(4DSM4 )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))

    C&%;5( O 5&$?&0#$%( '( DSM V ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))

    C($.5;4@( ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))

    R#2#!$."&4 B"K5"(!2".&4 )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))-

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    11/108

    >>

    INTRODUÇÃO

    E.7(!& &,& /&!%# '&+ #+/#5"&2"'&'#+ '& .#'"5"$&4 & /+"60"&%!"& %#. @"+%?!"& #

    5&!&5%#!8+%"5&+ /&!%"502&!#+) S0& @"+%?!"& # +0&+ 5&!&5%#!8+%"5&+ < (!&. # &"$'& +-(

    &./2&.#$%# #+%0'&'(+ # '"+50%"'(+) U. '(+ %#%(+ '# !##!=$5"& +(7!# & @"+%?!"& '&

     /+"60"&%!"&  A História da Loucura4 '# M"5@#2 F(05&02% >;9Q4 ($'# &7(!'&'& & (!.& '(

    @(.#. 2"'&! 5(. ( 60# 5($+"'#!(0 5(.( +#$'( 2(050!& '#+'# ( !#$&+5".#$%( &% &

    .('#!$"'&'#) H< 0. 5($+#$+( +(7!# ( .&!5( "$"5"&2 '& @"+%?!"& '& /+"60"&%!"& 60&$'(4 $&

    F!&$,&4 P"$#2 +#/&!(0 ( 2(05( '(+ (0%!(+ "$'"38'0(+ 60# %&.7. #!&. #5208'(+ '& 3"'&

    +(5"&24 /!(/($'( #$%-( %!&%Q) P"$#2 0+(0 /&!%# '& %#!."$(2("& 0+&'& $& .#'"5"$& @"/(5!  %&"+ 5(.( .&$"&4 .#2&$5(2"& #

    '#.=$5"& S#!/&4 >;;WQ)

    O '"&$?+%"5( '(+ %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ 0. '(+ /!"$5"/&"+ &+/#5%(+ '& /+"5(/&%(2("&)

    A %&!#& '# '"&$(+%"5&!4 #+/#5"&2.#$%# #. /+"60"&%!"&4 %#. +# .(+%!&'( 0. '(+ !&$'#+

    '#+&"(+ $&

    '"&$?+%"5( #. /+"60"&%!"& $-( &5(./&$@& #&%&.#$%# '& .#+.& (!.& ( /#!50!+( '(

    '"&$?+%"5( $&+ '#.&"+

    8+"5(+4 7"(2?"5(+4 (7#%"3(+4 !##!"'(+ (0 $-( & 0.& #%"(2("& 5($@#5"'&4 60# /#!."%#.

    > L(050!&

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    12/108

    >9

    !##!#$5"&! & '(#$,& & 0.& 5&%#(!"& #+/#58"5&) E$60&$%( $( 60# '" !#+/#"%( /+"60"&%!"&

    $-( #$5($%!&.(+ ( .#+.( 60&'!(4 /("+ &/#+&! '# 2"'&! 5(. +"$&"+ 0$5"($&"+ # 8+"5(+4 #+%#+

    $#. +#./!# +-( (7#%"3(+4 # $-( @< &#$%# #%"(2?"5( #3"'#$%# P&(2"#22(4 9:::Q)

    M0"%( &$%#+ .#+.( '# P"$#24 & (!"#. '& /!#(50/&,-( 5(. & #2&7(!&,-( '#

    '"&$?+%"5(+ /('# +#! !#.#%"'& & 5"$5( +502(+ &)C)4 %&2 5(.( (7+#!3&!#.(+ $( 5&/8%02( 0.

    '#+%& /#+60"+&4 # '#+'# & &$%"Z"'&'#4 '"3#!+&+ 2"$0&#$+ (!&. 0%"2"&'&+ /&!& '#+5!#3#! (+

    .&"+ 3&!"&'(+ 60&'!(+ /+"5(/&%(2?"5(+) F(" '#$%!( '#+%& #3(20,-( '# 5!"%!"(+ 0+&'(+ /&!&

    $(.#&! %&"+ #$[.#$(+ 60# #. >;9 (" 5!"&'( /#2( C(."%= '# N(.#$52&%0!& # E+%&%8+%"5& '&

     American Psychiatric Assiciation, ( M&$0&2 '# D"&$?+%"5( # E+%&%8+%"5& '&+ P#!%0!7&,#+

    M#$%&"+ DSMQ4 (7#%( +(7!# ( 60&2 $(+ '#7!0,&.(+ $#+%& /#+60"+&)

    D#+'# +0& 5!"&,-(4 ( DSM %(!$(0K+# 0. "./(!%&$%# "$+%!0.#$%(4 0%"2"&'(

    "$"5"&2.#$%# $(+ E+%&'(+ U$"'(+ # /(+%#!"(!.#$%# #. '"3#!+(+ /&8+#+ $( .0$'(4 5(. &

    "$&2"'&'# '# 0$"(!."&! & 2"$0&#. 0%"2"&'& /&!& & 52&++""5&,-( '&+ /#!%0!7&,#+ .#$%&"+)

    A /!".#"!& #'",-(4 ( DSMKI4 (" 2&$,&'& 5(. >9 /\9

    %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ #. >] / S8$'!(.#+ 528$"5&+4 E"(

    9 T!&$+%(!$(+ '& /#!+($&2"'&'# # '( '#+#$3(23".#$%(4 E"( C($'",#+ # %!&$+%(!$(+ 8+"5(+4 E"( ]G!&3"'&'# '(+ #+%!#++(!#+ /+"5(++(5"&"+ # ( E"( A3&2"&,-( 2(7&2 '( '#+#$3(23".#$%()

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    13/108

    >

    %#%( '& %#!5#"!& #'",-( # (" 2&$,&'( ( DSMKIIIKR4 &/!#+#$%&$'( 9;9 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+

    #. +0&+ ; /

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    14/108

    >]

    '"3#!+(+ .('(+ '# 5(./!##$'#! # 52&++""5&! &+ '(#$,&+ .#$%&"+) N#+%& /&!%# +"%0&!#.(+ &

    5!"&,-( # 2&$,&.#$%( '# 5&'& 0.& '&+ #'",#+ '( M&$0&2 @"+%(!"5&.#$%#4 #+/#5"&2.#$%# (+

    &%(!#+ 60# "$20#$5"&!&. $& 5!"&,-( '# 5&'& 0.& '#2&+)

     N( +#0$'( 5&/8%02(4 &$&2"+&!#.(+ &+ .0'&$,&+ $( %#%( '# 5&'& 0.& '&+ #'",#+

    60# '#.($+%!&. +0& '0/2& "./(!%$5"& K &2. '( &%( '# 60# ( M&$0&2 !#2#%# & /+"60"&%!"&4

    #2# %&.7. & 5!"&) T&"+ .0'&$,&+ +# !##!#. &(+ %#!.(+ 0+&'(+ # + 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+

    60# (!&. 5!"&'&+4 .('""5&'&+ # #5208'&+ '(+ %#%(+ '(+ M&$0&"+)

     N( %#!5#"!( 5&/8%02( &7(!'&!#.(+ ( .&%#!"&2 60# < (" 2&$,&'( &% ( .(.#$%( +(7!# (

    DSMKV) A /&!%"! '(+ &!%"(+ /072"5&'(+ (7+#!3&!#.(+ 60&"+ &+ (!,&+ &%0&$%#+4 60&"+ &+

     /!(3

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    15/108

    >

    "$%#!$&5"($&24 "$3#+%"&$'( &+ &%"%0'#+ '# '"3#!+(+ /!("++"($&"+ 2"&'(+

    .#$%&2 (!& '(+ E+%&'(+ U$"'(+4 # 5@#&!&. 5($520+-( 60# ( DSMKIII # ( DSMKIIIKR +-(

    .&"+ &./2&.#$%# 0%"2"&'(+ $( .0$'( '( 60# & C2&++""5&,-( I$%#!$&5"($&2 '&+ D(#$,&+4 $(

    #$+"$(4 $& /#+60"+& # %&.7. $& /!;;> 9>Q) C($5208.(+ 60# +#

    +-( 0+&'(+ '#+%& (!.& /!#'(."$&$%# $& 528$"5&4 /(!60# &#. /&!%# '& 5($+%!0,-( '#+%&

     /!

    60# #2#+ '#3#. +#! !#5($@#5"'(+ $& /!

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    16/108

    >W

    (7"& +(5"&2 $& +(5"#'&'# #./!#&$'( ( CIDK>: # ( DSMKIIIKR4 G"2"(%%" # B#++& 9::]Q60#

     /#+60"+&!&. (+ 5!"%!"(+ '"&$?+%"5(+ /&!& & +8$'!(.# '# '#/#$'=$5"& '( ;\:4 (

    60# !#++&2%& & +0& "./(!%$5"& #$60&$%( #!!&.#$%& '"&$?+%"5&4 %&2 5(.( < (" &/($%&'( /(!

    (0%!(+ &0%(!#+4 5(.(4 "22"&$ J!) et al. >;;9Q4 A!$% et al ) >;;9Q # S!# et al. >;;>Q) A2.

    '# !#++&2%&! & "./(!%$5"& '( 0+( '& #$%!#3"+%&4 (+ &0%(!#+ '#+%&5&. & $#5#++"'&'# '# 0.

    50"'&'(+( %!#"$&.#$%( 528$"5( /&!& ( /!("++"($&2 60# (! &#! 0+( '#+%& #!!&.#$%&4 /("+

    #.7(!& &+ /#!0$%&+ '& #$%!#3"+%& +#&. #+%!0%0!&'&+4 & /($%0&,-( +# !##!# &( 02&.#$%(

    528$"5( '( #$%!#3"+%&'(!4 5(. !#2&,-( /!#+#$,& (0 $-( '# '#%#!."$&'( 5!"%!"(4 # $-(

    !#+/(+%& '&'& /#2( /&5"#$%# D#2KB#$ et al )49::> >\Q) R#++&2%&.(+4 & /&!%"! '#+%# &!%"(4 &

    "$20=$5"& ##!5"'& /#2( /!?/!"( M&$0&2 $& (!"#$%&,-( 528$"5& '(+ .'"5(+ /+"60"&%!&+) U.&

    3# 60# & #+5(2@& '#+%& #$%!#3"+%&4 #"%& /#2(+ &0%(!#+4 #$%!# %&$%&+ (0%!&+ #"+%#$%#+ ("(!"#$%&'& /#2& /!##!=$5"& '&'& $#+%# "$+%!0.#$%(4 &( 0+( '(+ 5!"%!"(+ 0+&'(+ $( DSM # $(

    CID)

    V#$%0!& # B(%"$( 9::>Q4 /(! +0& 3#4 #+%0'&!&. & 5($"&7"2"'&'# '& 3#!+-( #.

     /(!%00=+ '# 0.& #$%!#3"+%& 528$"5& #+%!0%0!&'&   /&!& ( '"&$?+%"5( '# '#.=$5"& '# &5(!'(

    5(. (+ 5!"%!"(+ '"&$?+%"5(+ '( DSMKIIIKR # CIDK>:) N( 5&+( & ENEDAM E$%!#3"+%&

    ] SCID 0.& #$%!#3"+%& 528$"5& $-( #+%!0%0!&'& 60# 0+&'& /&!& & #2&7(!&,-( '( '"&$?+%"5()

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    17/108

    >

    E+%!0%0!&'& /&!& ( D"&$?+%"5( '# D#.=$5"& '( T"/( A2@#".#!4 D#.=$5"& /(! M12%"/2(+

    I$&!%(+ # D#.=$5"&+ '# O0%!&+ E%"(2("&+Q) S#0$'( (+ &0%(!#+4 0. '(+ .(%"3(+ '# %#!#.

    #+5(2@"'( #+%& #$%!#3"+%& (" /(!60# #2& &/!#+#$%& 0.& #+%!#"%& 5(!!#2&,-( 5(. (+ '"&$?+%"5(+

    '( DSMKIIIKR # CIDK>:)A/?+ &/2"5&!#. & #$%!#3"+%& #. 9: /&5"#$%#+ "'(+(+ 5(. '"&$?+%"5(

    '# '#.=$5"&4 5($5208!&. 60# %&2 #$%!#3"+%& /('# +#! 5($+"'#!&'& 0. "$+%!0.#$%( 5($"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    18/108

    >\

     /&!& &2. '& &/2"5&,-( '#++#+ 5!"%!"(+)

    E+%#+ %!=+ &!%"(+ &/!#+#$%&'(+ %=. #. 5(.0. ( &%( '# !#++&2%&!#. ( 60&$%( (

    %!#"$&.#$%( 528$"5( "./(!%&$%# /&!& & #2&7(!&,-( '# 0. '"&$?+%"5(4 .&+ %&.7.

    '#.($+%!&. 60# .#+.( 0. /!("++"($&2 "$#/#!"#$%# (0 +#. %!#"$&.#$%( &/!(/!"&'( /('#!"&

    ##%0&! 0. '"&$?+%"5( & /&!%"! '( M&$0&24 &"$'& 60# #60"3(5&'() A/($%&. %&.7. &

    "./(!%$5"& '# 60# (+ "$+%!0.#$%(+ $#+%# 5&+( #$%!#3"+%&+ 528$"5&+ # %!#"$&.#$%(Q +#&.

    "'#'"$(+ &(+ 5!"%!"(+ '"&$?+%"5(+ '( DSM # '( CID)

    D#$%!# (+ +#"+ &!%"(+4 '("+ '"+50%"&. #+/#5""5&.#$%# &20$+ &+/#5%(+ & !#+/#"%( '(

    0+( '( DSM) M&%(+ #% &2)9::Q &7(!'&!&. & "./(!%$5"& # &+ 2"."%&,#+ '( DSMKIV '#$%!(

    '& /!

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    19/108

    >;

    B&$&%( #% &2) 9::Q %&.7. &7(!'&. ( 0+( '( DSM #. +#0 &!%"( O 60# (+

     /+"60"&%!&+ 7!&+"2#"!(+ #+/#!&. '&+ 52&++""5&,#+ '"&$?+%"5&+`4 ($'# '"+50%#. ( 0+( %&$%( (

    DSM4 60&$%( '( CID) T&2 &!%"( $(+ /&!#5#0 #+/#5"&2.#$%# "./(!%&$%# /(!60# (+ &0%(!#+

    "#!&. 0.& /#+60"+& 5(. &20$+ /+"60"&%!&+ +(7!# & 0%"2"'&'# /#!5#7"'& /(! #2#+ '(+

    M&$0&"+ 0+&'(+ /&!& & #2&7(!&,-( '"&$?+%"5&4 &2. '# +0&+ #/#5%&%"3&+ +(7!# (+ 0%0!(+

    +"+%#.&+ '"&$?+%"5(+ K %#.& 60# $(+ '# #+/#5"&2 "$%#!#++# $#+%& '"++#!%&,-() A 5($520+-(

    '(+ &0%(!#+ (" '# 60# &2. '# &./2&.#$%# 0+&'( $& 528$"5&4 & .&"(! /&!%# '(+ /+"60"&%!&+

     /#+60"+&'(+ &5@&!&. 60# #++& #!!&.#$%& '"&$?+%"5& "./(!%&$%# /(! /#!."%"! 0.& 5($"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    20/108

    9:

    .'"5(+4 0.& 2#"%0!& 1$"5& '( +(!".#$%( /+860"5(4 ( 60# "$'"5&!"&4 %&2 5(.( #. $(++&+

    @"/?%#+#+4 60# &++". 5(.( ( M&$0&2 !#2#%# & /+"60"&%!"& $(!%#K&.#!"5&$& /&!& ( .0$'(4 #2#

    %&.7. 5($+%!?" #+%& /+"60"&%!"& &%0&24 /("+ /&!%# '& (!.&,-( '(+ .'"5(+) E. +#0"'&

    G0&!"'( &7(!'& & .#'"5&2"&,-( '& 5!"&$,& # ( 0+( '( /&!&'".& '& 528$"5& /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    21/108

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    22/108

    99

    5(.( #. "$2=+4 $-( #$5($%!&.(+ $#$@0.& (5(!!=$5"& $& 7&+# '# '&'(+) F(!&. #$5($%!&'&+

    W> (5(!!=$5"&+ /&!& & +"2& DSM4 '&+ 60&"+4 >] &/!#+#$%&3&. %#.&+ !##!#$%#+ & '"+50++-(

    +(7!# ( DSM # (+ (0%!(+ ] &/#$&+ ( 5"%&3&. #. !#2&,-( & &20. (0%!( %#.&) D("+ '#++#+

    &!%"(+ (!&. (+ .#+.(+ #$5($%!&'(+ $( S5"#2(4 & +&7#!4 '# M&%(+ et al ) 9::Q # D#2KB#$

    >;;\Q)

    D#$%!# (+ (0%!(+ >9 &!%"(+ #$5($%!&'(+4 #. C2&++""5&$'( /#++(&+ # +0&+

     /#!%0!7&,#+ & !#3(20,-( %#!."$(2?"5& '( DSMKIII R0++( # V#$$5"( 9::WQ '"+50%#. &

    .0'&$,& '# /&!&'".& 60# ( DSMKIII "./2"5(0 # #/#. & $(3& &!60"%#%0!& '( M&$0&2 #.

    !#2&,-( + #'",#+ &$%#!"(!#+ # & +0& 2?"5& 52&++""5&%?!"& R0++( a V#$$5"(4 9::WQ

    !#%(.&$'( & @"+%?!"& '&+ 52&++""5&,#+ /+"60"

    #3"'#$%# 0. .('( /+"5&$&28%"5( '# 5(./!##$'#! & '(#$,& .#$%&2)

    S"%0&. #. +#0"'& & 5!"&,-( '( DSMKIII # &/($%&. 60# #+%& #'",-( '( M&$0&2 5&0+(00.& !0/%0!& #. %!=+ $83#"+ $( $83#2 '& #+%!0%0!& 5($5#"%0&24 /(!60# /!(/[+ 0.& 1$"5& 2?"5&

    52&++""5&%?!"& $( $83#2 '& @##.($"& '(+ 5&./(+ '# +&7#!#+ 5($5(!!#$%#+4 /("+ !(./#0 5(.

    & &7(!'&#. /+"5&$&28%"5& 60# #!& '(."$&$%# # $( $83#2 '&+ !#/!#+#$%&,#+ +(5"&"+ !#2&%"3&+ &(

    "$'"38'0( .('#!$(4 /("+ 5!"(0 $(3&+ 5($5#/,#+ #$%!# ( $(!.&2 # ( /&%(2?"5() E$60&$%( (

    DSMKI # ( DSMKII 0+&3&. ( 5@&.&'( '"&$?+%"5( '".#$+"($&24 ($'# $-( @&3"&. !($%#"!&+

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    23/108

    9

    52&!&.#$%# '#.&!5&'&+ #$%!# &+ '(#$,&+4 ( DSMKIII '#.&!5&3& $"%"'&.#$%# %&"+ !($%#"!&+4 (

    60# 2#3(0 & 0.& #+/#5""5&,-( '&+ 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+)

    A"!.&. %&.7. 60# & /!#%#$+& '#+5!",-( &%#?!"5& '( DSMKIII4 %#. &"$"'&'#

    #3"'#$%# 5(. & 3"+-( "+"5&2"+%& '& /#!%0!7&,-( .#$%&2 # 60# & '"0+-( '& $(.#$52&%0!&

     /!#+#$%# $( DSMKIII 5(!!#+/($'#0 &+5#$+-( '& /+"60"&%!"& 7"(2?"5& $( .0$'() E++& 3"+-(

    "+"5&2"+%& "$%#!#++(0 & "$'0+%!"& &!.&5=0%"5&4 60# 5(.#,(0 #$%-( & "$&$5"&! /#+60"+&+ /&!& &

    5!"&,-( '# $(3(+ .#'"5&.#$%(+ /&!& +#!#. 2&$,&'(+ $( .#!5&'()

    E. +#0"'& &+ &0%(!&+ &7(!'&. &+ .0'&$,&+ 60# (5(!!#!&. $( 0+( '( %#!.( $#0!(+#4

    60# $( DSMKII &/&!#5#0 &/#$&+ #$%!# /&!=$%#+#+ # '#+&/&!#5#0 5(./2#%&.#$%# $( DSMKIIIK

    R4 # %&.7. &+ .0'&$,&+ #. !#2&,-( + 5&%#(!"&+ '#+3"(+ +#0&"+) N(+ '("+ 5&+(+4 '&+

    $#0!(+#+ # '(+ '#+3"(+ +#0&"+4 & 60&$%"'&'# '# 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+ 60# +0!"!&. /&!&

    +07+%"%0"! &+ &$%"&+ 5&%#(!"&+4 5(!!#+/($'#$%#+ & #++#+ '("+ '"+%1!7"(+4 5!#+5#0) A7(!'&!#.(+

    $( 5&/8%02( '("+ '#++& /#+60"+& &+ .0'&$,&+ $&+ 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+ #. 5&'& 0.& '&+

    #'",#+ '( M&$0&2)

    E+%# &!%"( %#3# !&$'# !#2#3$5"& /&!& $(++& /#+60"+&4 /("+ #. /&!%# +#0+ (7#%"3(+

    5("$5"'#. 5(. (+ $(++(+) A( %!&%&!#. '& !0/%0!& 5&0+&'& /#2( DSMKIII &+ &0%(!&+ .(+%!&!&.

    &20.&+ 5($+#6Z=$5"&+ #. !#2&,-( 5($5#/,-( '& '(#$,& .#$%&2 # .&"+ &"$'& #. !#2&,-(

    (!.& '# %!&%

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    24/108

    9]

    5($%#./(!$#& %&.7. 5@&.&'& '# /+"60"&%!"& 7"(2?"5&)

    E2# !#%(.& (+ %!=+ .(3".#$%(+ 60# +# +05#'#!&. 5!($(2("5&.#$%# $& @"+%?!"& '&

     /+"60"&%!"&4 60# +-( & .#'"5&2"&,-( (/#!&5"($&2"&'& /#2& /+"60"&%!"& 7"(2?"5&4 #.

    +#0"'& & '#+.#'"5&2"&,-( #"%& /#2& /+"60"&%!"& '"$."5& # %&.7. /#2(+ .(3".#$%(+ '&

    !#(!.& /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    25/108

    9

    #+/#5"&2.#$%# & /!(/(+%& '& &3&2"&,-( .02%" &"&24 &7(!'&$'( 5&'& 0. '(+ #"(+ &+

    +8$'!(.#+ 528$"5&+4 (+ %!&$+%(!$(+ '# /#!+($&2"'&'# # '( '#+#$3(23".#$%(4 &+ 5($'",#+ #

    %!&$+%(!$(+ 8+"5(+4 (+ #+%!#++(!#+ /+"5(++(5"&"+ # & &3&2"&,-( 2(7&2 '( '#+#$3(23".#$%(Q)

    A/($%& 60&"+ +-( (+ (7#%"3(+ '( DSMKIII +#! 52"$"5&.#$%# &5#"%(4 +#! &5#"%( /(!

     /!("++"($&"+ '# (!"#$%&,#+ %#?!"5&+ '"+%"$%&+4 +#! 5(./&%83#2 5(. & CIDK;4 %#! 3&2"'&'# # %#!

    5($"&7"2"'&'# "'.&!4 >;\\Q) P&!& & &0%(!&4 0.& 5($+#6Z=$5"& "./(!%&$%# '& (!.02&,-( '#

    5!"%!"(+ '"&$?+%"5(+4 60# (!&. & 7&+# '( DSMKIII4 ( &%( '# 60# @< /&5"#$%#+ 60# $-( +#

    "$520#. #. $#$@0.& '&+ 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+4 "$'"5&$'( &++". & $#5#++"'&'# '& 5!"&,-(

    '# $(3&+ 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+ /&!& +0/!"! #+%& '#"5"=$5"&)

    D#$%!( '& '"+50++-( '#+%#+ &0%(!#+4 '# #+/#5"&2 "./(!%$5"& /&!& #+%# %!&7&2@( #+%-( &+

    .0'&$,&+ $( '"&$?+%"5( /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    26/108

    9W

    "$%#!$&5"($&24 7&+#&$'( ( %#%( '( M&$0&2 #. !#+02%&'(+ '# /#+60"+& 528$"5&) E++& %#$%&%"3& '#

    !#"$+#!,-( +# '#0 #. %!=+ &+/#5%(+ #$&%"&$'( $( .('#2( '# '"&$?+%"5( (/#!&%"3(4 70+5&$'(

    & !#'0,-( '(+ #"(+ 0+&'(+ $( M&$0&2 # &./2"&$'( +0& 0%"2"&,-( /&!& '"3#!+(+ /!("++"($&"+

    # $-( /!("++"($&"+) O &!%"( '# A2&!5?$ (" #+5!"%( &$(+ &$%#+ '( 2&$,&.#$%( '( DSMKIV #

    $(%&.(+ 60# ( &0%(! /!#%#$'#0 &%!&3+ '& @"+%?!"&4 /!#3#! &+ .0'&$,&+ '& %#!5#"!& /&!& &

    60&!%& #'",-( '( M&$0&2)

    A !#3"+%& &!#$%"$&4 Questiones de infância, #. +#0 3(20.# >> /072"5&'( #. 9::4

    &/!#+#$%(0 ( %#.& U+( # &70+( '( '"&$?+%"5( #. 5!"&$,&+ # &'(2#+5#$%#+ & %"5&

     /+"5&$&28%"5& !#$%# &( DSMKIV) N#2&4 O+.#! 9::Q # 0.& '"+50++-( +(7!# ( 0+( '( DSM4

    &/!#+#$%&$'( ( 5&+( '# 0. .#$"$( '# '(# &$(+4 2#3&'( /&!& %!&%&.#$%( 5(. & &0%(!&4 60#

    &/?+ '"&$(+%"5&'( 5(. #$5(/!#+# 5?'"( F;\)> '( DSMKIVQ &(+ 5"$5( &$(+4 "5(0 +#%# &$(+

    +#. !#5#7#! $#$@0. %"/( '# %!&%&.#$%() A &0%(!& %(.& #+%# 5&+( 5(.( ##./2( '# 60#4

    60&$'( &/#$&+ 2#3&'( #. 5($+"'#!&,-( 0. '"&$?+%"5( (0 &+ 2#%!&+ # $1.#!(+ 60# (

    !#/!#+#$%&.4 & '".#$+-( @"+%?!"5& '( /&5"#$%# '#+&/&!#5#4 &++". 5(.( +0&+ '#%#!."$&,#+

    "$%!& # "$%#!+07#%"3&+) N( 5&+( '#+5!"%(4 ( M&$0&2 %#!"& 3"!&'( 0. "$+%!0.#$%( /&!& (

    &&+%&.#$%( '# 60&260#! (0%!& '".#$+-( '& '(#$,&4 (0 .#+.( '( '(#$%#4 60# $-( & '".#$+-(

    (7+#!3

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    27/108

    9

    H"/#!&%"3"'&'#4 # 60# (" %!&%&'( /(! #2# &%!&3+ '& /+"5&$

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    28/108

    9\

    5($'0%(! '#++& /#+60"+& %#$'( +# '&'( /(!60# ( M&$0&2 0+&'( '"&!"&.#$%# $& /!

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    29/108

    9;

    @"+%?!"5( %#. 0.& (!.& '# 5(./!##$'#! # %&.7. '# 52&++""5&! &+ '(#$,&+ .#$%&"+) O 60#

    5($+"'#!&'( $(!.&2 #. 0.& /(5& /('# +#! 5($+"'#!&'( /&%(2?"5( #. (0%!&4 (0 3"5#K3#!+&)

    C(.( ##./2(+4 & @(.(++#0&2"'&'#4 60# &% >;;] # /&!%# '& 2"+%& '# %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+

    '( DSM # '#/("+ (" #5208'& &++". 5(.( & $#0!(+# 60# #!& 0. '"&$?+%"5( 5(!!"60#"!( &% (

    "$&2 '& '5&'& '# +#%#$%& # '#/("+ +# '#+'(7!(0 #. (0%!(+ '"&$?+%"5(+ '"#!#$%#+4 &#$'(

    5(. 60# ( %#!.( $#0!(+# '#+&/&!#5#++#) O DSM 5($+%!?" # 5($+%!08'( /(! #++&+ .0'&$,&+4

    0.& 3# 60# 5&'& 0.& '&+ #'",#+ '( M&$0&2 5($+"'#!& (0 '#+5($+"'#!& &%(!#+ $( .(.#$%(

    '# '#+5!#3#! &+ 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+ 60# ( 5(./#.)

    C&'& 0.& '&+ #'",#+ !#2#%# ( .(.#$%( '& /+"60"&%!"& $& /(5& '( +#0 2&$,&.#$%()

    P(! ##./2(4 #$60&$%( $( DSMKI $(+ '#/&!&.(+ 5(. & 2"$0&#. '& /+"5&$

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    30/108

    :

    .#2&$5(2"& /&!& $(.#&! &20.&+ (!.&+ '# 2(050!&)

    C(. ( '#5(!!#! '(+ +502(+4 '"3#!+(+ (0%!(+ %#!.(+ (!&. "$5(!/(!&'(+ &(

    3(5&702

    +(5"#'&'#4 %&"+ 5(.( (+ 2(05(+4 # (+ !#+/($+;\Q #

    R#"2 >\:Q) C(.( .&!5( '#+%# &%( /('#.(+ '#+%&5&! 60&$'( $& F!&$,&4 #. >;94 ( .'"5(

    P@"2"//# P"$#2 +#/&!(0 (+ 2(05(+ '(+ (0%!(+ #5208'(+ '& 3"'& #. +(5"#'&'# W) C(+%0.&K+#

    W

     P&!& .&"(!#+ '#+'(7!&.#$%(+ '#++& 60#+%-(4 3"'# S&"$ >;\Q # G&05@#% # S&"$ >;\:Q)

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    31/108

    >

    &/($%&! 60# $#+%# .(.#$%( (" 0$'&'& & /+"60"&%!"&4 5(.( 0.& 5"=$5"& .'"5& !#+/($+;;WQ) E2#

    5($5#7"& & "$+&$"'&'# 5(.( 0. '"+%1!7"( '# &0%(5($%!(2# # '& "'#$%"'&'#4 60# 5@&.&3& '#

    &2"#$&,-( N0$#+4 >;;WQ4 60# '#3#!"& +#! +07.#%"'& & 0. c%!&%&.#$%( .(!&2c) A /!(/(+%& '(

    %!&%&.#$%( .(!&2 #!& & '# '#"&! ( 2(05( !#&"! $&%0!&2.#$%# 2(050!&4 &/#$&+ 5($%!(2&$'( #

    .($"%(!&$'( +0&+ .&$"#+%&,#+) P&!& (7%#! %&2 5($%!(2# # .($"%(!&.#$%(4 /&++(0K+# &

    $#5#++"%&! '# 0. #+/&,( #+/#58"5( /&!& "++(4 0. &.7"#$%# ($'# ( 2(05( "5&++# "+(2&'( #

    +07.#%"'( & 0. 5(%"'"&$( '"+5"/2"$&'( # !8"'( R"55"&!'"4 9::9Q) * &/#$&+ 5(. P"$#2 60# &

    "$%#!$&,-( /&++(0 & %#! 0. 5&!

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    32/108

    9

    '#+5!#3#0 ."$05"(+&.#$%# 60&'!(+ .#$%&"+4 &%!&3+ '& (7+#!3&,-( '# &%(+ 528$"5(+4 #

    +#/&!(0 &+ /+"5(+#+ #. '("+ !&$'#+ !0/(+ & 2(050!& .&$8&5(K'#/!#++"3& # & '#.=$5"&

     /!#5(5#4 $( %#%( '& +#%& #'",-( '# >\;; '( +#0 2"3!( !ratado de Psi"uiatria N0$#+4 >;;WQ.

    E. /(05( %#./( ( .('#2( /!(/(+%( /(! !/#2"$ %#3# !&$'# &5#"%&,-( # 5($%!"70"0 /&!&

    0.& !#2&%"3& 0$"(!."&,-( 5($5#"%0&2 '& /+"60"&%!"& #0!(/"& G(('"$ # J&."+($4 >;;:Q)

    E. >\]: (" 5!"&'&4 /#2( (3#!$( &.#!"5&$(4 & /!".#"!& 52&++""5&,-( /+"60"\4 (" /072"5&'( /(! B$'"5% A00+%"$ M(!#24 0. /+"60"&%!&

    !&$5(K&0+%!8&5(4 0. 2"3!( 5@&.&'( !rait% des &%$%n%rescences Physi"ues, ($'# ( &0%(!

     /!(/[+ 0.& $(3& "$%#!/!#%&,-( /&!& &+ 5&0+&+ '& '(#$,& .#$%&24 & %#(!"& '&+

    '##$#!#+5=$5"&+) P&!& M(!#24 & '##$#!#+5=$5"&+ +-( '#+3"(+ '(#$%"(+ '( %"/( $(!.&2 '&@0.&$"'&'#4 %!&$+."%"'(+ @#!#'"%&!"&.#$%# P!(%(5&!!#!(4 9::9Q) E2# &%!"708& & '##$#!&,-(

    '&+ 5202&+ '( +"+%#.& $#!3(+( "$%("5&,-(4 # #+%& #!& & 5&0+& '& '(#$,& .#$%&2) C(. #++&

    %#(!"&4 #2# 70+5&3& 0.& !#2&,-( '& '(#$,& .#$%&2 5(. & .#'"5"$& #. #!&2 #. +0&+ /&2&3!&+4

    /#!+#0" ."$@& "'"& '(."$&$%#4 60# #!& 2"&!4 .&"+ (!%#.#$%# '( 60# @&3"& +"'( #"%( &%

    #$%-(4 & &2"#$&,-( .#$%&2 .#'"5"$& #!&2 M(!#2 &/0' P(!%(5&!!#!(4 9::9Q)

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    33/108

    A %#(!"& /!(/(+%& /(! M(!#2 !#+02%(0 #. 0.& %!&$+(!.&,-( $& 5($5#/,-( '# '(#$,&

    .#$%&2 '& /(5&4 /("+ &( &%!"70"! +0& #"+%=$5"& & 0.& 5&0+& (!$"5&4 ( &0%(! +# &&+%(0 '#

    0.& !&5"($&2"'&'# +(5"&2 '& 2(050!&4 &/!(".&$'(K+# '& &7(!'&#. 0+&'& /#2& .#'"5"$& #.

    #!&2) P(+%#!"(!.#$%#4 $( "$&2 '( +502( XIX4 !/#2"$ 5!"(0 0.& 52&++""5&,-( '&+ '(#$,&+

     /+"60";> >;9Q) F!#0' $-( 70+5& & 5&0+& '( +"$%(.&

    $( 5(!/( '( /&5"#$%#4 #2# 70+5& $( +#0 /+"60"+.(4 #. +0& +07#%"3"'&'#)

    T&2 5(.( E@!#$7#! '#+5!#3# 5(.( &60"2( 60# '#$(."$(0  su*eito cere+ral Q4 & /&!%"!

    '# F!#0'4 #$60&$%( ( @(.#. &2&$%# #!& (7#%( '& /+"5(/&%(2("&4 ( @(.#. 5#!#7!&2 /&++(0 &

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    34/108

    ]

    +#! ( (7#%( '& $#0!(2("& E@!#$7#!4 9::]Q) E@!#$7#! !#++&2%(0 60# #++# /#!8('( ("

     /&!%"502&!.#$%# .&!5&$%# /(!60# !&,&+ &(+ #+%0'(+ '# &20$+ .'"5(+ C@&!5(%4 B#!$@#".4

    B&7"$+" # F!#0'Q +(7!# & @"+%#!"&4 !#3#2(0K+# ( /+"60"+.() E++& !#3#2&,-( +# '#04 /("+ $-( #!&

    $& 7&+# (!$"5& '& /&5"#$%# @"+%!"5& 60# #+%&3& ( .&2 # +". #. 0.& (0%!& (7#%"3"'&'#)

    D0!&$%# !&$'# /&!%# '( +502( XX4 & /+"5(/&%(2("& # & $#0!(2("& /#!.&$#5#!&. 5(.

    !0.(+ '"+%"$%(+) P(!60# #$60&$%( $& $#0!(2("& ( /&5"#$%# %#. 0.& '(#$,& #. +#0 +"+%#.&

    $#!3(+( 60# 0+%""5& ( +"$%(.& 60# ( /&5"#$%# &/!#+#$%&4 $& /+"5(/&%(2("& ( /&5"#$%# +#

    #$5($%!& '(#$%# '# +" .#+.(4 '# +0& "$%#$5"($&2"'&'# E@!#$7#!4 9::]Q)

    E. >;> (" 5!"&'(4 $(+ E+%&'(+ U$"'(+4 ( C(."%= '# E+%&%8+%"5&+ '& A++(5"&,-(

    M'"5(KP+"5(2?"5& A.#!"5&$&4 60# /072"5(0 ( tatistical #anual for the se of nstitutions

     for the nsanes, #. 5(2&7(!&,-( 5(. ( C(."%= N&5"($&2 /#2& S&1'# M#$%&2) O .&$0&2 %#3#

    '# #'",#+ #$%!# >;>\ # >;]9) F(" #$%-( $& '5&'& '# 9: 60# +# "$"5"(0 0.& .0'&$,& $&

    (!.& '# #2&7(!&! '"&$?+%"5(+ $(+ E+%&'(+ U$"'(+4 /("+ &$%#+ '#++& '&%&4 5&'& 5#$%!( '#

    #+%0'(+ %"$@& +0&+ /!?/!"&+ $(.#$52&%0!&+4 '# .('( 60# 0. .'"5( (!.&'( #. 0.&

    "$+%"%0",-( 5($@#5"& (+ %#!.(+ &2" 0+&'(+4 60# $-( #!&. $#5#++&!"&.#$%# "0&"+ &(+ 0%"2"&'(+

    #. (0%!(+ 5#$%!(+ '( /&8+ APA4 >;9Q) E. >;4 ( tatistical #anual for the se of

     nstitutions for the nsanes  (" "$5(!/(!&'( /!".#"!& #'",-( '( tandart Classied

     omenclature of &isease '& A++(5"&,-( M'"5& A.#!"5&$& "! # 0%5@"$+4 >;;\Q) S0&"$&2"'&'# (" &%#$'#! '#.&$'& '# 0. 5#$+( #+%&%8+%"5( 0$"(!.# '(+ @(+/"%&"+ /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    35/108

    E. >;] & A'."$"+%!&,-( '# V#%#!&$(+ # & M&!"$@& '#+#$3(23#!&.4 & /&!%"! '&

    "$20=$5"& '( /+"60"&%!& # /+"5&$&2"+%& $(!%# &.#!"5&$( "22"&. M#$"$$#!4 0. +"+%#.& '#

    52&++""5&,-( '"&$?+%"5& 5($%#$'( 9] !0/(+ 5(. \] +07'"3"+#+) E+%& 52&++""5&,-( ("

    5!"&'& '#3"'( $#5#++"'&'# 52&++""5&%?!"& +0!"'& '0!&$%# & II G0#!!&)

    E. >;]\ #"+%"&.4 #$%-(4 %!=+ %"/(+ '# $(.#$52&%0!& 0+&'&+ $(+ E+%&'(+ U$"'(+4 0.&

    '& A++(5"&,-( M'"5&4 (0%!& 0+&'& /#2&+ F(!,&+ A!.&'&+ # 0.& %#!5#"!& 0+&'& /#2&

    A'."$"+%!&,-( '(+ V#%#!&$(+ 60# +# &++#.#2@&3& 5(. & 0+&'& /#2&+ F(!,&+ A!.&'&+Q APA4

    >;9Q) N#+%# &$( (" /072"5&'& & +#%& C2&++""5&,-( I$%#!$&5"($&2 '&+ D(#$,&+ – CIDKW

    OMS4 >;]\Q4 #+%& (" & /!".#"!& #'",-( '& CID & 5($%&! 5(. 0.& +#++-( /&!& (+ %!&$+%(!$(+

    .#$%&"+) N& CIDKW &2%&3&. "$(!.&,#+ +(7!# &+ +8$'!(.#+ 5#!#7!&"+ 5![$"5&+4 (+ '"+%1!7"(+

    '# /#!+($&2"'&'# # &+ !#&,#+ +"%0&5"($&"+ H#$!"60#+4 9::Q) E (" !&,&+ &( &%( '#++&

    #'",-( '& CID +#! "$5(./2#%& #. !#2&,-( &(+ %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+4 60# & &++(5"&,-( .'"5(K

     /+"5(2?"5& &.#!"5&$& 60# /(+%#!"(!.#$%# (" '#$(."$&'& &++(5"&,-( /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    36/108

    W

    .&2&!"(%#!&/"&4 & 2(7(%(."&4 & "$%!('0,-( '& 52(/!(.&"$& # '( 5"%!&%( '# 28%"(4 502."$&$'( $&

    5!"&,-( '(+ /+"5(;9) P(!. !&$'# /&!%# '#2&+ (" /!(3(5&'& /#2( ". '&

    +#0$'& 0#!!& .0$'"&24 #. >;])

     N#+%& /(5&4 (+ E+%&'(+ U$"'(+ # ( .0$'( +(!"&. &+ 5($+#6Z=$5"&+ '& 0#!!&)

    E$5($%!&.(+ '"3#!+(+ !#2&%(+ +(7!# & !&$'# 60&$%"'&'# '# 60&'!(+ &0'(+ '# %!&0.&%"+.(

     /+860"5( $(+ +(2'&'(+ 60# /&!%"5"/&!&. '& 0#!!&) P(! 5&0+& '#+%# #$[.#$( & /+"60"&%!"&

    5(.#,(0 & +&"! '(+ &+"2(+ # &/&!#5#! #. +#!3",(+ 5(.0$"%

    !#+02%&$%#+ '( ". '& +#0$'& 0#!!& (" & 5!"&,-( $& I$2&%#!!& '( N&%"($&2 H#&2%@ S#!3"5#4

    #. >;]] # & 5!"&,-( '& S#0!&$,& S(5"&24 $& F!&$,& #. >;]) S0!"&4 &++".4 0.& $(3&

    (!&$"&,-( '& +&1'#4 /&!& &%0&! $& !#5($+%!0,-( '(+ /&8+#+ $( /?+ 0#!!&) O /?+ 0#!!& ("

    .&!5&'( /(! '0&+ 3#!%#$%#+ .(!&"+ '& /+"60"&%!"&4 /(! 0. 2&'( & /+"5&$

    &%"3& '(+ /&5"#$%#+ $& +0& %#!&/"& # $& +(5"#'&'# & /+"60"&%!"& '# +#%(!4 $& F!&$,&4 60# 2#3(0 &

     /+"60"&%!"& /&!& (!& '( @(+/"%&24 /(++"7"2"%&$'( &( /&5"#$%# 0. %!&%&.#$%( $& +0& 5(.0$"'&'#

    A.&!&$%#4 >;;Q & /+"60"&%!"& "$+%"%05"($&24 %&.7. $& F!&$,& # & &$%"/+"60"&%!"&4 $( "$85"(

    '& '5&'& '# +#++#$%&4 $& I$2&%#!!&4 60# %#3# 5(.( /!"$5"/&"+ !#/!#+#$%&$%#+ D&3"' C((/#! #

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    37/108

    R($&2' L&"$ S#!/&4 >;;\Q)

    F(" $#+%# 5($%#%( @"+%?!"5( 60#4 #. >;94 (" 2&$,&'& & /!".#"!& #'",-( '( M&$0&2 '#

    D"&$?+%"5( # E+%&%8+%"5& '&+ P#!%0!7&,#+ M#$%&"+ DSMKIQ4 60# (!$#5#0 5!"%!"(+

    '"&$?+%"5(+ '&+ /#!%0!7&,#+ .#$%&"+) O M&$0&2 (" &./2&.#$%# 0%"2"&'( /(! /!("++"($&"+

    '&

     N& /(5& #. 60# (" 2&$,&'( ( DSMKI4 ( '"&$?+%"5( '&+ '(#$,&+ .#$%&"+ #!& #"%(

    &%!&3+ '( CIDKW /!('0"'( /#2& OMS) S#0$'( L0" 9::Q4 (+ /+"60"&%!&+ &5@&3&. ( CIDK

    W 2"."%&'( # "$&'#60&'( & /!;4 & /&!%# !#2&%"3& &(+ %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ $-( +(!#0 $#$@0.& &2%#!&,-(4 5($%"$0&$'(

    #&%&.#$%# "0&2 +#%& !#3"+-( APA4 >;W\Q)

    A/#+&! '# %#! +"'( .0"%( 0%"2"&'(4 0.& /&!%# '(+ /+"60"&%!&+ &.#!"5&$(+ # '#

    "$+%"%0",#+ 60# 50"'&3&. '# '(#$%#+ .#$%&"+ +# !#50+(0 & &'(%&! ( DSMKI 5(.( !##!=$5"&

     /&!& & /!;;Q)

    E. >;W\ (" 2&$,&'& & +#0$'& #'",-( '( M&$0&2 DSMKIIQ4 0%"2"&'& /(! 5&%(!#

    &$(+) O0 +#&4 60&$'( !#2#%".(+ +(7!# ( /#!8('( '# 0+( '(+ '("+ M&$0&"+4 #+%&.(+ /#$+&$'(

    +(7!# 0. /#!8('( '# %!"$%& &$(+4 60# 5(!!#+/($'# + '5&'&+ '# 5"$6Z#$%&4 +#++#$%& # +#%#$%&)O DSMKII /#!."%"& & #2&7(!&,-( '# .12%"/2(+ '"&$?+%"5(+4 +#$'( 60# /&!& "++( @&3"&

    '("+ 5!"%!"(+ 60# '#3#!"&. +#! +#0"'(+ & +&7#!4 & 5($'",-( 60# $#5#++"%&! %!&%&.#$%( .&"+

    0!#$%# '#3#!"& +#! 5($+"'#!&'& /!".#"!(4 #4 #. +"%0&,#+ ($'# $-( @&3"& @"#!&!60"& #.

    !#2&,-( 0!=$5"& '# %!&%&.#$%(4 & 5($'",-( .&"+ !&3# '#3#!"& +#! 2"+%&'& #. /!".#"!( 20&!)

    O %"/( '# '"&$?+%"5( 0%"2"&'( $( DSMKII #!& ( '"&$?+%"5( '".#$+"($&2 Y(0$4 >;;Q4

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    38/108

    \

    ($'# & 52&++""5&,-( #"%& '# (!.& 5($%8$0&4 $-( @&3#$'( 0.& '#.&!5&,-( $8%"'& '#

    !($%#"!&+ #$%!# '(#$,&+) P!(3&3#2.#$%# /(! #++# .(%"3(4 #$5($%!&3&.K+# #5#++(+ '# /#++(&+

    '"&$(+%"5&'&+4 # '"3#!+(+ 5&+(+ ($'# 0. .#+.( "$'"38'0( %"$@& '"&$?+%"5(+ '"#!#$%#+4

     /!('0"'(+ /(! /!("++"($&"+ '"#!#$%#+4 & /&!%"! '& "$#!=$5"& 528$"5& '# 5&'& 0.) O 60# #!(0

    0.& 5!8%"5& !##!#$%# & 0.& +0/(+%& 7&"& 5($"&7"2"'&'# '(+ '"&$?+%"5(+ /!('0"'(+ & /&!%"!

    '&+ '0&+ /!".#"!&+ #'",#+ '( DSM4 # (" ( &!0.#$%( 0+&'( /#2(+ &0%(!#+ '& %#!5#"!& #'",-(

     /&!& /!(.(3#! 0.& !#(!.02&,-( '& $(.#$52&%0!& 0%"2"&'&)

     N( %#%( '( M&$0&2 #!&. 0%"2"&'(+ '"3#!+(+ %#!.(+ # 5($5#"%(+ '& /+"5&$

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    39/108

    ;

    P+"60"'# +&1'# .#$%&2) O 5(."%= (!&$"&'(! '( DSMKII /!(/[+ ( 60# 5($+"'#!(0 +#! 0. 5($+#$+(

    #$%!# (+ /+"60"&%!&+ 7#. "$(!.&'(+ '&60#2& /(5&4 5(. ( (7#%"3( '# &5"2"%&! & 5(.0$"5&,-(

    #$%!# (+ /!("++"($&"+ # #3"%&! & &.7"Z"'&'# '( '"&$?+%"5() P&!& %&$%(4 +#0$'( ( 5(."%=4

    #3"%(0K+# 0+&! %#!.(+ 60# 5&!!#&++#. 5($(%&,#+ !#2&5"($&'&+ $&%0!#& '& '(#$,&4

    !#5(!!#$'( & #/2"5&,#+ 5&0+&"+ &/#$&+ 60&$'( #++&+ (++#. 0$'&.#$%&"+ &( 5($5#"%(

    '"&$?+%"5() P&!& ##./2""5&!4 G!0#$7#! 5"%& ( 5&+( '( 60# $( DSMKI !#5#7"& & $(.#&,-(

    '# !#&,-( #+60"(!=$"5&4 # 60# $( DSMKII /&++(0 & +#! $(.#&'( #+60"(!#$"&4 +#. 60#

    #++& .0'&$,& '# $(.#$52&%0!& &2%#!&++# & $&%0!#& '( %!&$+%(!$( APA4 >;W\ "Q) E+%&

    '#5"+-( +#. '13"'& '#+#$5(!&(0 0. '#7&%# 5($%8$0( +(7!# & +0& $&%0!#& (0 5&0+&)

    A/#+&! '( &!0.#$%( '& .0'&$,& '# %#!.(+ /&!& ( &&+%&.#$%( '( '#7&%# +(7!# &+

    5&0+&+ '&+ '(#$,&+4 &( $(+ '#/&!&!.(+ 5(. & $#0!(+# 5(.( & .&"(! '&+ 52&++#+ '#

     /#!%0!7&,#+4 (7+#!3&.(+ 60# & &7(!'&#. /+"5&$&28%"5& &"$'& #/285"%&4 &2"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    40/108

    ]:

    52&++""5&'&+ &60") APA4 >;W\4 /)]:4 !"( .#0Q

    O0%!(+ &0%(!#+ < &7(!'&!&. #+%# %#.&4 '& "$20=$5"& '& /+"5&$;9Q 60# 5"%&.(+ $& "$%!('0,-( '#++& '"++#!%&,-(4 ($'# ( &0%(! &7(!'& & @"+%?!"&

    '& 2(050!&  #anic/mios, Pris0es e Con1entos '# E!3"$ G(.&$ >;Q 60# &$&2"+(0 &+

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    41/108

    ]>

    "$+%"%0",#+ %(%&"+ # &+ 7&!!#"!&+ #$%!# ( "$%#!"(! # ( #%#!"(! '#+%&+ # O #ito da &oen(a

     #ental, '# T@(.&+ S&+ >;;Q4 60# '"+50%# & #"+%=$5"& '& '(#$,& .#$%&2 # 60&"+ +#!"&. (+

    5!"%!"(+ /&!& & +0& '#"$",-() E++#+ %#%(+ !#/!#+#$%&!&. .&!5(+ $& @"+%?!"& '& /+"60"&%!"&

     /("+ &7(!'&!&. & 2(050!& '#$%!( '# /#!+/#5%"3&+ '"#!#$%#+ "$520"$'( '"#!#$%#+ (!.&+ '#

    2"'&! 5(. #+%# #$[.#$()

    D#/("+ '& '5&'& '# +#++#$%&4 & /+"60"&%!"& +(!#0 0.& 5($%#+%&,-( #. !#2&,-( & +0&

    2#"%"."'&'# #/"+%#.(2?"5&4 #$!#$%&$'( #$%-( '""502'&'#+ /&!& +#! !#5($@#5"'& 5(.( 0.&

     /&!%# '& .#'"5"$& P#!#"!&4 9:::Q) U. '(+ .(%"3(+ 60# !#3#2&3& +0& !&"2"'&'# 5"#$%8"5&4 #!&

    & &2%& '# 5($5(!'$5"& #$%!# '"&$?+%"5(+ #"%(+ /&!& 0. .#+.( 5&+(4 /(! /+"60"&%!&+

    '"#!#$%#+) G!&,&+ & #++# &%(4 '0!&$%# & '5&'& '# +#%#$%& @(03# 0. !&$'# "$%#!#++# #.

    .#2@(!&! # 0$"(!."&! & 52&++""5&,-( /+"60"

    5($#-( #$%!# .0'&$,&+ $( M&$0&2 # /!(5#++(+ +(5"(/(28%"5(+ # #5($[."5(+)

    O+ /!".#"!(+ /+"5(

    '5&'& '# 60&!#$%& (!&. "$%!('0"'(+ (+ /!".#"!(+

    !0/(+ '# /&5"#$%#+ .&$8&5(+4 $( H(+/"%&2 U$"3#!+"%

    H#&24 9::9Q) E. >;: &5($%#5#0 & !#02&.#$%&,-( '( 0+( '( 28%"( #. /+"60"&%!"& $(+ EUA)

    H#&2 9::9Q &/($%& 60# (+ /!".#"!(+ #+%0'(+ '0/2(K5#(+4 !#&2"&'(+ & ". '# &3&2"&! & #"5

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    42/108

    ]9

    A"$'& #. >;94 +0!"0 & 52(!/!(.&"$& 60# (" 0+&'&4 /(! P&02 C@&!/#$%"#!4 #.

     /&5"#$%#+ 5"!1!"5(+ '# 0. @(+/"%&2 ."2"%&!4 #. P&!"+4 5(. & "$&2"'&'# '# &$&2#+"&) P(!.4

    #2# (7+#!3(0 60# (+ /&5"#$%#+ &/!#+#$%&!&. 0. '#+"$%#!#++# /#2( .#"(4 /#2&+ +0&+ &%"3"'&'#+4

    60&$'( #+%&3&. +(7 ##"%( '& '!(& H#$!"60#+4 9::Q) E. +#0"'& & '!(& (" %#+%&'&4 #.

     /&5"#$%#+ 5(. '"&$?+%"5( '# /+"5(+#4 /(! /+"60"&%!&+ '( .#+.( @(+/"%&2) O+ !#+02%&'(+

     /(+"%"3(+ '(+ %#+%#+ +0!/!##$'#!&. (+ .'"5(+)4 # /(! 3(2%& '# >;] & +07+%$5"& +# "!.(0 $(

    5#$

    E. >;] # >;4 +0!"!&. (+ /!".#"!(+ &$+"(28%"5(+4 ( .#/!(7&.&%( # (

    52(!'"&#/?"'(4 !#+/#5%"3&.#$%#) L(( ( .#/!(7&.&%( %#3# !&$'# !#/#!50++-( $(+ EUA #

    "5(0 5($@#5"'( 5(.( 0. %!&$6Z"2"&$%# H#$!"60#+4 9::Q) E. >;\ (" #"%& & +8$%#+# '(

    @&2(/#!"'(2 # #. >;; '( '"&#/&.) E. >;\ (!&. 5!"&'(+ %&.7. (+ /!".#"!(+

    &$%"'#/!#++"3(+) A "/!($"&"'&4 0. "$"7"'(! '& .($(&."$("'&+# IMAO+Q4 (" "$%!('0"'&

    $( %!&%&.#$%( '# /&5"#$%#+ "$%#!$&'(+ 5(. '#/!#++-(4 +#0"'( /#2& "."/!&."$& 60# (" (

     /!".#"!( &$%"'#/!#++"3( %!"5852"5( 5!"&'( S5&3($# a G(!#+%#"$4 >;;>Q) N( "$&2 '& '5&'& '#

    5"$6Z#$%& $-( @&3"& .0"%(+ /&5"#$%#+ 5(. ( '"&$?+%"5( '# '#/!#++-(4 (+ 5&+(+ &++".

    '"&$(+%"5&'(+ #!&. &/#$&+ (+ .&"+ !&3#+) O %!&%&.#$%( &'."$"+%!&'( &% #$%-( $#++#+

     /&5"#$%#+ #!& #"%( &%!&3+ '# +#++#+ '# #2#%!(5@(60#) E. >;W> (" 2&$,&'& & &."%!"/%"2"$&

     /#2( 2&7(!&%?!"( M#!5) E$60&$%( & "."/!&."$& #!& 0+&'& #. 5&+(+ '# '#/!#++-( #$'?#$& (03"%&24 & &."%!"/%"2"$& &/#+&! '# +#! .0"%( +"."2&! "."/!&."$&Q #!& 0+&'& $( %!&%&.#$%( '&

    '#/!#++-( $-(K3"%&2 !#&%"3& (0 $#0!?%"5&Q)

    U. &%( 60# $(+ '#+/#!%(0 &%#$,-( (" 60# ( 2&7(!&%?!"( M#!5 5(./!(0 :)::: 2"3!(+

     /!('0"'(+ /#2( /+"60"&%!& F!&$ A"' "$%"%02&'(  2econhecendo o Paciente &e'ressi1o  # (+

    '"+%!"70"0 #. 3

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    43/108

    ]

    5($+#6Z#$%#.#$%#4 3#$'#! ( .#'"5&.#$%( "$'"5&'( /&!& 5(.7&%=K2()

    O7+#!3&.(+ 60# &% ( "$&2 '& '5&'& '# 5"$6Z#$%& < #"+%"&. 5"$5( !0/(+ '# '!(&+

    5&/&#+ '# /!(.(3#! ##"%(+ 528$"5(+ #. %!&$+%(!$(+ /+"60";W ( 2&7(!&%?!"( R(5@# 2&$,(0 ( '"&#/&. 5(.

    ( $(.# 5(.#!5"&2 V&2"0.) E. >;W; ( V&2"0. 02%!&/&++(0 #. $1.#!( '# 3#$'&+ (

    L"7!"0. $(+ EUA) E. >;WW (" #"%( ( /!".#"!( !#2&%( '( 0+( '# 3&2/!(&%( #. /&5"#$%#+

    5(. %!&$+%(!$( '# @0.(! 7"/(2&!) E. >;W (" '#+5!"%( ( 0+( '# 52(."/!&."$& #. 5&+(+ '#

    %!&$+%(!$( (7+#++"3(K5(./02+"3() E. >;> (" #"%( ( /!".#"!( !#2&%( '( 0+( '#

    5&!7&.&#/"$& #. /&5"#$%#+ 5(. %!&$+%(!$( 7"/(2&!)

    E. >;\ & 20(#%"$& (" &/!(3&'&4 /#2& FDA\4 /&!& 0+( #. /&5"#$%#+ 5(. '"&$?+%"5(

    '# '#/!#++-() A +07+%$5"& 5(.#,(0 #$%-( & +#! 5(.#!5"&2"&'& 5(. ( $(.# P!(&5 $(+

    EUA /#2& "$'1+%!"& &!.&5=0%"5& E2" L"22)

    S#0$'( A$'#!+($ >;;Q ( P!(&54 $(.# 5(.#!5"&2 '& 20(#%"$&4 /&++(0 & +#!

    !#5#"%&'( /#2(+ .'"5(+ /&!& '"3#!+(+ /!(72#.&+4 %&"+ 5(.( 702"."&4 &$+"#'&'#4 %!&$+%(!$((7+#++"3(K5(./02+"3(4 '#$%!# (0%!(+) S(7!#%0'(4 ( &0%(! '#+%&5& 60# !&,&+ & /!(.#++&+ #"%&+

     /#2& .8'"&4 (+ ##"%(+ /!(.(3"'(+ /#2& +07+%$5"& /!(.#%"&. %!&$+(!.&! +#0+ 0+0

    O 2"3!(  Listenin$ to Pro3ac4 '( /+"60"&%!& $(!%#K&.#!"5&$( P#%#! !&.#! >;;Q4 5(2&7(!(0

    \

    A FDA 0.& &=$5"& #+%&%&24 5!"&'& /#2( (3#!$( $(!%#K&.#!"5&$(4 #. >;\) S#0 (7#%"3( 5($%!(2&! &5(.#!5"&2"&,-( '# &2".#$%(+ # !#.'"(+ $(+ E+%&'(+ U$"'(+)

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    44/108

    ]]

     /&!& & /(/02&!"&,-( '& '!(& # +#0+ ##"%(+ '# (7%#$,-( '# #2"5"'&'#) !&.#! '#+5!#3#0

    5&+(+ '# /&5"#$%#+ %!&%&'(+ /(! #2# 5(. ( .#'"5&.#$%( # !#2&%& 60# ( P!(&5 !#3#2(0 & 0. '#

    +#0+ /&5"#$%#+ +0& 3#!'&'# .&"+ "$%#!$&4 # '( /&5"#$%# &20. 7#.K+05#'"'( 5(.( $-(

    @&3"& +"'( &% #$%-() O 2"3!( 3"!(0 0. +est-seller 4 &./2&.#$%# '"302&'( /#2& .8'"&) E.

    >;;] ( P!(&5 +# %(!$(0 & '!(& .&"+ 3#$'"'& $( .0$'( S@(!%#!4 >;;Q)

    A 5!"&,-( '(+ /+"5(

    !#(!.02&,-( $&+ /!&$%"'#/!#++"3(+ IMAO+ #!&. #"5&#+ $( 5(.7&%# & '#/!#++#+ &%8/"5&+4 '"&$?+%"5(

     /!(/(+%( /(! /+"60"&%!&+ '&60#2& /(5&) A++". 5!"&3&. 0. $(3( .#!5&'( 5($+0."'(!4'"#!#$%# '&60#2# < &%"$"'( /#2& "."/!&."$&)

    O (3#!$( $(!%# &.#!"5&$( %&.7. "$3#+%"0 $(+ 2&7(!&%?!"(+ &!.&5=0%"5(+ '0!&$%# (

    +502( XX) G!&,&+ &(+ ##"%(+ (7%"'(+ /#2(+ .#'"5&.#$%(+4 0.& $(3& 5($5#/,-( '#

    %!&%&.#$%( '& '(#$,& .#$%&2 &/&!#5#04 '"#!#$%# '( (2@&! '& /+"5&$

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    45/108

    ]

    O .&!5( '#+%& $(3& 5($5#/,-( '# %!&%&.#$%( /&!& & '(#$,& .#$%&2 /('# +#!

    5($+"'#!&'( & 5!"&,-( '& 52(!/!(.&"$&4 #. >;94 /("+ & /&!%"! '&8 '#+(!'#$+ /+"60";\\ A0"&!4 9::Q

    E$60&$%( /(! 0. 2&'( %#.(+ & /+"5&$

    '(#$,& .#$%&24 '# .('( 60# &% ( "$&2 '& '5&'& '# +#++#$%& 5@#(0K+# &( /#!8('( 60# #2#5@&.& '# !#.#'"5&2"&,-( '& '(#$,& .#$%&24 & 5(./!##$+-( /!(/!"&.#$%# .'"5& '(+

    #$[.#$(+ /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    46/108

    ]W

    & '"!""!K+# .&"+ # .&"+ /&!& /#+60"+&+ #. /+"60"&%!"& 7"(2?"5&)− F&."2"&!#+ '# '(#$%#+ .#$%&"+4 !#0$"'(+ $& N&%"($&2 A2"&$5#

    (! %@# M#$%&22 III4 %&23# /(! +#$%"!#.K+# &%&5&'(+ /(!5($5#"%(+ /+"5( (0 +?5"(K%#!&/=0%"5(+4 &'#!#. /+"60"&%!"& 7"(2?"5& S#!/&4 >;;\ 9]:Q)

    E. +0.&

    A $#5#++"'&'# '# 0.& .&"(! (7#%"3&,-( # 60&$%""5&,-( $('(.8$"( '& /+"60"&%!"& 5(.#,& & "./(!K+# '#++& (!.&) A$#5#++"'&'# '# 5($+#0"! 5!'"%(+ '# /#+60"+& # 5($%!&%(+ 5(.+#0!&'(!&+ &2& .&"+ &2%( S#!/&4 >;;\ 9]:Q)

    F#"@$#!4 R(7"$+ # G0# &/0' P#!#!#"!&4 9:::Q /072"5&!&.4 #. >;94 0. &!%"(

    "$%"%02&'( D"&$(+%"5 5!"%#!"& (! 0+# "$ /+5@"&%! !#+#&!5@4 ($'# /!(/0+#!&. 0.&

    (/#!&5"($&2"&,-( /&!& & /#+60"+& #. /+"60"&%!"&) O+ &0%(!#+ '"+5(!!"&. +(7!# & $#5#++"'&'#

    '# 5!"%!"(+ 60# '#3#!"&. +#! #+/#5""5&'(+ '# (!.& #/285"%& /&!& & #2&7(!&,-( '&

    52&++""5&,-( /+"60";]4 %&2

    5(.( 3#!#.(+ $( 5&/8%02( 9 '#++& '"++#!%&,-()

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    47/108

    ]

    E. >;\: (" 2&$,&'& & %#!5#"!& #'",-( '( M&$0&2) O DSMKIII !#/!#+#$%(0 0. .&!5(

    $& @"+%?!"& '& /+"60"&%!"&4 /("+ (" & /!".#"!& 52&++""5&,-( 7&+#&'& #. 5!"%!"(+ '"&$?+%"5(+

    5($+"'#!&'(+ #/285"%(+ ($'# .&"+ 0.& 3#4 &++". 5(.( $( DSMKII4 (" '"%( 60# &

    5&0+&2"'&'# '( %!&$+%(!$( .#$%&2 (" '#"&'& '# 2&'(Q4 $( 60&2 #!&. '#+5!"%(+ +"$&"+ #

    +"$%(.&+ '&+ /#!%0!7&,#+ .#$%&"+) F(" %&.7. ( /!".#"!( +"+%#.& .02%"&"&2 &'(%&'(

    ("5"&2.#$%# B&$&%(4 9::]Q) T&"+ +"$&"+ # +"$%(.&+ +-( '#+5!"%(+ &%!&3+ '(+

    5(./(!%&.#$%(+ '( /&5"#$%#) E+%& #'",-( (" 5($+"'#!&'& 0. '"3"+(! '#

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    48/108

    ]\

    &/#$&+ #$%!# /&!=$%#+#+ #. &20$+ 5&+(+ # '#+&/&!#5#0 ##%"3&.#$%# & /&!%"! '( DSMKIIIKR

    2&$,&'( #. >;\; K # #. +#0 20&! +0!"!&. #. .0"%( .&"(! 60&$%"'&'#4 (0%!(+ %!&$+%(!$(+)

    S#0$'( ( 5(."%= 2"'#!&'( /(! R(7#!% S/"%#! ; APA4 >;\:Q4 60&$'( & #%"(2("& (0 (

     /!(5#++( '# &'(#5".#$%( (++#. '#+5($@#5"'(+4 & 52&++""5&,-( '( %!&$+%(!$( .#$%&2 '#3#!"&

    +#! 7&+#&'& &/#$&+ #. #$[.#$(+ (7+#!3;\:Q

    P&!& C0$@& 9::Q4 ( &%( .&"+ "./(!%&$%#4 60# &0"2"(0 ( 5!#+5".#$%( '&

    DSMKIII4 5(. & &'(,-( '# 0.& 2"$0&#. '#+5!"%"3&4 #$(.#$(2?"5&4 52&!&.#$%# &$%"K

     /+"5&$&28%"5&) O0%!&+ 5($%!"70",#+ '#++# +"+%#.& +# !##!#. &( &%( '& 0%"2"&,-( '# 0.&

    2"$0&#. '#+5!"%"3& $& (!.02&,-( '(+ 5!"%!"(+ '"&$?+%"5(+ # '( &!0/&.#$%( '#

    %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ /(! 52&++#+ APA4 >;\:4 >;\Q)

    P!(3&3#2.#$%# 0. '(+ &+/#5%(+ .&"+ "./(!%&$%#+ '( DSMKIII (" & @"#!&!60"&,-( '(+

    '"&$?+%"5(+) D"#!#$%# '( DSMKII4 $( DSMKIII 0. /&5"#$%# $-( /('"& .&"+ %#! '("+

    '"&$?+%"5(+ '# "0&2 !&3"'&'#4 & /&%(2("& 5($+"'#!&'& .&"+ !&3# /&++(0 & +#! +"%0&'&

    @"#!&!60"5&.#$%# &5".& '& /&%(2("& 5($+"'#!&'& .#$(+ !&3#) N#+%# /#!8('( 60# (" 2&$,&'( ( DSMKIII4 & .#'"5"$& #. #!&2 /&++&3& /(! &20.&+

    %!&$+(!.&,#+) A/?+ & +#0$'& 0#!!& .0$'"&24 5(.#,(0 & !#3(20,-( '& /+"5(&!.&5(2("&4

    60# %#3# 5(.( .&!5( "$"5"&2 ( %#+%# '& 52(/!(.&"$&4 ( /!".#"!( &$%"/+"5?%"5(4 5($(!.#

    &/($%&.(+4 #. >;9) P&!& &20$+ &0%(!#+ R0++( # H#$$"$4 >;;; A0"&!4 9::Q4 (

    ;

    P+"60"&%!& # /+"5&$&2"+%& $(!%# &.#!"5&$( 60# 2&!(0 & /+"5&$

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    49/108

    ];

    +0!".#$%( # & '"0+-( '& $(3& $(.#$52&%0!& /!#+#$%# $( DSMKIII 5(!!#+/($'# /&02&%"$&

    &+5#$+-( '& /+"60"&%!"& 7"(2?"5& 5(.( 3#!%#$%# '(."$&$%# $( /&$(!&.& /+"60"2&$,&.#$%( '( &$%"'#/!#++"3( P!(&54 #. >;\\ A0"&!4 9::Q)

    E$60&$%( &+ '0&+ /!".#"!&+ #'",#+ '( M&$0&2 #!&. 0+&'&+ 5(.( 5?'"(+

    &'."$"+%!&%"3(+ +#. !&$'#+ /!#%#$+#+ 5"#$%8"5&+ R0++( # V#$$5"(4 9::WQ4 & %#!5#"!&

    #'",-( 2(( +# %(!$(0 0.& !##!=$5"& .0$'"&24 60# /!(.(3#0 & 2(7&2"&,-( '& /+"60"&%!"&

    $(!%#K&.#!"5&$& '# .('( 60# @(03#4 "$520+"3#4 0.& !#(!.02&,-( $( CIDK>:4 '( 5&/8%02(

    !##!#$%# + '(#$,&+ .#$%&"+4 60# !#%(.(04 /!&%"5&.#$%# $& 8$%#!&4 & $(.#$52&%0!& '( DSMK

    IIIQ)

    P&!& P"&!!# 9::>Q O DSM /(++"7"2"%(0 60# (5(!!#++# $& /+"60"&%!"& ( .#+.(

     /!(5#++( '# &7+%!&,-( 60# /#!."%# .#'"5"$& #. #!&2 52&++""5&! # %!&%&! &+ '(#$,&+ 5(.(

    #$%"'&'#+ 0$"3#!+&"+4 %!&$+5#$'#$%#+ &( (!&$"+.( 3"3( "$'"3"'0&2 '(+ /&5"#$%#+) A '5&'& '#

    ;: (" '#52&!&'& /#2( (3#!$( '# G#(!# B0+@ 5(.( & '5&'& '( 5!#7!() E$60&$%( &

    &7(!'&#. /+"5&$&28%"5& %!&%&3& (+ 5&+(+ +"$02&!#+4 '"85#"+ '# +#!#. #$#!&2"&'(+4 5(. &

    2"$0&#. '#+5!"%"3& '( DSMKIII /&++(0 & +#! /(++83#2 #$#!&2"&!4 # %!&%&!4 5&+(+ 5(.

    &/!#+#$%&,-( '# +"$%(.&+ +#.#2@&$%#+) P&!& '#.($+%!&! ( 60&$%( (+ %#!.(+ '( DSM

     /&++&!&. & "$20#$5"&! & /+"60"&%!"& $( .0$'(4 !#2#.7!&.(+ ( +0#+%"3( %8%02( '( '5".(5($!#++( '& A++(5"&,-( M0$'"&2 '# P+"60"&%!"& !#&2"&'( #. M&'!" #. >;;W O$# (!2'4

    O$# L&$0&#)

    O+ "'#&2"&'(!#+ '( DSMKIII #+5!#3#!&.4 $( %#%( '( M&$0&24 60# %#$%&3&. +# &&+%&!

    '# 60&260#! '#7&%# '& %#(!"& #/2"5&%"3& '( %!&$+%(!$( .#$%&2) O 60# !#/!#+#$%(0 /&!& G&"$#+

    >;;9Q 0.& &/!(".&,-( '(+ .('#2(+ #%"(2?"5(+ # 7"(2?"5( '( %!&$+%(!$( .#$%&2) A

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    50/108

    :

    #2&7(!&,-( '( '"&$?+%"5( .0'(0 & "'#$%""5&,-( '(+ +"$%(.&+ %!&$+(!.&'& '# 0.&

    "$%#!/!#%&,-( '(+ +8.7(2(+ '( +(!".#$%( $0.& 2#"%0!& '(+ +"$&"+ '& '(#$,& G&"$#+4 >;;9Q)

    P&!& A0"&! 9::Q4 ( DSM (/#!& 0.& .0'&$,& !&'"5&2 $& 528$"5& /+"60";;]4 (+ 0$'(+ '# /#+60"+& '( NIMH5@#&!&. & USg W:: ."2@#+4 7#. .&"+ 60# (+ USg ;:."2@#+ '# >;W4 #4 +(7 & "$20=$5"& '( "$+%"%0%(4 ( 5($!#++((" /#!+0&'"'( & '#52&!&! (+ &$(+ >;;: 5(.( c& '5&'& '(5!#7!(c) A0"&!4 9::]4 /) ]9Q

    A/?+ 3#!""5&! &+ .0'&$,&+ 60# (5(!!#!&. $( DSMKIII4 60# %"3#!&. 5(.( ( .&"(! '#

    +#0+ &!0.#$%(+4 & (7#%"3"'&'#4 3#!""5&.(+ 60# & 2?"5& "./285"%& $#+%# 5&+( & '# 60# +#

    5($+"'#!(0 60#4 60&$%( .&"+ '#+5!"%"3(4 60&$%( .&"+ "+"(2?"5( # 0$"3#!+&24 .&"+ (7#%"3(

    +#!"& ( '"&$?+%"5(4 &&+%&$'(K+# &++". 60&"+60#! 5($+"'#!&,#+ +07#%"3&+4 60# $-( /('#!"&.

    +#! (7#%"3&.#$%# '#"$"'&+) T#!"& 5($+#0"'( ( DSM &25&$,&! #++& (7#%"3"'&'#` U.&

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    51/108

    >

    !#2#-( +(7!# (+ M&$0&"+ 2&$,&'(+ '#/("+ '( DSMKIII /('# &0'&! & !#+/($'#! & #+%&

    60#+%-()

    E. >;\; (" 2&$,&'& & !#3"+-( '( DSMKIII4 ( DSMKIIIKR4 60# .&$%#3# & .#+.&

    !&5"($&2"'&'# '( +#0 &$%#5#++(!) E$%!#%&$%( & $(,-( '# @"#!&!60"& (" &7&$'($&'&4 +#$'(

    !#%(.&'( ( 5($5#"%( '# 5(.(!7"'&'# K '#+5!"%( /(! F#"$+%#"+ >;:Q 5(.( 60&260#! #$%"'&'#

    528$"5& &'"5"($&2 60# %"3#++# #"+%"'( (0 60# /0'#++# (5(!!#! '0!&$%# ( 50!+( 528$"5( '# 0.

     /&5"#$%#4 60# %"3#++# & '(#$,& 8$'"5# #. #+%0'() O .&$0&2 /&++(0 & "$5#$%"3&! 60# .&"+ '#

    0. '"&$?+%"5( (++# #"%( /&!& 0. /&5"#$%# M&%(+4 9::Q) P(!.4 +0& /!"$5"/&2 .0'&$,& ("

    ( &7&$'($( '#"$"%"3( '( %#!.( $#0!(+#)

     N( "$85"( '(+ &$(+ >;;:4 ( DSMKIII # ( DSMKIIIKR < @&3"&. +"'( %!&'0"'(+ #. .&"+

    '# 9: "'"(.&+4 ( 60# '#.($+%!& +0& "$20=$5"& #. %('( ( .0$'() P(!.4 H"22 a F(!%#$7#!!

    >;;9Q &"!.&. 60# 0.& /&!%# '(+ /+"60"&%!&+ &.#!"5&$(+ $-( 0+& $#$@0.& '&+ '0&+ 3#!+#+

    '( M&$0&2 /("+ ( 5($+"'#!&. 0.& #%#$+-( $-( #./8!"5& '( .('#2( .'"5(4 $-( 0$"3#!+&24

     /(++08'( /#2& /+"60"&%!"& # "./02+"($&'( /#2( !##.7(2+( '# +#0!&'(!&+ '# +&1'# H"22 a

    F(!%#$7#!!4 >;;9Q)

    D("+ &$(+ &$%#+ '( 2&$,&.#$%( '( DSMKIV4 (" 5!"&'( # '"+%!"708'( /#2( !0/( '#

    %!&7&2@( #2&7(!&'(! '( M&$0&24 0. 2"3!( 5@&.&'(  &#-8 O'tions Boo9 $( 60&2 (!&.

    5(2(5&'&+ &+ /!(/(+%&+ 60# (+ .#.7!(+ '( 5(."%= #2&7(!&'(! /!#%#$'"&. "$%!('0"! $& $(3&#'",-( '( M&$0&2) P#'"0K+#4 #$%-(4 (/"$"#+ # '&'(+ & !#+/#"%( '#+%&+ /!(/(+%&+ &(+

     /+"60"&%!&+ &.#!"5&$(+ 60# ( !#5#7#!&.) T&"+ (/"$"#+ # '&'(+ 5(2#%&'(+ +#!3"!&.

     /(+%#!"(!.#$%# /&!& & #2&7(!&,-( '( %#%( '( M&$0&2)

    A 60&!%& #'",-(4 DSMKIV4 (" /072"5&'& #. >;;]4 5($%#$'( ; 5&%#(!"&+

    '"&$?+%"5&+4 '#+5!"%&+ #. \\W /

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    52/108

    9

    !#3"+-(4 # (" 2&$,&'( ( DSMKIVKTR) O DSMKIV # ( DSMKIVKTR .&$%"3#!&. & .#+.&

     /#!+/#5%"3& &7#!%& /#2( DSMKIII # 5($%"$0&'& $( DSMKIIIKR H#$$"$4 >;;\Q)

     N& "$%!('0,-( '& 60&!%& #'",-( '( M&$0&24 #$5($%!&.(+ 60# #+%# /!#%#$'# +#! 0. 0"&

     /&!& (+ 528$"5(+ # &'"5"($&2.#$%# &5"2"%&! & /#+60"+& # .#2@(!&! & 5(.0$"5&,-( #$%!# (+

    528$"5(+ # (+ /#+60"+&'(!#+4 &2. '# +#! 0.& #!!&.#$%& '# #$+"$( '& /+"5(/&%(2("& # 0.

    "$+%!0.#$%( 3"+&$'( .#2@(!&! & 5(2#%& '# '&'(+ '# "$(!.&,#+ 528$"5&+) N&+ /&2&3!&+ '(

    %#%( M&"+ '( 60# 60&260#! (0%!& $(.#$52&%0!& '# %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+4 ( DSMKIV #+%<

     7&+#&'( $& (7+#!3&,-( #./8!"5& APA4 9::: 3Q) T&2 (7+#!3&,-( #./8!"5& (" #"%&4 +#0$'(

    & APA 9:::Q4 '# %!=+ (!.&+ !#3"+-( +"+%#.

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    53/108

    ^0&$'( 0. /&5"#$%# '#+5!#3#4 /(! ##./2(4 & c&($"&c # ( .#'( '# /#!'#! ( 5($%!(2# 60#

    +#$%# &( .#+.( %#./( #. 60# +#0 5(!&,-( '"+/&!&4 60# +0&+ .-(+ "5&. #2&'&+ # #2# +0&

    !"(4 %#$%& $(.#&! +#$+&,#+ 60# /&!#5#. $-( &#! +#$%"'() A2. '( /&5"#$%#4 ( .'"5( &(

    (03"K2( ( "$%#!/!#%& %&.7. /&!& +"%0

    '"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    54/108

    ]

    9Q +#"+ (0 .&"+Q '(+ +#0"$%#+ +"$%(.&+ '#@"/#!&%"3"'&'# /#!+"+%"!&. /(! /#2( .#$(+ W .#+#+4 #.

    !&0 .&2K&'&/%&%"3( # "$5($+"+%#$%# 5(. ( $83#2 '#'#+#$3(23".#$%(H"/#!&%"3"'&'#&Q !#6Z#$%#.#$%# &"%& &+ .-(+ (0 (+ /+ (0 +# !#.##$& 5&'#"!&7Q !#6Z#$%#.#$%# &7&$'($& +0& 5&'#"!& #. +&2& '# &02&(0 (0%!&+ +"%0&,#+ $&+ 60&"+ +# #+/#!& 60# /#!.&$#,&+#$%&'(5Q !#6Z#$%#.#$%# 5(!!# (0 #+5&2& #. '#.&+"&4 #.+"%0&,#+ $&+ 60&"+ "+%( "$&/!(/!"&'( #. &'(2#+5#$%#+# &'02%(+4 /('# #+%&! 2"."%&'( & +#$+&,#+ +07#%"3&+ '#"$60"#%&,-(Q

    'Q 5(. !#6Z=$5"& %#. '""502'&'# /&!& 7!"$5&! (0 +##$3(23#! +"2#$5"(+&.#$%# #. &%"3"'&'#+ '# 2&#! #Q #+%< !#6Z#$%#.#$%# h& ."2h (0 .0"%&+ 3##+ &#5(.( +# #+%"3#++# h& %('( 3&/(!hQ !#6Z#$%#.#$%# &2& #. '#.&+"&I./02+"3"'&'#Q !#6Z#$%#.#$%# '< !#+/(+%&+ /!#5"/"%&'&+ &$%#+ '# &+ /#!0$%&+ %#!#. +"'( 5(./2#%&'&+@Q 5(. !#6Z=$5"& %#. '""502'&'# /&!& &0&!'&! +0& 3#"Q !#6Z#$%#.#$%# "$%#!!(./# (0 +# .#%# #. &++0$%(+ '#(0%!(+ /(! #)4 "$%!(.#%#K+# #. 5($3#!+&+ (0 7!"$5&'#"!&+Q

    B) A20$+ +"$%(.&+ '# @"/#!&%"3"'&'#K"./02+"3"'&'# (0'#+&%#$,-( 60# 5&0+&!&. /!#08( #+%&3&. /!#+#$%#+&$%#+ '(+ &$(+ '# "'&'#)C) A20. /!#08( 5&0+&'( /#2(+ +"$%(.&+ #+%< /!#+#$%##. '("+ (0 .&"+ 5($%#%(+ /(! #)4 $& #+5(2& e(0%!&7&2@(f # #. 5&+&Q)D) D#3# @&3#! 52&!&+ #3"'=$5"&+ '# /!#08( 52"$"5&.#$%#+"$""5&%"3( $( 0$5"($&.#$%( +(5"&24 &5&'=."5( (0(50/&5"($&2)E) O+ +"$%(.&+ $-( (5(!!#. #520+"3&.#$%# '0!&$%# (50!+( '# 0. T!&$+%(!$( I$3&+"3( '( D#+#$3(23".#$%(4E+60"(!#$"& (0 (0%!( T!&$+%(!$( P+"5?%"5( # $-( +-(.&"+ 7#. #/2"5&'(+ /(! (0%!( %!&$+%(!$( .#$%&2 /(!#)4 T!&$+%(!$( '( H0.(!4 T!&$+%(!$( '# A$+"#'&'#4T!&$+%(!$( D"++(5"&%"3( (0 0. T!&$+%(!$( '&P#!+($&2"'&'#Q)

    C(.( 5($520"! 60# 0.& 5!"&$,& 60# &/!#+#$%& &20$+ '#++#+ 5(./(!%&.#$%(+ '#3#

    !#5#7#! ( '"&$?+%"5( '# TDAH +#. !#2#%"! 60# /!#5"+( "$%#!/!#%&! #++# 5($0$%( '#

    5(./(!%&.#$%(+ /&!& &#! ( '"&$?+%"5(` T&$%( 5&7# "$%#!/!#%&,-( 60# & 60&$%"'&'# '#

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    55/108

    5!"&$,&+ &++". '"&$(+%"5&'&+ 5!#+5#$%# # '"3#!+&+ 3##+ 60&$'( &3&2"&'&+ /(! (0%!( .'"5(

    ( '"&$?+%"5( $-( 5($"!.&'() E+%&.(+ '"&$%# '# 5&+(+ '# '"&$?+%"5(+ (7#%"3(+` S#0$'(

    D#!&$'/!# 9:::Q4 d '& /(/02&,-( .0$'"&2 (" '"&$(+%"5&'& 5(. ( %!&$+%(!$() G(!'($ #

    #"+#! >;;\Q &"!.&!&. 60# &+ 5($%!(3!+"&+ +(7!# ( '"&$?+%"5( '( TDAH $&+5#. < $&

    &5# "$%#!$& '( %!&$+%(!$() P("+ (+ +"$%(.&+ 60# +-( 0+&'(+ 5(.( 5!"%!"( /&!& ( '"&$?+%"5(

    "./02+"3"'&'#4 '#+&%#$,-( # @"/#!&%"3"'&'#Q +-( 5(.0$+ $& .&"(! /&!%# '&+ /#++(&+) N( 5&+(

    '( '"&$?+%"5( '# 0. &'02%( & 60#+%-( "5& &"$'& .&"+ 5(./2"5&'&) A2. '# "$(!.&,#+

    5(2#%&'&+ 0$%( &.82"& # /#++(&+ /!?".&+ &( /&5"#$%#4 ( /&5"#$%# /!#5"+& &3&2"&! %('& & +0&

    @"+%?!"& '# 3"'&4 '#+'# & "$$5"&4 /&!& 3#!""5&! +# #$5($%!& (+ %!&,(+ '( TDAH $(+

    5(./(!%&.#$%(+ 0&!'&'(+ /#2& +0& .#.?!"&)

    O 60# 5($#!# (7#%"3"'&'# "./02+"3"'&'# (0 '#+&%#$,-(` E"+%# &20.& (!.& '#

    60&$%""5

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    56/108

    W

    CAPÍTULO II

    A4 0;'&$?&4 (.(!!"'&4 $(4 %#/%(4 '(4 DSM4

     N#+%# 5&/8%02( &/($%&!#.(+ & /&!%"! '( %#%( '( DSM 60&"+ (+ %#!.(+ 0+&'(+4 &+

    .0'&$,&+ $&+ '#"$",#+4 & 5!"&,-( # ( '#+&/&!#5".#$%( '# 5&%#(!"&+ '"&$?+%"5&+ #$%!# &+

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    57/108

    #'",#+ '( M&$0&2 60#4 #. $(++& 5($5#/,-(4 !#2#%#. &%(+ @"+%?!"5(+) A #2#",-( '&+

    5&%#(!"&+ &60" #/(+%&+ (" #"%& & /&!%"! '& 2#"%0!& "$%#!&2 '# %('(+ (+ M&$0&"+) N-(

     /!#%#$'#.(+ &60" #$5#!!&! %('&+ &+ .0'&$,&+4 # +".4 &/#$&+ '#+5!#3#! 60#2&+ 60# $(+

    '#+/#!%&!&. .&"+ &%#$,-()

    O DSMKI (" 5!"&'( #. >;94 5($%#$'( >9 /:W 5&%#(!"&+ 60# 5(./0$@&. (

    M&$0&24 ]] 5($%"$@&. ( %#!.(4 (0 +#&4 .&"+ '# ]:d '&+ 5&%#(!"&+) P(! ##./2( $&+

    +#0"$%#+ 5&%#(!"&+ :::K9: R#&,#+ E+60"(!=$"5&+ :::K;W R#&,-( /+"5?%"5&

    "$3(205"($&2 :::K>: R#&,#+ &#%"3&+ ( %#!.( #+%< /!#+#$%# #. %('(+ (+ 60&'!(+ '#

    '"+%1!7"( /+"5("+"(2?"5( &0%[$(.( # 3"+5#!&24 %&"+ 5(.( ::>K\: R#&,-( P+"5("+"(2?"5&

    C0%$#& # ::WK\: R#&,-( P+"5("+"(2?"5& G&+%!("$%#+%"$&24 '#$%!# (0%!&+)

    P(! '#"$",-( & /&2&3!& rea()o +"$""5& &%( (0 ##"%( '# !#&"! !#+/(+%& & 0.& &,-(

     /(! .#"( '# (0%!& 60# %#$'# & &$02;;9Q (7+#!3& 60# ( 0+( '#+%& /&2&3!& !#2#%# & 3"+-( '&

     /+"60"&%!"& '&60#2& /(5& '# A'(2 M##!Q4 60# 5($+"'#!&3& & '(#$,& .#$%&2 5(.( 0.&

    !#&,-( &(+ /!(72#.&+ '& 3"'& # &+ '""502'&'#+ +"%0&5"($&"+ "./"$"'&+ &(+ "$'"38'0(+)

    O7+#!3&.(+ &"$'& 60#4 #$60&$%( 0.& rea()o4 & '(#$,& .#$%&2 $-( #"+%"& '#+'# +#./!# $&

    3"'& '( "$'"38'0( '"&$(+%"5&'(4 $-( #!& &2( 7"(2?"5(4 .&+ &2( 60# +0!"0 '0!&$%# & +0&3"'& # 60# /('#!"& %#! 0. 5&!

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    58/108

    \

    O+ '"+%1!7"(+ /+"5($#0!?%"5(+ (!.&3&. 0. !0/( '# ("%( 5&%#(!"&+4 '#$%!# &+ 60&"+4 :::K

    :: R#&,-( /+"5($#0!?%"5&4 :::K: R#&,-( '# 5($3#!+-( # :::K: O0%!& !#&,-(

     /+"5($#0!?%"5&) O %#!.( .#5&$"+.( '# '##+& &/&!#5# $& '#+5!",-( '(+ '"+%1!7"(+

     /+"5($#0!?%"5(+4 5(.( 0. .#"( '# 5($%!(2&! & &$+"#'&'# 60# 5&!&5%#!8+%"5& '#+%&+

    '#+(!'#$+) N(+ %#!.(+ '& APA

    A 5&!&5%#!8+%"5& /!"$5"/&2 '#++# %!&$+%(!$( & &$+"#'&'#60#

     /('# +#! +#$%"'& '"!#%&.#$%# # #/!#++&'& (0 /('# +#!"$5($+5"#$%# # &0%(.&%"5&.#$%# 5($%!(2&'& &%!&3+ '& 0%"2"&,-('# 3 R#&,-( '# A$+"#'&'#)

    E. >;W\ (" /072"5&'( ( DSMKII4 5($%#$'( >\9 %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ #. >] /;9]4 F!#0' #+%&7#2#5#0 & $(+(!&"& /+"5&$&28%"5&'"+%"$0"$'( $#0!(+#+ &%0&"+4 $#0!(+#+4 $#0!(+#+ $&!58+"5&+ # /+"5(+#+)

    >9 T@# 5@"# 5@&!&5%#!"+%"5 ( %@#+# '"+(!'#!+ "+ h&$"#%h @"5@ .& 7# '"!#5%2 #2% &$' #/!#++#' (! @"5@.& 7# 0$5($+5"(0+2 &$' &0%(.&%"5&22 5($%!(22#' 7 %@# 0%"2"&%"($ ( 3&!"(0+ /+5@(2("5&2 '##$+#.#5@&$"+.+ '#/!#++"($4 5($3#!+"($4 '"+/2&5#.#$%4 #%5)Q) I$ 5($%!&+% %( %@(+# "%@ /+5@(+#+4 /&%"#$%+ "%@

     /+5@($#0!(%"5 '"+(!'#!+ '( $(% #@"7"% !(++ '"+%(!%"($ (! &2+""5&%"($ ( #%#!$&2 !#&2"% '#20+"($+4@&2205"$&%"($+4 "220+"($+Q &$' %@# '( $(% /!#+#$% !(++ '"+(!&$"&%"($ ( %@# /#!+($&2"%) L($"%0'"$&22"#2($Q +%0'"#+ ( "$'"3"'0&2+ "%@ +05@ '"+(!'#!+ 0+0&22 /!#+#$% #3"'#$5# ( /#!"('"5 (! 5($+%&$%

    .&2&'0+%.#$% ( 3&!"$ '#!## !(. #&!2 2"#) S/#5"&2 +%!#++ .& 7!"$ &7(0% &50%# +./%(.&%"5#/!#++"($ ( +05@ '"+(!'#!+)

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    59/108

    ;

    O %#!.( rea()o4 60# @&3"& +"'( .0"%( 0+&'( $( DSMKI4 (" /!&%"5&.#$%# &7&$'($&'(4

    &/&!#5#$'( &/#$&+ $&+ 5&%#(!"&+ '(+ '"+%1!7"(+ %!&$+"%?!"(+ (0 +"%0&5"($&"+ # '(+ '"+%1!7"(+

    '# 5(./(!%&.#$%( '& "$$5"& # '& &'(2#+5=$5"&) A+ 5&%#(!"&+ 60# &/!#+#$%&3&. ( %#!.(

    '#"&!&. '# &/!#+#$%: R#&,#+ &#%"3&+ '( DSMKI /&++&!&. & 5(!!#+/($'#! $( DSMKII + 5&%#(!"&+ 9;

    E+60"(!#$"& # 9;W T!&$+%(!$( &#%"3( .&"(!) S#0$'( G&"$#+ >;;9Q ( DSMKII4 &( !#'0"! (

    0+( '( %#!.( rea()o +# &&+%(0 '& "'"& '(+ %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ 5(.( !#&,#+ %!&$+"%?!"&+ +

    +"%0&,#+ &'3#!+&+ '& 3"'& 5(%"'"&$&)

    R0++( # V#$$5"( 9::WQ #$%#$'#. 60# & '(#$,& .#$%&2 /&++(0 & +#! 5($+"'#!&'&

    5(.( #/!#++-( 3"+83#2 '# 0.& !#&2"'&'# /+"5(2?"5& (502%& 60# '#3#!"& +#! "$%#!/!#%&'&

    '0!&$%# ( 50!+( '( '"&$?+%"5( (0 '( %!&%&.#$%() E++& (!.& '# &7(!'&! & '(#$,& .#$%&2

    !#2#%# 0.& "$20=$5"& '& /+"5&$9 5&%#(!"&+ K #$60&$%( $( DSMKI @&3"& &/#$&+ \4 K

    +#$'( & /!"$5"/&2 5&%#(!"& 0%"2"&'& $#++# M&$0&2) M0"%( .&"+ '( 60# '#+5!#3#! 0.& '(#$,&

    .#$%&24 %&2 5(.( &$0$5"& G!0#$7#! $& "$%!('0,-( '( DSMKII4 ( 0+( '( %#!.( $#0!(+# +#

    !##!# & 0. .#5&$"+.(4 0.& #+%!0%0!&) S#"+ #$%!# (+ '# .#.7!(+ '( 5(."%= '& APA

    !#+/($+

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    60/108

    W:

    DSMKII #+%& 5&%#(!"& :9 D#+3"(+ S#0&"+4 60# 5($%"$0(0 52&++""5&'& '#$%!( '( !0/(

    '"+%1!7"(+ '& /#!+($&2"'&'# # (0%!(+ '"+%1!7"(+ .#$%&"+ $-( /+"5?%"5(+4 (" '#+.#.7!&'& #.

    $(3# 5&%#(!"&+ #+/#58"5&+4 5&'& 0.& 5(. & +0& /!?/!"& '#+5!",-() ^0&"+ +#&. :

    H(.(++#0&2"'&'#4 > F#%"5@"+.(4 9 P#'("2"&4 T!&3#+%"+.(4 ] E"7"5"($"+.(4 V(0#!"+.(4

    W S&'"+.(4 M&+(60"+.(4 \ O0%!(+ '#+3"(+ +#0&"+ # ; D#+3"( S#0&2 $-( #+/#5""5&'( . A

    '#+5!",-( '(+ '#+3"(+ +#0&"+ $( DSMKI #!&

    O '"&$?+%"5( "!< #+/#5""5&! ( %"/( '# 5(./(!%&.#$%( /&%(2?"5(4 5(.( & @(.(++#0&2"'&'#4 %!&3#+%"+.(4#'("2"&4 #%"5@"+.( # +&'"+.( +#0&2 "$520"$'( #+%0/!(+4&%&60#+ +#0&"+ # .0%"2&,#+Q>APA4 >;9Q

    O7+#!3&.(+ 60# #$60&$%( $( DSMKI & @(.(++#0&2"'&'# #!& 5($+"'#!&'& 0.

    5(./(!%&.#$%( /&%(2?"5( %&2 5(.( ( #%"5@"+.( (0 ( +&'"+.( '#$%!( '# 0.& .#+.&

    5&%#(!"& '"&$?+%"5& '#+3"( +#0&2Q4 $( DSMKII 5&'& 0. '(+ 5(./(!%&.#$%(+ /&++& & +#!

    0. %!&$+%(!$( #+/#58"5(4 /&!%#)

    A (0%!& 5&%#(!"& '"&$?+%"5& 60# %&.7. 5!#+5#0 +"$""5&%"3&.#$%# $( DSMKII (" &

    '( R#%&!'( M#$%&2) E$60&$%( $( DSMKI & 5&%#(!"& D#"5"=$5"& M#$%&2 +# '"3"'"& #. '("+

    %"/(+4 & +&7#!4 :::K;: D#"5"=$5"& M#$%&2 &."2"&! (0 @#!#'"%

    M#$%&2 "'"(/: R#%&!'( M#$%&2 B(!'#!2"$#4 >> R#%&!'( M#$%&2 L#3#4 >9 R#%&!'( M#$%&2

    M('#!&'(4 > R#%&!'( M#$%&2 G!&3#4 >] R#%&!'( M#$%&2 P!(0$'( # > R#%&!'( M#$%&2

    $-( E+/#5""5&'() D#3#$'( &"$'& +#! 0%"2"&'( 0. 60&!%( '8"%( &/?+ #++&+ 5&%#(!"&+ /&!&

    >

    T@# '"&$(+"+ "22 +/#5" %@# %/# ( %@# /&%@(2("5 7#@&3"(!4 +05@ &+ @(.(+#0&2"%4 %!&$+3#+%"+.4#'(/@"2"&4 #%"+@"+.4 &$' +#0&2 +&'"+. "$520'"$ !&/#4 +#0&2 &++&02%4 .0%"2&%"($Q

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    61/108

    W>

    5(./2#.#$%&! ( '"&$?+%"5(4 +-( '# '"#!#$%#+ 5(./2#.#$%&,#+) P(! ##./2(4 ( '8"%( )9

    +"$""5& 60# ( !#%&!'( #+%< &++(5"&'( 5(. '#+(!'#. '( .#%&7(2"+.(4 5!#+5".#$%( (0

    $0%!",-( ( '8"%( ) +"$""5& 60# 0. !#%&!'( .#$%&2 5(. &$(.&2"& 5!(.(++[."5&)

    A+ 5!8%"5&+ +(!"'&+ %&$%( $( DSMKI 60&$%( $( DSMKII +# !##!"&. &( &%( '(+

    +"$%(.&+ '(+ %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ $-( +#!#. #+/#5""5&'(+ '#%&2@&'&.#$%#4 0+%&.#$%# /(!

    +#!#. '#+5!"%(+ 5(.( rea(0es .&2 &'#60&'&+ & +"%0&,#+ # /!(72#.&+ '& 3"'&) C($+"'#!&3&K+#

    60#4 &++".4 $-( @&3"& 0. 2"."&! 7#. '#.&!5&'( #$%!# ( 60# #!& 5($+"'#!&'( $(!.&2 # ( 60#

    #!& 5($+"'#!&'( /&%(2?"5() C(.( ##./2(4 /('#.(+ '#+%&5&!4 $(+ %#!.(+ '( DSMKI4 &

    '#+5!",-( '& 5&%#(!"& R#&,-( M&$8&5( D#/!#++"3&

    E+%#+ !0/(+ &/!#+#$%&. !#&,#+ /+"5?%"5&+ 60#0$'&.#$%&2.#$%# +-( .&!5&'&+ /(! +#3#!& &2%#!&,-( '#@0.(! # %#$'=$5"& & !#."++-( # !#5(!!=$5"&) V

    &205"$&,#+ # /('#. +#! &'"5"($&'(+ & &2%#!&,-( &#%"3&0$'&.#$%&2) A !#&,-( .&$8&5( '#/!#++"3& +"$[$".('( %#!.( /+"5(+# .&$8&5(K'#/!#++"3&) A !#&,-( +#!< /(+%#!"(!.#$%# 52&++""5&'& &/!(/!"&'&.#$%# #. 0. '(++#0"$%#+ %#!.(+ .&$8&5(4 '#/!#++"3( (0 (0%!(>] APA4>;9Q)

    O0 .#+.( $& '#+5!",-( '& N#0!(+# D#/!#++"3& $( DSMKII

    E+%# '"+%1!7"( .&$"#+%&'( /(! 0.& !#&,-( #5#++"3&'# '#/!#++-( '#3"'( & 0. 5($2"%( "$%#!$( (0 & 0.#3#$%( "'#$%""5 T@"+ '"+(!'#! "+ .&$"#+%#' 7 &$ #5#++"3# !#&5%"($ ( '#/!#++"($ '0# %( &$ "$%#!$&2 5($2"5% (! %( &$

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    62/108

    W9

    APA4 >;W\Q)

    A2. '# '#"&! & "./!#++-( '# 60# #++&+ '0&+ 5&%#(!"&+ /('#. +#! %#./(!

    0%"2"&. & #/!#++-( rea()o4 (7+#!3&.(+ %&.7. 0.& %#$%&%"3& '# '#+5!#3#! ( 60# 5&0+& (

    %!&$+%(!$(4 &60"2( 60# #+%&!"& /(! %!\ .#.7!(+4 '#$%!# #2#+ D($&2' 2#"$ 60# #!&

     /+"60"&%!& # /+"5(&!.&5(2("+%&4 # R(7#!% (('!0 # P&02& C2&%($ 60# %&.7. &"&.

     /&!%# '( !0/( '(+ c$#(K!/#2"$"&$(+c)

    E. >;\: (" /072"5&'( ( DSMKIII4 5($%#$'( 9W %!&$+%(!$(+ .#$%&"+ #. ];] /;;Q4 (7+#!3& 60# (

    DSMKIII (" & /!".#"!& $(+(2("& /+"60"

  • 8/15/2019 UMA REFLEXÃO CRÍTICA SOBRE AS EDIÇÕES DO MANUAL DE DIAGNÓSTICO E ESTATÍSTICA DAS PERTURBAÇÕES ME…

    63/108

    W

    #2&7(!&,-( '( '"&$?+%"5()

     N& "$%!('0,-( '( M&$0&2 (+ &0%(!#+ '#+5!#3#. & .#%('(2("& 0+&'& 5(.( &K%#?!"5&

    #. !#2&,-( &(+ /!(5#++(+ #%"(2?"5(+4 #5#%( #. 5&+(+ ($'# #++#+ /!(5#++(+ #+%-(

    #+%&7#2#5"'(+ # +-( "$5208'(+ $& /!?/!"& '#"$",-( '( %!&$+%(!$() C@&.&. &2" #++& &7(!'&#.

    '# '#+5!"%"3& 0.& 3# 60# & '#"$",-( '( %!&$+%(!$( #"%& & /&!%"! '& '#+5!",-( '# +#0+

    &+/#5%(+ 528$"5(+) P&!& '#.($+%!&! & .0'&$,& $& '#+5!",-( '(+ %!&$+%(!$(+4 '#+5!#3#.(+

    &7&"( $(+ %#!.(+ '& APA & '#+5!",-( '& 5&%#(!"& 2etardo #ental. E$60&$%( $( DSMKII

    O !#%&!'&.#$%( .#$%&2 !##!#K+# &( 0$5"($&.#$%("$%#2#5%0&2 #!&2 &7&"( '( $(!.&2 '0!&$%# ( /#!8('( '('#+#$3(23".#$%( # #+%< &++(5"&'( &2@& '& &/!#$'"&'(4&0+%# +(5"&2 (0 &.7(+) E+%&+ '#+(!'#$+ (!&. 52&++""5&'&+5(.( h+8$'!(.# 5#!#7!&2 5![$"5& 5(. '#"5"=$5"& .#$%&2h #h'#"5"=$5"& .#$%&2h $( DSMKIQ A 52&++""5&,-( '"&$?+%"5& '#!#%&!'( .#$%&2 +# !#2&5"($& &( ^I> APA4 >;W\Q)

     N( DSMKIII

    A+ 5&!&5%#!8+%"5&+ #++#$5"&"+ & #+%# '"+%1!7"( +-(>Q 0$5"($&.#$%( "$%#2#5%0&2 2(7&2 +"$""5&%"3&.#$%#"$#!"(! .'"&4 &5(./&$@&'( '#9Q '"5"%+ +"$""5&%"3(+ (0 "$5&/&5"'&'#+ $(0$5"($&.#$%( &'&/%&%"3(4 5(.Q "$85"( &$%#!"(! &(+ '#("%( &$(+)O '"&$?+%"5( #"%( "$'#/#$'#$%# '# +# 3#!""5&! (0 $-(& 5(#"+%=$5"& '# 0. '"+%1!7"( 8+"5( (0 (0%!( '"+%1!7"(.#$%&2 APA4 >;\:Q)

    T&23# & .&"+ +"$""5&%"3& .('""5&,-( $( DSMKIII (" & 60# '" !#+/#"%( &( &7&$'($(

    >   M#$%&2 !#%&!'&