revista servico publico

!"#$

$%&%'())#*+

,++-+%')

'-.!"/,

0 +-1#/2/

RSP Revisitada:3("++',#

$*441567!689:

388;6

Braslia 2015

Misso da Revista do Servio PblicoEFG'1+++1%'F1F'+*

,3,3%'

Presidente#)/)Diretor de Desenvolvimento Gerencial/2Diretor de Comunicao e Pesquisa:/)#&Diretor de Gesto Interna#+Conselho EditorialConselheiros nacionaisH"IJK+ILKIMN/JK+I-LKIMN# JI%'!'LI!MNI#JK+'LKMNI JI%'$7LI$=MNIJFOK+#P / LK#7/MN !" # $ J K+ ' LKMN / " #+ #Q J K+I) LKI)MN/)#&J,3%' L,3M/"/JK+ILKI,MN/EJK+'LKMN/) JI%'$7LI$=MN#E#JK+LKMN ##+JK+LKMN)#.JK+LKMNRSJK+ILKI,M*

Conselheiros internacionaisI J,PTEP,L,E,MNTJK+T(ULRRMN3#JK+E LK 0MN/I-)UJK+LKM*

Periodicidade)++%"%',3%'*

Comisso Editorial# U1 # +1 # # # I1 # #F /1 , I 1!#/1/-/U'1/)#&*

Expediente ,-+/)#&*, /V1/-WI*,F+I+V*###)*)+')I/'1)#)*/I*-X%'H//)*$*)+'-X##*#*L+,M

)++%*9>;Y=7,3%'*,319>;Y=*

+**N6:1:*

,E+*9>;Y)!"9>:>*+ %'12FF+SL9>>Z7688YM*

9>Y:79>Z89>>879>>;*

388;6

SumrioContents

FFF F

FF(T( 9Y9!

$%&%' (

$F\+F (( 9>:Roberto Rocha C. Pires e Alexandre de Avila Gomide

,++-+ %',T+ F 66Y"#$

'-F.+\( 6:Y%&'

0 F+- F1#R F+_F+T( F1# 6Z9&($&!

RSP Revisitada:3("++ 'F

'$% ;99

Editorial

#LMLM1

0)++%F"1%'))+1F9>Z:*0F1+%1++-+1'1(F+*

0F1%) *+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##011+. F%' F (%& F %' F * 02"2(`2&F%'1%'(+%`&.F%'*0 (%' 1 21 ( 1+11.2F%'++*

0 F1 23 ) +$# ## ,+# 41 -F .%'FS*1+%FF-+I(% % +% F* E + P'(++F1(F"1% (2+F%'%&+*

'22$521## "F*F+1(%%' =* 0 21 2 11%'+%'%' 1 ( X %& "F2++11FX.+*

0 2 F1 F #/ $ 5 #,+# 06#brasileiras1F++2F+'

'X%&P1(IRP1FREEF+b*2'1(X1 & +%'-F12'+*

0F7#0+2/$5#%+31+2.2*1F F+F1#*%(%F( . 1 S F%& X%'%'.accountability(*

8$422,+#"F %' ) )+* 0 F ( ) 9>Z:1 (1 2 F%' 1 F `(F+*0 1 1 + %' +%' (+ 1 21 (%-2F+*,"+%'H22FF+*1XS21(1F%&+1XFc+d1'F(+%'"*

*

#),

171

92%1;9%1ZZ 2.* 3 1 = + . ++ 2.%' (F+*,+11 %'++*31+=+PF1 +%& 2 ' (%'1 %'1 +%' F *X1=X+F*

&'()'("

0++19>4Z:1+%'+I`%'1X..F%'PL19>>4M*

0+F%'` %'F%&,'11*#F%'I-F1 9>ZZ1 ( + %& . %'++1*

19>>81%'(F11"F+%&2.%'+%*

!

175Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

I11%'12+'+%L16886M*

3+1 F+=%'F2F+* , 1 1 ' ( %'X"2+*

E+21F%'1F + 1+12"%'*#+L9>>>M1 GF ( X1 " F 21 +1` *+.%'+I111%'*

1 1 21 #F%' 9>ZZ (".%'F1 P #F%' " F + I %'2-F1(

P G F +L168961*9YM*

,F%'P+I'"`%'112%' ' + %' %' +I111X%'"+(F+*

g***h (F+ 2 (%' F F 2 (.1 " + %' * 1 1 "PF++-%'%&L168981*:>;M*

3 F1 + 2 F X 9>>8++%1X%'+I *, . %& F + L%' %'M1 . " ( + I F1

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01

176 Revista do Servio Pblico Braslia 66 (2) 171-194 abr/jun 2015

P & %' + F+ %&1 -+P#F%'I9>ZZL1 N1688Z11688:1168961688ZM*

E1++ (F+ 2 + I F+LF++%&M1P+`'+-1%'1F2'((L1688:N1688ZM*

L6888MX2"+(%' %'1 %' %'1 F-*,122(1+F2F+F1 X 2 F*

F "68881+ 1++F(1%&F%'H* L688:M1F %&+ . ++. +. G . +1&1X.1X-(F+11(%%'*11%'(F+( 2' ( F 1 22%'2F%'%'+I*

F=11+%'+%&(F+1P%'12+I %' + %'* , 1 + F + +++1"+1(%'1%'+%'F*

"++F(#F%'I9>ZZ21+1 S F%' 1 % F%' +

!


* 1#F%'+F%'2((F+FX1111(.1.1%FF+1*

, ' P + F%' PF1'F%'1"(F+1(%'2%'%',=*"L 1bN#168846884N N16884N1688Y6898N N$16898116898M%(12'F+12"%F%'%'FX+%'*

X1F+12"% F 1 " ++ +'+F*,++'` F%' P1 " %'%&'+%'F*,2'(E)(,19>>:*0+11F+'+L+1121Mc%'d1%&'21%'1+%X+*

,%&'+%P%'*,"9>>868881+.2F+%', %& 21 1 + F 2 + 1 1+L689;M*

1(%&%&FF"1++211&+F2%'(F+1FF1+%F%'

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


++++(%'%&*, + . F+ (F+1-FF*

!'*

\1UQL6896M.+-F'%&"'*R=%'Fc-Fd+ %& + F `%&FX%'*3+11+%''+=F+%'X1%&2 %' + %'F%&-F1X12F+%*

=2F,G1(1+* F 1 . %%'*FF"6888.+%&2.%

%& (F+1 ( %' (F+FN

1 F 2 (1+=(XN

' + 1 +1 %& '+1'%'F*

1+F*

#%'` 2'(F+1X1 + +%' %'(F+ F * b- %' +F'(F+1 F '* , . F -F1P%'(F+ ` ' +- +I*

!


+ - F 1 %+1 U L688ZM 2 - (F+ + %' (F+ 2 %' 1 cF+`'1`.F1F%'(11& %' Fd* 1 - 1F.P(.%'(&1'+-F%'(*

,+(+I1-#F%'I1'X. F1 2 X ((F+L16896M*

%+1 UL688ZM"2..%'1(GK1PF%'%&(F+1 F%' +% (1*

,%'(F+N 1 ' P ` +%' %' F %' %'*3F1"2(F+1+2'2"%' 2 (F*

+'1 UL6896M2+% F ' %& (F+ JJ1"*3F11=+%2'21(+11.1FF+1+'+*

1#LKM1.LM1%LM13#13b%'13/1*

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


1

02 + %'N N F+1 N +%' F N G%' 'N %'+ %' %'1 = +.N ( N N'(%'N.NFL1 N 16896M*

1+ /"1F++I2+%&P%&+I1(1 X1 % X F%' +1 P F%' '* = %' 1 F FFL(F+1M11* UI+L689;M112.21/"1.(%' F1 ( + (1 ' +%*

, F%'(1F+%'P -/#/$RP#1"+I*0F+` 1("111(F++X*

!-RP#F+++1 ( 1 P c 'd* $.=1 21 . P ( %'F*,+%'P%'F-P2++.+-*X%'P F%'&1 =F+1H11#3L689;M*

019>>868881+-. %' ++ (

!


* 3 .1 %LF+M+1.H1XF*#(IL6888McS %' F 1 + " ++ 1 9>>8d*

3"1+=HX*,F(&L+F+2+ F(M1(%'F2P11%&&L$N#16884M*I"+(%' ( F 1 P1.1*

F%'P(F%'%'%&1+I%++*E1=FF+1++F+P2+%&N1+IF+ F F + P X 2 PFFH1O*

=1F12+F.%'L1%&-MF+2&%&(F+XL1 1 . *MN %' L`"/"MN+'+%PXLRP#MN+'+%%'XL/#/$M*

1 - 2 %& F+ 2'L"K2%&/"M1"2++(12(+L/"RP#121%'"1(F%'"M*

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


b-"2'11+(%&N1++(%&N(F+1 ++ ( (F+N 2 ++%&1*

,+F'1X%'1.*EF+%'1FFX1 (%' ++ P1 F "12++%*

(2F+%'F2*

3P%'1'+F+F1+X((++F2F*

!'*

+1'-+ F*,F=%'*

L689;M&-F2F"=F+FJF'+1 %' %' P G "=F+ , %&+Le1689;1*Z>M*F&1&F(%'+%'* 0 +-+ L %' M((L+%'+%'M*

+%&F1 UI+L689;M& . - 2 1 %&(F+F%'N+(2'2L'M++*

3F1'-'+1+X( *R"' (++%'P(1

!


. UI+L689;M*02"+%&2.*1%'P(F-F*

0F"FFF*,F2'`1F*31(FF + F G+ (F2 +%& F'++(*

"'(

((%'F'112&,1%&'%'*

((%'1"2'2G2F(%'1"F*

#%'`+%&F12"21(1.=(F+%' (%'F1 SX +1 %' * , S + ( F+++1'*

1 1 K1 2 ( + S %'

#(. 1 % +% (%' F * %' + +1 -11*

#1 SF+K2X1F*#F+F+-11++%*

#' F L#M (PF+%'%&K1+ L M L -M*

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


#'RFL#RM(PF+%'%&K+I1+ L - M L-M*

3K1%%''FP1(2(F+'++(%'F*1K P%'(F+1=2+I' &1112&'(PF+2"++%'* 1+'*0+I+1%'F1(%&%'1.%'%'+`+*

, P (. " + (F+1 2 (. J 1 J (P %' (%'*1113#*3'"F+112FF+(.F*

3 /"1 " F " 21 1 - F 1%&+`F%''`P'*11%&2'X%F%'1(..*

3'-11%%'F%'+/"*02-"++++I1("1(%'1+21(+-"1-+X1%'1+*R=11F+`%'+I1F++%'*

3RP#1 (P%' ( F P 1 2 P F S %' 2 ++1 + "

!


++*,S"++1++I*

1 = 2 + F & % SP-2G((%'F*,S++(1%&1"S+FF%'*

!'(

(%'F"2%&('-F11'*'(2'-+++%'12'"1%'1(%'(%%'2((*

, X F 2 P %& (F+ ( %'1-P P%' 1 L(- P'XMXL%'XM*31+F++1(%'*

3 + F1 %'X2'-+%'1(++2(1-(1PF+%&1+(F+%&*

+%& F 1 =2- P F+ %&12 (F %' (F+* 3 F1 = 2 F+'(F++(1&%'%&*1%'.P211+22(XLM+(*,F11X+.+I11(((F+*

, ' F + 1 1F*

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


3 1 K 1 X-+%'%&+&S%'*1%'1%'1*

$" P/"RP#12+I1(1*%' 1 1 2 ( + (*311'SPF %'(1 *1 /"11X,F+1 (+"12+%&(*

b-2+L+(+M'++%'*11/#/$12L-MXLM'++%'*R""I12X'-+%'*

"%'%&/"12%&'%&'+1X+%(LNN1689;M*

E(1=2+%&F %'1 2 + 1%&F%'%& (* 2 F+1 '+S'` %'F1F+F%'*

#2P%'..2(%'*,2(."+1+1&%' S* # 1 %' &%'=*

Monitoramento e avaliao

(+%'%&2'+X(+*E

!


+F1+=2'++(12+-=1222.+%'L%'2(M*

E + F 1 ( +%' X + 2 (1F+P22.+%'PF*

+1=2(X%&' *1+"L%'%'M12.X+%&*

3 F1 + 1 (F+ -F1+%'%1(%%&-F*

3 X J K J1 +%' '12+S*11'(%'+2(+I2"* F +%' 2 * ,.O%'X2+-+-%&*

, F 1 2' +%'"(+F%'%&1'PJ2%&'+%&(F+*0"X-FLIN 1689;M*

11/"121-(1(1F+- 2 + (%& +2+&*

,%'(%&"(%'#L#M*,'1( %'1 -+ (%& -

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


#N ,F+1 ( + " 1 21&%&N #. /1 2 (%& F1 &*

=1(12F.(X++%'%&*0=%(1F1+X1 (%& +- %&-+%'F*

,1+%'11.(%'12+%&(H1+%'*1'%'FP* %' ` 1 ( +1% F ++* 3+ S +%'1 +2F+++%&1++F*

&,"

+F+(F1"+ FXXF*

X 2 " X %' 1 F +- ++((%'*0%&( F +1 " PF+%'*"1%&2'.%'P2%&+*b-"11(%&2%&*

K X1 ` 1 ( %'1(X2F+*

X = ( %' F%'(F+F%'

!


+*WTL6889M1"X%'F%'=1cF+S+'Od*

K2X=F%'.12(F+FF*0F+..1F(F+*,+` %'%&1` %'FF+

'1+.F%'1*

2 X + & F + I1 * #G F= F %& 1 .' %' FF%&*

%'1XFX(="F%&+++=c+` & % FdL=31 688>M1 ' %'X%&FF*

E(1"+%'12cd%&2F1+%'*

-*

.F ' F 1 + 2 F+( XF+ (F+ F P #F%'I9>ZZ*

+2`.(%$L6884M%'F12%'1+.=2F(`.*

#%'` '(1=2+.++1+

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


%'F++1%'*

%'%'+F (1 %' X + F+1 2 ` %' F%'1((%'F*

2+F+&%'1'*0+'F22%'*3'2X2+(%&-F'*#%'1=+2(+X. 1 X F (= F F+%2'+F*

0+F+='(" ' * 0 F ' -+ ( +%* & (= ` +%1XK12F2(2=%'++%*'"2 +%1 + 2 F ' F+ +%* , ' - ( %'1 2 " +* F1 (%' +%' F1&12X1+++%1*,11.+%'%'+%1X.%&1(2%'+%*0 + F ' '1 P1 X F1 (`

*

` (%1 += 2 F +2` *.'(/%'(%'+%(F+2+%2Faccountability*

!


K+2+++1+%1 %& 1 & +%1 " %'G(%'=".1++*

0+++1"%'+1"%&+%'F1.((%'+%'F*+F1 + F%' + S F+1 " %'F%'1%+%'+-++"+G`1+`2PF%'*

1+2' F * +1 +1 +

2'-2F'P.1"++

"%'`(F+%&+1F1%'F%-F'(%'*

XS+%''F%'+++1"*0F % 2 + I +%' '1 2 9>>81 +%' K' *R++I'X2 2& ` ( (F+ X* / 1 + +%' + -F F1

%',*#P=(.%'%F+,1 K'+%%'F*

, + X%' ( ,1 + "+-+(%'+%'F&%'N=G2%&2((F+1 ' %' (F+ F+*

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


0".1,

1I *#%'IF+.Ib#X+*)+F1#F1688:*1 / b R+ * ) (%'* )+* **156=>*1E*#*#(E+16896*E+U77\\\*+*77F7796*687987689;**/*E1(%'*9**)!I%'$7I16896*

* I R %' *EE0J)+#.1)!15;16898*

*/"F%'SPJI*)(F*,KI/*b6884*

*1 *+1F%&FF+%'%'`F%'*E1+*;1*:81*

!


I1#*I#F+F%'9>ZZF*RE*I%'$*'6898*I 1W*FG&(`-F-F*F1*6916888*1*/F*/F#I%'#,F*I1'688>*1 )*N 1 *N 1 /* %' (F+ F"P#F%'IZZ*,31;1688Z1+**+,* +1**P+9>>8*3+,15441*>9=98>*688;

*b1**N#1**)%'F%&++S%'XF*)+#.1+*6915481*

%)+$#,+#-#/!+#)+$##01


*1++*R%' I))*'IK3E19>>4*=3*F*%',#` EFX%'L,M,)'31688>*E+U77***7688>78Y7=F**6Y6896*1 )* 1 * 1 F FF++*,1*

*#++"*F-F=F*15916899*1#*+ #EE%'*#.#F+1+*Y15*;'6886*

* + # E E%'*#.#F+1+*Y15;1'16886*$1!"#*%+%P=F%'*#,1%'16884*$1 !" # #1 , * E++ F*, L,3M16884*1*R(,+'JF1F+F* +1 L*M*SF%'*'#16898*

U

E #. F K+ ' LKM1 (= # F P=%' F K+ I #LKI#M*#*U^*

!"#$

E %' , J (%' I%' $ LI$7M1(K+'LKMJ,1#.b1%'P=%''F*#+^*

195

Variaes setoriais em arranjos '(

"Roberto Rocha C. Pires

*+$($'#=#%#;*>:M1F"22+(*0111%&+*%'F1F+++%'%&1+L++(%'1(%'1'1%'11+%'*M1'P21XF*

Variaes setoriais em arranjos de implementao de programas federais


%' (%& %' %'(F+%' F* , +' F F %' P S*1(F ++ L1 F1 1 P' *M F%' %' %'FX*

3 2.1 &= -F+F+++I2`FF%'*I-FF+J"1FL((%MF"*"1=%'.2GF%&(-11(12%'#L#M J / #1 / $N %' ) 'INb"/NF++%'+JN3%'KN/NIN3,R", LM;*,+(%'+c+dF2+I+%'"+%F"*

X1= %' %' F1 2 LM% 2 cFd +% 2 %'F+IN LMF%&2`(--F2F21+%&*1(%=%' ( %' , S1

;1("+1(1++=+1Sc,1++ S F F F ++d*F1"1221R"2/#)#FN(E#FK+' LKM1 / ) 1 / R / I%' $LI$M ' N 2 F W1 2 E++3L3E7MJ+9*

Roberto Rocha C. Pires e Alexandre de Avila Gomide


+%%'(H1%&%&+%1 F*

4'

F""68"69. (%' ( %' %' 22,*R(%&'.+11"1(1*0+%%&J%&F.FSJ%>41*4:6M*

+%X%&%&F.21* 2 %' %'

1*96M*



XF ++ (. %' "(%&1(F1'1 + ( %' +11%' L G M1 (% + F(1 " ( +%'FG&F+L/16896M*

" %& (% 1.(F++%'L16896NN16896M*0+2((-=FF(F+1+*2%'(%&LPFM12+(%'%&1X1+++1+%'F+*11+%'%& FF1 1.F++*

L688



'("

FX%' . ( F+ F+ 2 %'+%"(1(++L1H1FM'%'FX*12'G'+%2F%'F'++F %& 2 '1%'%&e

, F %' 12X(F %' F X* 12(FX1%'+%%'* %' = & %& % F + %' 1 ++1 1 F+ %'1LM(%&'%&-*1

F%'X2'++12 ' " 2 ( %' %'1+X*E(1Fc%d2&%&+%&%&F1F-+%&F*

,%'+J(%'%'(1X1P1 PJ, %'* 3 1 -`(F+%' F ( 1F%'+Y*

1 1 + F+F%'

Y=112+GPF*31(%F(F1"122%'F*



F-F%'+IF"Z*1

= # X F L1 1 G *M2+IF

=F+(-F%'+

3%&1"PL%' " -M - F+N1%'%11+%'*

563

2& 1 - %'(-F+ E1 "1L(MF98*0(/#/$L/#/$M1%')'ILIM1Kb"/LKb/M1)+%'3+L)3M13%'KL3M1/L/M1ILIM3,R",LM*

0 9 1 F+1 LM%'- -F2+*R( 2 1 ++ F 2,HLM12FL(*N1689



G'2&J FX%'X%&%''%+%&>*

0 (FF-F+*1(FX%'-%%%'FL%'Aspectos comuns nos arranjos de implementaoM* , 1 FX (% %' 2(%2(--F*X1F#LF$+2+2AnalysisM1 2 2F+ 2 F - %& L/N)N)1689;M*

78-9,'(11

Caso :;- rea

Programa Minha Casa /$LMCMVM

% 688> F+ "X*R=FX+ I1 + %' ( " . -J#L N/N1689;M*



Caso :;- rea

Programa IL=M

# 688



Caso :;- rea

)+%'3+LRINM

F+F 6888 1 1 # F+ F P -1 %' %& *F+(

+ + X 1 2 F+%'+F %' + LNN1689;M*

Industrial

"

I,%'PL689



IX%'%'F*,'F+

+F+I1"2'FL(M%&L EM*

K 12`%1"++F+XP'(%'(%& F%' F+ F* 3 1 F + I ' 1 L1P7XM.F(*,1-%"1211(%'F%'%'*,111I1/"

%'3L/3M(1%'/"L#M##+*,131++9;(1F#',F+L#,M*

"P'%'11=%'P'%'(%&" %'* , 1 X %' P'FM.2(%&LF((+-+MNM.(1*3F1P'+(%'"+%'%'L11 1 H 1 *M* 1 F 2+(2+1H+-+1'%& F %'* 1 Kb/1 )31 I1 %' ++P'.3,,"LM1.3]L3MF/)3)+-+LM12F#/#+%'+L#/M1FHbPeF3LMI%'3LIM*

!-FP'%' '22(%'1 %' F* , %& &



G L 2 P' %' M 1 1' * 3 /1 = .(LI,JIML.E++JEM-+(%&F1F+1X+`21'*!-1=%')FI,%'XRP1-++'2X%'X*/ .1 % 1 * , F 11,1,-3E++L3E,M#,HI %' F* 1 '=+%'3Le+M1)3LR%' + %' (M1 / L F+ P -1 M* 1 #,H I %' %' F /#/$ L%' X %' +11F+%'1M1 I L%' (. X-M1 )3LX'XM*I11=%%'3E,1L=MF-*

K+++%'*,1%'I1+(%&+F%'F+F1X-* , 1 + +' +% 1 1 1 /#/$ L ++%&X-M1IKb/LP++M1LF%&++%%'XPM*,1'P+F1)313/L1%&X7F+1++HM*

K 2 " . %& + %' F* E( F11.1%'11.



11%&+ '+'LI1I1Kb/1)31/1M*$X=%312XX%'1+ 1%&FX%'#e+N/#/$12+

X F + -%'L/#/$,FM*#11 %& + ' %'F*

I1F+X%& %' ` %& P' LF1-FM10*,1F+%& P' R # K' LR#KM1 #=K'L#KM1/"1RILRIM1"#3*R(&1eF#1%'F+F ' F+ L( %'+1%'+P1%'+1.*M*,131/#/$1I1%(L'M1++(F1"&X*,1Kb/)31S(1(&-*'-F1#KR#K1'1(+LI1I1)3M1F%' F* I1 P' F%1RI/"1"+-12Kb/I1%'G++%&F*

, 1 - %' 2 c+d F 2 +. +IF"M'72

10 T %' +F%&2,F+L 16898NR16898N0+16898NIN+16898M*12F%&F1-F*



+I&(%'%'NM+%&L2F+FMNM 2 . 21(%&=+%'+%NM"1+++1'%'11%&+NMX1'+%'eP'F1-F*

2'*'(1

-F+%'F" + (%'* R= F+ 1 " * ,%'FF+122+%&'2F ++1 (*

%'%'.+-+111

9*F%'(F+LI,EM117.+F2'*2X=F2+IF+ L%'.M (%' %'1 +%& 2 `%'%'(%'*

6*`F%'L)RM1"1(F+F%'+1*,211%'7L)3IM1.(P&++L3M11F%''("L/1Kb//#/$M*

113X%'+-+=H121F+(PF#L)N)1688>M*

ClovisHLSRealce



;*#%' + L#,3R)M1 1 %' F 2' - ( -2 +L%'(%'(M*,2 = -2 P'%'F%'+%'11%'-(( " + * 3 1 F 2 # 1 1 ` P %' L##+1F1/"M*'#1IFF*

#F+FX%'+-+--FJ L0# M1 L3EKM (L3I)MJ1F"#FLcrisp-set QCAM*1FFF+%'-F((+HLM1(*

B8-1,'*

Casos#F ]

I,E )R #,3R) 0# 3I) 3EK

/#/$ 1 0 1 1 0 0I 1 0 1 1 0 0)3 0 1 1 0 1 1PBM 0 0 0 0 0 1I 0 1 1 0 1 0Pronatec 1 1 0 1 0 0PNPB 0 1 0 0 0 1Kb/ 0 0 1 0 1 0

I,%'P*

1`+-+ 3I)(+91 22F 2' ( X - (1 -1 +"*E1=+-+0# 3EK*,%'`FFF+1`+-+I,E(+9122.+F2'1-1=+N1`+-+)R(+912=2



(F+ F%' + 1 2'1-1=+N`%'#,3R)(+912=2%'F2'-(-2F+1-1=+*

KF=R12%&1(FXF%&+-+.-1videR6*

#(R61-X%&+91F+M/#/$INM*3X%'1+-+I,E#,3R)'NX%'LM1'+-+I,E)R*E1(FXF %& +-+ ` - ( L+-+ 3I)+9M1F+M)3INMKb/*0%+-+)R#,3R)1+-+#,3R)*

F - L+-+ 3EK + 9M1 (FX X%& F1 M /N M3E*31+-+-12X%'=+-+#,3R)*#1-F(X%'PLFXc#d+-+3EKM)3I*22%'+-+L)R#,3R)M1FX((L)3(X-F12I'(M9;*

BD-,'*

Variveis reas Casos

I,E )R #,3R) 0# 3I) 3EK

1 0 1 1 0 0 /#/$1I

0 1 1 0 1 C )31I

0 0 0 0 0 1 PBM

1 1 0 1 0 0 Pronatec

0 1 0 0 0 1 PNPB

0 0 1 0 1 0 Kb/

I,%'P*

12 #1 * 6899* Tosmana R ( =3 T g# h1 $ 9*;*6*8* RK+T(R*

9; )1 1 2 %' " L X%& @HM1)32I'F-(*



FXX%&1P1"1"+-+-F1-L(PPM2+-+`-F*

31=%'-F*

@'(1



= %' - P151"=(P

I,E9 0# 9

L/#/$1IM

P X %' (P+$LI9M*,P)LM*%'"X12+-++

+(H-LI,E9M*

(PXF-+=+(F+LM %'* 3 . 1 +-+ =L/#/$1IM*

=8&2G



=11%'X%&'X-L+8_+-+0# M1"=

I,E8 0# 8L)31I/3Kb/M

2 2 F ' X +=+(F+LM*,1+-+=)31I1/13Kb/*

1 = 2 F FF+ %' F - %' ` F - L( M " F%' (F+ LI9M*1I12%' + I1 %' %' F Le.g*1 %' #1*M* 1 + "1

%'* 3 /#/$1 "1 + +%' ++ * E(1 F ' ' F*"1- 21F-F"1+12%'F+F%'L1%'.F( (P %' X PMN 2 %'+L/#/$IM*

@'(1!A=0

/1 1 X%& F - (L3I)9M1=(P

I,E8#,3R)9 3I)9

L)31IKb/M

, (P 2F- ( . + (F+ %' + L%' -2 + M* , . 1 +-+ =)31IKb/*



X%&2'(X-(L3I)8M1"=1

I,E8#,3R)8)R9#,3R)8I,E9)R8#,3R)93I)8

L/3M L3M L/#/$1IM

R= (P * 3 (P 1=%'P94:

I,E9 #,3R)83I)8

L/#/$1IM L/3M

2%'F2F2'(X ( +-+ + %' LI,E9M %'+L#,3R)8M*

, 1 $ LI 6M1 %'F((F-LM.SF %' -2 . F%' (F+* R .F - ( LKb/1)3IM#11%' + P' %'(* R ( 2 %'+"-L/#/$I1-M111-F%'XF+ (F+1 %F(*

94bPXI,E9)R8#,3R)8I,E9)R9#,3R)9*



=D&2!A=0

I,%'P*

@'(1!A&>:*,1*Embedded autonomy*K+T*9>>:*I1I*N1 *#%'-F*#1*N/1*N1 *L0*M'3 +$L##N$O/Repblica.16898**4*1*N1)*Capacidades estatais e democraciaFF*1689



/1 N )1 *N )1 #* R 1 +1 F (

F+ #F+ T X 6: T* '$ +# ##Review1IT1*9=6Z1689;*/1 I* + T* +=I1 E* L0*M* J 704X?42#*0(K+T16896**6Z9=6>;*01#*+TX_+194::8=:461688>*01#*%'F,F+(*#1*N/1*N1 *L0*M'3+$L##N$O)*16898**Z:*1R*NI1W*T+FT\*+###F$K1>YL6M1*6::=6YZ19>Z6*



1,*++F* +=I1E*L0*MJ704X?42#*0(K+T16896**69:=66Y*R1 /** R # K' RP F EX#S*#1*N/1*N1 *L0*M,1F%&EJ$9)*,16898**;9:=

227

Energia e desenvolvimento 1

'(

92%1;9%1Y8 ( 1 2P* 21""9>Y81(PLZ8ML16898M*12((%'2(P-F1+%'F+(-+2`"F*2'%-F+F+`(PF+1"*

# ++1 X %&'+%'J2"FJ111'2+1F%' ( +-+ PP*

0

Energia e desenvolvimento sustentvel no Brasil em comparao internacional


#31 -F2E++/"#.RL/#RM##1X2c1 >>+/#R1#./%#L#/M1`##+*I #/ 2 1 688Z1 3 /% #L3/#M1 %'2+ ' P%& +P'((1"F=*31#029:1#1++%'1++-%'&(;419;Z1>%'`%'6868L688:M*#%'21%&1%'&,,9:6Y14:"*,1& `%'+';6>&PL#02M1688:1Z4Z*

0+-(X%'3 /%# L 596*9ZY16>688>M1>6898E5Y;>8* F%'%'`%*,689968961(-1%'17*

F 68981 E ,' ,LE,M;1 , 2 ,"F L,,M1+ /" / , L//,M1

F%' %' ` % -F*

1 ,+ ) $+1 R$ #1 9>78Z7689;* U77+***7++7=++===9>=8Z=689;==9

2 #(. L#0M " P' P S #+%' E+P L#EM1 0%' 3%& K L03KM ( ,#0=>6 J #(. 3%&K/E++L#3K/EM1)!9>>6* 2 & #0 ( * F 2 '1 #0*R='2F%'%&X9ZZ#E19ZYK',1+'F11%&.1%&'+1%&1%1+*

; 0 F+ ' "F X -(.%'+%&((*

"#$


0 451

1 1 F 21 % +-1"

' ( "1 ( ( F++-+1 P1 2 " 1 ( e+ X."FL16898M*

#%'e+1F991P1*31(21"-"+P1'.+%*

2"+-+1 -1 +1 1 "1 N +FeX=P%'F*

++1 . H = ++1 FF+ *

+F%'.FF+%-F1"="*0"211.%'%'1+-12GFF+*

E-1F-F%'*0F-+*31""F F+ F +%'1"'(,,*-%',,per capita & * 3 1 - 2 " c+ d* # 2 XF+ 1 1F2"12-,,*,+.-,,*

@6"

0(%F%&11"F(1*,(%"'F+1(*02%'=(.+'F+P+*



B8-'(6 J"DK8KL

Energia Mundo P ;6 ;Y1:#+' 6Z :1;- 69 981;3 6% 89Pb" 2% 14,1 %E+ 0% 17,5%0 11% 13,9%Total 988 988

IE++,"F/"/,L689

"#$


BH5'('(DKKQDK8D

6884 688Y 688Z 688> 2010 2011 2012P #+'+ 1 1 919 81Z 81Z 81Z 1KS 919 914 91Y 91Y 81Y 914 91:b- 91; 941> 9Y1:

0+-+ ;16 ;1< ;14 ;1>



0e+1,K1(+RY; 9*8Y8*448Brasil 6>9*:;; :ZZ*>88 :9Y*:Alemanha Z9*6:> 96;*>1('+-,K#-*,9>;>1=" ZZ< /1 21 1 1 Z8*488 / 6898* P ( %' holding ,19>461+-)&,1)'3N#(1)'3NI1)'*0(%'19>Z

"#$


688>8=9>>>8=688:FX+F%'&941



688>=6898LNN)16896M*b-221+("9>>81H' %%'++*31(2+("%'1('(+%'%1F*=X112'(+1%'F(-*21'%',,=;Z1Y688:68981("*%'2&:Y1:688:661M*

1+%+%'%'(',,1 + R :* , 2 F ( & ,,1 ( &,,-*

"#$


B^5'((455 "4-:D equivalente

8\\K DKKK DKK^ DK8KEnergia LM

9>9*:4 ;6Z*Z8Z ;>>*;86

Processos LM

:6*:;4 Y9*4Y; YY*>



41,H-per capita[3_GDK88

I/L689

RY1Z>%'*

B`-'( '([3_per capita

8\]K 8\\K DKKK DKK] DK88,K Y>

"#$


B]-'(G[3_per capita

Pas 8\]K 8\\K DKKK DKK] DK88$ 6;



B8K5*-:D3DK8D

Emisses totais em

*toneladas

DK8D

Emisses per

capita em toneladas

8\\K

Emisses per

capita em toneladas

DKKK

Emisses per

capita em toneladas

DK8K

Emisses per

capita em toneladas

DK8D,K :*688 9>14 6814 9Y14 9411Z 9616 9;

Alemanha Z98 961Y 981< >1> >1Y

K', ;*Y88 >19 Z1< Y1Z Y1*>88 619 61Z 41< Y19

/" 8 ;14 ;14 ;1> >8 9>9*:6*Y:4 9;1Y:9>>: 6;6*2000 ;89*8>4 6*8Z;*:Y8 9>*;86 9*6



" F & % + %11%*#-1-

F+1111F++Fe+F+1F*"1(%(%+X11-+*b+-&22"= 2 G % e+1 %12 & G- G * 0 - + (689912+'%P11(2FF+1F++F +-+1 ( 2 + + 2XF+(2*

B

K X " 1 -+&,,2111( %& F%'* 0 ( +P P rodoviaristas "1 "9>:8*"1-F%'+-*R9Y&,,+1X+-*

B8`5'(*455J-:D; CHP; ND:L4

DKKK DKKQ DK8K

#02 : *;6< :Z*;

#02 Y9*99: Z8*9;: >Z*>Y Y;1;: Z41YYN20

"#$


DKKK DKKQ DK8K

#02 9Y 9:1Y 9Z14CH< 4914 YZ1; >614N20 919 91< 91Y

R12#029; 6Z>*>:Z ;69*69< ;Z6*4>ZCH< ;ZZ1 :9Y1: :YY19ZN20 >14 12 9



%&1 & #06 + -1 68681 9>4 & N 21 9;9 & (P*

B8]-1'('(1*4551

CO A: COD688> 2020 688> 2020 688> 2020

#&7H7+

9Y 64 >6 >; 46 48

P++

"#$


Z12+-1;*!-68;91&'9;8/#021

ZZ1Z;9>Z4*%'X.(F*"12 % P F9>Z:1 (F9>ZY*E19>Z4+)%'#3 / L#M # %' $L+M1 Z*Y6;7>;19>>;1+%&P#1&++*

EX"9>Z81+'+2&("+1F/)3)+-+LM*, 68891 98*6>:1 2 & F 3 #+%' K ) ,1 #. 3+ ,X. ,"F L#,,M941 2 1 %&1 %'XF-2*F688:1(++*E(1

940#,,"P'F/"/,12N/"#.1R +%'N/"E++1 #",N.3,,"N.3PN+'1"1/,/,1+*



F2 + + ' + . %' X. + L4$ #K M +`(%X.+"F*K+(1++`%'(%'-* F%688>1=F2+*/'1+1 F2* !FX+=2""F2+-1-. 1 1 P %'1 ` ( P* I +2F2+`. 1 2 %' 2 %''F12%'PK',*E+(F2+-11 + +'(1 "F1%' F "F1 ( .* ,1+1` F2+*

F-2+(+&12--F"*,1,K!'1+.F"1.F*F+"222(+F(%'*

0 F X 688Z* # Fe1++(1F2` X.&1+%' * 3 688Z 68961 ( F+-O)[>&1FP+*I+(.F-F+++-+1FF/F%'/%#-F/L1689;M*

+-(cd*31"+FF&(('1'-2'+%*0(2

"#$


',, ('"(*

KF+++2(F+`+%'RP#F+$L+M1/*0"+-(%+16896*,+689;1+"X689Y*,LM ;8 + + + 689; 689Y1+.%'21"F12+'*-"%

9618ZP+"689Y1%'6899*0.&X."F . 1 2 ( - G1 F + *,%'(1#%',F2

,22'F(+"+1+I12"F.`2,-+"X%'-*0+FF2P689Y9Y*

E(1+1+(2%&12+.*+%'"2111%'2+F1'F2*

.P* , 9>>81 #' , + " %'#02P+1+-F+X X.* I 1 "1 21 F+ 1 -* E 1 #'%'F%'.19;8 #027Q968#027Q6896*0(F6869P'F->:#022H*0F+"+F+S F 1 + FF+ *

9YJ)%'5:;Y:9Z1;878



2'F-+2F'L1689

"#$


-'*,

"FF+1per capitaF+(2

%'-F',,'(2FG'F*#='F+FX%'+ +% *R'+% 2%'%'X%'%&21(1X%'%*

#21+%2F+%'&,,*12+1

-112FX*

0-+&,,1'&*1"(%&F%'*0+- F +F X. %'1 2 . P*31" +FF&(('1'-2 ' +% F * , 1+X.\0B4$*

0X"(%%'+-1"9>:8*""X(+-1-F%'+-*



0".1,

1!*N1#*#*N)1)*2H % F # T F+* ) ! K#=)!16896*1#"*,2.2', +I16886** 596*9ZY6>688>*FF3/% # L3/#M - +.* 1 688>* E+U77\\\**+*7+8;7688Y=68987688>77969ZY**681>6898*)*4519996 596*9ZY16>688>12 FF3 /% # L3/#M1 - +.* 16898*E+U77\\\**+*7+8;7688Y=6898768987E7EY;>8**6M*FX=2"=2(12 1 %' "F RP + c F+ -F cLR1688Z1*

Jos Antonio Gomes de Pinho e Maria Elisabete Pereira dos Santos


"FJF-F12%',1"+F+*

'(31gesto social

-.2XGS =+ P* , F+ %' (1 +=

%', F + %' * ,1 2 - 2X GS1 2 -F2'1+F+Q!2L6896M1 " - GS1 2F c . 2 1 F. P L ' ++12 M1 F-Hd*02c%'d1+"cPPdLN!168961*98M*

0 ( (1 ( 1 GS12RP*011+-(1 "9>>811%&%&*#%,F9>>81+(1XRPL688>M12F%',1F1 %' F ' 1 (*1RP1GS ('2+F%'1'1 J - F+1 `'"12- +12 P+LN!16896M*

0P'1RPL688ZM1IL6886M1I/L6884M1I%IL688ZM1%' ' P 1 2 F + (%' LN !1 6896M* 3 F1"X2'F2'(` F1 2 GS. No caso F 9>>81 = +F%'21

#/$5#,+#06#


1H$2-F1*

0"Q!2L6896M(2F,,L,32'M1P.+%'%'GS1688Y12+1F68981FF1



Autor N4*1# 11Y*1 10Z* 1"% 10R 9>:

I

Q!2L6896M1F,3,L688Y1688Z1688>16898168996896M*

=FX1IRP1`(+%&1(.-1I%I1+%&1 RS I1 " XF+ (.1'*3P+222XGS1.F++`'2F(P1"-F*,

cd P1 " F!"1

,3,1!1 688>1 2 ( F ` ( GS + " + 2F %& - `%'F+1SP*,FF+'GS(1F%'P*

L689;M-(%FGS1X` (RPPF(*(1%'GS `%& ( %' 2+ %' b12X+ RP1GS %&*1F2%'F+1( GS1 ` %& %'-F*,'2+2'' %& - ` %' F+1= -= J GS +% * 3F1"(%'/32X-GF1*%'1%'+11G.PP1%F211P

#/$5#,+#06#


2X++ L2"F.%&(M*#X31cF +S 2 - F G' (1 1Pd*,Fc2'P1P(%'1'-FdL31apud /1689;1*9:M*

, F1 1 P1 +=-.GS1+X*3'F++P-FFcdL ( GS M*= 1 ( 1 -F*

&.GS

$G'F%' # N # Z# #L1 #%1I RP !+- R + !1 GS * %' %& + 2 ++ ' GS1 + X . -F1F++XPPP='-F*R`%'+.1-%'2--X*

#c+%'PFF+)!J(PF+1F%'d12+cS F%' %' ++ dL$N#168961*:ZM1)!12(%'".*0F++F%'"+XcGS++d1Xc'PFF+F+dL$N#168961*:ZM*E1. 22XGS&+F*

3' 2 P F%' 1+(F*112GS"121F(



F+12cF%'++2'(d*0'+cdL$N#168961*44M*#((%&RP1X=2c''111'+-=-FdL$N#168961*4YM*1c%&'(%&P'%&P*0-P+dL$N#168961*4YM*2;8-9912(2F-(*0X2F-1c2F+-((-dL$N#168961*Y8M*

- c ' . FF+F(d L$N#168961*YYM1 1 2 c ( F%' ` %'d1 1 2 1 ( %'-9:+1cdL$N#168961*Y>M*1 2 c %' P GS em ' FF+ P1 F+ RP et al. L688ZM1 +-+ G +% ++ dL$N#168961*Z9M*#"2cFF+%'2dL$N#168961 * Z6M* 1 ' ( . -22XGSN-1PeF- 2 c F+1 F%'d F cd .*E1-1 1+&P1+22'F11c-GS++d"PL1+P1'2.MJ1+1=211(*

KF%'"!+-R+! ) ) L6896M1 F c' 1 X%- ++ 98 %' d* 3 F1 GS - e1 F11'GS1F+P=1 L=+'X%-++

#/$5#,+#06#


M*GS2F2 J =1 1 e* 0 'GS2P112+.12%&12*F'GS12X2%')#-(c X%' GS -d L !N168961*99:M*1GS1?42FGS12(%(("*

K F1 F c' ` F ++RP#3)!d1I*1R*WI*EL6896M1(+P'2GS1 F+1 P1 * 0 cF+territorial como (d'F++ " F ' 1 B$122F%'LNWNE168961*968M*0.%'RP#LR#M1'3,)*&GS1(RPLPFM1X2%&++(P+c+%'P ,1 + d LN WN E1 68961* 968M* 3 1 ( - 1 P%'PF(-F1+ 2 " 1 + I1 "++1 * 1 1 c - F=++12(%'P%'P1=F++dLN WN E1 68961 * 9



GS,` X%'/"E++-L/EM12cgesto social"(1FFF++%'++ - d LN WN E1 68961 * 9;;M1 %' -F 2 RP* -G(12cGSFG ' + %' (% SPd12+`'21+1 GS1 2 %' 1F1"G * 2 L F G (-M'X2'O+%'GSRP ( 1 1 %' ( ++2++--F,1+*'F2"2XGS12X2c%'` & P 2++. -1 F1 F- d LN WN E1 68961 * 9

#/$5#,+#06#


%'"%'F+XGS%'!F+1agirF+2c(F%'P1FF+d*R='c71%'%'d2c%F+d12+++1%'F+F1 F+ %' LN 0N E168961*949M*0'(-FX2GS2cF%' (2 . 7 . (2 .12+dLN0NE168961*9:Z=946M*

, % c %' +S12+%'21 + %&dLN0NE168961*946M*1cgh''++F=locus +1%-F'dLN0NE168961*946M*$21(21+'.+12X1++*22GS"(2X'1++*X1 (%'2 PX2cGS ++ 7d ' c F F%'1 1 %' g***hdLN0NE168961*946M*

0%F11="`X%'GS /E12"2GSc%'FF+ d LN0NE168961*94:M*/1/E2 %& *1F/E111X%'2c+++-F 12 %& PNX1"FF+2+2+ ++ (-=d LN0NE168961*94:M*

0 /E GS 2 c%' %' 1+%%'+'F (PF FF+ %' ++1 d



LN0NE168961*944M1`%'F1%1X1*K2( + /E cF%' +X%' %& ' %' F1 + F+1 dLN0NE168961*94YM*

( P1 = - 1RP#3LR#=3M+=*,1'%'%&S(++N'PPc'F%'X%'F2&dLN0NE168961*9Y>M*- (%& 1 1 % +1- +1 `%'12cdLN0NE168961*9Z8M*

,1(FX"(F%'12

- %' += c F%' d LN 0N E1 68961 * 9Z9M1 + ( & . * K - 2%c'(g***h*0+'"F%%'*I"2FdLN0NE168961*9Z9M*K('112c+'+'12+1(+g***h(+'F+dLN0NE168961*9Z6M*

02%'"F+11 . ) %FF+ 1 c S %' % " - "d* / 1 (+.c%'d1-F2c"-F+1F+`%''dLN0NE168961*9Z6M1Fc%`%'%'1X+121'-dLN0NE168961*9Z6M*=1 1 2 GS tanto /E1P'*

#/$5#,+#06#


/F112F%'c(-F d1 cF+d F &1 2 c2 & ' _dLN0NE168961*9Z;M*K"(( %' 1 1 1 c +2-+X'dLN0NE168961*9Z:M*

0R#=32c'F%' X%'1 %' %& + d* +%' 1 %& c ' "1 2 %' " Fd1 c S -Fd LN 0NE168961*9Z>M*1+=c-+S%'F+++` 2%'1(F+-F2& ' g***hd LN 0N E1 68961 *9>8M* 3 -1cdc F+ %'1 ` ( (%& F12++F+1`-F27Fd LN0NE168961 *9>8M* $X=1 1 2 1 %& P1-P*

KF(F2+.-F1" 1#!"/I #V1 F cF ++ d*0"+%'c+%1%''dLN/IN#168961*9>:M*0 ( P" (++1=RP1+c%''1FF+1 P1 F%' ` ' -F1 P1"1.=+LR19>>>MdLN / IN #1 68961 * 68:M* 0 ( - (21%&2`%' (. + I &



S1F+ %'*

#XFF'22 GS* "1 - F1 F -(12c'F`'+`%&1%'%' %' Fd LN / IN #1 68961 * 69>M* E X%'1%&*1'GS '1X122=22F+N*1P ( ` GS cd1 2 % .*22.1((%2'12-F1(S2GS*

,1=2F1(`GS12.'e*"1(F+%GS-F*2121 N P ( 7 GS '.-F*11GS 'P1$+1%'1 P 21 1 X .GS12.211++F%'GS*

&GS

%'1 %'1 GS1F 2 ` 2& F+ ` F%'1 -F (F+ \L688YM12FXS1 ' + 2X moderna1 F1F%&*3 1 X %'F-F1F-12F,(F+F+*+%F"L-.

#/$5#,+#06#


(%&689;111X%&PM1=111SF ,1 c %' 1 X ++-1d1++L1688Y1*;YM*1c-F'"(H1( %&2'(Fd*'22c%F-.2'+%'dL1688Y1*98MN'"P11121(%&1%'-1.1("+F*

1 1 ' - F%'1 2 1 21 12X+N'+X11.

+1.,*2'(1, '"%'c+%'111(2(%'2%'(+dL1688Y1*6YM*

K - 2 ' X c ++ ."%'22+'dL 1688>1 * :ZM1 2 1 2 (+*1" ( +2c1 d 2 ( , F+c' 1 enlaados * 3'+ 2 1 1 dL 1 688>1 * :ZM* 2 2 %' ('12"21 F1%&FF%'1*=11.c( F d12c-(F+dL 1688>1*48M*

0-+%F"c(%%+%'+d c (-+ +%' d1 2 ` ,L319>>Z1*69YM*3P1(=



c+1"(-Fd12++c+"++dL319>>Z1*69ZM*E c P . , . dL319>>Z1*69ZM*2,1c=%&g***h*R==1dL319>>Z1*669M*

F"1=+%*/+%'1Diretas j1% ( c d1 ( c d L1 68861 *;:M1&XN2%'++c%'1%'dL168861*;4M*E(1cF F -F=-d1+F-21 c"9>4ZZ1*1 *9M* (%' 1 2-1P=F%'c(+ d L#1 688>M* !-1 " c X1%'%'dL#1688>1*9M*,11%'X=Fc1 ,F+ H1 # 1 F 2 F + -d L#1688>1-*9M*,+F+%'+X..1(F+Sc.dL#1688>1*9M*

0 2 (%' " c `(%'`F1+22-_ ( " " e a vontadedL168891*;91(M*$2cd1

#/$5#,+#06#


c(+dc+d'(--F1F+*1c+%'%&-+%'F1+%'2%'2dL319>>Z1*69>M*$1%'1+&-F'22F%'F=+*

E 1 F+1 1 F+1 X cd c ,d L1 68891 *Y4M1 2 c( %& 1 ,-d1=.c. d1 2 2 F X c 2 %' d L1 68891*Y4M* 0 XF+ ( P-FX%'+FJFFF+2* 2 %' GS + F ( (* 3' 1 1 X ++%'"%&%'1F%'11F1(1F+F1XH1F(*, +1 ' ( %' P ++ -F GF X (%'*X11-+2(F+*

, - -F 1 +1 %' 2 + + * X1 2%'-FI "1 1 1 "2`%1`*,P1+ 2L9>Z:"M"2-FP1'2(((*122%'"1(1*%'- 1 , L1 , "M1 +- " F 9>Z81 0_E L9>ZZM.(*+X+-` F%' + -F1 2 =



%'-F*,F(11" O* , 2 = (*2 1 (%'1%'(%F%&-F1%'*12F%& -F1 ' 1 1X% %'1 +1 !F%1F*,%'11-11X!"/F1(F+?3 F L/1 6899M* 1 2 %'*

#1 1 - R-1 ++%'Rara temporum felicitas$+($2 ($ + # #1 * 0P0_EL9>>9M1%'F" FF%'1FX.- F+* 0 . .-FF1X(F.*R 2%' + F+ F=*31(1'1(=+F"P%&*1'"+21(%'F+*E1''+2(F%'-FF+1 (FP1F+1F+*

-*

, 2 + 21 ,1+ (%' ( .1 %'+%&1F*0(S F+1 F%&P * 1 F1 - c d1- * R= O1 1 FX 2 -FF+12.

#/$5#,+#06#


FJ2O22XF+1( 1 (1 1 (%&RP*$ 2 G'F'.(GS1122(GS1+P GS* , +1 ' 1 21 +& 2FGS*

12%'PGS-F+1 + 1 ( P1 2 + + L 2 "1 P1 FM* #2.FX1FF+1 (= ( L2-'M12'+-+11'1*0F+(++%11==2GS-(2%+%11+*3'%&%&122% 2" F+J21+"1F*

' X 2 F.F+1P1+- N 1 1 1 ( ' 1("11` +1LM1 11 XF%'X%'-F*F1+` 2'F2"(? )X212(LF+'PM` %'F+1.11*2.11'.'eF1FL2(+ scholar + - GSMN ' e -F 2'* K 21 +P12-2XGS'-F1%&'1,1 F +1 F & 1 +12F+%&



+1"%'LF+ + ++F MN ' 2 ++1 (1 F%' %'XFF%' ( ++1 P1 - " .*,1(1.'11 -(1 ((*

0".1,

1" *N01!")*NE1#FR*'RP#.*#1#NR1IN !1 !+- R L0*M* # B # Z# #L* ,K16896*1 *F%&*1 L0*M*1(1(* E F * ) ! #+%'16886*R%'//#1 !"/*, * !,'1 6Y 688>1 U77\\\*+**7+*I1 R* / E* 1 ++ ' %'

* I1 R* / E* L0*M* Gesto do desenvolvimento e poderes locais: P+%'*+#16886**96=;6* I1 R* / E*N /1 $* * ++ '

%' F+* I1 R* / E*N )1 *N /1 $* * Gesto do

226##/ *+,EKI1#7KI16884* *9;=

#/$5#,+#06#


/1!"*%,+#1* /F*',#16899*/1)*&0X=FF%'*',+1689;*31 / "* % ,+# " (-F,*'R19>>Z*0_E1 * R%&1 F * )1I-TN0_E1L0*M* %##1F+* '$"F19>ZZ*

*EF+Novos Estudos, '15;91*6:=>9*1!"*N1/,*Aporias em torno do conceito de gesto socialPF*)!,3E1689;* 1 N I I1 * ' -F %& + . (%'* 1!+-RN/1)"RN#1#N1#L0*M*Gesto social-F1%'*IK+-1688Z*1 * 1 $ *



1I*NW1R*NE1I*'`F++P ) !* #1 #N R1IN!*1!+-RL0*M*Gesto social=P%&* ,K16896*

!"

($,%'KI*ERegional PlanningK+ L ,M*/,%'LKM#0,=KI)!*#^**

/,

(

,%'KI*E#.K*/KI*#6Z^**

281

:F

1

9-

Monique Menezes92$,;9*ZZ1` )(,`+F%&1X%'R#K(F+%'%-*%,R#%'1" 1 F+ " + X- X.F%&+X%'*

1FF+ F X%' 1 ' " F+ X%'P'2*E+=2"+#.F1211(F(%'F+1SX*/X1- F%& 1 # F* . FX= . & F(1(+%'*F%F"1*#-F1('F+1-1-e%'*!-1. (% F1

7#0+2/$5#%+31


1P#F%'9>ZZ*X1#12" 1 F 1 F%'(%'"9>68*

2& ( ' 2 F%& X%'2,+1 F%& accountability ,F+P2"2F%&212.%&+*

F 2F1 F - + %&1%''*P%'' %' +*F+'#.F*,1%'%'(%& F%& N " S "68*32 %'1 -.F1X+F%&accountabilityO6#

-"2F+*" ( 1 ( " %& PF*0

F(-1X-12-1F*E1 (%&F1PF%&*

:'(

F+(%'X%'%'1(P'X1F%&X%'*EL688>1*6

Monique Menezes


- F+ F%& ++ F PF accountability* E F+ 1 accountability X 1 1 + 2 1 L1688YN/1688;M*

0_EL9>>>9N 1 688;M* 0 1 %&1 1 1 F%&*31%' F+,F+*%'F`N1#11(%&` &F-11`*

0 %'1 /# L9>>ZM1(=`(%'G * , 1 (%& + %& ' ' * +1+1F%&1(.*E(1LFM(2'1(.'*

7#0+2/$5#%+31


A accountability,F+1 F+!-(F1%'

+ +1 +%'*X.F+" F1 1 ++=`('*(FF'-F2F'*31F%&accountability = ( F* ,F%& + "X accountability +F* ,1 %' %' '1 '- ( 2 (% F F (% ' F 1 + 2 accountability+F'(*

E + F1 21 2((F+F%&X%'1+accountability .*,2.1

21+2%&,.+(`S*, 1 " ( +1 "2'+FL0_E19>>ZN16898M*E1F0_EL688;M1,+=2%&1+2F%&+1+(%'*

&'*,'(

# L688>M1 F%& X%' F1111.=&*0F,#F11'-X1-1+*b-112P''- + * 3 (.1 " F+ 2 ,F+* E (1 + +F"(+-F*

Monique Menezes


+%'1 1 ' F %' ` %' F+1*F" 1 %' F * # 1 F * , 1 - F +1F&*#%'1G.F%'*

3='12,K1#X%'%'"*0F'S3F0L30M+T0L0M*(%%''.'12XN%'1 *)=112-1 "F12*0"FN1F%'12P'*011X2'*3'"2 *F%'+PFP'F11+-=12X*,(%'1=P1+*X1F"%'*

, #F1 1 1 /"1$#1*R9X%'%'*

B8-

B- Auditoria Geral959='9!19946969969X(9@99/

, K1 ) K1 #-1

1 E1 #1 #H1]( 1 $1 ,1 #1/"1*

IL9>>YM*

FF1P'

'FX

7#0+2/$5#%+31


-F,F+*E1019>69F+X-. F+X%'1G.%F%&"68*

# F / L688YM1 ( F%& ( F+F-*,%'F1"(2 F1 P1 2 " - %'* SF%'` %'" 2 (F+* , F%'G F+1S2"(F+*-2F++*31%'F-(1+2'F2'(+2F+,F+*

E 1 " + + 21 " 681 +

( F%& * , + , K1 + * ,1 -2F%&F X1 % - F1%&*1F(R61-2F*

BD&

-@!

Auditor Geral B-

/' F+ ,F+1F %&* ,1 %'*

F+ ,F+1 " * , 1 %'*

,0

(%' F+* ,1F%'"

X+*

(%' F+*, (%& * +*

Monique Menezes


-@!

Auditor Geral B-

F%'com o F+

%' ' %*

%'"12 F%' %& F+ 1 + S &*

I X* -(*

R

I(* I1 ( (

/ I1 *

, " *

)I%'

)%' 1 2 (%&+*

)%' 1 2 (%& + 2` ,*! (%*

I/L688YM*

-R62"2(F+%'12 %&* 0 ( .F2`%'1+2%'+X*11%&'*0 F++,*E1 " ( F (F+ 1=22F'`%'%'1" F*

:6F

3 %'1 . " F F1 #* E 1 '+X12(

7#0+2/$5#%+31


2F*%'F' (11 "681*0 +X%'* 0 1 F1 % F "1 F + N 1 (F+ * 0 1 1 "9>1(F+1F%'F%'`%&+*,1X1#" 9>681 F%'-+%'*

R ; F . F* - - %&1+2F#1F1&F*#)#1+2'-+"1%&*#1F%'*

#%'11.SF*,FF++%F+P'1F(%&1(F`F%'*

(1 2 #) 2 R#K ex-ante veto players. , R#K 1 %&1 * !- #) (%' +' 1 2 ex-ante 1%&+*,(%&'(%& 1 2 - + .*

Monique Menezes


B H & '* ,'( J!=>Z81*ZYZ>

F:x 3'* 0SR#

K'19>>6

T0PT

#)9>4>< 9Z>8 9>6Y

Estrutura &3

#LYM*

#L>M*

/-FL9M*

!'(JLFJ

'

%#1

2`%'.

.#SE*

0"F"%'

#S

E-

*

F+L4M,F+L;M1

9+

*

,F+.L.2

M*

Mandato 01F

%'*

$ 01F

%'*

Controle

3' 3' Sim

2 $ F+1

'

F+

H1+

X 3' 21

*

*!(-1

*

7#0+2/$5#%+31


-

Poder de M*

Monique Menezes


F " %' F+ F+ ,F+ '* L688YM1 #F%' F 9Z:; cX % %' 3%'1 + +'dL,19>ZZ1*>6apud 1688Y*9;M*P%&"6819>:Z(FR#3PLR#3M1(%&"LH-MLM*

%' 1 * F%'"*#F1R#3"++1 2 ( veto player* # 1 R#3 (+ ( F(P1 accountability*

3 " 9>>81 F (1 F%' R#3 %' 3PL3M*0X+/F%'FR#31+((F+*,1F+%&2+L#1688>61*99YM*

, 9>>

7#0+2/$5#%+31


1F%'*0+F(%'.1%'+-%'X*0 F+"-+%'1..#SE1"F"%'#-F%'*2+%':8221%'1+2.F+21+%'*

# F L688YM1 % 3 F=

X%' * F%'%'%'1 1 +% F 2 (+F1 . * L1 688YM* 1X'*,12F(F+*

0"F121"F%'*,(F+ %',F+*#1-F1 F+1,F+1F%'1F2%&3(.*2'1,F+F1 1 * E (1 F %'1 ' F+1211+*

" + 1 (9>>8F."++*,%'3 3PLM1P' +*0"(%'3*F&F+*#,F+121&1+%&''11+*

,F13"P' F+ +' F%& , F*# F" 1%&'+ F+"%'L1688Y1*6;

Monique Menezes


..%' F+"+ %' 1 ( F* , + F1FL688YMH+2'2"12+F%'P'F* b- + P (. ,F+1 %'='+N1"XP'*31= 12X%'+%'*

0 X%' " F%' "12"*3Z88(-1+P'F %& F * 3' - (-12F%'X* 2 ( ` 31 %' .S2X+%(1P68%'*,((F(F%'*

0X%'"F"+F+(-1

+PL1688Y1*6

7#0+2/$5#%+31


,F+12+F*

X1"2.F2( " 9>>8 * %' P ( * 0 F 1 -1 ( . F`%'-F%'F*,'"F*-1%+F+11,F+*

0R#K'"F%'2++P1E5>44=18Y+9Z>81%' #F%' )* status F+= F+ P' # 31 F+"*#/L6898M1F##+ "681 F+*32=1X%'FF=%'*

#F%'9>;>Y1* 96

Monique Menezes


* # F L9>>YM1 F+ F+X%'e 1X%&*,1+E/1(%&.R#K1=+%'*

# X + /1 9>Z41 + #F%' I 9>ZZ1 . F((XF+*I%R#K1 1 " X1 (F+1 X. L/16898M*X%'11(1X%'2.*

EF+R#K2F1

9*F"+)1X#3N

6* -+ 1+%'N

;*1F+P1#SEI1%& -1 X1 %-1 1 F+ F+1,F+!-1F(N

81R-*

3 2 ( 1 R#K ( (-+*-2E/12'+(%'#31#F%'9>ZZ%'R#K1'-%'*, F+ %'1 ,F+1 %'*!-

7#0+2/$5#%+31


F1%'1X1"1%&P'L1688;M*31=H2$4KF30*E/TL688;M1XF1XF12F+F%&(%*

# ) I L # 5 98976888M1 R#K + +1"X%' %'X*, (-+ '1 P %'%-2'XF%&+%' internet*0R#K11P'(F%&2K'1);*,1 F 1 F 1 ' . (F+L19>>YM*3S1%'221R#K*3F1 P##+*E)PR#L689;M16*6Y+F+64EI*

"F1#F%'9>ZZ"%2`%'F+*#+##F1#3++).1"+*#1,F++I"1+1+21F1/">Z L/FM

+R#K

Augusto Nardes

2001 EI #3 PP

Dantas

689< # CN #sem

X%'F-

Walton

Rodrigues

9>>> /"

R#K

/

Ministrio

Raimundo Carreiro

688Y -=/I

CN +

Vital Rego =

689< CN PMDB

X6@Monteiro

=

688> EI/,

#()%&F

.)

CN R

Ana Arraes 2011 EI CN PSB

I,%'P*4

#3#3

5 F%'/689:*4 0 F I LI M ( 9>Z: F 688Y* , 1 I

(ELE,/M*

7#0+2/$5#%+31


E+ R #1 %' +F+12*,R#K(%'",F+1F*E(1##%'=*

3 2 ( ` %' F-1 " + + 2 F R E* ,F+`(.)=Ib2#L9>>:6886M*!-RF2%&1F+= L688;6898M11E)126899(689

Monique Menezes


R:X%&R#K6896689 212 6;19 9Auditoria :>< :61Z

44

7#0+2/$5#%+31


:*%(%FN

4* -+ (%' X% S%'*

%& R#K + P' X

->81-+ /" F+* ,1>8'"X*E1N'X*" & P !-* E / L6898M1 2 F%& X & X%'1 1FXF+*

, R#K (= P' 2*0F1 +F++11Y*#1 F+'!-1&+1(F+%&*/2P'+1!-F`&R#K1FX22'*

++1P'1%'R#K*,1-F12+"2''((*1%'R#KXX*E%'%'#/689

Monique Menezes


P19>>Z(F+"R#K*I%'E%'LXM(+-+F%'X%'F+=X.* (%&=%'+%*

F+F+R#K1688:(

X%'P'*,P+1+2(+FXF+"%'%'*0+R#K11(.+'(-+%'*3%'1+'(-1.X + F+ '1 "*31./"/,%'1`!F%LR#K1P'14M*

E+=2F 2F F%& 1 2 2 R#K ' + F+=X*312P"2%'(F+-1+2(-+'(-1212'1F+-*

" X%' 1 ' 1 2 ( X- X. F 1 2(XF+-F*0"(1+%'%'FF+*

-

0F1#1F X* 1 F S1 # )L#)M2*"(#)'+1 F+1,F+!-*,(%'1+"

2*.F2'122*

7#0+2/$5#%+31


0#%'12*!-9:681*E1%F+*

3 1 #) ( 9>6Y1 + F * ( ,F+ F+ " F+ 2 F%' F%'12* 1 P' %' . 1 %' X%* " 1 F%'2X%)F F+1 F+++PX%'1#)+*

1#)"F#2*"688:1+"P+%Y:*,688:1 568*8:8#121%'*c0#)L***M-)1+%'.21 '-.L#1688:1*9M*,

Monique Menezes


%'"XF+12%'#),F+ F+*688:1#X12+F*1#0+X9>YZ"9>>YN(2+*

F%'#impeachment*#F1#" * R (- #) ' + #N F+ -* " 1 1 # 1 +"*

0 #) " 1 + %&1 " * '2(%&*1-(%'+'12ex-anteF1 %& F+* 0 " 31 2 # %& * , ( ` #) veto player%'*#1,F+-#)112F1+P'*

(%'"%&ex-post ,F+12+*#)'+%' 4#1 1 " ' - %'1P' %&2+XX.(F+1*

(%'"-12#) %' X %' dictamenes LM*0&F%&F (-1F+2'+L/1688YM*31&P''+S%'*

X12(%'#) * , F+ F H ,* , 1 - (-1&P!-1SS*,(%'"12-1 -2" (%'e

7#0+2/$5#%+31


* 0 F+%'H(S1*

#)"(%&2'F * 1 " P' -+ %' * , (%' 1 P' ' * , %' (%& FX= P X '#)1211 (%&* ,1 (%& G 1 " ( F%'*,'1(%%'XF*,%'"2R#12(F+*%&+'2'12(4#*

G 1 += 2 #) 1 R#K1*&-F1 - spirit corpsF%'*,1#(%'2 F+12F.X%'(F+1 -2#)F+'*

X1 ' 1 2 ` (F+ %&%)1&'(F+*&R#)F+2&F+*312- %& %& 1 !-12#11%'+P'*

-(

-SF(*0P'#%&X1&1(F++F+1(X%&*!-F1+2F

Monique Menezes


F+e(F+2` X%'1+F%'3*

3 2 ( ` %' F+1 - . 2 ( %' F%' 12",F+1X%'.%&*1.1#1%'X%12'#)P'2,F+*321=-12%&1"#1&F+*

)`2'FJ_'*,'(_YJ12 2 1 %' . accountability (*0.,F+(1 F+*,(%'1.P=+S*X.F%&X%'2%&+(2+*

X1 - 2 (F+ %' + 7 ++ S "(2'*,11-FF%'+*2F!-(R#KX(XF+%'*3F1+=%&F2F%&*

0".1,

* T6>6*E+U77(**+*7(778=>>7::>Y*1 N$1(*FFTGT*#((RFT(3\FF,196*1688Y1)Q+Q*E+U77*7>4:

7#0+2/$5#%+31


1 !* 0 +F%' 3R0 %')K*)+R#K1;4198>>*1 /* 0 . F+F+%&1+X(*#

#)(E,TP1Z1688;1-**6Z=;9*

*,FXL,IM(%T.+%*)+R#K1;41598

Monique Menezes


,%'3P=%'#.LM1;:168991#1/*/1 #= * E * ' , 1 9>Y;*#%'0*0_E1*EF+T*R!(ET1+*:191*::=4>19>>*1#*((X+*0(0(K+T19>>>*1/*RT(+XF*0(0(K+T19>>>*1 I* R K F 0 ( ( */F!1+*9>1;1*;>>1688

7#0+2/$5#%+31


*)PF+6899*R#K16896**)PF+689;*R#K1689

311

RSP RevisitadaA"6

(

J0$#"32OO3O32!3O~}

, 9>Z:1 F , #U ( F+1 2 + - F * #U & ` ++&%'G+1+ %'1 F%' -F F+-*02+++%'F+-(F+ * R+1 ' + %'%'11+ + * KF= (P1#U (2+ 1 ' 2 -2+*1 (%'F+++'FX%&*'F(11+%'*,&+1(+ 1 %'*,+-(1#U2+-*,-+P112'`F+*3F+1"1"++*3%(-F*

'(

0 F ' (1 -1 =1 2' )( F+ * F+ '%'1' % 2 +

8$422,+#


-2F+ (*,(% ('"+11-121*

-=1+)(F+9>4Y*

11` +'+%'

F+1 G+1 O %'1"1++%'1-FF1F+1-*

&=P+F+")(%'+.S F1 %' 1 -1%'E1(%'2 2 %' * R+ 1 +1 ' +11 1 -F1 = ++*

8/:

/+++%'F+-XF+(%'1*%%'I*

+1211+%''%'11+%'1 1 +1 1 %'1%'1++`%'+ ,1 (%' ++H*

((1(1"1X-$)1$12FF1%'F+1+*

3(F%'++F1,+%1 F%& F1 + ++*

/+=1211%'(2(

'$%


%*1$) 9>4< ( F%' 2 $(* + +%' ,1 1%'XX1+"2%&H*/21P-F*

( ( F F F+ 1 +-1 1 F 1+*FX-=1+=)(F+9>4Y1E= *6881"

%'1"12*

R2($19>4

8$422,+#


'*I`)(%F%'12"1 -= +-1 + '+*

%'F+2F%'2F+%'`)(1211++1F1,"1111 1 2 2 -*

)( 2 % + 1 2 + ` ' 2 ++-1*,1'+1-*-+P112'`F+*31"1"+1+*

0PF2'.=+''1S"1++"21*#F+1=9>4

'$%


%&2FF%'(122%&P'(*I2 . " +* # 1 %&" 1 P 1 /" %'1 3 EF%' /%')(F+,/0)*

,'F("+%'%'*,"FF&+1+F1+"( %'* 1 ( -F%& (+ ,1 (F-PP'*

" 1 ( F- F P %'*

)1%9>Z:1I%'E++F+IK3E1,'1+-E= 5688*EF1 +'%&P)(9>4Y*

+212-1 - H1 . . 2 ++1'(%' 1 " - F+ + (%1 1 1 1 S + L 19>Z:1*>=69M2S%'*

3' - ' +- 1 ( %''1F+E= *688*01 +%' -1 1 %'%'F=-*

' " +E= 5688%X.1N"11+'"++1(%'%'%-N1%&*

/ 2 ' 21 68 1- , R(%&2'(

8$422,+#


F+ (F+02" ( 2 G . - 1P=4Z:1*9YM*

2 E= 5 688 (F+ %' %' *0 1 %' X S P 1 G F+F12+L 19>Z:1*9YM*

/ " * / F E*0,1F+2F+*

E11(" + 1 + * (S2.statusF+121/"I1 1 - * 1 +I1.1'PP%'1P2'+*

/%')(F+1P'((F+1P, 3=)1 + . +S F 3 EF%'1 + /'*

,"+.+ )( F+* 0 2 .1 "* F%'1 ' ( %'1 .1 2 X'==*

0 + " ' EX 3U *,-'P12 1" 1 1 (F+1+`+-+*

"'+1X'+-++H1=O1 -2F+*E

'$%


'2'=-+1 X.X-,*

0 " X -F1P-+'(-*-.HN(%2F-+++*

3 %' X= + += %'1 (1 1 2. F- +* P 2 (%' %' ( *, ++P1+*

/'*3211= (. . %'F+1 2 - 2F+ %' %' 2 & L 19>Z:1*9ZM*

(+%'EX3U%'1e2(F*

#(R1X%'+E++,H:

F2(1+1F2(.F1+*E 1 + .' 2++H1=2FF+ + F 1 2 + FN +-1 + X =1=&-F*

2%(211&=2X%&+ ( F+ %' ++H*,"F+-*

b-2 +* '2F+'1F+211"*K%'(1+1'2'( (2- (*E(

8$422,+#


12-((12X2%'%'(*

(%' 1 %' %&+ 1 + " ++*+F( 1 F+ 2%'XLE39>441*$1$$

M*

# /=#( . )1+12F-*R++2+*

***3'-%'*3-2*E ( 2 ' * 0 2 - ' F H 2 +- 2%'***,+%+(*,X2/1E*12+(_,11222+*,X+2-_***3P19>4

'$%


K"eR`+X+)(1F`*

) ( - E= 5 6881 + IK3E1 *** !b - " P=1 2"%&(*E(+1=%'K'1+% 1 +1 + 2F+1 %&F+%'211''"F*

%'""+"+1 1 #* (1 1 F+1 E ( --F-+++*31-F2(1

%X.HN

(1.(,/N

0(FN

%'%*

,('+%&1'+=+1=F+.FL 19>Z:*9Z=9>M*

H/("

R1)(F++(%(%-2F+1F+1%'1X.X-*,12"1X*

0(F+F+.=1P(1%%&EE1%&%&,/1(F%&F++1FS1P'*

E PF1 " 2 (%' %'I*E22(1F+(%-=1%'F*

8$422,+#


0 + %1 1"2&F11(112'12 %&,+X*

+%'&1'1 1 1 X F ( F+1 2 (%' %' *P-+(F2111%&+1.*

0(+1+(-=11" (F+ %'* , '1 1 1F1"X*

(% FX ( %' F+1=. ` ' "* , ("-12+"2*

,1("F111"*3%&1F-2-F1212%' 1 " XF+* %1 2+1"2'-*

1X1 ( & %' &1-+X&%'%X1X* +1 += %' 1 ( 1 & 1 2 1(%1.*

,+%''+"%'F+*/'(+%&P1 ( % H*

premissas1F+'+(F+1++=*E('=F+1=

'$%


)("(%(%&,21('F%&F-%'1'11X1=1(1F-X*

%' I1 )(1 ' (1*

2+#F%'I%'1%'.++F+%&1(%'1%'2 + %' %' I ' - XF+'(X.1X-(F+%&,/*

0-"11)(I*, " 21 1 ' - %& + 1 F+"%'F+*

R(+2'12+)(*

%' )( F+ -+1(+*

- +1 1 %' 2 (% %& 2+121FS1F12.X=X-*

('"22."12FF-11F%&+1P'*

R=111."F(.==12"(-=*

2 E+1X%'(%&,1+F-S1+'-FFF+2+*

8$422,+#


&)(F+-(*#+ 2 2 &*

+ F1 -+F2)(`+#F%'1F=1%'%'%&I1,/1.1FF` ((1(F%'+++%&N"1+'%'FF+*

+ 1 ' + =L(%&M=%'%&E N +'%&2&%'I1=*

/21+12'#+K'*'(112-FF=F+*#1"11X%'11''F(+1X%'(%'12"*

02&1++,1-X1-2-%'F2(,*

+(1=2'-%'F+(*31%=1+%)(9>4Y1F-2*.268-F-F1'P+'111 %'X%'F*

3F+111 X ` + )(* 3' " 2' " * , + * 0 X- %'F+,'-++F%'- 1 2 F1 1 +H=X*

'$%


+=11()(*22''""'F+*,"F+*,'-*b- F + 1 P 1 1 F1 - 1 XX F F+ 3+ )* / X%''-1+((-+*

0 X%' %' +%' +12`%'E1-%' * $ %' -+%'%'E"'O2%'1212FF+%',1+F*

I1+%&%'X1"-=X-F1=%F+(%'(1G,1+"-F1 F*R+1 ' +1 2& 2+1"%'1"+(+(*#' 12+1E= 5688

3 +' F( E1 + - %' %' G -1 + + (F%' %' F+1 ' + %'1 = + +%' F%'P

( XF+*b1 X%' %' =11)+%';8*

3 - (1 %' -F F+X'"F1-+-FX%'*3,/12(H F & " X1 F('(-F*

+1%'XE= 5688%&+1(+%'*

8$422,+#


0 1 1 (- + E+1G*

%' + -F1 1 11 %' -1 - 2 S(*K+(%'++P*)F=F+F*L 19>Z:1*68=69M*

P/>"

%'-F2112%'F++)(1*

FF+%*E%XF+H*,(%O1+%',X11+2"F"G*%'F+"(+%'*

0 + 1 %&1 + F * R 2 2 " %' 2 +%& 1 (1 ( 2 (+*/1F+1(-F%1e*,%&1FXF+"%&+122`%'%'2F*

b-11S(+(%'F2%'F112-FF+L19>Z:*:4=:YM*,+.

2F"12%'(F+F(si et in quantum11%'%'*

#=1 1 X =- e %'P+111X.-%&+1P%&-1==-2%' %'+*

'$%


(%& P 1 *

K (2 -+ X. %' -F + " %' (%'+1 P -F %' (=%'*/-1O2F%*

)2+F+(F+1FS1%&(%*,(1F+%'%'P+%'1 2 ( 1 = + X 1 1 %' F*

E " + )( -F F+%&-,*

#-1)(1P21"%'1++('-F%'F+,*''F%'F+*

1 "1 2 %' + + F+F'`%',1+1F%' 1 X%' "1P*

K+XX%'1+FF+1+%' , ' -N 1 1 X F+S*=%' F+1X1P'*R+112FX"2%'%' %' -* R ,1+P%&*

+)(+F+1+"%'1

F+12'F+'21a posteriori1+12"F1-F*

/ %'1 ( '

(++"X*, "1

8$422,+#


+1%'112(FF+1+P*3+)1F +1' F+ (-F %' + F %&*

+ )(1 2 X1 ' F +' 1 1 + %'S F+1 (%' ++ F+1 (%'1F*

#"+*/'2*

K + +' (1 111X-F%'*

3-(-E= 56881+EK3E1) L9>Z:1 * ::=Z6M + ' %' %'1(F+%''*3*

E -F FF+1 %'1 X%' ( 1+1+%'1(+1G(1+(%'&*

F +1 F F%'e'1` %' " ( +"

-1 ( %' ,1 + %& *, ' %' I L M+1 ( 1 +F111+*

,F+FFX%' %' ( F N FX%' 1 +%& F1 %& .N (%' 1 + %' F1 ( 1 F 1 2 XF+1P1%'%'2*

'$%


#2.1+%'F11 (1 =+*#"+*

EX-%'FF+%'F+++1)(1 F1 * + +FX%&"XF+ %' - + 21 F (1"+(=%'11SX1(X*

,+"F+(1FX%'F+1F1-F %' 21 ' F ((1F . ` %' * 0 1((1X1+X2("+P%'1FS*

)L9>Z:1*46=4

8$422,+#


%'11+%'F%&(F-N

%'1FF+1G&1(%&-+(N

a 4#1FX%'%'X-1+`-F*,1-"1F-*F+1%'N."N%'%'N2N

a # +$#1 %& )( (% F%&* 0 X -2%&" L%'M P F 2 X%' F12"2(2&F++F+F'F%'*

a negociao de rede1 +" 2 )( F+1 +" 1+'PG 1+1"-F +.-F+*

,X1=+'F++)(*#+'F12`%&1*

P/8/@"

E11"++2(%%'-+-F--%'*

b-112)(-1++*

!"#$"!'(##!##)*#

R="(F1'((F+%&.++*

+ 2 )( +% %' 1 = 1 .* #+

'$%


F-,/1SX%'P1+12.+F+*

+-#!/#!6

,3+)*)(11+- = %'1 = +1211

%' +1 (. (%&11++*R=%' %' %& (* , F+1 FF+1(F+,/F(%&(*E F+ 1 %'' "1 * X , / ' 1 1 ( F++1+%&*

%' +1 %' %&+("%' (12(%&*

%' +1 %& P'%'EF%'1-*32)(1%'1%&1+2FX%'*

%' %' F+ (1 2. 1 +" . E++)P'1%'K'*

%'(%',1+.*

" K' %'+,/1S%'+*b1,P%'+%-+F %' +" F + (*

8$422,+#


%& 1 1 %&

%& P ,N (* 3' " O 2 (% %'%'IP1+-+1FXP-2F+X*

EF+)(= 1" (FX%' %& 1 2 1++%'(11"%'*

P/D/(

" )( 9>4Y + F+ 2 ` ( . %'* #=1 +(1 F+* E %'1+(X%'( 21 HSP'1*3'"2(.%'"." X%' (%& 1 + F '1 (+P' %'F+*,F1P''1X=`%'%'*

P/H/,+F+)(*!FX1 2 ( ' 1(%' & 1 %' P' F '"2+'=++%')(*

# + (-1F%'holdings*

P/P/ 0 %' 1 " F+ 1 + ( 1 1,I%'1+11%' )(* E F + 3%'1 F%' . %' + -F1+GF%'X1-2%'F1

'$%


1'`+'*

P/^/ I1 %& ,F+ F+ !-1 1 F+1 2 1 F+1F*0P'%&!-'1+1 1 +1 (1 ( 2 `.%'X%'*/112%&(+)(*

31%')(1 +1 +' X (1 ' FF2'*

^/-*

0 - 2 ' P + +-1 " ` P %' 1 ` ' * # P %' -F %' %'+%',(+*

= + X%1 F (%'11(%-2F+*

+ " 2 -2 -F %'* b- " 1 ( +% F+%N 1 %' % . +%'N * 1 '(+1+ ( 2X1 + *"+12F+1+%*1 1 F F +%-*

#(%'1&F+(*+%1(F%''

8$422,+#


F1F-1=-%',1112*

=11+'.*2" ( F H + +%N1211F%'1'-%''+268*

,'%'%'F-F+*%'=+%&*

' %1 (1 2 ( %&*

F%'+=F%' + * 3' '1 +1 2'"-111&%'*2&%&1+(1*R=F+2FF+1F11

F%'P'F21=F=%'F+1+%'"* "1 P2*

)( ' 1 P1 22 %&FF+1(=+"1%'F*

F+1"-F%'%'P%'*

F%&(F+1-2F1FF1"(F+)(21P1-FX12`XF+*

'$%


0".1,

E 31 * ++ H* '7,EK*9>44*96Y*

* / ++ . ***, 37)*Z:**::=Z:LER1

335

A

)++%L)M",*"111,1F'*

,%689

336

~@58:;(?;@D:?F;=@:@?H@IKL

0 + F 2 " ' + I1 2 2'2 ( - + I ( * ,S G& , =1 2 * 1 2 + . = ( + 2 = 1 1 -+ ( = F 1 ' * 9 ~

0 # F+ 2 , 3 %'L,M1++F%'(%&,+1+X ( " %' ( F%&*%'+1 1 2. " +*

0 !~ 5 ~ ~

0 ++ )P

F ,1 %' LM%'1PNLM%' P1 - 2 o #? %' F+ %' %' %' ,N LM %' P1 F12(%'11F 1 *N L+M %' ' P1 %'21+P1"+%'1+%'+%'PNXL+M%&12X("'(%'F.F+,*

2%&,1+ \\\**+*

337

C~~2P1+='+"(

+*

37F%'

#I7#3!

,%

# KI #,

R( I

,=

0>Y)[Z188

-5

Z > 10 11 12 9; 9< 15 94 9Y9Z 9> 20 21 22 6; 6< 25 64 6Y6Z 6> ;8 ;9 ;6 ;;;< ;: ;4 ;Y;Z ;>

338

=

02%&,'=`, -= ( #1 ( e %& %*0(

9*3. #%P+%R

31.948Y=9#9Y8*:88=Z1(#I#3!F%'PFX991K99

revista servico publico

Documents