Transcript
Page 1: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

11R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

Ciências Jurídico-Criminais da Faculdade de Direito da Universidade de Lisboa.

Page 2: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 12

Page 3: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

13R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

2 BOUZON, 1986: 126.

Page 4: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 14

3 ARISTÓTELES, 1991: 56.4 BUSATO, 2009: 156.5 CARAMELO, 2001: 51.

Page 5: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

15R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

6 CARAMELO, 2001: p. 45. 7 Ibidem, p. 51.8 ZAFFARONI, 1965: 330.9 SILVA, 2011: 76.10 ZAFFARONI, 1965: 330.11 Ibidem, p. 331.

Page 6: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 16

12 ZAFFARONI, 1965: p. 331.13 CARRARA, 2002: 236-247.14 Ibidem, p. 55.15 Ibidem, p. 236-247.16 Ibidem, p. 236-247.17 Ibidem, p. 236-247.18 Ibidem, p. 236-247.

Page 7: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

17R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

19 SILVA, 2011: 76.20 ZAFFARONI, 1965: 345.21 BERTI, 2010: 438. 22 LANDECHO VELASCO; MOLINA BLÁZQUEZ, 2013: 367.23 SILVA, 2011: 90.24 BUSATO, 2009: 152.

Page 8: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 18

25 BALBINO, 2015: 30.26 Ibidem, p. 30.27 Ibidem, p. 23. 28 ROXIN, 2008: 850.

Page 9: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

19R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

29 HRUSCHKA, 2005: 27. 30 BALBINO, 2015: 24.31 Ibidem, p. 24.32 BUSATO, 2009: 154.33 Ibidem, p. 154.34 BALBINO, 2015: 24.35 BUSATO, 2009: 154.

Page 10: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 20

36373839

Page 11: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

21R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

404142 43 4445

Page 12: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 22

46474849

Page 13: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

23R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

5051525354

Page 14: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 24

55 5657585960

Page 15: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

25R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

616263646566

Page 16: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 26

67686970

Page 17: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

27R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

71 RAMOS; BERTOLOTE, 1997: 240. 72 CORDEIRO, 2011: 322.73 CROCE, 2012: 135.74 CORDEIRO, 2011: 314.75 Centro de Informações sobre Saúde e Álcool (CISA). Disponível em: <http://cisa.org.br/artigo/4010/-que-alcoolis-mo.php>. Acesso em: 5 ago. 2015.

Page 18: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 28

7677787980

Page 19: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

29R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

8182838485

Page 20: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 30

8687 SANTOS, 1968: 33. 88 Ibidem, p. 34. 8990919293

Page 21: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

31R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

949596979899100101102 CORDEIRO, 2011: 328.

Page 22: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 32

103 CROCE, 2012: 141.104 CORDEIRO, 2011: 323. 105 CROCE, 2012: 142. 106 CORDEIRO, 2011: 323. 107 WOELFERT, 2003: 140.

Page 23: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

33R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

108 CORDEIRO, 2011: 324. 109 WOELFERT, 2003: 140. 110 CORDEIRO, 2011: 324. 111 WOELFERT, 2003: 140. 112 LOPES SAIZ; CODON, 1951: 263.113 CROCE, 2012: 142. 114 CORDEIRO, 2011: 325.

Page 24: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 34

115116117118119120121

Page 25: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

35R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

122 CORREIA, 2015: 331.123 SANTOS, 1968: 35. 124 Ibidem, p. 35.125 ALMEIDA, 2003: 109.126127128129

Page 26: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 36

130131132133

Page 27: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

37R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

134135136137

Page 28: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 38

138139

140 MASSON, 2012: 467.

Page 29: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

39R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

141 BITENCOURT, 2009: 93.142143144145

Page 30: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 40

146 BITENCOURT, 2009: 94. 147 MASSON, 2012: 467. 148 BALBINO, 2015: 93.149 MASSON, 2012: 468.

Page 31: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

41R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

150 NEVES, 2003: 136.151152 GARCIA, 2010: 535.153 ZAFFARONI; PIERANGELI, 2011: 465.

Page 32: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 42

154 CARVALHO, 1999: 1108. 155 BRITO, 1991: 21.

Page 33: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

43R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

156 CARVALHO, 1999: 1108. 157 Ibidem. p. 1108. 158 Ibidem, p. 1110.159 BRITO, 1991: 157. 160 GARCIA; CASTELA RIO, 2014: 1108.

Page 34: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 44

161 CARVALHO, 1999: 1112. 162 Ibidem, p. 1112.163 NEVES, 2003: 143. 164 Ibidem, 2003: 144. 165 BRITO, 1991: 8. 166 CARVALHO, 2008: 477.

Page 35: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

45R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

167 ALBUQUERQUE, 2008: 1152.

Page 36: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 46

Page 37: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

47R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017

Page 38: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017 48

Page 39: $ (PEULDJXH] $OFRyOLFD H D 7HRULD GD $FWLR /LEHUD … · olehud lq fdxvd ,qlpsxwdelolgdgh 5hvsrqvdelolgdgh shqdo $%675$&7 7kh sxqlvkphqw iru loolflw dfwv frpplwwhg e\ lqwr ... 3 aristÓteles,

49R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 20, n. 79, p. 11 - 49, Maio/Agosto 2017


Top Related