aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

345
.'"/+," ,W( ).%( .% +*."--.+ .+'",&( )+(+& )[,+.YW( & +*."--.+ .+'",&( %." ..,-( (', BD9:A6<:B IG>9>B:CH>DC6A 8DBD 6<:CI: CD :CH>CD 6EG:C9>O6<:B C6H 9>H8>EA>C6H >CIGD9JIoG>6H 9: EGD?:ID 9: 6GFJ>I:IJG6 ,fD )6JAD #JC=D 9:

Upload: vuxuyen

Post on 08-Jan-2017

234 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P+

.'"/�+,"��������,W(�)�.%(

���.%���������+*."-�-.+����.+��'",&(

)+( +�&�����)[, +��.�YW(��&��+*."-�-.+����.+��'",&(

%�.�"���. .,-(��(',���

��BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�8DBD�6<:CI:CD�:CH>CD��6EG:C9>O6<:B�C6H�9>H8>EA>C6H>CIGD9JIoG>6H�9:�EGD?:ID�9:�6GFJ>I:IJG6

,fD�)6JAD

#JC=D 9:��� �

Page 2: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P++

%�.�"���. .,-(��(',���

��BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�8DBD�6<:CI:CD�:CH>CD��6EG:C9>O6<:B�C6H�9>H8>EA>C6H>CIGD9JIoG>6H�9:�EGD?:ID�9:�6GFJ>I:IJG6

-:H:�6EG:H:CI696�6 �68JA969:�9:

�GFJ>I:IJG6 :�.G76C>HBD�96

.C>K:GH>969:�9:�,fD�)6JAD E6G6

D7I:ChfD�9D�IlIJAD�9:�9DJIDG�:B

�GFJ>I:IJG6

UG:6�9:�8DC8:CIG6hfD�

)GD?:ID�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6

(G>:CI69DG��)GD;��G

+6;6:A��CIpC>D�96��JC=6�):GGDC:

,fD�)6JAD

#JC=D 9:��� �

Page 3: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P+++

�.-(+"3(���+�)+(�.YW(����"/.% �YW( -(-�%�(.�)�+�"�%���,-�-+���%!(��)(+

*.�%*.�+�&�"(��('/�'�"('�%�(.��%�-+\'"�(�)�+��"',�����,-.�(���)�,*.",��

��,���*.���"-�������('-�S

E-MAIL: [email protected]

�DCH:86�� A6J8>6 �J<JHID

�� BD9:A6<:B� IG>9>B:CH>DC6A� 8DBD� 6<:CI:� CD� :CH>CD�6EG:C9>O6<:B� C6H� 9>H8>EA>C6H� >CIGD9JIoG>6H� 9:� EGD?:ID� 9:� 6GFJ>I:IJG6� A6J8>6��J<JHID��DCH:86 v ,fD�)6JAD���� �

� � E��>A

-:H:���DJIDG69D� v UG:6�9:��DC8:CIG6hfD��)GD?:ID�9:

�GFJ>I:IJG6� v ��.�.,)

(G>:CI69DG��+6;6:A��CIpC>D�96��JC=6�):GGDC:

����GFJ>I:IJG6��+:EG:H:CI6hfD�����������GFJ>I:IJG6��&D9:ADH�

��&6FJ:I:���)GD?:ID�9:�6GFJ>I:IJG6���HIJ9D�:�:CH>CD���"�-lIJAD

��.����� ��

����B

Page 4: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P+7

'DB:���(',���� A6J8>6��J<JHID

-lIJAD� ��BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�8DBD�6<:CI:CD�:CH>CD��6EG:C9>O6<:B�C6H�9>H8>EA>C6H>CIGD9JIoG>6H�9:�EGD?:ID�9:�6GFJ>I:IJG6

-:H:� 6EG:H:CI696� `� �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :

.G76C>HBD� 96� .C>K:GH>969:� 9:� ,fD� )6JAD� E6G6� 6

D7I:ChfD�9D�IlIJAD�9:��DJIDG�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6

�EGDK69D :B�

�6C86��M6B>C69DG6

)GD;��G�+6;6:A�):GGDC: ��.�.,)

#JA<6B:CID� �HH>C6IJG6�

)GD;��G #DfD��6GADH�9:�(A>K:>G6��:H6G ��.�.,)

#JA<6B:CID� �HH>C6IJG6�

)GD;6��G6 �>7:AA>�-6G6AA> ��.�.,)

#JA<6B:CID� �HH>C6IJG6�

)GD;��G�#DG<:��6EI>HI6 9:��O:K:9D ��.�.��

#JA<6B:CID� �HH>C6IJG6�

)GD;��G !6GDA9D� 6AAD �+-�,�)%U,-"��,�.'"��&)

#JA<6B:CID� �HH>C6IJG6�

Page 5: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P7

)6>H

�A;G:9D��'>9:H�:�'6>G

Page 6: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P7+

�<G69:8>B:CIDH

��D�EGD;��G�+6;6:A�):GGDC:��E:A6�DG>:CI6hfD�A>KG:�:�H6<6O�FJ:�>BEJAH>DCDJ�D

EGD8:HHD�>CK:HI><6I>KD�96�E:HFJ>H6

�C6�%J8>6�,6CIDH�9L><:H�3688JG

�FJ>E:�9:�EGD;:HHDG:H�).��+>D

Page 7: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P7++

CDC�=6�>A�B><A>DG:�6GI>HI6�>A�8DC8:IID8=:�JC�7AD88D�9>�B6GBD�CDC�H>�A6KDG6

8DA�H<J6G9D���B6�HDAI6CID�H>�6GG>K66�FJ:AAD�8DC�A6�B6CD�8=:�J7>9>H8:�>A�>CI:A:IID

&>8=:A6C<:AD��HDC:ID� � �� ���

Page 8: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P7+++

y��9>HEDH>hfD�9DH�K6ADG:H�IbI:>H�:B

8DCH:FJkC8>6�9:�JB�9:H:?D�9:

:MEG:HHfD�G:HJAI6�:B�JB�CDKD�K6ADG

:MEG:HH>KD��96�B:HB6�B6C:>G6�FJ:

8DG:H�DJ�HDCH� FJ6C9D�9>HEDHIDH�:B

JB6�6HHD8>6hfD�8DCH8>:CI:��HfD

IG6CH;DGB69DH�:B�6A<D�8DB H:CI>9D��:B

JB�DG<6C>HBD�9D�FJ6A�>GG69>6�6�;DGh6

FJ:�j�86E6O�9:�EGDKD86G�JB CDKD

H:CI>B:CID�K>I6Az

%bHOAo�&D=DAN'6<N

Page 9: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P+8

�!#��

�(',����� A6J8>6��J<JHID��.0()-&*).�53+(+.)/4+0/&-�'0.0�&*)/5)�/0�)/4+/0�

&13)/(+9&*).�/&4�(+4'+1-+/&4�+/530(65F3+&4�()�130,)50�()�&326+5)563&��� � � � ;

-:H:� ��DJIDG69D� v �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� .G76C>HBD�� .C>K:GH>969:� 9:� ,fD

)6JAD��,fD�)6JAD���� �

�HI6� I:H:� IG6I6� 9: :M6B>C6G� D� ;6IDG� :HE68>6A�� :A:B:CID� 7bH>8D� 96� 6GFJ>I:IJG6�

>CK:HI><6G�DH� 6IG>7JIDH�:HE:8l;>8DH�� E:C:IG6G�CD� >BEDGI6CI:� 86BED�96� 8DBEDH>hfD

IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�� EGDEG>6B:CI:� 6GFJ>I:IpC>86� : 96� :H8DA=6� 9DH� 8DCI:t9DH� FJ:

;><JG6B�CD�:CH>CD�6EG:C9>O6<:B�9:� >CIGD9JhfD�`� 8DC8:EhfD�6GFJ>I:IpC>86�� I:C9D

8DBD� dB7>ID� :BElG>8D� 6� EGDEDHI6� B:ID9DAo<>86� 96� 9>H8>EA>C6� >CIGD9JIoG>6� 9:

EGD?:ID� 9:� 6GFJ>I:IJG6�B>C>HIG696� CD� EG>B:>GD� E:GlD9D� 9D� 8JGHD� 9:� 6GFJ>I:IJG6� :

JG76C>HBD� 96� ).�� +>D� �� 6EGDM>B6hfD� EGDEDHI6� E6G6� IG676A=6G� D� I:B6� 96

BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�;lH>86�j�G:6A>O696�EDG�B:>D�9:�9J6H�K>6H�E6G6A:A6H�'JB6

9:A6H��6�E6GI>G�96�9:;>C>hfD�9:�BD9:ADH�:�B6FJ:I:H� H:�E:G8DGG:�JB�:HIJ9D�68:G86

9:� HJ6� JI>A>O6hfD� 8DBD� 67DG96<:B� 9D� 8DC=:8>B:CID�� BjID9D� :� EGD8:HHD� 96

8DC8:EhfD� 6GFJ>I:IpC>86�� IG6O:C9D� JB� G6HIG:6B:CID� B>CJ8>DHD� :� 67G6C<:CI:� 9D

I:B6��CFJ6CID�6�DJIG6�K>6�H:�6EG:H:CI6�D�IG676A=D�:BElG>8D v H:B�EG:I:CHq:H�9:

76A>O6G�9:;>C>I>K6B:CI:�DH�H67:G:H�tC>8DH v 9:�8DCI:t9DH�9:�6EG:C9>O6<:B�IG6O>9DH

:B�9>;:G:CI:H�:M:G8l8>DH�9>9bI>8DH�EGDEDHIDH�C6 9>H8>EA>C6�9:�>CIGD9JhfD�6D�EGD?:ID

6GFJ>I:IpC>8D�G:6A>O696�CD�EG>B:>GD�H:B:HIG: 9D�8JGHD

)6A6KG6H8=6K:��BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A��B6FJ:I:��:CH>CD�6EG:C9>O6<:B 9:

6GFJ>I:IJG6��:CH>CD�9:�EGD?:ID��B:ID9DAD<>6�9D�EGD?:ID

Page 10: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P8

��!" ��"

�(',����� A6J8>6 �J<JHID��.0()-&*).�53+(+.)/4+0/&-�'0.0�&*)/5)�/0�)/4+/0�

&13)/(+9&*).�/&4�(+4'+1-+/&4�+/530(65F3+&4�()�130,)50�()�&326+5)563&��� � � � ;

-:H:� ��DJIDG69D� v �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� .G76C>HBD�� .C>K:GH>969:� 9:� ,fD

)6JAD��,fD�)6JAD���� �

-=>H� I=:H>H� H::@H� ID� :M6B>C:� I=:� HE6I>6A� ;68IDG�� 6� 76H>8� 6G8=>I:8IJG6A� :A:B:CI�� ID

>CK:HI><6I:� >IH� HE:8>;>8� 6IIG>7JI:H�� ID� :CI:G� I=:� >BEDGI6CI� ;>:A9� D;� HE6I>6A

8DBEDH>I>DC�� EGDE:GAN� 6G8=>I:8IDC>8�� 6C9� I=:� ;>:A9� D;� H:A:8I>DC� D;� 8DCI:CIH� I=6I

6EE:6G� >C� I=:� I:68=>C<�A:6GC>C<�D;� >CIGD9J8I>DC� ID� 6G8=>I:8IDC>8� 8DC8:EI>DC��JH>C<

6H�:BE>G>86A� ;G6B:LDG@� I=:�B:I=D9DAD<>86A� EGDEDH6A�D;� I=:� 8A6HH� y"CIGD9J8I>DC� ID

�G8=>I:8IDC>8� )GD?:8Iz�� I6J<=I� >C� I=:� ;>GHI� I:GB� D;� I=:� 8DJGH:� D;� �G8=>I:8IJG:� 6C9

.G76C>HB�D;�).�+>D�-=:�HJ<<:HI:9�6EEGD68=�ID�LDG@�I=:�I=:B:�D;�E=NH>86A�I=G::

9>B:CH>DC6A� BD9:A>C<� >H� G:6A>O:9� >C� ILD� E6G6AA:A� L6NH� "C� I=:� ;>GHI�� ;GDB� I=:

9:;>C>I>DC�D;�BD9:AH�6C9�B>C>6IJG:H��L:�HDJ<=I�ID�B6@:�6�HIJ9N�67DJI�>IH�JH:�6H�6C

6EEGD68=� ID� I=:� @CDLA:9<:�� B:I=D9� 6C9� EGD8:HH� D;� 6G8=>I:8IDC>8� 8DC8:EI>DC�

7G>C<>C<� ;DGI=� 6� B>CJI:� 6C9� :C8DBE6HH>C<� B6EE>C<� D;� I=:� I=:B:� (C� I=:� DI=:G

=6C9��>C�I=:�H:8DC9�L6N��L:�HDJ<=I v L>I=�CD�>CI:CI>DC�D;�9:;>C>I:AN�HJEEDGI>C<�I=:

>9:6�D;�HDA>I6GN�@CDLA:9<:H v ID�>CIGD9J8:�I=:�:BE>G>86A�LDG@>C<�D; 8A6HH�B6I:G>6AH

EGDEDH:9� >C� 9>;;:G:CI� 9>968I>8� :M:G8>H:H� G:6A>O:9� >C� I=:� 8A6HH� y"CIGD9J8I>DC� ID

�G8=>I:8IDC>8�)GD?:8Iz��I6J<=I�>C�I=:�;>GHI�I:GB

$:NLDG9� 9>B:CH>DC6A�BD9:A>C<� BD9:AH��B>C>6IJG:H� I:68=>C<�A:6GC>C<

6G8=>I:8IJG:� 6G8=>I:8IDC>8 EGD?:8I

Page 11: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P8+

�!#��

�(',����� A6J8>6��J<JHID��.0()-&*).�53+(+.)/4+0/&-�'0.0�&*)/5)�/0�)/4+/0�

&13)/(+9&*).�/&4�(+4'+1-+/&4�+/530(65F3+&4�()�130,)50�()�&326+5)563&��� � � � ;

-:H:� ��DJIDG69D� v �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� .G76C>HBD�� .C>K:GH>969:� 9:� ,fD

)6JAD��,fD�)6JAD���� �

�:II: I=iH:� 6� Ax>CI:CI>DC 9x:M6B>C:G� A:� ;68I:JG� HE6I>6A�� JC� 9:H� jAjB:CIH� A:H� EAJH

;DC96B:CI6AH� 9:� Ax6G8=>I:8IJG:�� jIJ9>:GH:H 6IIG>7JIH HEj8>;>FJ:H�� EjCjIG:G 96CH

Ax>BEDGI6CI 9DB6>C:� 9:� A6� 8DBEDH>I>DC� HE6I>6A:�� 6G8=>I:8IDC>FJ:� :� 9J� 8=D>M� 9:H

8DCI:CJH� FJ>� ;DGB:CI Ax:CH:><C:B:CI� :I Ax6EEG:CI>HH6<:� 9:� >CIGD9J8I>DC� `� A6

8DC8:EI>DC� 6G8=>I:8IDC>FJ: (C� 6� JI>A>Hj� EDJG� 8:IjIJ9:� A6� EGDEDH>I>DC

BjI=D9DAD<>FJ:� 9:� A6� 9>H8>EA>C:� 9x>CIGD9J8I>DC� 6J� EGD?:I9x6G8=>I:8IJG:�

:CH:><Cj:96CH�A:�EG:B>:G�H:B:HIG:�9J�8DJGH9x6G8=>I:8IJG:�:I�JG76C>HB:�9:�A6�).�

+>D� %x6EEGD8=:EGDEDHj:�EDJG� IG6K6>AA:G� A:� HJ?:I�9J�BD9:A6<:�:C� IGD>H�9>B:CH>DCH

E=NH>FJ:H� :HIGj6A>Hj:� E6G� 9:JM8=:B>CHE6G6AAiA:H�J� EG:B>:G�� `� E6GI>G� 9:� A6

9j;>C>I>DC�9:�BD9iA:H�:I�B6FJ:II:H��CDJH�:HH6NDCH�JC�jIJ9:HJG HDC�JI>A>H6I>DC�EDJG

JB� HDC96<:� 9:� A6� 8DCC6>HH6C8:�� A6� BjI=D9:� :I� A:� EGD8iH� 9:� A6� 8DC8:EI>DC

6G8=>I:8IDC>FJ:�� :C� 6EEDGI6CI� JC� 9j86AFJ:B>CJI>:JM� :I� K6HI:� 9J� I=iB:� %:

9:JM>iB:8=:B>C��9:�Ax6JIG:8DIj��H:�EGjH:CI:8DBB:�JC�IG6K6>A�:BE>G>FJ: v H6CH�A6

EG:I:CH>DC 9:� HJEEDGI:G� 9:;>C>I>K:B:CI� A:H� H6KD>GHJC>FJ:H v 9:H� 8DCI:CJH� 9:

Ax6EEG:CI>HH6<: 6EEDGIjH� E6G� 9>;;jG:CIH :M:G8>8:H 9>968I>FJ:H EGDEDHjH 96CH� A6

9>H8>EA>C:�9x>CIGD9J8I>DC�6J�EGD?:I 6G8=>I:8IDC>FJ: G:6A>Hj:�6J�EG:B>:G�H:B:HIG:�9J

8DJGH

&DIH8AjH�� BD9:A6<: IG>9>B:CH>DCC:A�� B6FJ:II:�� :CH:><C:B:CI�6EEG:CI>HH6<:

9x6G8=>I:8IJG:��:CH:><C:B:CI�9:�EGD?:I��BjI=D9DAD<>:�9:�EGD?:I

Page 12: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P8++

��!"���� ���# �!

�><JG6 �� ��6JIDG6�8DB�JB�6CD�9:�>969:�6D�;JC9D�:D�7G>CFJ:9D�9:�BDCI6G�)(%2 �

�><JG6 ��� #D<DH�>C;6CI>H �GJ:<=:A � ��� ������E>CIDG�;A6B:C<D

+:C6H8:CI>HI6��M:BEA>;>86hfD�9:����7G>C869:>G6H�>C;6CI>H �

�><JG6 ��� �G>6Ch6H�7G>C86C9D�8DB�DHHDH��,:76HI>fD�,6A<69D �

�><JG6���� (�G>8D�B6G6?b�9:�#D9=EJG�7G>C86 8DB�JB6�B>C>6IJG6�9:�86H6 �

�><JG6���� �G>CFJ:9D�9:�BDCI6G�:B�E6E:A��6�6JIDG6�6DH� ��6CDH

9:�>969:�8DB H:J�E6> �

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�:A67DG696H�EDG�8G>6Ch6H�8DB�86>M6�9:�H6E6ID�

ODC6�GJG6A�:�ODC6�JG76C6 �

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:�:A67DG696�EDG�JC>K:GH>IbG>DH�8DB�86>M6�9:

H6E6ID�E6G6�G:EG:H:CI6G�JB �%�*� �

�><JG6 ��� )GD8:HHD�96�BD9:A6<:B�:B�86>M6�9:�H6E6ID�E6G6

EDI:C8>6A>O6G�D�:CI:C9>B:CID�9D�9:H:C=D�6GFJ>I:IpC>8D �

�><JG6���� %NCC:��A>76CD;;w�:CI:G�!6AAx� 6AA:GN�#D:������ �

�><JG6�� � !DJH:�D;�06I:G �������&>8=6:A���&8&>AA:C��E6GI:�9:�HJ6>CHI6A6hfD��+:9�G:7DFJ:�&DI:A��CD�&JH:J�9:�(6@A6C9�4�� 5 ��

�><JG6 � &�*.�-� v )G6h6�9DH�&JH:JH�96�.C>K:GH>969:�9:

,fD�)6JAD�)6JAD�&:C9:H�96�+D8=6������ ��

�><JG6 � � &(��%( v )G6h6�9DH�&JH:JH�96�.C>K:GH>969:�9:�,fD

)6JAD�)6JAD�&:C9:H�96�+D8=6������ ��

�><JG6 � � &�'��,����+(�!� :�6�&(��%� �& v )G6h6�9DH�&JH:JH�96

.C>K:GH>969:�9:�,fD�)6JAD�)6JAD�&:C9:H�96�+D8=6������ ��

�><JG6 � � &(��%� �&�����( "-�%v )G6h6�9DH�&JH:JH�96�.C>K:GH>969:

9:�,fD�)6JAD�)6JAD�&:C9:H�96�+D8=6������ ��

�><JG6�� � &D9:AD�H:88>DC69D��):I:G��>H:CB6C��&JH:J�9:�!>HIoG>6

'6IJG6A��'DK6�"DGFJ:�� ��� ��

�><JG6�� � )A6I6;DGB6�9D�EGD8:HHD�8G>6I>KD���" ��-DGG:�%:<D��DE:C=6<:C ��

�><JG6�� � &D9:AD�9:�:HIJ9D�:B�EDA>JG:I6CD���" ��-DGG:�%:<D��DE:C=6<:C ��

�><JG6 � � &D9:AD�;>C6A�8DB�E:h6H�9:�%� (���" ��-DGG:�%:<D��DE:C=6<:C ��

Page 13: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P8+++

�><JG6 � � )GD8:HHD�EGD?:IJ6A�:�B6FJ:I: �G8=>I:8IJG:��6GB��-6>L6C�

�@>=>H6�!>G6I6 ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD�9:��G6C@� :=GN��06AI��>HC:N��DC8:GI�!6AA

�>CI:G>DG 96�H6A6�9:�8DC8:GIDH��� �����%DH��C<:A:H ��

�><JG6��� &D9:AD�9:��G6C@� :=GN��06AI��>HC:N��DC8:GI�!6AA

�>CI:G>DG�96�H6A6�9:�8DC8:GIDH E6A8D��� �����%DH��C<:A:H ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD�>CK:HI><6I>KD�9D�&JH:J�9:��GI:��DCI:BEDGdC:6

9:�'>I:Go>�(H86G�'>:B:N:G ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�>CK:HI><6I>KD�96��6H6�96H��6CD6H�(H86G�'>:B:N:G ��

�><JG6 ��� �CID>C:�)G:9D8@�BD9:A6C9D�:B�H:J�:H8G>IoG>D ��

�><JG6 ��� �CID>C:�)G:9D8@�BD9:A6C9D�9:CIGD�9:�JB�6K>fD�:B���� ��

�><JG6 ��� �A:M6C9:G��GD9H@N�(�E:CtAI>BD�9>6�9:�)DBEj>6� >CHI6A6hfD

-JGCD;;�)D>CIH�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� �A:M6C9:G��GD9H@N�:�"AN6�.I@>C��JDBD�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� ( ��� $ *%(��>CHIGJB:CID�9:�%:DC��6II>HI6��A7:GI> ��

�><JG6 ��� �G6C@� :=GN�IG676A=6�:B�JB�BD9:AD�E6G6�JB�CDKD�:9>;l8>D�

�����D�;JC9D�JB�BD9:AD�:B�DJIG6�:H86A6 �

�><JG6 ��� �G6C@� :=GN�&6FJ:I:�9D�>CI:G>DG�96��>HC:N�!6AA �

�><JG6 �� &D9:AD�9:�JB6�86H6�:<lE8>6�:C8DCIG696�:B�JB�ItBJAD

�8:G86�9:�� ���6�� ��

�><JG6 ��� )A686�9:��GDCO: ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�9:��6E>I:A�:B�;DGB6�9:�EA6CI6�9D�E:GlD9D

)IDADB6>8D v +DB6CD��<>ID��� ���6� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�9:�-:BEAD��8:G86�����6��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�9:�I:GG68DI6�B:HDEDIdB>6��8:G86������6���

&JH:J��<lE8>D���6A>;oGC>6 ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�9:�JB�ItBJAD�:B��A�BG6���<>ID�):GlD9D

EGj9>CbHI>8D�I6G9>D���8:G86�9:������6�����G>I>H=�&JH:JB ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�:B�I:GG68DI6���<>ID� �R�9>C6HI>6 �8:G86� ����6���

&JH:J��G>IdC>8D ��

�><JG6��� &D9:ADH�FJ:�BDHIG6B�D�8DI>9>6CD�9DH�BDG69DG:H���<>ID��&JH:J

�<lE8>D�9:�-JG>B ��

Page 14: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P8+7

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�H6A6�!>EoHI>A6��-:BEAD�9:�UBDC+b��8� ����6�� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�<G:<D�:B�I:GG68DI6 -:BEAD�9:�!:G6�:B��G<DH������6��

�I:C6H��&JH:J�'68>DC6A�9:��GFJ:DAD<>6 ��

�><JG6 �� &6FJ:I:�9D�-:BEAD�9:�/:HI6��->KDA>���8����6��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:�9D�"CI:G>DG�9D�)6CI:fD��+DB6� � v �� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD��=6KlC�9:�!JbCI6G�� ����6����&JH:J�'68>DC6A�9:

�=6KlC� ):GJ ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD 96�)G6h6��:G>BDC>6A�� �� ����9��

&JH:J�&�%"��%>B6��):GJ ��

�><JG6 ��� -6E:h6G>6 !DB:CH�IG6CHEDGI6C9D D�BD9:AD � ��� �

�><JG6���� )6E6��:A>M�"/��&DH6>8D�C6�"<G:?6�9:�,fD��DHB:�:��6B>fD�

+DB6������� ��

�><JG6 ��� �>HED��:A>H>JH��"<G:?6�9:�,6C />I6A:��+6K:C6��"IbA>6�������� ��

�><JG6 ��� �>HED��J;G6H>6CD���6H>A>86��J;G6H>6C6��)6G:8���GDb8>6�8���� ��

�><JG6 ��� )6E6�):A6<>JH�""��"<G:?6�9:�,6C�%DG:COD��>DG>�A:�&JG6��+>B6���� ��

�><JG6 ��� �:6ID��6GIDAD�%DC<D�6EG:H:CI6�6D�)6E6�%:fD�1"""�6�B6FJ:I:�9D

,6CIJbG>D�9:�)DBEj>6 ,6CIJbG>D�9:�'DHH6�,:C=DG6�9D�+DHbG>D�9:

)DBEj>6 ��

�><JG6 �� &6FJ:I: �769>6�9:�,6CI6��j���DCFJ:H���G6Ch6��8� ��� ���

&D9:AD�9D�IG6CH:EID�:�86BE6CbG>D ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I: �6I:9G6A�9:�'DIG:�6B:�9:�)6G>H ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�9D I>7tG>D��E6G6�6 �6I:9G6A�9:�&>AfD ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD��6K6AD�,;DGO6��BD9:AD�:B�7GDCO: ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I: 8>969:�BJAI>86B696H���6�/>C8>�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:ADH�9: :HIJ9D�96H�6H6H��BbFJ>C6�9: KD6G��E6G6FJ:96H�:�D

E6G6;JHD�6jG:D� �6 />C8> ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD�9: I6CFJ:��:B�;DGB6�9:�I6GI6GJ<6� �6 />C8> ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD &:G<JA=69DG�:�7o>6 ��

Page 15: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P87

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD+D7p ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�9D�6JIoBDK:A �

�><JG6 �� &D9:AD�9:�7>8>8A:I6 �

�><JG6 ��� "<G:?6 9:�,6>CI�&68ADJ��:B�+DJ:C� ��� �

�><JG6 ��� "<G:?6�9:�,8=rC:�&6G>6��:B�+:<:CH7JG<��9:� ��� �

�><JG6 ��� �:I6A=:H�96�8tEJA6�9:�,6CI6�&6G>6��:A��>DG:���ADG:Ch6 ��

�><JG6 ��� �tEJA6�9:��GJC:AA:H8=>�C6�86I:9G6A�9:��ADG:Ch6��"IbA>6 ��

�><JG6 ��� -699:D�:��:9:G>8D�3J886G>��/>C8:COD��DG<=>C>�

'>8DADH6�:� >DG<>D�/6H6G>�:B�;G:CI:�6D�BD9:AD�96��6I:9G6A

9:��ADG:Ch6�9:��ADG:Ch6��:9:G>8D�3J886G> ��

�><JG6 ��� &>8=:A6C<:AD�:�D�BD9:AD�9:�,fD�):9GD E6G6�D�E6E6�)6JAD�"/�

�6H6 �JDC6GGDI>���ADG:Ch6 ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:H�96�8tEJA6�9:�,fD�):9GD�EDG�&>8=:A6C<:AD ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:�9D�-:BEAD&6A6I:H>6CD�9:�+>B>C>���A7:GI> ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:�B>A>I6G�:B�8DCHIGJhfD��9:��A6>C�&6C:HHDC

&6AA:IxH��)�(�,�+-������()��DJ ���(*��� �� +�((���)6G>H�� �� ��

�><JG6 �� &D9:ADH�:HIG6Ij<>8DH��(H�B6E6H�:B +:A:KD�)6G>H��:B� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� �GFJ>I:IDH�:B�H:J�:HIt9>D�8DB�6�B6FJ:I:��9:��G6C8>JH8JH

)=>A>EEJH �ADG>CJH� �A:B6C=6�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:��"A�+:9:CIDG:��/:C:O6���C9G:6�)6AA69>D ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:� />AA6��6EG6 ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:�9:�9:I6A=: ��

�><JG6 ��� )>6OO6�,fD�):9GD��/6I>86CD���:GC>C>�� ����� ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:�:B�B69:>G6��9:�,>G��=G>HIDE=:G�0G:C��E6G6�6

�6I:9G6A�9:�,fD�)6JAD��:B�%DC9G:H��"C<A6I:GG6 ��

�><JG6 ��� �oE>6�=:A>D<Gb;>86�9:�EGD?:IDH�9:�6GFJ>I:IJG6�8� ��� �

�><JG6��� &D9:AD� :DG<:��9BJC9�,IG::I�:�)DAA6G9�#D=C�,:99DC�� ��� ��

Page 16: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P87+

�><JG6 ��� �6E>IoA>D�9DH��.���&:><H ��

�><JG6H �� (;>8>C6�9:� 6J9>��K6G6C96�96��6H6��6IAAo ��

�><JG6H ��� (;>8>C6�9:� 6J9> ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�DG><>C6A�9:� 6J9>�E6G6�6�;68=696�96� AoG>6 ��

�><JG6 ��� �CIpC>D� 6J9>� BD9:AD�86E:A6��DApC>6� J:AA ��

�><JG6 ��� /A69>B>G�-6IA>C� &DCJB:CID�96�-:G8:>G6�'68>DC6A�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:�96 -DGG: �>CHI:>C�:B�)DIH96B� �G>8�&:C9:AHD=C� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD��G>:9G>8=HIG6HH:� &>:H�K6C�9:G�+D=:���:GA>C�� �� ��

�><JG6H ��� &D9:AD />A6�,6KDN� %:��DG7JH>:G� �G6Ch6� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD �6H6�,8=r9:G� :GG>I+>:IK:A9��!DA6C96�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &D9:AD�96��6H6�,8=r9:G� :GG>I+>:IK:A9��!DA6C96�� ��� ��

�><JG6 �� �6J=6JH��:HH6J�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &>:H�IG676A=6C9D�:B�BD9:ADH�8DB�#6B:H�,E:N:G�:

�6C;DGI=� :DG<:��CD�"CHI>IJID�9:�-:8CDAD<>6�9:�"AA>CD>H�

�=>86<D�� ��� �

�><JG6 ��� (;>8>C6�9:�&>:H �

�><JG6 ��� &D9:ADH�96��b7G>86�#D=CHDC�� ����9: �G6C@�%ADN9�0G><=I ��

�><JG6 ��� &JH:J ��+)���(��+*)���$�+$)* ��6H6�96��GI:��A:Bf�

��� ����)6JA %J9L>< ��

�><JG6 ��� !>IA:G�>CHE:8>DC6C9D�JB6�B6FJ:I: ��

�><JG6 ��� !>IA:G�>CHE:8>DC6C9D�JB6�B6FJ:I: ��

�><JG6 ��� ,DA969DH�:HIJ96B�D BD9:AD�8DBD�:HIG6Ij<>6 ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:�96 'DK6��:GA>B���A:B6C=6� ��� ��

�><JG6 �� />8IDG>66G:6A�8DB��6;j�$G6COA:G�:�AD?6�9:�9:E6GI6B:CIDH��>A@6�

6GFJ>I:ID !6CCH��JHIB6CC ��� ��

�><JG6� � �6H6�96��6H86I6 ��

Page 17: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P87++

�><JG6� �� �AD8DH�9:��G:9:G>8@��GD:7:A ��

�><JG6� �� �G6C@�%ADN9 0G><=I�:�H:J�BD9:AD�:B�B69:>G6 ��

�><JG6� �� �:GD�,66G>C:C� B6FJ:I:�9D�-:GB>C6A�-0� ��

�><JG6� �� �:GD�,66G>C:C :�6H�K:G>;>86hq:H�:HIGJIJG6>H ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�9:��G6HlA>6�"HG6:A�)>C=:>GD� EG:H>9:CI:�96 '(/���)�

%J8>D �DHI6��(H86G '>:B:N:G�:�#$ ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�9D )6Ab8>D�96��HH:B7Aj>6�%:<>HA6I>K6�9:��=6C9><6G=�

������%:��DG7JH>:G ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�96�"<G:?6�'DIG:��6B:�9:�!6JI��+DC8=6BE��

%:��DG7JH>:G ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�96�"<G:?6�,6>CI�)>:GG:���>GB>C��%:��DG7JH>:G ��

�><JG6� � &6FJ:I:�96 �6H6�96H��6CD6H�� �����(H86G�'>:B:N:G ��

�><JG6� (H86G�'>:B:N:G�D7H:GK6�6�B6FJ:I:�9D�)6Ab8>D��AKDG696� ��� ��

�><JG6� � (H86G�'>:B:N:G�D7H:GK6�6�B6FJ:I:�9D�)6Ab8>D��AKDG696� ��� ��

�><JG6� � -0��-:GB>C6A���:GDEDGID�#�$�� ����� �:GD ,66G>C:C ��

�><JG6� � -0��-:GB>C6A���:GDEDGID�#�$�� ����� �:GD ,66G>C:C ��

�><JG6� � 0G><=I�8DB�!>AA6�+:76N�:�,DADBDC� J<<:C=:>B�K:C9D�6

B6FJ:I:�9D�BJH:J ��

�><JG6� � �G6C@�%ADN9�0G><=I��`�:HFJ:G96��BDHIG6�JB�BD9:AD�9D

,DADBDC�+� J<<:C=:>B�&JH:JB�E6G6�:HIJ96CI:H�9: -6A>:H>C ��

�><JG6H� � #DGC .IODC�:�JB�9:I6A=:�96�B6FJ:I:�96�[E:G6�9:�,N9C:N �

�><JG6� � #DGC .IODC�6EG:H:CI6 :�6�B6FJ:I:�96�[E:G6�9:�,N9C:N �

�><JG6� � &D9:AD�9:�9:BDCHIG6hfD 96�[E:G6�9:�,N9C:N���JHIGbA>6� �� ��

�><JG6 �� &6FJ:I:�[E:G6 9:�,N9C:N��# DGC .IODC�� ����� ��

�><JG6� � 'DGB6C��DHI:G�:�6�B6FJ:I:�96�-DGG:�!,�� !DA9>C<H ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�9D�8DC8JGHD��:CIGD� :DG<:�)DBE>9DJ�

+:COD�)>6CD���+>8=6G9�+D<:GH ��

Page 18: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P87+++

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�9D�EGD?:ID�:M:8JI>KD9D�8DC8JGHD��:CIGD

:DG<:�)DBE>9DJ� +:COD�)>6CD���+>8=6G9�+D<:GH ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�96H��DA>:H�EDG -H8=JB>��:GC6G9�

)6GFJ:�9:�%6�/>AA:II:��)6G>H ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�8DC8:>IJ6A��(E:C�!DJH:���6A>;oGC>6��(()�!>BB:A7A6J ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD :HIGJIJG6A��(E:C�!DJH:���6A>;oGC>6��(()�!>BB:A7A6J ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�;>C6A��(E:C�!DJH:���6A>;oGC>6 �(()�!>BB:A7A6J ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�9D �>6BDC9�+6C8=�!><=�,8=DDA��%DH��C<:A:H�

���&DGE=DH>H ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�9D�9:I6A=:�9:�JB6�H:hfD�9D��>6BDC9�+6C8=

!><=�,8=DDA��%DH��C<:A:H�� ����&DGE=DH>H ��

�><JG6� �� >DK6C>��:AA>C>�� ��� � ���&69DC6�:��G>6Ch6��oA:D

6A:G>6��DG<=:H:��+DB6�"IbA>6 ��

�><JG6� � �A6JH�,AJI:G��8� �����-JBJAD�9:��:A>E:�yD�(JH69Dz�

�JFJ:�9:��DG<DC=6�&JH:J�9:��GI:�9:��A:K:A6C9 ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A� :A:B:CID�9D�EGD8:HHD 9:�EGD?:ID

96�+:H>9kC8>6�%:L>H�� ����)DG��G6C@� :=GN ��

�><JG6� �� -:HI:�9:�B6I:G>6>H�96+:H>9kC8>6�%:L>H�� �����G6C@� :=GN ��

�><JG6� �� :=GN�6EG:H:CI6C9D�JB�BD9:AD�9:�:HIJ9D ��

�><JG6� �� )6GI:H�9D�&D9:AD��HIJ9D�9D�bIG>D�:MI:GCD��H:I:B7GD� ���

�G6C@� :=GN�� J<<:C=:>C���>A76D �

�><JG6� �� �G6C@� :=GN�BD9:A6C9D�D J<<:C=:>C��>A76D �

�><JG6� �� ):GHE:8I>K6 9><>I6A� &JH:J J<<:C=:>C �>A76D �

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD��G6C@� :=GN J<<:C=:>C��>A76D �

�><JG6� �� +:H<>HIGD�:MEADG6IoG>D�9:��G6C@� =:GN ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD %^�-$��� �$+���,���� /('�)"�+,��0 &D9:AA

�G8=>I:@IJG��:H><C ��

�><JG6� � %>KGD�)�,�.�%�"�&"+[�������+�('�+(��)���(��+�!� +�&6FJ:I>HBD

�GFJ>I:8IoC>8D ��

Page 19: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P8+8

�><JG6� �� %>KGD '�����+�&6FJ:I:H���&>C>6IJG6H ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD�$'(%%��0��!��!"' �+��&�&6FJ:I:H��GFJ>I:IpC>86H ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD �(',�%�3� %�&6FJ:I:H��6�G:EG:H:CI6hfD�9D�:HE6hD

CD�EGD?:ID�6GFJ>I:IpC>8D ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD�0�+'�+��&�&D9:A &6@>C< ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD��.''��'�&6FJ:I6H�9:��GFJ>I:8IJG6�&:9>DH���->EDH��

�EA>868>DC ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD���++�%2� %�-j8C>86H�9:�+:EG:H:CI68>oC ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD���++�%2��%��JC96B:CIDH�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6 ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD���++�%2��%��>7J?D E6G6 �A �>H:nD .G76CD ��

�><JG6� �� %>KGD�&"%%,����)GD?:I6C9D�8DB�&6FJ:I:H�.B�<J>6�9:�8DBD

;6O:G�:�JH6G�B6FJ:I:H�9:�EGD?:ID�9:�6GFJ>I:IJG6 ��

�><JG6� � %>KGD $.)�+��+ ��+� +�",�+�.&�&(-(� /�'�/�+$�%

�G8=>I:8IJG6A�&D9:A�%:69�ID��:H><C �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD +"'��+ ��#�"�3��Z(,�����+*."-��-.+�, �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD +"'��+ ��#������HIJ9>DH 9:A �HE68>D �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD �"%,!"%%��'.Z�3��&.Z( ����� �������#�'+�*�)���

�('+ *��*+(��$�� "� �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD -6A@� :=GN

�><JG6� �� %>KGD ���+(�!���) &6FJ:I:H�9:�)6E:A

�><JG6� �� �6GI6O�96�(;>8>C6�9:�&6FJ:I:�8DB��)6JAD�&:C9:H�96�+D8=6 v

y(�BD9:AD�:CFJ6CID�8DBEG::CHfD�9:�EGD?:IDz

�><JG6� �� �JGHD�)6JAD�&:C9:H�96 +D8=6�C6��6H6�/>A6CDK6��GI><6H �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD���$"$(��� -=: �GI�D;�I=:��G8=>I:8IJG6A�&D9:A �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD $.++�'-��� ,86A:�BD9:AH� =DJH:H�D;�I=:���I=�8:CIJGN �

�><JG6� � %>KGD&(('�$6G:C &D9:A>C<�&:HH6<:H��-=:

�G8=>I:8I�6C9�I=:�&D9:A �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD�(,0�%������G8=>I:8IJG6A�&D9:AH �

Page 20: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P88

�><JG6 �� %>KGD�&(++",��&��&D9:AH� 6G8=>I:8IJG:�6C9�I=:�B>C>6IJG: �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD &"2(.' �) �DCHIGJ8I>DC�6C9��:H><C�&6CJ6A�

�G8=>I:8IJG6A�&D9:AH� /DA� �:�� �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD /23(/"-"��, �DA9>C<��G8=>I:8IJG:� HE6I>6A��HIGJ8IJG6A�6C9

DG<6C>O6I>DC6A�9>6<G6BH �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD /23(/"-"� !�,JE:GHJG;68:H��;DA9>C<�6H�6�B:I=D9�D;

<:C:G6I>C<�;DGBH�;DG�6G8=>I:8IJG:��EGD9J8IH�6C9�;6H=>DC �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD�� $�-!"�",��� ,�!"%%" �� ):G;DGB6I>K:

:DB:IG>:H� -G6CH;DGB>C<�-:MI>A:�-:8=C>FJ:H �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD�� $�-!"�",����&D9JA6G�,IGJ8IJG:H�>C�9:H><C

6C9�6G8=>I:8IJG: �

�><JG6� �� %>KGD %"&��# �88:CIG>8�,IGJ8IJG:H�>C��G8=>I:8IJG: �

�><JG6� �� ,>I:�96��>H8>EA>C6�9:�&6FJ:I:H �H8DA6�-j8C>86�,JE:G>DG

9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�9:�/6AAiH �

�><JG6� � ,>I:�96��H8DA6�-j8C>86�,JE:G>DG�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�9:�/6AAiH

�>H8>EA>C6�9:�&6FJ:I:H �

�><JG6� �� ,>I:�96 �>H8>EA>C6�&6FJ:I:H v .C>K:GH>969:��:9:G6A�9D

+>D� G6C9:�9D�,JA �

�><JG6� �� -G676A=D�9D��AJCD� JHI6KD�,>AK6��� ��v .C>K:GH>969:

�:9:G6A�9D�+>D� G6C9:�9D�,JA �

�><JG6� �� ,>I:�9D�&JH:J�96H�&6FJ:I:H����.�.�� ��

�><JG6� �� &JH:J�96H�&6FJ:I:H����.�.�� v K>IG>C:�:�>CI:G>DG�96�H6A6 ��

�><JG6� �� ,>I: 9D���!().���HE6C=6 �

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�96�EDCI:�9:��N6A6�:��6I:9G6A�9:�&6C>A6���HE6C=6 �

�><JG6� �� �MEDH>hfD�9:�&6FJ:I:H��DCI:BEDGdC:6H�CD�Hj8JAD�11 ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:H�9:��DCI:BEDGdC:6H�CD�Hj8JAD�11��6AJCDH

.C>K:GH>969: %6�,:G:C6���=>A: ��

�><JG6� �� ,>I:��G8=>BD9:AH v 76C8D�9:�969DH ��

�><JG6� � &6FJ:I: )>:G8N ��8DBE6CN v "<G:?6 9G6NIDC<G:C��%DC9G:H ��

Page 21: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P88+

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:�):I:G��>H:B6C v !DJH:�1�� ��� ��

�><JG6� �� ,I6CA:N�-><:GB6C� ����� **"���%+)�� $�*���"%+�)�� ��� ��

�><JG6� �� �:H:C=D�:�B6FJ:I:��>6C6��<G:HI� �%+)���%(��

�+) � �$ � &6?DG86 ��

�><JG6 �� �:H:C=D�:�B6FJ:I: �>6C6��<G:HI� �%+)���%(��

�+) � �$� &6?DG86 ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�:B�8=JB7D���G6I6�"HDO6@>����HHD8>6I:H

!DJH:�D;�'>C:�,FJ6G:H�� ��� ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�9:�+>8=6G9�+D<:GH�)6GIC:GH=>ExH�9D�-G>7JC6A

�JGDE:J�9DH��>G:>IDH�9D�!DB:B ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�:B�68GlA>8D��G:H>C6��EG6I6��6AJBlC>D�:�B6A=6�6G6B696�

�AHDE��G8=>I:8IH��)6K>A=fD��MED�!6CCDK:G����� ��

�><JG6� �� �MEDH>hfD �%.�"������#.2) �(�� *��*+(� �%%# ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:ADH�EGD9JO>9DH�CD�:H8G>IoG>D�9:��G6C@� :=GN ��

�><JG6 � �8:GKD�9:�B6FJ:I:H�&JH:J�9:��GI:�&D9:GC6�9:�'DK6�2DG@ �

�><JG6 �� �8:GKD�9:�B6FJ:I:H �%.�"��$)* *+*�%� �( * )���(�� *��*) :B

%DC9G:H �

�><JG6 �� �6E6�96H�G:K>HI6H�+:KJ:�9:�A��GI���+�� �(�� *��*)2��%+($�"� ���

��))��$� �"-��: �(��(�� *�!* ��%� ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:AD�9:�&>8=:A:�,6::�E6G6 %"/�( +�)*�%+)� ��

�><JG6 �� &JH:J�96H�&6FJ:I:H�.������. ��

�><JG6� �� &D9:ADH�:MEDHIDH�C6 �"�( ����)��%+"���)� *0

��"��(�� *��*+(� ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:H�:MEDHI6H�C6 �"�( � �%��($��* %$*�#&%(� $�����( ) ��

�><JG6� �� &6FJ:I:H�:MEDHI6H�C6 �"�( � �%��($��* %$*�#&%(� $�����( ) ��

�><JG6 �� &JH:J�9:�B6FJ:I:H�:B�%DC<�"HA6C9 +>8=6G9�&:>:G ��

�><JG6 ��� &JH:J�9:�B6FJ:I:H :B�%DC<�"HA6C9 +>8=6G9�&:>:G ��

�><JG6��� :IIN��:CI:G��%DH��C<:A:H ��

Page 22: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P88++

�><JG6���� &:>:G�: 9:I6A=:�96�IDGG:��%DH��C<:A:H ��

�><JG6���� �H8JAIJG6H�9:�&:>:G ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�96�:MEDH>hfD H�����(�� *��*+(�"��%��"���%%"����* )��

�#�""��*%& �3;DID�Q�'>C6�+::IO@:� ,INA:E6G@ ��

�><JG6���� �DAD86hfD�96�EG>B:>G6�E:9G6�CD�.AB�&uCHI:G� ��� ��

�><JG6���� )GD?:IDH 9: (HL6A9�&6I=>6H .C<:GH ��

�><JG6���� �bEHJA6H�96H 86H6H�,DA>C<:C�6HE:GH7GD>8=�

0DA;<6C<��rG>C<� ��� ��

�><JG6���� �6H6�9:�8DGI>C6H��+6>BJC9��7G6=6B��BD9:AD� ��� ��

�><JG6���� �68=D�CD��G���G6I6"HDO6@>��BD9:AD� ��� ��

�><JG6�� � �b7G>86�-G6CHE6G:CI:��!:CC �G8=>I:8IH��BD9:AD���� ��

�><JG6�� ):h6�y'6IJG:O6�)G:H:GK696z� 9:�!6JH+J8@:G�D� ��� ��

�><JG6�� � &JH:J�9:��GI: $DAJB76��):I:G�3JBI=DG��BD9:AD�9:���� �9:

367DGDLH@N �

�><JG6�� � +:HDGI�!DJH:��&>:H�/6C�9:G�+D=:��BD9:AD 9:� ����EDG�2>O �

�><JG6H�� � )6K>A=fD��A:BfD�E6G6�6��MEDH>hfD�.C>K:GH6A�9:�&DCIG:6A��9:

0DA;<6C<�BD9:AD� ������ ��

�><JG6�� � �HI6hfD�9:�IG:B��,IJII<6G9���G:>�(IID ��

�><JG6�� � �HIb9>D�&JC>FJ:���G:>�(IID ��

�><JG6�� � -DGG:��>CHI:>C��G>8=�&:C9:AHD=C��BD9:AD�DG><>C6A�:�GjEA>86H

EGD9JO>96H�EDG�>BEG:HHDG6��� ��

�><JG6�� � �6IbAD<D�96�:MEDH>hfD �����(�� *��*+(�"��%��"���%%"����* )��

�#�""��*%& � ��

�><JG6�� � &6FJ:I:H� 6J9>��,6<G696��6BlA>6�� � � ��

�><JG6���� (;>8>C6�9:�BD9:ADH�9:�&>:H�K6C�9:G�+D=: ��

�><JG6��� �HIJ9DH�9:��:GD,66G>C:C�E6G6�D�-:GB>C6A�-0� ��

Page 23: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P88+++

�><JG6���� -G6CH�0DGA9��>GA>C:H�-:GB>C6A���:GDEDGID�#D=C���$:CC:9N�

'DK6�2DG@�� ��� ��� &D9:AD�:B�8DCHIGJhfD��:HIJ9DH�9:��:GD

,66G>C:C ��

�><JG6���� �G6C@� :=GN�: �9L>C��=6C6C�6A>H6C9D�JB�BD9:AD ��

�><JG6���� �G6C@� :=GN���9L>C��=6C��)6JA�+D9<:GH�:�)6JA�,I6AA6C

IG676A=6C9D�CD�EGD?:ID��6BEJH� A6H<DL�:B�%DH��C<:A:H ��

�><JG6���� "B6<:B�E6CDGdB>86�9D�:HIt9>D�9:� :=GN��BDHIG6C9D�DH

:HIJ9DH�>CK:HI><6I>KDH�9:�H:JH�EGD?:IDH ��

�><JG6���� �I:A>:G�9:�+:COD�)>6CD ��

�><JG6���� �HIt9>D��DHI:G�6C9�)6GIC:GH ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD�9D�I:6IGD�:�H6A6�9D�IDCD�9D� G6C9:�)6Ab8>D�9D�$G:BA>C�

&DH8DJ�� ��� ��� ��

�><JG6���� �6H6�&>Ab�� 6J9> ��

�><JG6���� D:I=:6CJB��,I:>C:G ��

�><JG6��� !:GB6CC�(7G>HI ��

�><JG6���� -DGG:��>CHI:>C���G>8=�&:C9:AHDC ��

�><JG6���� �:GD ,66G>C:C-0��-:GB>C6A ��

�><JG6���� ,66G>C:C�CD�>CI:G>DG�96�B6FJ:I: ��

�><JG6���� �:GD ,66G>C:C�9:�o8JADH���:H6G�):AA>��`�9>G:>I6��:�$:K>C�+D8=:��D

H:<JC9D�6�:HFJ:G96���>CK:HI><6B�6�B6FJ:I: ��

�><JG6 ��� �:GD ,66G>C:C 06H=>C<IDC �JAA:H��>GEDGI ��

�><JG6 ��� ,@>9BDG:��(L>C<H�:�&:GG>AA ,(&��=>86<DxH "CA6C9�,I::A��J>A9>C<�

#D=C !6C8D8@��:CI:G�6C9�,:6GH�-DL:G ��

�><JG6���� "&�):>�:�6�B6FJ:I:�9:�(@A6=DB6� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� )=>A>E�#D=CHDC��%>C8DAC��:CI:G�;DG�I=:�):G;DGB>C<��GIH�

:B�'DK6�2DG@ ��

�><JG6���� �G6C@ :=GN v �G>C<>C< &DK:B:CI ID �G8=>I:8IJG:� -=: �6C8>C<

!DJH: � �G8=>I:8I��G6C@� :=GN�>C��DCK:GH6I>DC� �G6C@� :=GN�>C

8DCK:GH6I>DCL>I=��6G76G6�"H:C7:G<���A:M�+DHH ��

Page 24: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P88+7

�><JG6��� &D9:AD�9D�EGD8:HHD�9:�IG676A=D �9>;l8>D ':9:GA6C9:C

:B )G6<6� �G6C@ :=GN ����� ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD�9D�8DCI:MID�JG76CD �9>;l8>D ':9:GA6C9:C :B )G6<6�

�G6C@ :=GN ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD�9D�EGD8:HHD�>C>8>6A��9>;l8>D ':9:GA6C9:C :B )G6<6�

�G6C@ :=GN ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD��>C6A �9>;l8>D ':9:GA6C9:C :B )G6<6� �G6C@ :=GN ��

�><JG6���� �H8G>IoG>D�'��#�:B�,:6IIA: ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�:B�G:H>C6�H>CIjI>86 ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�:B�68GlA>8D ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�:B�E6E:A �

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�:B�B69:>G6 ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�:B�B:I6A ��

�><JG6��� &6FJ:I:H�B>H8:AdC:6H ��

�><JG6���� ��HjG>:�9:�>B6<:CH�9:BDCHIG6�D�EGD8:HHD�9:�9:H:CKDAK>B:CID

EGD?:IJ6A�96�)DCI:�)6GD9>��.'�,IJ9>D ��

�><JG6���� )GD8:HHD�EDHI:G>DG�6H�B6FJ:I:H�>C>8>6>H��B6FJ:I:�9:�:MEADG6hfD

G:6A>O696�8DB�9>;:G:CI:H�B6I:G>6>H�)DCI:�)6GD9>��.'�,IJ9>D ��

�><JG6���� �9>;l8>D �:CIGD�#D6C��G:HE>76H�:B�)6AB6�9:�&6AADG86��%���� ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:�9D �:CIGD�#D6C �G:HE>76H�:B�)6AB6�9:�&6AADG86

�%������A67DG696�E:ADH�6JIDG:H�9D�EGD?:ID ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:�9D �:CIGD�#D6C��G:HE>76H�:B�)6AB6�9:�&6AADG86

�%������A67DG696�EDG�&6F >A v >A7:GID�+J>O ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:H�:B�6G<>A6 �CID>C:�)G:9D8@ &JH:J�9D�)6Ab8>D

'68>DC6A��&6GNA>6C��:CI:G���DAA:<:�)6G@��,6C��>:<D�

�H8DA6�/:CI6C6��G>ODC6 ��

�><JG6���� �HNBEIDI:��G8=>I:8IJG: v IDJG�9:�:HIJ96CI:H�CD�:H8G>IoG>D

9: !6C>�+6H=>9 ��

�><JG6���� �GDFJ>�HD7G:�B6FJ:I:� �DDE�!>BB:A7�A�6J ��

Page 25: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P887

�><JG6���� �GDFJ>�HD7G:�;DID��&JH:J J<<:CB=:>B��>A76D���G6C@� :=GN ��

�><JG6��� )>CIJG6�0>AA��AHDE ��

�><JG6���� &6FJ:I:�9:�9:H:CKDAK>B:CID����� �AHDE �G8=>I:8IH ��

�><JG6���� )>CIJG6 36=6 !69>9� />IG6��>G:�,I6I>DC ��

�><JG6���� />IG6 �>G: ,I6I>DC��BD9:AD�:B�E6E:A 36=6 !69>9 ��

�><JG6���� ,I:K:C�!DAA��DC?JCID�9:�9:H:C=DH�$>6HB6�&JH:J�9:��GI:

�DCI:BEDGdC:6��!:AH>C@>�� ��� ��� �

�><JG6���� ,I:K:C�!DAA�&6FJ:I:�$>6HB6�&JH:J�9:��GI:��DCI:BEDGdC:6�

!:AH>C@>�� ��� ��� �

�><JG6���� ,I:K:C�!DAA)A6CI6H�Ij8C>86H��$>6HB6�&JH:J�9:��GI:

�DCI:BEDGdC:6��!:AH>C@>�� ��� ��� �

�><JG6���� �:BDCHIG6hfD�9D�EGD8:HHD�8G>6I>KD�9:��G6C@� :=GN�

IG:8=D�9D�;>AB: ,@:I8=:H D; �G6C@ :=GN ��

�><JG6���� ):I:G��>H:CB6C�)GD8:HHD�EGD?:IJ6A�)GDEDHI6�E6G6�D�)A6CD

+:7HID8@E6G@��A:B6C=6� ��� ��

�><JG6���� ):I:G��>H:CB6C�)GD8:HHD�EGD?:IJ6A�)GDEDHI6�E6G6�D�)A6CD

+:7HID8@E6G@��A:B6C=6� ��� ��

�><JG6��� �DC?JCID�9:�>B6<:CH�9:��:H6G�):AA>�:�HJ6�G:A6hfD�8DB�DH

BD9:ADH 6IG6KjH�9DH�6CDH ��

�><JG6���� �G69��6BE���6>C7G>9<:"HA6C9�EDG��A:8 ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD�9D�"9:D<G6B6�9D�-G>7JC6A��:9:G6A�9DH��HI69DH�.C>9DH�

,:6IIA:��'��# ��

�><JG6���� �JIDG�6CpC>BD�&6FJ:I:�96�"<G:?6�9:�,6>CI�&68ADJ�

+DJ:C�� ��� � � ��

�><JG6���� "B6<:CH�96��MEDH>hfD -=:��G8=>I:8IJG6A�/>H>DC��)6DAD�,DA:G> ��

�><JG6���� ):I:G�)G6C�9:� ����D�-:GB>C6A�96��B:G>86C��>GA>C:H���'DGI=L:HI

�>GA>C:H��:GDEDGID�#�$��:B�'DK6�2DG@ ��

�><JG6���� ):I:G�)G6C�9:� ����D�-:GB>C6A�96��B:G>86C��>GA>C:H���'DGI=L:HI

�>GA>C:H��:GDEDGID�#�$��:B�'DK6�2DG@ ��

Page 26: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P887+

�><JG6���� ):I:G�)G6C�$LJC�-DC<�-DLC��:CIG: �

�><JG6���� &D9:AD 9:�-DND�"ID�E6G6�D�EGD?:ID�9:�JG76C>HBD�E6G6

6�UG:6��:CIG6A�9D�,=6C<6> %J>?>6OJ>��:CI:G ��

�><JG6���� �6C>:A�%>7:H@>C9 �%*)��#�( �"�*/� �:GA>B ��

�><JG6��� 36=6�!69>9 �:CIGD�9:��GI:�&JAI>B:9>6�3DAA=D;��

�uHH:A9DG;���A:B6C=6� ���� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:��-=DB &6NC:� +D8@L:AA��DAA>C ��

�><JG6 ��� &6FJ:I:��-=DB�&6NC: �=>76� DA;��AJ7 ��

�><JG6���� DAO6G> J:HI�!DJH:��&>8=:A:�,6::�� ��� ��

�><JG6 ��� $6H>B>G &6A:K>8=��G8=>I:@IDCH�(GC6B:CID�� ��� ��

�><JG6���� 36=6�!69>9�8:CIGD�9:�6GI:H 9:�:HE:Ib8JADH��7J��=67>������ ��

�><JG6���� 0DA;�)G>M���DDE�!>BB:A7�A�6J����:CIGD�9:��>C:B6�.���

�G:H9:C�� ����� ��

�><JG6H���� (9>A:��:8F -:GB>C6A�9:�)6HH6<:>GDH�-6C<>:G ��

�><JG6���� &>8=6:A� G6K:H�-6BE6�E6G6�7>8D�9:�8=6A:>G6 ��

�><JG6���� &D9:AD 36=6�!69>9 �%)�$*��"��$*�(��%(�%$*�#&%(�(.

�(*)� �>C8>CC6I>��(=>D ��

�><JG6��� 36=6�!69>9��:G<>H:A�,@>�#JBE����� ��

�><JG6 ��� 36=6�!69>9 -:GB>C6A�&6GlI>BD�,6A:GCD ��

�><JG6���� ��96B6�:�D�.C>8oGC>D��/>HfD ��

�><JG6���� ��96B6�:�D�.C>8oGC>D���J9>hfD ��

�><JG6��� ��96B6�:�D�.C>8oGC>D��)6A696G ��

�><JG6���� ��96B6�:�D�.C>8oGC>D��(A;6ID ��

�><JG6���� ��96B6�:�D�.C>8oGC>D��-6ID ��

�><JG6���� �D�B:J�tC>8D�9:H:?D ��

�><JG6���� �HFJ:B6 !>:G6GFJ>6�9DH�H:CI>9DH v E>GdB>9:�G:C6H8:CI>HI6 ���

Page 27: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P887++

�><JG6���� %D<DB6G86�9D�8JGHD�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�.G76C>HBD�).�+>D ���

�><JG6 �� "BEA6CI6hfD ).�+>D���6BEJH� bK:6 � �

�><JG6���� �9>;l8>D��6G9:6A�%:B6���6BEJH� bK:6 �

�><JG6���� �9>;l8>D�"&����6BEJH� bK:6 �

�><JG6���� �>7A>DI:86�).��+>D � �

�><JG6���� �69DH�:HI6IlHI>8DH���>7A>DI:86�).��+>D � �

�><JG6���� %67DG6IoG>D 9: "C;DGBbI>86 ).��+>D � �

�><JG6���� %67DG6IoG>D�(;>8>C6�:�-G:>C6B:CID�9:��:H:CKDAK>B:CID:�)GDIoI>EDH � �

�><JG6���� %67DG6IoG>D 9: -:8CDAD<>6 96 �DCHIGJhfD ).��+>D � �

�><JG6���� �JA6�I:oG>86��%67DG6IoG>D�9: �DC;DGID �B7>:CI6A ).��+>D � �

�><JG6�� � %67DG6IoG>D 9: &6FJ:I:H ).��+>D � �

�><JG6�� )GD;:HHDG:H�9:�)A6C:?6B:CID :��:H:CKDAK>B:CID�:GC6C9D��:I>B���:GC6C9D��HEoH>ID��%:>A6��:6IG>O�,>AK:>G6�+6JA�,B>I= � �

�><JG6�� � )GD;:HHDG:H�9:�+:EG:H:CI6hfD A6J8>6��J<JHID��DCH:86��!:CC>C< )rE:A��%J8>6CD��AK6G:H :,>AK>D��>6H � �

�><JG6�� � )GD;:HHDG:H�9: -:DG>6�!>HIoG>6�:��DC;DGID��B7>:CI6A�C6�)6JA6�)DA>OOD : 06AI:G�-:>M:>G6 � �

�><JG6�� � ,6A6�9:�6JA6��G:8:EhfD�9DH�CDKDH�:HIJ96CI:H ���

�><JG6�� � )G:E6GD�9:�8DB>96H��G:8:EhfD�9DH�CDKDH�:HIJ96CI:H ���

�><JG6�� � ,6A6�9:�6JA6��E6CDG6B6�<:G6A�9D�8JGHD�:�6EG:H:CI6hq:H�E:HHD6>H ���

�><JG6�� � ,6A6�9:�6JA6��9>CdB>86�9:�<GJED ���

�><JG6�� � �6GIfD�9D� T�E:GlD9D ���

�><JG6�� � �69:GCD�9:�G:<>HIGDH�:A67DG69D�E:ADH�6AJCDH�CD�9:8DGG:G9D�8JGHD ���

�><JG6���� &tH>8D�9:H:C=69D�EDG��G6C@��=>C<�:B�H:J�869:GCD�9:�G:<>HIGDH ���

Page 28: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P887+++

�><JG6��� %>KGD�:��G6C@��=>C<�8DB�DH�869:GCDH�9:�G:<>HIGDH�9DH6AJCDH�9D�LDG@H=DE C6��G<:CI>C6�:B��� � ���

�><JG6���� �GFJ>I:IJG6 v AJ<6G��6JA6���EGDEoH>ID���GFJ>I:IJG6 ���

�><JG6���� �GFJ>I:IJG6 v 67G><D��6JA6���EGDEoH>ID���GFJ>I:IJG6 ���

�><JG6���� �GFJ>I:IJG6 v <:HID��6JA6���EGDEoH>ID���GFJ>I:IJG6 ���

�><JG6���� �GFJ>I:IJG6 v l8DC:��6JA6���EGDEoH>ID���GFJ>I:IJG6 ���

�><JG6���� �GFJ>I:IJG6 v I:8CDAD<>6��6JA6���EGDEoH>ID���GFJ>I:IJG6 ��

�><JG6���� �IBDH;:G6�6I:BEDG6A���EGDEoH>ID���GFJ>I:IJG6 ��

�><JG6���� �M:G8l8>D�9:�9D7G69JG6H ���

�><JG6���� �M:BEADH�9:�6AJCDH�9:H:C=6C9D ���

�><JG6���� �GDFJ>H��+:COD�)>6CD��&6G>:�-?>76DJ��JAIJG6A��:CI:G ���

�><JG6��� �GDFJ>�-696D��C9D��"<G:?6�96�%JO ���

�><JG6���� �GDFJ>��AK6GD ,>O6 ���

�><JG6���� �GDFJ> ,I:K:C�!DAA��&JH:J ':AHDC�I@>CH ���

�><JG6���� �GDFJ>�����=>C<��,fD�&6G8D��/:C:O6 ���

�><JG6���� �GDFJ>H�9: �9<6G9D &>CDC9� �6B>C>ID���J:CDH��>G:H ���

�><JG6���� �A67DG6hfD�9:�8GDFJ>�:B�JB6 BDK>B:CI696�+J6�9:��J:CDH��>G: ���

�><JG6���� )GD9JID ;>C6A�9:���B>CJIDH�9:�IG676A=D�9: 0>A9:G� oB:O�-6>E:9:�%>B6���9<6G9D &>CDC9�96��G<:CI>C6�:��G6C@��=>C<��HI69DH�.C>9D ���

�><JG6���� �:I6A=:�9DH�8GDFJ>H�9DH���6GI>HI6H ���

�><JG6���� �DCI:t9D�96�6JA6�9D�)GD;:HHDG 'DG7:GID��DG6CI:H����.�� ���

�><JG6���� &DCJB:CID�9:�':K:<�:�/:C>8: !DJH: ���

�><JG6��� �EG:H:CI6hfD�9D�EGD?:ID �6H6�C6�,:GG6��%J8>6CD��AK6G:H ���

�><JG6���� �JA6��HIGJIJG6� Gb;>86 v ,>AK>D��>6H ��

�><JG6���� &��H8=:G )DGB:CDG�9:�&:I6BDG;DH:��M>AD<G6KJG6 ���

�><JG6���� �68=696�9: :H8DA6��!6<J:�!DA6C96 ���

�><JG6���� &6A=6H�G:<JA6G:H ���

Page 29: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P88+8

�><JG6���� �DCHIGJhfD�96�B6A=6�IG>6C<JA6G ���

�><JG6���� �DCHIGJhfD�96�B6A=6�=:M6<DC6A ���

�><JG6���� �DCHIGJhfD�96�B6A=6�FJ69G696 ���

�><JG6 ��� �:H:C=D�96�B6A=6 FJ69G696���M�� ���

�><JG6���� ):GHE:8I>K6�<:G696�E:A6�B6C>EJA6hfD 96�B6A=6�FJ69G696 ���

�><JG6��� �:H:C=D 96�B6A=6�FJ69G696���M���:���M���� ���

�><JG6���� �:H:C=D 96�B6A=6�FJ69G696��M�������M�����:�����M���� ���

�><JG6���� �M:8JhfD�9:�BD9:ADH�:�9:H:C=DH�96H�IGkH�K6G>bK:>H�9D�:M:G8l8>D ���

�><JG6���� �69:GCD�9:�G:<>HIGD�:M:G8l8>D��� B6A=6 ���

�><JG6���� &6E6�9D�GDI:>GD�9:�K>H>I6�6D�8:CIGD ���

�><JG6���� &6E6�9D�GDI:>GD�9:�K>H>I6�6D�8:CIGD ���

�><JG6���� />H>I6�6D�8:CIGD :CFJ69G6B:CID�;DID<Gb;>8D ���

�><JG6���� />H>I6�6D�8:CIGD :CFJ69G6B:CID�6AID�<676G>ID ���

�><JG6���� />H>I6�6D�8:CIGD v 8DC?JCID�9>86H�;DID<Gb;>86H ��

�><JG6���� �6H6��G6Ch6��G6H>A�EDCID�9:�:C8DCIGD�&�&�G:<>HIGD�EDCID�;>C6A�96�K>H>I6 ���

�><JG6��� !>HIoG>8D�9DH�:9>;l8>DH�K>H>I69DH�CD�8:CIGD ���

�><JG6���� �AJCDH�CDH�:9>;l8>DH�K>H>I69DH�CD�8:CIGD ���

�><JG6���� )GD9JID�EGD9JO>9D�EDG�6AJCDH�C6�K>H>I6�6D�8:CIGD ���

�><JG6���� �DC;:8hfD�9DH�E6>Cj>H�96�K>H>I6�6D��:CIGD ���

�><JG6���� �:I6A=:H�:HE:8l;>8DH�9:�8696�I:B6�9D�E6>C:A ���

�><JG6���� �:H:C=DH�,DA6G� G6C9?:6C�9:�&DCI><CN v IG6h69DH�G:<JA69DG:H ���

�><JG6���� �:H:C=DH�G:IdC<JAD�bJG:D��:HE>G6A�:�E:CIb<DCD ���

�><JG6���� %:K6CI6B:CIDH�:�G:<>HIGDH�9D�,DA6G� G6C9?:6C�9:�&DCI><CN ���

�><JG6���� �JA6 BD9:A6<:B IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�9D ,DA6G G6C9?:6C ���

�><JG6���� �:H:CKDAK>B:CID�96�BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�9D�,DA6GE:ADH�6AJCDH ��

�><JG6��� &6FJ:I:H�,DA6G� G6C9?:6C�9:�&DCI><CN; ;>C6A>O696H ��

Page 30: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P888

�><JG6 ��� �69:GCD�9:�G:<>HIGD�9:�6AJCD v &6FJ:I:�,DA6G� G6C9?:6C9: &DCI><CN ���

�><JG6���� �69:GCD�9:�G:<>HIGD�9:�6AJCD v IG6h69DH�G:<JA69DG:H ���

�><JG6���� �JA6�IG6CH;DGB6hfD�96�;DGB6 v )GD;6 �C6�)6JA6�)DA>OOD ���

�><JG6���� �JA6�IG6CH;DGB6hfD�96�;DGB6 v )GD;6 �C6�)6JA6�)DA>OOD ���

�><JG6���� �JA6��>G8JA6hfD v )GD;6 �C6�)6JA6�)DA>OOD ���

�><JG6���� �EG:H:CI6hfD ,:B>CbG>D��=>C<�8DB�JHD�9:�BD9:ADH�:�9:H:C=DH ���

�><JG6���� �JA6��DBEDH>hfD�&D9JA6G v )GD;6�C6�)6JA6�)DA>OOD ���

�><JG6���� �JA6��DBEDH>hfD�&D9JA6G ���

�><JG6���� &D9:ADH�9: 9:H:CKDAK>B:CID�:M:G8l8>D�8DBEDH>hfD�BD9JA6G ��

�><JG6��� &D9:ADH DG<6C>O6hfD�96H�:9>;>86hq:H�C6H�FJ69G6H ��

�><JG6���� �6C86�9:�H>IJ6hfD�8DBEDH>hfD�G:<JA6G�:�BD9:AD�;>C6A ���

�><JG6 ��� 0DG@H=DE�9:��ME:G>B:CI6hq:H ���

�><JG6���� �JA6�I:oG>86���9>G:IG>O:H�9D�LDG@H=DE�9::ME:G>B:CI6hq:H v !:CC>C<�)DEE:G ���

�><JG6���� 0DG@H=DE��ME:G>B:CI6hq:H�BD9:A6<:B�7>�:�IG>9>B:CH>DC6ACD�6G6B: ���

�><JG6���� 0DG@H=DE��ME:G>B:CI6hq:H�BD9:A6<:B�7>�:�IG>9>B:CH>DC6ACD�E6E:A ���

�><JG6���� 0DG@H=DE��ME:G>B:CI6hq:H�BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A6G6B:�:�E6E:A ���

�><JG6���� 0DG@H=DE��ME:G>B:CI6hq:H�BD9:A6<:B�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A7J8=6�K:<:I6A ���

�><JG6���� 0DG@H=DE��ME:G>B:CI6hq:H v 6C:A�EGD9JO>9D�EDG�6AJC6�C6H=DG6H�A>KG:H ���

�><JG6���� �JA6��CbA>H:��GFJ>I:IpC>86�)GD; 6 �C6�)6JA6�)DA>OOD ���

�><JG6��� �CbA>H:��GFJ>I:IpC>86�&DG;DAD<>6��OJB6 !DJH: ���

�><JG6���� �CbA>H:��GFJ>I:IpC>86��HIGJIJG6��+:H>9kC8>6�"I6B6C7J86 ���

�><JG6���� �CbA>H:��GFJ>I:IpC>86��8:HHD�:�8>G8JA6hfD���6H6�/6G6C96 ���

�><JG6���� �CbA>H:��GFJ>I:IpC>86 (G>:CI6hfD��+:;t<>D�,fD��=>8D ��

Page 31: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P888+

�><JG6���� �CbA>H:��GFJ>I:IpC>86��&6I:G>6A>969:��+:;t<>D�,fD��=>8D ��

�><JG6���� �JA6�I:GG:CD�).� ���

�><JG6���� �EG:H:CI6hfD��C6A>H:�9D�I:GG:CD ���

�><JG6���� �EG:H:CI6hfD <GJEDH�EDG�86I:<DG>6H��C6A>H:�9D�I:GG:CD ���

�><JG6���� !:A>D9DC�:HIJ9D�9D�I:GG:CD ���

�><JG6���� �>8=6�G:HJBD�IG676A=D�;>C6A ���

�><JG6 �� �KDAJhfD�9D�EGD?:ID�;>C6A ���

Page 32: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P888++

!#�; ��

� ��" ��#?=� �

)GD7A:B6 ��

� ,D7G:�D�D7?:ID�9:�:HIJ9D ��

� (7?:I>KDH ��

� #JHI>;>86I>K6 �

� �$�����������"�! �

� #!����!�������!������������! ���! ��

� ������!�" ������!�����!��#������������#� ��

� +:K>HfD�9:�%>I:G6IJG6 ��

� �JChq:H��B6I:G>6>H�:�Ij8C>86H ��

� � -DB696�9:�9:8>Hq:H��6EA>867>A>969:�CD�:CH>CD�9:�EGD?:ID ��

� � +:;A:Mq:H�:�9>6<G6B6H�CD�EGD?:ID�6GFJ>I:IpC>8D ��

� � �GFJ>I:IDH�FJ:�;6O:B�B6FJ:I:H �

� � +:;A:Mq:H�6D�BD9:A6G �

�� ,>I:H��869kB>8DH v &6FJ:I:H �

�� �MEDH>hq:H v &DHIG6H�)t7A>86H v �DA:hq:H ��

� "���"�����������?=� ��

$�!=��������������"� ��

� ���%=������ "� ����#����%�� �@����������"����" ��#?=������ ���"������ �#�"�"# ����:�1)3C0(0��#� G +0 ���

�����#!B�! ���

��� @����! ��

���!!; �� ���

���%�! ���

Page 33: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 1

���������

%>� 5905AS0@:>� ;:>>5A17819?1�� >U�;:01819?1901= -� =1-750-01�18�<@1 4-.5?-8;:=

815:01� =1;=1>19?-PW1>� � ;=U;=5- -?5?@01 01� =1;=1>19?-= ;:>>5A17819?1 2-D� /:8

<@1�:> 5905AS0@:> ;1=/1.-8 >@- -;?50N: 01�=-/5:/S95:�1 -;=58:=18>@-�/-;-/50-01

/:395?5A-� �:9?@0:� @8-�=1;=1>19?-PN:�9N:�Q�- Z=1-750-01�18 >5[� 9N:�;:01�>1=�:

Z:.61?:�18�>5[ 1 18�?:0:�:�8:819?:>1=J819:>�0: <@1�-<@57:�-�<@1�>1� =1;:=?-�

+8-�=1;=1>19?-PN:�;:=�>@- 9-?@=1D-�;-=?5/@7-=� >1�=181?1�- >1@>�=121=19?1>� &-=-

>1�=1;=1>19?-= @8�5901?1=859-0: ->;1/?:�01 <@-7<@1= >5?@-PN:�>1=J ;=1/5>: 257?=J�

7-� ;1=85?590: <@1 -;19->�->�/-=-/?1=S>?5/->;=58:=05-5>:.?194-8 @8�01?1=859-0:

19?1905819?:� >:.� @8- ;1=>;1/?5A- 1>;1/S25/-� $1>>1 ;=:/1>>:� =10@?:= 18� >@-

:=5318�� =1/:=?-0:� 1 Z=10@D50:[ �18� @8� 0@;7:� >19?50:�� 2:=8-�>1 @8-� 58-318

=1;=1>19?-?5A-� <@1�;:01�>1=� 19?N:� 8-95;@7-0-�

� /:9>?=@PN:� 0-� 59A1>?53-PN:� 9->/1� ;17:� A5Q>� 0-� :.>1=A-PN:� 0- 0XA50-� 1 0:

<@1>?5:9-819?:�% 59?1=1>>1� 18� -9-75>-=�/:8;=11901=->� =17-PW1>� 0-� 7593@-318� 1

=1;=1>19?-PN:� ?=505819>5:9-7� /:8�:>�;=:/1>>:>�01;19>-819?:�1�;1=/1;PN:� A5>5:�

1>;-/5-5> -.=-9319?1> 9-� /=5-PN:� ;=:61?@-7�� ;-@?-=-8 1� ;-@?-8 :� /:?505-9:� 01

9:>>- 1C;1=5R9/5-;=:25>>5:9-7�1 ;1>>:-7�

95/5-7819?1 /-.1� 192-?5D-= - 1C;1=5R9/5-� A5A50-� 9-� 592L9/5- /:8� @8- 10@/-PN:

A:7?-0-� H� >19>5.5750-01� 01>19A:7A190:: ;19>-819?:� -.>?=-?:� .=59/-90:� /:8 :>

:.61?:>� )1<@19/5-7819?1 /:8:�1>?@0-9?1�01�-=<@5?1?@=-�-�1C;1=5R9/5-�/:9>?=@?5A-

=1-7�1�>@/1>>5A-� �>�<@1>?W1> 8@7?5>>19>:=5-5>��8-5>�0:�<@1�@8�>58;71>�-=?52S/5:�01

=1;=1>19?-PN:��;:018�>1�/:9>?5?@5=�18�@8�;=:/1>>:�59A1>?53-?5A:�01�/:941/5819?:

1� /=5-PN:� 0-� -=<@5?1?@=-�&:>?1=5:=819?1� -> ;=J?5/-> 0:/19?1> 9:>� /:90@D5=-8� -

Page 34: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 2

/:9>501=-=� :� ;=:/1>>:� 050J?5/: 18;=13-0: 18� 05>/5;759->� <@1 -.-=<@18 -

?=505819>5:9-750-01� /:8: @8� 0:> 2-?:=1> 8-5>� 58;:=?-9?1 9N:� >U ;-=-� :

01>19A:7A5819?:� 1� 0:8S95:� 0-� 7593@-318� 1� =1;=1>19?-PN:� ;=:61?@-5>�� /:8:

?-8.Q8�0:>�;=:/1>>:>�/:395?5A:>�<@1�0N:�>@;:=?1�-�-8.->��;:0190:�2-A:=1/1= :@

7585?-=�:�01>18;194:�0:>�>@615?:>�;=:61?5>?-> 18�2:=8-PN:�

#:017-=� =17-/5:9-�>1� /:8� -� /-;-/50-01� 01� :.>1=A-=�� ;1=/1.1=� 1� /:8;=11901=

2:=8-> Y /:9?=-=5-90: -:>� <@1�� -:� 7:93:� 0-� 45>?U=5-� 1� /@7?@=-�01>539-8:>

5905AS0@:>�<@1�;:>>@18�@8-�4-.5750-01�8-9@-7 1>;1/5-7 /:8:�;:>>@50:=1>�01 0:9>

-=?S>?5/:> 59-?:>�� 0521=19/5-90:�:>� 0:>� 018-5>� 5905AS0@:>�� � ;1=/1;PN:� A5>@-7� Q�

;=:A-A17819?1��:�;=59/5;-7�=1<@5>5?:�;-=-�<@1�>1�;:>>-�01>19A:7A1=�1>>-�-?5A50-01�

;:01�>1=�?=159-0-�1�=1259-0-�

!:>Q )-=-8-3: 2=1<@19?1819?1 =1/:==1� H� 9:PN:� 01� :74-=� 1� >@->� 59X81=->

;:>>5.5750-01>� ;-=-� /:9>?=@5=� =-/5:/S95:>� =1271C5A:>�� 81?-2U=5/:>� 1� -713U=5/:>�� $:

=:8-9/1 ��������������� -�;1=/1;PN:�0:�:74-=�Q�=17-?5A-�-:�:.>1=A-0:=��Q�->>58

<@1�-�;1=>:9-318�&10=:�%=/1�:�/:9/1.1�-:�58-359-=�18�@8-�;10=-�->�2:=8->�01

@8-�18.-=/-PN:��-259-7�

����� /-0-� @8� 01� 9U>� AR� :�8@90:� /:8� :>�:74:>� <@1� ?18�� 1� :>� :74:>� AR18� :� <@1

<@1=18��:>�:74:>�2-D18�-�05A1=>50-01�0:�8@90:�1�2-.=5/-8�->�8-=-A574->��-590-

<@1�>16-8�01�;10=-��1�-7?->�;=:->��-590-�<@1�>16-8�01 57@>N:���!&������

$:�=:8-9/1 ����*����������������������� 19>59-�->�9@-9/1>�1�>@?571D->�0:�:74-=�

�%74-=�� A1=� 1� =1;-=-=� >N:� 8-915=->� 05>?59?->� 01� @>-=� :� U=3N:� 0-� A5>?-�� /-0-� <@-7

/:8�-�>@-�59?19>50-01�;=U;=5-��-?Q�9->�013191=-PW1>��;:=�1C18;7:��:74-=�>18 A1=�

<@-90:� @8-� ;1>>:-� >1� 19/:9?=-� 19>581>8-0-�� >5?@-PN:� /:8@8� 9:>� -9?53:>

=:8-9/1>��:@�A1=�1�9N:�0-=�;:=�5>>:��>1�:>�:74:>�;:=�/-9>-P:�:@�2->?5:�>1�01219018

01� >:.=1/-=3->� 59/V8:0->�� )U� :� =1;-=-=� ;:01� /413-=� -� >1=� A5>N:� ;719-�� <@-90:

9@8�;:9?:�01?1=859-0: :@�>@/1>>5A-819?1�-�-?19PN:�>1�/:9/19?=-��:�<@1�?-9?:

>@/101=J� ;:=� 1215?:� 0@8-� 0175.1=-PN:� 0-� A:9?-01� <@-9?:� ;:=� @8-� 1>;Q/51� 01

1>?-0:�>591>?Q>5/:�59A:7@9?J=5:�18�<@1�:�A5>?:�>:75/5?-�>1=�A5>?:�9:A-819?1��->>58

>1� ;->>-90:� 01� @8-� >19>-PN:� -� :@?=-�� =1?190:�� -==->?-90:� :� :74-=�� /:8:� >1� -

58-318�?5A1>>1�01�;=:0@D5=�>1�18�0:5>�7@3-=1>�05>?59?:>�0:�/Q=1.=:�/:8�0521=19P-

?18;:=-7� 01� @8� /19?Q>58:� 01� >13@90:�� ;=5815=:� :� >59-7� >58;7525/-0:�� 01;:5>� :

01>194:�=53:=:>:��-�012595PN:�9S?50-����� ���"������

Page 35: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 3

&-=-� >1=� -9-75>-0:� /:8� ;=:;=510-01�� : :.61?: 01A1� >1= 8-5>� <@1 A5>?:�� =1;-=-0:

01?-74-0-819?1�� *=-D1=� H� 7@D� 0-� =-DN:� /=S?5/-�� ?:=9-=� A5>SA17� -73:� :/@7?:� -73:

5905>>:7XA17�0:�58;@7>:�<@1�71A-�H�59?1=;=1?-PN:��H�-9J75>1��)190: :�:74:- 2=:9?15=-

8UA17� 1� -.1=?-� 19?=1� : 8@90:� 1C?1=9:� 1� :� >@615?:�� ?-9?:� =1/1.1� 1>?S8@7:>

7@859:>:>��7:3:��;:01�A1=��-590-�<@1�59A:7@9?-=5-819?1��<@-9?:�>1�8:A1�H�;=:/@=-

01�-73@8-�/:5>-��<@1�:�>@615?:� 5=J�05>?593@5=�� /:941/1=�:@�=1/:941/1=�� =1/:=?-=�0:

/:9?S9@:�0->�58-319>��8105=��012595=��/-=-/?1=5D-=��59?1=;=1?-=��18�>@8-��;19>-=�

�� =1;=1>19?-PN:� 3=J25/-� 8-9521>?-0- ;:=� 815: 0:� 01>194: ?:=9-�: :� 815:� 8-5>

@?575D-0:�0@=-9?1�-�;=:61?-PN:�-=<@5?1?V95/-��/:8:�>@;:=?1�/:395?5A:�1�21==-819?-

01�=135>?=:�1 -;=58:=-819?:�0- 5015-� �:8:�0125950:�;:=�"->1-@��������:�;=:/1>>:

01�01>194:�19A:7A1�:�:74:��-�819?1�1�-�8N:�18�@8�/5/7: =1-75819?-0:= /:9?S9@:�

%>�01>194:>�-=<@5?1?V95/:>�?R8�>50:�?18-�01�1C?19>:>�1>?@0:>�9:>�-9:>�=1/19?1>�

;:=Q8� -�81>8-�-25=8-?5A-�9N:�;:01�>1=�;:9?@-0-�<@-90:�:�?18-�Q�-�8:017-318�

�>� <@-750-01>� 59?=S9>1/->� 1� - >539525/-PN: 0->� 8-<@1?1>� -=<@5?1?V95/->� @?575D-0->

/:8:� 59>?=@819?:>� 01� -;=1905D-318� @95A1=>5?J=5-� 9-� 2:=8-PN:� -/-0R85/-� 2:=-8

1>/->>-819?1� =1/:941/50->� %.>1=A-�>1 <@1� - 8:017-318 ?18� 1>?-0:

01>/:91/?-0- 0-� 10@/-PN:� ;=:61?@-7�� <@1=� >16-;:=� 01>-=?5/@7-PN:� 01

;:>5/5:9-819?:� 0->� 05>/5;759->� 9-� 8-?=5D� /@==5/@7-=� 0:>� /@=>:>�� <@1=� ;:=� >1=18

/:9/1.50->�1� ?=-.-74-0->�/:8:�@8� 258�18�>5�81>8->� <@1= ;17:>�;=:/105819?:>

050J?5/:>�-0:?-0:>��2=1<@19?1819?1�=10@D50:>�H�?Q/95/-�

�> <@-750-01>� 0->� =17-PW1>� 19?=1� :� /:941/5819?:�� ;19>-819?:� 1� 05819>W1>� <@1

A-750-8� :>� 1C1=/S/5:>� ;=:61?@-5> /19?=-75D-8�>1� 9-� -9J75>1� 0-� ;=:.718J?5/-

;10-3U35/-� 9-� 2:=8-PN:� -/-0R85/-�%;=:/1>>:� 01 -;=1905D-318 ?=-9>5?-� 0:

/:9/=1?:� -:� -.>?=-?:�� -?=-AQ>� 0:� 01>19A:7A5819?:� 01 0521=19?1>� ;=:/1>>:>�

<@1=1/:941/1�->�;:>>5.5750-01>1�->� 7585?-PW1>�01�/-0- @8�0:>�815:>�18 2:/:���>

59?1=-PW1>�/:8;71819?-=1>�19?=1�-�8:017-318�8-?1=5-7��:�01>194:��-� 2:?:3=-25-�

->� >58@7-PW1>� 171?=V95/->�� ;:018� /:8;19>-=� ->� =1>?=5PW1>� 01� @8� 815:� 5>:7-0:�

-8;75-90:�->>58�->�;:>>5.5750-01>�01�05J7:3:�>:.=1�:�;=:61?:�

Page 36: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 4

�>>-�?1>1 ;=:;W1 /:8;-=?574-=�-73@8-> =1271CW1>�1�590-3-PW1>�>:.=1�-�8:017-318

?=505819>5:9-7 /:8:�815:�01�>@;:=?1�;-=-753-PN:�19?=1�-� 5015-�1�-�8-?1=5-750-01�

>>:� 58;75/-� 0539525/-=� 1� -;=1>19?-= >@->� ;:>>5.5750-01>18� >58@7-PW1>�� ;:>>5.575?-=

-?=-AQ>�01�012595PW1>�/=1>/19?1>�:� 71A-9?-819?:�0:�;=:.718-�-?Q�-�/:9/=1?5D-PN:

0:�;=:0@?:�259-7��<@1�>1 A-5�1>;1/525/-90:�9:�;=U;=5:�>-.1=�

��59?=:0@PN:�0-> 21==-819?->�/:8;@?-/5:9-5> 9-�-=<@5?1?@=- ?18�:/@;-0: ;:>5PN:

/19?=-7 9:� /:9?1C?:� 9-/5:9-7 01>01� :� 59S/5:� 0-� 0Q/-0-� 01 ��� >190:� ;-@?-� 01

59X81=->� 05>/@>>W1>�� �:� 7:93:� 01>?1>� -9:>�� -� ;=J?5/- =13@7-=0: ;=:61?:� -@C575-0:

;:=�/:8;@?-0:=�;1=85?5@ @8-�/:8;=119>N:�8-5>�=1-75>?-�01�>@->�;:>>5.5750-01>��1

01�>@->�7585?-PW1>��&->>-0- -�=-05/-75D-PN:�01�;:>5PW1>�1C?=18->�01�/:9?1>?-PN:�1

=1/@>- :=5359-90:� 01.-?1>� -/-7:=-0:>� 1� 05/:?V85/:>�-?@-7819?1� :>� 01.-?1>

/:9A1=318�;-=-�/:9253@=-PW1>�01�=17-PW1>�/:8;71819?-=1>�

%>� 59>?=@819?:>� 592:=8-?5D-0:>� /:7:/-=-8� 9:A->� <@1>?W1>� -� >1=18;19>-0->� 1

05>/@?50->�9:�L8.5?:�-/-0R85/:�;-=-�-?1901=�H�=1-750-01�0-�;=J?5/-�;=:25>>5:9-7�18

/:9>:750-PN:� %.>1=A-�>1 9N:� >:819?1 <@1 :� ;=:/1>>:� ;=:61?@-7� -=<@5?1?V95/:

1>?-A-� >@>/1?SA17� -� AJ=5->� 8:0525/-PW1>� 01� /-=J?1=� :;1=-/5:9-7�� 8->� ?-8.Q8� :>

;=:/1>>:>�/:395?5A:>�0:>�>@615?:>1>?-A-8�>@.81?50:>�-�9:A:>�/:9?1C?:>��A5>?:�<@1

:>� 59>?=@819?:>� 8105-0:=1>� 0535?-5>� @?575D-0:>� ;-=-� -� 8:017-318� :21=1/5-8

=1/@=>:>�59@>5?-0:>�18�=17-PN:�-:>�?=-05/5:9-5>�

$:� 19?-9?:�� ->� 21==-819?->� /:8;@?-/5:9-5>� ;-=-� 01>194:� 1� ;=:61?:� >N: =1/@=>:>

59>1=50:>� 5>:7-0-819?1�9-�8-5:=�;-=?1�0:>� /@=>:>�01�-=<@5?1?@=- -�/@6->�8-?=5D1>

/@==5/@7-=1>�?R8�>1 -/1>>:�

�:8@819?1�-�1C5>?R9/5-�01�@8-�05>/5;759-�05=5350-�-:�?=-.-74:�/:8�>:2?B-=1�;-=-

;=:0@PN:�01�=1;=1>19?-PW1>�.505819>5:9-5>� �;7-9?->��/:=?1>�� 2-/4-0->��>13@50-�01

Page 37: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 5

:@?=-�05>/5;759-�A:7?-0-�;-=-�->� =1;=1>19?-PW1>� ?=505819>5:9-5>� �8-<@1?1��;7J>?5/-

:@�9:819/7-?@=-�-259>� �

�:941/190:�->�/-=-/?1=S>?5/->��=1/@=>:>�1�;:>>5.5750-01>�0-�8:017-318��;->>-8:>

-� 9:>� <@1>?5:9-=� >:.=1� ->� =17-PW1>� 19?=1� :� @>:� 01>>-� 21==-819?-� 1� :

01>19A:7A5819?:�0-� /-;-/50-01�01� A5>@-75D-=�� ;1=/1.1=�� /:8;=11901=�1� 1C;=1>>-=

->�2:=8->�?=505819>5:9-5>�

%.>1=A-8:> 19?N: <@1�9-� ;=J?5/-� 0:� 19>59:� 9:� �=->57�: /:96@9?:� 0-> /5R9/5->� 0-

592:=8-PN: -590-�91/1>>5?-�=1>:7A1=�->�<@1>?W1>�0-�=1;=1>19?-PN:�?=505819>5:9-7�9-

-=<@5?1?@=-� �<@SA:/:>�01� 59?1=;=1?-PN:�913-8�18�-73@9>�/->:>�-�8-<@1?1�/:8:

59>?=@819?:� 01� -9J75>1� 1� 01� ;=:61?:�� =10@D50-2=1<@19?1819?1 -:� =1/@=>:� 01

-;=1>19?-PN:� 259-7� 01� @8� ;=:61?:� ;=1A5-819?1� 01?1=859-0:� 18� 2@90-819?-PW1>

.505819>5:9-5>� F1C-?-819?1�-�;-=?5=�01>?-�/:9>?-?-PN: <@1�>1�2-D�91/1>>J=5-�@8-

=1A5>N: 9:�;-;17�0-�8:017-318�2S>5/-�8-9@-7�9:�;=:/1>>:�01�;=:61?:�

&:018:>�-25=8-= Y -;:>5PN: 01�-@?:=1>� /:8:�"->1-@� ������ ��� &:=?1=� �����

���� 1 (:..59>���� �Y <@1�:�;=:/1>>:�/=5-?5A:�;=:61?@-7�-=<@5?1?V95/: 018-90- -

4-.5750-01� 01� ;1=/1.1=1� /:8;=11901=� 2:=8->� ?=505819>5:9-5>� 1� 1C;=1>>J�7->

3=-25/-819?1�18�=1;=1>19?-PW1>�.51�?=505819>5:9-5>��<@1 /413-8�- 59/:=;:=-=�:@

9N:� @8-� 7593@-318� 3=J25/-� >5>?18-?5D-0-� �19:859-�>11>>-4-.5750-01 01

/-;-/50-01� A5>5:3=J25/-�?=505819>5:9-7�� -� <@-7 18;=13- ->=1;=1>19?-PW1>� 3=J25/->

/:8: 2@90-819?-7 59>?=@819?:� 8105-0:=� 9:� ;=:/1>>:� 05-7U35/:� <@1� :;=:61?5>?-

1>?-.171/1� /:8� >@->� 5015->�;=:;:>?->� 01� /:9/1;PN:�>:7@PN:� 0:� ;=:.718-

;=:61?@-7�01A190:��;:=?-9?:��>1=�01>19A:7A50-> 1�17-.:=-0->�

1A pesquisa investigou as matrizes curriculares e ementas relacionadas ao tema maquete dos cursos dearquitetura e urbanismo do Brasil. Dos cursos da região Sudeste analisaram sedezessete cursos, que possuem asseguintes nomenclaturas disciplinares: introdução ao projeto, plástica, maquete, estudo da forma.

Page 38: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 6

� &(%�"�#�

�5;:?1?5/-819?1�-> -?5A50-01>�050J?5/->�9:>�-?175R>�01�;=:61?:��9:�;=5815=:�-9:�0->

1>/:7-> 01 -=<@5?1?@=-�� 71A-8� 18� /:9?-� 9-� >@-� ;=:;:>5PN:� <@1 :>� 1>?@0-9?1>

13=1>>:>� 9N:� >N:� /-;-D1>� 01� 192=19?-=� -0A1=>50-01>� 01� ;=:61?:� 01� 8-915=-

-@?:>>@25/519?1�� � -@>R9/5- 01� 4-.5750-01>� 1� /:941/5819?:>� .J>5/:>� ;-=-� <@1� :>

-7@9:>�;:>>-8�-A-9P-= /:395?5A-819?1 Q�@8�0521=19/5-7 /:8;-=-0:�/:8�->�?@=8->

8-5>� -05-9?-0->�� &:=� >@-� A1D�� 19?1901�>1� <@1 /-=?574->� 1� 3@5->� 01� 59?=:0@PN:� -:

;=:61?:�9N: ?18�/:9>13@50:�859585D-=�918�17@/50-=�1>>->�0525/@70-01>�595/5-5>�

%>�>-.1=1>�1>>19/5-5>�;-=-�-�;=J?5/-�0-�/:9/1;PN:�-=<@5?1?V95/-�9N:�>N:�-0<@5=50:>

>18�>@- :;1=-/5:9-75D-PN:� #1>8:�/:9>501=-90:�<@1�:�;=:21>>:=�0:8591�05A1=>:>

815:>�� ;=:;:>5PW1>� 01� >5?@-PW1>� 01� 19>59:� 1� ;:>>@-� =1/@=>:>� <@1� /:90@D-8� :>

-7@9:>�H =1271CN:�1�-:�/:941/5819?:�<@1�;1=85?-8�-�>@-�2:=8-?-PN:� *:0-A5-��->

/5=/@9>?L9/5-> /:?505-9->>13@18 >190:-8.S3@->�

%�01>19A:7A5819?:�/-;-/50-01 01�;1=/1.1=�1�/:8;=11901=�2:=8->�?=505819>5:9-5>

1>?J 1>?=15?-819?1� =17-/5:9-0:� -:� ;=:/1>>:� 01� 10@/-PN: >19>:=5-7 01� <@1� :

5905A50@: ;-=?5/5;-� -:� 7:93:� 0-� A50-�� 1�� 1>;1/5-7819?1�� 0@=-9?1� :� /@=>:� 01

-=<@5?1?@=-���>>58��;=1>>@;W1�>1�<@1�-�8-?=5D�01�/:9?1X0:>��-> 81?:0:7:35->�1�:>

59>?=@819?:> 3=J25/:>�-.-=/-0:> 9:�;=:/1>>:�;:?19/5-75D-8�:�01>19A:7A5819?:�0-

/-;-/50-01 01�A5>@-75D-PN: ?=505819>5:9-7�1�1>?-�;:01� 5927@19/5-=�;:>5?5A-819?1�:

;=:/1>>:�/=5-?5A: 0:�>@615?:��9-�81050-�18�<@1�-8;75-�>1@�;:?19/5-7�01�1C;=1>>N:�

��>5?@-PN:�>1�;=:.718-?5D-�;:=�->;1/?:>�=17-/5:9-0:>�- 1<@-PN:�0-�<@-9?50-01�01

2@90-819?:>�-�>1=18�-;=19050:>�A1=>@>�:�?18;:�;-=-�-;=190R�7:>��*-5>�/:905PW1>

58;75/-8� -� 1715PN:� 01� @8-� 81?:0:7:35- 01 >-.1=1>� 1>;1/S25/:>� :;?-90:� ;17-

1C/7@>N:�01�:@?=:>�

�:7:/-8�>1��;:=?-9?:��->�>13@59?1>�<@1>?W1>��&:=�<@1�2-D18:>�8-<@1?1>��'@-5>�->

=17-PW1>�19?=1�-�8:017-318�1�:�;=:61?:�$1/1>>5?-=5-8 :>�1>?@0-9?1> 01 59-@3@=-=

>@-� 2:=8-PN:� -;=190190:� -� 750-=� /:8� -� 591A5?JA17;=J?5/-� 0-� /:8;:>5PN:� 1

Page 39: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 7

8-95;@7-PN:� 0-� 2:=8-�� /::=019-90:� 815:>� 01� =1;=1>19?-PN:� 1� /:9/1;PW1> 01

>:7@PW1>� )1=5-� 2@90-819?-7� <@1� -9?1=5:=819?1� /:941/18� :>� 19/-8594-819?:>

0->� /:9253@=-PW1>� 1>;-/5-5>� 9:� 01>18;194:� 1� 9->� -?5A50-01>� 1C1=/50->� ;17:>

@>@J=5:>� 01� 1>;-P:� -� >1=18� ;=:61?-0:>���:9>501=-90:� 1>?@0-9?1>� 01� 81>8:

>181>?=1�9:�/@=>:�01�3=-0@-PN:� :>�<@1�?=-.-74-8�/:8�-�8:017-318�-;=1>19?-8

-� /-;-/50-01� A5>5:3=J25/-�?=505819>5:9-7� �9:� ?:0:� :@� 18� -73@8->� /-=-/?1=S>?5/->�

0521=19/5-0-� 0:>� <@1� 9N:� @>-8� 1>>-� 21==-819?-� *=-.-74-=� -� 8:017-318� /:8

1>?@0-9?1>� 595/5-9?1>�0:� /@=>:�01�-=<@5?1?@=-�;=:;:=/5:9-=5-�@8�/-8594:050J?5/:

8-5>� 125/519?1� 1� =J;50:� 01� 01>19A:7A5819?:� 0-� /-;-/50-01� 01� A5>@-750-01� 18

=17-PN:�-:>�;=:/1>>:>�01�19>59:�-;=1905D-318�?=-05/5:9-5>�

%>�1>?@0-9?1>�01A1=5-8�18�@8�;=5815=:�8:819?:�=1/1.1=�@8 =1;1=?U=5:�� >1=18

/-;-D1>� 01� -;=1901=� :� 19>59-819?:� :21=1/50:� ;17:� >-.1=� -=<@5?1?V95/:� 2=19?1 H

:.>1=A-PN:� 1� -9J75>1� 01� -9?1/1019?1>�� =17-/5:9-=�>1� /:>?@815=-819?1� /:8� -

7593@-318� 01� -=<@5?1?:>� ;-=-0538J?5/:>� 1� /:941/1= ->� >:7@PW1>� ;-=-� ;=:.718->

<@1� >1=N:� =1/:==19?1>� 9-� >@-� ;=J?5/-� �1A1=5-8 A1=�>1� /-;-D1>� 01� /:9/1.1=� 1

2-.=5/-=� -=?12-?:>�� 5927@5=� 05=1?-819?1 /:8� -� 8-?Q=5-/:9?-?-90:�- 1� -;=1901=

8-915=->�01�-7?1=J�7-���1A1=5-8�/:941/1=�:>�2@90-819?:>�?Q/95/:>�0:�10525/-=�1�->

2:=P->�<@1�-?@-8�>:.=1�->�1>?=@?@=->� �1A1=5-8�171>�=1/:941/1=�-�;=11C5>?R9/5- 01

/:9?1X0:> <@1� >1=N:� ?=-9>2:=8-0->� 18� >1@� ?=-.-74:�� /:8;=11901=� >@-� 45>?U=5-�

8:=2:7:35-��171819?:>�1�059L85/->�>:/5-5>��>-.1= /:8: =1;=1>19?J�7->��-9-75>J�7->�1

05-39:>?5/-=�>1@>�;=:.718->�;-=-�;:01=�;=:;:=�59?1=A19PW1>�%@�01A1=5-8��18�@8

;=5815=:� 8:819?:�� >1=� /-;-D1>� 01� 7-9P-=� :74-=1>� >:.=1� -� 1C;1=5R9/5-� <@1� ->

;1>>:->� /:8@9>� ?R8� 0-� -=<@5?1?@=-� 1� 0-� /50-01�� 590-3-=�>1� >:.=1� :>

-/:9?1/5819?:>�1�->�>@.61?5A50-01>�<@1�>1 A118 ;=:0@D5=�9-�=17-PN:�0:>�5905AS0@:>

/:8� :� -8.519?1� /:9>?=@S0:�� /:941/1= :� -7/-9/1� 1� :>� 7585?1>0:� ?=-.-74:� 0:

-=<@5?1?:�9:�8@90:�18�<@1�A5A1�

F� 91>>1 ;-9:=-8-<@1 -27:=--� <@1>?N: /19?=-7� 0:� ?=-.-74: � ;:>?:� :� ;=:.718- �

59A1>?53-8:>>:.=1� -> 1715PW1> 01� /:9?1X0:> 9-� ?=-9>85>>N:� 01� /:941/5819?:>

;=175859-=1>� 0:� 19?1905819?: -=<@5?1?V95/:�)18� - ;=1?19>N:� 01� >:7@/5:9-=� :>

Page 40: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 8

;=:.718->�� 7-9P-0:� 1>?J� :� ;1=/@=>:� ;=1?19050:� -� >1=� ?=574-0:� 1� 01A1=J� >1=

;1=/:==50:�/:8�/-@?17-�1�-8;-=-0:�;17- ;1><@5>-�.5.75:3=J25/- <@1�/:9?1C?@-75D- :

:.61?:Y: 8:017:� ?=505819>5:9-79:� ;-9:=-8-� 0:� 19>59: 01� ;=:61?:� -=<@5?1?V95/:�

%.61?5A-90:� ;:?19/5-75D-=� :>� :.61?:>� ?=505819>5:9-5>� /:8:� 21==-819?-� ;-=-� -

/:9/1;PN:�-=<@5?1?V95/-� .@>/-8�>1 81?:0:7:35->�01�19>59:;=:;:>?->9-�05>/5;759-

01� 59?=:0@PN:� -:� ;=:61?:� 9:� ;=5815=:� >181>?=1 9:� /@=>:� 01� -=<@5?1?@=-� 0-

&:9?52S/5-�+95A1=>50-01��-?U75/-�0:�(5:�01�!-915=:�

�� )%�(��% %�!�*%�����)*+�%

�1>/=5?:� :� ;=:.718-� 0:� ?=-.-74:� /:8;1?1 ;=:/101=� -� -73@9>� 1>/7-=1/5819?:>

-/1=/-�0:�>1@ :.61?: 01�1>?@0:��:>�/:9?1X0:> 050J?5/:> 0->�;=J?5/->�9:�19>59:�01

59?=:0@PN:� H� /:9/1;PN: -=<@5?1?V95/-� 9-� &+��(!/:8� R92->1� 9-� 8:017-318�

&=5815=-819?1 2-D�>1� 91/1>>J=5: -;:9?-=: <@1� >1� 19?1901� ;:= 8:017-318

?=505819>5:9-7� 1;:= /:9?1X0:� 01� 19>59: 9-� 1>21=- 0-� /:9/1;PN:� -=<@5?1?V95/-� �

;-=?5= 0- ;=1>>@;:>5PN: 01�<@1�18�@8-�;=J?5/-�050J?5/-�:>�/:9?1X0:>�9N:�=181?18

-;19->�-� 592:=8-PW1>�:@�0-0:>�<@1�01A18�>1=�?=-9>85?50:>�-:>�1>?@0-9?1>�1�;:=

171>�/:9?50:>���8.:=-�1>?-�;:>>-�>1= @8-�01�>@-> /:9253@=-PW1>��17-�9N:�/:9?18;7-

:�<@1�4J�01�8-5>�=1>539525/-?5A: 9-�/:9/1;PN:�-=<@5?1?V95/-��:�/:941/5819?:�/:8:

;=J?5/-� �8;=13-90:� :� ;=:/1>>: /:9>?=@?5A5>?-� :901 :>� /:9?1X0:> >1=N:� -<@5

19?19050:>� /:8:� >59V958:>� 0:>� /:941/5819?:> Y ;:?19/5-7819?1 Y /:9>?=@S0:>

;17:�1>?@0-9?1�;:=�815:�0->�;=J?5/->�050J?5/->��:@� >16-��-<@57:�<@1� >1�;:01=J�A1=

;=:0@D50: ;17: -7@9: 18�/1=?:�1C1=/S/5:� >?:� 58;75/-�1>/7-=1/1=�:�<@1� >1�19?1901

;:=�/:941/5819?:�1�/:8:�171�>1�8-9521>?-�9-�;=J?5/-�0-�/:9/1;PN:�-=<@5?1?V95/-�

�>?1�?18-�>1=J�-.:=0-0:�9: >1C?: /-;S?@7: /:8�-@CS75:�01 ?1:=5-> 1�;=J?5/-> >:.=1�:

;=:/1>>:�01�/:9/1;PN:�18�-=<@5?1?@=-�

+8-� ;1=>;1/?5A-� -9J7:3- 0-� 012595PN:� 0:� :.61?: 01� 1>?@0:� <@1� 018-90-

1>/7-=1/5819?:� Q� : ������� ��� ������ '%�� #� ������'%�� ��� ����,����1� -

�����������8.->�>N:�/:9?1X0:> 01�19>59:�05>/5;759->� 58;7-9?-0->�9:>�;=5815=:>

Page 41: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 9

-9:>�0:�/@=>:�01�-=<@5?1?@=-�1�@=.-95>8: ;-=-�-<@171> <@1�01.@?-8 9:�-?175R�01

;=:61?:�

�=1<@19?1819?1� ->� ;=J?5/->� 595/5-5>� 01� ;=:61?-PN:� -0:?-8� 1>>-� ;=J?5/- ;:=� 9N:

;=:8:A1=� 1C1=/S/5:>� 01� ;=:61?:� ;=:;=5-819?1� 05?:>� -;:9?-90: 18� >1@� 7@3-=

-?5A50-01>� 050J?5/->� <@1� A5>-8� 19>59-=� 2@90-819?:>� ;=:;10R@?5/:>� /:9>501=-0:>

5905>;19>JA15> ;-=-� ->� ;=J?5/->0:>� ;1=S:0:>� >@.>1<@19?1>� ����� '%�� ��� �������

��� ����,����� ��������������� �������������������'%�������������� ����,���� >N:

-> 9:819/7-?@=-> =1/:==19?1�0->��05>/5;759->�18�<@1>?N:�

�59-7819?1� -;:9?-= <@1�:�:.61?:�01�1>?@0:�>1�>5?@-�9:�L8.5?:�01�@8-�X95/-�1>/:7-

01� -=<@5?1?@=-� .=->5715=-� 9N:� >539525/-� <@1� >1� ;=1?1901 19-7?1/R�7-� /:8:� 8Q?:0:

592-7SA17� 9->� ;=J?5/->� 01� 19>59:� 01� 59?=:0@PN:� -� /:9/1;PN:� -=<@5?1?V95/-�

(1>>-7?-8:>� <@1-� =1A5>N:� 0-� 75?1=-?@=-� 18� <@1� >1� -;=1>19?-� -� 1A:7@PN:� 0-

?18J?5/-��>@-�;=:.718-?5D-PN:�1�=171AL9/5-�;-=-�:�/-8;:�0:�:.61?:�1>?@0-0:�/:8:

:.61?:�01�59A1>?53-PN:��1>?-=N:�9->�@7?58->�7-@0->�

�� %�!�* ,%)

%� :.61?5A: 01>?-� ?1>1 QA1=525/-=� ;:=� 815:� 1C-859-?U=5:�� @8-� >@/1>>N:� 01

1C1=/S/5:>050J?5/:>�� 5019?525/-= =13@7-=50-01>� 19?=1� >1@>� /:9?1X0:>� ;1=85?590:� :

7-9P-819?:� 01� <@1>?W1>� -� =1>;15?: 0->� 1>/:74->� <@1� /:9>?5?@18 :� 1>?@0:

;=175859-= 0-�/:9/1;PN:�-=<@5?1?V95/-�

�7Q8� 01>?1� :.61?5A:� ;=59/5;-7�� 1>?-.171/1=-8�>1� -73@9>� :.61?5A:>� ;-=/5-5>� <@1

:=519?-=-8� -� /:9>?=@PN:� 1� :� 01>19A:7A5819?:� 01� /-0-� @8� 0:>� /-;S?@7:>� <@1

/:9>?5?@18�:�?=-.-74:�

Page 42: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 10

�8�=1>@8:��:�1>?@0: 0-�Z8:017-318�?=505819>5:9-7�/:8:�-319?1�9:�19>59:�

-;=1905D-318�9->�05>/5;759->�59?=:0@?U=5->�01�;=:61?:�01�-=<@5?1?@=-[�>13@5=J�:>

>13@59?1>�;->>:>�

Y 019?525/-PN:�0->�?1=859:7:35->�=17-/5:9-0->�-:�?18-�/:9A19PN:�01>19A:7A50-�;-=- -�7593@-318�0-�-=<@5?1?@=-��

�Y �;=1>19?-PN:�0-�45>?U=5-�01�8:017:>�1�8-<@1?1>�

�Y (1A5>N:�0:>�>@;:=?1>�=1/1;?5A:>��;:= 815:�58;=1>>:��0535?-71�8:>?=-�;X.75/-�

Y 019?525/-PN:� 0:>� ;=:/1>>:>� 01� /=5-PN:� 9->� -?5A50-01>-=?S>?5/->�

�Y (1/:941/5819?:� 0: ;=:/1>>:� 01� /=5-PN:�� 9-?@=-7� H>-?5A50-01>�-=?S>?5/->�1�1C;=1>>N:�;=U;=5-�0-�-=<@5?1?@=-�

�Y &=:;:>5PN:� 01� @8-� >1<@19/5-� 01� ;->>:>� 18;=13-90:=1/@=>:>�0-�8:017-318�?=505819>5:9-7�2S>5/-�

� ?1>1�Q�-;=1>19?-0-�18 :5?: ;-=?1>�

Y 9?=:0@PN:�

� Y (1A190: �:9/15?:>�

� Y %�@>:�0:�8:017:�-:�7:93:�0:>�-9:>��45>?U=5-��

Y #:017:>�?=505819>5:9-5>��@8-�7594-�/:8@8��=1A5>W1>��

� Y �=?12-?:�1� 8-359-PN:�

� Y ,5>N:�1��:941/5819?:�

� Y (1271CN:�-�;-=?5=�01�@8-�1C;1=5R9/5-�0:/19?1�� 59?=:0@PN:-:�;=:61?:�01�-=<@5?1?@=-��E�;1=S:0:�&+� Y (5:�

� Y �:9/7@>W1>�

(121=R9/5-�

�7:>>J=5:�

�91C:�

%�/:9?1X0: 59?=:0@?U=5: 0:�;=5815=:�/-;S?@7:� 1C;75/-�:>�8:?5A:>�0-�=1-75D-PN:�0:

1>?@0: 192-?5D-90:� :� ;:9?:� 01� ;-=?50-� 1� :� 01� /413-0-� 01>?-/-90: >@-

Page 43: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 11

58;:=?L9/5-��:=91/190:� -9?1/1019?1>� 6@>?525/-?5A:> 9:>� <@-5>� ->� <@1>?W1>

;1=?5919?1>�>1=N:�018:9>?=-0->�

% >13@90: /-;S?@7:>1 05=1/5:9- ;-=-�- ;=:;:>5PN:�01�=1@95=�1�59?1=;=1?-=�:�8:017:

?=505819>5:9-7�18�@8-�;1=>;1/?5A-�01�>@-�:=5318�1�9:819/7-?@=-�

%?1=/15=:�/-;S?@7: 1C;W1�@8�45>?U=5/:�-/1=/-�0-�1A:7@PN: 0:>�8:017:>

?=505819>5:9-5>��=1>>-7?-90:�-�9:?-PN:�01�/:9/1;PN:�/:8:�@8-�0->�;=5815=->

2:=8->�01�1C;=1>>N:�1�5905/- :�;1=/@=>:�45>?U=5/:�0->�8-<@1?1>�1�8:017:>�-?=-AQ>

0:> -/:9?1/5819?:>�>:/5-5>��1/:9V85/:>�1�-=<@5?1?V95/:>�

&-=-� :� 01>19A:7A5819?:� 0-� ?1>1� 9:� <@-=?:� /-;S?@7:� 2:=-8 =17-/5:9-0->

595/5-7819?1� @8-� =1A5>N:� 75?1=J=5-� 1� @8-� ;1><@5>-� .5.75:3=J25/-� -.:=0-90:� :>

->>@9?:>� 1>;1/S25/:>� 1 :>� ->>@9?:>� /:91C:>� <@1� 5019?525/-=N:� 1� ;:?19/5-75D-=N:� :

19?1905819?:� 0:>� 8:017:>� ?=505819>5:9-5>� � �!��%� /:9?18;7:@� :>� >@;:=?1>

=1/1;?5A:>�� ;:= 815:� 58;=1>>:� �/:8:� /5?-8:>� -9?1=5:=819?1��� 815:>� 0535?-5>

�-;:9?-90:�;-=-�>5?1>�=171A-9?1>�9-�J=1-��1�8:>?=-�;X.75/-��1C;:>5PW1>�1�1C5.5PW1>��

*:=9-�>1� ;1=?5919?1� 1A5019/5-=� <@1� -� =121=R9/5-� H 1>21=-� 0:>� 8:017:>

?=505819>5:9-5>� 01A1�>1� -� 59?19PN:� 01� 1C;7:=J�7:>� /:8: 05>;:>5?5A:>� -@C575-=1>� 01

=1;=1>19?-PW1> -9?1 @8�4:=5D:9?1�/:8@8�-�;=J?5/-�;=:61?@-7��*-5>�/:9?1X0:>2-D18

;-=?1� 0:� /-;S?@7:� /59/:�% ;=:/1>>:� 01� /=5-PN:�� 9-?@=-7� H>� -?5A50-01>� -=?S>?5/->�� -

-=<@5?1?@=-�-;=1>19?-�@8-�2:=8-�;=U;=5-�01�>1�1C;=1>>-=��)@-�1C;=1>>N:�01;1901

01� @8� >5>?18-� .->1-0: 18� >S8.:7:>� 3=J25/:>� 1� 171819?:>� =1;=1>19?-?5A:>� <@1

?=-0@D18�� 0-� 8-915=-� 8-5>� /7-=-� ;:>>SA17�� >1@� /:9/15?:� :@� 5015-� -=<@5?1?V95/-� %

/-;S?@7: A5>- -� 1>?@0-=� ->� :=5319>� 1� 0:� ;-;17� 01� 8-<@1?1>� 1� 8:017:>

?=505819>5:9-5>� /:8@9> H> 2-9?->5->�� ->� 1>;1/@7-PW1> 1� :>� -9-/=:95>8:>�� <@1

31=-7819?1�?=-9>;W18�2:=8->�8:01=9->�0:�?=-.-74:�01�-=<@5?1?:>�-:�;->>-0:�1�H>

/@7?@=->�/:9>?=@?5A->�?=-05/5:9-5>�

%� /-;S?@7:� >15> -;=1>19?-� -� 8:017-318� >5?@-0-� /:8:� 815:� 01� 05J7:3:� 19?=1� ->

2:=8->�819?-5>�0:�;19>-819?:�1�->�2:=8->�8-?1=5-5>�1C?1=9-> � A5>N:��;:0190:�>1=

;1=/1.50->�1�;1=/:==50->�-?=-AQ>�01�-73@9>�>19?50:>�/:8:�-�A5>N:�1�:�?-?:�

Page 44: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 12

%�/-;S?@7: >Q?58:�/-;S?@7:�59?5?@7-0: ����"%�������������� ����"����(������������

?18 ;:=� :.61?5A:� /:9>?=@5=� @8-� .->1� ?1U=5/-� <@1� ;1=85?-� -.:=0-=� :� ?18-� 0:

/:941/5819?:� 9-� ;=J?5/-� 0:� ;=:61?:� 1� >1@� 19>59:� 59?=:0@?U=5: -:� /@=>:� 01

-=<@5?1?@=-�% =1/:=?1�;=:;:>?: 9- ;1><@5>-�18;S=5/-� >1=J� -.:=0-0:� 6@9?:� /:8�->

;=:;:>?-> 81?:0:7U35/->� -;=1>19?-0->��>� ;=J?5/->� 050J?5/->� A59/@7-0->� -� /-0-

1?-;- >1=N:� /:9>501=-0->� 18� /:96@9?:� /:8� ;:>5PW1>� ?1U=5/->� 1� -.:=0-319>

/:9/1;?5A->� 1� -� 17->� A59/@7-0->� %� /-;S?@7: ?=-?-=J� 0-� -.:=0-318� 81?:0:7U35/-

10:>� /=5?Q=5:>� @?575D-0:> ;-=-� 012595PN:� 0:� =1/:=?1� 0- ;1><@5>-�� ->>58� /:8: :>

8Q?:0:>�1�21==-819?->�18;=13-0:> 1 -> -9J75>1>�0:>�1C1=/S/5:>� )1<@19/5-7819?1

?18�>1 ;:=�:.61?5A:�1C;:= -�;=:0@PN: 31=-0-�9-01>/=5PN: 1C;:>5PN:��-;=1>19?-PN:

1� 018:9>?=-PN: 0:>� 0-0:>�� ?=-D190: 01>/=5PW1>� 0:>� 1C1=/S/5:>� 1C-859-0:>

-3=@;-0->� 18 0521=19?1>� ->;1/?:> /:==1>;:90190:� -:>� ?5;:>� 01 /:9?1X0:>� <@1

;1=85?18� ;=:0@D5=� 9?1=1>>-� -<@5� 1C;7:=-=� :� ->;1/?:� 1>;1/S25/:� 0-� =1;=1>19?-PN:

?=505819>5:9-7�0-�-=<@5?1?@=-��18�>@->�/-=-/?1=S>?5/->�1�;:>>5.5750-01>�

� !+)* � ��* ,�

%�-=3@819?: 01�59A1>?53-=�;=J?5/->�050J?5/-> /:8�:�@>:�01�8:017:>�?=505819>5:9-5>

9:� 19>59:� 01� 59?=:0@PN:� H� /:9/1;PN:� -=<@5?1?V95/-� 1 =1/:941/1=>1@>� /:9?1X0:>

?18 58;:=?L9/5-�;-=?5/@7-=9-�59>1=PN: 0:�-8.519?1�-/-0R85/:� &=58:=05-7819?1��:

?=-.-74:;:>>5.575?-=J 01>/=1A1=�05>/@?5=;=J?5/-> 1 8Q?:0:>� 050J?5/:>

<@1�;:>>5A17819?1 9N:�>1=5-81C;7:=-0:> 2:=-�0:>� 7585?1>�0-�1>/:7-�:@�81>8:�0:

01;-=?-819?:�-�<@1�1>?N:�A59/@7-0->�

�:8�5>>:�;=1?1901�>1�/:9?=5.@5=��;:=�59?1=8Q05:�0-�/5=/@7-PN:�01�592:=8-PN:��;-=-

-�;=:0@PN:�01�/:941/5819?:�1=1271CN:�-/1=/-�01�;=J?5/->�01�19>59:�%�:.61?5A:�0-

?1>1�� ;:=Q8�� 9N:� Q� 2:=91/1=� >@.>S05:>� ;-=-� -=1;=:0@PN:� :@� :� 18;=13:� 01

1>?=-?Q35->�050J?5/->�$N:�>1�;=1?1901 2@90-819?-= - 58;:=?L9/5- 0:�?=-.-74:�/:8

@8� A:?: 01� :;1=-/5:9-750-01� 9: L8.5?: 0119>59:�� 8->� >58 -?=-AQ>� 01 >@-

/:7-.:=-PN: ;-=- :�<@1>?5:9-819?: 0-> :;PW1>�;10-3U35/->�

Page 45: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 13

�� 58;:=?L9/5-�01�@8-� =1271CN:�/=S?5/-� >:.=1�->�;=J?5/->�01 @>:�0-�8:017-318�9:

19>59:� >1� 6@>?525/-=5-� ;17:� 19?1905819?:� 01� <@1->� 1>/:74->� 050J?5/->� /:9>?5?@18

=1.-?5819?:>��01�0521=19?1>�;:>5PW1>;=1>19?1>�9:�/-8;:�05>/5;759-=�0-�-=<@5?1?@=-�

&:>?:>� 9-� 259-75D-PN:� 0:� /-;S?@7:� >1?1 :>� /:9?1X0:>� ;=1>19?1>� 9:� 19>59:� 01

59?=:0@PN:� H� /:9/1;PN:� -=<@5?1?V95/-� 9N: >1 /:35?-� -1C/7@0R9/5--� ;=5:=5�� 8->

/:8;71819?-=50-01��%-3=@;-819?: 01 <@1>?W1>�-;=1>19?-0->Q�?=-?-0: 91>?-�?1>1

/:8�4:=5D:9?-750-01� :@�>16-�>18�@8-�451=-=<@5D-PN:�01�A-7:=�

�>� ;=J?5/->� 05>/@=>5A-> 59A1>?53-0->� 9:� L8.5?:� -/-0R85/: ?1=859-8 ;:=� -21?-=� ->

;=J?5/->�01�/:9/1;PN:�-=<@5?1?V95/-���>>58��->�=1271CW1>�;=:;:>?->�-<@5��18.:=-�>1

05=56-8� -:� 19>59:� 18� 9SA17� 59?=:0@?U=5:�� ?-7A1D� ;:>>-8� /:9?=5.@5=� ;=:A:/-90:

<@1>?5:9-819?:>�9-�05=1PN:�01�>1�/:9?=-;:=�31>?:>�;=:61?@-5>�01�8174:=�125/J/5-�

$194@8-�01>?->�590-3-PW1>�>1=5-�;:>>SA17�>18�-�1C;1=5R9/5-�0-�8:017-318�91>?1>

0:>�A59?1�1�;:@/:>�-9:>�01�8-35>?Q=5:�?=-.-74-90:�/:9/:85?-9?1819?1�18�<@-?=:

@95A1=>50-01>�

�-.1�=1>>-7?-=�-�4-.575?-PN:�01�?=-9>5?-=�;:=�1>21=->�.-75D-0->�;:=�05A1=>->�A5>5?->�-

@95A1=>50-01>�9:��=->57�1�9:�1C?1=5:=��->>58�/:8:�@8-�=1/1;PN:�>18;=1�-8JA17�01

-73@9>� S/:91>� 0-� -=<@5?1?@=-� 9-/5:9-7� 1� 8@905-7� <@1� >1� @?575D-8� 0:>� 8:017:>

?=505819>5:9-5> 18�>1@>�;=:/1>>:>�/=5-?5A:>�

Page 46: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 14

�EC <H;GK_D9?7�� GK7D:E� I;� :;I;@7 7B97D]7H� 7� C7=D?JK:;�� E� GK;� J;C� :?C;DId;I

CK?JE� C;DEH;I� GK;� E� J7C7D>E� D7JKH7B� DEI� 7<?=KH7� C7?I 79;II`L;B� � <7I9?D7][E

F;B7I� C?D?7JKH7I� ;D9EDJH7�� D7I� H7`P;I�� E� I;DJ?C;DJE� :; :EC`D?E GK;� ;IJ7I

?D<KD:;C�(�CKD:E�C?D?7JKH?P7:E�DEI�9ED<;H;�KC7 I;DI7][E�:;�FE:;H��^�C7?I�<W9?B

9EDJHEBW�BE�;�C7D?FKBW�BE��E8I;HLW�BE�;�;DJ;D:_�BE�&7?I�7?D:7��GK7D:E�<78H?97CEI

7 C?D?7JKH7� 7J?D=?CEI� KC7� H;B7][E� FH?L7:7� GK;� B;L7� ?CFB`9?J7� 7� I;DI7][E� :;

FHEN?C?:7:;��:;�?DJ?C?:7:;�#W�GK;�I; JH7J7�:;�7B=E�J[E�9ED9H;JE�;�eJ?B�9ECE�7�HE:7�

EK� :;� KC7� L;H:7:;�C7?I� 78IJH7J7� ;� IKJ?B�� EI� :;I9E8H?C;DJEI� GK;� H;7B?P7CEI� FEH

C;?E�:;II;I�CE:;BEI FE:;C�7IIKC?H�KC�L7BEH�:;�C7?EH;I�FHEFEH]d;I�'7�?D<YD9?7�

:;I;DLEBL;CEI� DEII7I� DE]d;I� :E� ;DJEHDE� FEH� C;?E� :; C?D?7JKH7I� �7I7I� :;

8ED;97I��<EHJ?<?97]d;I��I?IJ;C7I�<;HHEL?WH?EI�I[E�7I�F7?I7=;DI�C?DeI9KB7I�F;B7I GK7?I

L;CEI�H;7B?P7:EI�DEIIEI�:;I9E8H?C;DJEI�; H;B7]d;I ?D<7DJ?I

�EC�E�7L7D]E�:7I�J;9DEBE=?7I��7�8KI97�:;�DEL7I�J^9D?97I�GK;�E<;H;]7C�UI�9H?7D]7I

KC�7FH;D:?P7:E�C7?I�;DLEBL;DJ;��9H?7J?LE�;�CEJ?L7:EH�L;C�I;�JEHD7D:E�9ECKC�FEH

F7HJ;� :EI� F7?I� ;� ;:K97:EH;I� �;IJ7� <EHC7�� L7BEH;I� 9ECE� >78?B?:7:;I� ;

9ECF;J_D9?7I��GK;�FE:;C�I;H�7:GK?H?:EI�D7�;I9EB7�;�B;L7:EI�F7H7�JE:7�7�L?:7��I[E�7

97:7�:?7��C7?I�L7BEH?P7:EI��7I;7:E�D;IJ7I�D;9;II?:7:;I�;�D7�<EHC7�:;�;NFBEH7H�;

:;I;DLEBL;H�7� ?C7=?D7][E�:7I�9H?7D]7I��>E@; 7�7KJEH7�9ECFH;;D:; E�;CF;D>E�:;

C;KI� F7?I� ;C� FHEF?9?7H� KC� 7C8?;DJ;� Be:?9E� 9EC� 7I� F;]7I� :7� )(%%2� �<?=� ��� �

8H?DGK;:E� :;� CEDJ7H FHE:KP?:E F;B7� �W8H?97� �IJH;B7� DEI 7DEI ���� f 9EC� 7

��������������

Page 47: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 15

<?D7B?:7:;�:;�:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:7I�97F79?J7]d;I (�GK;�H;C;J; 7�;II7 ;NF;H?_D9?7

:;�?D<YD9?7�^�H;JH7J7:E 9ECE�7B=E�GK;�I;�;IJ;D:;�7�EKJH7I L?L_D9?7I :;�?D<YD9?7

�;BEHI� ������� �� �� 7FEDJ7� GK;� 7� FHWJ?97� F;:7=b=?97� :;L;� FH;E9KF7H�I;� ;C

:;I;DLEBL;H�GK7JHE�7FH;D:?P7=;DI�<KD:7C;DJ7?I��GK;�I;H[E�F7H7�97:7�?D:?L`:KE�EI

F?B7H;I�:E�9ED>;9?C;DJE��7FH;D:;H�7�9ED>;9;H�?D:?97�E�?DJ;H;II;��7�78;HJKH7�F7H7�7

8KI97� :E� 7KJE9ED>;9?C;DJE� 7KJE;IJ?C7�� F;DI7C;DJE� 9H`J?9E� ;� 9H?7J?L?:7:;�

7FH;D:;H�7� <7P;H CEIJH7�7�9EH7=;C�:;�;N;9KJ7H��:;�9EHH;H�H?I9EI��:;�;HH7H�C;ICE

D7�8KI97�:;�79;HJ7H��7FH;D:;H�7�9EDL?L;H�JH7P�E :;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:7�F;H9;F][E�:7

?DJ;H:;F;D:_D9?7 :;I7<?E�:7�9EDL?L_D9?7�GK;�7FH;I;DJ7�E��H;IF;?JE�;�L7BEH?P7][E�:E

FHbN?CE ;� E� ;N;H9`9?E� :;� <H7J;HD?:7:;� 9ECE� 97C?D>E� :E� ;DJ;D:?C;DJE�� ;�

<?D7BC;DJ;��7FH;D:;H�7�I;H� FHE9KH7D:E E�F7F;B�:;�9?:7:[E�;�E�E8@;J?LE�:;�L?L;H

1 Jacques Delors, autor e organizador do relatório para a UNESCO da Comissão Internacional sobre Educação para o século XXI, intitulado: Educação,um Tesouro a descobrir (1996), em que se exploram os Quatro Pilares da Educação,

�?=KH7�������7KJEH7�9EC�KC�7DE�:;�?:7:;�7E�<KD:E�;�E�8H?DGK;:E :;�CEDJ7H�)(%2�EDJ;���EJE �B<H;:E� 7H9?7�+EP7������

Page 48: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 16

��FEII?8?B?:7:;�:;�8H?D97H�9EC�KC�E8@;JE�^�GK;�<7P�:;B;�KC�8H?DGK;:E� ?D:KP?D:E 7

?C7=?D7][E��9H?7][E�;�?DJ;H7][E 'E�7JE�:;�8H?D97H� EI�I?D7?I��EI�=;IJEI��EI�E8@;JEI�;

EI�;IF7]EI�L7B;C�;�I?=D?<?97C�EKJH7�9E?I7�:7GK?BE�GK;�7F7H;DJ7C�I;H��<?=�� �

�E� 8H?D97H� 7I� 9H?7D]7I� H;9H?7C� ;� H;F;DI7C� EI� 79EDJ;9?C;DJEI� GK;� B>;I� :;H7C

EH?=;C�� I78;D:E� GK;� ;IJ[E� 8H?D97D:E� (I� 9ED>;9?C;DJEI :7� 9H?7D]7� FHEL_C� :7

?C?J7][E�:;�7B=K^C�EK�:;�7B=E�9ED>;9?:E��:;�KC7�;NF;H?_D9?7�L?L?:7�D7�<7C`B?7�EK

;C�EKJHEI�7C8?;DJ;I��:E�H;B7JE�:;�KC�9EB;=7�EK�:;�KC�7:KBJE��:;�9;D7I�7II?IJ?:7I

D7� J;B;L?I[E�� DE� 9?D;C7�EK�D7HH7:7I�;C� B?LHEI� S�DE�7JE�:;�8H?D97H�GK;�7 9H?7D]7

;IJ78;B;9;�EI�:?<;H;DJ;I�L`D9KBEI�;DJH;�7I� 97H79J;H`IJ?97I�:E�F7F;B�7IIKC?:E�� IK7I

9ECF;J_D9?7I�;�7I�H;B7]d;I�GK;�FEIIK;C�9EC�EKJHEI�F7F^?I��JEC7D:E�9EDI9?_D9?7

:?IJE�;�=;D;H7B?P7D:E�F7H7�EKJH7I�I?JK7]d;I�)7H7�8H?D97H�^�FH;9?IE�GK;�7I�9H?7D]7I

J;D>7C�9;HJ7�?D:;F;D:_D9?7�F7H7�;I9EB>;H�I;KI�9ECF7D>;?HEI�;�EI�F7F^?I�GK;�?H[E

7IIKC?H� DE� ?DJ;H?EH� :;� KC� :;J;HC?D7:E� J;C7� ;� ;DH;:E�� 9K@EI� :;I;DLEBL?C;DJEI

:;F;D:;C�KD?97C;DJ;�:7�LEDJ7:;�:;�GK;C�8H?D97

�?=KH7�� � #E=EI�?D<7DJ?I � �HK;=>;B���� � � ������ F?DJEH�<B7C;D=E�+;D7I9;DJ?IJ7 �N;CFB?<?97][E�:;����8H?D97:;?H7I?D<7DJ?I�EDJ;� +K8;DI�7D:��HK;=>;B����0EHA?D=��H?;D:I>?F�� ���

Page 49: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 17

*K7D:E� 8H?D97C :;� 9EDIJHK?H�� D7� 7KI_D9?7 :; 7B=KC7� FH^L?7 KC7� H;9H;7][E�� 7I

9H?7D]7I�9H?7C�E�8H?DGK;:E�(I�F;GK;D?DEI�GK;�8H?D97C�;�:EHC;C�@KDJE�7�EIIEI�;

;D9EDJH7C�D;II;I�EIIEI��F;:7]EI�787D:ED7:EI�F;B7�CEHJ;��EI�eD?9EI�8H?DGK;:EI

F7H7�JH7DI<EHCW�BEI�;C�7D?C7?I�F;H<?B7:EI�:;�KC7�<7P;D:7�?C7=?DWH?7��<?=������C

KC� 9EDJH7IJ;� I?=D?<?97J?LE E8I;HL7CEI� ;C� I;K� F7BW9?E� E� C7H7@W� :;� #E:>FKH

9;H97:E�:;�BKNE��7�8H?D97H�9EC�KC7�C?D?7JKH7�:;�97I7��<?=����

�I�H;B7]d;I�9EC�E�9EJ?:?7DE�I;�JEHD7C�C7?I�B7J;DJ;I I;�H;87J?:7I�;C�8H?D97:;?H7I

(� F7F;B� ^� KC� <78KBEIE� H;9KHIE� F7H7� 7J?L?:7:;I� H;9H;7J?L7I� �� J^9D?97� :;�CEDJ7H

F;HIED7=;DI�� E8@;JEI� ;� 9?:7:;I� 9EC� 7� KJ?B?P7][E� :;IJ;�C7J;H?7B� IKH=?K� :;I:;� IK7

9H?7][E� ;� F;HC7D;9;� 7J^� EI� :?7I� :;� >E@; �<?=� ���� �I� C;D?D7I� =;H7BC;DJ;� I;

?:;DJ?<?97C�87IJ7DJ;�9EC�8ED;97I�:;�F7F;B�GK;�JHE97C�:;�HEKF7�)7H7�EI�C;D?DEI

J7C8^C� I;CFH;� >EKL;� EF]d;I�� FEIJE� :;� =7IEB?D7�� B7L7� 7� @7JE�� ;:?<`9?E� :EI

8EC8;?HEI�;J9��7B^C�:;�B?D:7I�9?:7:;I�9EC�JE:7�IK7�;<;HL;I9_D9?7

�?=KH7���� �H?7D]7I�8H?D97D:E�9EC�EIIEI��,;87IJ?[E�,7B=7:E�EDJ;��,�% ��(��,�-;HH7��F���

�?=KH7���� (�H?9E�C7H7@W�:;�#E:>FKH�8H?D97�9EC�KC7�C?D?7JKH7�:;�97I7��� ��EDJ;� �����(�'"!���''*����'(%���"����'�"! �� �I��F���

Page 50: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 18

�I C7GK;J;I ;I9EB7H;I� J7C8^C� I[E� KJ?B?P7:7I� 9ECE�CE:E�:;� JH7P;H� H;7B?:7:;� UI

7KB7I� ;� JEHDW�B7I� C7?I� 9ED9H;J7I� ;� :?DYC?97I� &;JE:EBE=?7I� :?<;H;D9?7:7I� I[E

7FB?97:7I� U C7GK;J; .C7� :7I� C7?I� KJ?B?P7:7I� ^� 7� FHE:K][E� <;?J7� FHEFH?7C;DJ;

:;DJHE�:;�KC7�97?N7��FE:;D:E�I;H KC7 97?N7�:;�F7F;B[E�=H7D:;�EK KC7 97?N7�:;

I7F7JE� :;F;D:;D:E�:E�FHE@;JE�;�:E�J7C7D>E�:;I;@7:E��J7F7I�:?<;H;DJ;I�:7�L?:7�

FEH^C�� 9EC H;9KHIEI� ;� FHEFbI?JEI� F7H;9?:EI �� 9H?7][E� :;II7I� ;N;CFB7H;I

9EDIJHK`:EI� :;DJHE� :;� KC7� 97?N7� :;� I7F7JE� L;C� :7� D;9;II?:7:;� :;� FHEF?9?7H� KC

H;9KHIE�GK;�;NFB?GK;�F7H7� 7I� 9H?7D]7I� 9EC�^�7� L?:7�DE� 97CFE�;�D7� 9?:7:;� D;IJ;

97IE��FE:;CEI�L;H�PED7�7�KH87D7�;�PED7�HKH7B��<?=���� (�C;ICE�H;9KHIE�^�7FB?97:E

D7� =H7:K7][E� :E� 9KHIE� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� 9ECE� ?DIJHKC;DJE� :;� FEJ;D9?7B?P7][E� :7I

9ECFH;;DId;I�F;HJ?D;DJ;I�7E�:;I;D>E�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7 �<?=���

�?=KH7������H?DGK;:E�:;�CEDJ7H�;C�F7F;B� 7�7KJEH7�7EI����7DEI�:;�?:7:;�9EC�I;K�F7?�EDJ;� �EJE f �B<H;:E� 7H9?7�+EP7������

Page 51: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 19

��<?D7B?:7:;�:;IJ7�FHEFEI?][E ^ 97F79?J7H�EI�7BKDEI�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�DE E�7FH;D:?P7:E

:E�:;I;D>E ;C�:K7I�:?C;DId;I� �L?IJ7I�EHJE=ED7?I� 9ED<EHC;�DEHC7I�J^9D?97I�DE

:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE� :EI� C;?EI� :;� ;NFH;II[E� ;� H;FH;I;DJ7][E� =HW<?97� :EI� FHE@;JEI

�<?=���

�?=KH7�����&7GK;J;�;B78EH7:7�FEH�KD?L;HI?JWH?EI�9EC�97?N7�:;�I7F7JE�F7H7�H;FH;I;DJ7H�KC �"�'��EDJ;���EJE�:7�7KJEH7

�?=KH7�����&7GK;J;I�;B78EH7:7I�FEH�9H?7D]7I�9EC�97?N7�:;�I7F7JE��PED7�HKH7B�;�PED7�KH87D7�EDJ;���EJE�:7�7KJEH7

�?=KH7�����)HE9;IIE�:7�CE:;B7=;C�;C�97?N7�:;�I7F7JE�F7H7�FEJ;D9?7B?P7H�E�;DJ;D:?C;DJE�:E�:;I;D>E7HGK?J;JcD?9E�EDJ;���EJE�:7�7KJEH7

Page 52: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 20

�I ;B78EH7]d;I�:;IJ7I 7J?L?:7:;I�;IJ[E�<KD:7C;DJ7:7I�D7�?DJ;D][E�:;�FH;F7H7H�EI

@EL;DI� 7BKDEI� F7H7 KC� CKD:E� =BE87B?P7:E� ;� :?DYC?9E� 9ECE CEC;DJEI� :;

7FH;D:?P7:E� 9EDJ;D:E� :?<;H;DJ;I� ;J7F7I� GK;� F7II7C� F;B7� 9EDJ;NJK7B?P7][E� :7

FHEFEIJ7�7�I;H�;N;9KJ7:7�,EC7D:E�E�9ED>;9?C;DJE�7DJ;H?EH�7E�GK;�I;HW�7:GK?H?:E

FEH C;?E�7JK7B�:;�;NF;H?_D9?7�� J;C�I; 7 9EDIJHK][E�F;B7�;IJ?CKB7][E�:7�7FB?97][E

:E�9EDJH7IJ;�C;DJ7B�C7DK7B� ;�E F;DI7H�9EC�7I�C[EI��E�GK;�7�C;DJ;�F;DI7��7�C[E

H;7B?P7��(KJH7�GK;IJ[E�I?=D?<?97J?L7�F7II7�F;B7�L;H?<?97][E�;�7II?C?B7][E�:EI�79;HJEI

;� ;HHEI� FEH� C;?E� :;� ;NF;H?_D9?7I� ;� 7DWB?I;I� �;IJ7� C7D;?H7� 7:GK?H;�I; E

;DJ;D:?C;DJE� :;� GK;� 7� C7D?FKB7][E� :;IJ;I� E8@;JEI� FEJ;D9?7B?P7� E� I;DIE� :;

;IJ^J?97�� ?C7=?D7][E�� 9H?7J?L?:7:;�� F;H9;F][E� L?IK7B�� FB7D;@7C;DJE�� H;7B?P7][E ;

?D?9?7J?L7�:;�GK;C�E�;N;9KJ7

�I�C7GK;J;I� J_C� J7C8^C� KC� BK=7H� ;C� DEII7� L?:7� 7:KBJ7� )7H7� EI� @7FED;I;I�� 7

F7?I7=;C� :;� KC7 C?D?7JKH7 ;NFH;II7� KC� I;DJ?C;DJE :;� BE97B� ;IF?H?JK7B� �I

:?IFEI?]d;I� :;� F;:H7I�� 7H;?7I� ;� KC� Ib� 7H8KIJE�� J[E� JH7:?9?ED7?I� DE� #7F[E� FE:;C

;LE97H�KC�F7DEH7C7�:;�CEDJ7D>7I��L7B;I�;�H?EI��C�<EHC7�I?C?B7H��7I C?D?7JKH7I

F?9JbH?97I�:7�)^HI?7�;� TD:?7� I[E�KC�C?9HE9EICE�:;�;IFB;D:EH�� B;D:7I� <EB9BbH?97I�;

;HEJ?ICE�;C J;C7I�H;9EHH;DJ;I�7J^�E�I^9KBE�1/""��GK7D:E�EI�;KHEF;KI�9EC;]7H7C

7�9>;=7H��JH7P;D:E�9EC�;B;I�EI�I;KI�:?<;H;DJ;I�L7BEH;I�CEH7?I

'7�7JK7B?:7:;��7HJ?IJ7I�;�;I9KBJEH;I�J_C�;B;=?:E�L7H?7DJ;I�D7�;B78EH7][E�:;�CE:;BEI

JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I� 9ECE�C;?E� :;� ;C87I7H� I;K� :?I9KHIE� (I� CE:;BEI� FEIIK;C� KC7

7JCEI<;H7�I;:KJEH7�;�`DJ?C7�97F7P�:;�FHELE97H�KC�:?WBE=E GK7I;�GK;�9ED<?:;D9?7B

9EC�E�;IF;9J7:EH�'7�GK7B?:7:;�:;�KC�7C8?;DJ;�9EDJHEB7:E�FE:;CEI�;N;CFB?<?97H

EI� ?DJ;H?EH;I� C?D?7JKH?P7:EI� :;� %ODD;� �B?87DE<<� ?DIF?H7:EI� ;C� ?DJ;H?EH;I

7HGK?J;JcD?9EI�� 9EDIJHK]d;I� ;C� 97?N7I� <;9>7:7I� :;� FEK9EI� 9;DJ`C;JHEI� �<?=� ����

;LE97D:E� :?C;DId;I� C7?I� L7IJ7I� ;� C7?I� C?IJ;H?EI7I� :;� F;GK;D7� ;I97B7�� GK;

DEHC7BC;DJ;�7FH;I;DJ7C�GK7HJEI�L7P?EI�9EC�:;J7B>;I�C`D?CEI���F;GK;D7�;I97B7

F;HC?J;�7E�;IF;9J7:EH�L?IK7B?P7H�;�;NFBEH7H�7�E8H7�I;�:;IBE97D:E�:;�KC�B7:E�F7H7

EKJHE�D7�J;DJ7J?L7�:;�:;I9E8H?H�E�GK;�;IJW�C7?I�7�9?C7�EK�7E�L?H7H�:7�;IGK?D7

Page 53: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 21

�� ;I9KBJKH7� :;� �B?87DE<<� 78H7]7� 7� ?C7=?D7][E� 9EC� I;KI� L7P?EI� ;� KC7� ;IJH7D>7

<7C?B?7H?:7:;��;LE97D:E�:?C;DId;I�C7?I�L7IJ7I�;�C7?I�C?IJ;H?EI7I

�� ?D<YD9?7� :E E 7HJ?IJ7 &9&?BB;D� FEH ;N;CFBE� <E? C7H97:7 FEH KC7 9KH?EI?:7:;

IE8H; EI 7HJ;<7JEI :; FbI�=K;HH7��B;L7DJ7:7I FH?D9?F7BC;DJ; FEH I;KI 7LcI �B=KC7I

:7I C;CbH?7I :; ?D<YD9?7 L?H?7C C7?I J7H:; 7 EH=7D?P7H ; 9H?7H >?IJbH?7I 7 H;IF;?JE�

KI7D:E H;<;H_D9?7I 7HGK?J;JcD?97I 9ECE KC7 B?D=K7=;C C;J7<bH?97 F7H7 ;NFH;II7H

; H;L;B7H KC ;IJ7:E 9EDJ`DKE :; <BKNE �<?=���� �I C;CbH?7I :E ;IF;9J7:EH ; I;DIE

:; H;7B?:7:; I[E IKJ?BC;DJ; IK8L;HJ?:7I F;BE KIE :; ;I97B7 7BJ;H7:7 ; 7 <78H?97][E

:; ;B;C;DJEI GK; I[E 7E C;ICE J;CFE <7C?B?7H ; ;IJH7D>E

�?=KH7���� %ODD;��B?87DE<<g�;DJ;H�!7BBh� 7BB;HO�#E;�� ����EDJ;��>JJF�MMM=7BB;HO@E;9EC7HJ?IJI9B?87DE<<B�;C����� ���

Page 54: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 22

�� B?D=K7=;C� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7� ; ;C� F7HJ?9KB7H� 7� C?D?7JKH?P7][E� J;C� I?:E

H;9EHH;DJ;C;DJ;� KI7:7� FEH� 7HJ?IJ7I� :;� :?L;HI7I� ;IF;9?7B?:7:;I� (� CE:;BE

JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�FHEF?9?7�7�FHEN?C?:7:;�<`I?97�;�;CE9?ED7B� ��� `D:EB;�7<;J?L7 :7�7HJ;

;C� C?D?7JKH7� FHEL^C� :E� GK;� 7IIE9?7CEI� 9EC� 7� ?D<YD9?7�� ;C� L?HJK:;� :;� IK7I

FHEFEH]d;I� :;� 8H?DGK;:EI� GK;� ;D=;D:H7C� KC7� I;DI7][E� :;� 9ECF7HJ?B>7H� KC7

L?I[E�F7HJ?9KB7H f KC�:?WBE=E�F7HJ?9KB7H

�� <?C�:;� 9EDIEB?:7H� KC�;DJ;D:?C;DJE�C7?I� ;IF;9`<?9E� 7� H;IF;?JE� :E� J;C7�� <7P� I;

D;9;IIWH?E� 78EH:7H� GK;IJd;I H;B79?ED7:7I� UI� 79;F]d;I :;� :;J;HC?D7:7I F7B7LH7I

H;9EHH;DJ;I�DE�J;NJE�)EHC;DEH?P7D:E�7I 79H;:?J7�I; 7�FHEFEIJ7 :;IJ;�JH787B>E I;

JEHD7HW� C;B>EH� FEJ;D9?7B?P7:7�� KC7 L;P� F;H9;8?:7� 7� <H7=?B?:7:;� ;� 7FB?978?B?:7:;

:;IJ7I� F7B7LH7I� I;C� 7� ;CFH;=78?B?:7:;� 9EHH;J7 EK� :e8?7� FEH� :?L;HIEI� 7KJEH;I

�?=KH7���� �!EKI;�E<�07J;H��� �����&?9>7;B���&9&?BB;D� F7HJ;�:;�IK7�?DIJ7B7][E��+;:�H;8EGK;�&EJ;B��DE&KI;K�:;�(7AB7D:�4 ���5�EDJ;� &?9>7;B���&9C?BB7D��%��=H;B>7� 7BB;HO

Page 55: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 23

�B=KC7I�L;P;I� 7�7KJEH7�I;�L_ D7�I?JK7][E�:;�DEC;7H�E�J;C7��7�<?C�:;�KC7�C;B>EH

9ECFH;;DI[E� FEH� F7HJ;� :EI� B;?JEH;I� :E� E8@;JE� JH7J7:E f KI7D:E� E� J;HCE

iCE:;B7=;C� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B� <`I?97j �ECE� I;� F;H9;8;� DE� :?9?EDWH?E�� 7I� 79;F]d;I

9EHH;DJ;I�:;�KC7�:;J;HC?D7:7�F7B7LH7 J_C 9;HJ7 CKBJ?FB?9?:7:;�:;F;D:;D:E�:EI

KIEI�^�GK;�I[E�<;?JEI

��&(��%( ?J�"�-��"��B7J�"����(& :; "�(&

�"�(& EK�CE:E � C7D;?H7��C^JE:E��<EHC7

�GK?BE�GK;�I;HL;�:; E8@;JE�:;�?C?J7][E�F7H;B>E�EK�9ED@KDJE�:;�7F7H;B>EI�GK;�F;HC?J;C�7�H;FHE:K][E�:;�:;J;HC?D7:7F;]7�FEH�FHE9;IIEI�KI7:EI�;C�<KD:?][E�F7H7�E�FH;F7HE�:;�E8@;JEI�:;�C;J7B��CEB:;)HbFH?E�F7H7�I;H�?C?J7:E&E:;BE�H;:KP?:E��H;FHE:K][E�;C�F;GK;D7�;I97B7�:;�KC�7F7H;B>E�EK�:;�KC9ED@KDJE

&E:;BE��F7:H[E� F7H7:?=C7

�HGK?J;JKH7� �HGK?J;JKH7��;N;CFBE�GK;�I;HL;�:;�F7:H[E�7�I;H�?C?J7:E�U�9H?7][E�:;7B=E

�N;CFBE� 7HGK^J?FE��9YDED;��;D97HD7][E��;IF;B>E��;IF^9?C;� ;N;CFBE��<?=KH?DE�?:;7B� ?C7=;C� DEHC7� EH?=?D7B� F7:H[E� F7H7:?=C7� F;HIED?<?97][E�)HEJbJ?FE� H;<;H_D9?7� H;JH7JE

-?FE��7CEIJH7� ;N;CFB7H� C7H97��H;FH;I;DJ7DJ;��J?FE�EDIJHK][E�J;bH?97��9ED@KDJE�:;�>?FbJ;I;I��9ED@KDJE�:;�?:;?7I��9EDIJHK][EJ;bH?97� I?IJ;C7"CFH;IIE�F7H7�I;H�FH;;D9>?:E��8EB;J?C��<EHCKBWH?E��?CFH;IIE+;FH;I;DJ7][E�;C�;I97B7�H;:KP?:7��C7GK;J;��C?D?7JKH7)HE<?II[E� C7D;GK?C);HIED?<?97][E� ;NFH;II[E��?D:KC;DJWH?7� HEKF7��JH7@;��L;IJ?C;DJ7&EB:;��8?JEB7��9>7F7��9H7L;?H7��;IJ7B[E� <EHC7��<cHC7� C7JH?P� C;:?:7� CEB:;

�&�*.�-� <H��$(�''� ��?J�������''��� ������� B7J +�(���

&?D?7JKH7��CE:;BE�HGK?J;JKH7��D=;D>7H?7���EHC7�:;�H;JH7J7H�;C�J7C7D>E�H;:KP?:E�KC7�E8H7�GK;FE:;HW�EK�:;L;HW�I;H�9EDIJHK`:7

Page 56: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 24

�HJ;I�=HW<?97I� )HE@;JE :;�KC7�9ECFEI?][E�=HW<?97��;N� �$(�'�����( ��#+��!�� �$(�'�����( ���)%"��?D;C7���;D7�EK�9;DWH?E�9EDIJHK`:E�;C�J7C7D>E�H;:KP?:E�F7H7�H;JH7J7H�7B=KDI7C8?;DJ;I�9K@7I�<?BC7=;DI�JEHD7C�I;�9ECFB?97:7I�EK�?DL?WL;?I�;C�9ED:?]d;IDEHC7?I�I9KBJKH7��+7I9KD>E�;C�<EHC7�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�:;�KC7�;I9KBJKH7�;IF;9`<?97�9EDIJHK`:E�;C�LWH?EI�C7J;H?7?I)K8B?9?:7:;���NFEI?JEH��87B9[E�9K@7�KJ?B?P7][E�I;�H;IJH?D=;�7�;NF;H?C;DJ7][E�:EIFHE:KJEI�7DJ;I�:;IJ;I�I;H;C�CEIJH7:EI

QK:?E� ,KFEHJ;�:;�WK:?E�:;IJ?D7:E�7�:;CEDIJH7][E�EK�7�FHECE][E � ��&(

��&(��%� �&

�][E�EK�;<;?JE�:;�CE:;B7H��CE:;B7][E

��&(��%�+�CEB:7H��CEB:7H�7P;H�E�CE:;BE EK�E�CEB:;�:;�KC7�F;]7�;DKD9?7H�EK�?DI?DK7H�7I�<EHC7I�EHC7H�:;�79EH:E�9EC�KC�CE:;BE

�I�F7B7LH7I�JH7J7:7I�79?C7 <7P;C F7HJ;�:;�KC7�9ECF?B7][E�:EI I;=K?DJ;I�7KJEH;I�

�!(.�",,�� /"%%�+�� �������&"�!��%",�� ����� �!(%�'���� �����;��+(3�,-+�-�'�

����

)7H7�:;J;HC?D7H�GK7B�E�I;DJ?:E�:7:E�7E�J;HCE�CE:;BE D;IJ7�F;IGK?I7��L7B;�;NFBEH7H

I;KI� I?=D?<?97:EI� 9EDJ;CFEHYD;EI� �9ECE� JH7J7:E�D7�FW=?D7� 7DJ;H?EH��� 9ED9;?JEI� ;

KIEI 9EHH;DJ;I�;C�:?<;H;DJ;I�:EC`D?EI�:E�<7P;H��I78;H

(�J;HCE�CE:;BE�^�CK?JE�;NJ;DI?LE��7FH;I;DJ7D:E�79;F]d;I�;IF;9`<?97I EH?KD:7I�:;

WH;7I�:E�9ED>;9?C;DJE FHbFH?7I &7I�9EDI;HL7�KC�I?=D?<?97:E�=;H7B��KIK7B�7�GK7I;

JEJ7B�;I<;H7�:E�9ED>;9?C;DJE

Page 57: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 25

,?=D?<?97][E�=;D^H?97 ;N;CFBE ?:;7B��H;<;H_D9?7� F7:H[E

,?=D?<?97][E ;IF;9`<?97 ;N;CFBE���?:;7B ��H;<;H;D9?7�� F7:H[E

�F7HJ?9KB7H?:7:;I�:7�WH;7�:;�9ED>;9?C;DJE

&(��%(

�?_D9?7

CE:;BEI9ED9;?JK7?I

;CE:;BEIC7J;H?7?I

)HE9;IIE�:;9ED>;9?C;DJE

);H9;F][E

�NF;H?C;DJ7][E

&E:;BEI�J;bH?9EIEK�9ED9;?JK7?I

&E:;BEI�:?:WJ?9EI

&E:;BEI;NF;H?C;DJ7?I

&(��%(

�?_D9?7

CE:;BEI9ED9;?JK7?I

CE:;BEIC7J;H?7?I

&E:;BE�9ECE�9ED@KDJE�:;9ED9;?JEI��FH;C?II7I�;�<EHC7I�GK;97H79J;H?P7C�KC7�FHEFEIJ77HGK?J;JcD?97�EK�KH87D`IJ?97

&E:;BE�9ECE�7�H;<;H_D9?7;I9EB>?:7�F;BE�7HGK?J;JE�F7H7�IK79ECFEI?][E��I;@7�KC7�?:;?7�EK�KC7<EHC7�C7J;H?7B

&E:;BE�9ECE�KC�I?IJ;C7;NF;H?C;DJ7B��C7J;H?7B�EK;B;JHcD?9E��9EDIJHK`:E�9EC�?DJK?JE:;�7KN?B?7H�7�<EHCKB7H�EK�J;IJ7HKC7�>?FbJ;I;�H;B79?ED7:7�7E:;I;CF;D>E�:;�KC�7C8?;DJ;

&(��%(

�HJ;I)BWIJ?97I

&7J;H?7B?:7:;:E�<7P;H

":;7B�:;9ECFEI?][E

7HJ`IJ?97��H;7B�EK?C7=?DWH?E

&E:;BE�:;H;<;H_D9?7

&E:;BE�:;FHE@;JE��;IJK:E�

;NF;H?C;DJ7][E�;7FH;I;DJ7][E

&(��%(

�HJ;I)BWIJ?97I

&E:;BE�:;�J;IJ;�FH^�I^H?;��EKFHEJbJ?FE��E8@;JE�EH?=?D7B�<;?JE9ECE�iFH?C;?HE�J?FEj�F7H7�J;IJ;�:;KC7�FHE:K][E�I;H?7:7�<KJKH7

&E:;BE�9EC�J?FE��97J;=EH?7��=_D;HE:;�E8@;JEI

&E:;BE�I?=D?<?97D:E�7I�:?L;HI7IH;FH;I;DJ7]d;I�FB7D7I�:77HGK?J;JKH7��9HEGK?I��FB7DJ7I�9EHJ;I��;B;L7]d;I��F;HIF;9J?L7I��I<EJE=H7<?7I��EI�<?BC;I��7I�7D?C7]d;I;�7I�I?CKB7]d;I�;B;JHcD?97IFHE@;J7:7I�;C�J;B7�J7C8^C�I[ECE:;BEI�7HGK?J;JcD?9EI8?:?C;DI?ED7?I

&(��%(

�;I;D>E"D:KIJH?7B

�H;��FHE:K][E:;�E8@;JE�7F7HJ?H�:EEH?=?D7B

&E:;BE

&(��%(

�;I;D>E"D:KIJH?7B

&E:;BE� 9ECE� H;FH;I;DJ7][EJH?:?C;DI?ED7B� :;� KC� E8@;JE� EKKC7� 7HGK?J;JKH7� <;?J7� ;C� ;I97B7C7J;CWJ?97� �II7� H;FH;I;DJ7][EFE:;� ;� H;<;H?H� 7� KC7� 7HGK?J;JKH7;N?IJ;DJ;��;C�FHE@;JE��EK�D[E�C7?I;N?IJ;DJ;� *K7D:E� ;II7H;FH;I;DJ7][E� ^� <;?J7� ;C� ;I97B7H;:KP?:7�:;DEC?D7�I;�C7GK;J;

�+EP;IJH7J;D�� �����F���

��+�*�.�"�-���-�.�+��

I?=D?<?97:E &(��%(

I;DJ?:E :E�&(��%(

D7I�9?_D9?7I��7HJ;I�FBWIJ?97I��:;I;D>E�?D:KIJH?7B�; �"!%�$�$%"�

Page 58: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 26

(� I;DJ?:E� :7� F7B7LH7 ������ KI7:7� D;IJ7I� FW=?D7I� FE:;� J;H KC� I?=D?<?97:E

=;D^H?9E� :;�C7?EH�78H7D=_D9?7��EK KC�I;DJ?:E ;IF;9`<?9E� FHbFH?E :E�7C8?;DJ;�:;

9ED>;9?C;DJE :E�GK7B�I;�EH?=?DEK�(8I;HL7CEI�79?C7�GK;�DE�KD?L;HIE�:7I��?_D9?7I

J7DJE�E�I;DJ?:E�C7J;H?7B GK7DJE 9ED9;?JK7B�FE:;C I;�KJ?B?P7H�:E�J;HCE�CE:;BE��FE?I

;IJ; I; H;B79?ED7 7E� FHE9;IIE� :E� 9ED>;9?C;DJE�� IK8:?L?:?D:E�I;� ;C� 97J;=EH?7I

J;bH?9E9ED9;?JK7?I�� :?:WJ?9EI� ;� ;NF;H?C;DJ7?I '7I� �HJ;I�)BWIJ?97I� 7� F7B7LH7

CE:;BE� ;IJW� 9EHH;B79?ED7:7� 9EC� 7� C7J;H?7B?:7:;� :E� <7P;H� 7HJ`IJ?9E�� I;D:E

IK8:?L?:?:E� ;C� CE:;BEI� :;� H;<;H_D9?7� EK� CE:;BEI� :;� FHE@;JE� 9EC� _D<7I;� DE

;IJK:E�� ;NF;H?C;DJ7][E� ;� 7FH;I;DJ7][E� 'E� 7C8?;DJ;� :E� �;I;D>E� "D:KIJH?7B

CE:;BE� I;� 7FB?97� U H;FHE:K][E� :;� E8@;JEI� 7� F7HJ?H� :7� F;]7� EH?=?D7B� 'E EH8;� :7

�HGK?J;JKH7� ;D9EDJH7CEI� 7� 7HJ;�� 7� 9?_D9?7� ;� 7� ?D:eIJH?7� ;C� JEJ7B� ?DJ;=H7][E ; EI

I;DJ?:EI�FE:;C�I;H�EI�C7?I�L7H?7:EI�FEII`L;?I��9ECE�E8I;HL7CEI�DE�GK7:HE�79?C7

�?D9BKI?L;�9EC�7�7FB?978?B?:7:;�:7�F7B7LH7�C7GK;J;�;C�97IEI�;IF;9`<?9EI�

)EH ������ ;DJ;D:;CEI�7 7C8?=K?:7:; GK;�I;�H;<;H;�U�<EHC7�C7J;H?7B�;�U <EHC7

78IJH7J7 �C� J;HCEI� C7?I� 78IJH7JEI� E� CE:;BE� 7HGK?J;JcD?9E� ^� ;C� FH?D9`F?E� KC7

E8H7� :;� H;<;H_D9?7� �N�� (� )7HJ;DED� FE:;� I;H� KC�CE:;BE� F7H7 :?L;HIEI� J;CFBEI

F;H`FJ;HEI

�C� DEIIE� ;IJK:E�� E� J;HCE ������ I;HW� 7:EJ7:E� F7H7� :;I?=D7H� iCE:;BE

7HGK?J;JcD?9Ej�� 787H97D:E 7I� <EHC7I� :;� :?L;HIEI� E8@;JEI� KI7:EI� ;C ;I97B7I

H;:KP?:7I�GK;�FE:;C�J;H�KIEI�:?L;HI?<?97:EI

�II?C� CE:;BE� I;� 9EDI?:;H7� E� E8@;JE� �J7C8^C� 7� ?:;?7�� GK;� I;HL;� :;� FEDJE� :;

F7HJ?:7�F7H7�7�9H?7][E�:;�KC7�E8H7��9ECE�KC�;IGK;C7��;�GK;�:KH7DJ;�E�FHE9;IIE

9H?7J?LE� FE:;� IE<H;H� CE:?<?97]d;I� ;� 7:EJ7H� IEBK]d;I� <?D7?I� CK?JE� :?<;H;DJ;I� :7I

FH?C;?H7I�?:;?7I

�?<;H;DJ;C;DJ;� E� J;HCE ��!%�$� I;� 97H79J;H?P7 FEH� KC7� :?H;J7� H;<;H_D9?7� U

C7J;H?7B?:7:;� :7� <EHC7� )EHJ7DJE� 7� F7B7LH7 ��!%�$� I;HW� KI7:7� F7H7� DEC;7H� EI

CE:;BEI� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7� H;B79?ED7:EI� :?H;J7C;DJ;� U <EHC7][E� ;� JH787B>E� :;� KC

7HGK?J;JE� �;H?L7:7� :7� F7B7LH7� <H7D9;I7 �$(�''� GK;�� FEH� IK7� L;P� FHEL;C� :7

Page 59: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 27

?J7B?7D7 ������''��� :?C?DKJ?LE� :; �������� EH?=?DWH?E� :E� B7J?C +�(�� �C7D9>7��

;C�FEHJK=K_I�7�F7B7LH7�C7GK;J;�^�:;�KIE�CK?JE�H;9;DJ;��FE?I�7J^�E�I^9KBE�1/"""�D[E

7F7H;9;�9ECE�F7HJ;�:E�LE978KBWH?E�:;�8;B7I�7HJ;I

(�9ED9;?JE�:; ��!%�$� I;�;CF7H;B>7�9EC�E�:;�CE:;BE�;��;C�:?L;HI7I�E97I?d;I��I;

9ED<KD:;C�F7II7D:E�7�I;H�KJ?B?P7:EI�9ECE�I?DcD?CEI�;C�:?L;HI7I�E97I?d;I��II?C�

E� =H;=E� 9BWII?9E� I;� KJ?B?P7L7� :;� :K7I� F7B7LH7I� F7H7 I;� H;<;H?H 7E� 9ED9;?JE� :;

C7GK;J;I� '*#"& ;C�H;<;H_D9?7�7E�iJ?FEj��7E�CE:;BE�EK�I`C8EBE�H;FH;I;DJ7J?LE�:;

7B=E�� FEH� ;N;CFBE�� 7� C7GK;J;� :;� KC� ;:?<`9?E� ;C� ;I97B7� H;:KP?:7� ;DGK7DJE

#�%+���� � <7P?7� H;<;H_D9?7� 7� iF7H7:?=C7j�� GK;H� :?P;H�� ;N;CFBE� EK ;N;CFB7H� :7

C7GK;J;�DE�J7C7D>E�H;7B �&(.+(�� ����

����� ; ��!%�$� J_C� ;C� 9ECKC� 7 EH?=;C� H;B79?ED7:7� U� <EHC7� J7C8^C� E

I;DJ?:E� :;� CEB:;�� EH?KD:E� :E� 97IJ;B>7DE� ;� :E� B7J?C "�(�(&� ,K7� J;HC?DEBE=?7

7FEDJ7 F7H7B;B7C;DJ;� D7 7C8?=K?:7:;� :; EH?=;C�� ;N?IJ_D9?7� 9EDIJHK][E� ;

H;FHE:K][E�:7�<EHC7 .C7�L;P�;IJ78;B;9?:7I�UI�:?<;H;D9?7]d;I�;�I?C?B?JK:;I�;DJH;

������# ;��!%�$�#��79H;I9;DJ7H;CEI�KC�J;HCE�GK;�J7C8^C�<7HW F7HJ;�:;�DEII7I

;IF;9KB7]d;I "DJ;H;II7� 7GK?� ;NFBEH7H� E� 7IF;9JE� ;IF;9`<?9E� :7� H;FH;I;DJ7][E

JH?:?C;DI?ED7B� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7� ;� L;H?<?97H� IK7I� 97H79J;H`IJ?97I� ;� FEII?8?B?:7:;I�� DEI

C;?EI�C7DK7?I�:E�FHE9;IIE�:;�FHE@;JE�;C�I;KI�FH?C;?HEI�CEC;DJEI�DE�9KHIE�:;

7HGK?J;JKH7 �II?C�EI� B?C?J;I� ;DJH;� 7C8EI�EI� 7IF;9JEI� ������# ; ��!%�$�#�� I[E

:?<KIEI ;�;C�9;HJ7I�E97I?d;I�;CFH;=7:EI :;�<EHC7�;HHED?7�F7H7�H;<;H?H�I;�7�C;IC7

9E?I7� ,;�7E� BED=E�:7�>?IJbH?7��;II;I� 9ED9;?JEI�L7H?7H7C�� I;D:E�KJ?B?P7:EI�UI�L;P;I

9ECE� I?DcD?CEI� D7� 7JK7B?:7:;� I[E� 9EDI?:;H7:EI� :?<;H;DJ;I� � �IJ7� J;I;� FH;J;D:;

:;?N7H� ;L?:;DJ;� GK;� 7� :?<;H;D9?7][E ;DJH;� J7?I� 9ED9;?JEI� L7?� 7B^C� :7 C;H7

DEC;D9B7JKH7 )7H7� J7DJE� ^� ?DJ;H;II7DJ; 7FHE<KD:7H ;II7� :?I9KII[E :7� F7B7LH7

��������� D7� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� GK; <7P 7� 9ED;N[E :7I� C[EI 9EC� E� 9^H;8HE� (

:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE� :7� ?:;?7� :E� 7JE� :;� F;DI7H� 9EC� 7I�C[EI <?97HW�� D;IJ;�CEC;DJE

?DJHE:KJbH?E� 7:EHC;9?:E� FEH^C� E� H;;D9EDJH7H;CEI� DE� 97F`JKBE� � )EH� <?C�

I7B?;DJ7CEI 7�GK;IJ[E�:7I�<BKJK7]d;I�:7I�F7B7LH7I ��!%�$���������������������

�<?=�������<?=�� ��;��<?=����

Page 60: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 28

�?=KH7���� &�*.�-� f )H7]7�:EI�&KI;KI�:7�.D?L;HI?:7:;�:;�,[E�)7KBE�)7KBE�&;D:;I�:7 +E9>7�� ����EDJ;� +(�!���)�&�)7KBE�&;D:;I�:7�+E9>7� )HE@;JEI������ �����F���

�?=KH7�� � &(��%( f )H7]7�:EI�&KI;KI�:7.D?L;HI?:7:;�:;�,[E�)7KBE�)7KBE�&;D:;I�:7+E9>7�� ����EDJ;� +(�!���)�&�)7KBE�&;D:;I�:7�+E9>7� )HE@;JEI����� �����F���

�?=KH7�����&�'��,����+(�!� ;�7�&(��%� �& f )H7]7�:EI�&KI;KI�:7.D?L;HI?:7:;�:;�,[E�)7KBE�)7KBE�&;D:;I�:7�+E9>7�� ����EDJ;� �EJE�:7�7KJEH7��0EHAI>EF���KH?J?87� ���

&(��%(

&(��%� �&���T,"��

&(��%� �&�����" "-�%�?=KH7���� &(��%� �&�����( "-�%f )H7]7�:EI�&KI;KI�:7�.D?L;HI?:7:;�:;�,[E�)7KBE�)7KBE�&;D:;I�:7�+E9>7�� ����EDJ;� >JJF�MMM MF�9EDJ;DJKFBE7:IFH7]76:EI6CKI;KI6KIF@F=�;C����� ���

&(��%(

&�*.�-�

Page 61: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 29

�C�IKC7� ;DGK7DJE�E�J;HCE ������ H;<B;J;�7 <EHC7�C7J;H?7B�;�7�<EHC7�78IJH7J7��E

J;HCE ��!%�$� 7IIKC;�KC7� H;B7][E�:?H;J7� 9EC�7�C7J;H?7B?:7:;�:7� <EHC7�';IJ7

FHEFEIJ7� E� J;HCE ������ I;HW� ;CFH;=7:E� 9ECE� iCE:;BE� 7HGK?J;JcD?9Ej F7H7

:;I?=D7H�E�9ED@KDJE�:;�E8@;JEI�9EC�<EHC7I�7HGK?J;JcD?97I�;C�;I97B7�H;:KP?:7�GK;

FEIIK;C�:?<;H;DJ;I�KIEI�)EH�IK7�L;P� E�J;HCE��!%�$� I;HW�;CFH;=7:E�DE�I;DJ?:E

C7J;H?7B�;�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�F7H7�:;I?=D7H�CE:;BEI�7HGK?J;JcD?9EI�/7B;�H;II7BJ7H�GK;

7C8EI�;IJ[E�H;B79?ED7:EI�J7DJE�7E�JH787B>E GK7DJE�U <EHC7][E�:E�7HGK?J;JE

�EDIJ7J7CEI� 7II?C� GK;� EI� :;IB?P7C;DJEI� :;� I;DJ?:E 79EDJ;9;H[E ;C� :?<;H;DJ;I

CEC;DJEI�;C� <KD][E�:7I�D;9;II?:7:;I�>KC7D7I�S� ?DJ;H;II7DJ;�L;H?<?97H� 9ECE�E

FHbFH?E�:?9?EDWH?E�;IJW�;D9>7H97:E :;�79;F]d;I��L;H`=K7�I;� :;IJ7�C7D;?H7��GK; 7I

F7B7LH7I�C7GK;J;��CE:;BE�; CE:;B7=;C�I;�:?<;H;D9?7C�KC7�:7I�EKJH7I�D7�WH;7�:7

B?D=K7=;C �7:7� F7B7LH7 i97C7B;ED?97C;DJ;j L7?� 7IIKC?D:E :?<;H;DJ;I� I;DJ?:EI�

:;�79EH:E�9EC 7I�D;9;II?:7:;I�:;�GK;C�7I�KI7

�� CE:;B7=;C� J;C� I;K� I?=D?<?97:E� D7� 7][E� EK� ;<;?JE� :;� CE:;B7H�� CE:;B7][E (

J;HCE CE:;B7=;C� J7DJE� FE:;� I;� 7FB?97H� 7� KC7� EF;H7][E� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7][E� :7

<EHC7�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�DE�FB7DE f ;C�KC7�<EB>7�EK�J;B7��7�;N;CFB?<?97][E�FE:;H?7�I;H

KC7� F;HIF;9J?L7� f GK7DJE� 7� KC7� 9ECFEI?][E� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B� :E� ;IF7]E� �FEH

;N;CFBE�� 7� 9EDIJHK][E� :;� KC7� C7GK;J;�� �ECE� :;I:E8H7C;DJE� :;II7I� :K7I

FEII?8?B?:7:;I�I;�7=H;=7�7�F7HJ?H�:7I�eBJ?C7I�:^97:7I 7�7C8?=K?:7:;�:EI�IE<JM7H;I

�� �<?=� ���� 'E� ?:?EC7� ?D=B_I� "�����!� ^� I;CFH;� KC7� H;FH;I;DJ7][E� FB7D7� :;

<EHC7I� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I�� D7� J;B7� :E� 9ECFKJ7:EH� EK� ;C� KC7� ?CFH;II[E� E� ��

"�����!� I;CFH;�I;HW�KC7�H;FH;I;DJ7][E�FB7D7�:;�<EHC7I JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I�)EH^C�

D[E�FE:;CEI�;IGK;9;H�GK;�;IJ;�E8@;JE�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�=;H7:E�;B;JHED?97C;DJ;�;C

I7`:7� J?FE� ��&� ��" #(' ������ �"�����!��� ^� L?IK7B?P7:E� ;C� :K7I� :?C;DId;I

�DJH;J7DJE��^ 9ECKC�:;I?=D7H�9ECE�C7GK;J;�;B;JHcD?97� C7GK;J;�:?=?J7B�EK�L?HJK7B

7�F;HIF;9J?L7�FHE:KP?:7�;C�KC 7C8?;DJ; =HW<?9E�9ECFKJ79?ED7B��L?IK7B?P7:E D7�J;B7

:E 9ECFKJ7:EH��;IJ7 I?CKB7][E�LEBKC^JH?97 J7C8^C ^ 9ED>;9?:7 FEH CE:;B7=;C

JH?:?C;DI?ED7B

Page 62: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 30

&7GK;J;I�� CE:;BEI� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I�� I?CKB79HEI� ;� FHEJbJ?FEI�� I[E� H;FH;I;DJ7]d;I

H;7?I�� ;C� ;I97B7� ;N7J7� EK� 7FHEN?C7:7�� 9EC� <KD]d;I�� E8@;J?LEI�� C7J;H?7?I�

79787C;DJEI� ;� 97H79J;H`IJ?97I� L7H?7:7I �� KJ?B?P7][E� :7I� H;FH;I;DJ7]d;I� I; :W

GK7D:E�D;9;II?J7C�:7� H;7B?P7][E� <`I?97� 9ED9H;J7�DE�;IF7]E�:;�7B=KC�9ED9;?JE�EK

7B=KC7� DE][E FH^L?7� IKH=?:7� :;� IK7� ;B78EH7][E� ?DJ;B;9JK7B�� F7II`L;B� EK� D[E� :;

7BJ;H7][E� ;� 9EC� 7I� <?D7B?:7:;I� :;� 7KJE;I9B7H;9?C;DJE� EK� 9ECKD?97][E� 9EC

J;H9;?HEI

(� C^JE:E� FHE@;JK7B� I;� KJ?B?P7� :;� :?L;HI7I� <EHC7I� :;� B?D=K7=;C� :KH7DJ;� E

:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:7�FHEFEIJ7�:;�KC 7HJ;<7JE� L;H?<?97D:E�I;�<KD:7C;DJ7BC;DJ; E

KIE� :7� B?D=K7=;C� L?IK7B� FEH� C;?E :E� :;I;D>E� ;� :;� CE:;BEI� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I� �

7HGK?J;JKH7� I;CFH;� ;N?=?K� H;FH;I;DJ7][E� �HGK?J;JEI� J_C� ?:;?7I �?C7=^J?97I��� ;� 7I

?:;?7I�:;L;C�I;H�L?IK7B?P7:7I�;�9ECKD?97:7I�;�EI�CE:;BEI�JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I�I[E�KC7

:7I�<;HH7C;DJ7I�:E�7HGK?J;JE

�� D;9;II?:7:;� :;� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B?P7][E� ;� C7J;H?7B?P7][E� :EI� I?IJ;C7I� :;

H;FH;I;DJ7][E J_C� B;L7:E� DEI� eBJ?CEI� J;CFEI�� U H;L7BEH?P7][E� :E� F7F;B� :7

;B78EH7][E :EI� CE:;BEI �I� J;D:_D9?7I� <7P;C� 9EC� GK;� 97:7� L;P� C7?I� I;@7

D;9;IIWH?E�:?IFED?8?B?P7H�?DIJHKC;DJEI�:;�H;FH;I;DJ7][E�;�I`DJ;I;I��;DJH;�7I�GK7?I�7

C7GK;J;��� GK;� JEHD;C� 7� B;?JKH7� 9ECFB;J7� :;� KC7� FHEFEIJ7� ?C;:?7J7C;DJ;

9ECFH;;DI`L;B� (� F7F;B� :EI� CE:;BEI� ; C7GK;J;� JH7DI9;D:;� 7� I?CFB;I� :;I9H?][E

I?DJ^J?97� :E� FHE@;JE� GK;� I;� :;I;@7� H;FH;I;DJ7H� �E?I� 7IF;9JEI� I[E� F;H9;8?:EI� E

FH?C;?HE�9EDI?IJ; DE�F7F;B�EF;H7J?LE�GK;�E�CE:;BE�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B 7IIKC;�:KH7DJ;

E� :;I;DLEBL?C;DJE� :E� FHE@;JE�� 9ECE� 87D9E� :;� FHEL7I� :;� :?<;H;DJ;I� IEBK]d;I

FHE@;JK7?I�;C�GK;�IEC;DJ;�7�L;H?<?97][E�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�FE:; 9ED<?HC7H�EK�9H?7H�KC

FHE8B;C7��7 I;=KD:7�H;I?:;�D7�;NFH;II?L?:7:;�GK;�97H79J;H?P7�7�C7GK;J;�9ECE�KC

E8@;JE��EK�I;@7��IK7�7KJEDEC?7�<EHC7B�H;IF;?J7�E�FHE@;JE�H;7B�GK;�7FH;I;DJ7

*K7BGK;H� <EHC7� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7][E� 7HGK?J;JcD?97 f KC� :;I;D>E�� KC7� F;HIF;9J?L7

=;H7:7� FEH� C;?EI� :?=?J7?I� EK� FEH CE:;B7=;C� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B� <`I?97 f I;� ;DJ;D:;

9ECE�KC�C7J;H?7B� 9ED9;?JK7B�� GK;� I; 7FE?7 ;C� ?C7=;DI GK?C^H?97I F;HJ?D;DJ;I� U

Page 63: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 31

C;DJ;� :E� 9H?7:EH� �;� JE:7I� ;IJ7I� <EHC7I� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7][E�� E� CE:;BE� ^� 7 eD?97

H;FH;I;DJ7][E�<`I?97 f 7�H;7B?P7][E�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�:7 ?:;?7 �?C7=^J?97�

��CE:;B7=;C�J;C�KC�F7F;B�<KD:7C;DJ7B�DE�FHE9;IIE�FHE@;JK7B�I;D:E KC7�FEJ;DJ;

<;HH7C;DJ7�:;�;DI?DE�;�7FH;D:?P7=;C f J;C7�7�I;H�FHEFEIJE�DE�97F`JKBE���-;D:E

DEI I?IJ;C7I I;DIEH?7?I� KC� ?CFEHJ7DJ;� ?DIJHKC;DJE� :;� ?DJ;H<79; ;� ;<?9W9?7� DE

FHE9;IIE :;�7II?C?B7][E�:;�?D<EHC7]d;I��L;CEI�EI CE:;BEI JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I��9ECE

F7HJ;� :7� H;FH;I;DJ7][E�� GK;� CK?JE� I;� 7FHEN?C7� :7� H;7B?:7:;� �79?BC;DJ;

9ECFH;;D:?:EI�F;BEI EB>EI� ;II;I�CE:;BEI�I[E C7?I�79;II`L;?I�7�KC�C7?EH�DeC;HE

:; E8I;HL7:EH;I� GK;� :;I<HKJ7H[E :; CK?J7I� L?IK7B?P7]d;I �E8@;JE� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�

,[E�J7C8^C�C7?I�<79?BC;DJ;�9ECFH;;D:?:EI�:E�GK;�7I�?C7=;DI =;H7:7I�D7�J;B7�:;

KC�9ECFKJ7:EH��FE?I�H;GK;H;C�C;DEI�JH;?D7C;DJE�:;�B;?JKH7

(�7HGK?J;JE�);J;H�)H7D�:;I9H;L; 7I�F;]7I�GK;�:;I;DLEBL; 9ECE�KC7� i;IF^9?;�:;

B?D=K7=;C�KD?L;HI7B��ED:;�JE:EI�FE:;C�9ECFH;;D:;H�E�CE:;BE��GK;�^�7�8;B;P7

:7�9E?I7��;I;D>EI�U�C[E�B?LH;��7II?C�9ECE�7I�F;HIF;9J?L7I�J_C�=H7D:;�7F;BE��C7I

EI� CE:;BEI� <7B7C� F7H7� JE:EI DbIj �� <H7DGK;P7� ;� ?C;:?7J?ICE� :;� CE:;BEI�

7KN?B?7C� J7DJE� 7� L?IK7B?P7][E� F7H7� E� 7HGK?J;JE� GK7DJE 7� 9ECKD?97][E� 9EC� EI

EKJHEI��J;D:E�7II;=KH7:E�7�IK7�FEFKB7H?:7:;�7E�BED=E�:EI�I^9KBEI

&E:;BEI�JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I�I[E�;NJH7EH:?D7H?7C;DJ;�L;HIWJ;?I��FE?I�F;HC?J;C�GK;�EI

7KJEH;I� JH7DIC?J7C� KC7� I^H?;� :;� ?D<EHC7]d;I� IE8H;� IK7� FHEFEIJ7�� FE:;D:E� FEH

7FHEN?C7][E� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7][E� U� <KJKH7� H;7B?:7:;� 7HGK?J;JcD?97� 7FH;I;DJW�B7� :;

CE:E� C7?I� ;NFB`9?JE� 9ECE� H;L;B7H� EI� 7IF;9JEI� 9ED9;?JK7?I� ;DLEBL?:EI� DEI

FHE9;:?C;DJEI�:;�9ED9;8_�B7

&E:;BEI��J7C8^C 9ECFH;;D:;C�CK?JE�C7?I�:E�GK;�7I�H;7B?:7:;I�:;�IKF;H<`9?;�:;

KC�FHE@;JE�;C�IK7�C7J;H?7B?:7:;� FE:;C�H;L;B7H�EI�F;DI7C;DJEI�:;�I;K�9H?7:EH�;

H;L;B7H�<EDJ;I�:;�?DIF?H7][E�;�?:;?7I�IK8@79;DJ;I�9ED9;?JK7?I�&E:;BEI�:;�>E@;�I[E

;NJH;C7C;DJ;�L7H?7:EI��;B;I�FE:;C�I;H�<7I9?D7DJ;I�;C�IK7�;N7J?:[E�9ECE�L;HId;I

;C C?D?7JKH7� :7� H;7B?:7:;�� EK FE:;C� I;H� H;FH;I;DJ7]d;I� :;I9EDJHEB7:7C;DJ;

2 Conferência dia 09/10/2009, XII BIENAL de Buenos Aires 2009.

Page 64: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 32

;D;H=^J?97I� :;� L?IK7B?P7]d;I� ;� ;IF79?7B?:7:;I� 9EC� GK;� EI FHE<?II?ED7?I <EHC7C

9ED9;?JEI�;II;D9?7BC;DJ;�78IJH7JEI�;C�IK7�FB7IJ?9?:7:;��IJ7�D7JKH;P7�9ECFEIJ7�:E

CE:;BE��7� IK7�97F79?:7:;�:;�;D<H;DJ7H�;� H;IFED:;H�:;I7<?EI�;C� J7B� L7H?;:7:;�:;

D`L;?I��E�JEHD7�?DJH?=7DJ;�;�:?=DE�:;�?DL;IJ?=7][E

�7:7�CE:;BE�;N;9KJ7:E�FHEF?9?7�9ECE E�H;IKBJ7:E 7I ;I9EB>7I�IE8H;�E�GK;�CEIJH7H

;� 9ECE�CEIJH7H�� ; GK7?I <7JEH;I� I[E� ?DJ;D9?ED7BC;DJ;�;N9BK`:EI ,K7�;I97B7�� I;KI

C7J;H?7?I�� IK7I� 9EH;I ;� I;K� =H7K� :;� H;7B?ICE� ; 79787C;DJE� :;L;C EH8?J7H� D;IJ7

7][E� �7:7� :;9?I[E� I;F7H7:7� 7<;J7� E� CE:E� 9ECE� E� CE:;BE� I;� 7FH;I;DJ7� ;� 7

C;DI7=;C�=;H7B�GK; ;B;�JH7DIC?J;

(�CE:;BE�I;�9ECKD?97�7JH7L^I�:;�KC7�L7H?;:7:;�:;�<EHC7I GK;�;IJ[E�?DJ;HB?=7:7I

)H?C;?H7C;DJ;� F;BE�7IF;9JE�EK�F7HJ;�:E�FHE@;JE�GK;�;B;�78EH:7 f E <E9E�FE:;�I;H

;C�KC�F;GK;DE�<H7=C;DJE��9ECE�KC�F;H<?B�:;�;I97:7��EK�IE8H;�KC�;:?<`9?E�9ECE

KC�JE:E��DE�I;K�I`J?E�9?H9KD:7DJ;�EK�C;?E�KH87DE�&K?J7I�L;P;I�E�CE:;BE�CEIJH7

7B=E�7E�;IF;9J7:EH�GK;�DKD97� ?H?7�L;H f KC7�<7J?7�7JH7L^I�:E�;:?<`9?E��KC�CE:;BE

I;99?ED7B�EK�9EHJ7DJ;��FEH�;N;CFBE����<?=������E�=;H7B�H;B79?ED7C;DJE�:;�C7II7I�:;

9EDIJHK][E��KC�CE:;BE�:;�8BE9EI�I?CFB?<?97:E���EK�J7BL;P�KC7�97H79J;H`IJ?97�?IEB7:7

:E�FHE@;JE��9ECE�E�7HH7D@E�9>[E��EI�I;HL?]EI�C;9YD?9EI�EK�HEJ7I�:;�JH7DIFEHJ;��EK

C7?I� 78IJH7J7C;DJ;�� 7I� B?D>7I� ?C7=?D7:7I� :;� CEL?C;DJE� 7JH7L^I� :E� ;IF7]E� GK;

?DIF?H7H7C�?:;?7�:E�7HGK?J;JE���?D<EHC7][E�E<;H;9?:7�;C�KC�CE:;BE�CK?J7I�L;P;I

^�87IJ7DJ;�;IF;9`<?97�;� B?C?J7:7��;�D;D>KC�CE:;BE�FE:;�DEI�:?P;H�JK:E�IE8H;�KC

FHE@;JE

�?=KH7�����&E:;BE�I;99?ED7:E��);J;H��?I;DC7D��&KI;K�:;�!?IJEH?7�'7JKH7B��';M�2EHA�������EDJ;��&EED��$7H;D�&E:;B?D=�&;II7=;I��F���

Page 65: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 33

�7:7�CE:;BE�J;C�KC�FHEFbI?JE� FE:;�I;H�;B78EH7:E�F7H7�KIE�:E�FHbFH?E��9ECE�KC

C;?E� 7JH7L^I� :E� GK7B� 7I� ?:;?7I� ?D?9?7?I� I[E� ;NFBEH7:7I� :;� KC7� <EHC7� FKH7C;DJ;

;NF;H?C;DJ7B��EK�9ECE�KC7�<;HH7C;DJ7�F7H7�7D7B?I7H�:?<;H;DJ;I�IEBK]d;I�)E:;�I;H

:;IJ?D7:E�F7H7�KC�C;Jb:?9E�J;IJ;�79eIJ?9E�EK�F7H7�7�KC7�FHEL7�:;�;<?9W9?7�:;�KC7

?BKC?D7][E� �B;� FE:;� 7@K:7H� 7� :;CEDIJH7H� 7� ;IJHKJKH7� F7H7� KC� ;CFH;?J;?HE� EK

7FH;I;DJ7H�7�?:;?7�F7H7�E�9B?;DJ;

�?=KH7 ����)B7J7<EHC7�:E�FHE9;IIE�9H?7J?LE���" ��-EHH;�%;=E��EF;D>7=;D�EDJ;��+;L?IJ7��/�)HEO;9JEI� � ����F����;��

�?=KH7�����&E:;BE�:;�;IJK:E�;C�FEB?KH;J7DE���" ��-EHH;�%;=E��EF;D>7=;D�EDJ;��+;L?IJ7��/�)HEO;9JEI� � ����F���

�?=KH7�����&E:;BE�<?D7B�9EC�F;]7I�:;�%� (���" ��-EHH;�%;=E��EF;D>7=;D�EDJ;��+;L?IJ7��/�)HEO;9JEI� � ����F���

�������������#$%����� ��

�����������������#$%����� ��

�����������#$%���������%����.,�

Page 66: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 34

(I�KIEI�:EI�CE:;BEI� I[E�7CFBEI��C7I�FE:;C�I;H� 9EDL;D?;DJ;C;DJ;� I?DJ;J?P7:EI

;C�:E?I� =H7D:;I� J`JKBEI� �#$%����� �� �<?= ��� ; �<?= ��� ����� ���%����.,� �<?=

��� ��C7?EH?7�:7I�FHWJ?97I�7HGK?J;JcD?97I�KI7�EI�CE:;BEI�;C�7C8EI�EI� I;DJ?:EI�

C7I�7B=KC7I�9EHH;DJ;I�EI�KI7C�C7?I�F7H7�JH7DIC?J?H�IK7I� ?:;?7I��;DGK7DJE�EKJHEI

KI7C�C7?I�F7H7�I?��F7H7�=;IJ7H�E�:;I;D>E f E�;C8H?[E�:E�FHE9;IIE�9H?7J?LE

�II;I FHEFbI?JEI�D;C�I;CFH;�I[E�CKJK7C;DJ;�;N9BKI?LEI��;�KC�eD?9E�CE:;BE�FE:;

J;H� KC7� I^H?;� :;�;D97HD7]d;I� :?<;H;DJ;I�:KH7DJ;� 7� L?:7�:;�KC�FHE@;JE�� UI� L;P;I�

F7H7� E� ;IJK:E� ;�� FEH� L;P;I�� F7H7� 7� 9ECKD?97][E�� EK� FE:;� ?D9EHFEH7H� <KD]d;I

Fe8B?97I�;�FH?L7:7I��7E�C;ICE�J;CFE

&E:;BEI DEI�:?P;C�IE8H;�E�FHE@;JE�H;B79?ED7:E�EK�IE8H;�7I�?:;?7I��C7I�J7C8^C�I;

9ECKD?97C�:;�EKJH7I�C7D;?H7I�"D;L?J7L;BC;DJ;��7JH7L^I�:7�IK7�<EHC7��JH7DIC?J;C

C;DI7=;DI f D[E� FHEFH?7C;DJ;� ;DJ;D:?:7I � IE8H;� EI� FHbFH?EI� 9H?7:EH;I�� IK7I

F;HIED7B?:7:;I�;�78EH:7=;DI 7HGK?J;JcD?97I 'E�FHE@;JE�:E�7HGK?J;JE !?J7J7 �<?=����

7 i?:;?7j�F7HJ?K�D[E�:;�KC7� ?C7=;C�;N?IJ;DJ;�D7�C;DJ;�:E�9H?7:EH�C7I�;C KC7

H;<;H_D9?7�;NFB`9?J7�;C�<EHC7I�9EDJ?:7I�;C�EKJHEI�E8@;JEI

&E:;BEI I[E J7C8^C KC� FHE:KJE� :7I� ;I9EB>7I� :EI 7KJEH;I GK;� 7I� <78H?97C

+;<B;J;C 7FJ?:d;I ;� F;HIED7B?:7:;� ,K7I� >78?B?:7:;I� J^9D?97I� FE:;C� :?H;9?ED7H

IK7I� :;9?Id;I� ;C� H;B7][E� 7E� JH787B>E� ;C� :?<;H;DJ;I�C7J;H?7?I�CEJ?L7:EI� FEH� KC

H;F;HJbH?E� J^9D?9E� EK� 7HJ;I7D7B )E:;C� I;H� L;HIWJ;?I� ;� ;NJH;C7C;DJ;� L7H?7:EI�� ;

D[E :;L;C B?C?J7H� E� ;IF;9J7:EH� �9ECE� <7P� KC7� F;HIF;9J?L7�� F7H7� KC7� eD?97

?C7=;C�I;B;9?ED7:7�9ECE�7�C7?I�7JH7;DJ; ��+�&)-('�;�$(%�(0,$"�� ����

�?=KH7�����)HE9;IIE�FHE@;JK7B�;�C7GK;J;���H9>?J;9JKH;��7HC��-7?M7D��A?>?I7�!?H7J7

"!'����)�&'������%"*��'"&�������#����

Page 67: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 35

�;� ;I97B7� J?F?97C;DJ;� H;:KP?:7�� KC� CE:;BE� FE:;� 97KI7H B?C?J7]d;I �IF7]EI

?DJ;H?EH;I� D[E� FE:;C� I;H� ;NFBEH7:EI� B?LH;C;DJ;� 9ECE� ;C� KC7� I?CKB7][E

8?:?C;DI?ED7B� ;C CEL?C;DJE�� =;H7:E� FEH� KC7� F;HIF;9J?L7� :?=?J7B� EK� FEH� KC

F;H9KHIE� :?H?=?:E� 7JH7L^I� :;� KC� <?BC;� �F;D7I�CE:;BEI� ;C� =H7D:;� ;I97B7� I;H?7C

L?WL;?I�F7H7�GK; 7�CEL?C;DJ7][E FK:;II;�E9EHH;H�;C�I;K�?DJ;H?EH��7II?C��E�CE:;BE

I;�JEHD7H?7�L?WL;B �<?=� ���;��<?=� ��

�?=KH7� ���&E:;BE�:;��H7DA� ;>HO��07BJ��?ID;O��ED9;HJ�!7BB��?DJ;H?EH�:7�I7B7�:;�9ED9;HJEI���������%EI��D=;B;I�EDJ;� �+"��&��,� �!+2��� ,(+$"'��&?9>7;B���%*�����&��%���'��'(%�����%"��&& F����

�?=KH7� ���&E:;BE�:;��H7DA� ;>HO��07BJ��?ID;O��ED9;HJ�!7BB��?DJ;H?EH�:7�I7B7�:;�9ED9;HJEI� F7B9E���������%EI��D=;B;I�EDJ;� �+"��&��,� �!+2��� ,(+$"'��&?9>7;B���%*�����&��%���'��'(%�����%"��&& F����

Page 68: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 36

'7�C7?EH?7�:EI�97IEI��KC�CE:;BE��7E�9EDJHWH?E�:;�KC7�FB7DJ7�EK�:;�KC7�;B;L7][E�

D[E�^� KC7� <EHC7� 9EDL;D?;DJ;�F7H7� 9ECKD?97H� ;IF;9?<?97]d;I� �7� D[E� I;H� GK;� I;@7

9ED<;99?ED7:E� 9EC� ;IJ7� ?DJ;D][E�� -7C8^C� D[E� FE:;� I;H� H;FHE:KP?:E� J[E

<79?BC;DJ;�9ECE�KC�:;I;D>E�-E:7I�7I�<EHC7I�:;�H;FH;I;DJ7][E�J_C�L7DJ7=;DI�;

B?C?J7]d;I� ?D;H;DJ;I�� ;� ^� FEH� ;IJ7� H7P[E� GK;� 7� C7?EH?7� :EI� 7HGK?J;JEI� KJ?B?P7� EI

C;?EI�:;�9ECKD?97][E�:?<;H;DJ;I�;C�IK7I�9EC8?D7]d;I

(� CE:;BE� ^� KC� ;B;C;DJE� DE� FHE9;IIE� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� ;� I?CKBJ7D;7C;DJ;� ;B;

J7C8^C� J;C� KC7� ;N?IJ_D9?7� :?I@KDJ7� 9ECE� KC� E8@;JE�� ?D:;F;D:;DJ;C;DJ;� :E

FHE@;JE�9EC�E�GK7B�;B;�;IJW�7IIE9?7:E���H;B7][E�7C8`=K7�;DJH;�CE:;BE�;�;:?<`9?E

?D9;II7DJ;C;DJ;�F;HJKH87�EI�7HGK?J;JEI��;�IKH=;�7�F;H=KDJ7� ��!%��/��&�$����$��/

%��������� .C�CE:;BE�D[E�^�KC�;:?<`9?E�;C�C?D?7JKH7��FEHGK;�7�C?D?7JKH?P7][E

<7P�EKJH7�9E?I7�.C�;:?<`9?E�^�F7H7�7�>78?J7][E�>KC7D7��I;�KC�CE:;BE�<EII;�97F7P

:;� 9KCFH?H� ;II;� F7F;B�� I;H?7� KC� ;:?<`9?E�� D[E� KC�CE:;BE� +;9ED>;9;D:E� GK;� EI

CE:;BEI�FE:;C�H;?L?D:?97H�KC7�7KJEDEC?7�H;B7J?L7�:E�;:?<`9?E��7B=KDI�7HGK?J;JEI EI

J_C�9EDI?:;H7:E�7DWBE=EI�U�7J?L?:7:;�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7��GK7I;�;GK?L7B;DJ;I�i*K7D:E

KC�FHE@;JE�^�<EHC7J?LE�EK�;C8H?EDWH?E�EI�:;I;D>EI I[E <H;GK;DJ;C;DJ; 9ED9?IEI�;

�?=KH7� ��&E:;BE�?DL;IJ?=7J?LE�:E�&KI;K�:;��HJ;��EDJ;CFEHYD;7�:;�'?J;Hb?�(I97H�'?;C;O;H�EDJ;� �EJE� B7K9?7��K=KIJE��EDI;97�&KI;K�:7I�&7GK;J;I����.���K;DEI��?H;I�(KJK8HE�:;� ��

� ������)'� ������ ����

�?=KH7� ���&E:;BE�?DL;IJ?=7J?LE�:7��7I7�:7I��7DE7I�(I97H�'?;C;O;H�EDJ;� �EJE� B7K9?7��K=KIJE��EDI;97�&KI;K�:7I�&7GK;J;I����.���K;DEI��?H;I�(KJK8HE�:;� ��

������ �*�����������

��������������������� �������� �������������*���

Page 69: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 37

?C;:?7JEI�� KC7� ;IF^9?;� :;� 9E:?<?97][E� EK� �'�� GK;� ?HW� ?D<EHC7H� 7� JEC7:7� :E

;:?<`9?E� �&"%%,� 7FK:� )+��(�$�� ����� F� � � �IJ;I� :;I;D>EI� FH;B?C?D7H;I� EK

7DJ;9?F7JbH?EI� B;L7C� 7� CE:;BEI� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I� :;� 7H=?B7�� GK;� FE:;C� I;H� CK?JE

F;GK;D7I � :;�JH_I�FEH�9?D9E�FEB;=7:7I�9ECE��7B�)EBO��EK�CK?JE�=H7D:;I��9ECE�E�:;

�=7:?H��9?D9E�C;JHEI�:;�9ECFH?C;DJE�;�JH_I�C;JHEI�:;�B7H=KH7��ECF7H7:E�9EC�KC

:;I;D>E�;C�F7F;B��EI�CE:;BEI�I[E�CK?JE�H;7?I��FE?I�;B;I�I[E�E�;:?<`9?E��B;I�D[E�I[E

i@KD]d;I� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?Ij�� ;B;I� H79?ED7BC;DJ;� 78EH:7C� ;B;L7]d;I� ;� FB7DJ7I

�)+��(�$ � �DJE?D;� )H;:E9A �H9>?J;9J � FW=?D7� E<?9?7B� :;� I;K ;I9H?JbH?E

>JJF�MMMFH;:E9A9EC�B7O9B7O>JCB ;C� �� �� �

�?=KH7� ����DJE?D;�)H;:E9A�CE:;B7D:E�:;DJHE�:;�KC�7L?[E�;C� ����EDJ;���.''�'�&7GK;J7I�:;��HGK?J;9JKH7��F�

�?=KH7� ����DJE?D;�)H;:E9A�CE:;B7D:E�;C�I;K�;I9H?JbH?E�EDJ;��>JJF�MMMFH;:E9A9EC�B7O9B7O>JCB�;C� �� ��

Page 70: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 38

(KJH7�9EHH;DJ;�:;�F;DI7C;DJE�;IJW�L?D9KB7:7 7E�=HKFE�:;�@EL;DI�B?9;D9?7:EI��F;BE

"DIJ?JKJE� :;� �HGK?J;JKH7� :;� &EI9EK ?DJ?JKB7:E iEI� 7HGK?J;JEI� :;� F7F;Bj �

�F7F;HI7H9>?J;9JI���;C�KC7�^FE97��:^97:7�:;������ ;C�GK;�EI�7HJ?IJ7I�:?II?:;DJ;I

D7� .D?[E� ,EL?^J?97� ;H7C� <EH]7:EI� 7E� ;N`B?E� +;FH;I;DJ7:EI� FEH &?9>7;B

�;BEL� �B;N7D:;H� �HE:IAO ;� "BO7� .JA?D�� &?A>7?B� �B?FFEL�� '7:?7 �HEDPEL7� ;� 2KH?

�LL7AKCEL� ;DJH;� EKJHEI� ;IJ;� =HKFE FHE:KP?K� 7� 7HGK?J;JKH7� :;�F7F;B� 9ECE�KC7

<EHC7�:;� 9H`J?97� U� D7JKH;P7� :;IKC7D?P7DJ;� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7� HKII7�:E� F;H`E:E�� KC7

C7D;?H7 :;�9EDJEHD7H�7I�H;IJH?]d;I �<?=� ���;� �<?=� �����FHE:K][E�H;FH;I;DJ7L7�7

?:;?7�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7��;�D[E�7�H;7B?:7:;��KC�E8@;JE�<78H?97:E��9EDIJHK`:E�7�F7HJ?H�:;

?:;?7I�� 9ECE� #7GK;B?D� +E8;HJIED� :;I9H;L;K� DE� 97JWBE=E� :7� ;NFEI?][E� ����� �":;?7

9ECE�CE:;BE�� ;C�eBJ?C7�7DWB?I;��9ED9BK?D:E��i�(�CE:;BE��^�IE8H;�I?�C;ICE�KC7

?:;?7� F7H7� 7� 9E?I7� H;7B�� IE8H;� 7� ;II_D9?7� :;� 9;HJ7I� ?DJ;D]d;I� <KJKH7I�� IE8H;� 7

;IJHKJKH7�<EHC7B�;�7�:;DI?:7:;�9ED9;?JK7B�.C�8H?DGK;:E�97HH;=7:Ej ��+�&)-('

;�$(%�(0,$"� �����

�?=KH7� �� �B;N7D:;H��HE:IAO�(�F;DeBJ?CE�:?7�:;�)ECF^?7� ?DIJ7B7][E-KHDE<<�)E?DJI�������EDJ;��>JJF�MMM8;:DE;HK;D=8HE:IAO>JCB�;C����� ���

�?=KH7� �� �B;N7D:;H��HE:IAO�;�"BO7�.JA?D��KECE�������EDJ;��>JJF�MMM L?7�DICK>;:K��;C����� ���

Page 71: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 39

(�CE:;BE��;DJ[E� ^�KC7� ?:;?7��C7I�J7C8^C�KC�E8@;JE��;B;� JH7J7�:E�FHE@;JE��C7I

J7C8^C� :;� I?� C;ICE� �ECE� KC� E8@;JE�� ;B;� J;C� IK7I� FHbFH?7I� ?:;DJ?:7:;I� ;

FH;I;D]7�� GK;�;N?=;C�7J;D][E�� ;�GK;�FE:;� IKHFH;;D:;H�E�FHbFH?E� 7KJEH�&?9>7;B

H7L;I� FED:;H7� ;II7� 97H79J;H`IJ?97� F;HJKH87:EH7�� i.C7� L;P� GK;� J;D>7CEI

CE:;B7:E�EK�H;FH;I;DJ7:E�KC7�?:;?7��GK;�7�H;FH;I;DJ7][E��E�E8@;JE�<;?JE��9EC;]7

7�J;H�KC7�L?:7�FHbFH?7��7B=E�L7?�7B^C�:;�DEII7�9ED9;F][E�EH?=?D7Bj� +;9ED>;9;D:E

EI� F;H?=EI� 7IIE9?7:EI� U FEI?][E� 7C8`=K7� :E�CE:;BE� FE:;CEI� E8I;HL7H� GK;� IK7

?D:;F;D:_D9?7� D[E� ^� I;CFH;� 8;C�L?D:7�� ;� ;II7� 97H79J;H`IJ?97� 9H?EK� KC7 87J7B>7

�;DJH;� 7HGK?J;JE� ;� CE:;BE�� GK;�� F7H7� 7B=KDI� DKD97� <E?� H;IEBL?:E�� KC� 9ED<B?JE

;NFB?9?J7C;DJ;�H;9ED>;9?:E�FEH�FHE<?II?ED7?I�J[E�:?L;HIEI�DE�J;CFE

7B?B;K� 9H?J?97L7� ;NFB?9?J7C;DJ;� 7� FHWJ?97 :;� KJ?B?P7][E� :;� CE:;BEI� ;C� F;GK;D7

;I97B7� F7H7� FHE@;J7H� 9EDIJHK]d;I� ;� CWGK?D7I�� FEHGK;� ;B;� 79H;:?J7L7� GK;� ;B;I

FE:;H?7C�<EHD;9;H�7F;D7I�?D<EHC7]d;I�C;9YD?97I���9H`J?97 :;� 7B?B;K U FHWJ?97�:;

KI7H�CE:;BEI�^� :?H;9?ED7:7� UGK;B;I� GK;� ;IJ7L7C� 9EDL;D9?:EI� GK7DJE�7 KJ?B?:7:;

:EI� C;ICEI�� GK;H 7HGK?J;JcD?97C;DJ;� EK� ;I9KBJKH7BC;DJ;� EI GK; <?;BC;DJ;� EI

H;FHE:KP?7� ;C� IK7� <EHC7�� I;C� FH;IJ7H� 7J;D][E� UI� :?<;H;D]7I� ;DJH;� EI� C7J;H?7?I

KJ?B?P7:EI�DE�CE:;BE�;�7GK;B;I�KJ?B?P7:EI�DE�E8@;JE�H;7B

�DJ;H?EHC;DJ;� �B8;HJ?� J;D7PC;DJ;�:;<;D:;D:?7�E�KIE�:;�CE:;BEI �<E?�E�FH?C;?HE

:;FE?I�:;�/?JHeL?E�7�B?IJ7H�IK7I�L7DJ7=;DI�9ECE�J7C8^C�<;P��7B:?DK99?���;DGK7DJE�

DE� ;DJ7DJE� ;N9BK? ;IF;9?<?97C;DJ;� 7� IK7� KJ?B?P7][E� 9ECE� ?DIJHKC;DJEI� F7H7

:;J;HC?D7H� 7� <EH]7� :;� KC7� ;IJHKJKH7� EK� :;� GK7BGK;H� :;� IK7I� F7HJ;I ,;=KD:E

�B8;HJ?� 7I� <EHC7I� I[E� :;J;HC?D7:7I� F;BEI� DeC;HEI� ;� :?C;DId;I�� ;� D[E� I;� FE:;

I?CFB;IC;DJ;� ?=DEH7H� 7� ?CFEHJYD9?7� :E� <7JEH� :E� F;IE�� ;N9;JE�� J7BL;P�� :KH7DJ; 7

<EHCKB7][E� ?D?9?7B�:E�FHE8B;C7��;� IEC;DJ; ;C�I;=K?:7� ;DGK7DJE�7�:?C;DI[E�:E

CE:;BE�<EH�CK?JE�F;GK;D7�;C�H;B7][E�7E�E8@;JE�7�I;H�H;7B?P7:E

)EH� EKJHE� B7:E�� ^� CK?JE FHELWL;B� GK;� �B8;HJ?� J;D>7� 9E:?<?97D:E� KC7� 9ED9;F][E

FHWJ?97� KJ?B?P7:7� DEI� CE:;BEI� F7H7 H;IEBL;H� EI� FHE8B;C7I� :;� ;IJ78?B?:7:; ; :;

<EH]7 �B8;HJ? <?N7� IK7I� H;=H7I� :;� FHE9;:?C;DJE� 9EC� E� C^JE:E ����!�'�"� (� GK7B

3 FRAMPTON e KOLBOWSKI, IDEAS AS MODEL (New York: Institute for Archictecture and Urban Studies/Rizzoli, 1981, p.38)

Page 72: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 40

KJ?B?P7�KC�?DIJHKC;DJE�GK;�;B;�FHbFH?E�?DL;DJEK � E ����!�'"%� �<?=� ����9K@E�E8@;J?LE

^�97B9KB7H�7I�L7H?WL;?I�J;CFEH7?I�FHE:KP?:7I�F;BE�CEL?C;DJE�:E�CE:;BE

�ED<HEDJ7D:E� FEH�;N;CFBE� 7I�9EDL;D]d;I�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�KI7:7I�DE�I^9KBE�1/�FEH

%;ED��7JJ?IJ7��B8;HJ?�;�7I�:E�I^9KBE�11�9EC��H7DA� ;>HO��FE:;CEI�9EDI?:;H7H�GK;

�B8;HJ?�J;DJ7�IKFH?C?H�7�7JH7][E�:E�CE:;BE��EI�CE:;BEI�:;L;C�I;H�iFKHEI ;�I?CFB;I�

:;�CE:E�GK;�;B;I :;CEDIJH;C�7� ?D=;DK?:7:;�:;�GK;C�9ED9;8;K�7� ?:;?7��;�D[E�7

>78?B?:7:;�:;�GK;C�E�<78H?9EK�E�CE:;BEj ��%��+--"����� �

;>HO� FHE9KH7� 8KHB7H� E� FE:;H GK;� EI�CE:;BEI� J_C� :;� I;:K][E� JH787B>7D:E� ;C

C7GK;J;I� :;� :K7I� EK� JH_I� ;I97B7I� I?CKBJYD;7I�� FEHGK;�� F7H7� ;B;� i�E� DEI

9ED9;DJH7HCEI�;C�KC7�;I97B7� <?97CEI ;D97DJ7:E�9EC�E�E8@;JE�:?7DJ;�:;�DbI��;�4E

�?=KH7� ���( ����!�'"%��?DIJHKC;DJE�:;�%;ED��7JJ?IJ7��B8;HJ?�EDJ;� >JJF�MMM;C?I:;@EKHD7BI''#��)7IGK7B;>JCB �� ��

Page 73: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 41

CE:;BE5�I;�JEHD7�KC�<?C�;C�L;P�:;�KC�FHE9;IIEj � �!+2�"DJ;HL?;M��H7DA� ;>HO

�97:;CO�E<��H9>?;L;C;DJ � ;DJH;L?IJ7 ;C� ��� ��� � F��

�� FHE8B;C7J?P7][E� :;� �B8;HJ?� F7II7L7� F;B7� GK;IJ[E� :7�CWGK?D7�� ;DGK7DJE� ;>HO

7IIE9?7�7�;I97B7���:?<?9KB:7:;�9EC�EI�CE:;BEI�^�GK;�;B;I�FEIIK;C�7�IK7�FHbFH?7

7JH7][E� ?DJH`DI;97�� E� GK;� D[E� ^�� D;9;II7H?7C;DJ;�� 7� 7JH7][E� :;� KC� ;:?<`9?E

�DGK7DJE�7B=KDI�7HGK?J;JEI�BKJ7C 9EDJH7�;II7�GK7B?:7:;��EKJHEI�H;9ED>;9;C�E�I;K

FEJ;D9?7B�;�E�KJ?B?P7C�F7H7�7J?D=?H�I;KI�FHbFH?EI�E8@;J?LEI��B=KDI�JH7J7C�E�CE:;BE

�?=KH7 ����H7DA� ;>HO�JH787B>7�;C�KC�CE:;BE�F7H7�KC�DELE�;:?<`9?E��������E�<KD:E�KC�CE:;BE;C�EKJH7�;I97B7�EDJ;��>JJF�MMM79>?;L;C;DJEH=7KJE:E9F>EJE9H;:?J79>?;L;HI=;>���� �;C� �� ��

�?=KH7������H7DA� ;>HO�&7GK;J;�:E�?DJ;H?EH�:7��?ID;O�!7BB�EDJ;��>JJF�MMM79>?;L;C;DJEH=7KJE:E9F>EJE9H;:?J79>?;L;HI=;>���� �;C� �� ��

Page 74: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 42

9ECE�KC�JEJ;C��F7II7C�DE�9ECE�KC7�;NFH;II[E�I?C8bB?97��E�GK;�I?=D?<?97�CK?JE

C7?I� :E� GK;� E� FHE@;JE� GK;� :;I9H;L;� (KJHEI E� KJ?B?P7C F7H7� 7JH7?H� E� E8I;HL7:EH

�7JH7L^I� :;� =H7KI� IKHFH;;D:;DJ;I� :;� :;J7B>;I� EK� JHKGK;I� :;� <EJECEDJ7=;C�� :;

CE:E�7�<7P;H�7�79H;:?J7H�;C�IK7�H;7B?:7:;

(� GK;� ;C;H=;� :;� KC� EB>7H� C7?I� 7J;DJE� IE8H;� EI� CE:;BEI� ^� E� 9ECFB;NE

;C7H7D>7:E� :;� D`L;?I� ;C� GK;� 7JK7C� ,;H?7� JEB?9;� ?=DEH7H� J7?I� H;9;FJW9KBEI� :;

C7=D;J?ICE� ;� FE:;H�� IE8H;JK:E�� E� CE:;BE� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B� GK;� :;L;� H;L;B7H� 7

97F79?:7:;�:;�I`DJ;I;�F7H7�9EDI;=K?H�H;FH;I;DJ7H�7�;II_D9?7�:E�FHE@;JE�;C�;I97B7

H;:KP?:7� ;� 7E� C;ICE� J;CFE�� 7� >78?B?:7:;� J^9D?97�� :;� CE:E� GK; i7I� B?D=K7=;DI

?D:?H;J7I�:;H?L7:7I�:7I�CeBJ?FB7I�;B;?]d;I�EF;H7J?L7I�J7?I�9ECE��C7J;H?7?I��J^9D?97I

9EDIJHKJ?L7I��9EH;I��JH7J7C;DJEI�:;�IKF;H<`9?;I��;J9�;IJ;@7C�H;=KB7:EI�I;=KD:E�KC

I78;H�9ECFEI?J?LEj �/+� '�3� ����� F��

Page 75: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V43

�������������������

�MLPDO@OJN� PN<M<H� HJ?@GJN OMD?DH@INDJI<DN K<M<� ?@N@IQJGQ@M� NP<N� D?@D<N� @

>JHPID><M NP<N� DIO@Iip@N� <JN� ?@H<DN� ?@N?@� <� �IODBPD?<?@ � �K@N<M� ?@� <GBPH<N

JN>DG<ip@N� ?@� KJKPG<MD?<?@ @�H@IJM@N� AGPOP<ip@N�� @NN<N� APIip@N�� @ @HKM@BJ� ?JN

HJ?@GJN� @H� B@M<G�� H<IODQ@M<H�N@� >JINO<IO@N� <J� GJIBJ� ?J� O@HKJ +J?@GJN� NgJ

>MD<ip@N LP@� Q@MDAD><H <� Q<GD?<?@� ?JN� KMJE@OJN� @� KJNND=DGDO<H� <� <Q@MDBP<igJ� ?@

?@N@HK@ICJ� ?J� J=E@OJ� @H� LP@NOgJ�� N@MQDI?J� O<H=jH� K<M<� @SKJM� J� KMJE@OJ

0@>PMNJN�@QJGPODQJN ?@H<I?<H�?@� DIQ@NODB<igJ��@�J�HJ?@GJ�N@�<KM@N@IO<�>JHJ <

Q@MDAD><igJ�?J >JI>@DOJ @NN@I>D<G�?@�PH<�AJMH<�AlND><

#H�OJ?JN�JN�HJH@IOJN�?<�CDNOnMD<��JN�HJ?@GJN�AJM<H�PN<?JN�>JIODIP<H@IO@ �#NN@N

<MLPjODKJN OkH�>JIOMD=Pl?J�K<M<�<�KMcOD><�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�@H�>PGOPM<N ?lNK<M@N�>JHJ

<IODBJ�#BDOJ� 2PMLPD<�JOJH<I<��]I?D<��0sNND<�@�(<KgJ �,J�#BDOJ��Cc�@QD?kI>D<N�?@�LP@

JN�HJ?@GJN AJM<H�>MD<?JN�@NK@>D<GH@IO@�K<M<�<PSDGD<M�<�>JINOMPigJ �ADB ���

�GBPIN� K@NLPDN<?JM@N� NPB@M@H� LP@� KDIOPM<N� MPK@NOM@N� KJ?@MD<H� O@M� ND?J

@S@>PO<?<N�<�K<MODM�?@�HJ?@GJN �'H<B@IN�@H�K@LP@IJN�=GJ>JN�?@�<MBDG<�@N>PGKD?JN

@H� @N><G<� @H� <GOJ� M@G@QJ�� IJ� GJ><G� ?J� @Q@IOJ�� @M<H� KJNO@MDJMH@IO@� OM<INKJNO<N

K<M<�<N�K<M@?@N�?<N�><Q@MI<N�JP�K@?M<N �ADB ���

Page 76: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V44

-N� HJ?@GJN� OkH� ND?J� QDO<DN� K<M<� J� @NOP?J� ?J� ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?@ >JI>@Kip@N

KMJE@OP<DN�� <BDI?J� K@MNDNO@IO@H@IO@� >JHJ� PH<� GDIC<� ?@� >JHPID><igJ� @IOM@� J

<MLPDO@OJ� @ JN J=N@MQ<?JM@N� ?J� KMJE@OJ � ,@NO<� ><K<>D?<?@�� J� HJ?@GJ� N@MQ@

KMDI>DK<GH@IO@�>JHJ�H@?D<?JM��KM@@I>C@I?J�JN�>JH=DI<?JN�K<KjDN�?@ DIAJMH<IO@�

OM<?POJM�@�?@A@INJM ?@�D?@D<N

+<N�JN�HJ?@GJN�O<H=jH�KJ?@H�A<U@M�K<MO@�?J�?DcGJBJ�@IOM@�<N�@LPDK@N�?@�KMJE@OJ

@�>JINOMPigJ �.JM�@S@HKGJ��JN BM@BJN�PN<M<H JN�>C<H<?JN yHJ?@GJN�?@�<HJNOM<Nz�

>MD<?JN�K<M<�OM<=<GC<?JM@N�?<�>JINOMPigJ �-N�HJ?@GJN @M<H�PH�HJNOMPcMDJ�JP�PH

@S@HKGJ�PN<?J�K<M<�@NOP?<M�JN�@G@H@IOJN�<MLPDO@OoID>JN�@NK@>lAD>JN��>JHJ ><KDOjDN

JPOMlBGDAJN� �ADB ��� @ �ADB ��

4Tríglifo é o ornato arquitetônico do entablamento dórico constituído por dois sulcos verticais (glifos) inteiros centrais, dois meio-sulcos e uma faixa nocume. (Do grego tríglyphos, «com três sulcos», pelo latim trigl’ phu-, «idem»)

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�?@�!<KDO@G�@H�AJMH<�?@�KG<IO<�?JK@MlJ?J .OJGJH<D>J u 0JH<IJ #BDOJ��������< ! $JIO@��)',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ ?@�PH<�><N<�@BlK>D<�@I>JIOM<?<�@H�PH�OsHPGJ�>@M><�?@����� < ! $JIO@��COOK���RRR CDNOJMTAJMFD?N JMB�G@<MI�@BTKO�<M>CDO@>OPM@�CJPN@N COH�@H����������

$DBPM<���� .G<><�?@� MJIU@ $JIO@� *-++#*��� ��������.G<><�?@� MJIU@������[email protected]�&DNOnMD><�@�.MDHDODQ<���*DQM<MD<�(JNj�-GTHKDJ#?DOJM<��1gJ�.<PGJ��K ��

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�?@�2@HKGJ ��>@M><�����< �! $JIO@��3IDQ@MND?<?@�&@=M<D><�?@�(@MPN<GjH COOK���K@M@BMDI<>PGOPM< RJM?KM@NN >JH@H�����������

Page 77: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V45

� >JI>@KigJ ?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�<�N@M�@?DAD><?<�N@�H<IDA@NOJP�I<N�KMDH@DM<N�>DQDGDU<ip@N�

>JHJ�I<N�>PGOPM<N�H@NJKJOeHD><N �ADB ����@�@BlK>D<N��ADB ����@��ADB �����<OM<QjN�?@

?@N@ICJN�@�HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN �#H=JM<�JN�?@N@ICJN� O@IC<H�N@�?@O@MDJM<?J

KJM�N@PN�AMcB@DN�NPKJMO@N�?@�H<O@MD<DN�K@M@>lQ@DN��<N�H<LP@O@N�N@�A<U@H�KM@N@IO@N

@H�DIsH@M<N�K@i<N�@H�HPN@PN�?@�HPDOJN�K<lN@N

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�?@�O@MM<>JO<�H@NJKJOeHD<��>@M><�����< �! +PN@P�#BlK>DJ��!<GDAnMID< $JIO@�COOK���CMN=NO<AA @?I@O IN ><�R<TH<>�&DNOJMT���������2@MH������ ���1PH@MD<IN�NGD?@N COH�@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�@H�O@MM<>JO<��#BDOJ ���W�?DI<NOD< �>@M><�����< �! +PN@P� MDOeID>J $JIO@�COOK���RRR =MDODNCHPN@PH JMB�@SKGJM@�CDBCGDBCON�CDBCGDBCO;J=E@>ON�<@N�H�HJ?@G;JA;<;CJPN@ <NKS @H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�?@�PH�OsHPGJ�@H�#G��HM<��#BDOJ .@MlJ?J�KMj�?DIcNOD>J�O<M?DJ���>@M><�?@������< �! MDODNC�+PN@PH $JIO@�COOK���RRR =MDODNCHPN@PH JMB�@SKGJM@�CDBCGDBCON�CDBCGDBCO;J=E@>ON�<@N�H�HJ?@G;JA;<;CJPN@ <NKS @H�����������

Page 78: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V46

,J� #BDOJ� N@ >JIN@MQ<M<H ?<� jKJ><� ?J� <MLPDO@OJ� 'HCJO@K IPH@MJN<N� H<LP@O@N�

<GBPH<N�?<N�LP<DN�>JINODOP@H�PH�Q@M?<?@DMJ� DINOMPH@IOJ M@KM@N@IO<ODQJ @�JPOM<N

>JH�>JI?Dip@N�<G@BnMD><N�@�QJODQ<N K<M<�N@M@H�?@KJNDO<?<N�IJN�N@KPGO<H@IOJN �ADB

��

2<H=jH�< OM<?DigJ�C@=M<D><�<K<M@>@�I<�D?@D<�?@ PH HJ?@GJ�KMjQDJ�?<�>JINOMPigJ

#H�%kI@N@N��7<CQj�?DO<�<�,Jj�J�KMJE@OJ�?<��M>< �#H�JPOM<�K<NN<B@H�=l=GD><�QJGO<<

<K<M@>@M < H@NH<� D?@D<� ?@� 7<CQj�� KJMjH IJ� GPB<M� ?<N� DINOMPip@N� Q@M=<DN� PODGDU<

HJ?@GJN�JP�H<LP@O@N ��NNDH��IJ�GDQMJ�?@�[SJ?J��7<CQj�JM?@I<�<�+JDNjN��[SJ?J�����

���� y$<U�H@� PH� 1<IOPcMDJ� K<M<� LP@� @P� KJNN<� C<=DO<M� IJ� H@DJ� ?@G@ � -� A<McN

>JIAJMH@�J�HJ?@GJ�?<�+JM<?<�@�?J�HJ=DGDcMDJ�LP@�QJP�GC@�HJNOM<Mz 2<H=jH�N@

M@A@M@� KJNO@MDJMH@IO@� <JN� HJ?@GJN� >JI>M@OJN� @G<=JM<?JN� K<M<� <� >JINOMPigJ� ?J

><I?@G<=MJ�@�?J�<GO<M�[6-"-������������������

$DBPM<N ����+J?@GJN�LP@�HJNOM<H�J�>JOD?D<IJ�?JN�HJM<?JM@N��#BDOJ ��+PN@P�#BlK>DJ�?@�2PMDH $JIO@��AJOJN�?<��POJM<

Page 79: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V47

,<� <IODBPD?<?@� K<M<� <� >JINOMPigJ� ?@� @?DAl>DJN� DHKJMO<IO@N� @M< I@>@NNcMD<

<@G<=JM<igJ� ?@� DH<B@IN ?@ADID?<N� KMjQD<N�� OM<INHDOD?<N KJM ?DQ@MNJN� NPKJMO@N�

>JHJ�PH�HJ?@GJ��KG<IO<N�JP�DINOMPip@N�Q@M=<DN �ADB ���

,J� HPI?J� BM@BJ� <� PODGDU<igJ� ?@� HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� @M<� PH<� KMcOD><

>JMMDLP@DM<�� >JHJ� <O@NO<H� JN� IPH@MJNJN� @S@HKGJN� ?@ HJ?@GJN ?@ @?DAl>DJN � #NO<

KM@ADBPM<igJ�@NOc�@H�>JINJIeI>D< >JH�<�>JI>@KigJ�KG<OoID><�?@�D?@D<� @H LP@�<N

J=M<N� CPH<I<N� NgJ� H@M<N� DHDO<ip@N�� O<G� >JHJ� N@� @SKM@NN<� IJ� ?DcGJBJ� DIODOPG<?J

�#&�. �.<M<�.G<OgJ��<�D?@D<�j� DH<O@MD<G�� DIQDNlQ@G�@�<=NOM<O<��KJMjH�N@�H<IDA@NO<�IJ

ODKJ�� HJ?@GJ� JP� K<M<?DBH<� PH<� H<M><� >JI>M@O<� ?<LP@G<� >JI>@KigJ LP@� N@

M@<GDU<Q< @H�>nKD<N�K<M<�NP<�PODGDU<igJ �ADB ��� �"@NO<�H<I@DM<�J�OM<=<GCJ ?@ LP@H

KMJE@O<� j� OM<U@M J� HPI?J� M@<G� @� ?JO<M ?@ H<O@MD<GD?<?@� <� @NNkI>D<� ?<N� D?@D<N

�53,# 30%#0��������K ��

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�BM@BJ�@H�O@MM<>JO< � 2@HKGJ�?@�&@M<�@H��MBJN�����< �! ��O@I<N� +PN@P�,<>DJI<G�?@��MLP@JGJBD< $JIO@�COOK���BM@>D<IODB< JMB�DHB�DI?@S <NK�IPH�������@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�N<G<�&DKnNODG<��2@HKGJ�?@�XHJI�0c��> ������< �! $JIO@� )',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K �

V47

,<� <IODBPD?<?@� K<M<� <� >JINOMPigJ� ?@� @?DAl>DJN� DHKJMO<IO@N� @M< I@>@NNcMD<

<@G<=JM<igJ� ?@� DH<B@IN ?@ADID?<N� KMjQD<N�� OM<INHDOD?<N KJM ?DQ@MNJN� NPKJMO@N�

>JHJ�PH�HJ?@GJ��KG<IO<N�JP�DINOMPip@N�Q@M=<DN �ADB ���

,J� HPI?J� BM@BJ� <� PODGDU<igJ� ?@� HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� @M<� PH<� KMcOD><

>JMMDLP@DM<�� >JHJ� <O@NO<H� JN� IPH@MJNJN� @S@HKGJN� ?@ HJ?@GJN ?@ @?DAl>DJN � #NO<

KM@ADBPM<igJ�@NOc�@H�>JINJIeI>D< >JH�<�>JI>@KigJ�KG<OoID><�?@�D?@D<� @H LP@�<N

J=M<N� CPH<I<N� NgJ� H@M<N� DHDO<ip@N�� O<G� >JHJ� N@� @SKM@NN<� IJ� ?DcGJBJ� DIODOPG<?J

�#&�. �.<M<�.G<OgJ��<�D?@D<�j� DH<O@MD<G�� DIQDNlQ@G�@�<=NOM<O<��KJMjH�N@�H<IDA@NO<�IJ

ODKJ�� HJ?@GJ� JP� K<M<?DBH<� PH<� H<M><� >JI>M@O<� ?<LP@G<� >JI>@KigJ LP@� N@

M@<GDU<Q< @H�>nKD<N�K<M<�NP<�PODGDU<igJ �ADB ��� �"@NO<�H<I@DM<�J�OM<=<GCJ ?@ LP@H

KMJE@O<� j� OM<U@M J� HPI?J� M@<G� @� ?JO<M ?@ H<O@MD<GD?<?@� <� @NNkI>D<� ?<N� D?@D<N

�53,# 30%#0��������K ��

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�BM@BJ�@H�O@MM<>JO< � 2@HKGJ�?@�&@M<�@H��MBJN�����< �! ��O@I<N� +PN@P�,<>DJI<G�?@��MLP@JGJBD< $JIO@�COOK���BM@>D<IODB< JMB�DHB�DI?@S <NK�IPH�������@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�N<G<�&DKnNODG<��2@HKGJ�?@�XHJI�0c��> ������< �! $JIO@� )',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K �

V47

,<� <IODBPD?<?@� K<M<� <� >JINOMPigJ� ?@� @?DAl>DJN� DHKJMO<IO@N� @M< I@>@NNcMD<

<@G<=JM<igJ� ?@� DH<B@IN ?@ADID?<N� KMjQD<N�� OM<INHDOD?<N KJM ?DQ@MNJN� NPKJMO@N�

>JHJ�PH�HJ?@GJ��KG<IO<N�JP�DINOMPip@N�Q@M=<DN �ADB ���

,J� HPI?J� BM@BJ� <� PODGDU<igJ� ?@� HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� @M<� PH<� KMcOD><

>JMMDLP@DM<�� >JHJ� <O@NO<H� JN� IPH@MJNJN� @S@HKGJN� ?@ HJ?@GJN ?@ @?DAl>DJN � #NO<

KM@ADBPM<igJ�@NOc�@H�>JINJIeI>D< >JH�<�>JI>@KigJ�KG<OoID><�?@�D?@D<� @H LP@�<N

J=M<N� CPH<I<N� NgJ� H@M<N� DHDO<ip@N�� O<G� >JHJ� N@� @SKM@NN<� IJ� ?DcGJBJ� DIODOPG<?J

�#&�. �.<M<�.G<OgJ��<�D?@D<�j� DH<O@MD<G�� DIQDNlQ@G�@�<=NOM<O<��KJMjH�N@�H<IDA@NO<�IJ

ODKJ�� HJ?@GJ� JP� K<M<?DBH<� PH<� H<M><� >JI>M@O<� ?<LP@G<� >JI>@KigJ LP@� N@

M@<GDU<Q< @H�>nKD<N�K<M<�NP<�PODGDU<igJ �ADB ��� �"@NO<�H<I@DM<�J�OM<=<GCJ ?@ LP@H

KMJE@O<� j� OM<U@M J� HPI?J� M@<G� @� ?JO<M ?@ H<O@MD<GD?<?@� <� @NNkI>D<� ?<N� D?@D<N

�53,# 30%#0��������K ��

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�BM@BJ�@H�O@MM<>JO< � 2@HKGJ�?@�&@M<�@H��MBJN�����< �! ��O@I<N� +PN@P�,<>DJI<G�?@��MLP@JGJBD< $JIO@�COOK���BM@>D<IODB< JMB�DHB�DI?@S <NK�IPH�������@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�N<G<�&DKnNODG<��2@HKGJ�?@�XHJI�0c��> ������< �! $JIO@� )',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K �

Page 80: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V48

2<H=jH�@H�PH�O@SOJ�?@��MDNOnO@G@N�KJ?@HJN�@I>JIOM<M�PH�O@NO@HPICJ�?<�KMcOD><

?<�@G<=JM<igJ�@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ�?J�KMJE@OJ�H@?D<IO@�HJ?@GJN �,<�!JINODOPDigJ�?@

�O@I<N�� J� ADGnNJAJ� IJN� I<MM<� >JHJ� JN� <MLPDO@OJN� BM@BJN� <KM@N@IO<Q<H� K<M<� J

!JIN@GCJ�?JN�/PDIC@IOJN�?<�>D?<?@�NP<N�H<LP@O@N�?@�H<?@DM<�JP�>@MeHD><�K<M<�<

>JINOMPigJ�?JN�@?DAl>DJN�Ks=GD>JN ��"�+� ����� K ���

� C<=DGD?<?@�?@�KG<I@E<M�J�KMJ?POJ�@�<�NP<�@S@>PigJ�N@�KMJ>@NN<�N@BPI?J�?DA@M@IO@N

@NOM<OjBD<N� <J� GJIBJ�?<�CDNOnMD<� @� I<N� ?DA@M@IO@N� J=M<N �� CDNOnMD<� ?<N� >DQDGDU<ip@N

AJMI@>@� DIsH@MJN� @S@HKGJN� ?< ><K<>D?<?@� CPH<I<� K<M<� M@<GDU<M� KMJE@OJN� @

HJ?DAD><M� >JIN>D@IO@H@IO@� <� I<OPM@U< �� Oj>ID><� >JINOMPODQ<�� ?@N?@� >@?J� I<

CDNOnMD<��@NOc�<NNJ>D<?<�<�PH�KMJE@OJ�LP@�N@�KM<OD>< <IO@N�@�?PM<IO@�<�J=M<

,<� jKJ><� ?J� 'HKjMDJ� 0JH<IJ� JN� KMJE@OJN� ?<N� J=M<N� Ks=GD><N� ?@N@IMJG<Q<H� ?@

<>JM?J�>JH�PH�KMJ>@?DH@IOJ ?@�IJMH<N LP@�>JIODIC<�J�HJ?@GJ�?J�@?DAl>DJ�@H�NP<

M@KM@N@IO<igJ �ADB ���

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J 2@HKGJ�?@�4@NO<��2DQJGD���> ����< �! $JIO@� $JIO@��)',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K ��

V48

2<H=jH�@H�PH�O@SOJ�?@��MDNOnO@G@N�KJ?@HJN�@I>JIOM<M�PH�O@NO@HPICJ�?<�KMcOD><

?<�@G<=JM<igJ�@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ�?J�KMJE@OJ�H@?D<IO@�HJ?@GJN �,<�!JINODOPDigJ�?@

�O@I<N�� J� ADGnNJAJ� IJN� I<MM<� >JHJ� JN� <MLPDO@OJN� BM@BJN� <KM@N@IO<Q<H� K<M<� J

!JIN@GCJ�?JN�/PDIC@IOJN�?<�>D?<?@�NP<N�H<LP@O@N�?@�H<?@DM<�JP�>@MeHD><�K<M<�<

>JINOMPigJ�?JN�@?DAl>DJN�Ks=GD>JN ��"�+� ����� K ���

� C<=DGD?<?@�?@�KG<I@E<M�J�KMJ?POJ�@�<�NP<�@S@>PigJ�N@�KMJ>@NN<�N@BPI?J�?DA@M@IO@N

@NOM<OjBD<N� <J� GJIBJ�?<�CDNOnMD<� @� I<N� ?DA@M@IO@N� J=M<N �� CDNOnMD<� ?<N� >DQDGDU<ip@N

AJMI@>@� DIsH@MJN� @S@HKGJN� ?< ><K<>D?<?@� CPH<I<� K<M<� M@<GDU<M� KMJE@OJN� @

HJ?DAD><M� >JIN>D@IO@H@IO@� <� I<OPM@U< �� Oj>ID><� >JINOMPODQ<�� ?@N?@� >@?J� I<

CDNOnMD<��@NOc�<NNJ>D<?<�<�PH�KMJE@OJ�LP@�N@�KM<OD>< <IO@N�@�?PM<IO@�<�J=M<

,<� jKJ><� ?J� 'HKjMDJ� 0JH<IJ� JN� KMJE@OJN� ?<N� J=M<N� Ks=GD><N� ?@N@IMJG<Q<H� ?@

<>JM?J�>JH�PH�KMJ>@?DH@IOJ ?@�IJMH<N LP@�>JIODIC<�J�HJ?@GJ�?J�@?DAl>DJ�@H�NP<

M@KM@N@IO<igJ �ADB ���

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J 2@HKGJ�?@�4@NO<��2DQJGD���> ����< �! $JIO@� $JIO@��)',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K ��

V48

2<H=jH�@H�PH�O@SOJ�?@��MDNOnO@G@N�KJ?@HJN�@I>JIOM<M�PH�O@NO@HPICJ�?<�KMcOD><

?<�@G<=JM<igJ�@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ�?J�KMJE@OJ�H@?D<IO@�HJ?@GJN �,<�!JINODOPDigJ�?@

�O@I<N�� J� ADGnNJAJ� IJN� I<MM<� >JHJ� JN� <MLPDO@OJN� BM@BJN� <KM@N@IO<Q<H� K<M<� J

!JIN@GCJ�?JN�/PDIC@IOJN�?<�>D?<?@�NP<N�H<LP@O@N�?@�H<?@DM<�JP�>@MeHD><�K<M<�<

>JINOMPigJ�?JN�@?DAl>DJN�Ks=GD>JN ��"�+� ����� K ���

� C<=DGD?<?@�?@�KG<I@E<M�J�KMJ?POJ�@�<�NP<�@S@>PigJ�N@�KMJ>@NN<�N@BPI?J�?DA@M@IO@N

@NOM<OjBD<N� <J� GJIBJ�?<�CDNOnMD<� @� I<N� ?DA@M@IO@N� J=M<N �� CDNOnMD<� ?<N� >DQDGDU<ip@N

AJMI@>@� DIsH@MJN� @S@HKGJN� ?< ><K<>D?<?@� CPH<I<� K<M<� M@<GDU<M� KMJE@OJN� @

HJ?DAD><M� >JIN>D@IO@H@IO@� <� I<OPM@U< �� Oj>ID><� >JINOMPODQ<�� ?@N?@� >@?J� I<

CDNOnMD<��@NOc�<NNJ>D<?<�<�PH�KMJE@OJ�LP@�N@�KM<OD>< <IO@N�@�?PM<IO@�<�J=M<

,<� jKJ><� ?J� 'HKjMDJ� 0JH<IJ� JN� KMJE@OJN� ?<N� J=M<N� Ks=GD><N� ?@N@IMJG<Q<H� ?@

<>JM?J�>JH�PH�KMJ>@?DH@IOJ ?@�IJMH<N LP@�>JIODIC<�J�HJ?@GJ�?J�@?DAl>DJ�@H�NP<

M@KM@N@IO<igJ �ADB ���

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J 2@HKGJ�?@�4@NO<��2DQJGD���> ����< �! $JIO@� $JIO@��)',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K ��

Page 81: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V49

+D>C@G<IB@GJ N@� M@A@MD< <� @NO<� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� >JHJ� J� y?@N@ICJ� <IBjGD>J� @� IgJ

CPH<IJz -� .<IO@gJ ?@� 0JH<KJNNPD� AJMO@N� OM<iJN� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<� C@G@IlNOD><� @

M@Q@G< a >JI>GPNgJ� GnBD><� ?@� PH<� @NOMPOPM<� <MLPDO@OoID><� A@DO<� ?@� GDIC<N� @� ?@

NPK@MAl>D@N� >PMQ<N >JH� <� >sKPG<� <=J=<?<?<� OJH<?<� KJM� <GQjJGJN� @H� AJMH<OJ

LP<?M<IBPG<M � ,J� OJKJ� ?@NO<� H@NH<� >sKPG<� <DI?<� N@� @I>JIOM<� PH<� <=@MOPM<

>DM>PG<M u A@DO<�@H�CJH@I<B@H�<J�?@PN� NJG u >JH�IJQ@�H@OMJN�?@�?DeH@OMJ�LP@

K@MHDO@� <� @IOM<?<�?@�PH� A@>CJ�?@� GPU� IJ� M@>DIOJ � 1@PN� >JINOMPOJM@N� <>M@?DO<Q<H

LP@� <� ?DNOeI>D<� ?<� <=@MOPM<� <J� >CgJ� ?@� LP<M@IO<� @� OMkN�H@OMJN�� K@MHDOD<� LP@� <

>CPQ<�N@><NN@�<IO@N�?@�OJ><M�J�OjMM@J

,J�>JIODI@IO@��H@MD><IJ�O<H=jH�AJD�KJNNlQ@G�@I>JIOM<M�M@NOJN�H<O@MD<DN�?@�JPOM<N

>PGOPM<N �,<��HjMD><�KMj�>JGJH=D<I< JN�HJ?@GJN�?@�<MBDG<��H<?@DM<�@ K@?M<�AJM<H

@HKM@B<?JNKJM�?DNODIO<N�>DQDGDU<ip@N �ADB ����@ �� y��KM@?JHDIeI>D<�?@�PNJ N@�?@P

>JH� KMJAPNgJ� I<� >DQDGDU<igJ DI><�� >PEJN� >JINOMPOJM@N� HJ?@G<M<H� IPH@MJN<N

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J 'IO@MDJM�?J�.<IO@gJ��0JH< ���� u ���$JIO@� $JIO@��)',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K �����

V49

+D>C@G<IB@GJ N@� M@A@MD< <� @NO<� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� >JHJ� J� y?@N@ICJ� <IBjGD>J� @� IgJ

CPH<IJz -� .<IO@gJ ?@� 0JH<KJNNPD� AJMO@N� OM<iJN� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<� C@G@IlNOD><� @

M@Q@G< a >JI>GPNgJ� GnBD><� ?@� PH<� @NOMPOPM<� <MLPDO@OoID><� A@DO<� ?@� GDIC<N� @� ?@

NPK@MAl>D@N� >PMQ<N >JH� <� >sKPG<� <=J=<?<?<� OJH<?<� KJM� <GQjJGJN� @H� AJMH<OJ

LP<?M<IBPG<M � ,J� OJKJ� ?@NO<� H@NH<� >sKPG<� <DI?<� N@� @I>JIOM<� PH<� <=@MOPM<

>DM>PG<M u A@DO<�@H�CJH@I<B@H�<J�?@PN� NJG u >JH�IJQ@�H@OMJN�?@�?DeH@OMJ�LP@

K@MHDO@� <� @IOM<?<�?@�PH� A@>CJ�?@� GPU� IJ� M@>DIOJ � 1@PN� >JINOMPOJM@N� <>M@?DO<Q<H

LP@� <� ?DNOeI>D<� ?<� <=@MOPM<� <J� >CgJ� ?@� LP<M@IO<� @� OMkN�H@OMJN�� K@MHDOD<� LP@� <

>CPQ<�N@><NN@�<IO@N�?@�OJ><M�J�OjMM@J

,J�>JIODI@IO@��H@MD><IJ�O<H=jH�AJD�KJNNlQ@G�@I>JIOM<M�M@NOJN�H<O@MD<DN�?@�JPOM<N

>PGOPM<N �,<��HjMD><�KMj�>JGJH=D<I< JN�HJ?@GJN�?@�<MBDG<��H<?@DM<�@ K@?M<�AJM<H

@HKM@B<?JNKJM�?DNODIO<N�>DQDGDU<ip@N �ADB ����@ �� y��KM@?JHDIeI>D<�?@�PNJ N@�?@P

>JH� KMJAPNgJ� I<� >DQDGDU<igJ DI><�� >PEJN� >JINOMPOJM@N� HJ?@G<M<H� IPH@MJN<N

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J 'IO@MDJM�?J�.<IO@gJ��0JH< ���� u ���$JIO@� $JIO@��)',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K �����

V49

+D>C@G<IB@GJ N@� M@A@MD< <� @NO<� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� >JHJ� J� y?@N@ICJ� <IBjGD>J� @� IgJ

CPH<IJz -� .<IO@gJ ?@� 0JH<KJNNPD� AJMO@N� OM<iJN� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<� C@G@IlNOD><� @

M@Q@G< a >JI>GPNgJ� GnBD><� ?@� PH<� @NOMPOPM<� <MLPDO@OoID><� A@DO<� ?@� GDIC<N� @� ?@

NPK@MAl>D@N� >PMQ<N >JH� <� >sKPG<� <=J=<?<?<� OJH<?<� KJM� <GQjJGJN� @H� AJMH<OJ

LP<?M<IBPG<M � ,J� OJKJ� ?@NO<� H@NH<� >sKPG<� <DI?<� N@� @I>JIOM<� PH<� <=@MOPM<

>DM>PG<M u A@DO<�@H�CJH@I<B@H�<J�?@PN� NJG u >JH�IJQ@�H@OMJN�?@�?DeH@OMJ�LP@

K@MHDO@� <� @IOM<?<�?@�PH� A@>CJ�?@� GPU� IJ� M@>DIOJ � 1@PN� >JINOMPOJM@N� <>M@?DO<Q<H

LP@� <� ?DNOeI>D<� ?<� <=@MOPM<� <J� >CgJ� ?@� LP<M@IO<� @� OMkN�H@OMJN�� K@MHDOD<� LP@� <

>CPQ<�N@><NN@�<IO@N�?@�OJ><M�J�OjMM@J

,J�>JIODI@IO@��H@MD><IJ�O<H=jH�AJD�KJNNlQ@G�@I>JIOM<M�M@NOJN�H<O@MD<DN�?@�JPOM<N

>PGOPM<N �,<��HjMD><�KMj�>JGJH=D<I< JN�HJ?@GJN�?@�<MBDG<��H<?@DM<�@ K@?M<�AJM<H

@HKM@B<?JNKJM�?DNODIO<N�>DQDGDU<ip@N �ADB ����@ �� y��KM@?JHDIeI>D<�?@�PNJ N@�?@P

>JH� KMJAPNgJ� I<� >DQDGDU<igJ DI><�� >PEJN� >JINOMPOJM@N� HJ?@G<M<H� IPH@MJN<N

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J 'IO@MDJM�?J�.<IO@gJ��0JH< ���� u ���$JIO@� $JIO@��)',"#01*#7��"JMGDIB �"D>DJIcMDJ�4DNP<G�?<��MLPDO@OPM<��K �����

Page 82: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V50

H<LP@O@N�K<M<�<�>JINOMPigJ�?@�NP<N�J=M<N�HJIPH@IO<DN��>JHJ�O@HKGJN��K<Gc>DJN�

AJMO<G@U<N�@�N@KPG>MJNz� -**',%#0��������K ����

$DBPM<���� +J?@GJ�?<�.M<i<�!@MDHJID<G��MDOP<G�M@G<>DJI<?J�<J�>PGOJ�<JN�HJMOJN��H<?@DM<O<GC<?<�@�>JI>C<N �#NODGJ�!CDHs�2<M?DJ�����������? �! #SKJNDigJ ��(��%�'�(��%�&.'�(�

�&3!�'�,��� %� �+*.#-��-.+� )+��(%(&�#'��� +PN@P�+�*'��*DH<��.@MP $JIO@��$JOJ ?<�<POJM<

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�!C<QlI�?@�&PcIO<M�������< �! ��+PN@P�,<>DJI<G�?@�!C<QlI��.@MP $JIO@��$JOJ ?< <POJM<

Page 83: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V51

-N� JOJH<IJN� @I>JIOM<M<H IJ� HJ?@GJ� <� A@MM<H@IO<� @NN@I>D<G� K<M<� J

?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?@� N@PN KMJE@OJN >JH� J� DIOPDOJ� ?@ >JHPID><M� NP<N� D?@D<N� <JN

>GD@IO@N�@�>JIQ@I>k�GJN�<�>JINOMPDM 3H�@S@HKGJ�j�J HJ?@GJ�?@O<GC<?J @H H<?@DM<

@�H<MADH ?<�H@NLPDO<�1tG@TH<IDT@��M@KM@N@IO<?<�KJM�PH<�O<K@i<MD< �ADB ���

,J� K@MlJ?J� H@?D@Q<G <N� DH<B@IN <KM@N@IO<H N@� >JH� PH<� AJMO@ ADI<GD?<?@

K@?<BnBD>< � 'BM@E<� !<OnGD>< <NNPH@J K<K@G� ?@ ADGOM<M<N� KMJ?Pip@N� >D@IOlAD><N� @

>PGOPM<DN� A<U@I?J� >JH� LP@� HPDO<N� J=M<N <MOlNOD><N ODQ@NN@H PH<

O@HcOD>< M@GDBDJN< �BM<I?@� LP<IOD?<?@ ?@� M@KM@N@IO<ip@N� <MOlNOD><N� �HJN<D>JN�

<AM@N>JN� @� @N>PGOPM<N M@OM<O<H� ADBPM<N� ?@� M@DN�� KMlI>DK@N�K<K<N@� N<IOJN @SD=DI?J

HJ?@GJN�?@�<MLPDO@OPM<��K<MOD>PG<MH@IO@�DBM@E<N ��ADB �������������������@ ��

$DBPM<���� &JH@IN�OM<INKJMO<H�J�HJ?@GJ�@�M@>DO<I?J�Q@MNJN�M@A@M@IO@N�CJH@I<B@<I?J�JN

<MLPDO@OJN�@IB@IC@DMJN�LP@�NPK@M<M<H�<�OJ?JN�JN�N@PN�K<M@N�I<�>JINOMPigJ�?<�H@NLPDO<

�5%�2&�'#2���M@<GDU<?J�?PM<IO@�PH�A@NODQ<G�@H�����

$JIO@� COOK���RRR F<IT<F >JH�NDI<I COHG�@H�����������

V51

-N� JOJH<IJN� @I>JIOM<M<H IJ� HJ?@GJ� <� A@MM<H@IO<� @NN@I>D<G� K<M<� J

?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?@� N@PN KMJE@OJN >JH� J� DIOPDOJ� ?@ >JHPID><M� NP<N� D?@D<N� <JN

>GD@IO@N�@�>JIQ@I>k�GJN�<�>JINOMPDM 3H�@S@HKGJ�j�J HJ?@GJ�?@O<GC<?J @H H<?@DM<

@�H<MADH ?<�H@NLPDO<�1tG@TH<IDT@��M@KM@N@IO<?<�KJM�PH<�O<K@i<MD< �ADB ���

,J� K@MlJ?J� H@?D@Q<G <N� DH<B@IN <KM@N@IO<H N@� >JH� PH<� AJMO@ ADI<GD?<?@

K@?<BnBD>< � 'BM@E<� !<OnGD>< <NNPH@J K<K@G� ?@ ADGOM<M<N� KMJ?Pip@N� >D@IOlAD><N� @

>PGOPM<DN� A<U@I?J� >JH� LP@� HPDO<N� J=M<N <MOlNOD><N ODQ@NN@H PH<

O@HcOD>< M@GDBDJN< �BM<I?@� LP<IOD?<?@ ?@� M@KM@N@IO<ip@N� <MOlNOD><N� �HJN<D>JN�

<AM@N>JN� @� @N>PGOPM<N M@OM<O<H� ADBPM<N� ?@� M@DN�� KMlI>DK@N�K<K<N@� N<IOJN @SD=DI?J

HJ?@GJN�?@�<MLPDO@OPM<��K<MOD>PG<MH@IO@�DBM@E<N ��ADB �������������������@ ��

$DBPM<���� &JH@IN�OM<INKJMO<H�J�HJ?@GJ�@�M@>DO<I?J�Q@MNJN�M@A@M@IO@N�CJH@I<B@<I?J�JN

<MLPDO@OJN�@IB@IC@DMJN�LP@�NPK@M<M<H�<�OJ?JN�JN�N@PN�K<M@N�I<�>JINOMPigJ�?<�H@NLPDO<

�5%�2&�'#2���M@<GDU<?J�?PM<IO@�PH�A@NODQ<G�@H�����

$JIO@� COOK���RRR F<IT<F >JH�NDI<I COHG�@H�����������

V51

-N� JOJH<IJN� @I>JIOM<M<H IJ� HJ?@GJ� <� A@MM<H@IO<� @NN@I>D<G� K<M<� J

?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?@� N@PN KMJE@OJN >JH� J� DIOPDOJ� ?@ >JHPID><M� NP<N� D?@D<N� <JN

>GD@IO@N�@�>JIQ@I>k�GJN�<�>JINOMPDM 3H�@S@HKGJ�j�J HJ?@GJ�?@O<GC<?J @H H<?@DM<

@�H<MADH ?<�H@NLPDO<�1tG@TH<IDT@��M@KM@N@IO<?<�KJM�PH<�O<K@i<MD< �ADB ���

,J� K@MlJ?J� H@?D@Q<G <N� DH<B@IN <KM@N@IO<H N@� >JH� PH<� AJMO@ ADI<GD?<?@

K@?<BnBD>< � 'BM@E<� !<OnGD>< <NNPH@J K<K@G� ?@ ADGOM<M<N� KMJ?Pip@N� >D@IOlAD><N� @

>PGOPM<DN� A<U@I?J� >JH� LP@� HPDO<N� J=M<N <MOlNOD><N ODQ@NN@H PH<

O@HcOD>< M@GDBDJN< �BM<I?@� LP<IOD?<?@ ?@� M@KM@N@IO<ip@N� <MOlNOD><N� �HJN<D>JN�

<AM@N>JN� @� @N>PGOPM<N M@OM<O<H� ADBPM<N� ?@� M@DN�� KMlI>DK@N�K<K<N@� N<IOJN @SD=DI?J

HJ?@GJN�?@�<MLPDO@OPM<��K<MOD>PG<MH@IO@�DBM@E<N ��ADB �������������������@ ��

$DBPM<���� &JH@IN�OM<INKJMO<H�J�HJ?@GJ�@�M@>DO<I?J�Q@MNJN�M@A@M@IO@N�CJH@I<B@<I?J�JN

<MLPDO@OJN�@IB@IC@DMJN�LP@�NPK@M<M<H�<�OJ?JN�JN�N@PN�K<M@N�I<�>JINOMPigJ�?<�H@NLPDO<

�5%�2&�'#2���M@<GDU<?J�?PM<IO@�PH�A@NODQ<G�@H�����

$JIO@� COOK���RRR F<IT<F >JH�NDI<I COHG�@H�����������

Page 84: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V52

$DBPM< ��� .<K<�$@GDS�'4��+JN<D>J�I<�'BM@E<�?@�1gJ�!JNH@�@�"<HDgJ��0JH<�������� $JIO@� COOK���>JPIO@MGDBCONM<ION<I?=G<OC@M� =GJBNKJO >JH =M���������>M@<ODJI�JA�>CMDNOD<I�<MO�>JINO<IODID<I COHG

$DBPM< ��� DNKJ�$@GDNDPN��'BM@E<�?@�1<I�4DO<G@��0<Q@I<��'OcGD<��������� $JIO@��COOK���><O@?M<DNH@?D@Q<DN =GJBNKJO >JH =M���������M<Q@II<�KJHK<�CD@M<OD><�?<�DBM@E< COHG

$DBPM< ��� DNKJ�#PAM<ND<IJ�� <NDGD>< #PAM<ND<I<��.<M@>��!MJc>D<�> ���� $JIO@� COOK���>JHHJIN RDFDH@?D< JMB�RDFD�$DG@�.JM@�!���";�; <N�!���"GD><;#PAM<ND<I<;�;+JN<D>N;?@;G�<=NDN (.%

Page 85: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V53

$DBPM< ��� .<K<�.@G<BDPN�''��DBM@E<�?@ 1<I�*JM@IUJ�$DJMD�G@�+PM<��0DH<��������$JIO@��COOK�����Q<MQ<M< RJM?KM@NN >JH������������PIFIJRI�<MODNO�H<E@NO<N�?JHDID�>CMDNO�DI�H<E@NOT�

=<NDGD><�K<K<G@�?D�N<I�GJM@IUJ�APJMD�G@�HPM<�MJH<�DO<GT�G<O@��OC�>@IOPMT�PIFIJRI�<MODNO�H<E@NO<N�?JHDID�>CMDNO�DI�H<E@NOT�=<NDGD><�K<K<G@�?D�N<I�GJM@IUJ�APJMD�G@�HPM<�MJH<�DOG<T�G<O@��OC�>@IOPMT�

$DBPM< ��� @<OJ� <MOJGJ�*JIBJ�<KM@N@IO<�<J .<K<�*@gJ�6'''�<�H<LP@O@�?J�1<IOPcMDJ�?@�.JHKjD< 1<IOPcMDJ?@�,JNN<�1@ICJM<�?J�0JNcMDJ�?@�.JHKjD<

$JIO@� COOK���RRR <>INA JMB =M�<MOD>G@������� @<OJ� <MOJGJ�*JIBJ��"@�?@QJOJ�?J�?@HJIDJ�<�<KJNOJGJ�?J�0JN<MDJ�� COHG

Page 86: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V54

-N� <MLPDO@OJN QD<E<Q<H� >JH AM@LPkI>D< K<M<� @NOP?<M� @� M@BDNOM<M� <N� KMJKJMip@N

API?<H@IO<DN ?JN�@S@HKGJN�>GcNND>JN�LP@��KJNO@MDJMH@IO@��<?<KO<MD<H�@H�APIigJ

?J�?@N@EJ�?J�>GD@IO@ �#H=JM<�<N�H<LP@O@N�IgJ�AJNN@H�AM@LP@IO@N�I@NN<�jKJ><��@H

<GBPH<N�J><NDp@N�J�HJ?@GJ�N@�M@<GDU<Q<�@H�H<?@DM<�>JH�<�ADI<GD?<?@�?@�<KM@N@IO<M

<J�>GD@IO@�PH<�?@N>MDigJ�?@O<GC<?<�@�O<H=jH�?@�><G>PG<M�JN�H<O@MD<DN�@�>PNOJ�?<

>JINOMPigJ

�N� >JINOMPip@N� BnOD><N ><M<>O@MDU<H�N@K@G<N� <=n=<?<N� ?@� I@MQPM<� @� <M>JN

<KJIO<?JN� JP� ?@� G<I>@O<�� <M>J=JO<IO@N�� M@I?DGC<?JN� >JH� K@?M<N� @� E<I@G<N� >JH

QDOM<DN �ADB ��@���

$DBPM< ��� �=<?D<�?@�1<IO<�$j��!JILP@N�$M<Ii<��> ���������� �+J?@GJ�?JOM<IN@KOJ�@�><HK<IcMDJ$JIO@��$JOJ ?<��POJM<

$DBPM<���� !<O@?M<G�?@�,JOM@ "<H@ ?@�.<MDN $JIO@��$JOJ�?<�<POJM<

V54

-N� <MLPDO@OJN QD<E<Q<H� >JH AM@LPkI>D< K<M<� @NOP?<M� @� M@BDNOM<M� <N� KMJKJMip@N

API?<H@IO<DN ?JN�@S@HKGJN�>GcNND>JN�LP@��KJNO@MDJMH@IO@��<?<KO<MD<H�@H�APIigJ

?J�?@N@EJ�?J�>GD@IO@ �#H=JM<�<N�H<LP@O@N�IgJ�AJNN@H�AM@LP@IO@N�I@NN<�jKJ><��@H

<GBPH<N�J><NDp@N�J�HJ?@GJ�N@�M@<GDU<Q<�@H�H<?@DM<�>JH�<�ADI<GD?<?@�?@�<KM@N@IO<M

<J�>GD@IO@�PH<�?@N>MDigJ�?@O<GC<?<�@�O<H=jH�?@�><G>PG<M�JN�H<O@MD<DN�@�>PNOJ�?<

>JINOMPigJ

�N� >JINOMPip@N� BnOD><N ><M<>O@MDU<H�N@K@G<N� <=n=<?<N� ?@� I@MQPM<� @� <M>JN

<KJIO<?JN� JP� ?@� G<I>@O<�� <M>J=JO<IO@N�� M@I?DGC<?JN� >JH� K@?M<N� @� E<I@G<N� >JH

QDOM<DN �ADB ��@���

$DBPM< ��� �=<?D<�?@�1<IO<�$j��!JILP@N�$M<Ii<��> ���������� �+J?@GJ�?JOM<IN@KOJ�@�><HK<IcMDJ$JIO@��$JOJ ?<��POJM<

$DBPM<���� !<O@?M<G�?@�,JOM@ "<H@ ?@�.<MDN $JIO@��$JOJ�?<�<POJM<

V54

-N� <MLPDO@OJN QD<E<Q<H� >JH AM@LPkI>D< K<M<� @NOP?<M� @� M@BDNOM<M� <N� KMJKJMip@N

API?<H@IO<DN ?JN�@S@HKGJN�>GcNND>JN�LP@��KJNO@MDJMH@IO@��<?<KO<MD<H�@H�APIigJ

?J�?@N@EJ�?J�>GD@IO@ �#H=JM<�<N�H<LP@O@N�IgJ�AJNN@H�AM@LP@IO@N�I@NN<�jKJ><��@H

<GBPH<N�J><NDp@N�J�HJ?@GJ�N@�M@<GDU<Q<�@H�H<?@DM<�>JH�<�ADI<GD?<?@�?@�<KM@N@IO<M

<J�>GD@IO@�PH<�?@N>MDigJ�?@O<GC<?<�@�O<H=jH�?@�><G>PG<M�JN�H<O@MD<DN�@�>PNOJ�?<

>JINOMPigJ

�N� >JINOMPip@N� BnOD><N ><M<>O@MDU<H�N@K@G<N� <=n=<?<N� ?@� I@MQPM<� @� <M>JN

<KJIO<?JN� JP� ?@� G<I>@O<�� <M>J=JO<IO@N�� M@I?DGC<?JN� >JH� K@?M<N� @� E<I@G<N� >JH

QDOM<DN �ADB ��@���

$DBPM< ��� �=<?D<�?@�1<IO<�$j��!JILP@N�$M<Ii<��> ���������� �+J?@GJ�?JOM<IN@KOJ�@�><HK<IcMDJ$JIO@��$JOJ ?<��POJM<

$DBPM<���� !<O@?M<G�?@�,JOM@ "<H@ ?@�.<MDN $JIO@��$JOJ�?<�<POJM<

Page 87: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V55

- ?@N@ICJ�a HgJ�@�JN�HJ?@GJN�OMD?DH@INDJI<DN NgJ�NDHDG<M@N a @N>MDO<� <�PODGDU<igJ

?JN NDNO@H<N� ODKJBMcAD>JN� ?@� @N>MDO<� ?@K@I?@ ?@� PH� N@IOD?J� ?@� >JIADBPM<igJ ?@

G@OM<N� K<M<� AJMH<M K<G<QM<N� @� AM<N@N� LP@� O@IC<H� PH� NDBIDAD><?J � �KGD><I?J @NO@

KMDI>lKDJ�a�<MLPDO@OPM<��KJ?@�N@ ?DU@M�LP@�yNn N@�<KM@I?@�<�A<U@M�H<LP@O@N�A<U@I?J�

<Nz �*_"2)#��4-,�.'#01������ ��?@NOM@U<�KMcOD>< NJH@IO@�N@�?@N@IQJGQ@�H@?D<IO@

J�OM<=<GCJ�>JOD?D<IJ

"PM<IO@�J�0@I<N>DH@IOJ��J�NPMBDH@IOJ�?J�@?DAl>DJ��<>JHK<IC<?J�?< DIOMJ?PigJ�?@

IJQ<N� AJMH<N� IgJ BnOD><N�� NJGD>DOJP� PH�<PH@IOJ� I<� A<=MD><igJ�?@�HJ?@GJN� >JHJ

AJMH<� ?@� ?@HJINOM<M� <� DIO@IigJ� ?J� <MLPDO@OJ� K<M<� J� >GD@IO@�� =@H� >JHJ� K<M<� J

?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?J� KMJE@OJ � � 1@H� ?sQD?<�� J� @HKM@BJ� AM@LP@IO@� ?@� >JHK@ODip@N

?PM<IO@�@NO@�K@MlJ?J��@H�LP@��K<M<�B<M<IODM�<�DBP<G?<?@� OJ?JN�JN�<MLPDO@OJN�@M<H

J=MDB<?JN� <� A<U@M�HJ?@GJN� DI>@IODQJP� <� O@I?kI>D< ?@� >JINOMPDM� H<LP@O@N�� <NNDH

>JHJ� <� I<OPM@U<� H<DN� <=@MO<� ?J� KMJ>@NNJ� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM<�� <� <KM@N@IO<igJ� ?J

@NLP@H<�K<M<�>JHDNNp@N�JP�H@NHJ�K<M<�J�Ks=GD>J K<M<�<KMJQ<igJ�@M<�>JHPH ,J

0@I<N>DH@IOJ� J� <MLPDO@OJ� ?@DSJP� ?@� N@M� PH� ><MKDIO@DMJ K<M<� N@� >JIQ@MO@M� <

KMJADNNDJI<G� LP@� OM<=<GC<Q<� >JH� J� KMJKnNDOJ� ?@� >JHPID><M� N@PN� ?@N@ICJN� <JN

JK@McMDJN� K<M<� LP@� JN� @S@>PO<NN@H � � #NO<� ?DQDNgJ� Oj>ID><� ?J� OM<=<GCJ� JMDBDIJP� <

I@>@NND?<?@�?@�?@N@IQJGQ@M�PH�DINOMPH@IOJ�LP@�M@AG@OD<�<�>JI>@KigJ�?J�@?DAl>DJ�@

<�OM<INHDODNN@�IJN�?DQ@MNJN�JAl>DJN�LP@�K<MOD>DK<Q<H�?<�J=M<�

y-� IJQJ� <MLPDO@OJ�� LP@� @NO<Q<� OM<=<GC<I?J� IJ� ><IO@DMJ�� I@H� N@HKM@

KM@N@IO@�IJ�GPB<M�?<�@?DAD><igJ��I@>@NNDO<Q<�?<M�<�N@PN�JK@McMDJN�DINOMPip@N

KM@>DN<N � 9 :� K<NN<I?J� @IOgJ� <� PODGDU<M� H<LP@O@N�� ><?<� Q@U� H<DN�� K<M<

>JHPID><M�N@PN�KMJE@OJN�<JN >JINOMPOJM@Nz �5'*)',1-,�������K ��

*@JI<M?J� "<� 4DI>D� j ?@N>MDOJ� >JHJ� J <MLPjODKJ ?J� CJH@H� ?J 0@I<N>DH@IOJ�

<GBPjH� >PE<� >PMDJND?<?@� DIN<>DcQ@G� @M<� DBP<G<?<� <K@I<N� K@G<� NP<� ><K<>D?<?@� ?@

DIQ@IigJ �%�0",#0����� &JE@�� j M@>JIC@>D?J� @� M@Q@M@I>D<?J� KJM� NP<

@IB@ICJND?<?@� O@>IJGnBD><KJM� O@M� >JI>@=D?JD?@D<N�HPDOJ� a� AM@IO@� ?@� N@P� O@HKJ

3H� IsH@MJ� M@G<ODQ<H@IO@� K@LP@IJ� ?@� N@PN� KMJE@OJN� >C@BJP� <� N@M� >JINOMPl?J

?PM<IO@�NP<�QD?<��KJDN�HPDOJN�?@G@N�IgJ�ODQ@M<H�>Mj?DOJ�<GBPH�K<M<�J�HPI?J

Page 88: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V56

!JIND?@M<?J LP<N@�LP@�PI<IDH@H@IO@ PH�?JN�H<DJM@N�BkIDJN�?<�CDNOnMD<��?@QD?J�<

NP<� HPGODKGD>D?<?@� ?@� O<G@IOJN K<M<� >DkI>D<N� @� <MO@N�� NP<� @IB@ICJND?<?@� @

>MD<ODQD?<?@ � �GBPjH� >PE<� >PMDJND?<?@� DIN<>DcQ@G� @M<� DBP<G<?<� <K@I<N� K@G<� NP<

><K<>D?<?@ ?@� DIQ@IigJ � .JM� NP<� ><K<>D?<?@� DIQ@NODB<ODQ<�� <� <IcGDN@� ?@� N@PN

OM<=<GCJN� @� HjOJ?JN� KJ?@� >JG<=JM<M� >JH� J� ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?@NO<� K@NLPDN<� @

J=N@MQ<?<�>JH�H<DN�<O@IigJ�IJN�K<McBM<AJN�LP@�N@BP@H

�� BM<I?@�H<DJMD<� ?JN� @NOP?JN� @� @SK@MDH@IOJN� ?@� *@JI<M?J� "<� 4DI>DJ <EP?JP I<

=PN><�?<�<MO@�K@MA@DO<��NP<�H@OJ?JGJBD<�?@�OM<=<GCJ�=<N@<Q<�N@�I<�@SK@MDH@IO<igJ

?DM@O< *@JI<M?J� ODIC<� ��� <IJN� LP<I?J� <NNPHDP� J� KJNOJ� ?@� !JIN@GC@DMJ� ?@

$JMODAD><ip@N� @+@NOM@� ?@� <ILP@O@N� ?J� "PLP@� ?@� +DGgJ� *P?JQD>J� 1AJMU<�� �-

+JPMJ� � �GD K@MH<I@>@P KJM� ��� <IJN�� ?@?D><I?J�N@ <J� ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ >MD<ODQJ

�>M@?DO<�N@�LP@�<>@DOJP�<�<OMD=PDigJ�>JHJ�H@DJ�?@�KMJNN@BPDM�N@DN�JPOMJN�DIO@M@NN@N

>D@IOlAD>JN @ <MOlNOD>JN

"< 4DI>D�@N>M@Q@P��?@N@ICJP�@�HJ?@GJP�NJ=M@�QcMDJN�O@H<N �+<IPN>MDOJN�>C@B<M<H

DIO<>OJN�<JN�?D<N�<OP<DN��@SDNO@H�@NOP?JN�?@�KM<OD><H@IO@�OJ?<N�<N�cM@<N�?J�N<=@M�

=DJGJBD<��B@JH@OMD<��<I<OJHD<��B@JGJBD<��=JOeID><��<NOMJIJHD<��nKOD><��H@>eID><�

<MLPDO@OPM<�@�KMJE@OJN�=jGD>JN ��GBPIN�?J>PH@IOJN�CDNOnMD>JN�M@Q@G<H�LP@�"<�4DI>D

OM<=<GCJP�>JH�<MO@NgJN�GJ><DN�<�>JINOMPigJ�?@�<GBPH<N�?@�NP<N�HcLPDI<N��KJMLP@

>JIND?@M<Q<�LP@�@M<�I@>@NNcMD<�<�@QJGPigJ �.#2#01-,��������K �

*<H@IO<Q@GH@IO@��I@ICPH<�?@NN<N�HcLPDI<N�NJ=M@QDQ@P <JN�?D<N�?@�CJE@

��DBM@E<�>JINDNO@ ?@�PH�>JMKJ�KG<IJ�>DM>PG<M��@I>DH<?<�KJM�PH<�G<IO@MI<�@�>sKPG<

>@IOM<G��@H�OJMIJ�?J�LP<G�@NOgJ�?DNKJNO<N�JDOJ�OD=sMDJN H@IJM@N�>sKPG<N�@ <ADIN �ADB

�� #NO@�HJ?@GJ�j�PH<�DIO@MKM@O<igJ�?@�PH�@NOP?J�K<M<�PH<�DBM@E< @ j�PH<�?<N

QcMD<N� M@AG@Sp@N� NJ=M@� J� O@H<�� ?@N@IQJGQD?JN� KJM� QcMDJN� <MLPDO@OJN� ?J

0@I<N>DH@IOJ ��J=M<�?@� *@JI<M?J DI>D?@� NJ=M@�<N�KJNND=DGD?<?@N�@SKM@NNDQ<N�?JN

QJGPH@N�@�H<NN<N�KGcNOD><N�@H�M@G<igJ�aN�KG<IO<N�>@IOM<DN

Page 89: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V57

- HJ?@GJ�?@�PH�DH@INJ HJIPH@IOJ @LP@NOM@ K<M< $M<I>@N>J�1AJMU< �ADB ��� J�<IO@>@NNJM

?@�*P?JQD>J��O<H=jH�A@U�K<MO@�?@�NP<�KMJ?PigJ !JH�@NN@�OM<=<GCJ� @S@>PO<?J�@H�=MJIU@

>JH� PH<� <GOPM<� K@MOJ� ?@� N@O@� KjN�� *P?JQD>J� 1AJMU<� KM@O@I?@P� M@KM@N@IO<M JN NP>@NNJN

HDGDO<M@N�?@�N@P�K<D��$M<I>@N>J�1AJMU<

#HKM@@I?@P� >JH� BM<I?@� DIO@M@NN@� JN� @NOP?JN� PM=<IJN�� KMDI>DK<GH@IO@� NJ=M@

+DGgJ��@�<�M@>PK@M<igJ�?@�<GBPIN�?@�N@PN�@?DAl>DJN�?@KJDN�?<�KM<B<�LP@�DIA@NOJP�<

>D?<?@�@H����� �.MJE@OJP�<�>D?<?@�D?@<G��PH<�>D?<?@�KG<IDAD><?<�N@BPI?J�>MDOjMDJN

?@�C<MHJID<�@�PID?<?@�ADB ���

-�BM<I?@�PIDQ@MNJ�KMJKJNOJ�KJM�"<�4DI>D�OM<INDO<Q<�K@G<�>JI>@KigJ�?@�KMJKJNO<N�?@

?DA@M@IO@N N@BH@IOJN � �N ��������� ��� ����>JHJ� J @NOP?J� ?<N� <N<N�� LP@� N@

<NN@H@GC<�<�PH�HJM>@BJ�� O@I?J�PH�sID>J�K<IJ�@NOD><?J� NJ=M@�PH<�<MH<igJ�?@

H<?@DM<� @ =<H=PN � � DIODOPG<?<� HcLPDI<� ?@� QJ<M >JH� <N<N� ?@� PH� KcNN<MJ � � -

$DBPM<���� "<�4DI>D�KMJE@OJP�<�>D?<?@�HPGOD�><H<?<N�D?@<G��@NOM<?<N�KMJE@O<?<N�@H�IlQ@DN�NPK@MDJM@N�GDB<I?J�JNH<M@N�>JHJ�PH<�<GO@MI<ODQ< N<P?cQ@G�K<M<�<N�@NOM@DO<N�>D?<?@N�@N>PM<N�LP@�M<KD?<H@IO@�AJM<H�?DUDH<?<N�K@G<K@NO@�?@����� $JIO@��$JOJ�?<��POJM<

$DBPM<���� +J?@GJ�?J OD=sMDJ��K<M<�< !<O@?M<G�?@�+DGgJ $JIO@� COOK���RRR HPN@JN>D@IU< JMB�@H�����������

$DBPM<���� !<Q<GJ�1AJMU<��HJ?@GJ�@H�=MJIU@ $JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�@H�����������

Page 90: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V58

K<M<LP@?<N� >JINOMPl?J� >JH� PH<� >JMODI<� ?@� GDICJ� >JH� PH<� AJMH<� KDM<HD?<G�� @� J

K<M<APNJ<jM@J �ADB ���

"<� 4DI>D� KMJE@OJP O<H=jH IPH@MJN<N ������� DI>GPDI?J� =@NO<N� BDB<IO@N�

H@OM<GC<?JM<N� >JH� QcMDJN� O<H=JM@N� =<M>JN� AJD>@�� ><ICp@N� @N><?<N� HJMO@DMJN� @

<Oj�PH�KM@>PMNJM�?J�O<ILP@�?@�BP@MM<�HJ?@MIJ� KJMjH�<=JHDI<Q<�<�BP@MM< vLP@

@G@� >C<H<Q<� ?@� �GJP>PM<� =@NOD<G� v H<N� >JHJ� <� 'OcGD<� M@I<N>@IODNO<� @NO<Q<

>JINO<IO@H@IO@�@H�BP@MM<��@G@�IgJ�Ko?@�@QDOc�G< �ADB ���

$DBPM<���� .MJKJNO<N�?@�*@JI<M?J�"<�4DI>D �@NOP?J�?<N�<N<N��HcLPDI<�?@�QJ<M��K<M<LP@?<N�@�J�K<M<APNJ�<jM@J $JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI

Page 91: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V59

-N �������� �������� �� <KM@N@IO<Q<H� J @NOP?J� ?J� H@MBPGC<?JM� ?@K@I?@� ?<

HcN><M<�?@�?JDN�OP=JN�>JH�H@H=M<I<�?@�HJ?J�LP@ PH N@ @G@Q<�K<M<�DI<G<M�@�PH

K<M<� @S<G<M � 3H� OP=J� IgJ Nn� IgJ N@MD<� NPAD>D@IO@ >JHJ� N@MD<� KM@@I>CD?J� >JH

?DnSD?J� ?@� ><M=JIJ� @� NPAJ><M� J� H@MBPGC<?JM -� ?@N@EJ� ?@� ?JHDI<M� OJ?JN� JN

@G@H@IOJN�LP@�>DM>PI?<H�J CJH@H OJMIJP�N@ <�=PN><�?@ H@DJN�K<M<�LP@�J�CJH@H

KP?@NN@�HJQ@M�N@�A<>DGH@IO@�NJ=M@�<�NPK@MAl>D@�?<�cBP< *@JI<M?J�KMJKp@ @H�N@PN

HJ?@GJN� PH<� HgJ� >JH� <N� MDK<N� >JHJ� @SO@INgJ� ?JN� ?@?JN� @� PH<� H@H=M<I<

<PSDGD<MK<M<�<�I<O<igJ�@�PH�N<GQ<�QD?<N�?@N>MDOJ�>JHJ��>C@DJ�?@�<M� �ADB ���

$DBPM<�����HJ?@GJ�?@ O<ILP@��@H�AJMH<�?@�O<MO<MPB<��<MH<?JN>JH�<MH<N�?@�AJBJ�<J�M@?JM� J�=<M>J�AJD>@��JK@M<?J�G@Q<IO<I?J�<Q<M<�?@�PH�H@><IDNHJ�?@�><MM@O@G�?@�H<?@DM<��<ODIB@�<N�Q@G<N�?JNI<QDJN�DIDHDBJN�BDM<I?J�����BM<PN��><ICgJ�>JH�< ><K<>D?<?@�?@<EPNO<M�<�OM<E@OnMD<�?<N�=<G<N�@N><?<�MJG<IO@�LP@ K@MHDO@�<�<O<><MAJMODAD><igJ�?J�DIDHDBJ $JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI

Page 92: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V60

-POMJ�DIQ@IOJ�NDBIDAD><ODQJ�AJD�J�MJ=o��H@><IDNHJ�?@�@NLP@H<�K<M<�PH< <MH<?PM<

H@?D@Q<G <POJHcOD><��LP@� <GjH�?@�N@M PODGDU<?JN�K<M<�ADIN�?@�O@<OMJ��AJD�<?<KO<?J

K<M< PH<� M@>@KigJ� M@<G�� JI?@� QcMDJN� ?@G@N�� <GDIC<?JN� @H� AJMH<igJ�� >JH� PH

>JH<I?J�@NK@>D<G�G@Q<IO<M<H JN�=M<iJN�K<M<�<�N<P?<igJ�<J�NJ=@M<IJ �ADB ���

#IOM@�<N ��������� �� ��� ����ADBPM<H�J�><MMJ�@�<�=D>D>G@O< -�<POJHnQ@G j�PH<�?<N

H<DN� >JIC@>D?<N HcLPDI<N� ?@� *@JI<M?J� ?<� 4DI>D�� J=E@OJ ?@� ?DQ@MN<N� HJIO<B@IN

AlND><N�� QkH N@I?J� @NOP?<?J� ?@N?@� ���� � 1n� M@>@IO@H@IO@� AJD� ?@N>J=@MO<� NP<

Q@M?<?@DM<�ADI<GD?<?@��IgJ�j�PH�<POJHnQ@G�N@BPI?J�<�>JI>@KigJ�HJ?@MI<��H<N�PH

Q@l>PGJ�><K<U�?@�HJQ@M�N@�NJUDICJ�ADB ��� 3H�>JHKGD><?J�NDNO@H<�?@�@IBM@I<B@IN

$DBPM<����+@MBPGC<?JM��HJ?@GJ�LP@�HJNOM<�J�HJ?J�?@�><HDIC<M�NJ=M@�<�cBP<�@�PH<�=nD< $JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI @H�����������

$DBPM<����0J=o$JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI @H�����������

Page 93: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V61

LP@ K@MHDO@�O@I>DJI<M�<N�HJG<N�LP@�API>DJI<H�>JHJ HJOJM�?@NO<�HcLPDI< @IOM<Q<

@H�>@I<�QDI?<�?<N�>JSD<N�?@�PH�O@<OMJ��>JH�=JI@>JN�?@�K<K@G�NJ=M@�@G<��JN�LP<DN

KJ?D<H�HJQ@M�<GBPH<N�?@�NP<N�K<MO@N� �KJM�@S@HKGJ��KJ?D<H HJQ@M�<�><=@i<��JP

H@S@M�J�=M<iJ

#H� PH�K@MlJ?J�?@� OM<INDigJ� CDNOnMD><�� JN�HJ?@GJN� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM<� M@KM@N@IO<Q<H

@?DAl>DJN��>JHKG@SJN PM=<IJN�@�AJMODAD><ip@N �#IOM@�<N�H<LP@O@N�<MLPDO@OoID><N =@H

?J>PH@IO<?<N� N@� DI>GPD�<� 'BM@E< ?@ 1<DIO�+<>GJP �ADB �����@H�0JP@I�?@������ @ <

'BM@E<�?@�1>CqI@�+<MD< �ADB ���� @H�0@B@IN=PMB��?@�����

$DBPM<����+J?@GJ�?J�<POnHJQ@G$JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI@H�����������

$DBPM<� ���� 'BM@E<� ?@� 1<DIO� +<>GJP�� @H0JP@I����� $JIO@�COOK���RRR K@MN@@ AM�R@=�M@QP@N�CJH@�KM@N>MDKO�<MOD>G@�KDJO;���������;����;IPH;��;�;����@H�����������

$DBPM<� ���� 'BM@E<� ?@� 1>CqI@� +<MD<�� @H0@B@IN=PMB��?@����� $JIO@�� COOK���RRR =DG?DI?@S ?@�J=E�������� COHG@H�����������

$DBPM<����+J?@GJ�?@�=D>D>G@O<$JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI@H����������

V61

LP@ K@MHDO@�O@I>DJI<M�<N�HJG<N�LP@�API>DJI<H�>JHJ HJOJM�?@NO<�HcLPDI< @IOM<Q<

@H�>@I<�QDI?<�?<N�>JSD<N�?@�PH�O@<OMJ��>JH�=JI@>JN�?@�K<K@G�NJ=M@�@G<��JN�LP<DN

KJ?D<H�HJQ@M�<GBPH<N�?@�NP<N�K<MO@N� �KJM�@S@HKGJ��KJ?D<H HJQ@M�<�><=@i<��JP

H@S@M�J�=M<iJ

#H� PH�K@MlJ?J�?@� OM<INDigJ� CDNOnMD><�� JN�HJ?@GJN� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM<� M@KM@N@IO<Q<H

@?DAl>DJN��>JHKG@SJN PM=<IJN�@�AJMODAD><ip@N �#IOM@�<N�H<LP@O@N�<MLPDO@OoID><N =@H

?J>PH@IO<?<N� N@� DI>GPD�<� 'BM@E< ?@ 1<DIO�+<>GJP �ADB �����@H�0JP@I�?@������ @ <

'BM@E<�?@�1>CqI@�+<MD< �ADB ���� @H�0@B@IN=PMB��?@�����

$DBPM<����+J?@GJ�?J�<POnHJQ@G$JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI@H�����������

$DBPM<� ���� 'BM@E<� ?@� 1<DIO� +<>GJP�� @H0JP@I����� $JIO@�COOK���RRR K@MN@@ AM�R@=�M@QP@N�CJH@�KM@N>MDKO�<MOD>G@�KDJO;���������;����;IPH;��;�;����@H�����������

$DBPM<� ���� 'BM@E<� ?@� 1>CqI@� +<MD<�� @H0@B@IN=PMB��?@����� $JIO@�� COOK���RRR =DG?DI?@S ?@�J=E�������� COHG@H�����������

$DBPM<����+J?@GJ�?@�=D>D>G@O<$JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI@H����������

V61

LP@ K@MHDO@�O@I>DJI<M�<N�HJG<N�LP@�API>DJI<H�>JHJ HJOJM�?@NO<�HcLPDI< @IOM<Q<

@H�>@I<�QDI?<�?<N�>JSD<N�?@�PH�O@<OMJ��>JH�=JI@>JN�?@�K<K@G�NJ=M@�@G<��JN�LP<DN

KJ?D<H�HJQ@M�<GBPH<N�?@�NP<N�K<MO@N� �KJM�@S@HKGJ��KJ?D<H HJQ@M�<�><=@i<��JP

H@S@M�J�=M<iJ

#H� PH�K@MlJ?J�?@� OM<INDigJ� CDNOnMD><�� JN�HJ?@GJN� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM<� M@KM@N@IO<Q<H

@?DAl>DJN��>JHKG@SJN PM=<IJN�@�AJMODAD><ip@N �#IOM@�<N�H<LP@O@N�<MLPDO@OoID><N =@H

?J>PH@IO<?<N� N@� DI>GPD�<� 'BM@E< ?@ 1<DIO�+<>GJP �ADB �����@H�0JP@I�?@������ @ <

'BM@E<�?@�1>CqI@�+<MD< �ADB ���� @H�0@B@IN=PMB��?@�����

$DBPM<����+J?@GJ�?J�<POnHJQ@G$JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI@H�����������

$DBPM<� ���� 'BM@E<� ?@� 1<DIO� +<>GJP�� @H0JP@I����� $JIO@�COOK���RRR K@MN@@ AM�R@=�M@QP@N�CJH@�KM@N>MDKO�<MOD>G@�KDJO;���������;����;IPH;��;�;����@H�����������

$DBPM<� ���� 'BM@E<� ?@� 1>CqI@� +<MD<�� @H0@B@IN=PMB��?@����� $JIO@�� COOK���RRR =DG?DI?@S ?@�J=E�������� COHG@H�����������

$DBPM<����+J?@GJ�?@�=D>D>G@O<$JIO@� COOK���RRR H<>>CDI@?DG@JI<M?J >JH�DI?@S KCK�G@�H<>>CDI@H����������

Page 94: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V62

#NN@N�HJ?@GJN� @M<H� J=M<N� @G<=JM<?<N� @H� BM<I?@� @N><G<�� A<=MD><?<N� @H�H<?@DM<�

B@NNJ�@�<MBDG< �� ?DA@M@Ii< @IOM@�JN KMDHDODQJN�HJ?@GJN�@NOP?<?JN�I<� '?<?@�+j?D<

AD><Q<�IJ�KM@iJ��IJ�@S<B@MJ�@ I<�HDIs>D<�?@�KJNND=DGDO<M�<J�J=N@MQ<?JM K@M>@=@M�<N

N@ip@N ?@NHJIOcQ@DN �2@OJN�@�KDNJN� M@HJQlQ@DN�LP@�K@MHDOD<H�Q@M�J� DIO@MDJM� @ I<

A<>DGDO<igJ�?J�?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ�?J�KMJE@OJ

"PM<IO@� @NO@� K@MlJ?J�� JN� HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� <MLPDO@OoID>JN� ODQ@M<H� PH<

BM<I?@� Q<GJMDU<igJ � .<NN<M<H� <� N@M� H<DN LP@� PH� >JHKG@H@IOJ� ?@� ?@N@ICJ�

>JIQ@MO@I?J�N@ @H� PH� HjOJ?J� API?<H@IO<G� K<M<� >JHPID><M� D?@D<N� ?@� ?@N@ICJ

<MLPDO@OoID>J (<>JKJ 2@?@N>J@G<=JMJP�J�HJ?@GJ�?< <NlGD><�?@��NNDN�IJ�Nj>PGJ�6'''�

�I?M@<�.DN<IJ�>JIA@>>DJIJP J ?J 2@HKGJ�?@�1<I�%DJQ<IID�?@ .DNOnD<�@��MIJGAJ�?D

!<H=DJ�@G<=JMJP J�?J�KMJE@OJ�=cND>JK<M<�1<IO<�+<MD<�"@G�$DJMD� >PEJ ><HK<IcMDJ AJD

A@DOJ�KJM�%DJOOJ

-N�@S@HKGJN�M@G@Q<IO@N�?JN�HJ?@GJN>JHJ�K<MO@�?J�KMJ>@NNJ�?@�KMJE@OJ�AJM<H JN

?<N >sKPG<N�?@�><O@?M<DN�?@�$GJM@Ii< ����������?@�$DGGDKKJ MPI@I@GG@N>CD� @ ?@ 1gJ

.@?MJ� @H� 0JH< ����������� ?@� +D>C@G<IB@GJ MPI@GG@N>CD� JMDBDI<GH@IO@� PH

<MO@NgJ�@� KJMO<IOJ�Cc=DG�>JH�<N�HgJN��A@U�PNJ�K<MOD>PG<MH@IO@�MD>J�?@G<N�>JH�N@PN

HJ?@GJN� K<M<� >@IcMDJN� O@<OM<DN� @� <� ?@HJINOM<igJ� KMcOD><� ?J� API>DJI<H@IOJ� ?J

@?DAl>DJ�@�NP<N�K<MO@N �,JN�<NK@>OJN�>JINOMPODQJN��DI>GPl<�@N><G<N�CPH<I<N�?@N>@I?J

G@IO<H@IO@� ?<� NPK@M@NOMPOPM<�� <GjH� ?@� @IBM@I<B@IN�� H<LPDI<MD<�� HJQDH@IOJN�

NJH=M<N�� >JM@N�� O@SOPM<N #NN@I>D<GH@IO@�� @G@� O@I>DJI<Q<� ><KOPM<M� <� M@NKJNO<

KND>JGnBD><� ?JN� J=N@MQ<?JM@N� AM@IO@� <J� >JIO@SOJ� <MLPDO@OPM<G� ?<� QD?<� M@<G�� @� IgJ

<K@I<N�HJNOM<M� J� LP@� N@MD<� <� J=M<� ?@KJDN� ?@� KMJIO< � .<M<� DNNJ� =PN><Q<� >MD<M� PH

<H=D@IO@� >JH� MPNOD>D?<?@� ?@NB<NO<?J�� O@IO<I?J� <KMJSDH<M� J� HJ?@GJ� ?J� LP@

NPKJNO<H@IO@�N@MD<�< J=M<�Ec�@H�PNJ -�<MLPDO@OJ ?@N@IC<Q<�@H�OMkN�?DH@INp@N�@

PODGDU<Q<�IPH@MJNJN�HJ?@GJN� B@M<GH@IO@�PHH<DN�@G<=JM<?J I<�@N><G<�?@�����@H

H<?@DM<� K<M<� <KM@N@IO<igJ <J� >GD@IO@ @� PH� O<GC<?J M<KD?<H@IO@� @H� >@M<� K<M<

@SKGD><M� <N� D?@D<N� <MLPDO@OoID><N� <JN� >JINOMPOJM@N � �� @S@>PigJ� ?@�HPDOJN� ?@� N@PN

HJ?@GJN� AD><Q<� <� ><MBJ� ?@� PH� ><MKDIO@DMJ� >C<H<?J� <MOJGJH@P�� LP@� HJM<Q<

KMnSDHJ�<J�N@P�@NOs?DJ �#G@N�?@QD<H�>JIO@M�MDBJMJN<H@IO@�<N�KMJKJMip@N�?<�>sKPG<

Page 95: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V63

@� OJ?JN� JN� ?@O<GC@N� H<DN� ?DAl>@DN�� >JHJ� @N><?<N� DGPHDI<?<N� @� @N>PM<N� @ JPOMJN

MPI@GG@N>CD @G@H@IOJN <�N@M@H HDIP>DJN<H@IO@ M@KM@N@IO<?JN

MPI@GG@N>CD� N@� Q<GD<� ?@ HJ?@GJN� >JHJ� PH<� KM<BHcOD><� A@MM<H@IO< #'� %(�.�

@S<HDI<Q<� >PD?<?JN<H@IO@� <N� K@?M<N� ?JN� ><IO@DMJN� K<M<� Q@MDAD><M� JN� @I><DS@N� @

KJNNlQ@DN A<GC<N�ADB � �� "@HJINOM<Q<� NP<� DIO@IigJ KJM� H@DJ� ?<LP@G@N LP@

<KJIO<Q<H�PH<�M@AG@SgJ K<M<�QcMDJN�KMJ=G@H<N�I<�>JINOMPigJ��Q@IOJN��O@MM@HJOJN�

J� K@NJ� KMnKMDJ #G<=JMJP >JIODIP<H@IO@� HJ?@GJN� ?@� ?@O<GC@N� >JH� <� O@MM<

HJGC<?<��>JH�>@M<��>JH�H<?@DM<��JP�>JH�BM<I?@N�I<=JN�>JMO<?JN�>JH�PH<�A<><�

?@�HJ?J�<�HJNOMc�GJN�K<M<�JN� OM<=<GC<?JM@N �4�1�0'� ���� <KP?�5-*$%�,%��������K

���

,J� K@MlJ?J� IJN� LP<DN� <N� M@KM@N@IO<ip@N� =D?DH@INDJI<DN� AJM<H� H@IJN

?@N@IQJGQD?<N��JN�>cG>PGJN KMjQDJN�LP<IOJ�<JN�KM@iJN?JN�H<O@MD<DN�@ ?JN�>PNOJN�?@

>JINOMPigJ� HPDO<N� Q@U@N @M<H� @NODH<?JN� >JH� =<N@� IJ� HJ?@GJ� OMD?DH@INDJI<G

�G=@MOD� J=N@MQJP� LP@� JN� HJ?@GJN� AJMI@>D<H� PH<� DI?D><igJ� H<DN� N@BPM<� ?JN

KMJQcQ@DN >PNOJN @� K@MHDOD<H� J� >cG>PGJ� ?@� @G@H@IOJN� DI?DQD?P<DN DNJG<?<H@IO@�

KJNND=DGDO<I?J O<H=jH�PH�IJQJ�><HDICJ�K<M< <�?DQDNgJ�?@�OM<=<GCJ @IOM@�J�JAD>DJ

?J�<MLPDO@OJ�@�<�@S@>PigJ�?J�KMJE@OJ

�GBPH<N� KDIOPM<N� DGPNOM<H� >JH� K@MA@DigJ� <� DHKJMOeI>D< ?@� M@>JMM@M�N@� a

KMcOD><?PM<IO@� @NO@� K@MlJ?J � Z� J� ><NJ ?<� KDIOPM<� ?@� %DJMBDJ� 4<N<MD�� I<� LP<G

MPI@GG@N>CD�HJNOM< <�H<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�?@�1gJ�*JPM@IiJ��ADB ��� JP ?J�OM<=<GCJ

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJN � ?@O<GC@N�?<�>sKPG<�?@�1<IO<�+<MD< "@G�$DJM@��$GJM@Ii< $JIO@��$JOJ ?<��POJM<

V63

@� OJ?JN� JN� ?@O<GC@N� H<DN� ?DAl>@DN�� >JHJ� @N><?<N� DGPHDI<?<N� @� @N>PM<N� @ JPOMJN

MPI@GG@N>CD @G@H@IOJN <�N@M@H HDIP>DJN<H@IO@ M@KM@N@IO<?JN

MPI@GG@N>CD� N@� Q<GD<� ?@ HJ?@GJN� >JHJ� PH<� KM<BHcOD><� A@MM<H@IO< #'� %(�.�

@S<HDI<Q<� >PD?<?JN<H@IO@� <N� K@?M<N� ?JN� ><IO@DMJN� K<M<� Q@MDAD><M� JN� @I><DS@N� @

KJNNlQ@DN A<GC<N�ADB � �� "@HJINOM<Q<� NP<� DIO@IigJ KJM� H@DJ� ?<LP@G@N LP@

<KJIO<Q<H�PH<�M@AG@SgJ K<M<�QcMDJN�KMJ=G@H<N�I<�>JINOMPigJ��Q@IOJN��O@MM@HJOJN�

J� K@NJ� KMnKMDJ #G<=JMJP >JIODIP<H@IO@� HJ?@GJN� ?@� ?@O<GC@N� >JH� <� O@MM<

HJGC<?<��>JH�>@M<��>JH�H<?@DM<��JP�>JH�BM<I?@N�I<=JN�>JMO<?JN�>JH�PH<�A<><�

?@�HJ?J�<�HJNOMc�GJN�K<M<�JN� OM<=<GC<?JM@N �4�1�0'� ���� <KP?�5-*$%�,%��������K

���

,J� K@MlJ?J� IJN� LP<DN� <N� M@KM@N@IO<ip@N� =D?DH@INDJI<DN� AJM<H� H@IJN

?@N@IQJGQD?<N��JN�>cG>PGJN KMjQDJN�LP<IOJ�<JN�KM@iJN?JN�H<O@MD<DN�@ ?JN�>PNOJN�?@

>JINOMPigJ� HPDO<N� Q@U@N @M<H� @NODH<?JN� >JH� =<N@� IJ� HJ?@GJ� OMD?DH@INDJI<G

�G=@MOD� J=N@MQJP� LP@� JN� HJ?@GJN� AJMI@>D<H� PH<� DI?D><igJ� H<DN� N@BPM<� ?JN

KMJQcQ@DN >PNOJN @� K@MHDOD<H� J� >cG>PGJ� ?@� @G@H@IOJN� DI?DQD?P<DN DNJG<?<H@IO@�

KJNND=DGDO<I?J O<H=jH�PH�IJQJ�><HDICJ�K<M< <�?DQDNgJ�?@�OM<=<GCJ @IOM@�J�JAD>DJ

?J�<MLPDO@OJ�@�<�@S@>PigJ�?J�KMJE@OJ

�GBPH<N� KDIOPM<N� DGPNOM<H� >JH� K@MA@DigJ� <� DHKJMOeI>D< ?@� M@>JMM@M�N@� a

KMcOD><?PM<IO@� @NO@� K@MlJ?J � Z� J� ><NJ ?<� KDIOPM<� ?@� %DJMBDJ� 4<N<MD�� I<� LP<G

MPI@GG@N>CD�HJNOM< <�H<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�?@�1gJ�*JPM@IiJ��ADB ��� JP ?J�OM<=<GCJ

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJN � ?@O<GC@N�?<�>sKPG<�?@�1<IO<�+<MD< "@G�$DJM@��$GJM@Ii< $JIO@��$JOJ ?<��POJM<

V63

@� OJ?JN� JN� ?@O<GC@N� H<DN� ?DAl>@DN�� >JHJ� @N><?<N� DGPHDI<?<N� @� @N>PM<N� @ JPOMJN

MPI@GG@N>CD @G@H@IOJN <�N@M@H HDIP>DJN<H@IO@ M@KM@N@IO<?JN

MPI@GG@N>CD� N@� Q<GD<� ?@ HJ?@GJN� >JHJ� PH<� KM<BHcOD><� A@MM<H@IO< #'� %(�.�

@S<HDI<Q<� >PD?<?JN<H@IO@� <N� K@?M<N� ?JN� ><IO@DMJN� K<M<� Q@MDAD><M� JN� @I><DS@N� @

KJNNlQ@DN A<GC<N�ADB � �� "@HJINOM<Q<� NP<� DIO@IigJ KJM� H@DJ� ?<LP@G@N LP@

<KJIO<Q<H�PH<�M@AG@SgJ K<M<�QcMDJN�KMJ=G@H<N�I<�>JINOMPigJ��Q@IOJN��O@MM@HJOJN�

J� K@NJ� KMnKMDJ #G<=JMJP >JIODIP<H@IO@� HJ?@GJN� ?@� ?@O<GC@N� >JH� <� O@MM<

HJGC<?<��>JH�>@M<��>JH�H<?@DM<��JP�>JH�BM<I?@N�I<=JN�>JMO<?JN�>JH�PH<�A<><�

?@�HJ?J�<�HJNOMc�GJN�K<M<�JN� OM<=<GC<?JM@N �4�1�0'� ���� <KP?�5-*$%�,%��������K

���

,J� K@MlJ?J� IJN� LP<DN� <N� M@KM@N@IO<ip@N� =D?DH@INDJI<DN� AJM<H� H@IJN

?@N@IQJGQD?<N��JN�>cG>PGJN KMjQDJN�LP<IOJ�<JN�KM@iJN?JN�H<O@MD<DN�@ ?JN�>PNOJN�?@

>JINOMPigJ� HPDO<N� Q@U@N @M<H� @NODH<?JN� >JH� =<N@� IJ� HJ?@GJ� OMD?DH@INDJI<G

�G=@MOD� J=N@MQJP� LP@� JN� HJ?@GJN� AJMI@>D<H� PH<� DI?D><igJ� H<DN� N@BPM<� ?JN

KMJQcQ@DN >PNOJN @� K@MHDOD<H� J� >cG>PGJ� ?@� @G@H@IOJN� DI?DQD?P<DN DNJG<?<H@IO@�

KJNND=DGDO<I?J O<H=jH�PH�IJQJ�><HDICJ�K<M< <�?DQDNgJ�?@�OM<=<GCJ @IOM@�J�JAD>DJ

?J�<MLPDO@OJ�@�<�@S@>PigJ�?J�KMJE@OJ

�GBPH<N� KDIOPM<N� DGPNOM<H� >JH� K@MA@DigJ� <� DHKJMOeI>D< ?@� M@>JMM@M�N@� a

KMcOD><?PM<IO@� @NO@� K@MlJ?J � Z� J� ><NJ ?<� KDIOPM<� ?@� %DJMBDJ� 4<N<MD�� I<� LP<G

MPI@GG@N>CD�HJNOM< <�H<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�?@�1gJ�*JPM@IiJ��ADB ��� JP ?J�OM<=<GCJ

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJN � ?@O<GC@N�?<�>sKPG<�?@�1<IO<�+<MD< "@G�$DJM@��$GJM@Ii< $JIO@��$JOJ ?<��POJM<

Page 96: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V64

?@ "JH@ID>J !M@NOD�?<�.<NNDBI<IJ��JI?@� N@�Qk +D>C@G<IB@GJ�@SD=DI?JK<M< J�K<K<

.<PGJ�'4 <�H<LP@O@�?<�>sKPG< ?@ 1gJ�.@?MJ �ADB ��� @��

$DBPM< �����>sKPG<�?@� MPI@GG@N>CD�I<�><O@?M<G?@�$GJM@Ii<��'OcGD< -N�HPM<DN�AJM<H�KDIO<?JN�KJM�%DJMBDJ�4<N<MD�@$@?@MD>J�8P>><M MPI@GG@N>CD <KM@N@IO<M J HJ?@GJ ?@ 1<I*JM@IUJ ?@ !JNDHJ� .<G<UUJ 4@>>CDJ $JIO@� COOK���RRR <MO@GDNO< >JH�@I�BM@<O�H<NO@MN�<MORJMF������������������=MPI@GG@N>CD�KM@N@IODIB�OC@�HJ?@G�JA�N<I�GJM@IUJ�OJ�>JNDHJ�OC@�@G?@M COHG @H����������� @COOK���RRR <MO@GDNO< >JH�@I�BM@<O�H<NO@MN�<MORJMF������������������=MPI@GG@N>CD�KM@N@IODIB�OC@�HJ?@G�JA�N<I�GJM@IUJ�OJ�>JNDHJ�OC@�@G?@M COHG @H�����������

$DBPM< ��� 2<??@J�@�$@?@MD>J�8P>><MD��4DI>@IUJ� JMBCDID�,D>JGJN<�@�%DJMBDJ�4<N<MD�@H�AM@IO@�<J�HJ?@GJ�?<�!<O@?M<G�?@$GJM@Ii<�?@�$GJM@Ii< �$@?@MD>J�8P>><MD $JIO@� COOK���RRR <MO@<IOD>< @P�JK@M<�<MO@�UP>><MD�A@?@MD>J�UP>><MJ�2<??@J�J�$@?@MD>J�8P>><MD��4DI>@IUJ� JMBCDID��,D>JGJN<�@�%DJMBDJ�4<N<MD�?<Q<IOD�<G�HJ?@GGJ�?@G�"PJHJ�?D�$DM@IU@;���������� COHG@H�����������

$DBPM< ��� +D>C@G<IB@GJ�@�J�HJ?@GJ�?@�1gJ�.@?MJK<M<�J�K<K<�.<PGJ�'4��!<N<� PJI<MMJOD��$GJM@Ii< $JIO@��COOK���DO RDFDK@?D< JMB�RDFD�"JH@ID>J;!M@NOD@H�����������

Page 97: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V65

��M@G@QeI>D< ?J�HJ?@GJ�>JHJ�HjOJ?J�?@ >JHPID><igJ�AD><�@QD?@IO@�I<N�KDIOPM<N �-

M@>PMNJ ?<�HJ?@G<B@H j�J�O@H<�>@IOM<G�?<N�>JIQ@MN<ip@N��@�HJNOM<�<�HP?<Ii<�@H

NP<APIigJ ?PM<IO@ @NO@�K@MlJ?J� K<NN<I?J <� N@M�PH�Q@l>PGJ�K<M<�<� @SKGJM<igJ@H

Q@U?@�PH<�A@MM<H@IO<�?@N>MDODQ<�PODGDU<?<�K<M<�@SKGD><M�PH�KMJE@OJ ��=<NlGD><�?@�1gJ

.@?MJ� @H� 0JH<� AJD� M@KM@N@IO<?<� KJM� PH�HJ?@GJ� @H�H<?@DM<� LP@� KJNNPl<� ����

K<MO@�?J�O<H<ICJ�M@<G�?<�@?DAD><igJ �ADB ���

$DBPM< ��� +<LP@O@N�?<�>sKPG<�?@�1gJ�.@?MJ�KJM�+D>C@G<IB@GJ $JIO@��COOK���N<DIOK@O@MN=<NDGD>< JMB�.G<IN��M>CDO@>OPM@� COH@H�����������

V65

��M@G@QeI>D< ?J�HJ?@GJ�>JHJ�HjOJ?J�?@ >JHPID><igJ�AD><�@QD?@IO@�I<N�KDIOPM<N �-

M@>PMNJ ?<�HJ?@G<B@H j�J�O@H<�>@IOM<G�?<N�>JIQ@MN<ip@N��@�HJNOM<�<�HP?<Ii<�@H

NP<APIigJ ?PM<IO@ @NO@�K@MlJ?J� K<NN<I?J <� N@M�PH�Q@l>PGJ�K<M<�<� @SKGJM<igJ@H

Q@U?@�PH<�A@MM<H@IO<�?@N>MDODQ<�PODGDU<?<�K<M<�@SKGD><M�PH�KMJE@OJ ��=<NlGD><�?@�1gJ

.@?MJ� @H� 0JH<� AJD� M@KM@N@IO<?<� KJM� PH�HJ?@GJ� @H�H<?@DM<� LP@� KJNNPl<� ����

K<MO@�?J�O<H<ICJ�M@<G�?<�@?DAD><igJ �ADB ���

$DBPM< ��� +<LP@O@N�?<�>sKPG<�?@�1gJ�.@?MJ�KJM�+D>C@G<IB@GJ $JIO@��COOK���N<DIOK@O@MN=<NDGD>< JMB�.G<IN��M>CDO@>OPM@� COH@H�����������

V65

��M@G@QeI>D< ?J�HJ?@GJ�>JHJ�HjOJ?J�?@ >JHPID><igJ�AD><�@QD?@IO@�I<N�KDIOPM<N �-

M@>PMNJ ?<�HJ?@G<B@H j�J�O@H<�>@IOM<G�?<N�>JIQ@MN<ip@N��@�HJNOM<�<�HP?<Ii<�@H

NP<APIigJ ?PM<IO@ @NO@�K@MlJ?J� K<NN<I?J <� N@M�PH�Q@l>PGJ�K<M<�<� @SKGJM<igJ@H

Q@U?@�PH<�A@MM<H@IO<�?@N>MDODQ<�PODGDU<?<�K<M<�@SKGD><M�PH�KMJE@OJ ��=<NlGD><�?@�1gJ

.@?MJ� @H� 0JH<� AJD� M@KM@N@IO<?<� KJM� PH�HJ?@GJ� @H�H<?@DM<� LP@� KJNNPl<� ����

K<MO@�?J�O<H<ICJ�M@<G�?<�@?DAD><igJ �ADB ���

$DBPM< ��� +<LP@O@N�?<�>sKPG<�?@�1gJ�.@?MJ�KJM�+D>C@G<IB@GJ $JIO@��COOK���N<DIOK@O@MN=<NDGD>< JMB�.G<IN��M>CDO@>OPM@� COH@H�����������

Page 98: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V66

-�?@=<O@�@IOM@�J�?@N@ICJ�@�<�H<LP@O@��>JHJ�H@DJ�?@�?@ADIDigJ�@�M@KM@N@IO<igJ

?J�KMJE@OJ��B<ICJP�H<DN�AJMi<�>JH�+D>C@G<IB@GJ��O@I?J�@NO@�G@Q<?J�<�H<LP@O@�<J

N@P� HcSDHJ� @NKG@I?JM� I<� APIigJ� ?@� @G@H@IOJ� B@M<?JM� @� >JHPID><?JM� ?<

<MLPDO@OPM<

,JN�@N>MDOJN�?@�*@JI <OODNO<��G=@MOD Q@MDAD><�N@ <�I@>@NND?<?@�?@�PH�KMJE@OJ�KMjQDJ

IJ�LP<G�N@�>JI>@IOM<�<�@G<=JM<igJ�?@�?@N@ICJN JP�<�>JINOMPigJ�?@�H<LP@O@N �ADB

��

�G=@MOD� KMJKp@� @H� N@P� OM<O<?J� OJ?J� PH� NDNO@H<� KMJE@OP<G� LP@� DI>GPD� ?@N?@� <N

<IcGDN@N�KMjQD<N�<Oj�<�M@KM@N@IO<igJ�@NK<>D<G ���AJMH<�H<DN�C<=DOP<G�?@�OM<INHDNNgJ

?@�KMJE@OJ� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM<� M@I<N>@IODNO<� @M<� <� M@KM@N@IO<igJ�H@?D<IO@�H<LP@O@N

y.JMO<IOJ�N@HKM@�<KMJQ<M@D J�Q@GCJ�>JNOPH@�?JN�LP@�@?DAD><H��LP@�IgJ�NJH@IO@

K@IN@HJN >JH�@N>MDOJN�JP�KDIOPM<N��N@IgJ�O<H=jH�>JH�HJ?@GJNz ��* #02'������

�GjH�?JN�@S@HKGJN�?@� MPI@GG@N>CD�JP��G=@MOD��4<N<MD� M@G<O<�<� AM@LP@IO@�PODGDU<igJ

?<� H<LP@O@� K@GJN� <MLPDO@OJN� $M<I>@N>J� ?D� %DJMBDJ�� "JI<OJ� M<H<IO@� @ 1<IB<GGJ

� �*!0'!&������

.@M>@=@�N@� LP@<� K<MODM?JN� Nj>PGJN� 64'� @� 64''� K@GJ� H@IJN� ?JDN A<OJM@N NPMBDM<H

>JIOMD=PDM�K<M< >JH J�@NO<=@G@>DH@IOJ�?J�HJ?@GJ��<�KMJ?PigJ�?@�HJ?@GJN�HDGDO<M@N

@� @NOM<OjBD>JN� @� PH� <PH@IOJ� ?J� DIO@M@NN@� IJ� KG<I@E<H@IOJ� K<DN<BlNOD>J �ADB

����ADB ����@ ��

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J�2@HKGJ�+<G<O@ND<IJ�?@�0DHDID���G=@MOD $JIO@��COOK���@N API?<>DJIH@?DI<>@GD JMB�HJIPH@IOJN�@H�����������

Page 99: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V67

��K<MODM�?J Nj>PGJ�64'� <MLPDO@OJN @IA<ODU<M<H�N@PN�OM<=<GCJN�>JH�J�PNJ?<N�AJMH<N

?@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� =D?DH@INDJI<G � "@N@ICJN� Oj>ID>JN� AJM<H� M@ADI<?JN� >JHJ� PH

NDNO@H< ?@� >JHPID><igJ� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM< @� CJPQ@� PH<� H<DJM @SKGJM<igJ ?<

$DBPM<�����!JG@igJ�AM<I>@N<�?@�HJ?@GJN@NOM<OjBD>JN ��-N�H<K<N @H�M@G@QJ�AJM<H�DINO<G<?JNI<N�B<G@MD<N�?J�*JPQM@��@H�.<MDN��@H����� $JIO@��+--,��)<M@I �+J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N �K ���

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�HDGDO<M�@H�>JINOMPigJ��?@��G<DI+<I@NNJI�+<GG@OxN ��,�+�/�.1������+,��JP ��+-���

%��.�++���.<MDN������ $JIO@��+--,��)<M@I �+J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N �K ���

$DBPM<������MLPDO@OJN�@H�N@P�@NOs?DJ�>JH�<�H<LP@O@��?@�$M<I>DPN>PN .CDGDKKPN $GJMDIPN� � ��('(&., )+.��',�-%�!�%#,

,tMI=@MB���G@H<IC<����� $JIO@��+--,��)<M@I �+J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N �K ���

Page 100: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V68

K@MNK@>ODQ<�� KJMjH J� PNJ� ?@� HJ?@GJN� >JIODIPJP �N� KMJKJNO<N ?J� OM<O<?J� ?@

�I?M@<�.<GG<?DJ �ADB ��� @�<N�M@KM@N@IO<ip@N�=D?DH@INDJI<DN� KJM�H@DJ ?@�KG<IO<N�

>JMO@N�@� A<>C<?<NM@Q@G<H <�KJNND=DGD?<?@�?@� DIQ@IigJ�@�<HKGDOP?@�?@�PH�NDNO@H<

ODKJGnBD>J� @H� HJ?@GJN� NDIOjOD>JN �N� QDG<N� K<GG<?D<I<N �ADB � �� ODIC<H PH� >JMKJ

>@IOM<G� J�GJ><G�?<�><N<�K<M<�C<=DO<igJ�?J�KMJKMD@OcMDJ�@�NP<�A<HlGD<��@�<G<N�G<O@M<DN

DBP<DN�@�NDHjOMD><N��KMnKMD<N�<J�PNJ�@�API>DJI<H@IOJ�?@�PH<�A<U@I?< �.MJ>PM<Q<�N@�

I<� y><N<� ?@� QDG<z� @HPG<M� JN� K<Gc>DJN� >JINOMPl?JN� I<� >D?<?@ � �N� QDG<N� K<GG<?D<I<N

<NNPH@H� <NNDH� ><M<>O@MlNOD><N� <Oj� @IOgJ� DI@SDNO@IO@N� K<M<� PH<� OM<?D>DJI<G

A<U@I?<@� M@KM@N@IO<H J� H@GCJM� ?@� ?JDN� HPI?JN�� J� <MDNOJ>McOD>J� @� J� MPM<G �

H<OPMD?<?@�?@��I?M@<�.<GG<?DJ������������>JHJ�<MLPDO@OJ�AJD�>JILPDNO<?<�<OM<QjN

?@�NP<N�QD<B@IN�a 0JH<��JI?@�QDNDO<Q<��H@?D<�@�?@N@IC<Q<�JN�@?DAl>DJN�@H�KG<IO<�@

KMJE@ip@N� JMOJBJI<DN�� ?J>PH@IO<I?J� @S<O<H@IO@� <� AJMH<� <MLPDO@OoID><� @� IgJ� N@

GDHDO<I?J�<�M@KMJ?PUDM�NP<N�KMnKMD<N�DHKM@NNp@N�QDNP<DN �y.<GG<?DJ�@INDI< J�Q<GJM�?<N

M@BM<N� @� ?<� ODKJGJBD<� I<� @G<=JM<igJ� ?@� PH<� D?@D< � +JNOM<� >JHJ� PH� wNDNO@H<x

<MLPDO@OoID>J�KJ?@�N@M�K@MA@DO<H@IO@�>JHK<OlQ@G�>JH�<�><K<>D?<?@�?@�DIQ@IigJ �-

?DcGJBJ�LP@�@NO<=@G@>@�@IOM@�J�K@IN<M�@�J�A<U@MNgJ�MD>JN�@�>JINO<IO@N��@IOM@�PH<�@

JPOM< <MLPDO@OPM<�� @IOM@� PH� D?@<G� @� PH<� KMcOD><z�ADB � ���� �*�,!&��� �����

@IOM@QDNO<

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@��'G�0@?@IOJM@�4@I@U<���I?M@<�.<GG<?DJ $JIO@�COOK���RRR UDH=DJ >JH�KD>OPM@N�.*EJN,7.#LN�0JT<G�><?@HT�MON@H����������

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@� 4DGG<�!<KM< $JIO@� COOK���NPDO@��� >JH�<MOD>G@�<I?M@<�K<GG<?DJ�CDN�GDA@�<I?�G@B<>T�<�����@H�����������

$DBPM<��� +<LP@O@�?@�?@O<GC@$JIO@� COOK���RRR <G<DIOMPJIB >JH�O<B��I?M@<���.<GG<?DJ@H����������

Page 101: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V69

-N� KMDH@DMJN� HJ?@GJN� NJ=M@QDQ@IO@N� ?<� $M<Ii<� @� �G@H<IC<� <� K<MODM� ?J� KMDH@DMJ

OMDH@NOM@� ?J� Nj>PGJ� 64'AJM<H� IJQ<H@IO@� API?<H@IO<DN� IJ� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�

LP<I?J� J� AJ>J� @NO<Q<� I<N� LP<GD?<?@N� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM< LP@J� HJ?@GJ� DGPHDI<� H<DN

@S>GPNDQ<H@IO@��J�@NK<iJ��JN�@A@DOJN�?@�GPU�@�NJH=M<��@�AJMH<�@N>PGOPM<G�>JHKG@S<

'INKDM<I?J�N@� I<� <NlGD><� ?@� 1gJ� .@?MJ� ?@� 0JH< �ADB ���� NDM� !CMDNOJKC@M�5M@I� N@

@I><MM@BJP�?@�@S@>PO<M�BM<I?@�HJ?@GJ�K<M<�N@P�KMJE@OJ�?<�><O@?M<G ?@�1gJ�.<PGJ

@H�*JI?M@N�ADB ���

.MJ?PUD?<�@IOM@������@������KJM�PH<�@LPDK@�?@�<MO@NgJN��<�BDB<IO@N><�H<LP@O@ AJD

M@<GDU<?<�>JH�HPDO<�KM@>DNgJ I<�@N><G<�?@ ����� ?@�HJ?J�<�K@MHDODM�LP@ J�>GD@IO@�@

JN� APOPMJN� >JINOMPOJM@N KP?@NN@H ><HDIC<M� KJM� N@P� DIO@MDJM�� >PEJ� <G><I>@� @M< ?@

���H�?@�<GOPM< ,<�Q@M?<?@��<�I@>@NND?<?@�?J�HJ?@GJ�<PSDGD<M�J�@IO@I?DH@IOJ�?JN

JK@McMDJN A@U�>JH�LP@�J�OM<=<GCJ�?@�HJ?@G<B@H�N@�DID>D<NN@�HPDOJ�<IO@N�?<�J=M<�?J

@?DAl>DJ

,J� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�� <� KM@>DNgJ� ?@N>MDODQ<� K@MH<I@>@P� @H� B@M<G� >JHJ� J� >MDOjMDJ

?JHDI<IO@ � ��H<LP@O@� OMD?DH@INDJI<G� OJMIJP�N@� KMJBM@NNDQ<H@IO@� J� DINOMPH@IOJ

KMDQDG@BD<?J� @� B@I@M<GDU<?J� ?@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� ?<� D?@D<� ?J� KMJE@OJ�� ><K<U� ?@

<KM@N@IO<M� IJ� H@GCJM� ?JNHJ?JN� OJ?J� J� @A@DOJ� >@IJBMcAD>J� ?<N� >JINOMPip@N

=<MMJ><N��HPDOJ�H<DN�DIOMDI><?J�LP@�J�?<�0@I<N>@Ii< �-N�HJ?@GJN AJM<H�=<NO<IO@

PODGDU<?JN IJ� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�� LP<I?J� J� AJ>J� DI>D?D<� NJ=M@� <N� LP<GD?<?@N� ?<

<MLPDO@OPM<

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�@H�H<?@DM<��?@�1DM�!CMDNOJKC@M�5M@I��K<M<�<!<O@?M<G�?@�1gJ�.<PGJ��@H�*JI?M@N��'IBG<O@MM< $JIO@��COOK���RRR G<IBAJM?<M>CDO@>ON >JH�ADMNO;H@OCJ?DNO COH�@H�����������

$DBPM<�����.D<UU<�1gJ�.@?MJ��4<OD><IJ�� @MIDID��������� $JIO@��COOK���RRR BJJBG@ >JH =M�DHBM@N�L�N<IKD@OMJHJ?@GN><G@@H����������

V69

-N� KMDH@DMJN� HJ?@GJN� NJ=M@QDQ@IO@N� ?<� $M<Ii<� @� �G@H<IC<� <� K<MODM� ?J� KMDH@DMJ

OMDH@NOM@� ?J� Nj>PGJ� 64'AJM<H� IJQ<H@IO@� API?<H@IO<DN� IJ� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�

LP<I?J� J� AJ>J� @NO<Q<� I<N� LP<GD?<?@N� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM< LP@J� HJ?@GJ� DGPHDI<� H<DN

@S>GPNDQ<H@IO@��J�@NK<iJ��JN�@A@DOJN�?@�GPU�@�NJH=M<��@�AJMH<�@N>PGOPM<G�>JHKG@S<

'INKDM<I?J�N@� I<� <NlGD><� ?@� 1gJ� .@?MJ� ?@� 0JH< �ADB ���� NDM� !CMDNOJKC@M�5M@I� N@

@I><MM@BJP�?@�@S@>PO<M�BM<I?@�HJ?@GJ�K<M<�N@P�KMJE@OJ�?<�><O@?M<G ?@�1gJ�.<PGJ

@H�*JI?M@N�ADB ���

.MJ?PUD?<�@IOM@������@������KJM�PH<�@LPDK@�?@�<MO@NgJN��<�BDB<IO@N><�H<LP@O@ AJD

M@<GDU<?<�>JH�HPDO<�KM@>DNgJ I<�@N><G<�?@ ����� ?@�HJ?J�<�K@MHDODM�LP@ J�>GD@IO@�@

JN� APOPMJN� >JINOMPOJM@N KP?@NN@H ><HDIC<M� KJM� N@P� DIO@MDJM�� >PEJ� <G><I>@� @M< ?@

���H�?@�<GOPM< ,<�Q@M?<?@��<�I@>@NND?<?@�?J�HJ?@GJ�<PSDGD<M�J�@IO@I?DH@IOJ�?JN

JK@McMDJN A@U�>JH�LP@�J�OM<=<GCJ�?@�HJ?@G<B@H�N@�DID>D<NN@�HPDOJ�<IO@N�?<�J=M<�?J

@?DAl>DJ

,J� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�� <� KM@>DNgJ� ?@N>MDODQ<� K@MH<I@>@P� @H� B@M<G� >JHJ� J� >MDOjMDJ

?JHDI<IO@ � ��H<LP@O@� OMD?DH@INDJI<G� OJMIJP�N@� KMJBM@NNDQ<H@IO@� J� DINOMPH@IOJ

KMDQDG@BD<?J� @� B@I@M<GDU<?J� ?@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� ?<� D?@D<� ?J� KMJE@OJ�� ><K<U� ?@

<KM@N@IO<M� IJ� H@GCJM� ?JNHJ?JN� OJ?J� J� @A@DOJ� >@IJBMcAD>J� ?<N� >JINOMPip@N

=<MMJ><N��HPDOJ�H<DN�DIOMDI><?J�LP@�J�?<�0@I<N>@Ii< �-N�HJ?@GJN AJM<H�=<NO<IO@

PODGDU<?JN IJ� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�� LP<I?J� J� AJ>J� DI>D?D<� NJ=M@� <N� LP<GD?<?@N� ?<

<MLPDO@OPM<

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�@H�H<?@DM<��?@�1DM�!CMDNOJKC@M�5M@I��K<M<�<!<O@?M<G�?@�1gJ�.<PGJ��@H�*JI?M@N��'IBG<O@MM< $JIO@��COOK���RRR G<IBAJM?<M>CDO@>ON >JH�ADMNO;H@OCJ?DNO COH�@H�����������

$DBPM<�����.D<UU<�1gJ�.@?MJ��4<OD><IJ�� @MIDID��������� $JIO@��COOK���RRR BJJBG@ >JH =M�DHBM@N�L�N<IKD@OMJHJ?@GN><G@@H����������

V69

-N� KMDH@DMJN� HJ?@GJN� NJ=M@QDQ@IO@N� ?<� $M<Ii<� @� �G@H<IC<� <� K<MODM� ?J� KMDH@DMJ

OMDH@NOM@� ?J� Nj>PGJ� 64'AJM<H� IJQ<H@IO@� API?<H@IO<DN� IJ� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�

LP<I?J� J� AJ>J� @NO<Q<� I<N� LP<GD?<?@N� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM< LP@J� HJ?@GJ� DGPHDI<� H<DN

@S>GPNDQ<H@IO@��J�@NK<iJ��JN�@A@DOJN�?@�GPU�@�NJH=M<��@�AJMH<�@N>PGOPM<G�>JHKG@S<

'INKDM<I?J�N@� I<� <NlGD><� ?@� 1gJ� .@?MJ� ?@� 0JH< �ADB ���� NDM� !CMDNOJKC@M�5M@I� N@

@I><MM@BJP�?@�@S@>PO<M�BM<I?@�HJ?@GJ�K<M<�N@P�KMJE@OJ�?<�><O@?M<G ?@�1gJ�.<PGJ

@H�*JI?M@N�ADB ���

.MJ?PUD?<�@IOM@������@������KJM�PH<�@LPDK@�?@�<MO@NgJN��<�BDB<IO@N><�H<LP@O@ AJD

M@<GDU<?<�>JH�HPDO<�KM@>DNgJ I<�@N><G<�?@ ����� ?@�HJ?J�<�K@MHDODM�LP@ J�>GD@IO@�@

JN� APOPMJN� >JINOMPOJM@N KP?@NN@H ><HDIC<M� KJM� N@P� DIO@MDJM�� >PEJ� <G><I>@� @M< ?@

���H�?@�<GOPM< ,<�Q@M?<?@��<�I@>@NND?<?@�?J�HJ?@GJ�<PSDGD<M�J�@IO@I?DH@IOJ�?JN

JK@McMDJN A@U�>JH�LP@�J�OM<=<GCJ�?@�HJ?@G<B@H�N@�DID>D<NN@�HPDOJ�<IO@N�?<�J=M<�?J

@?DAl>DJ

,J� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�� <� KM@>DNgJ� ?@N>MDODQ<� K@MH<I@>@P� @H� B@M<G� >JHJ� J� >MDOjMDJ

?JHDI<IO@ � ��H<LP@O@� OMD?DH@INDJI<G� OJMIJP�N@� KMJBM@NNDQ<H@IO@� J� DINOMPH@IOJ

KMDQDG@BD<?J� @� B@I@M<GDU<?J� ?@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� ?<� D?@D<� ?J� KMJE@OJ�� ><K<U� ?@

<KM@N@IO<M� IJ� H@GCJM� ?JNHJ?JN� OJ?J� J� @A@DOJ� >@IJBMcAD>J� ?<N� >JINOMPip@N

=<MMJ><N��HPDOJ�H<DN�DIOMDI><?J�LP@�J�?<�0@I<N>@Ii< �-N�HJ?@GJN AJM<H�=<NO<IO@

PODGDU<?JN IJ� K@MlJ?J� <MMJ>J�� LP<I?J� J� AJ>J� DI>D?D<� NJ=M@� <N� LP<GD?<?@N� ?<

<MLPDO@OPM<

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�@H�H<?@DM<��?@�1DM�!CMDNOJKC@M�5M@I��K<M<�<!<O@?M<G�?@�1gJ�.<PGJ��@H�*JI?M@N��'IBG<O@MM< $JIO@��COOK���RRR G<IBAJM?<M>CDO@>ON >JH�ADMNO;H@OCJ?DNO COH�@H�����������

$DBPM<�����.D<UU<�1gJ�.@?MJ��4<OD><IJ�� @MIDID��������� $JIO@��COOK���RRR BJJBG@ >JH =M�DHBM@N�L�N<IKD@OMJHJ?@GN><G@@H����������

Page 102: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V70

,J� ADI<G ?J� Nj>PGJ� 64'''� JN <MLPDO@OJN� =PN><Q<H� <� NDHKGDAD><igJ� ?<N� AJMH<N � �

KM@>DNgJ� <ODIBDP� ><M<>O@MlNOD><N� DI?DNK@INcQ@DN �NNDH� N@I?J�� J I@J>G<NND>DNHJ N@

>JI>@IOMJP� I<N� KMJKJMip@N�� I<N� JM?@IN� >GcNND><N @ I<� >JHKJNDigJ� ?<N� A<>C<?<N�

OJMI<I?J�N@ PH�NJGJ�H@IJN�AjMODG�K<M<�JN�HJ?@GJN OMD?DH@INDJI<DN

,@NO@� K@MlJ?J� J=N@MQ<�N@� J� Cc=DOJ� ?J� ?@N@ICJ� MDBJMJN<H@IO@� GDI@<M� @H� KM@OJ� @

=M<I>J�LP@�QDBJM<�<Oj�CJE@�IJ�eH=DOJ�KMJADNNDJI<G��>JHJ�J�H<DN�M@KM@N@IO<ODQJ -

@NKlMDOJ� DGPHDIDNO<�� <KGD><?J� <J� M@K@MOnMDJ� ?<� OM<?DigJ M@I<N>@IODNO<�� M@>JGC@

I<LP@G<N� AJMH<N�?JDN�HJODQJN ?@�Q<GD?<?@� <� >JMM@NKJI?kI>D<� >JH�JN�HJ?@GJN�?<

<MLPDO@OPM<� <IODB<�� BM@B<� @ MJH<I<�� @� <� M<>DJI<GD?<?@� ?<N� KMnKMD<N� AJMH<N

<NNDHDG<?<N�< @G@H@IOJN�?@�>JINOMPigJ (PIOJ�>JH�J�<PH@IOJ�?J�>PNOJ�?@�OM<=<GCJ

@� ?@K@I?kI>D<� >M@N>@IO@� ?@� ?@N@ICJN�� J� PNJ� ?<� HJ?@G<B@H� QDP�N@� @H� ?@>GlIDJ�

<K<M@IO@� <Oj� J� ADI<G� ?@� ?J� Nj>PGJ� 64'''� I<� #PMJK<�� =@H� >JHJ �HjMD><� ?J�,JMO@

-POMJ� ?<?J� NDBIDAD><ODQJ� AJD� >JINO<O<?J I<� cM@<� @?P><>DJI<G� KJDN a�H@?D?<� LP@J

@INDIJ�?<�<MLPDO@OPM< OJMIJP�N@ ?JHlIDJ�?<N�@N>JG<N�?@�=@G<N� <MO@N�� <N�H<LP@O@N

K<NN<M<H�<�N@M�NP=NODOPl?<N LP<N@�LP@�>JHKG@O<H@IO@�KJM�?@N@ICJN ���<MLPDO@OPM<

N@�M@NOMDIBD<�< @NOP?JN�?@�KG<IO<N��@G@Q<ip@N @�H@DJN�OMD?DH@INDJI<DN�ODIC<H�KJP><

M@G@QeI>D< �+'**1��������K QD

Z�=@H�KMJQcQ@G�LP@�< AJMH<igJ ?@AD>D@IO@ @H�<MLPDO@OPM<�@�<�DIAGPkI>D<�?JN�K<M@N

O@IC<H�@S@M>D?J�PH @A@DOJ�I@B<ODQJ�NJ=M@�<�PODGDU<igJ�?@�HJ?@GJN �#NO@�A<OJ KJ?@

N@M� @S@HKGDAD><?JIJ� K@MlJ?J� ?<� NPKM@H<>D< ?< ��.1�+-,�� LP<I?J� BM<I?@

DHKJMOeI>D<� AJD� >JGJ><?<� IJ� ?@N@ICJ�� J� LP@ G@QJP� <� PH<� A<GO<� ?@� DIO@M@NN@� @H

>JINOMPDM�HJ?@GJN @H�QcMD<N�M@BDp@N�?PM<IO@�J�Nj>PGJ�6'6

.M@NNp@N� H<DJM@N� >JIOMD=PlM<H� K<M<� J� ?@>GlIDJ� ?J� HJ?@GJ� ?PM<IO@� J� Nj>PGJ� 6'6

!DO<�N@�>JHJ�@S@HKGJ�J�KMJ>@NNJ� AJOJBMcAD>J �%.�)+#'-#'!u C@GDJBMcAD><��?J�BM@BJ�

�BM<Q<M�>JH�NJG� �ADB ��� �!MD<?J�IJ Nj>PGJ�6'6��@H�LP@�<�'H<B@H�&@GDJBMcAD><�@M<

A@DO<� >JH�PH<�KG<><�?@�@NO<ICJ�?@MDQ<?J�?@�PH�K@OMnG@J� AJOJNN@INlQ@G��KJ?@I?J

AD><M�>@M><�?@���CJM<N�I<�@SKJNDigJ�NJG<M �#NN<�Oj>ID><�?@�DHKM@NNgJ��><M<>O@MDU<?<

KJM�GDIC<N�>JGJMD?<N�?@�GPU�NJ=M@�PH�API?J�<UPG @�K@G<�LP<G N@�J=ODIC< PH�I@B<ODQJ

?J� JMDBDI<G�� K@MHDODP� <� M@KMJ?PigJ� McKD?<� @� KM@>DN<� ?@� ?J>PH@IOJN� PODGDU<?JN� I<

Page 103: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V71

>JINOMPigJ� >DQDG� @� I<� DI?sNOMD<�� M@?PUDI?J� JN� >PNOJN� ?@� @G<=JM<igJ� ?<N

M@KM@N@IO<ip@N�=D?DH@INDJI<DN �-�<?Q@IOJ�?@NO@�KMJ>@NNJ DIO@INDAD>JP�< KMJ?PigJ

?JN�HJ?@GJN

��?@NK@N<�?@�HgJ�?@�J=M<�LP<GDAD><?<�>JIODIPJP�<�NP=DM��@�IJ�ADI<G�?J�Nj>PGJ�6'6�

@NK@>D<GH@IO@�JI?@�<� DIAGPkI>D<�?< ��.1�+-, IJ� OM@DI<H@IOJ� AJD�KM@?JHDI<IO@�

JN� HJ?@GJN� >C@B<M<H� <� N@M� >JIND?@M<?JN� HPDOJ� ><MJN�� PH� GPSJ � -� H@NHJ

<>JIO@>DH@IOJ� N@� K<NNJP� K<MOD>PG<MH@IO@� O<H=jH� IJN� #NO<?JN� 3ID?JN�� LP@�� <J

>JIOMcMDJ� ?<� #PMJK<�� IgJ� ODIC<� OM<?DigJ� ?@� HJ?@G<B@H � -N� A<=MD><IO@N� >PE<N

NPK@MDJM@N� C<=DGD?<?@N @H� N@P� JAl>DJ ADU@M<H� >JH� LP@� B<IC<NN@H >JHDNNp@N

DHKJMO<IO@N >JHJ� JN�HJ?@GJN� K<M<� J� !<KDOnGDJ� ?JN� #3�� @ JN ?@� @?DAl>DJN� K<M<� <

#SKJNDigJ� +PI?D<G �(%.&�#�'� N@� N@IOD<H M@G<ODQ<H@IO@� N@BPMJN�� PH<� Q@U� LP@

@NN@N� OM<=<GCJN� KJ?@MD<H� J>PK<M� PH<� @LPDK@� ?@� HJ?@GDNO<N� KJM� QcMDJN� <IJN

>JIN@>PODQJN��H<N�JN�?@H<DN�@NO<Q<H�N@INDQ@GH@IO@ QPGI@McQ@DN

-N�HJ?@GJN�AJM<H�PN<?JN ?PM<IO@�OJ?J�J�Nj>PGJ�6'6 I<�%Mg� M@O<IC< I<�KMJ?PigJ

?@� DHKJMO<IO@N�@?DAl>DJN�Ks=GD>JN�@�HJIPH@IOJN�� DBM@E<N�@�KMJE@OJN�?@�@IB@IC<MD<

>JHJ� KJIO@N � +<DN ?@� �� ?@G@N AJM<H� NP=H@OD?JN� <� >JI>PMNJ�� @H ����� K<M<� J

$DBPM<�����!nKD<�C@GDJBMcAD>< ?@�KMJE@OJN�?@�<MLPDO@OPM<�> �����$JIO@��COOK���JGC<M>JINOMPD?J RJM?KM@NN >JH�=GP@KMDIO�>JHJ�OP?J�<>JIO@>@P��@H�����������COOK���H@NF@M=MJOC@MN RJM?KM@NN >JH������������JI�OCDN�GJO�@H�����������

Page 104: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V72

+JIPH@IOJ� ?@� ,@GNJI� @H� 2M<A<GB<M� 1LP<M@ � !JHK@ODip@N� OMJPS@M<H� O<H=jH� <

@G<=JM<igJ� ?@ JPOMJN =@H� H<DN� HJ?@NOJN�� >JHJ� J� @G<=JM<?J� KJM� ?@� %@JMB@

#?HPI?�1OM@@O�@�.JGG<M?�(JCI�1@??JI�K<M<�J�>JI>PMNJ�K<M<�?J�2MD=PI<G�@H�*JI?M@N�

@H����� �ADB ���

,<��HjMD><�O<H=jH��H@NHJ�LP<I?J�J�PNJ ?<�Oj>ID><�?@�HJ?@G<B@H�AlND>< @NO<Q<

@H ?@>GlIDJ�� @G< <DI?< @M< >JIND?@M<?<� I@>@NNcMD< @H� KMJE@OJN� ?@� @?DAl>DJN

DHKJMO<IO@N�@�@G<=JM<?<�?@�PH<�H<I@DM<�DI?@K@I?@IO@ �-�BM<I?@�HJ?@GJ�?@�B@NNJ

?J�!<KDOnGDJ�?JN�#3�������� G@QJP�H<DN�?@�?JDN <IJN�K<M<�N@M�>JI>GPl?J !JIOP?J�

@NN@� M@>PMNJ AJD KJP>J PODGDU<?J� I<� KMcOD><� B@M<G�� KJDN� @M<� ><MJ�� @ M@<GH@IO@� Nn

@S@>PO<?J� ?@QD?J� < PH�HJ?DNHJ� JP a� NP<� DHKJMOeI>D<�� KJM� EPNODAD><MPH BM<I?@

@NAJMiJ�IJ�@NOP?J�?@�N@P�KMJE@OJ

-�<>MjN>DHJ�?<�>sKPG<�>@IOM<G�?J�!<KDOnGDJ�?JN�#3���>M@?DO<?J�<J�<MLPDO@OJ�2CJH<N

3 �5<GO@M�� IgJ� KJ?@MD<� O@M� ND?J� M@<GDU<?J� N@H� <� >JG<=JM<igJ� ?@�+JIOBJH@MT� !

+@DBN #H� ������ J� "@K<MO<H@IOJ� ?@� %P@MM<� <NNPHDP� J� >JIOMJG@� ?J� KMJE@OJ� ?@

@SO@INgJ�?J�!<KDOnGDJ�@�+@DBN�AD>JP�@I><MM@B<?J�?<�@S@>PigJ�?J�KMJE@OJ �ADB ���

#G@� OJHJP� <N� Mj?@<N� ?J� KMJE@OJ� @I@MB@OD><H@IO@�� H@MBPGC<I?J� IJ� @NOP?J� ?<

<MLPDO@OPM<�� <>sNOD><�� <LP@>DH@IOJ� @� Q@IODG<igJ � &<QD<� PH<� =J<� ?JN@� ?@

>JIOMJQjMND<�NJ=M@�N@�<�>sKPG<�@NO<MD<�JP�IgJ�N@I?J�>JINOMPl?<�?@�<>JM?J�>JH�<N

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJ�@G<=JM<?JN�KJM�%@JMB@�#?HPI?�1OM@@O�@�.JGG<M?�(JCI�1@??JI������ $JIO@��COOK���<M>CDN@@F >JH�O<B������@H������������@�+--,��)<M@I �+J?@GDIB+@NN<B@N��K ��

Page 105: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V73

KG<IO<N �+@DBN� ODIC<H�PH�HJ?@GJ� ?@�H@O<G� K<M<� N@P� KMnKMDJ� >JIOMJG@� A@DOJ� K<M<

O@NO<M�<�@AD>DkI>D<�?@�NP<N�D?@D<N �#G@�<>M@?DO<Q<�LP@�J�!<KDOnGDJ�@M<�H<DN�?J�LP@�PH

G@B<?J�?@�OM<=<GCJ

,J�ADI<G�?J�Nj> �6'6� J�<MLPDO@OJ��IOoIDJ�%<P?D�>JH@i<Q<�<�PN<M�JN�HJ?@GJN�>JHJ

H@DJ�K<M<�@SKGJM<M� D?@D<N�@NOMPOPM<DN�@�?@N@IQJGQ@M�PH<� GDIBP<B@H�<MLPDO@OoID><

%<P?D� IgJ� AJD� PH� O@nMD>J� IJ� N@IOD?J� @NOMDOJ� ?<� K<G<QM< � #N>M@Q@P� =M@Q@N

>JH@IOcMDJN� @H� NP<� EPQ@IOP?@� @� O@Q@� <K@I<N� ?JDN� <MODBJN� KP=GD><?JN � 1@PN

K@IN<H@IOJN�NgJ�>JIC@>D?JN�K@G<N�?@>G<M<ip@N�A<G<?<N�@�>JH@IOcMDJN�LP@�A@U�NJ=M@

NP<N�J=M<N��@NK@>D<GH@IO@�NJ=M@�<�1<BM<?<�$<HlGD<��<�LP<G�=MDI?JP�>JH�<�H@O<?@�?@

NP<�QD?< �2gJ�KJP>J�N@�?@?D>JP�<J�@INDIJ�<><?kHD>J �y%<P?D�AJD�<IO@N�?@�OP?J�PH

<MLPDO@OJ�@�NJH@IO@�<MLPDO@OJz� �11#%-"���������K ����

"@N?@�>MD<Ii<� %<P?D AJD�PH�J=N@MQ<?JM�NPODG�?<�I<OPM@U<�@�?<�>MD<igJ��?JN�<IDH<DN�

KG<IO<N�@�B@JGJBD<�?@�NP<�>D?<?@ �#M<�PH�<AD>DJI<?J�K@G<N�@S>PMNp@N�><HK@NOM@N�LP@

>JINODOPl<H� PH<�IJQD?<?@� K<M<� <� jKJ>< � #H� N@PN� K<NN@DJN� >JOD?D<IJN� @NOP?JP� <

I<OPM@U<� @� ><KOPMJP� <GBPIN� ?@� N@PN� N@BM@?JN�� ?@N>J=MDP <� <MLPDO@OPM<� DIO@MI<� ?@

OP?J� LP@� GC@� N@MQD<� >JHJ�HJ?@GJ� K@MA@DOJ� ?@� DHDO<igJ� K<M<� NJGP>DJI<M� LP<GLP@M

O@H<� >JINOMPODQJ � �KM@I?@P� >JHJ I<� I<OPM@U<� <OM<QjN� ?@� HDGCp@N� ?@

<IJN�HJ?@G<M<H�N@<N AJMH<N�?<N�>JDN<N�@�NP<�@NOMPOPM<�@H�JPOM<N�K<G<QM<N� >JHJ

$DBPM< ����!<KDOnGDJ�?JN�#3���+@DBN $JIO@��COOK���RRR HH?OFR JMB�4,<O PDG?+PN COHG�@H�����������

Page 106: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V74

AJM<H M@NJGQD?<N < @NOjOD>< @ <� @NOcOD>< ?@G<N y.<M<� N@IODM� J� KM<U@M ?@� ?@NAMPO<M� <

J=M< ?@� %<P?D�� H<DN ?J LP@� OJ><M�� JPQDM�� Q@M@BJNO<M�� j� I@>@NNcMDJ� N@M� ><K<U� ?@

M@NKDM<M� N@P� K@MAPH@� N<BM<?Jz �-02#%�� 7� %�11#2�� ������ K ��� ?DNN@NJ=M@� @G@

1<GQ<?JM�"<Gl �ADB ��������@���

$DBPM<���� +J?@GJ�JMDBDI<G�?@�%<P?D�K<M<�<�A<>C<?<�?<�%GnMD< $JIO@� COOK���JOC<P?J=GJB =GJBNKJO >JH =M���������<IOJID�B<P?D COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<N����@���� -AD>DI< ?@�%<P?D �,J >CgJ��?<�DH<B@H�����a�@NLP@M?<��<K<M@>@��PH�HJ?@GJ�?@�PH<�Q<M<I?<�?<�!<N<� <OGGn $JIO@� COOK���RRR B<P?D>GP= >JH�DIBG@N�D;QD?<�AJON<BMA�NB�� EKB�@H�����������

Page 107: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V75

.<M<�<�@S@>PigJ�?@�NP<N�J=M<N��%<P?D M@<GDUJP�H<LP@O@N�OMD?DH@INDJI<DN�PODGDU<I?J

>JM?<N�LP@� K@MHDO<H� ?@O@MHDI<M� ?@� H<I@DM<� >JMM@O< <� >PMQ<� ?< ><O@MIcMD< JP

K<Mc=JG< �ADB � ���� M@BDNOM<I?J� BM<AD><H@IO@� J� HJ?@GJ�� A<UD<� BDM<M� <� DH<B@H� @

J=ODIC<� <� QJGPH@OMD<� ?J� >JIEPIOJ � -� OM<=<GCJ� N@� >JHKG@O<Q<� >JH� J� >cG>PGJ� ?<N

N@ip@N�I@>@NNcMD<N�K<M<� NPKJMO<M�<N� ><MB<N�@� >JH�<N� >JINOMPip@N ?JN�HJ?@GJN�?@

B@NNJ� ?<N� ?DA@M@IO@N� K@i<N� LP@� @IOM@B<Q<� <JN <MO@NgJN K<M<� LP@ @NO@N <N

@S@>PO<NN@H @H�H<O@MD<G� @� @N><G<� M@<G � <MLPDO@OPM<�?@�%<P?D j� <O@HKJM<G�� <GjH

?JN� HJ?DNHJN� @� >JMM@IO@N� @NODGlNOD><N� ?@� OJ?<� jKJ>< � 1@P� NDNO@H<� >JINOMPODQJ�

Oj>ID>J�@�DH<BDI<ODQJ�j�sID>J�@�KJ?@MD<�O@M�ND?J�PN<?J O<IOJ KJM�H@NOM@N�H@?D@Q<DN

>JHJ�K@GJ�sGODHJ ?JN�Q<IBP<M?DNO<N

$DBPM<���� �IOoIDJ�%<P?D�@�J�HJ?@GJ�<IOD�APID>PG<M�?PM<IO@�J@NOP?J�?<�><K@G<�!JGoID<�%P@GG�K@I?PM<?J�I<�JAD>DI<�<J�G<?J�?JKMj?DJ �+J?@GJ�M@Q@NOD?J�@H�K<K@G�AJD M@<GDU<?J�>JH�<�<EP?<�?J@IB@IC@DMJ�#?JP?%J@O $JIO@� COOK���RRR <H@MD><I=@IP??C< >JH�B<P?D �>JGGDIN KG<O@N �� COH��@H����������

$DBPM<���� �IOoIDJ�%<P?D�@�J�HJ?@GJ�<IOD�APID>PG<M�?PM<IO@�J�@NOP?J�?<�><K@G<�!JGoID<�%P@GG�K@I?PM<?J�I<JAD>DI<�<J�G<?J�?J�KMj?DJ �+J?@GJ�M@Q@NOD?J�@H�K<K@G�AJD�M@<GDU<?J�>JH�<�<EP?<�?J�@IB@IC@DMJ�#?JP? %J@O $JIO@� COOK���RRR <H@MD><I=@IP??C< >JH�B<P?D �>JGGDIN KG<O@N �� COH��@H�����������

Page 108: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V76

,J�ADI<G�?J�Nj>PGJ�6'6�@�IJN�KMDH@DMJN�<IJN�?J Nj>PGJ�66 u @H�K<MOD>PG<M�IJN�#NO<?JN

3ID?JN�� JI?@ JN� PNJN� ?@� HJ?@GJN� AJM<H H<DN GDHDO<?JN u N@ M@>JIC@>@P LP@� <

K<DSgJ�?< ��.1�+-, K@GJN ?@N@ICJN�QDMOPJNJN�@M<� G<O@IO@�� >JIN@LP@IO@H@IO@�JN

HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN ?@� @NOP?J� AJM<H� N@ OJMI<I?J @G@H@IOJN KJNOJN� @H

N@BPI?J� KG<IJ� @H=JM< I<� @HDIkI>D<?@� KMJQJ><M� PH� @A@DOJ� <?Q@MNJ� NJ=M@� <

LP<GD?<?@�?<�>JI>@KigJ

#NN<� KM@J>PK<igJ� AJD� G@Q<IO<?< >JH� AM@LPkI>D<� >M@N>@IO@� @IOM@� ����� @� ���� �-N

>MlOD>JN� O@HD<H� LP@� <� @S<>@M=<?<� kIA<N@� @H� KG<IO<N� @� @G@Q<ip@N� O@MD<� <

>JIN@LPkI>D<�?<�K@M?<�?<�><K<>D?<?@�?@�K@IN<H@IOJ�?JN�NnGD?JN �-N�@?P><?JM@N

O<H=jH� ?@NO<><M<H� J� J=E@ODQJ� ADI<G� @� DINOMPODQJ� ?J� @INDIJ� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<�� J� ?@

@INDI<M� JN� <GPIJN <� >JINOMPDM� =JIN� @?DAl>DJN DIQjN� ?@� >JI>@=@M� ?@N@ICJN� =JIDOJN

#NO<� >MlOD><� M@A@M@�N@� <J� AM<><NNJ� ?<� @N>JG<� AM<I>@N<�� LP@� <KM@N@IO<Q<� ?@N@ICJN

H<M<QDGCJNJN��KJMjH�@I>J=MD<�<�D?@D<�>JMM@O<�?J�@?DAl>DJ�>JINOMPl?J

!JHJ�M@NPGO<?J��IJ�DIl>DJ�?J�Nj>PGJ�66��< H<DJMD<�?<N�K@NNJ<N�ODIC<�<�DHKM@NNgJ�?@

LP@�JN�HJ?@GJN <MLPDO@OoID>JN�@M<H�?@ ?DAl>DG�@G<=JM<igJ�@�><MJN �!JIOP?J��<GBPIN

<MLPDO@OJN� >JHJ�$M@?@MD> ! �&DMJIN <MBPH@IO<M<H�@H������LP@ @NN<N�?DAD>PG?<?@N

IgJ�@M<H�NDBIDAD><ODQ<N�@ I@H <�>JINOMPigJ�?J�HJ?@GJ�N@MD<�?DNK@I?DJN< ��=PN><�?@

H<O@MD<DN� <GO@MI<ODQJN� N@� DID>D<Q<�� <NNDH� >JH� JN� HjOJ?JN� ?@� A<=MD><igJ� LP@

K<NN<MD<H�<�N@M�H@IJN�KMJADNNDJI<DN��@ <�@S@>PigJ N@MD<�@G<=JM<?< IJN�@N>MDOnMDJN�?@

<MLPDO@OPM< �!JH�< <?@LP<igJ ?@NO<�H@?D?<��>JIN@BPDP�N@�<H@IDU<M�@�HPDO<N�Q@U@N

@QDO<M J�>PNOJ�?@�<MO@NgJN�KMJADNNDJI<DN

"@U@I<N� ?@� <MODBJN� @S<GO<I?J� <N� QDMOP?@N� ?J HJ?@GJ� OMD?DH@INDJI<G >C@B<Q<H aN

H@N<N� @?DOJMD<DN� ?@� K@MDn?D>JN� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM<� <H@MD><I<�� @IOM@� ����� @� ���� .JM

HPDOJN <IJN J�HJ?@GJ�AlND>J AJD�PN<?J�K<M<�HJNOM<M�J�KMJE@OJ�?@�BM<I?@N�@?DAl>DJN

Ks=GD>JN�@�N@HDKs=GD>JN��KJMjH Nn�KJNO@MDJMH@IO@ @H H@<?JN�?JN�<IJN����j�LP@�J

H@NHJ�HjOJ?J�K<NNJP�<�N@M�PN<?J�O<IOJ�@H�@NOP?J ?@�KMJE@OJN�M@ND?@I>D<DN�K@GJ

KMnKMDJ�<MLPDO@OJ LP<IOJ I<�<KM@N@IO<igJ�?J�KMJE@OJ�>JHKG@OJ�K<M<�J�N@P�>GD@IO@

,@NO@� H@NHJ� Nj>PGJ�� >JDI>D?DI?J� >JH� <� M@>@IO@� API?<igJ� ?@� @N>JG<N� Oj>ID><N�

@NO@I?@P�N@ <� PODGDU<igJ� ?@�H<LP@O@N� AlND><N < KMJKnNDOJN� @?P><>DJI<DN .JM�H@DJ

Page 109: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V77

?@G<N� N@� M@KM@N@IO<Q<H� <N� >JI?Dip@N @NOMPOPM<DN� @� >JINOMPODQ<N� H<DN� >JHKG@S<N

LP@� D<H� NPMBDI?J� I@NN<� jKJ><� ?@� HJ?J� <� A<QJM@>@M� <OM<QjN� ?J� J=E@OJ

OMD?DH@INDJI<G� <� >JHKG@H@IO<igJ� ?@� @IO@I?DH@IOJ� IJN� H@DJN� <><?kHD>JN� I<

AJMH<igJ�?JN�@NOP?<IO@N�Oj>ID>JN�@ O<H=jH�?JN >JINOMPOJM@N

,<� @NO@DM<� ?< 0@QJGPigJ� 'I?PNOMD<G� <N H<LP@O@N� N@� M@NOMDIBDM<H� H<DN� <� O@NO@N

@NOMPOPM<DN��@QD?@I>D<I?J <NNDH J�?@N@HK@ICJ�?<�O@>IJGJBD<�?JN�H<O@MD<DN�I<�J=M<

�GBPIN�KMJE@OJN� AJM<H�O@NO<?JN H@?D<IO@�J�PNJ�?@�H<LP@O@N KMnSDH<N�aN�@N><G<N

I<OPM<DN��@S>GPDI?J�N@�<NNDH�JN >cG>PGJN�H<O@HcOD>JN

��DIO@IigJ�?@ 4G<?DHDM 2<OGDI AJD >MD<M PH�HJIPH@IOJ�LP@�M@KM@N@IO<NN@ PH<�IJQ<

JM?@H�NJ>D<G�I<�0sNND<�J�G@QJP�<�>MD<M�PH�HJ?@GJ�OMD?DH@INDJI<G��?@N>MDOJ�@H�PH<

BM<I?@� OJMM@� C@GD>JD?<G� DI>GDI<?< �� H<LP@O@� AJD� @HKM@@I?D?<� N@H� @N=JiJN

KM@GDHDI<M@N�@H�H@IJN�?@�JDOJ�H@N@N��K@MHDODI?J�<NNDHQ@MDAD><M <N�KJNND=DGD?<?@N

?@ @SKGJM<igJ�?JN�?@N@ICJN a�H@?D?<�LP@�@M<�>JINOMPl?< �ADB ���

$DBPM<������EP?<IO@N�?@�4G<?DHDM�2<OGDI�>JINOMJ@H�J�KMDH@DMJ�HJ?@GJ +JIPH@IOJ�?<�2@M>@DM<�,<>DJI<G������ �+<?@DM<N�PID?<N KJM�KG<><N�H@OcGD><N $JIO@��"3,,��,D>F �+<LP@O<N�?@��MLPDO@>OPM<��K ���

V77

?@G<N� N@� M@KM@N@IO<Q<H� <N� >JI?Dip@N @NOMPOPM<DN� @� >JINOMPODQ<N� H<DN� >JHKG@S<N

LP@� D<H� NPMBDI?J� I@NN<� jKJ><� ?@� HJ?J� <� A<QJM@>@M� <OM<QjN� ?J� J=E@OJ

OMD?DH@INDJI<G� <� >JHKG@H@IO<igJ� ?@� @IO@I?DH@IOJ� IJN� H@DJN� <><?kHD>JN� I<

AJMH<igJ�?JN�@NOP?<IO@N�Oj>ID>JN�@ O<H=jH�?JN >JINOMPOJM@N

,<� @NO@DM<� ?< 0@QJGPigJ� 'I?PNOMD<G� <N H<LP@O@N� N@� M@NOMDIBDM<H� H<DN� <� O@NO@N

@NOMPOPM<DN��@QD?@I>D<I?J <NNDH J�?@N@HK@ICJ�?<�O@>IJGJBD<�?JN�H<O@MD<DN�I<�J=M<

�GBPIN�KMJE@OJN� AJM<H�O@NO<?JN H@?D<IO@�J�PNJ�?@�H<LP@O@N KMnSDH<N�aN�@N><G<N

I<OPM<DN��@S>GPDI?J�N@�<NNDH�JN >cG>PGJN�H<O@HcOD>JN

��DIO@IigJ�?@ 4G<?DHDM 2<OGDI AJD >MD<M PH�HJIPH@IOJ�LP@�M@KM@N@IO<NN@ PH<�IJQ<

JM?@H�NJ>D<G�I<�0sNND<�J�G@QJP�<�>MD<M�PH�HJ?@GJ�OMD?DH@INDJI<G��?@N>MDOJ�@H�PH<

BM<I?@� OJMM@� C@GD>JD?<G� DI>GDI<?< �� H<LP@O@� AJD� @HKM@@I?D?<� N@H� @N=JiJN

KM@GDHDI<M@N�@H�H@IJN�?@�JDOJ�H@N@N��K@MHDODI?J�<NNDHQ@MDAD><M <N�KJNND=DGD?<?@N

?@ @SKGJM<igJ�?JN�?@N@ICJN a�H@?D?<�LP@�@M<�>JINOMPl?< �ADB ���

$DBPM<������EP?<IO@N�?@�4G<?DHDM�2<OGDI�>JINOMJ@H�J�KMDH@DMJ�HJ?@GJ +JIPH@IOJ�?<�2@M>@DM<�,<>DJI<G������ �+<?@DM<N�PID?<N KJM�KG<><N�H@OcGD><N $JIO@��"3,,��,D>F �+<LP@O<N�?@��MLPDO@>OPM<��K ���

V77

?@G<N� N@� M@KM@N@IO<Q<H� <N� >JI?Dip@N @NOMPOPM<DN� @� >JINOMPODQ<N� H<DN� >JHKG@S<N

LP@� D<H� NPMBDI?J� I@NN<� jKJ><� ?@� HJ?J� <� A<QJM@>@M� <OM<QjN� ?J� J=E@OJ

OMD?DH@INDJI<G� <� >JHKG@H@IO<igJ� ?@� @IO@I?DH@IOJ� IJN� H@DJN� <><?kHD>JN� I<

AJMH<igJ�?JN�@NOP?<IO@N�Oj>ID>JN�@ O<H=jH�?JN >JINOMPOJM@N

,<� @NO@DM<� ?< 0@QJGPigJ� 'I?PNOMD<G� <N H<LP@O@N� N@� M@NOMDIBDM<H� H<DN� <� O@NO@N

@NOMPOPM<DN��@QD?@I>D<I?J <NNDH J�?@N@HK@ICJ�?<�O@>IJGJBD<�?JN�H<O@MD<DN�I<�J=M<

�GBPIN�KMJE@OJN� AJM<H�O@NO<?JN H@?D<IO@�J�PNJ�?@�H<LP@O@N KMnSDH<N�aN�@N><G<N

I<OPM<DN��@S>GPDI?J�N@�<NNDH�JN >cG>PGJN�H<O@HcOD>JN

��DIO@IigJ�?@ 4G<?DHDM 2<OGDI AJD >MD<M PH�HJIPH@IOJ�LP@�M@KM@N@IO<NN@ PH<�IJQ<

JM?@H�NJ>D<G�I<�0sNND<�J�G@QJP�<�>MD<M�PH�HJ?@GJ�OMD?DH@INDJI<G��?@N>MDOJ�@H�PH<

BM<I?@� OJMM@� C@GD>JD?<G� DI>GDI<?< �� H<LP@O@� AJD� @HKM@@I?D?<� N@H� @N=JiJN

KM@GDHDI<M@N�@H�H@IJN�?@�JDOJ�H@N@N��K@MHDODI?J�<NNDHQ@MDAD><M <N�KJNND=DGD?<?@N

?@ @SKGJM<igJ�?JN�?@N@ICJN a�H@?D?<�LP@�@M<�>JINOMPl?< �ADB ���

$DBPM<������EP?<IO@N�?@�4G<?DHDM�2<OGDI�>JINOMJ@H�J�KMDH@DMJ�HJ?@GJ +JIPH@IOJ�?<�2@M>@DM<�,<>DJI<G������ �+<?@DM<N�PID?<N KJM�KG<><N�H@OcGD><N $JIO@��"3,,��,D>F �+<LP@O<N�?@��MLPDO@>OPM<��K ���

Page 110: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V78

-� Nj>PGJ� 66� M@QDQD<� J� DIl>DJ ?<� A<N@ ?JN�HJ?@GJN � 1gJ� @S@HKGJN� NJ=M@QDQ@IO@N JN

KMJ?PUD?JN <�K<MODM ?JN�K@MlJ?JN�LP@�<IO@>@?@M<H�<� N@BPI?<�BP@MM<�HPI?D<G�KJM

?DA@M@IO@N <MLPDO@OJN� O<DN�>JHJ� >JHJ #MD>�+@I?@GNJCI� +D@N Q<I ?@M 0JC@� %@MMDO

0D@OQ@G?��*@�!JM=PND@M�@�$M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO

� H<LP@O@� ?< 2JMM@ #DINO@DI� K<M<� J J=N@MQ<OnMDJ @ J DINODOPOJ <NOMJAlND>J� @MBPD?J

@H� .JNO@M?<H� �ADB � �� j� JPOMJ� @S@HKGJ �� OJMM@� <KM@N@IO<Q<� PH<

QDNgJ ?DIeHD>< ?J� JMB<IDNHJ <MLPDO@OoID>J � -� KMJE@OJ� N@� HJNOM<Q< M@G<ODQ<H@IO@

K@LP@IJ��H<N� QDBJMJN<H@IO@�HJ?@G<?J �� D?@D<� ?@�+@I?@GNJCI� @M<� NDH=JGDU<M� <

BM<I?@U<�?JN�>JI>@DOJN�?@�#DINO@DI��K@MH<I@>@I?J�PH�@?DAl>DJ�?@�<NK@>OJ�API>DJI<G

@H� N@P� DIO@MDJM=PN><I?J PH<KG<NOD>D?<?@� >JHKG@O<� @H� NP<� >JI>@KigJ�� I< <

>JINOMPigJ�N@H�eIBPGJN� H<N�>JH�><IOJN�M@?JI?JN

- HJ?@GJ�?J�<MM<IC<�>jP�$MD@?MD>CNOM<NN@ �ADB �����KJM�*P?RDB�+D@N�Q<I�?@M�0JC@�

@MGDI� @H� ����� AJD� @G<=JM<?J� I<� @N><G<� ?@� ����� @� ������ >C@BJP�N@� <� IlQ@DN� ?@

@NOP?JN @IOM@�J�HJ?@GJ�@�<� M@<GD?<?@ $JM<H�>JGJ><?JN�QD?MJN�IJN�HJ?@GJN��K<M<

Q@MDAD><M� J� LP@� <� @AD>DkI>D<� ?JN� M@AG@SJN � +D@N� @NO<Q< QJGO<?J� K<MOD>PG<MH@IO@� aN

DIsH@M<N�IP<I>@N @NK<>D<DN

$DBPM<���� +<LP@O@�?< 2JMM@ #DINO@DI @H.JON?<H������KJM #MD>�+@I?@GNJCI $JIO@� +--,��)<M@I �+J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N �K ���

$DBPM<���� +J?@GJ�?J��MM<IC<�>jP�$MD@?MD>CNOM<NN@��KJM*P?RDB�+D@N�Q<I�?@M�0JC@�� @MGDI������ $JIO@� COOK���@GJB@?@G<MO ><I<G=GJB >JH�O<B�&<EJ���0JN@@H����������

Page 111: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V79

*@� !JM=PND@M� @G@QJP� J� PNJ� ?@� H<LP@O@N� <J ,-�-., ?@� >JHKJI@IO@� DIO@BM<G� ?<

@?P><igJ� @� KMcOD><� @H� <MLPDO@OPM< �ADB � �� %M<I?@� <MLPDO@OJ� @� KG<I@E<?JM� ?J

Nj>PGJ� 66M@QJGP>DJIJP<� <MLPDO@OPM<� @� PM=<IDNHJ� HPI?D<G <J� KMJKJM� PH<� IJQ<

GDIBP<B@H� QDNP<G u KPMDNHJ u>JH� =<N@ I< NDHKGD>D?<?@� ?<� AJMH<�� JMB<IDU<igJ� @

?DN>DKGDI<

,< !<N<�1>Cq?@M� < @S@HKGDAD><igJ IJ�HJ?@GJ AJD�<�O@IO<ODQ<�?@ %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G? �ADB

�� @ �� ?@� KMJKJM>DJI<M� PH<� AJMH<� <MLPDO@OoID><� <N� D?@D<N� NJ=M@� J� @NK<iJ

@SKGJM<?J �-�KJIOJ ?@�K<MOD?<�@M<�PH�=GJ>J�>PEJN�KG<IJN�>JGJMD?JN N@�DIO@M><G<Q<H

>JHJ�K@i<N�DI?@K@I?@IO@N K<M<�MJHK@M�<�NJGD?@U�?J�QJGPH@

$DBPM<���� %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G?�>JH�J�HJ?@GJ�?< !<N<1>Cq?@M� &JG<I?<������ $JIO@��2'#8��(tMB@I��&DNOJMD<N�?<�<MLPDO@OPM< �@COOK���AJO@M >JH�KCJOJ�B@MMDO�MD@OQ@G?�N>CMJ?@M�CJPN@�KCTND><G�HJ?@G��@H�����������

$DBPM< ��� +J?@GJ�?< !<N<�1>Cq?@M� %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G?�&JG<I?<������ $JIO@��2'#8��(tMB@I��&DNOJMD<N�?<�<MLPDO@OPM< @COOK���AJO@M >JH�KCJOJ�B@MMDO�MD@OQ@G?�N>CMJ?@M�CJPN@�KCTND><G�HJ?@G��@H�����������

$DBPM<N���� 4DG<�1<QJT��������$M<Ii<� *@�!JM=PND@M $JIO@��COOK���RRR KC<D?JI >JH�<B@I?<�<M>CDO@>OPM@�<MOD>G@N������?@>@H=@M����JR@I�C<OC@MG@T�=G<NON�<M>CDO@>OPM<G�KCJOJBM<KCT��@H�����������

V79

*@� !JM=PND@M� @G@QJP� J� PNJ� ?@� H<LP@O@N� <J ,-�-., ?@� >JHKJI@IO@� DIO@BM<G� ?<

@?P><igJ� @� KMcOD><� @H� <MLPDO@OPM< �ADB � �� %M<I?@� <MLPDO@OJ� @� KG<I@E<?JM� ?J

Nj>PGJ� 66M@QJGP>DJIJP<� <MLPDO@OPM<� @� PM=<IDNHJ� HPI?D<G <J� KMJKJM� PH<� IJQ<

GDIBP<B@H� QDNP<G u KPMDNHJ u>JH� =<N@ I< NDHKGD>D?<?@� ?<� AJMH<�� JMB<IDU<igJ� @

?DN>DKGDI<

,< !<N<�1>Cq?@M� < @S@HKGDAD><igJ IJ�HJ?@GJ AJD�<�O@IO<ODQ<�?@ %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G? �ADB

�� @ �� ?@� KMJKJM>DJI<M� PH<� AJMH<� <MLPDO@OoID><� <N� D?@D<N� NJ=M@� J� @NK<iJ

@SKGJM<?J �-�KJIOJ ?@�K<MOD?<�@M<�PH�=GJ>J�>PEJN�KG<IJN�>JGJMD?JN N@�DIO@M><G<Q<H

>JHJ�K@i<N�DI?@K@I?@IO@N K<M<�MJHK@M�<�NJGD?@U�?J�QJGPH@

$DBPM<���� %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G?�>JH�J�HJ?@GJ�?< !<N<1>Cq?@M� &JG<I?<������ $JIO@��2'#8��(tMB@I��&DNOJMD<N�?<�<MLPDO@OPM< �@COOK���AJO@M >JH�KCJOJ�B@MMDO�MD@OQ@G?�N>CMJ?@M�CJPN@�KCTND><G�HJ?@G��@H�����������

$DBPM< ��� +J?@GJ�?< !<N<�1>Cq?@M� %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G?�&JG<I?<������ $JIO@��2'#8��(tMB@I��&DNOJMD<N�?<�<MLPDO@OPM< @COOK���AJO@M >JH�KCJOJ�B@MMDO�MD@OQ@G?�N>CMJ?@M�CJPN@�KCTND><G�HJ?@G��@H�����������

$DBPM<N���� 4DG<�1<QJT��������$M<Ii<� *@�!JM=PND@M $JIO@��COOK���RRR KC<D?JI >JH�<B@I?<�<M>CDO@>OPM@�<MOD>G@N������?@>@H=@M����JR@I�C<OC@MG@T�=G<NON�<M>CDO@>OPM<G�KCJOJBM<KCT��@H�����������

V79

*@� !JM=PND@M� @G@QJP� J� PNJ� ?@� H<LP@O@N� <J ,-�-., ?@� >JHKJI@IO@� DIO@BM<G� ?<

@?P><igJ� @� KMcOD><� @H� <MLPDO@OPM< �ADB � �� %M<I?@� <MLPDO@OJ� @� KG<I@E<?JM� ?J

Nj>PGJ� 66M@QJGP>DJIJP<� <MLPDO@OPM<� @� PM=<IDNHJ� HPI?D<G <J� KMJKJM� PH<� IJQ<

GDIBP<B@H� QDNP<G u KPMDNHJ u>JH� =<N@ I< NDHKGD>D?<?@� ?<� AJMH<�� JMB<IDU<igJ� @

?DN>DKGDI<

,< !<N<�1>Cq?@M� < @S@HKGDAD><igJ IJ�HJ?@GJ AJD�<�O@IO<ODQ<�?@ %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G? �ADB

�� @ �� ?@� KMJKJM>DJI<M� PH<� AJMH<� <MLPDO@OoID><� <N� D?@D<N� NJ=M@� J� @NK<iJ

@SKGJM<?J �-�KJIOJ ?@�K<MOD?<�@M<�PH�=GJ>J�>PEJN�KG<IJN�>JGJMD?JN N@�DIO@M><G<Q<H

>JHJ�K@i<N�DI?@K@I?@IO@N K<M<�MJHK@M�<�NJGD?@U�?J�QJGPH@

$DBPM<���� %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G?�>JH�J�HJ?@GJ�?< !<N<1>Cq?@M� &JG<I?<������ $JIO@��2'#8��(tMB@I��&DNOJMD<N�?<�<MLPDO@OPM< �@COOK���AJO@M >JH�KCJOJ�B@MMDO�MD@OQ@G?�N>CMJ?@M�CJPN@�KCTND><G�HJ?@G��@H�����������

$DBPM< ��� +J?@GJ�?< !<N<�1>Cq?@M� %@MMDO 0D@OQ@G?�&JG<I?<������ $JIO@��2'#8��(tMB@I��&DNOJMD<N�?<�<MLPDO@OPM< @COOK���AJO@M >JH�KCJOJ�B@MMDO�MD@OQ@G?�N>CMJ?@M�CJPN@�KCTND><G�HJ?@G��@H�����������

$DBPM<N���� 4DG<�1<QJT��������$M<Ii<� *@�!JM=PND@M $JIO@��COOK���RRR KC<D?JI >JH�<B@I?<�<M>CDO@>OPM@�<MOD>G@N������?@>@H=@M����JR@I�C<OC@MG@T�=G<NON�<M>CDO@>OPM<G�KCJOJBM<KCT��@H�����������

Page 112: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V80

� DID>D<ODQ<�?@� API?<igJ�?<�@N>JG< �."�., �><N<�?<� >JINOMPigJ�� @H�<G@HgJ�� @H

������OM<INAJMHJP�N@�IPH�HJQDH@IOJ�PIDAD><?JM�?<N�<MO@N�?@�O<G�DHKJMOeI>D<�LP@

@G<�NJ=M@K<NNJP�<�APIigJ�?@�LP<GLP@M�>@IOMJ�?@�@INDIJ�@IOgJ�QDB@IO@��OJMI<I?J�N@

PH<�M@A@MkI>D< HPI?D<G�?@QD?J�<J�N@P�>JI>@DOJ�DIJQ<?JM�@�Q<IBP<M?DNO< #H�����

N@�@NO<=@G@>@P�@H�"@NN<P �ADB ��� �PH<�>D?<?@ DI?PNOMD<G�<INDJN<�KJM�KJO@I>D<M�NP<

JA@MO< >PGOPM<G

5<GO@M�%MJKDPN��API?<?JM�?<� <PC<PN������������JKOJP�KJM�@SKGJM<M�JN�HJ?@GJN

K<M<� KMJQ<M� NP<N� D?@D<N� >JH� H<DN� M<KD?@U � �� K<MODM� ?@NO@� HJH@IOJ� <� H<LP@O@

QJGOJP�<�N@�DHKJM�>JHJ�A@MM<H@IO<�API?<H@IO<G�K<M<�J�?@N@ICJ�<MLPDO@OoID>J

�NNDH� @NO@N� HJ?@GJN� ?@� OM<=<GCJ� ?@N@HK@IC<MD<H� PH� DHKJMO<IO@� K<K@G� I<

>JI>@KigJ�@�M@QDNgJ�?@�DIsH@MJN�KMJE@OJN�?PM<IO@�<�@M<�HJ?@MI<

*P?RDB�+D@N�Q<I�?@M�0JC@ AJD�J�N@BPI?J�@�sGODHJ�?DM@OJM�?<� <PC<PN��PH�KJNOJ <J

LP<G 5<GO@M� %MJKDPN� M@IPI>DJP @H� M<UgJ ?<N� >JINO<IO@N� KM@NNp@NKJGlOD><N� @

O@nMD><N -�<MLPDO@OJ�PODGDU<Q< PH <I@SJ�?@ N@P�@N>MDOnMDJ�>JHJ�JAD>DI<��JI?@ @M<H

@G<=JM<?JN�HJ?@GJN OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� >JHJ <PSDGD<M@N @H�@NOP?JN�?@�H<O@MD<DN��<ADH

?@� <Q@MDBP<M� N@PN� KMJQcQ@DN� DHK<>OJN� I<� >JINOMPigJ +D@N� O<H=jH KMJ?PUD< <N

H<LP@O@N?<N <H<MM<ip@N� @NOMPOPM<DN� H@OcGD><N >JH� <� DIO@IigJ ?@� <I<GDN<M J

>JHKJMO<H@IOJ ?@�NP<N�J=M<N

$DBPM<����� <PC<PN�"@NN<P������ $JIO@� COOK���GD= C<DA< <> DG�>JGG@>ODJIN�<MO�HJ?@MI;<MO�<MODNON�B�BMJKDPN COHG�@H�����������

Page 113: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V81

�� ?@NK@DOJ� ?JN� O@HKJN� OPM=PG@IOJN� LP@� <� <PC<PN� QDQ@I>DJP� <J� ?@N<AD<M� >@MO<N

OM<?Dip@N��N@M�G@Q<?<�<�HP?<M�?@�>D?<?@��K<NN<M�KJM�?DQ@MBkI>D<N�KJGlOD><N�@�O@nMD><N

@�>PGHDI<M�>JH�N@P�A@>C<H@IOJ�IJ� DIl>DJ�?<�N@BPI?<�BP@MM<�HPI?D<G��@G<�@S@M>@P

PH<�AJMO@�DIAGPkI>D<�I<�KMJ?PigJ�NP=N@LP@IO@�?@�<MLPDO@OJN��@N>PGOJM@N��KDIOJM@N�@

?@N@ICDNO<N� DI?PNOMD<DN�� ?@DS<I?J� J=E@OJN� LP@� <DI?<� ><PN<H� <?HDM<igJ� @� NgJ

KMJO<BJIDNO<N ?@�IJNNJ�?D<�<�?D<��ADB ����@ ��

��DI?PNOMD<GDU<igJ�OM<INAJMHJP�JN�K<?Mp@N�?@�QD?<�@� G@QJP�a KMJGDA@M<igJ�?@�IJQJN

@?DAl>DJN�� @NO<ip@N� ?@� OM@H�� ><N<N� NP=PM=<I<N� @� <MM<IC<�>jPN K<M<� JN� LP<DN� IgJ

C<QD<� KM@>@?@IO@N � �N� >JMM@IO@N� ?@� K@IN<H@IOJ� <MLPDO@OoID>J� @NO<Q<H

KM@J>PK<?<N�>JH�<�KJNND=DGD?<?@�?@� N@� >MD<M� AJMH<N�LP@�IgJ� AJNN@H�K<NOD>C@N�?@

@NODGJN� K<NN<?JN�� H<N� @SKM@NNp@N� B@IPlI<N� ?J� KM@N@IO@ � �� IJigJ� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM<

HJ?@MI<�DHKGD><Q<�@H�PH<�NjMD@�?@ ?DA@M@IO@N�<ODOP?@N�LP<IOJ�a�BkI@N@�?<�AJMH<

#G@H@IOJN� M@K@ODODQJN� @� >JI@Sp@N� @NO<I?<M?DU<?<N� ><M<>O@MDU<Q<H� PH<

<KMJSDH<igJ� NDNO@HcOD><� ?J� ?@NDBI�� LP@� DHKGD><Q<� CD@M<MLPD<� I<� JMB<IDU<igJ� ?JN

>JHKJI@IO@N�H<DN�?J�LP@�AJMH<N�>JHKJNDODQ<N��ADB ��� �-�BM<I?@ ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ

?<N� DI?sNOMD<N ?@H<I?<Q<�?@ @NK<iJN�H<DN�<HKGJN�@�< KMJQ<�?@� AJBJ ���H<?@DM<�

K<PG<ODI<H@IO@ K<NN<Q< <�N@M NP=NODOPl?<�K@GJ�A@MMJ�I<�>JINOMPigJ�?@NN@N�B<GKp@N

#H�QcMDJN�K<lN@N�?<�#PMJK<�<�kIA<N@�I<�PODGDU<igJ�@�IJ�?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ�?J� A@MMJ

B@MJP PH<� NjMD@� ?@� OM<O<?JN� @� @NOP?JN� ?@?D><?JN� <� @NN@� ODKJ� ?@� H<O@MD<G �N

@NOMPOPM<N�AD><Q<H><?<�Q@U�H<DN�?@GD><?<N�@ OM<INK<M@IO@N .JM�@S@HKGJ��J�KMJE@OJ

$DBPM<�����-AD>DI<�?@�+D@N$JIO@��COOK���AJMHKDB >JH�=GJB���������HD@N�RJMFNCJK��@H����������

$DBPM<�����+D@N�OM<=<GC<I?J�@H�HJ?@GJN�>JH�(<H@N1K@T@M�@�"<IAJMOC�%@JMB@��IJ�'INODOPOJ�?@�2@>IJGJBD<�?@'GGDIJDN��!CD><BJ������ $JIO@��COOK���OC@M@?GDNO AM�RDFD�������������������������QD@R�B@MH<I�=<PC<PN �COHG@H�����������

Page 114: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V82

?<� Ac=MD><� (JCINJI� @SKGJM<Q< O@>IJGJBD<N� ?@� >JINOMPigJ� <Q<Ii<?<N� @� K<?Mp@N

B@JHjOMD>JN =@H�?@ADID?JN

���G@H<IC<�<KM@N@IO<Q< – <OM<QjN�?@�HJ?@GJN –<J�HPI?J�N@PN @S@HKGJN ?@�AJMi<�

KMJHJQ@I?J�KMJK<B<I?<N�I<UDNO<N��ADB �� @ ��

� 1@BPI?<�%P@MM<�+PI?D<G�?@P�PH�DHKPGNJ�<JN�HJ?@GJN�OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� K@GJ�A<OJ

?@�LP@ OJ?JN�JN�ODKJN�N@�A<UD<HPMB@IO@N�@�I@>@NNcMDJN�K<M<�ADIN�HDGDO<M@N��ADB ��� @

��

$DBPM<���� +PN@P ��.,���+���.-,�"�'�.',- �!<N<�?<��MO@�G@Hg ����������.<PG *P?RDB$JIO@��-15�*"��� �+<LP@O<N�?@��MLPDO@>OPM< �K ���

$DBPM<���� &DOG@M�DINK@>DJI<I?J PH<�H<LP@O@$JIO@��+--,��)<M@I +J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N �K ���

$DBPM<���� 1JG?<?JN�@NOP?<H�JHJ?@GJ >JHJ�@NOM<OjBD<$JIO@��COOK���NGD?@MPG@HPN@PH >JH�10;#KC@H@M< COH@H�����������

$DBPM<���� &DOG@M�DINK@>DJI<I?J�PH<�H<LP@O@$JIO@��COOK���RRR BP<M?D<I >J PF�=JJFN������EPI����CDOG@MN�=@MGDI�OCJH<N�AMD@?MD>C�M@QD@R@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJN�?<�$c=MD><�(JCINJI�������?@ $M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO $JIO@��COOK���RRR NO@DI@M<B >JH�AGR��MODA<>O���.<B@N�.CJOJ(5 COH�@�%0', #0%��(<DH@� ,-.�#(���%� ,)��#(� K �� @H�����������

V82

?<� Ac=MD><� (JCINJI� @SKGJM<Q< O@>IJGJBD<N� ?@� >JINOMPigJ� <Q<Ii<?<N� @� K<?Mp@N

B@JHjOMD>JN =@H�?@ADID?JN

���G@H<IC<�<KM@N@IO<Q< – <OM<QjN�?@�HJ?@GJN –<J�HPI?J�N@PN @S@HKGJN ?@�AJMi<�

KMJHJQ@I?J�KMJK<B<I?<N�I<UDNO<N��ADB �� @ ��

� 1@BPI?<�%P@MM<�+PI?D<G�?@P�PH�DHKPGNJ�<JN�HJ?@GJN�OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� K@GJ�A<OJ

?@�LP@ OJ?JN�JN�ODKJN�N@�A<UD<HPMB@IO@N�@�I@>@NNcMDJN�K<M<�ADIN�HDGDO<M@N��ADB ��� @

��

$DBPM<���� +PN@P ��.,���+���.-,�"�'�.',- �!<N<�?<��MO@�G@Hg ����������.<PG *P?RDB$JIO@��-15�*"��� �+<LP@O<N�?@��MLPDO@>OPM< �K ���

$DBPM<���� &DOG@M�DINK@>DJI<I?J PH<�H<LP@O@$JIO@��+--,��)<M@I +J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N �K ���

$DBPM<���� 1JG?<?JN�@NOP?<H�JHJ?@GJ >JHJ�@NOM<OjBD<$JIO@��COOK���NGD?@MPG@HPN@PH >JH�10;#KC@H@M< COH@H�����������

$DBPM<���� &DOG@M�DINK@>DJI<I?J�PH<�H<LP@O@$JIO@��COOK���RRR BP<M?D<I >J PF�=JJFN������EPI����CDOG@MN�=@MGDI�OCJH<N�AMD@?MD>C�M@QD@R@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJN�?<�$c=MD><�(JCINJI�������?@ $M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO $JIO@��COOK���RRR NO@DI@M<B >JH�AGR��MODA<>O���.<B@N�.CJOJ(5 COH�@�%0', #0%��(<DH@� ,-.�#(���%� ,)��#(� K �� @H�����������

V82

?<� Ac=MD><� (JCINJI� @SKGJM<Q< O@>IJGJBD<N� ?@� >JINOMPigJ� <Q<Ii<?<N� @� K<?Mp@N

B@JHjOMD>JN =@H�?@ADID?JN

���G@H<IC<�<KM@N@IO<Q< – <OM<QjN�?@�HJ?@GJN –<J�HPI?J�N@PN @S@HKGJN ?@�AJMi<�

KMJHJQ@I?J�KMJK<B<I?<N�I<UDNO<N��ADB �� @ ��

� 1@BPI?<�%P@MM<�+PI?D<G�?@P�PH�DHKPGNJ�<JN�HJ?@GJN�OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� K@GJ�A<OJ

?@�LP@ OJ?JN�JN�ODKJN�N@�A<UD<HPMB@IO@N�@�I@>@NNcMDJN�K<M<�ADIN�HDGDO<M@N��ADB ��� @

��

$DBPM<���� +PN@P ��.,���+���.-,�"�'�.',- �!<N<�?<��MO@�G@Hg ����������.<PG *P?RDB$JIO@��-15�*"��� �+<LP@O<N�?@��MLPDO@>OPM< �K ���

$DBPM<���� &DOG@M�DINK@>DJI<I?J PH<�H<LP@O@$JIO@��+--,��)<M@I +J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N �K ���

$DBPM<���� 1JG?<?JN�@NOP?<H�JHJ?@GJ >JHJ�@NOM<OjBD<$JIO@��COOK���NGD?@MPG@HPN@PH >JH�10;#KC@H@M< COH@H�����������

$DBPM<���� &DOG@M�DINK@>DJI<I?J�PH<�H<LP@O@$JIO@��COOK���RRR BP<M?D<I >J PF�=JJFN������EPI����CDOG@MN�=@MGDI�OCJH<N�AMD@?MD>C�M@QD@R@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+J?@GJN�?<�$c=MD><�(JCINJI�������?@ $M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO $JIO@��COOK���RRR NO@DI@M<B >JH�AGR��MODA<>O���.<B@N�.CJOJ(5 COH�@�%0', #0%��(<DH@� ,-.�#(���%� ,)��#(� K �� @H�����������

Page 115: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V83

�G=@MO�1K@@M�@G<=JMJP�KMJE@OJN�LP@�HJNOM<H <N�H<IDA@NO<ip@N�?@�KJ?@M�?J�.<MOD?J

@H� ,PM@H=@MB � -� KJIOJ� cPM@J ?<N� DIO@Iip@N� AJM<H� JN KMJE@OJN� K<M< @MGDH� <

><KDO<G�?J�'HKjMDJ �3H< BDB<IO@ @�OMDPIA<G <Q@ID?< GDB<Q<�< H<DJM @NO<igJ�?J HPI?J

<Oj�J�BM<I?@�<P?DOnMDJLP@ >JI?PU�<�>sKPG<�DHKJI@IO@� I<�LP<G M@DI<Q< PH<�cBPD<

I<UDNO<�>JH�J�BGJ=J�O@MM@NOM@�@IOM@�NP<N�B<MM<N �ADB ��

- �((& ?@�>JINOMPigJ�?J�KnN�BP@MM<�>JIOMD=PDP�K<M<�PH�<PH@IOJ�I<�<ODQD?<?@�?<

HJ?@G<B@H � �-� A@IoH@IJ�K<NNJP <�N@M�>JIND?@M<?J PH<�M@QJGPigJ� DID>D<I?J�N@<

=PN><�K<M<� <� >JHKM@@INgJ�?@NO@ M@I<N>DH@IOJ�@�J�@IO@I?DH@IOJ�?@� NP<�JMDB@H

�NNDH JN<MLPDO@OJN�@IAM@IO<M<H�<NI@>@NND?<?@N?@ K@M>@=@M<�>JIODIPD?<?@ @IOM@�<N

M@AJMH<N�?<�HJ?@MID?<?@��JN�?@N@ICJN�I<UDNO<N�@�<�M@>JINOMPigJ�KJNO@MDJM�<�����

&<IIN�"PNOH<II�OM<=<GCJP�>JH�%MJKDPN�IJN�<IJN �����@�>JH�1K@@M�IJN ������N@

DINKDMJP� I<� J=M< ?@� $MD@?@D>C%DGGT� K<M<� HJ?@G<M� @� KMJE@O<MN@PN HPN@PN� I<N

KMJKJMip@N�?< 0JH<�'HK@MD<G �ADB ����

$DBPM<���� +<LP@O@�?< ,JQ<� @MGDH���G@H<IC<� ���� $JIO@��COOK���RRR IT>�<M>CDO@>OPM@ >JH��0!&�,JO@N�$<N>DNO�%#0 COH�@%7+.#*��( �&DNOnMD<�?@�*<��MLPDO@>OPM<�?@�*<�IODBPD?<?@�<�IP@NOMJN�?D<N �K ��

Page 116: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V84

��HJ?@MID?<?@�<H@MD><I<�N@�A@U�KM@N@IO@ >JH�JN�QDNDJIcMDJN�?< #N>JG<�?@�!CD><BJ

LP@� @I>JIOM<M<H� PH<� >JIODIP<igJ ?@� N@PN� KMJKnNDOJN IJN #NO<?JN� 3ID?JN� ?<

�HjMD><��DI>GPDI?J�$M<IF *GJT? 5MDBOC �#NO@ <MLPDO@OJ C<QD<�?@NK@MO<?J�PH<�BM<I?@

<?HDM<igJ�AM@IO@�a�.MDH@DM<�%P@MM<�+PI?D<G� NJ=M@OP?J�BM<i<N�aN�y.M<DMD@CJPN@Nz�

@� NP<N� KG<IO<N� <=@MO<N � ,< ��%%#'!��-�+ u !<N<� ?<� !<N><O< u 5MDBOC� KMJE@OJP <

@?DAD><igJ� NJ=M@� PH<� ><N><O<�DINKDM<I?J�N@ IJN @NAJMiJN ?JN� DHDBM<IO@N LP@

>C@B<M<H�<JN�#NO<?JN�3ID?JN � 1<=@�N@�LP@ 5MDBOC ODIC<�JMDB@IN�HJ?@NO<N�� N@I?J

?@N>@I?@IO@� ?@� DHDBM<IO@N� B<G@N@N � 3ODGDUJP�� <GD�=GJ>JN� ?@� >JI>M@OJ GDNJN� @

<NN@IO<?JN� ?@� AJMH<� <NNDHjOMD><� @IOM@� JN� LP<DN AJM<H� >JGJ><?<N <N� E<I@G<N�

KMJKD>D<I?J� <NNDH� PH<� H<DJM� ?DA@M@I>D<igJ� I<N� K<MO@N� ?J� @?DAl>DJ � 0JHK@P� JN

>JIOJMIJN� ?J� >P=J� @� >JIOM<KoN� JN KG<IJN� CJMDUJIO<DN� @IOM@� @G@N � "@NN@� HJ?J�� <

<MLPDO@OPM<�@IAM@IO<�<�KJ?@MJN<�I<OPM@U<�@ N@�DHKp@�>JH�PH<�AJMi<�@G@H@IO<M �ADB

���

5“Prairie houses” Casas urbanas nos subúrbios de diversas cidades dos Estados Unidos da América. O nome reflete a característica de sua implantaçãohorizontal em grande área plana. Nos dez primeiros anos do século XX, Frank Lloyd Wright construiu mais de cem Prairie Houses. Eram casas parafamílias abastadas, situadas em áreas verdes, funcionais, com uma articulação volumétrica e uma sintaxe espacial muito própria. Geralmente com partidoem cruz ou duplo “T”, envolvendo a lareira – centro de força e ponto de cruzamento dos eixos imaginários. Apresentavam lajes com grandes balanços etelhados pouco inclinados. Fonte: Apostila da Disciplina de Teoria e História das Artes e Arquitetura do ano de 2009 da Universidade Federal deUberlândia.

$DBPM<N������ 4D>OJMD<�<M@<G�>JH�!<Aj�)M<IUG@M�@�GJE<�?@�?@K<MO<H@IOJN� DGF<��<MLPDO@OJ&<IIN�"PNOH<II���� $JIO@� COOK���KDOU�CJC ?@�DI?@S �KCK�GDIF�BPO<>CO@I�JM?@M�OC@H<�BD?���COOK���RRR G<PAR@MF�= ?@�RD@?@M<PA=<P���;FG<NNDF@M;KJKPK� DGF<� DGF<� COHG@H�����������

Page 117: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V85

��J=M<�?@�$M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBOC AJD�O<H=jH H<M><?<�KJM�BM<I?@�DIAGPkI>D<�?JN�=GJ>JN

?@�$M@?@MD>F�$MJ@=@G ,<�NP<�DIAeI>D<��NP<�Hg@��II<�5MDBCO��@H�QDNDO<�a�$DG<?jGAD<�

>JHKMJP�GC@ PH� EJBJ�?@�=GJ>JN� =MDILP@?J�@NO@ LP@ J <KMJSDHJP�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<

,<LP@G<� jKJ><� JN� =GJ>JN� ?@�H<?@DM<� @M<H� Q@I?D?JN� >JH� DINOMPip@N� ?@� PNJ� LP@

OM<INHDOD<H� OJ?<� <� ADGJNJAD<� K@?<BnBD><� ?@� $MJ@=@G � .<M<� <KM@I?@M� <� H<IPN@c�

GJNKMJQ@DOJN<H@IO@���II<�5MDBCO�AJD�a JNOJI�OJH<M�GDip@N�NJ=M@�@NN<�ADGJNJAD<�K<M<

=MDI><M�>JH�JN�N@PN�ADGCJN�<KnN�<N�O<M@A<N�?JHjNOD><N �5MDBCO�>JH@iJP�<�@S@M>DO<M

NP<�DH<BDI<igJ�<J HJIO<M�>JIEPIOJN�?@�?DA@M@IO@N�AJMH<OJN >JH <LP@G<N�K@i<N �ADB

��� y3H�K@LP@IJ�HPI?J�DIO@MDJM�?@�>JM�@�AJMH<�Q@DJ�<KJ?@M<M�N@�?JN�K@LP@IJN

?@?JN � !JM� @� K<?Mp@N�� IJ� KG<IJ� @� IJ� >JIOJMIJ � $JMH<N� @N>JI?D?<N� <OMcN� ?<

<K<MkI>D<�?@�OJ?<N�@G<N z �50'%&2������� K ��

-N� <MLPDO@OJN� HJ?@MIDNO<N�� >JHJ� JN� <MODNO<N�� M@>PN<Q<H� J� @>G@OD>DNHJ� CDNOnMD>J

><MM@B<?J� ?@� AJMH<N� ?@NKD?<N� ?@� NDBIDAD><?J� @� KMJKPIC<H�PH<� <MLPDO@OPM<�H<DN

API>DJI<G�I<�IJQ<�NJ>D@?<?@�HJ?@MI< ��N�>D?<?@N�IJN�#NO<?JN�3ID?JN�IgJ�ODIC<H

JN� KMJ=G@H<N�@PMJK@PN�� <N� BM<I?@N� ?DH@INp@N�?J� >JIODI@IO@�IJMO@�<H@MD><IJ� N@

OM<?PUDM<H� O<H=jH� @H� BM<I?@N� @NK<iJN� K<M<� <N� @?DAD><ip@N�� K<M<� JN� <H=D@IO@N

PM=<IJN�@�@?DAl>DJN�JI?@�<�NJ>D@?<?@�N@�JMB<IDU<Q<�?@�<>JM?J�aN�APIip@N�@NK<>D<DN

.<M<�5MDBCO�JN�<MM<IC<�>jPN�@M<H�<�@SKM@NNgJ�?J�KJ?@M�KJGlOD>J�@�<>M@?DO<Q<�LP@

I<��HjMD><�<�<MLPDO@OPM<�?@QD<�N@M�GDQM@�?@�@NODGJN�CDNOnMD>JN

$DBPM<����� =GJ>JN�?@�$M@?@MD>F�$MJ@=@G$JIO@��COOK���@?R<M?GDANJI =GJBNKJO >JH =M���������<M>CDO@>OPM@�KM@N@ION�AJM�TJPM�FD?N COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<����� ��%%#'!��-�+

$JIO@�COOK���<MOD>G@ RI >JH�QD@R������������2C@;H<E@NOT;JA;$M<IF;

*GJT?;5MDBCON;$<GGDIBR<O@M;KCJOJN�@H�����������

V85

��J=M<�?@�$M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBOC AJD�O<H=jH H<M><?<�KJM�BM<I?@�DIAGPkI>D<�?JN�=GJ>JN

?@�$M@?@MD>F�$MJ@=@G ,<�NP<�DIAeI>D<��NP<�Hg@��II<�5MDBCO��@H�QDNDO<�a�$DG<?jGAD<�

>JHKMJP�GC@ PH� EJBJ�?@�=GJ>JN� =MDILP@?J�@NO@ LP@ J <KMJSDHJP�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<

,<LP@G<� jKJ><� JN� =GJ>JN� ?@�H<?@DM<� @M<H� Q@I?D?JN� >JH� DINOMPip@N� ?@� PNJ� LP@

OM<INHDOD<H� OJ?<� <� ADGJNJAD<� K@?<BnBD><� ?@� $MJ@=@G � .<M<� <KM@I?@M� <� H<IPN@c�

GJNKMJQ@DOJN<H@IO@���II<�5MDBCO�AJD�a JNOJI�OJH<M�GDip@N�NJ=M@�@NN<�ADGJNJAD<�K<M<

=MDI><M�>JH�JN�N@PN�ADGCJN�<KnN�<N�O<M@A<N�?JHjNOD><N �5MDBCO�>JH@iJP�<�@S@M>DO<M

NP<�DH<BDI<igJ�<J HJIO<M�>JIEPIOJN�?@�?DA@M@IO@N�AJMH<OJN >JH <LP@G<N�K@i<N �ADB

��� y3H�K@LP@IJ�HPI?J�DIO@MDJM�?@�>JM�@�AJMH<�Q@DJ�<KJ?@M<M�N@�?JN�K@LP@IJN

?@?JN � !JM� @� K<?Mp@N�� IJ� KG<IJ� @� IJ� >JIOJMIJ � $JMH<N� @N>JI?D?<N� <OMcN� ?<

<K<MkI>D<�?@�OJ?<N�@G<N z �50'%&2������� K ��

-N� <MLPDO@OJN� HJ?@MIDNO<N�� >JHJ� JN� <MODNO<N�� M@>PN<Q<H� J� @>G@OD>DNHJ� CDNOnMD>J

><MM@B<?J� ?@� AJMH<N� ?@NKD?<N� ?@� NDBIDAD><?J� @� KMJKPIC<H�PH<� <MLPDO@OPM<�H<DN

API>DJI<G�I<�IJQ<�NJ>D@?<?@�HJ?@MI< ��N�>D?<?@N�IJN�#NO<?JN�3ID?JN�IgJ�ODIC<H

JN� KMJ=G@H<N�@PMJK@PN�� <N� BM<I?@N� ?DH@INp@N�?J� >JIODI@IO@�IJMO@�<H@MD><IJ� N@

OM<?PUDM<H� O<H=jH� @H� BM<I?@N� @NK<iJN� K<M<� <N� @?DAD><ip@N�� K<M<� JN� <H=D@IO@N

PM=<IJN�@�@?DAl>DJN�JI?@�<�NJ>D@?<?@�N@�JMB<IDU<Q<�?@�<>JM?J�aN�APIip@N�@NK<>D<DN

.<M<�5MDBCO�JN�<MM<IC<�>jPN�@M<H�<�@SKM@NNgJ�?J�KJ?@M�KJGlOD>J�@�<>M@?DO<Q<�LP@

I<��HjMD><�<�<MLPDO@OPM<�?@QD<�N@M�GDQM@�?@�@NODGJN�CDNOnMD>JN

$DBPM<����� =GJ>JN�?@�$M@?@MD>F�$MJ@=@G$JIO@��COOK���@?R<M?GDANJI =GJBNKJO >JH =M���������<M>CDO@>OPM@�KM@N@ION�AJM�TJPM�FD?N COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<����� ��%%#'!��-�+

$JIO@�COOK���<MOD>G@ RI >JH�QD@R������������2C@;H<E@NOT;JA;$M<IF;

*GJT?;5MDBCON;$<GGDIBR<O@M;KCJOJN�@H�����������

V85

��J=M<�?@�$M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBOC AJD�O<H=jH H<M><?<�KJM�BM<I?@�DIAGPkI>D<�?JN�=GJ>JN

?@�$M@?@MD>F�$MJ@=@G ,<�NP<�DIAeI>D<��NP<�Hg@��II<�5MDBCO��@H�QDNDO<�a�$DG<?jGAD<�

>JHKMJP�GC@ PH� EJBJ�?@�=GJ>JN� =MDILP@?J�@NO@ LP@ J <KMJSDHJP�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<

,<LP@G<� jKJ><� JN� =GJ>JN� ?@�H<?@DM<� @M<H� Q@I?D?JN� >JH� DINOMPip@N� ?@� PNJ� LP@

OM<INHDOD<H� OJ?<� <� ADGJNJAD<� K@?<BnBD><� ?@� $MJ@=@G � .<M<� <KM@I?@M� <� H<IPN@c�

GJNKMJQ@DOJN<H@IO@���II<�5MDBCO�AJD�a JNOJI�OJH<M�GDip@N�NJ=M@�@NN<�ADGJNJAD<�K<M<

=MDI><M�>JH�JN�N@PN�ADGCJN�<KnN�<N�O<M@A<N�?JHjNOD><N �5MDBCO�>JH@iJP�<�@S@M>DO<M

NP<�DH<BDI<igJ�<J HJIO<M�>JIEPIOJN�?@�?DA@M@IO@N�AJMH<OJN >JH <LP@G<N�K@i<N �ADB

��� y3H�K@LP@IJ�HPI?J�DIO@MDJM�?@�>JM�@�AJMH<�Q@DJ�<KJ?@M<M�N@�?JN�K@LP@IJN

?@?JN � !JM� @� K<?Mp@N�� IJ� KG<IJ� @� IJ� >JIOJMIJ � $JMH<N� @N>JI?D?<N� <OMcN� ?<

<K<MkI>D<�?@�OJ?<N�@G<N z �50'%&2������� K ��

-N� <MLPDO@OJN� HJ?@MIDNO<N�� >JHJ� JN� <MODNO<N�� M@>PN<Q<H� J� @>G@OD>DNHJ� CDNOnMD>J

><MM@B<?J� ?@� AJMH<N� ?@NKD?<N� ?@� NDBIDAD><?J� @� KMJKPIC<H�PH<� <MLPDO@OPM<�H<DN

API>DJI<G�I<�IJQ<�NJ>D@?<?@�HJ?@MI< ��N�>D?<?@N�IJN�#NO<?JN�3ID?JN�IgJ�ODIC<H

JN� KMJ=G@H<N�@PMJK@PN�� <N� BM<I?@N� ?DH@INp@N�?J� >JIODI@IO@�IJMO@�<H@MD><IJ� N@

OM<?PUDM<H� O<H=jH� @H� BM<I?@N� @NK<iJN� K<M<� <N� @?DAD><ip@N�� K<M<� JN� <H=D@IO@N

PM=<IJN�@�@?DAl>DJN�JI?@�<�NJ>D@?<?@�N@�JMB<IDU<Q<�?@�<>JM?J�aN�APIip@N�@NK<>D<DN

.<M<�5MDBCO�JN�<MM<IC<�>jPN�@M<H�<�@SKM@NNgJ�?J�KJ?@M�KJGlOD>J�@�<>M@?DO<Q<�LP@

I<��HjMD><�<�<MLPDO@OPM<�?@QD<�N@M�GDQM@�?@�@NODGJN�CDNOnMD>JN

$DBPM<����� =GJ>JN�?@�$M@?@MD>F�$MJ@=@G$JIO@��COOK���@?R<M?GDANJI =GJBNKJO >JH =M���������<M>CDO@>OPM@�KM@N@ION�AJM�TJPM�FD?N COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<����� ��%%#'!��-�+

$JIO@�COOK���<MOD>G@ RI >JH�QD@R������������2C@;H<E@NOT;JA;$M<IF;

*GJT?;5MDBCON;$<GGDIBR<O@M;KCJOJN�@H�����������

Page 118: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V86

"PM<IO@�<�?j><?<�?@�������J�+J?@MIDNHJ�?@P�>JMKJ�a�AJMH<�KJM H@DJ�?@�KMJE@OJN

HDIDH<GDNO<N !JH� @NN<� <GO@M<igJ�� <GjH� ?@� AJMI@>@M� PH�H@DJ� ?@� QDNP<GDU<igJ� ?<N

@N><G<N� @� ?<N�H<NN<N�� J� K<K@G� ?JN�HJ?@GJN� NJAM@P� <GO@M<ip@N -� D?@IODAD><?JM� ?J

KMDI>DK<G�A<OJM� LP@�DIAGP@I>DJP< @SKGJNgJ�?@�IJQJN ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJN ?JN�HJ?@GJN�

AJD�<�HP?<Ii< IJ @NODGJ�<MLPDO@OoID>J�@�JN�<Q<IiJN�I<N�Oj>ID><N�>JINOMPODQ<N

,@NO@� H@NHJ� K@MlJ?J� #@MJ 1<<MDI@I OM<=<GCJP MJODI@DM<H@IO@� >JH� HJ?@GJN�

K<NN<I?J� <J� GJIBJ� ?@NO<� A<N@�� OJ?J J N@P� @IOPND<NHJ� K<M<� HPDOJN� EJQ@IN

<MLPDO@OJN?@� N@P� @N>MDOnMDJ�� DI>GPDI?J !@N<M� .@GGD� @� )@QDI� 0J>C@� LP@ ?gJ

>JIODIPD?<?@�<J�HjOJ?J�KMJE@OP<G��ADB ���� @ ���

$DBPM<������$M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO @�N@P�HJ?@GJ�@H�H<?@DM< $JIO@� COOK���B<GG@MDNOIT >JH���������HJH<�<I?�>JGPH=D<�<>LPDM@�OC@�<M>CDQ@N�JA�AM<IF�GGJT?�RMDBCO�AJM�K@MH<I@IO�>JGG@>ODJIN� @H�����������

$DBPM<����� #@MJ�1<<MDI@I� H<LP@O@�?J�2@MHDI<G�25� #@MJ1<<MDI@I�a�?DM@DO<��>JH!@N<M.@GGD�0J>C@)@QDI�@JPOMJN�<MLPDO@OJN $JIO@�COOK���<MOC<B OTK@K<? >JH�<MOC<B���������@@MJ�N<<MDI@I�HPN@PH�JA�OC@�>DOT�JA�I@R�TJMF COHG�@H����������

$DBPM<����� #@MJ�1<<MDI@I @�<NQ@MDAD><ip@N�@NOMPOPM<DN $JIO@�COOK���@I RDFDK@?D< JMB�RDFD�%<O@R<T;�M>C

V86

"PM<IO@�<�?j><?<�?@�������J�+J?@MIDNHJ�?@P�>JMKJ�a�AJMH<�KJM H@DJ�?@�KMJE@OJN

HDIDH<GDNO<N !JH� @NN<� <GO@M<igJ�� <GjH� ?@� AJMI@>@M� PH�H@DJ� ?@� QDNP<GDU<igJ� ?<N

@N><G<N� @� ?<N�H<NN<N�� J� K<K@G� ?JN�HJ?@GJN� NJAM@P� <GO@M<ip@N -� D?@IODAD><?JM� ?J

KMDI>DK<G�A<OJM� LP@�DIAGP@I>DJP< @SKGJNgJ�?@�IJQJN ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJN ?JN�HJ?@GJN�

AJD�<�HP?<Ii< IJ @NODGJ�<MLPDO@OoID>J�@�JN�<Q<IiJN�I<N�Oj>ID><N�>JINOMPODQ<N

,@NO@� H@NHJ� K@MlJ?J� #@MJ 1<<MDI@I OM<=<GCJP MJODI@DM<H@IO@� >JH� HJ?@GJN�

K<NN<I?J� <J� GJIBJ� ?@NO<� A<N@�� OJ?J J N@P� @IOPND<NHJ� K<M<� HPDOJN� EJQ@IN

<MLPDO@OJN?@� N@P� @N>MDOnMDJ�� DI>GPDI?J !@N<M� .@GGD� @� )@QDI� 0J>C@� LP@ ?gJ

>JIODIPD?<?@�<J�HjOJ?J�KMJE@OP<G��ADB ���� @ ���

$DBPM<������$M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO @�N@P�HJ?@GJ�@H�H<?@DM< $JIO@� COOK���B<GG@MDNOIT >JH���������HJH<�<I?�>JGPH=D<�<>LPDM@�OC@�<M>CDQ@N�JA�AM<IF�GGJT?�RMDBCO�AJM�K@MH<I@IO�>JGG@>ODJIN� @H�����������

$DBPM<����� #@MJ�1<<MDI@I� H<LP@O@�?J�2@MHDI<G�25� #@MJ1<<MDI@I�a�?DM@DO<��>JH!@N<M.@GGD�0J>C@)@QDI�@JPOMJN�<MLPDO@OJN $JIO@�COOK���<MOC<B OTK@K<? >JH�<MOC<B���������@@MJ�N<<MDI@I�HPN@PH�JA�OC@�>DOT�JA�I@R�TJMF COHG�@H����������

$DBPM<����� #@MJ�1<<MDI@I @�<NQ@MDAD><ip@N�@NOMPOPM<DN $JIO@�COOK���@I RDFDK@?D< JMB�RDFD�%<O@R<T;�M>C

V86

"PM<IO@�<�?j><?<�?@�������J�+J?@MIDNHJ�?@P�>JMKJ�a�AJMH<�KJM H@DJ�?@�KMJE@OJN

HDIDH<GDNO<N !JH� @NN<� <GO@M<igJ�� <GjH� ?@� AJMI@>@M� PH�H@DJ� ?@� QDNP<GDU<igJ� ?<N

@N><G<N� @� ?<N�H<NN<N�� J� K<K@G� ?JN�HJ?@GJN� NJAM@P� <GO@M<ip@N -� D?@IODAD><?JM� ?J

KMDI>DK<G�A<OJM� LP@�DIAGP@I>DJP< @SKGJNgJ�?@�IJQJN ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJN ?JN�HJ?@GJN�

AJD�<�HP?<Ii< IJ @NODGJ�<MLPDO@OoID>J�@�JN�<Q<IiJN�I<N�Oj>ID><N�>JINOMPODQ<N

,@NO@� H@NHJ� K@MlJ?J� #@MJ 1<<MDI@I OM<=<GCJP MJODI@DM<H@IO@� >JH� HJ?@GJN�

K<NN<I?J� <J� GJIBJ� ?@NO<� A<N@�� OJ?J J N@P� @IOPND<NHJ� K<M<� HPDOJN� EJQ@IN

<MLPDO@OJN?@� N@P� @N>MDOnMDJ�� DI>GPDI?J !@N<M� .@GGD� @� )@QDI� 0J>C@� LP@ ?gJ

>JIODIPD?<?@�<J�HjOJ?J�KMJE@OP<G��ADB ���� @ ���

$DBPM<������$M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO @�N@P�HJ?@GJ�@H�H<?@DM< $JIO@� COOK���B<GG@MDNOIT >JH���������HJH<�<I?�>JGPH=D<�<>LPDM@�OC@�<M>CDQ@N�JA�AM<IF�GGJT?�RMDBCO�AJM�K@MH<I@IO�>JGG@>ODJIN� @H�����������

$DBPM<����� #@MJ�1<<MDI@I� H<LP@O@�?J�2@MHDI<G�25� #@MJ1<<MDI@I�a�?DM@DO<��>JH!@N<M.@GGD�0J>C@)@QDI�@JPOMJN�<MLPDO@OJN $JIO@�COOK���<MOC<B OTK@K<? >JH�<MOC<B���������@@MJ�N<<MDI@I�HPN@PH�JA�OC@�>DOT�JA�I@R�TJMF COHG�@H����������

$DBPM<����� #@MJ�1<<MDI@I @�<NQ@MDAD><ip@N�@NOMPOPM<DN $JIO@�COOK���@I RDFDK@?D< JMB�RDFD�%<O@R<T;�M>C

Page 119: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V87

-� OMDPIAJ� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<� HJ?@MI<� <KJMOJP I<� N@BPI?<� H@O<?@� ?J� Nj>PGJ� SS -

D?@IODAD><?JM� ?J� KMDI>DK<G� A<OJM� LP@� DIAGP@I>DJP� <� @SKGJNgJ� ?@� M@?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ

?JN� HJ?@GJN AJD <HP?<Ii< ?@ @NODGJ� <MLPDO@OoID>J� @� JN� <Q<IiJN� I<N� Oj>ID><N

>JINOMPODQ<N ��N�AJMH<N�JMBeID><N��JN>DG<IO@N�@�NPNK@IN<N K<NN<M<H�< N@�<KM@N@IO<H

>MD<I?J PH<� <MLPDO@OPM<� @N>PGOPM<G �N� @SK@MDkI>D<N� Q@MDAD><?<N� I<N� API?<ip@N� ?@

>D?<?@N�IJQ<N @H�?DA@M@IO@N�KJIOJN�?J�KG<I@O<� >JHJ M<NlGD< �IJ� M<NDG �ADB ���� @

!C<?DB<MC� �I<� ]I?D<�ADB � ���� N@� >JIQ@MO@M<H� @H� @SKM@NNp@N� ?@� GD=@M?<?@� @

?@HJ>M<>D< 1J=� O<DN� =<I?@DM<N� <N� AJMH<N� JMBeID><N�� LP@� NDH=JGDU<Q<H� PH

?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� GDQM@� BM<i<N� a >PMQ<OPM<� @� <NNDH@OMD<�� >JIODIP<M<H� QDB@IO@N� I<

<MLPDO@OPM<�KnN�BP@MM<

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?@� M<NlGD< 'NM<@G�.DIC@DMJ� KM@ND?@IO@�?< ,-4�!�.��*P>DJ !JNO<��-N><M ,D@H@T@M�@�()$JIO@� COOK���Q@E< <=MDG >JH =M��������K;��� COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?J .<Gc>DJ�?<��NN@H=GjD<�*@BDNG<ODQ<�?@�!C<I?DB<MC��������� �*@�!JM=PND@M$JIO@�%0', #0%��( �#NOP?DJN ?@G #NK<>DJ K ��

V87

-� OMDPIAJ� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<� HJ?@MI<� <KJMOJP I<� N@BPI?<� H@O<?@� ?J� Nj>PGJ� SS -

D?@IODAD><?JM� ?J� KMDI>DK<G� A<OJM� LP@� DIAGP@I>DJP� <� @SKGJNgJ� ?@� M@?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ

?JN� HJ?@GJN AJD <HP?<Ii< ?@ @NODGJ� <MLPDO@OoID>J� @� JN� <Q<IiJN� I<N� Oj>ID><N

>JINOMPODQ<N ��N�AJMH<N�JMBeID><N��JN>DG<IO@N�@�NPNK@IN<N K<NN<M<H�< N@�<KM@N@IO<H

>MD<I?J PH<� <MLPDO@OPM<� @N>PGOPM<G �N� @SK@MDkI>D<N� Q@MDAD><?<N� I<N� API?<ip@N� ?@

>D?<?@N�IJQ<N @H�?DA@M@IO@N�KJIOJN�?J�KG<I@O<� >JHJ M<NlGD< �IJ� M<NDG �ADB ���� @

!C<?DB<MC� �I<� ]I?D<�ADB � ���� N@� >JIQ@MO@M<H� @H� @SKM@NNp@N� ?@� GD=@M?<?@� @

?@HJ>M<>D< 1J=� O<DN� =<I?@DM<N� <N� AJMH<N� JMBeID><N�� LP@� NDH=JGDU<Q<H� PH

?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� GDQM@� BM<i<N� a >PMQ<OPM<� @� <NNDH@OMD<�� >JIODIP<M<H� QDB@IO@N� I<

<MLPDO@OPM<�KnN�BP@MM<

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?@� M<NlGD< 'NM<@G�.DIC@DMJ� KM@ND?@IO@�?< ,-4�!�.��*P>DJ !JNO<��-N><M ,D@H@T@M�@�()$JIO@� COOK���Q@E< <=MDG >JH =M��������K;��� COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?J .<Gc>DJ�?<��NN@H=GjD<�*@BDNG<ODQ<�?@�!C<I?DB<MC��������� �*@�!JM=PND@M$JIO@�%0', #0%��( �#NOP?DJN ?@G #NK<>DJ K ��

V87

-� OMDPIAJ� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<� HJ?@MI<� <KJMOJP I<� N@BPI?<� H@O<?@� ?J� Nj>PGJ� SS -

D?@IODAD><?JM� ?J� KMDI>DK<G� A<OJM� LP@� DIAGP@I>DJP� <� @SKGJNgJ� ?@� M@?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ

?JN� HJ?@GJN AJD <HP?<Ii< ?@ @NODGJ� <MLPDO@OoID>J� @� JN� <Q<IiJN� I<N� Oj>ID><N

>JINOMPODQ<N ��N�AJMH<N�JMBeID><N��JN>DG<IO@N�@�NPNK@IN<N K<NN<M<H�< N@�<KM@N@IO<H

>MD<I?J PH<� <MLPDO@OPM<� @N>PGOPM<G �N� @SK@MDkI>D<N� Q@MDAD><?<N� I<N� API?<ip@N� ?@

>D?<?@N�IJQ<N @H�?DA@M@IO@N�KJIOJN�?J�KG<I@O<� >JHJ M<NlGD< �IJ� M<NDG �ADB ���� @

!C<?DB<MC� �I<� ]I?D<�ADB � ���� N@� >JIQ@MO@M<H� @H� @SKM@NNp@N� ?@� GD=@M?<?@� @

?@HJ>M<>D< 1J=� O<DN� =<I?@DM<N� <N� AJMH<N� JMBeID><N�� LP@� NDH=JGDU<Q<H� PH

?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� GDQM@� BM<i<N� a >PMQ<OPM<� @� <NNDH@OMD<�� >JIODIP<M<H� QDB@IO@N� I<

<MLPDO@OPM<�KnN�BP@MM<

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?@� M<NlGD< 'NM<@G�.DIC@DMJ� KM@ND?@IO@�?< ,-4�!�.��*P>DJ !JNO<��-N><M ,D@H@T@M�@�()$JIO@� COOK���Q@E< <=MDG >JH =M��������K;��� COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?J .<Gc>DJ�?<��NN@H=GjD<�*@BDNG<ODQ<�?@�!C<I?DB<MC��������� �*@�!JM=PND@M$JIO@�%0', #0%��( �#NOP?DJN ?@G #NK<>DJ K ��

Page 120: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V88

$DU@M<H� K<MO@� ?@NN@� HJQDH@IOJ�� @IOM@� JPOMJN�� JN� <MLPDO@OJN� @� NP<N� J=M<N�

?@NO<><?JN�<�N@BPDM

,JN� <IJN� �� *@� !JM=PND@M� 'BM@E<� ?@� 0JI>C<HK�� ������� �ADB � ��� @� 'BM@E<� 1<DIO

.D@MM@��$DMHDIT������ �ADB �����

-N><M ,D@H@T@M��!<N<�?<N�!<IJ<N������ �ADB �����

-N><M�,D@H@T@M� .<Gc>DJ��GQJM<?<����� �ADB ���� @ �ADB ����

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�,JOM@ "<H@�?@�&<PO�0JI>C<HK��*@ !JM=PND@M $JIO@� $JOJ�?<��POJM<

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�1<DIO�.D@MM@�$DMHDI��*@�!JM=PND@M $JIO@� <MLQ<> OPH=GM >JH@H�����������

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�!<N<�?<N�!<IJ<N��������-N><M,D@H@T@M $JIO@��COOK���RRR AGD>FM >JH�KCJOJN�OC><HKA@MM�K<B@�� @H����������

$DBPM<�����@������-N><M�,D@H@T@M�J=N@MQ<�<�H<LP@O@�?J�.<Gc>DJ��GQJM<?<����� $JIO@��COOK���RRR @H >JH =M�<KK�IJOD>D<�@NK@>D<DN�JN><M�ID@H@T@M������������DIO@MI<N;JN><M;ID@H@T@M��������><KDO<G�?J�KMJBM@NNJ N�@H����������COOK���=MPIJH<SR@G RJM?KM@NN >JH�K<B@����@H�����������

V88

$DU@M<H� K<MO@� ?@NN@� HJQDH@IOJ�� @IOM@� JPOMJN�� JN� <MLPDO@OJN� @� NP<N� J=M<N�

?@NO<><?JN�<�N@BPDM

,JN� <IJN� �� *@� !JM=PND@M� 'BM@E<� ?@� 0JI>C<HK�� ������� �ADB � ��� @� 'BM@E<� 1<DIO

.D@MM@��$DMHDIT������ �ADB �����

-N><M ,D@H@T@M��!<N<�?<N�!<IJ<N������ �ADB �����

-N><M�,D@H@T@M� .<Gc>DJ��GQJM<?<����� �ADB ���� @ �ADB ����

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�,JOM@ "<H@�?@�&<PO�0JI>C<HK��*@ !JM=PND@M $JIO@� $JOJ�?<��POJM<

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�1<DIO�.D@MM@�$DMHDI��*@�!JM=PND@M $JIO@� <MLQ<> OPH=GM >JH@H�����������

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�!<N<�?<N�!<IJ<N��������-N><M,D@H@T@M $JIO@��COOK���RRR AGD>FM >JH�KCJOJN�OC><HKA@MM�K<B@�� @H����������

$DBPM<�����@������-N><M�,D@H@T@M�J=N@MQ<�<�H<LP@O@�?J�.<Gc>DJ��GQJM<?<����� $JIO@��COOK���RRR @H >JH =M�<KK�IJOD>D<�@NK@>D<DN�JN><M�ID@H@T@M������������DIO@MI<N;JN><M;ID@H@T@M��������><KDO<G�?J�KMJBM@NNJ N�@H����������COOK���=MPIJH<SR@G RJM?KM@NN >JH�K<B@����@H�����������

V88

$DU@M<H� K<MO@� ?@NN@� HJQDH@IOJ�� @IOM@� JPOMJN�� JN� <MLPDO@OJN� @� NP<N� J=M<N�

?@NO<><?JN�<�N@BPDM

,JN� <IJN� �� *@� !JM=PND@M� 'BM@E<� ?@� 0JI>C<HK�� ������� �ADB � ��� @� 'BM@E<� 1<DIO

.D@MM@��$DMHDIT������ �ADB �����

-N><M ,D@H@T@M��!<N<�?<N�!<IJ<N������ �ADB �����

-N><M�,D@H@T@M� .<Gc>DJ��GQJM<?<����� �ADB ���� @ �ADB ����

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�,JOM@ "<H@�?@�&<PO�0JI>C<HK��*@ !JM=PND@M $JIO@� $JOJ�?<��POJM<

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�'BM@E<�1<DIO�.D@MM@�$DMHDI��*@�!JM=PND@M $JIO@� <MLQ<> OPH=GM >JH@H�����������

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<�!<N<�?<N�!<IJ<N��������-N><M,D@H@T@M $JIO@��COOK���RRR AGD>FM >JH�KCJOJN�OC><HKA@MM�K<B@�� @H����������

$DBPM<�����@������-N><M�,D@H@T@M�J=N@MQ<�<�H<LP@O@�?J�.<Gc>DJ��GQJM<?<����� $JIO@��COOK���RRR @H >JH =M�<KK�IJOD>D<�@NK@>D<DN�JN><M�ID@H@T@M������������DIO@MI<N;JN><M;ID@H@T@M��������><KDO<G�?J�KMJBM@NNJ N�@H����������COOK���=MPIJH<SR@G RJM?KM@NN >JH�K<B@����@H�����������

Page 121: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V89

#@MJ 1<<MDI@I� 2@MHDI<G 25�� ��������� �ADB ����@��ADB ����

$M<IF� *GJT?� 5MDBCO� M@<GDUJP K<M<� J +PN@P %PBB@IC@DH� ?@� ,JQ<� 7JMF ��������

<GBPIN�HJ?@GJN -�J=E@OJ�OMD?DH@INDJI<G�LP@�M@KM@N@IO<�J�+PN@P %PBB@IC@DH�j <

DGPNOM<igJ?@ >JHJ j� KJNNlQ@G KJO@I>D<GDU<MJ� KMJE@OJ� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM< �� DH<B@H

M@KM@N@IO<�<�J=E@ODQD?<?@�?J�<POJM�@H�<KM@N@IO<M�NP<�J=M<�LP@�H@M@>@P�M@QDNp@N

?JN�KG<IJN�?@�>JINOMPigJ @�@N><NN@N�?@�H<O@MD<DN�@�HgJ�?@�J=M<�>JIND?@M<I?J�N@�J

KnN�BP@MM<�ADB ��� ��@I>JH@I?<�?J�KMJE@OJ��@H� EPICJ�?@������� AJD� A@DO<�<�$M<IF

*GJT?� 5MDBCO� KJM� &DGG< 0@=<T�� <NN@NNJM<� ?@� <MO@� ?@� 1JGJHJI� %PBB@IC@DH�� LP@

?@N@E<Q< PH<�IJQ<�N@?@�K<M<�<�API?<igJ � PH�O@HKGJ�K<M<�<�<MO@�>JIO@HKJMeI@<

$DBPM<�����@����� 25��2@MHDI<G���@MJKJMOJ�($)��������� #@MJ 1<<MDI@I$JIO@��COOK���RRR K@MFDINRDGG >JH�RJMF�EAF�DIO@MI<ODJI<G�<DMKJMO COHG�@H�����������

V89

#@MJ 1<<MDI@I� 2@MHDI<G 25�� ��������� �ADB ����@��ADB ����

$M<IF� *GJT?� 5MDBCO� M@<GDUJP K<M<� J +PN@P %PBB@IC@DH� ?@� ,JQ<� 7JMF ��������

<GBPIN�HJ?@GJN -�J=E@OJ�OMD?DH@INDJI<G�LP@�M@KM@N@IO<�J�+PN@P %PBB@IC@DH�j <

DGPNOM<igJ?@ >JHJ j� KJNNlQ@G KJO@I>D<GDU<MJ� KMJE@OJ� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM< �� DH<B@H

M@KM@N@IO<�<�J=E@ODQD?<?@�?J�<POJM�@H�<KM@N@IO<M�NP<�J=M<�LP@�H@M@>@P�M@QDNp@N

?JN�KG<IJN�?@�>JINOMPigJ @�@N><NN@N�?@�H<O@MD<DN�@�HgJ�?@�J=M<�>JIND?@M<I?J�N@�J

KnN�BP@MM<�ADB ��� ��@I>JH@I?<�?J�KMJE@OJ��@H� EPICJ�?@������� AJD� A@DO<�<�$M<IF

*GJT?� 5MDBCO� KJM� &DGG< 0@=<T�� <NN@NNJM<� ?@� <MO@� ?@� 1JGJHJI� %PBB@IC@DH�� LP@

?@N@E<Q< PH<�IJQ<�N@?@�K<M<�<�API?<igJ � PH�O@HKGJ�K<M<�<�<MO@�>JIO@HKJMeI@<

$DBPM<�����@����� 25��2@MHDI<G���@MJKJMOJ�($)��������� #@MJ 1<<MDI@I$JIO@��COOK���RRR K@MFDINRDGG >JH�RJMF�EAF�DIO@MI<ODJI<G�<DMKJMO COHG�@H�����������

V89

#@MJ 1<<MDI@I� 2@MHDI<G 25�� ��������� �ADB ����@��ADB ����

$M<IF� *GJT?� 5MDBCO� M@<GDUJP K<M<� J +PN@P %PBB@IC@DH� ?@� ,JQ<� 7JMF ��������

<GBPIN�HJ?@GJN -�J=E@OJ�OMD?DH@INDJI<G�LP@�M@KM@N@IO<�J�+PN@P %PBB@IC@DH�j <

DGPNOM<igJ?@ >JHJ j� KJNNlQ@G KJO@I>D<GDU<MJ� KMJE@OJ� ?@� <MLPDO@OPM< �� DH<B@H

M@KM@N@IO<�<�J=E@ODQD?<?@�?J�<POJM�@H�<KM@N@IO<M�NP<�J=M<�LP@�H@M@>@P�M@QDNp@N

?JN�KG<IJN�?@�>JINOMPigJ @�@N><NN@N�?@�H<O@MD<DN�@�HgJ�?@�J=M<�>JIND?@M<I?J�N@�J

KnN�BP@MM<�ADB ��� ��@I>JH@I?<�?J�KMJE@OJ��@H� EPICJ�?@������� AJD� A@DO<�<�$M<IF

*GJT?� 5MDBCO� KJM� &DGG< 0@=<T�� <NN@NNJM<� ?@� <MO@� ?@� 1JGJHJI� %PBB@IC@DH�� LP@

?@N@E<Q< PH<�IJQ<�N@?@�K<M<�<�API?<igJ � PH�O@HKGJ�K<M<�<�<MO@�>JIO@HKJMeI@<

$DBPM<�����@����� 25��2@MHDI<G���@MJKJMOJ�($)��������� #@MJ 1<<MDI@I$JIO@��COOK���RRR K@MFDINRDGG >JH�RJMF�EAF�DIO@MI<ODJI<G�<DMKJMO COHG�@H�����������

Page 122: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V90

3H� ?JN� <KM@I?DU@N� ?@�5MDBCO�� J� <H@MD><IJ� (JCI� *<POI@M� LP@ KJNO@MDJMH@IO@� N@

OJMI<MD<�PH�IJOcQ@G� <MLPDO@OJ� Nn� AJD�<>@DOJ K@GJ�H@NOM@ I<�#N>JG<�?@��MLPDO@OPM<

��%#�,#' KJMLP@� ?@N>JIC@>D<� OJ?JN� JN� @INDI<H@IOJN� NJ=M@� <MLPDO@OPM<� @� ODIC<�

KJMO<IOJ�� H@IJN� <� ?@N<KM@I?@M 5MDBCO� <K<M@>@� @H� KMDH@DMJ� KG<IJ�� NJ=� J� JGC<M

<O@IOJ�?JN�<KM@I?DU@N �ADB ����� LP@�J=N@MQ<H J HJ?@GJ�=@H�?@O<GC<?J KJM�H@DJ

?@�<MOD>PG<ip@N�LP@ @N>G<M@N>@H KJIOJN�DHKJMO<IO@N�?<�J=M<

$DBPM<����� 5MDBCO�>JH�&DGG< 0@=<T�@�1JGJHJI�%PBB@IC@DH�Q@I?J�<�H<LP@O@�?J�HPN@P$JIO@��+JJI��)<M@I �+J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N��OC@�<M>CDO@>O�<I?�OC@�HJ?@G ���� �K ��

$DBPM<����� $M<IF�*GJT?�5MDBCO��a�@NLP@M?<��HJNOM<�PH�HJ?@GJ ?J 1JGJHJI�0 �%PBB@IC@DH+PN@PH�K<M<�@NOP?<IO@N�?@�2<GD@NDI $JIO@��COOK���?@NDBIN=TAM<IFGGJT?RMDBCO >JH�K<B@���

Page 123: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V91

!MPU<I?J�>JIODI@IO@N��KJ?@HJN�@S@HKGDAD><M�JPOM<�J=M<� NDBIDAD><ODQ< !JIND?@M<?<

PH�?JN� l>JI@N�QDNP<DN�?J�Nj>PGJ�K<NN<?J� <�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T ������?@ (JMI 3OUJI

�ADB � ���@ ����� AJD� J� KMJE@OJ� Q@I>@?JM� ?J >JI>PMNJ� DIO@MI<>DJI<G @� J� OJMIJP

HPI?D<GH@IO@� >JIC@>D?J 2<G� >JI>@KigJyNDIO@ODU<� OJ?<N� NP<N� QDMOP?@N� >JHJ

<MLPDO@OJ�@�A<U�>JH�LP@�KJNN<HJN�K@IN<M�LP@�J�LP@�A<U@HJN�KJ?@�>C@B<M�< @NO<M

HPDOJ�<>DH<�?J�LP@�NJHJNz�+�**%0�4#�@�%--"+�,�������K ���?DNN@�PH<�Q@U�J

<MLPDO@OJ� @NK<ICJG� 0<A<@G� +JI@J�� LP@� OM<=<GCJP� LP<I?J� EJQ@H� IJ� @NOs?DJ� ?@

3OUJI� I<� "DI<H<M>< �� KM@N@Ii<� ?<� I<OPM@U<� >JHJ� AJIO@� ?@� DINKDM<igJ� @� NP<

><K<>D?<?@�?@�><KO<M�<�@NNkI>D<�@H�<MLPDO@OPM<N�?@�JPOM<N�>PGOPM<N�NgJ�JN�KMDI>DK<DN

OM<iJN�?@�NP<�J=M<

$DBPM<N������(JMI 3OUJI�@�PH�?@O<GC@�?<�H<LP@O@ ?<�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T $JIO@N��COOK���RRR NHC >JH <P�<MOD>G@N�������������������������� COHG@H�����������

$DBPM< �����(JMI 3OUJI�<KM@N@IO<�@�<�H<LP@O@ ?<�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T $JIO@N��COOK���RRR NT?I@TJK@M<CJPN@ >JH�<=JPO�KCJOJB<GG@MT <NKS�@H�����������

V91

!MPU<I?J�>JIODI@IO@N��KJ?@HJN�@S@HKGDAD><M�JPOM<�J=M<� NDBIDAD><ODQ< !JIND?@M<?<

PH�?JN� l>JI@N�QDNP<DN�?J�Nj>PGJ�K<NN<?J� <�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T ������?@ (JMI 3OUJI

�ADB � ���@ ����� AJD� J� KMJE@OJ� Q@I>@?JM� ?J >JI>PMNJ� DIO@MI<>DJI<G @� J� OJMIJP

HPI?D<GH@IO@� >JIC@>D?J 2<G� >JI>@KigJyNDIO@ODU<� OJ?<N� NP<N� QDMOP?@N� >JHJ

<MLPDO@OJ�@�A<U�>JH�LP@�KJNN<HJN�K@IN<M�LP@�J�LP@�A<U@HJN�KJ?@�>C@B<M�< @NO<M

HPDOJ�<>DH<�?J�LP@�NJHJNz�+�**%0�4#�@�%--"+�,�������K ���?DNN@�PH<�Q@U�J

<MLPDO@OJ� @NK<ICJG� 0<A<@G� +JI@J�� LP@� OM<=<GCJP� LP<I?J� EJQ@H� IJ� @NOs?DJ� ?@

3OUJI� I<� "DI<H<M>< �� KM@N@Ii<� ?<� I<OPM@U<� >JHJ� AJIO@� ?@� DINKDM<igJ� @� NP<

><K<>D?<?@�?@�><KO<M�<�@NNkI>D<�@H�<MLPDO@OPM<N�?@�JPOM<N�>PGOPM<N�NgJ�JN�KMDI>DK<DN

OM<iJN�?@�NP<�J=M<

$DBPM<N������(JMI 3OUJI�@�PH�?@O<GC@�?<�H<LP@O@ ?<�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T $JIO@N��COOK���RRR NHC >JH <P�<MOD>G@N�������������������������� COHG@H�����������

$DBPM< �����(JMI 3OUJI�<KM@N@IO<�@�<�H<LP@O@ ?<�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T $JIO@N��COOK���RRR NT?I@TJK@M<CJPN@ >JH�<=JPO�KCJOJB<GG@MT <NKS�@H�����������

V91

!MPU<I?J�>JIODI@IO@N��KJ?@HJN�@S@HKGDAD><M�JPOM<�J=M<� NDBIDAD><ODQ< !JIND?@M<?<

PH�?JN� l>JI@N�QDNP<DN�?J�Nj>PGJ�K<NN<?J� <�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T ������?@ (JMI 3OUJI

�ADB � ���@ ����� AJD� J� KMJE@OJ� Q@I>@?JM� ?J >JI>PMNJ� DIO@MI<>DJI<G @� J� OJMIJP

HPI?D<GH@IO@� >JIC@>D?J 2<G� >JI>@KigJyNDIO@ODU<� OJ?<N� NP<N� QDMOP?@N� >JHJ

<MLPDO@OJ�@�A<U�>JH�LP@�KJNN<HJN�K@IN<M�LP@�J�LP@�A<U@HJN�KJ?@�>C@B<M�< @NO<M

HPDOJ�<>DH<�?J�LP@�NJHJNz�+�**%0�4#�@�%--"+�,�������K ���?DNN@�PH<�Q@U�J

<MLPDO@OJ� @NK<ICJG� 0<A<@G� +JI@J�� LP@� OM<=<GCJP� LP<I?J� EJQ@H� IJ� @NOs?DJ� ?@

3OUJI� I<� "DI<H<M>< �� KM@N@Ii<� ?<� I<OPM@U<� >JHJ� AJIO@� ?@� DINKDM<igJ� @� NP<

><K<>D?<?@�?@�><KO<M�<�@NNkI>D<�@H�<MLPDO@OPM<N�?@�JPOM<N�>PGOPM<N�NgJ�JN�KMDI>DK<DN

OM<iJN�?@�NP<�J=M<

$DBPM<N������(JMI 3OUJI�@�PH�?@O<GC@�?<�H<LP@O@ ?<�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T $JIO@N��COOK���RRR NHC >JH <P�<MOD>G@N�������������������������� COHG@H�����������

$DBPM< �����(JMI 3OUJI�<KM@N@IO<�@�<�H<LP@O@ ?<�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T $JIO@N��COOK���RRR NT?I@TJK@M<CJPN@ >JH�<=JPO�KCJOJB<GG@MT <NKS�@H�����������

Page 124: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V92

�� DHKJMOeI>D<� ?<� KG<O<AJMH<� I<N� J=M<N� ?@� 3OUJI� OM<IN>@I?@� <� >JHKM@@INgJ� ?J

@G@H@IOJ�<MLPDO@OoID>J�@H�ND �1@BP?J�!JGG<M@N �������@H�PH�O@SOJ�?<O<?J�?@ ����

u�%�- (+&,� �'�� �%�-��.1u 3OUJI� ?@ADI@� <� <MLPDO@OPM<� @H� O@MHJN� ?@� KG<O<AJMH<N

CJMDUJIO<DN� @� O@OJN� AGPOP<IO@N�� A<U@I?J� M@G<ip@N� ?<� <MLPDO@OPM<� >JH� @G@H@IOJN

I<OPM<DN� @� PH<� @NKj>D@?@� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� ?J� >JNHJ �J� ?@QJGQ@M@H a� <MLPDO@OPM<

N@P� @NO<OPOJ� ?@� <MO@�� <N� >J=@MOPM<N� QkH� <� N@M� <� H<IDA@NO<igJ� ?@� >JHJ� <� QD?<

CPH<I<�J>JMM@�NJ=�J�>jP

�� @NOMPOPM<� ?J� O@GC<?J� ?J� KMJE@OJ ?@ 3OUJI K<M< < >JHK@ODigJ� Q@I>@?JM<� IgJ

KJ?@MD<� N@M� >JINOMPl?< >JHJ AJM<� KG<I@E<?< �ADB � ����� @H� QDMOP?@� ?<N� AJMH<N� ?@

,"�%% ?J�O@GC<?J N@M@H DMM@BPG<M@N @�@NOMPOPM<GH@IO@�?@A@DOPJN<N ���NJGPigJ AJD�<�?@

OJHc�G< < K<MODM�?@�PH<�sID><�@NA@M<�>JHJ�HJNOM<?J HJ?@GJ�?@�?@HJINOM<igJ�ADB

��� � 'NNJ� K@MHDODP� LP@� OJ?JN� JN� >JHKJI@IO@N� ?J� @N>P?J KP?@NN@H� N@M KMj�

A<=MD><?JN

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�?@�?@HJINOM<igJ ?<�^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T���PNOMcGD< +<?@DM<�KDIO<?<��>JINOMPl?<����� �0' ��!JG@igJ� D=GDJO@><�"@N@ICJN$JIO@�COOK���RRR <M>CDO@>OPM@ >JH�5C<ON-I�#SCD=DODJIN��O2C@4D>OJMD<�I?�G=@MO+PN@PH��M>CDO@>OPM@%<GG@MT��M>CDO@>ON�I?�M>CDO@>OPM@�1T?I@T-K@M<&JPN@+J?@G <NKS@H�����������

$DBPM<����� +<LP@O@�@H�BM<I?@�@N><G< ^K@M<�?@�1T?I@T��(qMI 3OUJI��������� $JIO@��,-0 #0%�1!&3*8��!CMDNOD<I��0JJON�JA�+J?@MI��M>CDO@>OPM@��2JFTJ������ �K ���

Page 125: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V93

,J�ADH�?<�?j><?<�?@������,JMH<I�$JNO@MKMJE@OJP�<�OJMM@?@�����H@OMJN�?@�<GOPM<

?J <I>J� ?@� 1C<IB<D�� CJE@� N@?@� ?J� <I>J &1 !�� NDOP<?J� I<� !CDI< �ADB � ��� -

KMj?DJ ?@� <GO<� O@>IJGJBD<j� NPNO@IO<?J� KJM JDOJ KDG<M@N� ?@ >JI>M@OJ J>PGOJN

@Hn?PGJN� @NOMPOPM<DN� <>JKG<?JN� QDNlQ@DN -=N@MQ<�N@� I<� HJ?@G<B@H� J� PNJ� ?@

KGcNOD>JN�@H�KMJAPNgJ��>JHJ�JN�<>MlGD>JN��KJGD@NODM@IJN @O> -�HJH@IOJ�@H�LP@NOgJ

M@DQDI?D><Q<�J�?@O<GC<H@IOJ�?JN�@G@H@IOJN�<MLPDO@OoID>JN

#H� ������ PH� @?DAl>DJ� LP@� K<M@>D<� O@M� >C@B<?J� ?J� @NK<iJ� DIO@MKG<I@OcMDJ� N@

DHKG<IOJP� @H� .<MDN 1@P� KMJE@OJ� AJD� @N>JGCD?J�H@?D<IO@� PH� >JI>PMNJ� D?@<GDU<?J

K@GJ�@IOgJ�KM@ND?@IO@�?<�$M<Ii<�����������%@JMB@N .JHKD?JP��LP@�?@P�IJH@�<J

>JHKG@SJ �-�!@IOMJ�%@JMB@N�.JHKD?JP �ADB ���� MJHK@P�>JH�<�@NOMPOPM<�?<�>D?<?@

@� @S@M>@P� PH�BM<I?@� DHK<>OJ� NJ=M@� <� KJKPG<igJ�� O<IOJ�K@GJ� ?@N@ICJ�@� ?@>DNp@N

KMJE@OP<DN�LP<IOJ�K@GJ�A<OJ�?@�JN�KMnKMDJN�<MLPDO@OJN u 0@IUJ�.D<IJ� 0D>C<M?�0JB@MN

@�.@O@M�0D>@uN@M@H�LP<N@�?@N>JIC@>D?JN�I<�jKJ><

$DBPM<������,JMH<I�$JNO@M�@�<�H<LP@O@�?<�2JMM@�&1 ! &JG?DIBN $JIO@N��COOK���H<>�F@O<N =GJBNKJO >JH =M���������BM<I?@N COHGCOOK���RRR IJOD>D@MJ�<MLPDO@>OPM< >JH�AJNO@M�K<MOI@MN�@G�<MO@�?@�G<�<MLPDO@>OPM<�@I�N<I�DG?@AJIN@H�����������

Page 126: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V94

-�HPMJ�<>JMODI<?J�?@�QD?MJ�?<�>JINOMPigJ�?@����H@OMJN�?@�<GOPM<�@NO<Q<�J>PGOJ�KJM

OMcN� ?@� PH� @H<M<IC<?J� ?@� OP=JN� ?@� Q@IODG<igJ�� K<NN<M@G<N� @� @N><?<N� MJG<IO@N

.JMjH��@H� N@BPD?<� N@�K@M>@=D<� <� BDB<IO@N><�HcLPDI<� >PGOPM<G� >JH� N@PN�@SKJNOJN

HsN>PGJN�Oj>ID>JN

��DIO@IigJ��I<�@G<=JM<igJ�?JN�HJ?@GJN��AJD�<�?@�<KM@N@IO<M�PH�KMJE@OJ�=<N@<?J�I<N

KJNND=DGD?<?@N�?<�<GO<�O@>IJGJBD<��@NOMPOPM<?J�>JH�PH�NDNO@H<�?@�>JI@Sp@N��OP=JN�@

><=JN� ?@� <iJ �ADB � ��� � �� >JIND?@M<igJ� H<DN� K@M>@KOlQ@G� ?J� KMJE@OJ� AJD� <� ?@

@SO@MI<GDU<M� OJ?<� <� DIAM<@NOMPOPM<� ?J� KMj?DJ�� OJMI<I?J�<� PH� >JHKJI@IO@� ?J

<NK@>OJ� QDNP<G� ?J� @?DAl>DJ � #NN@� @SJ@NLP@G@OJ� @NOMPOPM<G� K@MHDODP KJM� PH

G<?J�D?@IODAD><M� >G<M<H@IO@� <� APIigJ� ?@� ><?<� @G@H@IOJ� ?J� @?DAl>DJ�� @�� KJM� JPOMJ�

?@DS<M�J�DIO@MDJM�>JHKG@O<H@IO@�GDQM@�@�?@NJ=NOMPl?J

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�?J�>JI>PMNJ�!@IOMJ�%@JMB@�.JHKD?JP� 0@IUJ�.D<IJ��0D>C<M?�0JB@MN $JIO@�COOK���RRR <M>C?<DGT >JH =M�������>G<NND>JN�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�>@IOMJ�B@JMB@N�KJHKD?JP�M@IUJ�KD<IJ�MD>C<M?�MJB@MN� @H�����������

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�?J�KMJE@OJ�@S@>PODQJ $JIO@�COOK���RRR <M>C?<DGT >JH =M�������>G<NND>JN�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�>@IOMJ�B@JMB@N�KJHKD?JP�M@IUJ�KD<IJ�MD>C<M?�MJB@MN� @H�����������

Page 127: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V95

+@NHJ�<�>MDN@�?J�K@OMnG@J�@�LP@?<�?<�>JINOMPigJ�IgJ�AJM<HNPAD>D@IO@N�K<M<�?@O@M

J�PNJ�?JN�HJ?@GJN�IJN�<IJN ���� �2<HKJP>J�<�KJNO@MDJM�DIOMJ?PigJ�?<�HJ?@G<B@H

OMD?DH@INDJI<G� KJM� H@DJN� ?DBDO<DN� @S@M>@P� PH� DHK<>OJ� NDBIDAD><ODQJ� NJ=M@� NP<

PODGDU<igJ��@H=JM<�J�N@P�@A@DOJ�<�Hj?DJ�@�GJIBJ�KM<UJ�AJM<�H<DN�?DAl>DG�?@�KM@?DU@M

3H<�IJQ<�HJ?@MID?<?@�NPMBD<�@�<� M@=JLP@�?<N�A@MM<H@IO<N�?DBDO<GDU<?<N�>C@B<Q<

PH�H@DJ� ?@ JK@M<ip@N ?@N>JINOMPODQDNO<�� PH<� =PN><� ?<N� AJMH<N� @NK@O<>PG<M@N� @

JNO@IOJN<N� LP@� N@� @SKM@NN<NN@H� >JHJ� JKJNDigJ� aN� IJMH<N� ?@� >JINOMPigJ� @

JMI<H@IO<igJ�� N@H� G@Q<M� @H�>JIO<� <N� @SDBkI>D<N� API>DJI<DN � .<NN<Q<�<� DHK@M<M�J

G@H<� >JI>@=D?J� KJM� @MIC<M?� 2N>CPHD �ADB � ��� .<M<� < ?@N>JINOMPigJ�� y<� AJMH<

N@BP@�<�A<IO<ND<z

�� K<MODM� ?@� OJ?J� J� ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?@� >JI>@DOP<igJ� ?@� PH<� K@MA@DigJ

<K<M@IO@H@IO@� K@MOPM=<?<�� J� >JIEPIOJ� <K<M@>D<� >JHJ� J� HJ?@GJ � #G@H@IOJN

?@GD><?JN� >JIQ@MN<Q<H�>JH�JPOMJN�HJINOMPJNJN�@� BDB<IO@N>JN��?@�H<I@DM<�LP@�<

@NOMPOPM<�?@�DHKM@NNgJ�><nOD><�KMJ?PUDNN@�PH�@A@DOJ�DINOcQ@G

,@NO@� H@NHJ� K@MlJ?J�� JN� <MLPDO@OJN 5JGA� .MDS� @� &@GHPO� 1RD>UDINFT�� Nn>DJN� ?J

@N>MDOnMDJ !--.� &DHH@G=G<P� @G<=JM<M<H < �)�'� �(.,� ��������I< !<GDAnMID<

�ADB ���� ���� @ ��� �� D?@D<� @M<� >MD<M PH� HJIPH@IOJ� <MLPDO@OoID>J� >JHJ� PH<

>JMKJMDAD><igJ� @� M@KM@N@IO<igJ� <=NOM<O<� ?J� >JMKJ� CPH<IJ � �� J=M<� =PN><Q< <

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?<N�$JGD@N�KJM 2N>CPHD @MI<M? � .<MLP@�?@�*<�4DGG@OO@��.<MDN $JIO@� COOK���RRR AM<>�>@IOM@ AM�>JGG@>ODJI�>JGG@>ODJI�<MO�<M>CDO@>OPM@�DI?@S�?@N�<PO@PMN�<PO@PMN�KMJE@ON��� COHG�<POC'"�����@IN@H=G@'"����� @H����������

Page 128: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V96

?@K@I?kI>D<�I<�<I<GJBD<�<IOMJKJHnMAD>< ?< KMJKJM>DJI<GD?<?@�LP@ AJD�<=<I?JI<?<

>JHJ�>JG<KNJ�?<�OM<?DigJ�>GcNND><�@�J�I<N>DH@IOJ�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�O@>IJGJBD><H@IO@

?@K@I?@IO@

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�>JI>@DOP<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�@NOMPOPM<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�ADI<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

V96

?@K@I?kI>D<�I<�<I<GJBD<�<IOMJKJHnMAD>< ?< KMJKJM>DJI<GD?<?@�LP@ AJD�<=<I?JI<?<

>JHJ�>JG<KNJ�?<�OM<?DigJ�>GcNND><�@�J�I<N>DH@IOJ�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�O@>IJGJBD><H@IO@

?@K@I?@IO@

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�>JI>@DOP<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�@NOMPOPM<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�ADI<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

V96

?@K@I?kI>D<�I<�<I<GJBD<�<IOMJKJHnMAD>< ?< KMJKJM>DJI<GD?<?@�LP@ AJD�<=<I?JI<?<

>JHJ�>JG<KNJ�?<�OM<?DigJ�>GcNND><�@�J�I<N>DH@IOJ�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�O@>IJGJBD><H@IO@

?@K@I?@IO@

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�>JI>@DOP<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�@NOMPOPM<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�ADI<G��-K@I�&JPN@��!<GDAnMID< �!--.�&DHH@G=G<P $JIO@� +'**1 �.MJE@O<I?J�>JH�H<LP@O@N ����� �K ����

Page 129: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V97

,J�DIl>DJ�?<�?j><?<�?@�������J�K<K@G�?JN�HJ?@GJN�AJD�?@N<AD<?J�KJM�PH<�HP?<Ii<

?@� O@>IJGJBD< � ,@NN@� HJH@IOJ�� DH<BDIJP�N@� LP@� J ,( -0�+� ?@� KMJE@OJ� @� ?@

H<LP@O@N�@G@OMoID><N�NP=NODOPDMD<�<LP@G@N�M@>PMNJN�PODGDU<?JN�<IO@MDJMH@IO@

2JH�+<TI@��<MLPDO@OJ�?J�+JMKCJNDN u @N>MDOnMDJ�KDJI@DMJ�@H�KMJOJODK<B@H�McKD?<u

M@<BDP� a� D?@D<� I<� J><NDgJ�� <ADMH<I?J� LP@� <N� H<LP@O@N� AlND><N� IPI><

?@N<K<M@>@MD<H� @� <>M@N>@IO<I?J� LP@� <� KM@N@Ii<� >JI>M@O<� @� J� M@G<>DJI<H@IOJ

JA@M@>D?J�K@G<�H<LP@O@�?@N@HK@IC<Q<H�PH<�APIigJ�QDO<G�IJ�?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ�?JN

KMJE@OJN �ADB �����@ ���

!C@B<HJN�<JNj>PGJ�66'�>JH <�@IJMH@� GD=@M?<?@�?<�>JHKJNDigJ�<MLPDO@OoID>< @�<

>JI?PigJ�?@�HJ?@GJN�@SOM@H<H@IO@� NJADNOD><?JN�� BM<?<ODQ<H@IO@ KMJ?PUD?JN�@H

H<O@MD<DN�NDIOjOD>JN�@�IJQJN��LP@�M@KM@N@IO<H�?@ADIDip@N�?<N�K<MO@N�?J�KMJE@OJ ��N

@SK@MDH@IO<ip@N� @� >JI>@Kip@N� QDN<H� @IQJGQ@M�� ?@� H<I@DM<� >JIO@SOP<GDU<?<�� J

J=N@MQ<?JM� K<MOD>DK<IO@� IJ� eH=DOJ� ?<� D?@D<� @� ?<� DIO@MKM@O<igJ� K<NN<B@DM<� @

HPOcQ@G

6 MAYNE, Thom. Morphosis: Tangents and Outtakes. London, Artemis Verlags AG, 1993.

$DBPM<������+<LP@O@�?J "D<HJI?�0<I>C�&DBC�1>CJJG��*JN�IB@G@N������ +JMKCJNDN$JIO@�COOK���RRR C<>FDO@>OPM< I@O�JNA<Q@G<?JN�@ON<;C<>F���;���KJNHJ?@MID?<? COHG�@H�����������

$DBPM<�����+<LP@O@�?J�?@O<GC@�?@�PH<�N@igJ�?J "D<HJI?0<I>C&DBC�1>CJJG��*JN��IB@G@N������ +JMKCJNDN$JIO@�COOK���FP�<M>CDO@>O =GJBNKJO >JH =M�

Page 130: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V98

$DBPM<����� O@NO@�?@�H<O@MD<DN ?<0@ND?kI>D<�*@RDN������ $M<IF�%@CMT$JIO@� $0'#"+��1 ��%#&07 �$ � 1-0)',��+D>C<@G ��"+2���%$,��+�"#-��-.+�����+(��,, K �����@����

$DBPM<������HJ?@GJ�OMD?DH@INDJI<G� @G@H@IOJ�?J�KMJ>@NNJ ?@KMJE@OJ�?<�0@ND?kI>D<�*@RDN������ .JM�$M<IF�%@CMT$JIO@: $0'#"+��1 � %#&07 �$ � 1-0)',��+D>C<@G ��"+2���%$,��+�"#-��-.+���

�+(��,,K ���

.0-!#11-�!0'�2'4-�"#�$0�,)�%#&07��KMJE@OJ�0@ND?kI>D<�*@RDN�����������

$DBPM<����� !G<PN 1GPO@M��> ����� 2PHPGJ�?@�$@GDK@�yJ�-PN<?Jz�"PLP@�?@� JMBJIC< �+PN@P�?@

�MO@�?@�!G@Q@G<I?$JIO@� $0'#"+��1 � %#&07 �$ � 1-0)',�

+D>C<@G ��"+2���%$,��+�"#-��-.+���

�+(��,, K ���

$DBPM<�����%DJQ<ID� @GGDID���������� �+<?JI<�@!MD<Ii<��nG@J �%<G@MD< JMBC@N@��0JH<�'OcGD< $JIO@� $0'#"+��1 � %#&07

$ � 1-0)',��+D>C<@G ��"+2���%$,�

+�"#-��-.+�����+(��,, K ���

Page 131: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V99

$M<IF %@CMT j�PH�@S@HKGJ�?@�KMJADNNDJI<G�a�AM@IO@�?@�N@P�O@HKJ�?@N@IQJGQ@P�PH

>JIC@>DH@IOJ� LP@� O@H� GC@� K@MHDOD?J� >JINOMPDM� <� K<MODM� ?@� HJ?@GJN� ?DBDO<DN

OMD?DH@INDJI<DN � 1@P� @N>MDOnMDJ� Q@H� @HKM@B<I?J� KMJ>@?DH@IOJN� H@OJ?JGnBD>JN

?DM@>DJI<?JN� a� JODHDU<igJ� ?@� M@>PMNJN� <� K<MODM� ?<� O@>IJGJBD<� >JHKPO<>DJI<G � -N

y��/�%()��%�,.+ ���,z� OJMI<H� KJNNlQ@G� >JHKM@@I?@M� >JHJ J� <MLPDO@OJ O@H

PNPAMPl?J�?<�O@>IJGJBD<�K<M<�QD<=DGDU<M�N@PN�KMJE@OJN

#NO@ ?DA@M@I>D<G� <?QjH� ?@� N@P� DIO@M@NN@� K@G<� @N>PGOPM<�� K@G<� >JIQDQkI>D<� >JH

<MODNO<N�� LP@� GC@� KMJKD>D<M<H� PH� <KMJAPI?<H@IOJ� IJ� @IO@I?DH@IOJ� ?@� LP@NOp@N

@IOM@�<�@N>PGOPM<�@�<�<MLPDO@OPM<�@�<�AJMO@�KM@N@Ii<�<MO@N<I<G -N�KMJE@OJN�?@�$M<IF

%@CMT�IgJ�N@�@SKGD><H NJH@IO@ KJM�>MJLPDN�JP�?@N@ICJ��j�<�K<MODM�?<�DIO@MKM@O<igJ

?@�H<LP@O@N� @� ?@� HJ?@GJN� ?DBDO<DN� LP@ N@� OJMI<� KJNNlQ@G K@I@OM<M� IJN� <NK@>OJN

M@G<ODQJN� <J� N@P�HJ?J�K@>PGD<M�?@� >MD<igJ � #IOM@O<IOJ�� @G@�KMnKMDJ�?@A@I?@�LP@�J

?@N@ICJ�j�PH�H@DJ�?@�M@AG@SgJ�?<�H<DJM�DHKJMOeI>D<

-�KMJ>@NNJ�?@�>MD<igJ�?J�<MLPDO@OJ IgJ�j� GDI@<M��J>JMM@�KJM� NP>@NNDQ<N� DIO@M<ip@N

@IOM@� <LPDGJ� LP@� j� K@IN<?J� @� <LPDGJ� LP@� j� ?@N@IC<?J � .<M<�%@CMT�� @G@� ?@Q@� N@M

DID>D<?J�N@H�KMj�>JI>@DOJN ���=PN><�?<�NJGPigJ�@�J�>JI>@DOJ�<?QkH�?J�A<U@M��DNOJ�j�

?<� @SK@MDH@IO<igJ� ?PM<IO@� J� <OJ� ?@� KMJE@O<M � +<DN� ?J� LP@� PH� <K<M@IO@

AJMH<GDNHJ�� j� KM@>DNJ� DIJQ<M� @� QD<=DGDU<M� <� >JINOMPigJ�� <BJM<� >JH� J� <HK<MJ� ?JN

M@>PMNJN� O@>IJGnBD>JN� ?DBDO<DN � �NNDH�� @SKGD><H�N@� JN� HJODQJN� LP@� >JI?PUDM<H� <N

<ip@N� KMJE@OP<DN� I<� K<NN<B@H� ?@� J=M<N� >JH� AJMH<N� KPM<N� @� ?D<BJI<DN� K<M<

NPK@MAl>D@N�>PMQ<N�AGPOP<IO@N��>JHJ�?@>JMMkI>D<�?<�OM<INDigJ�?J�HJ?J�?@�KMJ?PigJ

H<IP<G�K<M<�<�>JHKPO<>DJI<G

1P<N�J=M<N�IgJ�NgJ�J�M@NPGO<?J�?@�PH<�?DN>DKGDI<�MDBJMJN<��API?<?<�@H�?D<BM<H<N

JP�M@BM<N�M@B@I@M<ODQ<N�N@Q@M<N��<J�>JIOMcMDJ��JMDBDI<H�N@�I<�DIOPDigJ�?@�PH�<MODNO<

?@NKM@J>PK<?J�>JH�<�@G<=JM<igJ�?@�PH<�M@A@MkI>D<�O@nMD><�H<DN�KMJAPI?<

#H� NP<�KMJKJNO<� ?@� IJQ<N� AJMH<N�@SKM@NNDQ<N� %@CMT DINDNO@�IJ� Q<GJM� @N>PGOnMD>J�

@IA<ODU<I?J�<�@IQJGQ@IO@�?J�@?DAl>DJ �"@N@IQJGQ@I?J PH<�?DA@M@IO@�<GO@MI<ODQ<�?@

Page 132: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V100

KMJ?PUDM�J�KMJE@OJ�<MLPDO@OoID>J��K<PO<?J�K@GJ� DIO@M@NN@�I<�@N>PGOPM<�@�I<�KMcOD><

?@�DH<BDI<M�@�>MD<M�@NK<iJN�KJM�HJ?@GJN OMD?DH@INDJI<DN

-�K@M>PMNJ�<?JO<?J�<KnN�<� DIAJMH<ODU<igJ�?@�N@P�@N>MDOnMDJ�IJ�ADI<G�?<�?j><?<�?@

������ K@GJ� @N>MDOnMDJ ��"+2 �'� ��+-'�+, j� HPDOJ� K@>PGD<M � "J� <MO@N<I<G� <J

O@>IJGnBD>J��%@CMT�@�NP<�@LPDK@�OMDGC<H�PH�><HDICJ��JI?@�@NOgJ�@IQJGQD?JN�HPDOJN

@NOP?JN�� @SK@MDH@IOJN�� K@NLPDN<�?@�H<O@MD<DN�� @IQJGQ@I?J�KMJADNNDJI<DN�?@�JPOM<N

cM@<N�@H�PH�OM<=<GCJ�?@�@LPDK@�@�DH=Pl?J�?@�PH�@NAJMiJ�>JG@ODQJ

-POM<�HP?<Ii<�NDBIDAD><ODQ<�IJ�KMJ>@NNJ�?@�OM<=<GCJ�@NOc�I<�H<I@DM<�?@�K@IN<M�<

B@JH@OMD< �#ILP<IOJ�I<N�A<N@N�KMDHcMD<N��%@CMT�KMJE@O<Q<�@H�APIigJ�?<N�M@NOMDip@N

DHKJNO<N�K@G<�B@JH@OMD<�?@N>MDODQ<��IJ�ADI<G�J�<MLPDO@OJ�?@DS<�?@�N@�KM@J>PK<M�>JH

<�B@JH@OMD<�?<N�AJMH<N�M@BPG<M@N�@�K<NN<�<�<?JO<M�AJMH<N�GDQM@N��>PE<�B@JH@OMD<�j

?@ADID?<�KJNO@MDJMH@IO@��IJ�>JHKPO<?JM

$DBPM<����� %@CMT�<KM@N@IO<I?J�PH�HJ?@GJ�?@�@NOP?J $JIO@� COOK���RRR BJJBG@ >JH =M�DHBM@N�NO<MO����PH���CG�KO�@H�����������

Page 133: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V101

-�IJQJ�MPHJ�K<M<�<�<MLPDO@OPM<�?@�%@CMT�?@P�N@�@H�QDMOP?@�?J�N@P�?DA@M@IO@�HJ?J

?@� KMJ?PigJ� ?@� KMJE@OJN�� JP� N@E<�� <� K<MODM� ?<� >JI>DGD<igJ� @IOM@� <� OM<?DigJ� ?J

@N>MDOnMDJ�� I<� >MD<igJ� =<N@<?<� I<N� <MMJE<?<N�H<LP@O@N� AlND><N�� @� <� ><K<>D?<?@� ?@

?DBDO<GDU<igJ� @� ?@N@IQJGQDH@IOJ� ?@� HJ?@GJN� ?DBDO<DN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN�� LP@

<MH<U@I<H�PH�=<I>J�?@�?<?JN�>JH�<N�>JJM?@I<?<N�@NK<>D<DN�?@�OJ?JN�JN�KJIOJN

GJ><GDU<?JN�NJ=M@�JN�@G@H@IOJN�?@N@IC<?JN �'NNJ�KMJKJM>DJIJP�<J�H@NHJ�O@HKJ�<

?@N>MDigJ�B@JHjOMD><�KM@>DN<�?@�><?<�@G@H@IOJ�@�J�>JIOMJG@�NJ=M@�<�H<IDKPG<igJ

?<N�AJMH<N�B@M<?<N �-N�?@N@ICJN�?DBDO<DN��<J�>JIOMcMDJ�?JN�H<IP<DN��>JIOkH�OJ?<N

<N�?@N>MDip@N B@JHjOMD><N�I@>@NNcMD<N�K<M<�<�NP<�M@<GDU<igJ

!JH�<�ADI<GD?<?@�?@�@NOP?<M�<N�M@G<ip@N�?J�@?DAl>DJ�KMJKJNOJ�>JH�J�>JIO@SOJ�@�<N

><M<>O@MlNOD><N� ?J� @IOJMIJ�� %@CMT� @S@>PO<� NP<N� H<LP@O@N� @H� @N><G<� M@?PUD?<�

IJMH<GH@IO@������ �*JBJ�<KnN��NP<�@LPDK@�KMJQD?@I>D<�>nKD<N�<HKGD<?<N�@H�@N><G<

$DBPM<������.<MO@N�?J�+J?@GJ �#NOP?J�?J�cOMDJ�@SO@MIJ��N@O@H=MJ���� $M<IF�%@CMT��%PBB@IC@DI�� DG=<J $JIO@�� 03%%#,��!JJNE@ �$M<IF�- �%@CMT #G�+PN@J�%PBB@IC@DH� DG=<J �K ���

$DBPM<�����$M<IF�%@CMT�HJ?@G<I?J�J %PBB@IC@DI DG=<J$JIO@��COOK���RRR <>CD@Q@H@IO JMB�<POJ?J>�KCJOJ>M@?DO�<>CD@Q@MN�B@C�����

$DBPM<������.@MNK@>ODQ<�?DBDO<G��M@KM@N@IO<igJ�!�2'� +PN@P %PBB@IC@DI DG=<J$JIO@�� 03%%#,��!JJNE@ �$M<IF�- �%@CMT #G�+PN@J%PBB@IC@DH� DG=<J �K ����

$DBPM<������+J?@GJ�$M<IF�%@CMT %PBB@IC@DI� DG=<J$JIO@��+JJI��)<M@I �+J?@GDIB�+@NN<B@N��OC@�<M>CDO@>O�<I?�OC@�HJ?@G ���� K ����

Page 134: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V102

�������K<M<�QDNP<GDU<M�@�@S<HDI<M�<N�M@G<ip@N�API>DJI<DN�?J�@?DAl>DJ �3H<�Q@U�>MD<?<

<� AJMH<� ?@N@E<?<�� <N� QcMD<N� K@i<N LP@� >JHKp@H <�H<LP@O@� AlND><� KMJ?PUD?<� NgJ

?DBDO<GDU<?<N ����B@JH@OMD<�?<N�NPK@MAl>D@N @SO@MI<N�?<�H<LP@O@�AlND><�j y@N><I@<?<z

�ADB ������?<I?J�JMDB@H�<J�KMDH@DMJ�HJ?@GJ�?DBDO<G�MP?DH@IO<M ��N�DH<B@IN�?DBDO<DN�

?DQPGB<?<N�K@GJ�@N>MDOnMDJ��HJNOM<H�<N�@O<K<N�K@M>JMMD?<N�I<�?@ADIDigJ�?J�HJ?@GJ

?DBDO<G �ADB � ��� � �� O@>IJGJBD<� @IQJGQD?<� KJNND=DGDO< LP@� ><?<� @G@H@IOJ� N@E<

?DA@M@IO@��DNNJ�KJMLP@�J�<MLPDO@OJ�@SKGJM<�<J�HcSDHJ�J�>JI>@DOJ�?@�A<=MD><igJ�IgJ

K<?MJIDU<?<��LP@�<OP<GH@IO@�j�QD<=DGDU<?<�K@GJ�KMJ>@NNJ�!�"�!�+

!JHJ� A@MM<H@IO<� ?@� OM<=<GCJ�� J� KMDI>DK<G� M@>PMNJ� K<M<� <� B@M<igJ� ?@� H<LP@O@N

@G@OMoID><N� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN� <� K<MODM� ?@� HJ?@GJN� AlND>JN� j� J� !�2'��� PH� KMJBM<H<

<@MJ@NK<>D<G� ?@N@IQJGQD?J� K@G<� J@DIB � -N� J=E@OJN� NgJ� H<M><?JN� @H� NP<N

DIO@MN@ip@N� @� KJIOJN� ?@� NP<N� BM<?@N � -N� KJIOJN� NgJ� ?DBDO<GDU<?JN� K<M<� ?@ADIDM

>JJM?@I<?<N�@NK<>D<DN�678�@�NgJ�DIN@MD?JN�IJ ,( -0��+ �"#'(��+(, @�OM<INAJMH<?JN

@H� >PMQ<N � #NO<N� DIAJMH<ip@N� NgJ� OM<INA@MD?<N� K<M<� J� !�2'��� JI?@� NgJ� CDK@M�

M<>DJI<GDU<?<N�� GDB<?<N�@�< HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN j� ADI<GDU<?< �"@O<GC@N�>JHJ�JN

HPDOJN� @� Q<MD<?JN� K<DIjDN� @H� K@?M<� @� JN� KJIOJN� ?@� <KJDJ� NgJ� H<K@<?JN� >JHJ

yKJIOJN� KM@>DNJN� ?J� KMJBM<H<z�� >JH <� K<M<H@OMDU<igJ ?@�H<LP@O@N� @G@OMoID><N

#NN@N� ?@N@ICJN� KJ?@H� N@M� DIN@MD?JN� @� M@ODM<?JN� ?<� H<LP@O@� @G@OMoID><� K<M<

KMJ?PUDM@H�>JHKJI@IO@N�<POJH<OD><H@IO@�<EPNO<?JN

�N�KMJNK@>ip@N�<KJIO<H�K<M<�<� A@GDU�>JIQDQkI>D<�?@�HJ?@GJN� OMD?DH@INDJI<DN�@�JN

KMJOnODKJN� McKD?JN�� LP@� QDN<H� M@>JI>DGD<M� HjOJ?JN� AlND>JN� @� ?DBDO<DN� @H� A<QJM� ?@

=JIN�KMJE@OJN -�KMJBM@NNJ�?<�<MLPDO@OPM<�I@NO@�Nj>PGJ�IJN�KJNND=DGDO<�><?<�Q@U�H<DN

HJ?@G<M�>JH�A@MM<H@IO<N�?@�@SKGJM<igJ�?@IOMJ�?J�KMJ>@NNJ�>MD<ODQJ �-�@NOP?J�?<N

@SK@MDkI>D<N@� ?@� N@PN� KMJ>@NNJN� KMJE@OP<DN� IJN� M@Q@G< <� I<OPM@U<� @SKGJM<OnMD<

=<N@<?<�I<�>JHKM@@INgJ�?<N�KJNND=DGD?<?@N�@NK<>D<DN ���HJ?@G<B@H�N@�@NO<=@G@>@�

@IOgJ� >JHJ� PH� KJO@IO@� HjOJ?J� ?@� >JHPID><igJ� I<� ?@N>MDigJ�� @SKGJM<igJ� @

DIQ@NODB<igJ ?<�<MLPDO@OPM<

+<O@MD<GDU<I?J� NP<N� D?@D<N� NJ=M@� @NO@� NPKJMO@� AlND>J� O<IOJ� K<M<� M@BDNOM<M� JN

K@IN<H@IOJN� >JHJ� K<M<� ?@N>J=MDM� IJQ<N� KJNND=DGD?<?@N� <� K<MODM� ?JN� DI?l>DJN

Page 135: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

V103

AJMI@>D?JN�K@GJ�KMnKMDJ�<OJ�?@�HJ?@G<M �-N�HJ?@GJN�?@�>JI>@KigJ NgJ�JN�<MO@A<OJN

H<DN� KMnSDHJN� ?J� K@IN<H@IOJ � 1gJ� M@BDNOMJN� @SKGJM<OnMDJN�� >PE<� <H=DBPD?<?@

@NODHPG<�<� DH<BDI<igJ �� KMJ?PigJ�?@�?DA@M@IO@N� D?@D<N�j�JMDPI?<�?< DI>@MO@U<�?J

KMJ>@NNJ�>MD<ODQJ �ADB ����

�I<GDN<M@HJN� <� N@BPDM� JN� KMJ>@NNJN� >JBIDODQJN� KM@N@IO@N� ?PM<IO@� <� KMJ?PigJ� ?@

HJ?@GJN� I<� A<N@� DID>D<G� ?J� KMJ>@NNJ� ?@� KMJE@OJ� @� Q@MDAD><M@HJN� >JHJ� D?@D<N� @

>JIC@>DH@IOJN�@H@MB@H�IJ�<OJ�>MD<ODQJ

$DBPM<����� 0@NBDNOMJ�@SKGJM<OnMDJ�?@�$M<IF�%C@MT$JIO@� COOK���RRR =PNOG@M I@O�DI?@S KCK�<MOD>G@�AM<IF;B@CMT;<O;RJMF;JI;QD@R;DI;I@R;TJMF;>DOT� @H�������������

Page 136: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 104

�� H;L?I`E 7GK?� 7FH;I;DJ7:7 J;C� 7� ?DJ;DI`E� :;� :?IJ?D=K?H E� GK;� <E?� JH7J7:E

H;B79?ED7:E�ZI %�)-�,�+��KI97H�L7H?\L;?I� ?CFEHJ7DJ;I�;�H;B;L7DJ;I�7E�J;C7�F7H7

?:;DJ?<?97H�7�H;B7b`E�;DJH;�7I�?:;?7I�;�7�FH\J?97�+H;J;D:;�I;�I?DJ;J?P7H�;�7:GK?H?H�KC7

DEL7� F;HIF;9J?L7� :;<?D?D:E� 9EC� 9B7H;P7� 7I� DEC;D9B7JKH7I� 7:EJ7:7I� F7H7� E

9EDJ;o:E�;C�GK;IJ`E

$:;DJ?<?97� I;� D;IJ;� 97FfJKBE� 7�C;JE:EBE=?7� FH?D9?F7B� ;� 7I� Jd9D?97I� :;� ?DL;IJ?=7b`E

GK;� KJ?B?P7C� 7Jd� E� CEC;DJE� �EBE97� I;� 7� ?DL;IJ?=7b`E� :;� KC� 9EDJ;NJE� >?IJjH?9E

F7H7�:;CEIJH7H�7�<7C?B?7H?:7:;�9EC�7I�F;IGK?I7I�7JK7?I

�?IJH?8Kf:7I�;C�JHeI ;I<;H7I��EFJEKI; FEH I;F7H\B7I ;C�F7HJ;I KI7D:E�E�9H?JdH?E�:;

:?<;H;D9?7bl;I� :;� H;9;Fb`E� :7� ?D<EHC7b`E� �IKFEHJ;� DE� GK7B� E� H;9;FJEH� 7D7B?I7� 7

?D<EHC7b`E�*I ?J;DI�<EH7C�EH=7D?P7:EI 9EC�7I�I;=K?DJ;I�:?L?Il;I� C;?E "%(*�++'�

�"!",�$ ; %'+,*��(:�$"��

*� FH?C;?HE ?J;C� JH7J7� :7� B?J;H7JKH7� ;� 787H97:7 7HJ?=EI� ;C� F;H?j:?9EI� D79?ED7?I� ;

?DJ;HD79?ED7?I�� B?LHEI�� J;I;I� :?II;HJ7bl;I� ;� 7D7?I� ;C� 9ED<;HeD9?7I� D79?ED7?I� ;

?DJ;HD79?ED7?I��E�I;=KD:E�C;?E�H;oD;�I?J;I�GK;�7FH;I;DJ7C 9EDJ;o:EI�H;B79?ED7:EI

7EI� CE:;BEI;� E J;H9;?HE�� H;7B?P7 KC H;=?IJHE7JK7B :7I ?DIJ?JK?bl;I� GK;� 78H?=7C

9EB;bl;I�:;�C7GK;J;I�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�;� <7P�KC�7F7D>7:E�=;H7B�:7I�C7?I� H;9;DJ;I

;NFEI?bl;I�E9EHH?:7I�7Jd�E�FH;I;DJ;�CEC;DJE

��� ������� ���������������������������

Page 137: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 105

��� ��."+1'�����",�*�,-*�

�� B?J;H7JKH7� :EI�CE:;BEI� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7� 97H79J;H?P7I;� FEH� GK;IJl;I� ;IF;9f<?97I� ;

FEDJK7?I �� 8?8B?E=H7<?7� H;<;H;DJ;� ZI� C7GK;J;I� ;� CE:;BEI <E? :?L?:?:7 ;C

I;?I:?<;H;DJ;I =HKFEI�

* FH?C;?HE JH7J7�:?H;J7C;DJ;�:E�CE:E�:;�;N;9KJ\BEI��78EH:7D:E�:;�<EHC7�:?H;J7

EI� C7J;H?7?I�� Jd9D?97I� ;� FHE9;IIEI� :;� ;B78EH7b`E :?L;HI?<?97:EI� *I;=KD:E JH7J7

:7I7FH;I;DJ7bl;I� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I� 9ECE� KC7� <;HH7C;DJ7� 9EC� E� GK7B� E� 7HGK?J;JE

:;L;�JH787B>7H�:KH7DJ;�JE:E�E�FHE9;IIE�:;�FHE@;JE*I�B?LHEI�?D9BK;C :;I9H?bl;I :;

C7J;H?7?I�� <;HH7C;DJ7I�� :?97I� :;� 9EDIJHKb`E� ;� Jd9D?97I� ?DIJHKbl;I� ;� 9EDI;B>EI

FH\J?9EI��7BdC�:; ;N;CFBEI�:;�JH787B>EI�:;�7HGK?J;JEI

*� J;H9;?HE�8BE9E 9EDIJ?JK?I;FEH� 9EDJ;o:EI GK;� 7FH;I;DJ7C E CE:;BE 78EH:7D:E

I;K� I?=D?<?97:E� F7H7� 7� 7HGK?J;JKH7 DLEBL;�� FH?D9?F7BC;DJ;�� FHE9;IIEI FHE@;JK7?I

9ECE�<;HH7C;DJ7�:;�9ECKD?97b`E

*� GK7HJE� =HKFE d <EHC7:E� FEH� FK8B?97bl;I 9ECFEIJ7I� FEH ;I9H?JEI� :;� 7HGK?J;JEI

GK;� 7FH;I;DJ7C� I;K� ;DJ;D:?C;DJE� IE8H;� I;K� FHjFH?E� FHE9;IIE� :;� FHE@;JE�

78EH:7D:E�7�CE:;B7=;C�?DL;IJ?=7J?L7�9ECE�C;?E�:;�:?\BE=E�;DJH;�E�F;DI7C;DJE�;

7�C7JdH?7

* GK?DJE�; F;DoBJ?CE�=HKFE�JH7P 7�H;KD?`E�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7I� ?9kD?97I�H;FH;I;DJ7:7I

FEH CE:;BEI� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I�� FHE:Kbl;I� :;� 7HGK?J;JEI� ?DJ;HD79?ED7?I� ;� KC� HEB� :;

C7GK;J?IJ7I 7FH;I;DJ7D:E�7B=KDI�:;�I;KI�JH787B>EI� D9;HH7:E��E I;NJE�=HKFEI;�<7P

H;FH;I;DJ7H�FEH FK8B?97bl;I�9ECFB;C;DJ7H;I�KJ?B?P7:7I�D7I�797:;C?7I

����� �-&39�+��%�,�*"�"+���,4�&"��+

C8EH7� 7IH;<;HeD9?7I ;:?JEH?7?I� D`E� I;@7C CK?JE� ;NJ;DI7I�� DE� FH?C;?HE =HKFE

:;IJ797CI;� EI� B?LHEI� :; 78EH:7=;DI� I;C;B>7DJ;I�� C7I� 9EC� ;N;CFB?<?97bl;I

:?IJ?DJ7I��;IJ;I�7KJEH;I� JH787B>7C�EI�:?L;HIEI�J?FEI�:;�CE:;BEI �'X�/& ��&- � .�

Page 138: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 106

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE)�����-�(7GK;J;I��(?D?7JKH7I!EDJ;��!EJE�:7�7KJEH7

!?=KH7� ��� '?LHE &)*''�2��# �#$)" -��((7GK;J;I��HGK?J;JkD?97I!EDJ;��!EJE�:7�7KJEH7

!?=KH7� ��� '?LHE�*).�' 5� '�(7GK;J;I��7H;FH;I;DJ7b`E�:E�;IF7bEDE�FHE@;JE�7HGK?J;JkD?9E!EDJ;��!EJE�:7�7KJEH7

!?=KH7� � ��'?LHE+�.�0�'�$($-V�� ����-�*) -*��+��*� -�#��-(7GK;J?ICE�HGK?J;9JjD?9E!EDJ;��!EJE�:7�7KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE'X�/& � �&- � .����1*)�+$ -.��2 (E:;BB�H9>?J;AJKH��;I?=D!EDJ;��!EJE�:7�7KJEH7

1*)� +$ -.�� ������<?= ���� :;CEDIJH7C� IK7I� <KDbl;I�� 9?J7C� EI� C7J;H?7?I

:?IFEDfL;?I�;�FEIIfL;?I�� ?BKIJH7C�7�I;GKeD9?7�:; ;B78EH7b`E�;�7FH;I;DJ7C�:?L;HIEI

CE:;BEI�GK;�I`E H;IKBJ7:EI�H;7?I�:7�7FB?97b`E�:7I�Jd9D?97I�;�C7J;H?7?I KI7:EI�FEH

;B;I

�� ?:;?7�:;�78EH:7H 7I�C7GK;J;I�FEH�KC ^C8?JE�FHE<?II?ED7B��:?H?=?D:EI;� 7EI�GK;

JH787B>7C� EK� :;I;@7C� 7FH;D:;H� E� E<f9?E� :;� C7GK;J?IJ7�;II;D9?7BC;DJ; LEBJ7:E

F7H7� 7� 7FH;I;DJ7b`E�:;�E8H7I� 7HGK?J;JkD?97I� I;� JEHD7�;<?97P�;C�7B=KDI� 7IF;9JEI

);IJ;�I;DJ?:E� 7 ?DJHE:Kb`E�:7I Jd9D?97I�:;�9ED<;9b`E�:;�C7GK;J;I�I;�<7P�FH;I;DJ;

D7� E8H7� :;� JE:EI� EI� 7KJEH;I� FHE:KP?D:E� KC� C7DK7B� :;� EF;H7bl;I F7H7� 7

9ECFH;;DI`E� :EI�C7J;H?7?I�� <;HH7C;DJ7� ;� KIEI�+�.�0�'� $�($-V�� �� �� �<?= � ��

)������������<?=� ���� &)*''���# �#$)" -������ �<?=� ���� �*)5�' .������ �<?=

��� ;�%�)& �� ����

�ECFB;C;DJ7D:E 7� ;NF;H?eD9?7� <fI?97� L?IK7B� ;B78EH7:7 FEH� C7J;H?7?I� H;7?I�

;D9EDJH7I; DEI� CE:;BEI� <fI?9EI D7� ;NF;H?C;DJ7b`E� I;DIEH?7B� F7H7 E� ;IJK:E:7I

<EHC7I� ;DLEBL;D:E� 7� jJ?97� :E� EB>E� >KC7DE�� 9ECE� E� 9ED;� L?IK7B� ;� E� 97CFE� :;

FHE<KD:?:7:;�� GK;� D`E� FE:;� I;H� H;FB?97:E� ;C� KC7� J;B7 )E� 9EDJ;NJE� :;IJ7

FK8B?97b`E� 7 EH=7D?P7b`E� :?:\J?97� I;� JEHD7� ;<?9?;DJ;� FEH� KC� =BEII\H?E� ;� <7PI;

FH;I;DJ;�FEH�CdJE:EI�:; $�1'-, B?CFE�;�KC� @E=E�:;�FEI?9?ED7C;DJE�GK;�JEHD7�7

<?N7b`E�:E�9EDJ;o:E�JH7J7:E�7JH7LdI�:;�C7J;H?7?I��<;HH7C;DJ7I�;�J;9DEBE=?7I�7JK7?I

�2 -) -� �� ����<?=� ���

Page 139: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 107

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE��0))��)�(7GK;J7I�:;�HGK?J;9JKH7�(;:?EI���/?FEI����FB?979?ED!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

������'%����������"+9�+���($"���"$"�����&'��&+"&'����(*'#�,'

);IJ;�I;=KD:E�=HKFE� 7 FHEFEI?b`E�:;�:;CEDIJH7H�7�?CFEHJ^D9?7�:7I�C7GK;J;I�DE

FHE9;IIE�:;�JEC7:7�:;�:;9?Il;I��; 7�=;H7b`E�:;�8KI97 ;�?DL;IJ?=7b`E�:EI�?CFKBIEI

9H?7J?LEI I;� <7P� D;9;II\H?7�� IE8H;JK:E� DE� 97CFE� :7I� :;I9E8;HJ7I� ?:;?7I�

;N;CFB?<?97b`E� I;� JEHD7� FH;I;DJ;� 9ECE� <EHC7�:;� <?N7b`E� :;� 9EDJ;o:EI FEH�C;?E

:7I ?DIJHKbl;I� =H7:K7?I�:;I9H?bl;I� :;� :?L;HIEI� C7J;H?7?I ; 9EDI;B>EI� FH\J?9EI :;

9EDIJHKb`E�;�Jd9D?97I �<?=� ���� ��0))���� ��

*8I;HL7CEI�7� ;N?IJeD9?7�:;� 9EDJ;o:EI 787H97D:E 7I�C;IC7I�78EH:7=;DI� 9?J7:7I

DE� 9EDJ;NJE� 7DJ;H?EH� FEHdC� :?IJH?8Kf:7I ;DJH; J;C7I GK;� H;<B;J;C� 7I� :?<;H;DJ;I

!?=KH7� ��� '?LHE 2 -) -��(�(E:;B�(7A?D=!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 140: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 108

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE($''.����+HE@;J7D:E�9EC�(7GK;J;I�0C�=K?7�:;�9ECE<7P;H�;�KI7H�C7GK;J;I�:;�FHE@;JE�:; 7HGK?J;JKH7!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ��� '?LHE�!�-- '4� '/d9D?97I�:;�-;FH;I;DJ79?jD!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ��� '?LHE�!�-- '4� '!KD:7C;DJEI�:;��HGK?J;JKH7!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ��� '?LHE�!�-- '4� '�?8K@E�F7H7 ;B �?I;iE�0H87DE!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

EFbl;I� ;N?IJ;DJ;I� F7H7 7� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7 �<?=� �����!�-- ''4�

�� ���<?=� ���� �!�-- ''4���� ��� �<?=� ���� �!�-- ''4�������

�� 8H;L;� 7D7B?I;� :7� <KDb`E� 7� KJ?B?P7b`E :7I� C7GK;J;I� 7E� BED=E� :E� J;CFE� ;

EJH7J7C;DJE7EI�CE:;BEI�9ECE�F7HJ;�?DJ;=H7DJ;�:EI�FHE@;JEI� 7FH;I;DJ7 7HGK?J;JEI

:;� =H7D:;� DEJEH?;:7:;� H;7B?P7D:E� I;KI� FHE9;IIEI� FHE@;JK7?I� ; IEB?:?<?97D:E IK7

FEJ;D9?7B?:7:; �<?=� ��� �($''.�������

Page 141: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 109

������� $�/9�+����"�!*�%�+ &'�(*'#�,'��*)-",�,8&"�'

)E� 97C?D>E� :7� ?DL;IJ?=7b`E� ;� H?=EH� DE� ;IJK:E�� EI� 7KJEH;I :E� J;H9;?HE� 8BE9E

JH787B>7C9EC� H;<B;Nl;I� IE8H;� 7� 7HGK?J;JKH7 FEH� C;?E :;� C7GK;J;I(E:;BE� :;

;IJK:E�; :?7=H7C7I�I`E�;B78EH7:EI�7�F7HJ?H :;�:;J;HC?D7:EI�FHE9;IIEI�; JEHD7CI;

<;HH7C;DJ7I�:;�9ECKD?97b`E�GK;�7KN?B?7C�E�:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:E�FHE@;JE �<?=� � �

�&0+ -� -"� - $. -�0( (*/*� 1�)�1 -& '���� ��

*I� :;I7<?E� :7� CE:;B7=;C F7H7� :EJ7H� 9ED>;9?C;DJEI� ;� KJ?B?P7H ?DIJHKC;DJEI

D;9;II\H?EI�F7H7�GK;�EI�7BKDEI�FEII7C�;B78EH7H�;IJH7Jd=?7I�FHE@;JK7?I� B;L7D:EEI

:7� 78IJH7b`E� Z C7J;H?7B?:7:;�d� KC� J;C7� H;9EHH;DJ;� ;�D;9;II\H?E�D;IJ;� 9EDJ;NJE

�<?=� ��� �"-$)� -"� �� ���; �<?=� ����"-$)� -"� ��� � )7�FHEFEI?b`E :;�<EHC7H

7HGK?J;JEI�GK;�FEII7C�9EDIJHK?H�IK7I�?:;?7I� LeI; 7�C;JE:EBE=?7 :7�H;<B;N`E�IE8H;

7��HGK?J;JKH7

��L7BEH?P7b`E�:7�H\F?:7�9ED<;9b`E�:;�CE:;BEI�CEIJH7D:E�7�;II;D9?7B?:7:;�:;�97:7

E8H7� B;L7C� 7I� 7HJ?9KB7bl;I 7 JH7DI?J7H:;� KC� FB7DE FH;B?C?D7HC;DJ; :;� :K7I

:?C;DIl;IF7H7�KC7�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B?:7:;��7�<?C�:; =;H7H�CE:;BEI�;IF79?7?I�<?=� ���

/H7J7I;�:7�FHEFEI?b`E�:; F;GK;D7I�C7GK;J;I�:;�;IJK:E GK;�J;C�9ECE�H;IKBJ7:E�7

7JH7J?L7�;�IKHFH;;D:;DJ;�;NFH;II`E�:7�F7F?HE<B;N?7� GK;�9EC8?D7 7HGK?J;JKH7�;�@E=E

;C�KC7�C7D;?H7�<\9?B�:;�9EDIJHK?H�KC�CE:;BE�87I;7:E�;C�:E8H7I�:;�F7F;B��I?C?B7H

7E EH?=7C? �! $'.#$'' � )WT 5� �(0T*5�������

.;=K?D:E�7�C;IC7�C;JE:EBE=?7�E8I;HL7I; GK; 7�KJ?B?P7b`E�:;�C7J;H?7?I�:E8H\L;?I

;�CE:;B\L;?I� FE:; H;IKBJ7H� ;C�CE:;BEI :;� =H7D:; FEJ;D9?7B?:7:;�.0/# -'�)��

����

Page 142: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 110

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE "-$)� -"��%�$ 5�T*.�� ��-,0$/ �/0-�.!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE "-$)� -"��%���� IJK:?EI :;B IF79?E!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE !$'.#$''��)0T 5��(0T*

� .+' "�-�����C7GK;J7I�:;�HGK?J;9JKH7 ;D��>?B;!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7�!$'.#$''��)0T 5��(0T*5

!?=KH7� � � '?LHE&0+ -� -"��-�- $. -�0( (*/*� 1�)�1 -& '�H9>?J;9JKH7B�(E:;B�';7:�JE��;I?=D!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

������*)-",�,'+�)-�� �0�%�%�)-�,�+

+7HJ?D:E�F7H7�EKJH7�<EHC7�:;�78EH:7H�EI�CE:;BEI�JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I �9ECFEIJE�F;B;I

FHjFH?EI� 7HGK?J;JEI� 9ECE� FH\N?I� ;� 9ECFB;J7D:E E� GK7HJE7=HKF7C;DJE FE:;I;

9?J7H!H7DA� ";>HO9ECE� E� H;FH;I;DJ7DJ;� :;� :E?I FjBEI� D7� C;JE:EBE=?7� :;� FHE@;JE

�<?=� ��� �;�KC�B7:E�E�:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:; KC�:EI�C7?I�IE<?IJ?97:EI FHE=H7C7�:E

C;H97:E� :;� KC I?IJ;C7� :?=?J7B� F7H7� 7� FHE:Kb`E� :;� FHE@;JEI�;� ;C� EKJH7

;NJH;C?:7:;�7�C7DKJ;Db`E�:7 <?:;B?P7b`E 7EI�CdJE:EI�:;�FHE:Kb`E�:;�C7GK;J;I

;C�FHE<KI`E�" #-4�������

| 110

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE "-$)� -"��%�$ 5�T*.�� ��-,0$/ �/0-�.!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE "-$)� -"��%���� IJK:?EI :;B IF79?E!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE !$'.#$''��)0T 5��(0T*

� .+' "�-�����C7GK;J7I�:;�HGK?J;9JKH7 ;D��>?B;!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7�!$'.#$''��)0T 5��(0T*5

!?=KH7� � � '?LHE&0+ -� -"��-�- $. -�0( (*/*� 1�)�1 -& '�H9>?J;9JKH7B�(E:;B�';7:�JE��;I?=D!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

������*)-",�,'+�)-�� �0�%�%�)-�,�+

+7HJ?D:E�F7H7�EKJH7�<EHC7�:;�78EH:7H�EI�CE:;BEI�JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I �9ECFEIJE�F;B;I

FHjFH?EI� 7HGK?J;JEI� 9ECE� FH\N?I� ;� 9ECFB;J7D:E E� GK7HJE7=HKF7C;DJE FE:;I;

9?J7H!H7DA� ";>HO9ECE� E� H;FH;I;DJ7DJ;� :;� :E?I FjBEI� D7� C;JE:EBE=?7� :;� FHE@;JE

�<?=� ��� �;�KC�B7:E�E�:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:; KC�:EI�C7?I�IE<?IJ?97:EI FHE=H7C7�:E

C;H97:E� :;� KC I?IJ;C7� :?=?J7B� F7H7� 7� FHE:Kb`E� :;� FHE@;JEI�;� ;C� EKJH7

;NJH;C?:7:;�7�C7DKJ;Db`E�:7 <?:;B?P7b`E 7EI�CdJE:EI�:;�FHE:Kb`E�:;�C7GK;J;I

;C�FHE<KI`E�" #-4�������

| 110

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE "-$)� -"��%�$ 5�T*.�� ��-,0$/ �/0-�.!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE "-$)� -"��%���� IJK:?EI :;B IF79?E!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE !$'.#$''��)0T 5��(0T*

� .+' "�-�����C7GK;J7I�:;�HGK?J;9JKH7 ;D��>?B;!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7�!$'.#$''��)0T 5��(0T*5

!?=KH7� � � '?LHE&0+ -� -"��-�- $. -�0( (*/*� 1�)�1 -& '�H9>?J;9JKH7B�(E:;B�';7:�JE��;I?=D!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

������*)-",�,'+�)-�� �0�%�%�)-�,�+

+7HJ?D:E�F7H7�EKJH7�<EHC7�:;�78EH:7H�EI�CE:;BEI�JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I �9ECFEIJE�F;B;I

FHjFH?EI� 7HGK?J;JEI� 9ECE� FH\N?I� ;� 9ECFB;J7D:E E� GK7HJE7=HKF7C;DJE FE:;I;

9?J7H!H7DA� ";>HO9ECE� E� H;FH;I;DJ7DJ;� :;� :E?I FjBEI� D7� C;JE:EBE=?7� :;� FHE@;JE

�<?=� ��� �;�KC�B7:E�E�:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:; KC�:EI�C7?I�IE<?IJ?97:EI FHE=H7C7�:E

C;H97:E� :;� KC I?IJ;C7� :?=?J7B� F7H7� 7� FHE:Kb`E� :;� FHE@;JEI�;� ;C� EKJH7

;NJH;C?:7:;�7�C7DKJ;Db`E�:7 <?:;B?P7b`E 7EI�CdJE:EI�:;�FHE:Kb`E�:;�C7GK;J;I

;C�FHE<KI`E�" #-4�������

Page 143: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 111

��)-�,�+������(�$d�E� J?JKBE�:7�FK8B?97b`E�<?=� ���GK;� H;B7J7�7�7KB7� ?D7K=KH7B�:;

+7KBE�(;D:;I� :7� -E9>7� ;C KC� 9KHIE H;7B?P7:E� D7� �7I7� :;� 1?B7DEL7� �HJ?=7I ;C

�KH?J?87� GK;� J;L;� 9ECE� J;C7� s(7GK;J;t �<?= ��� ;� JH7JEK� :E ;DJ;D:?C;DJE� :E

7KJEH� DE I;K FHE9;IIE� :;� FHE@;JE*� ;D9EDJHE�9EC :KH7b`E� :;� :E?I� C;I;I <E?

:;IJ?D7:E� 7� KC� B?C?J7:E� =HKFE� :; ;IJK:7DJ;I� ; FHE<?II?ED7?I� :7� \H;7�:E� GK7B� 7

7KJEH7�<;P F7HJ;�; JH7J7L7�:E�:;FE?C;DJE�?Dd:?JE�:E7HGK?J;JE�IE8H;�I;K�CdJE:E�:;

JH787B>E�-;<;H?D:EI;�7�CE:;B7=;C��sR�7�C7GK;J;�9ECE�9HEGK?I ��C7GK;J;�GK;

LE9e� <7P� 9ECE� KC� ;DI7?E :7GK?BE� GK;� ;IJ7� ?C7=?D7D:E�ECE� E� FE;J7� GK7D:E

H78?I97 �� C7GK;J;� 7GK?� d� KC� ?DIJHKC;DJE� GK; <7P� F7HJ;� :E� FHE9;IIE� :;

JH787B>E7I C7GK;J;I <;?J7I� ;C IEB?:`E�� F7H7� D?D=KdC� L;Ht �-*�#��� ����� .;� 7

C7GK;J;� d� E� ;NF;H?C;DJE :E� GK;� I;� ;IJ\� ?C7=?D7D:E� ;D9EDJH7CEI� D;IJ7

C7D?<;IJ7b`EKC�:?\BE=E�;DJH;�CE:;BEI�;�?:;?7I GK;�9ED:KP?H\�7E�FHE@;JE�<?D7B?P7:E

;�GK;�I;�:;I;DLEBL;�:;�<EHC7�=H7:7J?L7��L7B;D:EI;�:;�H;FH;I;DJ7bl;I�C7J;H?7?I

� E8H7 :;�+7KBE�(;D:;I�:7�-E9>7�7J;D:; :;�KC7�C7D;?H7�;<?97P ;�;IJ\� ?DI;H?:7

9ECE�H;<;HeD9?7�8?8B?E=H\<?97�8\I?97�D7I�;C;DJ7I�:;�:?I9?FB?D7I�GK;�JH787B>7C ;IJ7

\H;7� :;� 9ED>;9?C;DJE�� <7PI;� ?CFEHJ7DJ;� ;� <KD:7C;DJ7B� KC7� DEL7� FK8B?97b`E

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE ���-*�#��+(7GK;J;I�:;�+7F;B!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE" #-4�!�H9>?J;9JKH;�FHE9;II /7BAI�";>HO!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� �����7HJ7P�:7 *<?9?D7�:;�(7GK;J;9EC��+7KBE (;D:;I�:7�-E9>7 q s*�CE:;BE;DGK7DJE�9ECFH;;DI`E�:;�FHE@;JEt!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ��� /7BA�";>HO!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 144: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 112

9EDJ;D:E� EI� E8@;JEI� CE:;B7:EI� �E8H7I� :;� +7KBE� (;D:;I� :7� -E9>7�� ;� I;KI

H;87J?C;DJEI�DE�:;I;DHEB7H�:E�9KHIE �<?= ���

*I�CE:;BEI�;�C7GK;J;I�I;CFH;�<EH7C�C?DK9?EI7C;DJ;�?DL;IJ?=7:EI��?:;DJ?<?97:EI

;N7C?D7:EI�� JH7J7:EI�� ?DJ;HFH;J7:EI� ;� =;D;HEI7C;DJ;� 9ECF7HJ?B>7:EI FEH

;IJK:?EIEI� GK; F;H9EHH;C7� F;IGK?I7� IE8H;� 7I� H;B7bl;I� ;DJH;� E� FHE@;JE� :;

7HGK?J;JKH7� ;� 7� CE:;B7=;C� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B .;D:E� ;B7� E� oD?9E� C;?E� :;

H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� GK;� 9ECF7HJ?B>7� 7I� GK7B?:7:;I� ?D;H;DJ;I� ;� ?D:?IIE9?\L;?I� :7

7HGK?J;JKH7� �C7J;H?7B?:7:;�� ;IF79?7B?:7:;� ;� FHE9;IIE� 9EDIJHKJ?LE� �-*5 ./-�/ )�

�� �� ������ ������ ������ ������ ������ � '?D=K7=;C� ;� 7I� :?<;H;DJ;I� ;IJH7Jd=?7I� :;

;NFH;II`E� :7I� ?:;?7I� 9H?7J?L7I� I`E� FH?CEH:?7?I D7� ;B78EH7b`E� :;� FHE@;JEI

7HGK?J;JkD?9EI��(�-�)"*)$��� ��*'$1 $-����� �

NF;H?eD9?7I� I;HL;C�:;�87I;�F7H7 E�F;DI7C;DJE IE8H;�7I� 7J?L?:7:;I�:?:\J?97I�:;

;DI?DE� ;C� KC� 9ED@KDJE� :;� :?I9?FB?D7I�� <KD:7C;DJ7B� F7H7� E� :;I;DLEBL?C;DJE� :E

!?=KH7� ��� �KHIE�+7KBE�(;D:;I�:7�-E9>7�D7��7I7�1?B7DEL7 �HJ?=7I!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 145: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 113

;IJK:7DJ;� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7� :KH7DJ;� 7� =H7:K7b`E��� ;NF;H?eD9?7 :E� KIE�:;�CE:;BEI

JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I�9ECE�<EHC7�:;�7FH;D:?P7:E�FE:;�I;H�L;H?<?97:7 D7I�:?I9?FB?D7I�:;

>?IJjH?7� ; J;EH?7� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7� ;� KH87D?ICE ;C� :?L;HI7I� ;I9EB7I� .`E ;B;I

?DIJHKC;DJEI� ;II;D9?7?I� :;� H;<B;N`E� ;� ;B78EH7b`E :E� FHE@;JE�� ;IF;9KB7D:E

9H?J?97C;DJ; E� F7II7:E� 7HGK?J;JkD?9E� ;� 7� 9ED9H;J?P7b`E :E� FEJ;D9?7B� :7� >?IJEH?7

9ECE KC7�<;HH7C;DJ7�;II;D9?7B�:E�:;I?=D���..*������� !0%$*&��������

0C7� C;JE:EBE=?7� :;� CE:;B7=;C� GK;� ;DJ;D:;� E� FHE@;JE� 9ECE� KC� FHE9;IIE�

FH;IIKFl;� I;K :;I;DLEBL?C;DJE� FHEFKBI?ED7:E� FEH� CdJE:EI� :?D^C?9EI�� 9K@7

7FH;;DI`E� :;L;� I;� ?D?9?7H� DEI� 7DEI� <EHC7J?LEI� :E� <KJKHE� FHE<?II?ED7B�� F;HC?J; 7

H;<B;N`E�9H?J?97�;�FHEF?9?7 9EDJ?DK?:7:;�:;�:?L;HI?<?97:EI�I;=C;DJEI�:7�CE:;B7=;C

;C�7HGK?J;JKH7� 7I�JEHD7C�H;L;B7:EH7I�;�?DJ;DI7I��I�FHEFEI?bl;I�JeC�E ?DJK?JE�:;

;B78EH7H� ;� 7FH?CEH7H� 7I� ;IJH7Jd=?7I� :;� ;DI?DE� ;� 7FH;D:?P7=;C�GK;�F;HC?J7C�7EI

;IJK:7DJ;I� KJ?B?P7H� ?DIJHKC;DJEI� :;� 9H?7b`E� F7H7� E:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE� :;� ?:;?7I� GK;

7=H;=K;C�L7BEH;I�D7 IK7 <EHC7b`E ���-1�'#*������� . "�''� ����� $.#$���������

'�-��� ����

(E:;BEI�;C�;I97B7�I`E�:;�L7BEH�?D;IJ?C\L;B�F7H7�E�7HGK?J;JE�7E�L;H?<?97H�FHE@;JEI�;

;IJ78;B;9;H�<EHC7I��C7I�J7C8dC�C;B>EH7H�7�9ECKD?97b`E�;DJH;�IK7I�FHEFEIJ7I�;

EI�;DLEBL?:EI�D7I�;J7F7I�:;�FB7D;@7C;DJE�;�9EDIJHKb`E 0C�CE:;BE�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B

<7B7� KC7� BfD=K7�� GK;� FE:;� I;H� ;DJ;D:?:7� :;� ?C;:?7JE�� ;� F;HC?J;� GK;� 7I� H;B7bl;I

;IF79?7?I� I;@7C� F;H9;8?:7I� ;C� KC� oD?9E� EB>7H� � I;B;b`E :;� CE:;BEI� :; 97I7I

?9kD?97I :E� Id9KBE� 33 �<?=� ��� �&0-- )/�� ����� ; 7� L;H?<?97b`E :E� I?=D?<?97:E

7HJfIJ?9E�:E�CE:;BE�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�DE�C;H97:E�:;�JH787B>E��H;KD?D:E�KC7�F;IGK?I7

:EI� C;B>EH;I� CE:;BEI� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� F7H7� 7HGK?J;JEI�� :;I?=D;HI� :;� ?DJ;H?EH;I�

F7?I7=?IJ7I�;�KH87D?IJ7I��7II?C�9ECE�7�;N;CFB?<?97b`E�:;�<78H?97DJ;I�CKD:?7?I�;�7I

FH?D9?F7?I� ;CFH;I7I� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� <EHD;9;C KC7� H?97� <EDJ;� :;� ?DIF?H7b`E� ;

9EDJH?8K?b`E F7H7�7�F;IGK?I7�9?;DJf<?97 �<?=� ������&$&*� ����

Page 146: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 114

������ $�/9�+��'�%'��$�*

IJ; =HKFE�78EH:7�H;<B;Nl;I�IE8H;�E�7JE�:;�CE:;B7H ��<EHC7�9EC�GK;�EI�7HGK?J;JEI

KI7C�CE:;BEI�F7H7�FHE@;J7H�IK7I�?:;?7I�;�CEIJH7H 9ECE�7BJ;H7bl;I�DEI�C7J;H?7?I�;

FHE9;IIEI� 9EDJH?8KfH7C� F7H7� 7� 97F79?J7b`E� :;� CE:;BEI� ;NFH;II?LEI �<?=

� ���(**)������ (dJE:EI� :;� JH787B>E� :;� C7GK;J?IJ7I� 9EDJ;CFEH^D;EI� I;

7FH;I;DJ7C� 7JH7LdI� :;� ;DJH;L?IJ7I� ;� ;DI7?EI� ;NFB?97J?LEI �<?=� �� ; <?= ����

�*.2�'�� ����� (*--$.�� ����� I9H?JjH?EI� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7� ?DJ;HD79?ED7?I

7FH;I;DJ7H7C� ;IJK:EI� :;� 97IE� 9EC� KIE� :;�CE:;BEI �($4*0)"�� �� �� *� JfJKBE

sC7DK7Bt� D`E� 9ED:?P� ;N7J7C;DJ;� 9EC�E� 9EDJ;o:E� :7� E8H7�� KC7� L;P� GK;� D`E� >\

D;D>KC� ?D:f9?E� IE8H;� E� 9ED9;?JE� :E� B?LHE�� IE8H;� E� FHE9;IIE� :;� I;B;b`E� �� EH:;C

7B<78dJ?97� :EI� 7HGK?J;JEI� F7H;9;� I;H� 7� oD?97� ;IJHKJKH7� GK;� E� ;:?JEH� FE:;H?7

;D9EDJH7H�F7H7�;IJ7�C7II7�:;�?C7=;DI�;�?D<EHC7bl;I �<?=� ���

!?=KH7 ����'?LHE &0-- )/��! .97B;�CE:;BI� >EKI;IE<�J>;���J>�9;DJKHO!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7 ����'?LHE �&$&*��� />;��HJ�E<�J>;�H9>?J;9JKH7B�(E:;B!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 147: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 115

�� J;D:eD9?7� H;B7J?L7C;DJ;�DEL7�D7�7HGK?J;JKH7��GK;�F7II7�FEH�KC�CdJE:E� Bo:?9E

GK;�78H;�E�FHE9;IIE�9H?7J?LE�F7H7�7�;IFEDJ7D;?:7:;�;�IKHFH;I7��F7II7�7�I;H�KC�<E9E

:;�?DL;IJ?=7b`E�DE�;DI?DE�:7�CE:;B7=;C�*I�9ECF7HJ?B>7C;DJEI�:;�H;IKBJ7:EI�:;

F;IGK?I7I�IE8H;�7 Jd9D?97��H;7B?P7:7I�;C�;I9B7H;9;C�;�?DIF?H7C�DEL7I�F;IGK?I7I��<?=

�����145*1$/$� �����;� �<?= �����145*1$/$������ IJK:EI� ;IJHKJKH7?I� :7� <EHC7

7HGK?J;JkD?97�;D<E97D:E�7I� H;B7bl;I�;DJH;� <EHb7�� <EHC7�;�;IF7bE� <7P;C�F7HJ;�:EI

FHE9;IIEI�:;�:;I;DLEBL?C;DJE�:;�:?<;H;DJ;I�?DL;IJ?=7bl;I�GK;�F7II7C�FEH�;�L7H?7C

:;� ?D;H;DJ;C;DJ;� ?DIJ\L;?I <EHC7I� F7H7� 78H7D=;H�CoBJ?FBEI� ;IF7bEI� ;C� ;:?<f9?EI

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE ($4*0)"�+ �EDIJHK9J?ED�7D:�;I?=D�(7DK7B���H9>?J;9JKH7B�(E:;BI�1EB� �;��!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE *.2�'�����H9>?J;9JKH7B (E:;BI�!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE (*--$.��((E:;BI��7H9>?J;9JKH;�7D:�J>;C?D?7JKH;!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� � ��'?LHE(**)�&7H;D (E:;B?D=�(;II7=;I��/>;�H9>?J;9J�7D:�J>;�(E:;B!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 148: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 116

F7H7� 7� 9H?7b`E� :;� CKBJ?97C7:7I� �<?= �����'$(� �� ���� �<?= ���� ��"&�/#$�$.�

�� �;�<?= �����"&�/#$�$.�������

��� �",�+ ����6%"�'+ ; ��)-�,�+

*I� I?J;I� I`E� ?DIJHKC;DJEI� CK?JE� ?CFEHJ7DJ;I� F7H7� 9ECKD?97H� ;� FEJ;D9?7B?P7H� 7I

?D<EHC7bl;I� 7� H;IF;?JE� :;� F;IGK?I7H� ;� JH787B>EI� 797:eC?9EI *I� I?J;I� 7FEDJ7:EI

JeC� 9ECE FHEFEI?b`E� KD^D?C;� ;IJ?CKB7H� E� F;DI7C;DJE� 7 ?DL;IJ?=7b`E� ;� 7

FHE:Kb`E�:7� 7HGK?J;JKH7� 7JH7LdI� :;�CE:;BEI� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I� �ECE� 97H79J;HfIJ?97

FH?D9?F7B� EI� ;D:;H;bEI� ;B;JHkD?9EI� I`E� ?DIJ?JK9?ED7?I� +;HJ;D9;C� 7� ;I9EB7I� :;

7HGK?J;JKH7�; KH87D?ICE

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE145*1$/$�. !EB:?D=�H9>?J;9JKH;� IF7J?7B�IJHK9JKH7B�7D:EH=7D?P7J?ED7B:?7=H7CI!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE�"&�/#$�$.���(E:KB7H�.JHK9JKH;I?D�:;I?=D�7D:7H9>?J;9JKH;!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE145*1$/$� ..KF;HIKH<79;I��<EB:?D=7I�7�C;J>E:�E<=;D;H7J?D=�<EHCI�<EH7H9>?J;9JKH;��FHE:K9JI7D:�<7I>?ED!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE�"&�/#$�$.���.�#$''$"��"+;H<EHC7J?L;";EC;JH?;I� /H7DI<EHC?D=�/;NJ?B;/;9>D?GK;I!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

!?=KH7� ����'?LHE'$(��% 99;DJH?9.JHK9JKH;I�?D�H9>?J;9JKH;!EDJ;��!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 149: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 117

I9EB7�/d9D?97�.KF;H?EH�:;��HGK?J;JKH7��;B�17BBcIq 0+�� IF7D>7�?I9?FB?D7�:;�(7GK;J;I

>JJF���MMM;JI7LKF9;:K�C7GK;J;I�97J�9JI?J<>JC��79;II7:E�;C

�������� � �<?=� ���

* I?J;�7FH;I;DJ7�EI CE:;BEI�;B78EH7:EI�D7�0+� :;�17BBcI GK; JeC 9ECE�FHEFjI?JE

;IJ78;B;9;H�7�L;H?<?97b`E�;�E�9ED>;9?C;DJE�I;KI�L7BEH;I�9ECE�H;9KHIEI�:;�7D\B?I;

FHE@;JK7B�� 7BdC� :;� FHEF?9?7H� KC� 9ED>;9?C;DJE� :EI� C7J;H?7?I� GK;� F;HC?J7C� KC

C7?EH� :ECfD?E� :;� 9ECFED;DJ;I� ;IJdJ?9EI *I� JH787B>EI :;I;DLEBL?:EI� F7H7� 7

:?I9?FB?D7 :;� C7GK;J;I FHEF?9?7C F7H9;H?7I q *I� 7BKDEI� JH787B>7C� 9ECE

9EB78EH7:EH;I�:; ?CFEHJ7DJ;I ;DJ?:7:;I q 9ECE�7 �7?N7��7J7BKDO7� �*�����;DJH;

+ECF?:EK�� EKJHE� FHE@;JE� :;� L?I?8?B?:7:; I`E� 7I� C7GK;J;I� ;B78EH7:7I� F7H7� 7

!KD:7b`E�"7K:? �<?=� � �

!?=KH7� ����I?J;�:7��?I9?FB?D7�:;�(7GK;J;I I9EB7�/d9D?97�.KF;H?EH�:;��HGK?J;JKH7�:;�17BBcI!EDJ;� >JJF���MMM;JI7LKF9;:K�C7GK;J;I�97J�9JI?J<>JC ;C��������� �

Page 150: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 118

0D?L;HI?:7:;�!;:;H7B�:E�-?E�"H7D:;�:E�.KB 0!-".� �H7I?B�?I9?FB?D7�:;�(7GK;J;I

>JJF���C7GK;J;IK<H=I8BE=IFEJ9EC8H���<?=� ��� 79;II7:E�;C�������� �

*� I?J;� 7FH;I;DJ7� 7� C7GK;J;� 9ECE� ?DIJHKC;DJE� :;� 7FE?E� D7� ?DL;IJ?=7b`E� ;

H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� :E� E8@;JE� 7HGK?J;JkD?9E�� CEIJH7� 7� 9ED<;9b`E� :;� C7GK;J;I� ;

C7J;H?7?I KJ?B?P7:EI� D7� :?I9?FB?D7� �� F\=?D7� ;B;JHkD?97� FEIIK?� 7B=KDI� 7J7B>EI� F7H7

EKJHEI� I?J;I� :;� C7GK;J;I�� 7BdC� :;� EH=7D?P7H� ;� 7FH;I;DJ7H� EI� JH787B>EI

:;I;DLEBL?:EI� FEH� I;KI� 7BKDEI� DEI� oBJ?CEI� 7DEI� )EC?D7BC;DJ;� EI� 7BKDEI� I`E

!?=KH7� � ��I?J;�:7� I9EB7�/d9D?97�.KF;H?EH�:;��HGK?J;JKH7�:;�17BBcI�?I9?FB?D7�:;�(7GK;J;I!EDJ;� >JJF���MMM;JI7LKF9;:K�C7GK;J;I�97J�9JI?J<>JC

Page 151: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 119

?:;DJ?<?97:EI� ;� IK7I� FHEFEIJ7I� C7J;H?7B?P7:7I� I`E� ;N?8?:7I� FEH� <EJE=H7<?7I� ;C

:?<;H;DJ;I�<7I;I�:7�:?I9?FB?D7 +7H7�KC7�<79?B?J7b`E�:7�?DI;Hb`E�:;�9EDJ;o:EI� E�I?J;

:?IFED?8?B?P7 KC� JKJEH?7B� F7H7� E� FHjFH?E� 7BKDE� <7P;H� IK7� ?DI;Hb`E CEDJ7D:E� IK7

F\=?D7��?DI;H?D:E�EI�J;NJEI�;NFB?97J?LEI�;�7I�?C7=;DI�:EI�CE:;BEI �<?=� ���

���� IJK:?EI�:;B�;IF79?E .JK:?;I�ED�IF79; (KI;K�:7I�(7GK;J;I0D?L;HI?:7:;�:;��K;DEI��?H;I���H=;DJ?D7!79KB:7:;�:;��HGK?J;JKH7 �?I9?FB?D7�:;�(7GK;J;I

!?=KH7� ����I?J;�:7 �?I9?FB?D7�(7GK;J;I q 0D?L;HI?:7:;�!;:;H7B�:E�-?E�"H7D:;�:E�.KB!EDJ;� >JJF���C7GK;J;IK<H=I8BE=IFEJ9EC8H� 79;II7:E�;C�������� �

!?=KH7� ��� /H787B>E�:E��BKDE�"KIJ7LE�.?BL7��� �� q 0D?L;HI?:7:;�!;:;H7B�:E�-?E�"H7D:;�:E�.KB!EDJ;� >JJF���C7GK;J;IK<H=I8BE=IFEJ9EC8H�

Page 152: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 120

>JJF���MMM<7:KK877H�I?J?EI����� �<?= ���

*� I?J;� 7FH;I;DJ7 E� (KI;K� :7I� (7GK;J;I� GK;� I;� ;D9EDJH7� D7� !79KB:7:;� :;

�HGK?J;JKH7�� �;I;D>E� ;� 0H87D?ICE� :7� 0D?L;HI?:7:;� :;� �K;DEI� �?H;I� � F\=?D7

;B;JHkD?97� 9EDJdC�;NFB?97bl;I�:;J7B>7I�:E�FHEFjI?JE�:E�CKI;K�� =H7D:;� I7B7�:;

;NFEI?b`E�CEIJH7�7�?DL;IJ?=7b`E�FHE=H;II?L7�:E�97CFE�7HGK?J;JkD?9E�CE:;HDE 9EC

C7GK;J;I� :;I;DLEBL?:7IFEH� 7BKDEI :?I9?FB?D7� :;� C7GK;J;I :7� <79KB:7:;� :;

�HGK?J;JKH7� �<?=� ���� *� I?J; :;B?C?J7� FEH� 97J;=EH?7I EI� CE:;BEI� JH?:?C;DI?ED7?I

�J;CFE�� J;HH?JjH?E�� BKP ;J9� GK;� 9EDIJ?JK;C�KC 7CFBE� 9ECFeD:?E� :7I� E8H7I�C7?I

?CFEHJ7DJ;I�:E�Id9KBE�33

�;DJHE�:;� IJK:EI�#?IJjH?9EI�:;�*8H7I�+o8B?97I�;�0H87D?ICE � #*+0� IF7D>7

!?=KH7� ����I?J;�:E�(KI;K�:7I�(7GK;J;I�!��0�0��!EDJ;� >JJF���MMM<7:KK877H�I?J?EI�����

!?=KH7� ��� (KI;K�:7I�(7GK;J;I�!��0�0�� q L?JH?D;�;�?DJ;H?EH�:7�I7B7!EDJ;�!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 153: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 121

>JJF���MMMCKI;EL?HJK7B9;:;N;I�

NFEI?b`E�L?HJK7B�:;�C7GK;J;I����EB;b`E�:;�C7GK;J;I�<E?�9H?7:7�7�F7HJ?H�:;�JE:7I

7I�;NFEI?bl;I�GK;�EH=7D?P7:7�DE��;DJHE�:;� IJK:EI�#?IJjH?9EI�:;�*8H7I�+o8B?97I�;

0H87D?ICE� � #*+0� D7� IF7D>7 *� I?J;� CEIJH7� I;K� JH787B>E� :;� ?DL;IJ?=7b`E� ;C

:?<KD:?H�7�>?IJjH?7�;�7�Jd9D?97 :7I�E8H7I�Fo8B?97�:E�KH87D?ICE��JH7LdI�:7I�F\=?D7I

;B;JHkD?97I��E� B;?JEH�FE:;�9ED>;9;H�7 ;NFEI?bl;I� ?J?D;H7DJ;I�:E�9;DJHE*� <HKJE�:7I

;NFEI?bl;I :E � #*+0 FE:;�I;H�L?IJE�D7�F\=?D7 9EC�KC7�9EB;b`E :; C7GK;J;I�;

CE:;BEI�IE8H;�7�>?IJjH?7�:7I�E8H7I�Fo8B?97I

NFEI?b`E�:;�(7GK;J;I��EDJ;CFEH^D;7I :E�Id9KBE�330D?L;HI?:7:; :; '7 .;H;D7� �>?B;!79KB:7:;�:;��HGK?J;JKH7 q �?I9?FB?D7#?IJEH?7�:7�7HGK?J;JKH7�9EDJ;CFEH^D;7

!?=KH7� ��� .?J;�:E � #*+0�� IF7D>7!EDJ;� >JJF���MMMCKI;EL?HJK7B9;:;N;I�

!?=KH7� ��� (7GK;J;�:7�FEDJ;�:;��O7B7�;��7J;:H7B�:;�(7D?B7�� IF7D>7!EDJ;� >JJF���MMMCKI;EL?HJK7B9;:;N;I�

Page 154: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 122

>JJF���MMM7HGKBI9B��� �����;NFEI?9?ED:;C7GK;J7I7HGK?J;9JKH79EDJ;CFEH7D;7��NN�

*� I?J;� ;N?8;� 7� (EIJH7� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7 s��33t :E� 9KHIE� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7

9EDJ;CFEH^D;7� :;� �� ��)7I� F\=?D7I� E8I;HL7CI;� E8H7I� :;� :?L;HIEI� 7HGK?J;JEI�

f9ED;I� :E� 9;D\H?E� CE:;HDE� GK;� 79;H97� EI� 7DEI� :;� � �� 7� ���� I;D:E� FEIIfL;B

?:;DJ?<?97H7�KJ?B?P7b`E�:;�DEL7I�Jd9D?97I�9EDIJHKJ?L7I�F7H7�7�dFE97

�7D9E�:;�:7:EI�:;�C7GK;J;I�-�#$(*� '.�7HJ;�:7�CE:;B7=;C

!?=KH7� ��� NFEI?b`E�:;�(7GK;J;I��EDJ;CFEH^D;7I�DE�Id9KBE�33!EDJ;��>JJF���MMM7HGKBI9B��� �����;NFEI?9?ED:;C7GK;J7I7HGK?J;9JKH79EDJ;CFEH7D;7��NN�

!?=KH7� ��� (7GK;J;I :; �EDJ;CFEH^D;7I�DE�Id9KBE�33��7BKDEI�0D?L;HI?:7:;'7�.;H;D7���>?B;!EDJ;��>JJF���MMM7HGKBI9B��� �����;NFEI?9?ED:;C7GK;J7I7HGK?J;9JKH79EDJ;CFEH7D;7��NN�

Page 155: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 123

>JJF���7H9>?CE:;BI?D<E�

�ECE� J7H;<7� FH?D9?F7B FHEFl;� 7� 9H?7b`E� :;� KC� 87D9E� :;� :7:EI� :;7HGK?LEI 9EC

<EJEI :; CE:;BE�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�*�I?J;�I;�:?L?:;�;C�:?<;H;DJ;I� JjF?9EI�9ECE��FEH

;N;CFBE� KC7�I;b`E�H;I;HL7:7�F7H7�7�9ECFH7�:;�B?LHEI�;�C7J;H?7?I�F7H7�;B78EH7b`E

:;� C7GK;J;I� *<;H;9;� J7C8dC� ;IF7bE� F7H7� 7� CE:;B7=;C�CKD:?7B�� :?L?:?:7� FEH

F7fI;I�� 7II?C� 9ECE KC7� B?IJ7=;C� F7H7� 8KI97� FEH� DEC;� :EI� 7HGK?J;JEI� .;=KD:E

;II7I� IK8:?L?Il;I�;D9EDJH7I;�KC�I;JEH� H;I;HL7:E�7EI� 9ECFED;DJ;I :;�C7GK;J;I

�<?=KH7� >KC7D7�� \=K7�� 97HHEI�� BKP;I�GK;� JH7P;C� <EJEI� :;� FHE:Kbl;I� :;� :?L;HIEI

9EB78EH7:EH;I� D9EDJH7I; J7C8dC�E� =HKFE�:EI�C7J;H?7?I� �79HfB?9E�� 87BI7��C;J7B�

I;CFH;�;N;CFB?<?97:EI�FEH�C;?E�:;�C7GK;J;I�9EDJ;CFEH^D;7I

��� �/('+"39�+ ; �'+,*�+��:�$"��+ � �'$�39�+

!?=KH7� ��� .?J; �H9>?CE:;BI q 87D9E�:;�:7:EI!EDJ;� >JJF���7H9>?CE:;BI?D<E�

!?=KH7� � ��(7GK;J;F?;H9O��9ECF7DO q$=H;@7:H7OJED=H;D��'ED:H;I�!EDJ;� >JJF���7H9>?CE:;BI?D<E�

!?=KH7� ��� (7GK;J;�+;J;H� ?I;C7D q#EKI;�3�� ���!EDJ;� >JJF���7H9>?CE:;BI?D<E�

Page 156: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 124

*� H;9ED>;9?C;DJE� :7� 7KJEDEC?7� :E� CE:;BE� d� H;B7J?L7C;DJ;� H;9;DJ;� +7H;9;

IKHFH;;D:;DJ;� GK;�� 7Jd� FEK9E� J;CFE�� D`E� >7L?7� GK7I;� D;D>KC7� F;IGK?I7

797:eC?97�IE8H;�E�F7F;B�:E�CE:;BE�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�DE�Id9KBE�33� C8EH7�;N?IJ7C

CK?JEI� B?LHEI� F7:HED?P7:EI�� GK;� 7FEDJ7C�F7H7�;II7�C;JE:EBE=?7� 9EDIJHKJ?L7� 9EC

?D:?97J?LEI� :;� KJ?B?P7b`E� :;� C7J;H?7?I�� D`E� >\� KC� =K?7� 9EDJ;CFEH^D;E� F7H7

B;=?J?C7H�E�>?IJjH?9E�:7�CE:;B7=;C�EK�:;I9H;L;H�9ECE�7 CE:;B7=;C�d�?DI;H?:7�;C

FHE9;IIEI� FHE@;JK7?I� D7� 7HGK?J;JKH7 �;I:;� C;7:EI� :E� Id9KBE� 3$3�� ;I97L7bl;I

JHEKN;H7C� Z� BKP� :?L;HIEI� E8@;JEI� 97H79J;H?P7:EI� 9ECE� CE:;BEI� H;:KP?:EI� 9EC

<EHC7I�7HGK?J;JkD?97I

�E�BED=E�:E�Id9KBE�33��;II7I�F;b7I�F7II7H7C�7�<7P;H�F7HJ;�:;�9EB;bl;I�;IF;9f<?97I

:;�79EH:E�9EC�KC7�:?L?I`E�=;E=H\<?97��CE:;BEI ;=fF9?EI��=H;=EI��?D97I�;J9

-;<;HeD9?7I�7DJ;H?EH;I�7E�Id9KBE�33�I`E�;C�DoC;HE�F;GK;DE��?D:?H;J7I�;�E8I9KH7I

)7I� :d97:7I� :;� ������� @KDJ7C;DJ;� 9EC� EKJH7I� <EHC7I� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E

7HGK?J;JkD?97��E�CE:;BE�9EC;bEK�7�7JH7?H�7�7J;Db`E�9ECE�KC�E8@;JE�;C�I?�C;ICE

*I� 7HJ?=EI� <EH7C� ;I9H?JEI� ;� ;NFEI?bl;I� ?D7K=KH7:7I�� CKI;KI� JEC7H7C� DELE

?DJ;H;II;�F;B7�9EB;b`E�:;�CE:;BEI

�JK7BC;DJ;��7I�C7GK;J;I�;IJ`E�:?IJH?8Kf:7I�F;BEI�CKI;KI�;�KD?L;HI?:7:;I�:;�JE:E

E� CKD:E� NFEI?bl;I� 9EC� ;II;� <E9E� ;H7C� ?D9ECKDI� 7DJ;I� :EI� 7DEI� ���� *I

CE:;BEI� I;CFH;� <EH7C� ?D9BKf:EI� 7E� B7:E� :;� EKJH7I� <EHC7I� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E

7HGK?J;JkD?97��9ECE�I;�L?K�D7 �*�!",��,-*�$���& -�'���'.���'*#��D7 �'&�'&7+��'1�$

�����%1� �-%%�* ;� DE� .7B`E� :;� +7H?I� .K7� ;N?8?b`E� E9EHH;K� IEC;DJ;� 9EC� 7

<?D7B?:7:;�:;�7KN?B?7H�D7�?BKIJH7b`E�:EI�FHE@;JEI�:;I;DLEBL?:EI�D7GK;B;�F;HfE:E

(7I�� KC7� DEL7� 9EDI9?eD9?7� :E� CE:;BE� 9ECE� E8@;JE� <BEH;I9?7� DE� CKD:E� �

;NFEI?b`E�:;�*N<EH:�;C� �� �� $D=B7J;HH7�� 79EDJ;9;K� 9EC E�FHEFjI?JE�:;�:;9B7H7H

GK;�E�I;K�E8@;J?LE�FH?D9?F7B�;H7�CEIJH7H�E�L7BEH�:;�CE:;BEI�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7

1?DJ;�;�GK7JHE�7DEI�:;FE?I��J7C8dC�D7�$D=B7J;HH7��%E>D�2?BJED BO�EH=7D?PEK�s�!�

�*�!",��,7+� �"+"'&9 D7� 0D?L;HI?:7:;� :;� )EJJ?D=>7C� F7H7� ;NFBEH7H� 7� >?IJjH?7 ;� 7I

<KDbl;I� :EI� CE:;BEI� DE� FHE@;JE� 7HGK?J;JkD?9E� II;� ;L;DJE� <E?� 7FH;I;DJ7:E

Page 157: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 125

E<?9?7BC;DJ;�9ECE�7�FH?C;?H7�;NFEI?b`E�:;�CE:;BEI�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�7�I;H�H;7B?P7:7

D7� $D=B7J;HH7� *?JE� 7DEI� C7?I�� ;C� ����� E� (KI;K� 1?9JEH?7� ;� �B8;HJ� H;9;8;K� 7

;NFEI?b`E�s�;I;D>EI ;�(E:;BEI�:;�;:?<f9?EI�L?JEH?7DEIt

�;IJ7�C7D;?H7� ?IEB7:7;� :;� 9ED>;9?C;DJE�Fo8B?9E� F;GK;DE�� 7I� ;NFEI?bl;I� ?D?9?7?I

H;?L?D:?97H7C� 7� H;F;J?:7� FH;9;:eD9?7� :EI� CE:;BEI C� ����� KC7� ;NFEI?b`E� GK;

H;JH7J7L7� KC� 7F7D>7:E� =;H7B� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7 <E?� FHE:KP?:7� F;B7� .E9?;:7:;

.>;<<?;B:�I� ;NFEI?bl;I� I;� ?D9KC8?H7C�:;�CEIJH7H� EI�CE:;BEI� ;C� L\H?EI� ;L;DJEI

?DJ;HD79?ED7?I�H;9ED>;9?:EI��:;IJ797D:E�E�I;K�F7F;B�DE�FHE9;IIE�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�;

7KC;DJ7D:E� I?=D?<?97J?L7C;DJ;� 7� H;B;L^D9?7� :;II;� H;9KHIE� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� �

<?D7B?:7:;�FH?D9?F7B�:;�97:7�KC7�:;II7I�CEIJH7I��DE�;DJ7DJE��<E?�7�:;�;I9B7H;9;H�KC

:;J;HC?D7:E� F;HfE:E� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� KI7D:E� CE:;BEI� 9ECE� C;?E� :;� ;IJK:E� �

?:;?7�:;�LeBEI�9ECE�E8@;JEI�;C�I;K�FHjFH?E�:?H;?JE��F7H7�7BdC�:E�I;K�F7F;B�;C�KC

FHE@;JE��;�9ECFH;;D:;H�7�IK7 ?CFEHJ^D9?7�F;H7DJ;�E�7KJEH DE�97IE�E�7HGK?J;JE

<E?�FEK9E�9EDI?:;H7:7

)7�:d97:7�:;� �����D7�9ED:?b`E�:;� ?DL;IJ?=7J?LEI��EI�CE:;BEI� <EH7C�7F7H;9;D:E

9EC� KC7� <H;GKeD9?7� 97:7� L;P� C7?EH� D7� $D=B7J;HH7�� ;� FEIJ;H?EHC;DJ;� 7� ?D?9?7J?L7

;IJ;D:;KI;� Z� �CdH?97 8 ���� �+� �'��$9� 7FH;I;DJ7:7� ;C� );M� 4EHA� DE� 7DE� :;

�����FE:;� I;H�:;I9H?J7� 9ECE�7�FH?C;?H7�;NFEI?b`E� L;H:7:;?H7C;DJ;� 9;DJH7:7�DE

CE:;BE��;C8EH7� <EII;�:;IJ?D7:7�7� ?D9;DJ?L7H�7�KJ?B?P7b`E�:;�CE:;BEI� 9ED9;?JK7?I�

;C�FH?C;?HE�FB7DE��DE�FHE9;IIE�:;�FHE@;J7H��II?C�;L?:;D9?EK�+;J;H� ?I;DC7D��7E

7II?D7B7H� DE� FH?C;?HE� F7H\=H7<E� :E� J;NJE� :E� 97J\BE=E�� GK;� sEI� CE:;BEI�� 9ECE

:;I;D>EI� 7HGK?J;JkD?9EI�� FE:;H?7C� CK?JE� 8;C� J;H� KC7� ;N?IJeD9?7� 7HJfIJ?97� EK

9ED9;?JK7B� FHjFH?7�� H;B7J?L7C;DJ;� ?D:;F;D:;DJ;� :E FHE@;JE� GK;� ;B;I

H;FH;I;DJ7L7Ct �!-�(+/*)�;�&*'�*2.&$�� �� �F$�

�� D7JKH;P7� :E� CE:;BE� <E?� :;IJ797:7� ;C� KC7� IdH?;� :;� 7HJ?=EI� FK8B?97:EI� 9EC� 7

9EDJH?8K?b`E� :;� KC� =HKFE� :;� F7HJ?9?F7DJ;I� 9EDL?:7:EI�� GK;� ?D9BKf7� EI� DEC;I� :;

+;J;H� ?I;DC7D�� �>7HB;I� (EEH;�� -7?CKD:� �8H7>7C�� .J7DB;O /?=;HC7D �<?=� ����

(?9>7;B� "H7L;I�� �?7D7� �=H;IJ �<?=� ��� ; <?=� ����� (7H?E� "7D:;BIED7I� ;� -7<7;B

(ED;E� 1\H?EI� :;II;I� 7HGK?J;JEI� ;NFBEH7H7C� 7� <HEDJ;?H7� ;DJH;� E� :;I;D>E� ;� EI

Page 158: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 126

CE:;BEI�� ?D?9?7D:E� KC� :?\BE=E� IE8H;� 7� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� 7HGK?J;JkD?97� GK;� 7?D:7

9EDJ?DK7�+7H7� ?I;DC7D��E�CE:;BE� H;FH;I;DJ7L7�sKC7� ?:;?7�;C�I?�C;IC7�;�KC7

?:;?7�IE8H;�EI�E8@;JEIt��F7H7�/?=;HC7D��;H7�sKC7�?:;?7�IE8H;�?:;?7I��;C�L;P�:;�KC7

?:;?7�IE8H;�7HGK?J;JKH7t �!-�(+/*)�;�&*'�*2.&$�� �� � F���

IJ;� <E?� E� FEDJE� ;C� GK;� 7� ?D:;F;D:eD9?7� :E� CE:;BE� JEHDEKI;� H;9ED>;9?:7

78;HJ7C;DJ;��EI�CE:;BEI�7IIKC?H7C�KC DELE BK=7H�DE�9;D\H?E���;NFEI?b`E�I;HL?K

F7H7�7BJ;H7H�7�7J?JK:;�;C�H;B7b`E�7E�FHE9;IIE�FHE@;JK7B�D7�7HGK?J;JKH7���I?JK7b`E

:E�E8@;JE�JH?:?C;DI?ED7B�F7IIEK�7�J;H�KC7�H;B;L^D9?7�@7C7?I�L?IJ7��DJ;H?EHC;DJ;�7

;IJ;� ;L;DJE�� 7� ;N?8?b`E� ;IJ78;B;9?7I;� F;BEI� :;I;D>EI� 9ED9;?JK7?I�� FEHdC� EI

CE:;BEI� D`E� ;N;H9?7C� KC7� <KDb`E� ?CFEHJ7DJ;�� F7HJ?9?F7L7C� :E� FHE9;IIE� 9ECE

9E7:@KL7DJ;I� IJ7�L?I`E�<E?�KC�9EDL?J;�Z�H;<KJ7b`E�:;�GK;�7�DEL7�FHEFEIJ7�F7II7H?7

7�FEJ;D9?7B?P7HI;

*� DELE� <E9E� :;8HKbEKI;� J7C8dC� IE8H;� EI� E8@;JEI� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E

7HGK?J;JkD?97B?=7:EI� ZI� J;EH?7I� :7� 7HJ;� CE:;HD7� :E� F;HfE:E� ;C� GK;IJ`E� ;�� ;C

;IF;9?7B�� H;B79?ED7:EI� 7E� CEL?C;DJE� 9ED>;9?:E� 9ECE� �HJ;� �ED9;?JK7B�

97H79J;H?P7:E�FEH�KC7�CK:7Db7�DE�I;DJ?:E�:;�FHECEL;H�7�7HJ;�s?:;?7t�7�F7HJ?H�:7

?D9EHFEH7b`E�<fI?97���E8H7�:;�7HJ;�FE:;�I;H�L?IJ7�;II;D9?7BC;DJ;�9ECE�E�C7F7�:;

KC� FHE9;IIE� :;� F;DI7C;DJE�� KC� H;IKCE� L?IfL;B� :;� JE:EI� EI� F7IIEI�� GK;� <EH7C

D;9;II\H?EI� F7H7� E8J;H� KC� H;IKBJ7:E <?D7B� ;IF;9f<?9E� 7� I;H� 7B97Db7:E�� :7f� E� KIE

<H;GK;DJ;� :;� HjJKBEI� 9ECE� sFHE9;IIEt� ;� sI?IJ;C7t�� E GK;� I;� JEHDEK� C7?I

?CFEHJ7DJ;� D7 :E9KC;DJ7b`E� :E� FHE9;IIE� )7� L;H:7:;�� E� 97J\BE=E� :7� ;NFEI?b`E

!?=KH7� ����.J7DB;O�/?=;HC7D��!���",,$���'-+��"&�,!��$'-�+�� ���!EDJ;�>JJF���7H9>?L;E<7<<?D?J?;IJKC8BH9EC�FEIJ���� ���� ��IJ7DB;OJ?=;HC7DJ>;B?JJB;>EKI;?DJ>;9BEK:I�;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7I� ���;� �����;I;D>E�;�C7GK;J; �?7D7��=H;IJ� �'-+���'*���-+"�"�&�(7@EH97!EDJ;��>JJF���J7BB;H7L88BE=IFEJ9EC8H��� �� ��:?7D77=H;IJ97I7F7H7KDCKI?9E;D>JCB�;C���� ���� �

Page 159: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 127

s ��"���+��'��$t��FE:;�I;H�B?:E�9ECE�KC�C7D?<;IJE�:7��HJ;��ED9;?JK7B��;C�GK;�7I

;:?<?97bl;I� I`E� 7� s?D9EHFEH7b`E� <fI?97t� ;� EI� :;I;D>EI� ;� CE:;BEI� H;FH;I;DJ7C� 7

s?:;?7t��7�:E9KC;DJ7b`E GK;�7IIKC;�KC�DELE�I?=D?<?97:E

�FjI�;IJ;�CEC;DJE��:?L;HI7I�=7B;H?7I�:;�)EL7�4EHA� H;7B?P7H7C��;C�I;KI�;IF7bEI�

CEIJH7I�GK;�7FH;I;DJ7L7C�E CE:;BE�9ECE�7HJ;�s�'-+�+��'*���$�t�D7 ��' ��+,�$$"

��$�*1 �;IF7bE JH7:?9?ED7BC;DJ;� H;I;HL7:E� F7H7� 7� 9EDJ;CFB7b`E� :;� 8;B7I7HJ;I��

;C� ����� 7FH;I;DJEK�CE:;BEI� 9H?7:EI�FEH�KC�=HKFE�:;�7HGK?J;JEI��H7J7 $IEP7A?�

;C� ;IF;9?7B�� ;N?8?K� KC7� IdH?;� :;� E8@;JEI� ;D?=C\J?9EI� GK;� GK7BGK;H� 9EB;9?ED7:EH

=EIJ7H?7� :;� J;H� J?:E� ;C� IK7� F7H;:; �<?= ���� +;B7� FH?C;?H7� L;P�� E8I;HLEKI;� E

;DLEBL?C;DJE� :;� KC7� =7B;H?7� :;� 7HJ;� D;IJ;� F7F;B� �� L?IK7B?P7b`E� :EI� ;:?<f9?EI�

7DJ;H?EHC;DJ;� :?IFED?8?B?P7:7� :;� KC7� <EHC7� H;IJH?J7� Z� F?DJKH7�� ;I9KBJKH7� ;

<EJE=H7<?7�F7II7L7�7�JH7P;H�7�7HGK?J;JKH7�F7H7�E�:ECfD?E�:7�7HJ;�9EDJ;CFEH^D;7�*I

CE:;BEI�;�:;I;D>EI�<EH7C��;DJ`E��JEC7:EI�F;B7I�=7B;H?7I

)7I� ;N?8?bl;I� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7� JH7:?9?ED7?I�� EI�CE:;BEI� J7C8dC<EH7C� I;D:E� L?IJEI

IE8�KC7�DEL7� BKP�)7 NFEI?b`E�:;�1;H`E�:7 �'1�$������%1� ;C�'ED:H;I�� 7HJ;�;

7HGK?J;JKH7�� FEIJ7I� B7:E� 7� B7:E�� ;L?:;D9?7L7C� 7� IK7� ?CFEHJ^D9?7 9H;I9;DJ; 9ECE

E8@;JEI�:;�7HJ;

!?=KH7� ����(E:;BE�;C�9>KC8E���H7J7 $IEP7A?���IIE9?7J;I #EKI;�E<�)?D;�.GK7H;I�� ���!EDJ;��(EED��&7H;D�(E:;B?D=�(;II7=;I��F���

Page 160: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 128

*� CE:;BE� ;B78EH7:E� F;BE� ;IJo:?E� -?9>7H:� -E=;HI� +7HJD;HI>?F� F7H7� E� /H?8KD7B

KHEF;K�:EI��?H;?JEI�:E�#EC;C �<?= �����;C� IJH7I8KH=E��<E?�KC�:EI�JHeI�<?D7B?IJ7I

D7 �'1�$� �����%1 ;C� ���� *� @KB=7C;DJE� D`E� I;� F7KJEK� F;B7� 9EDI?:;H7b`E� :E

E8@;JE�EK�:E�:;I?=D��;�I?C�F;BE�CE:E�9ECE�7�F;b7�:;�7HJ;�JH7DIC?J;�I;K�9EDJ;o:E

� ��,"'&�$ ��$$�*1 '� �*, :;�27I>?D=JED�;�E ��$�22'��*�++" ;C�1;D;P7�IK8I?:?7H7C

7�;NFEI?b`E�?J?D;H7DJ;�:;� �����:;DEC?D7:7�s�HGK?J;JKH7�:7�-;D7I9;Db7�$J7B?7D7�:;

�HKD;BB;I9>?�7�(?9>;B7D=;BEt� GK;�H;KD?K�:;I;D>EI�;�C7GK;J;I

)E�7DE�:;� �����E��;DJHE��KBJKH7B�:;��7H9;BED7��;C�F7H9;H?7�9EC�EKJHEI�CKI;KI�;

9;DJHEI�:;�F;IGK?I7��EH=7D?PEK�7�;NFEI?b`E�s��+���+�+���$��$%�9� 9K@7�7FHEFH?7b`E

:E� JfJKBEEH?=?DEKI;:E� 9ED@KDJE� :;� E8@;JEI� :;I9E8;HJEI� DE� =?JE� I?JK7:EI� D7I

JKC87I��GK;� H;FHE:KP?7C�7I� 97I7I�:EI� <7B;9?:EI�F7H7�7II;=KH7HI;�:;�GK;�7�7BC7

E8J;H?7�KC�H;<o=?E�DE�<KJKHE�*�79;HLE�:7�;NFEI?b`E�s�I�97I7I�:7��BC7 q (7GK;J;I

7HGK?J;JkD?97I�:7��DJ?=K?:7:;�������7���������:���t H;KD?7C F;b7I�:;����CKI;KI

:;� JE:E� E� CKD:E�� F;HC?J?D:E� ;N?8?H� F;B7� FH?C;?H7� L;P� KC� 9ED@KDJE� :;� CE:;BEI

!?=KH7� ����(E:;BE�:;�-?9>7H:�-E=;HI +7HJD;HI>?FrI�:E�/H?8KD7B KHEF;K�:EI��?H;?JEI�:E�#EC;C!EDJ;��>JJF���MMM;�7H9>?J;9J9EKA�;L;DJI�7HJ?9B;6��67K9J?ED>JC�;C��� ���� �

Page 161: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 129

?DJ;=H7:EI� FEH� F;b7I� EH?=?D7?I�� 9EHH;IFED:;DJ;I� ZI� 7DJ?=7I� 9KBJKH7I� :E� =?JE�

(;IEFEJ^C?7���H;J7��"Hd9?7�;�-EC7

DJH;� EI� 7DEI� :;� ������ �� 7� ;NFEI?b`E� s/H?KD<E� :E� �7HHE9E q �HGK?J;JKH7� D7

KHEF7� ��� ���t <E?� H;9;F9?ED7:7� FEH� CKI;KI� :7� !H7Db7�� �7D7:\�� $J\B?7� ;

IJ7:EI� 0D?:EI� �B?�� 7FH;I;DJ7H7CI;� CE:;BEI� 7HGK?J;JkD?9EI� 9H?7:EI� F7H7

<?D7B?:7:;I� 9fL?97I�� C?B?J7H;I� ;� ;IJHKJKH7I� 9EC;H9?7?I�� ?=H;@7I�� F7B\9?EI�� H;I?:eD9?7I

F7HJ?9KB7H;I�� 8;C� 9ECE� EKJHEI� ;:?<f9?EI�� @KDJ7C;DJ;� 9EC� :;I;D>EI� H;B79?ED7:EI�

F?DJKH7I�� C;:7B>7I�� ;� C7GK;J;I� :;� ;I9KBJKH7�� ;L?:;D9?7D:E� IK7� 9EDJH?8K?b`E

<KD:7C;DJ7B� 9ECE� 7DJ;9;IIEH7� :;� :;I;D>EI� �I� C7GK;J;I� 9EDIJ?JKf7C� 7� 87I;

C7J;H?7B� F7H7� 7� ;B78EH7b`E� :;�F;HIF;9J?L7I� 7HGK?J;JkD?97I�� 9ECE�FEH� ;N;CFBE:7I

:;� <EDJ;I� HEC7D7I�� ;DJH;� ;B7I� 7 '&,�&�� ��" �-�,,*' "-%" �9� ����� D7 �"�22�

��.'&���FHE@;J7:7�FEH�"?7D�'EH;DPE��;HD?D?

�7H79J;HfIJ?97I :?<;H;D9?7:7I� <EH7C� E8I;HL7:7I GK7D:E� 7I� C7GK;J;I� F7II7H7C� 7

F7HJ?9?F7H�:;�9ED9KHIEI (E:;BEI�FK:;H7C�I;H�I;B;9?ED7:EI�F7H7�E�+HeC?E �!�*$�+

�'$$�+,'& :7� NFEI?b`E�:;�1;H`E�:7 �'1�$� �����%1 ;C� �����FEH� IK7�GK7B?:7:;

L?IK7B�;�78IJH7J7��9ECE�E�97IE�:E�9ED9;8?:E�FEH �$+'( �*�!",��,+ F7H7�E�F7L?B>`E�:7

NFE�#7DDEL;H����� �<?= �����ED:;�7�I;F7H7b`E�;DJH;�EI�E8@;JEI�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�;

EI�E8@;JEI�:;�7HJ;�JEHDEKI;�C;DEI�:;<?D?:7

!?=KH7� ����(E:;BE�;C�79HfB?9E��H;I?D7��FH7J7��7BKCfD?E�;�C7B>7�7H7C7:7���BIEF�H9>?J;9JI��+7L?B>`E� NFE�#7DDEL;H�����!EDJ;��(EED��&7H;D�(E:;B?D=�(;II7=;I��F���

Page 162: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 130

*KJHEI�;IF7bEI�9KBJKH7?I�:;�)EL7�4EHA��9ECE�FEH�;N;CFBE� 7 ��0��*',�,�! ��$$�*1

<?= ���� I;� 7B?7H7C ZI� DEL7I� CK:7Db7I� *I� CE:;BEI� F7II7H7C� 7� I;H� ;NFEIJEI

F;D:KH7:EI�D7I�F7H;:;I�9ECE�F?DJKH7I�EK�;I9KBJKH7I

*I�CE:;BEI�<EH7C�J7C8dC�E8I;HL7:EI�7 F7HJ?H�:;�EKJH7I�F;HIF;9J?L7I�;�7IIE9?7:EI

9EC� EI� E8@;JEI� :;� L7BEH� 9KBJKH7B� ;� ;IJdJ?9E� DEI� 7HGK?LEI� D79?ED7?I� �� 9H;I9;DJ;

9EJ7b`E�:;�CE:;BEI�:;�JH787B>E�=7D>EK�<EHb7�7�F7HJ?H�:;IJ;�F;HfE:E�;��;C�;IF;9?7B�

EI� C7?I� 7DJ?=EI� JEHD7H7CI;� :;I;@\L;?I� E8@;JEI� :; 9EB;9?ED7:EH;I� �;L?:E� Z

?CFEHJ^D9?7�:7:7�FEH�!H7DA�";>HO�Z�9EDIJHKb`E�:;�CE:;BEI�<?= �����I;K�;I9H?JjH?E

d�FHE9KH7:E�FEH�CK?J7I F;IIE7I�:?IFEIJ7I�7�F7=7H�C?B>l;I�:;�:jB7H;I�F7H7�9ECFH\

BEI�.`E��FH?D9?F7BC;DJ;��EI�CKI;KI�GK;�8KI97C�;II;I�E8@;JEI� KC7�L;P�GK;�;IJ;I

E9KF7C� KC� ;IF7bE� <fI?9E� GK;� EI� JEHD7� C;DEI� 7JH7;DJ;I� F7H7� 9EB;9?ED7:EH;I

F7HJ?9KB7H;I

!?=KH7� ���� NFEI?b`E �'1�$������%17+ �*�!",��,-*� �''%

!EDJ;��>JJF���L?C;E9EC��������� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7� ����(E:;BEI�FHE:KP?:EI�DE�;I9H?JjH?E�:;�!H7DA�";>HO!EDJ;� />;�27I>?D=JED�+EIJ�>JJF���MMMM7I>?D=JEDFEIJ9EC�B?<;IJOB;�C7=7P?D;�J>;CEDKC;DJM7H<H7DA=;>HOI;?I;D>EM;HC;CEH?7B��� ��������=$,�$,!L!06=7BB;HO>JCB�F>EJE� � ;C���� ���� �

Page 163: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 131

�DJ;I�:7�:d97:7�:;� �����;NF7D:?H7CI;�9EB;bl;I�DE�(KI;K�:;��HJ;�(E:;HD7�:;

)EL7�4EHA��<?=� � � ;�DE �'1�$� &+,",-,� '� �*","+!��*�!",��,+ ;C�'ED:H;I �<?=� ���

!?=KH7I� � ���9;HLE�:;�C7GK;J;I (KI;K�:;��HJ;�(E:;HD7�:;�)EL7�4EHA!EDJ;��>JJF���MMMH?87F?N9EC�?D:;N�FKF7�MEH:I;7H9>�I�=7BB;HO�A;O�29PE *?%J8�-B8�$��FF���� ;C��� ���� �

��

�����

���� �����

����� �����

�BL7H��7BJE��1??FKH?��?JO'?8H7HO��1??FKH?��!?DB^D:?7

';� �EH8KI?;H 1?BB7.7LEO;��+E?IIO

'EK?I $ &7>D �B<H;:);MJED�-?9>7H:I(;:?97B��0D?L;HI?JO�E<+;DDIOBL7D?7�+>?B7:;BF>?7

- �K9AC?DIJ;H!KBB;H �OC7N?ED��M;BB?D=(79>?D;��2?9>?J7

#;HPE= � :;(;KHED.?=D7B��EN7K<�:;C2EB<���7I;B

(?;I�L7D�:;H-E>;�!H?;:H?9>IJH7II;�.AOI9H7F;H�;HB?C

!?=KH7I� �����9;HLE�:;�C7GK;J;I �'1�$� &+,",-,�'���*","+!��*�!",��,+ ;C�'ED:H;I!EDJ;��>JJF���MMMH?87F?N9EC�?D:;NF>F�7�MEH:I;7H9>�I�=7BB;HO�A;O�29PE *?%J8�-B8�$��FF���� ;C��� ���� �

Page 164: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 132

�EDJ7I;�J7C8dC�9EC�EI�GK;�<EH7C�7:GK?H?:EI�F7H7�I;H;C�;NFEIJEI�;C�?DoC;H7I

9?:7:;I�:EI� 0��;�:7� KHEF7�1\H?EI�DELEI�CKI;KI�;DJH7H7C�D7�:?IFKJ7��?D9BK?D:E�E

��&��"�&� ��&,*�� �'* �*�!",��,-*�� ��,!�*$�&�+ �*�!",��,-*� &+,",-,�� ���� ��&,�*

D7�!H7Db7� �-,+!�+ �*�!",�#,-* �-+�-% ;C�!H7DA<KHJ�;�E �-+�-% '� �'��*& �*,

;C�.`E�!H7D9?I9E

�� ?CFB7DJ7b`E� :;� ;:?<f9?EI� :;� 9KD>E� 9KBJKH7B�� CK?JEI� :;B;I� H;I;HL7:EI� 7� I;H;C

CKI;KI D7� :d97:7� :;� ��� 9E?D9?:?K� 9EC� 7� 9H;I9;DJ;� 7J;Db`E� 797:eC?97� :7:7� 7E

FHE9;IIE� FHE@;JK7B� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� Z� FH\J?97� ;� Z� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7�

J;D:eD9?7�;IJ7�GK;�<BKf7�F7H7B;B7�7E�<E9E�:E�FHE9;IIE�D7I�7HJ;I�FB\IJ?97I��E�BED=E

:EI�7DEI� �����KC�?DJ;H;II;�797:eC?9E�;C�CE:;BEI�L7HH;K�JE:7�7� KHEF7��<7JE�GK;

FE:;�I;H�9EDIJ7J7:E�;C�;NFEI?bl;I�DEI�CKI;KI�;�;C�DKC;HEIEI�7HJ?=EI�:;�7HJ;�;

7HGK?J;JKH7�FK8B?97:EI�;C�F;H?j:?9EI�+\=?D7I�?DJ;?H7I�:;�@EHD7?I�:;:?97L7CI;�7EI

CE:;BEI� ��.-�����$��*, �!-�� �*�!",��,+7��'-*&�$�"��� ��++� &� �$/��; �*��*�!",�#,

��'� �<?=I ���

C� ����� DEI� 0��� 7 �*�!",��,-*�� ��/ ��*+�1 :;:?9EK� KC7� ;:?b`E� 7E� J;C7� :7

H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� 7HGK?J;JkD?97 �� ;:?b`E� <E? 79ECF7D>7:7 FEH� KC7� =H7D:;

GK7DJ?:7:;�:;� 7HJ?=EI� GK;� 7KC;DJ7H7C I?=D?<?97J?L7C;DJ;� 7� 79KCKB7b`E� JEJ7B� :;

B?J;H7JKH7� IE8H;� E� 7IIKDJE� !?D7BC;DJ;�� ;C� �� �� L?KI;� E� FH?C;?HE� ;I<EHbE� IE8

<EHC7� :;� B?LHE� F7H7� ?DL;IJ?=7H� E� CE:;BE� CE:;HDE� �!�� �*, '� ,!� �*�!",��,-*�$

�'��$� FEH��A?AE �KI9>

!?=KH7I� �����7F7�:7I�H;L?IJ7I�-;LK;�:;�B��HJ��!-�� �*�!",��,+7��'-*&�$�"��� ��++� &� �$/��; �*��*�!",�#, ��'�!EDJ;��;8EEAI9EC� ;C���� ���� �

| 132

�EDJ7I;�J7C8dC�9EC�EI�GK;�<EH7C�7:GK?H?:EI�F7H7�I;H;C�;NFEIJEI�;C�?DoC;H7I

9?:7:;I�:EI� 0��;�:7� KHEF7�1\H?EI�DELEI�CKI;KI�;DJH7H7C�D7�:?IFKJ7��?D9BK?D:E�E

��&��"�&� ��&,*�� �'* �*�!",��,-*�� ��,!�*$�&�+ �*�!",��,-*� &+,",-,�� ���� ��&,�*

D7�!H7Db7� �-,+!�+ �*�!",�#,-* �-+�-% ;C�!H7DA<KHJ�;�E �-+�-% '� �'��*& �*,

;C�.`E�!H7D9?I9E

�� ?CFB7DJ7b`E� :;� ;:?<f9?EI� :;� 9KD>E� 9KBJKH7B�� CK?JEI� :;B;I� H;I;HL7:EI� 7� I;H;C

CKI;KI D7� :d97:7� :;� ��� 9E?D9?:?K� 9EC� 7� 9H;I9;DJ;� 7J;Db`E� 797:eC?97� :7:7� 7E

FHE9;IIE� FHE@;JK7B� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� Z� FH\J?97� ;� Z� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7�

J;D:eD9?7�;IJ7�GK;�<BKf7�F7H7B;B7�7E�<E9E�:E�FHE9;IIE�D7I�7HJ;I�FB\IJ?97I��E�BED=E

:EI�7DEI� �����KC�?DJ;H;II;�797:eC?9E�;C�CE:;BEI�L7HH;K�JE:7�7� KHEF7��<7JE�GK;

FE:;�I;H�9EDIJ7J7:E�;C�;NFEI?bl;I�DEI�CKI;KI�;�;C�DKC;HEIEI�7HJ?=EI�:;�7HJ;�;

7HGK?J;JKH7�FK8B?97:EI�;C�F;H?j:?9EI�+\=?D7I�?DJ;?H7I�:;�@EHD7?I�:;:?97L7CI;�7EI

CE:;BEI� ��.-�����$��*, �!-�� �*�!",��,+7��'-*&�$�"��� ��++� &� �$/��; �*��*�!",�#,

��'� �<?=I ���

C� ����� DEI� 0��� 7 �*�!",��,-*�� ��/ ��*+�1 :;:?9EK� KC7� ;:?b`E� 7E� J;C7� :7

H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� 7HGK?J;JkD?97 �� ;:?b`E� <E? 79ECF7D>7:7 FEH� KC7� =H7D:;

GK7DJ?:7:;�:;� 7HJ?=EI� GK;� 7KC;DJ7H7C I?=D?<?97J?L7C;DJ;� 7� 79KCKB7b`E� JEJ7B� :;

B?J;H7JKH7� IE8H;� E� 7IIKDJE� !?D7BC;DJ;�� ;C� �� �� L?KI;� E� FH?C;?HE� ;I<EHbE� IE8

<EHC7� :;� B?LHE� F7H7� ?DL;IJ?=7H� E� CE:;BE� CE:;HDE� �!�� �*, '� ,!� �*�!",��,-*�$

�'��$� FEH��A?AE �KI9>

!?=KH7I� �����7F7�:7I�H;L?IJ7I�-;LK;�:;�B��HJ��!-�� �*�!",��,+7��'-*&�$�"��� ��++� &� �$/��; �*��*�!",�#, ��'�!EDJ;��;8EEAI9EC� ;C���� ���� �

| 132

�EDJ7I;�J7C8dC�9EC�EI�GK;�<EH7C�7:GK?H?:EI�F7H7�I;H;C�;NFEIJEI�;C�?DoC;H7I

9?:7:;I�:EI� 0��;�:7� KHEF7�1\H?EI�DELEI�CKI;KI�;DJH7H7C�D7�:?IFKJ7��?D9BK?D:E�E

��&��"�&� ��&,*�� �'* �*�!",��,-*�� ��,!�*$�&�+ �*�!",��,-*� &+,",-,�� ���� ��&,�*

D7�!H7Db7� �-,+!�+ �*�!",�#,-* �-+�-% ;C�!H7DA<KHJ�;�E �-+�-% '� �'��*& �*,

;C�.`E�!H7D9?I9E

�� ?CFB7DJ7b`E� :;� ;:?<f9?EI� :;� 9KD>E� 9KBJKH7B�� CK?JEI� :;B;I� H;I;HL7:EI� 7� I;H;C

CKI;KI D7� :d97:7� :;� ��� 9E?D9?:?K� 9EC� 7� 9H;I9;DJ;� 7J;Db`E� 797:eC?97� :7:7� 7E

FHE9;IIE� FHE@;JK7B� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7�� Z� FH\J?97� ;� Z� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� :7� 7HGK?J;JKH7�

J;D:eD9?7�;IJ7�GK;�<BKf7�F7H7B;B7�7E�<E9E�:E�FHE9;IIE�D7I�7HJ;I�FB\IJ?97I��E�BED=E

:EI�7DEI� �����KC�?DJ;H;II;�797:eC?9E�;C�CE:;BEI�L7HH;K�JE:7�7� KHEF7��<7JE�GK;

FE:;�I;H�9EDIJ7J7:E�;C�;NFEI?bl;I�DEI�CKI;KI�;�;C�DKC;HEIEI�7HJ?=EI�:;�7HJ;�;

7HGK?J;JKH7�FK8B?97:EI�;C�F;H?j:?9EI�+\=?D7I�?DJ;?H7I�:;�@EHD7?I�:;:?97L7CI;�7EI

CE:;BEI� ��.-�����$��*, �!-�� �*�!",��,+7��'-*&�$�"��� ��++� &� �$/��; �*��*�!",�#,

��'� �<?=I ���

C� ����� DEI� 0��� 7 �*�!",��,-*�� ��/ ��*+�1 :;:?9EK� KC7� ;:?b`E� 7E� J;C7� :7

H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� 7HGK?J;JkD?97 �� ;:?b`E� <E? 79ECF7D>7:7 FEH� KC7� =H7D:;

GK7DJ?:7:;�:;� 7HJ?=EI� GK;� 7KC;DJ7H7C I?=D?<?97J?L7C;DJ;� 7� 79KCKB7b`E� JEJ7B� :;

B?J;H7JKH7� IE8H;� E� 7IIKDJE� !?D7BC;DJ;�� ;C� �� �� L?KI;� E� FH?C;?HE� ;I<EHbE� IE8

<EHC7� :;� B?LHE� F7H7� ?DL;IJ?=7H� E� CE:;BE� CE:;HDE� �!�� �*, '� ,!� �*�!",��,-*�$

�'��$� FEH��A?AE �KI9>

!?=KH7I� �����7F7�:7I�H;L?IJ7I�-;LK;�:;�B��HJ��!-�� �*�!",��,+7��'-*&�$�"��� ��++� &� �$/��; �*��*�!",�#, ��'�!EDJ;��;8EEAI9EC� ;C���� ���� �

Page 165: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 133

�B=KDI�7HGK?J;JEI� 7FjI�7�9EDJ;NJK7B?P7b`E�:7�CE:;B7=;C�DE�F;HfE:E��H;IFED:;H7C

:?H;J7C;DJ; 9EC :?\BE=E�� 7FH;I;DJ7D:E� 7BJ;H7bl;I� ;C� IK7� C;JE:EBE=?7� :;

JH787B>E� )7� ;N?8?b`E� :;� *:?B; �;9G� ;� �;DEhJ �EHD;JJ;� s(E:;BEI� $CFHEL\L;?I�� E

CE:;BE�d�7�(;DI7=;Ct�� �����;�s#OF;H�/;DI`Et�� ����� 7�?CFEHJ^D9?7�:E�CE:;BE

9ECE� C;?E� :;� ;NFH;II`E� <E?� IK8B?D>7:7�� ; 7I� GK;IJl;I H;B79?ED7:7I7E CE:;BE

<EH7C�:?H;J7C;DJ;� JH7J7:7I� +;H9;8;I;�>7L;H�KC7�FHE:Kb`E�GK7I;� <H;DdJ?97�DEI

CE:;BEI� 9ED9;8?:EI� DEI� <?D7B� :EI� 7DEI ����� :;L?:E� 7� KC7� 9EDL;H=eD9?7� :;

<7JEH;I�0C�:;IJ;I��D`E�C;DEI�?CFEHJ7DJ;�GK; EI�:;C7?I��:;L;KI;�7EI�FHE8B;C7I

;9EDkC?9EIH;IKBJ7DJ;I� :E� F;JHjB;E� D7� :d97:7� :; ���� EI� GK7?I�� FH;II?ED7D:E� 7

?D:oIJH?7� :7� 9EDIJHKb`E� ;� H;:KP?D:E� EFEHJKD?:7:;I�� B;L7H7C�CK?JEI� 7HGK?J;JEI� 7

=7D>7H�9EC?IIl;I��JEHD7D:E�EI�CE:;BEI�KC�<E9E�:;�7J?L?:7:;�FHE:KJ?L7�;�9H?7J?L7

��H;CKD;H7b`E�F7=7�D7�;B78EH7b`E�:;�CE:;BEI�Ij�7KC;DJEK�:KH7DJ;�;IJ;�F;HfE:E

&7H?D -7I>?:�d >E@;� 9EDI?:;H7:E�KC�:EI�C7?EH;I�DEC;I�DE�C;H97:E�:;�:;I?=D�;

H;9ED>;9?:E� ?DJ;HD79?ED7BC;DJ;� F;BE� 7F;BE� FEF� <KJKH?IJ7� :;� IK7I� 9H?7bl;I� .K7

C?II`E�d :;CE9H7J?P7H�E�:;I?=D F7H7�<7P;H�F7HJ;�:7�L?:7�9EJ?:?7D7�;�F7H7�CK:7H�7

C;DJ7B?:7:;� >KC7D7� <7P;D:E� 7� B?=7b`E� ;DJH;� 7� 7DJ?=7� DEb`E� :;� :;I?=D� �7B=E

7IIE9?7:E� 7Jd� ;DJ`E� Z� ?:;?7� :;� FHE:KJEI� ;N9BKI?LEI� ;�CE8?B?\H?EI ED;HEIEI�� ;� I;K

I?=D?<?97:E�:;�>E@; q KC7�<;HH7C;DJ7�F7H7�7�9H?7b`E�:;�FHE:KJEI�FEFKB7H;I�GK;�I;

:?<;H;D9?;C�:EI�9ED9EHH;DJ;I�F;B7�;B;=^D9?7�;�L7DJ7=;DI�:;�KIE

+7H7� CK?JEI� 7HGK?J;JEI�� E� 7F;=E� 7EI� I;KI� CE:;BEI� L7?� 7BdC� :;� KC7� 7<;?b`E�

JH7DI<EHC7D:EI;�DE�IfC8EBE�:;�IK7�H;7B?P7b`E� II;�H;9KHIE�d�E C;?E�F;BE�GK7B�I;

F;H9;8;� 7� IK7� ?:;?7�� C7I� J7C8dC� H;FH;I;DJ7� 7� ?:;?7� ;C� IK7� FKH;P7� EH?=?D7B� :;

9ED9;Fb`E� +H;I;HL7I;� 7B?� E� ?:;7B� ?C79KB7:E�� KC7� ?C7=;C� CK?J7I� L;P;I� C7?I

8ED?J7�:E�GK;�7�H;7B?:7:;��ED:;�E�J;CFE�D`E�C7D9>7�E�79787C;DJE�;�7I�\HLEH;I

D`E� F;H:;C� 7I� <EB>7I� .;� KC� FHE@;JE� d� 787D:ED7:E�� E�CE:;BE� FE:;� I;H� 7� oD?97

FH;I;Db7�<fI?97�IE8H;L?L;DJ;�;�JEHD7HI;�KC�C;CEH?7B�9EC;CEH7J?LE�:;�KC�IED>E

797B;DJ7:E� *I� CE:;BEI� FE:;C� I;H� I?D=KB7HC;DJ;� <KD9?ED7?I� <;HH7C;DJ7I� :;

JH787B>E��C7I�J7C8dC�E�;B;C;DJE�GK;�FHEF?9?7�7�EFEHJKD?:7:;�:7�;NF;H?C;DJ7b`E

9EC� ?:;?7I� ?C7=?D\H?7I�:;� I;� 9H?7H� I;C�H;IFEDI78?B?:7:; ;IFd9?;�:;� B?8;HJ7b`E�7

Page 166: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 134

F7HJ?H�:E�CKD:E� H;7B ;� ?D9;DJ?L7C�KC7� ?DJ?C?:7:;�;IF;9?7B -7I>?: EI�:;I9H;L;

9ECE�s7B=E�CK?JE�FHjN?CE�7E�C;K�9EH7b`Et ���.0'/��� ���;DJH;L?IJ7�

*� 7HGK?J;JE� ?H7D?7DE� (?9>;B;� .7;;� L?L;D9?EK� KC� H;B79?ED7C;DJE� ?DJ;DIE� DE

:;I;DLEBL?:E� :;� I;K�CE:;BE� JH?:?C;DI?ED7B� F7H7� 7 �'$2�*" �-�+, �'-+� �<?= ���

�KH7DJ;� E� FHE9;IIE� :;� 9EDIJHKb`E� E� E8@;JE� C7D?FKB7:E� JEHDEKI;� GK7I; KC7

;NJ;DI`E�:E�7KJEH �B;L7D:EI;�;C�9EDJ7�E�=H7K�:;�?DJ?C?:7:;�GK;�KC�;IJ78;B;9?7

9EC�E�EKJHE���*�CE:;BE��7II?C�9ECE�E�FHE@;JE��EB>7�F7H7�:;DJHE�:;�I;K�I?IJ;C7��I

<HEDJ;?H7I�;DJH;�E�?DJ;H?EH�;�E�;IF7bE�;NJ;H?EH�I`E�JeDK;I�F7H7�9H?7H�BK=7H;I�GK;�I;

H;IF;?J7C��I;C�>?;H7HGK?7

)7� �CdH?97� :E� .KB�� E� (KI;K� :7I� (7GK;J;I� I;� ;D9EDJH7� D7� !79KB:7:;� :;

�HGK?J;JKH7�� �;I?=D� ;� 0H87D?ICE� :7� 0D?L;HI?:7:;� :;� �K;DEI� �?H;I �<?= ���� *

;IF7bE� :7I�C7GK;J;I�CEIJH7� 7� FHE:Kb`E� I;C;IJH7B� :EI� 7BKDEI� :E� oBJ?CE� 7DE�:E

9KHIE� :;� 7HGK?J;JKH7� D7� :?I9?FB?D7� GK;� E� 7HGK?J;JE� %7?C;� "H?C8;H=� C?D?IJH7� D7

!��00�� :;I:;� ���

!?=KH7� ����(E:;BE�:;�(?9>;B;�.7;;�F7H7 �'$2�*"�-�+,�'-+�!EDJ;�>JJF���MMMDEC7:IKIF8H�;DGK;J;�FHE@;JEI� ;C���� ���� �

Page 167: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 135

*� 9EDJ;o:E� :EI� CE:;BEI� <fI?9EI� d� <HKJE� :7� ?DL;IJ?=7b`E� FHE=H;II?L7� :E� 97CFE

7HGK?J;JkD?9E� CE:;HDE� GK;� I;KI ���� 7BKDEI H;7B?P7C� C� DoC;HE� IKF;H?EH� 7

GK7JHE9;DJEI�;�E?J;DJ7� 7I�C7GK;J;I�;NFEIJ7I�H;FH;I;DJ7C�KC�7CFBE�9ECFeD:?E

:7I�E8H7I�C7?I�?CFEHJ7DJ;I�:EI�C;IJH;I�:E�Id9KBE�33

� �",3����$��*�!",��,-*���, �- ��,*"%'"&� d�KC�CKI;K�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�BE97B?P7:E�DE

��$�"+�����!�"$$',��;C +7H?I��!H7Db7��EC�7�LE97b`E�:;�78H?=7H CE:;BEI��C7GK;J;I�;

E8@;JEI� :;� JH7:?b`E� :;� KC7� C7D;?H7� :;CEDIJH7J?L7� ;� ;:K97J?L7�� <E?� FHE@;J7:E� ;

9EDIJHKf:E�;DJH;������;�������9EC8?D7D:E�9EB;bl;I�;N?IJ;DJ;I�;�H;9;DJ;I

)E� ;IF7bE� :;IJ?D7:E� 7I� C7GK;J;I�� IE8H;II7;C D7 ��$�*"� ��+ �'-$� �+�� 9EC

CE:;BEI� :E� Id9KBE� 3$$� 7E� 31$$$� GK;� I;� :;IJ797C� ;C� ;I97B7I� ;�C7J;H?7?I� :?L;HIEI

�<?= ���� �I� 9EB;bl;I� :EI� (EDKC;DJEI� !H7D9;I;I�� 9ECFEIJ7I� :;� F;b7I� oD?97I� ;

!?=KH7I� ����(KI;K�:7I�(7GK;J;I�0���!��0!EDJ;��!EJEI�:7��KJEH7

Page 168: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 136

9ED@KDJEI�� H;<B;J;C� KC7� L7H?;:7:;� :;� KIEI�� ;NFB7D7D:E� E� 9KHIE� :7� >?IJjH?7� :7

7HGK?J;JKH7��E<;H;9;D:E�KC7�78EH:7=;C�J?FEBj=?97

)7 ��$�*"� �'��*&� �, �'&,�%('*�"&� EI�CE:;BEI�:7�7HGK?J;JKH7 ?DJ;HD79?ED7?I�I`E

;N?8?:EI FEH�F;HfE:EI�7�F7HJ?H�:;� ����7Jd�EI�:?7I�7JK7?I �<?=� ��� ; �<?= ���

*I�9ED@KDJEI�7B?�;NFEIJEI�I`E�97H79J;H?P7:EI�F;B7�IK7�FH;9?I`E�DE�GK;�:?P�H;IF;?JE�Z

9EDIJHKb`E�H;FH;I;DJ7:7�F;B7�IK7�78EH:7=;C�7D7BfJ?97�;�IK7�;B;L7:7�GK7B?:7:;�:;

79787C;DJE

!?=KH7� ��� CE:;BEI�;NFEIJEI�D7 ��$�*"� �5+ �'-$� �+ �",3����$��*�!",��,-*�

!EDJ;��!EJE :7��KJEH7

!?=KH7I� �� ; ����(7GK;J;I�;NFEIJ7I�D7 ��$�*"� �'��*&� �, �'&,�%('*�"&����*"+!EDJ;��!EJEI�:7��KJEH7

| 136

9ED@KDJEI�� H;<B;J;C� KC7� L7H?;:7:;� :;� KIEI�� ;NFB7D7D:E� E� 9KHIE� :7� >?IJjH?7� :7

7HGK?J;JKH7��E<;H;9;D:E�KC7�78EH:7=;C�J?FEBj=?97

)7 ��$�*"� �'��*&� �, �'&,�%('*�"&� EI�CE:;BEI�:7�7HGK?J;JKH7 ?DJ;HD79?ED7?I�I`E

;N?8?:EI FEH�F;HfE:EI�7�F7HJ?H�:;� ����7Jd�EI�:?7I�7JK7?I �<?=� ��� ; �<?= ���

*I�9ED@KDJEI�7B?�;NFEIJEI�I`E�97H79J;H?P7:EI�F;B7�IK7�FH;9?I`E�DE�GK;�:?P�H;IF;?JE�Z

9EDIJHKb`E�H;FH;I;DJ7:7�F;B7�IK7�78EH:7=;C�7D7BfJ?97�;�IK7�;B;L7:7�GK7B?:7:;�:;

79787C;DJE

!?=KH7� ��� CE:;BEI�;NFEIJEI�D7 ��$�*"� �5+ �'-$� �+ �",3����$��*�!",��,-*�

!EDJ;��!EJE :7��KJEH7

!?=KH7I� �� ; ����(7GK;J;I�;NFEIJ7I�D7 ��$�*"� �'��*&� �, �'&,�%('*�"&����*"+!EDJ;��!EJEI�:7��KJEH7

| 136

9ED@KDJEI�� H;<B;J;C� KC7� L7H?;:7:;� :;� KIEI�� ;NFB7D7D:E� E� 9KHIE� :7� >?IJjH?7� :7

7HGK?J;JKH7��E<;H;9;D:E�KC7�78EH:7=;C�J?FEBj=?97

)7 ��$�*"� �'��*&� �, �'&,�%('*�"&� EI�CE:;BEI�:7�7HGK?J;JKH7 ?DJ;HD79?ED7?I�I`E

;N?8?:EI FEH�F;HfE:EI�7�F7HJ?H�:;� ����7Jd�EI�:?7I�7JK7?I �<?=� ��� ; �<?= ���

*I�9ED@KDJEI�7B?�;NFEIJEI�I`E�97H79J;H?P7:EI�F;B7�IK7�FH;9?I`E�DE�GK;�:?P�H;IF;?JE�Z

9EDIJHKb`E�H;FH;I;DJ7:7�F;B7�IK7�78EH:7=;C�7D7BfJ?97�;�IK7�;B;L7:7�GK7B?:7:;�:;

79787C;DJE

!?=KH7� ��� CE:;BEI�;NFEIJEI�D7 ��$�*"� �5+ �'-$� �+ �",3����$��*�!",��,-*�

!EDJ;��!EJE :7��KJEH7

!?=KH7I� �� ; ����(7GK;J;I�;NFEIJ7I�D7 ��$�*"� �'��*&� �, �'&,�%('*�"&����*"+!EDJ;��!EJEI�:7��KJEH7

Page 169: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 137

(E:;BEI� JeC� KC� BK=7H� ;IF;9?7B� DE� FHE9;IIE� 9H?7J?LE� :E� 7HGK?J;JE -?9>7H:�(;?;H�

GK; ;C�C7?E�:;��� H;78H?K�I;K�CKI;K�:;�C7GK;J;I�;C�'ED=$IB7D: �<?=� �� ; <?=

�����*�;IF7bEE<;H;9;�KC�H7HE�C7J;H?7B�GK;�;D7BJ;9;�E�FHE9;IIE�FHE@;JK7B�7JH7LdI

:;�F;b7I�9H?7:7I�7E�BED=E�:;����7DEI�:;�IK7�97HH;?H7�9ECE�7HGK?J;JE

*�7C8?;DJ;�E9KF7�C7?I�:;�C?B�C;JHEI�GK7:H7:EI�;�FEIIK?�E8H7I�97H79J;HfIJ?97I�:7

:d97:7�:;� ����7Jd�E�FH;I;DJ;�CEC;DJE �I�F;b7I�:;�C7?EH�H;B;L^D9?7�DE�CKI;K

I`E�EI�=H7D:;I�CE:;BEI�:;�7FH;I;DJ7b`E�;�CE:;BEI�:;�;IJK:E�:E�";JJO��;DJ;H��;C

'EI��D=;B;I �<?=�� ���9EDI?:;H7:E�9ECE�E�FHE@;JE�C7?I�7C8?9?EIE�:;�(;?;H�;�GK;

;N?=?K�C7?I�:;� ��7DEI�F7H7�I;H�9ED9BKf:E

�� 9EB;b`E� ?D9BK?� E� FH?C;?HE� CE:;BE� F7H7� 7� �7I7� .C?J>�� ;C� �EDD;9J?9KJ�� KC� :EI

FH?C;?HEI�JH787B>EI�GK;�;IJ78;B;9;K�7�H;FKJ7b`E�:E�7HGK?J;JE���;NFEI?b`E�J7C8dC

!?=KH7I� ���;����� (KI;K�:;�C7GK;J;I�;C�'ED=�$IB7D:�-?9>7H:�(;?;H!EDJ;��!EJE �7BL7�!;HH7H?

Page 170: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 138

7FH;I;DJ7� KC7� IdH?;� :;�C7GK;J;I� :;� FHE@;JEI� D`E� 9EDIJHKf:EI�� 9ECE� E� :;� ����

F7H7�E�2EHB:�/H7:;��;DJ;H�(;CEH?7B�.GK7H;��;C )EL7�4EHA �<?=������FHEJjJ?FEI�:;

CE8?B?\H?E� ;� :;I?=D� :;� FHE:KJE�� 8;C� 9ECE� 9EB7=;DI� ;� ;I9KBJKH7I� 9ECFEIJ7I� :;

;B;C;DJEI�:;�9;H7 �<?=�����

�JK7BC;DJ;�� E� ;IF7bE� H;9;8;� KC� Fo8B?9E� :?L;HI?<?97:E� :;� ;IJK:7DJ;I�� 7HGK?J;JEI

FH7J?97DJ;I�;�;DJKI?7IJ7I�:;�7HJ;�;�:;I?=D

��;NFEI?b`E <�!���*�!",��,-*�$ �'��$ ��''$���,"+!���%�$$��,'("�9 <E?�KC�C7H9E�D7

97J7BE=7b`E�:7�>?IJjH?7�:7�CE:;B7=;C *�JH787B>E�I;�9EDIJ?JK?K�:7�:E9KC;DJ7b`E

:;� 9EDJ;o:E� 7JH7LdI :;�CE:;BEI�CKD:?7?I�� 7FH;I;DJ7:7� :;�C7?E� 7� I;J;C8HE� :;

�� ���DE �-,+�!�+ �*�!",�#,-*%-+�-% ���(���;C�!H7DA<KHJ �<?=�����

!?=KH7�������;J7B>;!EDJ;�>JJF���MMM<B?9AH9EC�F>EJEI�7H9>?:EI;������������� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7��� � ";JJO��;DJ;H��'EI��D=;B;I ;";>HO!EDJ;�>JJF���MMM:7H;9EKA�7H9>?J;9JKH;�H?9>7H:C;?;HCE:;BI?DBED=?IB7D:9?JOM7H;>EKI;�;C��� ���� �

!?=KH7����� C7GK;J;I�:7�;NFEI?b`E�s�!���*�!",��,-*�$�'��$���''$���,"+!�

�%�$$��,'("�9 <EJE�Q�)?D7�-;;JPA;��.JOB;F7HA!EDJ;��>JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C��� ���� �

!?=KH7������ I9KBJKH7I��'EI��D=;B;I!EDJ;�>JJF���MMM:;I?=DH;B7J;:9EC�D;MI�FEIJ6:;J7?B� ��� �C;?;HCE:;BCKI;KC� ;C��� ���� �

Page 171: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 139

��;NFEI?b`E� ?D9BK?K� 7B=KC7I� :7I� E8H7IFH?C7I�:7� 9EB;b`E� :E�CKI;K�� 7BdC�:;� KC

=H7D:; DoC;HE� :;� ;N;CFB7H;I� :;� CE:;BEI� :;� 9EB;bl;I� ?DJ;HD79?ED7?I N?8?K

7IC7GK;J;I�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�GK;�C7H97H7C�7�>?IJjH?7�;�J7C8dC�7FH;I;DJEKCE:;BEI

9ECEKC7�<;HH7C;DJ7�:;<;J?9>;�9ECE�KC7�<EHC7�:;H;FH;I;DJ7b`E�;:;�:;I?=D

�EC�C7?I�:;����CE:;BEI �<?=�������� ����������� ;� ����7 CEIJH7�:;K�:;IJ7GK;�

;DJH;�EKJHEI��7�CE:;BEI:;'K:M?=(?;IL7D�:;H-E>; �<?=�� ����*JJE !H;? �<?=�� �� ;

�<?=�� ��-;C&EEB>77I��+;J;H� ?I;DC7D ;�+;J;H�5KCJ>EH �<?=�� ��

!?=KH7����� �7I7�:;�9EHJ?D7I��-7?CKD:��8H7>7C��CE:;BE� ���!EDJ;� <EJE�Q���(��#7=;D�.J?;H>JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7����� �EBE97b`E:7�FH?C;?H7�F;:H7 DE 0BC (pDIJ;H� ���!EDJ;� <EJE�Q�)?D7�-;;JPA;��.JOB;F7HA >JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I

7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7����� +HE@;JEI :; *IM7B:�(7J>?7I 0D=;HI!EDJ;� <EJE�Q�)?D7�-;;JPA;�.JOB;F7HA>JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7�������\FIKB7I�:7I 97I7I�.EB?D=;D�7IF;HI8HE?9>��2EB<=7D=��mH?D=��� ���!EDJ;� <EJE�Q���(��#7=;D�.J?;H>JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D

?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7�������79>E�DE��H���H7J7 $IEP7A?��CE:;BE� ���!EDJ;� <EJE�Q���(��#7=;D.J?;H>JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7�� �� !\8H?97/H7DIF7H;DJ;��#;DD�H9>?J;9JI��CE:;BE���� !EDJ;� <EJE�Q�)?D7�-;;JPA;��.JOB;F7HA>JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

Page 172: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 140

(K?JEI�:EI�CE:;BEI�7B?�7FH;I;DJ7:EI J?L;H7C�7BJEI�L7BEH;I�:;�I;=KHE�)E�;DJ7DJE�

D`E�;N?IJ;�KC�C;H97:E�F7H7�CE:;BEI�9ECF7H\L;B�7E�:;�E8H7I�:;�7HJ;��F;BE�C;DEI

D`E�;C�J;HCEI�:7I�FHE@;J7:7I FEH�7HGK?J;JEI�9EDJ;CFEH^D;EI

�� ;NFEI?b`E� CEIJHEK� KC� CE:;BE� 7HGK?J;JkD?9E� :;� ���� :E� 7KIJHf79E� �E� #7KI

-K9A;H� KC�<H7I9E�:;�L?:HE�9EDJ;D:E�KC7�9787D7�FH?C?J?L7 �<?=�� �� II7�FHEFEIJ7

H;<B;J?7� KC7� 9HfJ?97� Z� :;IJHK?b`E� :E�C;?E� 7C8?;DJ;� ;�:7� ?D=;DK?:7:;�:E� ?:;7B� :E

CKD:E�KJjF?9E�*�9ED@KDJE�<E?�FHE:KP?:E�;C�KC7�;:?b`E�:;����;N;CFB7H;I

+;J;H� ?I;DC7D� 9H?EK� JHeI� ;:?bl;I� :E� CE:;BE� :;� I;K FHE@;JE� ;� E L7BEH� :7� F;b7

7J?D=?K ;C� ����7�GK7DJ?7�:; JHeI�C?B�C7H9EI�7B;C`;I��- /55& ��;DJH;L?IJ7�

�7:7�CE:;BE�d�KC7� ?DJ;HFH;J7b`E��;B;C;DJEI�I`E�EC?J?:EI��;<;?JEI� ?DJ;DI?<?97:EI

0C�;N;CFBE�d�7�C7GK;J;�:;�+;J;H�5KCJ>EH�:E�CKI;K�&EBKC87 �<?=�� ����;C GK;�7

<79>7:7�:7�F;b7��CEIJH7:7�;C�J?@EBE��d�CK?JE�C7?I�;IJHKJKH7B�:E�GK;�7�:E�CKI;K

H;7B

!?=KH7�� ��F;b7�s)7JKH;P7�+H;I;HL7:7t� :;�#7KI-K9A;H�E�� ���!EDJ;�<EJE�Q���(��#7=;D�.J?;H >JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

Page 173: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 141

*KJHE�;N;CFBE�d E�CE:;BE�:7 97I7�-;IEHJ�:;�(?;I�L7D�:;H�-E>;��<?=�� ����9;:?:E

F;BE�(E(��:;�)EL7�4EHA

��L?I?8?B?:7:;�FEII?8?B?J7:7�7E�E8I;HL7:EH�H;JH7J7�9ECE�E�7HGK?J;JE�=EIJ7H?7�:;�EB>7H

7�H;7B?:7:;�:E�;:?<f9?E�<?= � ���,K7D:E�;IJ;�E8@;J?LE�D`E�d�7B97Db7:E��E�CE:;BE�I;

JEHD7�KC7�;IFd9?;�:;�<;J?9>;��KC�7JE�:;�9ECF;DI7b`E

!?=KH7�� ���(KI;K�:;��HJ; &EBKC87��+;J;H�5KCJ>EH��CE:;BE�:;���� �:;�578EHEMIAO!EDJ;� <EJE�Q���(��#7=;D�.J?; >JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7�� ���-;IEHJ�#EKI;��(?;I�17D�:;H�-E>;��CE:;BE�:;� ����FEH�4?P!EDJ;�F?DJ;H;IJ9EC�F?C�������������� ����� ;C���� ���� �

Page 174: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 142

�I�H;FH;I;DJ7bl;I�9H?7J?L7I�FE:;C�7<;J7H�E�H;IKBJ7:E�:;�7HGK?J;JKH7�R�E�97IE��FEH

;N;CFBE��:EI�CE:;BEI�:;�7KJEH?7�:E�7HGK?J;JE�!H;?�*JJE��I�F;b7I ;B78EH7:7I�;C

C7J;H?7?I�9ECE�FB\IJ?9E s8EB>7t �<?=�� ����7H;?7�EK�J;9?:E�<?DE�?BKIJH7C 7�L?78?B?:7:;

:;� KIE� :;� DELEI� C7J;H?7?I� * �-,+�!�+� �*�!",�#,-*� �-+�-% 7FH;I;DJEK� I;KI

;N;CFB7H;I��GK;�9EDIJ?JK?H7C�KC�:EI�:;IJ7GK;I�:7�;NFEI?b`E

!?=KH7I�� �� +7L?B>`E��B;C`E�F7H7�7� NFEI?b`E�0D?L;HI7B�:;�(EDJH;7B��:;�2EB<=7D=�CE:;BE ������!EDJ;� <EJE�Q���(��#7=;D�.J?; >JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C��� ���� �

!?=KH7�� �� IJ7b`E�:;�JH;C��.JKJJ=7H:��!H;?�*JJE!EDJ;��7H9>?J;9JKH;>78?J7J8BE=IFEJ9EC8H��� �� � <?D7BIK8C?II?ED>JCB� ;C���� ���� �

Page 175: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 143

0C�:EI�CE:;BEI�C7?I� I?=D?<?97J?LEI�:7�;N?8?b`E�� 7�F;b7�GK;� H;FH;I;DJ7�E IJ\:?E

*BfCF?9E� :;� (KD?GK;;C� KC7� ;I97B7� :;� ������ E9KFEK� KC7� I7B7� 9;DJH7B:E I7B`E

CKBJ?KIE�:;�(7DD>;?D

�E CE:;BE�:;�=;IIE�:7�/EHH;� ?DIJ;?D �<?=�� �� J;C�I?:E�9EDI?:;H7:E�KC�:EI�C7?I

L7B?EIEI�:E�?DL;DJ\H?E�:E��H9>?J;AJKHCKI;KC��;KJI9>;I��FEH�I;H�EH?=?D7B :7J7:E :;

���

!?=KH7�� �� IJ\:?E�(KD?GK;��!H;?�*JJE!EDJ;� <EJE�Q���(��#7=;D�.J?;� >JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

!?=KH7�� �� /EHH;� ?DIJ;?D� H?9>�(;D:;BIE>D��CE:;BE�EH?=?D7B�;�HdFB?97I�FHE:KP?:7I�FEH�?CFH;IIEH7���!EDJ;� <EJE�Q���(��#7=;D�.J?;

>JJF���MMMIJOB;F7HA9EC�;D�D;MI�;79>CE:;B?I7D?DJ;HFH;J7J?ED����� �� ;C���� ���� �

Page 176: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 144

*I�F;HfE:EI�:;�:;FH;II`E�;9EDkC?97�;�7�<7BJ7�:;�;CFH;;D:?C;DJEI�:; 9EDIJHKb`E

CK?J7I�L;P;I�B;L7C�7�CEC;DJEI�:;�H;<B;N`E�;�H;7L7B?7b`E�:7�7HGK?J;JKH7��;�7�9H?I;

;KHEF;?7�:;��� ��D`E�d�KC7�;N9;b`E <�!���*�!",��,-*�$ �'��$���''$���,"+!���%�$$

�,'("�9�<?=� � �� <E?� 7� oBJ?C7� ;NFEI?b`E� C7H97DJ;� H;B79?ED7:7� Z� CE:;B7=;C

+H;;D9>;D9>;D:E�;II7�B79KD7� 9EC�<E9E�D7 >?IJjH?7�:EI�CE:;BEI

�I� ;NFEI?bl;I� 7E� BED=E� :EI� 7DEI� 7CFB?7H7C� EI� >EH?PEDJ;I� :7� CE:;B7=;C� �

KJ?B?P7b`E� :;� C7GK;J;I� 9ECE� C;97D?ICE� F7H7� 9EDI;=K?H� KC7 7CFB?7b`E :EI

9ED>;9?C;DJEI� 7HGK?J;JkD?9EI� ;� 7� ?DEL7b`E� :EI� CdJE:EI� :;� H;FH;I;DJ7b`E� ;C

7HGK?J;JKH7��I;�CEIJHEK�87IJ7DJ;�I?=D?<?97DJ; �ECE�<;HH7C;DJ7�:?D^C?97�GK;�FE:;

97J7B?I7H�;�H;D;=E9?7H�7I�H;B7bl;I�;DJH;�9ED9;?JEI�� Jd9D?97I�;�CdJE:EI�:?IJ?DJEI�:;

?DL;IJ?=7b`E�� ;IJ;� KD?L;HIE� DEI� ;IF;H7� F7H7� GK;� 7I� ;NFBEH;CEI ;C� <KJKH7I

;N?8?bl;I

!?=KH7�� ����7J\BE=E�:7�;NFEI?b`E �!���*�!",��,-*�$

�'��$���''$���,"+!���%�$$��,'("��

!EDJ;�!EJE�:7��KJEH7

Page 177: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 145

������������������

��<HG>Q^H�>GMK>�H�:KM>?:MH�>�:�BF:@BG:`^H�M>F�<K>L<B=H�=>L=>�H�BGc<BH�=H�La<NEH�44�

)H=>EHL� MHKG:K:FL>�F:BL� BGMBF:F>GM>� BGM>@K:=HL�XL� ?>KK:F>GM:L� K>E:<BHG:=:L�X

>QIK>LL^H�=>�NF�IKHC>MH���EaF�=BLLH�:�M>G=bG<B:�I:K:�:�:;LMK:`^H M>F�IHLB<BHG:=H

H� FH=>EH� >F� NF� GcO>E� <:=:� O>S� F:BL� >E>F>GM:K� G:� <KB:`^H� =:� :KJNBM>MNK:

I>KFBMBG=H�JN>�>E>�MK:GLFBM:�:�OBL^H�LN;C:<>GM>�=H�:KJNBM>MH�>F�MH=:�:�LN:�?HK`:��W

>LL>�>LMN=H�HN�IKH<>LLH�=>�FH=>E:@>F JN>�L>�<HGLMBMNB�:�<KB:`^H�:�JN:E�L>�K>O>E:

=NK:GM>� H� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =>� NF� IKH<>LLH� �FNBM:L� O>S>L� F:L� G>F L>FIK>

=HFaLMB<H��JN>�<:K:<M>KBS:�:�FH=>E:@>F�<HGM>FIHK\G>:�

!F;HK:�FNBM:L�O>S>L�M>GA:�LB=H�NMBEBS:=H�H�IKH<>LLH�=>�FH=>E:@>F�a�:@HK:�NF:

<:K:<M>KcLMB<:� ?:FBEB:K� X� IKZMB<:� >� K>?E>Q^H� :KJNBM>MfGB<:�� )H=>EHL� =>

=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=>�IKHC>MH @:GA:K:F�=>LM:JN>� K>GHO:=H�=NK:GM>�H� La<NEH� 44�>

>LM^H�GH�FHF>GMH�L>G=H�F:BL�:FIE:F>GM>�>FIK>@:=HL�>�IKH=NSB=HL�=H�JN>�>F

JN:EJN>K�I>KcH=H�:GM>KBHK��)NBMHL�=HL�:KJNBM>MHL�F:BL�IK>LMB@B:=HL =HL�hEMBFHL�<>F

:GHL <HGM:K:F�<HF�FH=>EHL�I:K: H�=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=H�IKHC>MH� �GMHGB�#:N=B�IHK

>Q>FIEH MK:;:EAHN� <HGLM:GM>F>GM>� <HF� FH=>EHL� +;L>KO:L>� >F� LN:� O:LM:

IKH=N`^H� =>� H;C>MHL� MKB=BF>GLBHG:BL� H =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� <HF� =BO>KL:L

IK>H<NI:`g>L�?HKF:BL�>�>LMKNMNK:BL�>F�L>NL FH=>EHL�=>�?HKFNE:`^H �?B@�������

Page 178: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 146

��H?B<BG:�=>�FH=>EHL�=>�)B>L�O:G�=>K�.HA> IHK�>Q>FIEH�H<NI:O:�NF�JN:KMH�=>

L>N�:M>EB>K �?B@���� ��

"B@NK:����� ):JN>M>L�#:N=B�/:@K:=:�":FcEB:������"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�@:N=B=>LB@G>K�<HF�?K�L:@K:=:?:FBEB:�>F� �� ��� ��

"B@NK:��� ��+?B<BG:�=>�FH=>EHL�=>�)B>L�O:G�=>K�.HA>"HGM>��AMMI���MA>K>=EBLM�?K�PBDB������������������OB>P@>KF:G;:NA:NL�IKH?BE>FB>LO:G=>KKHA>EN=PB@��AMFE >F� �� ��� ��

Page 179: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 147

!>KH�/::KBG>G�>LMN=HN�H�0>KFBG:E�03��=>�MH=HL�HL�\G@NEHL�:MK:OaL�=>�FH=>EHL�=>

=BLMBGM:L�>L<:E:L�BF:@BGZO>BL �?B@������> �����

*HL� hEMBFHL� :GHL� HL� :KJNBM>MHL� MHKG:K:FL>� :BG=:� F:BL� ?:FBEB:KBS:=HL� <HF� HL

FH=>EHL MKB=BF>GLBHG:BL I:K:�H�=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=H�IKHC>MH��$HC>�IHN<HL�:F:GM>L

=:� :KJNBM>MNK:� =>L<HGA><>F� H JN:GMH JN>� "K:GD� #>AKR� =>LI>G=>� I:K: >F� L>NL

>LMN=HL�=:�FH=>E:@>F�I:K: L>N�IKH<>LLH�<KB:MBOH �?B@� ��������> �����

"B@NK:������0K:GL�3HKE=��BKEBG>L�0>KFBG:E��>KHIHKMH�&HAG�"�'>GG>=R�*HO:�5HKD���������� )H=>EH�>F�<HGLMKN`^H�>LMN=HL�=>!>KH�/::KBG>G"HGM>�AMMI���PPP�IA:B=HG�<HF�:@>G=:�:K<ABM><MNK>�IB<MNK>@:EE>KB>L�� ���H<MH;>K�� �>>KHL::KBG>GLMP:�"HMe@K:?H��:EMA:S:K�'HK:;��>F� �� ��� ��

"B@NK:� �����>LMN=HL�=>�!>KH�/::KBG>G�I:K:�H�0>KFBG:E�03�"HGM>�AMMI���PPP�IA:B=HG�<HF�:@>G=:�:K<ABM><MNK>�IB<MNK>@:EE>KB>L�� ���H<MH;>K�� �>>KHL::KBG>GLMP:M>KFBG:E�>F� �� ��� ��

"B@NK:������%F:@>F�I:GHK\FB<:�=H�>LMh=BH�=>�#>AKR�FHLMK:G=H�HL�>LMN=HL�BGO>LMB@:MBOHL�=>�L>NL�IKHC>MHL�"HGM>L��AMMI���;EH@�FB<A>EE>D:N?F:GG�<HF��I������>F� �� ��� ��

"B@NK:������"K:GD�#>AKR�>�!=PBG��A:G:G�:EBL:G=H�NF�FH=>EH�"HGM>L��AMMI���;EH@�FB<A>EE>D:N?F:GG�<HF��I������>F� �� ��� ��

"B@NK:������"K:GD�#>AKR�!=PBG��A:G�,:NE�.H=@>KL�>�,:NE�/M:EE:GMK:;:EA:G=H�GH�IKHC>MH��:FINL�#E:L@HP�>F�(HL��G@>E>L�"HGM>L��AMMI���;EH@�FB<A>EE>D:N?F:GG�<HF��I������>F� �� ��� ��

Page 180: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 148

!=PBG� �A:G� a� NF� =HL� =BK>MHK>L� =>� IKHC>MH� =H� >L<KBMeKBH� =>� "K:GD� #>AKR >

K>LIHGLZO>E�I>E:�>E:;HK:`^H�=:L�FBEA:K>L�=>�I>`:L�=>L>GOHEOB=:L�I>E:�>JNBI>��0H=:

:� IKH=N`^H� =H� >L<KBMeKBH� HK;BM:� GHL� FH=>EHL� ?cLB<HL� >E>L� ?NG=:F H� Gh<E>H� =H

IKH<>LLH <HGLMBMNBG=H H� FH=H� =>� >E:;HK:`^H� =>� =BO>KLHL� IKHC>MHL� =>� #>AKR�

�HGMN=H� =NK:GM>� MH=H� H� IKH<>LLH :� F:GBINE:`^H� =>� IKH@K:F:L� =B@BM:BL� a

B@N:EF>GM>� >LL>G<B:E� NF:� O>S� JN>� >E>L� L^H HL MK:=NMHK>L� JN>� MK:GLIHKM:F

BG?HKF:`g>L I:K:�HL�=H<NF>GMHL�=>�<HGLMKN`^H�

��H?B<BG:�=>�FH=>EHL�=>�.>GSH�,B:GH M:F;aF�a�<HGA><B=: GH�F>BH�:KJNBM>MfGB<H

�?B@������� /BMN:=: :H�E:=H�=H�KBH�/>G:�L>�F>L<E:�<HF�JN:EJN>K�HNMK:�>GMK:=: IHKM:

F>MZEB<:�<:FI:BGA:�NF:�IE:<:�LBFIE>L�IHKaF�<HF�NF�LNMBE�=>M:EA>��:�IE:<:�G^H

=BS� m.>GSH� ,B:GH� �KJNBM>MHn� >� LBF m.>GSH� ,B:GH� +?B<BG:� =>� !=B?c<BHLn�

�� >LI:`HL:� H?B<BG:� =>� F:JN>M>L� ?NG<BHG:� <HFH� OBMKBG>� >OH<:G=H� :� <B=:=>� =HL

:KM>L^HL� JN>� ,:KBL� CZ� ?HB� <HF� K>?BG:=:L� FBGB:MNK:L� =>� IKa=BHL I:K>=>L� <HF

?>KK:F>GM:L�;>F�:KKNF:=:L�>�IKHC>`g>L�=>�>GHKF>L�GHOHL�I>=:`HL�=>�<B=:=>L�:H

K>=HK�=H�FNG=H�

"B@NK:�������M>EB>K�=>�.>GSH�,B:GH"HGM>L��AMMI���:KJNBM>MNK:NGB<>I� ��LI:<>;EH@�<HF�;K��������.>GSH,B:GH>/>N�M>EB>K�AMMI���PPP�:K<LI:<>�<HF�>QAB;BMBHGL�NGLHKM>=�K>GSHIB:GHMA>:K<ABM><MLLMN=BH� >F� �� ��� ��

Page 181: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 149

�LLBF <HFH�.>GSH�,B:GH�"HLM>K�:G=�,:KMG>KL�IHLLNB NF: @K:G=>�H?B<BG:�MHM:EF>GM>

>JNBI:=: IKH?BLLBHG:EF>GM> <HF NF:� >JNBI>� >F� NF� L>MHK =>� =>LM:JN>� GH� IBLH

IKBG<BI:E�=>LL>�>LI:`H �?B@�������

�� NMBEB=:=>� =H�FH=>EH GNG<:� ?HB� =>IK><B:=:� :H� EHG@H� =:� ABLMeKB:� =><>KMH� :� LN:

<:I:<B=:=>� I:K:� :NQBEB:K� :� >L<E:K><>K > :G:EBL:K� :L IKHIHLB`g>L =>� NF� IKHC>MH

:KJNBM>MfGB<H�L> MHKGHN�;:LM:GM>�LB@GB?B<:MBOH����E;>KMB�=>=B<HN�OZKB:L�IZ@BG:L�=>�L>N

MK:M:=H�.>G:L<>GMBLM:�I:K:�IKHFHO>K�:�LN:�NMBEBS:`^H�=>?>G=>G=H :�<HGM>FIE:`^H

=H�IKHC>MH�:IHK�F>BH =>�FH=>EHL�:H�EHG@H�=>�NF�I>KcH=H�=>�M>FIH��)NBMHL�HNMKHL

:KJNBM>MHL�>�<KcMB<HL�=>�:KJNBM>MNK:�MbF�>G?:MBS:=H�:� BFIHKM\G<B:�=:�NMBEBS:`^H�=HL

FH=>EHL�=>�>LMN=HL�

&HAG� /H:G>� NL:O:� L>NL FH=>EHL� I:K:� BGO>LMB@:K� :LLNGMHL =BO>KLHL� <HFH� IHK

>Q>FIEH� H� >?>BMH� =:L� O>=:`g>L� G:L� ?>G>LMK:`g>L� :EM>KG:MBO:L� >LMKNMNK:BL >� :L

K>E:`g>L�=:�BENFBG:`^H�=>�L>NL�>LI:`HL�BGM>KBHK>L��/H:G>�=>?>G=B:�JN> FNBM:L�=:L

"B@NK: �����!LMh=BH�"HLM>K�:G=�,:KMG>KL"HGM>L��AMMI���PPP�?HLM>K:G=I:KMG>KL�<HF��:K>>KL�.><KNBMF>GM� >?:NEM�:LIQ

AMMI���PPP�OB>PIB<MNK>L�<H�ND� >M:BEL�:LIQ�% ��������0RI>% ���>F� �� ��� ��

Page 182: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 150

=><>I`g>L� F:BL� @K:O>L� JN>� :M>G=>F� :L� <HGLMKN`g>L� L>KB:F� >OBM:=:L� L>� HL

FH=>EHL�?HLL>F�IK>OB:F>GM>�>E:;HK:=HL�>F�LN:�<HG<>I`^H�<KB:MBO:�

*H�La<NEH�42%%%�NF�=HL�IKBG<BI:BL�:KJNBM>MHL�KNLLHL�2:LBER�%O:GHOB<A��:SA>GHO�JN>

>LMN=:K: >F�,:KBL G:�=a<:=:�=>���� �MKHNQ>K: =>�OHEM:�I:K:�L>N�I:cL�:L�B=>B:L�F:BL

:O:G`:=:L�=H G>H<E:LLB<BLFH� !E>�:?BKF:O:�JN> I:K:�>GM>G=>K :�;>E>S:�>�>Q<>EbG<B:

=H >=B?c<BH�H�:KJNBM>MH�BG>OBM:O>EF>GM>�=>O>KB:�>Q><NM:K�NF�FH=>EH�I:K:�>E>�

+� NLH� =>� FH=>EHL� <HFH� ?>KK:F>GM:L� I:K:� H� >GM>G=BF>GMH� =H� IKHC>MH >

=>M:EA:F>GMH�=:�<HGLMKN`^H�LNK@BN <HFH NF:�IKZMB<:�<HFNF�:�I:KMBK�=HL La<NEHL

42% > 42%%%� F:L� LN;L>JN>GM>F>GM>� =><EBG:=:�� *H� La<NEH� 4%4� :� FH=>E:@>F� =>

>LMN=H� ?HB� F>GHL� :IKHO>BM:=:� :I>L:K� =>� LN:� >?B<Z<B:� <HFIKHO:=:�� *:� �FaKB<:

I>KF:G><>N�IKBG<BI:EF>GM>�<HF�:�?BG:EB=:=>�=H�>LMN=H�=>�HKG:F>GMH�

+�FH=>EH�=>�>L;H`H�I:LLHN�: L>K�NL:=H�>Q:NLMBO:F>GM>�GH�BGc<BH�=H�La<NEH�44��+L

:KJNBM>MHL MHKG:K:F� NG:GBF>L� LN:� NMBEB=:=> I:K:� H >LMN=H� G:� IKZMB<:� =>� L>NL

:M>EB>KL� > >L<HE:L� =>� :KJNBM>MNK: <HGMKB;NBG=H :LLBF I:K:� :� LN:� K>BGM>@K:`^H GH

:F;B>GM>� :KJNBM>MfGB<H� �:M>=KZMB<HL� =>� :KJNBM>MNK:� BG<>GMBO:O:F� HL� :ENGHL� :

I>GL:K > OBLN:EBS:K�LN:L�<HG<>I`g>L�>F�MKbL�=BF>GLg>L�

��B=>B:�=>�BG<ENBK�:�FH=>E:@>F�G:�<HG<>I`^H�:KJNBM>MfGB<:�?HB MKBEA:=: >F����� IHK

�N=LE>R��mW�FNBMH�=>L>CZO>E�JN>�MH=HL�HL�:ENGHL�=:L�>L<HE:L�=>�:KJNBM>MNK:�=>�MH=H

H�I:cL�=>O:F�L>K�>GLBG:=H�>LL>�MBIH�=>�FH=>E:@>F�:KJNBM>MfGB<:�I>EH�F>GHL�GHL

@K:NL�>E>F>GM:K>L�n ��1 /(!5 �����I�������

"B@NK:������)H=>EH�=H�M>:MKH > L:E:�=H�MHGH�=H�#K:G=>�,:EZ<BH�=H 'K>FEBG�)HL<HN����������"HGM>L��AMMI���PPP�G@:�@HO�>QAB;BMBHGL�� �;:KHJN>�����LAMF

Page 183: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 151

� ���!����� ��"���� $� ������� ��� ����� �� !�� ?HB� NF:� =:L� IKBF>BK:L� BGLMBMNB`g>L� :

BGMKH=NSBK� :� FH=>E:@>F :H� <NKKc<NEH� IHK OHEM:� =>� ����� >� IHLM>KBHKF>GM>� HL

FH=>EHL� MHKG:K:FL>�<:=:�O>S F:BL I:KM>� BGM>@K:GM>�=:�>=N<:`^H�=:�:KJNBM>MNK:�

+NMK:� :EM>K:`^H� H;L>KO:=:� GHL� !LM:=HL� 1GB=HL� >F� ����� I:KMBN =:L� >L<HE:L� =>

:KJNBM>MNK:�� !F�NF:�ZK>:� <BK<NG=:GM>�=H� K><BGMH�>=N<:<BHG:E HN�:Ma�F>LFH�G:L

IKeIKB:L�>L<HE:L�=>�:KJNBM>MNK: =>M><M:L> : BGLM:E:`^H�=>�EHC:L ;>F�>JNBI:=:L�<HF

F:M>KB:BL�I:K:�>E:;HK:`^H�=> F:JN>M>L�

*:�#K^�K>M:GA:�:�I:KMBK�=>������:�F:BHKB:�=:L�>L<HE:L�=>�:KJNBM>MNK:�<HGLB=>K:F

HL� FH=>EHL� <HFH� NF:� I:KM>� >LL>G<B:E =:� :IK>G=BS:@>F�� /BFNEM:G>:F>GM> HL

FH=>EHL� =>� >LMN=H� @:GA:O:F� ?HK`:� GHL� >L<KBMeKBHL� =>� :KJNBM>MNK:� MHKG:G=HL>

F:BL�:FIE:F>GM>�:<>BMHL�K>?>K>G<B:=HL >�K>@BLMK:=HL���+L�FH=>EHL�=>�)B>L�O:G�=>K

.HA>�MHF:K:F�@K:G=>�?HK`:�I:KMBK�=>����� mH�FH=>EH�=>O>�7LN;LMBMNBK8�=>L>GAHL

=>�I>KLI><MBO:L�<HFH�:�?>KK:F>GM:�=HFBG:GM>�=>�I>LJNBL:�GH�>LI:`H�>�OHENF>�n

�(�)�!.0�� ��I������

�HFH�H�La<NEH�44�:O:G`:O:�H�>FIK>@H�=>�FH=>EHL�<HFH�?>KK:F>GM:�>QIEHK:MeKB:

=H� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =>� IKHC>MHL� >� L>� MHKG:� <:=:� O>S� F:BL� =B?NG=B=H�� )NBMHL

:KJNBM>MHL�G:�:MN:EB=:=>�>LM:;>E><>F ?HKF:�>�<HG<>BMH�=H�IKH<>LLH�IKHC>MN:E IHK

F>BH =>� =>L>GAHL� F:GN:BL� HN� =B@BM:BL� >� IHLM>KBHKF>GM> I>E: IKH=N`^H� =>� NF

FH=>EH :LL>@NK:G=H H� ?NG<BHG:F>GMH� =>� LN:� B=>B:� >F� MKbL� =BF>GLg>L�� !F

:E@NF:L� IKZMB<:L� HL� FH=>EHL� =>LM>� MBIH� IH=>F� L>K� ?>BMHL� I>KBH=B<:F>GM>� I:K:

M>LM:K�:� B=>B:�=>�<HFH�H IKHC>MH�IKH@KB=>��*H�>GM:GMH�>LM>L�FH=>EHL�L^H�<KB:=HL

I:K:�O:EB=:K�H�<HG<>BMH�>F�O>S�=>�<HGMKB;NBK�=BK>M:F>GM>�I:K:�:�LN: ?HKF:`^H�=>

NF:�?HKF: =BG\FB<: >QI>KB>G<B:E�

��BGM>@K:`^H�=H�FH=>EH�GH�IKH<>LLH�=>�<HG<>I`^H�IH=>�L>K�>GM>G=B=:�<HFH�NF:

>L<:E:�=>�>GOHEOBF>GMH�JN>�L>�FHO>�:�I:KMBK�=H�I:LLBOH�HN�FH=>EH�<HGM>FIE:MBOH

I:K:�H�:MBOH�HN�>QI>KBF>GM:E�GH�HNMKH�>QMK>FH�

�� =BLMBG`^H� >GMK>� :MBOH�> I:LLBOH� IH=>� L>K�I>K<>;B=:�IHK� :KJNBM>MHL�=BLMBGMHL� >F

=B?>K>GM>L�FHF>GMHL� +�FH=>EH� I:K:��E;>KMB ?HB� NF�F>BH� =>� >LMN=:K� >� I>K<>;>K

Page 184: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 152

NF:� B=>B:� &Z� I:K:� �KNG>EE>L<AB� >� F:BL� M:K=>� I:K:� )B<A>E:G@>EH� :H� <HGMKZKBH� H

FH=>EH� >K:� :I:K>GM>F>GM>� : K>IK>L>GM:`^H =>�NF:� B=>B:� CZ� ?HKF:=:�G:�F>GM>

I:K:� L>KOBK� <HFH� NF� @NB:� I:K:� HI>KZKBHL� =>� <HGLMKN`^H�� *H� :G=:F>GMH� ?BG:E� =>

�E;>KMB� HL� FH=>EHL� L^H� MHM:EF>GM>� BGM>@K:=HL� GH� IKH<>LLH� >GOHEOB=HL� >F� <:=:

IHGMH�GH�=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=:�IKHIHLM:�>�G:�:GZEBL>�=:L�B=>B:L�IHK�MKZL�=H�IKHC>MH�

+�FH=>EH�>F�LB�a�H�O>c<NEH�=>�=>L<H;>KM:��a�?NG=:F>GM:E�I:K:�I>K<>;>K�>�<HKKB@BK

>LM:L� >?>F>KB=:=>L� B=>B:L� <HG<>BMN:BL� JN>� I:BK:F� LH;K>� :� <:;>`:� =H� :KJNBM>MH

=NK:GM>�HL�IKBF>BKHL�>LMZ@BHL�=>�=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=H�IKHC>MH�<HGMKB;NBG=H I:K:�:

>OHEN`^H� =:� IKHIHLM:� >F>K@>GM>� >LMBFNE:G=H� B=>B:L� => <HFH� H� F:M>KB:E� a

?HKF:=H�<HGMBGN:G=H�<HFH�:�;:L>�I:K:�:�FN=:G`:�>�=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�>F�MH=H�H

IKH<>LLH�=>�IKHC>MH�

)>LFH�<HF�:�FH=>E:@>F�F:BL�>GOHEOB=:�GH�IKH<>LLH�NF:�=BLMBG`^H� LNMBE� :BG=:

IH=>�L>K� ?>BM:�>GMK>�:�I:KMB<BI:`^H�=BK>M:�>� BG=BK>M:�IKH@GHLMB<:G=H�H�IKHC>MH��+L

FH=>EHL� IH=>F� L>K� BGMKH=NSB=HL� <HF� F:BHK� ?K>JNbG<B:� I:K:� O>KB?B<:K� H

=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=>� B=>B:L�>E>L�IH=>F�L>K�NMBEBS:=HL�I:K:�:O:EB:K�HL�:LI><MHL�G^H

OBLN:BL�=H�IKHC>MH� BG<ENBG=H�JN:EB=:=>L�:<hLMB<:L� K>LBLMbG<B:�=H�:K�>�=:�>LMKNMNK:

LN;C:<>GM>�� *H� >GM:GMH� :Ma� JN>� L>C:F <HFIK>>G=B=HL� >� F:GBINE:=HL� LN:

H;L>KO:`^H�I>KF:G><>�I:LLBO:��/HF>GM>�JN:G=H�H�FH=>EH�a�<HGM:M:=H�<HFH�NF:

?>KK:F>GM:� =>� >QIK>LL^H� <KB:MBO:� a� MHM:EF>GM>� NMBEBS:=H� MHKG:G=HL>� >L;H`H

MKB=BF>GLBHG:E�NF:�I:KM>�BGMKcGL><:�=H�I>GL:F>GMH�=H�:KJNBM>MH�LH;K>�H�IKHC>MH�

��>QIEHK:`^H�=H�NLH�=>�FH=>EHL�I:K:�H�>LMN=H�MKB=BF>GLBHG:E�=> NF:�>=B?B<:`^H a

<:K:<M>KcLMB<:�=H�IKH<>LLH�=>�<HG<>I`^H NF:�:;HK=:@>F�JN>�?EHK>L<>N�:H�EHG@H

=H�La<NEH�44����F:GBINE:`^H�?cLB<: =:�FH=>E:@>F GHL�:GHL�GHO>GM: =H�La<NEH�4%4

?HB EBFBM:=:� I:K:� H� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =>� =>M:EA>L HKG:F>GM:BL� >Q><N`^H� >LM:

K>:EBS:=:� IHK� >LI><B:EBLM:L� �>L<NEMHK>L� =>� :KJNBM>MNK:� >F LN;LMBMNB`^H� :HL

:KJNBM>MHL��!LM:�>M:I: MKHNQ>�H�F:GNL>BH =HL�FH=>EHL�=>�OHEM:�I:K:�H�IKH<>LLH�=>

NF: F>MH=HEH@B:� JN>� :GM>KBHKF>GM>� ?HK: IHN<H�NL:=:� =>L=>� H� I>KcH=H��:KKH<H�

�:LHL� IK><H<>L :I:K><>F�>F���� �JN:G=H�HL�F:M>KB:BL� MK:=B<BHG:BL� =H� >L<NEMHK

�:K@BE:�>�@>LLH��I:LL:K:F�:�L>K�>FIK>@:=HL >F�<HGCNGMH�<HF�:L� EBGA:L� ?ENB=:L�=H

Page 185: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 153

�KM�*HNO>:N >�F:BL�M:K=>�IHK #:N=B �?B@�������.N=HEIA�/M>BG>K �?B@���� ��$>KF:G

+;KBLM �?B@�������$:GL�,H>ESB@ >�!KB<�)>G=>ELHAG �?B@������ MH=HL�MK:;:EA:K:F�<HF

FH=>EHL�=>LM>�MBIH�

�HFH� F>=B=: <HGMcGN:� I:K:� L>� :FIEB:K� :L� ?>KK:F>GM:L� >QIEHK:MeKB:L� =:

FH=>E:@>F�O>KB?B<HNL>�:�:=H`^H�=>�F:M>KB:BL�F>GHL�F:E>ZO>BL�<HFH�H�I:I>E^H�>

:�?HEA:�=>�IEZLMB<H�GHL�JN:BL�I:LL:K:F�:�L>K�:IEB<:=HL G:�>Q><N`^H�=HL�MK:;:EAHL�

/BFNEM:G>:F>GM>� H� !LMBEH� %GM>KG:<BHG:E <HF>`:O:� :� =HFBG:K H� I:GHK:F:� =H

IKHC>MH�:KJNBM>MfGB<H�

"B@NK:������0HKK>�!BGLM>BG�!KB<A�)>G=>ELHG�"HGM>���AMMI���:KJAHR�;EH@LIHM�<HF�;K�� �����>LI><B:E>L:KJNBM><MNK:=>:R>K>KB<A�AMFE>F� ������ ��

"B@NK:�������:L:�)BEZ�#:N=B�"HGM>��AMMI���IBGM>K>LM�<HF�;>MLRCH���MA>EB?>PHKDH?@:N=B��>F� ������ ��

"B@NK:��� ��#H>MA>:GNF�/M>BG>K�"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�KL:K<ABO>�HK@�.>E�NMAHKL� :OR&HAG��>F� ������ ��

"B@NK:������$>KF:GG�+;KBLM�"HGM>�AMMI���MA><NEMNK>ONEMNK>�<H�ND�;EH@�:NMAHK�I:NE�>F ������ ��

Page 186: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 154

*:� L>@NG=:�F>M:=>� =H� La<NEH� 44 >LL>� NLH� >QI>KBF>GM:E� =HL�FH=>EHL L>� MHKGHN

F:BL� BGM>GLH�� +� I:I>E� <KN<B:E� =:� FH=>E:@>F L>� MHKG:� E:M>GM>� G:� H;K:� =>� !>KH

/::KBG>G I:K:�H�0>KFBG:E�03��>F;HK:�:KJNBM>MHL� <HFH�(>��HK;NLB>K�>�)B>L�O:G

=>K�.HA> M>GA:F L> ;:L>:=H >F�FH=>EHL�=>�>LMN=H�I:K: HL�L>NL�IKHC>MHL�GHL�:GHL

��� � > ��� � /::KBG>G� MK:;:EAHN� =>� ?HKF:� BGM>GLBO:� I:K:� =>L>GOHEO>K� ?HKF:L

<HFIE>Q:L� =H� >=B?c<BH� >� @:GA:K� <HG?B:G`:� MHM:E� =HL� L>NL� <HE:;HK:=HK>L� G:

F:GBINE:`^H�=H�FH=>EH� /::KBG>G�>�LN:�>JNBI> NMBEBS:K:F :L F:JN>M>L I:K:�<A>@:K

X� ?HKF:� @>K:E� =:� <HG<A:� =>� <HG<K>MH� JN>� <H;KB:� H� >=B?c<BH� !LM>L� IKBF>BKHL

>Q>FIE:K>L K>O>E:K:F� IKH;E>F:L� >LMKNMNK:BL > I:K:� >G<HGMK:K� NF:� ?HKF:� F:BL

Ee@B<:� =>S>G:L� =>� FH=>EHL� =>� I:I>E^H� <HKKN@:=H� ?HK:F >E:;HK:=HL

IHLM>KBHKF>GM>�� +L� FH=>EHL� L>� MHKG:K:F� H� ?H<H� :MBOH� =:L� K>NGBg>L� =>� >JNBI>

�I>KFBMBG=H :H�@KNIH =>L>GOHEO>K�<HKM>L�M>GM:MBO:L�M>LM>L�>�=BL<NLLg>L��>�>LM:O:F

GH�<>GMKH�=>�NF�=BZEH@H�OB@HKHLH�L>G=H IHK�O>S>L =BE:<>K:=HL�>�K><HGLMKNc=HL GH

EH<:E�=:L�K>NGBg>L �?B@��������������> �����

"B@NK:������!>KH�/::KBG>G 03��0>KFBG:E�"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�:K<A=:BER�<HF��������D>OBGKH<A>:K<ABM><MNK>:L>GOBKHGF>GM�MP:M>KFBG:E>>KHL::KBG>G:G=D>OBGKH<A>�>F �� ��� ��

"B@NK:������/::KBG>G�GH�BGM>KBHK�=:�F:JN>M>�"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�?:LM<H=>LB@G�<HF���� ����:LMNGGBG@LNKO>RH?IB<L;R>>KHL::KBG>GLBGAHNL>IAHMH@��>F�� ������ ��

"B@NK:������!>KH�/::KBG>G�=>�e<NEHL��>L:K�,>EEB��X�=BK>BM:��>'>OBG�.H<A>��H�L>@NG=H�:�>LJN>K=:��BGO>LMB@:F�:�F:JN>M>�"HGM>��)++*�':K>G��)H=>EBG@�)>LL:@>L�� ��I���

"B@NK:������!>KH�/::KBG>G 3:LABG@MHG NEE>L��BKIHKM�"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�:F:SHG�<HF�/::KBG>GFH=>E NEE>L%GM>KG:MBHG:E

�BKIHKM�=I�� �-/!54�

Page 187: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 155

*:� =a<:=:� =>� ��� � >LM:� O>KB?B<:`^H� L>� =>N� <HFH� NF:� IKZMB<:� <HKKBJN>BK:�� � +L

FH=>EHL�=>�>L;H`H�CZ�MBGA:F�>F�@K:G=>�I:KM>�L>�BG<HKIHK:=H�:HL =>L>GAHL�<HFH

?>KK:F>GM:L� ;ZLB<:L� I:K:� H� IKHC>MH� =>� :KJNBM>MNK:�� 2ZKBHL� >L<KBMeKBHL� =>� F:BHK

IHKM>�G:�!NKHI:�>��FaKB<:�<HFH�/DB=FHK>�+PBG@L���)>KKBEE �?B@������� %)�,>B��

,:KMG>KL �?B@�� ����� ,>KDBGL� ��3BEE� "HLM>K� :G=� ,:KMG>KL� �KNI� �LLH<B:M>L� >� ,ABEBI

&HAGLHG �?B@�� ����� >LM:;>E><>K:F� HL� FH=>EHL� <HFH� ?HK`:� OBM:E� G:� K>LHEN`^H� =H

IKHC>MH�

"B@NK:������/DB=FHK>�+PBG@L�>�)>KKBEE /+)���AB<:@HlL�%GE:G=�/M>>E��NBE=BG@�&HAG�$:G<H<D��>GM>K�:G=�/>:KL�0HP>K�"HGM>�AMMI���PPP�LHF�<HF�G>PL�E>@>G=:KR:K<ABM><M;KN<>C@K:A:F=B>L�>F� ����� ���

"B@NK:������%)�,>B�>�:�F:JN>M>�=>�+DE:AHF: �����"HGM>�AMMI���HMKHHMKH;EH@�;EH@LIHM�<HF�;K�� ��9 �9 �9:K<ABO>�AMFE�>F ����� ���

"B@NK:������,ABEBI�&HAGLHG�(BG<HEG��>GM>K�?HK�MA>,>K?HKFBG@��KML�>F�*HO:�5HKD�"HGM>�AMMI���PPP�:<AB>O>F>GM�HK@�:NMH=H<�IAHMH<K>=BM�:<AB>O>KL�CHA

���>F� ����� ���

Page 188: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 156

!LL: A:;BEB=:=> <K>L<>N�BGM>KG:<BHG:EF>GM>�>�G:�OBK:=:�=H�La<NEH�44%�:�?:;KB<:`^H

KZIB=:� =>� >L;H`HL� FhEMBIEHL� >� FH=>EHL� =>� >LMN=H GHL� F>LFHL� FHE=>L

:IK>L>GM:=HL�IHK�/::KBG>G L>�MHKG:K:F NF:�IKZMB<:�FNBMH�F:BL�<HFNF�

� =BL<NLL^H�:MN:E�=H�NLH�=HL�FH=>EHL G:�BFIK>GL: JN> K>@BLMK:�HL�:<HGM><BF>GMHL

=:� ZK>:� =: :KJNBM>MNK:� FHLMKHN NF� BGM>K>LL>� F:BL :FIEH� GH� IKH<>LLH =:

FH=>E:@>F� +�>FIK>@H =>�FH=>EHL MKB=BF>GLBHG:BL� ?cLB<HL >F :E@NGL IKHC>MHL =>

"K:GD� #>AKR F>K><>K:F� >Q:@>K:=HL� >EH@BHL >F� =BO>KL:L� IN;EB<:`g>L =:� hEMBF:

=a<:=:�=H�La<NEH�I:LL:=H�

�� =>L<KB`^H� =>� #>AKR� LH;K>� H� I:I>E� =>L>FI>GA:=H� I>EHL� FH=>EHL� GH

=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=>�L>N�IKHC>MH�I:K:�H � ����������������� �!������ >F ,K:@:�a

;:LM:GM>�<HGA><B=: GH�F>BH�=HL�>LMN=BHLHL�G:�ZK>: �?B@� �� ��

"B@NK:��� � "K:GD #>AKR k �KBG@BG@ )HO>F>GM MH �K<ABM><MNK>�� 0A> :G<BG@ $HNL> � �K<ABM><M�"K:GD�#>AKR�BG�HGO>KL:MBHG�� "K:GD�#>AKR�BG�<HGO>KL:MBHG�PBMA��:K;:K:�%L>G;>K@����E>Q�.HLL�"HGM>�AMMI���PPP�RHNMN;>�<HF�P:M<A�O��>�+2�&B3:H AMMI���PPP�RHNMN;>�<HF�P:M<A�O�AE6��;0OIBP>FAMMI���?HK:�MO�� � ��������K<ABM><M9"K:GD9#>AKR9BG9�HGO>KL:MBHG AMMI���PPP�GRIE�HK@�:N=BHOB=>H�?K:GD@>AKR<HGO>KL:MBHG;:K;:K:BL>G;>K@:E>QKHLL�>F� �� ��� ���

Page 189: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 157

#>AKR�G:KK:�>F�NF:�=>�LN:L�>GMK>OBLM:L �#>AKR � ��>GMK>OBLM: �#������!����

�����$�

7���8 !N� >LM:O:� ENM:G=H� <HF� H� KHFIBF>GMH� =:L� C:G>E:L� :=C:<>GM>L� =HL

>=B?c<BHL� =H� La<NEH� 4%4��� >GM^H� >N� I>GL>B� JN>� IH=>KB:� ?:S>K� ;HK=:L

:;:NE:=:L I:K:� JN>� :L� I>LLH:L� G^H� I>K<>;>LL>F� :� >QBLMbG<B:� =>� F:BL

:G=:K>L� !N� BGB<B>B� :� >E:;HK:`^H� =H� FH=>EH� >� <HF><>B� :� >FINKK:K� :L

C:G>E:L�I:K:�<BF:�>�I:K:�;:BQH�� !FINKK:=H�NF�:Ma�H� MHIH�=H� M>MH�> I:K:

;:BQH�:Ma�MH<:K�H�<A^H����!N�<HGLMKNc�GH�FH=>EH�:�M>QMNK:�

.>?>KBG=HL>� :H� IKHC>MH� =:� �:L:� :G`:GM>� JN>� L>� BGB<BHN� >F� ������ +� !=B?c<BH

M:F;aF� ?HB�:I>EB=:=H�=>�"K>=�> #BG@>K�I>E:�IHINE:`^H� EH<:E �?B@����� ��� ����>

�����

"B@NK:����� )H=>EH�"BG:E� !=B?c<BH *>=>KE:G=>G>F ,K:@: "K:GD #>AKR�"HGM>� .>OBLM:�!E��KHJNBL��������"K:GD�#>AKR����������I��� �

"B@NK:������)H=>EH�=H�IKH<>LLH BGB<B:E �!=B?c<BH *>=>KE:G=>G >F ,K:@: "K:GD #>AKR�"HGM>� #!$.5�"���K<ABM><MNK>���IKH<>LL�� ���I����

"B@NK:������)H=>EH�=H�<HGM>QMH�NK;:GH� !=B?c<BH *>=>KE:G=>G >F ,K:@: "K:GD #>AKR�"HGM>� .>OBLM:�!E��KHJNBL��������"K:GD�#>AKR����������I��� �

"B@NK:������)H=>EH�=H�IKH<>LLH�=>�MK:;:EAH� !=B?c<BH *>=>KE:G=>G >F ,K:@: "K:GD #>AKR� �������"HGM>� .>OBLM:�!E��KHJNBL��������"K:GD�#>AKR����������I��� ��� �

Page 190: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 158

+ =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =H� La<NEH� 44� =>BQHN� >OB=>GM> JN> NMBEBS:G=H� H� IKH<>LLH� =>

FH=>E:@>F�G:�=>?BGB`^H�=:�:KJNBM>MNK:�L>�>LM:;>E><>F�F>BHL�?NG=:F>GM:BL�I:K:�H

=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=HL�IKHC>MHL�?:<BEBM:G=H�:�<HFIK>>GL^H�=:�MKB=BF>GLBHG:EB=:=>�

!E>L� M:F;aF� MbF� :MK:c=H :KJNBM>MHL� I:K:� NF� >GOHEOBF>GMH� F:BL� ?cLB<H� <HF

IKH;E>F:L� =>� K>LHEN`^H� =H� IKHC>MH�� � �L� JN>LMg>L� G^H� HK;BM:F� F:BL >F NF:

mIK:G<A>M:n� :� G:MNK>S:� =:� :MBOB=:=>� =:� :KJNBM>MNK:� ?HB� LNMBEF>GM>� :EM>K:=:� +

>L<KBMeKBH� *��&� >F� />:MME> �?B@�� ���� K><>GM>F>GM>� BGLM:EHN� NF ���#���� JN>

<HGM:� <HF� IKH?BLLBHG:BL� =:� ZK>:� =:� FH=>E:@>F�� /N:� FBLL^H� a� :� =>� BG<>GMBO:K� :

BGM>@K:`^H�=>�FH=>EHL�GH�FaMH=H�=>�<HG<>I`^H�G:�?:L>�BGB<B:E�=H�IKH<>LLH�<KB:MBOH�

��>FIK>L:�M>F�:�<HGOB<`^H�=>�JN>�HL�FH=>EHL�K>:EF>GM>�>LMBFNE:F�HL�:KJNBM>MHL :

I>GL:K�=B?>K>GM>�� >;:M>L�L^H�HK@:GBS:=HL�>�=BL<NLLg>L�>GMK>�:KJNBM>MHL�=:�*��&�>

FH=>EBLM:L�MK:M:F�=>�E>O:GM:K�JN>LMg>L�K>E>O:GM>L�LH;K>�:L�F:JN>M>L�

-N:GMH� F:BHK� H� >GOHEOBF>GMH� =HL� L>GMB=HL� <HF� H� FH=>EH� I>K<>;>L>� NF

:IKBFHK:F>GMH�=:�HIHKMNGB=:=> M:F;aF =>�:IK>G=BS:@>F�JN>�:?>M:�H�IKH<>LLH

=>�NF�BG=BOc=NH�I>GL:GM>�JN>�L>�MHKG:�F:BL�:MBOH��$Z�:E@H�FNBMH�=B?>K>GM>�>F�NF:

>QI>KBbG<B:�MZMBE :�<HFIK>>GL^H�a�=B?>K>GM>�=H�>GM>G=BF>GMH�=:L�<HBL:L�JN>�G^H�L>

IH=>�>GM>G=>K�:I>G:L�<HF�H�HEA:K �<?� <:IcMNEH ���

"B@NK:����� !L<KBMeKBH�*��&�>F�/>:MME>"HGM>��AMMI���@K>>GLHNK<>�<HGLMKN<MBHG�<HF�G>PL� � � ��EE>R���:LI�>F� �� ��� ��

Page 191: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 159

$HC>� :� F:GBINE:`^H� =>� F:M>KB:BL� =>� NF:� ?HKF:� F:BL� IEZLMB<:� MHKGHNL>� FNBMH

=B?NG=B=:����:MBOB=:=>�<HGM>FIHK\G>:�=:�FH=>E:@>F�BG<ENB�F:M>KB:BL�=>�FHE=:@>F

=BO>KLB?B<:=HL� �HFH�IHK�>Q>FIEH�

.>LBG:L LBGMaMB<:L

"B@NK:����� ):JN>M>L�>F�K>LBG:�LBGMaMB<:�"HGM>��. !%/!.���.1.��K<ABM><MNK>��K<ABM><MNK:E�)H=>E�(>:=�MH� >LB@G��� � ��I�����

� ,BG:NEM�)H=>KG��KM�)NL>NF�):GN>EE>�#:NMK:G=��K<ABM><MNK>

� $B@A�/JN:K>�& /��K<ABM><ML

��>�� "BEFNL>NF�*(��K<ABM><ML

� �:<>K>L�#NMB>KK>S >E:?N>GM>��KJNBM><MHL

Page 192: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 160

�<KcEB<H

"B@NK:����� ):JN>M>L�>F�:<KcEB<H"HGM>��. !%/!. ��.1.��K<ABM><MNK>��K<ABM><MNK:E�)H=>E�(>:=�MH� >LB@G��� � ��I�����

� "BEBILM:K=�/I:<>@KHNI

� HN;EBG@��<ABM><ML

��>�� �NEE?B@AM>KlL��HLMNF>�#BE;>KMH�.NBS�

� �

� �

Page 193: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 161

,:I>E

� �

� �

"B@NK:����� ):JN>M>L�>F�I:I>E"HGM>��. !%/!.���.1.��K<ABM><MNK>��K<ABM><MNK:E�)H=>E�(>:=�MH� >LB@G��� � ��I��� ��

�/MN��:FINL��C�(BF�/MN=BH����K<ABM><ML

� /IHKMI:E>BL�*(��K<ABM><ML

� &�$HNL>��>=L

� )NL>N�=:�#N>KK:�m��� n�!� )

� /NLL>G;KNGG� :M:?B>E=0A>�*>QM�!GM>KIKBL>

Page 194: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 162

):=>BK:

"B@NK:����� ):JN>M>L�>F�F:=>BK:"HGM>��. !%/!.���.1.��K<ABM><MNK>��K<ABM><MNK:E�)H=>E�(>:=�MH� >LB@G��� � ��I��� ��

� �

� �>GMKH��NEMNK:E��N=BMeKBH�>�!L<HE:K� >�)NLB<:�3BEER�)iEE>K��K<ABM><ML

� �HGLIBK:MBHG��HFFHGL�2!./�� >LB@G

� )HGM>�(:;;KH�.>L>:K<A��>GM>K��MK��K<ABM>MMNK:

� �BFIHL>K�0NK;BG�)HGNF>GM�6BSB���5HRH

� 0>KK:<BG:�$:K;HK�����K<ABM><ML

� �

Page 195: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 163

)>M:E

� �

"B@NK:��� � ):JN>M>L�>F�F>M:E"HGM>��. !%/!.���.1.��K<ABM><MNK>��K<ABM><MNK:E�)H=>E�(>:=�MH� >LB@G��� � ��I��� ��

� /AHIIBG@��NEMNK:E�>��HF>K<B:E�":GM:LMB<��K<ABM><MNK>�

� )NLN>�=>��KM>�)H=>KG:�(BEE>�):GN>EE>�#N:MK:G=��K<ABM><MNK>

� �:L:��:K:D:E=H�3BEER�)iEE>K��K<ABM><ML

Page 196: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 164

)BL<>E\G>:L �

� �

� �

��

"B@NK:����� ):JN>M>L�FBL<>E\G>:L�"HGM>��. !%/!.���.1.��K<ABM><MNK>��K<ABM><MNK:E�)H=>E�(>:=�MH� >LB@G��� � ��I��� ��

� /H<B:E�0>QMBE>�.���/B>

� �>G=�1I���>G=�+O>K�*(��K<ABM><ML

� �<:=>FB<�3HKD�(BF:�1K;:G�(:;

� �:I>�,:EHL�):KMBF>�,:MA 4IBK:E

�,:K:EHHI �<M:K��KJNBM><MNK:

� %=>GLBM:M�*:;BMH��KJNBM><MNK:�/���,�

� �

Page 197: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 165

� <HG<>I`^H�@>K:E�=: ?HKF:�?HB H ?H<H�=:�FH=>E:@>F�GH�La<NEH�44 �>F�HIHLB`^H :H

?H<H�=H�La<NEH�4%4�JN>�?HK:�F:K<:=H�I>EH HKG:F>GMH� > BG<>GMBOHN�:�G><>LLB=:=>

=>� >QIEHK:`^H� MKB=BF>GLBHG:E� NF:�F:BHK� =BLIHGB;BEB=:=>� =>�F:M>KB:BL :=>JN:=HL

I:K:�NLH�>F�:M>EB>KL�?HB�H;L>KO:=:�<HF�<HGMKB;NB`^H�

+� NLH� >QI>KBF>GM:E� =>� FH=>EHL� @>K:F :KM>?:MHL <:MBO:GM>L� JN>� >F>K@>F� =H

IKH<>LLH�<KB:MBOH�>F�=B?>K>GM>L <HG<>I`g>L�?HKF:BL �?B@������> ����� +�L>GMBF>GMH

=>� >FH`^H� >� BGLIBK:`^H� JN>� FNBM:L� O>S>L� :<HFI:GA:� :� K>LIHLM:� BGB<B:E� =H

:KJNBM>MH� I:K:� NF� ;K>O>� IKHC>MH� >LMZ� IK>L>GM>� GHL� IKBF>BKHL� :KM>?:MHL� <KB:=HL�

)NBMH� F>GHL� K>LMKBMHL =H� JN> HL FH=>EHL ?BG:BL� �=>� K>IKH=N`^H� =:� H;K:�� >LL>L

H;C>MHL�>F;KBHGZKBHL�>QIK>LL:F :�OBL^H�IKBFZKB:�=H�:NMHK I:K:�NF�IKHC>MH�>�FNBM:L

O>S>L�K>O>E:F I:K: H�HNMKH�H�<HG<>BMH�=>�BGLIBK:`^H�HN�=:�B=>B:�<HG<>;B=:�>F�LN:

F:BL�INK:�?HKFNE:`^H�

"B@NK:��������LaKB>�=>�BF:@>GL�=>FHGLMK:�H�IKH<>LLH�=>�=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�IKHC>MN:E=:�,HGM>�,:KH=B�1*�/MN=BH�"HGM>�� 1**�*B<<D�):JN>M:L�=>��KJNBM><MNK:�� � ��I����

"B@NK:������,KH<>LLH�IHLM>KBHK�:L�F:JN>M>L�BGB<B:BL�F:JN>M>�=>�>QIEHK:`^H�K>:EBS:=:�<HF�=B?>K>GM>L�F:M>KB:BL�,HGM>�,:KH=B�1*�/MN=BH�"HGM>�� 1**�*B<<D�):JN>M:L�=>��KJNBM><MNK:�� � ��I����

Page 198: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 166

)NBM:L�O>S>L HL�FH=>EHL�>E:;HK:=HL�GHL�:M>EB>KL�=>�IKHC>MH�L^H�F:BL�IE>G:F>GM>

BF;Nc=HL =H�>LIcKBMH�=H�:NMHK�>�=>�L>NL�B=>:BL�=H�JN>�H�IKH=NMH�:<:;:=H�>�JN>�IHK

O>S>L�I:LL:�:�L>K�M>K<>BKBS:=H�IHK�>FIK>L:L�>LI><B:EBS:=:L� ,HKaF�>F�:E@NGL�<:LHL

:�LBMN:`^H�IH=>�L>K O>KB?B<:=:�=>�F:G>BK:� BGO>KL:�<HFH�IHK�>Q>FIEH�HL�FH=>EHL

=H��>GMKH�&H:G��K>LIB;:L�>F�,:EF:�=>�):EEHK<: �?B@��������+;L>KO:FHL�NF�FH=>EH

>Q><NM:=H� I>EH� >L<KBMeKBH� :NMHK� =H� IKHC>MH� H� (� �� � k >� (:� ,N>KM:� �� �KL>GLBH

�?B@������IHLM>KBHK X�<HGJNBLM:�=H�<HG<NKLH�� > HNMKH�E:=H�: F:JN>M>�:IK>L>GM:=:

G:�<HG<HKKbG<B:�=H�<HG<NKLH�>E:;HK:=H�IHK�#BE;>KMH�.NBS �?B@�������F:JN>MBLM:�=>

K>GHF>� G:� >NKHI:� >� K><HGA><B=H� IHK� @K:G=>L� :IK>L>GM:`g>L� =>� FH=>EHL� G:L

>M:I:L�=>�:O:EB:`g>L�Ih;EB<:L�=HL�<HG<NKLHL�=>�IKHC>MHL�=>�:KJNBM>MNK:�

�GMHBG>� ,K>=H<D� >QIEB<:� -N:G=H� NF� IKHC>MH� >LMZ� MHF:G=H� ?HKF:� HN� >F� NF

>LMZ@BH�>F;KBHGZKBH�HL�=>L>GAHL�L^H�FNBM:L�O>S>L�KZIB=HL�>�BF>=B:MHL�NF�MBIH�=>

<H=B?B<:`^H� HN� *�� JN>� :<K>L<>GM:KZ� =:=HL� I:K:� :� @>K:`^H� =H� >=B?c<BH�� !LL>L

"B@NK:������!=B?c<BH �>GMKH�&H:G��K>LIB;:L�>F�,:EF: =>�):EEHK<:� (�����"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�=>E:IN>KM:�<HF��>F�������� ��

"B@NK:������):JN>M>�=H �>GMKH�&H:G��K>LIB;:L�>F�,:EF:=>�):EEHK<:�� (������!E:;HK:=:�I>EHL�:NMHK>L�=H�IKHC>MH�"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�=>E:IN>KM:�<HF��>F�������� ��

"B@NK:������):JN>M>�=H �>GMKH�&H:G��K>LIB;:L�>F�,:EF:�=>�):EEHK<:�� (������!E:;HK:=:�IHK�):J#BE k #BE;>KMH�.NBS�"HGM>��"HMH =:��NMHK:

Page 199: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 167

=>L>GAHL� IK>EBFBG:K>L� HN� :GM><BI:MeKBHL� E>O:F� XL F:JN>M>L� MKB=BF>GLBHG:BL� >F

:K@BE: JN>�IH=>F�L>K FBGB:MNK:L�HN�FNBMH�@K:G=>L���H� MK:;:EA:K� <HF�:�:K@BE: H

:KJNBM>MH� <HGMBGN:� >QIEHK:G=H�F:L� MK:;:EA: ;NL<:G=H� NF:� ?BG:EB=:=> �?B@�� �����

-N:G=H <HFI:K:=:L�<HF�=>L>GAHL�LH;K>�I:I>E�:L�F:JN>M>L�L^H�FNBMH�F:BL�K>:BL�

>E:L�L^H�:�>=B?B<:`^H��!E:L�G^H�L^H�F:JN>M>L�=>�OHENF>L��>E:L�MK:M:F�K:<BHG:EF>GM>

=>�L><`g>L�>�IE:GM:L;:BQ:L �)%((/�� ��I�� ���

!LL: =>L<KB`^H a�B@N:EF>GM>�:IEB<ZO>E�: HNMKHL�IKH?BLLBHG:BL�JN> =>LM:<:F H�<:KZM>K

L>FBG:E =:�NMBEBS:`^H�=>�FH=>EHL�IHK ?HKG><>F�NF�IHGMH�=>�K>?>KbG<B:�I:K:�JN>F

JN>K� >GM>G=>K� :� G:MNK>S:� =H� <HG<>BMH� =>� NF� >=B?c<BH� )H=>EHL L^H� H;C>MHL� =>

BF:@BG:`^H�JN>�>F�LB� L^H� LcF;HEHL�=>� BGM>G`^H� BGM>GL:F>GM> LB@GB?B<:MBOHL�I:K:

L>NL� :NMHK>L�� 0:BL�FH=>EHL� IH=>F� L>K� MHM:EF>GM>� >?bF>KHL� LNLI>GLHL� <HF� ?BM:

L>@K>@:=HL� K>?>BMHL� =>L<:KM:=HL > :LLBF BGMBF:F>GM> IH=>F :<HFI:GA:K� H

IKH<>LLH�=>�I>GL:F>GMH��!E>L�M:F;aF IH=>F�L>K�?:;KB<:=HL�F:BL�LHEB=:F>GM>�>

IKH=NSB=HL >F L>JNbG<B:� <:=:� NF� K>IK>L>GM:G=H� NF:� ?:L>� ?BGBM: GH

=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�=:�B=>B: <HFH FHF>GMHL�<HG@>E:=HL�GH�M>FIH�

"B@NK:����� ):JN>M>L�>F�:K@BE: �GMHBG>�,K>=H<D� )NL>N�=H�,:EZ<BH�*:<BHG:E ):KREB:G �>GM>K �HEE>@>�,:KD��/:G� B>@H !L<HE:�2>GM:G:�KBSHG:"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�IK>=H<D�<HF��E:R�<E:R�AMFE�>F�� �� �� ��

Page 200: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 168

+L�FH=>EHL�L^H�BGMKH=NSB=HL�GH�IKH<>LLH�=>�IKHC>MH�>F�OZKB:L�?:L>L��0K:;:EA:K�<HF

FH=>EHL <HFH� :� IKBF>BK:� BGM>G`^H� IKHC>MN:E� :GM>L� => NL:K� HNMKHL� F>BHL� =>

<HFNGB<:`^H�G^H�a�:�IKZMB<:�F:BL�<HGO>G<BHG:E��*H�>GM:GMH�>LM>�IKH<>LLH�L>�=Z

G:MNK:EF>GM>�I:K:�:JN>E>L IKH?BLLBHG:BL�JN>�:IK>L>GM:F NF�ABLMeKB<H�=>� <HGM:MH

<HF�F:M>KB:BL�>�>E>F>GMHL�?>BMHL <HF�:L F^HL�

$:GB�.:LAB= �?B@����� <K>L<>N�>F NF:�:MFHL?>K: =>�:MBOB=:=>L�:KM>L:G:BL�;:L>:=:

G:L� MK:=B`g>L� =:� :KM>� FH=>KG:�� />N� I:B� >K:� NF� >L<NEMHK� <>K:FBLM:� >� IBGMHK�

!GJN:GMH� >E>� >LM:O:� G:� @K:=N:`^H� =H� <NKLH� =>� :KJNBM>MNK:� H� L>N� IKH<>LLH� =>

FH=>E:@>F� >K: OBLMH� <HFH� IHN<H� HKMH=HQH� IHBL BGB<B:O:� L>NL� IKHC>MHL� <HF� NF

FH=>EH� :GM>L F>LFH� =>� L>� :IKHIKB:K� =>� NF: <:G>M: >� NF I:I>E� />N� IKH<>LLH

IKHC>MN:E� H<HKKB:� BGB<B:EF>GM>� I>E:� FH=>E:@>F� >� IHLM>KBHKF>GM>� =:O:

IKHLL>@NBF>GMH X >LMKNMNK:`^H� <HF� =>L>GAHL� ,:K:� .:LAB=� K>LIHGLZO>E� I>EH

>L<KBMeKBH ��$�� � ��:L�>LMK:Ma@B:L�?HKF:BL�JN>�>FIK>@:F�H�IKH<>LLH�=>�IKHC>MH

G^H�L^H�:NMfGHF:L�I:K:�>E> HL�FH=>EHL�MbF�?BGL�FhEMBIEHL�IHG=>K:=HL�=>�:<HK=H

<HF�H�IKHIeLBMH�=H�:KJNBM>MH�

"B@NK:����� �LRFIMHM>��K<ABM><MNK> k MHNK�=>�>LMN=:GM>L�GH�>L<KBMeKBH�=>�$:GB�.:LAB=��KBSHG: "HGM>� PPP�?:<>;HHD�<HF�/MN=BH$:GB.:LAB= � �� �� ��

Page 201: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 169

"B@NK:����� �KHJNB�LH;K>�F:JN>M> �HHI�$BFF>E;�E�:N�"HGM>��AMMI���=CI:K<A�MNF;EK�<HF��>F�� ����� ��

"B@NK:��� ���KHJNB�LH;K>�?HMH�)NL>N #N@@>GFA>BF��BE;:H�"K:GD�#>AKR�"HGM>��2�*��.1##!*�"K:GD�+��#>AKR� !E�)NL>H�#N@@>GA>BF��BE;:H�������I����

+NMKHL :KJNBM>MHL�<HF�?HKM>L� BG?ENbG<B:L G: :KM>�>L<NEMeKB<: <HFI:KMBEA:K:F�=>LL:

I>KLI><MBO:� �HFH� OBFHL� :GM>KBHKF>GM> �GMHGB� #:N=B� IHK� >Q>FIEH� :=>KBN :H

MK:;:EAH� =BK>MH <HF� HL FH=>EHL� ?cLB<HL :GM>L� =>� ?:S>K� =>L>GAHL� >F� I:I>E

>G<A>G=H� L>NL� >LMh=BHL� <HF� NF:� O:KB>=:=>� =>� KZIB=HL� FH=>EHL� >F� @>LLH�� *H

>GM:GMH�IHK�F:BL�JN>�:E@NGL�:KJNBM>MHL�BGLBLM:F�JN>�H�NLH�=HL�FH=>EHL�a => F:BL

KZIB=:�>E:;HK:`^H =H�JN>�H�=>L>GAH�:�<HGO>GBbG<B: <HFI:K:MBO:�>�:<>LLB;BEB=:=>

=:�K>IK>L>GM:`^H�;B=BF>GLBHG:E �H�>L;H`H�IHK�>Q>FIEH��G^H�IH=>F�L>K�G>@:=HL�

�HGL>JN>GM>F>GM>�>GJN:GMH�:E@NGL�:KJNBM>MHL� ?:S>F�>QI>KBF>GMHL =BK>M:F>GM>

GH�FH=>EH�a�F:BL�<HFNF�H�FH=>EH�L>@NBK�NF�>L;H`H�BGB<B:E�

*H�>L<KBMeKBH�=>�.B<A:K=�.H@>KL�,:KMG>KLABI�>F�(HG=K>L�HL�FH=>EHL�L^H�>E:;HK:=HL

=>IHBL�=HL�<KHJNBL� 3HE?�,KBQ�>�$>EFNM�/PB<SBGLDR =:��HHI�$BFF>E;�E�:N�G: UNLMKB:

M:F;aF� <HF>`:F� <HF� NF� =>L>GAH� �:� F:K<:� >FH<BHG:E HL� IKeIKBHL�� >

IHLM>KBHKF>GM>�FHO>FL>�I:K:�BGB<B:K�NF�IKH<>LLH�JN>�L>�:EM>K: K:IB=:F>GM>�I:K:

HL FH=>EHL �?B@�������+�IKH<>LLH�>GM^H�HL<BE: >GMK>�=>L>GAHL FH=>EHL�BF:@>GL�>

FH=>EHL�=B@BM:EBS:=HL��"K:GD�#>AKR�MK:;:EA:�>F�L>NL�>QI>KBF>GMHL�<HF�=>L>GAHL

=>�EBGA:L K:IB=:F>GM>�>Q><NM:=:L�>GJN:GMH�HL�;EH<HL�LBFIE>L�JN>�K>IK>L>GM:F�HL

<HFIHG>GM>L� =H� IKH@K:F:� L^H� FH=>E:=HL� IHK� LN:� >JNBI>�� -N:G=H� H� IKH<>LLH

:O:G`:�HL�IKBF>BKHL H;C>MHL >QIK>LLBOHL L>�?HKF:F ;:L>:=HL�G>LL>L�>L;H`HL �?B@�

�� ��

��F:BL�BG<HFNF�?HKF:�;B=BF>GLBHG:E�=:�<HG<>I`^H�<:K:<M>KBS:L>�I>EH�FaMH=H�=>

IKHC>MH =>�3BEE��ELHI �?B@� ��� > ���� > =>�6:A:�$:=B= �?B@�������>��?B@������� +L�=HBL

:KJNBM>MHL�=>L>GOHEO>F LN:L�B=>B:L�>F�IBGMNK:L�>�>L;H`HL�L>FB:;LMK:MHL�:H�E:=H

Page 202: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 170

=>� >LMN=HL� =>� ?HKF:L� MKB=BF>GLBHG:BL� �L� IBGMNK:L� =>� �ELHI� ?K>JN>GM>F>GM>

IK><>=>F� >� L> MHKG:K� ;:L>� I:K:� HL� FH=>EHL�� �NKBHL:F>GM>� >LM>� IKH<>LLH

B=BHLLBG<KZMB<H�a�OBLMH�IHK�L>NL�:NMHK>L�<HFH�;:LM:GM>�LBFIE>L�

�E@NGL�:KJNBM>MHL BGB<B:F�L>N�IKH<>LLH <HF�?HKFNE:`g>L�>LJN>FZMB<:L�=:�B=>B:�=H

IKHC>MH�� /M>O>G�$HEE� <KB:� >F�=B:@K:F:L� =>� <HG<>BMH �?B@�� ����� <HF�;:L>� >F�NF:

BGMNB`^H� BGB<B:E O>KB?B<:� JN>� HL� =B:@K:F:L� L^H� <HG<>BMHL� MK:GL?HKF:=HL� >F

>E>F>GMHL� OBLN:BL� I>EHL� JN:BL� H� <HG<>BMH� IH=>� L>K� <HFIK>>G=B=H� >� =:K� HKB@>F� X

I:KMB=HL� ?HKF:BL� =H� H;C>MH� :� >E:� <HG<>;B=H� !LM:L� BG?HKF:F� :� K>:EBS:`^H� =>� NF:

LaKB>�=>�FH=>EHL�=>L>GAHL�> mK>G=>KBS:`g>Ln�=>�:JN:K>E:L� + IKHC>MH�=H�)NL>N�=>

�KM>� �HGM>FIHK\G>:� => $>ELBGDB JN>� =>L=>� H� BGc<BH� =H� IKH<>LLH� <KB:MBOH >LM:O:

"B@NK:������,BGMNK:�3BEE��ELHI"HGM>�AMMI���PPP�:ME:LBG=NLMKB>L�<HF�BG=>Q�IAI�E�����MRI>�LEB=>���>F�� ����� ��

"B@NK:������):JN>M>�=>�=>L>GOHEOBF>GMH�� �� �ELHI��K<ABM><ML"HGM>��AMMI���O��:KDBM>K:�<HF�>O>GM�IAI�:<MBHG�=BLIE:R!O>GM�% ��� ��>F

� ����� ��

"B@NK:����� ,BGMNK:�6:A:�$:=B= 2BMK:�"BK>�/M:MBHG"HGM>�AMMI���E>;;>NLPHH=L�PHK=IK>LL�<HF�� �� �����S:A:A:=B=L=K:PBG@L���>F�� ����� ��

"B@NK:����� 2BMK:�"BK>�/M:MBHG FH=>EH�>F�I:I>E 6:A:�$:=B=�"HGM>��AMMI���LNFF>KLL<>� �PHK=IK>LL�<HF�� � � �����K>?>K>G<>BF:@>LIKHC><M��S:A:A:=B=��>F�� ����� ��

Page 203: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 171

I:NM:=H�IHK�I>KLI><MBO:L�L>KO>�=>�>Q>FIEH��H FNL>N�=>O>KB:�<HGM>K�NF:�LaKB> =>

>LI:`HL =>LMBG:=HL�:�<HFI:KMBF>GMHL� BG=BOB=N:BL IHKM:GMH =>L>GOHEO>K:F OZKBHL

FH=>EHL� =>� >LMN=H� >F� @>LLH� O:E>G=H� =: G:MNK>S:� OHENFaMKB<:� =H� <HG<>BMH�� +

IKH<>LLH�L>�=>N�:�I:KMBK�=>LL>L�FH=>EHL�=>�@>LLH�HG=>�:�>LMK:Ma@B:�<HG<>BMN:E�?HB

O:@:F>GM>� =>?BGB=:� I:K:� H� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =>� MH=HL� HL� :LI><MHL� BGM>KGHL�� $HEE

>E:;HKHN� >GM^H� I>KLI><MBO:L� :JN:K>E:=:L� :GM>KBHK>L� XL� IE:GM:L� *>LM>� IKHC>MH

>Q><NM:K:F� HL FH=>EHL� ;:L>:=HL� GHL� =>L>GAHL �?B@�� ���� > IHLM>KBHKF>GM>

>E:;HK:K:F :L�IE:GM:L �?B@�������

"B@NK:����� /M>O>G�$HEE� ):JN>M> 'B:LF:�)NL>N�=>��KM>��HGM>FIHK\G>:�$>ELBGDB����������"HGM>� $+(( 0%�*!*��)NL>NF�H?��HGM>FIHK:KR��KM�:G=�0A>�"BGGBLA��NBE=BG@��>GM>K�(M=�����

"B@NK:����� /M>O>G�$HEE�,E:GM:L�Ma<GB<:L 'B:LF:�)NL>N�=>��KM>�HGM>FIHK\G>:�$>ELBGDB����������"HGM>� $+(( 0%�*!*��)NL>NF�H?��HGM>FIHK:KR��KM�:G=�0A>�"BGGBLA��NBE=BG@��>GM>K(M=�����

"B@NK:����� /M>O>G�$HEE���HGCNGMH�=>�=>L>GAHL�'B:LF:�)NL>N�=>��KM>�HGM>FIHK\G>:�$>ELBGDB����������"HGM>� $+(( 0%�*!*��)NL>NF�H?��HGM>FIHK:KR��KM�:G=�0A>�"BGGBLA��NBE=BG@��>GM>K�(M=�����

Page 204: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 172

*:�F:BHKB:�=HL�<:LHL >F�JN> HL�:KJNBM>MHL� BGB<B:F�L>NL�IKH<>LLHL�IHK�FH=>EHL�H

L>N� NLH� a� <HGMBGN:=H� :H� EHG@H� =H� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =H� IKHC>MH�� �� :;HK=:@>F

:=HM:=:�IH=>� O:KB:K��)B<A:>E� /HKDBG�>QIEHK:� K>E:`g>L� ?HKF:BL� >� LHEN`g>L�>F�NF:

:MBOB=:=>� IKeQBF:� =:� >L<NEMNK:� !F� LN:� HIBGB^H� H� FH=>EH� ?cLB<H� a� NF� F>BH

>LL>G<B:E� =>� =>L>GAH� :LLBF� <HFH� a� H� I>GL:F>GMH� =>� NF� :FIEH� >LI><MKH� =>

:KJNBM>MHL :�FH=>E:@>F�a�NF:�Ma<GB<:�?NG=:F>GM:E�G:�;NL<:�=:�?HKF:�

#>AKR� ,:KMG>KL� =>L>GOHEO>N� NF� IKH<>LLH� >QIK>LLBOH� >� BGMNBMBOH� >F� JN>�FH=>EHL

L^H� <HGMBGN:F>GM>� FH=B?B<:=HL� IHK� MHK`^H� >� FH=>E:@>F� =>� I:I>E� <:KM^H� <HF

:=B`g>L�>�LN;MK:`g>L�=>�I:I>BL�=>�@K:F:MNK:�F>GHK�IEBLL:=HL �?B@�������

"B@NK: ����� >FHGLMK:`^H�=H�IKH<>LLH�<KB:MBOH�=>�"K:GD�#>AKR�MK><AH�=H�?BEF> /D>M<A>L H? "K:GD #>AKR"HGM>� ?BEF> /D>M<A>L H? "K:GD #>AKR

Page 205: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 173

0:BL�I>LJNBL:L�?HKF:BL�IH=>F�L>K�BFINELBHG:=:L�IHK�NF:�LaKB>�=>�IK>H<NI:`g>L���

BGJNB>M:`^H�IH=>�L>K�IKBG<BI:EF>GM>�OBLN:E�FHMBO:=:�IHK�NF�=>L>CH�=>�<KB:K�NF:

?HKF:� =BG\FB<: >QM>KG:� HN� BGM>KG:�� �EM>KG:MBO:F>GM>� IH=>� L>K� F:BL� <H@GBMBOH

>GOHEO>G=H :� :GZEBL>� =>� NF:� B=>B:� M>eKB<H� :;LMK:M:��)H=>EHL� =>� ,>M>K� !BL>GF:G

>LM^H� EB@:=HL� :� ABIeM>L>L� IK><HG<>;B=:L� =>�F:M>FZMB<:L� >� @>HF>MKB:L� >LM>L� L^H

>LMN=:=HL� :MK:OaL� =>� NF:� LaKB>� =>� FH=>EHL� >QIEHK:MeKBHL� JN>� <HGLMBMN>F� L>N

FaMH=H�=>�MK:;:EAH �?B@�������

!BL>GF:G�=>L>GOHEO>N�NF�FH=>EH� MKB=BF>GLBHG:E� ?NG<BHG:E� JN>� L>KO>� <HFH�;:L>

I:K:� MH=HL� HL� >E>F>GMHL MHIH@K:?B:� >=B?c<BHL� KN:L� ?EHK:� BENFBG:`^H >M<� >F

MH=:L�:L�=BF>GLg>L�

/>N� H;C>MBOH� >K:� H� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =>� NF:� EBG@N:@>F� :KJNBM>MfGB<:

<HGM>FIHK\G>:�HKB>GM:=:�I:K:�:�<HFIE>QB=:=>�=:�K>:EB=:=>�=:L�Fc=B:L�FH=>KG:L�

+�>E>F>GMH�<>GMK:E�=H�IKHC>MH�<HG<>BMN:E�I:K:�.>;LMH<DI:KD�a�:�=H;K: =>KBO:=:�=H

FH=>EH�F:M>FZMB<H =H� <HG<>BMH� <HGMB=H� G:� M>HKB:� =H� <:HL� =>� .>Ga� 0AHFL� >� GH

"B@NK:����� ,>M>K�!BL>GF:G��,KH<>LLH�IKHC>MN:E��,KHIHLM:�I:K:�H�,E:GH�.>;LMH<DI:KD���E>F:GA:���� "HGM>��AMMI���PPP�K>;LMH<DI:KD??F�=>�K>;LMH<DI:KD9>BL>GF:G9>�AMF�>F�������� ��

Page 206: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 174

<HG<>BMH�=>�#BEE>L� >E>NS>�=>�=H;K:=NK:��+ ?:FBEB:K LBLM>F:�HKMH@HG:E a�LN;LMBMNc=H

IHK�NF�>QI:G=B=H�JN>�G^H�L>�K>LMKBG@>�:�\G@NEHL�K>MHL��+�M>KK>GH�a�FH=>E:=H�IHK

=N:L� @K:=>L� =>� <:=:� NF� =HL� JN:BL� a IKHIHLM:� NF:� MHK`^H� =>� NF� =HL� IE:GHL

<:KM>LB:GHL� JN>� L^H� NMBEBS:=HL� I:K:� :L� ?KHGM>BK:L� =>� IKHIKB>=:=>L� =H� FH=>EH�� �

K>E:`^H�=>�<:=:�>=B?c<BH�:�HNMKH�:LLBF�<HFH�:�=HL�>=B?c<BHL�I:K:�H�>LI:`H� EBOK> a

=>M>KFBG:=:�I>E:�=H;K:���� B=>B:�a�:�=>�=H;K:K�>�=>L=H;K:K� �M>HKB:�=>� >E>NS>����

@K:G=>�K>=>�a�=>KBO:=:�=:�=NIEB<:`^H�=:�:FIEBMN=>�=:�I>JN>G:�@K:=>��1F:�O>S�JN>

:L�IKHIHK`g>L�=H�M>KK>GH�>�MH=H�H�EH<:E�=>�<HGLMKN`^H G^H�L^H�B=bGMB<HL�:�@K:=>

E:K@:� a >QI:G=B=:� I:K:� �� Q� �� L>@F>GMHL �M>HKB:� =>� 0AHFL��� !LM:� @K:=>� a� >GM^H

IKHC>M:=:�LH;K>�:�BF:@>F�=>�MH=H�H�EH<:E�>�=BLMHK<B=:�M:E�<HFH�>QB@B=H�I>E:�?HKF:

=:�IKHIKB>=:=>��"BG:EF>GM>�:F;:L�:L�K>=>L�L^H�F>L<E:=:L�>F�IHGMHL�=:�@K:=>�>

IHGMHL�=H�IKHC>MH� EB@:=HL�:�HNMKH���L� EBGA:L�=>�<HG>Q^H�>GMK>�>LL>L� BM>GL�?HKF:F

NF:�GHO:�NGB=:=> :�@K:G=>�K>=> �?B@���� ��

"B@NK: �� � ,>M>K�!BL>GF:G��,KH<>LLH�IKHC>MN:E��,KHIHLM:�I:K:�H�,E:GH�.>;LMH<DI:KD���E>F:GA:���� "HGM>� AMMI���NK;:G@:F>LMK:M>@B>L�;EH@LIHM�<HF�;K�� �9 �9 �9:K<ABO>�AMFE >F�������� ��

Page 207: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 175

*:�<HG<>I`^H�=>��>L:K�,>EEB�: ;NL<:�=:�?HKF:�IH=>�L>K�NF�IKH@K:F:�=BKB@B=H�BLMH

a�=HFBG:=H�I>EHL�=>M:EA>L�=:�NMBEBS:`^H�=H�>=B?c<BH�

7���8 MH=HL�HL�IKHC>MHL <HF>`:F I>E:�=:�<HGLMKN`^H�=>�NF�FH=>EH�<HF�=BK>BMH�:

MHIH@K:?B:� >� LN:L� >LMKNMNK:L� :=C:<>GM>L� >� >GM^H� BGB<B:FL> H� I>GL:F>GMH� =H

IKHC>MH� >F� ?NG`^H� =HL�FH=>EHL� <HEH<:G=H� H� IKa=BH� IKHIHLMH� NF�I:K� =>� <:BQ:L

JN>�K>IK>L>GM:F�H�OHENF>�<HKK>MH�IHKJN>�G^H L>�IH=> I>GL:K�>F�?HKF:�:Ma�M>K

NF:�B=>B:�=H�BFI:<MH�=H�OHENF>�>QB@B=H�I>EH�IKH@K:F:��!F�L>@NB=:�IKBG<BIB:L> H

>LMN=H�=HL�>LI:`HL�>�:L�K>E:`g>L�=>�?HKF:L �?B@������ �,!((%�� ��>GMK>OBLM:��

���� ���� � � � � ��

,HK� >Q>FIEH �GMHGB ,K>=H<D� NL:� ?HKF:L� =>� I:I>E^H� K><HKM:=H� I:K:� K>IK>L>GM:K

I:KM>L� =H� IKH@K:F:� ?NG<BHG:E =>� L>NL� IKHC>MHL�� !E> >GM^H M>LM:� >�F>L<E:� <HF�:

:K@BE:� F:MaKB:� IKBF:� =:� F:BHKB:� =>� L>NL� FH=>EHL�� �� FHGM:@>F� >� FH=>E:@>F

@:K:GM>F�JN>�H�IKH@K:F:�L>C:�BG<HKIHK:=H�=>L=>�H�BGc<BH�

3HE?�,KBQ =:��HHI�$BFF>E;�E�:N Ob�H�IKH<>LLH�<KB:MBOH�=>�IKHC>MH�<HFH�>FHMBOH

>�=>�<:KZM>K�>QIK>LLBHGBLM:�NF�:MH�FNBMH�<HFIE>QH�>�=BG\FB<H��0K:=B<BHG:EF>GM>

MHF:F� H NLH =>� <KHJNBL� >� FH=>EHL� IK>EBFBG:K>L� I:K:� BGc<BH� =>� L>NL� IKHC>MHL�� �

BGM>@K:`^H�=>�FH=>EHL�>E>MKfGB<HL�G:�LN: IKZMB<:�IKH?BLLBHG:E�G^H�K>LNEMHN�>F�NF:

FN=:G`:� K:=B<:E� GH� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� => LN:L� IKHIHLB`g>L�� �H� <HGMKZKBH� L>N

BFI:<MH�IKBG<BI:E�M>F�@>K:=H�NF:�IKH=N`^H�F:BL�Kc@B=:����M>GM:MBO:�a =>�=>?BGBK�H

L>GMBF>GMH�:�>FH`^H�JN>�H�>LI:`H�IKHIB<B:KZ�GH�?NMNKH�

"B@NK:�������HGCNGMH�=>�BF:@>GL�=>��>L:K�,>EEB�>�LN:�K>E:`^H�<HF�HL�FH=>EHL�:MK:OaL�=HL�:GHL�"HGM>���AMMI���PPP�PHKE=?BG:G<B:E<>GM>K�<HF�<HGM>GM�BG9MA>9G>PL�P?<9K>GHO:MBHG9BL9:EE9BG9MA>9?:FBER9K>M:BE9������AMFE�AMMI���PPP�>;:R�<HF�L<A�LBL�AMFE�9GDP�PL�9BM>F%=���� ���������AMMI���;EH@�:KM���HK@�� ��� �����GHIK>L>KO:MBO>L<A:HL�K>MNKGLMHEB?>��AMMI����PPP�<HNK:GM�<HF�;NLBG>LL�K>:E>LM:M>�A<IB<MNK>L;NBE=BG@L=>LB@G>=;RI>EEB<E:KDI>EEB� �� �� ��������AMMI���PPP�<KHGBLM:�<HF�<E:L>>C><NMBO:�0:;E>KHNGBO>KL:E� �� ��� ����AMFE� >F�������� ��

Page 208: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 176

*H IKeQBFH�<:IcMNEH�L>KZ�>QIEHK:=: :�>QBLMbG<B:�=> NF:�EB@:`^H�>GMK>�:�<HG<>I`^H

>�H� :MH� ?cLB<H�=H ?:S>K� BG=B<:=H�G:� EcG@N:�>�F>MZ?HK:L� JN> HL� :KMBLM:L NL:F�I:K:

=>L<K>O>K� LN:� :MBOB=:=>�� ,:K:� >E>L� >LL:� >QI>KBbG<B:� L>GLHKB:E H� <HG?KHGMH� <HF�:

F:M>KB:EB=:=> a� >LL>G<B:E� I:K:� H� :MH� <KB:MBOH�� +� @K:G=>� GhF>KH� =>� :KJNBM>MHL

<HGM>FIHK\G>HL� :MBO:F>GM>� >GOHEOB=HL G:� IKH=N`^H� => FH=>EHL� =>� IKH<>LLH

LN@>K> NF:�G><>LLB=:=>�;ZLB<:�I:K:�>LM:�>QI>KBbG<B:���KJNBM>MHL� L^H�H;KB@:=HL� :

MK:;:EA:K�<HF�K>IK>L>GM:`g>L�=>�L>NL�IKHC>MHL >�I:K><>F�<:=:�O>S�F:BL�L>I:K:=HL

=:� <HGLMKN`^H�� +L� FH=>EHL� I:KMB<BI:F� HL� :KJNBM>MHL� <HF� H� FNG=H� K>:E� >F� NF

>G<HGMKH�?cLB<H�OBM:E�>F�JN>�H�:MH�=>�?:S>K�:L�?HKF:L�OBG<NE:�B=>B:�>�K>:EB=:=>�

�E@NGL�?:MHK>L K>?HK`:K:F :�IHM>G<B:EB=:=> =HL�FH=>EHL�MKB=BF>GLBHG:BL GH�La<NEH

44����:;LMK:`^H� EB;>KMHN�H�FH=>EH�I:K:�>G@:M:K�=BK>M:F>GM>�GH�IKH<>LLH�<KB:MBOH

I>KFBMBG=H� JN>� H� :KJNBM>MH >� H� >LMN=:GM>� =>� :KJNBM>MNK: IK>G=:F :L� B=>B:L

M>eKB<:L�;>F�<HFH�?K:@F>GMHL�G^H�?HKFNE:=HL�=>�OBL^H�>�=>�BF:@>GL�:�I:KMBK�=>

HNMKHL�:LI><MHL�=:�K>:EB=:=>�IK>M>G=B=:��$HC>�FH=>EBLM:L�<HFH��E><�2:LLBEB:=BL�=:

*��&�IH=>F�=BOB=BK�HL�FH=>EHL�>F�JN>�MK:;:EA:F�:�I:KMBK�=>�<:M>@HKB:L�=BLMBGM:L��:

IKBF>BK:� <:M>@HKB:� ?:S�I:KM> =HL� JN>� L^H� :� K>IK>L>GM:`^H� =H�JN>� >LM^H� M>GM:G=H

?:S>K� > :� HNMK:� <:M>@HKB: IKHIHK<BHG:� <BK<NGLM\G<B:L� F:BL� :?ZO>BL� L^H� :JN>E>L

FH=>EHL�JN>�K>IK>L>GM:F�:L�B=>B:L�I>LLH:BL �?B@�������

/<HM�3:EEL�HNMKH�IKH?BLLBHG:E�=:�*��&�Ob�HL�FH=>EHL <HFH�F:GB?>LM:`g>L�=>�NF:

FBGB:MNK:�=H�>=B?c<BH�F:L�:IHGM:�:�>QBLMbG<B:�=>�M>HKB:L�>�<HG<>BMHL�JN>�IH=>F�L>K

"B@NK:����� �K:= �:FI��:BG;KB=@>�%LE:G=�IHK��E><"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�;:BG;KB=@>K>OB>P�<HF�;NLBG>LL�� � �����AMFE�>F�������� ��

Page 209: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 177

FH=>E:=HL� 3:EEL� =>?>G=>� IKH<>LLHL� =>� I>GL:F>GMH� JN>� L>� F:GB?>LM:F� G:

MKB=BF>GLBHG:EB=:=>��>�G>LM>�<:LH�>E>�HL�<A:F:�=>�� �>�G^H�=>�� �

1F:�K><>GM>�;B;EBHM><:�IKHC>M:=:�I>E:�*��&�>EN<B=:�>LM>L�<HF>GMZKBHL����>JNBI>�=>

IKHC>MH�NLHN FH=>EHL�I:K:�>QIEHK:K�H��L>GMB=H�=H�EN@:K��:LLH<B:=H <HF�:�B=>B:�=>

NF:�;B;EBHM><:��+L�IKH?BLLBHG:BL�M>GM:K:F K>IK>L>GM:K�HL�L>GMBF>GMHL�K>E:<BHG:=HL

<HF�:L�:MBOB=:=>L�=>�NLH�=:�;B;EBHM><:�>�=:�:MFHL?>K:�=H�EN@:K�IK>OBLMH�<HFH�NF:

>L<NEMNK:�NF�H;C>MH�MKB=BF>GLBHG:E��!F;HK:�NF�>Q>K<c<BH�:I:K>GM>F>GM>�:;LMK:MH

IKHIB<BHN�:HL�BGO>LMB@:=HK>L�>LM:;>E><>K>F�NF�JN:=KH�<HG<>BMN:E�> NF:�OBL^H�I:K:

H�IKHC>MH �?B@�������

)H=>EHL� M:F;aF MbF :� <:I:<B=:=>� =>� K>O>E:K� >E>F>GMHL� =H� I>GL:F>GMH� =>

IKHC>MHL� <HG<>BMN:BL�JN>�G^H� L^H�OBLcO>BL�G:�:KJNBM>MNK:� BGM>KG:� �HFH�HNMKHK:� L>

FHLMKHN NF�FH=>EH�HKB@BG:E�@eMB<H�I:K:�:� %@K>C:�=>�/M��):<EHN�>F�.HN>G� �����

������=>L<H;>KMH�IHK�NF�ABLMHKB:=HK =>�:KJNBM>MNK:�:F>KB<:GH�GH�BGc<BH�=H�La<NEH

44�?HB�K><>;B=H�<HF�@K:G=> >GMNLB:LFH�G^H�:I>G:L�IHK�B=:=>�F:L�IHKJN>�K>O>EHN

: @>HF>MKB:� LN;C:<>GM>� =:� >LMKNMNK:� F:BL� <E:K:F>GM>� =H� JN>� MBGA:� LB=H

:GM>KBHKF>GM>�=BLMBG@NcO>E�:MK:OaL�=>�NF�>LMN=H�=H�>=B?c<BH �?B@�������

"B@NK:������FH=>EH�=H�%=>H@K:F:�=H�0KB;NG:E�">=>K:E�=HL�!LM:=HL�1GB=HL�/>:MME>�*��&"HGM>��)+**�':K>G��)H=>EBG@�)>LL:@>�� ���I����

Page 210: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 178

0:BL�FH=>EHL�?HK:F�?>BMHL <HFH�CZ�?HB�OBLMH�G>LM> MK:;:EAH�GHL�M>FIHL�IKBFBMBOHL

F:L�a�Le�:�I:KMBK�=H�La<NEH 44�JN>�HL�:KJNBM>MHL�K>GNG<B:F :H�K>:EBLFH�:LIBK:G=H

K>MK:M:K� LN:L� B=>B:L� <HG<>BMN:BL� BG=BOB=N:EF>GM>� L>F� :� IK>H<NI:`^H� => NF

<HGM>QMH�� !LM:� IHLB`^H� ?HB� :E<:G`:=:� :MK:OaL� =>� NF:� K>?E>Q^H� IKH@K>LLBO: =:

<HG<>I`^H�=> FH=>EH�Ma<GB<:L�F:M>KB:BL�>LMaMB<:�@EH;:E�>�:<BF:�=>�MN=H =H�@K:N

=>�K>:EBLFH�>L<HEAB=H�

+L�FH=>EHL�=>�,:HEH�/HE>KB >�LN:L�B=>B:L�OBLBHGZKB:L�I:K:�<B=:=>L�O>KMB<:BL�?>BM:L�GH

?BG:E� =>� ��� L^H NF� >Q>FIEH� =>LL:� K>?E>Q^H� IKH@K>LLBO:�� �KB:=HL >F� :<KcEB<H

MK:GLI:K>GM>�L>NL�FH=>EHL�G^H�MBGA:F�:�BGM>G`^H�=>�K>IK>L>GM:K�:�K>:EB=:=>�?cLB<:

=:L�>LMKNMNK:L�IKHC>M:=:L HL�F:M>KB:BL NL:=HL IHK�LB�Le CZ G^H�>K:F <HGLB=>K:=HL

<HGO>G<BHG:BL I:K: :�aIH<:�>F�JN>�?HB�>E:;HK:=H �?B@�������

"B@NK: ���� �NMHK�:GfGBFH��):JN>M>�=:�%@K>C:�=>�/:BGM�):<EHN�.HN>G����������)NL>N�=�+KL:R,:KBL"K:G`:"HGM>� AMMI���PPP�FNL>>HKL:R�?K�?K�<HEE><MBHGL�<:M:EH@N>=>L

Page 211: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 179

+� F>BH� ?HB� >L<HEAB=H� IHK� /HE>KB� G^H� IHK� L>N� K>:EBLFH� F:L I:K:� H� L>N� >?>BMH

LNKIK>>G=>GM>�� : MK:GLI:KbG<B:� =H� F:M>KB:E� >� MK:GLFBLL^H� =>� JN:EB=:=>L� =:� ENS

?HK:F� :IKHO>BM:=:L� I:K:� @>K:K� H =K:F:� =H� FH=>EH� <KB:G=H� NF:� ENFBGHLB=:=>

LH;K>G:MNK:E�>�:L�:LLH<B:`g>L�=HL�F:M>KB:BL�NEMK:FH=>KGH�>�K>E:MBO:F>GM>�GHOHL

LN@>KBG=H� OB=KH� �M><GHEH@B<:F>GM>� ?NMNKBLM:� H� JN> =>BQ:O:F� :L� F:JN>M>L

:MK:>GM>L�

!F;HK:�:L�IKHIHLM:L =: F:BHKB:�=: <EB>GM>E: JN>�IKH<NK:�HL�F:JN>MBLM:L L>C:F�I:K:

?:S>K� FH=>EHL� K>:EBLM:L HL� FH=>EHL� >E:;HK:=HL� =NK:GM>� H� IKH<>LLH� =>� IKHC>MH

IH=>F L>K� F:BL� >QIK>LLBOHL >� I:KMB<NE:K>L�� 0:BL� FH=>EHL� ?HK:F� HL� IKBF>BKHL� :

;>G>?B<B:K�>LM:�?HKF:�=>�O>K�>�<HGMBGN:K:F :�L>K�>Q><NM:=HL <HFH�H�IKBG<BI:E�?H<H

I:K:�HL�FH=HL�:;LMK:MHL�=H�I>GL:F>GMH��K>O>E:G=H :L�BGMBFB=:=>L�=>�BF:@BG:`^H�>

"B@NK:������%F:@>GL�=:�!QIHLB`^H 0A>��K<ABM><MNK:E�2BLBHG ,:HEH�/HE>KB�HK<HK:G�#:EE>KR�H?��KM�3:LABG@MHG����� �"HGM>� AMMI���FBL<>EE:G>HNLIB<L�;EH@LIHM�<HF�;K�� ��� �I:HEHLHE>KB�AMFEAMMI���BGM>KBHK=>LB@G=><HK:MBG@AHF>�;EH@LIHM�<HF�;K�� ��� ��I:HEHLHE>KBL;KB=@>=>LB@G<HEE><MBHG�AMFE >F�������� ��

Page 212: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 180

H� <HGM:K� =>� NF:� ABLMeKB:� =>GMKH� =H� =>L>GOHEOBF>GMH� =H� IKHC>MH� �@HK:� <HFH

=BZKBHL� =>LMBG:=HL� X IN;EB<:`^H� HL� FH=>EHL� =>� IKH<>LLHL� L^H� IKHIHLBM:=:F>GM>

FHLMK:=HL��!E>L�L^H IHK�O>S>L�<HGL<B>GM>F>GM>�:;LMK:MHL >�FNBM:L�O>S>L�L^H�F:BL

<HFIE>QHL�>F�LN:L� BGM>G`g>L�=H�JN>�I:K><>F��!F�M>FIHL�:MN:BL :�OBL^H�I:LLHN

=H�IKBO:=H�I:K:�H�K>BGH�=>�>QB;B`^H�Ih;EB<:�

*^H�a�=>�>LMK:GA:K�JN>�HL�FH=>EHL�=>�/HE>KB M>GA:F�LB=H >QIHLMHL >F NF�FNL>N

=>� :KM>�� >L<:KM:G=H� =>M:EA>L� LNIaK?ENHL� >� K>:EBLFH� =>?BGBG=H� LN:�F>GL:@>F� H

FH=>EH�MHKG:L>�NF:�?>KK:F>GM:�I:K:�:�MK:GLFBLL^H�=>�B=>B:L�LH;K>�H�IKHC>MH �?B@�

�����:�OBL^H�>�:�IH>LB:�=>�BGLIBK:`^H���LLBF�H�FH=>EH�=>�,>M>K�,K:G�=>����� I:K:

H�0>KFBG:E�=:��F>KB<:G��BKEBG>L���*HKMAP>LM��BKEBG>L��>KHIHKMH�&"'�*HO:�5HKD�?HB

<KB:=H�I:K:�>G?:MBS:K�LN:�B=>B: <A:O> G>LM>�EHG@BEcG>H�IKHC>MH�=> M>EA:=H�<NKOH�=>

:`H�?ENMN:GM>�JN>�I:K><>�L:BK�=H�<A^H�L>F�<HF>`H�HN�?BF�

+�FH=>EH�FHLMK: HL�IE:GHL�IKBG<BI:BL�=H�IKHC>MH�=>�NF:�?HKF:�LBFIEB?B<:=:�<HFH

L>� LNLI>GLHL GH� >LI:`H�� ,:K:� ,K:G a� :� >Q>FIEB?B<:`^H� =: IHLMNK:� L>E>MBO:� =H

FH=>EH� I:K:� >QIK>LL:K� H� L>GMBF>GMH M><MfGB<H� =>� MH=H� H� >=B?c<BH�� 0HKG:G=H� H

FH=>EH�NF:�=><E:K:`^H�IHaMB<:�=>�MH=:�: OBL^H�=H�IKHC>MH �?B@�������

"B@NK:������,>M>K ,K:G�=>������H�0>KFBG:E�=:��F>KB<:G��BKEBG>L���*HKMAP>LM��BKEBG>L��>KHIHKMH�&"'�>F�*HO:�5HKD�"HGM>� ,.�*�*+.�!.#/�$1(6�(%�!/'%* ���K<ABM><MNK>�H?�,H>MB<�)HO>F>GM��������I����

"B@NK:����� ,>M>K�,K:G�=>������H�0>KFBG:E�=:��F>KB<:G��BKEBG>L���*HKMAP>LM��BKEBG>L��>KHIHKMH�&"'�>F�*HO:�5HKD�"HGM>� ,.�*�*+.�!.#/�$1(6�(%�!/'%* ���K<ABM><MNK>�H?�,H>MB<�)HO>F>GM������ I���

Page 213: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 181

:� F>LF:� ?HKF: =>L>GOHEO>N� IHLM>KBHKF>GM> NF� FH=>EH� I:K:� :� 'PNG� 0HG@

0HPG��>GMK> �?B@��������/N:�F>M:�I>LLH:E�I:K:�H�IKHC>MH�?HB�:MBG@BK�:�JN:EB=:=>�=>

NF:� >L<NEMNK: => �HGLM:GMBGB� �K:G<NLB NF� H;C>MBOH� JN>� IH=>KB: L>K� F:BL

<E:K:F>GM>� >QIK>LLH� >F� NF� FH=>EH� =H� JN>� >F� NF� >=B?c<BH�� ,:K: ,K:G MH=:� :

BGLIBK:`^H�: >LLbG<B:�IHaMB<:�=H�IKHC>MH a <HFNGB<:=:�GH�FH=>EH�

+NMKHL�>Q>FIEHL�FHLMK:F�JN> H�NGBO>KLH�:KJNBM>MfGB<H M>F NMBEBS:=H <:=:�O>S >F

F:BHK� GhF>KH� :� FH=>E:@>F� MKB=BF>GLBHG:E� MHKG:G=H� FH=>EHL� F:BL :;LMK:MHL

<HFH NF�F>BH�=>�>QIK>LL^H�>EHJN>GM>�<HFH IHK�>Q>FIEH�H�FH=>EH�=> 0HRH�%MH

I:K:�H IKHC>MH�=>�NK;:GBLFH =:�ZK>:�<>GMK:E�=H�/A:G@:B�(NBCB:SNB �>GM>K �?B@�������

%MH� F:GB?>LM:� NF:� ?:L<BG:`^H I>E:� BFI>KF:GbG<B:� =H� GHLLH� FNG=H� FH=>KGH

>E>MKfGB<H >F� JN> HL� H;C>MHL� BGOBLcO>BL� �BFINELHL� >E>MKfGB<HL�� >LM^H

<HGLM:GM>F>GM>�?ENBG=H�:MK:OaL�=H�>LI:`H���HGLMKNc=H�=>�OB=KH�>�F>M:E�I>K?NK:=H

HL >=B?c<BHL K>MK:M:=HL�GH�FH=>EH I:K><>F�E>O>L�?ENMN:G=H�:<BF:�=H�<A^H�:;:BQH�>

:H�K>=HK�=>E>L >G<HGMK:L> NF�?ENQH�=>�<:KKHL�ENS>L�>�FNEMB=g>L�:�L>�FHOBF>GM:K

"B@NK:����� ,>M>K�,K:G�'PNG�0HG@�0HPG��>GMK>�"HGM>� �:I:�=H�(BOKH�=> ,>M>K�,K:G�?HMH�=:�:NMHK:

Page 214: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 182

H�JN> I:K:�>E>�MHF: H�EN@:K�=:�Z@N:� +�FH=>EH�=>�%MH�<HFNGB<:�>LL:�OBL^H�:MK:OaL

=>� LN:L� <:F:=:L� >GMK>E:`:=:� =>� F:M>KB:BL� <HEHKB=HL� MK:GLI:K>GM>� >

L>FBMK:GLI:K>GM>�JN>�?EN>F�>GMK>�HL�:KK:GA:<aNL�

+�FH=>EH => :GB>E�(B;>LDBG=�I:K:�H�IKHC>MH�=>�K><HGLMKN`^H�=: � ��������� %

>F��>KEBF �?B@�� �� � ?HB� <HG<>;B=H�:�I:KMBK� =>�;EH<HL�=>� L>@F>GMHL�=BLMBGMHL�JN>

K>IK>L>GM:F� :� BF:@>F� =:� <B=:=>� >LMBEA:`HL� L>@NBG=H� =B?>K>GM>L� EBGA:L JN>

:MK:O>LL:F�:� @>H@K:?B:�=:� ,HML=:F>K� ,E:MS� ;>F� <HFH� :� MHIHEH@B:� =:� <NEMNK:�=>

�>KEBF��+�FH=>EH <HFH�NF�FHL:B<H ?HB�>E:;HK:=H�<HF�I>`:L�=>LM:<ZO>BL => NF

JN>;K:<:;>`:� K>IK>L>GM:G=H� ?K:@F>GMHL� LBF;eEB<HL� =:� F>FeKB:� >F� NF:

MK:=N`^H� EBM>K:E� =>� L>N� <HG<>BMH�� �� ?HKF:� ?cLB<:� =:� FH=>EH� <HF� L>N� <HGMHKGH

BKK>@NE:K� JN>;K:=H� M:F;aF� MK:GLFBM>� :� G:MNK>S:� ?K:MNK:=:� =>� LN:� OBL^H

=>L<HGLMKNMBOBLM:�

"B@NK:������)H=>EH =>�0HRH�%MH�I:K:�H�IKHC>MH�=>�NK;:GBLFH�I:K:�:�UK>:��>GMK:E=H�/A:G@:B�(NBCB:SNB��>GM>K�"HGM>��)+**�':K>G��)H=>EBG@��)>LL:@>�� ���I����

Page 215: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 183

+L� FH=>EHL� >E>@:GM>L� =>� 6:A:� $:=B=� M:F;aF� :LLH<B:=HL� <HF� H� FHOBF>GMH

=>L<HGLMKNMBOBLM:� L^H� ;:LM:GM>� <HGMK:LM:GM>L�� !E>L� L>� K>E:<BHG:F� >LMK>BM:F>GM>

<HF�LN:L�IBGMNK:L�JN>�K>MK:M:F�H;C>MHL�>F�<HEBL^H�@>HFaMKB<:�>LMBEA:`HL�OH:G=H

I>EH�>LI:`H�<HF�H�=BG:FBLFH�=>�NF:�>QIEHL^H�=>�<:<HL�=>�OB=KH��/>N�FH=>EH =>

<HG<>BMH� BGB<B:E� I:K:� :� 6HEEAH?� �� )>=B:� �>GM>K �?B@�� ���� K>=NSBN� >LM:� OBL^H� NF:

=><E:K:`^H�LBFIEB?B<:=:�>�<HFIHLM:�=>�>F;E>FZMB<HL�LeEB=HL�MK:GLEh<B=HL�<HF�ENS

?BEMK:=:�

"B@NK:��� � :GB>E�(B;>LDBG=� � ��������� %� �>KEBF�"HGM>� AMMI���PPP�;S;>KEBG�=>�DNEMNK�>GMPN>K?>?N>K;>KEBGE>B=>K:;@>E>AGM:KMB<E>�������AMFE�>F�������� ��

"B@NK:����� 6:A:�$:=B=� �>GMKH�=>��KM>�)NEMBF>=B:�6HEEAH?�� � iLL>E=HK?��E>F:GA:�����������"HGM>��AMMI���PPP�>E��<KHJNBL�>L�/AHI�%LLN>� >M:BEL����IM% ���LA,@���:KM% ����� >F ������� ��

Page 216: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 184

)H=>EHL�@>K:=HL�I>EH�>L<KBMeKBH�)HKIAHLBL�=>�(HL��G@>E>L�>�L>N�IKBG<BI:E =>LB@G>K

0AHF�):RG>� >QIK>LL:F HNMK:L� IK>H<NI:`g>L�� !E>L� ?NG<BHG:F� <HFH >E>F>GMHL

LBF;eEB<HL� >�FHGNF>GM:BL� H;C>MHL� >L<NEMeKB<HL� IK>H<NI:=HL� <HF�F:M>KB:BL� >� :L

JN:EB=:=>L�=>�LNI>K?c<B> �?B@������>������

� IKHIHLB`^H� =>LL>L� FH=>EHL� G^H� L>� IK>G=>� :H K>:EBLFH� F:BL LBF :H� JN>� L>

IK>M>G=>� MK:GLFBMBK�� !E>L� :KMB<NE:F HL L>GMBF>GMHL =HL� L>NL� :NMHK>L�� �I>G:L

L><NG=:KB:F>GM>�:;HK=:F�H�JN>�L>KZ�H�>=B?c<BH�>F�LN:�L>F>EA:G`:�

�� <K>L<>GM>� IHINE:KB=:=>� =HL� FH=>EHL� GH� La<NEH 44% K>?E>M>� :� G><>LLB=:=>� =HL

:KMc?B<>L�=:�:KJNBM>MNK: I:K:�H�<HGM:MH�<HF�:�K>:EB=:=>�?cLB<:�;NL<:G=H�>QIK>LL:K

LN: OBL^H� >Q:@>K:G=H�:L�IKBG<BI:BL� B=>B:L� LN;C:<>GM>L�I:K:� <:KK>@:K�H�FH=>EH =>

LB@GB?B<:=HL�

+L�FH=>EHL�JN> @:GA:F�OB=:�>QIK>LL:F�H�=BG:FBLFH�=H�IKH<>LLH�<KB:MBOH�> H�HEA:K

I:K:� :EaF� =:L� K>@K:L� =:� K>:EB=:=>� �E@NGL� >Q>K<>F� K>E:`g>L� M^H ?HKM>F>GM>

F:K<:=:L <HF� H� FH=>EH JN>� H� =>L:I>@H� :H� H;C>MH� MHKG:L>� =B?c<BE�� 0HKG:G=HH

I:KM>� =:� CHKG:=:� I>LLH:E� =H� :KJNBM>MH� >F� LB� :� >QI>KBbG<B:� ?NG=:F>GM:E� =:

:KJNBM>MNK:�:�<HGO>KL^H�GH�FNG=H�=H�H;C>MH��+�K>E:<BHG:F>GMH�?H<:=H�=>�)B<A>E>

/:>> <HF�:� LN:�F:JN>M>� =: #HES:KB�#N>LM�$HNL> �?B@�� ����� a� K>E>O:GM> IHBL >E>

<HFI:KMBEAHN L>NL�ANFHK>L�<HF >E: =NK:GM>�H�IKH<>LLH�=>�>E:;HK:`^H��+�FH=>EH

JN:L> JN>�L>�MHKGHN NF:�>QM>GL^H�=H�:NMHK�

"B@NK:L�����>������0AHF�):RG>��.H<DP>EE��HEEBG���0AHF�):RG>� �AB;:�#HE?��EN;"HGM>� AMMI���FHKIAHI>=B:�<HF�?BE>L�FH=>E�>F ������� ��

Page 217: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 185

�KJNBM>MHL M>GM:F� K>IK>L>GM:K� I:K:� =>L>GOHEO>K LN:L� B=>B:L >F� IKHIHLB`g>L

?HKF:BL�>�>LI><B:BL�ENM:G=H�I:K:�K>LHEO>K�HL�IKH;E>F:L =H�K>:EBLFH�>�=:�:;LMK:`^H

L>F� BLHEZEHL��!LM:L�IK>H<NI:`g>L�>LM^H�IK>L>GM>L� M:F;aF�GHL�=>;:M>L�>F�MHKGH

=H�La<NEH�44�G:�IBGMNK:�>�G:�>L<NEMNK:�K>?E>MBG=H�NF:�EB@:`^H�=>�EHG@:�=:M:�>GMK>

:KM>�>�:KJNBM>MNK:����:MK:`^H�=:L�:KM>L�IEZLMB<:L�a�>OB=>GM>�G:�:=FBLL^H�=>�"K:GD

#>AKR�JN>�L>FIK>�<KNS:�:�EBGA:�>GMK>�:KJNBM>MNK:�>�>L<NEMNK:�

1F� I:K:E>EH� BGM>K>LL:GM>� <HF� :L� :KM>L� IEZLMB<:L� L>� :IK>L>GM:� GHL� FH=>EHL� =>

>QIEHK:`g>L� OHENFaMKB<:L� >� >LI:<B:BL� =>� ':LBFBK�):E>OB<A� JN>� L^H NF�=BOBLHK� =>

Z@N:L�� /N:L� I>LJNBL:L� :;LMK:M:L� K>:EBS:=:L� >F� MKbL� =BF>GLg>L� :;HK=:K:F� HL

IKH;E>F:L� =:� :KJNBM>MNK:� M:GMH� JN:GMH =:� :KM>� ):E>OB<A� <A:FHN� LN:� LaKB>� =>

>LMN=HL�>F�@>LLH ������ =>��K<ABM>DMHGL �?B@�������

"B@NK:����� #HES:KB�#N>LM�$HNL>�)B<A>E>�/:>>������"HGM>� GR><BK<NE:KJN:R� � ?NEE?:MAHF?BO>�;EH@LIHM�<HF

"B@NK:������':LBFBK�):E>OB<A���K<ABM>DMHGL�+KG:F>GMH�����"HGM>� AMMI���L<:E>FH=>E�MNF;EK�<HF�IHLM������� ��� �CNEB:GFBGBF:D:SBFBKF:E>OB<A:K<ABM>DMHGAMMI���PPP�MA><BMRK>OB>P�<HF�F:E>OB<A�AMFE�>F�������� ��

Page 218: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 186

+NMK:� :;HK=:@>F� I>KMBG>GM>� GH� <:FIH� =:L� :KM>L� I>KI:LL:� NF:� :G:EH@B:�� �LLBF

<HFH�:�BGO>G`^H�=:�?HMH@K:?B:�GH�La<NEH�4%4�?>S�IBGMHK>L�JN>LMBHG:K>F H�IKHIeLBMH

=>�IBGMNK:�:�<K>L<>GM>�<:I:<B=:=>�Ma<GB<:�=HL�FH=>EBLM:L�I:K:�BFBM:K�:�K>:EB=:=>�:

I:KMBK�=>�F>:=HL�=H�La<NEH�44� ?>S�<HF�JN>�LNK@BLL>F�JN>LMBHG:F>GMHL�LH;K> HL

FH=>EHL� >� H� <HGM>h=H� =:L� BG?HKF:`g>L� :� L>K>F� MK:GLFBMB=:L�� +� K>:EBLFH

?HMH@KZ?B<H�GNG<:�?HB�G><>LL:KB:F>GM>�H�=>L>CH�=HL�>GOHEOB=HL�<HF�:�:KJNBM>MNK:�

>L=>� :�=a<:=:� =>� ��� � H� K>Ih=BH�=HL� IKH?BLLBHG:BL BGHO:=HK>L� >� >QI>KBF>GM:BL

I:K:�H�K>:EBLFH�GHL�FH=>EHL�>K:�NF�?:MH�

W�<HFNF�H;L>KO:K�:�EB@:`^H�=>�FHOBF>GMHL�:KMcLMB<HL�=H�La<NEH�44�<HF�:L�H;K:L�=>

6:A: $:=B= �?B@������ 3HE?�,KBQ �?B@�������> +=BE>� ><J �?B@������

"B@NK:L������+=BE>� ><J��0>KFBG:E�=>�,:LL:@>BKHL�0:G@B>K�"HGM>� AMMI���PPP�>:K<ABM><M�<H�ND�FHKH<<H�I:LL>G@>K9M>KFM>KF9M:G@B>K�AMF�>F�� � ��� ��

"B@NK:������6:A:�$:=B=�<>GMKH�=>�:KM>L�=>�>LI>MZ<NEHL� �;N� A:;B�� ��"HGM>� �!..%!�&>:G):K<�6:A:�$:=B=�NG>��K<ABM><MNK>� � ���I�����

"B@NK:������3HE?�,KBQ���HHI�$BFF>E;�E�:N���>GMKH�=>�BG>F:�1"�� K>L=>G�������"HGM>� &+. %+� ��HGM>FIHK:KR��K<ABM><ML�� ���I������

Page 219: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 187

!LM>� M>KKBMeKBH� =>� :;LMK:`^H� >LM:� SHG:� BGM>KF>=BZKB:� >F�JN>�FH=>EHL k EBOK>� =>

K>:EBLFH k HI>K:F a HG=>� L>� <HGLMKeB� :L� F>MZ?HK:L� =>� #K:O>L� KBMN:BL� >� B=>B:L

>QIEHK:=:L �?B@��������+� EN@:K�I:K:�HG=>�:KJNBM>MHL <HGM>FIHK\G>HL�IKH@K>LLBLM:L

I:K><>F�F:@G>MB<:F>GM>�:MK:c=HL�

!F� M>FIHL� :MN:BL� FH=>EHL� H?>K><>F� NF�F>BH�FNBMH�F:BL� KB<H� =>� BGO>LMB@:`^H

JN>K� I:K:� :� I>LJNBL:� =>� G:MNK>S:� >LI><NE:MBO:� HN I:K: H� >LMN=H� =>� B=>B:L

OBLBHGZKB:L�

1MHIB:� �:K@NF>GMH� => 0HRH %MH�� a� NF:� I:E:OK:� LB@GB?B<:MBO:�� )H=>EHL� JN>� G^H

IK><BL:F ?NG<BHG:K� GH� FNG=H� K>:E� =:� <HGLMKN`^H� IK>LM:FL>� I:KMB<NE:KF>GM>� X

K>IK>L>GM:`^H� =H� BF:@BGZKBH� HN� B=>:E�� !E>L� L^H� H� M>KKBMeKBH� G:MNK:E� =:� OBL^H

I>K?>BM:F>GM>�:=:IM:=H�I:K:�:�IKHC>`^H�?NMNKBLM: =>�IKHIHLM:L�=H JN>�>E>L�IH=>F

L>K�� $:GB� .:LAB=� >L<E:K><>� JN>� H� LB@GB?B<:=H� =>� FH=>EHL� GHL� IKBF>BKHL� :GHL� =H

�LRFIMHM>� >K:� =B?>K>G<B:=H� =:L� IKHIHLM:L� :MN:BL�� +� >L<KBMeKBH� MBGA:� :� IKZMB<:� =>

?:S>K�FH=>EHL�<HFH�B=>B:L�?NMNK:L�IHKJN>�GBG@NaF�HL�<HGMK:M:O:�>�LN:L�IKHIHLM:L

G^H�L>KB:F�>=B?B<:=:L�

"B@NK:������)B<A:>E�#K:O>L��0:FI:�I:K:�;B<H�=>�<A:E>BK:"HGM>� AMMI���;>KDLABK>?BG>:KML�<HF��� �� � 9:E>LLB<K>:MBG@AHF>IKH=N<MB<HGL�AMF�>F�������� ��

Page 220: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

T 188

$:=B=� :I>L:K� =>� IKH=NSBK� NF:� LaKB>� =>� IKHC>MHL� IK>FB:=HL� M>O>� IHN<:L� H;K:L

>=B?B<:=:L�>F�F>:=HL�=:�=a<:=:�=>���� �����<HGLMKNMB;BEB=:=>�=>�LN:L�B=>B:L�IH=>

L>K� :@HK:� CNE@:=:� <HF� IKHC>MHL� <HG<ENc=HL� >F� �BG<BGG:MB �?B@�� �� ��3HE?L;NK@ >

(>BISB@ �?B@� ���� .HF:�� > /:E>KGH� �?B@�� ���� F:L� L>NL� IKBF>BKHL� IKHC>MHL

LH;K>OBO>K:F� ?BLB<:F>GM>� :I>G:L� <HFH� FH=>EHL� =:G=H� :� >LL>L� H;C>MHL� NF:

BG<HFNF BFIHKM\G<B:�:HL�HEAHL�=>�M:GMHL�

+� FH=>EH� MKB=BF>GLBHG:E <HFH� ?HKF:� =>� >QIK>LL^H� MHKG:L>� NF� =HL� IKBG<BI:BL

F>BHL�I>EHL�JN:BL�:�BF:@BG:`^H =>�L>NL�:NMHK>L IH=>�L>K�:KMB<NE:=:��W NF:�?HGM>�=>

O:EHK�IHM>GM> I:K:�:�<HFIK>>GL^H�=>�LN:L�BGM>G`g>L�<HG<>BMN:BL�

,:K:� NF� >LMN=:GM>� =>� :KJNBM>MNK:� H� FH=>EH� a� :� IKBF>BK:� >QI>KBbG<B:� ?cLB<:

:KJNBM>MfGB<:� >� I:K:� H� :KJNBM>MH� NF F>BH� ?cLB<H� >QI>KBF>GM:E� =:

MKB=BF>GLBHG:EB=:=>�=:�:KJNBM>MNK:�=BLIHGcO>E�

�� B=>B:� a� <HGLMKNc=:� >� @>K:=:� I>E:�FH=>E:@>F�� *^H� a� :E@H� JN>� L>� :IK>L>GM:� G:

F>GM>� F:L� :E@H� JN>� L>� K>O>E:� GH� IKH<>LLH�� !LM>� a� H� IHGMH� <>GMK:E� =>� JN>� L>

:IK>G=>�> L>�=>?BG>�<HFH�:KJNBM>MNK: IHK�F>BH�=HL�FH=>EHL�

*H� >GLBGH� H� >LMN=:GM>� :H� >E:;HK:K�FH=>EHL� IH=>� :HL� IHN<HL� L>� MK:GLIHKM:K� =:L

IKBF>BK:L� >QI>KBbG<B:L� ?cLB<:L� I:K:� FH=>E:@>GL� HG=>� L>� IH=>F� IKHIB<B:K� :L

:O>GMNK:L� =:� BF:@BG:`^H� >� IKHIHLB`g>L� :KJNBM>MfGB<:L� F:BL� >QI>KBF>GM:BL �<?�

<:IcMNEH����

"B@NK:��� � 6:A:�$:=B=� ����� ������� ��

������� �������$��� �� �BG<BGG:MB�+ABH��*HO�������"HGM>� AMMI���PPP�G;F�HK@�>QAB;BMBHGL<HEE><MBHGL�>QAB;BMBHGL�S:A:A:=B=E:;HK:MHKR�AMFE�>F�������� ��

"B@NK:����� 6:A:�$:=B=� �>K@BL>E�/DB�&NFI�� ��"HGM>� AMMI���PPP�:K<LI:<>�<HF�?>:MNK>L�S:A:A:=B=:K<ABM><ML�;>K@BL>ELDBCNFI� �� >F�������� ��

"B@NK:����� 6:A:�$:=B=� 0>KFBG:E):KcMBFH�/:E>KGH�"HGM>�AMMI���HI>G;NBE=BG@L�<HF�;NBE=BG@L�L:E>KGHF:KBMBF>M>KFBG:EIKH?BE>�����>F������� ��

Page 221: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J189

������������������

$4BC4�20?]CD;>�?A4C4=34�B4�38B2DC8A�0B�5>A<0B�34�4=C4=38<4=C>�4�2><?A44=BX>�3>

<D=3>� @D4� ?0AC4<� 34� 303>B� 7T?C82>B� 4� =X>� 4G2;DB8E0<4=C4� 34� 303>B� >D

?4A24?Za4B�_C820B�

$>� 4=B8=>� 30B� 0AC4B� E8BD08B� >D� ?;TBC820B� 7T� 34� ?A8=2]?8> D<0� 20?028C0ZX>� 4

7018;8C0ZX>� <08B� 5;06A0=C4� 34� DC8;8I0ZX>� 34� ?4A24?Za4B�� ?A>?>B8Za4B� 4

34B4=E>;E8<4=C>�34�20?0283034B�E>;C030B�0>�0?0A4;7>�E8BD0;�� BC>�=X>�>2>AA4�2><

>DCA>B�20<?>B�30B�<0=854BC0Za4B�0AC]BC820B�2><0�0�<bB820��>�C40CA> >D�0�30=Z0��=0B

@D08B�>DCA>B�B4=C83>B�C\<�<08>A�?A43><]=8>�=>�4=5>@D4�4�2>=BCADZX>�34�B014A4B�4

4G?A4BB8E83034B�

�� 43D20ZX>� 3>�0A@D8C4C>� 5>8 2>=241830 C4=3>� 2><>�?A8<0I80� 0� 2>=BCADZX>� 34�D<

?4=B0<4=C>� E8BD0;� 2><� 10B4� 4<� 2A8C[A8>B� _C82>B� =>C030<4=C4� ?>A� <48>� 3>

34B4=7>���B�14;0B�0AC4B��0A@D8C4CDA0��?8=CDA0�4�4B2D;CDA0�BX>�E8BC0B�2><>�58;8030B�0>

34B4=7>�

�=CA4C0=C>�� =>� 20?]CD;>� 0=C4A8>A� @D0=3>� B4� CA0C>D� 34� 0AC450C>� 4� 8<068=0ZX>� B4

>1B4AE>D @D0=C>�@D4�>B�0A@D8C4C>B�B4�DC8;8I0A0<�34�<>34;>B�CA838<4=B8>=08B � ?0A0

34B4=E>;E4A=X> �B_� 0B� A4?A4B4=C0Za4B� 34� B4DB� ?A>94C>B� 2><>� ?0A0� 34;8=40A� >B

?A8=2]?8>B� 4G?4A84=280A�4�34B4=E>;E4A�BD0B�?A>?>B8Za4B�0A@D8C4C`=820B�4�4B?02808B�

�BC4B� ?A>2438<4=C>B� DC8;8I03>B� =>B� ?A>24BB>B� 34� ?A>94C>� ?>34<� 4� 34E4<� B4A

8=2>A?>A03>B� =0B� ?A>?>B8CDA0B� 34� 4=B8=>0?A4=38I064<� 30B� 502D;3034B� 34

0A@D8C4CDA0�

Page 222: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J190

�014�0>B�43D203>A4B�4�0>B�0?A4=38I4B� 8=2>A?>A0A4< >B�?A>24BB>B�34�<>34;064<

0>� 4=B8=>� 34� ?A>94C>� 8=BC860=3>� 0� 8=2;DBX>� 30� ?A>3DZX>� 34� <>34;>B� 2>=248CD08B�

8=E4BC860C8E>B� 4G?4A84=2808B� 4� @D0;85820C8E>B� =>B� ?A>2438<4=C>B� 34� 2>=24?ZX>� 4

34B4=E>;E8<4=C>�30B�20?028C0Za4B�=424BBTA80B�R�5>A<0ZX>�3>�0A@D8C4C>�

��<>34;064<�34E4�2><?>A�?0AC4�30B�C0A450B�34�?4B@D8B0�4�2>=586DA0ZX>�30B�>1A0B

0� B4A4<� ?A>?>BC0B� 2><>� 2D8303>� 34� =X>� B4A4<� 2>=241830B� 2><>� <4A0B

A4?A4B4=C0Za4B� 34� D<0� 83480� >D� 34� 34B4=7>B�� <0B� 2><>� 50C>A� ?A>?D;B8>=03>A� 4

E4A858203>A�34�B>;DZa4B�?A>94CD08B�

)4�4BC0�[�D<0�C4B4�@D4�B4�0?;820�4<�A4B60C0A�D<0�0A@D4>;>680�3>�<>34;>�C0<1[<

=X>�?>34A80�348G0A�34�1DB20A�<8=8<0<4=C4�BD0�>=C>;>680 =0�4BB\=280� %�2>A?>�50;0�

2A80� 4� 0?A4=34� 4<� ?4A<0=4=C4� <>E8<4=C>�� 2><> �� ��� ������ 4G?A4BB0=3>�B4

C0<1[<� 0CA0E[B� 3>B� 64BC>B�� ?;4=>B� 34� B4=C83>B�� B86=858203>B� 4� 8=C4=28>=0;83034B�

�=CA4C0=C>�� ?4;0� E8E\=280� 34� D<0� 78BC_A80�� >B� BD948C>B� 5A4@D4=C4<4=C4� 348G0<� 34

?4A2414A� B4D� ?A_?A8>� 2>A?>�� B4DB� 34B49>B� 4� BD0B� ?>C4=280;83034B�� 348G0=3>� 34

4G?A4BB0A�0�C>C0;83034�3>�7D<0=>�@D4�B4�0?;820�0�2>=7424A�>�<>E8<4=C>�3>�<D=3>

4�0�CA0=B5>A<T�;>�

�@D4;0�74A0=Z0�2;TBB820�34�&;0CX>�4<�@D4�0�E8BX>�3>�2>=7428<4=C>�4A0�A4BCA8C0�0>

<D=3>�30B�83480B��4�@D4�B4�A4?;820�=0�B4?0A0ZX>�20AC4B80=0�4=CA4�<4=C4�4�2>A?>��[

2A4B24=C4<4=C4�BD1E4AC830� %�@D4�02>=C424��34B34�>B�6A46>B� 9T�@D4 �4AT2;8C>�5>8

3>B� ?A8<48A>B� 0� B4� 30A� 2>=C0� 34� D<� <D=3>� 4<� ?4A<0=4=C4� 34E8A� #08B

A424=C4<4=C4� 0�382>C><80�4=CA4�BD948C>�4�>194C>�E4<�B4=3>�?>BC0�4<�@D4BCX>��?>A

#0CDA0=0� @D4� 3454=34� 0� C4B4� 34� @D4� d2>=7424A� [� E8E4A�� 4� E8E4A� [� 2>=7424Ae

�#�*+(�$���������?�������&0A0�>�0DC>A��>�2>=7428<4=C>�[�4=20A=03>�=0�E830�4�=0

2D;CDA0�� �BB0� C4B4� 8=C4A4BB0� R� 38B2DBBX>� 3>� ?A>24BB>� 34� 2A80ZX>�� @D4� 0=8<0� 4BB0

?4B@D8B0�� =0� <43830� 4<� @D4� ?A>54BB>A4B� 34� 38B28?;8=0B� 34� 8=CA>3DZX>� 0>� ?A>94C>

?A428B0<� ;4E0A� 4<� 2>=C0� 0� 8<1A820ZX>� 30� ;D38283034� 4 8<068=0ZX>�� 4G?4A8\=280� 4

8=CD8ZX>��?4A24?ZX>�4�A0IX>�B4=B]E4;�

Page 223: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J191

%� @D4� B86=85820� 38I4A� @D4� 0B� ?ATC820B� 3>24=C4B� =0� 38B28?;8=0� 34� ?A>94C>� ?A428B0<

;4E0A�4<�2>=C0�0�A8@D4I0�30B�4G?4A8\=280B�CA0I830B�4�?>BB]E48B�34�B4A4<�0<?;8030B

?4;>B� 4BCD30=C4B� 34� 0A@D8C4CDA0�� 01A8=3>� ?>BB818;83034B 0� >DCA0B� 5>A<0B� 34

2>=BCADZX>�34�BD948C>B�

Q� E8C0;� ?0A0� >� CA010;7>� 34� @D4<� 4=B8=0� 0� 38B28?;8=0 34 8=CA>3DZX>� 0>� ?A>94C>� 34

0A@D8C4CDA0� 38B2DC8A� @D4� >� <>34;>� CA838<4=B8>=0;� 8<?;820� D<� ?A>24BB>� 34� 2A80ZX>

@D4�=X>�342>AA4�30�<4A0 CA0=B<8BBX>��34�B8<?;4B<4=C4�dD<�34?>B8C0Ae�34�0;6D<0

2>8B0�<0C4A80;8I030�?4A0=C4�>�>1B4AE03>A��%�>194C>�CA0C03>�0@D8�=X>�[�D<�?A>3DC>

?A>=C>� 0� B4A� CA0=B<8C83>� 4� A4?A>3DI83>�� *A0C0�B4� 34� 8=CA>3DI8A� D<0� 38B2DBBX>� 30

<>34;064<�CA838<4=B8>=0;�2><>�?A>24BB>�34 ?4=B0<4=C>�4�2>=24?ZX>�0�?0AC8A�34

D<0�A4;0ZX>�4BC014;42830�2><�D<�2>=7428<4=C>�B4=B]E4;�

�� ?A>?>B8ZX> 0@D8� 0=D=28030� C4<� 08=C4=ZX>34� BD?4A0A� 0� 7464<>=80�� B4=X>� 0

38C03DA0�3>�>;7>�� C4=C0=3>�4B20?0A�0�D<0�784A0A@D80�34� B4=B0Za4B�4�34� B4=C83>B�

4<�?A>;�34�D<0�B4=B818;83034�0;0A6030�4�4=A43030�

�8BC>A820<4=C4� ?>34<>B� 38I4A� @D4� >� >DE83>� C4E4� D<0� 0<?;0� 24=CA0;83034� =0B

2D;CDA0B�34� CA038ZX>�>A0;��4=@D0=C>�>�>;7>�60=7>D�D<0�?>B8ZX>�34�?A8E8;[68>��@D4

08=30� >2D?0�� 0� ?0AC8A� 30� 8=E4=ZX>� 30� 4B2A8C0� 4� 34� D<0� 42>=><80

4B2A8CDA]BC820���(*��+�����?������ @D4�B4�38BB4<8=>D��B>1A4CD3>�=>�B[2D;>�-, �

Q� ?A428B>� 0BB8=0;0A� @D4� D<0� E4A30348A0� A4E>;DZX>� 02>=C424D 2><� 0

CA0=B8ZX>� 30� 2D;CDA0� >A0;� ?0A0� 0� 2D;CDA0� 4B2A8C0�� >D� B490� 30� ?A4E0;\=280

3>� >DE83>� ?0A0 0� 3>� >;7>�� $0 0CD0;83034�� 4BC0<>B� 380=C4� 34� D<0� =>E0

A4E>;DZX>�� 0� 30� 2D;CDA0�3868C0;�� @D4� 4G864� <D;C8BB4=B>A80;83034B��<D;C8<>30;83034B

34�;8=6D064=B���8=2;D8=3>�D<0�E0A843034�34�?4A24?Za4B�4�<48>B�34�CA0=B<8BBX>�34

8=5>A<0Za4B�� 'D0=3>� >� 24=TA8>� 3868C0;� =>B� ?>BB818;8C0 0� 4G?4A8\=280� 34� <b;C8?;0B

;8=6D064=B�� >2>AA4<� ;8=6D064=B� @D4� 50;0<� 0>� >;7>� 4� 0>� >DE83>�� @D4� 8<?;820<

C4GCDA0B�� 4� @D4� 08=30� ?>34<� 02>A30A� B4=B0Za4B� >;50C8E0B� 4� 6DBC0C8E0B�� 'D0=3>

C>3>B� >B� B4=C83>B� BX>� 4G8683>B� 4� B4� 8<1A820<� 0� 38C03DA0� 3>� >;7>� B4� C>A=0

8=BD58284=C4�

�Diversidade de recursos que os usuários da língua dispõem para criar significação durante a produção.

Page 224: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J192

$0� E4A3034�� 0� 8<1A820ZX>� 3>B� B4=C83>B� 4� ;8=6D064=B� =X>� 02>=C424� 0?4=0B =0

2>=C4<?>A0=483034�� <0B� 50I ?0AC4� 30� 2>=BCADZX>� 3>B� 2>=7428<4=C>B� 34� 2030

BD948C>�� �B� E8E\=280B� 4G?4A8<4=C030B� ?4;0B� 2A80=Z0B� 2A80<� 50<8;80A83034B� 2><� >B

>194C>B�@D4�B4<?A4�d4=G4A60A0<e 2>< 0B�<X>B��<>A34<�4�2748A0<��=4BC4�B8BC4<0

>?4A028>=0;�34�50<8;80A83034�2><�>B�>194C>B��&>A[<�0>�;>=6>�3>�2A4B28<4=C>�4�3>

?A>24BB>�34�4B2>;0A8I0ZX>��0B�2A80=Z0B�EX>�B4�0?0AC0=3>�34BB0�<D;C8BB4=B>A80;83034�

�� 43D20ZX>� E08� ?A8E8;4680A� 0� 2D;CDA0� d4B2A8CDA]BC820e� 2D90� b=820� 5>=C4� 34

2>=7428<4=C>�[�0� ;48CDA0�34� ;4CA0�4�=b<4A>B� $4BB4�<4B<>�2>=C4GC>�0 43D20ZX>

E8BD0;� 3>� d>;7>e ?4A34D� BD0� 5>AZ0� 4� 348G>D 34� B4A� 4=B8=030� 2><� 0� A4C8A030� 30B

38B28?;8=0B�34�34B4=7>�30�43D20ZX>�5D=30<4=C0;�

%� <>E8<4=C>� 8=24BB0=C4� 34� 8=C4A0ZX>� 34� D<� 2>A?>� @D4� 2><� >DCA>B� 2>A?>B� 4� >

<48>� >1A860��?>A�4G4<?;>��0�E4A85820A<>B0;6D=B 2>=248C>B� %�24=CA> 34BC4CA010;7>

[ 4G?>A @D4 >�<>34;>�CA838<4=B8>=0; 8<?;820 4< D<�?A>24BB>�34�2A80ZX>�@D4�=X> [

B8<?;4B<4=C4 dD< 34?>B8C0Ae34 0;6D<0� 2>8B0� <0C4A80;8I030 ?4A0=C4� >

>1B4AE03>A�%�>194C>�CA0C03>�0@D8�=X>�[�D<�?A>3DC>�B>1A4 D<�0C>�542703>� *A0C0�B4

34� 4BC014;424A� D<0� 38B2DBBX>� 3>� <>34;>� CA838<4=B8>=0; 2><> >� ?A>24BB>� 4� 30

A4;0ZX> 4BC014;42830 2><�>�2>=7428<4=C>�

%�?0A0386<0�0@D8�0=D=2803>�C4<�0�?A>?>B8ZX>�34�D<0�BD?4A0ZX>�7464<`=820�30

38C03DA0 3>�>;7>� *4=C0=3>�=X> CA010;70A 2><�D<0�784A0A@D80�34� B4=B0Za4B�4�34

B4=C83>B�

%�>DE83>�C4E4�0<?;0�24=CA0;83034�=0B�2D;CDA0B�34�CA038ZX>�>A0;��0BB8<�2><>�>�>;7>

C4E4� ?0A0� 0 CA038ZX>� 4B2A8C0� Q� ?A428B>� 0BB8=0;0A 0� >2>AA\=280� 34� D<

54=`<4=>�30�CA0=B8ZX>�3>�>DE83>�?0A0�>�>;7> 0�?0AC8A�30�8=E4=ZX>�30�4B2A8C0�

0BB8<� 2><>� 0 2D;CDA0� 3868C0;� 30� 0CD0;83034� @D4� 4G864� 0B <D;C8<>30;83034B��� =X>

38B?4=B0=3>� 2>8B0 0;6D<0� %=34� C>3>B� >B� B4=C83>B C\< @D4 4BC0A 8<1A8203>B 4

0C4=C>B�C>A=0=3>�>�>;7> 8=BD58284=C4� % 24=TA8> 3868C0;=>B ?>BB818;8C0�0 4G?4A8\=280

34� E0A80Za4B� ;8=6D]BC820B�"8=6D064=B� @D4� 50;0< 0>� >;7>� <08B� C0<1[< ;8=6D064=B

@D4�50;0<�0>�>DE83>��@D4�0?>=C0<�?0A0 C4GCDA0B @D0B4�CT2C48B�

�Diversidade de recursos que os usuários da língua dispõem para criar significação durante a produção.

Page 225: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J193

&A>2DA0�B4� =4BC0 C4B4 A4B60C0A� 4BB0� <D;C8BB4=B>A80;83034 38BC0=280=3>�B4 30

BD?A4<0280�01B>;DC0�3>�>;7>� B>1A4�>B�34<08B� B4=C83>B�0�?>=C>�34�0105T�;>B���BC4

>;7>�� =X>� <08B� 2><>� 24=CA0;83034� 34� D<0� E8BX>� 7464<`=820�� <0B�� 3030B� 0B

28A2D=BCV=280B� 30� A0?834I� 4� E>;0C8;83034� 30� [?>20� 0CD0;� @D4 B4� 38B?4AB0� 4� ?>D2>

A4C[<�30B�<8=b280B 4�34C0;74B���<�2>=CA0?>=C>��>�4G4A2]28>�34�<b;C8?;0B�B4=B0Za4B

?>34�CA0I4A�0�?>C4=280;83034�30�4G?4A8\=280�30�<D;C8BB4=B>A80;�

�T� 3>8B� 0B?42C>B� =X>� A4B60C4� 30� <D;C8BB4=B>A80;83034�� %� ?A8<48A>

CA0C0� 30� BD?4A0ZX>� 34� D<0� 2D;CDA0� 4B2A8CDA]BC820�� >� >DCA>� 30

0<?;80ZX>�30�DC8;8I0ZX>�3>B�38E4AB>B�B4=C83>B�?0A0�2><?A44=BX>�3>

<D=3>�� $4BC0� 0<?;80ZX>� 4BCT� 0� 4GC4=BX>� 30� 2><?A44=BX>

<4A0<4=C4� E8BD0;� ?0A0� >DCA0B� 2><>� 0� 28=4BC[B820�� 0� >;50C8E0�� 0

0D38C8E0�4C2���&�((%$����� �

#08B� 3>@D4� 8BB>�� C42=>;>680B� 34� ;8=6D064< ?A>3DI4<� <D30=Z0B� B4=B_A80B� @D4

054C0<� B86=85820C8E0<4=C4� =>BB0B� ?4A24?Za4B� 4� 0Za4B�� 4BCADCDA0ZX>

?0A280;<4=C4B>1A4?>BC04=CA4� >B� =>E>B� 38B?>B8C8E>B�� >B� =>E>B� 0AC450C>B?A>E>20<0

0?A4=38I064<�D1]@D0�d��0?A4=38I064<�D1]@D0 C>A=0A�@D4�>�0?A4=38I03>�B490�D<0

4G?4A8\=280�<4;7>A�38BCA81D]30�=>�C4<?>�4�=>�4B?0Z>�e���+(�+"�)�������

%B� 3854A4=C4B� ?0A0386<0B� 30� 0?A4=38I064<� D1]@D0 ?>BB818;8C03>B� ?4;0B� <T@D8=0B

@D4� ?4A<8C4<� 0?A4=34A� 4<� @D0;@D4A 4� C>3>� C4<?>� 4� ;D60A�� BX>� 34� 4GCA4<0

8<?>ACV=280�4<�=>BB>B�380B��%�0;D=> E08�0?A4=34A�0�1DB20A��>�@D4�[�=424BBTA8>��>

@D4�[�34B4903>��>�@D4�[�>?>ACD=>��$4BB4 ;D60A�34�0?A4=38I064<�D1]@D0� 0B�A4;0Za4B

4=CA4 ?A>54BB>A4B4�0;D=>B� C4=34<�0� B4�7>A8I>=C0;8I0A���030�E4I�<08B�[�=424BBTA8>

@D4�>B�2>=C4b3>B�=X>�E0;70<�4<�B8�<4B<>B��<0B�B4�C>A=4<�=424BBTA8>B��34B4903>B

4�>?>ACD=>B�?0A0�>B�0?A4=38I4B�

$4BB0� E8A030� 3868C0;�� >� <D=3>� CA0I� 2>=B86>� >DCA0� 2>=586DA0ZX>�� =X>� <08B� ?0DC030

4<�5A06<4=C>B�4�2>=C4b3>B�0;748>B�0>B�BD948C>B���G4<?;85820=3>��4=C4=34�B4�@D4�>

<4=>A�B46<4=C>��=>�@D4�B4�A454A4�R�4B2A8C0��[�0�;4CA0��<0B�>�@D4�8=C4A4BB0�[�>�C4GC>

@D4� [� B86=85820C8E>� ?0A0� 0;6D[<�� %� ?43028=7>� =>� C>20=C4� 0� 4;01>A0ZX>� 34� D<0

<0@D4C4�B4A80��?>A�4G4<?;>��D<�<0C4A80;�0�B4A�3>1A03>�?0A0�50I4A�D<0�d20B8=70e�

Page 226: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J194

$>�4=C0=C>��0�C[2=820�=X>�A4E4;0�C>30B�0B�?>BB818;83034B�3>�50I4A����34B2>14AC0�=0

4;01>A0ZX>�34�D<0�<0@D4C4�?0BB0�?4;>�<>3>�34�C>A24A�>�<0C4A80;��D<�0A0<4��D<

58>� 4� =X>� 0?4=0B� =>� @D4� ?A>54BB>A� 4=B8=0�� �B� 34B2>14AC0B� ?0BB0<� 0� B4A� ?4BB>08B

08=30�@D4�2><?0AC8;7030B�

&A>94C0�B4�D<0�7>A8I>=C0;83034�=0B�A4;0Za4B�>=34�0=C4B�B_�E86>A0E0�0�E4AC820;83034

4=CA4� 0� ?>B8ZX>� 3>�?A>54BB>A� 4� 0� 3>� 0;D=>�� $0�?A>?>BC0�@D4�34B4=E>;E4A�B4�T =>

?A_G8<> 20?]CD;>��C4=C0�B4 B08A�34�D<�2>=C4b3>�4BCTC82>�4�A48=CA>3DI8A�0�A8@D4I0�30B

4G?4A8\=280B� 3>B� 0;D=>B� =0B� ?A>?>BC0B� 34B4=E>;E830B�� �>=B4@D4=C4<4=C4� 4<

0;6D<0B�B8CD0Za4B��>�0;D=>�?>34�B014A�<08B�@D4�>�?A>54BB>A��)08=3>��0BB8<� 34�D<

2>=C4b3>�4BCTC82>��4� A4;028>=0=3>�0�50;C0�34�784A0A@D80�0>=34�>�0;D=>�?>34�B014A

<08B�3>�@D4�>�?A>54BB>A�4<�B4�CA0C0=3>�34�34C4A<8=03>B�0BBD=C>B�

$0� 0?A4=38I064<� D1]@D0� [� <D8C>� 8<?>AC0=C4� >� ?A>24BB>� 2><>� B4� 0?A4=34� ?>8B

=X>� B4� CA0C0�0?4=0B�3>� ;D60A��0>=34�4�@D0=3>� 4� B8< 2><>�4�?>A@D4� B4�0?A4=34�

*A0C0�B4�34�D<0�0?A4=38I064<�<08B�B>280;�4�4BCT�A4;028>=030�2><�0B�0C8E83034B�3>

43D203>A��[�5D=30<4=C0;�C0<1[<�0�<>C8E0ZX>�3>�0;D=>�?0A0�0?A4=34A�8=5>A<0Za4B

50CD08B� �;01>A0A 4BCA0C[680B� 8=C46A03>A0B� ?0A0� 4=CA0A� =>� 9>6>30B

2><?;4<4=C0A83034B� [� >� 6A0=34� 34B058>� 3>B B8BC4<0B� 43D2028>=08B� 4� 2DAA82D;0A4B

=>�<D=3>�

�B�<D30=Z0B�C42=>;_6820B 4�B>2808B�4BCX>�A4;028>=030B�4=CA4 B8�4�D<0�E08�<D30=3>

0�>DCA0����C42=>;>680�=X>�B_�?>34�B4A�E8BC0�2><>�D<0�54AA0<4=C0��2><>�C0<1[<

2><>� ?A>24BB> @D4� B4� A4;028>=0� 2><� >B� 38BC8=C>B� <>E8<4=C>B� B>28>2D;CDA08B� @D4

8=C4A064<� =0� 2>=BC8CD8ZX>� 3>� 2>=7428<4=C>�� �B� <D30=Z0B� C42=>;_6820B� 4

B>28>2D;CDA08B� 270<030B� ?>A �DA1D;4B�� 34� d0?A4=38I064<� D1]@D0e� >D

d0?A4=38I064<�34�C>30B�0B�?0AC4Be�

%�34B4=E>;E8<4=C>�3>B�38B?>B8C8E>B�?>ACTC48B�B><03>�R 38B?>=818;83034�34�C>30B�0B

=>E0B� C42=>;>680B��<08B�0B�<D30=Z0B� B>28>2D;CDA08B� 2A80A0<�=>E>B� ;D60A4B�>=34�[

?>BB]E4;� 0?A4=34A�� �B� A434B� 3868C08B� ?4A<8C4<� @D4� 0� 0?A4=38I064<� B4� 3\ 4<

38BC8=C>B�;D60A4B��=X>�B><4=C4�4<�D<�205[��D<0�181;8>C420�>D�4<�=>BB0B�20B0B���<

Page 227: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J195

C>3>B� >B� ;D60A4B� 4� C4<?>�� �=50C8I0�B4� =X>� B><4=C4� d0>=34e� 4� d@D0=3>e� <0B

C0<1[<�>�d2><>e�4�>�d?>A�@D\e�B4�0?A4=34�

�B�0;C4A0Za4B�B>2808B�CA>DG4A0<�?0A0�0 7D<0=83034� D<�0?DA>�64=4A0;8I03> 4� ?>A

2>=B4@D\=280��BDA68A0<�0B�C42=>;>680B�@D4�B4�0?A4B4=C0<�34�<0=48A0�0 42>=><8I0A

4B5>AZ>B� 4� >C8<8I0A>� C4<?>�� ,8E4�B4 4<� D<0� 2D;CDA0 30� ?A4BB0 4� =424BB8C0�B4 34

024;4A03>A4B�34�0?;820ZX>����2A80ZX>�34�0AC450C>B�4�<0C4A808B�@D4�?>BB0< 0Z>30A�0B

C0A450B�

�1A4�B4�� 0BB8<�� D<� ?A>24BB>� 2DA8>B>� B4� C\<� 2030� E4I� <08B� 2><>383034B�� <08B

0?0A0C>B 4;4CA`=82>B� 4� 4;[CA82>B� 34BC8=03>B� 0� 50I4A� =>BB0� E830� <08B� 5T28;�� &>A[<�

0?4B0A�34BC4B�0E0=Z>B��50I4<>B�0;6>�<0;��)X>�<D8C>B�>B�@D4�E8E4<�B4<�C4<?>�?0A0

=030� B04<� C0A34� 3>� CA010;7>�� BX> 8=8=C4AAD?C0<4=C4 4=2>=CA03>B� ?>A� B4DB

C4;45>=4B� 24;D;0A4B�� 4� A4B?>=34<� <08B� 34� CA8=C0 4�<08;B� 38TA8>B� B4<� 50;0A� 30B

A4D=8a4B 4C2�

%�A424?C03>A�34�8=5>A<0Za4B�7>94 =X>�[�D<0�?4Z0�@D4�B4�A43DI�0�A424?ZX>�� BB> [

8=C4A4BB0=C4�?0A0�>B ?A>54BB>A4B�?>A 0?A4B4=C0A�34B3>1A0<4=C>B�=>�<><4=C>�30

2A80ZX>��25���0?]CD;>����

,8E4=280A�4G?4A8\=280B�2>;4C8E0B�4�2><?0AC8;7030B�?>34�C>A=0A�>�0?A4=38I03>�<08B

45820I�� %� 2><?0AC8;70<4=C>� 30B� B4=B0Za4B� 4� 30B 4G?4A8\=280B� 2>;4C8E0B�� C>A=00B

<08B� 34=B0B� 4� <D8C> <08B� B86=85820C8E0B�� ?>8B� 5>A=424 D<0� @D0=C83034� A820� 34

A4C0;7>B� 34� 4G?4A8\=280B @D4� 2>=BCA>4<� D<0� 4G?4A8\=280� <08>A�� $>� <>B082>

4G?4A8<4=C0;� 8=38E83D0;�� >D� 2>;4C8E>�� 8=C4A4BB0� >� <>3>� 4<� @D4� 2030� D<� 2>=C0�

=0AA0��4G?A4BB0�>�@D4�E8E4D��B4=C8D��E8D�4 ?4A2414D�� BB>�B4�0<?;85820�=0�<43830 0

@D0; B4� C4<� D<0� CDA<0� 8=C48A0� 34� 0?A4=38I4B� ?0BB0=3>� ?4;0� 4G?4A8\=280�� @D4� B4

C>A=0� b=820�� B>280;� 4� 2><?0AC8;7030�� �030� 8=38E]3D>� ?4A2414� 34� D<0� <0=48A0�

?>A[<� 0� ?0AC8A� 30� 8=B4AZX>� 30B� ?4A24?Za4B� 8=38E83D08B� B8=6D;0A4B� ?>BC0B 4<

38B2DBBX>��2><?0AC8;70�B4�4 C>A=0�B4<08B�A82>B�

Page 228: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J196

'D0=3>�=>BB0B�E8BC0B�?0A0<�4<�0;6D<� ;D60A��[�D<� 8=3828>�34�@D4�0@D8;>� C4<�D<

B86=858203>�� �� ;48CDA0� 34� <D=3>� =X>� [� B><4=C4� E8=2D;030� 0>� >;7>� �>8B� 0DC>A4B

5A0=24B4B�34�64A0Za4B�2>=B42DC8E0B�B4�?A4>2D?0A0<� 2><�>�0BBD=C>�

#4A;40D�&>=CH� 0?>=C0� 0� ?4;4� 2><>� 20?028C03>A0� 34�38BC8=Za4B� 34� 2>A4B� E0A8030B�

�=C4B� 34� B4A� E8BC0�� 0� 2>A� 0=D=280�B4� 4=CX>� ?4;0� 4G?4A8\=280� 34� 24AC0� 0C8CD34� 3>

2>A?>�@D4�B_�2>=E[<�0�4;0�4�2><�34C4A<8=030�?A428BX>��!T��4=A8��4A6B>= 38I @D4�>

2[A41A>�[�28=4<0C>6AT582>��>D�B490��4;4�4BCT�A4?;4C>�34�8<064=B @D4�=X>�BX>�0?4=0B

_?C820B�� ?0A0� 4;4� 0B� 8<064=B� BX>� 02bBC820B�� ?A>E4=84=C4B� 34� 38E4AB0B� 4G?4A8\=280B

B4=B>A808B� 4� =X>� 0?4=0B� 3>� >;7>�� �>=B834A0=3>� @D4� >� 2[A41A>� [� 28=4<0C>6AT582>�

?>34�B4 38I4A�@D4�0B�8<064=B�BX>�<D;C8BB4=B>A808B�

%�>;70A�B4�58G0>=34�4=2>=CA0�D<�B86=858203>� %�2[A41A>�4<8C4�D<0�>A34<�?0A0�@D4

4;4�B4�34<>A4�=0@D8;>�4�=X>�4<�>DCA0�2>8B0� ��6A0=34�<08>A80�30B�?4BB>0B�08=30�3T

0>� >;7>� 4BB4� ?0?4;� 7464<`=82>�� &>A[<�� 8=C4A4BB0 0@D8�� 4G?;820A� 0� 8<?>ACV=280� 3>

C0C>�

�� @D4BCX>� A4CA0C030 =0 8=E4BC860ZX> 34BC0� C4B4 ?4A<480� 0 38B2DBBX>� 30� 0ZX>

3>24=C4� 4� 3>� 38T;>6>� 2><� >B� 38B24=C4B�� �1>A30<>B� 0� ?A4>2D?0ZX> 0CD0; 2>< 0

?A438;4ZX>�30�E8BX> 4<�34CA8<4=C>�3>B�34<08B�B4=C83>B�4�> 34B0?0A428<4=C>�30B

20A02C4A]BC820B�B4=B>A808B�=0�2>=24?ZX> 4�4=B8=>�30�0A@D8C4CDA0�

d*4=C48� 4G?A4BB0A� 0� 8<?>ACV=280� 3>� C0C>� ?0A0� 4G?4A8<4=C0A<>B� 4

4=C4=34A<>B�>� <D=3>��<0B� C0<1[<� 1DB@D48� ?A>E>20A� D<�2DAC>�

28A2D8C>�2>=248CD0;�4=CA4�>�B4=C83>�3><8=0=C4�30 E8BX>�4�3>�C0C>��0

<>30;83034�A4?A8<830�3>B�B4=C83>B�e��!D70=8&0;;0B<00� �����

Page 229: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J197

(4<4C4�B4�06>A0 0>�2>=9D=C>�34 C0?4Z0A80B 5A0=24B0B <4384E08B�4G8BC4=C4B�=>

<DB4D�34��;D=H 4<�&0A8B�

%� 2>=9D=C> d�� �0<0� 4� >� +=82_A=8>e A4?A4B4=C0 2030� D<� 3>B� B4=C83>B� �8=2>

C0?4Z0A80B�A4?A4B4=C0<�>B�B4=C83>B�4GC4A=>B��0�E8BX>��0�0D38ZX>��>�?0;030A��>�>;50C>

4� >� C0C>�� 4D<0� B86=85820C8E0� B4GC0� C0?4Z0A80�� � ����������� ���>� <4D� b=82>

34B49>��� 586������[� 8=C4A?A4C030 2><>�> 4=C4=38<4=C> 40�2><?A44=BX>� %�34B49>

50I 2><�@D4�B4�E490 2>8B0B @D4 =X> B4A80<�E8BC0B��%�34B49>�4BCT�=0�?>=C0�3>B�343>B�

%� 34B49>� 4BCT� =0� E8BX>�� <08B� 0=C4B� 34� <08B� =030� >� 34B49>� 4BCT� 34=CA> 34� 2030

8=38E]3D>�

�86DA0 �� �*0?4Z0A80B����30<0�4�>�+=82_A=8>��B[2D;>�-,����E8BX>�?03AX>�[�@D4�0B�C0?4Z0A80B�A4?A4B4=C0<�>B�28=2>�B4=C83>B��>=C4��7CC?�FFF�12�43D?D1;820C8>=B=4F0A203800A278E4B�8B/C74A4/0/B8GC7/B4=B4�4<������

Page 230: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J198

�030�D<�3>B�B48B�C0?4C4B�<>BCA0�D<0�B4=7>A0�=>1A4�4�D< D=82_A=8>�

�86DA0���� ��30<0 4�>�+=82_A=8>�&0;030A�

�>=C4�7CC?�FFF�12�43D?D1;820C8>=B=4F0A203800A278E4B�8B/C74A4/0/B

8GC7/B4=B4�4<������

�86DA0 ���� ��30<0�4�>�+=82_A=8>��D38ZX>��>=C4�7CC?�FFF�12�43D?D1;820C8>=B=4F0A203800A278E4B�8B/C74A4/

0/B8GC7/B4=B4�4<������

�86DA0 �� ���30<0�4�>�+=82_A=8>�,8BX>��>=C4�7CC?�FFF�12�43D?D1;820C8>=B=4F0A203800A278E4B�8B/C74A4/0/B8GC7/B4=B4�4<������

�86DA0 ���� ��30<0�4�>�+=82_A=8>�*0C>�

�>=C4�7CC?�FFF�12�43D?D1;820C8>=B=4F0A203800A278E4B�8B

/C74A4/0/B8GC7/B4=B4�4<������

�86DA0 ���� ��30<0�4�>�+=82_A=8>�%;50C>�

�>=C4�7CC?�FFF�12�43D?D1;820C8>=B=4F0A203800A278E4

B�8B/C74A4/0/B8GC7/B4=B4�4<������

�86DA0����� �>�<4D�b=82>�34B49>

�>=C4�7CC?�FFF�12�43D?D1;820C8>=B=4F0A203800A278E4B�8B/C74A4/0/B8GC

7/B4=B4�4<������

Page 231: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J199

$4;0B�� >� C0C>� 4G4A24� D<0� 5D=ZX>� ?A43><8=0=C4� [� 0� <X>� @D4� B46DA0� >� 201>� 3>

4B?4;7> �586��������[�0�<X>�@D4�C>20�0�C42;0�3>�_A6X>��586� ������[�0�<X>�@D4�4BC4=34

>�343>�?0A0�0�0E4��586� ����� [�0�<X>�@D4�B46DA0�0�5;>A�0�B4A�2748A030 �586� ������[�0

<X>�@D4 020A8280�>�0=8<0;��586������

�><� >� 8=CD8C>� 34� 9DBC85820A 0 8=E4BC860ZX>� 3>� ?A>24BB>� ?A>94CD0;� 0CA0E[B� 3>B

<>34;>B� B4� 50I� =424BBTA8>� > 4=C4=38<4=C>� 34 @D4>� C0C>� C4<� D<0 ;>20;8I0ZX>

8<?>AC0=C4 =>�4G?4A8<4=C>�4 => 4=C4=38<4=C>�3>�<D=3>��4=50C8I0=3>�>�B4=C83>�

�<�E4I�30�7464<>=80�34�D<�>D 34�>DCA>�B4=C83>��0?>=C0�B4 ?0A0 0�8<1A820ZX>�34

D<�4>DCA>��2><�D<0�BDC8;�A4;4EV=280�3><8=0=C4�30�E8BX>�4�3>�C0C>�

*>30�4BB0 8=C4A0ZX> 4=CA4�>B�B4=C83>B�[�?A>24BB030�=>�2[A41A>��4=CX>� 0>�8=E[B�3>

34B;>20<4=C> 34�D<�<>34;>�@D4�78?4A�38<4=B8>=0E0�> >;7>� ?0A0�D<�<>34;>�@D4

78?4A�38<4=B8>=0�> C0C>��0�<>E8<4=C0ZX>�B4�3T�4<�38A4ZX> 0>DCA> ?0A0386<0 4<

@D4� C>3>B� >B� B4=C83>B� B490< 2>=9D603>B 2>=2><8C0=C4<4=C44<� D<0� 8<1A820ZX>

3>B�B4=C83>B�

�� E8E\=280� =>� <D=3>� 0CA0E[B 30� B4=B818;83034� 4� ?4A24?ZX>2>;>20�B4 5A4=C4� 0>

34B4=E>;E8<4=C>�4� A458=0<4=C>�3>B� B4=C83>B��% B014A� B4=B]E4;� B4�4;01>A0�0�?0AC8A

30B� 4G?4A8\=280B� B4=B>A808B� CA0=B5>A<030B� 4<� 0?A4=38I064=B� B86=85820C8E0B� =0B

@D08B >� 2>A?>�[� 01>A303>� 2><>�?>=C>�34�?0AC830�?0A0�>B� B014A4B�7D<0=>B�� 2D90

8=C46A83034�?A428B0�B4A�A4C><030����4G8BC\=280�A40;8I0�B4 =>�2>A?> 4�[�?>A�<48>�34;4

@D4� ?>34�B4 4BC0A�=>�<D=3>�� 2><?A44=3\�;>� 4� 4=2>=CA0A� D<0� B86=85820ZX>� ?0A0

4;4�

%1B4AE0�B4 @D4� >� 2>A?>� [� 2>=38ZX>� 34� E830� 4� 4G8BC\=280�� 2D90� ?;DA0;83034� 4

2><?;4<4=C0A83034�B4�4G?A4BB0<�=0�2>A?>A483034���CD0;<4=C4��>�2>=C4GC>�B>280;

5A06<4=C03>� C4=C0� B8;4=280A� 0� B0143>A80� 3>� 2>A?>� 4� BD0� ;8=6D064<� B4=B]E4;�

010=3>=0� 4BB0� 2>=38ZX>�� ?A8>A8I0=3>� 0� <0C4A80;83034�� D<� 2>A?>� 34� 2>=BD<>�� 34

8<064=B�8340;8I030B��B4<�834=C83034��B4<�4G?4A8\=280B�B4=B]E48B�@D4 A4?>DB0 B>1A4

8=C4A4BB4B�42>=`<82>B�4� BD0B� 8<?;820Za4B�2D;CDA08B�342>AA4=C4B��%1B4AE0�B4�4=CX>

Page 232: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J200

>B�0B?42C>B�@D4�?4A<480<�0�6;>10;8I0ZX>� 0B�<D30=Z0B�=>�2>C8380=>�30B�?4BB>0B�4

0�0C4=ZX>�RB�?4A24?Za4B�3>�<D=3>�

�� 4G?4A8\=280� B4=B>A80;� 2><?A44=34� C>30B� 0B� ?4A24?Za4B� 3>� 2>A?>� ?>A� <48>� 3>B

B4=C83>B�� A468BCA0=3>� 4� 0?4A548Z>0=3>� 4BC]<D;>B� 4;4<4=C0A4B� CTC48B�� E8BD08B�

0D38C8E>B�4 B>=>A>B�=0@D8;>�@D4� B4� 0?A4B4=C0�=>�<D=3>�� 0� 4G?4A8\=280� B4=B]E4;� [

2>=BC8CD]30�34�B4=C83>B�4�B86=85820Za4B�<08B�2><?;4G>B��4;01>A03>B�D<�?>D2>�0;[<

30B�E8E\=280B�B4=B>A808B��?>34�B4A�4@D8?0A030�R�4G?4A8\=280�4BC[C820�?A>?>A28>=030

?4;0� 0AC4�� @D4� B4� DC8;8I0� 30B� ?4A24?Za4B� B4=B>A808B�� 3>B� B4=C83>B� 4� B86=858203>B

A45;4C83>B��0AC82D;0=3>�A4;0Za4B�=0�2>A?>A0;83034�

%B� B014A4B� B4=B]E48B� 4BCX>�=> 2>C8380=>�4 =>� B4=B>� 2><D<� ?>8B 50I4< ?0AC4�30B

CA038Za4B�BX>� B014A4B� <b;C8?;>B� @D4� ?>34<� B4A� 20?0I4B� 34� ?A>?>A28>=0A� >

A44=2>=CA>�34�?4A24?Za4B�?>BC0B�0> ;03>�0>�;>=6>�30�E830���CD0;<4=C4��?4A24?Za4B

4� 8=5>A<0Za4B� B4=B8C8E0B� BX>� 050BC030B 3>B� 2>A?>B�� >D� B490� 4;4B A42414<� 0B

8=5>A<0Za4B� B4=B>A808B� 3>� <D=3>� 4GC4A=>�� <0B� =X>� 0B� ?4A2414<�� =X>� ?A4BC0<

0C4=ZX>� =0@D8;>� @D4� ?>34A80� B4A� B4=C83>�� &>A� 4BC0� A0IX>� B4� 50I� ?A4B4=C4� 0

?A>?>B8ZX>� <4C>3>;_6820� 34� A45>AZ0A� 0� 43D20ZX>� ?>A� <48>� 30� 0<?;80ZX>� 30B

A424?Za4B�B4=B>A808B��0>�50I4A�2>=5;D8A�0B�8=5>A<0Za4B�3>B�B4=C83>B�4�30�?4A24?ZX>

=0�2>=BCADZX>�3>B�2>=7428<4=C>B�

'D0=3>�0�34E830�0C4=ZX> [�0CA81D]30 0>�34B?4AC0A 30� B4=B818;83034��<>18;8I0<�B4

>A34=0Za4B�4�A4>A34=0Za4B�=D<0�2><?A44=BX>�<08B�?A>5D=30�34�B8�<4B<>�4�3>B

>194C>B 28A2D=30=C4B�� ?A>E>20=3>� 0� 9D=ZX>� 3>� <D=3>� 8=C4A=>� 2><� >� <D=3>

4GC4A=>�

��<>34;064<�CA838<4=B8>=0;�=0 ?ATC820�<4C>3>;_6820�34� CA010;7>�30�38B28?;8=0�34

8=CA>3DZX>� 0>� ?A>94C>� 0A@D8C4C`=82>� C4<� ?>A� >194C8E>� 3458=8A� 83480B�� 4E>;D8�;0B� 4

4G?4A8<4=CT�;0B 34=CA>� 34� D<� 4=B8=>� ?0DC03>� ?4;0B� E8E\=280B�� 4G?4A8\=280B� 4

A45;4Ga4B�?4BB>08B�3>B�43D20=3>B�

$4BC4� 2>=C4GC>� 0� ?A>?>B8ZX>� 34� 5>A<0B� 4� 4B?0Z>B� B4AT� 0?A44=3830� 4<� B4D

6A030C8E>� 34B4=E>;E8<4=C>� =D<0� 8=C46A0ZX>� <08B� ?A>5D=30� 3>� ?4=B0<4=C>�� 3>

Page 233: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J201

B4=C8<4=C>� 4� 30� ?4A24?ZX>�� �>=CA81D8=3>� 0BB8<� ?0A0� >� 34B4=E>;E8<4=C>� 34

8=38E]3D>B� <08B� 2>=B284=C4<4=C4� ]=C46A>B� =0B� BD0B� A4;0Za4B� 2><� >� <D=3>�

4;01>A0=3>�=>E>B�?0AV<4CA>B�3>�2>=7428<4=C>��?0A0�>�B014A�<08B�5D=30<4=C0;��>

B014A�E8E4A�

%� CA010;7>� 2A80C8E>� 4G864� 0� 834=C85820ZX>� 2>A?>A0;� 4 <4=C0; � D<0 2><?4C\=280

?4A24?C8E0�4�B4=B]E4;�?0A0�34?A44=34A�>�B86=858203>�30�?A>?>B8ZX>�34�D<�>194C>�0

B4A�?A>94C03>��$0�8<068=0ZX>��>�>194C>�3>�?A>94C>�4BCT�2>=9D=C0<4=C4 =0B�<X>B�4

=>�8=C4;42C>��4�0�8<064<�5]B820�?A>?>BC0�4�2A8030�[�<>34;030 ?4;>B 2>A?>B� %�>194C>

4BCT 0>�<4B<>�C4<?>�34=CA>�4�5>A0�

�� ?A_?A80� 4BB\=280� 30� E8E\=280� [� <>;3030� ?4;0� C0C8;83034� 4� ?4;0� E8BX>� ?4A85[A820

05>20;�� �� E8BX>� ?>34� B4A� 2>=B834A030� >� <>3>� 34� A4;0ZX>� 4=CA4� >� >1B4AE03>A� 4� >

<D=3>��2>=CD3>� >�@D4�7018CD0;<4=C4�34B86=0�B4�?>A�E8BX> =0B24�30�2>=9D60ZX>�34

3854A4=C4B� C8?>B� 34� ?4A24?ZX>�� <09>A8C0A80<4=C4 ?4A24?ZX>� E8BD0;� 4� CT2C8;�

&0;;0B<00�������34<>=BCA0�@D4�C>30�4G?4A8\=280�[�<D;C8BB4=B>A80;�4�@D4�C>3>B�>B

B4=C83>B�3458=4<�D<0�8=C4A5024�4=CA4�0�?4;4�4�>�0<184=C4�

*>3>B�>B�B4=C83>B� 8=2;DB8E4�0�E8BX>��?>34<�B4A�2>=B834A03>B�2><>

4GC4=Ba4B�3>�B4=C83>�3>�C0C>� �B<X>B�BX> _A6X>B�34�?4=B0<4=C>f

��?4;4�;\�0�C4GCDA0��>�?4B>��0�34=B83034�4�0 C4<?4A0CDA0��&0;;0B<00�

�������� ��

%B�380B�0CD08B�0?A4B4=C0<�A42>AA4=C4B B8CD0Za4B 0CA4;030B�R�B>1A420A60�B4=B>A80;��%

>;70A� 58G>� 3454=B8E>� 01A4� =>E0B� 4B54A0B� 34� E8BX>� 4� ?4=B0<4=C>�� 34B>1A86030B� 3>

34B49> BD14=C4=383>�@D4�>B�>;7>B�C\<�2><0=3>�4�3><]=8>�

�E834=C4<4=C4 D<0� 0A@D8C4CDA0� 4=A8@D4243>A0� C4<� @D4� 38A868A� C>3>B� >B� B4=C83>B

B8<D;C0=40<4=C4� 4� 5D=38A� 0 8<064<� 3>� 4D� 2>< 0� 4G?4A8\=280� 3>� <D=3>� �

A4;4EV=28030 4;01>A0ZX>�<4=C0;�=0�0A@D8C4CDA0�B4�4=2>=CA0 4<4BC>20A�4�8=C46A0A� %

2[A41A>�?>BBD8�D<�4BC>@D4�34�8<064=B�@D4�B4�028>=0�=>�<><4=C>�30�2A80ZX>��4BB4

Page 234: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J202

4BC>@D4� 34� 8<064=B� ?0BB0� ?>A� D<0� 4;01>A0ZX>� <4=C0;� @D4� >� C>A=0 3854A4=C4� 4

b=820� ��4;01>A0ZX>�<4=C0;�0;>90�4�=4BB4�0;>90<4=C> A42>AA4�B4 0�4BB4 4BC>@D4�

��0A@D8C4CDA0�0AC82D;0�4G?4A8\=280�34�B4�50I4A�?0AC4�3>�<D=3>�4�A45>AZ0�0�B4=B0ZX>

34� A40;83034� 4� 4=C83034� ?4BB>0;�� C>A=0 7018CTE4;� ?4;>� C>@D4� ?4BB>0;� �

4G?4A8<4=C0ZX>�0AC]BC820 B4�0AC82D;0 0CA0E[B�30�A424?ZX>�30B�4<>Za4B�3>�0AC8BC0�4<

D<0 2>=9D=CDA04B?0280;�� +<0� >1A0 0A@D8C4C`=820� =X>� [� 4G?4A8<4=C030

8B>;030<4=C4� 2><>� D<0 b=820 8<064<��� 4G?4A8<4=C0ZX>� B4� 3T� ?>A� BD0� 4BB\=280

<0C4A80;��2>A?_A40�4�4B?8A8CD0;�=0�<08B�70A<>=8>B0�8=C46A0ZX>�

$> 8<068=TA8>�� >� >194C>� 4BCT� B8<D;C0=40<4=C4 =0B <X>B� 4� 34=CA> 30 <4=C4�� 4� 0

8<064<� 5]B820� ?A>94C030� 4� 2A8030� [� <>34;030 ?4;>B 2>A?>B�� %� 4<?>34A0<4=C>

2A80C8E>� B8CD0�B4�=>� ;D60A�30�?A>94C0ZX>� *>30�0�2>=BC8CD8ZX>�<4=C0;�4� 2>A?>A0;�3>

50I43>A� B4� 2>=E4AC4=3>=> ?A>24BB>� 34� 8=C46A0ZX>64A03>A� 30� >1A0 @D4� ?0BB0 ?>A

ETA8>B <><4=C>B�4�A42A80Za4B�

� BD194C8E83034 ?4BB>0; [�C42830�4<�D<�9>6>�2><�>DCA0B�BD194C8E83034B��4;0�=D=20�[

C42830�34�D<�B_ <>3>��$0B24�B4�>DE8<>B�E>I4B��4B2DC0=3> 2>=E4AB0B� 4�01A0Z0=3>

0 2D;CDA0�4� 2>=B4@D4=C4<4=C4� 501A820=3>�2D;CDA0B�

�� ?A>?>B8ZX> 30� 38B28?;8=0� 8=CA>3DZX>� 0>� ?A>94C>� =>� 2DAB>� 34 �A@D8C4CDA0� 4

+A10=8B<>�=0�&+��(8>�?>BBD8�D<�2><?>=4=C4�2DAA82D;0A�@D4 20A02C4A8I0�B4�?>A D<

34B4=7> @D45>8�?4=B03> 2><�0�58=0;83034�34�C4=C0A A><?4A�2>< 0;6D<0B�74A0=Z0B

@D4� >B� 0;D=>B CA0I4<� 34� B4DB� 2DAB>B 34� �K� 6A0D�� �=CA4� 4BB0B� 74A0=Z0B� 4BCT� 0

784A0A@D80� 3>B� B4=C83>B� @D4� >� >;7> 586DA0� =>� C>?>� 30� ?8AV<834� �4A0=Z0� 4BB0

A4B@D]28>� 30� (4=0B24=Z0� @D4� 2>=B834A0E0� @D4� >B� 28=2>� B4=C83>B� 5>A<0E0<� D<

B8BC4<0�784ATA@D82>�=>�@D0;�0�E8BX>�4BC0E0�=>�C>?>�30�10B4�586�������

3Empoderamento, ou empowerment, em inglês, significa em a ação coletiva desenvolvida pelos indivíduos quandoparticipam de espaços privilegiados de decisões, de consciência social dos direitos sociais. Essa consciênciaultrapassa a tomada de iniciativa individual de conhecimento e superação de uma realidade em que se encontra

Page 235: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J203

�� 58<� 34� 0;C4A0A� 4BB4�?0=>A0<0� 34� 5>A<0ZX>�34� 4=B8=>�=0B283>� 34� E4AC820;83034B

4=CA4 ?A>54BB>A�4�0;D=>� C4>A80�4�?ATC820�@D4�5D=30A0<�6A0=34�?0AC4�30�5>A<0ZX>

3>B�4BCD30=C4B��0�38B28?;8=0�?4=B0�4<�D<�2>;4C8E>�34�?A>54BB>A4B�2><�4G?4A8\=280B

<b;C8?;0B�� 50;0=3>� ;]=6D0B� 3854A4=C4B�� 4� @D4� C\<� D<� A4?4AC_A8>� 38BC8=C>� 4� @D4

C4=C0< CA010;70A� 34� <>3>� 034B5>A<0C0A� 4� 2>=BCAD8A� =>E>B� 0?A4=38I03>B� =0@D8;>

@D4�>�4BCD30=C4�E8E4=28>D�0C[�>�<><4=C>�

��38B28?;8=0 8=CA>3DZX>�0> ?A>94C>�CA0I�4<�BD0�<4C>3>;>680�?4306_6820�>DCA0�E8BX>

4?8BC\<820����4?8BC4<>;>680�30�A028>=0;83034�2;TBB820�@D4�E4<�3>B�6A46>B��?0DC030

=0� D=8;0C4A0;83034� 2><>� B4� CD3>� C8E4BB4� B46D8=3>� 34=CA>� 34� D<� b=82>� ?03AX>�

�=B8=>� 34� C4>A80B�� ?A8=2]?8>B�� =>A<0B� 4C2�� ?4;>B� ?A>54BB>A4B� 4� 0?;820Za4B� B46D=3>

4BC4B� ?03Aa4B� ?4;>B� 0;D=>B�� $X>� B4� 50;0� 3>B� B014A4B� <b;C8?;>B� <8BCDA03>B� 4

4?8BC4<>;>680B� >DCA0B� @D4� ?>34<� E8A� 3>B� 0AC8BC0B�� 34� 8=E4BC860Za4B� 4� 30� ?A_?A80

2>=BCADZX>�34�2>=7428<4=C>B�4 0?A4=38I064<����?;0BC8283034�[�14<�<08>A��4=CX>�0

38B28?;8=0� 34=CA>� 34� B4DB� 7>A8I>=C4B�� ?A>?a4� A><?4A� 2><� >� 7T18C> 30� 4B2>;0� 34

20<8=70A� 2><� D<0� ;_6820� b=820�� D< ?03AX>� b=82>� @D4� 0� CD3>� ?>34� B4A� 0?;8203>

47><>64=48I03>�� @D4� CD3>� ?03A>=8I0�� %� 0;D=>� 0>� 8=E[B� 4=CA0A� =0� 5>A<0� 4� =0

, )N% c �%�%

&�"���( � L�+�

*�*% � *�((�

%"��*% � ,�&%(

�+� PN% � �(

�86DA0�������84A0A@D80�3>B�B4=C83>B c ?8AV<834�A4=0B24=C8BC0

Page 236: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J204

5`A<0� A42>=BCA_8� ?4A2DAB>B�� 0<?;80� B4D� 2>=7428<4=C>� 8<068=0� 4� E4A85820

?A>?>B8Za4B�

�><�0�83480�30 34B5>A<0C0ZX>��0�38B28?;8=0�B4�34B4=E>;E4 =0�8=C4A0ZX>��0>�8=E[B�34

CA010;70A�2>< D<�50I4A�?0A0� 4<�@D4�>�?A>54BB>A >2D?0�B4 ?0A0�>B�0;D=>B� 4;4�1DB20

343820A�B4 2><�>B�0;D=>B�[�>�@D4�&0D;>��A48A4�270<0�34�50I4A�2><��$4BB4�50I4A�2><

>B� 0;D=>B� BX>� >DE83>B�� 4;4B� 50I4<� 4;4B� 4G?4A8<4=C0<�� 4;4B� 38B2DC4<� 4 4;4B

BD64A4<�

�� 38B28?;8=0� C0<1[<� ?A>?a4 D< ?;DA8�;8=6D]B<>�� >� @D4� �0:C8= ���� � 270<0� 34

74C4A>6;>BB80�� �3854A4=C4� � 6;>BBTA8>B�� +C8;8I0<�B4 50;0B� @D4� A40;<4=C4� BX>

01B>;DC0<4=C4� 38BC8=C0B�� )X>� >DCA0B� ;]=6D0B� >DCA>B� A4?4AC_A8>B� 34� 4G?4A8\=280B� 4

>DCA0B� 2>=24?Za4B� @D4� E\<� 34=CA>� 30� ;]=6D0�� &>A@D4� D<0� ;]=6D0� C0<1[<� C4<

2>=24?Za4B� +B0�B4� 0� ?>;85>=80�� >=34� ?4BB>0B� 50;0<� 34� 3854A4=C4B� ;D60A4B�� 34

3854A4=C4B�?TCA80B�34�3854A4=C4B�8=E4=CTA8>B�4�8BB>�[�D<0�C4=C0C8E0 34�=X>�5>A<0C0A

34�=X>�2>;>20A�4<�D<0�b=820�<0CA8I��34�=X>�>;70A�CD3>�?0A0�>�<4B<>�;D60A���BC0

?ATC820�B4�3T?>8B 34=CA4�0�4@D8?4�34�?A>54BB>A4B�@D4�5>A<0<�>�6AD?>�C4<�B4�D<

?A>54BB>A�278;4=>��D<�0<4A820=>�4�D<�0;4<X>�

�<� C4A<>B� 34� 4=B8=>� 34� ?A>94C>� 34� 0A@D8C4CDA0� =D=20� [� 34<08B� ;4<1A0A� @D4� >

d?A>94C>�[�0�34B2A8ZX>�34�D<�>194C>�@D4�=X>�4G8BC4�=>�2><4Z>�3>�?A>24BB>���BC0

34B2A8ZX>� B4� 50I� ?>A� <48>� 34� 0?A>G8<0Za4B� BD24BB8E0Be� ��>A>=0� #0AC8=4I�� ��

? ���� �� 2>=BCADZX>� 34BC4� ?A>24BB>� A4@D4A� 0E4A86D0Za4B� 4� ?A>?>B8Za4B� BD24BB8E0B

?0A0�>�4=2>=CA>�30�5>A<0�4�3458=8Za4B�58=08B�3>�>194C>�0�B4A�2>=BCAD]3>��*4=3>�4<

E8BC0�@D4�>�>194C>�0�B4A�43858203>�[�D<�?A>94C>�4�0BB8<�B4=3>�[�D<� ;0=Z0A�?0A0�0

5A4=C4� 4;4� =D=20� [� 0� 2_?80� 34� D<� <>34;>� 0=C4A8>A�� )D0� 34C4A<8=0ZX>� 4=E>;E4AT�

?>AC0=C>��D<0� 8<068=0ZX>�2A803>A0�4�D<�?A>24BB>�34�E4A85820ZX>�4� 2>=BCADZX>�34

BD0�4B?0280;83034��3458=8ZX>�5>A<0;�4�2>=BCADC8E0��&0A0�@D4�>�A4BD;C03>�3>�?A>24BB>

B490�4BC4�>194C>�0�B4A�2>=BCAD]3>�

Page 237: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

J205

#08B�?A428B0<4=C4�0�34B2A8ZX>�?>A�<48>B� 0=0;_682>B � 34B4=7>B�4

<0@D4C4B�� 02><?0=703>B� 34� 4B?4285820Za4B� 4B2A8C0B� B>1A4

?A>?A843034B� 3>B� <0C4A808B� ?A>?>BC>B� ?0A0� BD0� 2>=BCADZX>�� �

8=E4=ZX>�3>�>194C>�A40;8I0�B4�?>A�<48>�34�dA4?A4B4=C0Za4Be�34BB0

2>8B0�8=4G8BC4=C4��2>38582030B�34�<0=48A0�8<?A428B0�4<�D<�B8BC4<0

6AT582>� 2D90� B8=C0G4� [� ?0A42830� 2><� 0@D4;0B� 30� A4?A4B4=C0ZX>

3458=8C8E0���%(%$��#�(* $�.������?� ���

)4�>�>194C>�=X>�[ D<�<>34;>�0�B4A�2>?803>�4=C4=34�B4�@D4�0�4B2>;0�34�0A@D8C4CDA0�

10B4030�4<�5>A<0ZX>�?0A0�0C8E83034B�?A>94CD08B� 34E4�B4A�0=C4B�34�CD3>�B4A�0=C8�

AA4?A>3DC>A0�34�2>=7428<4=C>B��10B40=3>�B4D�4=B8=>0?A4=38I064<�=0�?A>?>B8ZX>

34�=>E>B�>194C>B�@D4�0C4=30<�RB�=>E0B�=424BB83034B�30�B>2843034�

�B�?A>?>B8Za4B�?A>94CD08B�B_�?>34<�B4A�2><?A44=3830B 34=CA>�34�D<�4=B8=>�@D4

?A>?8284�4G?4A8<4=C0Za4B�4�?A>?>B8Za4B =>�B4=C83>�34�20?028C0A >B�0?A4=38I4B�0>

34B2>AC8=>� 34 BD0B� ?A>?>B8Za4B�� C><0=3>� 2><>� 10B4� 8=BC860A� 2>=C]=D>B

?A>2438<4=C>B� 34� 0?A>G8<0ZX>� BD24BB8E0� ?0A0� 0� 3458=8ZX>� 58=0;� 3>B� >194C>B� 3>

?A>94C>��&0A0�C0=C>� 34E4�>2>AA4A�D<�B0;DC0A�2>=E]E8>�4=CA4�A4?A4B4=C0Za4B�6AT5820B

4� <>34;064<� CA838<4=B8>=0;�� &A>2438<4=C>B� 8<?>AC0=C4B� C0=C>� ?0A0� >

34B4=E>;E8<4=C>� 3>� ?A>94C>� =>� 20<?>� ?A>58BB8>=0;� 2><>� =0� 5>A<0ZX>� 3>B

0A@D8C4C>B�

&0AC4�B4�3>�?A8=2]?8>�@D4�C4<�B4 D<0�4B2>;0�A4?A>3DC>A0�@D4�[�0�0=C]C4B4�34�CD3>�>

@D4� [� =424BBTA8>� ?0A0� 0� BD?4A0ZX>� 30� A4?A>3DZX>�� @D4� ?>A� BD0� E4I� =X>� 380;>60

2><� >B� ?A>24BB>B� 2A80C8E>B�� *A0C0�B4� 4=CX>�� 2><� 0� 38B28?;8=0� 4<� @D4BCX>� 34

A42D?4A0A�D<�20<8=7>�4�30A�2>=B8BC\=280 0�D<0�?ATC820�34B4=E>;E830��34B34�@D4�>

2DAB>�34�0A@D8C4CDA0�4�DA10=8B<>�5>8�2A803>�=0�&>=C85]280�+=8E4AB83034��0C_;820�3>

(8>�34�!0=48A>�=>�?A8<48A>�B4<4BCA4�3>�0=>�34����

Page 238: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 206

&���*D#���$�&(�&����)!���*$�&�G"�����#��"(����"(&#�)FD#��#

$&#��(#�����&%)�(�()&���A�9/;S8.8�$)� X &38

)��IFGC� 89� �FEI=H9HIF5� 9�/F65B=GAC�85� */��,=C :C=� 7F=58CBCG� DF=A9=FCG� 5BCG� 8C

Gc7I@C�22#�/A5�7CA=GG`C�89 DFC:=GG=CB5=G�9 DFC:9GGCF9G 89�8=J9FG5G�\F95G�=895@=NCI

C� 7IFGC� 7CA�C�89G9>C�89 DFCDCF�IA5� :CFA5H5b`C =BCJ58CF5 9A�GI5G�DFCDCG=bi9G

7CA�:CFH9�=BH9;F5b`C�7CA�CG��IFGCG 89��B;9B<5F=5�9��9G=;B�85 /B=J9FG=8589

� DF=A9=F5� HIFA5 :CFACI�G9� 7CA� HF9N9� 5@IBCG�� 9A� ���� 9� 9A� �� � C� 7IFGC

7CAD@9HCI 89N� 5BCG�"C>9 C� �IFGC�89��FEI=H9HIF5� 9�/F65B=GAC�85� */��,=C� 7CBH5

7CA� EI=B<9BHCG� 9� C=H9BH5� 9� G9=G� 5@IBCG�� BCJ9BH5� 9� G9=G� DFC:9GGCF9G� 9� 7=B7C

:IB7=CB\F=CG �CA�C�C6>9H=JC�89�:CFA5F =B8=Je8ICG EI9�9@56CF9A�F9:@9Li9G�7FeH=75G�

@=85B8C� 7CA� 7CB<97=A9BHCG� 9GHFIHIF5BH9G� 8C� D9BG5A9BHC� 7CBGHFIH=JC�

F97CB<979B8C�� :CA9BH5B8C� DFC79GGCG� =BH9FDF9H5H=JCG�� 7CBHeBICG� 9� 7F=5H=JCG

�LD@CF5B8C BCJ5G�\F95G�8C�7CB<97=A9BHC�=BH9F5;=B8C�7CA�CIHFCG�7IFGCG 8C�75ADIG

9 6IG75ACG =BH9F7^A6=CG� 7CA� CIHF5G� IB=J9FG=8589G� 9� 79BHFCG� 89� D9GEI=G5G� �A

HC85G� 5G� 5H=J=8589G� D985;g;=75G� F9@57=CB585G� 7CA� 5G� 5I@5G� 9LDCG=H=J5G�� 5G� J=G=H5G

;I=585G� 9 5� DF\H=75� 9LD9F=A9BH5@�� J=G5B8C IA5� 7CAD@9H5� =BH9;F5b`C� 9BHF9� 5

D9GEI=G5�5758dA=75�9�5�DF\H=75�DFC:=GG=CB5@

IB858C� BC� DF=A9=FC� G9A9GHF9� 89� �� � C� �IFGC� 89� �FEI=H9HIF5� 9� /F65B=GAC

B5G79I 85�HF58=b`C�9�85�9LD9F=dB7=5�85�*/��,=C�BC�9BG=BC�9A�RF95G�.97BC@g;=75G�

9A� �FH9G� 9� �9G9B<C� #B8IGHF=5@� 9� 9A� "=GHgF=5�� 9GH5B8C� GC6� 5� F9GDCBG56=@=8589

5758dA=7C�58A=B=GHF5H=J5� 8CG� �9D5FH5A9BHCG� 89 �FH9G � �9G=;B 9� 89 �B;9B<5F=5

�=J=@�� 9A� 9GHF9=H5� 7C@56CF5b`C� 7CA� CIHFCG� �9D5FH5A9BHCG� 85� /B=J9FG=8589� �GG5

5GGC7=5b`C� =B7CFDCFCI 56CF85;9BG� 8=:9F9B7=585G� 5C 7IFFe7I@C� 8C

Page 239: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 207

=;IF5������&C;CA5F75 �IFGC�89�FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC�*/��,=C CBH9� KKK75IDI7�F=C6F 9A����� ���

7IFGC�A5F7585A9BH9� =BH9F8=G7=D@=B5F� 9� =BCJ58CF�� EI9� =BH9;F5� IA� Gg@=8C

9A65G5A9BHC�Gg7=C�7I@HIF5@�7CA�IA�:CFH9�7CADCB9BH9�H97BC@g;=7C

n(9GG5�F9IB=`C��85�EI5@�D5FH=7=D5F5A�� �D9GGC5G � Gg�7CB<97=5�IA5�89@5G ���EI5B8C

A9�D98=F5A�D5F5�:5@5F� 89DC=G�89�D5GG5F9A�=B:CFA5bi9G�GC6F9�C�EI9�=A5;=B5J5A

EI9�G9F=5�C�7IFGC��IG9=�5�=A5;9A�8C�GI>9=HC�57CGHIA58C�5�HCA5F�6CB89�9�EI9�D9;5

C�DF=A9=FC�89@9G�G9A�G569F�D5F5�CB89�=5��DC=G�H=J9�5�G9BG5b`C�89�EI9�C�7IFGC�>\�9F5

IA�6CB89�9A�ACJ=A9BHC�*5F5�CB89�9@9�=5��9I�B`C�G56=5�8=N9F�,9GG5@H9=�EI9��BC

�F5G=@��<5J=5�5D9B5G�89N�9G7C@5G�EI9� F95@A9BH9�9BG=B5J5A�5FEI=H9HIF5�9�EI9�B`C

G56=5�7CAC�5�*/�� =F=5�DFC7989F�,9J9@9=�A=B<5G�DF9C7ID5bi9G�9�5F;IA9BH9=�EI9�

9A�F5N`C�85�HF58=b`C�9A�CIHF5G�\F95G�CB89�5�*/��5HI5J5��9@9G�89J9F=5A�DFC7IF5F

:5N9F� 5� A9@<CF� 9G7C@5� 89� 5FEI=H9HIF5� 8C� ,=C� 89� $5B9=FC�� 9� B`C� 5D9B5G� IA5

=BGH=HI=b`C� 5� A5=G� D5F5� 7CB7989F� 8=D@CA5G� )� 9BG=BC� H9A� EI9� G9F� :9=HC

:IB85A9BH5@A9BH9� 5� D5FH=F� 8C� HF=Dc� 9ACb`C�� =B:CFA5b`C� 9� =BJ9Bb`C� +I5B8C

@97=CB5J5� B5� /B=J9FG=8589� 989F5@� 8C� ,=C� 89� $5B9=FC�� 9I� <5J=5� DFCDCGHC� IA5

8=G7=D@=B5� 89BCA=B585� =BHFC8Ib`C� Z� DFC:=GG`C� 8C� 5FEI=H9HC�� 9� 9I� 5� F9HCA9=� B5

*/�o�BHF9J=GH5�89��@:F98C��F=HC� 5 *CF 9FB5B8C -9F5D=`C -C6F9 5 =AD@9A9BH5b`C 8C

�IFGC 89 �FEI=H9HIF5 9 /F65B=GAC B5 */� ,=C *I6@=7585�CF=;=B5@A9BH9

9A $&#��(#��-#!(�8=b`C�� ��$IB<C�89� ���

)� 7IFGC GIF;=I� 7CA� C� DFCDgG=HC� 85 6IG75 DCF� IA� D58F`C� 89� 9L79@dB7=5 m 7CAC

HF58=b`C�8CG�89A5=G� 7IFGCG�C:9F97=8CG�B5� =BGH=HI=b`C m 89G9BJC@J9F C�D9BG5A9BHC

7FeH=7C� 9� :CFB979B8C CG� =BGHFIA9BHCG� DFC>9HI5=G� 9� Hc7B=7CG� B979GG\F=CG� D5F5� 5

=BG9Fb`C� 89 BCJCG� DFC:=GG=CB5=GEI9� 9L9Fb5A� G=;B=:=75H=JCG� D5Dc=G� GC7=5=G�

97CBhA=7CG�9�7I@HIF5=G��EI9�9GH9>5A�9BJC@J=8CG�DFC8Ib`C�89�7=8589G�9�<56=H5b`C

*5F5�H5BHC��5�A9HC8C@C;=5�58CH585�DFC7IF5�HF5N9F�D5F5�C�8=5�5�8=5�8C�5DF9B8=N58C

G=HI5bi9G�85�F95@=8589�8C�:IHIFC�DFC:=GG=CB5@��GG5�7CB79Db`C�G9�F9:@9H9�B5�9GHFIHIF5

7IFF=7I@5F� 8C� �IFGC� EI9� c� GI68=J=8=85� 9A� ;FIDCG� 89� 8=G7=D@=B5G� 9� DFC;F5A5G 89

1 Alfredo Britto é arquiteto e urbanista. UFRJ (1961).Atualmente é professor titular da Pontifícia UniversidadeCatólica do Rio de Janeiro, professor titular da Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro e membro do ConselhoSuperior do IAB-RJ.

Page 240: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 208

5HI5b`C�DFC:=GG=CB5@��GH9G =B7@I9A�C�*FC;F5A5�89�*FC>9HCG��C�*FC;F5A5��CBH=BI58C

89� �GH\;=C� 9� 5G� �H=J=8589G� �758dA=75G� �CAD@9A9BH5F9G�� EI9 D9FA=H9A� H9GH5F� 9

5A58IF979F� =89=5G� :5N9B8C�7CA�EI9�C�5@IBC��89G89�C�=Be7=C�8C��IFGC��HF565@<9�B5

8=F9b`C�89�IA5�5FEI=H9HIF5�A5=G�7CAD@9H5�9�A58IF5

)G� ;FIDCG� 89� 8=G7=D@=B5G� DF9C7ID5A�G9� 7CA� CG� 7CB<97=A9BHCG� =BH9;F5H=JCG� 85

:CFA5b`C� <IA5B5� 9� 7CA� CG� 7CB<97=A9BHCG� EI9� 75F57H9F=N5A� 5G� 5HF=6I=bi9G� 9

F9GDCBG56=@=8589G� DFC:=GG=CB5=G� 8C� 5FEI=H9HC� 9� IF65B=GH5� �CAD@9A9BH5FA9BH9�� C

7IFFe7I@C� 8C� �IFGC� =B7@I=� 8=G7=D@=B5G� 9@9H=J5G� @=JF9G�� EI9� D9FA=H9A� EI9� C

5@IBC8=F97=CB9� GI5� :CFA5b`C� D5F5� \F95G� 89� =BH9F9GG9� 9GD97e:=7C� 9� J=56=@=N5A� GI5

9LDCG=b`C�5�CIHF5G�\F95G�89�7CB<97=A9BHC�9�5�CIHF5G�A9HC8C@C;=5G�89�9BG=BC

)��IFFe7I@C�8C��IFGC�89�!F58I5b`C�9A��FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC�85�*/��,=C�=BH9;F5

A5HcF=5G� 89� CFA5b`C� !9F5@�� 89� ,9DF9G9BH5b`C� 9� �LDF9GG`C�� .97BC@g;=75G�� 89

*FC>9HC��89�5H=J=8589G�9LHF5�7@5GG9�9�89�8=G7=D@=B5G�89� CFA5b`C�,9@=;=CG5

��CF;5B=N5b`C�8C�7IFGC�H9A�5�8IF5b`C�89�7=B7C�5BCG��9�7CBH5�<C>9�7CA�����5@IBCG

8=J=8=8CG� 9A� 8C=G� HIFBCG� )G� DF=A9=FCG� 7=B7C� G9A9GHF9G� 57CBH979A� BC� HIFBC� 85

H5F89��G9;IB85�Z�G9LH5� :9=F5�85G�������ZG�������<CF5G 9�5�D5FH=F 8C�EI=BHC�G9A9GHF9�

CG�5@IBCG�9GHI85A�D9@5�A5B<` 85G������ZG�������<CF5G )G�5@IBCG�:F9EI9BH5A�5G

5I@5G

)� ;FIDC� 89� 8=G7=D@=B5G� 89� CFA5b`C� !9F5@� 56F5B;9� �I@HIF5� 'C89FB5� 9

�CBH9ADCF^B95�� #BHFC8Ib`C� Z� *FC:=GG`C� 89� �FEI=H9HC�� .9CF=5� 9� "=GHgF=5� 85

�FEI=H9HIF5�� "=GHgF=5� 85� �FEI=H9HIF5� BC� �F5G=@�� "=GHgF=5� 85G� �=8589G�� /F65B=GAC�

*@5B9>5A9BHC� /F65BC� 9� ,9;=CB5@�� �GHcH=75�� �GHI8CG� -g7=C��BHFCDC@g;=7CG� '9=C

�A6=9BH9�9��9G9BJC@J=A9BHC�-IGH9BH\J9@�9��7CBCA=5

�G�8=G7=D@=B5G�89�,9DF9G9BH5b`C�9��LDF9GG`C�9BJC@J9A�5G�<56=@=8589G�89�9LDF9GG`C

B979GG\F=5G� Z� 5H=J=8589� DFC>9HI5@�� �9G9B<C� 89� )6G9FJ5b`C�� !9CA9HF=5� �9G7F=H=J5�

�9G9B<C� 89� �FEI=H9HIF5� �=B7@I=B8C� 5D@=75bi9G� 89� #B:CFA\H=75��� IB85A9BHCG� 85

&=B;I5;9A�0=GI5@�9��CADF99BG`C�9�*FC8Ib`C�8C�.9LHC�.c7B=7C

Page 241: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 209

(C�;FIDC�89�.97BC@C;=5�G`C�7CBH9AD@58CG��GC6�5�:CFA5�89�8=G7=D@=B5G�9�7CBH9l8CG

6\G=7CG�BC�*FC;F5A5�89�*FC>9HCG��CG�7CB<97=A9BHCG�89�'5H9A\H=75�8C��GD5bC�9�85G

CFA5G�� �\@7I@C�� eG=75�� �CB:CFHC� �A6=9BH5@�� .CDC;F5:=5�� �F;CBCA=5�� -=GH9A5G

�GHFIHIF5=G�� !9CH97B=5� �CBGHFIb`C� �=J=@�� *@5B9>5A9BHC� 9� �CBHFC@9� 89� )6F5G�

'5H9F=5=G�89��CBGHFIb`C��.c7B=75G��CBGHFIH=J5G�9�#BGH5@5bi9G�*F98=5=G�9�/F65B5G

�A� CFA5b`C� ,9@=;=CG5�� 5G� 8=G7=D@=B5G� )� "CA9A� 9� C� 9BhA9BC� ,9@=;=CGC�

�F=GH=5B=GAC��WH=75��F=GH`�9�WH=75�*FC:=GG=CB5@�5DCBH5A�D5F5�5�7CADF99BG`C�8C�D5D9@

8C�DFC:=GG=CB5@�B5�GC7=98589

)�*FC;F5A5�89�*FC>9HCG�:C=�9@56CF58C�5�D5FH=F�89�IA�AC89@C�D985;g;=7C�89�5H9@=d

=BH9;F58C� EI9� 7CBG=89F5� 5� 5H=J=8589� DFC>9HI5@� 7CAC� IA� DFC79GGC� 89� 7CCD9F5b`C

9BHF9� 8=J9FGCG� G569F9G�� 7CB:=;IF58CG� B9GH9� 7IFFe7I@C� 7CAC� �CBH9l8CG� �\G=7CG� 9

�CBH9l8CG��CAD@9A9BH5F9G��EI9�G9�=BH9;F5A�9�G9�7CAD@9A9BH5A�B5�7CB79Db`C�9

9@56CF5b`C� 89� 7585� *FC>9HC� )G� *FC>9HCG� HF5H5A� 89� 75ADCG� 89� 5H=J=8589� EI9

56F5B;9A� J\F=CG� G9;A9BHCG� 89� 5HI5b`C� 8C� 5FEI=H9HC� 9� IF65B=GH5�� #BHFC8Ib`C� 5C

*FC>9HC��*FC>9HC�8C��GD5bC�,9G=89B7=5@��*FC>9HC�8C��GD5bC�8C�.F565@<C��*FC>9HC�8C

�GD5bC��C@9H=JC��*FC>9HC�89�,9J=H5@=N5b`C�9�,9IH=@=N5b`C��*FC>9HC�/F65BC��*FC>9HC�89

�FEI=H9HIF5�/HgD=75��5@cA�8C�*FC>9HC� =B5@�7CA�H9A5�@=JF9

)�9BG=BC�89�*FC>9HC� 5C�9L9F7=H5F�5� =BJ9GH=;5b`C�9�5�DF\H=75�85�DFC:=GG`C��9GH=AI@5�

8IF5BH9�C�D9FeC8C�89�:CFA5b`C�8C�5@IBC��5�F95@=N5b`C�89�DFC>9HCG�5HI5@=N58CG�7CA

5G� 8=J9FG5G� J9FH9BH9G� EI9� 7CADi9A� 5� 5H=J=8589� DFC>9HI5@� �� D5FH=7=D5b`C� 89

DFC:9GGCF9G� 89� 8=J9FG5G� \F95G�� 7CAD5FH=@<5B8C� 7CBH9l8CG� 9� 89G9BJC@J9B8C�BCJ5G

7CAD9HdB7=5G��J=G5�5� =BH9;F5b`C�9:9H=J5�9BHF9�5�H9CF=5��5�DF\H=75��5�7F=5H=J=8589�9�C

D9BG5A9BHC�7FeH=7C

)�7IFFe7I@C �7:�5B9LC���� 5AD@=5�C�7CB79=HC�89�5H=J=8589�5758dA=75�5C�DCGG=6=@=H5F�C

F97CB<97=A9BHC�89��H=J=8589G��758dA=75G��CAD@9A9BH5F9G�F9@9J5BH9G�D5F5�EI9�C

5@IBC�58EI=F5�C�G569F�9�5G�<56=@=8589G�B979GG\F=5G�Z�GI5�:CFA5b`C�9�5C� =BGH=HI=F�C

*FC;F5A5��CBH=BI58C�89��GH\;=C�EI9�DCGG=6=@=H5�5C�5@IBC�9L9F7=H5F�5�=BJ9GH=;5b`C�9

5�DF\H=75�85�DFC:=GG`C�:CF5�85�/B=J9FG=8589

Page 242: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 210

)� D9FeC8C� 89� 5I@5� c� 8=J=8=8C� 9A� H9ADCG� 8=:9F9B7=58CG� 89� 57CF8C� 7CA� 5

DFC;F5A5b`C� 9@56CF585� D9@CG� 7CCF89B58CF9G� EI9� 58A=B=GHF5G� 7585� IB=8589

G9A9GHF5@ �� A9HC8C@C;=5� H5BHC� B5� \F95� 85G� 8=G7=D@=B5G� 89� �FEI=H9HIF5� CI

/F65B=GAC� 9GH\� CF=9BH585� D9@5� =BG9Fb`C� 89� 5GD97HCG� H9gF=7CG� B5G� 5H=J=8589G

DFC>9HI5=G �� A5=CF� D5FH9� 85G� 8=G7=D@=B5G� 5DCBH5 5C� 7CB<97=A9BHC 9

89G9BJC@J=A9BHC� 89� DFC>9HC� 9A� G9I� G9BH=8C� A5=G� 5AD@C� 9� 5G� 8=G7=D@=B5G

7CAD@9A9BH5F9G =BH9F�F9@57=CB5A�G9IG�7CBH9l8CG�H5BHC�5CG�9=LCG�H9A\H=7CG�7CAC

ZG� 9GD97=:=7=8589G� 9� 7CAD@9L=8589G� 5� G9F9A� HF5H585G� 5� 7585� 7=7@C� G9A9GHF5@

�L9AD@=:=75B8C�C�9LDCGHC��C�7CBH9l8C�89�HCDC;F5:=5�c�858C�EI5B8C�CG�9GHI85BH9G

B979GG=H5A�@9J5BH5F�IA�H9FF9BC�D5F5�5�9@56CF5b`C�8CG�DFC>9HCG =B8=J=8I5=G

�� A9HC8C@C;=5� 8C� 7IFGC H9A� 7CAC� 65G9� DFCD=7=5F� IA5� =BH9F5b`C� 9BHF9� 7=8589� 9

5@IBC� �GG=A� 5� @C75@=N5b`C� 9GHF5Hc;=75� 9� 5� =B:F59GHFIHIF5�� DFCDCF7=CB5A� F9:@9Li9G

GC6F9�5�8=J9FG=8589�89�IA5�;F5B89�A9HFgDC@9

&C75@=N58C�B5�4CB5�-I@�8C�,=C�89�$5B9=FC��C��5ADIG�!\J95�85�*/��,=C�F9lB9�9A IA

Gg�7CAD@9LC�HC85G�5G�GI5G�5H=J=8589G�89�9BG=BC�9�D9GEI=G5

=;IF5 ����#AD@5BH5b`C */��,=C���5ADIG!\J95 CBH9���BI\F=C�*/��,=C� ���

-5@5G�89�5I@5�8C�7IFGC�89�FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC

�8=:e7=C�#'��8=:e7=C�5F895@�&9A9

Page 243: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 211

*5F7=5@A9BH9� BC �8=:e7=C �5F895@� &9A9 9 BC �8=:e7=C� #'�� 9B7CBHF5A�G9 5G

=BGH5@5bi9G�8C�7IFGC 89 �FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC� ��/�*/��,=C

�� =B:F59GHFIHIF5� IB=J9FG=H\F=5� c� D5FH9� :IB85A9BH5@� BC� 5DF=ACF5A9BHC� 8C

7CB<97=A9BHC � 9L79@dB7=5� 5758dA=75� c� IA =ADCFH5BH9� J5@CF� 89� EI5@EI9F

/B=J9FG=8589�89� ;F5B89�DCFH9�9 9GG5�DF9FFC;5H=J5� J9A�57CAD5B<585�89�89H5@<9G

:IB85A9BH5=G� EI9� GIGH9BH5A C� D=@5F� 85� 57589A=5� /A� 89@9G c� 5� 9GHFIHIF5 89

GIDCFH9�EI9�HCFB5 5�J=JdB7=5�8C�9GHI85BH9�9�GI5G�89J=85G�5H=J=8589G�9B;F5B897=85G

*5F5�EI9�C�9GHI85BH9�DCGG5�:F9EI9BH5F�5GG=8I5A9BH9�5�/B=J9FG=8589��9GHFIHIF5G�89

5DC=C� 89J9A� 9GH5F� G9ADF9� Z� 8=GDCG=b`C� W� C� 75GC� 89� F9GH5IF5BH9G� IB=J9FG=H\F=CG�

ACF58=5G�D5F5�9GHI85BH9G��79BHFC�Ac8=7C��6=6@=CH975G��65B7CG� :5FA\7=5G 9�9GD5bCG

89�9BHF9H9B=A9BHC

��57589A=5�c�IA�5A6=9BH9�89�8=J9FG=8589��89�F9GD9=HC�Z�=B8=J=8I5@=8589�9�9GG9

DF=B7eD=C�89J9�;5F5BH=F�C�579GGC�ZG�9GHFIHIF5G�IB=J9FG=H\F=5G�5�HC8CG � */��,=C G9

9B7CBHF5 569FH5 D5F5�89:=7=9BH9G�:eG=7CG�89�H5@�:CFA5�EI9 5@IBCG�EI9 7CAD5F979A

ZG�5I@5GH9A�IA�57CAD5B<5A9BHC�=BH9;F5@�89�IA�DFC:=GG=CB5@�D5F5�5IL=@=5�@C�B5G

GI5G�8=:=7I@8589G

)�9BHFC�89��FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC � ��/�69B9:=7=5�G9�89�HC85�5�=B:F59GHFIHIF5�85

/B=J9FG=8589�EI9�=B7@I=�

=;IF5��� � �8=:e7=C��5F895@�&9A9 CBH9�� CHC 85�5IHCF5

=;IF5 �����8=:e7=C�#'� CBH9�<HHD�KKKJ=HFIJ=IG7CA6FF9J=GH5GF958DFC>9HCG��� ����� 9A����� ��

Page 244: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 212

� �=6@=CH975

�� �=J=G`C� 89� �=6@=CH975G� 9� �C7IA9BH5b`C� ������ c� 5 IB=8589� 7CCF89B58CF5� 8C

-=GH9A5�89 �=6@=CH975G�85�*/��,=C��DCGGI=�IA�579FJC�89�5DFCL=A585A9BH9� �����

HeHI@CG�� 9BHF9� @=JFCG�� ACBC;F5:=5G�� H9G9G� 9� D9F=g8=7CG� -9IG IGI\F=CG� HdA� 579GGC� 5

65G9G� 89� 858CG� =BH9FB57=CB5=G� 9� 5C� G=GH9A5� �)'/.� 5HF5JcG� 8C� EI5@� DC89A� G9F

C6H=85G�7gD=5G�89�5FH=;CG�89�D9F=g8=7CG�@C75@=N58CG�9A�CIHF5G�6=6@=CH975G

� &56CF5HgF=C 89 #B:CFA\H=75

��*/��8=GDi9�89�5DFCL=A585A9BH9����@56CF5HgF=CG�89�A=7FC�=B:CFA\H=75�9EI=D58CG

7CA�GC:HK5F9G�89�l@H=A5�;9F5b`C

=;IF5 �����=6@=CH975�*/��,=C CBH9�� CHC�!@5I7=5��I;IGHC� CBG975

=;IF5����� &56CF5HgF=C 89 #B:CFA\H=75 */��,=C CBH9�5I@5�DI7�F=C�GCIF79�@BAG�H6A�=G7<�G5�2�9�9A����� ��

=;IF5 ���� �58CG�9GH5HeGH=7CG���=6@=CH975�*/��,=C CBH9��<HHD�KKK868DI7�F=C6F868D<D�9A����� ��

Page 245: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 213

� &56CF5HgF=C�):=7=B5�9�.F9=B5A9BHC�89��9G9BJC@J=A9BHC�9�*FCHgH=DCG

� &56CF5HgF=C 89 .97BC@C;=5 85 �CBGHFIb`C

(C�89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�89�GI5G�5H=J=8589G�CG�5@IBCG�8C �IFGC�89��FEI=H9HIF5�IH=@=N5A

C� &56CF5HgF=C� �GHFIHIF5G� 9� '5H9F=5=G�� 8C� �9D5FH5A9BHC� 89� �B;9B<5F=5� �=J=@�� EI9

7CBH5�7CA�9EI=D5A9BHCG 8=J9FGCG

=;IF5 ����&56CF5HgF=C�):=7=B5�9�.F9=B5A9BHC�89��9G9BJC@J=A9BHC�9

*FCHgH=DCG */��,=C

CBH9� <HHD�KKKG?MG7F5D9F7=HM7CAG<CKH<F958D<D�H������ 9A����� ��

=;IF5 ���� &56CF5HgF=C 89 .97BC@C;=5 85 �CBGHFIb`C */��,=C CBH9� <HHD�KKKG?MG7F5D9F7=HM7CAG<CKH<F958D<D�H������ 9A����� ��

Page 246: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 214

� &56CF5HgF=C 89 �CB:CFHC �A6=9BH5@

)�&56CF5HgF=C�89��CB:CFHC��A6=9BH5@�D9FA=H9�C�89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�89�9LD9F=A9BHCG�

9GHI8CG� 9� HF9=B5A9BHCG� 9BJC@J9B8C� 7CB8=bi9G� 89� H9AD9F5HIF5�� J9BH=@5b`C�

=BGC@5b`C�� =@IA=B5b`C� 9� 57lGH=75�� 75D5N9G� 89� 5:9H5F� C� 5A6=9BH9� B5HIF5@�� IF65BC� 9

98=:=758C

� &56CF5HgF=C 89 '5EI9H9G 9 56F=75b`C �=;=H5@

) �IFGC�89��FEI=H9HIF5 9�/F65B=GAC 7CBH5�7CA�IA�&56CF5HgF=C�89�,9DF9G9BH5b`C

9A�0C@IA9��7CA CG�9EI=D5A9BHCG�B979GG\F=CG�5C�89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�85G�5H=J=8589G

=B9F9BH9G�5CG�*FC>9HCG�8CG�5@IBCG

=;IF5 ������I@5�H9gF=75��&56CF5HgF=C�89 �CB:CFHC �A6=9BH5@*/� ,=C CBH9�� CHC�!@5I7=5��I;IGHC� CBG975

=;IF5 ����&56CF5HgF=C 89 '5EI9H9G*/� ,=C CBH9�<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F=BGH=HI7=CB5@�D5;9#8���9A����� ��

Page 247: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 215

)�C6>9HC�89�=BJ9GH=;5b`C�85�H9G9�G9�F9GHF=B;9�5�8=G7=D@=B5 � �,+����� � #(.,)�/VT)

�)�*,)$�.)��C:9F97=85�BC�G9A9GHF9�=B=7=5@�8C�7IFGC�89��FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC

�A�@=B<5G�;9F5=G�5G�DF\H=75G�8=G7=D@=B5F9G�8C�7IFGC�7CBGHFC9A�G9�9A�HFdG�=BGH^B7=5G�

�� )6G9FJ5b`C�9�7CBGHFIb`C�8C�DFC6@9A5�89�DFC>9HC

� �B\@=G9�9�7CB<97=A9BHC�89�DFC>9HCG�F9:9F9B7=5=G

�� �L9F7e7=CG�89�DFC>9HCG�9�DFCDCG=bi9G

�GHFIHIF5�85G�8=G7=D@=B5G�89�DF=A9=FC�D9FeC8C � ����5@IBCG�

A$�&I#�#

�U.318 "86/�.+��3<-39537+ �;R.

�,+����� #BHFC8Ib`C�Z�*FC:=GG`C�89��FEI=H9HC

�,+����� #BHFC8Ib`C�5C�*FC>9HC �

�,.��� � �9G9B<C�89 )6G9FJ5b`C�# �

�,.��� � �I@HIF5�'C89FB5�9��CBH9ADCF^B95 �

�,������ )�"IA5BC�9�C� 9BhA9BC�,9@=;=CGC �

'�.����� '5H9A\H=75�8C��GD5bC�9�85G CFA5G

)�$�.#0)�����#-�#*&#(�

�� 8=G7=D@=B5� HF5H5� 8C� 7CBH9LHC� 5FEI=H9HhB=7C� 9� @=B;I5;9A� 5FEI=H9HhB=75� �G75@5�

DFCDCFb`C�� 9@9A9BHCG� 5FEI=H9HhB=7CG� 9� 5B\@=G9G� ;F\:=75G� 0C@IA9G� 9� AC89@C

HF=8=A9BG=CB5@� �CADCG=b`C� 9� =BH9Bb`C� ,9:9F9B7=5=G� 5FEI=H9HhB=7CG� #BHFC8Ib`C� Z

DF\H=75�89�DFC>9HC

�#-�#*&#(��.,�.����(��.�-�

Page 248: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 216

�-.,/./,������#-�#*&#(�

��8=G7=D@=B5� G9�89G9BJC@J9�9A� � �8I5G�� H5F89G�DCF G9A5B5�)G�9B7CBHFCG�C7CFF9A

85G���<�ZG���<����<CF5G��BC�HCH5@�89�� �<CF5G�G9A5B5=G

�CBH5 7CA�5�D5FH=7=D5b`C�89�DFC:9GGCF9G�9�ACB=HCF9G � �CI���

*,) �--),�- $5+7/4+6/7=8�/��/</7?85?36/7=8� 9FB5B8C��9H=A�� 9FB5B8C��GDgG=HC��&9=@5��95HF=N�-=@J9=F5��,5I@ -A=H<

&/9;/</7=+QO8�!@5I7=5 �I;IGHC� CBG975��"9BB=B;*jD9@� &I7=5BC �@J5F9G9-=@J=C��=5G

(/8;3+��3<=U;3+��B5�*5I@5�*C@=NNC�8708;=8��6,3/7=+5�15@H9F�.9=L9=F5

-ID9FJ=GCF5��&9=@5��95HF=N -=@J9=F5 P��������ZG�������P��������ZG������

=;IF5��� � *FC:9GGCF9G 89�,9DF9G9BH5b`C!@5I7=5��I;IGHC� CBG975��"9BB=B;*jD9@��&I7=5BC��@J5F9G 9�-=@J=C��=5G CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

=;IF5������*FC:9GGCF9G 89�*@5B9>5A9BHC�9��9G9BJC@J=A9BHC 9FB5B8C��9H=A�� 9FB5B8C��GDgG=HC��&9=@5��95HF=N�-=@J9=F5��,5I@�-A=H< CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

=;IF5������*FC:9GGCF9G�89 .9CF=5"=GHgF=5�9��CB:CFHC��A6=9BH5@�B5�*5I@5�*C@=NNC 9 15@H9F�.9=L9=F5 CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

O 216

�-.,/./,������#-�#*&#(�

��8=G7=D@=B5� G9�89G9BJC@J9�9A� � �8I5G�� H5F89G�DCF G9A5B5�)G�9B7CBHFCG�C7CFF9A

85G���<�ZG���<����<CF5G��BC�HCH5@�89�� �<CF5G�G9A5B5=G

�CBH5 7CA�5�D5FH=7=D5b`C�89�DFC:9GGCF9G�9�ACB=HCF9G � �CI���

*,) �--),�- $5+7/4+6/7=8�/��/</7?85?36/7=8� 9FB5B8C��9H=A�� 9FB5B8C��GDgG=HC��&9=@5��95HF=N�-=@J9=F5��,5I@ -A=H<

&/9;/</7=+QO8�!@5I7=5 �I;IGHC� CBG975��"9BB=B;*jD9@� &I7=5BC �@J5F9G9-=@J=C��=5G

(/8;3+��3<=U;3+��B5�*5I@5�*C@=NNC�8708;=8��6,3/7=+5�15@H9F�.9=L9=F5

-ID9FJ=GCF5��&9=@5��95HF=N -=@J9=F5 P��������ZG�������P��������ZG������

=;IF5��� � *FC:9GGCF9G 89�,9DF9G9BH5b`C!@5I7=5��I;IGHC� CBG975��"9BB=B;*jD9@��&I7=5BC��@J5F9G 9�-=@J=C��=5G CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

=;IF5������*FC:9GGCF9G 89�*@5B9>5A9BHC�9��9G9BJC@J=A9BHC 9FB5B8C��9H=A�� 9FB5B8C��GDgG=HC��&9=@5��95HF=N�-=@J9=F5��,5I@�-A=H< CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

=;IF5������*FC:9GGCF9G�89 .9CF=5"=GHgF=5�9��CB:CFHC��A6=9BH5@�B5�*5I@5�*C@=NNC 9 15@H9F�.9=L9=F5 CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

O 216

�-.,/./,������#-�#*&#(�

��8=G7=D@=B5� G9�89G9BJC@J9�9A� � �8I5G�� H5F89G�DCF G9A5B5�)G�9B7CBHFCG�C7CFF9A

85G���<�ZG���<����<CF5G��BC�HCH5@�89�� �<CF5G�G9A5B5=G

�CBH5 7CA�5�D5FH=7=D5b`C�89�DFC:9GGCF9G�9�ACB=HCF9G � �CI���

*,) �--),�- $5+7/4+6/7=8�/��/</7?85?36/7=8� 9FB5B8C��9H=A�� 9FB5B8C��GDgG=HC��&9=@5��95HF=N�-=@J9=F5��,5I@ -A=H<

&/9;/</7=+QO8�!@5I7=5 �I;IGHC� CBG975��"9BB=B;*jD9@� &I7=5BC �@J5F9G9-=@J=C��=5G

(/8;3+��3<=U;3+��B5�*5I@5�*C@=NNC�8708;=8��6,3/7=+5�15@H9F�.9=L9=F5

-ID9FJ=GCF5��&9=@5��95HF=N -=@J9=F5 P��������ZG�������P��������ZG������

=;IF5��� � *FC:9GGCF9G 89�,9DF9G9BH5b`C!@5I7=5��I;IGHC� CBG975��"9BB=B;*jD9@��&I7=5BC��@J5F9G 9�-=@J=C��=5G CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

=;IF5������*FC:9GGCF9G 89�*@5B9>5A9BHC�9��9G9BJC@J=A9BHC 9FB5B8C��9H=A�� 9FB5B8C��GDgG=HC��&9=@5��95HF=N�-=@J9=F5��,5I@�-A=H< CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

=;IF5������*FC:9GGCF9G�89 .9CF=5"=GHgF=5�9��CB:CFHC��A6=9BH5@�B5�*5I@5�*C@=NNC 9 15@H9F�.9=L9=F5 CBH9��<HHD�KKK75IDI7�F=C6F<CA9 9A����� ��

Page 249: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 217

��8=G7=D@=B5�56CF85�5�=BHFC8Ib`C�5�DF5H=75�89�DFC>9HC��H9A�7CAC C6>9H=JC�DFCACJ9F

Z =BH9;F5b`C8C� 5@IBC� BC� 5A6=9BH9� 85 5FEI=H9HIF5�� DFCDCB8C� IA5� GcF=9� 89

9L9F7e7=CG�DF\H=7CG�9�9LD9F=A9BH5=G�EI9�G9FJ=F`C�89�GIDCFH9�D5F5�C�5DF9B8=N58C�89

7CB<97=A9BHCG� 6\G=7CG� B979GG\F=CG� 5� DF\H=75� DFC>9HI5@� -`C 5DCFH585G� 9

89G9BJC@J=85G� EI9GHi9G� F9@5H=J5G� Z� 7CB79=HI5b`C�� =BH9F:9FdB7=5G� 9� DFCDCG=bi9G� 89

C7ID5b`C� 8C� 9GD5bC�� 9G75@5G�� D9F79Db`C� 8C� 9GD5bC �@56CF5b`C� 89� AC89@CG� 9

F9DF9G9BH5b`C�;F\:=75��5HF5JcG�89�8=8\H=75 D5FH=7=D5H=J5�9�9LD9F=A9BH5@

�� 9A9BH5 7CBH9AD@5� C� 7CBH9LHC� 5FEI=H9HhB=7C� 9� @=B;I5;9A� 5FEI=H9HhB=75� �G75@5�

DFCDCFb`C�� 9@9A9BHCG� 5FEI=H9HhB=7CG� 9� 5B5@=G9G� ;F\:=75G H5A6cA� G`C� 56CF858CG

0C@IA9G� 9�AC89@CG� HF=8=A9BG=CB5=G A9F979A�IA� @I;5F� 89� 89GH5EI9� 9A� HC85G� 5G

9H5D5G� 85G� 5DFCL=A5bi9G �G� 7CADCG=bi9G� =BH9Bbi9G� DFC>9HI5=G� 9� 5G� F9:9F9B7=5=G

5FEI=H9HhB=75G G`C�HF5H585G�B5�8=G7=D@=B5 .F565@<5�G9�7CA�5�=BHFC8Ib`C�5�DF5H=75�89

DFC>9HC� 9� C� 9GHI8C� 85� :CFA5� 9� JC@IA9HF=5�� 5B\@=G9� 8C� 9GD5bC� 5FEI=H9HhB=7C�

CF;5B=N5b`C� 9� 9GHFIHIF5b`C� 8C� 9GD5bC� )� 9GHI8C� 85G� F9@5bi9G� 9GD57=5=G� 9

DFCDCFbi9G

)� DFC;F5A5� 89� *FC>9HCG� DFCDi9� IA5� A9HC8C@C;=5� =BH9;F585� D5F5� C� 9BG=BC� 89

�FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC��GG5�=BH9;F5b`C�c�5@75Bb585�D9@5�5GGC7=5b`C�89�A5HcF=5G

89� :IB85A9BH5b`C� 7CA� DF\H=75� DFC:=GG=CB5@� )� *FC;F5A5� 56CF85� 75ADCG� 89

5H=J=8589G�DFC:=GG=CB5=G�8C�5FEI=H9HC�IF65B=GH5��DFCACJ9B8C�8=G7IGG`C� =BH9;F585�9

56F5B;9BH9� 85G� 8=J9FG5G� EI9GHi9G� 9BJC@J=85G� B5� 9@56CF5b`C� 89� DFC>9HCG� 89

�FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC

#BHFC8Ib`C�5C�*FC>9HC�c 8=J=8=85�9A�� �HFdG� Ag8I@CG �7: 5B9LC�� � 7CA�9L9F7e7=CG�

D5@9GHF5G�9�J=G=H5G�89� �57CF8C�7CA�5�9JC@Ib`C�8C��IFGC�9�F97969 =BH9F:9FdB7=5�8CG

G9;I=BH9G� 7CBH9l8CG�� *@5B9>5A9BHC� 9� �9G9BJC@J=A9BHC�� ,9DF9G9BH5b`C�

/F65B=GAC�� .9CF=5"=GHgF=5�� -=GH9A5G� �GHFIHIF5=G�� .97BC@C;=5G� �@H9FB5H=J5G�

�F=5H=J=8589���9BHF9�CIHFCG

)G�5@IBCG�G`C�5J5@=58CG�89�57CF8C�7CA�GI5�D5FH=7=D5b`C�9A�G5@5�89�5I@5��EI5@=8589

8CG� 9L9F7e7=CG� DFCDCGHCG�� DF9GH9N5� BC� 7IADF=A9BHC� 8CG� A9GACG� 9� 5H9Bb`C� 5CG

Page 250: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 218

C6>9H=JCG� 9GD97e:=7CG� 85� 8=G7=D@=B5 .C8CG� CG� 9L9F7e7=CG� G`C� 5J5@=58CG�� H5BHC� CG

=B8=J=8I5=G�� EI5BHC� CG� F95@=N58CG� 9A� ;FIDC� �G� 5J5@=5bi9G� @9J5A� 9A� 7CBH5� B`C

5D9B5G�C� F9GI@H58C�8C�DFC8IHC� :=B5@��A5G�5�9JC@Ib`C�8C�DFC79GGC�89� HF565@<C��89

57CF8C� 7CA� CG� C6>9H=JCG� 9GH569@97=8CG� D5F5� 7585� 9L9F7e7=C �585� 9H5D5� 89J9� G9F

F9;=GHF585�� H5BHC� CG� C6>9HCG� HF=8=A9BG=CB5=G9A� HC8C� G9I� DFC79GGC� 89� 9@56CF5b`C�

7CAC�5G�D9b5G�;F\:=75G 89J9A�G9F 5B9L58CG BC�7589FBC�89�F9;=GHFC

��Ac8=5�:=B5@�c 7CADCGH5�D9@5�!���D9GC� ��9�D9@5�! ��D9GC��

�=6@=C;F5:=5�DF=B7=D5@�9�6=6@=C;F5:=5�6\G=75�5IL=@=5F���B9LC����

)�*,)�&�'������0�&#�,�*,)��--)-�-#(!/&�,�-

)� D@5BC� 89� 5I@5� c� IA5� :9FF5A9BH5 89 ;F5B89� =ADCFH^B7=5 D5F5� C� DFC:9GGCF� *CF

A9=C� 89@9�� C� 98I758CF� DC89� :5N9F� 5� DF9J=G`C� 8CG� 7CBH9l8CG� EI9� G9F`C� 858CG�� 5G

5H=J=8589G�EI9�G9F`C�89G9BJC@J=85G��CG�C6>9H=JCG�EI9�DF9H9B89�5@75Bb5F��9�5G�:CFA5G

89� 5J5@=5b`C �@9 9B75A=B<5� 5� IA� F9:9F9B7=5@� H9gF=7C EI9� F9lB9� 8=A9BGi9G

:=@CGg:=75G��DG=7C@g;=75G�9�GC7=5=G�7CA�F9D9F7IGGi9G�8=F9H5G�BC 7CBH9l8C�8C�EI9�G9

9BG=B5��DCF�EI9�G9�9BG=B5�9�5�A5B9=F5�89�9BG=B5F

��9LD9F=dB7=5�7CH=8=5B5�5DCBH5�EI9�5�7CB79Db`C�8C D@5B9>5A9BHC�H9A�D5GG58C�DCF

J\F=5G� AC8=:=75bi9G�� 9BH9B8=8C� 7CAC� =BGHFIA9BHC� C6F=;5HgF=C�� 89:=B=H=JC� 9

=B:@9LeJ9@

)F=;=B5@A9BH9�DFCDCGHC�DCF�65G9 8C�DFC>9HC�D985;g;=7C�=BGH=HI7=CB5@�EI9 8=B5A=N5

5G� 8=F9bi9G� 8C� 9BG=BC�� 5� 9EI=D9� 89� DFC:9GGCF9G� HF565@<57CB>IBH5A9BH9� 7CA� 5

GID9FJ=GCF5� 89� 7585� 8=G7=D@=B5� DFC>9HI5@�� 5� :=A� 89� @56CF5F� C� 89H5@<58C D@5BC� 89

7IFGC 85�8=G7=D@=B5� =BHFC8Ib`C�5C�DFC>9HC 89��FEI=H9HIF5�9�/F65B=GAC 85 */��,=C

�HF5JcG�89�IA5�DF9J=G`C�89�5H=J=8589G�J=B7I@585G�5C�D@5BC�89�9BG=BC�A5=G�5AD@C

89G9BJC@J=8C� 9A� 9H5D5G� G9EI9B7=5=G�� 9A� 7CBGCB^B7=5� 7CA� C6>9H=JCG� 9� 7CBH9l8CG

DF9J=GHCG� -9FJ=B8C D5F5� CF;5B=N5F� 5� =BH9Bb`C� 8CG DFC:9GGCF9G 9� C� AC8C� 89

Page 251: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 219

CD9F57=CB5@=N\�@5� �LDF9GG5�� 5=B85��5G�CDbi9G 8C DFC:9GGCF�8=5BH9�89� G9I� 7CBH9LHC

89�HF565@<C��EI9�=AD@=75�D9BG5F�G=AI@H5B95A9BH9�C�7CBH9l8C�9�CG�GI>9=HCG�7CA�CG

EI5=G�=BH9F5;9

+I9GHi9G� =AD@e7=H5G� 8C� ;FIDC� 89� DFC:9GGCF9G� 7CADFCA9H=8CG� 7CA� 5� 8=G7=D@=B5� 89

=BHFC8Ib`C�5C�DFC>9HC�7CB8IN9A�5�9@56CF5b`C�89�IA�FCH9=FC�EI9�6IG75 F9GDCGH5G

9A�5@;IBG�EI9GH=CB5A9BHCG �CAC�DCF�9L9AD@C��+I5@�c�5�BCGG5� H5F9:5�� �*CF�EI9

:5N9ACG89GH5� A5B9=F5 5C� 9BG=B5F�� )� EI9� c� 5� 5I@5�� 9GD5bC� 89� D5F79F=5� CI� 89

F9G=GHdB7=5�� �CAC� AC6=@=N5F� C� 5@IBC� D5F5� 5DF9B89F�� �CAC� J9F=:=75F� G9� C� 5@IBC

5DF9B89I�

)�D@5BC�DCGG=6=@=H5�5CG DFC:9GGCF9G��B5�A98=85�8C�DCGGeJ9@�9�8C�89G9>\J9@��A5BH9F�5

5FH=7I@5b`C�85�8=G7=D@=B5�7CAC�IA�HC8C�D9@5�F9@5b`C�7CA�C�D@5BC�89�9BG=BC�9�5=B85

F95@=N5F� IA5� 5IHC�5J5@=5b`C� 85� 5I@5� CI� IA5� 5J5@=5b`C� 7CCD9F5H=J5� D5F5� CF=9BH5F

897=Gi9G� :IHIF5G m :5HC�EI9�C7CFF9�5C� HcFA=BC�89�7585�D9FeC8C��GD97HCG�5�G9F9A

A5BH=8CG� CI� 5� F9:CFAI@5F� DC89A G9F� =89BH=:=758CG� 7CA� A5=G� G9;IF5Bb5

�569B8C89GH575F� EI9� C� D@5BC� 89� 5I@5� B`C� =AD@=75� C6F=;5HCF=5A9BH9� G9I

7IADF=A9BHC� Fe;=8C� )� 79B\F=C� 85� 5I@5� 9L=;9� D9FA5B9BH9� 5H=HI89� F9:@9L=J5� 8CG

DFC:9GGCF9G D5F5 F97F=5F� 9� F98=F97=CB5F� 5bi9G� G9ADF9� EI9� BCJCG� =BH9F9GG9G� 9

B979GG=8589G� =ADF9J=GH5G� GIF;=F9A�� C� EI9� B`C� G=;B=:=75� 89GDF9D5FC 8C79BH9�� A5G

7CAD9HdB7=5� D5F5� n5;=F� B5� IF;dB7=5� 9� 897=8=F� B5� =B79FH9N5o�� 7CAC� 9BG=B5

�*9FF9BCI8 �� ����

)� D@5BC�� 7CAC� F9GI@H58C� 8C� DFC79GGC� 89� D@5B9>5A9BHC�� D9FA=H9� 5C� DFC:9GGCF

8=GH5B7=5F�G9�89�GI5�DF\H=75��G=GH9A5H=N\�@5�9�HCFB5F�A5=G�7CBG7=9BH9G�5G�CDbi9G�D5F5

5�CF;5B=N5b`C�85�5I@5�)�D@5BC�8C7IA9BH5�5�9LD9F=dB7=5�9A�GI5G�=BH9Bbi9G�=B=7=5=G

9�D9FA=H9�C�F9HCFBC�5�9@5�5DgG�C�J=J=8C D5F5�GI5�5J5@=5b`C

*5F5� 5� 9:9H=J5b`C� 8C� D@5BC� 89� 5I@5� 85� 8=G7=D@=B5� =BHFC8Ib`C� 5C� DFC>9HC�� :C=

5DF9G9BH58C�� 89� :CFA5� DF97=G5� 9� CF;^B=75�� C� C6>9H=JC� 85� 5I@5�� C� 7CBH9l8C� 5� G9F

2Philippe Perrenoudé doutor em sociologia e antropologia e professor da Faculdade de Psicologia e de Ciências daEducação da Universidade de Genebra. Estudioso da evasão e das desigualdades na escola e especialista empráticas pedagógicas em instituições de ensino é diretor do Laboratório de Pesquisas sobre a Inovação na Formaçãoe na Educação (Life).

Page 252: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 220

89G9BJC@J=8C�� 5G� 5H=J=8589G� 9� 5� 5J5@=5b`C� �� 5J5@=5b`C� c� 9BH9B8=85� 7CAC� C

8=5;BgGH=7C� 85� 5DF9B8=N5;9A�9�9LD@=7=H5� 5bi9G�D5F5� 7CBH=BI=8589�CI� F9CF=9BH5b`C

8C�DFC79GGC�89�9BG=BC�(CGG5�A9HC8C@C;=5�G9�D5IH5�B5G�F9@5bi9G�9BHF9�=BH9Bbi9G�9

C� AC8C� 7CAC� CG� 5@IBCG� 5G� D9F7969A�� DC=G� ZG� J9N9G� G`C� B979GG\F=CG� D9EI9BCG

5>IGH9G�9A�EI5@EI9F�8CG�9@9A9BHCG�8C�D@5BC D5F5�IA5�6C5�7CB8Ib`C�85�5I@5

�� 9EI=D9� 89� DFC:9GGCF9G� 5� 8=G7=D@=B5� 89 =BHFC8Ib`C� 5C� DFC>9HC 57F98=H5� 9A IA

9BG=B5F� 7CBHeBIC� EI9� 6IG75 DFC7IF5F BCJ5A9BH9 7CBH9l8CG� �BG=B5ACG� DCFEI9

6IG75ACG��DCFEI9� =B85;5ACG��9�9BEI5BHC� =B85;5ACG .F565@<5ACG�7CA�C� =BHI=HC

89� 7CBGH5H5F�� 7CBGH5H5B8C�� DFCDCACG� =BH9FJ9Bbi9G�� =BH9FJ=B8C�� 98I75ACG� 9� BCG

98I75ACG� *9GEI=G5ACG� D5F5� 7CB<979F� C� EI9� 5=B85� 5C� 7CB<979ACG� 9� D5F5

7CAIB=75F�5G�BCJ5G 89G7C69FH5G

�� 7IF=CG=8589� 7CAC� =BEI=9H5b`C� =B85;58CF5�� 7CAC�DFC7IF5�89 9G7@5F97=A9BHCG G9

HCFB5�IA5�6lGGC@5�9A�BCGG5A9HC8C@C;=5�89�9BG=BC�(`C�<5J9F=5�7F=5H=J=8589�G9A�5

7IF=CG=8589� EI9� BCG� ACJ9� 9� EI9� BCG� Di9� D5F7=5@A9BH9� 9:9FJ9G79BH9G� 8=5BH9� 8C

AIB8C�EI9�B`C�:=N9ACG��57F9G79BH5B8C�5�9@9�5@;C�EI9�:5N9ACG

,).�#,)��R-#�)�*�,��*&�()�����/&��7:�5B9LC���

/G5B8C�5�A9HC8C@C;=5�89�:57=@=H5b`C�89�IA�9BH9B8=A9BHC�A5=G�8=8\H=7C��CDH5ACG

DCF�89ACBGHF5F� 5G�DFCDCG=bi9G�8C� 7IFGC�� 5HF5JcG�89�5H=J=8589G�9� 9L9F7e7=CG� 9�B`C

DCF�7CBH9l8CG�89�5I@5G

�BG=B5F� 9L=;9� C� F97CB<97=A9BHC� 9� 5� 5GGIBb`C � C 5HC� 89� 5GGIA=F � 85� =89BH=8589

7I@HIF5@��CI�G9>5��IA5�85G�H5F9:5G�A5=G�=ADCFH5BH9G�85�DF\H=75�98I75H=J5�c�DFCD=7=5F

5G�7CB8=bi9G�9A�EI9�CG�5@IBCG�9A�GI5G�F9@5bi9G�IBG�7CA�CG�CIHFCG�9�HC8CG�7CA�C

DFC:9GGCF� CI� 7CA� CG� DFC:9GGCF9G� 9BG5=5A� 5 9LD9F=dB7=5� DFC:IB85� 89� 5GGIA=F�G9

�GGIA=F�G9� 7CAC� IA� G9F� GC7=5@�� 7CAC� IA� G9F� D9BG5BH9�� 7CAIB=75BH9�� 7F=58CF�

HF5BG:CFA58CF�9�F95@=N58CF�89�GCB<CG

Page 253: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 221

�2*�,#'�(.�VT)��#�.,# �#'�(-#)(�&

(�#&�� $&B(���

�I@5���

�I@5�=B5I;IF5@*5@9GHF5��� DFCDgG=HC�5FEI=H9HIF5

�@/;-S-38�� �C6F58IF5G�9�F9;=GHFC;F\:=7C �I@5���

�I@5 �

�I@5�H9gF=75���GHFIHIF5�!F\:=75*5@9GHF5���CBH9LHC�<=GHgF=7C��9BHFC

8C�,=C

�@/;-S-38���*9FGD97H=J5=A5;9BGCF=9BH5b`CF9;=GHFCG �I@5 �

�I@5 �� 0=G=H5�5C��9BHFC 0=G=H5�5C�79BHFC �I@5 ��

�@/;-S-38���'5D5�8C��9BHFC �I@5 ��

�@/;-S-38� � -C@5F�!F5B8>95B �I@5 ��

�I@5 ��

�I@5�H9gF=75��.F5b58CGF9;I@58CF9GG9b`C�\IF95

�I@5�H9gF=75��'CBH5;9A�8C�-C@5F�L9F7e7=C�����-C@5F�!F5B8>95B1CF?G<CD�5FH9G�D@\GH=75G �I@5 ��

�I@5 ���I@5�H9gF=75��.F5BG:CFA5b`C�85�:CFA5 �L9F7e7=C�����-C@5F�!F5B8>95B

�I@5 ��

�I@5 �� �I@5�H9gF=75��)F;5B=N5b`C�L9F7e7=C�����-C@5F�!F5B8>95B1CF?G<CD�5FH9G�D@\GH=75G �I@5 ��

�I@5 �� �I@5�H9gF=75� �=F7I@5b`C �L9F7e7=C�����-C@5F�!F5B8>95B �I@5 ��

-9A=B\F=C��<=B;��5DF9G9BH5b`C�8CGHF565@<CG�@/;-S-38��� �CADCG=b`C�'C8I@5F

�I@5���

�I@5 �� �I@5�H9gF=75��'C8I@5b`C �L9F7e7=C������CADCG=b`C�'C8I@5F �I@5 ��

�L9F7e7=C���� �CADCG=b`C�'C8I@5F �I@5��

�L9F7e7=C������CADCG=b`C�'C8I@5F �I@5 ��

�L9F7e7=C������CADCG=b`C�'C8I@5F �I@5 ��

�L9F7e7=C������CADCG=b`C�'C8I@5F �I@5 ��

�L9F7e7=C������LD9F=A9BH5b`C0C@IAcHF=75 �I@5 ��

�@/;-S-38��� �LD9F=A9BH5b`C0C@IAcHF=75 �I@5 ��

�I@5 ���I@5�H9gF=75���B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �@/;-S-38��� �B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �I@5 ��

�L9F7e7=C������B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �I@5 ��

�L9F7e7=C������B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �I@5 �

�L9F7e7=C �����B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �I@5 �

�L9F7e7=C������B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �I@5

�I@5 ��I@5�H9gF=75���B\@=G9�8C�H9FF9BC �@/;-S-38��� *FC>9HC�����/ �I@5 �

�L9F7e7=C�����*FC>9HC�����/1CF?G<CD�5FH9G�D@\GH=75G �I@5 �

�L9F7e7=C���� *FC>9HC�����/ �I@5 �

�I@5 � �I@5�H9gF=75���CB:CFHC��A6=9BH5@�L9F7e7=C�����*FC>9HC�����/1CF?G<CD�5FH9G�D@\GH=75G �I@5 �

�L9F7e7=C�����*FC>9HC�����/ �I@5 �

�I@5 � �I@5�H9gF=75��'5H9F=5=G�89�'5EI9H9 �L9F7e7=C�����*FC>9HC�����/ �I@5 �

�I@5 �

�I@5�H9gF=75���DF9G9BH5b`C��9G9B<C89��FEI=H9HIF5 �L9F7e7=C�����*FC>9HC�����/ �I@5 �

�L9F7e7=C�����*FC>9HC�����/ �I@5 ��

�DF9G9BH5b`C�*FC>9HC�����/

!

J

)

#

!

J

)

#

!

J

)

#

Page 254: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 222

��A5B9=F5�58CH585�89�5DF9G9BH5F�5�A9HC8C@C;=5�IH=@=N585�D9@CG�DFC:9GGCF9G�85 8=G7=D@=B5�89

#BHFC8Ib`C�5C�*FC>9HC�85�*/�� ,=C�C7CFF9F\�D9@5�8=J=G`C�8CG�HFdG�Ag8I@CG�9�D9@5�GI68=J=G`C

8CG�9L9F7e7=CG

'Y�/&)��

���DF9G9BH5b`C�8C�7CBH9l8CDFC;F5A\H=7C�9�8CG�C6>9H=JCG�8C�7IFGC

��I@5���GHFIHIF5�!F\:=75��L9F7e7=C�*9FGD97H=J5G��=A5;9BG*5@9GHF5���9BHFC�8C�,=C

��0=G=H5�5C��9BHFC�8C�,=C

���L9F7e7=C��'5D5�8C��9BHFC

���L9F7e7=C��-C@5F �@5Bb5A9BHC�

���I@5��.F5b58CG�F9;I@58CF9G��G9b`C\IF95��L9F7e7=C��-C@5F �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

���I@5��.F5BG:CFA5b`C�85� CFA5 �

�<=B;��L9F7e7=C��-C@5F �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

���I@5��)F;5B=N5b`C � ��<=B;�

�L9F7e7=C��-C@5F �:=B5@=N5b`C�

���I@5���=F7I@5b`C � ��<=B;� �L9F7e7=C��GC@5F�9BHF9;5�

'Y�/&)�

���-9A=B\F=C��<=B;��L9F7e7=C�

�CADCG=b`C�AC8I@5F �@5Bb5A9BHC�

����I@5��'C8I@5b`C��L9F7e7=C�

�CADCG=b`C�AC8I@5F �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

� ��L9F7e7=C���CADCG=b`C�AC8I@5F�89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

���*CBHC�89�G=HI5b`C m �P�J5@=5b`C

����L9F7e7=C���CADCG=b`C�AC8I@5F�:=B5@=N5b`C�

����5B75�9BHF9;5�8C�9L9F7e7=C�

�CADCG=b`C�AC8I@5F � �0�&#�VT)� #(�&

!J�) #��

����L9F7e7=C���LD9F=A9BH5bi9G

����L9F7e7=C���LD9F=A9BH5bi9G

����I@5���B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75��DF9G9BH5b`C�8CG

9L9AD@CG

����L9F7e7=C���B5@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

���L9F7e7=C���B5@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

���L9F7e7=C���B5@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75 �:=B5@=N5b`C�

��5B75�5DF9G9BH5b`C�8C�9L9F7e7=C�89��B\@=G9

�FEI=H9HhB=75

���I@5���B\@=G9�8C�H9FF9BC

�L9F7e7=C��*FC>9HC�����/�0=G=H5�5C�H9FF9BC

���L9F7e7=C��*FC>9HC�����/ �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

�B\@=G9�8C�H9FF9BC

���L9F7e7=C��*FC>9HC�����/ �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

�LD9F=A9BH5bi9G

���I@5���CB:CFHC��A6=9BH5@��L9F7e7=C��*FC>9HC

����/ �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

� *CBHC�89�G=HI5b`C m �P��J5@=5b`C

���L9F7e7=C��*FC>9HC�����/ �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

�I@5��'5H9F=5=G�A5EI9H9G

���L9F7e7=C��*FC>9HC�����/ �89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

�I@5���9G9B<C�895FEI=H9HIF5

����L9F7e7=C��*FC>9HC�����/ �:=B5@=N5b`C�

����5B75�5DF9G9BH5b`C�8C�DFC>9HC�����/ m

�0�&#�VT)� #(�&�!

�@/;-S-38�� �C6F58IF5G�9�F9;=GHFC

�@/;-S-38���*9FGD97H=J5=A5;9BGCF=9BH5b`CF9;=GHFCG

�@/;-S-38��� '5D5�8C��9BHFC

�@/;-S-38� � -C@5F�!F5B8>95B

�@/;-S-38��� �CADCG=b`C�'C8I@5F

-9A=B\F=C �<=B;

�@/;-S-38��� �LD9F=A9BH5b`C�0C@IAcHF=75

�@/;-S-38��� �B\@=G9�5FEI=H9HhB=75

�@/;-S-38��� *FC>9HC�����/

Page 255: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 223

��-�(0)&0#'�(.)�'Y�/&)���

�) ��

�8+<�?37.+<�1/;+3<�+8<�+5>78<�

*5F5�CG�BCJCG�5@IBCG��5�57C@<=85�9A�G5@5�89�5I@5�c�IA5�GIFDF9G5��IA5�J9N�EI9�BC

HIFBC�5BH9F=CF�D5FH=7=D5A�89�IA5�D5@9GHF5�D5F5�HC8CG�CG�7IFGCG�85�IB=J9FG=8589��9A

9J9BHC�BC 5I8=HgF=C�79BHF5@�BC�D9FeC8C�A5HIH=BC��57C@<=85�7CBH=BICI�9A�G5@5�89

5I@5� 7CA�IA�;9GHC� 89�5A56=@=8589��DFCD=7=58C� D9@CG� 8C79BH9G� �)G BCJCG� 5@IBCG

G`C� F9796=8CG� 9A� IA5� 7CB:F5H9FB=N5b`C� 5CB89� CG� DFC:9GGCF9G� 7CB:977=CB5A

A5BI5@A9BH9�5G�9A65@5;9BG�8CG�5@=A9BHCG�EI9�:=75A�8=GDCGH5G�B5�A9G5

!8.>58����9;/</7=+QO8�.8�-87=/W.8

9;81;+6K=3-8�/�.8<�8,4/=3?8<�.8�->;<8 ��I@5���GHFIHIF5�!F\:=75��L9F7e7=C�

*9FGD97H=J5G��=A5;9BG*5@9GHF5���9BHFC�8C�,=C

��0=G=H5�5C��9BHFC�8C�,=C���L9F7e7=C��'5D5�8C��9BHFC

� �L9F7e7=C��-C@5F��@5Bb5A9BHC����I@5��.F5b58CG�F9;I@58CF9G�

G9b`C�\IF95��L9F7e7=C��-C@5F�89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

���I@5��.F5BG:CFA5b`C�85� CFA5� ��<=B;���L9F7e7=C��-C@5F��89G9BJC@J=A9BHC�

���I@5��)F;5B=N5b`C�� ��<=B;��L9F7e7=C��-C@5F��:=B5@=N5b`C�

���I@5���=F7I@5b`C�� ��<=B;���L9F7e7=C��GC@5F��9BHF9;5

=;IF5������-5@5 89�5I@5��F979Db`C�8CG�BCJCG�9GHI85BH9G CBH9�� CHCG�&9=@5��95HF=5N

.�),#�

�>5+�37+>1>;+5(duração 2h)

$+5/<=;+� �� 9;89U<3=8

+;:>3=/=>;+(duração 2h)

*,R.#��

�@/;-S-38<�+���8,;+.>;+<(duração 1h)

�@/;-S-38 ,� &/13<=;8�1;K03-8(duração 1h)

=;IF5 ���� *F9D5FC�89�7CA=85G� F979Db`C�8CG�BCJCG�9GHI85BH9G CBH9�� CHCG�&9=@5��95HF=5N

�) �� ����9;/</7=+QO8�.8�-87=/W.8 9;81;+6K=3-8�/�.8<�8,4/=3?8<�.8�->;<8

Page 256: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 224

�9;/</7=+QV/< .8<�9;80/<<8;/<��+5>78<�/ 9+78;+6+�1/;+5�.8�->;<8

)� C6>9H=JC c� 5DF9G9BH5F� 5� 8=G7=D@=B5� 9� G9IG� DFC:9GGCF9G� BIA� 7@=A5� A5=G

89G7CBHF5e8C�� DF9D5F5F� 5� HIFA5� D5F5� IA� F9@57=CB5A9BHC� A5=G� :5JCF\J9@� 9

D5FH=7=D5H=JC�G7@5F979F� C� 7CBH9l8C� 85� 8=G7=D@=B5�� GI5� 8=B^A=75� 89� 5I@5G� 9

5J5@=5bi9G +I96F5F� D9F79Dbi9G�� 5DF=CF=GH=75A9BH9� DF97CB79=HICG5G� 9A� F9@5b`C� Z

8=G7=D@=B5� 9� 5C� 7IFGC� 89� 5FEI=H9HIF5�LDF9GG5F� 9LD97H5H=J5G� CI� DFC6@9A5G� EI9

5:9H5A�C�7@=A5�8C�;FIDC�9 C�89G9AD9B<C�8CG�G9IG�A9A6FCG

)G DFC:9GGCF9G G9� 5DF9G9BH5A� 5CG� 5@IBCG� 9LDi9A� G9I D9EI9BC

7IFFe7I@C*CGH9F=CFA9BH9� 6IG75ACG� 7CB<979F F5D=85A9BH9� IA� <=GHgF=7C� ;9F5@ 89

7585�5@IBC �DCFEI9�5�9G7C@<5�8C� 7IFGC�� :5A=@=5F9G� 5FEI=H9HCG�� =B79BH=JC�89�CIHFCG

7C@9;5G�� F9:9FdB7=5G� 8C� 7IFGC� 85� */��� 9H7� /A� D5BCF5A5� ;9F5@� 8C� 7IFGC� 9� 85

8=G7=D@=B5� 89� DFC>9HC� G`C� 9LDCGHCG�� 9B:5H=N5B8C� 5G� A5HcF=5G� DF=B7=D5=G� 9� @=B<5G

9GHFIHIF5=G�8C�7IFGC

.��()&)!#�����,.�-�����-#!(���"#-.Y,#����������*,)$�.)��-eBH9G9� 9GD=B<5�8CFG5@

8C 7IFGC m =@CGC:=5�"IA5B=GH5

�5ADC�89�=BH9FJ9Bb`C m CG�9GD5bCG�BCG�EI5=G�C�<CA9A�J=J9

Page 257: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 225

$&B(��� � �37M63-+�-86�8<�+5>78<

��D=BHIF5�;9GHI5@�c�C�F9GI@H58C�89�AI=HC�9GHI8C��585�HF5bC�H9A�IA5�DCG=b`C��H9A

IA�;9GHC�9A�D5FH=7I@5F ��DFCDCG=b`C�c�IG5F�5�9LHF9A=8589�8C 898C�85�A`C�D5F5

:CFA5F� IA5� =A5;9A� � �C� D5GG5F� C� 898C� 75FF9;58C� 7CA� 5� H=BH5 C� 5@IBC� 89J9

7CBH=BI5F� C� ACJ=A9BHC� 5Hc� EI9� 5� H=BH5� 89� G9I� 898C� 57569 �CBH=BI5A9BH9� CG

89A5=G�5@IBCG�:5F`C�C�A9GAC�;9GHC� CFA5B8C�G9�IA�;F5B89�D5=B9@�89�5IHCF=5�8C

;FIDC�89�BCJ5HCG�5@IBCG

=;IF5 �����-5@5�89�5I@5��8=B^A=75�89�;FIDC CBH9�� CHCG�&9=@5��95HF=5N

�) �� ����9;/</7=+QO8�.8�-87=/W.8�9;81;+6K=3-8�/�.8< 8,4/=3?8<�.8�->;<8

=;IF5 ������5FH`C�8C��Q�D9FeC8C 89�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G CBH9� 89�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

Page 258: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 226

(�#&�� � �9;/</7=+QO8�.+�.3<-39537+��/6/7=+��6+=/;3+3<��,3,5381;+03+

(5�5DF9G9BH5b`C�85�8=G7=D@=B5�G`C�8=GHF=6Ie85G�5G�9A9BH5G�9�C�D@5BC�89�5I@5G� �@=8C

7CB>IBH5A9BH9�� )G DFC:9GGCF9G� 9LD@=75A� 5� 8=B^A=75� 85G� 5I@5G BC� 5H9@=d

�57CAD5B<5A9BHC���5J5@=5bi9G����=BH9FJ5@CG��DF9G9Bb5G��ACB=HCF9G��5J=GCG��G=H9

�=GDCB=6=@=N5ACG� IA� G=H9�� 5CB89� CG 5@IBCG� HdA� 579GGC� 5� HC8CG� CG� 7CBH9l8CG� 85G

5I@5G �<HHDG�G=H9G;CC;@97CAG=H95I@5GDI7�D9A9BH5���7:��B9LC����9 �B9LC���

*CGH9F=CFA9BH9� G`C GC@=7=H58CG CG� A5H9F=5=G 6\G=7CG� B979GG\F=CG� D5F5� 89G9B<C� 9

9@56CF5b`C� 89� AC89@CG� 6=� 9� HF=8=A9BG=CB5=G�@=GH5� DF=B7=D5@� �� @C75=G� 89� 7CADF5� �

89G9B<C�5FEI=H9HIF5� ,9EI=G=H5ACG�H5A6cA�IA 7589FBC�89�F9;=GHFCG��CB89�C�5@IBC

89DCG=H5F\� GI5G� =ADF9GGi9G� 5� F9GD9=HC� 89� G9I� 7CH=8=5BC �ACGHF5ACG� 5@;IBG

9L9AD@CG�

)G� 7589FBCG� G`C� ;F5B89G� 7CAD5B<9=FCG� 85EI9@9G� EI9� 89G9BJC@J9A�EI5@EI9F� H=DC

89� 5H=J=8589� 7F=5H=J5� � 8=J9FG=8589� 89� H9FACG� EI9� :5N9A� F9:9FdB7=5� 5� 9GG9G

D9EI9BCG� GIDCFH9G�� 7CAC� 7589FBCG� 89� J=5;9A�� 89� HF565@<C�� 89� 7F=5b`C�� 7589FBCG

;F\:=7CG�� 89� F9;=GHFC�� 89� 5FH=GH5�� 7589FBCG� 89� F5G7IB<CG� )� EI9� 75F57H9F=N5� IA

7589FBC�c�GI5�:IBb`C�89�GIDCFH9�D5F5�C�F9;=GHFC J9F65@�9CI�J=GI5@�89�=B:CFA5bi9G

�9� B5HIF9N5� =BHFCJ9FH=85�� 9� DCFH\H=@�� 89J9� G9F� 7CBG=89F58C� IA� GIDCFH9

D5F55BCH5bi9G�D5F5�CG�9GHI85BH9G�EI9�5C�9@56CF5F�G9IG�F9;=GHFCG�89ACBGHF55�5IHC�

CF;5B=N5b`C�89�GI5�D9FGCB5@=8589

=;IF5�������589FBC�89 F9;=GHFCG�9@56CF58C�D9@CG�5@IBCG�BC�897CFF9F�8C�7IFGC CBH9�� CHC�85�5IHCF5

�) �� ����9;/</7=+QO8�.8�-87=/W.8 9;81;+6K=3-8�/�.8<�8,4/=3?8<�.8�->;<8

Page 259: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 227

�9ACBGHF5ACG� 5CG� 5@IBCG EI9� 5� C6G9FJ5b`C� D5GG=J5� c� IA5� :9FF5A9BH5 DCH9BH9

D5F5�75DH5F�C�9GDeF=HC�IF65BC�9�5GG=A�D9F7969F�89�AC8CG�8=:9F9BH9G�C IB=J9FGC EI9

CG� FC89=5�9G9B<5F� DFCD=7=5� 5� D9F79Db`C� 89� DCGG=6=@=8589G� F9DF9G9BH5H=J5G� 8CG

C6>9HCG� 5� D5FH=F� 85� =BH9F5b`C� 7CA� C� IB=J9FGC� 85� =B:CFA5b`C� 89� EI9A� 89G9B<5

�DF=ACF5F� 5� <56=@=8589� 89� J9F� 9� F9DF9G9BH5F� C� 9GD5bC� 5GGIA9� IA5� :IBb`C

DF9DCB89F5BH9�BC�DFC79GGC��L9AD@=:=75�G9�7CA�IA5�79B5�8C�7CH=8=5BC��IH=@=N5B8C

7CAC�D9FGCB5;9A�IA�8CG�5IHCF9G�EI9�:IHIF5A9BH9�CG�5@IBCG�9GHI85F`C

=;IF5�� �� 'lG=7C�89G9B<58C�DCF� F5B?��<=B;�9A�G9I�7589FBC�89�F9;=GHFCG CBH9� CHC�!@5I7=5��I;IGHC� CBG975

�) �� ����9;/</7=+QO8�.8�-87=/W.8�9;81;+6K=3-8�/�.8<�8,4/=3?8<�.8�->;<8

Page 260: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 228

�DF9G9BH5ACG 5�6=6@=C;F5:=5 �@9J5ACG�CG�@=JFCG�9�:5@5ACG 89�7585�IA� -C@=7=H5ACG 5

7CADF5�8C�@=JFC �;:>3=/=>;+���8;6+���<9+Q8�/�#;./6 X �;+7-3<��������2371� 7CAC

F9:9FdB7=5�H9gF=75�D5F5�5�8=G7=D@=B5

)�@=JFC�G9�5DF9G9BH5�7CAC�5 =BHFC8Ib`C�7@\GG=75�5CG�DF=B7eD=CG�85�5FEI=H9HIF5��585

D\;=B5 A9H=7I@CG5A9BH9 9@56CF585� =B7CFDCF5F� 9L9AD@CG� 7CBH9ADCF^B9CG� 8CG

DF=B7eD=CG�89�:CFA5��9GD5bC�9�CF89A 9 IH=@=N5�IA JC756I@\F=C�:IB85A9BH5@ D5F5�CG

9GHI8=CGCG�85�5FEI=H9HIF5

�DgG�9GH5�9LDCG=b`C�9LD@=75ACG�89�F9;F5G�89 �0�&#�VT)�

D5FH=7=D5b`C� �� EI5@=8589� 8C� HF565@<C� �� DF9GH9N5� BC� 7IADF=A9BHC� 85G� H5F9:5G� 9

5H9Bb`C�5CG�C6>9H=JCG�8CG�9L9F7e7=CG

*CBHC�89�-=HI5b`C���5J5@=5b`C�=BH9FA98=\F=5

'c8=5�:=B5@�� �9L9F7e7=CG���5�����!�� ����9L9F7e7=CG���9�����! ��

��

=;IF5�� ���&=JFC�9� F5B?��<=B;�7CA�CG�7589FBCG�89�F9;=GHFCG�8CG�5@IBCG�8C�KCF?G<CD�B5��F;9BH=B5�9A� �� CBH9� CHC�85�5IHCF5

�) �� ����9;/</7=+QO8�.8�-87=/W.8�9;81;+6K=3-8�/�.8<�8,4/=3?8<�.8�->;<8

Page 261: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 229

TEMPLO DE CONCORD . GRÉCIA - 470

CASA SCHROEDERARQ. GERRIT RIETVELD 1925

TEORIA - $� �'(&�����$&#$J'�(#���&%)�(�()&� m *FC:9GGCF�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

�G@=89G�85�5I@5 � �B9LC����

�� D5@9GHF5� =B=7=5 IA5� 8=G7IGG`C� GC6F9� 5� 5FEI=H9HIF5� 89� :CFA5� G9BGeJ9@�ACGHF5B8C

5@;IBG� 5GD97HCG� 85� @g;=75� 9�D9BG5A9BHC� 5FEI=H9HhB=7C �DF9G9BH5� G9� 55FEI=H9HIF5

;9F5@A9BH9�7CB796=85��DFC>9H585��F95@=N585��7CBGHFIe85�9A�F9GDCGH5 5�IA�7CB>IBHC

89� 7CB8=bi9G� 9L=GH9BH9G� �GG5G� 7CB8=bi9G� DC89A� G9F� 89� B5HIF9N5� DIF5A9BH9

:IB7=CB5@� CI� DC89A� H5A6cA� F9:@9H=F�� 9A� ;F5IG� J5F=58CG�� 5� 5HACG:9F5� GC7=5@�

97CBhA=75�9�DC@eH=75�)�5HC�89�7F=5F�5FEI=H9HIF5 7CBGH=HI=�IA�DFC79GGC�89�F9GC@Ib`C

89�DFC6@9A5G�CI�DFC>9HC �G�=A5;9BG�9LDCGH5G�F9A9H9A�5CG�9GD5bCG�D9@5�gH=75�89

EI9A�<56=H5��D9@5�J=G`C�89�EI9A�5�DFC>9H5�9�D9@5�5DF97=5b`C�89�EI9A�5�Jd

�F=5b`C�� HF5BG:CFA5b`C�� A9AgF=5�� G98Ib`C�� 9GD5bC� 5HACG:9F55FEI=H9HIF5� c

=BJ9Bb`C

�FEI=H9HIF5 m @I;5F

)�5A6=9BH9�:eG=7C�7CA�75F57H9FeGH=75G�D5FH=7I@5F9G�CI�IH=@=N58C�D5F5�IA5�:=B5@=8589

D5FH=7I@5F

=;IF5�� ���FEI=H9HIF5 m @I;5F��5I@5���DFCDgG=HC���FEI=H9HIF5 CBH9� #A5;9BG�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

�) �� ���$+5/<=;+����$;89U<3=8���;:>3=/=>;+

Page 262: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 230

�FEI=H9HIF5 m 56F=;C

�@;C� GC6� C� EI5@� IA5� D9GGC5� 9GH\� DFCH9;=85� 85G� =BH9AD9F9G� 9� CIHF5G� 7CB8=bi9G

58J9FG5G

�FEI=H9HIF5 m ;9GHC

CFA5� 8C G9F� <IA5BC G9� 9LDF9GG5F� 5HF5JcG� 85G� A`CG� 9� 8C 7CFDC� �G� =BH9Bbi9G

DFC>9HI5=G�EI9�9LDF=A9A�IA5�8585�J=G`C�89�AIB8C�CI�IA�79FHC ��������

�FEI=H9HIF5 m e7CB9

n-9�5�F9H5�c�C�75A=B<C�A5=G�7IFHC�9BHF9�8C=G�DCBHCG��5�7IFJ5�c�C�EI9�:5N�C�7CB7F9HC6IG75F�C�=B:=B=HCo

��������������

ARQ. AURÉLIO MARTINEZ =;IF5�� ����FEI=H9HIF5 m 56F=;C� 5I@5���DFCDgG=HC���FEI=H9HIF5 CBH9� #A5;9BG�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

=;IF5 � ����FEI=H9HIF5 m ;9GHC��5I@5���DFCDgG=HC���FEI=H9HIF5 CBH9� #A5;9BG�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

=;IF5 � �� �FEI=H9HIF5 m e7CB9��5I@5���DFCDgG=HC���FEI=H9HIF5 CBH9�#A5;9BG�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

COBIJO

�) �� ���$+5/<=;+����$;89U<3=8���;:>3=/=>;+

Page 263: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 231

PLANETÁRIO CIDADE DAS ARTES E CIÊNCIASARQ. SANTIAGO CALATRAVA

�FEI=H9HIF5 m H97BC@C;=5

��H97BC@C;=5�CD9F5�B5 CF89A�85G�=89=5G� EI9�BC�75GC�8C�DFC79GGC�DFC>9HI5@��G9F=5�C

AC8CCI�C�AcHC8C�89�=895@=N5b`C�5GGC7=58C�Z�:=B5@=8589�89�DFC8Ib`C��IA�DFC79GGC

=BH9F5H=JC� 7CA� =B:@IdB7=5G� F97eDFC75G� �BJC@J9� DFC79GGCG� 569FHCG� 9� 8=B^A=7CG�� BC

EI5@� 5� Hc7B=75� 7CBGHFIH=J5� B`C� G9� HCFB5� A5=G� GIDCFH9�� A5G� GI6GH5B7=5� 85G

J9F8589=F5G�CDbi9G�DFC>9HI5=G

�FEI=H9HIF5�69@5��<5FAhB=75��9B:5H=N5B8C�5�5HACG:9F5�9GD57=5@ *9BG5A9BHCG�7@5FCG

9�F=;CFCGCG�5HF5JcG�89�IA5�8=A9BG`C�J9F8589=F5A9BH9�DCcH=75

*5=L`C�DCF�n��������������o �F=5F�5HACG:9F5GDF9G9Bb5�:CFH9�9�5H9ADCF5@

=;IF5�� �� �FEI=H9HIF5 m H97BC@C;=5��5I@5���DFCDgG=HC���FEI=H9HIF5 CBH9�#A5;9BG�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

=;IF5 � ����HACG:9F5�5H9ADCF5@���DFCDgG=HC���FEI=H9HIF5 CBH9�#A5;9BG�"9FA5BC� F9=H5G

���:=A�89�DFC>9H5F

98=:e7=CG�7CA�IA5

7CB9L`C�G9BGI5@�D5F5�5

J=85��89J9�G9�D9BG5F�9A

IA5 A5B9=F5�EI9�J5=

AI=HC�5@cA�85�:CFA5�9�85

7CBGHFIb`C�*9H9F�4IAH<CF

�) �� ���$+5/<=;+����$;89U<3=8���;:>3=/=>;+

Page 264: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 232

*,R.#�� -�@/;-S-38�+��.8,;+.>;+ �/6 � =+6+728<�

)�9L9F7e7=C�HF565@<5F�5�@g;=75�9GHFIHIF5@��5�DFCDCFb`C9G75@5�9�7CADCG=b`C�89JC@IA9G��L9F7=H5F�C�89G9B<C�9�5�C6G9FJ5b`C

,9GI@H58CG

'C89@C�HF=8=A9BG=CB5@��7CADCG=bi9G

�9G9B<C� *9FGD97H=J5

�CADCG=b`C��

�9G9B<C� 0=GH5�-ID9F=CF

�CADCG=b`C��

�9G9B<C� 0=GH5� FCBH5@

�CADCG=b`C��

�9G9B<C� 0=GH5� FCBH5@

�CADCG=b`C��

�9G9B<C� 0=GH5�&5H9F5@

�CADCG=b`C��

=;IF5�� ����L9F7e7=C�89�8C6F58IF5G CBH9� CHCG�85�5IHCF5

�� �� �A�IA5�:C@<5����89�D5D9@��5BGCB�:5N9F�5�G9;I=BH98=J=G`C�9�F97CFH5F�5G�D5FH9G�89A5F7585G

� � (5��P�*5FH9�:5N9F HFdG�8C6F5G��8=5;CB5=G��89�AC8C

5�7CBGH=HI=F�IA5�9GHFIHIF5�9GH\J9@

�� �� ,9D9H=F�CG�A9GACG�DFC798=A9BHCG�B5G�D5FH9G

F9GH5BH9G� �9��

�� �� �CA�5G�HFdG�9GHFIHIF5G�7CBGH=HI=F�HFdG

DCGG=6=@=8589G�89�7CADCG=b`C�GC6F9�CIHF5�:C@<5���

7C@C75B8C�IA5�:=;IF5�<IA5B5�D5F5�85F�9G75@5

�� �� ,9;=GHF5F�5G�7CADCG=bi9G�7CA�G9;I=BH9G�89G9B<CG�

J=GH5�@5H9F5@��J=GH5�GID9F=CF�9�@=JF9�C6G9FJ5b`C

)G�89G9B<CG�G`C�5B9L58CG�DCGH9F=CFA9BH99A�IA�7589FBC�89�F9;=GHFC�7589FBC�89F9;=GHFCG�EI9�c�IH=@=N58C�8IF5BH9�HC8C�C7IFGC

�) �� �� �@/;-S-38�+��.8,;+.>;+

�9G9B<C� 0=GH5 FCBH5@

�CADCG=b`C��

Page 265: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 233

TEORIA -�@/;-S-38��� ;/13<=;8< 1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./�8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

*5F5�5DF9B89F�5�89G9B<5F�9�85F�5C�89G9B<C�IA�IGC�9:9H=JC�7CAC�=BGHFIA9BHC�89

89G9B<C� c� =B8=GD9BG\J9@� 5� 5EI=G=b`C� 89� 79FH5G� <56=@=8589G� :IB85A9BH5=G� 7CAC

HF5b5F� @=B<5G� 9� 5D@=75F� HCBG �� Hc7B=75� DCFcA� 57CAD5B<5� CG 7CB<97=A9BHCG

D9F79DH=JCG�9A�EI9G9�89GH575A�IA�7CB>IBHC�89� Hc7B=75G�(5�9@56CF5b`C�89�7585

89G9B<C� 9GH\� 75@758C� DCF� IA� DFC79GGC� =BH9F5H=JC� 89� J=G`C�� =A5;=B5b`C 9

F9DF9G9BH5b`C� 85� =A5;9A� �G� =A5;9BG� 7F=585G� BC� D5D9@�� CG� 89G9B<CG� EI9

9ADF9;5ACG� D5F5� BCG� 7CAIB=75F� H5BHC� 7CA� BCGG5G� =89=5G� 7CAC� BCGG5G

D9F79Dbi9G�DF9B89F� 5� J9F� G=;B=:=75� AI=HC� A5=G EI9� C@<5F� G=AD@9GA9BH9� 7CA� CG

C@<CG�� c� B979GG\F=C� 9JC75F� HC8CG� CG� G9BH=8CG�75DeHI@C� 5BH9F=CF� EI9� DCGG5ACG

5@75Bb5F�7CA�C�C@<5F

��DFCDCG=b`C�c�5�9@56CF5b`C�89�7FCEI=G�7CB79=HI5=G EI9 F9J9@9A�5�9GGdB7=5 89�IA5

=89=5� 7CAD@9L5�� 7CAIB=75B8C� 89� :CFA5� 7@5F5� 9� 7CB7=G5� 85� =BH9Bb`C� 8C� 89G9B<C

*989�G9�IA 89G9B<C� F\D=8C�� GC@HC�9�569FHC�,9GG5@H5� G9�5 F5D=89N� =B9F9BH9�5�9GG9

H=DC� 89� 89G9B<C EI9 DF97=G5A9BH9� G9 7CBJ9FH9 9A� DC89FCGCG� =BGHFIA9BHCG� 89

=89=5G

)6>9H=JC

�� D5FH=F� 89� J=GI5@=N5bi9G� 89� =A5;9BG� DFC>9H585G� 9A� IA5� H9@5� CG� 5@IBCG� H9A� IA

H9ADC� DFc�89H9FA=B58C� D5F5� 9@56CF5F� 7585� 89G9B<C� ) 89G9B<C 89� C6G9FJ5b`C

75F57H9F=N5�G9�� 7CAC IA� =BGHFIA9BHC� 89� 7CB<97=A9BHC� �HF5JcG� 89� GI5

56F5B;dB7=5��89GD9FH5F��BCJCG�C@<5F9G�GC6F9�5�F95@=8589�C6G9FJ585

=;IF5 � ����L9AD@CG�89�5@IBCG�89G9B<5B8C CBH9� CHC�85�5IHCF5

�) �� ����@/;-S-38����;/13<=;8<�1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./�8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

Page 266: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 234

�L9AD@=:=75�G9 C�9LDCGHC�5DF9G9BH5B8C�7FCEI=G 89�5@;IBG�5FEI=H9HCG

,9BNC�*=5BC m *9BG5F�9�G=BH9H=N5F

�9G9B<CG� EI9� H9BH5A� F9D5GG5F� CG� 7FCEI=G� 85G� DF=A9=F5G� =89=5G�� 89� HCA585� 85G

DF=B7=D5=G� 897=Gi9G�� 7CBGHFI=B8C� 9A� DCI75G� @=B<5G� 8=5;F5A5G� G=AD@9G� 9� AI=HC

D985;g;=7CG� GC6F9� C� DFC79GGC� 89� 89G9B<C� 9� 5� 5FH=7I@5b`C� 8CG� 9@9A9BHCG

7CBGHFIH=JCG

.585C��B8C

�FCEI= 89� =89=5G� 9A� D@9B5� 9H5D5� 89 5>IGH9�� 9A� IA5� D9F:9=H5� <5FACB=5� 89�A`CG�

7CF5b`C� 9� 7cF96FC� �� B9@9GJ9ACG� 5� =B897=G`C�� C� HF5bC� 8C� @\D=G 7CB:=FA5B8C C

75A=B<C�9G7C@<=8C

=;IF5�������FCEI=G��,9BNC�*=5BC� '5F=9�.>=65CI��I@HIF5@��9BH9F�(9K��5@98CB=5 CBH9�(CIA95���9BHF9��I@HIF9@�$95B�'5F=9�.>=65CI

=;IF5�������FCEI=�.585C��B8C��#;F9>5�85�&IN CBH9�� /,/3/�'���'��B8C

�) �� ����@/;-S-38����;/13<=;8<�1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./�8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

Page 267: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 235

�@J5FC-=N5 � �F5A9G�BC�5F

�G6Cb5�C�DFC>9HC�5BH9G�EI9�H9FA=B9�89�7CADF99B8d�@C��5BH9G�EI9�@<9�C7CFF5�CIHF5

=89=5��C�@\D=G�C�;I=5

-H9J9B"C@@

-9IG 9GEI9A5G�=89C;F5A\H=7CG�9LD@=75A 5G�=89=5G�9�5G�J9F=:=75A�F5D=85A9BH9��G`C

IA ��� 5B5@g;=7C�EI9�57CAD5B<5 C�9GHI8C�8C�DFC>9HC

�<=B;

=;IF5��� � �FCEI=��@J5FC-=N5 CBH9� R@J5FC�-=N5 m -?9H7<9G�5H8=BB9F

=;IF5������-H9J9B�"C@@��'IG9I(9@GCB��H?=BG CBH9� <HHD�KKK5F7GD5797CA:95HIF9GGH9J9B�<C@@�5F7<=H97HGB9@GCB�5H?=BG�AIG9IA�C:�5FH�9A� ��� ���

CBH9�

<HHD�KKK5F7GD5797CA:95HIF9GGH9J9

B�<C@@�5F7<=H97HGB9@GCB�5H?=BG�AIG9IA�

C:�5FH

CBH9�

�) �� ����@/;-S-38��� ;/13<=;8<�1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./�8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

=;IF5����� �FCEI=� ��<=B;��-`C�'5F7C CBH9� <HHD�6@C;<5K5==98I75ADIGH5@?H5;:F5B7=G�7<=B;�9A����� ��

O 235

�@J5FC-=N5 � �F5A9G�BC�5F

�G6Cb5�C�DFC>9HC�5BH9G�EI9�H9FA=B9�89�7CADF99B8d�@C��5BH9G�EI9�@<9�C7CFF5�CIHF5

=89=5��C�@\D=G�C�;I=5

-H9J9B"C@@

-9IG 9GEI9A5G�=89C;F5A\H=7CG�9LD@=75A 5G�=89=5G�9�5G�J9F=:=75A�F5D=85A9BH9��G`C

IA ��� 5B5@g;=7C�EI9�57CAD5B<5 C�9GHI8C�8C�DFC>9HC

�<=B;

=;IF5��� � �FCEI=��@J5FC-=N5 CBH9� R@J5FC�-=N5 m -?9H7<9G�5H8=BB9F

=;IF5������-H9J9B�"C@@��'IG9I(9@GCB��H?=BG CBH9� <HHD�KKK5F7GD5797CA:95HIF9GGH9J9B�<C@@�5F7<=H97HGB9@GCB�5H?=BG�AIG9IA�C:�5FH�9A� ��� ���

CBH9�

<HHD�KKK5F7GD5797CA:95HIF9GGH9J9

B�<C@@�5F7<=H97HGB9@GCB�5H?=BG�AIG9IA�

C:�5FH

CBH9�

�) �� ����@/;-S-38��� ;/13<=;8<�1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./�8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

=;IF5����� �FCEI=� ��<=B;��-`C�'5F7C CBH9� <HHD�6@C;<5K5==98I75ADIGH5@?H5;:F5B7=G�7<=B;�9A����� ��

O 235

�@J5FC-=N5 � �F5A9G�BC�5F

�G6Cb5�C�DFC>9HC�5BH9G�EI9�H9FA=B9�89�7CADF99B8d�@C��5BH9G�EI9�@<9�C7CFF5�CIHF5

=89=5��C�@\D=G�C�;I=5

-H9J9B"C@@

-9IG 9GEI9A5G�=89C;F5A\H=7CG�9LD@=75A 5G�=89=5G�9�5G�J9F=:=75A�F5D=85A9BH9��G`C

IA ��� 5B5@g;=7C�EI9�57CAD5B<5 C�9GHI8C�8C�DFC>9HC

�<=B;

=;IF5��� � �FCEI=��@J5FC-=N5 CBH9� R@J5FC�-=N5 m -?9H7<9G�5H8=BB9F

=;IF5������-H9J9B�"C@@��'IG9I(9@GCB��H?=BG CBH9� <HHD�KKK5F7GD5797CA:95HIF9GGH9J9B�<C@@�5F7<=H97HGB9@GCB�5H?=BG�AIG9IA�C:�5FH�9A� ��� ���

CBH9�

<HHD�KKK5F7GD5797CA:95HIF9GGH9J9

B�<C@@�5F7<=H97HGB9@GCB�5H?=BG�AIG9IA�

C:�5FH

CBH9�

�) �� ����@/;-S-38��� ;/13<=;8<�1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./�8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

=;IF5����� �FCEI=� ��<=B;��-`C�'5F7C CBH9� <HHD�6@C;<5K5==98I75ADIGH5@?H5;:F5B7=G�7<=B;�9A����� ��

Page 268: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 236

�8;5F8C'=BCB8 � �9G7F9J9�5�G9BG=6=@=8589�8C�C@<C

.CA5�F5D=85A9BH9�C�=AD57HC�5FEI=H9HhB=7C�9�IF65BC�85G�=89=5G��7CA�IA5�9BCFA9

:57=@=8589�D5F5�HF5BGA=H=F�5G�G9BG5bi9G�:F9BH9�5�7585�9GD5bC

=;IF5 ���� �@56CF5b`C�89�7FCEI=�9A IA5ACJ=A9BH585�,I5�89��I9BCG��=F9G CBH9� CHC�85�5IHCF5

=;IF5 ���� *FC8IHC�:=B5@�89���A=BIHCG�89�HF565@<C1=@89F�!gA9N�.5=D9�89�&=A5���8;5F8C'=BCB8�85��F;9BH=B5�9� F5B?�<=B;���GH58CG�/B=8CG CBH9� CHC 85�5IHCF5

=;IF5�������FCEI=G�89 �8;5F8C'=BCB8� �5A=B=HC���I9BCG��=F9G CBH9� <HHD�KKKIF65BG?9H7<9FGCF; �����A999A����� ��

<HHD�KKKIF65BG?9H7<9FGCF; �����A99

CBH9�

CBH9� <HHD�KKK5F7GD5797CA:95HIF9GGH9J9B�<C@@�5F7<=H97HGB9@GCB�5H?=BG�

AIG9IA�C:�5FH

CBH9�

�) �� ����@/;-S-38����;/13<=;8<�1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./ 8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

Page 269: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 237

*,R.#�� � �2�,�X�#) �6�,9;=GHFC�!F\:=7C

n+I5@EI9F�IA�EI9�BIB75�H9B<5�7CA9H=8C�IA�9FFC�BIB75�H9BHCI�5@;C�BCJCo �@69FH��=GH9=B

�� D5FH9� DF\H=75� 8C 9L9F7e7=C� 89�ACBH5;9A� 9� 7CADCG=b`C� 89� =A5;9BG� 57CBH979� 5

D5FH=F� 89� DFC>9bi9G� 89� :CHC;F5:=5G� 5FEI=H9HhB=75G� B5G� EI5=G� CG� 5@IBCG� H9A 7=B7C

A=BIHCG�D5F5�89G9BJC@J9F�7FCEI=G�F\D=8CG�7585�C6F5

.F565@<5�G9 7CA 5G�G9;I=BH9G�C6F5G�

'CBIA9BHC�89�(9J9;�#GF59@�����������5B=�%5F5J5B�

.9AD@C�89��CB7CF8��#H\@=5�

-5@HNA5B�"CIG9� =@58c@:=5�������,=7<5F8�'9=9�

09B=79�"CIG9� �5@=:gFB=5� ���� �BHCB=9*F98C7?�

'IG9I�89��FH9 �CBH9ADCF^B95 89�(=H9Fg=��)G75F�(=9A9M9F

=;IF5�������9H5@<9�8CG�7FCEI=G�8CG���5FH=GH5G CBH9� CHC 85�5IHCF5

=;IF5����� �CBH9l8C�85 5I@5 8C *FC:9GGCF (CF69FHC��CF5BH9G�� �/�� CBH9� <HHD�H5@@9FD9FGD97H=J56@C;GDCH7CA6F�9A� �� ���

�) �� ����@/;-S-38����;/13<=;8<�1;K03-8< � ./</728<�./�8,</;?+QO8�;K93.8<

Page 270: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

O 238

,9GI@H58C� H9A� 5� =BH9Bb`C� 89� DFCD=7=5F� IA D@5BC� ;9F5@� 8CEI9 7585� 5@IBC DC89

89ACBGHF5F�BC�DF=A9=FC�8=5�89�5I@5��5DgG�5�9@56CF5b`C�8C�9L9F7e7=C�C�DFC8IHC�:=B5@

89G9B<58C�89J9�G9F�5FEI=J58C�9�5B9L58C�BC�7589FBC�89�F9;=GHFC

=;IF5 LL� CBH9

=;IF5 �����'CBIA9BHC�89�(9J9;�9�09B=79"CIG9 CBH9��F7<=H97HIF9(CK

#'�!�'�)�-�,0���'�(�#,�����')-.,�,)�,�!#-.,)

#'�!�',�*,�-�(.���,�*#��'�(.�

Page 271: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 239

DESENVOLVIMENTO MÓDULO 01

AULA 02

TEORIA - Palestra obra autoral – Através de revezamentos semestrais a equipe de

professores da disciplina de Introdução ao Projeto apresentam alguns de seus

projetos. O objetivo da aula é explicar a metodologia de trabalho utilizada na

execução do projeto ressaltando o raciocínio projetual e suas consequências na

solução final. A partir das estratégias mencionadas pelo professor na execução do

trabalho profissional o aluno pode ser iniciado numa forma de pensar a arquitetura.

Aula - Professor Arquiteto Luciano Alvares – Casa na Serra - Área: 162 m2

Tópicos abordados na apresentação Orientação, acesso/circulação, morfologia,

estrutura, materialidade, obra e maquete.

Na fachada, destacam-se dois materiais: a madeira plástica (Ecoblock) e telhas de

fibra vegetal (Onduline), que revestem a torre onde se localizam os banheiros.

Estrutura metálica, painéis de OSB, cimento queimado, ventilação cruzada,

Modulo 1 1. Apresentação do conteúdo

programático e dos objetivos do curso 2. Aula: Obras Autorais,

Estrutura Gráfica. Exercício: Malha 7 x 7 Palestra: Centro do Rio 3. Visita ao Centro do Rio

4. Exercício: Mapa do Centro 5. Exercício: Solar (lançamento) 6. Aula: Traçados reguladores /

seção áurea. Exercício: Solar (desenvolvimento)

7. Aula: Transformação da Forma (F. Ching) Exercício: Solar (desenvolvimento).

8. Aula: Organização (F. Ching) Exercício: Solar (finalização)

9. Aula: Circulação (F. Ching) Exercício: solar (entrega

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRA: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. , EXERCÍCIO: Malha 7x7

TEORIA

Palestra Obras Autorais (duração 1h)

+

Palestra: Estrutura Gráfica e

Recomendações para registro (duração 1h) +

Palestra Centro do Rio (duração 1h)

PRÁTICA

Exercícios 02: Malha 7 x 7 (duração 3h)

Page 272: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 240

aquecimento solar, reaproveitamento da água da chuva, estudo de insolação. A

casa se apresenta confortável, sustentável e de fácil manutenção.

Na fachada, destacam-se dois materiais: a madeira plástica (Ecoblock) e telhas de

fibra vegetal (Onduline), que revestem a torre onde se localizam os banheiros.

Estrutura metálica, painéis de OSB, cimento queimado, ventilação cruzada,

aquecimento solar, reaproveitamento da água da chuva, estudo de insolação. A

casa se apresenta confortável, sustentável e de fácil manutenção.

O objetivo desta apresentação é deixar o estudante mais próximo do universo da

arquitetura, adquirindo uma iniciação a novos vocabulários e visões mais específicas

a respeito do projeto de arquitetura. Tratamos assim de amenizar uma das

curiosidade dos estudantes de graduação, que involuntariamente, demonstram

curiosidade por saber quem é o professor que está a sua frente lhe ensinando

projeto. “Quais os projetos que ele desenvolveu?”; “Ele tem escritório?”; “Os

projetos dele são bons?”. Se falar das interrogações constantemente com a

pergunta chave dos estudantes. “Você trabalha ou só dá aula?” Considera-se

significativo, a questão de um professor de projeto ensinar ao estudante a prática

projetual concomitantemente com sua atividade na elaboração de projetos.

Figura 341: Projeto da Casa na Serra, Luciano alvares Fonte: Foto da autora

Page 273: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 241

TEORIA - Estrutura Gráfica (Anexo 8 - slides da aula)

Trabalhar a criação de unidades espaciais a partir de uma organização regulada por

um padrão ou campo em malha. Esse padrão estabelece um campo estável de

pontos e retas de referencia no espaço. As unidades espaciais criadas compartilham

essa relação comum. Observar a utilização deste tipo de organização

principalmente nos sistemas estruturais.

A aula apresenta alguns conceitos importantes para a elaboração de desenhos,

como por exemplo, a posição do desenho no suporte folha, enquadramento, linhas

fundamentais de desenho, assim como o ponto focal, perspectiva, linha do

horizonte e luz e sombra.

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO: Malha 7x7

Figura 342: Aula Estrutura Gráfica – Silvio Dias Fonte: https://sites.google.com/site/aulaspuc1p/ementa-1

Page 274: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 242

Trabalhar a criação de unidades espaciais a partir de uma organização regulada por

um padrão ou campo em malha. Esse padrão estabelece um campo estável de

pontos e retas de referencia no espaço. As unidades espaciais criadas compartilham

essa relação comum. Observar a utilização deste tipo de organização

principalmente nos sistemas estruturais.

PRÁTICA - EXERCÍCIO 02: MALHA 7 X 7

Apresenta se a turma conceitos básicos do conteúdo no qual desenvolverá o

exercício, no caso trata se das Malhas planas poligonais. Malha é um espaço aberto

entre nós de rede. No caso de os nós estarem situados num plano, como os nós se

interligam por segmentos de reta, os espaços abertos entre eles tomam a forma de

polígonos planos, cujos vértices são os próprios nós da malha. A teia de aranha é

um exemplo natural de malha plana com função-solução estrutural. As malhas

aleatórias são infinitas, já que um grupo de pontos em um plano define uma malha.

Se os pontos não estiverem contidos no mesmo plano, definirão uma rede espacial.

As malhas podem ser vistas a cada instante; seja num céu estrelado, numa calçada

de pedras, etc. As mais interessantes são as repetitivas, ou seja; as que seguem

regras de formação. Não sendo muito grande o número de malhas repetitivas.

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Figura 343: M.C.ESCHER - Pormenor de Metamorfose, xilogravura, 1939-40 e 1967-68 Fonte: ESCHER, 2008

Page 275: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 243

As malhas regulares são formadas por apenas um tipo de polígono regular, que

podem ser o triângulo regular, o hexágono regular e o quadrado.

1. A malha triangular é a mais densa de todas (maior número de vértices em uma

mesma área), o que pode ser avaliado considerando-se o somatório das áreas das

figuras em torno de um nó.

Figura 344: M.C.ESCHER – Fachada de escola, Hague. Holanda. Fonte:Ineke Ganzinotti, http://euler.slu.edu/escher/index.php/File:Den-Haag-gevel.jpg em 15/06/2013

Figura 345: Malhas regulares. Fonte: https://www.google.com/malhas+regulares&hl=pt-BR&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=PKi9UbzOIbKR7AaV7IDACw&ved=0CDEQsAQ&biw=1023&bih=15/06/2013

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Page 276: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 244

2. A malha hexagonal, utilizada pelas abelhas na construção das colméias, é a que

mais facilmente se adapta as formas curvas; sejam curvas planas ou espaciais. Um

só hexágono é menos estável que o quadrado, mas a malha hexagonal é quase tão

rígida quanto a de triângulos, com a vantagem de ser menos densa.

3. A malha quadrada é a que o homem mais utiliza em suas construções. O

quadrado não é muito estável, facilmente se deforma em um paralelogramo. Seu

uso é tão antigo que uma medida de área refere-se a "quadrados".

Construção da malha quadrada:

Figura 346: Construção da malha triangular Fonte: https://www.google.com/malhas+regulares&hl=pt-BR&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei= em 15/06/2013

Figura 347: Construção da malha hexagonal Fonte: https://www.google.com/malhas+regulares&hl=pt-BR&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei= em 15/06/2013

Figura 348: Construção da malha quadrada Fonte:www.mat.uel.br%252Fgeometrica%252Fphp%252Fimg%B167%3B253em 15/06/2013

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Page 277: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 245

A prática do exercício 02 se desenvolve em três etapas distintas:

1- Pela divisão de uma folha A4 em módulos de 7 x 7 cm utilizando-se desta malha

modular, promover cortes e dobras a fim de se construir uma composição

tridimensional da seguinte maneira:

Utilizando-se desta malha modular, promover cortes e dobras a fim de se construir

uma composição tridimensional.

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO: Malha 7x7

Figura 349: Desenho da malha quadrada 7 x 7 Fonte: Programa de aula 1º p arquitetura Puc Rio

Figura 350: Perspectiva gerada pela manipulação da malha quadrada Fonte: Programa de aula 1º p arquitetura Puc Rio

Page 278: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 246

2- Em uma segunda folha A4, construir uma nova malha com módulos 7x7 e sub

módulos 7 x 3,5 cm. Horizontal ou verticalmente (utilizar os mesmos procedimentos

iniciais).

3- Em uma terceira folha, utilizar três tipos de módulos: 7x7; 7x3,5; 3,5x3,5 para

compor outro volume modular:

Algumas recomendações se fazem necessárias neste exercício. Os módulos

solicitados devem estar evidenciados em cada composição, as dobras quando

existirem devem manter um ângulo de 90º, os módulos quando dobrados não

devem se sobrepor e o papel não deve ser desmembrado ou dissociado.

Assinalamos também a importância da inserção da escala humana.

Figura 351: Desenho da malha quadrada 7 x 7 e 7 x 3,5 Fonte: Programa de aula 1º p arquitetura Puc Rio

Figura 352: Desenho da malha quadrada 7 x 7 ; 7 x 3,5 e 3,5 x 3,5. Fonte: Programa de aula 1º p arquitetura Puc Rio

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Page 279: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 247

Cada professor acompanha o desenvolvimento dos trabalhos concentrando se em

um grupo de aproximadamente 20 alunos. As observações na maior parte das vezes

deverão ser feitas para o grupo como forma de atingir um maior número de alunos.

Solicita se a para cada etapa a elaboração de desenhos de vista superior e duas

vistas laterais. O produto registrado (foto + desenho) será inserido no caderno de

registro.

Figura 354: Caderno de registro exercício 02

Fonte: Foto da Autora

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Figura 353: Execução de modelos e desenhos das três variáveis do exercício Fonte: Foto da Autora

Page 280: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 248

TEORIA – Palestra: Centro do Rio de Janeiro

A palestra tem o propósito de prepara o aluno para a visita ao Centro do Rio que

ocorre na aula seguinte.

Situada entre morros e mares, repleta de mangues e brejos, a urbanização do Rio

de Janeiro sempre representou um grande desafio grandes dificuldades técnicas,

solucionadas pela engenharia e arquitetura por meio de construção de pontes,

execução de aterros, aberturas de túneis, e devastação de morros por inteiro. No

começo do século XX, começam, de fato, as grandes transformações no espaço

urbano do Rio com a construção do porto e da Avenida Beira-Mar, na área central

da cidade, grandes reformas urbanísticas marcam o período. Precursor de

construções arrojadas como o Museu de Arte Moderna (MAM) e o Edifício Gustavo

Capanema.

Mapa roteiro visita ao Centro do Rio de Janeiro

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Figura 355: Mapa do roteiro de visita ao centro Fonte: Programa de aula 1º p arquitetura Puc Rio

Page 281: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 249

Ponto 1 CASA FRANÇA-BRASIL

Casa França-Brasil (originalmente Praça do Comércio) – Grandjean de Montigny, 1819. Centro Cultural Banco do Brasil (originalmente Praça do Comércio) – Francisco Joaquim Bethencourt da Silva, 1880. Igreja de N. Sra. da Candelária – final séc. XVIII a final séc. XIX. Avenida Presidente Vargas – abertura 1944. Atravessar Arco do Teles (brigadeiro Alpoim) – meados séc. XVIII

01 CASA FRANÇA-BRASIL

02 CENTRO CULTURAL BANCO DO BRASIL

03 IGREJA CANDELÁRIA

05 ARCO DO TELLES

1

5

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Figura 356: Mapa do roteiro de visita ao centro Fonte: Programa de aula 1º p arquitetura Puc Rio

Ponto 2 PRAÇA XV (antigo Terreiro do Carmo) Paço Imperial – séc. XVIII Chafariz Mestre Valentim, 1789. Igreja N.Sra. do Carmo (Antiga Catedral) – 2ª. metade do séc. XVIII. Convento do Carmo (atual Faculdade Cândido Mendes) – 1619. Avenida Perimetral – anos 1970. Intervenções urbanas – anos 1990. Subir Primeiro de Março (antiga Rua Direita)

Ponto 3 PILOTIS DO PALÁCIO GUSTAVO CAPANEMA (esquina Rua Araújo Porto Alegre e Graça Aranha) Esplanada resultante do arrasamento do Morro do Castelo, início anos 1920. Quadras do “Plano Agache” – 1929 Edifício-sede do Ministério do Trabalho – Mário dos Santos Maia, 1938. Edifício-sede do Ministério da Fazenda – Luiz Moura, 1939. Seguir na Rua Araújo Porto Alegre até a Cinelândia

Ponto 4 CINELÂNDIA – PRAÇA MAHATMA GANDHI Edifício-sede ABI / Associação Brasileira de Imprensa Marcelo e Milton Roberto, 1938. Teatro Municipal – Francisco de Oliveira Passos, 1904. Biblioteca Nacional – Hector Pépin, 1905. Museu Nacional de Belas Artes (originalmente Escola de Belas Artes) Adolfo Morales de los Rios, 1906. Avenida Central (atual Avenida Rio Branco), abertura 1904-5. Obelisco – inauguração Avenida Central Chafariz do Monroe – Louis Sauvageau,1861 Descer Avenida Rio Branco entrar no Aterro (passarela MAM)

Ponto 5 ATERRO DO FLAMENGO Museu de Arte Moderna – Affonso Eduardo Reidy, 1963

Page 282: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 250

TEORIA – Recomendações para a visita ao Centro do Rio

Para fotografar a cidade deve se levar em conta alguns aspectos:

Enquadramento e Orientação

Enquadramento de fotos de edificações que tenham um alto gabarito e perspectiva

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Figura 357: visita ao centro - enquadramento fotográfico. Fonte: Aula Silvio Dias

Figura 358: visita ao centro - enquadramento alto gabarito. Fonte: Aula Silvio Dias

Page 283: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 251

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 02 – PALESTRAS: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica, Centro do Rio. EXERCÍCIO 02: Malha 7x7

Evitar planos muito fechados

Preferir planos grandes

Preferir diagonais e perspectivas

Ser também atento e criativo

Figura 359: visita ao centro – conjunto dicas fotográficas. Fonte: Aula Silvio Dias

Page 284: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 252

DESENVOLVIMENTO MÓDULO 01

AULA 03

TEORIA E PRÁTICA - Visita ao Centro do Rio – Na segunda semana de aula é agendada a aula-passeio (termo usado por Célestin

Freinet).

A proposta é olhar de outros modos, o que já tenha sido visto em outro momento,

com outras percepções.

Na aula anterior os professores orientam os alunos a realizarem determinadas

atividades prévias que se deve observar na visita.

Modulo 1

1. Apresentação do conteúdo programático e dos objetivos do curso

2. Aula: Obras Autorais, Estrutura Gráfica. Exercício: Malha 7 x 7

Palestra: Centro do Rio 3. Visita ao Centro do Rio

4. Exercício: Mapa do Centro 5. Exercício: Solar (lançamento) 6. Aula: Traçados reguladores /

seção áurea. Exercício: Solar (desenvolvimento)

7. Aula: Transformação da Forma (F. Ching) Exercício: Solar (desenvolvimento).

8. Aula: Organização (F. Ching) Exercício: Solar (finalização)

9. Aula: Circulação (F. Ching) Exercício: solar (entrega)

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 03 – VISITA AO CENTRO

TEORIA

Visita ao Centro do Rio (duração 6h)

PRÁTICA

Visita ao Centro do Rio (duração 6h)

Figura 360: Casa França Brasil ponto de encontro/ MAM registro ponto final da visita Fonte: Foto da autora

Page 285: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 253

Espera-se desenvolver o universo cultural e social do aluno, permitindo-lhe refletir e

observar criticamente, os aspectos funcionais de sua cidade. Contendo um caráter

específico percebe-se o estreitamento do relacionamento aluno/aluno e

aluno/professores em ambientes diferenciados da sala de aula na qual o aluno

estuda diariamente.

Solicita-se a organização de materiais significativos para conteúdos da aula

seguinte, no qual os grupos desenvolverão um painel.

No ponto de encontro inicial os alunos recebem maiores informações sobre a visita

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 03 – VISITA AO CENTRO

Figura 361: Histórico dos edifícios visitados no centro Fonte: Conteúdo da aula 1º p.

Figura 362: Alunos nos edifícios visitados no centro Fonte: Foto da autora

Page 286: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 254

Desenhos textos e fotos fazem parte do material registrado pelos alunos

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 03 – VISITA AO CENTRO

Figura 363: Produto produzido por alunos na visita ao centro Fonte: Foto da autora

Page 287: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 255

DESENVOLVIMENTO MÓDULO 01

AULA 04

Exercício 04 : Mapa do Centro do Rio+ Discussão dos registros

O objetivo do trabalho é que os alunos em grupo operem mais “focadamente” em

alguns aspectos relacionados à visita ao centro do Rio de Janeiro. Na atividade da

visita as solicitações dos grupos de professores estavam pautadas nos registros

gráficos, sem que os alunos soubessem o que seria tratado nesta etapa. Munidos de

fotos, croquis, textos e papéis diversos, os alunos passam a receber as instruções.

Modulo 1

1. Apresentação do conteúdo

programático e dos objetivos do curso

2. Aula: Estrutura Gráfica. Exercício:

Perspectivas / imagens

Palestra: Centro do Rio

3. Visita ao Centro do Rio

4. Exercício: Mapa do Centro

5. Exercício: Solar (lançamento)

6. Aula: Traçados reguladores /

seção áurea. Exercício: Solar

(desenvolvimento)

7. Aula: Transformação da Forma

(F. Ching) Exercício: Solar (desenvolvimento).

8. Aula: Organização (F. Ching)

Exercício: Solar (finalização)

9. Aula: Circulação (F. Ching) Exercício: solar (entrega

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 04 – Elaboração Mapa do Centro do Rio

(duração 6h)

TEORIA

PRÁTICA

Mapa do Centro do Rio (duração 6h)

Figura 364: Confecção dos painéis da visita ao Centro

Fonte: Foto da autora

Page 288: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 256

A proposição da aula:

A “memória” - Representar a visita ao centro do Rio de Janeiro . Cada grupo

trabalha com um tema

1. Profundidade

2. Tempo e Cronologia

3. Distância e Largura

4. Luz e Sombra.

Figura 365: Detalhes específicos de cada tema do painel

Fonte: Foto da autora

MÓDULO 01 - AULA 04 – Elaboração Mapa do Centro do Rio

Page 289: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 257

��#��& �&����$ ��D�%� ��

������

$� "�� ��!"?$��� ��&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������� . % �$��#!�� ����*����# �

� +<+7)O)/4� )438/89+� 3'� '3G1/8+� '76:/9+9R3/)'� *4� #41'7� �7'3*0+'3� *+� �439/-3=�

�3;+89/-'3*4� 4� +*/,O)/4� +� 1+;'39'3*4� *'*48� 5'7'� +<+):MK4� *+� :2� 24*+14

97/*/2+38/43'1�

� 97'('1.4� 9+2� )424� 4(0+9/;4� *+8+3;41;+7� )'5')/*'*+8� /3897:2+39'/8� *+

24*+1'-+2� +� '� )4257++38K4� *4� +85'M4� '76:/9+9R3/)4��251/'7� 4� 574)+884� *+

4(8+7;'MK4�+�7+57+8+39'MK4 +2�7+1'MK4�E�'76:/9+9:7'�+�8+:�)439+<94�+89/2:1'3*4�4

)'254�5+7)+59/;4�

8�574)+*/2+3948�2+94*41Q-/)48�+257+-'*48�574):7'2�,:3*'2+39'7�'� ,472'MK4

*+�:2'�1Q-/)'�*+�7')/4)O3/4�+�4�5+38'2+394�'76:/9+9R3/)4�97/*/2+38/43'1�

� �$� �����57+8+39'MK4�*4�)439+T*4

574-7'2G9/)4�+�*48�4(0+9/;48�*4�):784���:1'���897:9:7'��7G,/)'���<+7)O)/4�

!+785+)9/;'8���/2'-+38!'1+897'���+3974�*4�"/4

���&/8/9'�'4 �+3974�*4�"/4����<+7)O)/4���'5'�*4��+3974

���&�!�+�� ��� ��!�����*����# � ���:1'��$7'M'*48�7+-:1'*47+8��8+MK4�G:7+'���<+7)O)/4��#41'7

�*+8+3;41;/2+394�����:1'��$7'38,472'MK4�*'��472'

�����./3-���<+7)O)/4��#41'7��*+8+3;41;/2+394������:1'�� 7-'3/>'MK4 �����./3-��<+7)O)/4��#41'7��,/3'1/>'MK4�

����:1'���/7):1'MK4������./3-���<+7)O)/4��841'7��+397+-'�

�( ������ � �����������. �&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������������ �#���'

(duração 6h)

$� "��

�&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������� .

% �$��#!�� ���!�*�� "�!��$��� !�"

!"?$���

�&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������� .

% �$��#!������*����# �

Page 290: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 258

��#��& �&����$ �� �:1'�9+Q7/)'�*+�574547MS+8�+�97'M'*48�7+-:1'*47+8�

�5Q8�'�':1'�9+Q7/)'�48�'1:348�*+8+3;41;+2�'1-:38�*+8+3.48�)42�'�,/3'1/*'*+�*+

549+3)/'1/>'MK4�*+ :2�'57/247'2+394�/3897:2+39'1�9N)3/)4� #:-+7+�8+�'

)43897:MK4�*+�6:'974�*+8+3.48�

'��)43897:MK4�*+�:2�7+9I3-:14�G:7+4�'�5'79/7�*4�1'*4�*4 6:'*7'*4(��)43897:MK4�*+�:2�7+9I3-:14�G:7+4�)42�*/'-43'/8�+�6:'*7'*48�-/7'39+8)��)43897:MK4�*'�+85/7'1*��)43897:MK4�*4�5+39G-434

�( ������ � �����������. �&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������������ �#���'

�/-:7'�� ��+8+3.48�#41'7��7'3*0+'3�*+��439/-3= U 97'M'*48�7+-:1'*47+8�439+���:1'�574,+8847+8��3'�!':1'�!41/>>4 +��+72'34��7+/9'8

Page 291: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 259�( ������ � �����������. �&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������������ �#���'

�/-:7'�� ���+8+3.48�7+9I3-:14�G:7+4��+85/7'1�+�5+39G-434��439+���:1'�574,+8847+8��3'�!':1'�!41/>>4�+��+72'34��7+/9'8

Page 292: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 260

� �:1'�9+Q7/)'�84(7+�4�#41'7��7'3*0+'3�*+��439/-3=

�� �+;'39'2+394�+�7+-/89748�*4�#41'7��7'3*0+'3�*+��439/-3=

���+8+3;41;/2+394�*4�24*+14�97/*/2+38/43'1�4754�57/3)/5'1 U 5'5+1�'0+8�*+ 5/84 U 51:2'�4(+79:7' U 5'5+1�97/51+<�+�2/)74)477:-'*4�'8+�*4�24*+14 U 51:2'�

�( ������ � �����������. �&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������������ �#���'

�/-:7'�� ���+;'39'2+3948 +�7+-/89748�*4�#41'7��7'3*0+'3�*+�439/-3=��439+� �4948�*'�':947'

�/-:7'�� ���:1'�+<51/)'9/;'�*+8+3;41;/2+394�*'�24*+1'-+2�97/*/2+38/43'1�*4�#41'7�439+���:1'��1':)/'��:-:894��438+)'

Page 293: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 261

�97'('1.4�8+7G�')425'3.'*4�5+148�574,+8847+8�+�*+8+3;41;/*4�57+,+7+3)/'12+39++2�8'1'�*+�':1'�/3*/;/*:'12+39+�4:�+2�-7:548�*+��'1:348�

�!"�#��$�CA

8�+1+2+3948�6:+�)4389/9:+2 '�+397+-'�*4�97'('1.4�

'��2'6:+9+�*4�#41'7

�( ������ � �����������. �&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������������ �#���'

�/-:7'������+8+3;41;/2+394�*'�24*+1'-+2�97/*/2+38/43'1�*4�#41'7�5+148�'1:348�439+���4948�*'�':947'

�/-:7'�����'6:+9+8�#41'7��7'3*0+'3�*+��439/-3=,/3'1/>'*'8�439+���4948�*'�':947'

Page 294: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

| 262

(��574)+884�*+�97'('1.4�/38+7/*4�34�)'*+734�*+�7+-/89748

)��*+8+3.48�*4�7+9I3-:14�G:7+4��+85/7'1�+�5+39G-434

*��*+8+3.48�*+�4(8+7;'MK4�*4�#41'7

�( ������ � �����������. �&�!�+�� �� ��!��!������������ �#���'

�/-:7'�����'*+734�*+�7+-/8974�*+�'1:34 U �'6:+9+�#41'7��7'3*0+'3�*+��439/-3=�439+���4948�*'�':947'

�/-:7'������'*+734�*+�7+-/8974�*+�'1:34 U 97'M'*48�7+-:1'*47+8�439+���4948�*'�':947'

Page 295: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

: 263

�� ��#��#����!���=�"�����

�����

�"�'�"������23(4(05$B@1�'1�&105(E'1

231*3$/>5,&1�(�'14�1%-(5,714�'1�&6341����6.$���4536563$��3>),&$���8(3&C&,1�

�(342(&5,7$4���,/$*(04�$.(453$� �(0531�'1��,1

��#,4,5$�$1��(0531�'1��,1���8(3&C&,1���$2$�'1��(0531

����8(3&C&,1�� 1.$3��.$0B$/(051�����6.$��!3$B$'14�3(*6.$'13(4��

4(B@1�>63($���8(3&C&,1�� 1.$3�'(4(071.7,/(051�

���'����$�!%�"$ �.,"�����"$ ��������!��� )�$�/��"��"��$ ���%�!("�(� �!&"��

����6.$���3*$0,9$B@1������+,0*��8(3&C&,1�� 1.$3��),0$.,9$B@1�

����6.$���,3&6.$B@1������+,0*���8(3&C&,1��41.$3��(053(*$

�*������� � ����� 2 �$�!%�"$ �.,"�����"$ ���������!��� )�$�/��"��"��$����%�!("�(� �!&"��

!�����

'����$�!�"$ �.,"���

�"$ �(duração 1h)

��;!���

�"��$��$�!����!�#��!"

�!���!��"(duração 5h)

�,*63$����6.$�53$04)13/$B@1�'$�)13/$ F �31)$�0$��$6.$��1.,991�105(���6.$�231)(4413$ �0$��$6.$��1.,991

Page 296: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

8 264

�����!��!��������;� �����

�������

�$ ������ � ������� , �4,"���1(".*7"@>/������)*.(���6&1$A$*/���/,"1��'*.",*7"@>/�

������

� ����#�(&� ���������� (duração 1h)

��9����

���� (duração 5h)

���!��������01&2&.3"@>/�%/�$/.3&C%/

01/(1"-<3*$/�&�%/2�/#+&3*5/2�%/�$412/����4,"���2314341"��1<'*$"���6&1$A$*/�

�&120&$3*5"2���*-"(&.2�",&231"���&.31/�%/ �*/

��!*2*3"�"/��&.31/�%/��*/���6&1$A$*/���"0"�%/��&.31/

����6&1$A$*/���/,"1��,".@"-&.3/�����4,"���1"@"%/2�1&(4,"%/1&2��2&@>/�<41&"���6&1$A$*/���/,"1

�%&2&.5/,5*-&.3/�����4,"���1".2'/1-"@>/�%"��/1-"

�����)*.(���6&1$A$*/���/,"1��%&2&.5/,5*-&.3/������!���� ����#�(&������������

�"� �)�������� ��������#�(&������4,"���*1$4,"@>/������)*.(���6&1$A$*/��2/,"1��&.31&("

�*(41"�����4,"��1(".*7"@>/�%"�'/1-" D �1/'" �."��"4,"��/,*77/�/.3&���4,"�01/'&22/1" �."��"4,"��/,*77/

Page 297: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

9265

�����"��"���� ���<�!�����

�������

�'������� � ������� / �!�$��+) ����� �������%�!�,�� ��" ��!����#!����

�����

�!�$��+) ���� ����� (duração 1h)

��: ���

� ��! ���#!����(duração 5h)

� �$� ������12'3'/4#A?0�&0�%0/4'D&0

120)2#.=4+%0�'�&03�0$,'4+603�&0�%5230����5-#���3425452#��2=(+%#���7'2%B%+0�

�'231'%4+6#3���+.#)'/3�#-'342#���'/420�&0��+0

��"+3+4# #0��'/420�&0��+0���7'2%B%+0���#1#�&0��'/420

����7'2%B%+0���0-#2��-#/A#.'/40�����5-#�� 2#A#&03�2')5-#&02'3��

3'A?0�=52'#���7'2%B%+0���0-#2�&'3'/60-6+.'/40�

����5-#�� 2#/3(02.#A?0�&#��02.#�����*+/)���7'2%B%+0���0-#2��&'3'/60-6+.'/40��

����5-#���2)#/+8#A?0������*+/)��%�!�,�� ��� ��!��������&�+) �

���$���� �!�$��+) ����� �������%�!�,�� ��" ��!����#!����

�+)52#�����5-#��+2%5-#A?0 E �20(# �/#��#5-#��0-+880�0/4'���5-#�120('3302#��/#��#5-#��0-+880

Page 298: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

E266

��'�"*# *�!�"(#�!M�) #��

�#���������

�������

�:<0=08>,TR9� :069=� ,6?89=� /,� :0=;?4=,� 0� 06,-9<,TR9� /0� ?7� =0748N<49� =9-<0� ,=

,?6,=�>0X<4.,=�/9�64@<9��<;?4>0>?<,���9<7,��=:,T9�0�#</07 � �<,8.4=���������"��

# 0B0<.V.49� >07� .979�9-50>4@9� ,7:64,<� 9�:<9.0==9� /0�9-=0<@,TR9� /,� ,<;?4>0>?<,�

/0=08@96@0<� .,:,.4/,/0=�/0�,8N64=0�/, 19<7,�0�/9�0=:,T9�,<;?4>0>Y84.9�� 60@,8>,<

4819<7,TZ0=�:0<>4808>0=�07�<06,TR9�,9=�/4@0<=9=�>07,=�,-9</,/9=�

�979�<0=?6>,/9�0=:0<,�=0�,�,:<0=08>,TR9�07�?7� �=0748N<49/,�:0=;?4=,� 46?=><,/,

.97� 0B07:69=� .98>07:9<P809=�� �� /47P74.,� /,=� ,:<0=08>,TZ0=� .98>07:6,� ,

<0.0:TR9�/0 .9708>N<49=��.<V>4.,=�0�=?20=>Z0=�/9=�9?><9=�2<?:9=�0�:<910==9<0=�

#� =0748N<49� 0=>N� � =0:,<,/9�:9<� >07,=� �=02?48/9� ,�70=7,�9<2,84D,TR9� /,=� ,?6,=

>0X<4.,=���0�/4@4/4/9�07�2<?:9= /0���,���,6?89=�

,��(<,8=19<7,TR9�/,�19<7,

-��#<2,84D,TR9

.���4<.?6,TR9

�% ������ � ������/ '0748N<49��3482���B0<.V.49���97:9=4TR9�79/?6,<��6,8T,708>9�

(�#&��

�����' ��������(duração 5h)

$&G(���

�����!�+)�����#��

����+����"���/?<,TR9 3�

�.�#����

���������' �����������$� �,���

�����!�+)�����#�� �����+����"��

���?6,��!9/?6,TR9���B0<.V.49�

�97:9=4TR9�79/?6,<��/0=08@96@4708>9�

���B0<.V.49� �97:9=4TR9�79/?6,<

�/0=08@96@4708>9�

���$98>9�/0�=4>?,TR9 [ F�@,64,TR9

����B0<.V.49���97:9=4TR9�79/?6,<

�148,64D,TR9�

���,8.,�08><02,�/9�0B0<.V.49���97:9=4TR9�79/?6,< ��*� ��KI#���"�

Page 299: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

E267

� [ 04>?<,�0�,8N64=0�/9=�=02?48>0=�>07,=

�<?:9� [ �,:V>?69���:�����,�:���� [ �#&!�$<9:<40/,/0=����9<7,=�<02?6,<0=���19<7,=�4<<02?6,<0=(<,8=19<7,TR9�/,�19<7,

�<?:9� [ �,:V>?69���:���,�:����� [ �#&!��964=Z0=�19<7,4=�<>4.?6,TR9�/,�19<7,��,<0=>,=�.,8>9=�0�=?:0<1V.40=�

�<?:9�� [ �,:V>?69�� �:���,�:���� [ �#&!�����'$�K#�60708>9=�/01484/9<0=�/9�0=:,T9��39<4D98>,4=�

�<?:9�� [ �,:V>?69����:���,�:�� � [ �#&!�����'$�K#�60708>9=�/01484/9<0=�/9�0=:,T9��@0<>4.,4=�

�<?:9� [ �,:V>?69����:� ��,�:��� � [ �#&!�����'$�K#�-0<>?<,=�07�060708>9=�/01484/9<0=�/0�0=:,T9%?,64/,/0=�/9�0=:,T9�,<;?4>0>Y84.9

�<?:9�� [ �,:V>?69����:����,�:�� � [ #&��"�+�KI#&06,TZ0=�0=:,.4,4=���#<2,84D,TZ0=�0=:,.4,4=

�<?:9�� [ �,:V>?69� ��:���,�:��� � [ ��&�) �KI#�60708>9=�/0�.4<.?6,TR9 [ ,.0==9��08><,/,��.98142?<,TR9 /,�@4,��<06,TZ0=�@4,�0=:,T9 19<7,�/9�0=:,T9�/0�.4<.?6,TR9

�<?:9�� [ �,:V>?69����:����,�:����� [ $&#$#&KI#����'�� �(09<4,=�/,�$<9:9<TR9 [ =0.TR9�N?<0,��9</08=�.6N==4.,=��>09<4,=�<08,=.08>4=>,=�79/?69<���08��,8><9:970><4,��0=.,6,�

�<?:9��[ �,:V>?69����:�����,��� � [ $&�"�L$�#'$<48.V:49=�/0�9</07 [ 04B9��=470><4,��340<,<;?4,�

�<?:9�� [ �,:V>?69����:������,����� [ $&�"�L$�#'

$<48.V:49=�/0�9</07 [ /,/9��<0:0>4TR9��><,8=19<7,TR9�

��� �#�&����$&�"��$� ����&���0911<0C�����8N64=4=�/0�6,�19<7,��?<-,84=79�0�,<;?4>0.>?<,��!UB4.9���?=>,@9��464���������&���0911<0C���� 0��9<-?=40<��?7,�,8N64=0�/,�19<7,��'R9�$,?69��!,<>48=��98>0=��������&(+��&��&���0<7,8�� 4TZ0=�/0�,<;?4>0>?<,��'R9�$,?69��!,<>48=��98>0=������

'�(�'�')��&��#'AAA�,<.30669�.97AAA�,<.3/,46C�.97AAA�,<.9A0-�.97�-<AAA�,<;?4>0.>?<,@4@,�.97AAA�06.<9;?4=�0=AAA�2<0,>-?46/482=�.97AAA�=?77,7,=�.97AAA�@4><?@4?=�.97�-<

�% ������ � ������/ '0748N<49��3482���B0<.V.49���97:9=4TR9�79/?6,<��6,8T,708>9�

Page 300: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

E268

#=�060708>9=�;?0�.98=>4>?07 ,�08><02,�/9 ><,-,639�=R9�9=�=02?48>0=�

,��<;?4@9�.98>08/9�,�,:<0=08>,TR9��:/1 � 08@49�:9<�07,46�

-��:<0=08>,TR9�9<,6��/,�:0=;?4=,�<010<08.4,/,�.97�0B07:69=�/0�9-<,=

.98>07:9<P80,=��::>�9?�:/1 � 7NB479�/0���=64/0=�

.��9<7?6,TR9�/0�:069�7089=�?7,�;?0=>R9�=9-<0�?7�/9=�9?><9=�>07,=�/9

64@<9�:,<,�=0<�.969.,/,�89�148,6�/,�,:<0=08>,TR9�

",=�,:<0=08>,TZ0= /9�=0748N<49�9=�,6?89=�>,7-U7�?>464D,7�<0:<0=08>,TZ0=�2<N14.,=

89� ;?,/<9� 0� 79/069=� ><4/4708=498,4=� :,<,� :9>08.4,64D,<� ,=� � 4819<7,TZ0=� 8,=

,:<0=08>,TZ0=�

�42?<,�������:<0=08>,TZ0=�'0748N<49��3482�.97�?=9�/0�79/069=�0�/0=0839=�98>0���9>9=�/,�,?>9<,

�% ������ � ������/ '0748N<49��3482���B0<.V.49���97:9=4TR9�79/?6,<��6,8T,708>9�

Page 301: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

>269

��#��& �&����$ ��D�%� ��

�� ��� ����

$�D"��

�2������� � �� �� ���� ; �:1'���4*:1'MK4���<+7)P)/4���42548/MK4�24*:1'7��*+8+3;41;/2+394�

$� "��

*"� �%#&%(!64%�#%�*"�'(duração 1h)

!"?$���

�<+7)P)/4� �%#&%(!64%�#%�*"�'

�*:7'MK4��.�

�:�*"%��

����#+2/3G7/4��./3-���<+7)P)/4�

�42548/MK4�24*:1'7��1'3M'2+394�

���� *"����%�*"�64%���,�'�7�!%�

�%#&%(!64%�#%�*"�'����(�$+%"+!#�$)%�

��� �,�'�7�!%���%#&%(!64%�#%�*"�'

���(�$+%"+!#�$)%�

����%$)%����(!)*�64% ;

�. +�"!�64%

����,�'�7�!%���%#&%(!64%�#%�*"�'

��!$�"!-�64%�

������$����$)'� ���%��,�'�7�!%���%#&%(!64%�#%�*"�' � � �� 1/����� �

�/-:7'�����:1' �42548/MK4��4*:1'7 V !74,' �3'�!':1'�!41/==4�439+���:1'�574,+8847'��3'�!':1' !41/==4

Page 302: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

>270

!"?$��

� +<+7)P)/4� 5745T+� '97';N8� *4� +89:*4� *'8� 574547MT+8� 4� '574,:3*'2+394� *48

)43)+/948� *+� )42548/MK4�� 2+*/*'� +� 2R*:14�� '1N2� *'� '(47*'-+2� *+� 574(1+2'8

7+1')/43'*48�E�47-'3/='MK4�*4�+85'M4��'�)43)+5MK4�*+�+1+2+3948�'76:/9+9S3/)48�*+

7+5+9/MK4�+�8:'�'884)/'MK4�

�� 574548/MK4� 9+2� 4� 4(0+9/;4� *+� *+8(146:+'7� ' )'5')/*'*+� *+� 7+57+8+39'MK4� +

5+86:/8'� *4� +85'M4��� :9/1/='MK4� *48� 24*+148� 97/*/2+38/43'/8 3'� /3;+89/-'MK4 +

*+8)4(+79'� *4� :84� *'8� ,472'8� 5'88'� '� 8+7� )438/*+7'*4� )42� ,47M'�� '88/2� )424� '

'(47*'-+2�*'8�6:+89T+8�*+ 8/89+2'9/='MK4�+�*'�47*+2 � :2'�;+=�6:+�4�+<+7)P)/4

'39+7/47�97'94:�*+�+82/:M'7�4�'88:394�

�� 5'79/7� *'8� ;/8T+8� +89'(+1+)/*'8� 3'8� 574548/MT+8� *+� 97'('1.4� 6:+� +3;41;+7'2� '

;/8/9'� '4� )+3974�� � ')7+*/9'�8+� 6:+� 48� '1:348� )4257++3*+2� � 2+1.47� � +� 8+

)438)/+39/='2 *'�/25479I3)/'�*4�)439+<94�:7('34� �'574,:3*'2+394�*'8�7+1'MT+8

+85'M4�/39+734��+85'M4�+<9+734��+1+2+3948�*+ ,7439+/7'��5'88'�'�8+7�'5439'*4�3+89'

+9'5'�)42�:2'�574,:3*'�7+1+;I3)/'�

��#��& �&����$

�� �43897:/7�:2'�2'1.'�4794-43'1�*+��

< �� � )2�� 8:(*/;/*/*'� +2� 2R*:148

6:'*7'*48� *+� ��� <� ��� )2�� !'7'

+<+):MK4� *4� +<+7)P)/4� )'*'� 2'1.'

)477+8543*+7G�'�:2�149+�*+�:2'�6:'*7'

,/)9P)/'� ('8+'*'� 34� 97'M'*4� :7('34� *4

!1'34��-').+�

�2������� � �� ��; �:1'���4*:1'MK4���<+7)P)/4���42548/MK4�24*:1'7��*+8+3;41;/2+394�

�/-:7'�����:1'��42548/MK4��4*:1'7�439+���494�*'�':947'

Page 303: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

>271

� �97';N8�*4�:84� 8/89+2G9/)4� �*+�:2�2R*:14�+85')/'1� )U(/)4�*+����2�*+�'7+89'

+<9+7/47��*+;+7G�8+7�+1'(47'*'�:2'�+*/,/)'MK4�5+14�'-7:5'2+394�*+88+8�+1+2+3948

84(7+�' 2'1.'�47/-/3'1��149+��

%9/1/='3*4�34�2P3/24�� �2R*:148�+�34�2G</24� �2R*:148�+� 9+3*4� )424�'19:7'

2G</2'� ����2� �97O8� 3P;+/8��� +89'� +*/,/)'MK4� *+;+7G� *'7� 7+85489'� E8� 8+-:/39+8

+</-O3)/'8�� +85'M48� '(+7948� +� ,+).'*48�97'385'7+39+8�+� 45')48� ��+;+7K4� 9'2(N2

8+7� 4(8+7;'*'8� '8� 6:+89T+8 7+1'9/;'8� '4� ')+884� +� E8� 7+1'MT+8� )42� '8� +*/,/)'MT+8

;/=/3.'8�

� �+;+7K4�8+7�)438:19'*48��57/3)/5'12+39+��48�)'5P9:148��� � 7-'3/='MK4

�5������+�� � )/7):1'MK4��5����*4�1/;74��76:/9+9:7'���472'���85'M4�+� 7*+2

V �7'3)/8��������./3-��)424�7+,+7O3)/'�9+R7/)'�5'7'�+<+):MK4�*4�97'('1.4�

�� �97'('1.4�8+7G�')425'3.'*4�5+148�574,+8847+8�+�*+8+3;41;/*4

57+,+7+3)/'12+39+�+2�8'1'�*+�':1'�+2�-7:548�*+��'1:348�

�2������� � �� ��; �:1'���4*:1'MK4���<+7)P)/4���42548/MK4�24*:1'7��*+8+3;41;/2+394�

�/-:7'�����4*+148�*+ *+8+3;41;/2+394�+<+7)P)/4�)42548/MK4�24*:1'7�439+���494�*'�':947'

�/-:7'���� 7-'3/='MK4�*'8�+*/,/)'MT+8�3'8�6:'*7'8�439+���494�*'�':947'

Page 304: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

>272

�!"�#��$�CA

8�+1+2+3948�6:+�)4389/9:+2 '�+397+-'�*4�97'('1.4�

'��2'6:+9+�*+,/3/9/;'

(��*+8+3.4�*48�3P;+/8

)��*+8+3.4�*+�4(8+7;'MK4�*4 )430:394

8�*+8+3.48�*+;+7K4�8+7�,+/948��'�1G5/8��34�5'5+1�2'39+/-'��,472'94���)42

2'7-+38�+�)'7/2(4�+�+397+-:+8�0:394�)42�'�2'6:+9+�

�/-:7'����'3)'�*+�8/9:'MK4�)42548/MK4�7+-:1'7 +�24*+14�,/3'1�439+� �494�*'�':947'

�2������� � �� ��; �:1'���4*:1'MK4���<+7)P)/4���42548/MK4�24*:1'7��*+8+3;41;/2+394�

Page 305: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 273

��&�!)"�)� �!'"� K�(�"���

������� ���

�%$����!'%"�(JH"��"�#%"��'"

�B/<-R-39��*9<5=29:��B:/<37/8>+PW/=

"�/B/<-R-39�-98=3=>/�8?7�A9<5=29:�38>/8=3@9�./�79./6+1/7�./ +:<9B37+.+7/8>/

><38>+ 9,4/>9=� 0R=3-9= ><3.37/8=398+3=�� 38@/=>31+8.9� =3=>/7+>3-+7/8>/� +-<3+PN9� ./

09<7+=�+�:+<>3<�.9=�@L<39=�7+>/<3+3=�?>363C+.9=�

"� ><+,+629� 9,4/>3@+� +7:63+<� 9� /8>/8.37/8>9� =9,</� 09<7+=� +,=><+>+=� /� +=� 6T13-+=

</=:/->3@+=��:9>/8-3+63C+<�+= 2+,363.+./=�./�-97?83-+PN9 =9,</�89PW/=�./�09<7+�/

/=:+P9� /� /=>37?6+<� 9� :/8=+7/8>9� =9,</� ?7� 7+>/<3+6� /� +=� ;?+63.+./=

-9<</=:98./8>/=� +9=�:<9-/==9=�./�7+83:?6+PN9��.9,<+<��-9<>+<��/>-���/�+�-9<</6+PN9

/8></�/6/=�

(=+8.9�.30/</8>/=�7+>/<3+3=��38-/8>3@+�=/ + :<9.?PN9�./�79./69=�><3.37/8=398+3=�/

./798=><+�=/ 9� ?=9� ./�7+;?/>/=� 89� :<9-/==9� -<3+>3@9� �� :<9:9=3PN9� ./=/8@96@/

-+:+-3.+./=�38=><?7/8>+3=�./�79./6+1/7�/�0?8.+7/8>+ +�09<7+PN9�./�?7+�6T13-+

�!������� � ������� + ���&������� ���������%#�

'�"%��

���&���� ���������%*��

#%F'���

���&���� ���������%*��

�)������

���� ���&���� ���������%*��

����B/<-R-39���B:/<37/8>+PW/=

����?6+���8L63=/�+<;?3>/>U83-+���:</=/8>+PN9�.9=�/B/7:69=�

����B/<-R-39���8+63=/�+<;?3>/>U83-+��./=/8@96@37/8>9�

����B/<-R-39���8+63=/�+<;?3>/>U83-+��./=/8@96@37/8>9�

���B/<-R-39���8+63=/�+<;?3>/>U83-+��038+63C+PN9�

���+8-+�+:</=/8>+PN9�.9�/B/<-R-39�./��8L63=/��<;?3>/>U83-+

����?6+���8L63=/�.9�>/<</89���B/<-R-39��#<94/>9�����(��)3=3>+�+9

>/<</89�

�� �B/<-R-39��#<94/>9�����(��./=/8@96@37/8>9����8L63=/�.9�>/<</89

���B/<-R-39��#<94/>9�����(��./=/8@96@37/8>9����B:/<37/8>+PW/=

����?6+���9809<>9��7,3/8>+6���B/<-R-39��#<94/>9�����(

�./=/8@96@37/8>9�

���#98>9�./�=3>?+PN9 X E��@+63+PN9

����B/<-R-39��#<94/>9�����(��./=/8@96@37/8>9����?6+�� +>/<3+3=

7+;?/>/=

����B/<-R-39��#<94/>9�����(��./=/8@96@37/8>9����?6+���/=/829�./

+<;?3>/>?<+

�����B/<-R-39��#<94/>9�����(��038+63C+PN9�

����+8-+�+:</=/8>+PN9�.9�:<94/>9�����( X �)����JH"���!����

Page 306: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 274

./� <+-39-R839� /� 9� :/8=+7/8>9� ><3.37/8=398+6� +><+@Q=� ./ :<9-/.37/8>9=

7/>9.96T13-9=�

��&�!)"�)� �!'"

� �/=/8@96@37/8>9�./�79./69=�><3.37/8=398+3=�/7�;?+><9�=Q<3/=�

�<+7/ � #+:/6 � �<+7/�-97�:+:/6 � �=:?7+

� �?6+�>/T<3-+�=9,</�09<7+=

�� "�A9<5=29:�+-98>/-/�/7 .?+=�+?6+=��=/8.9�.93= .3+= -98=/-?>3@9=�+-97:+82+.9= :/69=

:<90/==9</=�8+�=+6+�./�+?6+��"=�/B/<-R-39= =N9 ./=/8@[email protected]=�38.3@3.?+67/8>/�/

:9=>/<39<7/8>/�./,+>3.9= /7�1<?:9=�./� ���+6?89=�

�31?<+����� �?6+�>/T<3-+���.3</><3C/=�.9�A9<5=29:�./�/B:/<37/8>+PW/= X �/88381�#9::/<�98>/���9>9=�.+�+?>9<+

�31?<+����� *9<5=29:�./��B:/<37/8>+PW/=�98>/���9>9=�.+�+?>9<+

�!������� � ������� + ���&������� ���������%#�

Page 307: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 275

�'�%���&

� �3>+�.?:6+�0+-/��03>+�-</:/��+6038/>/=���� 77���=?:/<,98./<

� %Q1?+�7/>L63-+��/=;?+.<9�Y�Z��,+=/�./�-9<>/��/=>36/>/�/�>/=9?<+�./�:+:/6�

� �7,+6+1/7�:+<+�+�/8></1+�.+=�7+;?/>/=�

"�7+>/<3+6�:+<+�79./6+1/7�Q09<8/-3.9 :/6+�#(��

�#%�&�!'�JH"

"=�/6/7/8>9=�;?/�-98=>3>?/7�+�/8></1+�.9�><+,+629�=N9�9= =/1?38>/=�

+����=Q<3/=�-97:6/>+=�./�79./69=�

� 7+;?/>/=�./�+<+7/

� 7+;?/>/=�./�:+:/6

�31?<+����� *9<5=29:��B:/<37/8>+PW/= 79./6+1/7�,3�/�><3.37/8=398+6�89�:+:/6�98>/���9>9=�.+�+?>9<+ /��/8381�#9::/<

�31?<+��� � *9<5=29:��B:/<37/8>+PW/=�79./6+1/7�,3�/�><3.37/8=398+6�89�+<+7/�98>/���9>9=�.+�+?>9<+

�!������� � ������� + ���&������� ���������%#�

Page 308: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 276

� 7+;?/>/=�./�+<+7/�-97�:+:/6

� 7+;?/>/=�./�/=:?7+

,��:<9-/==9�./�><+,+629�38=/<3.9�89�-+./<89�./�</13=><9=

�31?<+����� *9<5=29:��B:/<37/8>+PW/=�79./6+1/7�><3.37/8=398+6�,?-2+�@/1/>+6�98>/���9>9=�.+�+?>9<+

�31?<+����� *9<5=29:��B:/<37/8>+PW/= X +8/6�:<9.?C3.9�:9<�+6?8+�8+=�29<+=�63@</=�98>/���9>9=�.+�+?>9<+

�31?<+����� *9<5=29:��B:/<37/8>+PW/=�79./6+1/7�><3.37/8=398+6�+<+7/�/�:+:/6�98>/���9>9=�.+�+?>9<+

�!������� � ������� + ���&������� ���������%#�

Page 309: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 277

��&�")# )�!�"'#�!L�( #���

������ ����

#� .A.;,W,28� ,87<2<=.� 7*� *7O52<.� *;:>2=.=Z72,*� -.� ->*<� .-2/2,*S[.<�� 27?.<=20*7-8

*<9.,=8< /8;6*2< .� .<9*,2*2<�� -.<,8+;27-8� <>*< 9;27,29*2<� ,*;*,=.;W<=2,*<� .

2-.7=2/2,*7-8�8<�-*-8<�89.;*=2?8<�-8�9;83.=8 ,868�9*;=.�27=.0;*7=.�-*�/8;6*SQ8�-.

>6*�6.=8-85802*�9;83.=>*5�

�� 9;898<=*� =.6� ,868� 8+3.=2?8� -.<.7?85?.;� ,*9*,2-*-.<� 27<=;>6.7=*2<� .

,87,.9=>*2<� 9*;* 8;0*72C*SQ8 -*� /8;6*� .� -8� .<9*S8� *;:>2=.=Z72,8� �6952*;� 8

9;8,.<<8� -.� 8+<.;?*SQ8� .6� ;.5*SQ8 M� *;:>2=.=>;*� .� <.>� ,87=.A=8� .<=26>5*7-8� 8

,*698� 9.;,.9=2?8� .� 2-.85Y02,8� #>=;*� +><,*� <>0.;2-*� T� *� 27<=;>6.7=*52C*SQ8� -� *

;.9;.<.7=*SQ8� 98; ,*=.08;2*<� -.� *7O52<.� *=;*?T<� -*� 68-.5*0.6� -.� 6*:>.=.<

*52*-*<�*�8>=;*<�=T,72,*<�-.�;.9;.<.7=*SQ8�

�(������ � ������ 4 �>5*���7O52<.�*;:>2=.=Z72,*���9;.<.7=*SQ8�-8<�.A.6958<

'�#%��

�$�� ���*��"���! $�#�#2�����

$%G'���

�&�!�/��� ������"���! $�#�#2����

�1�$���

����A.;,W,28���A9.;26.7=*S[.<

����A.;,W,28���A9.;26.7=*S[.<

����$�� ���*��"���! $�#�#2��������!�"��#�.,����"��&�����"�

�����&�!�/��� ������"� �! $�#�#2��������"��%��%����#��

�����&�!�/��� ������"���! $�#�#2��������"��%��%����#��

�����&�!�/��� ������"���! $�#�#2������������'�.,��

���*7,*�*9;.<.7=*SQ8�-8�.A.;,W,28�-.��7O52<.��;:>2=.=Z72,*

����>5*���7O52<.�-8�=.;;.78���A.;,W,28��$;83.=8�����(� )2<2=*�*8

=.;;.78�

����A.;,W,28��$;83.=8�����(��-.<.7?85?26.7=8����7O52<.�-8�=.;;.78

���A.;,W,28��$;83.=8�����(��-.<.7?85?26.7=8����A9.;26.7=*S[.<

����>5*���87/8;=8��6+2.7=*5���A.;,W,28��$;83.=8�����(

�-.<.7?85?26.7=8�

���$87=8�-.�<2=>*SQ8 ] E �?*52*SQ8

����A.;,W,28��$;83.=8�����(��-.<.7?85?26.7=8����>5*��!*=.;2*2<

6*:>.=.<

����A.;,W,28��$;83.=8�����(��-.<.7?85?26.7=8����>5*���.<.718�-.

*;:>2=.=>;*

�����A.;,W,28��$;83.=8�����(��/27*52C*SQ8�

����*7,*�*9;.<.7=*SQ8�-8�9;83.=8�����( ] �)� ��KI#���"� ��

Page 310: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 278

��&�")# )�!�"'#

� �>5*�=.Y;2,*�<8+;.�*7O52<.�*;:>2=.=Z72,*

� �9;.<.7=*SQ8�-8<�.A.6958<�

"8;6*56.7=.� .<,851.�<.� >6� *;:>2=.=8� 7*,287*5� .� >6� 27=.;7*,287*5� 9*;*� *

27?.<=20*SQ8 .�9*;=.�-*�=>;6*�*7*52<*�>6*�8+;*�7*,287*5�.�*�8>=;*�*7*52<*�>6*�8+;*

27=.;7*,287*5�� &.6.<=;*56.7=.� *5=.;*68<� *<� 8+;*<�� 98;T6� <.0>.�<.� .<<*� 6.<6*

5Y02,*�

�20>;*������>5*��7O52<.��;:>2=.=Z72,*�$;8/*��7*�$*>5*�$852CC8�87=.���87=.\-8�-*�*>5*�F�9.;W8-8

Page 311: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 279

*;:>2=.=8� '*-*8��7-8

^ 8+;*���*<*���A���58,*5���8+.���B808����*9Q8

*;:>2=.=8� &=>-28�$*;*5.588+;*��%./\028�&Q8��12,858,*5��&Q8��;*7,2<,8�-.�$*>5* � %&����;*<25

*;:>2=.=8� �7-;*-.�!8;.==27��;:>2=.=8<8+;*�%.<2-U7,2*�.6��=*6*6+>,* ] (+*=>+*��&$

*;:>2=.=8� '*-*8��7-88+;*���C>6*�8><.��#<*4*���*9Q8

*;:>2=.=8� �*;5*��>*S*+*8+;*���*<*�)*;*7-*��=*71*70O��%28�-.��*7.2;8

*;:>2=.=8� �5+.;=8��*698��*.C*8+;*���*<* �>.;;.;8���O-2C���<9*71*

*;:>2=.=8� �*;5*��>*S*+*8+;*���*<*�)*;*7-*��=*71*70O��%28�-.��*7.2;8

�� �.<.7?85?26.7=8�-*�*7O52<.�*=;*?T<�-*<�<.0>27=.<�,*=.08;2*<�

!8;/85802*

�20>;*�����7O52<.��;:>2=.=Z72,*�!8;/85802*��C>6*�8><.�87=.���8=8�-*�*>=8;*

Page 312: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 280

�<=;>=>;*

�,.<<8�.��2;,>5*SQ8

�20>;*������7O52<.��;:>2=.=Z72,*��,.<<8�.�,2;,>5*SQ8���*<*�)*;*7-*�87=.���8=8�-*�*>=8;*

�20>;*�����7O52<.��;:>2=.=Z72,*��<=;>=>;*��%.<2-U7,2*��=*6*7+>,*�87=.���8=8�-*�*>=8;*

Page 313: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 281

#;2.7=*SQ8

!*=.;2*52-*-.

�20>;*��� ��7O52<.��;:>2=.=Z72,*��!*=.;2*52-*-.� %./\028�&Q8��12,8�87=.���8=8�-*�*>=8;*

�20>;*������7O52<.��;:>2=.=Z72,*�#;2.7=*SQ8�87=.���8=8�-*�*>=8;*

Page 314: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

D 282

�� �.?.6 <.;�,87<>5=*-8<�8<�,*9W=>58<�-8�52?;8��;:>2=.=>;*���8;6*���<9*S8�.�#;-.6 �

�;*7,2<����������"���,868�;./.;.7,2*�=.Y;2,*�9*;*�*�.A.,>SQ8�-8�=;*+*518�

� #�=;*+*518�T *,869*71*-8�9.58<�9;8/.<<8;.<�.�-.<.7?85?2-8�9;./.;.7,2*56.7=.�.6�<*5*

-.�*>5*�.6�0;>98<�-.� �*���*5>78<�

�$%�&�"'�KI#

#<�.5.6.7=8<�:>.�,87<=2=>2;Q8�*�.7=;.0*�-8�=;*+*518�<.;Q8�8<�<.0>27=.<�

*��=.A=8�-.�*7O52<.�>=252C*7-8�78�6W7268���,*=.08;2*<�*9;.<.7=*-*<��6OA268�-.��9O027*

98-.7-8 *,;.<,.7=*;�-2*0;*6*<�.A952,*=2?8<�

+��6*:>.=.�*0;.0*-*�8>�7Q8�*�8>=;*<�=T,72,*<�-.�;.9;.<.7=*SQ8

+��9;8,.<<8�-8�=;*+*518�*9;.<.7=*-8�.6�<52-.<�78�98@.;�9827=

,��-./.<*�8;*5

Page 315: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

A 283

��%�!("�(� �!&"� J�'�"���

� ������"��

#962-;6�,-�)98<1;-;<9)

"� ->-9+U+16� +65:1:;-� -4� 796,<@19� <4)� .694)� )98<1;-;X51+)� +<2)� 15;-5QO6

+6476:1;1=)� -:;-2)� )5+69),)� 5)� )5M31:-� -� 9-79-:-5;)QO6� ,6:� -3-4-5;6:

)98<1;-;X51+6: Z .694):�-�-:7)Q6:��)4*1-5;-:�-�-:;9<;<9)�-:;<,),6:�5):�9-:1,S5+1):

,6�->-9+U+16�)5;-9169�,-�)5M31:- )98<1;-;X51+)�

��)*69,)/-4�,6�7962-;6�,-=-�-:;)9 691-5;),)�K�)796791)QO6�,6�;-99-56�36+)31@),6

56� +)47<:� ,)� #'��� +64� )� .15)31,),-� ,-� :-� 796,<@19� <4� �:7)Q6� �64<51;M916� ,-

�65=1=S5+1)�7)9)�6��-5;96��+),S41+6�,6��<9:6�,-��98<1;-;<9)�-�'9*)51:46 Z ��'�

�<� ���� � � �� ��"�� I �1.*&3.����� �

&�"$��

�1.*&3.�����

#$B&���

�1.*&3.�����

�E%4+.�

����>-9+U+16���>7-914-5;)QY-:

����>-9+U+16���>7-914-5;)QY-:

����<3)���5M31:-�)98<1;-;X51+)���79-:-5;)QO6�,6:�->-4736:�

����>-9+U+16���5)31:-�)98<1;-;X51+)��,-:-5=63=14-5;6�

����>-9+U+16���5)31:-�)98<1;-;X51+)��,-:-5=63=14-5;6�

���>-9+U+16���5)31:-�)98<1;-;X51+)��.15)31@)QO6�

�����"-$"�"/1&2&-3"B@.�%.�&6&1$C$).�%&��->+)2&��104)3&3F-)$"

����4+"���->+)2&�%.�3&11&-.���6&1$C$).���1.*&3.����� ��!)2)3"�".

3&11&-.�

����6&1$C$).���1.*&3.����� ��%&2&-5.+5),&-3.����->+)2&�%.�3&11&-.

�����6&1$C$).���1.*&3.����� ��%&2&-5.+5),&-3.�� �6/&1),&-3"BH&2

�����4+"���.-'.13.��,#)&-3"+���6&1$C$).���1.*&3.�����

�%&2&-5.+5),&-3.�

�����.-3.�%&�2)34"B@. I �8��5"+)"B@.

�����6&1$C$).���1.*&3.����� ��%&2&-5.+5),&-3.����4+"���"3&1)")2

,"04&3&2

�����6&1$C$).���1.*&3.����� ��%&2&-5.+5),&-3.����4+"���&2&-(.�%&

"104)3&341"

����6&1$C$).���1.*&3.����� ��')-"+)7"B@.�

����"-$"�"/1&2&-3"B@.�%.�/1.*&3.����� I �!����;9����������

Page 316: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

A 284

"� 796/9)4)� ,-� 9-8<-914-5;6:� .<5+165)1:� :-9M� )*)5,65),6� -4� .)=69� ,-� <4)

9-.3->O6� :6*9-� 6:� +65+-1;6:� 9-3);1=6:� K� -::S5+1)� ,6� 9-<519�� ,6 +65=1=-9�� K

+6479--5:O6�,):�)4*1S5+1):�5-+-::M91):��-�K�+65:-8<-5;-�15)</<9)QO6�,6�-:7)Q6

)98<1;-;X51+6�

�� ,1:+<::O6� ,6� 7962-;6� =)1� 15+3<19� 6� +65+-1;6� ,-;9)5:1QO6� � -5;9-� 6:� -:7)Q6:

->1:;-5;-:�-�6:�1,-)31@),6:��-�,-�8<-�.694)�-:;-:�-:7)Q6:�:-�9-3)+165)4�

�-=-4�:-9�+65:1,-9),6:�56�,-:-5=63=14-5;6�,6�;9)*)306�� -:7)Q6:�,-�+65=U=16���9-<51O6� -:7)Q6:�,-�9-;196���1:63)4-5;6� -:7)Q6:�,-�;9)5:1QO6

"�6*2-;1=6�,6�;9)*)306�R�)�,-.151QO6�,-�<4) =63<4-;91)�-�-:7)+1)31,),-�-4�-:+)3)

+647);U=-3�+64�6�%63)9��9)5,2-)5�,-� 65;1/5?� ��9-.3->O6�:6*9-�)�15)</<9)QO6�,6

-:7)Q6� )98<1;-;X51+6� 5)� ,-.151QO6� ,- :1;<)QY-:� 15;-95):� -� ->;-95):� �,-5;96�.69)�

:-7)9)9�<519��-�5):�46,)31,),-: ,-�7-9+<9:6� �;-476�46=14-5;6��� ;)4*R4�.)@-4

7)9;-�,)�79676:1QO6�

�1:+<;-4�:- ):� ,1=-9:):� 76::1*131,),-:� ,-� 1473)5;)QO6� 56� ;-99-56�� :-/<5,6� )

),-8<),)�9-3)QO6�-:7)+1)3�15;-956�->;-956 Z 7-9+<9:6:�-�6�:-5;1,6�,6�9-<519�

"� ,-:-5=63=-9� -� )796.<5,)9� )� +)7)+1,),-� ,-� 69/)51@)9�� -:;9<;<9)9�� +64769� -

)5)31:)9� )� .694)� )98<1;-;X51+)�� )::14� +646� +)7)+1;)9� )� ->79-::O6� ,-� 1,-1):� 7-3)

7-:8<1:)� -� ->7-914-5;)QO6� ,-� ,1=-9:6:� 4);-91)1:� -� ;R+51+):� ,-� 9-79-:-5;)QO6

,-=-4�-:;)9�79-:-5;-:�56�7962-;6�

$���$H!���%

�3-4-5;6:� )98<1;-;X51+6:=63<4-:� /-64R;91+6:� 7<96: � =63<4-:� +<9=6:� +631:Y-:

.694)1: � .694):� 9-/<3)9-:�-� 199-/<3)9-:� )9;1+<3)QY-:�,)� .694) � )9-:;):�� +)5;6:�-

:<7-9.U+1-:�

W,<36:� -:7)+1)1:�-3-4-5;6:� 0691@65;)1:� ,-.151,69-:� ,6� -:7)Q6 Z 73)56: �-:7)Q6

31=9- Z =)@16� -3-4-5;6:�5);<9)1:�-�-:+<3;W91+6:� -3-4-5;6:�=-9;1+)1:�,-.151,69-:�,6

�<� ���� � � �� ��"�� I �1.*&3.����� �

Page 317: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

A 285

-:7)Q6 Z +63<5):� 73)56� ,-� *91:-: � 73)56:� ,-� =1,96 Z )*-9;<9):� ,1=1:W91): �

73)56:9-;6:�-�+<9=6: � -3-4-5;6:�,-�+19+<3)QO6 � -:+),):�-�9)47):�

�%#��&"%�$���(�!&�%

#)1:)/-4� +65:;9<U,)�� -3-4-5;6:� )98<1;-;X51+6:� )::6+1),6:� )6� 7)1:)/1:46� -� K

7)1:)/-4�

#-9+<9:6�=1:<)3��,)�=1)�,-�)+-::6�)6�;-99-56��-�,6�;-99-56�+64�:<)�=1@150)5Q)

�65.1/<9)QO6� ,6:� 7962-;6:� )� 7)9;19� ,)� 4)517<3)QO6� ,-� 73)56:� -� =63<4-:� +64

,1:;15;):�796791-,),-:�.694)1: Z ;->;<9)��+69��+65;6956�-�;)4)506�

#915+U716:� ,-� 69,-4� +6476:1;1=) � -1>6�� :14-;91)�� 01-9)98<1)�� ,),6�� 9-7-;1QO6�

;9)5:.694)QO6�

��%�!("�(� �!&"

� �<3)�;-W91+)���5M31:-�,6�&-99-56

�1/<9)�������<3)�:6*9-�6�;-99-56�#'��65;-���6;6:�,)�)<;69)

�<� ���� � � �� ��"�� I �1.*&3.����� �

Page 318: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

A 286

�-=)5;)4-5;6�56�36+)3�,6 ;-99-56�-�,6�-5;6956

�-:-506:��+968<1:��.6;6:�

65;)/-4�,6�4);-91)3�,-�)5M31:- � �7)15R1:�->731+);1=6:�+64�6:�9-/1:;96:� �

/9<76:

�=)31)QO6�+63-;1=)�,6�4);-91)3�)79-:-5;),6�7-36:�/9<76:�

�1/<9)����� �79-:-5;)QO6��5)31:-�,6�;-99-56�65;-���6;6:�,)�)<;69)

�1/<9)����� �79-:-5;)QO6�/9<76:�769�+);-/691):���5)31:-�,6�;-99-56�65;-���6;6:�,)�)<;69)

�<� ���� � � �� ��"�� I �1.*&3.����� �

Page 319: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

A 287

� �<3)�;-W91+)���65.69;6��4*1-5;)3

�� �-:-5=63=14-5;6�,6�7962-;6

%631+1;)QO6�,-���=)91M=-1:�,-�1473)5;)QO6

�=)31)QO6�,6�+65.69;6�)4*1-5;)3�56�3)*69);W916

6,-3)/-4

�� �-=-4 :-9�+65:<3;),6:�6:�+)7U;<36:�,6�31=96��98<1;-;<9)���694)���:7)Q6�-�"9,-4� �9)5+1:� ��� �� ���!��� +646� 7915+17)3� 9-.-9-5+1)� ;-W91+)� 7)9)� )� ->-+<QO6� ,6;9)*)306�

� "� ;9)*)306� ,-=- :-9� )+647)50),6� 7-36:� 796.-::69-:� -� ,-:-5=63=1,679-.-9-5+1)34-5;-� -4� :)3)� ,- )<3)� -4� /9<76:� ,-� � )3<56:�� %O6� +647<;),):79-:-5Q):� 7)9;1+17);1=):�� 6<� :-2)�� )� 79-:-5Q) ,6� )3<56� -:;M� )::6+1),)� K� :<)796,<QO6�-4�:)3)�,-�)<3)�

�(����FD"�$�&G$�"%�)7)+1,),-� ,-� 1,-5;1.1+)QO6� ,):� 8<-:;Y-:� -5=63=1,):� 56� ;9)*)306� �79676:1QY-:.<5,)4-5;),):�-4�+65+-1;6:�+3)96:���)7)+1,),-�,-�/-9)9�1,-1):�-�->7369)9�)3;-95);1=):�7)9)�6:�796*3-4):$-:<3;),6�73M:;1+6�,)�=63<4-;91)�-�,6�7962-;6�/9M.1+6�

�1/<9)����� �-3-6,65�-:;<,6�,6�;-99-56�65;-���6;6:�,)�)<;69)

�<� ���� � � �� ��"�� I �1.*&3.����� �

Page 320: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

A 288

�4),<9-+14-5;6�,6�7962-;6�56�,-+699-9�,-�:-<�,-:-5=63=14-5;6��>79-::O6� -4� ,-:-506� -� 46,-36� -� 8<)31,),-� ,6� )+)*)4-5;6� ,6:� )9;-.);6:796,<@1,6:��9)< ,-�)::1,<1,),-�-�7)9;1+17)QO6�-4�)<3)�#65;<)31,),-�5)�-5;9-/)�,):�;)9-.):�:631+1;),):�

�#$�%�!&�FD"":�-3-4-5;6:�8<-�+65:;1;<19O6�)�-5;9-/)�,6�;9)*)306�:-9O6�6:�:-/<15;-:�

)��4)8<-;-�,-.151;1=)

*��73)5;):�,6:�5U=-1:���+69;-:���,-:-506�,-�6*:-9=)QO6 ,6�+652<5;6

+��.1+0)�9-:<46

,��,-.-:)�69)3

":�,-:-506:�,-=-9O6�:-9�.-1;6:�56�7)7-3�4)5;-1/)�-�-5;9-/<-:�+64�)�4)8<-;-����.1+0)9-:<46�,-=-9M�:-9�-5;9-/<-�-4�,<):�+W71):�1479-::): -4�7)7-3�����4U5146���/��

�1/<9)����� �1+0)�9-:<46�;9)*)306�.15)3�65;-���6;6:�,)�)<;69)

�<� ���� � � �� ��"�� I �1.*&3.����� �

Page 321: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

A 289

�=63<QO6�,6:�;9)*)306:

�1/<9) ��� �=63<QO6�,6�7962-;6�.15)3�65;-���6;6:�,)�)<;69)

�<� ���� � � �� ��"�� I �1.*&3.����� �

Page 322: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

290

���������

�������� ���������� ������� ��� ���/����� � � �� �+������������� ������� �� �

��� *�� � � � ���� */��� ����� ��! ��� ����������� �� � � �� � � ����� �� � ���/���

��������� ��������� � � ���� ���� �������.��� � � �� !�� � ���� �� �� �

��������� �� �(�� ��������� �� �� �������� � �!�#� � 0��� � �����# � � �� ������� ����

���� �� ������������ ����.���������� � ����

� � ���� �"������� ������ �������� ������������ ��� � � ���� �� ��������� ��� ��������

��������!� ��+������������������ ��!��� � � ����������(������������ ������� *(�

� � �� ���� � �

��� ������ ���� � ������ ���� � ����� !��,!���� �� � ���� �� ���� � �� �� ������

��������� ����� ��� � ������������ ������������ ���

�� �$������ ������ ��� ��# ���� �� � ��� �� ���� ��������� �������� ����� !�������

� �� ����� ��������� ����!��� �� � �*/��� � � ��������� *(�� � � �� ���� � �� ���

�+�� ��� ����� ������� ��� �����"(�� �� ������*(� ��� �������� �� � � ����� ��

��� ��� ����� � �� ���� �� �!$�� ��� ���� ��

������� ���� � �� � ������&��� � � � � � ���� � � �� � �� ������� �� ���� ��

�����!��!������� ��� �������� ����� ����� ���� �� �������.����� ��� ����� ��� �

��� ��!�� ���� ����� *(����� �� ������ �� �� ���� ��

���� ����� � � � ��� � *(�� ��� � ���� �� ������������ ��! �� ���������� ���� ����

�(�� ���� � ��� ���� ����� � � �"�������� *(�� ������������ �� �,��� � ���� ��������

!��� ��� �������������� ����������� */���

Page 323: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 291

*���*�&�!��!�$!'�*��!��

���%��":6C�(>:GG:� �92E:?C�I�=1AE5D1C��#1�3?>35@39[>�1BAE9D53D[>931�1>D97E1� �6I`AD<D$6H�86H6H�9:A�6AB6�B6FJ:I6H�6GFJ>I:ImC>86H�9:�$6��CI><J>:969���6G8:ADC6���JC968>lC���6?69:��GFJ>I:IDH�������

�#!#'���JH8=� +85��BD�?6�D85 �B389D53DEB1<�$?45<��Q��9��&:L�1DG@� &1��:H><C�(G:HH����������E�

�$��*,!�� $:DC� �6II>HI6� ��� ������ �������� ������%69G>9�� �DA:88>lC� �J:CI:H� 9:� �GI:�� $DH9>:OA>7GDH�9:�6GFJ>I:8IJG6���9>8>DC:H�@6A����������E�

�$�U&,�*��� �:C>H:� 9:� )56<5H]5C� C?2B5� ? 'B?35CC?� 45� �?>35@US?� �BAE9D5D\>931� @1B1� 1'BPD931� 4?� �>C9>?� 45� 'B?:5D?� (GD?:I6G� �� q !!� +:B>C6G� >C� ,:68=>C<� 6C9� *:H:6G8=� 6C9�G8=>I:8IJG6A� �:H><C�� �HH:B7A6<:�� EG68I>8:� 6C9� >CI:G;68:H� *>D� 9:� "6C:>GD�� ����� CDK:B7GD���

�$�0�&�*��� �6GADH� �A7:GID� !C`8>D� $?45<?C� 6XC93?C� 1@<9314?C� 1?� 45C5>8?� 9>4ECDB91<��DJIDG69D q �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� -G76C>HBD� 96� -C>K:GH>969:� 9:� +bD� (6JAD�� +bD(6JAD����� �

�$.�+� *J7:B� �<57B91 45 5>C9>1B� �� :9�� +bD (6JAD���GH (DgI>86� �����

�&�*����� "JA>D� %6G>6� 9:� &C� 5<5=5>D?C DB949=5>C9?>19C� 45� B5@B5C5>D1US?� 3?=?9>CDBE=5>D1<� 2PC93?� 5� CE1C� 1@<931U]5C� >?� 45C5>F?<F9=5>D?� 45� @B?:5D?C� 45� 45C5>8?9>4ECDB91<� �>HH:GI6fbD� 9:� %:HIG69D q �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� -G76C>HBD� 96-C>K:GH>969:�9:�+bD�(6JAD��+bD�(6JAD�������

�*��&���>JA>D��6GAD� 'B?:5D?�5�45CD9>?��+bD�(6JAD��SI>86���

�*%+,*'&����:GNA� �5C9>7�1>4��E9<4�/?EB�&G>���?<<2?EC5�&:L�1DG@�� DA<6I:���*J99D8@� :69A:N���(6B:A6����� �

�*& �!%�� *J9DA;� �BD5� 5� '5B35@US?�-9CE1<�� E=1�@C93?<?791� 41� F9CS?� 3B914?B1� +bD� (6JAD�,=DBHDC�$:6GC>C<��9>fn:H�$I96����

5555555555 #1 �?B=1�F9CE1<�45�<11BAE9D53DEB1� �6G8:ADC6���9���JHI6KD��>A>�����

�-�+$�1���:GI=DA9� $9>91DEB5C�1>4�+859B�-1<E5�9>��B389D53DEB1<�'B13D935�,=:�G>8@7J>A9:G�� �������E�����

�2�*���(:9GD� #5C 31C5C�45�<b1>9=1�!CHI>IJI�9s�9>8>DCH�9:�A6�>EJI68>l�9:��6G8:ADC6�>��:CIG:9:��JAIJG6��DCI:BEDG^C>6�9:��6G8:ADC6����&�������

Page 324: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 292

�� !��� �:C>H:� %6GFJ:H�&� EC?� 45� =?45<?C� DB949=5>C9?>19C� >?� 5>C9>?� 41� 3B91US?1BAE9D5D\>931��69:GCDH�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD���:AD DG>ODCI:��K����C����E�������9:O������

��#�*���:D;;G:N� DL:� �>P<9C9C�45�<1�6?B=1��EB21>9C=?�I�1BAE9D53DEB1� �6G8:ADC6� �1/0�2+�%(%�������

��# ,!&��%'$�%(���'$0%* �CDVD931�41��B91US?�-5B21<� +bD�(6JAD�%6GI>C��DCI:H�������Q�:9�

��*#!��"DHg� &�)9C3?�5�1� >F5>US?��E=�5CDE4?�C?2B5�1C�>?D1U]5C 7BP6931C�>1�3?>35@US?�4?@B?:5D?� ,:H:� ��DJIDG69D� :B� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� -G76C>HBD��*>D� 9:� "6C:>GD�� &o8A:D� 9:� (lH��G69J6fbD�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD��(*'-*��� �

��$�*!� ��"DHg�%6Gj6��:I>A� +B1J1�I�=?45<?�5>5<)5>139=95>D?��.DAJB:���9:�I:MIDH�9:9D8IDG69D��+:G>:��GFJ>I:8IJG6��+:K>AA6��9��-C>K:GH>969�9:�+:K>AA6����������E�

��**�,'�� %DC>86� %6GI>CH� �� $5D?4?<?791� @BPD931� >1� @B?4EUS?� 4?� 3?>8539=5>D?� 5=1BAE9D5DEB1�5�CE1� 9>6<EW>391�>1�12?B4175=�41�DV3>931�3?>CDBED9F1��E=�5CDE4?�45�31C?�>1��,,�)!��*>D�9:�"6C:>GD� -�*"(*'�*)����

��++'���C6��6GDA>C6��DGB><DC>� &�$?45<?�+B949=5>C9?>1<�>1��BAE9D5DEB1�4?�)5>1C39=5>D?�(GD?:I6G��� q !!�+:B>C6G�>C�,:68=>C<�6C9�*:H:6G8=�6C9��G8=>I:8IJG6A��:H><C���HH:B7A6<:�EG68I>8:�6C9�>CI:G;68:H� *>D�9:�"6C:>GD�������CDK:B7GD����

��+,'+��%�����"JCFJ:>G6��2�!&��*JI=� �B1C9<���BAE9D5DEB1C�1@[C����� +bD�(6JAD��(:GHE:8I>K6���

��+-$,�6K>9� �CIG:K>HI6 :B�������E6G6�G8=�6>AN =IIE�LLL�6G8=96>AN�8DB�����69�>CI:GK>:LH�=6C>�G6H=>9�6HNBEIDI:�6G8=>I:8IJG:

�'$$!&��*���GB>C� �CX�3?>CDBEX1>�<?C�9>;1C� �D8=676B76�N�$6�(6O��$DH�6B><DH��:A�A>7GD�����

�'-,!&�,�� ":6C�(>:GG:� �>DB?@?<?791� 4?� 'B?:5D?�� �6� :9�� ,G69JfbD(6IGj8>6�=>IIDC>� *6BDH�(DGID��A:<G:���9>IDG6�GIB:I�����

�*-���&��DDH?:�.6C� �B1>;�&���58BI��$EC5?��E775>859>���9<21?����

�-+� ���@>@D� �<��BD5�45�<1�$1AE5D1��BAE9D53D[>931�%gM>8D��JHI6KD��>A>�������

�-+� ���@>@D� +85��BD�?6�D85��1BD5�4? $?4?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1

��%('+����2����A7:GID� '5>C1B�3?>�<1C�=1>?C��J:CDH��>G:H��&D7J@D�����

��*+�$������A`K>D�9:�$:BDH� �>C9>?�45�@B?:5D?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1��E=1�F9CS?�3?>CDBED9F9CD1��:AD� DG>ODCI:��&o8A:D�9:�(lH��G69J6fbD�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6���H8DA6�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�96�-�%���������>HH:GI6fbD��%:HIG69D�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6��

Page 325: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 293

��*.�$ '� *6BDC +>AK6 � * �!&��&,2� (6JAD �;DCHD� �DCIG>7J>fn:H 96 (lH� �G69J6fbD� &5>C9>9?�45��BAE9D5DEB1�45�@B?:5D9?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1� !C���C6>H�9D�!�+:B>C`G>D�+D7G:��CH>CD�:(:HFJ>H6�:B�(GD?:ID�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6��(GD?:I6G � ���&6I6A��DJIJ7GD�9:�� �

��*,��-��%>8=:A�9:����:8DCDB>6�:H8G>IJGjHI>86��!C����>CK:CfbD�9D�8DI>9>6CD�� q �GI:H�9:;6O:G�����:9��(:IGlEDA>H��*"��.DO:H����� ���*,��-��DE��8>I��E������

� !&�� �� �GFJ>I:IJG6� �?B=1� �C@139? 5 &B45=� +bD (6JAD� %6GI>CH �DCI:H ����

�'$$�*�+��"JA>D�*6BDH �*'(+�����������6CD����H:I���!^B>�,DJ?> $5DP6?B1C�@1B1�?3?D9491>? =IIE�LLL�K>IGJK>JH�8DB�7GG:K>HI6HG:699GDEH�������

�'%�+���6GADH��9J6G9D��>6H�:I6AA>� 'B?:5D?��BAE9D5D\>93? � 49C39@<9>1�5=�3B9C5� 49C39@<9>1�5=B5>?F1US?��+bD�(6JAD��(GD?:ID�������

�'&+�$�2�� $DG:COD� $1AE5D1C�� #1� B5@B5C5>D139[>� 45<� 5C@139?� 5>� 5<� @B?I53D?1BAE9D53D[>93?�%gM>8D���9��JHI6KD�>A>����

555555555555 $1AE5D5C��1�B5@B5C5>D1US?�4?�5C@1U?�>?�@B?:5D?�1BAE9D5D\>93?� �9��JHI6KD��>A>���6G8:ADC6�����

�''#��(:I:G��$A:L:AANC�"DC:H��*DH>:�%5G�*@9B9D�9>��B389D53DEB5�&1��*>OODA>�������

�'*'&��%�*,!&�2���A;DCHD� �>C1I?�C?2B5�5<�@B?I53D?���J:CDH��>G:H���(��������

555555555555�>C19?�C?2B5�?�@B?:5D?���G6HjA>6��:9��-&�����

555555555555�B9C5�5�B5>?F1US?�>?�5>C9>?�45�@B?:5D?�5=�1BAE9D5DEB1� !C���'%�+���6GADH�DG<���(GD?:ID�6GFJ>I:IDC>8D��9>H8>EA>C6�:B�8G>H:��9>H8>EA>C6�:B�G:CDK6fbD��+b�(JAD��(GD?:ID������

��$� *!'�� .>8:CI:� �DG<��� �BAE9D5DEB1�� @5CAE9C1� �� @B?:5D?�� *>D� 9:� ?6C:>GD� (*'�*)�� (GD�9>IDG:H�������

�'*�$�+���>AAD� �<?79?�41�45C1B=?>91� $>H7D6���9>fn:H���������

�-�*,�� �� :I 6A� & <E71B 4? @B?:5D? >? 5>C9>? 5 >1 @5CAE9C1 5= 1BAE9D5DEB1 5 EB21>9C=?�*>D 9: "6C:>GD� �DCIG686E6� ���

�-&&��&>8@� $1AE5D1C�45��BAE9D53DEB1���6G8:ADC6��AJB:�����

�� �&!)-��� %6G8>6A� $?45<?C�� E>1� 49C3EC9[>�� >� c#1� 5CDBE3DEB1� 45<� 5C@139?� EB21>?��6G8:ADC6���9���JHI6KD��>A>�������

�+� �*�%���� $�����C385B � 7B1FEB1C�5�45C5>8?C� +bD�(6JAD��(6>H6<:B��>HIG>7J>9DG6�9:$>KGDH�$I96�����

��*'$$�!� �B>A>D���.�,,',!�%6G>6�(>A6G� �9P<?7?C�45��BAE9D5DEB1� +bD�(6JAD��+>8>A>6CD�������

��**�$$1��$DGG6>C:� +V3>931C�45�)5@B5C5>D139[>� �E>41=5>D?C�45��BAE9D53DEB1����6G8:ADC6��(GDBDEG:HH����

Page 326: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 294

5555555555�E>41=5>D?C�41��BAE9D5DEB1� (DGID��A:<G:�

�DD@B6C�����

5555555555 �92E:?�@1B1�5<�49C5Z?�EB21>?� �6G8:ADC6����AJB:������

��**�!*����JG:A>D��J6GFJ:�9:� DA6C96� �939?>PB9?��EB5<9?�41�#9>7E1�'?BDE7E5C1

�!+ �*��,=DB6H� )5F9C9D9>7�D85��9C39@<9>5�?6��B389D53DEB5� >C�,=: 9>H8>EA>C:�D;�6G8=>I:8IJG:�%>CC:6EDA>H��-�D;�%>CC:HDI6�(G:HH�����

�$Z*!'��/>AHDC� �1� )5@B5C5>D1US?� N� *9=E<1US?� >6?7BP6931� 4?C� �C@1U?C� �BAE9D5D\>93?C �

�>HH:GI6fbD� 9:� %:HIG69D�� �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� -G76C>HBD� 96� -C>K:GH>969:(G:H7>I:G>6C6�%68@:CO>:��+bD�(6JAD�������

55555555555 &� @?D5>391<� 45� 3B91US?� 45� 6?B=1C� 3?=@<5H1C� 1DB1FVC� 41C� 65BB1=5>D1C� 45=?45<175=�DB949=5>C9?>1<��C5E�9=@13D?�>1�6?B=E<1US?�45�E=1�>?F1�3?>35@US?�45�5C@1U?5=� 1BAE9D5DEB1� �M6B:� 9:� FJ6A>;>86fbD� ��DJIDG6C9D� :B� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� -G76C>HBD� �-C>K:GH>969:�9:�+bD�(6JAD� ���

�'�+,�*� :>COKDC�-9CS?53?>8539=5>D?�49C6E>U]5C45C57E>41?B45=�!C�+� &!,%�&������DG<���&DKDHE6G69><B6H�8JAIJG6:HJ7?:I>K>969:�(DGID�A:<G:��GI:H%g9>86H������EE�������

�*�%(,'&�� #:CC:I=�� #'$�'/+#!� +>AK>6� 451� 1C =?45<� &:L� 1DG@�� !CHI>IJI:� ;DG�G8=>8I:8IJG:�6C9�-G76C�+IJ9>:H*>OODA>�������������E�

�*!��%�� %>A9G:9+�� �� *1�� �G6C@� '�� +'*#!&�� %>8=6:A��58BI� +1<;C�� �B389D53DEB5� �'B?35CC�&:L�1DG@��-C>K:GH:(J7A>H=JC<� ����� �E�

�-"!'#���(6JAD�16HHJ96� $1AE5D5C�>? 5>C9>?�45��9CD[B91�41��BAE9D5DEB1��5H@5B9W>391C�455CDP79?�45�5>C9>?�>1���,,*'�(Z+ � *:K>HI6�9D�(GD<G6B6�9:�(lH��G69J6fbD�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6:�-G76C>HBD�96���--+(� +bD�(6JAD��C�����E��������?JC�����

��*�&�*�� :A:C������� �BD�D8B?E78�D85��75C� 6G8DJGI���G68:�6C9�/DGA9�

��*�!��� �A`J9>6�� �%Y*!�'�� �A>:A� 'B?:5D?� 45� 1BAE9D5DEB1� <9>7E175=� 5� 5H@B5CCS?�� E=1=5D?4?<?791� 45� @B?:5D?� (GD?:I6G� �� q !!� +:B>C6G� >C� ,:68=>C<� 6C9� *:H:6G8=� 6C9�G8=>I:8IJG6A� �:H><C�� �HH:B7A6<:�� EG68I>8:� 6C9� >CI:G;68:H� *>D� 9: "6C:>GD�� ����� CDK:B7GD���

�� *1���G6C@��B389D53DEB5�@B?35CC���58BI�D1<;C�&:L�1DG@���*>OODA>�����

��*#�&��%6G<�JC9�(6GIC:G� 451�1>4�$?45<�%:>C=6G9�K���:G@6C�>C�8DDE:G6I>DC�L>I=�"6C�H8=:�6C9��:GC9�(6HIJH8=@6�������

�!��!&�+���D7�6C9� DGC:��%6G<6G:I� �BD9CDKC� =@B5CC9?>C�9>��B389D53DEB1<��5C97>�+EDC(G:HH�����

�'�$��.� *;5D385C�?6�+8?E78D ��,=:�%!,�(G:HH���6B7G>9<:��%��������

Page 327: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 295

�'%�+�� %6NG6� *��� 65BB1=5>D1� G9;9� E=1� 5H@5B9W>391� @5417[7931�� !C�� �&���'%� �� q�lGJB�&68>DC6A� :B��:;:H6� 96�)J6A>969:� 9D� �CH>CD�9:� �DBJC>86fbD�� ��� ���-+(�� +bD(6JAD�

�'*�'&�� "�� ��+85� %5G� *395>35� ?6� *DB?>7� $1D5B91<C� $DC9DC�� (G>C8:IDC� -C>K:GH>IN� (G:HH(:C<J>C��DD@H�������

�*!&��*���"6>B:� ����CDE49?C45<�C@139?� �Q�:9�����-�-����J:CDH��>G:H�����-�-������

5555555555555� �0��L&*�����)(, +��+,)�*� �`I:9G6��G>C7:G<�68JA969�9: �GFJ>I:8IJG6��Q�:9���J:CDH��>G:H���A�6JIDG������

�-��!'&���%6G<=:G>I6� 0181�1494� �Q��9��%>A6C��%DII6��������E�

!*'&+��G:9:G>8���+85�EC5�?6�*31<5�$?4<C��(I�!��(:C8>A�(D>CIH��CDK:B7:G�����

!*'&+� �G:9:G>8��� � -*��&�$$!����A>H6 �!�13��.0/��*/0%010!�+"��!/%#*

�+(1)!���� !��!/%#*�0%+*�(%/0� &:L�1DG@��&�1��� $6C9B6G@H(G:H:GK6I>DC�DBB>HH>DC���9�$6C9B6G@H(G:H:GK6I>DC�DBB>HH>DC� ���������E�

'$$�+I:K:C� ,!�&�&� "JHH>�$EC5E=�?6�3?>D5=@?B1BI�1BD�85<C9>;9��"91C=1� �6A>;lGC>6�%JH:JB�D;��DCI:BEDG6GN��GI�6C9�,=:��>CC>H=��J>A9>C<��:CI:G�$I9������� ���E�

'-�!++���CImC>D� �939?>1B9?��?E19CC�41�#9>7E1�'?BDE7E5C1� +bD�(6JAD���9>IDG6�'7?:I>K6����

!+'$�!�� *DH>A6>C:� �C9Gg� �� 'BPD931� 4?� �>C9>?� 45� 'B?:5D?� 5� 1� �?>CDBEUS?� 4?C� *125B5C� 4?'B?65CC?B��BAE9D5D?� (GD?:I6G �� q !!�+:B>C6G�>C�,:68=>C<�6C9�*:H:6G8=�6C9��G8=>I:8IJG6A�:H><C���HH:B7A6<:��EG68I>8:�6C9�>CI:G;68:H��*>D�9:�"6C:>GD�������CDK:B7GD����

"�&#���*DA;� �B389D53DEB1<�=?45<C� &:L�1DG@���G8=>I:8IJG6A��DD@�(J7���D�������

"��#+'&�� �A7:GI�� ��1�� �6K>9� $1>E1<� 45� $?45<9C=?� %69G>9�� :GB6CC�AJB:� �9>8>DC:H�

����� ��E�

"'*�!'����?>D5=@?B1BI�B389D53DC������E��� �

#�((�� +>A@:�� r$1D5B91<� �6?B=1<�b� 5=� >D5B@B5D1B� �BAE9D5DEB1�� CD�� ��� KDA�� ��=IIE�LLL�6GF�J;B<�7G>6��9:O:B7GD�9:���

#�,�#-*��� (6JA6� &� 5>C9>?� 4?� @B?:5D?� 45� 1BAE9D5DEB1� �DJIDG69D � �68JA969:� 9:�GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD�96�-C>K:GH>969:�9:�+bD�(6JAD��+bD�(6JAD��� �

5555555555555&�@B?35CC?�4?�@B?:5D?�1BAE9D5D\>93?� �>HH:GI6fbD�9:�%:HIG69D�� �68JA969:9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD�96�-C>K:GH>969:�9:�+bD�(6JAD��+bD�(6JAD�������

#!&��*+$�1����� �939?>PB9?�-9CE1<�41��BAE9D5DEB1����� �

Page 328: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 296

#ADIO� :>CG>8=� �B?=�*D?>5�175�8ED�D?�*;IC3B1@5B��:JIH8=:H�G8=>I:AIJGBJH:JB���G6C@;JGI6B %6>C�

#&'$$��/DA;<6C<� �B389D53DEB1<�$?45<C��3?>CDBE3D9?>�D538>9AE5C� &:L�1DG@��%8�I6L� >AA���� �

#&'$$�� /DA;<6C<� �� �� !&��*�� %6GI>C� $1AE5D1C� 45� �BAE9D53DEB1�� +V3>931C� I�?>CDBE339[>� �9��JHI6KD��>A>��%gM>8D�������

�������������$1AE5D5C �BAE9D5D\>931C� +bD�(6JAD��%6GI>CH��DCI:H���

#- &��,=DB6H� +85�CDBE3DEB5�?6�C395>D9693�B5F?<ED9?>C���=>86<D��-�D;��=>86<D�(G:HH������

#-**�&,�� �G>:9G>8=�*31<5� =?45<C� 8?EC5C� ?6� D85� �D8 35>DEBI��6H:A�� �DHIDC�� �:GA>C��>G@=dJH:G�������

$��'%���� '8I6K>D� $>B6� %:C9:H� &� 'B?:5D?� 3?=?� �5C3?25BD1�� �>1<?791�� �917B1=1��H@5B9=5>D1US?� (GD?:I6G� �� q !!� +:B>C6G� >C� ,:68=>C<� 6C9� *:H:6G8=� 6C9� �G8=>I:8IJG6A�:H><C���HH:B7A6<:��EG68I>8:�6C9�>CI:G;68:H� *>D�9:�"6C:>GD�������CDK:B7GD����

$�%��*,��(=NAA>H� $95C�9>��=5B931� &:L�1DG@� �9� �7G6BH�����

$�&� ���"DJ7:GI�EGD;:HHDG�:�E:HFJ>H69DG�96�-+( �-C>K:GH>969:�9:�+bD�(6JAD����CIG:K>HI6�CD%���>C6J<JG6fbD�96�:MEDH>fbD�-B 9:H:C=D�E6G6�A:G�(6AA69>D�

$�&�!��+:76HI>bD�����DBEhC9>D�9:�B6FJ:I6G>6��(DfDH�9: �6A96H���DCI:H�96�.>96����

$�(-�*,���"DH:E�%6G>6� �<��B?AE9C��'B?I53D?�I��BAE9D53DEB1���6G8:ADC6��+8>CI>AA6�>K>C>I6I>H

$�*�� �:GC6C9D� %�*)-�+� +DC>6� (GD?:I6G� �5C169?C 5 3?>AE9CD1C 41 @5CAE9C1 5 4? 5>C9>?45 @B?:5D?�*>D 9: "6C:>GD� �9>IDG6 .>GIJ6A �>:CIj;>86� � �

$�*��� �:GC6C9D� �� �!$�� �A6 >49C39@<9>5�� 1>�B389D53DEB1<�9<5==1d��>B:CH>DCHKDA� ��� �CC�G7DG��,��-(����

$�/+'&���GN6C� �?G�45C97>5BC�D89>;�D85�45C9>7�@B?35CC�45=ICD96954� 'M;DG9���G8=>I:8IJG6A(G:HH����

$��, �*��**'/���6K>9 �B389D53DEB5� 9C� 9DC� ?G>� 49C39@<9>5�� ,=:� 9>H8>EA>C:� D;� 6G8=>I:8IJG:�%>CC:6EDA>H��-�D;�%>CC:HDI6�(G:HH�����

$��W.*�� )?4B97?��B?D5B?� %?D1C�45�E=��CDE4?�C?2B5�&2:5D9F?C�4?��>C9>?�41��BAE9D5DEB1�5$59?C�@1B1�1D9>79�<?C�5=�+B121<8?�45�'B?:5D?� +bD (6JAD����-�-+(��H�96I6�

$�!,���%6G>6��BgA>6��������s��O:K:9>� &�5>C9>?�45�D53>?<?791�5=�1BAE9D5DEB1�5�EB21>9C=?�+bD�(6JAD����--+(���������>HH:GI6fbD�9:�%:HIG69D�

$'%%�$���� ���BD5�'BV��9CD[B931�5�'B9=9D9F1��$>KG6G>6�"DHg�'ANBE>D��9>IDG6��+bD�(6JAD� �����

Page 329: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 297

$'(�+�� "DG<:� &� EC?� 45� =?45<?C� DB949=5>C9?>19C� >?� 45C5>F?<F9=5>D?� 45@B?:5D?C� -�*"�'((����C6>H�9D�(����:H><C����KDA���E� ��� ���

$\�,#����JG@=6G9��#*���+�%6GI>C��.'&�(!�*+��CC:II:�%pAA:G�JC9�/6AI:G���������

�������������������������������������������������� �Q�:9���:GA>B���JG@=6G9$p9I@:���� � �E�

%����'���������

%� �-2���9HDC�96��JC=6� &�@B?:5D?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1�5�CE1� 9>C5BUS?�>1�@[C�7B14E1US?� !C��GFJ>I:MIDH q (:G>l9>8D� B:CH6A� 9:� I:MIDH� 9:� 6GFJ>I:IJG6� 3'CA>C:4� �>HEDCjK:A� :BLLL�K>IGJK>JH�8DB�7G6GFJ>I:MIDH6GF��76H:H I:M�6HE�����

5555555555555555�>C19?� C?2B5� 1� B1JS?� 3?=@?C9D9F1�� .>fDH6�� -�.�� �:AD� DG>ODCI:���(��JAIJG6A������

%�$�*��� %6G>6� $J8>6��� �F1<91US?� >?� �>C9>?� 4?� 'B?:5D?� 45� �BAE9D5DEB1� 5� ,B21>9C=?�'B?2<5=1C� 5� �9693E<4145C�(GD?:I6G� �� q !!� +:B>C6G� >C� ,:68=>C<� 6C9� *:H:6G8=� 6C9�G8=>I:8IJG6A� �:H><C�� �HH:B7A6<:�� EG68I>8:� 6C9� >CI:G;68:H� *>D� 9:� "6C:>GD�� ����� CDK:B7GD���

%�$$�*�.��� 6GGN� �G6C8>H�� �''�%�&�� �6K>9��>� >DB?4E3D9?>� D?� �B389D53DEB1<� +85?BI������D?�D85�'B5C5>D� �Q��9���9 "D=C�/>A:N��+DCH����������E

55555555555 �9>3?�D5HD?C�C?2B5��BAE9D5DEB1���:AD� DG>ODCI:���9>IDG6�-�%������

%�*)-�+��+���$6G6���� 'B?:5D1B��45C169?C�5�3?>AE9CD1C�41�@5CAE9C1�5�4?�5>C9>?�45�@B?:5D?�*>D�9:�"6C:>GD��� �

%�*,!&�2�� �A;DCHD� �DGDC6� �<� @B?2<5=1� 45<� =?45<?� 5=� <1� 5>C5Z1>J1� 45� @B?I5D?� +:G>:�GFJ>I:8IJG6�N�-G76C>HBD�C�����J:CDH��>G:H����-��-C>K:GH>969�9:��:A<G6CD��H9�

5555555555� �>C19?�C?2B5�?�@B?:5D?���G6HjA>6��-&�����

%�,-*�&��� JB7:GID� &>D?<?791�41 B51<94145� %>C6H��:G6>H��-�%�������

%�1&���,=DB��+.,$+/%/ +1>75>DC�1>4�&EDD1;5C�$DC9DC���GI:B>H�.:GA6<H�������� �

%�!*�$$�+�����*��%DG:II>� � �?>359DE1US?�41��CDBEDEB1�5=�'B?:5D?C�45��BAE9D5DEB1��DB1FVC45�$?45<?C�(GD?:I6G �� q !!�+:B>C6G� >C�,:68=>C<�6C9�*:H:6G8=�6C9��G8=>I:8IJG6A��:H><C��HH:B7A6<:��EG68I>8:�6C9�>CI:G;68:H� *>D�9:�"6C:>GD�������CDK:B7GD����

%�&��+����*'� ���(6JAD�$1AE5D5C�45�'1@5<��+bD�(6JAD���DH68��&6>;N�����

%�&��',,'��"DHg�$J>O���*�-"'��,:G:O6��G>HI>C6�%6AK:>G6�9:� &�45C5>8?�4979D1<��+V3>931��1BD5���R�:9��*>D�9:�"6C:>GD��!CI:G8>hC8>6��K������ ��E���

%>AADC�� :CGN����%6<C6CD$6BEJ<C6C>��.>IIDG>D� ?�%*�/�%)!*0+� ���.1*!((!/�$%��

�%�$!(�*#!(+@� �DBE>6C>��%>A`C�������

Page 330: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 298

%!$$'&�� :CGN��� +B9?=@85C 4E��1B?AE5��#b�B389D53DEB5�5>��EB?@5���������Y9>I>DCH 6O6C��(6GjH�������

%!$$�*�����(DEE:G *5<53D9?>C��'B9>35D?>��'B9>35D?> -C>K:GH>IN�(G:HH�������

%!$$+� �G>H �� 'B?:5D1>4? 3?= =1AE5D5C� � :9� (DGID �A:<G:���DD@B6C� ���

5555555555 �5C97>9>7�G9D8 $?45<C����*DE49?��E945�D?��B389D53DEB1<�'B?35CC�$?45<C� Q��9�"D=C�/>A:N��+DCH�����������E�

%'&�'��*6;6:A� >AE95D9E4�D5[B931�I��CDB1D5791�'B?I53DE1<�5>�<1�?2B1�45�?38?�1BAE9D53D?C3?>D5=@?BP>5?C���6G8:ADC6���8I6G����

555555555555+85?B5D931<�1>H95DI 1>4�45C97>�CDB1D5795C�9>�D85�G?B;�?6�5978D�3?>D5=@?B1BI1B389D53DC�%!,�(G:HH��$DC9G:H�6B7G>9<:�����

%'&,�&�*��"��%6G>6� �5@?9C�4?�=?F9=5>D?�=?45B>?���GFJ>I:IJG6�96�H:<JC96�B:I69:�9DHg8JAD�00���6G8:ADC6���JHI6KD��>AA>�����

5555555555555*9CD5=1C�1BAE9D53D?>93?C�3?>D5=@?BQ>5?C���6G8:ADC6���JHI6KD��>AA>���

%'&2Y�$!'�� YA>9:� &� 45C5>8?� 3?>D1� E=1� 89CD[B91� *:K>HI6� +>CDEH:�� +bD� (6JAD�� �MEDH>fbD�HE:8>6A�%:BlG>6��E������������

%''&�#6G:C� $?45<9>7�$5CC175C��+85��B389D53D�1>4�D85�$?45<��Q��9��&:L�1DG@��,=:%DC68:AA>�(G:HH����� ��E�

%'*�$�+�� ��� $� #1C� 31C1C� 45<� 1<=1 ������� ���� > ��� ����� +� �!*0.+� !� �1(01.�

�+*0!),+.7*!�� !� ��.�!(+*� � ��05(+#+�� �6G8:ADC6�� �JC968>lC�6?6� 9:� �GFJ>I:8IDH�� ������6I`AD<D�96�:MEDH>fbD�

%'**!+��%6G@� $?45<C��1B389D53DEB5 1>4�D85�=9>91DEB5���Q��9��"D=C�/>A:N��869:BN�����

����E�

%'-*'��$J>O�%6CJ:A�9DH�&��5C5>8?�5=��5>1� -C>K:GH>969:�9:�$>H7D6���68JA969:�9:��:A6H

�GI:H���>HH:GI6fbD�9:�%:HIG69D�

&����� *:<>C6 %6OOD86ID� $1AE5D5C 5 $9>91DEB1C� +bD (6JAD� �>O �9>IDG>6A� ���

&���$���GC:HI� +85�*DBE3DEB5�?6�*395>35���6B7G>9<:�� 68@:II�(J7��D������

&�+�!, ��#6I:� ,=1�>?F1�175>41�@1B1�1�1BAE9D5DEB1��+bD�(6JAD���DH68&6>;N�����

&'&�$$��"D6C��6HH:<D96� �>D?>9��1E49� �9� .6AA:88=>����������E�

&'*��*��+� -$2����=G>HI>6C� )??DC ?6�$?45B>��B389D53DEB5� ,D@ND��������E�����

'�#%�&�� "D6C�� t+?G1B4C� 1� +85?BI� ?6� %?B=1D9F5� �B389D53DEB5u� >C +85� 1B389D53DEB5� ?65F5BI41I��&:L�1DG@��(G>C8:IDC��G8=>I:8IJG6A�(G:HH�������

Page 331: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 299

'*,����1���++�,��"DHg� )5F9CD1�45�?33945>D5 ���E���:9>IDG6 %69G>9����6AD�+`:O����� ��������9>fbD;DGBH6ID� (:G>l9>8D��G:K>HI6 ��(:G>l9>8D����HE6C=DA

'+/�$����CH<6G� �B389D53DEB1<$?45<C��Q�:9���9>IDG6$>C@H!CI:GC6I>DC6A� ������E��:9>8>DC�:HE6C=DA6��6G8:ADC6����

(�$$�+%����"J=6C>-DA:K>� #?C�&:?C�45�<1�'95<���9>IDG>6A��JHI6KD�(>A>� �6G8:ADC6����

(�+�-�$�!�%!*Z���K6����*�'&�*'��(::G:(:9G:GD���'��*� ��*>86G9(:9G:GD�$1AE5D9C=?�BAE9D53D[>93?��#1C�+V3>931C�45<$1AE5D9C=?�45�@B5C5>D139[>5H@E5CD1C�3?=B97?B�I�3<1B9414��Q�:9� �6G8:ADC6��(6GG6BlC���������E�

(�.+&�*��&>@DA6JH� c$?45B>��B389D53DEB5�1>4�D85�89CD?B91>��?B�D85�B5DEB>�?6�89CD?B939C=u�"DJGC6A�D;�I=:�*DN6A�!CHI>IJI:�D;��G>I>H=��G8=>I:8IH��������E�� ����

(�*�2��-�**�+�� *D7:GID� �BAE9D53DEB1� �?>35@DE1<�� 3B51D9F9414�� 45D1<<5� �6G8:ADC6�!CHI>IJID�%DCH6�9:��9>8>DC:H�����

(�*�2� '1�*2-&�� ��� �*�.�&�� %'*!��� ��� )-!&,�&!$$�� � �$��� "� #?C� 8538?C� 45<11BAE9D53DEB1��+6CI>6<D�9D��=>A:���9>8>DC:H��*)�����

(�**'&���*������JC=6���'&,�+��(��(� �CDE4?�C?2B5�E=�>?F?�=?45<?�494PD93? � ��5C3?<1�41394145�45�*S?�'1E<?�(GD?:I6G��� q !!�+:B>C6G�>C�,:68=>C<�6C9�*:H:6G8=�6C9��G8=>I:8IJG6A�:H><C���HH:B7A6<:��EG68I>8:�6C9�>CI:G;68:H� *>D�9:�"6C:>GD�������CDK:B7GD����

5555555555555555555&� 5>C9>?�� C?2B5� 1� 3?=@<5H94145� 5� ?� 1D?� 45� @B?:5D1B� +:B>C`G>D�CH>CD��GFJ>I:IJG6�-G76C>HBD����:9��+bD�(6JAD����-��-+(������K�����E�

(*�&� (:I:G���� &'*��*��+� -$2� �=G>HI>6C��$!��+#!&�� �6C>:A��B389D53DEB5�?6�'?5D93$?F5=5>D�%��=?>?7B1@8�(6E696@>H�(J7A>H=:G������������E�

%:GA:6J�(DCIN:B�$!��%/%�(!��* �0$!��*2%/%�(! �������

)-�,�$�+�� "DH:E� �C3E5<1C� 45� �BAE9D53DEB1�!C� �*0!.*!0� �.�$%0!�01.!� �+*! 3'C� A>C:4�>HEDCjK:A:B�=IIE�LLL��>6O�8DB

*���!�&&!��*>86G9D��(-((!��$>DC:AAD���-!$$�*%'��"68FJ:H� $1AE5DD5���%_=5B?

$?>?7B1693?49)1CC57>1��>G:IDG:�.>IDG>D��G:<DII>��>8:B7G:����� � C�� ����Q��9�%>A6C�

��!�(�!��������������E�

*��,2#���&>C6� �CIG:K>HI6�9:�8DB�D�8JG69DG�96��MEDH>fbD�'A>K:G��AH:G�

*�!+���CImC>D�,� )5@5BD[B9?���>P<9C5�5�*X>D5C5��,=1� >DB?4EUS?�1?�'B?:5D? �BAE9D5D\>93?�(DGID��A:<G:��-C>K:GH>969:��:9:G6A�9D�*>D��G6C9:�9D�+JA�����

*�!+�� #:AAN� ,=1� 5H@5B9W>391� 45� @B?:5D?� 3?=� W>61C5� >1� =?45<175=� =1>E1<�,G676A=D� 9:�DC8AJHbD�9:��JGHD���G69J6fbD�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD� � �:CIGD�-C>K:GH>I`G>D�%DJG6$68:G96� ���

Page 332: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 300

* �!&��&,2� (6JAD� *=:>C<6CIO� �C6� & 5>C9>? 45 @B?:5D?� 5C@1U? 45 14=9B1US?� 1=295>D545 9>D5B1US?� !C �C6>H 0. �C8DCIGD &68>DC6A HD7G: D �CH>CD 9: �GFJ>I:IJG6 : -G76C>HBD �&+��� �6BED �G6C9:� ����� ����� E� ������ �

*'�!&+'&��"JA>6���(!',*'/+#!� �C9GO:?� +85�49C39@<9>5�?6�1B389D53DEB5��%>CC:6EDA>H��-�D;%>CC:HDI6�(G:HH�����

*'���*+��(�����*��&������%8�'/&����� ,C9>7�3?>35@D�C;5D385C�D?�DB13;�45C97>�@B?7B5CC��:H><C�+IJ9>:H�.DA����&D���+:EI:B7:G����EE����������

*'2�+,*�,�&���GIJG� �CDE4? C?2B5�1��9CD[B91�4?C�$?45<?C��BAE9D5D\>93?C�>1��>D97E94145 ��>HH:GI6fbD� 9:�%:HIG69D�� �68JA969:� 9:� �GFJ>I:IJG6� :� -G76C>HBD� 96� -C>K:GH>969:� 9:� +bD(6JAD��+bD�(6JAD��� �

555555555555555$?45<175=�=1>E1<�3?=?�9>CDBE=5>D?�45�@B?:5D?� �GFJ>I:MIDH��,:MID�HE:8>6A�:HE��� ���:B�(DGI6A�.>IGJK>JH������3'CA>C:4��>HEDCjK:A�:B=IIE�LLL�K>IGJK>JH�8DB�7G6GFJ>I:MIDH6GF:HE� ��6HE

55555555555555��93?>?7B1691�4?�@?BD14?B�4?�=?45<?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1�>1�1BD5=5495F1<� �*+� !���0!*;9+ ��� �.%!*0� +. $J>O��BgG>8D�9:�+DJO6�%JC6G>�

5555555555555�CDE4?� C?2B5� 1� 89CD[B91� 4?C� =?45<?C� 1BAE9D5D\>93?C� >1� �>D97`94145�?B975>C� 5� 31B13D5BXCD931C� 41C� @B9=59B1C� =1AE5D5C� 45� 1BAE9D5D?� �*+� !

��0!*;9+ � � �.%!*0� +. $J>O��BgG>8D�9:�+DJO6�%JC6G>

555555555555 )5@B5C5>D1US?� 4?� @B?:5D?� 45� 1BAE9D5DEB1�� E=1� 2B5F5� B5F9CS?� 3BXD931�� (lH�*:K>HI6�9D�(GD<G6B6�9:�(lH��G69J6fbD�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD�96���--+(��K������E������������

555555555555 �?=5>DPB9?C� C?2B5� 1� =?45<175=� DB949=5>C9?>1<� >1� 1BAE9D5DEB1� 7B571� 5B?=1>1� 1>D971C�� �5B[4?D?�� �B9CD[D5<5C� 5� -9DB_F9?�� (lH�� *:K>HI6� 9D� (GD<G6B6� 9:� (lH��G69J6fbD�:B��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD�96���--+(��K������E��������������

5555555555555 �?>C945B1U]5C�C?2B5 1�93?>?7B1691�4?�@?BD14?B�4?�=?45<?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1>1�1BD5�=5495F1<� !C��(GD;6���G6��,:G:O>C=6�'A>K:>G6���'G<�����CI><J>969:�:�%:9>:KD � 'A=6G:H >HIlG>8D��>ADHl;>8DH� 96� �9J86fbD�� � :9�� %6G>C<`�� �9>IDG6� 96� -C>K:GH>969:� �HI69J6A� 9:%6G>C<`������K����E� ��������

55555555555555555 $?45<175=� =1>E1<� 3?=?� 9>CDBE=5>D?� 45� @B?:5D?�LLL�K>IGJK>JH�8DB�7G�����?JC�����

5555555555555555 &�45C5>8?��1�=?45<175=�5�?�49P<?7?��.>IGJK>JH����CDK�����

5555555555555555 $?45<?C� 45� C?<94S?�.>IGJK>JH � -C>K:GHD� E6G6A:AD� 9: �GFJ>I:IJG6� :-G76C>HBD��!CI:GC:I����6<D�����

5555555555555555 $S?C�AE5�=?<41B1=�1�C9�=5C=1C� (DGI6A�.>IGJK>JH � JC>K:GHD�E6G6A:AD9:�6GFJ>I:IJG6�:�JG76C>HBD��!CI:GC:I��K��� ���E��� � �����67G�����

Page 333: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 301

555555555555555�C@53D?C� 41� 89CD[B91� 41C� =1AE5D5C� 5 =?45<?C� DB949=5>C9?>19C� 451BAE9D5DEB1�>?��79D?��>D97?��.>IGJK>JH��GFJ>I:MIDH��+bD�(6JAD��E��� � ������DJI������

55555555555555 �C@53D?C� 41� 89CD[B91� 41C� =1AE5D5C� 5� =?45<?C� DB949=5>C9?>19C� 451BAE9D5DEB1�5=��B5D1�5�>1��BV391��>D971��.>IGJK>JH��GFJ>I:MIDH� +bD�(6JAD��K��� ���E��� � ��� CDK������

55555555555555 �C@53D?C� 41� 89CD[B91� 41C� =1AE5D5C� 5� =?45<?C� DB949=5>C9?>19C� 451BAE9D5DEB1�>?�=E>4?�B?=1>?�.>IGJK>JH��+bD�(6JAD��E��� � ���� �9:O������

55555555555555 )56<5H9?>5C� 135B31� 45<� @1@5<� 45� <1CB5@B5C5>D139?>5C5>5<@B?35C?� 4549C5Z?1BAE9D53D[>93?21C141C5>� 3?>35@D?C� 45� �5>B9� �5B7C?>� I� #E979� '1B5IC?>�� >�� -*9=@?C9?� >D5B>139?>1<�)5@B5C5>D139[>5><1�95>391�I�5>5<��BD5�������$6��6A96���J69:GC>AAD9:�*:HoB:C:H���lG9D76���-&��������K�����E����� �

55555555555555 �� 9=175=� 4?� @?BD14?B� 4?� =?45<?� >1� 1BD5� =5495F1<�� !C�� !� �C8DCIGD&68>DC6A� 9:� �HIJ9DH� 96� !B6<:B�� ���� $DC9G>C6�� �69:GCD� 9:� *:HJBDH� 9D� !� �C8DCIGD&68>DC6A�9:��HIJ9DH�96�!B6<:B��$DC9G>C6���-�$������E��������

55555555555555��93?>?7B1691�4?�@?BD14?B�4? =?45<?�5�?� 9=179>PB9?�=5495F1<�135B31�413B91US?�5�4?�@B?:5D?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1� !C��!0��>8AD�9:��HIJ9DH��CI><DH�:�%:9>:K6>H � �DGB6H�9:E:CH6G�C6��CI><J>969:�:�C6�!969:�%g9>6�������G6C86�+(���DGB6H�9:�(:CH6G�C6��CI><J>969::�C6�!969:�%g9>6���G6C86���&��%� ����K����

555555555555 �?>C945B1U]5C�C?2B5�1�93?>?7B1691�4?�@?BD14?B�4?�=?45<?�>1�1BD5�=5495F1<�!C��.!� "DGC696�9:��HIJ9DH��CI><DH�:�%:9>:K6>H�� ����%6G>C<`���69:GCD�9:� G:HJBDH�96�.!"��%��%6G>C<`����JC96fbD��G6J8`G>6�����

5555555555555 �?>C945B1U]5C C?2B5� 1� 697EB1� @?BD1>4?�?�=?45<?�45� 1BAE9D5DEB1� >1� 1BD5=5495F1<� !C�� !!� �C8DCIGD� 9:� >HIlG>6� 96� �GI:�� ���� �6BE>C6H�� �C6>H� 9D� !!� �C8DCIGD� 9: >HIlG>6�96��GI:�����

*-�!&'&!��%6CD:A6�*DHH>C:II>� %?F?C�5�F5<8?C�45C169?C�>?�5>C9>?�45�@B?:5D?�1BAE9D5D\>93?31=9>8?C� @1B1� 1� 6?B=1US?� 45� E=1� 3?>C39W>391� 3BXD931� 3'CA>C:4� �>HEDCjK:A� :B=IIE�LLL�8:;:IHE���GH>C:G<>6�E��8�=IBA����6EIJG69D�:B����9:�DJIJ7GD�9:����

+�&,'+�� "DG<:�*D7:GID�$DE:H� &�EC?�45�=?45<?C� DB949=5>C9?>19C�>?�45C5>F?<F9=5>D?�45@B?:5D?C� �* �C6>H� 9D� (��� �:H><C� ���� *>D� 9:� "6C:>GD�� -�*"� �'((��� KDA���� *>D� 9:� "6C:>GD������

+� '&���DC6A9��� �5C97>9>7�BE<5C��DI@5C�1>4�G?B<4C���:H><C�+IJ9>:H���6B7G>9<:��%!,�(G:HH������

5555555555�4E31>4?� ?� @B?69CC9?>1<� B56<5H9F?�� E=� >?F?� 45C97>� @1B1� ?� 5>C9>?� 5� 11@B5>49J175=� (DGID��A:<G:���GIB:9����

+!%'&�� ���� �C��9W>391C�4?��BD969391<� +bD�(6JAD���9>IDG6��GBhC>D��B69D�������

Page 334: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 302

+!$.��� �6>GD� �A7JFJ:GFJ:� 96��� 49C39@<9>1� $1AE5D5� >1� )9DD5B� 4?C� )59C�� B5<1D?� 45� E=15H@5B9W>391� �* �69:GCDH�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�*>II:G�9DH�*:>H��(DGID��A:<G:���9>IDG6�*>II:G�9DH�*:>H�K� ��E� ��� �����

+!$.���AK6C� *?2B5�1�B5>?F1US?�4?�3?>359D?@�45�@B?:5D?�1BAE9D5D?>93?�5�CE1�494PD931� !C��'%�+���6GADH��DG<���(GD?:ID�6GFJ>I:ImC>8D�9>H8>EA>C6�:B�8G>H:��9>H8>EA>C6�:B�G:CDK6fbD��+bD(6JAD� (GD?:ID������

+!$.���!$ '��*���� �BAE9D5DEB1�'1BD9>4?�4?C�-?<E=5C�$5D?4?<?791�45�'B?:5D?� �DJIDG69D ��68JA969:�9:��GFJ>I:IJG6�:�-G76C>HBD�96�-C>K:GH>969:�9:�+bD�(6JAD��+bD�(6JAD��� �

+'$��%'*�$�+�� !<C6H>� �9665B5>35C�� D?@?7B1@895C� ?6� 3?>D5=@?B1BI 1B389D53DEB5��6B7G>9<:��%!,�(G:HH�������

+-, �*$�&�� %6GI=6� $?45<=1;9>7� 1 21C93 7E945� &:L 1DG@� /�/� &DGIDC � �DBE6CN� �����

,!�2,��"pG<:C��#DC:B6CC�(J7A>H=:GH�+I6;;�� �9CD?B91�41�1BAE9D5DEB1�4?�CV3E<?�..� �9�#DC:B6CC��������E�

[7:96��A6C8D��%6GI6� #1�=1AE5D1�3?=?�5H@5B95>39145<5C@139?1BAE9D53D[>93?� +:8G:I6G>69D9:�(J7A>868>DC:H�:�!CI:G86B7>D� �9>IDG>6A�-C>K:GH>969�9:�.6AA69DA>9�����

-,2'&�� "DGC� '<1D16?B=� 1>4� '<1D51EC�� 451C� ?6� 1� �1>9C8�B389D53D�� 0?4913�� %>A6C��9>O>DC>�DBBJC>I6����� �����E�

.�*��+�� :A>6C6�DB>C� �>C9>?�@B5>49J175=� 5=� �BAE9D5DEB1� 5� ,B21>9C=?�� $9D?C� 5$VD?4?C� (GD?:I6G� �� q !!� +:B>C6G� >C� ,:68=>C<� 6C9� *:H:6G8=� 6C9� �G8=>I:8IJG6A� �:H><C��HH:B7A6<:��EG68I>8:�6C9�>CI:G;68:H� *>D�9:�"6C:>GD�������CDK:B7GD����

.�+�'&��$'+� �:AHD 9DH +6CIDH� �?>CDBEUS? 4? 3?>8539=5>D? 5= C1<1 45 1E<1��+bD (6JAD�$>7:GI69� �����

.�$'+'��%6jH6����$�$!���A:>8:� �P�<E71B�@1B1�?�@B?:5D?�45�1BAE9D5DEB1�>?C�5CDE4?C�45�@[C�7B14E1US?� LLL�K>IGJK>JH�8DB�7G6GFJ>I:MIDH6GF76H:HI:MID��������

.�*$�����CIDC�(JHI:I� *31<5�$?45<C��>:9G>8=#JGG:CI�������

.!�$�*���CI=DCN� ?�.�$%0!�01.!��%/)!)�!.! @� :B� �$!��.�$%0!�01.�(��*��**4 ��//�4/�%*�0$!�+ !.*��*$+)!(4��,=:�%!,�(G:HH�������

/�$$������DGLDG9��!C�� ' �-+�*��+� �B389D53DEB1<�1>4� >D5B9?B $?45<C��.6C�&DHIG6C9*:>C=DA9��DBE6CN��&:L�1DG@������

/�*&�*�� %:<6C� $?45<� $1;9>7��Q� �9�� &:L� 1DG@�� (G>C8:IDC� �G8=>I:8IJG6A� (G:HH�� ,=:�G8=>I:8IJG:��G>:;�+:G>:H������

/!�# �%��(:I:G�*6NBDC9�$?45<<54�1B389D53DEB5�:9>IDG6� (��%6GH=6AA�������

Page 335: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 303

/!$#!&+'&���6I=:G>C:� �<�>E5F?�@B?65CC9?>1<9C=?5=�5<�)5>1C39=95>D?:B#DHID;���A6GFJ>I:8ID����E�

Page 336: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 304

�$'++S*!'

6GI:;6ID %6CJ;6IJG6� ,G676A=D�B6CJ6A��D7G6�;:>I6�`�BbD�

=`EI>8D ' 69?:I>KD =`EI>8D H><C>;>86��G:A6I>KD�6D�I6ID����H>CmC>BD�9:

I`I>A���:

g�EGDK:C>:CI:�9D <G:<D $�,0%'=/�<�=* �EGlEG>D�E6G6�ID86G�

H:CHjK:A

6D I6ID���Y�D�8DGG:A6ID�I`I>A�96 lEI>86 �E6G6�D�K>HJ6A��:

96 68oHI>86 �E6G6�D�6J9>I>KD���)J:�CbD�DEn:�6DH�lG<bDH�9DH

H:CI>9DH��B6H�FJ:�EG:HHJEn: FJ:�D�DA=D�EDHH6�I:G�JB6

;JCfbD�I`I>A

:�CbD�lI>86��%6>H�G:8:CI:B:CI:��8JC=DJ�H:

:B >C<AhH D HJ7HI6CI>KD $�,0%�/ �FJ:�ED9:�H:G�696EI69D

:B EDGIJ<JhH 8DBD��=`EI>86���E6G6�9:H><C6G�6 8>hC8>6 9D

IDFJ:�

9:9>8696�6�:HIJ96G�:�6�H>BJA6G�6�EG:HHbD��6�I:MIJG6��6

K>7G6fbD�:

DJIG6H�H:CH6fn:H�7>DAl<>86H�G:A68>DC696H�8DB�D�IDFJ:��'JIGD

:M:BEAD�9:��=`EI>86��g�6�86G68I:GjHI>86�K>7G6IlG>6�:��B6>H

G:8:CI:B:CI:��6 G:HEDHI6�I`I>A�96�I:A6��:8Gb� 9DH I:A:;DC:H

8:AJA6G:H�

%6FJ:I:

$1AE5D5�

*:EG:H:CI6fbD�:B�:H86A6�G:9JO>96� �DGB6�9:�G:IG6I6G�:B

I6B6C=D�G:9JO>9D�JB6�D7G6�FJ:�ED9:G`�DJ�9:K:G`�H:G

8DCHIGJj96�

�;G6C8hH)�-1!00!��EG>B:>GD�:H7DfD�

� �H7DfD�:B�E:FJ:C6�:H86A6�:B�IGhH�9>B:CHn:H��9:�:HI`IJ6

DJ�FJ6AFJ:G�D7G6�9:�:H8JAIJG6��BD9:A69D�:B�76GGD��8:G6��DJ

DJIGD�B6I:G>6A�� %D9:AD�G:9JO>9D�9:�JB�:9>;j8>D��9:�JB

8:C`G>D�:I8� (GDIlI>ED�9:�E:FJ:C6H�9>B:CHn:H��BD9:AD

G:9JO>9D�

%>C>6IJG6 *:EG:H:CI6fbD�9:�E:HHD6H�DJ�D7?:IDH�:B�I6B6C=D�G:9JO>9D�

B6H8DI:�

1CompilaçãodosdicionáriosHouaiss e o AurélioBuarque de Holanda e Michaelis.

Page 337: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

P 305

%D9:AD �:�BD9:A6G���*6H8JC=D�:B�;DGB6�IG>9>B:CH>DC6A�9:�JB6

:H8JAIJG6�:HE:8j;>86�

�GFJgI>ED

%6FJ:I:

�� !B6<:B��9:H:C=D�DJ D7?:8ID FJ:�H:GK:�E6G6�H:G�>B>I69D

�9:H:C=6C9D�DJ�:H8JAE>C9D��

�� %DA9:��:M:BEA6G�

� 3�><JG69D4 �D>H6�DJ�E:HHD6�FJ:�g�DJ�B:G:8:�H:G

>B>I696� � �0�%($'

/���#�

�� (:HHD6�FJ:�EDH6�E6G6�6GI>HI6H��H:GK>C9D�9:�BD9:AD�K>KD�

�� (:HHD6�FJ:�I:B�8DBD 68I>K>969: :CK:G<6G�:�6EG:H:CI6G

GDJE6H�DJ�68:HHlG>DH� � %�&�)-!%

BD9:A6G

�)+ !(+�� ��.�

� &���#�

�� )J:�H:GK:�DJ�ED9:�H:GK>G�9:�BD9:AD�DJ�9:

:M:BEAD� � �0�%($�*

2��0.�

�� �6O:G�D�BD9:AD�9:�

� �JC9>G�:B�BDA9:�

�� *:EGD9JO>G�8DB :M68I>9bD �8DE>6C9D�9D�BD9:AD��

�� �DCIDGC6G��9:A>C:6G�DH�8DCIDGCDH�9:�

�� (A6C:6G��9>G><>G��G:<JA6G�

2��,.+*�

�� ,DB6G�EDG�BD9:AD�

�DC;GDCI6G��BD9JA6G�

(GDIlI>ED (G>B:>GD�BD9:AD� :M:BEA6G�B6>H�:M6ID� 6A<D�DJ�EGD9JID�FJ:�

:HI6G�:B�;6H:�9:�I:HI:H�E6G6�6EG>BDG6G��D�FJ:�?`�;D>�;:>ID�:

I6B7gB�D�FJ:�K6>�H:G�EGD9JO>9D�

)J:�I:B�IGhH�9>B:CHn:H� �8DBEG>B:CID��A6G<JG6�:

6AIJG6��)J:�6E6G:CI6�I:G�G:A:KD

Page 338: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G306

���!���;2D<� � �@A?BAB?.��B??60B9.? 1<��B?@<�12 �?>B6A2AB?.�2�)?/.;6@:<�1.

%)��&6<

�B%*(/ �/-&�%"��*2$*0,*." �1?% �B%*(/ �/-&�%"��*2$*0,*." �1?%

�6����7��� �6����7���

ARQ 1000 Introdução à Profissão deArquiteto 2 ARQ 1001 Teoria e História da Arquitetura I 3

ARQ 1101 Introdução ao Projeto 12 ARQ 1102 Projeto do Espaço Residencial I12

ART 1020 Desenho de Observação I 4 ART 1027 Geometria Descritiva 3

ART 1420 Cultura Moderna eContemporânea 4 ART 1028 Desenho de Arquitetura I 3

CRE 1100 O Humano e o FenômenoReligioso 4 ART 1210 Fundamentos da Linguagem Visual

I4

MAT 1071 Matemática do Espaço e dasFormas 2

�6����7��� �6����7���

ARQ 1002 Teoria e História da ArquiteturaII

3 ARQ 1005 Teoria e História da Arquitetura III 3

ARQ 1103 Projeto do Espaço do Trabalho 12 ARQ 1104 Projeto do Espaço Coletivo 12

ART 1029 Desenho de Arquitetura II 3 ART 1030 Desenho de Arquitetura III 3

CIV 1301 Topografia na Arquitetura 2 CRE 0700 Optativas de Cristianismo 4MAT 1072 Cálculo na Arquitetura 3 FIS 1011 Física na Arquitetura I 3

SOC 1139 Estudos Sócio-Antropológicos 2 HIS 1850 História das Cidades 3

�6����7��� 6����7���

ARQ 1003 Urbanismo 4 ARQ 1006 Conforto Ambiental 3

ARQ 1105 Projeto de Revitalização eReutilização

12 ARQ 1106 Projeto Urbano 12

CIV 1111 Sistemas Estruturais naArquitetura I

3 ARQ 1201 Programa Continuado de Estágio I 1

FIS 1012 Aspectos Físicos no ConfortoAmbiental

3 CIV 1112 Sistemas Estruturais naArquitetura II

3

HIS 1430 História da Arquitetura no Brasil 3 CIV 1305 Construção Civil 4

�6����7��� �6����7���

ARQ 1004 Planejamento Urbano e Regional 2 ARQ 1108 Projeto do Espaço Residencial II 12

ARQ 1107 Projeto de Arquitetura Utópica 6 ARQ 1202 Programa Continuado de Estágio II 1

ARQ1111 Projeto de Paisagismo 6 ART 1819 Ergonomia na Arquitetura 2

CIV 1113 Sistemas Estruturais naArquitetura III

3 CRE 1141 Ética Cristã 2

CIV 1324 Instalações Prediais e Urbanas 3 FIL 1815 Estética I 4

�6 ���7��� ��6����7���

ARQ 1109 Proposta do Projeto Final 6 ARQ 1110 Projeto Final 4

CIV 1342 Planejamento e Controle deObras

3 CRE 1158 Ética Profissional 2

CIV 1581 Geotecnia na Arquitetura 3 ECO 1103 Economia (para Arq., Eng. e Des.Ind.)

3

CIV 1715 Meio Ambiente eDesenvolvimento Sustentável

2

LET 1920 Compreensão e Produção doTexto Técnico

2

PERÍODO LETIVO INDETERMINADOACP 0900 Atividades Complementares 6 ELL 0900 Eletivas Livres - Dentro/Fora do Departamento20

�6@06=96;. 6;[email protected]. ;.�A2@2

Page 339: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G307

�;2D< � � ��:X1B9<@�1.�16@06=96;.��;A?<1BRP<�.<�%?<72A<�S�16C6161.

�/%4,/��

���=?2@2;A.RP<�1<�0<;A2[1<�=?<4?.:NA60<�2�1<@�</72A6C<@�1<�0B?@<

����B9.���@A?BAB?.��?N360.���D2?0V06<��%2?@=20A6C.@���6:.42;@

%.92@A?.���2;A?<�1<�&6<

���*6@6A.�.<��2;A?<�1<�&6<

���D2?0V06<��".=.�1<��2;A?<

����D2?0V06<��'<9.?��9.;R.:2;A<�

����B9.��(?.R.1<@�?24B9.1<?2@���@2RP<�NB?2.���D2?0V06<��'<9.? �12@2;C<9C6:2;A<�

����B9.��(?.;@3<?:.RP<�1.��<?:.������56;4���D2?0V06<��'<9.? �12@2;C<9C6:2;A<��

����B9.��$?4.;6F.RP<������56;4� �D2?0V06<��'<9.?��36;.96F.RP<�

����B9.���6?0B9.RP<������56;4���D2?0V06<��@<9.?��2;A?24.�

�B%4,/��

��'2:6;N?6<��56;4���D2?0V06<���<:=<@6RP<�:<1B9.?��9.;R.:2;A<�

���B9.��"<1B9.RP<���D2?0V06<���<:=<@6RP<�:<1B9.?��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<�

����D2?0V06<���<:=<@6RP<�:<1B9.?��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<�

���%<;A<�12�@6AB.RP< \ H�C.96.RP<

���D2?0V06<���<:=<@6RP<�:<1B9.?��36;.96F.RP<�

����.;0.�2;A?24.�1<�2D2?0V06<���<:=<@6RP<�:<1B9.? � �*�!��KI$���#�!

�B%4,/��

����D2?0V06<���D=2?6:2;A.RZ2@

����D2?0V06<���D=2?6:2;A.RZ2@

����B9.���;N96@2�.?>B6A2AY;60.���=?2@2;A.RP<�1<@�2D2:=9<@�

����D2?0V06<���;.96@2�.?>B6A2AY;60.��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<�

����D2?0V06<���;.96@2�.?>B6A2AY;60.��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<�

����D2?0V06<���;.96@2�.?>B6A2AY;60.��36;.96F.RP<�

�����.;0.�.=?2@2;A.RP<�1<�2D2?0V06<�12��;N96@2��?>B6A2AY;60.

�����B9.���;N96@2�1<�A2??2;<���D2?0V06<��%?<72A<�����)��*6@6A.�.<�A2??2;<�

� ���D2?0V06<��%?<72A<�����)��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<����;N96@2�1<�A2??2;<

�����D2?0V06<��%?<72A<�����)��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<����D=2?6:2;A.RZ2@

�����B9.���<;3<?A<��:/62;A.9���D2?0V06<��%?<72A<�����)��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<�

����%<;A<�12�@6AB.RP< \ H��C.96.RP<

�����D2?0V06<��%?<72A<�����)��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<����B9.��".A2?6.6@�:.>B2A2@

�����D2?0V06<��%?<72A<�����)��12@2;C<9C6:2;A<����B9.���2@2;5<�12

.?>B6A2AB?.

����D2?0V06<� %?<72A<�����)��36;.96F.RP<�

����.;0.�.=?2@2;A.RP<�1<�=?<72A<�����) \ �*�!��KI$���#�!���

Page 340: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G308

�;2D<�� � �6/96<4?.36.�=?6;06=.9�2�/6/96<4?.36.�/N@60.�.BD696.?

���!�$�&����%&�#��%�!

�� �&���2<33?2E��� ��$�� � ��������������"����� ��������"�!��!"��� "SD60<���[email protected]<��696�����

�� �&���2<33?2E��� ������" �����"�����$�� ����������� 'P<�%.B9<��".?A6;@��<;A2@������

���#����?.;06@���� � ���"�!�!"������������ ��(���������� 'P<�%.B9<��".?A6;@��<;A2@������

��&(-��&��&���2?:.;� �(*� �������"�!�!"����'P<�%.B9<��".?A6;@��<;A2@������

���!�$�&�����),�!��&$'+�!����;@4.?� ���"�!� �������"�!�!"��� �.?029<;.��!6;8@����

���#����?.;06@���� � ���"���������"�����"�!��!������

���#����?.;06@���� � ���� ��!�(&����$�����������"�!�!"����H��1����1� �<<8:.;��%<?A< �924?2� ��

���#����?.;06@���� � ������$����#� "���������"�!�!"����'%��!6C?.?6.�".?A6;@��<;A2@��16A<?2�!A1.������

�!�& ��&<42?���%�)'���"605.29� ���"�!��!"����!��� ��������� ���)�� �.?029<;.���[email protected]<��696������

"�&(�#�-���3<;@<��<?<;.� �� �����������������!�� �?.@V96.��);6C��12��?.@V96.����

�)##��#608� ���"�!� �������"�!�!"��������� ������ ���������(*� � �.?029<;.���9B:2���

%�����&���B;A2?���&�)#�� ��%2?� �� � ��$!��� �.?029<;.���[email protected]<��696�����

%�����&���B;A2?���&�)#�� ��%2?� �� � �������� � �.?029<;.���[email protected]<��696�����

-�*����?B;<��������#��������"�!�!"����'P<�%.B9<��".?A6;@��<;A2@������

-)"(�$&��%2A2?� ��� ��������"�!�!"��� �[email protected]<��696����

�64B?.�DD��'.9.�12�.B9.���163V06<��.?12.9�!2:2�<;A2���<A<��9.B06.��B4B@A<��<;@20.

�64B?.�DD��'.9.�12�.B9.���163V06<��.?12.9�!2:2�<;A2���<A<��9.B06.��B4B@A<��<;@20.

Page 341: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G309

�;2D<� � &<A26?<�/N@60<�=.?.�%9.;<�12��B9.

��.1.�.B9.�</21202?N�.�B:�=9.;<�2@=20V360<�

��� ��������� � �.A.�

��� � ���������������� $"��

�;@A6AB6RP<�

%?<32@@<?��.��

%?<32@@<?��.��[email protected]?6<��.��

�6@06=96;.�

%2?V<1<�

(B?:.�

���� ��� �

� <�A2:.�2@=20V360<�.�@2?�12@2;C<9C61<�;2@A.�.B9.

� 0<;026A<�3B;1.:2;A.9��?232?T;06.�@B06;A.�12�/.@2�56@A<?6<4?N360.�>B2�@B@A2;A.�<�A2:.

� � ��������� .�@2?2:�.90.;R.1<@ =29<@�.9B;<@�2�;P<�=29<�[email protected]?6<��</72A<@�1.�.C.96.RP<��6A2:�*�����

�#+&3*5/�(&1",��=?<72A.�[email protected]<�42?.9�?29.A6C<�.�2D20BRP<�12�0<;A2[1<@�2�=?<0216:2;A<@

�#+&3*5/2�&20&$@'*$/2��2@=206360.:�[email protected]<@�2@=2?.1<@�</@2?CNC26@��42?.9:2;A2�12���.� ��

$�'���0<:2R.�@2�@2:=?2�0<:�C2?/<@�6;160.A6C<@�12�5./6961.12@�0<:<��=<?�2D2:=9<�

"/� .@5&,� %&� $/.)&$*-&.3/ \ .@@<06.?�� 0<:=.?.?�� 0<;A?.@A.?�� 1236;6?�� 12@0?2C2?�� 1632?2;06.?�� 16@A6;4B6?�

612;A6360.?�� 6;160.?�� 96@A.?�� ;<:2.?�� =.?.3?.@2.?�� ?20<;5202?�� ?2=2A6?�� ?21236;6?�� ?2C6@.?��:<@A?.?�� 0<;@A.A.?�

@B:.?6.?��0<;A.?�

"/�.@5&,�%&�"0,*$"></ \ 0.90B9.?��12:<;@A?.?��A6?.?�<B�2DA?.6?��2:=?24.?��2@A6:.?��1.?�B:�2D2:=9<��69B@A?.?�

9<0.96F.?��:216?��<=2?.?��12@2:=2;5.?��=?2@0?2C2?��?246@A?.?��:<;A.?��2@/<R.?��@<9B06<;.?��A?.R.?��B@.?�

"/�.@5&,�%&�2/,4></�%&�01/#,&-"2 \ .1C<4.?��[email protected].?��2@0<952?��0<:=<?��0<;09B6?��0<;@A?B6?��0?6.?��0?6A60.?�

12/.A2?�� 120616?�� 1232;12?�� 12?6C.?�� 12@2;5.?�� 3<?:B9.?�� 6;32?6?�� 7B94.?�� <?4.;6F.?�� =?<=<?�� <?12;.?� <B

09.@@6360.?��?20<:2;1.?�

� �����&���0<;A2[1<@�=?<4?.:.1<@�=.?.�.�.B9.�<?4.;6F.1<@�2:�AX=60<@��12� �.���

�� ���������������������� � 12@0?6RP<�1.�./<?1.42:�A2X?60.�2�=?NA60.�1<�A2:.

��� ��������� ��� �������>B.1?<�� 46F�� ?2A?<�=?<72A<?�� 2A0��� 2� 3<;A2@ 56@AX?60<�2@0<9.?2@� �369:2�� :[@60.�

>B.1?6;5<@��2A0��

���� �� �� $"�� =<12� @2?� ?2.96F.1.� 0<:� 1632?2;A2@� =?<=X@6A<@� �16.4;X@A60.�� 3<?:.A6C.� 2� @<:.A6C.��

�6@0?6:6;.?��0<:�/.@2�;<@�</72A6C<@�2@A./292061<@�=.?.�.�.B9.�

� ����� ��� �2D�� ?2@=<@A.@�L@�=2?4B;A.@�=?</92:.�.<� 36;.9�1.�.B9.��16@0B@@P<�12� ?<A26?<�� 0<:=?22;@P<�12

4?.CB?.@��A?./.95<�0<:�1<0B:2;A<@��2A0��

� ����%����� ��� ����� � ������$"��� �� ����� ����

!�!� �������� �� � 6;160.?�A<1.�.�/6/96<4?.36.�0<;@B9A.1.�=.?.�<�=9.;27.:2;A<�1.�.B9.�16C616;1<�.�2;A?2 /N@60.

2�0<:=92:2;A.?

�9./<?.RP<��'B=2?C6@<?.�12�16@06=96;.��=?<32@@<?.�!269.��2.A?6F�'69C26?.

Page 342: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G310

�;2D<���%?<4?.:. � �:2;A.

Page 343: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G311

�;2D<�� \ %9.;<�12�.B9.

Page 344: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G312

�;2D<��

����������������9����������������� \ %?<32@@<?��2?:.;<��?26A.@

Page 345: aprendizagem nas disciplinas introdutórias de projeto de arquitetura

G313

�;2D<��

��������� �2314341"��1:'*$" C �1/'&22/1��*,5*/��*"2